Fantasy Football Today - Justify It! Make Your Case For Hurts Over Mahomes and Allen, Anthony Richardson in Round 5, & More! (05/08 Fantasy Football Podcast)

Episode Date: May 8, 2023

The FFT Crew justifies selections from our recent PPR mock draft! But first, we dive into the latest news from around the league (3:40). Then, the gang discusses round 3 quarterbacks and if this is th...e right spot for them (16:00). Next, 2023 rookies Jahmyr Gibbs (27:25) and Jordan Addison (36:55), go off the board early and wrap up our draft picks. Finally, we answer your emails! (44:15) Follow our FFT team on Twitter: @FFToday, @AdamAizer, @JameyEisenberg, @daverichard, @heathcummingssr, @ctowerscbs Follow the brand new FFT TikTok account: https://www.tiktok.com/@fftoday Watch FFT on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/fantasyfootballtoday Get 20% off Fantasy Football Today merch: https://store.cbssports.com/collections/fantasy-football-today%20?utm_source=podcast-apple-com&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=buy-our-merch&utm_content=fantasy-football-collection Join our Facebook group https://www.facebook.com/groups/FantasyFootballToday/ Sign up for the FFT newsletter https://www.cbssports.com/newsletter You can listen to Fantasy Football Today on your smart speakers! Simply say "Alexa, play the latest episode of the Fantasy Football Today podcast" or "Hey Google, play the latest episode of the Fantasy Football Today podcast." To hear more from the CBS Sports Podcast Network, visit https://www.cbssports.com/podcasts/ To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Kick off an exciting football season with BetMGM, an official sportsbook partner of the National Football League. Yard after yard, down after down, the sportsbook born in Vegas gives you the chance to take action to the end zone and celebrate every highlight reel play. And as an official sportsbook partner of the NFL, BetMGM is the best place to fuel your football fandom on every game day. With a variety of exciting features, BetMGM offers you plenty of seamless ways to jump straight onto the gridiron and to embrace peak sports action. Ready for another season of gridiron glory? What are you waiting for?
Starting point is 00:00:38 Get off the bench, into the huddle, and head for the end zone all season long. Visit BetMGM.com for terms and conditions. Must be 19 years of age or older. Ontario only. Please gamble responsibly. Gambling problem? For free assistance, call the Connex Ontario helpline
Starting point is 00:00:54 at 1-866-531-2600. BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario. What does possible sound like for your business? It's having the spend to power your scale with no preset spending limit. Redefine possible with Business Platinum. That's the powerful backing of American Express. Terms and conditions apply.
Starting point is 00:01:16 Visit amex.ca slash business platinum. This is Fantasy Football Today from CBS Sports. What a play! Can you believe this? I know I can. It's time to dominate your fantasy league. Off to the races, and he stays on his feet. He's just going to go the distance.
Starting point is 00:01:37 Now, here's some combination of Adam, Dave, Jamie, and Heath. Here I am with Jamie and Heath on this Monday afternoon to discuss some, I don't know, controversial picks. And I'm going to make these guys justify it. I'm Adam Azer, Jamie Eisenberg, and Heath Cummings are here. We're going to just go over some of the things that we did not, that Jamie and Heath and Dave did not talk about on Thursday. Thank you guys for stepping up. Jamie, thank you for filling in. How we doing?
Starting point is 00:02:03 I went on Tron. You like it? Yeah. Have you been? Not yet. No. Oh, it's really fast. It's really fast. I actually had somebody tweet me last week. I'm going to have to make sure that I put the link of this episode. They actually tweeted me and said, would you please go ride Tron and then talk about it on the podcast? I need to know how good it is. So you did it. Yeah, it was actually like Space Mountain better. I forgot how awesome Space Mountain was, but Tron is over really quickly.
Starting point is 00:02:35 It's very short. It's fast in two ways. You just go from zero to 60 almost instantly, and it's pretty awesome. And I've never, who who has been in a roller coaster like that where you're basically on your stomach in a motorcycle uh so that was interesting it was very fun and uh yeah but it was very quick that was my only i guess not even a complaint just the only thing bad about it is it's over before you know it but it it was awesome. So if you're in Orlando, check out Tron. I do like, though, that you are back in the studio.
Starting point is 00:03:12 And the last week when Adam was in the studio, he was dressed in a button-down shirt, clean-shaven. I believe he was wearing makeup, too, if I'm not mistaken. No. Nope. You look like you were in makeup. Now he's back back again As you see A little dressed down
Starting point is 00:03:28 Yeah, I'm wearing a t-shirt I put on my collared shirt It was really wrinkled I was like, forget it I'm just wearing a t-shirt Alright, listen First thing I want to ask Jamie, have we ever met?
Starting point is 00:03:38 You drafted for me last week With my name Which is a bit, you know I let you do it Big responsibility Do you even know me? Joe Burrow In round three with my name, which is a big, you know, I let you do it. Big responsibility. Do you even know me? Joe Burrow in round three, one pick after Hertz, Mahomes, Allen.
Starting point is 00:03:52 You gave me Burrow there. Heath criticized my pick, and I didn't even make it, and that's your fault? I can't believe you did that. Do you know anything about me? Well, as I explained, I know you like Joe Burrow, and given that there was a run on quarterbacks, I didn't want you to miss out on getting a guy that you, I think, are fond of. So I was trying to do justice by you.
Starting point is 00:04:15 So I apologize if that's not the move that you would have made. I would say, I mean, I think it's clear that Jamie doesn't know you as well as you know Jamie. He's not looked through the crack of the bathroom stall. You're a little more intimate knowledge of us than we do of you. That's true. I guess. I guess he has never seen my rankings. All right.
Starting point is 00:04:35 Well, I would not have taken him there. I may have taken Joe Burrow in the fourth round, but not in the third round. One thing to promote real quick, then we'll get into the news items here, and we'll get into the justify it segment of the show. Theefa champions league on paramount plus is down to the final four teams and two epic semi-final matchups defending champs real madrid take on tournament favorite manchester city in a rematch of last year's thrilling semi-final plus it's a clash of italian titans as uh inter squares off against ac milan in a battle for city bragging rights. Find out which clubs will reach the ultimate goal in soccer's greatest yearly competition. Stream every Champions League semifinal match live exclusively on Paramount+.
Starting point is 00:05:14 Try it free at ParamountPlus.com slash live sports. And hopefully I did not butcher any of those soccer team names. News and notes. Chicago offensive coordinator, Luke gets, he said that Justin Fields is light years ahead of where he was going into the 2022 season. And one of the things he's been better at is, is his footwork.
Starting point is 00:05:35 And that's something also is reading about Sam Howell and Washington being pretty high on Sam Howell and ESPN.com article about that. And he said, you know, the footwork was something that he had to learn too. So it's not something that we probably see with our eyes when we're watching football, but it's a big part of the game. And these young quarterbacks getting better there. So Justin Fields light years ahead of where he was this time a year ago. I just thought it was interesting.
