Going West: True Crime - Ylenia Carrisi // 466
Episode Date: January 7, 2025In December of 1994, a 23-year-old Italian actress headed to New Orleans to explore the city and write a novel. But shortly after arriving, she mysteriously vanished without a trace after leaving a ho...tel. And suspiciously, in the days leading up to her disappearance, she had been staying with a much older man there; one whom she was reportedly afraid of, who she wrote in her diary had practiced voodoo. This is the story of Ylenia Carrisi. Â
Transcript
Discussion (0)
What is going on true crime fans? I'm your host T and I'm your host Daphne and you're listening to going west
Hello everybody. Hope you're having a great day. Today is a very exciting day.
We have some very exciting news.
Keith and I, Going West, are officially
a part of the Unwell Network.
We are so excited.
Unwell is amazing.
They have some seriously great shows
that I'm sure a lot of you are already listening to.
We are absolutely pumped to join this network of just so
many different creatives, so many
awesome people. It is going to be a blast and we're so excited for you guys and for us.
The show is still going to stay the same. We're still going to come out with episodes every
Tuesday and Friday covering the same types of cases that we always do. But now we have
this incredible team behind us. So Going West is here to stay.
Going West is officially unwell yes we are big
thank you for today's case to Michelle for recommending it this story is so
spooky it's very suspicious it's very unsettling takes place in beautiful
haunting New Orleans so make sure that you share this one yes and go check out
our socials for photos of this case. We're on Instagram at going west podcast and we're also on Facebook.
Indeed.
So without further ado.
All right, guys, this is episode four hundred and sixty six of going west.
So let's get into it. I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna be a man, I'm gonna In January of 1994, a 23-year-old Italian actress was in New Orleans exploring the city
ready to write a novel.
But shortly after arriving, she mysteriously vanished without a trace after leaving her
hotel.
And suspiciously, in the days leading up to her disappearance She had been staying with a much older man there one whom she was reportedly afraid of
Who she wrote in her diary had practiced voodoo
This is the story of Alenia Carisi was born on November 29th, 1970 in Rome, Italy as the first child born to
singing duo Romina Power and Albano Carisi, but he is better known professionally just
as Albano Carisi, but he is better known professionally just as Albano.
So coming from a show business family,
she enjoyed a very unique and nomadic upbringing.
And I actually want to talk about her parents and her grandparents really quick
because they have an interesting story in the entertainment business
and it just kind of gives us a better idea of who Alenia was and what her inspirations were.
So Alenia's mom, Romina, was born into stardom
in Los Angeles, California.
The daughter of Mexican-American actress Linda Christian
and renowned actor Tyrone Power.
Linda Christian, so Alenia's grandmother,
was actually the first ever Bond girl,
and Tyrone rose to prominence for his roles
in action films like Jesse James and The Mark of Zorro.
Alenia's mother Romina was raised between Los Angeles,
Mexico and boarding schools in Europe,
before settling in Rome with her mother after her father's passing at just 44 years old.
And it was there that she began to follow in her own parents' footsteps
and began auditioning for roles in Italian cinema,
as she had become a fluent speaker from a young age. By the time she was 18, she had starred in
about a dozen Italian films. Remember, this is Romina, Alenia's mother. So she was really
motivated and she pushed herself to find success in acting. At 15, she was already engaged to a Polish prince,
eight years her senior,
but the couple eventually broke off the engagement.
And it was on set that she met her future husband,
Albano Carisi, who also happened to be eight years older
than she was.
After starring in multiple films together,
the two married on July 26 26, 1970, when Romina
was 19 years old.
And four months later, they welcomed Alenia.
Over the next 17 years, they had three more children, Alenia's younger brother, Yari,
and two younger sisters named Christelle and Romina.
Like her mother, Alenia had a cultured
and eccentric childhood marked with travel
and artistic ventures.
And it was while Alenia was still a young girl
and Romina was only in her twenties,
that Romina and Albano's singing duo
really started taking off.
They were especially beloved in Europe and Central America
and even came to be known as the Sonny and Cher of Italy.
So to kind of give you like a comparison,
they were kind of like Sonny and Cher.
Yeah, they were a power singing duo.
