Fin vs History - Instel (Involuntary Sterilised) | Charles Darwin & The Birth of Eugenics (Part 2)
Episode Date: April 24, 2025Charles Darwin’s cousin misunderstands what Charlie meant and starts a train of thought that ends in some very naughty trains in Germany We’re going on Tour in October! Patreon presale starts th...us Thurs Thursday 24th April @ 10am, general sale Friday 25th April 10am The show for people who like history but don't care what actually happened. For weekly bonus episodes, ad-free listening and early access to series, become a Truther and sign up to the Patreon https://www.patreon.com/fintaylor?utm_campaign=creatorshare_creator Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Ontario, the wait is over.
The gold standard of online casinos has arrived.
Golden Nugget Online Casino is live.
Bringing Vegas-style excitement and a world-class gaming experience right to your fingertips.
Whether you're a seasoned player or just starting, signing up is fast and simple.
And in just a few clicks, you can have access to our exclusive library of the best slots and top-tier table games.
Make the most of your downtime with unbeatable promotions and jackpots that can turn any mundane moment into a golden,
opportunity at Golden Nugget Online Casino. Take a spin on the slots, challenge yourself at the
tables, or join a live dealer game to feel the thrill of real-time action, all from the comfort
of your own devices. Why settle for less when you can go for the gold at Golden Nugget
Online Casino. Gambling problem call Connects Ontario 1866531-260. 19 and over, physically present
in Ontario. Eligibility restrictions apply. See Golden Nuggett Casino.com for details. Please play responsibly.
Grocery shopping.
Cha-ching.
Ordering food?
Cha-ching.
Filling up on gas?
Cha-ching.
Commuting?
Cho-ching.
Using streaming services.
Cha-cha-cha-cha-chee.
With your RBC I-O-plus visa,
earn three-tri-time points on groceries, gas, dining, and more.
Cha-ching.
Then, redeem your points on gift cards from over 200 grand.
Your idea of rewarding happens here.
Conditions apply.
Visit RBC.com slash Ion Cards.
We're going on tour.
Oh, my God.
Live.
Wow.
In real life.
Wow.
Three dimensions.
In October, we're going to be taking this crudy old show to.
This horror show.
Bristol, Newcastle, Newcastle, Glasgow, Manchester, Leeds, Birmingham, London.
You can get tickets.
Now.
No.
Oh.
If you're a Patreon, you're a truther, you can get access to the pre-sale, which starts this
Thursday, on 24th of October.
If you're not a true...
Ruth, then tickets
whatever's left
were gone general sale
this Friday the 25th
hot shit
shit in my mouth
out of my ass
into my mouth
shit in my mouth
that's exciting
we'll see you guys there
Welcome back to Finn versus history
I'm here with Horatio Gould
I like
White bugs.
And today, we are finally dipping our toes in the warm bath of scientific racism.
Hot.
Oh, it's lovely.
It's actually.
Come in, come in, the water's lovely.
This is the second part in our Darwin series.
We rattled through the life of Charles Darwin, boring nerd, and now we're getting to
the fun stuff, which is what people do with his ideas.
It's the most vibe science got, really.
just sort of free form.
Just like, just guessing at shit.
Yeah.
So 1882, Darwin's, it's a total football of racism for this.
There's no set position.
There's no rules.
Well, there are rules.
People can make their own rules.
There's no wrong answers.
Yeah.
How big is your head?
All right, I'm going to pay you less.
It's, you know, it's crazy stuff.
So Darwin dies in 1882, but his ideas.
Live on.
Live on.
And then they stop with,
hard stop in 1950.
When people go, we must stop this.
That's what I love about this, is that, you know,
the science is so, they're so front-footed,
let's try this.
The future.
Maybe it's what their nose is.
What's the shape of their nose?
Maybe it's the head.
Maybe they came out of an egg.
Why are we all different colours?
And then the 50s, they went, no more of this science.
The science is over.
Science is done.
No more.
But you can't be trusted to play around with these ideas.
I know.
That's the thing.
That's the thing.
And so now it's this kind of untapped,
it's this unfinished.
Everyone's gone, nope, we don't want to know.
whatever it is we don't want to know who cares we don't know you can't be trusted you went too
far the germans took it too far again we're not doing it anymore i mean all the all the nazi stuff
they stopped a lot of things that were just getting cooking yeah like um they just they just
arm bands can't have an arm band anymore if you're a politician you can't wear an armband can you
no even if it's like a thumbs up yeah thumbs up no and it's like red red thumbs up no
that looks like the nazis uh brown shirts can't really wear a brown shirt anymore even being
yeah yeah he's a bit nazi is a bit nazi just turning up on time you're fucking nazi well you've ruined punctuality have you
that mustache can't have a little massage yeah done that's gone that's gone it was chaplains first he was doing it
i know but fucking no one i'm a chaplain fan yeah no one believes you you can't walk into a pub with that
going oh is it oh is that a chaplain mustache is it i'm a cinephile so the nazis ruined many things
chief amongst them
is the pseudoscience of scientific racism
so in this episode
we will be dealing with Darwinism
social Darwinism
which leads to eugenics
which is
it's all quite lighthearted fun stuff
It's like a carry-on film
Yeah I will reiterate
If you're of a weaker stomach
Maybe skip this one
And go watch the First Crusade or something
One of his ones
One of the medieval ones
This is where I'm going to really start
cooking.
So cooking on gas, you might say.
Well.
Well, we'll get there.
We're warming up.
So Darwin's ideas
are not in a vacuum.
Right.
So Darwin publishes the origin of species
59, 1859,
and then the dissent of man in 1771.
He dies in 1882.
The 1870s and 1880s are a hotbed
of thought.
It's a lot of after-dinner clubs.
He's part of the Athenium club.
They're all chatting away.
There's lots of...
There's a frisson.
There's white guys.
chatting. Why are we
so great? It's mainly the topic.
We must get to the bottom. Why are we the best
and why are all these brown guys the worst?
What's going on? Right.
Why are we the best?
So obviously this is the
height of the British Empire. Yeah.