Starting point is 00:05:56 Jamie didn't want me to bring this up and to bring it up. Lamar Jackson. He said, they asked why he made his trade request, why he demanded a trade. He said it was just a negotiating ploy. He did it just to get the ball moving, basically, on the contract. So that all's well that ends well. Sounds like he acted like he was his own agent. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:06:13 Did pretty well for himself. He did. A lot of agents, according to reports, very praiseworthy of the job Lamar Jackson did for himself. Nice. Nick Kosmider of The Athletic covers the Broncos.
Starting point is 00:06:24 He thinks that, Heath, what do you make of this? Denver head coach Sean Payton will have a very specific role for rookie wide receiver Marvin Mims, even if it's not a high volume role. What does that suggest to you? That the Broncos traded up
Starting point is 00:06:38 into the second round to draft a wide receiver that they thought was good. I think he will have a role even if he doesn't earn a large volume role, maybe, is the way to look at it. I didn't take it as he won't have a high volume role, but if Sutton and Judy remain the one and two,
Starting point is 00:06:56 they have something specific that they have for Mims to do. Maybe the KJ Hamler role, which KJ Hamler was hardly on the field enough to say exactly what his role was, but I would think the deep ball specialist. Mims did not get drafted in the draft that we did last week, but Cortland Sutton was a chafee tee. Thomas Schaefer picked him in round 11.
Starting point is 00:07:19 Jamie, that was, I thought, pretty late for Sutton. I wasn't expecting him to go 124th overall. What did you think of that? It's great value. And look, it's the first draft we did post-NFL draft. So it was, I think a lot of people are still just processing information and trying to figure out, okay, where some of these guys fit. For a player like Sutton and factoring in Russell Wilson, the negative side,
Starting point is 00:07:44 also you have to factor in Sean Payton, the positive side, you know, just what changes are going to take place in Denver, not to go down this path again about what Marvin Mims will do to impact the Broncos guys. But I do think that it is going to impact these guys in some way, whether it's Judy Sutton, Dulcich, you know, Patrick, whoever it's going to, you know, hurt, it's going to hurt. But also I think, you know, from, from Sean Payton's Judy, Sutton, Dulcich, Patrick, whoever it's going to hurt, it's going to hurt. But also, I think from Sean Payton's perspective, he signed a pretty significant contract to be there.
Starting point is 00:08:10 And so whether this is a 2023 draft pick or a 2024 draft pick, essentially where they're going to have him play a bigger role next year, that could just be something that you're looking at. But yeah, for Sutton in round 11, that's just great value for somebody who probably playing for a new deal you know may still be auditioning for a new team if they're out of it you know by the trade deadline he could be shipped to another team you know mid-season so we still could see that in play as well so uh but yeah I think Sutton is is still in play for fantasy managers as a number three receiver to get him that late probably as a four or five is pretty good we uh there was one more piece of Justin Fields news as well, Adam. He, I believe, received his degree from The Ohio State University. Nice. Hey, congratulations.
Starting point is 00:08:50 A couple other rookie items here. Josh Downs, UNC wide receiver, now with the Colts. He had a great rookie camp, according to Kevin Bowen of 1075. 1075. The fan, Josh Downss had a great rookie camp. And Sean McVay said that rookie running back Zach Evans has a nice skill set that compliments Cam Akers.
Starting point is 00:09:13 Okay. And the Jets signed Randall Cobb. And they are apparently going to keep Corey Davis on the team. Heath Garrett Wilson went in the middle of round two in the draft last week. Was that too early? It was before the Randall Cobb news, which of course has no effect. But it was also before the news about Corey Davis staying on the team.
Starting point is 00:09:31 He's got that size that I guess Robert Sala wants on the squad. So Garrett Wilson went 18th overall, one pick before Amonra St. Brown and a bunch of running backs. Yeah, I can't take him ahead of Amonra St. Brown or A.J. Brown. I wouldn't take him ahead of T. Higgins Brown or A.J. Brown. I wouldn't take him ahead of T. Higgins or Jalen Waddell or Devontae Smith. I've got Garrett Wilson at 24th. I think he has the upside to justify that pick. I think he has the upside to be worth a first-round pick this year. But I'm just enough nervous about where the Aaron Rodgers targets are going to go and the, I don't know, 15%, 20% chance that this is just a complete
Starting point is 00:10:06 disaster. Okay. Let's, uh, let's play justify it. I looked at some, some picks, some trends sort of in this draft and going to make you guys justify it, even if you didn't make the picks, but first things first, let's talk about the dolphins passing game. So Jalen Waddle and Tyreek Hill, both top 24 picks. Hill goes seventh overall. Jalen Waddle goes 22nd overall. Tua Tungavailoa went 114th overall. So justify, Jamie, and honestly, he was QB 10,
Starting point is 00:10:37 but he was so far back. He was 40 picks after QB 9, which was Trevor Lawrence. Justify believing in Hill and Waddle, but being so concerned about to his injuries basically, and not, and not knocking the wide receivers. Well, I think the, um, first off, you know, once you get past and we'll probably see this even in non, you know, fantasy analyst drafts, youantasy analyst drafts, the second and third tier quarterbacks are going to fall. So once you get past, I think, the top six probably,
Starting point is 00:11:12 with Burrow, Lamar Jackson, Justin Fields being four, five, and six in some order behind Mahomes, Allen, and Hertz, then I think that next group you could say Lawrence, Richardson. So I think Tua's going to go anywhere between probably 10 and 15, depending on how you view him at quarterback. So he's going to definitely go later than the run on quarterbacks. So factor that into the equation. But I think you're hoping that he's going to stay healthy.
Starting point is 00:11:38 There's no guarantee he's going to stay healthy. So if he does stay healthy, then this is another incredible steal in this draft, in any draft where he's going to go. But if he does get hurt, that's kind of where you know, if he does stay healthy, then this is another incredible steal in this draft, you know, in any draft where he's going to go. But if he does get hurt, you know, that's kind of where you're, OK, did I make a huge mistake? Now, as I said, when we recap this draft that, you know, Dave was talking about taking Jalen Waddell, that the backup play last year, you know, he had Teddy Bridgewater in and out because of injuries and Skylar Thompson. I just don't know if he was ready for the job. Hopefully Mike White is better than both those guys. And if that's the case, then you get still great production from Tyreek Hill, but hopefully great production from Jalen Wallow as well.
Starting point is 00:12:10 So maybe the backup situation is a little bit better, but I mean, clearly you have to hope that Tua is, is playing at what was his peak last year, pretty close to it, to keep those guys afloat to where the level of where they're being drafted. Yeah. What do you think, Ethan? I mean, should we be, should we be fading those two dolphins receivers with the idea that they have? I mean, I don't believe we should because I don't think two is necessarily injury
Starting point is 00:12:36 prone. But that depends how you've, you know, how people view injuries. But what do you think? I was going to say that it was a good thing that you gave that one to Jamie to justify because I have two QB eight ahead of Trevor Lawrence. So I think the problem is there that two is going too late. Okay. Okay.
