Fantasy Football Today - Everyone is a Bust (Part One); FLEX Draft Results; NFL News (08/03 Fantasy Football Podcast)
Episode Date: August 3, 2020We've got so much news to cover today including an exciting quote about Miles Sanders and an exciting report about Josh Jacobs to begin the show. Are these guys set for huge workloads and huge seasons...? Then we discuss the LeSean McCoy signing (8:40) and more from around the NFL including the COVID news (16:00) as Matthew Stafford and Gardner Minshew are on the reserve/COVID-19 list ... Everyone is a Bust (22:40)! We tell you what could go wrong for each of the Top 10 players starting with new offenses for Christian McCaffrey and Saquon Barkley, perhaps a decline in touches for Ezekiel Elliott (30:30), and the cases against Alvin Kamara (33:00) and Michael Thomas (37:40). Then we get into Derrick Henry (40:00) and Dalvin Cook (43:10), Davante Adams (47:10) and finally Joe Mixon (49:00) and Tyreek Hill (52:30) ... Jamey and Adam participated in the FLEX draft this past weekend. How did it go (55:00)? Why does everyone seem to hate Adam's team? Jamey's team is awesome! ... Email us at fantasyfootball@cbsi.com 'Fantasy Football Today' is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Stitcher, Google Podcasts, Castbox, and wherever else you listen to podcasts. Follow the new FFT Twitch channel: https://www.twitch.tv/FFToday Follow our FFT team on Twitter: @FFToday, @AdamAizer, @JameyEisenberg, @daverichard, @heathcummingssr, @YardsPerGretch, @BenSchragg Watch FFT on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCviK78rIWXhZdFzJ1Woi7Fg/videos Join our Facebook group https://www.facebook.com/groups/FantasyFootballToday/ Sign up for the FFT newsletter https://www.cbssports.com/newsletter To hear more from the CBS Sports Podcast Network, visit https://www.cbssports.com/podcasts/ To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Kick off an exciting football season with BetMGM, an official sportsbook partner of the National Football League.
Yard after yard, down after down, the sportsbook born in Vegas gives you the chance to take action to the end zone
and celebrate every highlight reel play.
And as an official sportsbook partner of the NFL, BetMGM is the best place to fuel your football fandom on every game day. With a variety of exciting features,
BetMGM offers you plenty of seamless ways to jump straight onto the gridiron
and to embrace peak sports action.
Ready for another season of gridiron glory?
What are you waiting for?
Get off the bench, into the huddle, and head for the end zone all season long.
Visit BetMGM.com for terms and conditions.
Must be 19 years of age or older.
Ontario only.
Please gamble responsibly.
Gambling problem?
For free assistance, call the Connex Ontario helpline
at 1-866-531-2600.
BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement
with iGaming Ontario.
This is Fantasy Football Today from CBS Sports.
On his way to the end zone.
I'll tell you what, that was a spectacular play.
It's time to dominate your fantasy league.
What a play.
Off to the races.
Touchdown.
Oh, he's done it again.
Now here's some combination of Adam, Dave, Jamie, Heath, and Ben.
Man, what a busy show we have today.
Pup list, COVID list, unfortunately.
A nice quote about Miles Sanders.
Maybe something about Josh Jacobs here.
Are these year two running backs
going to take over fantasy football?
And the topic of today's show, the big topic,
everybody is a bust.
Okay, so what does that mean?
We did this last year.
We looked at like the top 20.
I think we're going to aim for the top 24 this year
and make a bust case for all of them.
What could go wrong for the elite players
that you're taking in rounds one and two?
It is Monday.
It is the first week of August.
Position previews begin this week
with quarterback on Thursday, tight end on Friday.
We have a live auction that we're doing on the air and on Twitch.
I'll tell you more about that. Guys, I am excited. It feels like football season. What's up, Jamie?
What's up, Heath? How are you guys doing? Doing great. How are you? Oh, yeah, I'm good. I'm good.
If you're watching on YouTube, I am okay. I promise. It looks where I am right now. I've
changed my settings. I need some wall art. I've where I am right now. I've changed my settings.
I need some wall art.
I've got a very boring backdrop.
But it's to be determined, apparently.
Yeah, wall art TBD.
I've got some ideas.
So just to make it clear,
you spent the time to make that sign
instead of just putting something on your wall.
Yeah, I printed out a sign that says wall art TBD.
YouTube.com slash fantasy football today. I've got a few that says WallArt TBD. YouTube.com
slash fantasy football today.
I've got a few things.
I've got this.
We're going to take out
of the casing
and put up.
These are giant
Super Bowl tickets.
I've got
a Knicks thing
and I'm going to order
one more thing
but until I order it,
I'm not putting anything up.
But anyway,
anyway.
Let's put your Beckham jersey up.
Oh,
that's not a bad idea.
I could do that. I wanted to get a fat head like the most random fat head of like a
fullback or something but they don't make those unfortunately um all right let's start with uh
oh by the way i'm ready 43rd birthday today happy birthday we're gonna try to talk about the flex
draft jamie and i participated in on sat about, like, we did this with other industry analysts out of the CBS bubble.
And Todd Gurley, Leonard Fournette, round two picks.
That really surprised me.
But it was good to get some different perspective
and kind of draft with other people.
I want to start with this quote of the day.
Wait, wait, hold on.
Before you get there, Heath, you'll appreciate this,
what Adam did.
He's about to draft Tyler Lockett, and he asked the room full of other fantasy analysts, hey, so on. Before you get there, Heath, you'll appreciate this, what Adam did. He's about to draft Tyler Lockett, and he
asked the room full of other fantasy analysts,
hey, so which guys do you like better,
Tyler Lockett or DK Metcalf?
Well, I said I'm going to draft Lockett,
but I'd love to know who would you guys take here,
Lockett or Metcalf? They're both on the board.
I took Lockett, and it
was, you know... There are some
places that'll get you
punched in the mouth for talking about players that haven't been drafted yet.
Come on.
I had the swing picks.
There's no way Lockett was going to make it back to me.
They were both on the board.
No, but what if somebody was four picks away
and was hoping for DK Metcalf,
and then you brought up that you think they're really close,
and then somebody takes him.
That actually did happen,
that somebody took DK Metcalf and said,
oh, Adam probably talked you into it.
Yeah, right.
All right, but I wish I had taken Miles Sanders because this is what Deuce Daly,
the Eagles running back coach, said about Miles Sanders. I'm excited about Miles. I'm excited
about handing him the full load or no, I'm excited about him handling the full load. I don't see
Miles as a guy. I have a blinding light in my face that I can't really see right now.
I don't see Miles as a guy that you have to monitor his touches.
I think you put him in and you let him go.
Heath, are you sold now on Miles Sanders?
I don't know why.
For three months, I've had Miles Sanders as a top 15 pick,
and you act like I have something against him.
The one thing this made me think was because I moved Clyde Edwards
E-layer up, not quite as high as everyone else did,
but still into the definite first round.
And I have Miles Sanders higher and non PPR,
but I do have Edwards E-layer higher in PPR.
And I'm not really sure that makes any sense.
So there's no question in my mind,
at least that the lower floor out of those two would be Edwards,
the guy that we haven't seen play in the NFL yet.
And I'm not sure there's really much difference in their ceiling.
So this quote,
while it's encouraging,
it is coach speak.
And we don't know that it necessarily means he's going to get more than 65%
of the touches.
It does make me think I might be a little silly for having Clyde ahead of
Sanders.
Oh,
I only brought it up because when Ross Tucker was on our most recent show,
that's,
you know,
he called you out on your miles Sanders ranking and you brought up the
split.
So I just thought,
you know,
I was kind of piggybacking off of that.
Oh,
okay.
But yeah,
sorry.
All right.
And then Jamie,
I know I,
you had something that you wanted to mention about Josh Jacobs, right?
Well, I just mentioned it to you, but I can mention it here, sure.
The Athletic, I think it's Vic Taffer, I hope I'm not pronouncing that incorrectly, I apologize,
who covers the Raiders for the Athletic, in his mailbag was asked if Josh Jacobs would maybe see more work,
I think was the question, or more work in the passing game.
I forget how the question was phrased,
but his answer was that John Gruden,
according to his sources,
was really upset that Jacobs did not win
Rookie of the Year last year,
and he is out to prove that he should have won the award
by going, he's going to give him more carries
and more catches.
Again, that's the second beat writer who covers the Raiders
to suggest that he's going to see more catches.
