Don Lemon’s Arrest and ‘Melania’ a Box Office Hit? Plus, Howard Bryant on the Erasure of Paul Robeson
00:00Yo, yo, yo, thought warriors.What is up?How I'm Learning is on.Is Ivan Lathin Jr.And it's me, Rachel and Lindsay.Look at this.Look at what you got going on.Oh, yeah.
00:18You know, I switch it up every now and then.Switch it up?I miss the braids, though.I miss the braids, but I have to take a break.I feel like it's my look.Oh, the braids are your look.Like, if I had to pick my favorite hairstyleor what I think I rock the best,
00:32it's the braids.I think they're a vibe.I think people are going to like this.Yeah.Yeah.Why?Principal Rach.Is that, is how what it's giving?
00:40It's giving business.Like, Rach, you sit down.Okay.I'll tell you guys something.All right.I think we can make this loan work.But I'm telling you right now, this next six months is going to be really important for you guys to keep up on your financials, get a couple of these things going on.The husband's looking like, I like this.
01:02The wife is like, we need to find another loan officer.I kind of like that for me nowI kind of like thatI usually do a bob around Super BowlYou know Super Bowl's coming upWe're just gonna rock it for a little bitI'll be in the braids againAre you traveling to the San Francisco City this week?
01:22YeahWhen are you leaving? ThursdayAfter higher learningAfter higher learning you travel up thereYou take a plane or you're gonna drive?Playing, playing, playing, plane, plane, planeSome people like to drive, I don't knowIt's always a girls weekend's fine
01:32I'm hosting a panelI'm not hosting, but I'm sitting on a panel with female quotient.So I'm doing that.It's like a brand.You know a quotient?Yeah, you've never heard of a female quotient?Never heard of them.Doesn't support the ladies.
01:47But anyways, female quotient is all about highlighting like women in business, particularlyrelated to sports.They're at major sporting events.They highlight people in community.It's all about, like, that's what I'm speaking on is about community and creators incommunity and how it's connected to business and sports and all of that.Very much, very much, very much, very much, very much needed conversation.Just to let you guys know something, okay, substack is going crazy.
02:14All right?Right now, I am live on the substack in the chat and people are talking to me about whatthey want us to talk about on the show.So if you guys, I'm going to be doing this every podcast.Oh, Lord.So if you join the substack, you join my page on the substack.I will be doing, only on a substack,I'll be doing live back and forth
02:38with you guys,telling you guys what we're talking about,and then maybe if you want me to ask rate somethingor guess something, I'll ask them.Top of the podcast before we get into it.You have to pay for your subset?No, it's free.For how long?
02:51I don't know, we'll see.You should eventually.We'll see what happens.Especially if you're doing all this live chat back and forth.Black History Month, you're into it.We're into it.We're having Howard Bryant on the show today to talk about two guys that are very important.His book, Kings and Ponds.
03:09Kings and Pons.Jackie Robinson and one of my father's favorite people ever, Paul Robeson.We also have Matthew Bellany from the town podcast, star of the Amazon show, the studio.Okay, if you ever seen that.Apple.Apple.Is it Amazon or Apple?Apple.
03:29Okay, leaving in.It's Apple.Okay.I watch.it, Matt's in it. Matt,if you guys don't know, works with us hereat the ringer. He's tall.It looks like a fucking giant.
03:40I've never seen him in person. You never seen him in person?Oh, big guy.Looks like a fucking giant ensued like he'sready to fucking crush Seth, Rogan.The playoffs are here, and you canpredict the action all the way to the finalswith Fandul Predict. Predict the spread, total points,and even the game winner.
03:57Sign up and get a $25 bonus.Offered by Fandul Prediction Markets LLC,registered futures commission merchant.18 plus.Bonus is non-withdrawable and expires seven days after receipt.Trading derivatives involve significant risk and may not be suitable for all investors.Manage your activity with our consumer protection tool.Restrictions apply.
04:13See terms at Fandul.com slash predict slash bonus dash offer dash terms.For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms, every choice matters.Tramphia offers self-injection or intravenous infusion from the start.Tramphia is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein every four weeks,followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks.If your doctor decides that you can self-inject trumphia, proper training is required.Tremfaya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's diseaseand adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis.
04:52Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections, or lower ability to fight them,and liver problems may occur.Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis.Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine.Explore what's possible.Ask your doctor about Tramphia today.Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit Tramphiara Radio.com.Grammy Awards.