Starting point is 00:12:54 Let's justify this one. Jamie, this was your pick. CeeDee Lamb ahead of Devante Adams. Adams had scored 34 more points, two more points per game than CeeDee Lamb. They both played 17 games. Lamb did have seven more catches, but more targets, more yards,
Starting point is 00:13:09 more touchdowns for Devontae Adams. You made this pick in the second round. Justify it. Lamb ahead of Adams. Yeah, I have it ranked that way, so I wasn't concerned about the pick. But I'm leaning toward youth. I'm leaning toward I still have a better quarterback. Maybe the situation is not as good just because of what Mikeccarthy said that they're not going to throw as much but i do think again as i as i explained that mccarthy tried to walk that back after the first time he said it
Starting point is 00:13:33 so um i think both these guys are going to lead their team in targets i think both their guys are going to be you know absolute superstars it's just a matter of you know one guy is you know 30 plus one guy is you know entering his prime, entering a contract situation, as they just picked up his fifth-year option, or I believe they did. But I think Sean Lamb has got the ability to be not to the level of what Devontae Adams was at his best, but in that next tier,
Starting point is 00:14:00 where I think Adams is going to start to fade a little bit. So this is one where one guy on the rise, I think one guy on the decline. not that he's going to decline to the point where he can't be a still great fantasy option because I do think he's worth taking the second round. But I think CD Lam's trajectory is a little bit better for me than where Adams is right now. Yeah, I've got Adams just slightly ahead in the projections, but I had Lam higher as well. I'd prefer to draft Lam. It's the age thing. I think Lamb was at a 28% target share last year.
Starting point is 00:14:27 I wouldn't be surprised with McCarthy fully taking over the offense if that goes over 30% for Lamb this year in terms of target share. Yeah, I guess the counter would be Brandon Cooks is more target competition than Dalton Schultz. Because I think Schultz was second on the team in receiving last year.
Starting point is 00:14:44 I don't know that that's true, but Schultz was second on the team in receiving last year. No, I don't know that that's true. But, I mean, Schultz was second on the team in receiving. I know what I'm saying is I think that's – I don't like to expect bounce backs from receivers that are running Cook's age. We've talked about that before. And he was not particularly good last year. I think Nico Collins is better than him last year. I think also, though though you look at it there probably is more target competition in dallas because they are talking up michael gallup again you know for whatever that's worth but a
Starting point is 00:15:13 year removed from his acl tear we'll see what they get out of their tight end position you know whether it's going to be ferguson or or schoonmaker schoonmaker right um the rookie that they they drafted um you know and and still maybe jaylen tolbert has has a role obviously again brandon cooks is there so there's there's moving parts in dallas plus you have you know a different running game you know just without zeke there so will they put more on tony pollard or as you know mccarthy said it's just about you know how the ball is distributed differently you know is more in the passing game, short area throws, as opposed to some of those inside runs that they were doing?
Starting point is 00:15:47 Who knows? It's all going to be split up. But I think if you just want to break it down as simple as you can, both of the alphas on their team, for me it's age, and the other part of it is quarterback. And Dak Prescott is a much better scenario for Adam, for Lamb than Garoppolo is for Adam. All right. Let's justify where the quarterbacks were drafted.
Starting point is 00:16:10 The first four. Well, I'm in the first three, you know, Jamie just didn't know anything about me and drafted Joe Burrow a little bit earlier than I would have, but at least those first three in the middle of round three, Jalen hurts 29,
Starting point is 00:16:21 Patrick, the homes 30, taking them in round four, it would have been like five picks apart. Yeah, but I would have gotten a, you know, who did I take in round four? Who did you take for me? Aaron Jones?
Starting point is 00:16:30 The end of round three is basically the beginning of round four. Right, and as Heath said, if we had done it differently, he thinks Aaron Jones should be a round three pick. I don't know who I would have taken if not Burrow there. I probably would have taken DeAndre Hopkins
Starting point is 00:16:42 in round three. He went beforeAndre Hopkins in round three. He went before my next pick in round four. He went 37th overall. Anyway, so Hertz 29, Mahomes 30, Allen 32, Burrow 33. Let's just assume it was those top three. And you guys already discussed the order of it on Thursday's show. But I thought we were on round two with these guys. I thought they were going to be round two picks.
Starting point is 00:17:04 I feel like they were. I was trying to look it up. I couldn't do it. I feel like they were round two picks in our post-free agency mock draft. Maybe I'm wrong about that. Not at all. No? No, just the three of them.
Starting point is 00:17:14 No. Okay. One or two got into it, but yeah. All right. Well, I'm still surprised that they made it to 29 overall. So you're talking about over Nick Chubb and derrick henry and jaylen waddle travis etn t higgins mark andrews uh davante smith chris olave that was dave's pick at 27 remandre stevenson all these guys were taken before those quarterbacks so justify it
Starting point is 00:17:35 heath why didn't these guys go in round two there's their studs and they're proven studs because they are all so three so close together that if you are in the second half of round two, you can feel pretty comfortable. One of those guys is going to be there early in round three. So you take your favorite running back or your wide receiver, and then if two of them get taken, you take whichever of the threes left. It would be different, and I think people viewed this way last year, that Josh Allen was kind of in a tier of his own, and then it was Mahomes and the rest of the guys because Allen had been QB1 two years in a row but I think right now we view Hurts, Mahomes, Allen in whatever order you want to put them in as a real top tier and so if you're at the end of round two and all three of them are still there there's no reason to take one until round three. Is that how you saw it Jamie? I mean I have a different view of this because I'm not going to be all of a sudden rushing to take one until round three is that how you saw it jamie i mean i i have
Starting point is 00:18:25 a different view of this because i'm not going to be all of a sudden rushing to take one of these quarterbacks that's just not the way i'm going to draft and i know last year was a little different in terms of only four guys going over 25 points per game with the guy that you took fourth being the low one at 25 but you know burrow allen, and Mahomes averaging 25-plus with the other three closer to 30, clearly. But I think we're going to get a bounce-back season from the position. And so I think you have Lamar Jackson in this incredible situation now, has a chance to be 25-plus. I think Justin Fields, with what he's going to do with his legs,
Starting point is 00:18:59 has a chance to be 25-plus. I think Trevor Lawrence is going to take a huge leap. He has a chance to be 25-plus. And then maybe you get the one that we're, I don't want to say not expecting, but maybe not counting on it, at least me not counting on it. And Anthony Richardson or Tua staying healthy are one of these type of guys that has that type of leap. And so for me, I'm going to wait. So no, I would not draft these guys in round two. I do think though, if you're at the back end of round two, and clearly again, as we've said many a time over the years in the show, that if you know,
Starting point is 00:19:28 you're not getting these players back and clearly you're not going to get a quarterback of that caliber at the four or five swing, as opposed to the two, three swing. And you just don't love anybody there. Then you should pull the trigger on it. You know, so, uh, round three is where I had these guys ranked, you know, I, again, I'll probably be one of the lower people in the industry on it, but I'm, I'm still fine with fine with it i think again the position will get not watered down to where the talent pool is a little bit more equal but uh we will get probably as we saw two years ago you know more guys in that 25 plus range than we saw last year anthony richardson i know you guys talked about it on thursday but that draft pick, that was bonkers.