Their personnel moves this offseason don't necessarily reflect that
because of what Lynn Bowden's, Bowden,
I don't know how we're going with his last name,
but what his skill set probably projects at
as a guy who's going to catch the ball.
Obviously, Jalen Richard, as we know, two years ago,
was great for them catching the ball.
Last year, DeAndre Washington had a role in the passing game.
So Jacobs, who didn't play, I think, on any third downs
or didn't have a target on any third downs, excuse me,
and was limited in his receiving totals.
You know, we've said this time and time again,
30 would be a nice next step.
Anything above that would, I think, be a bonus.
But, you know, he's clearly better in non-PPR than he is in PPR,
but he's going to be one of those guys, I think, that you have to decide.
For me, it's between him and Derrick Henry and Nick Chubb and Joe Mix
and the guys that aren't elite-level pass catchers yet.
You're going to have to depend on some significant rushing totals,
and hopefully Jacobs gets there.
All right, we've got a lot more to get to today,
including the LeSean McCoy signing and what that means.
Want to promote a few things.
From now until week one,
we're going to be streaming twice a week on Twitch.
We're going to have a mock draft every Tuesday
and a camp recap and an AMA and Ask Me Anything
with an expert on Thursday nights.
It's going to be Tuesday nights, typically at 7 p.m.
Not quite, not this week.
I'll get to that in a minute.
And Thursday nights at 7 p.m. Eastern, twitch.com slash FF today.
Tomorrow or Tuesday, whenever you're listening,
Tuesday, 3 p.m. this week,
we've got a big, big Twitch stream.
You're going to hear it as a podcast.
Not all of it, though.
We're doing an auction with other analysts
from around the industry.
Marcus Grant of NFL Network
is going to be one of those analysts.
We have live on-screen results,
mid-draft analysis,
auction strategy talk, all that.
So that's Tuesday at 3 p.m.
Twitch.com slash FF Today.
And then Thursday,
the AMA with Dave Richard.
You can ask him anything.
What should people ask Dave Richard?
Guys, what do you think?
I mean, the obvious question
is going to be pizza
because he's a big pizza guy.
Maybe Chicago stuff, wrestling stuff.
We've got to get something different.
Ask him why he hated his birthday prior to turning 40.
All right, so that's on Thursday at 7.
Tuesday at 3, though, is the auction.
Follow along there.
And we're back on CBS Sports HQ,
noon Eastern, Monday through Friday,
CBS Sports HQ app or CBSSportsHQ.com.
So thank you for letting me promote those things.
Now.
Yeah, we got a fun show today.
We got Shiel Kapadia on from the Eagles.
And we'll talk to him, obviously, about Doug Peterson.
Hopefully he's okay.
You know, coming down with,
reportedly coming down with COVID.
Do you say that?
Coming down with?
Contracting COVID?
Yeah.
Either way.
So hopefully, again, Peterson's okay.
She'll give us some insight on there.
We'll talk to Miles Sanders about what Deuce Daly said
and maybe get some clarity on this receiving core
for Philadelphia.
All right.
So I really wanted to draft Ronald Jones in the Flex League.
I think it was like 60th overall.
You got mad.
No, no, no.
It couldn't have been 60th overall.
That's the end of round five.
It must have been the end of round six, I believe.
72nd?
It was the end of round six, right before you.
Okay.
So he went 71st.
I was going to take him 72nd.
Instead, I took Marlon Mack.
But with LeSean McCoy signed to a one-year deal,
Jamie, what's the impact of that on the Bucs' backfield?
I don't think you should completely panic on Ronald Jones,
but this is not a good sign that a veteran coach
with a veteran-laden team, especially with a quarterback
who, again, just turned 43,
that they bring in a 32-year-old running back who has a, obviously, Hall of Fame pedigree.
So, you know, for Jones, who, as Dave, you know, talked to his trainer and, you know, seems to be
doing all the right things to, you know, secure himself as the guy there, clearly this is an
indication that the coaching staff does not feel the same way. If you go back to 2015 with Bruce
Arians, when he was the coach of the Cardinals,
he had a third round running back in David Johnson,
who ended up being the best guy on the team by the end of the season.
He had a guy coming off a productive year to a certain extent the year
before in Andre Ellington.
And they bring in Chris Johnson right before the season.
And Chris Johnson ended up being the leader in carries to start the year
until he got hurt.
So what's the same setup?
They have Ronald Jones has been disappointing,
but coming off a decent year.
Drafted Keyshawn Vaughn
in the third round
and now bring in an aging veteran.
So I hope history
doesn't repeat itself.
I hope Ronald Jones is the guy.
I think 71st overall
in a half PPR league
is a good spot for him.
Round six, I think,
is a good spot for him.
We had a fun argument
on CBS Sports HQ
following the news last week
where Heath started
the conversation by saying he would take Devin Singletary because we were talking about the
bills. Singletary over Ronald Jones. I agreed with Heath because I would take Singletary over
Jones. Obviously, Adam, you do as well because in that draft, you took Singletary in the fourth
round. And Dave said he would still take Ronald Jones. I don't get that personally because I
think Singletary is on a winning team that's going to run the ball and showed last year that he's better than Ronald Jones already,
at least production wise. So I would take Singletary, you know, and I posted a poll,
it was like almost 75% said that they would take, I did Heath's C results as well, just to make
it happen. But I posted a poll, it was like 70 some odd percent in favor of Singletary over Jones.
But again, I wouldn't run away from him. I just think that his value is clearly not going to reach the ceiling right now
that we thought it could have been prior to this move.
Yeah, I had Jones like a month ago right around running back 30
when I felt like, you know, I don't know between him and Keyshawn Vaughn
which one it's going to be.
I had them both pretty close.
And as we kind of realized there was no preseason and training camp was going to be weird, I kind of dropped Vaughn.
I'd moved Jones up to like running back 25, 24, right in that Devon Singletary range.
And all I did, I didn't like bury Jones.
I just moved him back to where I had him a month ago.
And he's right around running back 30.
He's a good number three running back that has the upside to be a top 20 guy.
But there's risk.
I mean, they gave 170 touches to peyton barber last year and peyton barber was terrible average like 3.1 yards per
carry so telling me that leshawn mccoy is washed up that's probably true i'm not sure it matters
so okay so let me tell you the running backs that went just before Ronald Jones in this draft.
And tell me if you'd take Jones ahead of any of them.
Well, you know, it was a big gap.
It was like David Montgomery went and then... Okay, Mark Ingram, Cam Akers...
This was half PPR?
Half PPR.
Mark Ingram, Cam Akers, Raheem Mostert.
You know, we start...
You can start up to four running backs in this league.
Okay.
It's two flexes.
Two flexes.
Mark Ingram, Cam Akers, Raheem Mostert,
Ronald Jones, Marlon Mack.
That was round six.
No, I missed the couple.
Ingram, Akers, this light, right?
Jeez.
Ingram, Akers, Mostert, Kareem Hunt,
DeAndre Swift, Ronald Jones, Marlon Mack.
It's a lot of running backs in that round.
My goodness.
Does he belong there with Ingram, Akers,
Mostert, Hunt jones mac in this
format the only two that i would definitely take over him would be mostert and ingram and i would
i have it ranked this way so i would take hunt over him as well uh i would take jones over the
rookies though just because of what sean mcveigh said about uh his running backs yesterday that
you know it's going to be a committee again. And then Swift, you know, just, I think for Swift, Swift is,
it could be a league winner for you, but you know,
you need that carry on.
That's an injury to happen.
I think for him to reach the ceiling.
Yeah, I agree.
All the veterans should go before Jones and the rookie should go after him.
All right.
More big news.
This was the right spot, Adam.
I think if you would have got him, it would have been a good pick.
You know,
Marlon Mack obviously is going to be dependent on how much Jonathan Taylor
plays or doesn't play early in the season.
T.Y. Hilton is on the non-football
injury list with a hamstring injury.
And they're saying it's not a big deal,
Heath, but he's been
dealing with nagging injuries. He's 30
years old now, I believe, T.Y. Hilton.
Is this a big deal to you?
Not yet. I'd kind of built
in some concern. Now, it's a bigger deal because he? Not yet. I'd kind of built in some concern.
Now, it's a bigger deal because he has a new quarterback that he's trying to build a relationship with and timing and all those things.
But I'll probably, like with a lot of the guys that have gone on the COVID-19 list, I haven't done anything in terms of their projection yet.
I'm going to give him a week.
And I'll probably give T.Y. Hilton a week.
If it's a week from now, 10 days from now,
then I may ding him just a little bit.
All right. Antonio Brown
is suspended for eight games.
