Fantasy Football Today - The Dynasty Episode! And Some NFL News (03/04 Fantasy Football Podcast)
Episode Date: March 4, 2021CHECK OUT LAST WEEK'S DYNASTY MOCK DRAFT: (LINK: https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/football/news/fantasy-football-dynasty-startup-mock-draft-results-recap-2021-the-rise-of-justin-jefferson-and-2020-cl...ass/) Who should be the first pick in a startup dynasty draft? We spend the first chunk of today's show answering that question and debating who it should be if it's NOT Christian McCaffrey. One of the young WRs? Jonathan Taylor, perhaps? Should DeAndre Hopkins be getting more consideration to be at least a first round pick in a startup dynasty league (11:55)? We also try to determine how old is too old when it comes to Fantasy production (16:00) ... Reviewing the latest news and notes (22:00). Golden Tate, Kyle Rudolph and Jared Cook were released. Does Tyrell Williams have value on Detroit? ... Back to Dynasty, we review last week's dynasty mock draft (30:45). Should Travis Kelce even be a Top 3 TE in this format (31:00)? Is Derrick Henry in Round 2 a better value than Austin Ekeler in Round 3 (39:00)? What other trends do Fantasy managers need to know? ... Your emails at fantasyfootball@cbsi.com Subscribe to the FFT in 5 podcast on Apple, Spotify, Google, or wherever you listen to FFT. Follow our FFT team on Twitter: @FFToday, @AdamAizer, @JameyEisenberg, @daverichard, @heathcummingssr, @CTowersCBS, @BenSchragg Watch FFT on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCviK78rIWXhZdFzJ1Woi7Fg/videos Join our Facebook group https://www.facebook.com/groups/FantasyFootballToday/ Sign up for the FFT newsletter https://www.cbssports.com/newsletter You can listen to Fantasy Football Today on your smart speakers! Simply say "Alexa, play the latest episode of the Fantasy Football Today podcast" or "Hey Google, play the latest episode of the Fantasy Football Today podcast." To hear more from the CBS Sports Podcast Network, visit https://www.cbssports.com/podcasts/ Want winning picks each morning in under 10 minutes? Subscribe to 'The Early Edge: A Daily SportsLine Betting Podcast' on Apple, Spotify, Stitcher or wherever else you listen to podcasts. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Kick off an exciting football season with BetMGM, an official sportsbook partner of the National Football League.
Yard after yard, down after down, the sportsbook born in Vegas gives you the chance to take action to the end zone
and celebrate every highlight reel play.
And as an official sportsbook partner of the NFL, BetMGM is the best place to fuel your football fandom on every game day. With a variety of exciting features,
BetMGM offers you plenty of seamless ways to jump straight onto the gridiron
and to embrace peak sports action.
Ready for another season of gridiron glory?
What are you waiting for?
Get off the bench, into the huddle, and head for the end zone all season long.
Visit BetMGM.com for terms and conditions.
Must be 19 years of age or older.
Ontario only.
Please gamble responsibly.
Gambling problem?
For free assistance, call the Connex Ontario helpline
at 1-866-531-2600.
BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement
with iGaming Ontario.
This is Fantasy Football Today from CBS Sports.
On his way to the end zone.
I'll tell you what, that was a spectacular play.
It's time to dominate your fantasy league.
What a play.
Off to the races.
Touchdown.
Oh, he's done it again.
Now here's some combination of Adam, Dave, Jamie, Heath, and Ben.
We had a fun show today. We're going to talk about dynasty leagues. I probably and Ben. We had a fun show today.
We're going to talk about dynasty leagues.
I probably shouldn't say we have a fun show today
because that implies other shows aren't fun,
but this one's going to be interesting.
We did a dynasty draft last week.
We'll talk about that.
A lot of picks that are worth talking about.
Devontae Adams was definitely not the number one wide receiver taken.
Some debate about who should be number one.
Lamar Jackson went way after the top two quarterbacks.
Who was number two, you might be thinking.
So all of that will be discussed.
We have Dynasty emails and getting some news.
Some important players being released.
Tyrell Williams signed by the Lions.
We'll get to some bigger headlines, I think, next week.
But things are picking up.
Things are picking up.
Adam Azer, Dave Richard, and Heath Cummings here on this Dynasty edition of Fantasy Football today.
And guys, I think we should just start with this.
Who should be the number one pick in a startup Dynasty League?
There are some parameters here.
No rookies, it's not super flex, and it's PPR.
So Heath, who should be the number one pick in a PPR startup Dynasty League, not super flex, and no rookies?
Well, it's Christian McCaffrey, and I think it's fairly obvious. I'm not even
going to make a big case for him.
I'll just apologize
for showing up so late today and
missing the first 45 minutes of the show.
This is
awesome. We're doing Dynasty
at the beginning of the show? An entire
show about Dynasty? We're not saving it
and pushing it for the last 15 minutes?
This is awesome
thank you adam is it really that obvious that it's christian mcafree to me it is okay dave i think
it's i think it's obvious too you think about the other players certainly they're they're more
likely running backs and wide receivers that you would consider taking at number one saquon's going
to make you squeamish because the injuries they've had over the past couple of years.
Derrick Henry is 27.
Jonathan Taylor,
maybe he's just not proven enough
to earn that number one overall spot.
Alvin Kamara,
kind of the same age as Christian McCaffrey.
And we know that McCaffrey
has been a little bit more productive.
So I get it.
I think McCaffrey is the top pick,
is the safest way to go.
Well, and I think the distinction
you made about PPR is an important one
because I think you could make an argument for Jonathan Taylor and non-PPR.
I think you could make an argument that the gap between McCaffrey and Taylor
next year won't be that big.
And after next year is the point where we probably start looking at
discounting McCaffrey a little bit because of his age.
And so in non-PPR, maybe you make the case for Taylor as the number one overall.
And can you make the case for Dalvin Cook?
Or do the injuries scare you off there too?
He's even older than McCaffrey, isn't he?
Okay.
I wasn't sure.
Let me bring it down for you.
I'm sure he's close.
He is.
He is.
So of the top, the elite running backs, and tell me if I'm forgetting anyone,
Saquon Barkley is 24. Now, okay, this is what age they will be
in the 2021 season.
Barkley will be in his age...
Week one is what I use, generally.
I use pro football reference.
So whatever they use,
like looking at last year
was Barkley's age 23 season.
So he is going to be 24.
I think he turned 24 in February.
But that's what I'm using.
Pro Football Reference has a way of doing it.
This is your age blank season.
That's what I used.
Barkley will be entering his age 24 season.
McCaffrey his age 25 season.
Kamara and Zeke 26.
And Derrick Henry will be entering his age 27th season.
He's the old guy.
He'll be going into his sixth season along with Zeke.
Kamara, McCaffrey, and Cook, their fifth season.
But McCaffrey's a year younger,
at least in terms of the metric I'm using.
And then Kamara and Cook.
And Barkley is the youngest.
He's going into his fourth season.
He's 24.
Obviously, Jonathan Taylor and Swift
and all those is the youngest. He's going into his fourth season. He's 24. Obviously, Jonathan Taylor and Swift and all those guys are younger.
But I had a tough time
coming up with a player
to take other than McCaffrey
because the rookie running backs,
the ones who were rookies last year,
they don't catch a ton of passes, right?
Like if Jonathan Taylor,
if there's going to be one guy,
it's going to be him. He doesn't catch a ton of passes. And then ifathan taylor's the if there's gonna be one guy it's gonna be him he doesn't catch a ton of passes and then if you want to go wide receiver
i had this thought you know who is that guy that player who's played one or two years in the nfl
that you could make the case for as the number one pick in a startup dynasty league
and unfortunately the three wide receivers that that everybody loves, Jefferson, Metcalf, A.J. Brown,
they're not huge catch guys.
You know, they're like in the 80s so far in their career.
And that hurts, especially compared to McCaffrey.
So I actually thought maybe in a half PPR league,
it's more justifiable to go with one of those wide receivers,
if that makes sense.
One of those three I mentioned,
Jefferson, AJ Brown, DK Metcalf,
over McCaffrey.
