Gilbert Gottfried's Amazing Colossal Podcast - GGACP Classic: The Godfather’s 50th Anniversary with Mark Seal
Episode Date: October 17, 2024GGACP celebrates October's National Book Month by revisiting this 2022 interview with award-winning journalist Mark Seal, author of the sensational book about the making of "The Godfather": “Leave t...he Gun, Take the Cannoli.” In this episode, Mark joins Gilbert and Frank to talk about the 50th anniversary of Francis Ford Coppola and Mario Puzo’s 1972 mob masterpiece, “The Godfather.” Also in this episode: Burt Lancaster closes in, Vic Damone bows out, Marlon Brando pulls off a shocking transformation and the mafia takes offense at the word “mafia.” PLUS: The music of Nino Rota! The genius of Dick Smith! Gilbert roasts Abe Vigoda! Mark climbs into bed with Robert Evans! James Caan’s performance is inspired by…Don Rickles!? And Richard Castellano ad-libs one of the great lines in movie history! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Upper Canada College inspires boys from senior kindergarten to year 12 to find their passions and realize their potential.
An IB world school, UCC offers a supportive environment, cutting-edge facilities and a best-in-Canada financial assistance program.
UCC, a place where tradition, excellence and innovation meet.
Learn more at our open house events on October 15th and 16th.
Register now at cause and effect.ucc.on.ca. Chiara, it means smart in Italian. Too bad
your barista can't spell it right. So you just give a fake name, your cafe name, Julia. But the
more you use it, the more it feels like you're in witness protection. Wait a minute. What kind
of espresso drinks does Julia like anyway?
Is it too late to change your latte order?
But with an espresso machine by KitchenAid,
you wouldn't be thinking any of this
because you could have just made your espresso at home.
Shop now at KitchenAid.ca.
-♪ TV comics, movie stars, hit singles and some toys.
Trivia and dirty jokes, an evening with the boys.
Once is never good enough for something so fantastic.
So here's another Gilbert and Franks. Here's another Gilbert and Franks. Here's another Gilbert and Franks.
Colossal Classic
Hi, this is Gilbert Gottfried and this is Gilbert Gottfried's Amazing Colossal podcast with my co-host Frank Santopadre.
Exactly 50 years ago today, almost to the minute, a highly anticipated new movie premiered at the Lowes State Theater in New York City.
An event attended by everyone from Jack Nicholson to Henry Kissinger.
The movie making its debut that night is one we've discussed many times on this show.
1972's gangster epic The Godfather.
And tonight's guests may just know a thing or two about that subject as well.
Mark Seal is a much admired journalist and contributing editor at Vanity Fair where he's covered stories ranging from the Bernie Madoff
scandal to the classic movie Pulp Fiction. He's a two-time finalist for
the National Magazine Awards and has written articles for Esquire, Playboy, Rolling Stone, and The New York Times.
And his 2016 Vanity Fair piece,
the Over the Hill Gang about a gang of thieves
who pulled off the biggest jewel heist in British history
was the basis of the 2018 Michael Caine film, King of Thieves. He's the author of the
books Wild Flower, The Man in the Rockefeller Suit, and notably the new book
Leave the Gun, Take the Cannoli, a well-researched, brilliantly written account of making what many consider
the greatest motion picture ever produced, featuring wonderful interviews with director
Francis Ford Coppola, actors James Kahn, Talia Shire, Robert Duvall and studio exec Robert Evans and many more. Frank and I are
excited to speak to a gifted writer and storyteller and a man who once found himself in a h Jersey deli with the son of mob boss Joe Colombo.
The talented Mark Seal.
Neh, neh, neh, neh, neh, neh, neh, neh, neh.
I believe in America.
America's where I make my fortune.
I raised my daughter in the American fashion.
I gave her freedom, but I taught her never
to dishonor her family.
She found a boyfriend, not an Italian.
They took her to the movies, they made her drink alcohol,
then they tried to take advantage of her, but she resisted. She kept
her honor, so they beat her like an animal. The next day in the hospital, her nose was
so broken, her jaw was so shattered, held together by wires. She couldn't even weep because of the pain. But I wept. The
next day in the courtroom, the judge gave three years suspended a sentence. Suspended
sentence. They went free that very day. And those bastards smiled at me. And I said to my wife, for justice, we must go to Don Corleone.
Why don't you go to the police?
Why don't you come to me first?
What do we think, Mark?
Well, it's pretty great.
I'm speechless.
Yeah.
Now, I don't want you to say anything else
for the rest of the show.
OK, I'll just let you run with it.
I'll just recite the card.
He was very proud of that, Mark.
He called me up, and he said, listen,
I know the bonus era speech.
And he said, but if I go too far, just stop me.
But I was watching Mark's face, and he was somewhere between entertained and befuddled. Yeah
Somewhere between that's great. What the fuck is this?
Anyway, it's great to be here. Thank you man and welcome and thanks for sticking with us
It wasn't it wasn't eat. You're a very busy man. It wasn't easy to nail you down and great to be here
Thank you so much. And here you are.
Judging by this book, if you really want scary mob stories, you shouldn't see the
Godfather. They should have filmed the making of the Godfather.
Yeah. The making of the movie was, uh, was, you know,
almost as wild off screen as what you see on screen.
Yeah. was almost as wild off screen as what you see on screen.
Yeah. Yeah.
Including something we referenced in the intro,
as part of your journey in writing this book,
you wound up in a diner in the wilds of Jersey
with the son of mobster Joe Columbo.
Yes.
In fact, that story opens your book.
Exactly, yes.
So I met him and he was older then and walked with, he was older than and walked with a cane we met in a in a diner in
New Jersey. And, you know, I wanted to talk to him about a
about potentially interviewing him for the book, but he actually
wrote his own book, which is really a great, great read as
well. But really, it was an amazing journey from start to
finish all the people that I met along the way
were just one interesting character after another.
Yes, I can imagine.
Tell us how this all began.
I mean, and I don't mean you seeing the film
as a college freshman back in 1972.
And as Gilbert pointed out again in the intro,
we are at six o'clock here, New York time
on the 14th of March,
which is 50 years almost to the hour.
Exactly.
That this film was first screened
or it's premier in New York.
50 years ago this evening at the Lowes State Theater
in New York, in the middle of a freezing, cold,
rainy night, people, there was a limo line up and down Broadway, uh, to
see the Godfather for the first time.
And as you noted, uh, uh, Robert Evans arrived with his then wife, uh,
Allie McGraw and, uh, Henry Kissinger.
Yeah.
Looked their seats in the theater and watched the magic begin for three hours.
Amazing.
I always remember like the Godfather, the advertisement on the radio was just the Godfather
is now a movie.
And then he played da da da da da da da da da da da da da. And and it was now the guy who You named the artist who drew the poster which was a hand holding marionette strings
right
Yes, he was a
Japanese artist. Yeah named Fujita and he had done
Various logos. He was quite a talented
artist and he looked at those strings. You know,
Mario Puzo mentioned men holding the strings and he took that and he created that very
simple stark logo of that hand holding the puppeteer's cross and the strings dangling
down and with the stark logo of the
Godfather in that typeface that you can never forget, right?