Exactly, a married power singing duo.
So in 1976, they entered the Eurovision Songwriting Contest.
I know a lot of us know what that is
on behalf of course of Italy.
And they took seventh place, which
was pretty good considering 18 countries in total competed.
The family traveled all over the world together for Romina and Albano's music, but Alenia
was primarily raised between Italy, the United States, and Mexico, so very similar to her
mother.
Like her parents, Alenia had a flair for the dramatic and was featured in a few films as a child
Including champagne in Paradiso, starring alongside her parents who portrayed the leading couple
So they they did a lot of things together as a family. They were all super involved in entertainment and each other's lives
Traveling the world they had a lot of fun
and entertainment and each other's lives, traveling the world, they had a lot of fun.
Now, after completing high school,
Alenia worked as the letter turner on La Ruota,
oh my God, I knew I was gonna mess this up,
La Ruota della Fortuna,
which is the Italian version of Wheel of Fortune.
And there's a bunch of photos of her on the show
that we will post, she was a gorgeous blonde
with curly hair, she had an amazing smile.
Yeah, I mean she definitely fit in for that role, and I just think the industry in general, but despite her good looks,
she was very charming and soft-spoken, but also very intelligent and introspective. Like for example,
she was asked on one broadcast how she felt about the attention that she had got throughout her life, and she quoted Gandhi in response.
And even though she wanted to remain in the entertainment industry, she also had literary goals,
so Elenia was accepted to and enrolled in the University of London, where she studied literature
and received the highest grades in her year. But while she was there, she couldn't shake her desire
to continue to explore the world. Like, she loved learning in a classroom, but she also wanted to have more of a real life
experience.
Her parents acknowledged that she was an experienced and skilled traveler, but as she shared her
interest in traveling outside of England by herself at the age of 22, her parents were
a bit worried about her going out there by herself.
But still, really wanting to get out there into the world on her own, in 1993 she left
London bound for her native Italy, where she sold off most of her belongings to fund her
trip.
And though her family was affluent, a former friend remembered that Alenia always preferred
to have her own money and to pay her own way.
She was very independent and very self-sufficient that way.
Now before heading off on her solo adventure, she first joined her family for a holiday in
the United States, in beautiful New Orleans, Louisiana. Now, Alenia was charmed and enchanted
by the energy of the city. It's naturally just such a great place for artists like herself,
and she loved the free spirits that it attracted.
And it just really inspired her.
Like during the trip, she told her parents that she wanted to write a book about the
characters that she met there.
You know, musicians, street buskers, fortune tellers, as well as some of the more seedy
underbelly that she saw in New Orleans.
When her parents returned to Italy after their vacation, Alenia headed to Florida, taking
with her only a backpack and a notebook.
She then stopped in Mexico before finally settling in Belize just over the Mexican border.
She spent a few months there in the small coastal town of Hopkins, where she turned
23.
But the allure of New Orleans was really strong and she set her sights
on returning to complete the research for her book. The day after Christmas in
1993 she boarded a bus bound for New Orleans traveling up through Mexico and
unbeknownst to Elenia her brother Yari who was a bit saddened at the thought of
her spending the holidays alone, actually arrived in Hopkins,
in Belize, the day after she departed, because he actually didn't even know that she left.
Now, not knowing where she was staying or where she was, he circled the town, knocking
on doors, since Hopkins is, you know, a small coastal village, and asked passers-by if they
knew her or had seen her, but by the time he had pinned down
her whereabouts, it was too late and she was already headed to New Orleans.
Yeah, she kind of just went there without telling anybody.
She did tell people when she arrived there because she was super close with her family
and everybody knew where she was and what she was doing, especially because, you know,
she was alone.
Now, in her previous visit to New Orleans with her family that past summer, Elenia had surrounded
herself with local artists, musicians, and drifters, and she loved hearing the stories
of people who lived on the fringes of society.
This is what really interested her.
She kept very detailed notes of the people that she met, asking them for their life stories
and writing notes down with genuine intrigue.
She would camp out in Jackson Square, which is the iconic and historic park located right
there in the French Quarter, but she was also aware of the darker side of the city.
Every city has a darker side and had even admitted as much to her parents.