Starting point is 00:20:06 That was completely bonkers. I don't know. Oh. I just, how? So he went ahead of Justin Herbert. He went two picks ahead of Justin Herbert. Went ahead of Trevor Lawrence. Not Lamar Jackson, though, right?
Starting point is 00:20:22 No. No. Okay, no, he went around after that. Yeah, so he went 60th. I don't think he went ahead of anybody that has more upside than him. I mean, you don't think, I mean, Justin Herbert was QB2 in 2021. Maybe he was QB3. I think he was QB2, right?
Starting point is 00:20:39 I mean, how can we not say that Justin Herbert is more upside than Anthony Richards? Wasn't that the down year for quarterback scoring at the top? No, last year was the down year for quarterback scoring. No, they were around 30, the guys at the top. It was down for the bottom half of the top 12 last year. Let's see. 2021.
Starting point is 00:20:57 Actually, the fifth quarterback in total points averaged 20 points per game. Yeah, okay. Herbert averaged 26.2 points per game. He threw 38 touchdowns. So that's about 85% of what Mahomes, Allen, Lamar, Hertz have shown the ability to do. Or maybe 90% of Hertz. Right, but I mean, I think...
Starting point is 00:21:22 They have a big difference. And I think Richardson has the 30-point upside. I don't know. I mean, okay, but in 2020, Aaron Rodgers averaged 29.9 points per game. You know, the Lamar Jackson-Patrick Wilhelm seasons from, what, five and six years ago, or four and five years ago, sorry, whatever it was, I don't think we can expect that from anyone, right? Lamar Jackson did it in 2019, 32.5 fantasy points.
Starting point is 00:21:45 2018, Patrick Holmes is 32.2 fantasy points. We're not really expecting that. I mean, I understand that they've done that before, but I can't really sit there and say that's their upside. That's probably going to be their best season. Well, yeah, but I just... But Holmes was at 29 last year. Yeah, but okay, fine.
Starting point is 00:22:01 So 20, right, that's fine. So will you think that Richardson can get to 29? Mahomes threw 41 touchdowns. I just don't see how Richardson is more upside than Justin Herbert in a six-point-per-passing touchdown league. There's more to the fantasy quarterback play than rushing. I think, but it's, if you're just using the word upside, Richardson has more upside.
Starting point is 00:22:25 Because if he does throw for 3,500 yards and runs for 1,000 yards, which would be amazing and probably hard to expect, but as we see these guys continue to evolve, again, what did Fields have last year? 2,200 and 1,100 rushing? You know, so you start to maybe scale back one of the two numbers, you know, from what I said, 35 and 1,000. You know, so let's say it's 3,000 and 1,000. You know, is that crazy? Okay, I guess I'd have to do math now, but if somebody wants to do this, 3,000 and 1,000, how does that compare to 5,000 passing yards
Starting point is 00:23:11 and 350 rushing yards? Because that's definitely within Herbert's upside. And then it's going to come down to touchdowns and interceptions, and Herbert's going to smash Richardson there. And I just, to smash Richardson there. And I just, I don't know. I can't. Just for a guy who's such a raw prospect who had the, you know,
Starting point is 00:23:36 a 53% completion rate for him to come in and be a great quarterback. I think it's very likely. His floor or his most likely outcome are way behind Herbert's. But even to take that word, though, to be a great quarterback, I think he just has to be a great fantasy player you know because he could still be a 50 completion guy and still get to those numbers you know as ugly as it may look at times you know because field struggled as a passer and still was great as a rusher you know so he doesn't have he doesn't have elite talent around him um but he does have the right coach you know a guy that just got an MVP caliber season out of Jalen Hurts and Shane Steichen.
Starting point is 00:24:06 And I, I think it's just like, I would take Herbert personally. I think he's would as well, you know, but, um, it's just a matter of when, when you, when you have to attach the word to something and you're attaching the word upside to it. If he hits all of those check marks, which is unrealistic, you know, you just have to factor that in but if he does you know if he does have that lamar jackson second season performance if he does have that patrick mahomes first year starting season performance you know those things are are anomalies for a reason but if they do happen then you're going to be thrilled about it so you know i understand what jacob gibbs was doing when he drafted him again picking on an end and not having the opportunity to probably get him coming back you know that's a gamble um But I think Lawrence has more upside. I think Herbert has more upside.
Starting point is 00:24:48 So I would take those guys. But it's a matter of if you think that player, forget about who it is, has that type of ability, then you've got to buy into it and just hope it's going to hit. And at the position that we're talking about, there's so many good fallback options, especially if you know who you're drafting with. And Jacob knows that we're not all going to take two quarterbacks. Are there that many good fallback options, especially if you know who you're drafting with. And Jacob knows that we're not all going to take two quarterbacks.
Starting point is 00:25:05 So are there that many good fallback options though? Cause there weren't last year. Yeah. Well, you say that though, but Jared Goff was, was a good fallback option. Gino Smith was a good fallback option.
Starting point is 00:25:15 Great. You're talking about when you're, when you're talking about relative position, there were five guys that were over there, four guys that were over 25 points per game. So four people in your league were playing at a different level than everybody else. Everybody else is playing from that other pool. And while the averages for the season are a little different,
Starting point is 00:25:32 Justin Fields had that 6-7 game stretch where he was 25 plus. Geno Smith had that stretch where he was over 25. Derek Goff had a stretch where he was hot. So it's just a matter of you can do it at the right time and still be successful. Yeah, but you can say that. You can make that optimistic case. But you know that it was's just a matter of you can do it at the right time and still be successful. Yeah, but you know, but you can say that you can make that optimistic case, but you know that it was a bad year for quarterbacks. It absolutely wasn't bad. It wasn't.
Starting point is 00:25:51 But they were all bad. As I was saying, they were all bad. So it wasn't, you know, if you were streaming a quarterback, you weren't. The question you asked was, was there a fallback option? And we just have to look how they compared to the quarterbacks last year and tua geno smith um lawrence like there were lots of guys who ended up finishing as low-end starting quarterbacks who were drafted in the double-digit rounds yeah i know but but they didn't really help you win a fantasy league and they helped you a lot more than justin herbert did yeah justin herbert was a bust, absolutely.
Starting point is 00:26:26 But, I mean – I have it in front of me because I wrote this for the first bust column. So, Fields was the number six quarterback at points per game. His ADP on CBS was around 12. Tua's ADP was around 11. He was the number seven quarterback at points per game. Now, again, you're talking low points per game, 21.1 for Fields, 21.1 for Tua. Geno Smith finished eighth in points per game at 20.4, was not drafted. Jared Goff, I'm assuming, was in a similar range.
Starting point is 00:26:48 I don't know if I have that in front of me. No, I don't. You know, so. Yeah, okay. Honestly, this is like saying, Jamie, this is like saying, I drafted Kyle Pitts, who was a huge bust at tight end, but I streamed Tyler Higby, who was tight end six per game. I streamed, actually, no, that's overall. I streamed Tyler Higby, who was tight end six per game. I streamed – actually, no, that's overall.