But in a full PPR league,
I feel like it's a bigger advantage to McCaffrey.
So I don't know.
It's like we don't, of these really young players,
especially at receiver,
if you wanted to go receiver with your first pick,
we don't have a guy right now that looks like a consistent 95 to 100,
like a Julio Jones
or an Antonio Brown
or something like that.
They're big play guys
and they so far
have not been high catch guys.
Does that make sense?
It does,
but I think you can make the case
that Jefferson could become one.
I mean, he had 88 catches last year.
You're getting pretty close to 100.
But he also was a big play guy.
He was yards per catch way up there.
No doubt.
But 88 catches is still 88 catches.
And it was a good catch rate for him as well.
He had 125 targets.
I think he could get more next year.
I think he absolutely could qualify
as that high volume plus big play like
you know a smashing playmaker in the nfl for a long time yeah and julio jones i'm sorry julio
jones um only had 79 catches in his second season in 16 full games and then he became you know
catch machine um so that's something to keep in mind. Go ahead, Ethan. Sorry. Well, and these, the other thing they all have in common is like, it's not that they haven't been huge catch guys because they can't earn target share. It's that oddly enough, the three best young wide receivers all play on teams that want to throw the ball more than ever or run the ball more than average. That's, that's a great point. Um. That's unlikely to remain the case.
I think we'll see more catches, targets for A.J. Brown this year.
I don't know about Jefferson.
I think it'll be really interesting because for most of the year,
you would have still said that Adam Thielen was the number one option on the Vikings.
Now, he wasn't late in the year for sure.
I don't think there'll be any doubt going into next year who teams are going to try to stop in the passing game on the Vikings. Now, he wasn't in this late in the year for sure. I don't think there'll
be any doubt going into next year who teams are going to try to stop in the passing game on the
Vikings. It's going to be Justin Jefferson. And I wonder, we saw that with Thielen and Diggs,
where a lot of times it was just the guy that didn't get all the attention.
What Diggs told us.
Yeah. So it might be a little bit of a bounce back for Thielen in that regard,
but Brown is the one of that trio that I feel more confident
we'll see more targets next year.
So now I'm pretty sure in the last six seasons,
there's only been one wide receiver that's finished top 12 in PPR
on an offense that was bottom five in pass attempts.
I don't think it happened last year.
And Jefferson was on a team that was sixth fewest in pass attempts.
So he almost broke that mold.
And you mean on a full season basis?
Because A.J. Brown was seventh on per game basis last year.
Okay, yes, on a full season basis.
He didn't finish top 12, did he? He was Um, top, he didn't finish 12, top 12. Did he,
he was 17th cause he only played 17, I think 13 games. Okay. So, um, no. So yeah, I don't think
it happened last year on any of those, any of the five teams that threw the fewest pass attempts,
but Minnesota through the six fewest and Jefferson was obviously in the top 12, but it's hard to do.
It's, it's really hard to do to finish top 12 on an offense that doesn't throw the ball much.
They had two top 12 wide receivers
on an offense that doesn't throw the ball very much.
It was top 12 both in overall fantasy points
and fantasy points per game.
A lot of that, though, had to do with Adam Thielen
catching a lot of touchdowns
because he had like 100-something targets,
but he had more touchdown catches
than Jefferson had targets inside the 10 last year.
So that's an area that Jefferson can improve into
is becoming a bigger target inside the 10-yard line.
But even think about what has to happen
for Minnesota to go back the other way and be,
well, I mean, it's not so far the other way,
but to be a run, run, run heavy offense.
Defense has to get a lot better, and
Dalvin Cook has to stay healthy. The offensive line
has to stay strong.
I'm not saying it can't happen.
Two years ago, we kind of saw it happen.
But I still think there's plenty
there for Justin Jefferson to be an impressive
fantasy wide receiver.
But is there enough to make the case for
him or any other wide receiver
as the number one overall pick in a dynasty league? The case for Jefferson to make the case for him or any other wide receiver as the number one overall pick in a
dynasty league the the case for jefferson to be the number one overall receiver in a dynasty league
is he just he's he's just had a good volume rookie season he's proven to be a great receiver
he's got room to grow in the red zone we just talked about that and he's only 21 years old
i'm i that's not me saying i would take him for sure i'm not
sure who i would take first tyreek hill is up there davante adams i think still deserves some
consideration and brown and dk i don't think i would take dk but brown would certainly be an
option as well there are a lot of good receivers that could go number one but jefferson might have
the most going for him because of age.
I think you can make an argument for Adams,
for Brown,
for Jefferson,
for Metcalf,
for Tyreek.
It's,
it's not a huge gap between any of the really top seven.
My thing is like on a per game basis, Devante Adams has,
was so much better than everybody else. And really for the last Adams has, was so much better than everybody else.
And really for the last three years has been so much better than everybody
else on a per game basis.
And,
um,
I just,
can you explain that?
Can you explain that?
Because that obviously wasn't true in 2019.
No,
not every single year,
but if you look at 2020 and then you look at what he's done over the last
three years on a three year average, it is true.
Is it really? Is that much better than Tyreek Hill?
Last year, I think he was four points
per game better than
Tyreek Hill, who was awesome.
Four points per game.
That's enormous. Well, he had, what, 18
touchdown catches?
So we know that's coming. Yes.
We think that's coming down because
Rodgers threw 48.
Adams had just an insane amount
of touchdown catches last year.
And in 2019,
he was sixth in PPR points per game.
No, but he was still sixth
in PPR points per game.
And 2018, I think he was
the best on a per...
2018, he was number one
on a per-game basis.
Now, the three-year average does not show because 2019 really holds that down.
But two of the past three years,
he has been the best wide receiver.
And last year he was four points better than anybody.
And like eight points per game,
better than guys like AJ Brown and DK Metcalf.
You're right about 2018,
21.6 PPR per game,
a half point better per game than Antonio Brown that year.
But he's the same age as,
both he and DeAndre Hopkins are going into their age 29 seasons.
Hopkins has been a top five wide receiver five times,
I think five times.
Yeah, that's incredible.
At age 23, 25, 26, 27, and 28,
he's been a top five wide receiver
five times in his career.
We don't even think about him
as the potential number one
wide receiver off the board.
But he's the same age as Devontae Adams.
Right.
I think he probably has,
but the last three years,
he hasn't been close to as good as Adams was last year.
Not as good as he was last year,
but you just talked about 2018
when Adams was the number one wide receiver per game.
He was barely better than Hopkins.
By 1.1 points per game.
Was it that?
I've had it by about a half a point.
I thought, I guess it depends on...
I'm looking at the FFT League.
It's 21.97 to 20.84, but you're right.
It could be different on a different site.
Yeah, okay.
I think I said he was number two.
He's actually number three.
2018, Devontae Adams, what I'm looking at on fftoday.com,
21.8 points.
Antonio Brown, 21.6.
DeAndre Hopkins, 21.1.
Let's just call it.
He was a point worse per game.
All right,
fine.
But my point stands.
DeAndre Hopkins maybe should be part of the discussion to same ages as Adams and five top five finishes.
I couldn't believe that.
Antonio Brown has six top five finishes,
by the way,
in his career.
But I think,
again,
the reason he's not
is because at 28 years old,
when you're comparing him to these 24 and 23
and even 22-year-olds,
the only way you get into that discussion
is if we think there's a chance
that you just blow those guys' doors off next year.
Is Devontae Adams' chance really that much better
than DeAndre Hopkins chance?
I think he's a much better touchdown producer.
Adams is.
Yeah.
And Hopkins.
And I also think there's a chance that Hopkins target share could go down
where we're not really seeing it.
You look at the Cardinals offense and,
you know,
he was their alpha on the outside and inside,
but they,
they could add a piece at some point during this offseason.
I know they want to get their run game better.
The Packers absolutely could do the same.
They could.
I was going to say, but I think Rodgers just leaned so heavily on Adams in the red zone that it might not matter.