The sort of the latter half of the 19th century,
1870, 1880s, the Scramble for Africa
is coming. So 1880s,
where are we? 1880s?
So 1880s, I want to say
1880 is after
the invention
of the xylophone
and then it's before the invention of the pen protector.
Actually, you did the last one, didn't you?
Yeah, but it's before the invention of the pen protector.
The pen protector?
You know, sorry, on your pocket.
Are you ever seen any...
It's maybe the nerdyest thing you can have.
Is it like when you get a lambie
and they come in that little wallet?
Sorry, not pepper.
It's a pen pocket protector.
So I've seen, you know, the writer of cherub.
You know, the cherub series?
The horny books.
No?
About young secret agents fucking each other.
No?
For kids.
and none of the parents.
You know about the cherub series?
You know about a cherished series,
you horny little dog.
What's the cherub series?
Well, this is all of our sexual awakenings
was the Cherub Spy series about,
you know,
it's a classic...
Some of us had their sexual awakenings
to Red Bull by Brian Jacks.
Robert Muchmore is...
These fucking hot shrews in the...
Do you not know about that?
Yeah, so it's like a school for spies,
the classic, you know...
Like Spy kids.
But, yeah, kind of.
But they're 14 years old,
and then he describes graphic sex scenes
and you're 14,
and none of our...
parents knew that we were reading basically erotic thrillers.
But it was written by this guy.
He came to our school and he had a pocket here, not only pens in there, but there was a
protector to protect his pocket from his pens.
And I believe this is before then.
I'm just saying that in our last episode, we spent a lot of time looking at mugshots
of paedophiles and I can sort of imagine this guy fitting in quite well.
Exactly, yeah.
All right, well, okay, there you go.
More much more child porn on my hard drive.
Gentleman's pens are not, their shirts are not protected.
They don't have a condom for pens in their shirt.
They're raw-dogging pens in their jacket.
Right.
And they're presumably they're using ink cartridges.
There's no biros at this point.
I don't think the ink cartridge has been invented yet.
Wow, there is it quills?
It's not quills.
Yeah.
When was the ink cartridge?
Fountain pens are around.
Oh, fountain pens?
I don't know that.
People are writing racist shit in fountain pens.
Yeah, I guess there's industrialized.
1890
Just
The cartridge system
Is 1890
But fountain pens are surely
Already around
You dip you're dipping in a pot of ink
That's a quill
No it's a fountain pen
Yeah but that's still the dip
They're not using ostrich feathers
Yeah but it's still the dip
Sorry
Dipping
The cartridge is what I'm struggling with
So people are writing these ideas
Yeah
In a fountain pen
And they're thinking
If only there was an easier way
To write this heinous racism
Which
And that does
That comes quite quickly after this
So, no, thank you.
It is quite funny writing racism with a quill, though.
I do think that there was a clear rank to racism globally.
Stop to dip.
Stop to dip.
Yeah, it gives it slightly more class, isn't it?
Yeah, you get so passionate, and then you're running out of ink.
Let's get this racism out of me.
Well, this is when racists could write.
They were literate.
Right, right.
Nowadays, racists are obviously thick.
Yes, yeah, uneducated.
What I love about this era is that racists are the cleverest people on the planet.
this is when like the genius he's got a 300 IQ he's fucking racist whereas now racism is a sign of stupidity and ignorance yeah yeah where it's it's the height of intelligence of enlightenment is to think that black people would came out of eggs or so like this what's so funny is that scholars you know are phrenologists are phrenologists they've got they're measuring skulls the thickest people you went to school with the phrenologist they don't even know the term phrenology that's how thick and racist they are
so Darwin dies in 1882 but towards the tail end of his life
his seminal work in 1859 on the origin of species
and the preservation of races in the struggle of life
now as we discussed he meant the races of cabbage
but his cousin Francis Galton
he thinks he's like I get you you mean you mean races
now this is not in a vacuum we should start to places with other ideas
because white guys in Europe
and a vacuum hasn't been invented at this point
they don't know what the vacuum is all right fine
so there's two things
yeah so sorry his ideas are not
operating in a dustpan and brush
that's what they'd understand it
um no uh we should
you know white guys in Europe
have been pop thinking about why
they're the best in their in their heads
why are we so much more developed
than these people who's all they're all we've
you know we've taken their land and their resources
all this stuff why why can we just take people's stuff
and they're not doing anything what's wrong with them right
so you have uh there's several different
theorists
I mean now
Malthus
that's in the late
this French Revolution
he's an English guy
Thomas Malthus but this is
less to do with race
this is more about class
Yes
brilliant stuff
He basically he writes an essay
In 1798
On the principle of population
Basically he thinks
That a nation's food production
Will always
The improvement will always be
Temporary
because it will lead to population growth
which will then
the population will always be outstripping food production
which means that people will always suffer
and be hungry and so you should kill the poor
I think the last one's quite a big jump
I think because it was a
he was a cleric right
he was Christian
which is hilarious because it's so funny
that he has Christian values basically saying
we should starve the poor
dirty other meek
basically
ugly are the meek
stinky are the me
that famous Jesus
Jesus saying
but there's this example
of
I'm going to turn bread into, I'm going to turn a thousand fish and a thousand, not for you.
He has this example of you're at a middle class dinner party and then some starving people
come on over and ask for food.
And as much as your human instinct is, to give the starving poor people food as charity.
He says the higher charitable thing is to not give them food and hope they starve to death.
Well, that's what they say on the overground, isn't it?
If you see someone begging, don't give them food.
Instead, think about donating to this charity.
It's Malthus.
Yeah, it is, it's Malthusian.
Yeah, but he says, he just misses out the donate to charity.
Yeah, you think it's just start, make sure they starve.
Yeah, make sure that if they're, you know, a dead poor person, you know, they're not sad, are they?
No, they're dead.
Yeah.
But this starts to be.
You can't be hungry if you're dead.
You're not hungry when you're dead.