Jamie, just give me a quick thought
on what that means and we can move on.
I'm kind of tired of talking about Antonio Brown,
but he's suspended eight games.
It means that if you're going to draft him,
you've got to have a deep bench and be able to either stash him as a
suspended player on an IR spot.
You know,
we're going to clearly have some commissioner changes with what the COVID
scenario is that people are going to add IR spots to their league.
So,
you know,
if you're able to stash him there,
then he's worth drafting.
But if you can't,
then it's hard to carry a player like this for eight games.
And,
you know,
go back to last year with Kareem Hunt,
when he has eight game suspension,
there's clearly a difference. Hunt was on a roster. He's a position that,
you know, is clearly of, of need for us in fantasy. And he's not 32.
Brown just turned 32. So you gotta have a really deep,
like dynasty leagues he's worth holding, you know,
deep keeper rosters he's worth holding.
I do think now that there's clarity,
you're probably going to see some teams bring up his name a little bit more
now that they know what they're, what they're dealing with.
But in a, in a redraft league, like I'm looking,
I know he went in this in this flex draft Adam, but he went in,
this is an 18 round draft. He went in round,
I think it was like 16 or 17 just toes tells you, you know, where,
I'm sorry, he went around 18 first pick around 18. Yeah.
So that's the type of, you know, move you're going to make, you know,
he's,
he's a guy that if you could sit on him,
if you're,
if your team doesn't have a lot of injuries or,
or,
you know,
needing some roster turnover,
you'll be in good shape.
If he signed somewhere and it's still the same type of guy,
I don't think he's going to be the same guy,
but you know,
we'll see the,
the,
the next move is a transaction.
You know,
there's a team sign.
All right.
So we will get to everyone as a bust very shortly.
We'll have to tell you why Christian McCaffrey is going to be a bust.
You know, you don't have to listen.
But first.
Is it injuries?
No.
We're taking that out.
No injuries.
Maybe Dalvin Cook.
But other than that, no.
But here's your COVID news.
Gardner Minshew, Matthew Stafford, both on the reserve COVID-19 list.
We don't know if this means they tested positive
or if they've been in close contact with somebody who's tested positive,
but they're on the reserve COVID-19 list,
along with Ryquel Armstead, Anthony Barr, Minnesota linebacker,
Jeff Wilson of the Niners, Mason Crosby and Jay Sternberger,
kicker and a tight end for the Packers,
Detroit cornerback Justin Coleman.
Pittsburgh wide receiver James Washington.
That's not necessarily a small deal.
Jalen Samuels for Pittsburgh as well.
And Miami left guard Eric Flowers, who's kind of a punchline as a left tackle,
but turned his career around as a guard.
We got a lot of time before the season starts,
so let's hope these guys are on the mend quickly here. Timetables are a little bit uncertain. We're learning a lot, time before the season starts. So let's hope these, these guys are on the men quickly here.
Timetables are a little bit uncertain.
We're learning a lot,
I think from baseball,
but with Minshew and Stafford Heath,
what's your reaction to them being on the COVID,
the reserve COVID-19 list.
For now.
I don't,
I'm not the Matthew Stafford when I hope that he feels better soon.
And it's fine.
But in terms of fantasy projections,
I'm not changing anything.
I'm a little bit more concerned about Minshew
just because lack of experience,
new offensive coordinator has a new system
and he has to learn.
And the more walkthroughs he can go through,
the more polished I'd expect him to be
at the beginning of the year.
Hopefully it's a quick recovery.
Okay, so let's say you take this news into account.
You're drafting today and DJ Chark is on the board.
Are you moving him down a little bit?
And let me just take a look at where he went.
But would you take DJ Chark or DK Metcalf?
I would still take Chark over Metcalf right now,
but it's very close.
Yeah, I would take Chark as well.
Okay, and the draft we did, it was in the Flex League,
it was Lock it to me then
charke then metcalf and then jayme absolute steel then took mcclure yeah i mean i thought so 49th
it's funny man there are people that are concerned about lockett you know i guess just because
metcalf may be getting better and taking over the run first offense it's almost like you know
people forget about the first half of the season. We do this a lot. People forget about how seasons start. David Johnson is a good example of that as
well. He was, I think, running back eight through the first four weeks of the season in PPR. Lockett
was obviously amazing, as we saw before that unfortunate situation in that game in San Francisco
where he had to go to the hospital. You know, hopefully that's the guy you're getting. He's a
very efficient, very good wide receiver
that plays with a good quarterback.
So Lockett was the 21st wide receiver
off the board in this draft.
And tell me how you guys feel about this.
But I feel like even if Metcalf takes that big leap
and becomes an elite top 12 wide receiver,
I still think Lockett,
this could be the year that they have two top 24 guys.
It's never happened with Wilson.
But this could be the year,
because they're the best two that
he's had, I think.
I mean, you could say Baldwin and Lockett,
but I think, you know, at this stage
in their careers, whatever. But I think
Lockett doesn't need that many targets to be
wide receiver 21.
That's kind of how I feel. So I feel like that was
a, even if Metcalf is great, I feel
like Lockett could still return value end of the
fourth round. Thoughts?
Yeah.
Agreed.
Totally agree.
All right.
And let's see.
Opt-outs.
Jacksonville defensive tackle Al Woods.
Rams offensive tackle Chandler Brewer.
Cincinnati defensive tackle Josh Tupou.
Marquise Lee for the Patriots.
CJ Mosley for the Jets.
That's a big one.
Jameez Olawale for the Cowots. CJ Mosley for the Jets. That's a big one. Jameis Oluwole for the Cowboys.
They're fullback.
And Buffalo cornerback EJ Gaines, who missed all of 2019.
This round of opt-outs, not as big as some of the ones we've had in the past,
but Mosley's a big deal, though.
He missed time last year.
Maybe Oluwole.
I mean, the Cowboys like using a fullback.
Yeah.
I think they have, like like four guys on the roster
though.
And Marquise Lee probably
wasn't going to have much of an impact, but that does
like they already had
Sonny Michel and Mohamed Sanu starting
on the pup.
So that's like they're
really short on players.
Rough offseason for the
Patriots. If they can win the division this year,
that would be pretty amazing.
I don't think on paper they're even close to the Bills right now.
Am I crazy?
I think you're crazy.
They lost Hightower and Chung, though.
And they're starting right tackle or left tackle, Marcus Cannon.
On paper, is Cam Newton healthy?
I don't know.
Because if on paper Cam Newton's
healthy, then I think that they're
not as good defensively,
but
I think they're probably better offensively. Really?
I would lean toward Cam,
but wouldn't you say a healthy Cam
at 31 is probably on par with a third-year Josh Allen?
See, I think running, yes.
But even though when Cam was not great as a passer, he was better than Josh Allen has been.
And the last time we saw him, he was completing 68% of his passes.
Oh, I'm with you.
I think it's a fun conversation, though, because you have a guy that's hopefully ascending versus a guy that's clearly breaking down,
you know? So I wonder where people would probably go. I think, you know, probably most,
most people would lean toward Cam, but it's probably something that would be fun to discuss.
But, but forget it, like not forget about Cam, but he's not the only player on the offense.
I think the rest of the players favor the bills, the skill position players.
Well, yeah. I mean, now you have Michelle Hurt.
You have Mohamed Sanu Hurt, you know,
and that's the guy that Cam is thrown with the most this offseason.
Lee not there.
Cannon not there.
So that's the offensive side, at least for now.
And then you go to the defensive side.
Oh, my God.
No Hightower, no Chung.
Those are big.
The Patriots are a bust.
All right.
Everyone is a bust, starting with Christian McCaffrey, the top 12, according to him.
Going with Fantasy Pros ADP today.
We'll mix it up a little bit.
Coming up, as soon as we get back from this quick break, we'll tell you what could go wrong for Christian McCaffrey,
for Saquon Barkley, Ezekiel Elliott, Alvin Kamara, Michael Thomas, and the rest of them.
We'll be right back on Fantasy Football today.
Whether in the game or in life, the right coverage can make all the difference.
Securian Canada gives you that coverage. For more than 65 years, Securian Canada has been helping
Canadians build secure tomorrows. Their insurance solutions are designed to help protect you and
your loved ones financially, giving you the peace of mind to focus on what truly matters.
Find their products through banks, credit unions, and associations,
or visit SecurianCanada.ca.
Securian Canada. Insurance designed for life.
What does possible sound like for your business?
It's having the spend that powers your scale with no preset spending limit.
