Fantasy Footballers - Fantasy Football Podcast - The TRUTH: RBs Part 2 + Late Round Hits - Fantasy Football Podcast for 1/28
Episode Date: January 28, 2025Conference Championship reactions and THE TRUTH on today’s fantasy football podcast! Running Back TRUTH Part 2 including Joe Mixon, Bucky Irving, Chase Brown, and many others! Get a deep dive look a...t consistency numbers, weekly performances, and 2025 outlooks. Plus, the latest coach hirings and how they impact fantasy football! Manage your redraft, keeper, and dynasty fantasy football teams with the #1 fantasy football podcast. -- Fantasy Football Podcast for January 28th, 2025. (00:00) - Intro (00:30) - Playoff Games Recap (09:20) - NFL News (21:30) - RB Truth Part 2 (25:52) - Alvin Kamara (29:35) - James Conner (33:35) - Chase Brown (37:20) - Chuba Hubbard (42:40) - Joe Mixon (46:40) - Jonathan Taylor (50:30) - Aaron Jones (53:30) - Bucky Irving & Rachaad White (57:21) - David Montgomery (01:00:50) - Breece Hall (01:06:10) - Najee Harris Connect with the show: Subscribe on YouTube Visit us on the Web Support the Show Follow on X Follow on Instagram Join our Discord Check out today's sponsors: News & Notes presented by USAA. Visit https://USAA.com/Insurance Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Hey Spotify, this is Javi.
My biggest passion is music,
and it's not just sounds and instruments.
It's more than that to me.
It's a world full of harmonies with chillers.
From streaming to shopping, it's on Prime.
Calling all sellers,
Salesforce is hiring account executives
to join us on the cutting edge of technology.
Here, innovation isn't a buzzword,
it's a way of life. You'll be
solving customer challenges faster with agents, winning with purpose, and showing the world
what AI was meant to be. Let's create the agent-first future together. Head to salesforce.com
slash careers to learn more. Welcome to the Fantasy Footballers Podcast with your hosts, Andy Holloway, Jason Moore
and Mike Wright. Welcome in.
Pack it up.
We're done?
Pack it up?
Yeah, we're done.
Pack it in?
Oh, no, man, no.
I disagree with you.
Are you talking about the season like we're all,
we're good here?
It's a wrap.
I think Andy is disappointed
in the Super Bowl outcome of who's playing it.
Emma, is that what the take is?
Tongue in cheek, yes.
I'm not actually, I mean, when it arrives,
it will be an event. We're watching history and
You know that's what will be on TV that day I
Get it. I think everyone in the world, you know, you're always rooting for the underdog
No one's rooting for the Chiefs this last weekend unless you're from Kansas City or you're wearing your kids chiefs hat
No one was rooting for them
And I and I think on the's hat. No one was rooting for them. And I think on the other side, everyone was rooting for
Jaden Daniels in the Cinderella story of the Commander.
So I totally get that.
But I think people are really missing the fact that I think
the two best teams are in the Super Bowl, and they're both
incredibly awesome teams.
And it's a rematch from a couple years ago.
There's a lot of storylines I actually like about this.
I could tell that was the angle you were going to take on the show today. You want to know why?
Tell me because you're the only person in our live game slack channel
That didn't think Josh Allen got the first down. So I knew I knew we were coming in here
I didn't think you got it either. I knew we were coming in here and you would be you know
I mean make no mistake. I was rooting for the Bills.
I was very upset with a lot of the play calling,
the constant fails, failures on the single tush push.
There is.
Taking James Cook out of the game way too often.
Yeah, and I think that was blood's pickup stuff
and I agree with you on the take.
I saw you tweet that.
I do feel a sense, we have a responsibility.
I wanna get this off on the right track.
I wanna put the fandom of the NFL,
the average NFL fan on the right pathway here,
which is not to focus on, did they get the first down,
or this play, did it hit the ground or any of those?
I mean, yes, there were some bad calls. In my opinion, there were some bad calls.
Game was still a great game. Big plays still had to happen. Two third downs and had to happen at the end of the game,
which Andy Reid is just unstoppable on those.
You know, what makes the Chiefs more irritating
is that they don't mess them up.
And that's what comes down to Mahomes.
Like, Samaaj P. Ryan for the third down line to gain
in the game instead of giving us a minute with Josh Allen.
He hadn't played in the game.
Can you drop it?
What if you drop it?
What if you screwed up?
What if the Chiefs screw up? What if the chief screwed
up? What if they had a player like Dalton Kincade that had the ball go right through
Hedarian?
And it doesn't have to be someone that has been a failure like Dalton Kincade. You've
seen Saquon Barkley have a couple of those mess ups this year and drop the importance.
Mark Andrews a great player.
Just screw up, Casey.
Nobody screws up there. But you know what's funny is like-
Now they win.
Mahomes is really, really good.
And we can complain about the calls.
We could complain about the short area passing
versus his heyday of airing it out.
But it's like, put him aside, Andy Reid is so good.
Like Mahomes did nothing great on that third down.
I was watching the play, I'm rooting against the Chiefs.
I see the whole play develop,
the entire offense goes to the right and there's Peter
I just leak it out hidden
No one could see him wide open here like that is such a good design and on the play where it can K drops the
Miracle throw from Josh Allen the fadeaway jumper
From the back right corner look he had Shakira on the same P Ryan play on the left side of the field wide open
That could have been the read Look, he had Shakir on the same P Ryan play on the left side of the field, wide open.
That could have been the read.
It's funny because you said, okay, give Andy Reed credit, give him a Holmes credit.
They deserve a lot of credit.
What's crazy though is it was the supporting cast.
It's the spagnola.
It's the defensive side of the ball.
Josh Allen has played in his three games against the Chiefs in the playoffs.
He hasn't thrown in interception.
He hasn't fumbled the football, he has nine touchdowns,
he's done literally everything you can do,
but you can't stop the Chiefs with 13 seconds left
two years ago.
You can't stop the Chiefs on third down
twice on the final drive.
He is...
As an Arizona native.
It's tough, man.
As an Arizona native, I have always thought,
and I think statistically speaking across the major sports, and I don't count baseball in that, we are the saddest fan base.
We've had winning franchises, we've never won anything of relevance.
The Cardinals have never won a Super Bowl, they never will.
The Suns have never won the championship, they never will.
But we got nothing on the Bills.
I feel so bad for the Bills fans who have,
I mean they just, they root through the bad times,
through the good times, and they've had so many good times
that will never, ever result in the championship.
I feel, it's just, it's so sad.
One team wins every year.
Everybody else failed.
They still can.
Everybody else screwed it up.
You mean the Chiefs?
The Chiefs win every year.
So I agree.
It's kind of boring in terms of fatigue,
like the two teams that are there.
But looking it up, because I was like, I don't know.
Because this is a game of not just this year.
Like that's how I'm going to try and look
at this game in my brain.
This is a game, this is my brain. This is a game.
This is a legacy.
This is greatness.
You either have the three-peat from Mahomes, which that will be a,
it's never been done.
And that will be, even if he doesn't catch Tom Brady.
That'll be its own marker.
If you're like, that guy got three in a row,
and it would be what, four and five years,
something like that, you're like, maybe he's,
maybe we can just call it, say that's the greatest
of all time, and then on the other side,
there's one quarterback who has two Super Bowl victories,
at least my quick research while you guys were talking,
Kyle, you can correct me if you know,
there's only one quarterback in the Super Bowl era
who has two Super Bowl
wins and is not in the Hall of Fame.
I mean, Eli, we still have time to go for him to see if he gets in or not, but Jim Plunkett
has two Super Bowl wins with the Raiders and no Hall of Fame.
Am I right on that, Kyle?
You go ahead and vet that.
I've never thought of,
well, is Jaylen Hurts gonna be a Hall of Fame title?
You mean two Super Bowl appearances?
I was gonna say you'd have to get another championship
after this year.