So, but this, this is kind of like, now, the English Victorians, they start to, you know, around the time of Jack the Ripper in the 1880s, they are massively.
concerned with
overpopulation
of the poor
because they're reading Darwin's
ideas about evolution
and they're not really thinking
about birds. Darwin's just thinking about birds
and bugs, right?
And people are taking his ideas
and going, well, a lot of people are poor
and so if they're having loads of children
then those children are going to be poor.
He kind of looks like a giant tortoise.
Yeah, he looks like a giant. Can we eat that poor person?
But they start thinking that poor
people are going to overwhelm
the rich, and if it's a struggle for survival,
if evolution is a struggle between species,
they basically think that poor people
are different species to rich people.
Well, you have white replacement theory,
which is pretty popular in America mainstream.
Now,
the idea of white people being outbred, basically.
You know, Tanya Carlson says stuff about white replacement.
This sort of starts, but in more of a class sense,
in the 19th century in England.
You also have some very wacky ideas.
There's a guy called Cuvier, a French guy.
Right.
He says that Adam and Eve were white.
Okay.
Well, they are in all the drawings in my school books, to be fair.
And all the drawings he was doing, they were white.
And that black and Chinese people came out basically because there was a disaster
and then survivors escaped in different directions, and then they developed in separate
in silos.
Yeah.
Or it's like Adam and Eve were just for the white people.
That was our origin, man.
Yeah, exactly.
Right.
Benjamin Rush, who is a founding father of the US, which I think is relevant, he believed,
that everyone is actually white
but that black people
have some kind of leprosy
which means that it's non-contagious
but means that underneath the black skin
is a white person
and he founded the US
which I think says quite a lot
about what the US then go on to do
is that he thinks
that's what black people are
so Benjamin Rush
thinks all black people on the US are Justin
Trudeau in his 20s
yeah exactly
stop partying
take that makeup off
we've got work to do
we've got work to
yeah
stop fucking around
yeah so guys before you pick your cotton
get that bloody shit off your face
put your makeup on
put your makeup on then pick the cotton
that's what we're doing
so he found he's one of the founding fathers
Thomas Jefferson
big big race guy
he he goes
yeah Thomas Jefferson complicated
Tom Jefferson
we'll get to Thomas Jefferson
sometime
he's got some amazing
Yeah, he builds on the ideas of rush.
Jefferson was the super horny one, right?
I think he was having sex with his slaves.
Yeah, but he had like 25 children
via like four or five different slave women
and he only, he had like,
he must have like 14 slave kids, right?
Yeah.
And he only set like two of them three.
Right.
The rest he was like, brilliant.
Oh, more slaves.
It's like, I'm a good chicken.
I'm making employees.
Yeah, it is.
Like a chicken.
Well, great.
I'll just, I'll eat those eggs.
And then I'll,
I'll leave those to hatch and I'll have more chickens.
Yeah.
I mean, it's like when you're having dinner party and you've,
you've picked a sprig of rosemary from your garden or something.
You're bragging to your friends.
I agree that.
You see that guy picking the rosemary?
Yeah.
He's my kid.
Do I love him?
Sort of.
In a way.
Yeah.
I love the stuff he does for me.
You know, I love my employees.
I love what they give me.
I'm a good boss.
Do I pay him?
No, I don't know.
I don't pay him.
He's my son.
I don't pay him.
So Francis Goulton, we need to deal with.
Francis Gorton is Darwin's first cousin.
And Gorton cannot get the evolution as applied to people out of his head.
Darwin's basically been like, this is all about, mate, this is bugs, this is plants,
this is mushrooms.
Gorton's like, fuck all that.
I reckon it's about why some people are Chinese and some people are white.
So he basically is, as we mentioned in the last series, he's a Victorian polymath in many ways.
a brilliant man
but if you go on his Wikipedia
the first thing they bring up is eugenics
not the fact that he made the first ever
weather map what's the weather what does that mean
he the first ever
like clouds and shit right right right right
like you're having a paper now
where you've got pressure right right right
and temperatures right he's Michael Fish
right he's Victorian Michael Fish
you should stop reading weather maps now
you know Thomas Schaffanacker
the weather reporter oh yeah yeah the guy did that
yeah yeah that's all you remember him for
you don't remember about that weather map
that's just like this cunt
yeah everyone's like oh oh yeah
but should we be boycotting the eugenics guy
no he invented the weather map
but maybe we should chuck weather maps out of the paper
because they're linked to racism
they're not linked it's just the same guy
he did a lot of things
how many things have you done
I guess not many podcasts stand up
sketches
eugenics you know I don't want to
remember for my treaties
on the hierarchy of races
exactly I've done other staff
you've got a special out on YouTube now
he's got a special on YouTube
He's not just ranking races
In that special I do rank races
But that's irrelevant
Is a dog, what, you what?
No, no, no, no.
He didn't invent a dog whistle.
Did he invent a dog whistle?
No fucking way.
Are you fucking joking?
He invented the dog whistle
That's fucking crazy
This is insane
Sorry, the man who invented eugenics
Invented the dog whistle
But the sorry, can we just get a moment
to appreciate it?
Let's get that, Goulton's whistle.
Sorry.
Can we, because the cosmic irony that eugenics, which is the least dog whistle racist thing of all time, because it's just like, yeah, let's kill, let's kill everyone who's not.
Was it like an air horn?
Eugenics is a racist air horn.
A dog air horn.
Leave that ball alone.
Galton's whistle.
Yeah, because he did a lot of stuff for deaf people.
He made an instrument to measure hearing in deaf people.
So deaf people, he'd get his racism into their ears.
yeah exactly
yeah sorry
it should be said
all his inventions
were to try
and advance eugenics
so the weather map
was like okay
it's raining here
so we shouldn't kill
anyone there
we can't set fire
to anyone there
because it's raining
I mean is that
an exclusive
pretty much
that the inventor
of eugenies invented
the dog whistle
you're not hearing
that on the rest of history
goal hanger
aren't touching this topic
with a fucking barge pole
did he invent the barge pole
is it goldson's barge pole
is it goldson's barge pole
my
God, that's absolutely insane.