More cash on hand to grow your business with up to 55 interest-free days. And the ability to reach further with access to over 1,400 airport lounges worldwide.
Redefine possible with Business Platinum.
That's the powerful backing of American Express.
Terms and conditions apply.
Visit amex.ca slash business platinum.
Christian McCaffrey, man.
2,392 total yards, 19 touchdowns,
3.7 more fantasy points per game than Derrick Henry in non-PPR,
8.6 more fantasy points per game than Dalvin Cook in PPR.
Dalvin Cook was number two per game.
Yeah, he's going to be a bust right now.
We'll give you the case against everyone. What
could go wrong for these players? All right. What could go wrong for Christian McCaffrey Heath?
I actually wrote this article and it's on CBSSports.com, the case against. And I think
there is a chance that the new coaching staff doesn't want Christian McCaffrey to play 100
more snaps than any other player and decides not to give him 400 touches. I do think that his touchdown production could regress
a little bit. What I said was he could lose 400 yards and six touchdowns off last year pretty
easily. If he just went to a little bit more normal usage, still high usage, but a little
more normal for an elite back like the Saquon Barkley, Ezekiel Elliott usage. And then that probably doesn't
make him the number one running back in non-PPR. I'm not sure how he
busts in PPR. You know, Jamie, when we talked to Ross Tucker
on Friday, he, you know, former offensive lineman, was
kind of concerned about teams that have new coaching. I think
he was talking about new coaching staffs and whatnot.
And I just think it's funny that the top two picks have new coaching staffs,
McCaffrey and Barkley.
How big of a concern is that to you?
It's a,
it's a concern.
I mean,
it's not only that for McCaffrey,
it's a new quarterback.
Yeah.
So it's no two new things that are,
are,
are clearly something he has to adjust to. I do think that this is a system that will benefit him you know based on what joe brady
showed us in college especially as we continue to talk about clive edwards-alair and the numbers
that he put up so you know pass catching running back in his offense clearly was successful
but you know he he said it matt rule i wrote the wrote the story on Christian McCaffrey for our magazine. And you know,
I think the, the, the,
the comment that Heath is referring to was Matt rule said he wants to use other
guys. Now you look at this backfield, Jordan Scarlett and Reggie Bonifan,
I think combined for 24 touches in their careers.
They have Mike Davis too, right?
They do have Mike Davis, but he's not a lock to make the final roster.
So if you just look at,
again,
looking at their depth chart,
the top two guys are clearly youngsters that don't have a lot of
experience.
So if Mike Davis on the roster changes things,
but,
and then the addition of Robbie Anderson,
you know,
so now you have three pass catchers that,
you know,
adding a proven guy that has spent time with,
with Matt rule,
Ian Thomas,
you know,
if he stays on the field,
maybe he's at this stage of his career better than Greg Olson's stage of his
career. Clearly he doesn't have the resume of Greg Olson. Um,
and we'll Bridgewater, you know,
check down to McCaffrey or will the play calls be there for McCaffrey?
So what's made McCaffrey so successful the last two years is really his
receiving numbers, um,
being the first running back ever to have back to back hundred yard catch season.
Excuse me, hundred catch seasons. So, you know, I don't think this is I think the thing you build in with these guys at the top of the draft.
And Heath talks about this a lot is where do they fall if they fail?
So if they fall from running back one to running back five, is that a complete failure?
And are you like completely disappointed that you didn't take Barkley or Zeke or Kamara or did he fall to running back 20 or 25 or worse like
David Johnson last year you know where he was a first round pick and then just completely fell
off the map I think that's the question you have to ask yourself when you're drafting these guys
and so I think barring injury McCaffrey should finish as at least a top 10 running back even
if things go completely off the rails for him and And one other thing that I didn't say, they ran 1,077 plays last year. They were one of the
more higher paced offenses in the league. And what we've seen over the last couple of years
is first time play callers are often a little bit slower. And that may be even more true without the
off season. So they could run 80 fewer plays. That might be 40 fewer touches right there.
Okay. If you're curious, I was curious.
Teddy Bridgewater's throw to his running backs.
I just looked at what he did last year.
Yes, he threw to Alvin Kamara quite a bit.
Alvin Kamara was on pace for like 83 catches in the five games he played
with Teddy Bridgewater.
That's typically where Alvin Kamara is.
He has 81 catches every year.
And so that was good.
And then Kamara missed one game. And Latavius Murray had five catches every year. That was good. Then Camara missed one game
and Latavius Murray had five catches
in that game for 31 yards.
We did see that at least last year when Bridgewater
was playing the five starts in the
one game that he took over for Breeze. He threw
a lot to the running backs.
Let's go to Saquon Barkley.
This is half PPR average draft position, by the
way. In fact,
all of the top three picks,
Coordinated Fantasy Pros, have new coaching staffs
because Ezekiel Elliott is number three.
He does have the same offensive coordinator, though.
But Barkley, what could go wrong for him?
Well, there's a new offense, new coaching staff.
They just lost their left tackle.
What I noticed, though, the last six games of the season,
he was on pace for only 51 catches.
And that's when basically everyone was healthy.
I think only one of the wide receivers,
I think it was Golden Tate,
missed one game and Shepard and Slayton played all six.
Now Evan Ingram didn't play,
but Caden Smith got a ton of targets.
So I do worry, I don't know, worry,
but I wonder about the catches with Saquon Barkley.
Jamie, what, if anything, scares you with Barkley?
What could go wrong?
You said it, the receiving totals.
You know, he was an 80-catch guy his rookie season,
and that was with Eli Manning being a statue back there.
And so now you have Daniel Jones with all these mouths to feed,
and he's going to run.
So, you know, I think that's the concern,
is that you're getting a guy who could be
I don't think this is going to happen but you know maybe closer to Derrick Henry than he is to
Christian McCaffrey and so that would be not a horrible thing if you get Derrick Henry from a
year ago but if you get you know a guy that's under 50 catches that's not the allure and that's
why you would probably pass on him for Ezekiel Elliott like I know Dave would so um I think the the pro Barkley uh fantasy manager is hoping for north of 50 catches which would
still be exceptional it wouldn't be to the level of McCaffrey or even Kamara based on what he can
do as a as a receiver but yeah there's a lot of mouths to feed on a team that's probably going to
be trailing a lot and so if they're throwing and not throwing to him, that could be a little bit frustrating.
Again, I don't think that'll be the case,
but that's clearly the concern.
He only averaged 5.6 targets per game last year
in games that Daniel Jones started
and only had three games with Jones
where he was over five targets.
So I do think that you should expect him
to not catch as many passes as he,
like, I don't know that 2018 upside is really there.
And then the other problem would be if the offensive line
is bad and he doesn't...
What if he's like 4.2 yards
per carry and he's only catching
55 passes and they don't score a bunch of
points so he doesn't have a ton of touchdowns. I think
there's a risk that he's not a top five running back.
He only scored eight touchdowns
in 13 games last year.
He was basically the number six running back on a per-game basis.
He was number seven in PPR.
Of course, when you do the per-game, it factors in the Bucs game.
He had eight carries for 10 yards, four catches in that game.
All right, that's Saquon Barkley.
Anything else you guys want to add about him?
Oh, you know what?
One other thing about the catches that I want to bring up.
They've got Deion Lewis now.
The previous two seasons, Wayne Gallman had the second most catches
of a Giants running back behind Barkley.
He had 15 in 2018.
He had 11 in 2019.
Does Deion Lewis factor in?
Could he get...
When you say that Gallman had 11,
Barkley missed three games.
That should tell you something.
Well, yeah, Gallman got hurt, though.
Right.
I'm just saying they haven't thrown any other... How many did John Hilleman haveman got hurt though. Right. I'm just saying
they haven't thrown
any other...
How many did John Hillman have?
Less than 11.
Yeah,
I wouldn't worry
about Deion Lewis
as the Tennessee experiment
showed us.
Okay.
Ezekiel Elliott.
So,
here's where he has finished
per game
in four seasons.
In non-PPR,
third,
second,
eighth,
and fifth.
In PPR,
third, third, sixth, and fifth. In PPR, third, third, sixth, and fifth.
And a couple years ago, outside the top five per game,
had a little bad luck with touchdowns.
But he's been a stud.
He's been super consistent.
He feels super safe.
Heath, what could go wrong with Ezekiel Elliott?
I kind of think his really high touchdown rate from last year
is disguising the difference in his usage in Kellen Moore's offense.
He saw 10% fewer carries per game than he has at any point in his career.
I believe it was the first time he was below 20 carries per game.