Starting point is 00:27:06 I streamed Tyler Higby. I streamed Evan Ingram. I streamed David Njoku, tight end nine per game. I streamed Pat Farmer. Yeah, go ahead. And you're 100% right. It's a matter of how your roster build also comes into play here. So you took Kyle Pitts in the third round last year, him him busting justin herbert was probably a great example comparable you know because he
Starting point is 00:27:28 was drafted probably early especially based on you know adp from you know most draft when those guys bust it's hard to recover from that you know but at this position you know when you're talking about if jacob hits on his first five picks right and jacob's a smart fantasy player so you know let's assume that that's the case he whiffs in round six on on anthony richardson but the rest of his draft is good and now he's playing with geno smith or daniel jones or you know jared goff or one of these other guys and still getting to that 20 point number on average or maybe 22 23 you know on a good week and 18 or so on a bad week if the rest of his roster is fine then it's okay but if richardson hits then he's in a great spot.
Starting point is 00:28:06 It's a matter of cost, too. I would say that hardly anyone is going to hit on all four of their first four picks. Let's just go back and look at a fantasy draft. It just rarely happens. Final question here. Just give me real quick. He took Richardson's 60th overall. His next pick was 61.
Starting point is 00:28:23 But after that, Jacob Gibbs' next pick was 84. So Trevor Lawrence went 74th. And I referenced this earlier with Tua. And then 40 picks later, Tua went. So Jacob's next pick, 84 and 85, he took Khalil Herbert and James Cook. That was during this big gap where no quarterbacks were taken. If he didn't take Richardson at 60,
Starting point is 00:28:49 do you think Richardson would have been there at 84, 85? I don't know. I do, yes. I think he would have. Yeah, I think it would have been close. And I think I wouldn't bet on it either way. All right, guys, let's take a break here. Justify it. We got to pay the bills.
Starting point is 00:29:04 Let's take a break here, and we'll come back. We'll the bills. Let's take a break here and we'll come back. We'll talk about Jameer Gibbs, Isaiah Pacheco, Mike Williams. I got a lot more here, so we'll go a little rapid fire. We'll be right back on Fantasy Football today. Also, your emails, fantasyfootballatcbsi.com. That's coming up at the end of the show. Stick around. Whether in the game or in life, the right coverage can make all the difference.
Starting point is 00:29:23 Securian Canada gives you that coverage. For more than 65 years, Securian Canada has been helping Canadians build secure tomorrows. Their insurance solutions are designed to help protect you and your loved ones financially, giving you the peace of mind to focus on what truly matters. Find their products through banks, credit unions, and associations. Or visit SecurianCanada.ca. Securian Canada. insurance designed for life. Did you know 66% of utility damage is caused by not requesting a locate? Don't let your project
Starting point is 00:29:55 become part of this statistic. A quick locate request can save you from unexpected downtime, financial penalties, and keep you safe. Don't let avoidable damage cost you time and money. Welcome back, everybody. All right, justify it. Jameer Gibbs in round four, ahead of Damian Pierce, Joe Mixon, and Dalvin Cook. Jameer Gibbs in round four, PPR, ahead of Damian Pierce, Joe Mixon, and Dalvin Cook. Heath, justify it. Do I have to?
Starting point is 00:30:37 Would you have done that? No, I would not. The justification, though, would be that DeAndre Swift's role has been a top 15 worthy in fantasy football when he's been able to stay healthy. And we have reason to believe that Jameer Gibbs is better as a pass catcher already than DeAndre Swift is in the NFL. And the Lions just spent an insane amount of draft capital to take Gibbs, which should indicate that they're going to use him a lot. So if Gibbs could have Swift's role and stay healthy and be more efficient as a pass catcher, he's worth a fourth round pick.
Starting point is 00:31:17 I don't know if I asked you this yet, Jamie, but this reminds me, this Montgomery Gibbs thing reminds me a little bit of James Robinson, Travis Etvis etn from last year and you were the high guy on etn going into fantasy drafts um obviously we needed robinson to get traded but it just seemed like they eventually wanted to transition to etn uh do you see similarities uh what similarities do you see or how similar do you think these two situations are uh lions this year jaguars last year the only thing i would say it's not similar is because there's a new coat there was a new coaching staff coming into jacksonville that inherited that duo and they also didn't have the luxury of seeing travis etn play the year before so that's i think somewhat you know
Starting point is 00:32:01 comparable as you know nfl nfl because youFL because Gibbs is coming into his rookie season. But I could see a transition where Gibbs takes over everything or a good chunk of everything, not because of a trade, but just because he's a more explosive player than David Montgomery. But I think the Lions want to have a better version of what they had last year. And I think they went about trying to accomplish that, you know, and so they feel like David Montgomery is an upgrade over Jamal Williams, who they loved. I mean, you know, I think as a player and as a locker room presence,
Starting point is 00:32:33 they loved Jamal Williams and I think they were sad to see him go. There were reports about trying to resign him, you know, so had he been maybe a little bit cheaper than Montgomery and what he was asking for, I don't know what the know what those numbers were behind the scenes, but I think Montgomery is just a, hopefully in their minds, a younger version of it. And Jameer Gibbs is a healthier version of what DeAndre Swift could be. So the thing that makes me a little bit nervous about Jameer Gibbs is
Starting point is 00:32:58 everybody from our perspective, fantasy perspective, you know, I haven't heard a lot of this from an NFL perspective is, Oh, his catches in college were so impressive. He led Alabama reception. The last time we had a first round running back who was so good as a pass catcher. You remember who it was? Yeah. It's Clyde. Clyde Edwards. Who was 55 catches on that LSU offense. And granted it was different because everybody was catching pass on LSU
Starting point is 00:33:24 offense. So it's not, not because everybody was catching passes on LSU offense. So it's not the same. But that we're getting too a little bit enamored by what he can do as a pass catcher. He obviously can catch the football. There's no doubt about that. And I'm not saying he's comparable to Clyde. I'm just talking situation. So I'm just a little bit concerned that the Lions, they got him at 12.
Starting point is 00:33:42 They said they would have taken him at six. There's still a proven commodity in this backfield that may get all the touchdowns may not have the pass catching role that should be gibbs but they try to do that with swift last year and while he averaged 5.5 yards per carry and was explosive did all those things and i know health matters here but he just didn't you know necessarily do it when he was on the field consistently week in week out so uh gibbs in round four i don't mind it i'm always going to lean toward the younger player that has the more upside and i think he
Starting point is 00:34:10 does and and we discussed this that joe mixon if he stays on the bangles is not going around for you know that's the way that's happening fantasy round five he went yeah and and maybe the same for dalvin cook the pierce thing is a little bit interesting in this format because while i i think we all agree he's going to be the lead running back ahead of Devin Singletary and he should get the majority of touches, that doesn't necessarily mean that there's going to be a significant pass-catching role here. That doesn't mean that he's not going to lose enough touches by comparison to where he was a year ago because I do think Singletary is a much better number two running back than what they had last year. And he's also a guy that the same, I think, concerns have to carry over even to his sophomore season that he did not hold up after being a full-time guy. He was not a full-time guy at Florida in his collegiate career.