But here's the thing, when she
left New Orleans that previous summer, she actually admitted to her parents
that she was afraid of two men in particular there, that they were trying
to kill her and that drugs were involved. She also told her mother Romina about
her fascination with a musician named Alexander
and that she couldn't keep herself away from him.
Alexander Masichela was a street performer who played the cornet, which is a brass instrument
that is slightly shorter and wider than a trumpet.
When Elenia returned to New Orleans, she was just 23 years old as we know, to Alexander's 54 years, which
is actually older than both of her parents were at the time.
She met him in the summer of 1993 after staying behind following her family vacation and described
being entranced by him.
Around New Orleans, he was known for his charm and his influence with women which is really interesting to me because
Like he's a super long white beard. He looks older than he was even at the time at least in my opinion
I mean no judge well actually I'm gonna judge slightly judge slightly judge because he is kind of a piece of shit
Yeah, so true as we're gonna get into but I will post a photo on our socials
So you guys can see yeah, but I agree with you. He does not look 50. He looks like 70
Yeah, that's so true. He really does and also her mom Ramina was just as confused as we are calling it a strange
mysterious attraction, but she said that he had Alenia quote
hypnotized.
Romina later remembered, quote, in her diaries, I found notes of her mentioning his name and him saying,
Remember me, remember my name repeatedly to her.
And she couldn't get him out of her mind.
Alenia even wrote that she believed Alexander was trained in voodoo and mused that he had
cast a spell on her.
In one entry she described him as magic and said that he had annulled her will.
So yeah, it's kind of interesting that she's saying these things given, you know, what
most of us know about New Orleans, that it has kind of like this magical feeling to it, you know?
Yeah, I mean, especially with all the voodoo and we know that he has spent so much time here and
just what everybody said about how he entranced women and entranced Elenya and I could definitely
understand her fascination in him not even having met him. I you know, he's a musician. She's fascinated by these types of characters
He's a little bit older. So he has a lot of experience probably has a lot of really interesting stories
But it's so spooky to me that she wrote this that she thinks that he's magic
That he is trained in voodoo that he cast a spell on her
Especially with with what's to come, I just find it a little
eerie, a little spooky."
Yeah, it's nothing short of strange.
Now when Alenia left to travel to Florida after leaving New Orleans in the late summer
of 1993, she told her parents that she needed to get away from the city because her life
was at stake.
Though whether she meant from Alexander specifically or just from the city of
New Orleans and its inhabitants, you know, she didn't really specify here. Romina didn't press
her daughter on the issue either because she didn't think that Elenia would return to New Orleans
and that everything would be fine. But it is really, I mean this is super foreshadowing
obviously, but the fact that she's saying that she needed to get away from the city,
she was afraid from- for her life. She also previously told her mom that two men were trying to kill her.
Now we have this other character, Alexander, thrown into the mix who is apparently trained in voodoo. Like, it seemed like she kind of encountered a lot of dark things and people the first time that she was there.
Yeah, and this is exactly why Romina was shocked to learn that Alenia had gone back to New Orleans in December of 1993,
after leaving so abruptly and after feeling threatened.
But Alenia assured her that she was fine.
Romina confirmed that her daughter had enough money, and Alenia confirmed that she had plenty of travelers checks.
So she'd be good during the remainder of her travels as she finished up her research for her book.
Romina and Albano last spoke with their daughter on New Year's Day, January 1st, 1994, and
claimed that she didn't seem fearful or vulnerable.
The only thing she mentioned that was even slightly unusual was that she was moving to
a different hotel, though she didn't explain why.
But we do know which hotel she did migrate to.
That day she moved herself and her belongings into the LaDale Hotel, which is a budget hotel located at 749 St. Charles Avenue,
just blocks from the bustling tourist area of the French Quarter.
And this hotel was located in the Warehouse District.
Now that hotel is just an empty lot, but at the time it was a popular boarding house for
the city's artists and musicians, known for its low cost, which ran its guests only
about $20 a night.
So Alenia checked in on New Year's Day, the last day her parents spoke to her. But, she was not alone.
She was sharing a room with Alexander Masichala.