He was down around 18.
He also saw his targets go back to where they were before 2018.
So I don't think he's necessarily going to be amongst the league leaders in
terms of carries or total touches, or he'll be amongst the league leaders.
I don't think he's going to lead the NFL in either of those.
And if he goes back to a year where we have,
and we had three straight years where Dak Prescott stole six rushing
touchdowns from Zeke and his rushing touchdown totals weren't great.
So that would be the risk.
You take away just one touchdown from last year and he's the number six
running back on a per game basis.
And then you get the Tony Pollard issue.
They haven't really had a good explosive second back.
I wouldn't be surprised if Pollard gets one or two more touches per game
that he did last year.
And Zeke's looking at 17 carries per game and only catching 45 passes?
Have we actually uncovered a legit concern so far,
or are these just sort of like, eh, whatever, it could happen,
but no big deal?
With any of these guys, or is he?
With any of them.
I mean, there's slight concerns, I would say.
If there were bigger concerns, I think hopefully we're all smart enough, not just us, but as an industry to have these guys lower, you know, I mean, there's, there's certainly, you know, I've seen a lot of people say, for example, you know,
Clyde Edwards, Hilaire, you can rank him as high as the second player off the board because of what
his upside could be. We've talked about Miles Sanders, what his upside could be. You know,
if you're in the Joe Mixon camp, you could probably make an argument that he could go
at this point, Derek Henry can go at this point at this point. So these guys are elite level running backs for a reason.
So I think we're nitpicking.
The only thing I would add to Zeke would be the offensive line,
they're replacing two new starters.
Missing Travis Frederick.
We did see Zeke, while he did have a fantastic season,
that while Frederick was sidelined with his illness. He did have only six touchdowns,
and I think he averaged 95.
I'm looking at right here, 95.6 yards per game.
It was a slight decline from his season the year before.
All right.
Alvin Kamara is fourth in Fantasy Pro's ADP,
and on a per-game basis, he was 15th in non-PPR.
He was eighth in PPR.
He got hurt, missed some time,
and I think, you know,
if you had asked this question a year ago,
which we did,
how could this guy be a bust?
Maybe you would have said his touchdown rate
would go down, and it did.
He didn't score that many touchdowns.
Jamie, what scares you with Alvin Kamara, if anything?
What could go wrong for Kamara?
The touchdowns.
You know, I mean,
he's not going to be a guy that's going to be,
you know, 1,500 yards on the ground
unless the Saints completely change their strategy and how they operate.
But I think the thing with Kamara is how much work would they give Latavius Murray also?
Maybe to sort of save him, spare him a little bit.
Maybe they realize that he's not a guy that should have that much work
if he's going to deal with some nagging injuries. Um, because when he was at his best,
he was with somebody else. Um, in terms of his season long production, clearly we saw some four
game sample sizes when Mark Ingram was suspended, that he was awesome. Uh, and last year to start
the season as well, but no, it could be the coaching staff just wanting to reign him in a
little bit, but you know, they retooled their offensive lines. He's Ruiz. I think it's going
to be a nice addition. And, um, you know, uh,ooled their offensive lines. Cesar Ruiz, I think is going to be a nice addition. And, you know,
if he's healthy, he can be the number one back.
It wouldn't surprise me at all.
Yeah. I think for him, it's just, and we've seen most of his career.
He's been just like super human in terms of efficiency.
After that rookie year, we were saying, well,
there's no way that he can average 10 yards per reception and five yards per
carry. And he didn't the next year, but he scored like 100 touchdowns, so it didn't matter.
And last year was the first year where we saw when he did get hurt, and that was probably part of it,
where he didn't have the elite efficiency and he didn't have the great touchdown rate.
And he doesn't have the floor that Barkley and McCaffrey and Elliott do because they're going to get 300 plus touches.
He's probably maxed out around 275.
If it's last year's efficiency, even if the touchdowns come up a little bit,
that won't be enough to make him worth the number four pick.
You mentioned the touches.
Would you say 275 is max for him?
So far, it looks like it.
I think I actually haven't maybe projected for a little bit higher than that,
but before 290 before his injury, he was
on pace for 323 touches.
And he got hurt. And he got hurt.
And
in the four games he played without Mark Ingram
in 2018, he was on pace for
even more than that.
That's what I'm so curious
about is, are they going to unleash him
like they did before the injury? Are they going to sort of hold them back a little bit, they going to unleash him like they did before the injury?
Are they going to sort of hold them back a little bit, Alvin Kamara,
like they did after the injury?
I wouldn't mind if they held him back a little bit, just a little bit,
just to make sure that he gets...
You'd rather have 16 games as opposed to this just four-game potential,
and then, okay, he got hurt.
Two years ago, Taysom Hill
had nine carries inside
the 10-yard line. Last
year, he had two
and none inside the 5-yard line.
It's hilarious that the year that he
had more, that's when Kamara scored
all the touchdowns. So they just need to give
the ball to Taysom Hill inside the 10
so that Alvin Kamara can score more touchdowns.
But I do...
The first three picks,
I mean, especially in non-PPR,
I don't even hesitate.
But if I'm looking at non-PPR
and I have the fourth pick in the draft,
I'm a little nervous about Kamara.
It's where I finally...
Okay, I'm not really concerned about the top three guys.
Yeah, something could go wrong, but whatever.
But in a strictly non-PPR league,
if I'm picking fourth,
is he the fourth pick?
I am taking Henry.
I'm taking Henry.
I would take Cook.
I would take Cook.
You would take Cook.
Yeah, see, for me, I'm taking Kamara.
I just think that we've seen him score 18 touchdowns in this offense.
For what we've talked a lot about this offseason,
continuity I think is going to be huge.
And, you know, in a down year for him lot about this off season continuity, I think is going to be huge. And, you know,
in a down year for him last year, he still caught 80 passes. Yeah.
So I think he rolls out of bed, catching 80 pass.
I don't care about Emmanuel Sanders being there and what's going to happen.
He's in a contract year. So like, honestly,
I struggle with half PPR with Zeke and Kamara because in PPR,
I'm taking Kamara for me. I think he's got a higher ceiling this year um not that zeke is is bad by any stretch but i just think that contract
year the catches the touchdowns could be even in kamara's favor you guys have said it i agree uh
zeke's floor is safer because of his rushing and his carries but i think uh you know kamara
profiles so much like what mcafree does like He could be a thousand-thousand guy.
Yeah.
In PPR, I'm taking Kamara over Zeke as well, and a half PPR too.
Okay.
All right.
Michael Thomas is next in ADP.
He's fifth overall.
He was the number one receiver last year.
And what could go wrong, Jamie, for Michael Thomas?
Well, just what I said, Emmanuel Sanders being there could take some targets away.
You know, he's a proven guy,
whether you think he's going to be good or not for fantasy,
that doesn't matter.
But, you know, he's a guy that is going to, you know,
at least draw a little bit more attention for Drew Brees.
Kamara being healthy.
The biggest thing, obviously, is the targets.
You know, if he goes from 180 plus targets to, you know,
closer to 150, if not below, he came out, I guess, this weekend,
or there was a report that he's going to,
he thinks he could break the single season catch record again.
Good luck to you doing that.
I'm sure everybody would bet the under.
He's a great player.
He's the best wide receiver in the NFL right now,
but he doesn't score double digit touchdowns.
And if the catches and yards come down,
then you're going to really be upset
that you passed on Dalvin Cook
or any of the other running backs in the spot i really feel like adam should
have just done this one we've seen michael thomas with 147 and 149 targets the two years before last
year and he wasn't even a top five wide receiver those two years it's true i i'll say this. You take his efficiency last year, his fantasy points per target,
give him 150
instead of 185,
which was the
most for a wide receiver since 2015, by the way.
Give him 150
and in non-PPR,
he's not the number one wide receiver.
In PPR,
he still is, but I think
actually not as good per game as Chris Godwin.
But here's the bottom line.
In any format,
if you take what Michael Thomas did on 185 targets
and give him just 150,
non-PPR, half PPR, full PPR,
in three of the last four years,
top four wide receiver at worst
based on the fantasy points he would have scored
with 150 targets.
So, you know, what got me,
kind of Heath was like,
he was the number eight wide receiver.
I think he was number six in PPR last year,
or in 2018 rather, number eight in non-PPR.
But it was such a great year for wide receivers
that even those fantasy points were so great.
He finished a little bit lower
because wide receivers just went off in 2018.
So once I kind of realized that,
it put things into context a little bit.