And teams know it's coming, and there's nothing they can do
about it i can't i can't say whether or not i it's close between rogers to adams in the red zone
versus kyler to hopkins in the red zone all i can tell you is that the cardinals in the red zone
have not been as great as we've hoped the past two seasons and it was like it was close last year. Hopkins was 160 targets. Adams was over that pace, over 10 per game, but not by a lot, like 10 and a half per game in terms of targets. But that was on a team that threw the ball 526 times versus how many times Arizona threw it. Like relative to last year, I think it's more likely that Green Bay throws the ball
more than Arizona.
Especially with running back changes potentially
happening there. Here, just look at red zone
targets last year. Devontae Adams had 28
of them. Yeah, but Devontae Adams,
I gave this stat a couple weeks ago,
I think like a wacky stat. 44.4%
of his team's targets
inside the 10-yard line. Yeah, I know.
I want guys that have that type of...
Yeah, no.
I know, I know.
It's not going to happen again.
A lot of things that happen for Devontae Adams
are not going to happen again.
That was an extremely high number.
Will he have more than 13 red zone targets?
He's going to catch more...
Okay, fine.
I just wanted to put him in the discussion
because Hopkins, I just think it's amazing.
What I did yesterday in prep for this show
was I looked at the last 10 years
at running back and wide receiver,
and I tried to find the ideal ages
to answer this question of who should be going number one overall
and who you should be prioritizing in a startup dynasty league
or if you're making a trade in an existing dynasty league or something like that, when does a player start to drop off?
And what I found was age 26 appears to be a peak year at both running back and wide receiver. It
had the most top five finishes at both positions. By age 28, you don't really want to invest heavily
in running backs after age 28. You don't see a ton of top five finishes.
You do see some top 12 finishes there, but they start to fall off once they get to 29.
Wide receiver, they also start, Chris Towers also did some research on this. They also start to fall
off at that age, but they last longer. They have better years after age 28 than running backs do.
But for running backs, the most top five finishes were ages 24, 25, and 26. And it was
a little bit older for wide receivers. It was 25, 26, 27. A little bit better. 25 to 28, really,
was the peak there. So basically, I just wanted to figure out how old is too old is christian mcafree
getting too old no not really he's going into his age 25 season he should have at least three really
good years left and he's such a sure thing so i that's yeah that's why i said next year is the
year i'll kind of start dropping him off a little bit because when the three-year window includes age 28 is when I start to get a little
bit more nervous. But just one more thing on the Adams Hopkins discussion, because we're talking
about how Adams is not going to score as many touchdowns last year, next year, and he's not,
but his 16 game pace over the last five years is 13 touchdowns per year. DeAndre Hopkins' career high he did once is 13 touchdowns.
Yeah.
Oh, look, I like Adams better.
You're 100% right.
The touchdowns are better.
But I do think it's interesting that they're the same age
and Hopkins has been so consistent with four straight top five finishes.
You know, the conversation makes me think that Hopkins is like a great guy to target
after everybody goes gaga over the first four or five receivers in a dynasty startup.
He might be a pretty good, he's a good target to trade for too,
because there's this stigma that he's old and that maybe he just, you know,
had one great year with Kyler Murray.
And you can always check in if you're close to getting a championship
in your dynasty league to see what it'll cost to get him in a trade.
Let me go to this draft.
Heath, you took Adams eighth.
I took Adams seventh, I believe.
Also, you've said many times that Hopkins and Adams are the same age.
They are currently the same age.
I have Hopkins as a year older because he'll be 29
when the season starts. He's about 200 days older than Devante Adams. So that that's again,
like maybe it'll be their age 29 season for both of them next year. It's a good reason to use
decimals when you're looking at age because Hopkins is closer to a year older than Adams
than he is to exactly the same age.
All right.
They are going to both be in their age 29 season,
but fair point.
You took Adams eighth Hopkins went 24th.
So there's just a big,
I think difference in the way Hopkins is being viewed.
And, and I guess to wrap up,
I was trying to say about,
you know,
how old is too old?
Well,
both of these guys are going to be 29.
And that's when we're starting to see some drop-off
for wide receivers.
Now, if they're truly elite,
like Antonio Brown, like Julio Jones,
you could get...
Reggie Wayne, I think, had a good year at like 34.
These guys could be good into their 30s.
Really good.
But it is a pretty compelling case
to start thinking about,
maybe it's Tyree Kill,
or maybe it's A.J. Brown,
or somebody like that,
or Justin Jefferson.
That is so weird.
I'm sorry, I'm stuck on the age thing now.
Devontae Adams is going to turn 29 on Christmas Eve.
Really?
Like week 16.
And they're making that his age 29 season?
No, it shouldn't be that way that that is the way that that is done on pro football reference but i just want to say that
like i don't think adams i look at it as he has his age 28 29 and 30 season and for a player his
caliber i don't expect to drop off in the next three years. Okay.
I mean, I think that's pretty fair.
I would, yeah.
But I would look at him slightly differently.
He wouldn't be number one, probably, if I had him in at 29.
So that's a big breaking point for you, that age.
That range, the 27 through 30 range, yes, is.
There's big breaking points.
You also wouldn't see him the same way if he didn't have his current quarterback.
And it looks like he's going to have Aaron Rodgers this year.
Is he going to have Aaron Rodgers in his 29 season,
in his 30 season?
We think, we hope.
I don't know if he's dominating, if it's Jordan Love.
One thing he can have beginning today is Paramount+. All right, it's Jordan Love. One thing he can have beginning today is Paramount Plus.
All right. It's launching today. Paramount Plus. You've probably seen the spots with Bill Cowher
and James Corden and Patrick Stewart, Beavis and Butthead. Now you can hear it from me.
It's live sports. I don't really belong in that group, by the way, not even with Beavis and
Butthead. It's live sports. It's breaking news. It's a mountain of entertainment. Go straight
from game day to movie night with Paramount Plus. Stream iconic movies like The Godfather,
Indiana Jones, Mission Impossible, new episodes of critically acclaimed original series like Star
Trek, Picard, The Good Fight, and The Stand. And get this, you can also dive into live sports from
CBS Sports. We got the NFL, March Madness, the Masters, Champions League Soccer. This is all in Paramount+.
And hit shows from CBS, from Nickelodeon, MTV, BET,
Smithsonian Channel, and Comedy Central.
So it's live sports, it's breaking news, and a mountain of entertainment.
Paramount Plus streaming starts today, March 4th.
Let's take a quick break from our dynasty discussions here
and talk about the latest news around the NFL.
The Giants released Golden Tate.
The Vikings released Kyle Rudolph.
Houston restructured David Johnson's contract.
I guess we look at the two releases.
Any major fantasy impact?
I mean, obviously, Irv Smith,
but we were kind of banking on Kyle Rudolph
not being there anyway.
But Dave, fantasy impact of the Giants releasing Tate
and Minnesota releasing Rudolph.
Yeah, my 2014 fantasy football team took a massive hit.
Look, Rudolph's going to get a gig.
There's already talk of him somehow going to Cleveland
and maybe he replaces David Njoku on the roster
and reconnects with Kevin Stefanski
there. I could see him going to New England and trying to get an extra year or two out there as
their kind of Gronk replacement. Rudolph is a giant out there. He just doesn't move as well
as other tight ends. And that's what he wants to do. He wants to go somewhere where he's going to
be able to be a factor in the passing game so that's why he wanted out of minnesota let's see what happens with him he's got a chance
to be a week one streaming tight end a guy that you take with your late pick uh there's all sorts
of excitement for smith now totally get it he's a top 12 tight end of course and uh i don't know
where golden take goes i don't know if anybody really cares.
Lots of people are saying the Kyle Rudolph to New England thing,
and I would like to propose a rule that following this year, if whoever the Patriots bring in to play tight end is irrelevant,
as non-Gronk tight ends most generally have been with the Patriots,
we can stop with the Patriots tight end thing and just say it was a Gronk thing.
Well, sure. I think we've been saying that all along anyway.
I don't think if Kyle Rudolph goes to New England.
We weren't chasing Devin Asiasi in 2020 drafts.
Kyle Rudolph. No one's going to chase Kyle Rudolph though, right?
I think some people will.
Only if he's got a good week one matchup would he be
worth picking up.