05:20Don't want to spend too much time on it.But they were last night in L.A.Anything interesting happened for you?I mean, the DeAngelo, Roberta Flack, Angie Stone tribute, I mean, the countless number of artists on stage, legends on stage from Shaka Khan.I mean, they had so many people on stage that came out to sing particular songs to those three artists.Really, it was Roberta Flack and DeAngelo, but of course they honored Angie Stone in the back.They had so many people on stage that Anthony Hamilton was singing background the whole time.Like that's how many artists just came out to honor these artists who were so influential to them, to us, to community, to culture.
06:07It was, it was amazing.And it was led by Lauren Hill, who hadn't taken, I didn't realize this, hadn't been on the Grammy stage since 1999.Yeah.But when there's a call to arms.Yeah.Lauren's going to, you know, show up, be there.those performers are just incredibly important.And shout out to Anthony Hamilton.
06:28Anthony Hamilton is a cultural staple.No, for sure.But my point and looked amazing on stage,but that's how big the star power wasthat there were so many people coming.He was like, I'm going to be a part of this.He was like right there front and center singing background.Yeah, yeah, yeah.
06:43Using that once in a generation voice.You've been to an Anthony Hamilton show?He is an incredible performer.Great show.easy.Politicalsort of expressions at the Grammys.Did you expect that?
07:00Yeah.Yeah.Because the music industryis way less pussythan Hollywood.Keep going.Hollywood, the actors and all of that,they
07:14really need the studiosand really needthe infrastructure of the studiosto be superstars.You don't think that music needs that?They do.They do need it.It is different, though.
07:30Okay.It's different in that music is something that you go into a studio and you perform.Now, don't get me wrong, you need radio.If you're going to be a superstar, you need radio.Yeah, you got the machine behind you for me.You need management.You need Spotify.You need all of that stuff, right?
07:49But it's between you and the audience what you're doing.boom so a lot of timesas far as protest is concernedas far as sticking up is concernedthe musician to mehas a little bit morecajonesokay or a little bit more
08:09fat labiaall right because I don't just want to make it aboutI don't want to make itfat labia is your comparison to big ballsI sit for that for a secondI just came up with that off theof my head, but I don't want to just make it about big balls.Don't do it again.
08:28But, okay, what's the right thing to say then?Because it's big balls is very heteronormative about, because big balls, but I want to,I want to give a shout out to the strength of the vagina as well.Like, what is it?Fat labia, big clit energy.It was, I don't know, man.I'm trying to be, you know what?I'm just going to stick with toxic.
08:51There's something.Because every time I try to get out of the realm.Because people say, Van, don't say that something is pussy because vaginas are actually very tough.Yes.Facts.Okay.But then I try to come back and say, hey, it takes balls to say this.And then I say it takes fat labia.
09:09Well, I don't think that's it.I commend you.I commend you for trying to find something equivalent for women.But I don't think it's fat labia.Okay.Can I get, are you going to help maybe?I'm thinking of it because what I don't want to do is make the mistake of.saying fat labia. Okay, Jade,
09:26is there, isJade, in this situationis somebody going to helpme as I try to evolveor is it just going to be aboutlet's kick van and fat labia? Maybe the problemis that there is no equivalent term.We'll come up with
09:42one and we'll think about it.It's not that, but thank you fortrying. I appreciateI appreciate the acknowledgement from my sistersin the room. Let me give you your creditfor trying to do that. I'msaying this, I'm not saying that Hollywoodis completely
09:58cowardly when it comes to thesethings. I'm saying that the musicindustry is essentiallyso I can distill this,they have to act like rebels.They have to be rebels. When you seea lot of times, they have to act like rebelsand be rebels. So when they
10:14actually have something to say, they say, nowincreasingly, a lot ofthese fucking rappers and other people aren'tsaying this stuff. Increasingly, they're not doingit. But you see, KalaniYou see a lot of other people up there.That energy, that direct confrontational energy is what I'm talking about.And it bothered Tommy Laren.