No, it's so memorable.
Yeah.
And I, I always liked like simplistic movie posters when they show too much
action, I thought they're desperate.
And but when it's something simple like that, that just makes you wonder.
I know it just so captivated. I mean, even today you look at that book cover.
It's so simple, but it says everything right.
And you use the font for your for your title.
Yeah, I mean that font is used quite a bit.
You know, you see that so often.
And that font as well was so brilliant and so simple. But
it just you know, when you look at it, it just says the
Godfather.
It works.
And you weren't no not you weren't the people the movie
makers were not allowed by the mob to use the word mafia.
Yes, because there was something called
the Italian American Civil Rights League
back in the 60s and early 70s.
And its leader was Joe Colombo,
the reputed head of one of the five families of New York.
He was the founder of the league
and he felt that that word mafia
put Italian Americans in a bad light. And so the producer of the movie met with the League
and with Colombo and let him read the script.
And the only thing he wanted was that word mafia
not be used in the movie,
but it had only been used one time in the original script.
So they took it out and a world of cooperation opened in New York.
And, but wasn't the whole Italian American civil rights league kind of a front
for the mob in the first place?
Well, on one hand, it really was a civil rights league and they were,
and they really did, they really did succeed in, in, in, in,
in getting the word mafia, uh mafia not used in press releases,
I think, from the Justice Department and other places and newspapers and publications, newspapers,
different places. So it really was a real cause. So yes, there was, you know, some
people say what you what you say, but others say it was a
real cause. So the truth is somewhere there in the middle,
like, well, they got so they managed to wrangle Sinatra to
perform at a benefit. Yes, exactly. Frank Sinatra
performed at a benefit for like, oh, my gosh, it was thousands
of people and raised a lot of money. And so this was a group.
This was a group that the movie makers
had to contend with.
And weren't the papers making fun of the movie
for not using the term mafia?
Yes, because after the producer already agreed
to delete the word mafia from the script,
even though it was only used once,
the newspapers covered it because there was a press
press conference the next day held in the Park Sheraton
hotel and members of the media attended that press
conference and it was in the headlines the next day.
And so there was a, there was a lot of backlash over the deal
about all of that.
So yes, it was in the headlines.
Now we mentioned Sinatra and okay,
so there's that whole scene where Sinatra
under a different name shows up at the Corleone party and
Johnny Fontaine.
Yeah. He wants to be in a movie and the
head of the studio doesn't want him.
And now what?
So Sinatra, there was that scene about Sinatra.
And yet wasn't he also asked to, or he was trying
to be Don Corleone in the picture.
At first he did not want it, want the movie.
I mean, at first he, he didn't, uh, you know, we don't know exactly what he said, but there
was the altercation between him and Mario Puzo at Chasen's restaurant in Los Angeles.
Um, she'll have to give us.
Yeah, I can tell you about that. But you know, he the character
of Johnny Fontaine, you can look at it two ways. I mean, in the
movie, he's comes on, he sings, he's a beautiful, beautifully
dressed, he's a great singer. And then the whole character of
Johnny Fontaine is where the movie
turns, you know, where he can't get that role that he wants so badly. And the Godfather says,
of course, you know, I'm going to make him an offer he can't refuse. And the horse's head scene
comes after that. So, you know, it was widely believed that that character was based in part,
if not in a lot of part by on Frank Sinatra.
And in the beginning, it seems that he did not like that portrayal portrayal.
Because in the book and Mario Puzo's novel, there's a lot more Johnny Fontaine than there
is in the movie. I will victim victim moan was attached originally, was he not victim was
attached at one point. But the story goes that he couldn't
get out of his Las Vegas dates. And so Al Martino, who had not acted in a movie, got the role. And he
was a long time singer in Las Vegas and nightclubs across America and New York. And he really inhabited that role, right?
And sure as hell did that. I, I, and according to your book,
that was a total ad lib. Uh,
when Marlon Brando slaps him and goes, she cannot like a man.
Exactly. Yes. That's what I was told that, you know,
that, uh, Al Martino was playing the role, yes, that's what I was told that, you know, that Al Martino was playing the
role and wasn't as animated as Brando thought he could be.
And so he ad libs that slap and he goes that you can act like a man, just like you said,
like Gilbert in person.
It's great.
I didn't know that.
I thought I knew so much about the making of this movie and I absolutely did not know
that.
It's one of the wonderful little gems and surprises in your book.
Godfather, I don't know what to do.
I don't know what to do.
You can act like a man!
What's the matter with you?
Is this how you turn around in Hollywood,
when you're crying like a woman?
What can I do?
What can I do?
What is that, Naz I don't say nothing.
Look at this.
You spend time with your family?
Sure I do.
Good.
Because a man who doesn't spend time with his family can never be a real man.
Come here.
You look terrible.
Once you're the...
Once you're the rest of the world and the month from now,
this Hollywood big shot's gonna give you what you want.
It's too late. They started shooting in a week.
I'm gonna make them an awfully can't refuse.
But just to take... Just to complete Gilbert's arc, his question about Sinatra, Sinatra originally objected
to the depiction of the character in Puzo's novel.
Right.
And their run in, it chases, the movie had not even been made yet.
Exactly.
It was based on, and they had to be pulled apart finally.
And then later in the book,
you say that Sinatra had changed his tune
to the point where he approached Coppola and said,
what, let me buy this thing and we'll do it together?
Yeah, he said, and I'll play the,
let's buy this thing and I'll do the Godfather.
Yeah, so.
Wow.
Yeah, because, you know, I think by that point,
it was a best seller.
Mario Puzo's novel was racing up the best seller list and Paramount had to make
this movie because Burt Lancaster wanted to buy it from the studio.
And Danny Thomas wanted to buy it from
the studio and either one of them might have played the Godfather.
Amazing. But Danny Thomas,
Danny Thomas, Danny Thomas is the Godfather. I. Danny Thomas wanted to buy Paramount. Danny Thomas is the Godfather.
I can't see it, Gilly.
Yeah.
But also he wanted to buy,
Danny Thomas was more ambitious than that.
He wanted to buy Paramount.
Well, Danny Thomas was doing pretty well
because he had all of those shows in syndication.
And you know, they were top 10 shows.
And you know, so he was a very successful producer
other than being an actor.
You know, you read the book, Mark,
and you know, and you've written extensively about movies.
You have a wonderful Vanity Fair article too
that will tell our fans about pulp fiction.
And you know as well as anybody
that so many things can go wrong in the making of a movie
and derail it immediately.
I mean, this film could have had Ernest Borgnein as the Godfather, Ryan O'Neill in the making of a movie and derail it immediately. I mean, this film could have had Ernest Borgnein
as the Godfather, Ryan O'Neill in the Michael role.
Because when I think of Italian gangsters,
the first one I think of is Ryan O'Neill.
Yeah, or Ernest Borgnein as the Don, or even Olivier,
and no disparaging of Olivier. don't see him in the part.
But there's so many things that could have gone wrong is what is the sense
that you get while you're holding exactly.