Because that can't, that, they can't have, when they invented dog whistle,
when they named dog whistle racism, they can't have known.
No, no, surely not.
Galton's whistle.
Fucking out.
Fuck me.
Reading, playing, learning.
Stellist lenses do more than just correct your child's vision.
They slow down the progression of myopia.
So your child can continue to discover all the world has to offer through their own eyes.
Light the path to a brighter future with.
Stellist lenses for Myopia Control. Learn more at SLR.com and ask your family eye care professional
for SLR Stellist lenses at your child's next visit. And people say they don't learn anything
on this part. A load of bollocks. Absolutely. In politics, a dog whistlers used as coded or
suggestive language in political messaging to garner support from a particular group.
Explain what dogwester is to people who wouldn't know the other form of it. Yeah, so Nixon basically invented
this form of talking about race
without actually overtly saying it.
So it's like, okay, so we've got to sort out crime
in the urban centres.
We've got to stop everyone with Afro's doing crime all the time.
Well, that's not a great one.
That's not that.
I mean, they sharpened this tool over, you know,
they were refining it.
But basically it's a way of mentioning
so that people who are racially minded
we think about race a lot,
they can pick up on the code.
Which is the frequency we can't hear
if you're not racist.
Yeah, exactly.
I don't think there was not much dog whistling
I think in like Sir Africa
they don't feel like very dog whistly racist
No that as you say
The blecks off my land
That's not a dog whistle
That's as you say that's an air horn
What's better than blecks
All right
At least some disguise on the past
No it's a very direct form of racism
It's overt
It's loud
It's out in the open
But I guess in America obviously
You know you post this is post civil rights
So if you want to talk about race
In a negative way
You've got to use Golton's
Whistle.
I mean, that's,
that's absolutely.
But right,
so these are all the things he invented,
right?
You show, eugenics,
behavioral genetics.
Why is that top?
Why is that top?
Regression toward the mean.
What's that?
That's an average,
I don't know,
I'm not,
you like math,
you got glasses,
you got glasses,
come on millhouse,
work it out.
It's like statistical thing.
It's one where one,
oh, fucking hell,
that's boring.
Yeah, I mean,
a lot of them are boring.
Standard deviation.
That's something.
I hear that all the time.
Anticycone.
Wait, standard deviation.
Is that not just a minute?
Uh,
The isochrome map?
I don't know what that is.
What's that?
Yeah, fucking weather maps.
Yeah, keep going on.
Let's see Gulton's board.
Gulton's board.
What's that?
That's something you strap people to?
The advice of it.
Oh, right.
Demonstrate the central limit theorem.
Right, fucking up.
Let's keep going through.
Gold's problem.
Let's see Galtons problem.
I reckon I know what the problem is.
It's black people.
He describes the problem as drawing it.
Right.
Inferences from cross-cultural data.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I guess.
He's a three-dimensional character.
That's absolutely fucking crazy.
I mean, he's a true Victorian.
Yeah, he is.
This is people of this age.
It's you invent a world-changing things and modern racism.
All things good and bad are invented by English polymaths in this period.
He's Elon Musk is what he is in that he's doing rockets, he's doing electric cars, and
he's just opening a sewer on Twitter.
You know, I guess Musk.
is kind of the only modern-day polymath
there is, really, that anyone would know.
Yeah.
You can't be professional polymaths now.
Although, I guess, could you
call people who like a Uber drivers, delivery
drivers, and it's all driving, isn't it?
Yeah, I don't know what a polymath.
People are chicken? Are we polymasts because we do
podcasting and stand-up?
No, it's all comedy.
No, it's all racist.
Oh, do you like that guy's racist stand-up?
What you like is racist podcast?
Can you be a polymaths you're in a polycule
and your varied interests
are the different, your five different girlfriends,
and boyfriends?
I don't know.
I don't know if you're a polymath.
Yeah, no.
I don't reckon,
I mean, the irony is that the polymaths
in the Victorian play,
they were a fucking one person.
Yeah, right.
If at all.
So, well, what a scoop.
What an absolute scoop.
Francis Galton,
he basically,
he coins the term eugenics
because he starts to apply,
he gets the Malthusian ideas
of population control.
Yes.
Explain it again,
so the idea is that we should let poor people die
because it's natural selection.
Yeah.
The whole point is...
The whole point is that you're using Darwin's observation
of adaptation to survive,
which means that weaker species die out,
because they don't adapt.
You're applying that to social dynamics of poor people.
And in English context, it's the Irish.
It's getting rid of the Irish, basically.
And we've worked with Irish people for a lot,
and I do think we should bring some of it back.
No, look, every idea...
There's some sense to it, of course.
Vittorio's got a fucking massive head.
I mean, you can't help but think...
or what's going on in there.
So in the 1880s, people are also on the ground in the colonies.
You know, they're getting their phrenology cranes out.
That looks like an Indian head massage, but it's not that, is it?
Well, the original Indian head massage was not to cause an orgasm.
It was to measure your head to see how stupid you work.
But was that the way that they tricked people in?
In many ways, in the death camp said, you're going to have a lovely shower?
And then it was a gash chamber.
instead they're like do you want a lovely head mashaws oh that's brilliant and he's like oh that's so
nice and it's like check the measurements yeah you're medically thick I think um so so you've got
Herbert Hope Rizley uh who's the guy in he's one of the Rizley Herbert Hope Rizley
Rizmaster General Herbert he's he's risen people he's risen people he's uh I think he's on
he's one of the administrators in India right he's he's he's um dangerous he's measuring noses he is
he's measuring how flat the nose is
And he's then divided...
A lost art.
Yeah.
I mean, again, this is something that, you know, the 1950s, they just drew a line under noses.
The science of noses is dead in the water.
What does it mean if you've got a big nose?
Nothing.
Don't lift that rock up.
We know what happens.
But so, again, the whole...
Now, at some point, they divide...
Some French guy, divide...
It says there are three races.
There's Caucasoid, Mongoloid, and then another one that we don't really feel comfortable
saying.