10:33So I appreciate that they got under her skin.Oh, it bothered her.It bothered Donald Trump.It bothered a lot of people.And you add the musicians getting on stage and using their platform to protest and say,ice out or fuck ice.And then Bad Bunny wins album of the year.an entirely
10:55everything is in Spanishon the albumjust even more adds tothe dismay of the trumpsthe MAGAthat whole administrationbut to your pointabout music
11:07I think that there ismusician becauseI think it like historicallywhen you think of musicand you think of songsthey've been usedto protestthey've been used
11:18to further a certain messagelike all the way backeven when you thinkof like old Negrospirituals, like there's a message behind it.There's a, you know, like, it's usedin furtherance of something. Whereasyou don't necessarily see that as much
11:32in movies or televisionor whatever. Unless it's like a documentary. So I'm not sayingit doesn't exist. I'm just saying with music,it's there. Yeah.I think,I'm trying to say, it's a lot of movies about a lot of important shit.Of course, of course, of course. A lot of actors have been at the forefrontand all that stuff like that. We talk about guys like
11:51you know, Harry Belafonte, who was also.singer as well and all that stuff like that.A lot of actors have always been at the floor for these movies.However, there is a thought that in music, and I hope that people, you know, contemporaryperformers understand this, that if your music does not at some point address social issuesor something that is more substantive than just making people dance, then it's not usefulin the long term, long run.it's not enduring, like, in the long-term, long run.
12:27Like, and so I think a lot of people, and, like, love can be that,and the human connection can be that.But I think when people listen to songs by serious people,they want to hear commentary on what's going on in the world.Yeah.It's like almost proof of concept of your talent that you can do something morethan just make somebody dance in the club.You can address something that's a little bit more substantive.
12:51Yeah, because where does the motivation come from,for what you're writing about.Like, you're writing about what you're feeling,what you're seeing, what you're, like,that's why music has a, as a way to hit youin a way that maybe watching somethingor reading something doesn't,because it connects to an emotion to a feeling.
13:08Did you see that the Ricky Jervas quotewas going around, this go around for Grammys?Even though it's a Golden Globes.Oh, where he was like, just get on the stage and take your-your-Yeah, he was like the stage isn'tfor your political speech, just get on, thank your agent,you know, whoever you believe in and get off,basically saying, like, there's no reason for you to do that.
13:26And I think the Grammy showed exactly why you do do that.I think that what they did was powerful.I think it's wrong to dismiss, kind of similar to what we were talking about last time.It's wrong to dis, if you have a platform and you believe you should use it for purpose,then why would you take that away from someone?I think that what we saw on the stage with people speaking out against the administration specifically,you had some people take theroute of saying
13:54you know like we can't hateit needs to be with love but we arehuman beings we are people you had peopleconnecting personal storiesmy parent was an immigrant my grandparentwas like that's that's powerfullike it madeimmigration policy
14:10talk what the administration's doingconversational I felt likebecause it was so big it wasn't just a penthat said ice outit was personal what was happeningon that stage.And so, you know, to all the people sharing that around, like.Sharing what around?
14:25The Riga Jerva's Day?Yeah.Like, I just.So there's a conversation about hypocrisy and a conversation about action that sometimesis difficult to have, right?Sure.Sometimes it's difficult to have.And the reason why the conversation is difficult to have is because of an end.
14:52expectation of purity when it relates to these issues.See, there's a cowardice in there.And the cowardice is from people who in some way want to find reasons to keep the party going.So what they say is unless you are the complete right spokesperson for something at the time,unless there's no flies on your rep, unless you are the, unless you are the, the,right messenger for this, then you shouldn't speak about it. What that's really saying is that no one should.Right. Because the expectation of purity that a lot of people have for people, you just can't meet that. You can't meet that expectation.So the problem with saying, hey, you work for Amazon or hey, you work for Disney or hey, you work, so you shouldn't say these things is dumb. It's stupid. It doesn't make any sense.
15:51because we all work for someoneand in who we work foris the trap of the American game.That's the trap.The trap is, hey, you can't really talk about thisbecause you got to come in to work and punch the clock.And we need you to be a good cog in the wheel.So fuck all of that other stuff.
16:11Just do what we ask.There's no pure spokesperson.There's no person that you can't investigatewho they are or where they've beenand you're not going to find somethingthat you don't like. The purest activist person in the world that is doing it at the grassrootsin the community has somebody that doesn't like them. I remember at 2018, I go to Baton Rouge.I'm not going to mention no names. I hear somebody talk. I go, that person is going to be a star.