Oh, oh, he didn't.
We were at that game.
We didn't win, yeah, no.
We had really good season there, Mike.
You were right there, Mike.
I was mixing the Eagles win in, or the Nick Foles won.
Yeah.
Okay.
My bad, everybody.
So just undo most of what you said?
I guess it's not, well well what a boring game, but hey
For sake one that's the only side of that of that team that I want to win
You can't win a second Super Bowl without the first so this is the beginning of your argument. That's true
I agree sake one is the storyline on the eagle side that I'm rooting for the most
I hate to admit it, but like I know you don't you don't hate to admit it I agree. Saquon is the storyline on the Eagle side that I'm rooting for the most I
Hate to admit it, but like I know you don't know hate to admit. Oh, I do I don't want to say it out loud
Oh, no, you've been saying it every way shape and form. I think I'm room for the big ref big chiefs over here
No, you've always been big ref. Not anymore. I'm getting get rid of all formation rules. Um
Yeah, 55
23 Eagles over the commander
32 29 chiefs over the Bills a much closer game for the commander's Eagles than that score
I mean the majority of the game was pretty close and they were they were with
I mean, I they were with 11 points. I mean there you go. I mean there
you go. That's a two score game. But that's a close game. They had one drive in the middle
of the game that they turned the ball over for the third time where they could have brought
it closer. When you're down by 11 and you have the ball, that's a close game. I will
say that I just felt bad for Jayden Dados who played outstanding because his team kept
fumbling the ball.
Yeah, they did.
Yeah, you don't win giving up 55 points in three turnovers.
But once you get to the end of the game,
like they had to go for it.
It was like fourth and long on the 30 or so.
It's like, well, we don't have a choice.
And that's when the score gets blown out of proportion.
I thought that game was fantastic.
Washington played a really strong game
despite giving up 55 points in the end.
And the future for the commanders is very, very bright.
All right, we will talk some more news.
News and notes from around the league presented by USA insurance
The Raiders hired Adam Thielen as their head coach.
Oh wait that's Pete Carroll.
73 years young.
He does seem younger than
than several head coaches. Yeah I actually think it's a very good hire.
You've got a guy who... I actually think it's a very good hire.
You've got a guy who.
I don't know what's going on today.
No, what is happening here?
No, it's not.
Wait.
No, it's not.
I'm not allowed to have my own opinions here
if they don't follow yours?
You are, but you're just wrong.
Okay, let's hear it.
Okay, here's, I believe that the Raiders,
as an organization, have not been the most functional.
Right, you've got this owner at the top who's obviously been a little bit too meddling.
And you're going from, a lot of times random head coach to random head coach,
Gruden was a stabilizing force, but that obviously ended in an upheaval, a bad fact.
Catastrophe.
Yes, because of things that weren't really football related.
Right.
Pete Carroll is a stabilizing force.
I know he's old.
He's 73.
That's insanely old for a head coach.
However, he doesn't-
For a human.
I don't-
Sure, for a human, for any job.
For a working human, 73 is extremely old.
But he's an outlier.
I mean, you could say that at 31 is extremely old for a running back. That's also a fact that's true. But Derrick Henry's an outlier. I mean you could say that it's 31 is extremely old for a running back
That's also a fact that's true
But Derek Henry's an outlier and I think Pete Carroll has more energy than I have
has pretty much always been part of winning programs and
When he got fired, it was a surprise. I don't think people he wasn't on the hot seat
And so I believe he is a good coach.
So when I look at-
He did hire Biden as offensive coordinator.
It makes sense.
I mean, they're, you know, probably cousins.
Just get all the old guys.
You know, this is to me when I'm thinking,
is it a good hire for a head coach?
My first question is, well, is he a good coach?
I think he is.
I'm gonna agree with Jason on this,
on the principle that of what was remaining,
which they failed horribly to acquire
any of the coaches they actually wanted,
this was the one that's gonna most positively
impact the locker room and probably be a bridge
to a future situation.
Now-
It was not a long-term plan.
I mean, I'll get on with it.
I won't say that.
If they end up like some, I think Jeremiah's mock draft
has Shadoor Sanders there at six.
You know, we've seen Pete Carroll
and a rookie quarterback before make waves.
Players will respect Pete Carroll, I agree with that, Brooks.
You have a situation that was kind of just dysfunctional
through and through over the last few years.
So, you know, in that regard, look,
it's probably a better NFL to see Pete Carroll
chewing bubblegum on the sidelines
and Peach Cobbler back in the business.
Ah, Peach Cobbler.
I'm in full agreement that Pete Carroll is an excellent coach.
It's just, he's 73 and the Raiders' job is,
that thing is the ashes right now.
There is absolute nothing.
That's how you get another job at 73, I'll tell you that.
You're trying to build your program up with,
like Pete Carroll has taken over an orphaned dynasty team.
That's what has happened.
And Pete Carroll, I mean.
He's probably got more testosterone
than the three of us combined.
For sure.
There was the video of him getting into office in
Raiders office today, and I'm like I'm analyzing this and it's that guy does not walk around like he is
73 like they're good. He just I do he could just move
Like when I'm walking down the hall, I'm like, oh, my hip. 73. Like, it, oh.
I hope it works.
Do you like it more or less than the Jaguars and Liam Cohen?
We had the absolute, what, like a three movie spectacle,
the Liam Cohen adventures.
We announced on our show.
Yeah, we did.
We had it in the news that.
Which was reported because of it being reported by, you know.
Yeah, I mean, it was officially reported,
obviously it was not officially signed,
that he was remaining with the Bucs as the head coach,
as great for continuity and all of that.
OC.
As the OC.
And, um.
Eight.
Nope.
Eight offensive coordinators in eight years
for Baker Mayfield now.
That's gotta be a record.
And Liam Cohen, what happened is he had,
they had extended him the contract
to make him the highest paid offensive coordinator ever,
and he hadn't signed it.
And instead of signing it on Thursday morning,
he secretly,
He feats, and under the cover of darkness.
He secretly traveled on a quote,
he reported a personal matter to Tampa Bay.
It was very personal.
At that point you have to take that job.
And then went to Jacksonville.
Didn't tell them that he was in Jacksonville.
And kind of, yeah, set up the next tenure here in.
Do you think, because this.
Jaguar country.
It's funny, the way that that process played out,
I keep going back and forth, obviously,
these are humans with relationships,
Baker, Bowles, they're a friend to this man.
But also, friends can piss you off
and do things to end friendships.
And I wonder if the fact that it seemed like,
oh, you're coming back and then you secretly go
and get another job, are they happy for him?
Or are they mad at him?
Mad.
Yeah, I mean, that was my first guess.
Yeah, because I think they're gonna feel a level of betrayal.
And it, like, this all didn't happen,
the reexamination of the hire,
that didn't happen until the Jaguars fired the GM, right?
Yes, Trent Balke.
Which was, like, to me, it's like, this is one of the problems of the Jaguars fired the GM, right? Which was, to me, this is one of the problems of the Jags,
of why are you gonna go take that job if you have a GM
who you don't have faith in, and this person's controlling
so much of my job right now, I don't wanna be a part of it,
and it was a shock that they kept him on,
when the season first ended, it kind of figured like
this would be a full clear house they didn't it almost costs them getting their guy but
eventually they make the decision to bring Cohen in. I forgot that that
was the that was the the zoom interview yes the owner and the GM are both on it
and they were asked like would you replace the GM and he's like yeah if
something better came along I would
Right there
you know you're gonna start seeing the
Travis ETN and the Bucky Irving role type of videos coming out and all of them the projection of how they might run the Jacksonville offense
Cuz I how it always works well I look with Jacksonville
Some teams you might be able to do that and say you know what?
This is gonna really be special when this guy comes into this situation
I'm gonna make them show me that first on the field in Jacksonville with the way that Trevor Lawrence has been inconsistent ETN inconsistent
Maybe it makes you more excited about stability for Brian Thomas jr. Moving forward
But the problem with the bucky Irving role, in quotes, is that it was him.