I mean, the whole thing is a miracle because it was the movie that
in the beginning, this Robert Evans and and Peter Barrett were saying,
what are we going to do with this thing?
A lot of the directors that they wanted turned it down.
Francis Ford Coppola initially did not want to do it, but only after George Lucas said,
you know, we do this, we need the money for our studio, American Zoetrope up in San Francisco.
And then you can do we can do the movies we want to do.
And he said, I don't know, you know?
And so Lucas, George Lucas told him,
we'll find something in the book you like.
And so he went to the Mill Valley library
and started looking at and reading books about the mafia.
And he decided in the end that the story was about a king
and his three sons.
And each one of the sons had something,
had aspects of what made the king great.
That's what pulled him in.
That pulled him in.
And Coppola didn't like the novel.
Initially, initially, but then he found these things in it
that he liked and he took the novel to a,
he took the novel every morning, he took the novel every morning he would go
to a coffee shop in San Francisco.
And he tore the novel apart out of its binder,
out of its binding and put holes in it
and three holes in it and put it in a notebook.
And in the margins of the notebook,
you can buy that notebook, the Godfather notebook, and you can see his notes where he took that novel
and that novel becomes the script.
So the novel really, Mario Puzo laid such groundwork
for this movie.
I mean, he invented this world of the Corleones
and all of the key scenes and everything that happened.
And then Coppola just elaborated on them
and brought so much magic and energy and danger
and blood and violence and everything else to it,
that it just became this amazing thing.
Almost like an opera,
which is kind of how he saw it, operatic.
Operatic, Shakespearean, bigger than life.
Mario Puzo said he had never met an honest, an actual gangster.
He did it all from research.
And yes.
I didn't mean to interrupt you.
I was going to say, you mentioned a second ago
that Coppola was desperate.
Lucas said, well, you have to do it.
You have to find something that you can attach yourself to here
because we need the money.
This entire project, if you go back to Puzo,
is born out of desperation.
Yes, because Puzo had published two novels before.
And while they were critically well received,
they weren't financially successful.
He made $3,500 in advance for the first novel
and I think 3,000 for the second.
And the classic story is one night
he suffered a gallbladder attack and got into a taxi
and directed the taxi to the VA hospital in New York.
And once he arrived at the hospital,
he opened the door and fell out with the pain of the
gallbladder attack and he fell into the gutter.
And there looking up at the night sky of New York, he goes, here I am a published author
and I'm dying like a dog.
And he said, that's when I decided I'm going to be rich and famous.
That's such a great story. And a story that you hear from every director who goes on a talk show is saying, oh, these
people were my first choice.
And in the case of The Godfather, that cast was actually Coppola's first choice.
I know he envisioned this cast, which is pretty amazing because these actors were not big
stars then. They had been in films, Robert Duvall and James Kahn had been in a Coppola
film that he directed, but you know, they weren't stars. Al Pacino had not been seen on screen in a film. He had shot the panic in
Needle Park. But he was primarily known as an actor on
Broadway and off Broadway. And everybody said, Who is Al
Pacino? You know, we want to give this to a star. And of
course, after Coppola envisioned this cast and brought them to
San Francisco, where he filmed them in these inexpensive screen tests, which you can see online, he sent them down to the studio
and they go, what is this? And they insisted that he embark upon a very expensive $400,000,
I think, casting process where they screen tested and tested and auditioned
many other actors for all the other roles.
And you make the point in the book that had they just listened to him in the first place,
Paramount would have saved themselves almost half a mil.
Exactly.
Yeah.
And it was a method to his madness.
There's a great line in the book.
You quote him as saying he wanted to smell the garlic coming off the screen.
Yeah, that was actually Robert Evans, you know.
Robert Evans said that.
Yeah, Robert Evans said, you know, you must smell the spaghetti.
He goes, you know, we want this movie to be, you know, Italian to the core.
And they wanted Italian actors for Italian roles, which in many cases they got.
Al Pacino, you know, of course, James
Khan was not Marlon Brando was not or in Tom Hagan, Robert Duvall wasn't, of
course, but some money at Al Lettere.
I mean, listen, look at him as, as, as Salazzo who could be better than that.
Sure.
I took Gilbert was surprised that Al Lettere by the way, was mobbed up that
his brother-in-law, his brother-in-law, was it what, Capo?
His brother-in-law was reputedly connected, let's just say that.
And Al Letire learned it from, you know, also Al Letire knew Marlon Brando. There was another
book, I think it's Peter Manso's book, quotes someone is saying,
Brando learned I could be a contender scene from Al Lettre,
which is quite interesting.
So Al Lettre was around
and he turned out to be an amazing actor.
I remember watching The Godfather with my mother.
And as that scene where it goes, you know, do you mind if we speak in Italian in the diner?
And, and I remember my mother saying to me that I'll let
Teary looked, sounds like he speaks Italian, but Pacino doesn't.
Yeah.
They were, uh, Alot here. He did, of course, of course he speaks Italian, but Pacino doesn't. Yeah, they were, Al Attyry did, of course.
Of course he spoke Italian.
And I think that somebody had told me for the book
that Al Pacino, when he breaks into English,
that was because he kind of lost the Italian aspect
for a moment.
And he said, and he started talking, uh, speaking in English,
but it worked so well for the same, right?
It works.
Yeah.
Because then the audience can understand what they're saying without subtitles.
It really that that part I thought for sure was in the script.
Yeah.
No, I think that was totally not in the script.
So it works too, because Michael is, because Michael is clearly of a different generation.
And if anything, he's turning his back on the old world.
So you completely buy that he wants to speak English
in that moment.
Yeah, exactly.
What I was alluding to before too,
when I misattributed that quote to Coppola,
is the method to his madness is he said,
Italian actors will understand what I mean culturally
because they grew up with this.
I don't have time in making this movie
to explain to non Italians.
Right, right.
He thought by casting Italian American actors
for the Italian American roles, they carry that
and they emanate from the screen, which was so true.
Look at Luca Brasi, Lenny Montana. of course, and he just, you know,
you look at him and you think, oh my gosh,
this guy could be the unenforcer.
What is the story in the back of the book at the,
toward the end of the book where Lenny Montana
punches out Al Ruddy?
Yes, that was so interesting.
That was one of the mysteries, yes.
What is a mystery?
That's a mystery, but he, yeah, he opens the door and there is a Lenny, Montana.
I mean, Lenny Montana was what?
300 and something pounds.
Yeah.
I don't think you want to, he, he was quite a fierce individual and
Al Ruddy was quite thin and very tall.
Um, and then that, yeah, that's an amazing story.
Right.
Hall. And then that, yeah, that's an amazing story, right?
Speaking of the actors who were in Italian, like, um,
James Kahn was a Jew from Queens and,
but you explain why he's so convincing as a mobster.
Yeah. He grew up in that world, Sunnyside, right? And he grew up in that world. He knew that world. He knew some of the people in his neighborhood.