The New Orleans Police Department admitted that Alexander had a history of sexual violence against women,
as well as drug use.
And Cindy Dale, who was the owner of the LaDale Hotel, later remembered quote,
he didn't seem clean. He dressed in jeans and maybe the same shirt for two or three
days. He smelled. It was just odd that they were together because he's about 60
years old and she's this real pretty 23 year old girl. I mean, she walked with her
head down, her hair in front of her face, and she only spoke when
spoken to.
But the strange thing about this is that her parents later said that this description of
their daughter confused and scared them, because this did not sound like the Elenya that they
knew.
Well, after their discussion on the phone on New Year's Day, her parents, who were
used to hearing from her at least once a week, like I said she did, keep them frequently updated on her travels, began to worry when she was not checking in.
The days continued to pass with no word from her and they were unable to reach her, so
their concerns just multiplied.
Romina and Albano checked in with a family friend of theirs who lived in New Orleans,
but even this local couldn't track her down.
Thus, Alenia's family friend reported her missing on January 18, 1994, so 17 days after
her parents had last spoken to her and after she checked into the LaDale Hotel with Alexander. But she had last been seen by others
five days after that day,
five days after the first on January 6th, 1994.
When New Orleans police arrived to speak with Cindy Dale,
she informed them that Alenia had checked out
of the LaDale Hotel on Thursday, January 6th,
just after noon, like she had just walked
out of the lobby and vanished.
Her parents rushed to the city to aid in the search efforts, setting up their headquarters
in a hotel only a few blocks away from where she went missing.
According to Cindy, again she's the owner of this hotel, Alenia was there for almost
a week and kept the same schedule every single day, leaving at the same time each morning
and returning around 6pm.
But Cindy said that it was not clear where she was going or what she was doing during
the day. The last confirmed sighting of her was between 1230 and 1
30 p.m. on January 6th when she checked out of the LaDale Hotel. However,
Alexander remained in the room during this time so she would leave for most of
the daylight hours every single day almost like she was going to work and
Alexander just stayed in the hotel the whole time.
And Cindy remembered this distinctly
because she was eventually forced
to kick him out of the hotel.
And suspiciously, in the days after
Alania's departure from the hotel,
Alexander was attempting to cash
her unsigned travelers checks.
Now Cindy, who had already been suspicious of this guy, said, quote,
I was told that he was a street musician.
Where is this man getting 50 and 100 dollar bills of travelers checks?
Well, we certainly know, of course, that Alania had travelers checks
because this is what she told her parents she was using during this trip.
Exactly.
Well, out of retaliation for her suspicion, he accused her employees of stealing the checks,
which had ultimately been stolen from Alenia in the first place.
He then attempted to pay his unsettled bill with her Travelers' Checks, so he's not even
sticking to his story, because here he
is using those checks.
Cindy kicked him out of the hotel on January 14th, so eight days after Elenya was last
seen, though she did agree to hold onto some items that he had in his room.
And then, two weeks later, police reported to the hotel to inquire about Elenia's disappearance,
and Cindy allowed police to sift through the items being stored in the basement of the
hotel.
Well, Cindy explained, quote, I took them down into our storage, and they opened up
the bags, and sure enough, I recognized that they were clothes that she wore, and her books,
and her paints. In addition to Elenia's books, clothing, and art supplies,
Elenia had also left her passport, backpack, camera, and all of her luggage behind,
as well as $2,500 in uncashed travelers checks,
which she obviously would have never done willingly.
Yeah, I mean, that was everything she had with her.
So this definitely was a startling realization
to say the least because if Eleni was planning
on continuing her research and her lifestyle
as a roaming artist, she would have needed
like at least a good number of these items.
Desperate for any information that would point them
in the right direction, her parents even sought
the help of a psychic and set out to speak with others who knew Alexander.
But he proclaimed his innocence from the start and was very little help to the investigation,
positioning himself as an innocent bystander in the international frenzy of Elenya's disappearance.
He told the press, quote, all of a sudden, I'm the Simon Legree in all of this, and it's not justified.
So he's basically referencing the villain in Uncle Tom's cabin,
inferring that the cause of his criminal prosecution was undue racism because he was a black man.