So even at 150 targets,
with the same efficiency as he had last year,
you're still talking about a floor of top fourth.
Right.
Yeah.
But if he gets 150 targets, he might not be the number one wide receiver,
especially in anything other than a full PPR league, but that's okay.
All right.
Next pick is Derek Henry.
What could go wrong for Derek Henry, Jamie?
The guy who's not drafting Derek Henry much this year.
Offensive line is a little bit of a concern now.
With Conklin gone and their rookie not healthy,
so we could see that being a problem.
Wear and tear is a concern for me,
for a guy that had 400 touches,
including the playoffs last year,
for running back of his size.
Clearly, the receptions are going to be a problem.
I don't see a dramatic increase,
considering last year with the same offense coordinator,
he had a career-high 18. And as we saw, this is more PPR. I haven't done the numbers in non PPR in his first eight games. He was only averaging 13 and a half PPR
points per game. He clearly was a monster in the second half of the season. And that's the guy you
hope to be getting. I'm just not sold that that's the guy you're going to get for an entire year,
given some of the changes on the line and the fact, again,
that his receiving numbers are not going to help him out in this regard.
So I also think that we're going to see a better backup guy.
I think Darrington Evans will be better than Deion Lewis.
At what point in the season will that happen? I don't know.
But I think a younger back that could maybe come in
and change some things a little bit with his offense,
that should help things a little bit,
maybe take some of the workload away from Derrick Henry.
So for me at this spot in the draft,
I would definitely take Dalvin Cook.
All right, and Heath, I'll just jump in and say
the first eight games that Jamie mentioned,
if you want to talk about maybe what's his floor,
he averaged 3.9 yards per carry in those games.
He was the number nine running back in non-PPR,
number 12 in PPR. Had 151 carries in those games. He was the number nine running back in non-PPR, number 12 in PPR.
Had 151 carries in those eight games, only eight catches, scored six touchdowns, but wasn't very
good. He was still top 12 in PPR, number nine in non-PPR. So there's that. If anything concerns
you about Derrick Henry, you seem to be the high guy on Derrick Henry. Yeah, I think the case against him is just a lot easier to make in PPR. It's not difficult to say that Derrick Henry, and I didn't even make
the case against Derrick Henry because he was not top 12 in our consensus rankings. But in PPR,
the risk is that his efficiency just normalizes just a little bit. They're not quite as good, so they throw more,
but his catches don't really go up more than four or five catches.
And he's just not that far in PPR from not being worth this type of pick.
In non-PPR, I really think the only worry is that the touches get him down.
I think he's going to get 300 carries.
I mean, even if he rushes for 1300 yards,
he's gonna rush for double digit touchdowns.
Let's go to Dalvin.
I would draft him in the first round of non PPR.
Okay.
Let's go to Dalvin cook per game.
He was number three in non PPR, number two in PPR last year.
He kind of struggled a little bit down the stretch,
was able to score some touchdowns, got a ton of work,
but faded a little bit and
got hurt as well. So
Heath, I'll give you the first word. What could go
wrong? Everyone is a bust, including
Dalvin Cook. What could go wrong for Dalvin Cook?
Let's just take out the Dalvin
Cook gets hurt like he has every other year
as what could go wrong. But that is certainly one of the things
that could go wrong. Every year, not every other year.
Every year, every year, yeah.
Yes. I know. Like he had, yes.
I know, I gotcha, Heath.
The thing that goes wrong is that the Vikings coaches noticing this and thinking, you know, we'd like to make the playoffs
and have this guy for the playoffs,
use Alexander Madison more than they did last year.
And the other thing that goes wrong is that the Vikings just aren't near as good.
They aren't as successful running the ball.
Their defense isn't as good. And so Kirk Cousins throws 50 more passes and Dalvin Cook will get a
few of those, but his rush attempts goes down. So those, I think the obvious one is Dalvin Cook
gets hurt again, but I do think even if he stays healthy, there's some risk that Minnesota tries
to lighten his load just a little bit so they can keep him healthy throughout the year.
Jamie, it's not like Madison had a hundred carries in 13 games last year.
They ran the ball so much.
Only Tennessee and Baltimore threw fewer passes than the, than the Vikings who are fifth in scoring defense, um, by the way.
Uh, but yeah, I mean, they just, they ran so much. So yeah, I mean,
if, if Madison, even if the carries per game don't go up,
maybe it's like just the total carries go down and he gets a bigger share.
But anyway, what worries you, Jamie, about Dalvin Cook?
I mean, similar to what Heath said, you know,
and maybe Madison just does take on more work because he's a good running.
It's like Tony Pollock, you know, like very similar setups that, you know,
two guys that are ranked as top five or top six running backs have very good backups behind them that probably
deserve more of an opportunity. In Dallas, it's harder because you paid Ezekiel Elliott and he's
got that track record of just being such an absolute stud. With Cook, he's great. And he's
showed himself last year to be one of the best running backs in football,
finally staying healthy for more than 10 games.
But Madison may deserve a little bit more of an opportunity to showcase himself as well.
So we'll see what Gary Kubiak, who's now stepping into the full-time role as the offense coordinator. Last year, he was more of a consultant.
But I think that's the only concern I have, really, aside from health.
But that's the biggest thing with Dalvin Cook.
It's just the health.
You know, he's the one guy that you look at and you say, oh, man, he makes me nervous.
Like he went before I picked, I think, right before in this best ball draft that Heath and I are doing.
It would have been a tough call in that format.
I took Cook in our magazine draft, our magazine that's coming out the next edition. And it, you know,
the only thing that, you know, like you gotta be like, I know Adam, like you said, you, you'd be
torn on maybe Dalvin cook over Alvin Kamara as the fourth running back. The thing I think when
you take Dalvin cook, it's like you, you automatically, I got to get out of there.
Like, I just have to make sure I get Madison. And it's like, it's so stressful. It's like,
you're going through the draft. It's like, Oh, is this, you know, you get past like round six.
It's like, okay, it's now like, and I was playing a game of chicken.
It was round eight.
And I was like, I like Deontay Johnson.
I needed a third receiver.
It's three receiver league for PPR.
And I was like, I'm just going to take Deontay Johnson.
And if I miss on, on, on Madison in round eight, so be it.
Thankfully he came back to me around nine and it was just like such a sigh of relief
that you just have that backfield locked up.
And we did this draft at the time when it was, is he or is he not going to report
and show up on time?
Thankfully, he did.
So, you know, maybe you get Madison
a little bit more of a discount now,
but it's just, it's not fun
if you feel like you have to handcuff Dalvin Cook
when you draft Dalvin Cook.
Well, yeah, I got lucky like in the flex draft,
he went, Alexander Madison went 118th overall.
And the guy who had Dalvin Cook didn't even take him.
That's a big miss, man.
You could have taken him in the 10th round, Bob.
All right, anyway, Devontae Adams is next in ADP.
What could go wrong?
I don't understand.
He's so safe.
You know, I mean, he's going to get all the targets. mean he's gonna get all the targets he's gonna get all the
target like i think what could go wrong is that um his quarterbacks like we've kind of questioned a
little bit is aaron rogers skill are his skills deteriorating or is it just that he doesn't have
any help or is it a combination of both adams has not been a very efficient wide receiver on a per target
basis if they only throw 500 passes this year and they just run the ball kind of like it looks like
they're going to and Rodgers is slightly less efficient he hasn't had a five percent touchdown
rate since 2017 so if he's around four percent touchdown rate and Adams gets 150 targets and
only scores seven or eight touchdowns he He's probably not worth a first-round pick.
Anything else, Jamie, or is that basically it?
I mean, I hate to say, you know, I hate when this argument is made,
like he's the only receiver on the field,
so defense is going to load up to stop him.
But that's going to happen a lot.
You know, he's going to have to beat a lot of double teams in this offense,
you know, unless we get Alan Lazard
or Reggie Bedleton or
Marquez Valdez-Scantling.
Matt LaFleur in his press conference
this weekend talked up
Equan...
I'm going to butcher his name. Equanimous.
Equanimous St. Brown, man. Just call him EQ.
EQ.
So, you know, that's
something that... You need something that you need.
You need something to help him.
I mean, he just needs a little bit of help
to draw a little bit of pressure off him.
He's one of the best route runners in the game.
He's a great wide receiver.
He's going to command targets like he deserves,
but he's going to have to do it
probably beating two people every time.
All right, we'll do two more.
We'll do Joe Mixon and Tyreek Hill.
That'll give us a top 10.