And that's no matter what team he goes to.
Unless he's like a backup.
Yeah. If he goes to Kansas City,
no one's drafting him,
obviously. But if he goes to New England
and the Patriots play,
I don't know, name a team with a bad defense, the Lions.
Why? I mean,
who's the Patriots quarterback, I don't know, name a team with a bad defense, the Lions. Why though? I mean,
who's the Patriots quarterback?
I mean, Kyle Rudolph doesn't deserve to be...
They're going to trade to get Trevor Lawrence.
Kyle Rudolph is not a streamer.
He doesn't deserve to be a streaming tight end,
even in a great matchup.
It just,
it is a matchup-based thing
and that's what he'll pretty much be all year.
When was the last time he was even that?
I think there were,
there might've been a week or two
during the 2020 season where we were interested
in Kyle Rudolph. I mean, there's probably a week
or two where you had a good game. I don't know that we were interested
in him. He's a
fantasy afterthought. He has been anyway.
That's why we're putting
him in this possible
streaming conversation.
Back to the actual relevant guy, Irv Smith.
Scott Fish fish our friend
of the program i had tweeted out my initial projection of irv smith which is right around
tight end 12 was like 550 yards or something it was really uninspiring but i felt like i was maybe
too low and he had followed up and said last year smith and rudolph combined for 58 catches, 699 yards, and 6 touchdowns.
That's really not very good.
No.
No, it is not.
You'd think if Irv Smith has a good fantasy year,
one of two things has to happen.
He has to catch a decent amount of touchdowns,
or Justin Jefferson or Adam Thielen have to fall off.
Right?
Or Dalvin Cook falls off.
Well, let's not say that.
Kirk Cousins did throw like 36 times per game
down the stretch.
I think it was his last eight games of the year.
So that helps.
And he caught three touchdowns.
Irv Smith caught three touchdowns
in four games without Kyle Rudolph.
And he played a lot.
He played about 80% of the snaps
in three of those four games.
Four touchdowns inside the 10, too.
The Saints cut Jared Cook.
So what do you think about Taysom Hill
catching passes at tight end from Jameis Winston?
Then we could really make up a tight end.
Don't try and take the shine away from Adam Troutman.
That's true.
That's going to be the guy new on. I think he was taking the shine away from Taysom Hill. I's true. That's going to be the guy new.
I think he was taking the shine away from Taysom Hill.
I just want him to be tight end eligible.
That was a really fun week.
Remember that?
It was wild.
That was fun.
Houston restructured David Johnson's contract.
He was good.
Super duper great value in best ball drafts right now.
Both places we looked, he was running back 33
in terms of ADP at running back right now.
Go get him at that cost.
Wow.
The Raiders.
Where do you have him ranked?
Projected like 16th,
and I think I dropped him down to like 22 or 23
because of all the uncertainty.
Right.
That's the range that he's in.
He's going to be one of those last gasp RB twos.
Raiders GM Mike Mayock endorsed Derek Carr.
Really threw a nice statement of support at him.
And Carr, I don't know.
Like this is something that's easy to forget.
He averaged 316 yards per game in his last six healthy games.
That's a plus 5,000-yard pace.
He had that one game where he left with the injury very early.
But, yeah, I mean, he scored 27-0.
Remember the game at Atlanta?
We were so excited about the Raiders.
They had some horrible games.
27 points, 0 points, 37, 27, 25, and 24 fantasy points
in his last six games, six healthy games,
in six-point-per-passing touchdown leagues.
He did have three rushing touchdowns.
That helped.
But also was throwing on a 5,000-yard pace.
I don't know.
Where do you guys have Derek Carr?
Is he inside your top 15?
No.
20?
Close.
Top 20 guy? I have 20? Close. Top 20 guy?
I have him 18th.
I for sure have him inside my top 20.
I have him 18th.
I'm not sure we're drafting him
unless he's got a really great week one matchup
and you've decided to stream quarterbacks
or in your two-quarterback league
and you want to have a really good second quarterback.
Most leagues draft two quarterbacks though, right? Start two quarterbacks or draft your two quarterback league and you want to have a really good second quarterback most most leagues draft two quarterbacks though right start two quarterbacks not ours yeah
most leagues draft two of sure so he would be one of those second quarterbacks
uh okay minnesota gm rick spielman he endorsed kirk cousins he said kirk cousins is our starting
quarterback detroit signed tyrell williams it's a one-year deal, $6.2 million. He missed all of 2020 with a torn labrum.
He had three straight, very consistent seasons of 41 to 43 catches, 651 to 728 yards,
four to six touchdowns before missing all of 2020. Tyrell Williams, guys. Is he a top 48 wide receiver?
He is not for me.
If the lions don't franchise Kenny Galladay or bring back Marvin Jones, then he would be a top 48 wide receiver for me.
I think the two relevant seasons in that case would be 2019 with the Raiders
and 2016 with the chargers.
Cause those would be the two years where he had an opportunity
to be the number one in terms of target share.
And he was like one of those years, he was a number two wide receiver.
One of them is a number four.
So he's probably a number four.
All right.
Some more news.
The Jets released defensive end Henry Anderson.
The Dolphins are releasing Kyle Van Nooy,
a linebacker that they signed last year.
Pittsburgh unlikely to resign James Conner,
according to ESPN's Brooke Pryor.
And we're seeing some rumors Aaron Jones could get franchise tagged.
Allen Robinson could get franchise tagged.
It's very vague.
Doesn't necessarily mean much.
We'll see what happens.
Next week's going to be a pretty big week.
Next week and, yeah, the week after that,
the new season starts. You know what I'm going to be doing next week, Dave week and, yeah, the week after that, the new season starts.
You know what I'm going
to be doing next week, Dave?
What's that, Adam?
Starting this weekend, really,
I'm going to be
full-court press
preparing for
fantasy baseball drafts
because it is time.
Me too.
Yes,
and there's a great
new tool for you
if you just don't have
the time.
Fantasy baseball today
in five.
Guess how long
each episode is. Yes is yes five maybe six minutes
uh every day first thing in the morning download fantasy baseball today in five check it out
great information and also go to our website go to cbssports.com slash fantasy there is so much
great fantasy baseball and football uh but and basketball but fantasy baseball content that's
what we're talking about right now it's a great way to get ready for the season okay some dynasty topics uh davante
adams was the i think was he the fourth or the fifth wide receiver off the board i'm sorry
he was fourth right so here's how round one went mcafree barkley cook aj brown A.J. Brown, Kamara, Tyreek Hill, Justin Jefferson, Devontae Adams, D.K. Metcalf.
Those are the first nine picks.
It had five wide receivers and McCaffrey, Barkley, Cook, and Kamara at running back.
Travis Kelsey was 10.
We got to talk about that.
Patrick Mahomes, 11, and Jonathan Taylor, 12.
Heath had the eighth pick.
He took Adams.
I had the ninth pick. I took Metcalf. Dave had the 8th pick. He took Adams. I had the 9th pick. I took Metcalf.
Dave had the 12th pick. He took Taylor.
But Heath, you had
Travis Kelsey going 10th overall.
George Kittle going
14th overall.
And Waller
was well behind them.
Waller was 53rd
and Andrews was 56th.
So Heath, you've got the dynasty rankings.
Everybody can check those out on the website.
How do you rank those top four tight ends?
In the draft, they went Kelsey and Kittle as top 14 picks.
Then in round six, or round five, pardon me,
Waller and Andrews.
Yeah, at tight end, I would rank them
Kittle, Andrews, Waller, Kelsey.
As far as where they went in this draft, I love, love, love where Andrews and Waller went.
I would not take...
I don't think I'd take Kittle where he went either.
I think both of the top two tight ends went earlier than I would prefer,
and the next two were better.
Okay, so you have Kelsey
as your number four tight end in Dynasty.
I do.
Dave, what about you?
How do you rank those four in startup Dynasty?
I think putting Kittle first makes a lot of sense
because of the age factor.
And I still think he's got potential to have a couple of big touchdown
seasons.
We haven't seen that from Kittle yet.