Well, he also attempted to kind of distance himself from Alenia and, like, whatever relationship the two shared,
because he told the New Orleans Police Department that he and Alenia were like whatever relationship the two shared because he told the New Orleans police department
that he and Alenia were not romantically involved.
And he even added that Alenia refused to sleep with him
and that she had requested two beds upon check-in.
Also, if she's refusing to sleep with you,
that means you're probably trying to sleep with her.
So I think that actually ends up making him look worse.
Yeah, like telling us a little bit more about that. Like how would you know that she didn't
want to sleep with you if you hadn't tried to sleep with her? Right. And also he said
that she saw him as a guru and not a sexual or romantic partner, but it's like, okay,
and how did you see her? Yeah okay, and how did you see her?
Yeah, exactly.
How did you see her?
Well, when police questioned him about Alenia's whereabouts,
he claimed that he didn't know where she was,
but that he knew she was okay.
Okay, how do you know that?
Yeah, and he didn't explain how he knew that she was okay.
Much to Alexander's dismay,
investigators were able to hold him on an unrelated charge in hopes of gleaning more information about him.
Because,
shortly before Elania's disappearance, an ex-girlfriend of Alexander's alleged that he had raped her.
So for this, he was arrested and held on a
$50,000 bond. So that is really disturbing that that happened right before she went missing.
Police already said that they knew he was a sexually violent man.
This is just not looking good.
Romina and Albano remained convinced that their daughter was being held captive
in the city somewhere and that maybe drugs or trafficking were involved.
Romina said, quote, she is somewhere in this city. I'm positive.
I just have this feeling.
I can't explain why.
I just have a feeling.
The secret is with this Alexander.
If he were to only confess.
In a telephone interview that Alexander granted with the local press during his time behind bars,
he explained that this was a bogus charge, the rape charge, adding,
quote, after cooperating with them and even meeting the father,
I decided the whole thing had become crazier and crazier and made myself unavailable to them.
And so I guess they wanted to keep their hands on me.
He continued on to say that the rape charge was far beyond my nature.
And unfortunately, the charges were later dropped.
Alexander was released and was never officially connected to Elania's disappearance. For weeks, Alenia's parents and her brother Yari combed the streets, and they put up missing
posters asking around for her, and injecting themselves into the social circles that they
believed she would run in.
Yari said, quote, Where could she be in a city like this?
There's lots of little pathways, lots of doorways,
lots of cars going in and out of the city. She could be stuck in a cellar.
She could be in a wonderful place. The New Orleans Police Department were
pretty quick to say that they had no sign or indication that the disappearance was the result
of foul play, but that was only because there was no crime scene. I mean, she just vanished.
And then they declined to state that they had no evidence to the contrary either, meaning
that they had absolutely nothing.
Her father Albano begged the FBI to get involved, and though they initially declined, they eventually
joined forces with the police.
An anonymous donor in Italy actually pledged $500,000 for information, making a massive
reward here for any information leading to her whereabouts, but that reward went unclaimed.
When asked if he had a message for his daughter, Albano said quote, she knows the message.
Now there is one possible sighting on the last day that
Elenia was seen and I want to give you guys the details because it is a little
bit strange. I don't know how much stock I put into it but basically on the
evening of Thursday January 6 1994 so the same day that she was last seen
publicly checking out of the Liddell, a possible sighting of her was reported.
Now, a security guard named Albert Cordova claimed that he believed that he had seen
Alenia, or a woman who looked like her, enter the Mississippi River that night, and that
she had never resurfaced.
Around 1130 PM, Albert, who worked as a security guard for what is now the aquarium that's
situated along the river, spotted a woman perched along the water.
When he approached her, she allegedly said to him, quote, I belong in the water, or I
belong in the water anyway, and then leapt from the banks into the river.
Though he apparently pleaded with her to come back to the shore, she ignored him as he watched her backstroke towards the center of the river. Though he apparently pleaded with her to come back to the shore, she ignored him as he watched
her backstroke towards the center of the river, about a hundred yards out.
But he says that she struggled against the pressure of the current, as well as the wake
of a passing boat, and began to panic and scream.
Albert said that she emerged from beneath the waves once or twice before getting pulled down, and that she did not re-emerge.