Starting point is 00:34:54 So can he do it over the course of a full season? So I don't mind Gibbs ahead of him. I would still take Pierce. But that's the one really that I think you can make a case for. All right, let's talk about Isaiah Pacheco because you guys did this draft basically as not long after Jarek McKinnon re-signed with the Chiefs. The legal news that happened, yes, that he was re-signed.
Starting point is 00:35:13 Yeah. So Pacheco went in round five, 55th overall. Round five actually had a lot of running backs. It was the three we just talked about, Pierce, Dalvin Cook, Joe Mixon. And then you had three non-running backs. And then Isaiah P we just talked about, Pierce, Dalvin Cook, Joe Mixon, and then you had three non-running backs, and then Isaiah Pacheco went. Justify it. Pacheco with his 13 catches last year, going ahead of Rashad White, Cam Akers, David Montgomery, and Javante Williams. Heath, do you want to justify this one? Isaiah Pacheco, 55th overall, ahead of Rashad White,
Starting point is 00:35:41 Cam Akers, David Montgomery, and Javante Williams? No. I think the justification would be it's a non-PPR league, and it was not. I would put Pacheco around round seven. I think I have him at RB 29-ish or 30-ish right now. I don't want to completely say that he doesn't have a chance to earn a larger role in the passing game in his second year. He might do that, but it should be the expectation that he's going to be sharing work on early downs and at least sharing work on passing downs.
Starting point is 00:36:14 And the Chiefs don't have a history since Patrick Mahomes got there of just handing the ball off to the same running back 15 times from inside the five-yard line to get him a lot of rushing touchdowns. So I think Pacheco is a flex unless he really does some things in camp and takes that passing game role that they brought McKinnon back for. How big of a deal was the re-signing of Jarek McKinnon, Jamie? I don't think it was a big deal because this is something I think that they've talked about and it was kind of expected. The thing where I think you've got to be excited about Pacheco and I generally agree with Heath,
Starting point is 00:36:49 but I think the thing we got to be excited about Pacheco is this is a very, very raw receiving core right now. You know, there's just so many ifs and they could be huge ifs from a potential standpoint. If Kadarius Toney plays a full season, if sky more takes a huge step you know if racy rice's or rajee rice however you say it um you know becomes you know a rookie sensation uh clearly right now it's travis kelsey and a lot of backup backup backup singers you know so um there's a lot of moving parts for a team that just won the super bowl and and granted it was not that different from a year ago but they did have miko harman for the majority or the majority of the first half of the season they had jud Mikko Hardman for the majority of the, or the majority of the first half of the season. They had Juju Smith-Schuster for the majority of the season.
Starting point is 00:37:27 Those are proven commodities. So maybe they do run the ball a little bit more to try and let's say, get to November, December, January. So the early part of the season, we could see that. And I think Heath alluded to this when we were breaking this draft down
Starting point is 00:37:39 that, you know, McKinnon is 31. And is he going to handle a heavy workload, even in the passing game early in the season to make sure he's fresh for November, December, and January, you know, McKinnon is 31. And is he going to handle a heavy workload, even in the passing game early in the season to make sure he's fresh for November, December, and January, you know? So, um, I don't think Clyde's going to be that much of a factor. I think they love what they have in Pacheco and the draft kind of told us that. So maybe there are a few more opportunities. Maybe
Starting point is 00:37:58 there is a few more opportunities in the passing game. So for me, I would start to look at him in round six. I do think round five is a little bit too rich. But, you know, again, if you have a feeling on somebody, he is right now in pencil one of their top offensive players. And so to say you're getting one of the top offensive players for the Chiefs, that's not a bad place to be, knowing how creative this offense has been and should continue to be. That's Isaiah Pacheco in round five before Rashad White, Cam Akers, David Montgomery, and Javante Williams.
Starting point is 00:38:26 All right, let's speed it up. Are you ready for Super Fast Justify It? All right, applause sign. Okay, Mike Williams, 69th overall. I know they drafted Quentin Johnston. Justify this, Heath. This is a guy two years ago when Justin Herbert was good, when Keenan Allen and Mike Williams were healthy. He was wide receiver 18 per game.
Starting point is 00:38:46 Now he's barely a sixth round pick toward the end of round six. Mike Williams, 69th overall in between two Steelers, George Pickens and Deontay Johnson. Yeah, I think this is just a little bit higher than I have Williams, but I am right in this range. He needs to go this high because he does have that upside to be a top 20 wide receiver, but he needs to go this low because there's enough concerns with the change in offensive coordinator and the draft selection of Quinton Johnston that his target share could be impacted from last year. So he is a boom or bust number three wide receiver. And would you take the Steelers guys or Mike Williams? In full PPR, I have the Steelers higher jamie steelers guys or mike williams i still have mike williams higher you know i'll see what happens come august but i still think quentin
Starting point is 00:39:31 johnson has a lot to prove to take mike williams off the field all right next up jamie justify it jordan addison in round seven ahead of tyler lockett michael pitman that one maybe surprised me a little bit he fell pretty far mich, Michael Pittman, into round seven. And Brandon Cooks. So Jordan Addison ahead of Tyler Lockett, Michael Pittman, and Brandon Cooks. Yeah, I know. With all the conversation, and we let off the show talking about this. We even talked to Joe Pisapia on the other show that you missed
Starting point is 00:39:59 about Justin Jefferson slipping from the number one spot. There's a lot of expectations for Jordan Addison right now. I think he's a super talented player. I think he's going to make a significant impact. But is he going to command that much more from a target perspective than what Adam Thielen had? He had 107 targets to be second on the team. And so, no, I don't think this is the right spot for Jordan Addison.
Starting point is 00:40:20 I think as we see the typical route for the rookie wide receivers to have success, most of them come in and eventually become the number one guy. He's not going to become the number one guy. He might not even be second on the team in targets if TJ Hawkinson continues to command a significant amount based on what he did last year. And so some people think even KJ Osborne might have the first half of the season better situation than Jordan Addison. We'll see. I think he's the second-best receiver in Minnesota, second-best pass catcher in Minnesota. I think round maybe eight, preferably round nine,
Starting point is 00:40:52 is where I'd like to take a chance on him. But I just don't see him, A, impacting Justin Jefferson to the level that should knock him off the top spot, and B, taking ahead of those guys. No. Do you think – okay, so you would have taken Lockett, Pittman, and Cooks ahead of Addison? I would have taken Pittman ahead of him. Probably would still take Lockett ahead of him.
Starting point is 00:41:13 And what was the third one? Brandon Cooks. No, I'd take him ahead of Cooks. I get the argument. I mean, Lockett's a loser with Jackson, Smith, and Jigba. Pittman's a loser with Anthony Richardson. That's what people are going to be thinking. Brandon Cooks is, we already talked about him. I get it. Heath, can you justify it?
Starting point is 00:41:27 Addison in round seven ahead of those three guys. Yes, I would put him ahead of those three guys. And I think he's going to be a number three wide receiver. I've actually got him just ahead of Mike Williams. All right, let's super fast justify it. James Conner ahead of DeAndre Swift. Heath, can you justify that one? James Conner ahead of DeAndre Swift. Heath, can you justify that one? James Conner ahead of DeAndre Swift. Yeah, both of them are going to miss time with injuries, but when James Conner is healthy, he gets to be a full-time running back. Okay. Okay, I like it.