But the interesting thing about James Kahn, first he goes out and he goes to like a thrift shop and
he buys these two-tone shoes that are too tight for him. So that gives him that kind of walk,
you know, that Sonny did. But he was stuck on a scene he told me and he said he couldn't wasn't responding
fast enough. And I think it was the scene in the olive oil factory where they're meeting with
Salazzo and he says, what do you mean that Tatalya's are going to guarantee our investment?
Gilbert can probably say that better than I can. But thank you. But then and Sonny, but but he but he was stuck. Then
he remembers Don Rickles. You know, Don Rickles, the insult comic who's talked a mile a minute
and would, you know, say anything to anybody, you know, and he thought about Don Rickles
and he brought that to his performance, where he's just talking off the top of his head.
He said once he got that, then he knew how to how to respond to Sonny.
I thought that was so interesting that he was to that to the Godfather.
It's just something you would never imagine.
So we Rickles comic delivery.
Yeah, that fast pace, you know, one one line or after another, you know,
just what do you mean all over your Ivy League suit,
bada bing. That was another ad lib, bada bing, because I asked him, I said, how did you come up
with that? He goes, I don't know. It just was like, I'd heard something similar, bada boom.
Did I say bada boom? Did I say bada bong? He said bada bing. It just comes out and that just entered
the vocabulary. Bada bing and then it becomes out and that just entered the vocabulary.
Bada bing and then it becomes a part of the sopranos.
Exactly.
We will return to Gilbert Gottfried's Amazing Colossal podcast after this.
Chiara, it means smart in Italian.
Too bad your barista can't spell it right.
So you just give a fake name, your cafe name, Julia.
But the more you use it, the more it feels like you're in witness protection.
Wait a minute. What kind of espresso drinks does Julia like anyway?
Is it too late to change your latte order?
But with an espresso machine by KitchenAid, you wouldn't be thinking any of this
because you could have just made your espresso at home.
Shop now at KitchenAid.ca.
just made your espresso at home. Shop now at KitchenAid.ca. Is that because you don't have any knees? Or... Ugh. The Scorebeck.
Trusted sports content.
Seamless sports betting.
Download today.
19 Plus. Ontario only.
If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or the gambling of someone close to you,
please go to connexontario.ca.
Metrolinx and Crosslinx are reminding everyone to be careful,
as Eglinton Crosstown LRT train testing is in progress.
Please be alert, as trains can pass at any time on the tracks.
Remember to follow all traffic signals.
Be careful along our tracks and only make left turns where it's safe to do so.
Be alert, be aware, and stay safe.
Well, here's another fascinating thing from the book.
I have seen the movie 200 times.
Until I read your book, I don't know why Jimmy Khan, James Khan is holding a cane in that
scene and he's using it quite comfortably.
So interesting.
So what happened is in the scene in Louie's Italian American restaurant in the Bronx, where Michael blows away
salazzo and McCluskey. Yeah. After that scene, he was
supposed to run out of the restaurant, drop the gun, and
then jump on a car, you know, to get away car, but nobody had
told him what to do. And so he jumps and he
missed the car and fell in the street and severely injured his ankle. I think it was. And so he had
to walk with a cane. So he had that cane in the room where Sonny says the bottom being line. And
that's why Sonny has the cane. Yeah and I've
seen the movie 200 times and I'm always wondering why the hell has he got a
cane? Yeah. Also why did Don Corleone have a cat in the opening scene?
Why has he got a cat in his arms? Well that cat was in the old Filmways studio
with just a vagabond cat that was eating the rats in the studio.
And he rambles on he kind of ambles onto the set and Brando picks him up. And then the rushes come
back to the dailies go back to Los Angeles, they go what, what the hell is this cat purring into
the microphone, we can't hear Brando because he's mumbling. And all we hear is this cat.
because he's mumbling and all we hear is this cat. It's amazing.
It's great stuff.
And tell us about how Pacino, what made him jump
on the car in the first place?
Well, because it was part of the scene.
He had been working all night and he
was supposed to jump on the car on the running board
as the car sped away board as the car run,
sped away in front of the restaurant, which you see, which you see in the movie.
But according to there was a assistant to
Kapala who wrote a diary of some of these of all of these events, a day by day
diary, which I quote a lot in the book.
And he had written that Pacino had said back then
that nobody had been instructed on how to jump on the car
or what to do.
And so he just leapt.
He leapt and he fell.
And that's why he sprained his ankle and he was using a cane.
And I think that's a low point in the book for Coppola
because Brando misses the flight.
Yes, on the first-
Pacino injures himself.
I'm trying to remember if that's the point
where Coppola was so frustrated,
he went home, took a blanket off the bed
and tore it into shreds with his bare hands.
Yes, exactly.
Yeah, because the first,
Brando misses his flight on the day of his first scene.
And then this happened with Pacino.
So it was one thing after another, you know?
I mean, Coppola is a young filmmaker,
just turned 30, he's 31, he's 32 when the movie comes out.
And all of these things were being thrown at him.
This, you know, this big cast,
all of these things were going wrong.
It was very difficult in the beginning.
There were threats that he might be replaced.
There was insurrection among his own crew.
There was talk of Al Pacino not being kept on until that amazing scene in the restaurant. Once they saw the scene in the restaurant,
there was no denying the greatness of Pacino or Coppola.
And before I forget, one of my favorite lines
in The Godfather is Al Leteary when he says,
you think too much of me, Michael, I am the hunted one.
He's so great.
Yeah, that's a great scene.
And the way he braids it is so good.
I mean, he's just he was great. Right. Oh, yeah.
Fantastic. Well, all of those secondary parts where he cast Italians,
you know, Louis Louis Guss, even down to the small, you know,
the smallest mobster part, but, but, uh, but Richard Conti and, and Lettere and
the guy playing Philip to taglia. I mean, they're all, they're all so wonderful.
And Johnny Martino is as, uh, you know, Johnny Martino's as Polly gotto in the beginning,
you know, right. Where he throws the sandwiches and he said, if this was anybody else's wedding, that that silk purse with all the money would be gone.
My own.
He's great.
What?
De Niro was almost going to play that.
Yeah, De Niro was they considered De Niro as Polly got to and had he gotten the role,
he couldn't have been in Godfather two because he would have been dead out on the and the
steer with his with his head in the steering
wheel out on that desolate road where the Statue of Liberty has his back to the murder
scene.
And as long as we're talking about that scene that lends its name to your book.
Yeah.
And another brilliant Italian actor is Castellano, Richard Castellano, playing Clemenza, a line
that he improvised.
Exactly.
Which I also didn't know until I read Mark Seale.
Thank you so much.
So yeah, the line is not in the novel.
The line was in the script that was co-written
by Francis Coppola and Mario Puzo,
but they only had written, leave the gun.
But Richard Castellano remembers what his wife told him from the stoop that
morning. Don't forget the cannoli, she yells out. And that was his real wife in real life.
And so they go out, they do the killing. And Richard Castellano tells Rocco, the driver,
you know, leave the gun. And
then he remembers what his wife told him that morning. And he
goes, take the cannoli. And to me, that says everything about
the movie, because it is a movie about guns. It's a movie about
criminals. It's a movie about murder and mayhem and everything
else that you see in the Godfather. But it's also about
the cannoli, maybe more about the cannoli,
because the cannoli represents the family, the food,
and what it takes to put that food on the table.