But you could sort of work it out.
Now, if you get the map up...
Now, is there something almost progressive about three races?
What do you mean?
Is it...
Is the more races or less races more progressive?
Because, again, there's been this long struggle,
or rather this long academic debate
of are we like mona-whatever or poly whatever?
Are we all from the same origin?
All out of Africa.
Are we all out of...
At some point, they say, out of Asia.
Yeah.
Are we all out?
Do we all come to the same?
Chinese people still believe that as well as still.
Hey what?
A lot of Chinese people still think it's out of Asia.
Yeah.
But they, they're basically, they're always, every point they're trying to classify
races.
We love procedure in this country.
We love, you know, we love an inquiry.
We love data gathering.
All this is is just data gathering.
Yeah.
It's nerds.
We just happen to be unbelievably racist at the time.
Yeah.
But again, in this day and age, racists are the top of society.
Yeah. Right.
They are the cream of the crop.
Right.
It's just, you know, he's in, you say,
You'd say, you must meet my friend, the esteemed racist, Dr. Galton.
You know, nowadays you'd say scholar and a gentleman, now you see a scholar and a racist.
Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
So, Goulton takes these, these Malthusian ideas with Darwin's ideas about natural selection
and starts talking about eugenics, which is the, basically, politically implementing social Darwiners.
some social engineering basically so it's uh in the 1880s as i was saying in so maybe this is an
age where so often uh you if you meet like if you don't crowd work you meet someone as an engineer
there's lots of types of engineering you can be mechanical engineering yeah you know software
engineering you probably making more money civil engineering civil engineering but this is actually
a time where if you're a comedian at the time and someone says they're engineered they could say
oh i'm a social engineer i um i try and stop poor people breeding with rich people um um i'm
like, yeah, I'm like the Isambard, Kingdom Brunel of stopping poor people of kids.
Yeah, in Britain it was mainly class.
They thought that the Irish and the poor people were outbreeding rich people.
Yeah.
And so they tried to, there's something called positive eugenics and negative eugenics.
And positive eugenics is where you, you're breeding up.
So you're like, great, you two went to Cambridge, you two fuck.
Negative eugenics is right.
You're in a wheelchair.
You're thick.
You two breed to try and like breed down.
So don't muddy the genes of the rich guys
That's what the idea is
Now
There's a lot of air quotes
This whole episode's in air quotes by the way
Yeah or it's ironic or whatever you need
Whatever you need to get through it
Just have a fucking drink and get on with it
Have a stiff drink and turn this one up
Well blast it
Blast it I reckon why if you're in the car
Wind your windows down
Well the weather's getting better
Drive through Brixton let's see what happens
Do it so loud
The neighbours can hear it out in the garden
It's a summer pod
This one's a summer pod
you know if you're at the queue at Wimbledon
listening to this
take your air
Be a fucking
I mean there's a bad example
Because I think secretly
They love this sort of stuff
All right
If you're at the Oval
The Wimbledon queue is social engineering
Because only white Protestants are going to wait in a queue that long
That's true
That's true
Well no hang on it's a chicken and egg thing
Right
It's not social engineering
Right
Are you saying that
They've engineered it to make sure
That only
The waspiest people in the world
Because I've been there
I went there to do some content
For some fucking gin
brand and yeah it's the fucking it's the snootiest
cuntiest white people you've ever seen yeah is yeah is and they absolutely love it
the whole thing is a quiet carriage yeah it's yeah it's the most
pot of six hours and then didn't get in
so the shit is purgine yeah yeah it's on the opposite of per guy yeah it's
cute for six hours didn't get in fucking yeah belly full of strawberries yeah just
strawberries and then fitted myself so in the 1890s you've got the scramble for
Africa. People are measuring skulls. They're measuring noses. And Francis Galton is trying to get
government to implement eugenics policies, which proudly, I'll say this proudly, never happens in
the UK. There is no government state-sponsored eugenics policy ever done in the UK. He starts a
society called like the Royal Society for Eugenics or something. They're handing out
Royal Charter.
They're handing out pamphlets.
Yeah.
It doesn't really work.
So it's similar to Oswald Mosley trying to be British Hitler.
It just never gets off the ground.
Yeah, exactly.
In Britain, it never takes off.
In America, they fucking love it.
Yeah, brilliant.
They absolutely love this in America.
So there's a guy called, there's another guy called Herbert Spencer,
who ends up being the biggest philosopher in China,
because they buy into all this shit as well.
Really?
And he's, Marx is a big fan of him.
Marx is also a big fan of Darwin.
but Darwin hates Marx
Interesting
Yeah
But they're all hanging around London at this time
Right
So Herbert Spencer is actually buried next to Karl Marx
In Highgate century
But Spencer's a massive eugenicist
Okay
It was kind of as I say
It was like kind of a cool thing to be
It was like a eugenicist
In the late 19th century
Right
It was like that's where the hip
Technology bisexual
Yeah they're the bisexuals
Yeah
Like nowadays if you're if you're like queer
That's like cool
Yeah
You get like a I don't know
You get a seat on the bar
Blue badge.
Well, I don't think it's cool to have a priority seat.
I don't think they're cool.
Let's make, give them a priority seat.
Do you reckon that's what Tucker Carlson thinks is happening in the UK?
Is that you have to give up your seat for a,
you have a seat for a queer person.
What kind of got a badge saying, queer?
But Tucker Carlson's view of London is he thinks it's this, should be this.
Yes.
And he's come here and he's, well, eugenics is.
And he's walked down Whitechapel and he's like, what the hell?
Eugenics is basically the mirror image
of critical race theory, isn't it?
Right.
In that like on the one side
you've got the far left people who are like
the world, like, you know,
taking privilege to its logical extent
and we have to like intervene
because no matter who you are,
if you are, you're like,
your race determines your life
because of society's factors.
Well, it almost needs to be
reverse social engineering
to make sure that we balance the
power as much as possible.
It's basically nature versus nurture, isn't it?