I,
I go back and forth with Waller and Kelsey at two,
because I know that Waller is up there in age,
but he should theoretically last a little longer than Kelsey.
The thing about Kelsey is that you might get two really great seasons out of
him before he starts to slow down.
It doesn't look like he's slowing down at all.
And he's just in a phenomenal offense.
So I think if I wanted to play it safe, it's Kelsey.
If I really wanted to take a little bit more of a long-term approach to my
dynasty league, I would go Waller.
Andrews is fourth
heath i wonder when the next person in their 30s was drafted because kelsey's going into his age
32 season you you have better age numbers than i do so maybe you can correct me but
uh he'll be 32 in 2021 he'll be 31 at the start of the season. But yes, he will turn 32 at some point during the season.
I'm trying to see who my next highest ranked player
in the trade chart is.
Or the top 150?
What's that?
Julio Jones, maybe?
That's probably a great guess.
Boy, if that's the case,
I don't believe Julio's in my top...
I'm still scrolling and I'm at 75.
Oh, I took Julio Jones 57th overall in this draft,
right after Mark Andrews.
Yeah.
That's quite...
First round for Travis Kelsey, buyer beware, I guess,
because he's getting up there in age.
I actually have Russell Wilson ahead of
Julio Jones
but age 32
for Russell Wilson doesn't really mean
very much age 32
for Julio Jones might mean that
you've got one or two years left
Wilson went in round
eight Jones went in round five how many
more years do we have of Kelsey playing like this
I'm thinking two the thing is Wilson went in round eight. Jones went in round five. How many more years do we have of Kelsey playing like this?
I'm thinking two.
The thing is, that's a fair guess.
Playing like he did last year, I think the best bet would be zero.
I would say the best bet is that last year was the best year of his career.
Yeah.
Want to compare him to Tony Gonzalez?
If you've got that info available, hit me.
Well, let me see what Tony Gonzalez's actual birthday is.
Okay, February.
So this works perfectly. His age 31 season, nearly 1,200 yards, 99 catches, five touchdowns.
His age 32 season, 1,058 yards on 96 catches, 10 touchdowns.
Monster years in 2007 and 2008.
He started to decline after that, but it's also coinciding with him going to Atlanta.
His first year on Atlanta was his age 33 season.
Still had 83 catches,
867 yards, six touchdowns. Basically, the rest of his career, he was around eight to 900 yards
and six to eight touchdowns. He had one year where he only had 656 yards, but he never reached
the yardage marks that he had in Kansas City when he went to Atlanta. Is that because he got old? I don't know. But at age 37, he had 859 yards and eight touchdowns.
Age 36, 930 yards and eight touchdowns.
I mean, that's a top five tight end in any year.
That might be like a top three tight end most years.
So that was when he was 36 and 37.
It's a matter of how long he can hold on to that role
and keep the coach's confidence.
And you look at his contract, he's not even going to be a consideration to get cut until maybe 2023,
when the Chiefs can save over $13 million off the cap. So I think the Chiefs are banking on
two more years of Kelsey. They can keep him at at this rate and there'll be a bargain at that point. If he's still playing well at a high level when he's 34 years old. So I think that, I think that's
the safe play with Kelsey and there's evidence with Antonio Gates, Gates numbers weren't necessarily
amazing. They were still like certainly top 10, maybe even top five fantasy tight end numbers
when he was playing into his thirties, some years he was much higher than that because he scored a lot of touchdowns.
So I think that it's just the role that he's got,
the athleticism he has, the amount of targets that he gets,
I don't see it slowing down this year or next year for Kelsey.
I think an interesting question is Kelsey and Devontae Adams.
Kelsey's obviously older.
There's a lot more competition
at wide receiver, though,
for that number one.
Adams was four points better
than everybody else
last year at wide receiver.
Kelsey was three points better
than everybody else
at tight end last year.
Who's more likely
to be number one this year?
At their position, Kelsey?
Yep.
Let me ask you another question about that.
Why is that, though?
Why?
Because there isn't as much competition
for that mantle at tight end.
But the competition that there is,
like Kittle was as good as him two years ago.
He was.
We've seen Waller be almost as good as him per game.
Right.
I think it's like an odds thing, Heath, where like what percentage chance would you give Kelsey of being the number one tight end in 2021? 25%, 30%, 50%. It's going to be a high number. And with Adams, I'm not sure if you can say that because of all the other great receivers that are out there.
I'd probably say 30 on Kelsey.
Fine.
But can you say 30 on Adams?
Maybe close to 30.
I don't know.
I mean, it's also dependent on injury and stuff too.
And Adams has had more injuries lately.
I don't know.
With the age difference, who I'd say is more likely to get hurt.
That's baked into the 30%.
Let me ask you this.
So Kelsey has basically played seven full seasons.
He's got kind of a late start.
And he didn't play his rookie season.
So at the same age,
Tony Gonzalez had played 11 seasons.
So Kelsey doesn't have the same type of mileage
that you might expect at his age.
And I think that also applies to Derrick Henry,
in my personal opinion,
because while he has like 700 carries
in his last two seasons almost,
he didn't really get that much work
in his first three seasons. 110 carries't really get that much work in his first three
seasons 110 carries 176 215 yeah there's research that i've done that proves that that it's not
necessarily an age thing as much as it is a workload thing right and which is weird for
henry because you're terrified of 373 or whatever it was regular regular season carries. The number was 370. The truth is that he's had over 400 touches each of the past two seasons.
And those who were worried about him going into last year, they looked at, I think it
was 409 touches that he had in the regular season, the playoffs.
And they said, there's no way that a normal human can hold up to that.
To which other people, the people who liked Henry would say he's not a normal human.
And now I think everybody's kind of shrugging their shoulders
and saying, okay, he's not normal.
He's had over 800 touches the past two seasons.
You've got to trust that he can stay upright and strong
for another year.
Yeah, and maybe he's Adrian Peterson.
Adrian Peterson had a top five finish at age 31
or something like that.
Age 30 in 2015.
LeSean McCoy was really good late in his career.
One thing that I think about,
and this is just off the top of my head,
how many times did we see Derrick Henry take a hit
and we go, wow, he got pummeled on that tackle
versus the amount of times that we see Derrick Henry
stiff arm somebody or
you know drag a defender or push a pile like i think he's the one dishing out the punishment
and i think that that helps him and again off the top of my head no evidence behind this just a
thought that's what makes him almost more appealing to fly into the face of the curse of 370
or the 400 touch thing
because he's the one dishing it out, not taking it.
He doesn't hobble off the field as many times
as Dalvin Cook does, which is like once a game.
Okay, so what's a better value?
Derrick Henry in round two,
specifically mid round two, sixth pick of round two, or Austin Eckround two, sixth pick of round two,
or Austin Eckler with the fifth pick of round three.
I mean, he's in his prime.
So who's a better value,
Henry in mid-round two or Eckler mid-round three?
And this is a full PPR league.
I would take Eckler over.
No, I wouldn't.
It's very close.
Eckler is a better value.
Do you trust Henry to stay upright?
You can't count on him to get a lot of catches.
And can you trust Austin Eckler to stay upright
and have him continue to get a lot of catches?
Remember, they're changing coaching staffs.
We think that Austin Eckler is going to remain in a very strong role where he's going to get a lot
of receptions, but he doesn't get a lot of touchdowns, doesn't work near the goal line very much.
He's fumbled down near the goal line, I think, once each of the past two seasons.
That could stick with the coaches that are there. And that offense,
I think it's going to revolve a lot more about Herbert
than it will be about anybody in the run game there.
I think I'm going to land on Henry over Eckler.
Overall, but what if you could wait around and get Eckler?
If I can wait around to get Eckler and I know I can wait around again, then I will probably wait to get Eckler if it's full PPR.
How about this group of running backs in round three?
Aaron Jones going 27.
So starting with the 26th pick 27th pick Aaron Jones,
cam makers,
Austin Eckler,
mile Sanders,
Jones acres,
Eckler Sanders.
Then you have McLaurin,
then James Robinson,
Joe Mixon,
Antonio Gibson.