So it's about the gun, yes,
but it's more about the cannoli,
and that's why the title,
Leave the Gun, Take the Cannoli.
And that's a perfect title.
I think Richard Castellano ad libbed that line perfectly
and came up with something extraordinary.
And also it's how cold blooded it is,
like just such a throwaway line.
Yeah.
Of like, like the cannolis are more important
than this guy that they killed.
Yeah, that's right. Yeah, that's right.
Yeah, you're right.
Let's get out of here.
You know, leave the gun.
I always wondered why they want to leave the gun.
Why wouldn't they take the gun?
You know, why leave the gun for evidence?
It's weird.
Now, Richard Castellano, they asked him to be in Godfather 2.
Yes.
And he had a lot of demands. He wanted script approval. Wow. According
to some. And that's what I'm going to happen. So, you know, it's a pity because he was so great.
I mean, he was one of the great he was when you left that movie, you kept thinking about him,
because he was as Coppola writes in his notes, you know, he's showing Michael,
he's like a uncle, your favorite uncle in the basement with popular mechanic magazines. This
is what Coppola wrote in the Godfather notebook. You know, there's popular mechanic, you know,
magazines and he's in a basement like instructing his relative how to do
something except he's instructing him on how to kill a man.
You know, you know, remember that scene?
That scene was so endearing.
You just I don't know.
There was something about Richard Castellano that was so profound.
I remember there's also that line.
Richard Castellano is listening in on the call and he goes, why don't you tell that girl you love her?
I love you with all of my heart.
If I don't see you, I'm going to die.
That's the best.
I love that.
Yes.
That's right.
I think that was also making the sauce and the meatballs.
Yeah.
You know, you put it, that's the great thing about making that, making the sauce.
But actually, you know, I have, uh, in some of the documents that I was able to see, Richard
Castellano actually writes a memo saying the specific type of sauce he wanted to use in
that scene.
That's fantastic. Now, but by them not getting Richard Castellano, I
heard is why they hired Michael V. Gazzo. Yeah, I'm not sure about that. You know,
I, you know, I'm not sure about what happened, but yes, because they didn't get Castellano,
you know, they had to come up with someone to play his role in
the younger days. So yes, but- Well, there was talk, you know, and this is one thing too,
that comes through in your book is that there are so many conflicting versions of events.
Yes. You know, you could start in this book, there's Coppola's version of events,
there's Robert Evans' version of events, There's Peter Barth's version of events, which is usually kind of an intermediary.
I believe Peter Barth.
But you also hear conflicting stories about, well, I read something that Castellano didn't
want to play the part of somebody who betrays the Corleone family.
He wasn't comfortable with that part, the part that Frankie Five Angel, the character that Frankie Five Angels becomes.
But now you're telling us something entirely different, that he had demands.
Yes, that's for sure. That's been pretty much documented.
That's been told quite a bit that he did have demands.
He wanted to have the script approval over what he said.
And that's what I was told. So I think that was kind of the over what he said. And, you know, that's just some, that's what I was told.
So that, I think that was kind of the overriding reason.
I haven't really heard that other one that you mentioned.
Was he or was he not related to Paul Castellano
who was shot dead in front of Sparks?
Well, okay, so some people, you know,
his wife said, yes, but I talked to a relative who said, no.
And so, you know, that's another one of conflicting stories.
That's the thing, everybody has a different, you know,
when you make a masterpiece, you know, there's a lot of,
everybody has different visions on,
versions on what happened, who did what.
But you know, the great thing is it's on the screen
and you watch that movie and you don't hear
all the background, but it's interesting the screen and you watch that movie and you don't hear all the the background
but it's interesting to know you know all the different versions of different ideas different
takes you know so i tried to include them all oh you got so much in there let me ask you a couple
go ahead go now brando at that point you know now you look at it and say oh the great marlon
brando but at that point he was looked upon as a
husband. Yeah, he was he was pretty much washed up at 47. He was so young.
I love your line that he gave everybody in Tahiti the clap.
That was that that was from Peter Biscan. Exactly. Yeah.
So he was considered box office poison.
His latest movies, the movies that he had done
recently had flopped at the box office. He was considered temperamental, but he didn't want to
do it. That's the other thing. He didn't want to play a mafia Don. He goes, I'm not going to be a
mafia Don. But then there was something that happened.
You know, Coppola's first of all, Mario Puzo saw him as the godfather from the beginning and he wrote him a letter.
He wrote him this extraordinary letter that you could see in the book.
And it said the address where Mario Puzo sent the letter from was
scrawled across the top.
It said North Carolina fat farm.
And he was at Duke University Fat Far Reducing Clinic.
And he wrote, dear Mr. Brando,
I wrote a book that has had some success
called The Godfather.
And I believe you were the only actor
who can play the Godfather with the quiet intensity
that the role deserves.
And the studio did not want Marlon Brando,
but Coppola wanted Marlon Brando so much that he almost not want Marlon Brando, but Coppola wanted Marlon Brando so
much that he almost insisted on Marlon Brando. And they said, okay, if you do a screen test
with Brando and other demands, we'll consider it. So Coppola went up to the Brando home
on Mulholland Drive with a small crew. And they didn't tell him it was going to be a
screen test. They said it was going to be a makeup test. And this is
one of the, you know, great fables stories of the
Godfathers that Brando comes out with a ponytail. He's young,
he's 47 in a kimono. And he right in front of the cameras,
he's, you know, put some shoe polish on his upper
lip, he pulls back his ponytail, he stuffs his cheeks with
Kleenex, he says, I want to talk like a bulldog. And he becomes
Don Corleone. And from that point on, Coppola took the tape
to New York, where he showed it to Charlie Bluthorn, who was the
head of Gulf and Western Paramount's parent company. And
he goes, you know, nobody could deny that
that Brando was the godfather.
Charlie Boodhorn, another great character in the book, by the way.
And Hurricane Charlie. Hurricane Charlie.
There's also another name that has to be mentioned
is the great makeup artist, Dick Smith.
Yes. Yes. Not only did he make Brando,
who was in his forties, into an old man,
but in the exorcist,
Max Von Sito was in his early forties when he did that.
Yeah.
He was a wizard.
I mean, Brando was, you know, you look at him
and you think, wow, that's Brando.
Then you see the pictures before, the before and after,
before the makeup and then after the makeup.
He's so young.
He's still 47.
And one of the unsung heroes of the movie is,
and I forget her name, forgive me,
is Brando's personal assistant.
Yes.
Alice Marshak.
Alice Marshak, who kept pushing him.
She kept pushing him.
And the interesting thing is that she said they were also considering Lawrence
Olivier and, uh, Brando just wasn't interested at all until she said she told
him, well, they're considering Lawrence Olivier and she, he goes, Lawrence
Olivier, he can't play a mafia Don.
He goes, then suddenly he was interested.
And it's great. There were a mafia Don. He goes, then suddenly he was interested. That's great. There were a few things. Now I could, you know, easily imagine Rotz Steiger as Don Corleone, but they said that Rotz Steiger called up and wanted to be Michael.