Like, the role was, he's super explosive,
and he's breaking tackles and getting away from people.
If you wanna talk about the Rashad White role
from a couple years ago where he was a great pass catcher,
that makes sense, that was more of the role.
Well, today's the truth episode part two for writing back,
so we will talk about both Bucky and Mr. White.
Yeah.
The Seahawks replaced the one year trial of Ryan Grub
with Clint Kubiak, their new offensive coordinator.
All right. Run that ball.
I mean, this, you know, Grub,
I think this is a defensive head coach
that wants to run the ball.
Grub came in, said all the right things,
said he was gonna run the ball, and then they threw it a lot. And I don't think that wants to run the ball. Grubb came in, said all the right things, said he was gonna run the ball,
and then they threw it a lot,
and I don't think that that was what was desired.
The Cowboys hired Brian Schottenheimer
to be their next head coach.
They're gonna hire Matt Eberfluss
as their defensive coordinator.
All right, guys, tell me how to feel about Schottenheimer.
This one is fascinating.
So if 10 is excited,
and one is as unexcited as you can get, Brooks as a cowboy fan, you're on the microphone, I think. Do we have Brooks
with us? Yeah, sorry, which is the least excited side? The small number, Brooks. The small number, Brooks.
We'll give him a two. OK.
I think that's been the general sentiment.
Jerry Jones coming out and saying, look,
I can live outside the box.
Here's a guy without coaching experience.
I'm making him my head coach.
Did you see him get teary-eyed at the press conference?
I think that was today talking about how he's known this guy
and he's talked to a bunch of people about him and...
I mean, look, I'm fine with it. I really am. What's your one through ten?
Excitement? Excitement. It can't be more than a four. I am a four. A four in excitement, but an
eight in consistency. So like we thought losing Kellen Moore would lead to the demise of the offense and instead what it led to was the success of Dak Prescott as a fantasy asset and CD Lamb as a
fantasy asset to the nth degree. So in that regard you're going to have
stability and to that I'm happy about that because those are the players that
I care about on that offense. Yeah Jerry Jones did confirm that Schottenheimer is
going to be the play caller as well, at least to start, which could be good news for going from
McCarthy trying to get a little bit more action in the motion, you know,
pre-snap stuff that the Cowboys didn't really do.
And it could be, like, everything in the NFL is chicken or egg, you know,
do you have the offense?
Do you have the players that can actually run the offense?
But there was an ESPN write-up that Hayden Winx
had tweeted about with the quote,
in 12 years as a playcaller, Schottenheimer
had four offenses finished inside the top 10
in points per game and three times in the top half
in the league in yards per game.
So we have plenty of years of shot and hire.
It's like, oh, he was with the Jets.
So it's hard to really know.
But did they win?
I don't really care about wins or losses.
I care about points.
For fantasy, yeah.
So.
Well, we were talking philosophically
why they would hire a player or hire a coach.
They do seem to care about wins in the NFL.
Yes, and he has, as an OC, win-loss percentage,
aside from last year, the four years before that,
with a couple years with Seattle, it's good.
Right.
I'm just curious.
I don't know the answer to that, but Bobby Sloak
went from a hot.
Oh my goodness.
Bobby Sloak was the offensive coordinator for the Texans,
now fired.
We bemoaned his play calling from the jump this year
after loving it last year.
It's one of the reasons Houston believes
they took a step back with CJ Stroud
was predictable play calling no adjustments
Basically everything that Liam Cohen did well slow it did poorly that man flew
In not too close to the Sun. He flew into the Sun
Sometimes you're projected to be a top-five pick and you go back. Yeah college
Yep, and it don't work out and your career never happens. That
was Bobby Sloan.
He could have had any of the jobs last year, whatever was open last year. You didn't want
to take them, but whoops.
I'm impressed by the Texans to make the change. It's very difficult to go to the second round
of the playoffs, two years in a row, and then say we need to remove our offensive coordinator.
But having that kind of thoughtful introspection
on what is good and what could be improved,
I'm pretty impressed,
because the play calling was, I think, very poor.
All right, that was today's News and Notes,
presented by USAA Insurance.
Learn more at usaa.com slash insurance.
We'll take a break.
We'll hit the running backs.
Toronto.
There's another great city that starts with a T.
Tampa, Florida.
Fly to Tampa on Porter Airlines to see why it's so tea-rific.
On your way there, relax with free beer, wine, and snacks,
free fast-streaming Wi-Fi, and
no middle seats.
You've never flown to Florida like this before, so you'll land in Tampa ready to explore.
Visit flyporter.com and actually enjoy economy.
All right.
It's time to get back into the truth.
You want answers?
I think I'm entitled.
You want answers?
I want the truth!
You can't handle the truth!
We still have a Saints head coaching job to figure out, don't we?
Yes, there was a...
Is Cliff going to end up in so Joe Brady or?
Mike McCarthy
Maybe I mean there's like you said it's slim Pickens left Joe Brady has elected to remain with Buffalo
He's going to stay he was garnering interest and so I think
What happened here is he saw what Liam Cohen did on?
like I'm totally I'm totally gonna stay with the Bucs.
And then the Jags were like, oh, we'll steal ya.
I don't know, not really.
That is the last coaching job left.
We also, Cliff can interview now, he's got time.
Monkin, Todd Monkin, the OC for the Ravens,
it was also, I don't know if he signed it.
Coming on back, yeah. Or if they were working on the extension,
but that's, whew, that's fantastic news
for Ravens Fantasy Football.
All right, we're back into the running backs.
We covered the top eight last week.
Today we'll get into the names like Kamara,
Connor, Chase Brown, Jonathan Taylor,
and talk about the truth,
which is our analysis of their consistency
and their
actual value to your fantasy team when contrasted to their fantasy finish and
how impactful were they? We talked through eight names. One of the headline
takeaways for running backs in 2024 was that, well, it wasn't a year for Zero RB.
The elite running backs they crushed. Yes, McCaffrey was a bust with the 101 or 102 in your
league, but you look at the next 10 guys off the board, you had a lot of hits. Bijon, Gibbs,
Saquon, Kyron, Henry, A-chan, these are names that we brought up in the first Running Back Truth episode.
There was a small pocket of late round hits that happened.
Chase Brown in the 10th round, Chuba Hubbard in the 11th round, but it took Chase Brown
a while to get going, so that didn't help you right out of the gate.
And then J.K. Dobbins was a contributor, so there was a little run there
in the 10th, 11th, and 13th round.
There was reinforcements.
There wasn't, like these weren't good.
Not league winners.
Yeah, well, I mean, Chase Brown was a league winner,
but if you managed to hold onto him long enough,
it wasn't a week two, oh, here we go.
Here was the late round hit
that's gonna be consistent all year long.
They were like band-aids for the season.
I will say that when projecting out these late round guys,
gotta give credit to Mike,
cause he was talking about the teams that you want
being Chargers, Bengals, Cowboys,
and those were three of the only later round running backs
that did much of anything
I think the real reason zero RB didn't work is there wasn't a bunch of waiver wire pickups because the top guys
You know didn't get injured
So the waiver wire is usually where the anti
fragility
Becomes a strength. Yes, and outside of Bucky at the very end of the season
There wasn't wasn't a whole lot. Yeah, when you outside of Bucky at the very end of the season there wasn't wasn't a whole lot Yeah, when you bring out Bucky
I start to think about the narrative and data that surrounds that you know that there's a rookie writing back that always ends up in that
Top tier well it wasn't the ones you it wasn't you know
Trey Benson wasn't one of those guys and Johnny's and brockham Blake Corum
It wasn't anybody that was predictably drafted even towards the end March on Lloyd. Those were the four names that got brought up a ton.
Even Jaylen Wright, none of those guys contributed.
The guy that contributed was a free agent running back,
Bucky Irving, who came in and just kind of
stole away the job and then we had.