By Albert's recollection, quote,
screaming for help. Then she went down once, twice, and after the third time, she didn't come back up. He immediately reported the incident to the Coast Guard, but they were
never able to recover a body. The vicinity of where the woman entered the river was searched,
as well as a 90 mile or 144 kilometer stretch of the Mississippi, reaching almost all the
way down to the Gulf of Mexico.
But despite their efforts, there was no sign of her, though it's possible that her body
was swept out to the sea with the strong current.
It wasn't until weeks later that he learned of Elenya's disappearance and connected her
to the young woman that he had seen that night.
However, it was a winter night on the water and Albert admitted that he couldn't be sure that the woman he had
seen was Elenia, saying quote, based on the photographs the police showed me I'd
say it wasn't her, but it could have been. I don't know for sure. It was dark.
Yeah, I don't know. I have a hard time believing it was her. If even he is
saying he really didn't think so. Like like we've heard so many cases where sightings were
Believed to have been made and then it it turns out that when they were made the victim was already dead and nobody knew it yet
So I don't know
I always have a hard time really believing sightings unless there is like video evidence of the person or if the person who is
witnessing them actually knew the victim like it's definitely a weird thing for this guy to allegedly see, but who knows?
I mean, yeah, at the very least, this guy just watched a woman drown,
whether it was Elania or not, very weird thing to witness.
It's just weird that they didn't find a body, which I'm gonna get into in a second.
I do want to say, in the Mississippi in general, there are known to sometimes be bull sharks, which as many of us know are
incredibly vicious sharks. And then there's also like alligators, but it's not like those two
predators are known to like really frequent this part of the river, but there are still predators in the river.
But like after hearing this report,
the Coast Guard and the New Orleans Police Department
spent a day and a half dragging the river,
but they found no sign of Alenia or her belongings
or anybody else.
A spokesman for the New Orleans Police Department,
a guy named Sam Friedidella said, quote,
That's a mean current and undertow. We haven't found a body and we're continuing to treat it as a missing persons investigation.
In part because the security guard gave us a tentative identification.
So we can't be sure beyond a doubt that it was Miss Carisi.
Albert's story was never
that it was Miss Carisi.
Albert's story was never substantiated. Like there was never any known proof
that this happened to anybody.
And the woman who jumped into the river supposedly
was never confirmed to be Elenya or anybody else.
Both of Elenya's parents maintained
that she was not suicidal and that she was a strong swimmer,
but that she had seemed afraid of the Mississippi
when they visited together.
Like she didn't show any interest in swimming in it or being near it particularly at all.
But Romina disputed this sighting from the beginning anyway, saying that she had a feeling
that the woman in the river or the supposed woman in the river that night was not Elenia.
The day after this potential drowning, there was another strange sighting of a young woman
who happened to speak Italian.
Basically, a fisherman visiting New Orleans from Croatia made a comment about Elenia's
or a different woman's ethereal beauty, and this woman responded in fluent Italian.
Romina explained, quote, He bumped into the girl in the street
"'and turned around and looked at her really close.
"'When he saw photographs of Alenia in the paper,
"'he identified her as the same girl.'"
And I mean, this isn't too strange.
Like, it's not like you saw anything bad happening.
This guy's basically saying,
oh yeah, the day after anybody else saw her,
I saw her in New Orleans and I thought
she was really pretty.
So yeah, I don't know.
That's not really too strange.
If it was her, it definitely could have happened the day after she was last seen and then something
happened to her after that.
Or maybe this woman was not her.
I think Albert's sighting saying, oh yeah, I saw this woman go into the river and drown.
Right.
That's like, oh shit, maybe we should look into that. But this this is like I saw a woman that looked like her and I thought she was pretty
Yeah, yeah exactly. It's it's a little less far-fetched. It's like okay
I saw a girl who speaks fluent Italian it looked like Elenia. Yeah, exactly
Okay, and obviously it is important to the timeline to know if this was her or not because if it was her
Then we would know that she was alive and in New Orleans on the 7th.
But you know, this guy also didn't know her, so was it her?
Was it not her?
To be honest, I really don't think that it was her.
I mean, it could have been, but I just don't think so.