Yeah, that's right. You know, I think that was, was that, uh, Sue
Mingers called, uh, Mark Cole, call Mario Puzo. That's right.
The agent Sue Mingers called Mario Puzo said, I wonder, can I
take you to lunch and Mario Puzo? You know, he liked to have
lunch, but he was, he didn't want to go to lunch with an
agent. So he just said, uh, you know, I guess maybe he didn't know who Sue Mingers was.
You know, she was one of the great agents,
the most powerful agents in Hollywood.
She goes, what about Rod Steiger for Michael?
And he goes, well, I don't know.
You know, Michael's pretty young.
And I think Rod Steiger was in his late 40s then,
or maybe older.
Yeah, unbelievable.
Let me ask you a couple of quick questions
from listeners and fans.
Mark Howard Sideman.
I want to know more about the casting of a Vagoda.
Somebody Gilbert and I got to know fairly well as Tessio.
Was he picked out at an open casting call?
And how did a non-Italian do such a good job?
And then we want to ask you about another person
that Gilbert and I have had on this show.
And that's Gianni Russo.
Oh yeah.
So Abe Bogota, amazing.
I was able to interview Abe Bogota in his New York
apartment.
And he told me he went down to little Italy
and studied the accents and the way people spoke and walked
and everything.
But he was not an Italian.
But I believe he was in an open casting call.
And he just embodied that role of Tessio so well, you know?
Remember the scene, Gilbert?
I know you can probably do that great, too.
Where he goes.
Thank you again.
Where he goes, you know, it wasn't me.
You know, it was, it was business.
It wasn't personal.
Yes.
And, and, and, you know, it just shows you what a great actor,
Abe Vigoda was cause in real life, he was like a commotionally old Jew.
And he is so convincing and the Godfather.
And, and yeah, that, that line, uh, uh, tell Michael, it was business.
Oh, he's like a little aside for you, uh, Mark. When, when Abe passed away,
the family asked Gilbert to roast Abe at his service.
Oh, wow. That's great.
Which he did.
And the, uh, it got all over the place.
All the papers covered it. That's roasting.
He was a sweet man. We both got to know him a little bit.
Well, didn't he play, he played a lot of, uh, mob roles after that. I believe.
That's what he told me.
At the funeral, when they were wheeling the casket away, the Godfather theme came on.
Oh my gosh.
And it was just terrific.
The music that Robert Evans hated.
Yes, Nino Rocha, yuck.
That was such a, that every time you hear that music, I mean, you just think of the,
so many things that you, about the Godfather, that you just know where you are in that point in time when you hear that music come on.
Yeah.
And there was this yet yet another moment of Godfather 3 that he hated is when the guy
who's supposed to be Pacino's son or something takes out a guitar and he sings the Godfather
theme. It's in the music of the Godfather theme, but different words.
Wow.
Yeah. And it's so weird.
I don't think Mark's going to write a book about the third movie. I don't think that's
on his agenda. But the second episode that we ever did of this show,
Mark, and we're up to 400 of them, our second guest after Dick Cavett was Gianni Russo.
Wow.
And so there are different accounts too of how he got that part. He was really a non-actor. He had
something, some version of a variety show in Vegas.
In Las Vegas, right?
Yeah, but he wasn't an actor.
And he led us to believe that his relationship
with Frank Costello, and not just us,
he's led others to believe this, if I have this right,
was instrumental in getting him that part.
But in your book, you make it seem more like
he just chased the part and-
Yeah, I think it's a little bit of everything.
You know, this is another, one of the stories of the Godfather. I mean, you know, Johnny Russo has
given me so much of his time. When I first met him for the Vanity Fair story, he said, meet me at
St. Patrick's Cathedral. And that's where we did our interview. And I spent spent I think I spent a day with him. And he's just one of the great storytellers of all his
and, and what a life he's led, right? And, and, you know, the
story goes is that he made a tape of himself playing all all
three roles, I think, I think, Michael, Sonny and, and Carlo.
And what I mean, look at what he did with the role of Carlo.
I mean, you just believe him that he would sell out,
you know, in the scene of him and Sonny in that fight.
And one of my favorite scene is again, Richard Castellano,
where after Michael gives, you know, says,
okay, you're going to Las Vegas, you know, and he's sitting there
almost trembling and they give him those airline tickets and
he's like nodding his head, you know, and then they take him out
to the car and Castellano says that famous line, Hello, Carlo,
you know, and then the, the garrison begins.
It's just wonderful. It's just wonderful.
And that was back in the days
when Pacino could give a subtle performance. Yes. Well, that was the whole thing about his role.
And that was the thing that that they didn't know about in the beginning because he thought the whole
role was in the transition. You know that he had to start slow because he was a college boy,
you know, and he was a milit in the military. And, and then, you know, you see the gradual
transformation of him, when he gets punched by McCluskey. And then he tells Sonny, you know,
you get me a gun, you plant it somewhere, a bar, a restaurant, someplace where we can get it in.
I wish Gilbert would do that same.
Uh, and then I'll kill them both.
Then I'll kill them both.
You know,
well, Evans was calling him the runt.
He was so impressed, impressed.
And, and, and, and in a way, as you say, Pacino was contributing to being
underwhelming by underplaying.
Yeah.
But that was his whole brilliant,
the way that he wanted to play it.
But then, you know, he was short,
but as Al Ruddy said, when he saw him on Broadway,
he looked about seven feet tall.
So he was a great actor,
but he just hadn't been seen on the screen before.
And you know, that reminds me again,
watching the movie with my mother and her saying,
he acts with his eyes.
Yeah, that's right.
That's what I think was George Lucas's wife,
they said, cast Pacino as Michael,
it's all in his eyes and it is, I mean, he just.
I think she said something like he addresses you with his eyes. That's his eyes and it is. I mean, he just.
I think she said something like he addresses you.
That's right.
Exactly.
You got it right.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And speaking of the scene, since you brought it up
where Carlo fights the street brawl,
it's not much of a brawl.
It's really a beating between Carlo and Sonny.
Khan improvised one of the weapons,
the sawed off mop.
That's right. The mop handle. He tells the weapons, the, uh, the sawed off mop. That's right.
The mop handle.
He tells the prop master, he goes, you know, what are those, uh, sawed off mop
handles, give me a mop handle and saw it up.
And then he goes, what are you being, what are you going to do with that?
It's not in the script.
He goes, don't worry.
Just, uh, you know, and then he throws it.
And, uh, you know, that scene was, uh, that scene was pretty wild.
That couple uses the take where he misses him,
but according to your book,
he clipped him in the back of the head in one of the takes.
That's what Gianni said, yeah.
So, I mean, it was authentic.
Let's just say that for sure.
Gianni told us that Khan had it out for him,
that the actors, the real actors on set did not view him,
they viewed him as an interloper
because he said Khan broke two of his ribs.
And he told us he thinks it was intentional.
Oh my gosh, yeah.
Yeah, he tells the story about that they met the night
before in a club and that there was some kind
of an altercation or disagreement, let's say.