Tyrone Tracy for the Giants was pretty good.
All right, so a quick refresh reminder for you.
We're looking at their game log,
how many great games of 21 or more points,
how many good games, 12 or more points,
how many bust games, fewer than seven points.
Coming in at number nine on the fantasy finish list
with a consistency rank of six, tried and true.
Alvin Kamara, we did it again.
Now we got hurt down the stretch.
So if you, you know, Kamara and James Connor to me were two of the best running
back values for the entire season, right?
You had Kamara in the fifth round, Connor in the fifth round, both of those guys in the top 12.
And Kamara did it for you pretty much the whole year you just didn't get him
during the fantasy playoffs yeah that was a real shame and I'm not sure how
much of that was you know towards the very the very very end of the season you
know the final three weeks was just shut him down because you had no one else out
there he's a veteran you you know you you don't have your quarterback you
don't have your wide receiver you don't have your wide receiver. You don't have your tight end. Like everybody got injured.
So why put him out there? I'm going to be honest with you. He's 29 years old. I'm not
usually in on, you know, aging running backs in the end of their thirties. I'm going to
be in on Camaro. I feel like we've worried about his age for the last two seasons and
he just catches the ball so much that for fantasy football
purposes, I think he has a very safe floor.
He wasn't always having those incredibly powerful,
week-winning performances.
He did very early in the season, like week two.
But it was very hard for him to not have a good fantasy game
when you're targeted as much as he is.
There is a, yeah, there he is.
There is a comfort level with Derek Carr being back
and they seem to have confidence that Derek Carr
is gonna be the quarterback.
That gives me confidence that, you know,
he will throw the ball to Alvin Kamara
and take the path of least resistance
oftentimes in the offense.
He was much better against bottom half defenses, like eight fantasy
points per game better when it was a matchup that you know, you could see
coming, so to speak, and defenses that weren't strong, you know, he's just
been so consistent and he is very much in the Derek Henry category, I think, in people's minds and fantasy now,
where it's like, well, you know it won't last forever,
but do you just keep enjoying this
and ride it right into the ground,
because he doesn't really have to do a lot
to give you a lot in fantasy with the receiving work.
Yeah, and that kind of stretched there.
So like week seven through 14, where he's still
giving you pretty much top 15 type numbers,
but because of the Saints, where the team was at that time,
they just weren't scoring.
And Alvin Camaro wasn't scoring.
So for him to be able to do all of those,
to give you that level of fantasy when he's not
getting the ridiculous touchdowns,
I think it's a good sign for next year.
His ADP will be fascinating to me.
I don't think it'll be that high.
He's not going to move up much.
But does he just chill out in the fifth round?
Because then, yeah, sure.
He'll be fourth.
I definitely think he'll be fifth or later.
I mean, he was the fifth round this year and he was great this
this season prior on a per game basis, got injured at the end of the year.
It was very similar to this year.
And I think next year going he's going to be 30.
I think he's in the fifth and I'll I'll draft him.
He is just fun fact.
He is a few months younger than Austin Eckler.
So, you know, the nice thing is his contract
situation he's under contract for a couple more years. Yeah and they made an
effort to bring him back to make him the you know. The way that the Saints
operate I assume they'll have to give him a contract extension soon and kick
that money further down. James Connor, I just mentioned him,
he comes in at number 10, consistency rank was 13.
I'll be honest, he felt more consistent than that
as someone who had him on my roster.
He did have a couple just absolute disappearing games,
but first half consistency rank was 14, second half 15,
better against bad defenses, much better at home.
Six points better at home.
13% great games, 69% good games, 25% busts.
I didn't give you those numbers for Kamara.
Kamara was 21% great, 71% good, 7% busts.
So they're very similar.
The bust games were really frustrating for James Connor because it never looked like
his fault.
And it probably wasn't.
Yeah, I mean there were games where it was really frustrating watching where it's like
this is the locomotive to your team.
Did you count our week 17?
Week 17 is in this data.
Which he got hurt on the first play, didn't play anymore.
Correct.
So that's one of the...
Basically, yeah. But you would have played him, and honestly,
if you had him and you were in the championship,
you know that week 17 counted.
If, for context, you just were curious
what it would be like without that, I could get it.
Maybe that's why it felt that way to me,
is that he was a little bit better than 13.
He would be consistency rank of running back 10.
Okay, he felt much more like 10.
Yeah.
So what do you think about James Connor? He
signed a two-year extension in late November to stay with Arizona. Very much
the identity of the team. You know, we talk about Philadelphia and the
transition to being Saquon's team. I feel like that happened this year in
Arizona. Like it went from Kyler's team to Connor's team in some ways. You
saw the commitment from the team in signing him again.
This really is, he is the heart of this offense.
So you can make a strong argument that the way he played
down the stretch was incredible.
He should be drafted highly with confidence.
However, he's not the, he doesn't have like,
you know, we're just
talking about Camara. Camara had 89 targets and missed three games. If you
compare that to James Connor, his receiving work, he can be a good
receiver, but he's not to that level. So I worry if you lose a step, like if both
of these guys lose a step, Camara and Connor, I think Camara will be fine for
fantasy and Connor will turn to dust. So I'm I'm a little bit more worried. I think Camaro will be fine for fantasy and Conor will turn to dust.
So I'm a little bit more worried. I saw nothing on film to make me worry that he
will turn to dust, but that's what happens with these, you know, Sean
Alexander's who go from being one of the best running backs in the entire league
to the next year just, you know, just one step too slow is too slow in the NFL.
And I think he'll be, he's gonna I think he'll be another great value pick to me next year.
I think that he has at least one year.
That dynasty-wise, does he have two?
I don't know.
But I'm going to put the chips on him having at least one more really strong season.
He stayed mostly...
So many games over 100 yards.
Mostly healthy, scored eight times on the ground,
had one receiving touchdown, but 414 receiving yards.
So yeah, I mean, he's definitely going to be
in that category of guys that just doesn't move up
in fantasy dress. Right.
It just won't happen at his age and with Arizona and no excitement of any kind around the franchise
ever again.
Because James Connor will not be a ceiling pick where you're like, oh, this is the year
that he can have an outlier season to give me 1300 rushing yards and 14 rushing
touchdowns. That seems impossible.
Yeah, that's why he's going to be a dead zone running back. And what you're hoping for is
that he just has another season like this one where he's consistent, has enough touchdowns
around the goal line, and is still breaking tackles next year.
He's a lunch pail guy for your fantasy team.
Yeah. At 11, Chase
Brown, 24 years old, drafted in the 10th round as the RB 41. Here's a diamond in
the rough. Consistency rank of 10 and even more impressive. Go look at that
second half where he was the third most consistent running back in football and
it's pretty fair to look at the second half alone because he was sharing time with Zach Moss
Was not the guy to start the year in the first couple games
Ends up 25% great games despite that
63% good 19% bust great at home and on the road great against top and bottom defenses
And you just need the Zach Moss injury to get him going and the team to trust him.
Zach Moss played the first eight games so this is a true split here the first eight and the rest
through 17 you know the first half consistency rank of running back 29 he was good on a per touch
basis we watched the games and we said he's he looks better than than Zach Moss. Yeah he had more
juice. It took that injury for the team to be forced to just say, okay, we're giving it to you.
And their offense got so much better.
Chase Brown was...
He's just so much more versatile.
So explosive and made plays that Zach Moss just couldn't
and didn't make.
Now the question becomes, do they commit to him?
Did they see that down the stretch and say,
that's the replacement for our Joe Mixon that
we lost.
We're going to commit to him going forward because it was so successful for us.
Or do they go, we can't rely on that.
We wanted two backs.
And I think it's transactions that will tell us.
I think they'll stick with him.
He's at that perfect age to me and the way he played for this team
to enter his Eckler era for Cincinnati.
I would believe that they saw his improvement
and his versatility and his pass catching.
Everything improved over the course of the year.