Starting point is 00:41:55 James Cook over A.J. Dillon and Samaje Pirine. James Cook, those were three consecutive picks. James Cook to Jacob Gibbs, A.J. Dillon to Marone Berkson, and Jamie took Samaje Pirine, 87th overall. Jamie, can you justify James Cook first in that trio, Cook, Dillon, Pirine? I mean, clearly if he's the lead guy in Buffalo and those other guys are going to be in backup situations, you know, if Jomante Williams is healthy,
Starting point is 00:42:18 clearly Samaje Pirine doesn't go in that range. A.J. Dillon, we know, is still behind Aaron Jones. And so, you know, I think if you're banking on who's the best running back in Buffalo, you want it to be James Cook. But the fact that they added Damian Williams and Latavius Murray feels like it's going to be another situation of just multiple guys touching the ball in a very frustrating scenario for a guy that doesn't necessarily profile as lead running back, wasn't lead running back in Georgia, for example.
Starting point is 00:42:41 So will he take that step forward? That's what Jacob Gibbs is hoping for. I think we all would love to see it, but no, I cannot justify James Cook ahead of those guys. Who's your favorite in that trio? And Damian Harris, by the way, going to the Buffalo Bills. Who's your favorite in that group? Damian Williams, right, I'm sorry.
Starting point is 00:42:58 Yeah, yeah. So that was Cook, Dillon, Pirine. Who do you have ranked highest? Right now, I believe I have P Ryan ranked highest, just with the hope that he's going to have a big role in Denver to start the season. Yeah, I've got them all within five spots. I've got a P Ryan at 76, Dylan at 80 and cook at 81.
Starting point is 00:43:19 All right. How about, let's talk about Carolina. Adam Thielen gets drafted in round eight ahead of Jonathan Mingo who I believe went in round nine the rookie second round pick fifth wide receiver selected in the NFL draft to make sure I have my rounds right here but feeling ahead of Mingo base oh no they oh yeah yeah yeah uh Thielen was middle of round eight and the last pick of round nine was Mingo uh Heath justify the old man ahead of the rookie. Yeah, he's a veteran, and he's proven it. And no, I would rather have Mingo over Thielen, so I don't agree with that.
Starting point is 00:43:53 But, I mean, there are plenty of question marks about Jonathan Mingo. You can ask how anyone would expect him to beat Adam Thielen when he couldn't beat out the guys for more work at Ole Miss last year. So I think it's justifiable, but I'd rather just go with the young guy because if Thielen hits his upside, I think he's probably like wide receiver 24. Mingo might have a lot more upside than that. Jamie, I'm not going to ask you to justify Chris Olave going ahead of Michael Thomas. I am going to ask you to justify Chris Olave going 66 picks ahead of Michael
Starting point is 00:44:25 Thomas. Can you, is that, is that right? Do you think he should be five rounds ahead of Michael Thomas? Five and a half? Uh, I,
Starting point is 00:44:32 yes, just because we've now seen Michael Thomas just not stay healthy, you know? So, you know, this is, um, hopefully a receiver,
Starting point is 00:44:40 excuse me, on the rise. That's going to have a, you know, huge sophomore campaign. There's a lot to love about what he showed as a rookie and hopefully will continue to show even with a new quarterback.
Starting point is 00:44:50 I think Derek Carr will be better for him than what he had last year. If Thomas is healthy, it's a steal. Absolute steal. But how can you count on it at this point? Alright, last one here. Heath, Kirk Cousins, Russell Wilson, Geno Smith all go undrafted.
Starting point is 00:45:10 Justify it. Well, you're not there in the draft. AJU is drafting for you, and we already talked about it. He doesn't know you very well. He should have taken each of those quarterbacks with your last three picks. And then I chose Kyler Murray and Daniel Jones over those three guys. I think I was the last guy to take a quarterback and took those two guys together. Kyler Murray and Daniel Jones over those three guys. I think I was the last guy to take a quarterback and took those two guys together. Kyler Murray and who? Daniel Jones.
Starting point is 00:45:30 Oh, alright. Alright, yeah, look, I mean, take your pick of those late round quarterbacks but in this league, if you're having quarterback issues, Kirk Cousins, Russell Wilson, and Geno Smith are on the waiver wire. Jamie, where are the characters in Disney?
Starting point is 00:45:47 How come they don't have characters walking around anymore? Well, they have them at planned meet and greets. Yeah, what's that all about? Let's get more characters. I mean, you see them walking around when they're going to their spots. I saw one character in two days, the Magic Kingdom. Also really liked the Aladdin ride.
Starting point is 00:46:09 It's pretty fun. Yeah, you haven't been there in a while, so the kids enjoy themselves? They had an amazing time. I mean, more rides, more rides, more rides. Buzz Lightyear was the smash hit for my son. We had a great time. We really did. You just went to Magic Kingdom or any other parks?
Starting point is 00:46:25 Magic Kingdom, twice. Nice. Yeah. By the way, now that everybody can see your arms in high definition, show everybody those. No, no, no.
Starting point is 00:46:33 The other side. The hairy side. Yeah, there they are. Yep. There they are. Very hard to put suntan lotion on arms like that. I can see that gym membership's paying off.
Starting point is 00:46:44 Cancel that after the two week trial when we come back when we come back we got your emails fantasy football at cbsi.com we're not done we're not done we are back with some emails i told you we'd have a 35 minute show the problem is i don't have a clock in front of me i have no idea how long it's been it's been more than that though i'm sure. Alright, this is an interesting email from Dominic in Austria. He says, Dear Wolfgang, Arnold, Sigmund, and Christoph, and those are Austrian
Starting point is 00:47:12 celebrities. So he has a draft system and wants to know your thoughts on it. This draft order is set differently in each round according to the following schedule. You make a pick and then you move back five spots the next round. So if you have the first overall pick in round one,
Starting point is 00:47:30 you will get the sixth pick in round two and the 11th pick in round three. The person with the first pick in each round drafts a player at a position and then everyone else in that round has to draft the same position. And that's quarterback, running back one running back two wide receiver one wide receiver two tight end and then flex one and i think flex two so basically you're trying to get a positional advantage as well but um you know but you're moving back five or six spots, five spots the next round for every round. So he says it's working out great for them. And what do you guys think about that system?
Starting point is 00:48:12 I mean, if you enjoy it, go ahead. I would assume one, one Oh one should be Kelsey, right? Yeah. That's what he was saying. He was, that was one of his questions. If you had one Oh one, would you take Kelsey? Cause I, yeah, the you take Kelsey? Yeah. The positional advantage. Okay, so let's say you had 101. Imagine you got to be your first pick is 12th pick as a tight end.