And I loved when Khan fights his hand.
Yes. That was a great, amazing. Yeah. That was an amazing touch.
I mean, Sonny Sonny, the character of Sonny was just now you, you asked me about Carmen
Karidi. That's right.
Yeah. Oh, I'm sorry. What about Carmen Cariti? I was able to interview
him for the Vanity Fair story back in 2008. And he was living in Los Angeles. And he told the story
that and you know, it was widely known he was cast as Sonny. But he hadn't signed the deal yet. But
he was told that he had the role.
And so he went out and he was in his old neighborhood and there was a parade and
he was celebrating and only to have at the last minute with Al Pacino cast as Michael.
Well, Carmen Cariti was so tall, it would have been, you know, improbable to have,
you know, such a tall man and such a, you know, he would tower over Al Pacino. And so they came
to the decision that let's cast James Cahn, who was being considered for Michael as Sonny. And
then we'll have, you know, Francis Coppola's first choice of Michael
to be Al Pacino. So they had to tell Carmen Caridi that he didn't get the job. And so,
you know, it was heartbroken, heartbreaking for him. And it was, you know, because he
was a fine actor. He was on Broadway, I think in Manila, Mancha at that time. And so he,
I'm sure he would have made a great son, a great sunny,
but he wasn't James con and John James con was, was an amazing sunny.
So who knows what would happen if those roles had been reversed.
And I, I remember in my early days at catcher rising star, Carmine
Corrini was just one of those guys.
Hanging out at the bar.
Oh, really? Wow.
Yeah. Yeah.
No, you know, he he was he was a great actor.
But who knows what would happen now?
You know, now he's gone.
So many of the great actors that were, you know, Al Martino is not here anymore.
Robert Evans is gone.
Oh, John Casale.
Ate Pagoda.
Yeah, Casale.
Richard Castellano.
Richard Castellano.
So anyway, so.
So many of them.
We will return to Gilbert Gottfried's
amazing colossal podcast,
but first a word from our sponsor.
Take back your free time with PC Express online
grocery delivery and pickup.
Score in-store promos, PC optimum points,
and more free time, and still get groceries.
Shop now at pcexpress.ca.
After decades of shaky hands caused by debilitating tremors,
Sunnybrook was the only hospital in Canada who could provide Andy with something special.
Three neurosurgeons, two scientists, one movement disorders coordinator,
58 answered questions, two focused ultrasound procedures,
one specially developed helmet, thousands of high intensity focused ultrasound waves,
zero incisions, and that very same day, two steady hands.
From innovation to action, Sunnybrook is special.
Learn more at sunnybrook.ca slash special.
Here's another question for you.
Mark Scoback, in Robert Evans' book, The Kid Stays in the Picture, he takes full credit
for making Coppola re-edit the film to make it longer.
Is that accurate and what was left out
of the original cut?
Well, of course.
Now that's one of the great battles in cinema.
You know, Coppola says he was told to make it shorter.
Evan says he was wanting to make it longer.
So, you know, you can read the telegrams between the two,
which were quite historic and one of the great battles.
So there are very big differing of opinions in that.
But Evans also wrote that he said, add more.
It's just like back and forth.
There are so many different opinions.
But this is probably the biggest one
between Coppola and Evans is who said,
I can't imagine Coppola wanting to make it shorter, for sure.
Can't imagine, can't imagine.
You also print in the book,
toward the end of the book,
one of the wonderful inclusions in the book
is these angry letters that they're firing off
at each other.
And did they make peace in the end? Yeah, well, Evans said that they're firing off at each other. And did they make peace in the end?
Yeah, well, Evan said that they did.
Evan said that on the 25th anniversary of the Godfather
held pointedly in San Francisco, not Los Angeles,
that Coppola came up to him and hugged him and said,
you must have done something right.
So yeah, I think they made peace at the end.
That's nice.
Also, I heard that scene at the end that goes between the christening and all the murders
wasn't Coppola and it was like an editor who said this would work much better.
I heard it was going to be a whole long christening scene and then the murders went right after.
Yeah, that's right. That was interesting. Yeah, I think where he kills all of his rivals all in one afternoon
where they're saying, you know,
Michael, do you renounce Satan and all of that.
So that was amazing.
And I believe the name escapes me of that great editor,
but it was a film editor who was quoted about that later.
Well, let me ask you about Evans because the book opens
with you visiting Robert Evans'
house and rather amusingly, you wind up lying in his bed.
That was so great.
So what happened was I go to Evans' home and it's 2008 and he was ready for me.
He had all the clippings covered the table. They let me in, his Butler let me in to the room and Robert
Emmons makes this grand entrance.
You know, he was known for making great entrances.
His hair is slicked back.
His smiles are dazzling white.
He's looking out through rose colored glasses.
And then he goes, let's go to bed.
And I went, what?
And he goes, his screening room had burned down.
And so he and his friends would watch movies in bed.
I went great.
Okay.
And so we go in and, um, he has a screen set up to show parts of the Godfather.
And so, you know, I lay, I, you know, sit on, I lay there and we're watching the
movie, we watched all these we're watching the movie,
we watched all these various scenes
and he's talking to me the whole time
and that's where he would watch movies.
And so it was just a wonderful experience.
He gave me so much that day as far as great quotes
and stories and memories.
And you know, he was just this amazing last, you know, they don't make Robert
Evans, which is this amazing. You can't even let sort of lions of the old studio system.
Exactly. I'm so blessed to have been able to speak with him. And at one point he took
a picture, a picture off the, off the shelf and showed it to you. And it's a bittersweet
moment or really a sad, not, not even bittersweet,
but just sad.
Exactly. He showed me a picture of him, of him at the Godfather premiere.
You can see the picture, uh, online where he, uh,
is dancing with his wife,
Allie McGraw and uh, you know, at the premiere and, uh,
and then, uh, you know, he says, little did he know that, you know, at the premiere and, and then, you know, he says, little did he know that,
you know, she was involved with Steve McQueen by then for the getaway.
And so it was a bittersweet moment for him to look back and talk about that.
Yeah.
And there's also a part in the book where you said Al Pacino and Diane Keaton went out to have dinner together and they were talking
about, well, it's over for both of us.
Yeah. What is this? What is this movie? What's going to happen to this movie? What is this
all about? You know? Yeah, because it's crazy. You know, I don't think anybody had an idea at the time
that they were making this classic movie that we'd
be talking about 50 years later.
Because it was so unlikely there was
all these miraculous forces, a series of miracles,
that this movie even came together.
And then to come together as it did with all of these ad libs and happenstance
and spur of the moment things that happened that just added to the magic of it.
It seems blessed in a way really because that's what you come away with when reading the book.
Every time you come to a fork in the road and something could go terribly wrong, it
goes right.
Coppola's instincts are pretty unerring.
Exactly, yeah.
The casting, the music, Gordon Willis,
all the choices that he made, everything that he fought for.
But still, there was so much luck.
So much luck, so much luck.
Puzo gets that great line.
Tell us about the, he's talking to the legendary Karl Cohen on the on the casino floor.