So I don't know what you would want in Cincinnati
beyond a 24 year old running back
that gave you that kind of production.
Yes, they might draft somebody,
but look, this is a team that has a lot of needs too.
The defensive side of the football betrayed Borough.
And if they do happen to invest in T Higgins,
that's even more of a reason I think that you don't go
and find anything other than a little Herbert style running back. to me a 10th round pick last year this is a guy I would take
ahead of Connor oh he will skyrocket third fourth round so Zach Moss signed a
two-year deal he should be back I mean so that's that's really up on my
expectation is that they're gonna come back into next year with the same core
that they came into this season and we won't know for sure what the commitment is
on a workload split.
Obviously when Zach Moss was healthy,
he was, it was pretty 50-50, so it'll be scary.
They'll just have to decide,
do they want to waste a down or not?
Right, but a lot of teams decide to waste downs.
I don't get it.
You call them the Tyler Johnson downs.
He's not expensive next year.
Talking about Zach Moss for the year two of his contract.
But the cap hit is $4.8 million, so just under $5.
Dead cap would be $1.5.
Yeah, they'd have to spend money to replace him
and add that dead cap.
But just saying, if they feel like, oh, this was.
Herbert.
Yeah, if they feel like Herbert was was we can try and bring him back
I don't remember if he's a free agent or not
But down the stretch those last eight games to give context to how good chase Brown was he was on pace for?
320 carries and
93 targets if that was a 17 game span 1300 rushing yards
650 in the passing game so So an exceptional fantasy asset,
and you'll have to call your shot next year.
I agree, he didn't just fill in.
No, he didn't.
He was in addition.
Yes.
All right, Chuba Hubbard.
Where's the respect for Chuba Hubbard?
I still don't have it, I still,
I can't get myself to have it.
I tried multiple times to give you the end of the season
of Chuba Hubbard with Carolina and eye test
and tell you, I tried to say this guy's a baller.
And you know what, I say I still don't have it,
but I definitely.
He'll wipe his tears with all his money.
Down the, I mean the film on Chuba was excellent.
Outstanding, yeah I mean 1195 yards, 10 touchdowns,
despite missing the last two weeks of the year.
And despite playing for the Panthers.
One of his least valuable traits.
They were very bad.
Yeah, I mean he did a lot.
You know, it's hard to remember going back.
I believe he was a five-star recruit out of high school
and a superstar track athlete. Yeah, I think you know
He had a two thousand yard rushing season in college and so to start his NFL career
He kind of dropped in the draft
I don't I don't remember the the context as to why maybe Kyle can because he had the huge year and then the next year
It was oh and it was not nearly
He profiled a couple years ago as somebody that would be that career backup, career second
tier committee back and transformed really over the back half of 2023 and then into 2024.
I mean the numbers that I just read out, he put them up with the second fewest total offensive
plays in football in Carolina, the third fewest offensive plays with the lead, which we like, running backs with the lead.est total offensive plays in football in Carolina. The third fewest
offensive plays with the lead, which we like running backs with the lead.
Yeah, we do.
And 20% great, 60% good, 20% bust games. Didn't, you know, he finishes at 12 with a consistency
rank of 12. Not a lot of receiving production. 43 catches, that's good. 171 yards, that's
not good.
No, that's good. 171 yards, that's not good. No, that's wildly low.
And they give them a four year $33 million contract
in November and all the Jonathan Brooks truethers
are going, oh my gosh.
And then Jonathan Brooks re-tears his ACL.
You get the Miles Sanders week 18.
And you know, Chuba was just so,
he reminded me the most of what Connor was for Arizona
this year.
Those two players.
Every down, Connor ran as hard as he could run.
Every down Chuba Hubbard ran as hard as he could run.
And a lot of tackle breaking.
I don't know.
I just, maybe it's the underdog story of being a Carolina Panther and having production
that also adds to the lore of Chuba Hubbard.
Or the fact that it was just a player
that no one wanted to draft
because he went in the 12th round.
No one wanted him, which process wise it makes sense.
You don't want a perceived grinder.
Or a perceived expiring asset.
Yes, yeah, with the rookies gonna come in
and take over for a bad team.
Like, it's not like, hey, I'm gonna have
the starting running back for the Kansas City Chiefs
for six weeks and then the rookies gonna take over.
I'll take that bet, I'll take that starting running back.
You certainly would have taken the bet
that the starting running back for, say, the Chargers, a team that profiled to be good that was going to
run a lot, would perform better than Truba Hubbard and he bucked the trend.
He's the outlier. So is the lesson here to learn nothing? I mean genuinely like
like that it's just a little bit he was better than we thought he was. I mean
that was kind of just the truth as an actual running back. Yeah. Or maybe the lesson, if you want to take one, is to have trusted what we saw in the field
during the back half of last year and not count that as a kind of an outlier performance. And I
don't know if that translates to- Yeah. No, that's fair for you. You did talk about that.
You believed it. You said it was really, really good down the stretch past the eye test. So-
There- We did have. So believe in yourself.
We had a very clean narrative coming into the year as to why Chuba could be not good.
It was very like vanilla, right? It was going to be obvious. It was like, okay, Chuba,
last year the contract, we get Jonathan Brooks, maybe he's a bridge, the team sucks.
Everything was very lined up for that to be the truth. And maybe that's the lesson too, is that
it's very circumstance specific
and Chuba was just the better player.
There was also, like, it took a while.
You know, like the first couple weeks,
they were still time sharing with Chuba
and week one was a disaster.
Chuba was six for 14 with no catches in week one.
And it was, well, there's the 11th round pick.
Was it Dalton that took over in week three?
Yes.
That made a difference.
Yeah, it certainly did.
But also his snaps going up.
Week one and week two and week three, 58% of the snaps.
But then you start going north and you're
in like an 80% player.
I mean, that's when things really were turning around.
He was getting, he would get you chunk plays,
but then other guys would come on the field
and you're like, yeah, give me somebody else.
Once Chuba's on there, worked out.
Yeah, Andy, you're gonna need to convince me next year
and remind me that I should be more in on Chuba,
because I still feel like I'm not going to be.
Because it's still the Panthers, he was so inefficient
in the passing game.
He needs that giant workload to be great, but he got it.
So yeah, just work on it.
Yeah, no, no, no, we'll do it again.
We'll run it back.
13 is Joe Mixon.
What a season for Joe Mixon,
because first half of the season,
he was the number three most consistent running back.
And it really, it took a nosedive in the second half,
19th in consistency, dealt with an ankle injury, dealt with one
from weeks three to five, then came out of that.
Just fine.
And delivered six consecutive top 12 performances
despite Bobby Slawick's play calling.
John Nixon was a revelation the first half.
This was like week to week,
he was in the Saquon Henry tier. If
you had him you felt like you could compete with those other players on a
weekly basis. So really a neat resurgence considering their offensive line was
ranked 29th and you saw that a little bit in the playoffs. What do you
make of the end of the season? Because it happened. We all watched it and you're like, dude, that guy's,
that's Cincinnati Bengals Joe Mixon.
That guy's not very good.
Yeah, I mean, I think you have to find a balance point here
and I think this is one of the few cases
where you look at this show and you go,
well, we're trying to tell you the truth,
the fantasy finish versus the reality.
Well, I think the fantasy finish is the reality
for Joe Mixon.
I think he is a fringe RB one in Houston.
He will, he has the ability to give you the big games.
This is a team that has offensive line issues,
Stevon Diggs, Nico Collins issues.
The team's identity on offense changed a lot
and is gonna change again
with a new offensive coordinator.
So I think that's where I'll probably have him slotted in.
Not first half Joe Mixon, not second half,
probably somewhere in 12 to 15.
I think that's fair.
And even though he didn't miss the games later on
when it was worse,
he was dealing with some injury concerns.
I remember we had some fears
that he would miss games, played through it.