Well, the Italian consulate in New Orleans was also involved in the search, but seemed
to back off the case after the news of the young woman who drowned came out, letting the locals deal with the matter. But
sadly, the New Orleans Police Department also seemed to be leaning towards
closing the case because there was just no evidence of a crime.
And I wonder if they looked at her and knew that she wasn't from there anyway.
They knew that she was a traveler and maybe they just assumed that since
there was no crime scene that she must be out there somehow
Which really is a shame knowing how close she was with her family and how much she
kept her loved ones in the loop of her travels and the fact that she had left
Everything in her hotel room the the person that she was staying with at the time was a known sexual predator
Who was way older than her and she
had previously told her mom that she was afraid of that very man, that he had this weird power
over her and there were these other two guys that apparently were out to kill her.
This is all just so weird and it doesn't feel like they're taking it very seriously based
on what we know.
Yeah, I mean, honestly, it's super disappointing because they really just kind of gave up here like even for Britsio Matzah
The Italian council general in New Orleans told the press quote. It's all over apparently
He added that Romina and Albano were just about the only two people who were keeping up hope that Elenia was still alive
Hoping that they could still find her but eventually her parents were forced to leave New Orleans empty-handed.
They even took the year off of touring and performing to be available to search for her,
but it didn't help lead them back to Elenia.
In 1996, over a year after Elenia vanished, an anonymous caller reported that Elenia was
still alive, and this caller apparently could not divulge her whereabouts
or any of the details about her safety.
And this caller was actually never identified and the tip was never even connected back to Elenia Carisi.
And years passed with no developments.
In 1999, Romina and Albano separated because it seemed like their relationship just really understandably
buckled under the weight of their grief.
Romina said sadly, quote,
When I see her face, I think she looks absolutely beautiful.
And if this story has a happy ending, it would make a very good script.
I feel it will have a happy ending and soon, I hope.
It seems like a film. It seems like a movie, it's very strange, because we've always
been like the protagonists of a happy story, and all of a sudden we're the protagonists
of a mystery story.
Albano agreed that the years that followed Alenia's disappearance were the worst of
his life, saying, quote, It was terrible. I thought God had abandoned me.
And with the real pain, a voice grew that said,
Albano, end it all.
But then I realized the devil was speaking to me, and I felt the presence of God, a deep
peace.
After 42 years of marriage, Romina and Albano officially divorced in 2012.
Some believe it's possible that Elenia is still alive somewhere and that she was either
detained or decided to live a life off the grid away from her family.
But this is really just based on her interest in traveling and nothing else.
Yeah, there's nothing really there to support that theory.
Yeah, she never expressed any interest in getting away from
her family or off the grid or away from society. You know, it's been 30 years. So the fact that
she hasn't said anything to her family is very concerning. In January of 2013, so 19 years since
she had last been seen, her father Albano filed a request to have his daughter declared legally dead,
and she was officially declared deceased in December of 2014.
Alenia would now be 54 years old. Alenia Carisi stood at 5'7'' tall and weighed
about 120 pounds. She had blonde hair and green eyes, and was last seen wearing a white jacket and a floral print dress.
If you have any information about the disappearance of Alenia Carisi,
please call the New Orleans Police Department at 504-658-5315. Thank you so much everybody for listening to this episode of Going West.
Yes, thank you guys so much and thank you Michelle for suggesting this case.
There are a lot of photos connected to this case of Albano, Ramina, Elenia, and also Alexander. So make sure
you head on over to our socials, go give us a follow, go check those out. We're on Instagram
at going west podcast, and we're also on Facebook. Yes, and let us know what you guys think of this
story. I mean, this is such a spooky story to me, the fact that there has never been any sight of
her, you know, no remains connecting to her have been found.
All the stuff that was left behind at the hotel that belongs to Elenia.
Yeah, it's just such a suspicious and odd story to me.
And to this day, her family still does not have concrete answers.
So please, please, please make sure that you share this story, share her photo on our socials,
check it out.
Thank you guys so much and we will see you on Friday for a wild case.
Get ready for this one.
All right guys, so for everybody out there in the world,
don't be a stranger. So Thanks for watching! you