So,
uh,
that's,
you know, a lot of really interesting
running backs in that round.
Aaron Jones, Akers, Eckler, Miles Sanders,
James Robinson, Joe Mixon, Antonio Gibson.
Heath, what do you make of that with those running
backs going in round three? Most of
those backs I've got ranked
between 23 and
28. So
that's right about where I think they should go.
I do think it's very good value on
Miles Sanders. I think it's
I still and I may not
be factoring in enough risk for Jacksonville
doing something different. I think that's very, very
good value for James Robinson,
but it's possible that they
decide to spend resources on a running back. I
suppose that is a risk.
Okay, so
what stood out to you,
Heath,
in this draft,
we're going to get to,
we're going to get to emails in a few minutes,
but what,
some of the major takeaways.
Well,
I mean,
I think one of the things that will stick out to people was probably Dan
Schneier taking Patrick Mahomes in the first round at number 11.
And they might even expect us to normally to say don't take a quarterback in
the first round um i have in dynasty mahomes ranked as a first round value so i think that
was a good pick um i thought it was interesting what you brought up about lamar jackson
and how far he fell below Josh Allen.
Yes.
Josh Allen,
three quarterback.
Josh Allen was the 22nd pick and Lamar Jackson was the next quarterback
taken.
What did I say?
He went in round six.
Was it?
I took him in round four.
Oh,
I'm sorry.
Round four.
Okay.
And it,
it could just be that,
uh,
Tom Fornelli took Josh Allen and and those may have been the two people
who were willing to draft a quarterback in the first three rounds,
and that's why there was a big gap there.
But I do think quarterbacks should go earlier, in my opinion,
in dynasty drafts than they do in redraft
because young quarterbacks might be studs for 10 years on your roster,
and you're not going to draft a running back or a receiver
or a tight end that's going to do that.
I was absolutely expecting Deshaun and Kyler to go sooner
and Lamar Jackson to go sooner than they did in our dynasty mock.
Okay.
I felt like running back was pretty good through three rounds.
And then after that, really dried up.
Like if I, you know,
I took Josh Jacobs in round two.
I think I went Metcalf,
Jacobs,
I had the ninth pick.
Metcalf, Jacobs, Mixon.
And I was pretty happy with that,
but not thrilled.
And then I did take David Johnson later in the draft,
but Keyshawn Vaughn
is on my team those are
my four running backs oh and rashad penny so my running backs really sucked there overall there
were some running backs that fell further than i think they should have aj dylan in the middle
around five yes great pick damian harris in the middle of round six. I think actually Jacob Gibbs picked both of those.
Yeah.
But those were good values.
And then you get to that range in the round six, round seven,
where there's the guys like Chris Carson and Kenyon Drake and Miles Gaskin,
who could either be top 15 running backs next year
or could be on the waiver wire by the middle of the season.
Yeah.
And David Johnson,
I took around nine.
So I was happy.
That was a great value.
Yeah.
But,
but a lot of these running backs,
it's an interesting time to do a dynasty draft,
right?
We haven't had free agency.
We haven't had the NFL draft.
Right.
I was about to ask,
when's the best time to do a dynasty startup.
It depends on if you want to include the rookie draft i think we had this question a couple weeks ago on the show and i think i said
the same thing it depends on if you want to do the rookie draft as part of the startup or not
because if you want to include the rookies in the startup then i wouldn't do it until after
the nfl draft right um if you don't then i'm fine with doing it in in february but why why not agency why not i
mean it's fun to do drafts but right why not just wait until after free agency and the nfl draft
right do it two weeks before the nfl draft do you and then at that point you can do well no do it
in july or whatever at that point you can do however you want. You can do a startup dynasty draft that includes rookies,
or you can do a startup dynasty draft that's just veterans
and then do a separate rookie draft.
However you want to do it.
But it's just so many players,
their values are going to change over the next few weeks and months.
I think people like doing that
because there's less information available to everyone.
And so you are more likely to get like, maybe there's somebody who really thinks that KJ
Hamler or real Davis or the Michael P Ryan, or some of those young guys are actually going
to get the opportunity and make the big step forward next year.
And they're available in round 11.
And it might be in May or June that it looks a little bit more obvious
that those things are going to happen
and they aren't near as cheap.
And we will take a break
and read some emails in a moment.
I just wanted to give you
some Twitter poll results
going all the way back to the conversation
that started the show.
Who should be the number one pick
in a startup dynasty draft?
PPR, not super flex.
Christian McCaffrey got 52%.
A different running back got 16%.
A wide receiver, 10%.
And Patrick Mahomes, 21.4%.
Second place on this list.
I don't think that's crazy.
Yeah, I agree.
I think that that's kind of normal and I love the idea
of getting him with a late first round pick and then coming
back this is what Dan did in our draft
he got George Kittle in round two
shored up two positions with his first
two picks oh well let's look at his team then
and let's see well alright then
the rest of his didn't work out
for Dan who's got Mahomes
and Kittle
and he's probably going to get the number one pick
in the draft next year in the rookie draft because he has tony pollard chase edmunds
levy on bell matt brita daryl henderson philip lindsey marlin mack jerek mckinnon
at running back and he has keenan allen, Kenny Galladay, Adam Thielen,
and Michael Gallup, and
Brashad Perryman at wide receiver.
And DJ Chark. DJ Chark, sorry,
is a flex for him.
He's loaded everywhere except running back,
at which point he
is pretty thin. Is he loaded?
Is this loaded at wide receiver?
I think it's a good,
I think it's a great start at wide receiver.
Keenan Allen,
Allen,
Allen,
and Chuck plus DJ shark.
There's,
there's plenty of upside to help win now.
And a little bit later.
Yeah.
But why have a win now receiving core when you're running back?
It's like either go all in or,
there's still a rookie draft that's coming that he could add a running
back or two there.
And you know that there's always going to be
a few running backs that come out of the woodwork
off the waiver wire.
He's just going to have to be aggressive
about going to get them.
Should we go through our teams real quick?
Yeah, sure.
But let me ask you this.
A lot of people do start-up dynasty drafts.
Not a lot, but maybe there's one or two in each league.
They kind of punt on year one,
and they try to establish some incredible future team so
if you know that you've taken mahomes and kittle with your first two picks and then in round three
you took kenny galladay after that run of running backs which was unfortunate for him jones acres
eckler sanders robinson mixon gibson all off the board right before Dan's next pick. He could have taken Clyde Edwards-Elair,
but he went with Galladay,
and then he took Keenan Allen.
Does it make more sense, instead of Galladay and Allen,
not that they're old,
but to go even younger at wide receiver?
Like, take DJ Moore?
I would have...
What I was going to say was,
he should have taken David Johnson.
Oh, late in the draft.
Yeah.
He should have taken Melvin Gordon.
Or the guys that are probably going to be starters next year,
but are being discounted because of their age.
Heath, let's see your team.
You had the eighth pick.
What do you got?
I have Lamar Jackson at quarterback.
My starting running backs are DeAndre Swift
and James Robinson.
My wide receivers
are Devante Adams, Tyler
Lockett, and Marquise Brown.
I have Mark Andrews
at tight end.
Currently have LaVisca Chenault
as my flex.
The bench is
interesting. I think it carves my
backup quarterback, whatever.
Running backs, I have DJ Dallas,
Michael P. Ryan, Devin Singletary,
and Ido Smith.
Wide receivers, I have Colin
Johnson, Sterling Shepard, and Travis
Fulgham. Try to get a little mix of
upside and security there.
Then I have both Austin Hooper and O.J.
Howard.
Do you think you have any really usable backup running backs?
DJ Dallas, Michael Pirine, Devin Singletary, and Ido Smith?
I hope so.
Those are the types of guys, though, that I want to take a shot on.
There's really four guys whose teams might go add superstar running backs,
but if one of those four don't,
there's four guys that could have an opportunity at legitimate touches in 2021.
Okay, I had the ninth pick.
I just have this weird, I have a weird team.
Aaron Rodgers, Josh Jacobs, and Joe Mixon.
I mean, that's the fate of my team right there.
They're young, Jacobs especially.