Critical race theory says
because of nurture, because of how racist society is,
you're basically, your life is determined by your race because of social factors,
whereas this is saying you're basically born thick if you're the wrong race.
Yeah.
Right.
So it's basically there's just mirror image of the same thing, right?
Anyway, so Gold, in America, they fucking love these ideas.
Each time he's publishing a paper, it's like the new Harry Potter book.
Yeah, like people are queuing outside the new iPhone.
They're finishing it.
They're getting photos, like, oh, fuck, what's this one I'm going to say?
Who's the worst race?
so the eugenics movement gains traction in the US
inspired by the work of British scientists of Francis Galton
Sir yeah of course
he's a polymack yeah yeah
for his services to racism he meant to the dog whistle
he meant to the dog whistle supported by philanthropists
because it seemed to be a philanthropic thing right
if we can out if we can breed out alcoholism
alcoholism if we can breed out alcoholism
then we can you know it's like
Yeah, the word for Lampthropist has really been muddied in this era.
It's doing some heavy lifting at this point.
It's, yeah.
So the Eugenics Record Office is established in Cold Springs Harbor in New York under the leadership of a guy called Charles Davenport.
I think might be an American Nazi.
I'm not sure.
Anyway, so this develops the idea of selective breeding.
Right.
And I just, there's a photo that I sent, Charlie, can you get the photo up of the placards that I sent you?
because there are people are protesting in the street for eugenic policies
and there is this photo right of people holding up signs
so this is this is a people on a sidewalk right in America
and they're holding up a placard I must drink alcohol to sustain life
shall I transfer this cruelty to others
and then there's one of the rights my favourite I cannot read this sign
by what right have I children and so this is basically essentially
it's disabled people holding signs saying that they should all be killed.
What?
Would the prisons and asylum?
Are they doing it satirically or are they?
No, these are pro-Eugenics protesters in early 20th century, New York.
I cannot read this sign, but by what right have I children?
Yeah.
So this is basically people, now I don't know whether he...
But this is like the recent disability protest against Rachel Reeves' policy.
Yeah, except.
But it's four.
Yeah.
It's the same people go, I don't want to be supported by the state.
Cut more.
Cut more.
I want to feel something.
They're holding up pictures of Rachel Reeves, like the Ayatollah.
Yeah, exactly.
Yeah.
Death to us.
Death to us.
More steps.
Less ramps.
More, less lifts.
Lose the lifts.
I want to be carried more.
I don't want food.
I want adrenaline.
Would the,
would the prisons and asylums be filled
if my kind had no children
right so these are now I don't
I don't know whether these people are genuinely
I mean the one the second one looks a bit funny
I reckon he's got something going on
but I don't know whether these people
are genuinely disabled but in
or is it a false flag
a false flag attack could be
but so that's also awesome
that is awful
able body guys just going
I'm disabled you should kill me
well they're not it's nothing
it's not about killing right
that's not about killing
it's about making sure that we
this never happens again
it's a no it's about um
you're getting let off with a warning
stop saying killing the germans
the Germans take it that far
in the early 20th century
American the eugenics record office
the um you know the extra
parliamentary
charity it's a charitable foundation
it's a fundamental foundation
it's what it's proposing
is involuntary sterilization
instills
they're trying to make
instells
out of the population
which is where if you are
mentally disabled
which will get to how they class this
then you are basically
you can't have kids
they just chop your balls off
right that's the philanthropic
against your well
they would argue they don't fucking know what's going on
right yeah but it's like I have a broken finger
why you chop it off
this is how in the early 20th century
they would class people
now for people listening this is a the it's like a staircase and at every point in the staircase there's a quite offensive drawing of someone if i was on spotify i'd go over to the video now
so all these terms of things we use now we're back in the day they these were in the psychiatric pseudoscience these were terms so at the very at the very let's go top to bottom at the very top you have a what's called a moron and that is someone who is really trying to get
on to the work that requires
reason.
There was a ranks too. Yeah, they're ranked.
So the moron is the least stupid.
So a moron is trying
the moron can handle complex
manual work and they're trying
to get to the
which what would be the normal
which is work that requires reason and judgment.
So what jobs are morons doing these days?
Is it like an estate agent?
Do they work at Morons work at Foxton's?
No, I'd say complex manual work
that's like
what would that be
I don't know
sparky like what
yeah
you'd say
you'd say all electricians
are morons
good luck
getting any
fucking house
renovation
done
so yeah
complex manual work
is sparky
uh
what requiring reason
and judgment
right
then you have
one step down
what's called
a high grade
imbecile
and these are people
who can only handle
simple manual work
high grade
doing a lot
of the heavy lifting
it works
it makes them feel
better. You're an imbecile. You're a top-notch. I mean, yeah, as tall as
, literally, so simple manual work. Smartest thick person. Yeah, high-grade
impassell, you can handle simple manual work, which I guess is like, what, painting?
Or complex manual work, it says. So that's what I mean? No, no, no, no. Moron are on the
complex manual work step. They're trying to get to work that requires reasonable judgment.
Right, that's why I was, okay, they're trying to get to a job at Foxxon's.
are trying to get to be a sparky
but they're too stupid
so they're stuck on the step
that's simple manual work
which is just painting I guess
right then you go down
you have medium imbecile
and these are simple mental work
minimal work
simple menial work which I guess is like
stitching or something
or like yeah finger painting
then you have a low grade imbecile
which all they can do
is self-preservation
that's all they can do
they can stay alive
but they can't work
Right, right, right, right.
Then you have an idiot who can't even stay alive.
So the idiot is, is, sort of drawn, kind of collapsed in a heap on the bottom of the staircase because they've fallen down because they're a fucking idiot.
So that is how, that this, what's amazing.
That is absolutely unbelievable.
This is psychiatry in the early 20th century.
So now, when people are like putting fucking ADHD autism in their bio, back in the day, they were putting high grade imbecile.
They were putting like, oh, actually, I need extra time.
my exams because I'm a low-grade imbecile.
Yeah.
Proud moron.
I'm an idiot.
This kind of makes more sense why.