Obviously not that great
Yeah, I mean Andy you had the experience right he was on your league of record team so you've you felt the
Confidence going towards the playoffs and the letdown in them Yeah
And in part of it was like you could see it coming in the fantasy playoffs pretty plainly at least
The first and second week it was Kansas City on the road okay you you weren't you didn't expect a lot
especially that was a game where they're like he he wasn't practicing so right
Kansas City he goes to Kansas City off an injury you could see it coming plays
Baltimore you could kind of see that coming to dealing with the ankle injury
he scored more points in week one
than he did in the entirety of the fantasy playoffs.
Yeah, yeah, he ran out of the mojo
and the age and the injuries.
I mean, it was a lot like James Connors finished
to the season.
He played and he shouldn't have played.
I also think that we've got to give a little bit of,
you know, the second half for the Texans was just harder.
Once you lose Tankdell and Stavon Diggs,
your offense is far more one-dimensional
and it's easier to play defense against that.
And he, you know, to his credit, 38% great games,
higher number than anybody we've talked about today
by a wide margin, 23% bust, 62% good.
You know, when you look at Mixon or Connor next year,
I'm probably gonna.
I'll be on the Mixon side.
I'll be on the Mixon side.
Not by tons, but by some.
Anything else about Mixon you guys wanna touch on?
He was better against bad defenses.
He was much better on the road.
We talked about that late in the year.
He had a weird home road split. Yeah, so weird. Way better, like almost 10 points better on the road. We talked about that late in the year. He had a weird home road split. Yeah, so weird.
Way better.
Like almost 10 points better on the road,
which is not usual.
But two more years under contract.
Age will probably keep him in the third to fourth round.
I think so.
I think he'll be in the third.
Jonathan Taylor, we'll talk about him in a minute.
Quick break, then back with some more truth.
["Truth or Dare?" by The Caps plays.]
Alright, Jonathan Taylor did more than, um...
Meets the eye.
I apologize.
Jay Taylor.
Um, first half consistency was sixth.
Missed three games in that stretch.
He actually didn't have the like the super top tier finishes in that stretch.
He had the number one number one back-to-back performances in the fantasy
playoffs. You just had to survive the great fumble and better at home. You know
this year's tough because like I think the truth of Jonathan Taylor
is a little bit like the Saquon Barkley story.
Like, Jonathan Taylor's just a tremendous,
tremendous running back.
Yes.
You're gonna have ebbs and flows
with quarterback changes and offensive changes,
which happened in New York for Saquon,
and they've happened in Indianapolis for Taylor
over the years.
But if you just give him, like,
somewhat of an even playing field, he'll be great.
I talked about this on the last dynasty podcast. We had some trade for trade away targets. He was
mentioned. I won't tell you in which side. Thank you. But I like wanting the next contract. I'm wanting the next contract. Where can he go after what Saquon did,
after what Derrick Henry did?
Because I love how you kicked it off.
It's my belief as well that Jonathan Taylor
is a tremendous running back.
He is not your average player.
He's not your average athlete
or even your above average athlete.
He's a superstar.
He's playing in a situation
where you can get vultured touchdowns,
you can not get dump offs.
Anthony Richardson does not check it down.
Yeah, we need dump offs.
Can I read?
Yeah, the target totals for Mr. Taylor
since coming in the league, 36, 40,
then 28, then 19, that's past year, 18.
Yeah, it's gross, but he did enough.
Target per outrun was 17.7, now it's 6.7.
He did enough on the ground to show what a great athlete he is, and he has the chops
to catch the ball.
This is a situation where the quarterback is not and should not be throwing to the...
Throw.
...be throwing to the...
Fair.
You can make a strong argument.
Bring back the, fair. You can make a strong argument. Bring back the wishbone.
I mean, so considering all of that,
because I think we all would agree in a neutral situation
that you'd rather have Jonathan Taylor than Joe Mixon.
But then you look at the quarterback, the playoff.
The team level.
The team's gonna be better in Houston probably.
Is that, which one wins in that situation? I'm going to be better in Houston probably. Is that, you know, which one wins in that situation?
I'm going to be on the Jonathan Taylor side because I'm looking for the highest upside
I can get.
And I think that Jonathan Taylor has the physical capabilities to be a top three back.
We don't know who the quarterback is going to be in week three.
You know, it could change to a situation where now all of a sudden he adds
to his repertoire the pass catching. And let's be fair about the end of season when he won people
championships and was the back to back number one running back on the week, that was with Anthony
Richardson. Yeah. We forget that JT was the number one overall running back. We've gotten that out
of him. Yeah, sophomore season, right?
Yeah. I mean, so much like Saquon's had those years and then we see it happen again,
that is in the cards where I don't think Mixon can give you that in Houston, probably.
And he's the type of talent where, and I'm not, I mean, you can't draft based on this, but
if a team that is Super Bowl contending
or whatever loses a running back and the Colts are bad,
you know, late in his contract, go trade,
you know, people might trade for him.
Christian McCaffrey was traded for.
And if you're a great talent,
your situation can change to where you can
be a league winner for fantasy football.
15, Aaron Jones, consistency rank of 21,
and just 6% great games, 44% good,
19% bust, so that's 50% of the time
he was in the good or great category.
1138 yards on 255 carries, five touchdowns on the ground.
Caught 408 passes.
I don't know how to think about Aaron Jones' season.
I'm out.
I feel like.
He was so good.
I'm out.
I don't know if we were wrong about him.
I have no idea.
I have no, because he was on our bus list in the UDK.
Aaron Jones, I believe he was, unless we audited that late.
But for a good period of time, he was.
The sentiment of the show was...
Negative.
You and my son.
I was going to say...
We were out.
Jason was in.
Okay.
Okay.
And we were all right.
He was drafted as the RB 18, and he finished as...
As 15 with a consistency of 21.
So that's 18 to me. That's a win.
That's a good year.
I think so.
It's a good return on your ADP.
It started well.
I think that was part of the issue of you
don't know how to feel about Aaron Jones,
because a month in, it felt like, oh, Jason was very right,
Aaron Jones with the Minnesota Vikings.
Yeah, I felt like that was a big L from me.
You ate the crow, you took the L,
and then from that point on, it was just mostly, it's pretty.
He's pretty irrelevant right now.
We don't know where he's playing football next year.
He looked good on a per touch.
It was only one year?
I think they have, you can bet that,
I think they have like, voidable years,
and I don't expect, I mean, they might bring him back.
The truth is,
Yeah, it was a one year, yeah.
He has been an erratic producer his entire career.
Even in Green Bay, there were games when you're like,
that might be the best running back in football.
And then there were games and you're like,
they either didn't use him, I think that was more of the case,
they didn't use him as much, or like, he gets banged up,
they shared time.
I mean, even this year on the Vikings,
you wanna talk about drives that were stopped
by taking Aaron Jones out, I feel like he was so far
and away their best running back.
On a per touch basis, he's excellent.
At 31 years old, currently without a team,
going into next year, he'll be 31.
It's very hard to do anything but have him
be a late round pick that you hope gets opportunity.
He could be entering his Dalvin Cook era.
Yeah, I mean you don't want the Dalvin Cook
No you don't.
second era.
No, you wanna get to James Cook.
So I don't know if Aaron Jones is a little brother,
we gotta get him up here.
17 games played, finished as the RB 15. So
he's all right. But Jason's out. You were in, now you're out.
Yep. He was great on a per touch basis. He's a phenomenal NFL player for fantasy purposes.
I'm going to let other people hold that back.
All right. It's time for Bucky and Dick. Bucky Irving at 16, Richard Dickwhite at 20.
Rashad.
Rashad.
Richard.
Rashad.
You see how we get there?
It's right there.
I'm telling you, when I just blindly read it,
I was trying to remember how and why we call him Dick.