We have a second edition of this coming out on Tuesday. But let's go do Joe Mixon and Tyreek Hill. That'll give us a top 10. We have a second edition of this coming out on
Tuesday. But let's go
to Joe Mixon here.
First eight games, 3.2
yards per carry. Hurt his ankle in week one.
Maybe that had a lot to do with it. 101
carries in those games. Last
eight games, 4.6 yards
per carry. 177
carries, most in the NFL in
that stretch. And he was the most in the NFL in that stretch.
And he was the number four running back in both formats.
Jamie, what could go wrong for Joe Mixon?
Ricky quarterback, lack of any semblance of knowing what he's doing because of no offseason, which hurts Mixon even more in the passing game.
And he doesn't have those type of numbers that I'm hoping he's going to get to. So, you know,
those, those are two pretty significant things you have to worry about,
you know, with with, with drafting Mixon, which I totally, totally get.
And so, you know, those are the biggest concerns for me. Plus, you know,
I keep saying it and I think a lot of people that are pro Mixon keep saying it,
but maybe Jonah Williams just doesn't automatically make this offensive line
that much better.
It'll make it better, but does he make it that much better?
So offensive line could be a concern,
but certainly more of the other two,
that he doesn't work in the passing game and Joe Burrow's got those rookie
struggles.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I think, I think Burrow running like the same thing we saw with Daniel Jones
and Saquon Barkley's targets.
The problem is Mixon's not coming from a place of eight targets per game he's coming from a place of four or five so if he loses that
same percentage it'd be a problem and the other thing is like he's this is what the number seven
running back being drafted yeah man he went ahead never been that good over a full season he went
ahead of Miles Sanders he went ahead of Clyde Edwards-Elair, Josh Jacobs in the flex draft on Saturday. He could just be a borderline number one,
high-end number two running back
like he has been the last two years,
and you will wish that you drafted a different running back.
He's one of these guys, like, similar to Henry,
similar to Jacobs, similar to Nick Chubb,
that half PPR and non-PPR, they're better.
It's just the nature of their games right now.
You're hoping again that Mixon and Jacobs,
because I don't think it's going to happen for Chubb with Kareem Hunt there.
And we've seen it with Derek Henry's career.
Their catches are almost certainly capped. Whereas again,
Mixon and Jacobs it's to what level they get to of how much better they can be
in half PPR and full PPR. But like, I like,
I like mixing and Jacob significantly better in those, in,
in those formats more so in non PPR. Um, but like to,
to take mixing over Edwards to layer at this point, I just, I,
I can't do it as much as I like mixing.
And I certainly can't do it over miles Sanders because of what his role is in
the passing game. So, um, you know, mixing is, Mixon is going to be a very polarizing guy.
I saw somebody tweet this over the weekend.
I apologize for not having it credited.
He has no fumble since 2018.
I think maybe it was PFF.
He hasn't fumbled the ball in two seasons.
Another thing to keep in mind if you want to be a downer on Joe Mixon,
Joe Burrow is very good.
He's a very good rusher.
He had five rushing touchdowns in 2019. Three of them were from three yards out or closer. One was
from five, one was seven yards out. So maybe he could steal some touchdowns as well. Again, we're
very negative today. This is Monday. We have a case of the Monday. He also threw 55 passes to his
running back too, though. Keep that in mind too. Well, okay. But well, you mean 55 catches for, uh.
So his running back caught 55 55. Okay. But I,
the LSU stats are incredible. Like,
I mean,
Justin Jefferson,
I think the only rookie wide receiver that,
you know,
that people are drafting this year that have more yards than Justin
Jefferson was Antonio Gandy golden.
Um,
and he wasn't even their best receiver and they played more games than
anyone else in football,
I think,
except for Clemson.
So, you know, like the LSU,
LSU had the greatest season ever, basically.
So keep it in mind.
Last one is Tyreek Hill.
I'm going to ask you this.
Like, he's not a high target guy.
You know, I think he had like 127 two years ago,
137 in his best year, 2018.
And you've got these young receivers that could be getting better.
And Sammy Watkins had a great postseason.
Heath, are you concerned about maybe like DeAndre Hopkins last year,
the targets went down, this Will Fuller, you know,
was more involved and whatnot.
Are you concerned of that happening a little bit here with the Chiefs and
Tyreek Hill?
Not really because Tyreek Hill doesn't require 10 targets per game to be a top
five wide receiver.
And we've seen him do it on seven or eight pretty consistently.
And he,
he can do it on a weekly basis on two or three.
So like there's the concern I think with Hill is just that week to week
inconsistency that is still a part of his game.
And if that hits you weeks,
14, 15 or 16, then it's hits you weeks 14, 15, or 16,
then it's really not much fun.
But I don't, other than injury or off the field stuff,
I don't really see how things are going to go too wrong
for Tyreek Hill this year.
Jamie, agree?
I do.
And I think one thing,
I know we're supposed to give the negative for him,
but they just lost a pretty big piece of their offense
with Damian Williams.
And what we saw from Tyree kill his rookie season, when he had 24 attempts,
I don't want to call him carries because he had 24 rushing attempts.
And then 2018, when their offense was off the charts,
he had 22 rushing attempts and he scored four combined rushing touchdowns in
that regard.
And so if you need some sort of an answer to be creative with your
quote unquote run game, if Edward Selaire doesn't take over completely for Damian Williams and has
success and the backups aren't good, then maybe he has a little bit bigger role in that part of it.
So his touches change a little bit in that regard. So targets, yeah, are clearly going to
be an issue for him. If Nicole Hardman's better and Sammy Watkins stays healthy, maybe they divvy
things up a little bit differently. They lost a big
offensive lineman, so that
could be a concern. But yeah,
it's hard to find a negative with Tyreek Hill
given how explosive he is and what
the upside. I guess the big thing would be is does he
cross over the 10
touchdown threshold? Otherwise, it could
be hard to justify him in half PPR and full
PPR as a first-round pick.
Do you guys have Tyreek Hill as your number three wide receiver?
In PPR and half PPR, I'd rather have Julio.
Yep, agreed.
All right, fair enough.
That's Everybody is a Bust, part one.
We'll do part two on Tuesday's show.
We'll try to get through 24 guys.
If not, we'll have at least 20.
We'll start with DeAndre Hopkins and Nick Chubb, and then
we'll get into round two.
What's that about your flex team? Why do people hate it?
I don't know. I really don't get
it. Heath, you can explain. All right. So it's a
flex team. It was 18 rounds.
People hated that I took three quarterbacks.
Joe Burrow was my third quarterback. He was my
last pick before DST. So
I don't really see why that's a huge deal.
Yeah. Okay.
You start two running backs, three receivers and two flexes and a tight end. So you can start up to four running backs, up to five receivers, two tight ends. I had the first pick half PPR
McCaffrey. Then I really wanted Chris Goblin. He went one pick before me in round two. Uh,
Juju Smith Schuster was my pick. Then George Kittle,
Tyler Lockett, Marlon Mack, Brandon Cooks, Daryl Henderson, Darius Slayton, Matt Ryan.
So my starting lineup is Matt Ryan, McCaffrey and Singletary, Juju, Lockett, and Cooks.
And then I have Kittle at tight end.
And my two flexes are Marlon Mack.
And I would guess week one,
I'm probably going Darius Slayton.
Oh, he's playing Pittsburgh.
But like Darius Slayton or Daryl Henderson.
And then I have some shot, you know,
AJ Dillon, Josh Kelly.
Hopefully they turn into something.
LaVisca Chenault, Reggie Bonifone to handcuff McCaffrey.
And I have Baker Mayfield and Joe Burrow.
I am happy with the team.
I don't really know why people don't like it.
I didn't say I didn't like it. You gave me, I think, a B-.
That's a pretty good grade, Adam.
That's above average.
But the thing is, you are gifted.
And I am in a league with Jamie right now
where I was gifted the same thing.
You were gifted Christian McCaffrey.
You get the best... You should get an A.
It kind of looks like maybe you went on auto draft in the second half of the draft.
Why? The problem is not Joe Burrow in round 18.
The problem is Baker Mayfield. Taking a second quarterback would have made sense, but you
threw away the Baker Mayfield pick. Well, I didn't know Joe Burrow was going to be there in round 18.
Baker Mayfield was my 14th round pick.
And I don't think you have very good prospects
for having good flexes very deep into the season.
Yeah.
I mean, look, if I didn't take Kittle
and I had a crappier tight end,
then I could have had a better flex.
I could have had Mike Evans there. Well, have had, you know, Mike Evans there.
Well, you're probably going to make the playoffs.