So at someone at uni who
had incredibly woke.
This is 2016.
I have wokeness.
Pete woke.
Yeah.
I, she told me off for using the word idiot.
Yeah.
To describe a thick cunt I knew.
She was spying with that for us.
Yeah.
To describe this absolute spaz.
But she said,
said um idiot was it comes from like like it has bad origin right is it's like a true ableist
language i was like but what else do you just describe as stupid people yeah and she couldn't get
through it because i'd say moron she said no i just kept going through it they all have bad origin
well that's right the words the word spastic now do you know what she landed on yeah not clever
it's got to be more diverse no it does there's too many stupid people you need a noun she said was
you could say you need a noun you need something yeah you can't just say that person who's not
clever because the person who's not clever can't understand five words in a row so you need a noun.
Well idiot actually made age agree to someone who didn't really read the newspaper or whatever
or like wasn't up to date with the news. Yeah but in the early 20th century you'd say like
oh I'm a carer or who for an idiot and that's that's that's politically correct language.
Oh you're a scientist I don't know that time yeah I'm a scholar and gentleman in my spare time
actually volunteer looking after a fucking idiot yeah it's like yeah it's like yeah it's like
but like now so the term idiot now is
completely harmless yeah right but much but then idiots aren't harmless they still cause a lot of
themselves they're idiots they can't walk upstairs but but like much like the term the term spastic now
people flinch at when in the when 40 years ago that was the that was the accepted term yeah but
maybe in a hundred years time spastic will be back again right well like the way idiot is do you know
I mean yeah anyway so um basically what has happened here is that charles darwin's written a book on
bugs and plants and his cousin's gone, oh, I see what you really meant. You meant we should
cut the balls off people with Down syndrome. And so what then happens, right, is that the Americans
introduce laws in 30 states, right? 32 states in America. That's more than half have eugenics
laws. And right, they think that up to 80,000 people are involuntary.
sterilized in the early 20th century in America.
Most of them, guess where?
Where?
Where's the prettiest place in America?
I don't know.
Montana?
No, where are the people the fittest in America?
Oh, California?
Right.
Yeah, join the dots.
A lot of people are bred out of California in the early 20th century.
Like, there is a state-sponsored campaign of sterilizing fucking mental...
And that's the home of the porn industry.
do the maths
two plus two equals
fuck
right
they also
I mean a lot of this are also
I should say
I think a lot of black
black women are sterilized
I think especially racialized
in America
but I mean so
back to the funny stuff
so
so eugenics
keep it like Finn
eugenics
it really takes off
in early 20th century America
there are a state
There are 32 states that have, you know, states' rights.
We don't want to interfere with states' rights.
God no.
At one point, it's going to become a federal thing.
Yeah, so Indiana's the first one.
Compulsory sterilization of individuals deemed unfit, such as those with intellectuals.
So, you know, Francis Bourgeois, cut your balls off.
Everyone doing editor of a show about their neurodiversity, gone.
Gone.
Absolutely gone.
You'd be in the bin.
I'm gone.
You're gone.
Yeah, I'm getting sterilized.
Yeah, you're getting sterilized.
You can't breathe.
It's you're a danger.
the American Eugenics Society
has founded in 1910
and this promotes eugenics
as a scientific and social policy
to improve the human gene pool
Well both my parents have ADHD
So I think
You wouldn't exist
Yeah so I wouldn't
It was just trying to stop this happening
Yeah
Double down making me
Like you can't be doing that
Look what's happened
And I think it's right
Look what's happened
We could have done so much
Look at the best you've made
We could have done more to this
Stop this
The first international eugenics
Congress is held in London
in 1912.
Davenport, Henry Lockland.
Now, Lachlin's a big one as well.
The boys.
This is, this is a convention.
They can't wait to go to this.
When they're packing, they're excited.
It's like they're going on a golf trip with the boys.
Oh, I mean, if you have to, in a...
Davenport's going.
Oh, he's fucking...
Sorry, there's no better place for an Edwardian stag do
than the London Congress of Eugenics in 1912.
This is also in the era of the Human Zoo.
You wear this? I did this at uni.
Human zoos.
Yeah, I think I was...
Yeah.
So this is in the height of the...
from the colonies, this is also, you know, the great exhibition,
the Crystal Palace, all that stuff,
and they're showing off everything they've got from the colonies.
And in 1906, in New York, in the Bronx,
a pygmy man called Otter Benga is displayed in between apes and other animals,
and on the label is the missing link.
And they basically are claiming that pygmies are like the gap in Darwin's ideas
between the apes and white people.
So this is happening in New York.
He's just shit.
Now, human zoos are a thing in the early 20th century.
I think they're mainly in Belgium
from what they're doing in the Congo.
So this is the peak era of like racialized science.
Marie Stopes, right?
She wants to sterilize the Irish in London.
Marie Stopes was a pioneering advocate
for women's reproductive rights.
Uh-oh.
It was also strong.
Strong eugenic to advocate for the sterilization of those.
she considered hopelessly rotten and racially diseased
to brackets the Irish.
Isn't that amazing?
Women's rights.
How it's like abortion is progressive.
I'm really excited to tell you this.
So what we're talking about Americans
and sterilization campaigns.
So in America,
this is a state's rights issue.
They're allowing the states to
involuntarily sterilized disabled people.
And then there's,
then in 1927,
someone takes it to the Supreme Court
in a case called Buck v. Bell,
which is essentially
it's Roe versus Wade
but it's not about abortion
it's about sterilizing disabled people
so someone goes to Supreme Court
going
Buck versus Bell
is Roe v. Bell
is Roe v. Wade
but for cutting down
people's balls off
right right so
basically now
at this point
the American eugenics
is industry is like flying
like eugenics as a thing
is accepted in many states in the other
20th century. Brilliant. Now,
who should be across the channel
thinking on these ideas?
But the Germans,
our old friends. Now,
obviously, it should be stressed
that Winston Churchill, he's a big fan of eugenics.
Right. But he's, again, it's more of a class thing
than a race thing with Winston.