I believe it was because you said Richard at one point. Um, it's obvious why
Bucky ends up at 16 white at 20
consistency wise Bucky at 16
White at 22 so not far off of their fantasy finishes
The storyline though rookie running back second half consistency eight overall for Bucky Irving
You would think that meant whites consistency in the second half would have declined. It was the opposite. He was
at 16, still very relevant. Rashad White though next year seems like he will enter the undraftable
category for me. That's an insurance running back. Like somebody else in our league, like we've got a
guy that just takes players that nobody wants to draft, Nick, and he will draft for Shaw White and
probably get good value out of him and play him and he'll be the guy that I
want to play against and he'll perform against me. That's just where White's
going to fall into the committee, but this is the Bucky Irving backfield at
this point in time. In the beginning of the year there were a lot of questions
that Todd Bowles had to answer
at the podium talking about are we going to get Buckey more involved. And you know he would come
out and say this is Rashad White's backfield but yeah Buckey's earned some touches and I think it
was a fair and well-earned transition because you know the first five weeks of the season
transition because you know the first five weeks of the season you had Rashad White who was really the center of the running back core the previous year at 67% of the snaps.
From that point on he was down at 51% of the snaps and they played pretty even snaps these
two guys were pretty 50-50 but if you look at it...
That doesn't work for Rashad White though.
If you look at it in chunks of the season,
the further and further they got to more and more important
games, Bucky started usurping him in the snap count area
while he should have because he was a much more
explosive player.
So this will be Bucky's team.
And I don't think Rashad White is undraftable next year
with his work in the passing game.
And you still always have the built-in upside,
just like we had with David Montgomery and Jameer Gibbs,
whenever you draft either one of these guys, you've got the opportunity for them to become the takeover back from an injury.
A couple other things I wanted to mention here. One is, you said like a natural transition. You got to remember these are not,
these head coaches are not just looking at explosive plays alone
when they're selecting who's out there on the field.
They're looking at pass protection.
He's a rookie.
He's learning the playbook.
He's making mistakes on a play or doesn't make a mistake.
The other story for Bucky was that he was on the injury
report with a toe injury, then a hip, and then a back.
I think the toe was, was it the toe?
Was that the mummy game?
The toe was week nine against the Chiefs, 14, hip and back.
And then he was, you know, he had limited snap counts
a couple of times.
He played 17, but man, he was beat up.
And that's the question mark around a guy that, you know,
is 5'10", 195.
Yeah, and I think that was the Carolina game in week 13,
where he had 28 opportunities, 25 carries on the ground
as a smaller back and was so good. He was the running back one that week, but I remember
walking to the locker room. He was like a mummy. He was wrapped up like a mummy. And
then the next week he basically only played 16% of snaps, got the ball four times because
he was dead yep and yeah Rashad White's gonna fill that
late round pass heavy upside like you said if either guy gets hurt roll 17 was
David Montgomery we got to talk about Gibbs on the last episode consistency
rank of seven and a man I had him I felt it consistency ranked top ten running back every week
He was somehow he always did it. I mean it wasn't
It wasn't great. I mean it's 7% great games
He didn't go out there and win you the week, but goodness gracious. You got a touchdown every I was like always
He's just my automatic 9% good game
I'm gonna get you know 10 to 15 points every week in half PPR not even worried about him. He's such a I
Think he's a tough pick for fantasy players
Maybe that is going to change but maybe not. I mean Jameer Gibbs is just what is it Sonic and Knuckles, right?
I mean Gibbs is so
Explosive that I think it's fair for anybody watching the game to always
want Jameer Gibbs on the field. If you're a Detroit Lions fan you would want that.
But Montgomery brings something to the offense. It's just a matter of does he
get into the end zone? He did this year. 12 touchdowns. 25 touchdowns on the
ground in the last two years. So will he get into the end zone next year? Yes. And
the worry of the injury is irrelevant.
He was back playing football this year.
So I'll be fully in,
because David Montgomery is not gonna rise.
He did this last year, and if anything,
he's going to fall from where he was in the draft last year.
Because of Gibbs' fantasy finish?
Exactly.
You're probably right.
You have the Ben Johnson variable
of he will no longer be in town.
What does the offense look like?
I know they'll do their best to keep it the same, but
will they have the same success when you don't have that mastermind sequencing your
plays?
And the other thing that was just weird was two years,
like Gibbs rookie season, right? You felt like there was a difference between the two,
insurance was like, no, Gibbs is gonna,
he's a passing weapon.
And then at the end of the year,
Monty gets hurt, Gibbs takes over,
and then they stay with Gibbs.
Like towards the end of two years ago,
Gibbs was getting snaps, he's getting all this goal line work.
Then you have this year, and their receiving work
is almost identical.
Before the injury it was, yeah.
That's because I think that's part of the genius
of Ben Johnson to me, was you don't have a prototypical,
well Melvin Gordon's out there,
he's not gonna get thrown in the football,
and Eckler's out there, so he will get thrown
in the football, they're both capable, there, so he will get thrown in the football.
They're both capable, so why run plays
that are specific to one?
You need to have the threat of both
for both guys out on the field,
and Monte is more than capable.
If you wanted to throw in the football,
like if there was no Gibbs, Monte's catching a lot of passes.
Monte would be a league winner.
I mean, these guys both know the full playbook.
They're both inside the five yardbook. They're both inside the
five yard line. They're both in the receiving game. They're both...
Here's... Sorry.
Yeah, I'm just saying, either one of them goes down. The other one is absolutely going
to help you win your league.
The question is, do you believe they're going to keep winning? Obviously, this year, number
one offense, 70% of Montgomery's carries came with them leading or tied. You know that when they're down, two minute offense,
they want the explosive versatility of Gibbs.
They can both catch the football, yes,
but Gibbs can get to places that Monte doesn't get to
in the route tree.
So look, you're probably right,
he'll probably be undervalued.
And I bet you'll take him over this guy.
Breece Hall at 18.
I'm out.
Breece Hall, Jason's favorite player.
The sad thing is he has been.
Consistency rank of 20.
And I am sad for you.
He went from 16 in the first half,
that's, you know, you can live with that,
to 26 in consistency in the second half
after being drafted as the RB3.
Breece Hall was, statistically, unequivocally,
one of the true busts of fantasy football in 2024.
Yeah, I mean, the Jets team as a whole, obviously,
was an implosion, a black hole, an albatross.
This was a hugely disappointing season.
What else were they?
For a team that was thought to be vying with the Bills
and with everybody in that division for the division lead.
It didn't work out. This team is a mess. The organization is a mess.
Going forward, you would expect that Bryce Hall is still going to be a centerpiece of the offense,
that the new coordinator will get them more involved, and yada yada.
There's going to be all sorts of hype pieces pieces of they got this new offensive lineman or we don't know what the Jets future will look
like but we do know it's bad because it always is I mean it's just it's like
you know no player that you have been more deeply destroyed by that has
corrupted any possible unbiased analysis correct I should not even be talking right now.
I think the truth of Breece Hall is going to be relative to expectation of Breece Hall.
If you're drafting him in the first round as the RB3 and you get
a consistency of 16, that's a bust, right?
So even that first half consistency
on a team that was like, what, dead last in rush plays inside the five yard line.
Breeze hall, eye test, film, week to week.
Okay player, not great.
Much better when you, Jason is like sitting over there
going yeah I know that sucks.
That's exactly what the biggest problem was.
He wasn't special.
He was special when you gave him the football
in the passing game, 10 yards, 7 yards down
from the line of scrimmage in space.
And he got ahead of steam and he could make some things happen in the open field.
But no, from behind the line of scrimmage with the offensive line, you know, that he
didn't do a lot of things that were like you earned something more than what was given
to you. Exactly, as a runner.
I would agree with you.
Whenever he gets the ball in space, he's, you know,
watch out.
But as a runner breaking tackles, getting around edges,
finding the right hole, all of that stuff,
I was really frustrated watching guys like Chuba Hubbard
and Chase Brown be true difference makers
and then constantly watch Breece Hall, who is a better, like, I mean,
coming into the NFL, he's a better,
he's a better running back, he's a better athlete.