16:38Let me get closer to that person. I think that this person is fantastic. Immediately, I startedhearing shit from people that they don't like about him. Immediately, about times that he's been too bombastic,about times of these raises,voice, all of that stuff.Some of it true.But the reality is thatthat doesn't matter.What matters is
16:58who's brave enoughand willing enoughto fucking go out thereand put themselves on the line.So sometimes it's performativeand you have to call that out.Talk about that.Of course.
17:09Sometimes it's performative,but most of the time what?Did you see it performative last night?What?You thought something was performative?No, I think sometimes it is performative.There are people out therethat are using
17:20causes that are meaningful to your lifeas part of their celebrity portfolio.I agree.There are people that are doing that.Yeah.But that's where you get to be a person.That's where you have to have a hit on your shouldersand really discuss and talk about
17:39what type of protests and action is meaningful to you.Everybody has different jobs.All right.Don Lemon is out.Okay.Yes, he is.And so are the other journalist.And so are the other journalists.
17:51Don Lemon and Georgia Fort.Georgia Fort.Shout out to you, sister.That's also a great name to be remembered in history.Georgia Fort.She's a fort.We're going to talk more about this.Hold on for a second.
18:03Let's see if Don will pick the phone up.Let's see if I can get Don Lemon,Vanguard of the Revolution,to answer the phone.Let's see if he'll pick up.He's probably getting calls from all kinds of people right now.Let's see.Don Lemon.
18:19I hope he sends you straight.rates of voicemail.Why?Because it would just be funny.Let's see.Don Lemon.Atlanta number.Oh, right to it.
18:29Right to it.Write to voicemail.Don!Hold on.Let's see if Don Lemon will answer the phone.Let's see.Don Lemon, one more time.We're going to try to break through the do not disturb.
18:40Don said fuck you.Hey, I'm telling you guys something right now.The arrest of Don Lemon and the persecution ofjournalists in this country.They're not even cloaking it anymore, guys.It's here.It's not, fascism is not around the corner.Yeah.
18:59You guys are living in the fascist nation.And maybe you were before.Maybe they were so good at cloaking it and hiding it that you didn't even realizeyou were.Maybe other people care about the illusion of freedom and stuff like that.So they're able to kind of negotiate that a little bit better in the ways that they movearound. They're able to give a little here, do a little here, but maybe there is a politicalmovement right now that says fascism that is whispering is not valuable. It only really matters
19:35when you shout it. And they're shouting it at you in all kinds of different ways.They're shouting fascism at you.They're shouting fascism with the way they're using ice. They're shouting fascism with the waythey are arresting journalists.They're shouting fascism with the way that they are using the government to go after thepresident's enemies.They are shouting it.They're looking at you right now, the Trump administration, and they're saying, hey, we are
20:07dominating and using this autocratic political power to influence and choke every singlefreedom that you have.Yeah.And I want to just once again talk to the right.You guys are such pussies.The right, I'm, I'm gonna be honest with you.Oh, you did it again.What?
20:32Pussies.Y'all don't have fat labia.Y'all got tiny labia.The right, you guys are the biggest fucking cowards I've ever seen.And let me tell you why I'm saying this.Yeah, why?I'll tell you why I'm saying this.I actually believed them.
20:54With what?Listen.If you ever get to, like, where I'm from, right?South Louisiana, you talk to the white boys down there that you know.Man, get them on a rant on Ruby Ridge and government overreach and why they need 150 guns.Like, get them on a rant.Talk about the Weaver family and how they went in there.and entrapped the family, the father, shot the dog,
21:27enticed the kid into a gunfight,killed the son, how Lon Horiuchi snipedand shot Weaver's wife in her head as she was holding her baby.And when you were in that growing up in the 90s and stuff like that,you're listening to these guys, they're saying the government itselfwill come and take everything that you have,including your family,then you go to Waco,
21:54you get into all of these guysand their sort of militia, patriot,air front era beliefs and all of that stuff.They'll tell you why they need all of their guns,why they don't need to be any rules.They'll relate all of this stuff.These conversations that I was having at this time,these conversations were around, like,
22:15the old governor, Mike Foster of Louisiana,signing legislation that was saying that people shouldn't have to wear helmets on motorcycles.And from a helmet on motorcycle conversation, you'll get into why perfect freedom is the abilityto do whatever you want without the government been able to tell you what you can do.Those people are lying fucking cowardly cuck bastards because I went to school with y'all.I worked with y'all.I've seen y'all now.masked people on the streets of the country
22:49shooting people and y'all with it.I mean, I guess I always knew this,but I am still shockedby the fact thatsome of the constructionof the mythology of the rightaround governmental overreach,around the need to protect yourself from this,
23:12about the sanctity of theConstitution. We're talking aboutoriginalists here.It's alldeadto take the tiniestsip from Trump's penis.Not penis, man.