You pick your poison, isn't it? We all like different
drinks for different needs. He's a man of his time.
What is, a lot of people don't realize,
is that after the First World War,
a lot of American companies
get very, very rich
of re-arming the Germans.
Right.
So the German and American capital,
like early Hitler,
late Weimar, early Hitler,
and capitalist golden age America.
I love that, those albums from early Hitler.
Early Hitler's, early Hitler's capitalist America,
some really great stuff.
So the Ford company, basically all...
Oh, yeah, I mean, the Ford company,
I mean, yeah.
All the tanks that invade Poland are Ford.
Right.
All the trucks are Ford.
All the time.
are American tires.
Fine.
The Americans have
invented synthetic fuel
and the Germans
don't have much oil
no access to it.
Yeah, of course.
But they get
the synthetic fuel
patent from the Americans
which essentially powers
the entire war machine.
So then we have oil fields
until they get Romania and stuff.
What they also do,
what Hitler does
is that he basically
copies and pasts
the writings
of an American eugenicist
and puts it in mine camp.
And the Nazis,
the German racial
they call eugenics
racial hygiene
ever the lyricists
the Germans
they can take something
that's maybe quite
lyrical and quite
subtle and they just
fucking spell it out
yes racial hygiene
I see what you mean
so they
they take basically
there's a big
eugenics
movement in
in Berlin or in Germany
that's separate to Hitler
but what they do
when Hitler comes to power
because they're scientists
who believe in eugenics
Hitler's like
okay well if we're going to do eugenics
you've got to take the Jews out right
and they're not anti-Semites
but they go well for the good of eugenics
okay we'll implement some
anti-Semitic eugenics
so they're basically
they like don't throw the baby out with the bath
who's your donors right
it's like he's lobbying
the anti-Jew lobby we've got to play to them
we have to if we want eugenics to survive
which we do because we're good guys
then we have to
genocide Jews yeah
So it's so much so that the Nazi euthanasia program
Because it's one of the first things the Nazis do
When they come to power
You know you sort of about your first hundred days
First thing they do
You know when Blair comes in
On the first day they nationalised Bank of England
Right I mean they privatised
Whatever they do to Bank of England
And then everyone's like oh this is a Labour government
That actually means business for business
Right first thing it does right
Sterilisation mass sterilisation
Anyone we don't like
That programme is heavily influenced
and funded by the American euthanasia program
that was started.
Right.
Because they're the wild leaders on it,
utenasia, Americans at this point.
The Americans are, look,
this is before Buck v. Bell.
So they've not got anything.
And when Buck versus Bell,
the result of that trial was like Roe v.
Wade,
where they made it a federal thing where you can...
No, they said they could,
they were not, the Supreme Court,
I think, I'd actually know what this is.
Was it a groundbreaking case?
I think so, but I don't really know
in what it resulted in.
But at the Nuremberg rallies,
after the war
in there's another one
with all the Nazi scientists and doctors
after like the war criminals
and then they then they do another
next wave like where they get their ideas from
they yeah like oh that's it
so Harry Lachlan is the inspiration
that all the Nuremberg scientists
they claim they're like we
mate we just fucking copied what he was doing
in America yeah so it's like a bad interviewer on a comedy
podcast asking a comedian where he gets his ideas
from yeah but instead it's the Nerobo trials
I mean it's crucial
to the...
Where did you get your ideas from?
That's not how I said it.
Hey guys.
Adam, where do you...
Where do you get your crazy idea?
Killing six million Jews.
Where on earth do you get your ideas from?
It was a guy called Harry Lachlan
who wanted to standardise eugenics policies
across all the states.
Right.
And the Germans just translate that
and make it essentially law in that 33.
So, and then obviously
it goes without saying that the Germans
take what the Americans are doing
and they run with it.
They have a real field day.
I don't they look back.
But it's Hitler's anti-Semitism.
The only thing the Nazis really bring to the already
quite like vibes of eugenics is anti-Semitism.
That's their new shit.
That's all Hitler.
So like Hitler and the Nazis are anti-Semitic.
Eugenics isn't really about the Jews at this point.
It's about disabled people.
Hitler is like, let's get these guys involved.
And I'm on board.
Yeah.
And so I think we have
We've reached the nadir of humanity
We've reached the Holocaust
We've reached, we have traced over these two episodes
The terrible perversion of a pure
nerdy British bug catchers ideas
Into the origins of eugenics and the Holocaust
There's also, we haven't talked about the Darwin Awards
Which is quite funny.
What's that?
You know the Darwin Awards?
No.
The Darwin Awards are, it's an internet award system
for videos of people
who have, like, done something stupid
and died.
You've been framed.
It's you've been framed,
but they died in every video.
Darwin Awards
recognized individuals
who have supposedly contributed
to human evolution
by selecting themselves
out of the G-Poor
by dying, by their own actions.
So, what are some of the winners?
Early post cite an example
of a person who tried to break into a vending machine
and was crushed a death
when he pulled it over on himself.
A man who strapped a jet-assisted take-off unit
to a Chevrolet and Parlor
in the Arizona Desert
and who died on the side of a car.
Cliff, this is car achieve speeds at 300 miles now.
That is natural selection.
That's not social engineering.
No.
That is just the invisible hand of nature.
Yeah, I'm selecting myself out of the gene pool.
That's what this is.
But what I wanted to say is we have reached the end of the perversion of Darwin's ideas.
We have reached the horror of the Holocaust.
And I can now reveal that next week we will be dealing with something related to the Nazis.
Finally.
Finally.
We've fucked around.
We've been treading water for too fucking long.
I've been edging myself for fucking three months.
We've gone through medieval Mongolia.
I can't believe we did the medieval Mongolians before we got to Hitler, personally.
But we will be doing something related to the Nazis next week on the pod.
If you want all seven parts, I'm saying it now,
if you want all seven parts of that series, it'll probably be three,
sign up to the Patreon, where you also get bonus Friday.
episodes.
But either way, thanks so much for checking us out, and we shall see you next week.
Goodbye.
Al-fi to Zen.