Still got some good years left, those two,
but disappointing in 2020.
Julio Jones, DK Metcalf, DJ Moore, Julio Jones.
Those are my starting wide receivers,
plus Michael Pittman as my flex,
and I have TJ Hawkinson at tight end.
And that's solid.
It's got a lot of similarities to my team, actually.
It's weird. You have Swift and lot of similarities to my team, actually. It's weird.
You have Swift and Robinson.
I have Jacobs and Mixon.
So I have a little bit more provenness, I guess.
I don't even know if you have more upside, but you're younger.
Dave, whose running backs would you prefer?
Jacobs and Mixon or James Robinson and Swift?
That's a great question.
I like them both.
I think I would go with Jacobs and Mixon.
I think I have one and four in that group and you have two and three in most
people's minds.
Probably.
Oh,
I don't know.
I think people really like Josh Jacobs still.
Well,
you can't,
you can't fight the age there,
but it's not like deandre swift is some
old coot in his scooter right so i i think that there's it's i think it's close between those two
i think mixon's third and and despite what we saw from robinson i think there's trepidation
about him being able to keep doing what he did last year for years to come it is again and this this is just different people looking at like obviously
the pedigree with joe mixon is much better than it is with james robinson joe mixon's been a future
star at running back for like half a decade now um james robinson in his rookie year just had a season as good or better as Joe Mixon ever has.
And two years younger.
And we're pretty confident in Joe Mixon moving forward.
We're not sure about James Robinson.
Well, I don't know if we're that confident about Joe Mixon, but we know that there's
big opportunity for him.
We think there could be big opportunity for James Robinson.
I'm confident in touches.
We have absolutely no idea what Urban Meyer thinks of James Robinson.
I'm confident in Joe Mixon's touches.
That's why I would take him over Robinson at this point.
I'll tell you what, though.
If the draft goes by and free agency finishes up
and Jacksonville doesn't do anything significant at running back,
they've told you what they think of James Robinson. And there have been running backs in urban Myers
offenses before that have been just amazing, statistically outstanding. And it's college.
It's not pro, but the opportunities are there. That's the point. And there are opportunities
to catch as well. And we've seen Robinson do that. So we're going to have a better grip on Robinson in about three months.
Yes. And to be clear, like I said, I have one in four and Adam has two and three. I think that's
in most people's minds. I would prefer Robinson to Mixon, but I've always kind of been the
poo-pooer of Joe Mixon. You have Swift and Robinson. I have Jacobs and Mixon. Who do
you think number one in most people's minds is Swift? I believe so. Yes. That's it. You know,
it's funny though, is that
Robinson and Swift are going to be the first
two drafted and redrafted this year.
No question about it.
Who? Robinson
and Swift.
I really think that people
could
forgive Josh Jacobs' season
because what we know about Jacobs is that
he's going to get a ton of
touches he's going to dominate at the goal line we think we know about that he won't have the
catches 30 catches something like that but maybe maybe 35 maybe more but not 50 um I think I don't
know I I mean the Raiders offensive line was really banged up last year I could see people
getting back on the Josh Jacobs train like they were last year. I could see that.
All right.
Anyway,
there'll be a fever pitch for Swift for sure.
I just looked and it's fantasy football calculator.
So I don't know.
But Deandre Swift is 18th and Josh Jacobs is 25th.
Okay.
Where's Robinson is 32nd and Joe Mixon is 33rd.
This is for what? That's ADP so far?
Dynasty average draft position.
There we go.
Oh, well, Dynasty's different because even one...
But that's what we're talking about.
No, you said in redraft that...
I made the point in redraft, yes.
Right, what I'm saying is in redraft, I think Jacobs...
I think he could end up being the first of this group to go.
Well, it almost
doesn't matter because my running backs are better than
both of yours.
My duo is better than your duo.
Maybe. I mean, you've got the passing
downs guy for the Chiefs,
Clyde Everett.
Actually, he was the running downs guy for the Chiefs.
Yeah, I know, but now that's going to be Damian Williams.
All right, you've got Russell Wilson. Well, you can give your team. Go ahead.
I got Wilson at quarterback.
I got good value on him.
Running back, Jonathan Taylor was my first-round pick.
Edwards Hilaire was my third-round pick.
Calvin Ridley was my second-round pick at receiver.
Tee Higgins was my fourth-round pick at receiver.
And I had back-to-back picks.
I was the last pick in round one.
I was in the 12th slot.
Put Will Fuller with those guys.
Put Robert Woods with those guys.
Tight end is Janu, hoping that he ends up in a great spot in free agency this offseason. And then the bench,
nothing great. At running back, it's Tariq Cohen, Josh Kelly, Jeff Wilson,
Bryce Love, Anthony McFarland. I was actually happy to get McFarland,
especially now with the news about Connor being on the outs in Pittsburgh. He's got a shot to get a good
role there. Wide receiver,
Emmanuel Sanders,
Julian Edelman,
Quintez Cephas.
And that's it at receiver.
I'm definitely thin at receiver depth,
but I like the guys that I have in my lineup.
Yeah,
they give a really good team.
In fact,
I think your bench running backs just having Tariq Cohen and Jeff Wilson.
That's nice.
Yeah.
And I have Robert Tunyon too.
I got Tunyon late in the draft,
so if John, who doesn't end up in a great spot,
I can just go to Tunyon.
Hopefully he can keep it going from last year.
Cool.
Okay, well, it's long overdue,
and we have to read your Dynasty email,
so we're going to have a longer show today.
We're going to take a quick break here
on Fantasy Football today.
When we come back,
your email is fantasyfootball at cbsi.com.
Whether in the game or in life,
the right coverage
can make all the difference.
Securian Canada
gives you that coverage.
For more than 65 years,
Securian Canada
has been helping Canadians
build secure tomorrows.
Their insurance solutions
are designed to help protect you
and your loved ones financially,
giving you the peace of mind
to focus on what truly matters.
Find their products
through banks, credit unions, and associations, or visit securiancanada.ca. Did you know that across Ontario, utility damage happens 19 times a day?
That's over 4,222 incidents a year.
Don't let your next dig be one that causes costly delays or safety risks.
Before you break ground,
make it a point to request a locate.
It's not just the law.
It's a step to keep your team and community safe.
Visit ontarioonecall.ca
and avoid unnecessary damages
to get the job done right.
Data sourced from the ORCGA 2023 Dirt Report.
Our first email is from Nicholas.
14-team dynasty startup, full PPR, one quarterback.
I just traded my 3-14 and 4-0-1 and 5-14 picks
and the first pick in the rookie draft.
So he's got the last picks, the 14 picks. He traded rounds 3 and 4 plus the last pick in the rookie draft. So he's got the last picks.
He's got the 14 picks.
He traded rounds three and four
plus the last pick of round five
and the first pick of a rookie draft.
Four, pick 203, 312, and 511.
Ooh, no, I don't like this.
He basically traded his fourth round pick
in the rookie 101 for 203. Yeah, I don't like this. He basically traded his fourth round pick and the rookie 101 for 203.
Yeah.
It's third pick.
So that's the 17th overall pick
in this league.
Would you rather straight up have the 17th overall pick
or rookie 101?
My 17th overall player is
Miles Sanders.
DeAndre Swift
was the 17th overall pick in
our Dynasty startup.
I would rather have DeAndre Swift than the 101.
Would you rather have Swift than the
101?
No.
Because I love Travis
Etienne, but I totally see someone disagreeing with that.
Would you rather have Swift than the 101 last year?
Probably not.
Yes, because Swift wasn't the 101 last year.
Well, I didn't really...
You're saying would I rather have Swift than...
At this time of year,
I would rather have had probably Miles Sanders
than the 101. And I compare Swift probably Miles Sanders than the 101
and I compare Swift to Miles
Sanders for obvious reasons
remember you also gave up the
fourth round a fourth round pick too
so
101 straight up for the second round pick
it's a fourth round or two no I like the
I don't like the trade
okay
okay so this one is from Matt in Los Angeles.
Joined an existing Dynasty League last year.
Fielded a decent team, but didn't play any defense.