Starting point is 00:48:33 That's just awful. I'm just thinking like the amount of trouble that we have getting people to pick at the right time when we're just doing a standard draft where you pick at the same time every round. Imagine how long it would take telling people they were on the clock i do two drafts that are similar to this but and when i say similar just because there's there's position requirements so we you've you've done this draft before heath it's our office draft which has ranged from anywhere from 22 teams to 28 teams i think depending on how many people join. And so the first round, we have to draft either running backs or quarterbacks. The second round is wide receivers.
Starting point is 00:49:11 I forget how the formula goes. But you can only draft those two positions. Then round three is a free-for-all. I guess it's only draft. I was going to say the 30-deep basketball one we do, but that's also free-for-all. But, yeah, it just makes it more complicated. Look, I mean, if you have fun doing it that way, go ahead. But yes, I would say Travis Kelsey should be the first pick of the draft.
Starting point is 00:49:30 All right, this one's from Anthony. I traded, he wants to know if he gave up too much for Bijan. I traded Rashad White, pick 106, 107, and a 2024 first round pick for 101. So to get Bijan Robinson, he gave up Rashad White, 106-107 and a 2024 first round pick. It is a super flex dynasty league. He still has 102, 202 and 203. So he can now take Bijan Robinson and the quarterback of his choice.
Starting point is 00:50:05 But he gave up Rashad White, 106, 107, and 2024 first-round pick. Heath, did he give up too much? I don't think so. Definitely not if B. John hits. But I will say, I kind of think it might be, if it is, it's because it's a super flex league. 106 and 107 are a lot more valuable,
Starting point is 00:50:25 especially this year in a super flex league than they are in a one quarterback league. But I have sent an offer to, our rookie draft starts today and I sent an offer to Dan and we're just waiting for Dan to wake up and decide what he's going to do because he is on the clock.
Starting point is 00:50:41 And I offered him 103, a bunch of third and fourth round picks this year. 2024 first, 2024 second, 2025 first, 2025 second for Bijan and Mark Andrews. So three firsts, two seconds, and Elijah Moore. And he's probably- Heath, I forgot to ask you, I'm doing a startup dynasty league.
Starting point is 00:51:04 Do you want in? Dave and Jamie are pretty much in, I forgot to ask you. I'm doing a startup Dynasty League. Do you want in? Dave and Jamie are pretty much in, I think. Dave was on the fence. Dave was like, I don't want to be in a league with your friends. It was essentially the gist of it. Oh, is this real? This is 100% real because my Dynasty League. You never actually invited me to anything.
Starting point is 00:51:19 My Dynasty League ended, so I have to restart it and be the commissioner yes yes i'm in oh cool all right all right i'm gonna get that i would i would say to answer the question um i like the trade i do agree with heath it's a lot to give up in superflex the question becomes is and i think you should but how much do you value how much more do you value bijan over Jameer Gibbs? Because if there's a run on quarterbacks and a receiver, Gibbs may fall to six. I doubt it. Well, he has 102. Remember, he has 102 also. No, no, no.
Starting point is 00:51:52 But 102, you've got to take your Richardson. You can't make that mistake in a super flex league. But again, if you really need running backs, you could play it the way you're talking at it. You take Gibbs at 102, and then you might be looking at whoever's left of stroud or young at 106 if it falls that way i doubt it but again you might um but in any event uh you know and and this is something dan should consider if dan is giving up bijan and mark andrews by the way which is insane um but if he's giving up those two players, those picks the next couple of years for Heath are going to be late first round picks.
Starting point is 00:52:28 That was the other part of this equation. This guy has 102, 106, and 107. Which one of those did you earn this year? If he was a true 102 roster, then I'm not sure I want to give up that much and a 20-24 first to get Bijan, because I'm not sure. So considering he has picked 202,
Starting point is 00:52:48 I think he probably had the second worst record. But he said the 2024 first round pick that he's giving up is not his own. All right, but we should move on. I would absolutely make that deal. Because the thing that swings it for me is how much do you value Rashad White? Because if Rashad White hits, then you're giving up a lot of first round capital and potentially a top-15
Starting point is 00:53:05 running back to get Bijan and Richardson. If you're hitting the reset button, no matter how you're resetting it, get those two players is a pretty good place to start. Bijan Robinson and Rich. All right. From Dan, who should I drop from this list? Full PPR 10-team league. Just drop one
Starting point is 00:53:21 player. A.J. Dillon, Javante Williams, Khalil Herbert, Isaiah Pacheco, Cortland Sutton, Alec Pierce, Sky Moore. It's between Sutton and Pierce for me. I'd probably drop Sutton.
Starting point is 00:53:39 I'd probably drop Pierce. From Sean, PPR league, one-year keeper, round six value, and you can only pick one. 10-team league, four-point-per-passing touchdown. All right. Pick Jalen
Starting point is 00:53:52 Hurts, Garrett Wilson, or Ken Walker. You're only keeping one of those? Mm-hmm. And it's three receivers. Four-point-per points for passing touchdown. Yeah. I wonder, does the four point for passing touchdown
Starting point is 00:54:09 actually make Jalen Hurts more valuable? Relative to other quarterbacks, yes, but not relative to other positions. Yeah, I'm keeping Wilson. All right. From Cody from the city that is about to have the annual run for the roses. All right. That actually happened.
Starting point is 00:54:24 Congratulations to the horse whose name I cannot pronounce. I don't know how it's said. So he's from Louisville and he needs help with pick one Oh two in a super flex league. One Oh one is going to be Bijon Robinson. Who do I take it to? I need some wide receiver help, but should I take Richardson?
Starting point is 00:54:40 He has, here's the thing. He has my homes, Trevor Lawrence and Ryan Tannehill. He has Debo Samuel, DJ Moore, Elijah Moore, Nico Collins, Kadarius Toney, and Sky Moore. He has Mark Andrews and some decent running backs. But actually, I don't know.
Starting point is 00:54:56 I think he could justify taking a running back. He has Damian Pierce, Zeke Akers, ETN, James Cook, Jeff Wilson. All right, the question, I guess, is Bijan's going to be one. He's got Mahomes, Trevor Cook, Jeff Wilson. All right. The question I guess is B. John's going to be one. He's got my homes, Trevor Lawrence and Tannehill. Do you still go with a quarterback in the super flex league or do you take a different position? I'm taking the quarterback because that's so much more trade capital, you know?
Starting point is 00:55:18 So if you want to try and flip whether Richardson or Lawrence, I'd probably try and flip Richardson, just the unknown for maybe a running back and a quarterback. So I'm not passing on Richardson. I'd probably see what receiver I could get for 102. Yeah. And then I'd probably see what I could get to move down to 105 or 106. But if I stay at two, I'm taking Richardson.
Starting point is 00:55:41 I mean, Tannehill might be gone anyway. She might only have two quarterbacks by the time we get to November. Okay. 35-minute show. You're welcome, guys. You got the numbers right. 3-5, 5-3. Alright.
Starting point is 00:55:56 We'll talk to y'all later. On Wednesday, we got another show. Thursday, we got another show. Thank you very much. Oh, that's right. The Dynasty Show I'm sorry I'm really out of it I'm sorry But yeah we'll talk to you tomorrow
Starting point is 00:56:10 With Heath's Dynasty Show on Fantasy Football Today See ya

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.