You've got Christian McCaffrey.
Like, they gave you a playoff spot.
But you just didn't rush your league like you should have.
Here's the one pick I regret.
Justin Jefferson in round 11.
I should have taken Chase Edmonds,
who could be a total zero,
but could also win you the league if Kenyon Drake gets hurt.
Kenyon Drake has never really had a big workload
over a full season.
I also didn't like your 6, 7, 8 picks,
I don't think.
I can understand that.
You didn't have a chance to get Chase Edmonds.
When they come back, no, you're right. It was going the other way.
Marlon Mack at the end of round 6,
that was right after Ronald Jones.
Brandon Cook, you don't like Brandon Cook's there? Round 7? First end of round six. That was right after Ronald Jones. Brandon Cook.
You don't like Brandon Cook's there?
Round seven?
First pick round seven?
It's okay.
It just feels a little early.
The next two wide receivers.
I could have taken Michael Gallup.
I get that.
He took Cook's over Marvin Jones.
I know you don't like that one.
You took Cook's over Michael Gallup?
I did, yeah.
That was a mistake.
May have been.
I had a little bit of regret. I was actually going to take Gallup. That's where I took. May have been. I had a little bit of regret. I was actually going to take Gallup.
That's where I took Deshaun Watson.
I had a little bit of regret.
But the next wide receiver was Christian Kirk,
then Marvin Jones, then Deontay Johnson.
So I don't feel bad.
You skipped Edelman, too.
Oh, and Edelman, yeah.
Damn light right in my eye.
And then Daryl Henderson, I like more than...
Whatever.
I think he's specified.
I like Daryl Henderson, but you took him where?
Right after
Kerryon Johnson and Matt Breida.
The next running backs off the board were
Phillip Lindsay and Latavius Murray.
So again, I have no regrets there.
End of round eight.
It's a good team. Mine's better.
Jamie's team.
Kamara, Aaron Jones.
That was interesting that you went with Aaron Jones
in the second round, by the way.
I moved him up following the lack of offseason.
I can't keep saying that these veterans are going to benefit
and not give him credit, too.
With AJ Dillon, probably going to be a little bit sluggish.
So I took him from the early part of round three
and put him back in the back end of round two.
Kamara, Aaron Jones, DJ Moore, Jonathan Taylor.
Jamie had the fourth pick, by the way.
In case I didn't say that.
Terry McLaurin, Will Fuller,
Deshaun Watson, Tariq Cohen,
Phillip Lindsey, Anthony Miller,
Blake Jarwin eventually,
Jared Goff as your quarterback.
Oh, backup quarterback to Deshaun Watson.
Okay, so Jamie's starting lineup
is Deshaun Watson, Kamara. Jamie's starting lineup is Deshaun Watson,
Kamara, and Aaron Jones.
Three receivers are DJ Moore, Terry McLaurin, and Will Fuller.
Tight end is Blake Jarwin.
Flexes, Jonathan Taylor, Tariq Cohen, Anthony Miller,
Alan Lazard, Phillip Lindsay.
Yeah, you do have a better team than I do.
It's just like if Jamie would have had the gift that you got and then made all those picks after round eight that he made,
everybody would just give up.
Okay.
Well, I mean, look, I would rather have Daryl Henderson
than Tariq Cohen in a half PPR league, Personally, I'd rather take a shot at Daryl Henderson being in every down bear of 15 touchback.
OK, so there's that.
Jamie took Blake Jarwin really 12th round.
I have George Kittle, so let's not forget about that advantage.
Let's see what other picks Dariusarius Slayton versus Phillip Lindsey?
I'd much rather have Lindsey.
Why?
Slayton's probably going to be on the waiver wire week three.
What are you talking about?
He got a 9% target share when everyone was open.
He was a rookie.
He was a rookie.
All of those guys are still there.
Yeah, but Golden Tate is...
I think it's like, honestly...
On the decline.
So this was the turn where Adam started to really piss me off
because I took Tariq Cohen and I was like, you know, I'm going to take one of Henderson or Lindsay.
That was my choice. And I wanted Henderson because at that point it would have been my
fifth running back and clearly the upside. I agree with Adam. I don't know about three,
three Cohen and half PPR, but I see where he's coming from. I think if Henderson hits and Lindsay
stuck behind Melvin Gordon, you'd much rather Henderson. So for me, that was the thing. I said,
you know, when, when he took Henderson, I'm like, okay, I got to pivot a little bit.
I need a fourth receiver.
Slayton makes a lot of sense.
Again, similar concept.
If he hits, you're in great shape.
I was going to make that type of move.
And so he made that turn.
I was like, you bleeper.
Yeah, it was fun.
And then I knew I got him on Jared Goff.
So when I took Goff, but he did it to me the round before
when he took Josh Kelly,
because I was another guy that I was like,
okay, I want to swing for the fences type of player.
And he also took AJ Dillon.
I'm like, okay, it's round 12,
not a bad move to maybe handcuff Aaron Jones here.
Let me make that pick.
So he takes Dillon and Kelly with that swing.
I was like, God, man, you're killing me here.
All right, well, thank you.
I'm glad somebody liked those picks.
But look, this was a
industry analyst draft. Quarterbacks
went very late. Lamar Jackson and Mahomes went
in round three. But the running
backs, I thought Fournette and Gurley going in the first two
rounds was very interesting.
DJ Moore fell to round three
to Jamie. I don't know how far he would have fallen, but
again, like he's Chris Godwin going
23rd, DJ Moore going
28th or something like that
later than what
we see typically in our drafts, I'd say.
But that tells you with... You're going to
see this a lot, I think, probably more so in industry drafts,
but one, two, three, four, five,
five wide receivers
in the first 22 picks.
Well, the draft that Jamie and I are in right now,
I'm getting ready to pick at the end of round in the first 22 picks? Well, the draft that Jamie and I are in right now,
I'm getting ready to pick at the end of round four,
the four or five turn.
I got gifted Christian McCaffrey as well.
Adam Thielen, Calvin Ridley, and Tyler Lockett are all still available.
Are you kidding?
I mean, I had Lockett.
That's full PPR.
But Ridley and Thielen went earlier.
That's wild.
So who are you going to take?
Ridley, right? I'll probably take Ridley and Thielen went earlier. That's wild. So who are you going to take? Ridley, right?
I'll probably take Ridley.
But I'm not sure.
There's still one guy to pick before me.
I'm hoping he takes one of those wide receivers.
Would you take both?
The other guy that's still there
and he's like the only running back left
that I think should have been taken is Le'Veon Bell.
And so like round five, I'll probably take Le'Vevy on bell in a ppr league it's funny you mentioned bell i struggled with bell in this draft in in the flex draft um he
because uh he went right before me in round four yeah and i was like i can't pass on round four i
don't i i think i made it clear i'm not a big levy on bell guy but with the way running back was going
like he went right before in round four and at that point it would have been my third running back which was the direction I was going
because at the time uh I was glad that uh Steve Gardner of USA Today took Devante Parker in round
four because that's not a pick I would have made um I was actually hoping for DJ Chark to come back
to me in round five because I knew Adam would take Tyler Lockett and so uh uh Pat Mayo took
Le'Veon Bell right before me I was like like, okay, thank you for taking the headache away from me
that I didn't have to make.
But as a third running back, it would have been fine.
Well, as an example of how much everyone has just agreed
to hate Le'Veon Bell this year,
the last three running backs taken in this draft,
Raheem Mostert, David Montgomery, and Mark Ingram.
Yeah, that didn't happen.
In a full PPR draft.
PPR, wow.
Wow.
Well, look, Jamie, you said you knew
I was going to take Lockett.
I wasn't going to take Lockett
until every other analyst
in the league
told me to take Lockett.
Also, the best part
of the draft
was the pizza I had.
My God,
that delicious pizza.
And then I asked everybody,
you order a pie,
how many slices do you eat?
Jake Sealy said like two or three.
And I was like, God, that is weak.
Everybody got on him for that.
But Jake, thank you for organizing the Flex Leagues
and thank you for inviting me back.
We were on Zoom and Adam texted me.
He goes, I'm going to try not to speak.
And then Jamie said, me too.
And then I just derailed the conversation with pizza talk.
And I just want you all to know,
you might think my team sucks,
but I won the Flex League.
I lost in the finals two years ago,
and I won last year.
I won the consolation bracket,
but I still won.
I won something.
So that is all you need to know.
Everyone is a bust part two coming up on Tuesday
for Jamie and for Heath.
I'm out.
Talk to you later.