I have five IDP players because I wanted to have the upside
of getting breakout players.
So I finished in last place.
I have the number one pick in the rookie draft.
I have to drop five players. Who I finished in last place. I have the number one pick on the rookie draft. I have to drop five players.
Who should I drop?
Okay.
Who are the options here?
Hertz, Tannehill, Tua, Daniel Jones,
Rashad, Penny, Zach Moss,
Chenault, Debo, Marquise Brown,
Johnnie Smith, Logan Thomas,
Ravens, and Butker.
I am confused.
He has to drop five players.
He said he didn't play any defense,
five IDP players,
but also he has the Ravens.
I guess you have a DST and IDPs.
So he didn't play any IDPs last year,
but he's going to this year,
so he needs to drop five players.
Can you drop your kicker in defense?
That's the first place I'd start.
Of course you can.
He didn't play five IDP players last year.
I think he can drop anybody he wants.
True.
So do that, and then you need three more.
Yeah, you've got some tough cuts to make after that.
Did he say if it was full PPR?
Yes, he did.
I think I would still drop Daniel Jones for sure.
Rashad Penny.
And I think I would cut Logan Thomas next.
So the kicker, the defense, Jones, Penny, Logan Thomas.
Everybody else has too much upside.
Man, I'd have a hard time cutting Logan Thomas and leaving Johnny Smith as my only tight end.
So then who do you cut instead?
Zach Moss?
Definitely Daniel Jones, the kicker, the defense,
Rashad Penny.
The other options could be...
I think I'd cut John U.
Leviska, Chenault, Debo, Samuel,
John U, and Logan Thomas.
I'll tell you what.
Can you make the decision
after John U figures out
where he's playing?
I really like John U's upside,
but his upside is all entirely
100% theoretical.
Right, but Logan Thomas was a byproduct of a check down quarterback
and a Washington offense that didn't have a whole lot of other pieces to it.
I'm sure they're going to upgrade around him.
It's hard to get excited about Logan Thomas,
especially in a dynasty league.
He's an older player.
Yeah.
Okay.
One of the tight end next year.
He could be good,
but Matt figure it out.
Let's go to our next one from Francis in London.
Hey,
Roger Novak and Rafa.
Those are tennis players.
They are tennis players.
Do you know their last names?
Federer.
Yeah.
Nadal. Yeah. Nadal.
Yeah.
And Novak.
Djokovic or something like that.
Djokovic.
Djokovic.
Sorry.
Yeah.
I have a solid team.
I won the league.
I'm looking to win now.
My wide receivers are Michael Thomas,
Calvin Ridley,
Juju,
Beckham,
and Gabriel Davis.
Do I take this trade?
Give up Gabriel Davis
and a third round
2021 rookie pick for
Julio Jones. Do it.
Yeah. Cool.
This is from Steve. Where's Steve from?
Steve is from Boise,
Idaho. Second year of a
14-team Superflex League. It's half
PPR. So it's Superflex. It's 14 teams
and you have to start two tight ends.
I have 101, 104, 109, 201, 202, 203.
Yes.
For a team that drafted last year
to be dominant in two to three years.
So with my starting tight ends being
Gasicki and Ian Thomas
and only Foster Moreau on the bench,
do you think it's worth drafting Kyle hits at one Oh four?
He won't be there at one Oh nine.
Okay.
I hope he's there at one Oh four.
Two tight ends.
You have to start.
Right.
I don't know.
I mean,
he also says I could take Brevin Jordan or one of the other prospects in the
second round.
Not smart enough to speak on any of the other prospects at tight end,
but I do know that it's not a deep class.
And I know that there's a chance that pits actually gets drafted and
converted to a receiver.
That's one thing that might make it a little bit nervous to take him in a
two tight end league,
but he's got so much athleticism.
He seems like a great,
great future player in the NFL.
Are you though?
Are you surprised that Brevin Jordan is not more highly thought of? Cause he, he was the number one tight end recruit in the NFL. Are you surprised that Brevin Jordan is not more highly thought
of? Because he was the
number one tight end recruit in the country, and I
always thought he was a spectacular
player. He went to Miami, so Dave and I watched
every game he's played.
I think he's tremendous, but he's not really...
I mean, he's potentially a day three pick,
and that's not someone you want to
bank on as a starting tight end.
So, I don't know. I'm surprised.
I'm interested to see where he ends up.
He's been very injured.
But again, number one tight end recruit in the country
and he's been awesome when he's played.
So I don't know, Dave.
I was surprised that he hasn't been ranked higher.
Maybe that's a topic for a different show.
You know what?
We're going to have an NFL draft series on FFT and 5
launching next week and we'll tell you more about that and five launching next week. And, uh,
we'll tell you more about that and get into these prospects.
Colin Snyder has a question.
Should I keep Jared golf or Derek car in a dynasty league car?
I think I have car.
Yeah,
just barely.
I mean,
it's a, it's a push.
They go back and forth every time I update the quarterback rankings.
All right.
Our last email is from Brandon.
Dear Bill, Hank, Dale, and Boomhauer.
Brandon in Newfoundland.
Longtime listener of the show,
and you've helped me win multiple titles in our Dynasty League.
Nice.
12 team, one quarterback, quarterback half ppr one flex so he needs a quarterback
he has trubisky as his quarterback i do not i do not have a pick until the third round since i went
for the championship last season i am ready and willing to move on from cly Edwards-Elair. He also has Akers and Dobbins and
Melvin Gordon and Jeff Wilson.
Who are
some of the quarterbacks you would target
for Clyde Edwards-Elair? I have been
offered Raheem Mostert and
the 102 pick in this
year's rookie class. If I
do that deal to give up Edwards-Elair
for Mostert and the second pick of the
rookie draft, would you take a position player or a quarterback
i would probably take a position player i would but i don't know like what's the point of doing
that trade really like you've got jk dobbins cam acres chris godwin tyreek hill davante adams J.K. Dobbins, Cam Akers, Chris Godwin, Tyreek Hill, Devontae Adams, Joe Mixon.
Oh, he has Mixon. I'm sorry. I missed that one.
You need to go get a quarterback to win the damn league.
You make the trade for 102 and then move down.
Maybe get 110 and a future first.
And then he can take one of the quarterbacks at 110.
But that's not going to help him this year.
If the quarterback is Lawrence and possibly Zach Wilson...
It's not going to be Lawrence at 110, I wouldn't think.
Probably not. I doubt it.
But he moves back to 105.
Wouldn't all of you take the second pick in the draft
plus Mostert for Clyde Edwards-Ealer at this point?
All two of you?
I think I would.
Oh, I would take the second pick in the draft for Clyde Edwards-Ealer. I don't even need Mostert. So do the tradeZehler at this point? All of two of you? I think I would. Oh, I would take the second pick in the draft
for Clyde Edwards-Zehler. I don't even need Mostert.
I'd love to have him. Do the trade
regardless of what position
you're in. You can address quarterback
in a separate trade, but do that trade.
Could he do that trade and then
deal off Mixon for
a first-round pick in the draft
and then use that pick to get Lawrence?
Can you just trade the number two for Lamar Jackson?
Probably could do that, but then, okay.
So now I'm trading Edwards a layer basically for a stud quarter.
I don't think you can trade layout is in the league.
I don't think you can trade Clyde for Lamar Jackson, but if,
but I think you could trade the number two
for Lamar Jackson.
Depends on who's got Lamar Jackson and what his
quarterback situation is.
Okay.
CBS Sports
tight end rankings, by the way.
Kyle Pitts, ninth overall.
Guy from Penn State,
Pat Fryermuth.
No idea how to pronounce that.
24th overall.
Brevin Jordan, 46th overall.
So if that's the case, then Jordan will have some appeal.
But I'm seeing a lot of different things on him.
All right, that's it for today's show.
It was a long one, just like your Dynasty Leagues.
Thank you for tuning in.
We appreciate it.
And we will talk to you next week,
unless there's some breaking news over the weekend.
You know, we'll always have those bonus pods for you.
Thanks to Dave and Heath and Ben Schrager.
I'm Adam Azer.
Have a good weekend, everybody.
See ya.