But his schedule was real difficult, Jay.
Oh, I assume this is not true.
No, it's the second easiest strength of schedule
for the running back.
Like, the Jets were the, which, we all know strength
of schedule is not everything, but when it
lines up and and a team gets hot, like two years ago with the Cowboys, you're like,
no this thing can really explode. The Jets, we were just staring at it, waiting,
waiting for this, the second half schedule to be incredible and Breece
Hall should take advantage of it, Braylon Allen, if Breece Hall misses time, should
be able to take advantage of it, and thelon Allen, if Breece Hall misses time, should be able to take advantage of it.
And the answer was no, nobody.
And we're two full years now from the ACL.
I don't know what the story is going to be when you write about Breece Hall five years
from now, but.
Running backs usually peak, genuinely.
Whether it's athleticism or understanding of NFL offense,
whatever, but running backs usually peak
and have their best season at age 24.
That will be the next season for Breece Hall.
The last two years, the Jets do not run
inside the five yard line.
They're dead last second year in a row.
So if the offense does better,
if he has more opportunity inside the five yard line
and he's coming into
what should be his prime as a very young back,
there are lots of reasons why he could really, really work.
But among 46 running backs with 100 plus carries,
he was 36th in forced miss tackles per attempt.
That's what I was talking about watching.
You watch Chuba, you watch Chase Brown,
these guys who have spent their careers being just a guy, an untouted average player. And then you watch the flip where Breeze used
to break all of that and there was something off.
Yeah, there was no exploding out of a cannon type of situation. I believe you said the
word albatross earlier to describe Breeze Hall amongst others.
No, the Jets.
The Jets. I am just curious, what do you think the plural,
how would you pluralize a bunch of albatross?
Albatrossi.
Albatrossi, I'm gonna go classic,
I'm gonna go albatrosses.
For albatrosses?
Yeah, I would.
Do you have the answer?
No, I don't.
Oh, I thought this was, I was waiting for the reveal.
Is it not albatrosses?
It is. It is albatrosses? That is correct. That's such a weird reveal. Is it not albatrosses? It is.
It is albatrosses?
That's such a weird word.
That's such an albatrossity.
I love it when the right answer is a dumb answer.
I wanna say albatry or something.
Yeah, albatry again.
All right, Najee Harris at 22.
Airball.
We weren't even acknowledging what happened, Jason.
No, we were moving on.
Najee.
Busted. He had an were moving on. Najee. Busted.
He had an air ball before the show, too.
Najee Harris at 22, consistency of 27.
J.K. Dobbins at 23, consistency of 19.
Rico Dowdell.
Yeah.
At 24, consistency rank of 29.
Yeah, that was good.
Kenneth Walker, 26, consistency of 15.
The truth of Kenneth Walker, it's a very TBD,
new offensive coordinator again.
And Charbonneau played better than he played last year.
He did, yeah, especially towards the second half
of the year.
Ken Walker, he's not the same level of player
of Saquon Barkley.
But like this, to me, I still believe in the talent
of the player, it seems like he's trying to do so much
on every single carry and he does succeed.
Like Ken Walker gives you some highlights.
Do you guys remember the front flip play
where he was on a body and then flips off?
He can do things.
Some players can't get rid of that quality
and when they lose their athleticism,
it hurts them even more.
And if he is going to always be
I have to do everything player,
you may see the continuation of what we've seen,
which is year one explosive 4.6 to carry,
year two still explosive 4.1 to carry, year two still explosive 4.1 to carry, year three
less explosive 3.7 to carry. I mean it has gone down. He was yeah the yards per
carry because he's trying to hit home runs but at the same time that stat J of
46 running backs with 100 carries Ken Bonewalker was number one enforced
miss tackle rate like he is he elusive, he is powerful,
he just is, he is not in a great situation
and he is in a timeshare.
And he keeps getting hurt.
He does, he is made out of wet newspapers.
That's what his bones are made out of.
Oblique calf, ankle, IR with the calf,
kept trying to come back.
I mean.
I think I'm going to be in, though.
He's too, you know, I want.
Mix in or Ken Bone next year?
Oh.
I still think I'm on the mix inside of that one.
I'd probably be on the mix inside of that one.
Connor or Ken Bone?
Ken Bone.
Yeah, that one will go well.
See, I just think it's, if you get the right season, and this team can perform, but I don't
have confidence yet in the quarterback, the head coach.
Well, they gotta fix that line.
The offensive line, yeah.
Their offensive line per PFF's ranking 31st.
71% of his rushing yards came after contact. That just shows what a special player
he is and what a bad offensive line he had. It also shows he had a lot of chances to try
to break tackles because they were permanent. Yeah, you said it. If the right season happens.
Yeah, you did. And I'm not expecting, I wouldn't push my chips that the right season's going
to happen. But it's one of those players, like Jonathan Taylor, where if the right season happens,
he's a top five back and a total difference maker.
If it presents itself.
And he started catching a ton of balls this year.
So we got a Super Bowl coming up, huh?
We do, two weeks.
A repeat of the one two years ago out here in Arizona.
We got any predictions?
Are you obviously your chiefs?
I mean, look, I called the chiefs over the Eagles
in the playoffs before.
He definitely got the first down.
He definitely got the first down.
If your butt is what qualifies.
Oh, it's not, it's the ball?
It's your, did you see the angle?
Did you see the angle though of the the ref that was on the ball side?
Yeah, was running across. Yeah. Oh for sure the rifle
Yeah, and he had to get a cheese player out of his way
And he was way ahead of the line and they put the ball where the back judge was that only had a booty shot
100% you are correct watching it live. I thought he crossed and got there because of your just talking one side angle
The down this the directly down the line angle where you can best shot right we had that's the one all didn't make it over
Deucer's alley. Do you think he got the first down raise your hand if you do you know their answers so no
I only knew one I only knew the Falcon definitely believed he got it
I was on a cruise
I just see it three for three three for three over there induces Alec well the heart wants what the heart wants
I wish it was first town. Yeah, well, you know
big chiefs guy over here
The I shouldn't know the old catch that one is more
Up in the air the catch was not a catch either. No no no no that one do people
in the air. The catch was not a catch either. No, no, no. That one, dude, people got mad at me. I loved your tweet. People got mad at me. I literally went to tweet the exact
same thing that you tweeted and saw that you did it and I didn't give you credit, but that
was, I mean, that was wonderful. People were not ready for my tweet. Tell the people what
that tweet was. I just tweeted the Dalton Kincaid missed catch and said the refs called this incomplete and the whole
world I mean I had to block some people. Oh man that's a good that's that's 10
out of 10 tweeting. And you know what you see Philly firing the guns off in the
crowd straight into the sky did you see that video? What? No. Frickin Philly. No.
Philly look you're your own thing, man.
Wait, like real guns?
Yes!
Oh my goodness.
Dude, somebody's in the-
What, PSA?
Who's doing the security up there?
I'm tired.
That can kill people.
It's like a cartoon.
What?
No.
Yes, dude, look at this.
Like Yosemite Sam's in the, just, kia-ya!
It was Yosemite Sam and Philly.
A guy just pulls a gun out, throws it over his head,
and boom, boom, boom!
Three into the sky. Wow. In the middle of a crowd can we not do that
please what's freaking Philly oh man they're a passionate bunch I don't know
if you knew that oh this was not in the stadium no that's why I was asking who's
doing the security no no no no. That makes far more sense.
It was the celebration.
Let's celebrate with dignity and some self-respect
as we head into the Super Bowl.
Not Yosemite Sam.
Oh my gosh, no Yosemite Sam.
All right, we're getting into Wide Receiver Truth
on Thursday.
More news, more to talk about about. Whoo it's been a good
one take care. Goodbye.
Thank you for listening to another episode of the fantasy footballers
podcast. Join our fantasy football community on jointhefoot.com and follow
us on Twitter at the FF Ballers.