Oh, yeah. Yeah. And it involves the actor story that involves the fugitive actor David Jansen.
Yeah. So I was told by the PIP boss.
Sorry, I was told by a PIP boss in Las Vegas, Edward Walters, uh, that, uh, one
night, uh, David Jansen, uh, came into the sands and was a bit unruly and, uh,
Carl Cohen, uh, subdued him and, uh, they go, well, how'd you do it?
And he goes, I made him an offer.
He couldn't refuse.
Of course others.
And then others say that that line came from Mario Puzo's
mother, because Mario Puzo said a lot of the great lines he gave to Don Corleone
were first spoken by his Italian American mother.
I love that.
His mother who stole the police club.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I heard that Coppola, uh, at one point he was talking to Martin Scorsese and he, uh, Martin
Scorsese said his mother always loved Richard Conti and, and said he
should be in the movie.
Ah, yeah.
You know that?
I don't know.
That's a new one for me, but I can believe it.
I'll do.
I'll have to redo the, I, I'm gonna have to include that.
Mark, what is your personal relationship to this movie?
And it may be a difficult question to answer,
but you saw it as a college student way back in 1972,
50 years ago, incredible.
I know, yeah.
And you couldn't have imagined sitting in that theater
that it would become such a part of your career.
And let's point out to people that this,
your relationship and your work on this
did not begin with this book.
As you said, it began with a Vanity Fair article years ago,
and you did talk to all of the principal players.
Right.
What is your personal feeling about this film in terms of why it's so beloved and why it's
that kind of movie you cannot turn off when you stumble across it?
Yeah, well there's two things.
First, I'll tell you, I was a college freshman, 19 years old, on spring break, and I visited
my mom in Memphis, Tennessee, and I went into a theater, I always say as a kid,
and I came out three hours later as an adult.
I had seen a world that I had never experienced before
on film and it just like floored me.
And I think there's two reasons why it endures.
First of all, it's a period piece.
Coppola insisted that it be filmed as a period piece
in the 1940s setting as Mario Puzo had written it
in his novel.
And so that gives the film this timeless feel.
It's as fresh today as it was 50 years ago
because it was a period piece then.
So that gives it this patina that doesn't diminish with age.
And the other thing that makes it endure
is that it's a story not just about gangsters or criminals
and blood and gore and all of that, which is certainly about,
but it's also about family.
And the family aspect is what gives it its heart and soul.
And so I think those are the two things that make the Godfather
endure 50 years and forever.
Yeah. And that one, and if I may add one thing that you point out in the book,
that people feel a certain powerlessness
and this fantasy, this fulfillment fantasy of there's a man who could
Yes. There's a man that can take care, especially in the 1970s, you know, when the, when the
America was in upheaval, you know, Watergate was ahead and, you know, Vietnam War was,
was, was raging.
I mean, you know, the, or, or coming to a head and, and then there was a man that you
could go to who could take care of things, you
know, it's like the new American Western. That's what the film
scholar, a film scholar said, and that Puzo had created this
world. And it's like, you know, where they're gunslingers, but a
lot of times the people that they're
gunslinging against deserved what they got.
So you know, what's odd is like that scene I did at the beginning of the show where he
talks about his daughter getting bonus bonus Sarah.
And I, every time I watch that, I'm kind of waiting for the scene of them actually, uh,
catching up with those guys. Yeah. You know, that was written in the book, uh, in the novel,
there's quite a bit of that scene where they do catch up with them and they, and what happens.
Uh, but you know, I don't know if you needed it in the movie because you kind of can imagine what happened
without seeing it.
You know what's interesting, Mark?
I'm sure you've seen the Godfather saga
where they reassembled the longer version
and they put Coppola's cuts back in.
And there's the scene where Fabrizio's car blows up,
Michael gets revenge against the bodyguard
that betrayed him.
There's a more extensive scene at Jack Walz's house gets revenge against the bodyguard that betrayed him.
There's a more extensive scene at Jack Walz's house
where you see the girl, one of the actresses.
Yeah, I saw it, right, exactly.
Who he's getting strung out on heroin
and all of this crazy stuff.
And you come away thinking Coppola made the right decisions
the first time. I think so, I do too.
Cause it's so economical and it just has a movement and it just moves so fast.
Yeah.
We got to thank you for writing this book, my friend.
Thank you so much.
I really appreciate your kind words.
Tell us, give us some plugs.
I mean, where can people, you got a website?
Yeah, I have a website.
It's www.mark-seal.com. And you can, you know, I'm on Instagram and
social media. And of course you can buy the book on Amazon or Barnes and Noble.
Somebody needs to make a film, a documentary based on your book.
Thank you. Yes, I really appreciate that.
And I'm so glad you liked the book.
I loved it.
And Al Franza lead it up.
That just reminds me, Al Ruddy's car got shot up.
Yes, that's right.
It's also crazy.
And he took to wearing a disguise at one point, didn't he?
Yeah, that's right.
Al Ruddy's assistant, Betty McCarp,
I was able to interview her as well.
And she said they traded cars because they were getting
all these threats.
And so they thought they would trade cars.
And so she took Al Ruddy's sports car up to her home
on Mulholland one night.
And in the middle of the night, she heard gunshots
and went out the next morning and the windshield had been blasted out.
And in place of the windshield was a note saying somebody didn't want the movie made.
Insane. And then somebody makes that threatening call to Evans.
That's right. It was Sherry, a hotel where he craziness.
Yeah, absolute craziness.
I mean, you do make the case that the making of the film
is as dramatic as the film itself.
But how busy have you been today on this day
where it's the actual 50th anniversary of the first time?
Yeah, today's the big day.
Yeah, can you imagine?
Yeah, I've been pretty busy.
So today's the day.
50 years ago, right now, just about.
Those Dilemmos were coming up to the Lowes State Theater
in New York and depositing all these stars in the rain.
Yeah.
And that's when it all began.
And they thought they had a flop on their hands
because the audience didn't applaud.
That's right.
Once it was over after three hours,
it was just stunned silence.
Nobody said a word.
And Robert Evans wrote, you know, it's a bomb,
you know, but they later realized that it was people couldn't they were stunned speechless
and that people that experience. It went across around the world. People were stunned beyond
words by this movie. Thanks for telling your story. Thanks for, you know, we know today's been a crazy day for you.
Thanks for squeezing us in.
Thank you so much.
I really appreciate your time and great words.
And lastly, much bothering you, Pop.
I told you I could handle it.
I'll handle it.
I wanted this kind of life for you.
I always thought when it was your turn, you'd be the one to pull the strings.
Senator Corleone, Governor Corleone.
We'll get there, Pop.
We'll get there.
Written by the great Robert Towne.
That's great.
So this has been Gilbert Gottfried's amazing colossal podcast with my cohost, Frank Santo
Padre.
And we've been talking to the author of Watch Me Fuck Up the Ten, Leave the Gun, Take the
Canoli, the very talented Mark Seal.
And to all our listeners who love The Godfather,
you will love this book, Get It Post-Haste.
It's a wonderful ride.
Thank you, Mark.
Thank you, okay, thank you. The End You