23:31I'm trying to fire age up.I'm doing a bad job today,between that, look, look at her.She's, she's, but you know.Because I was like, what, I'm following.I'm like listening to your every word.And you were like,to take the tiniest sip
23:47and I'm like, yeah.And I just like, I thought you were saying Trump's Kool-Aid.Oh.You said.That would have been better.Yeah.I'm just saying like I am actually, you know, I'm, it's actually.But they've been doing it for so long, Van, that I'm not, I don't know, like, when you're like,
24:06the right is, has tiny labia for the purposes of this episode.I get, they've been doing it.They've had it for a long time.They've been doing this.This is different.which when did it become different for you?Which thing was it ice?The ice deployments.
24:21The ice deployments show me the fragility of the entire message of the movement on the right.Like I go on CNN.I sit down on CNN and I'm like, okay, look, there's no way that these people who claim to be God and country conservatives,they can't begin to launder this.And they laundered.Ice deploying into these cities or ice,or what happened with Alex Prattie,particularly because of the Second Amendment rights.
24:50I'm talking about before Alex Prattie.Okay.I'm talking about before Alex Prattie.I'm talking about Alex Jones.Talk about a different Alex.His number one fear was masked agentsthat were going to be roaming the streets of America,harassing American citizens,
25:10and putting them in jail because of their political beliefs.that was his number one fear.He would say that all the time.We're going to get there.And we did.And it was his guy that got us there.Mm-hmm.Mm-hmm.
25:23So I don't know.This is, you know, maybe it was always a fairy tale.The NRA, all of this stuff, we've talked about it.It's always a fairy tale.But like, this is the moment that America should be looking at the death of Santa Claus.Well, a lot of people, you know, on social were saying, like, if you were upset about what happened with Jimmy Kimmel, then you need to be.even in more fear of what's happening with Don Lemon,Georgia Ford,
25:49and the other journalists,you need to be concerned about,because this is the party who's like freedom of speech,freedom of speech.You know,this is freedom of press.You had Blanche go on TV this weekendand say, well, this is freedom of religion
26:03versus freedom of press.That's actually not what it is.I mean, I don't even want to go into the legality of it,but when you look at the Face Act,it's, you know,it was for,anti-abortion protesters.And then there's, of course, a part in there about churches and places of worship as well.
26:22And they're using this to now attack a Don Lemon and Georgia Ford.I don't know how they win this.I mean, we know procedurally that they tried to get a magistrate judge to give an arrest warrant to Don Lemon and these other journalists.He said no.The Eighth Circuit, which is very conservative, said no as well.But then they were able to put it in front of a grand jury, get an indictment who said that there's enoughevidence there's probable cause to move this forward to possibly a trial. I think they'lllose. Like when you look at what the elements are of this, I think they will lose. But the fact is,
26:53it's happening. You know what the funniest thing about it is? It's a miscalculation. On who's,on their part? It's a miscalculation. This was the wrong thing to do. Well, don't you think the time,when I saw this too, when this happened and everybody was talking about it, then the files werereleased at the same time, which we'll talk about. Yeah. So I don't know if it, I, I,agree with you is a miscalculation, but I knew what they were trying to do. I'm like,okay, this makes perfect sense because everyone's up in arms and talking about what's happeningto the journalist, as they should, but also, we just got a whole bunch of files. And allthis went down on Friday. All right. There is no way to make us forget about the Epstein files.
27:35Okay. All right. I could be in Turks and Kekos right now. It's Turks and Kekos, right? I've beenbefore. It is Turks. I could be in Turks right now. I could have a drink called the BBC. Now,this is a drink. What's in it? It's Bailey's Banana and Cream. Ew. That's the drink.Now, I'll tell you guys something. If you've ever been to the islands before, you go to Anguilla,you go to Turks, you go to these places. I remember I'm in the islands one time. I'm with a friendof mine, and he goes up to the bar and he goes, I want a BBC.And I was like, yo, what kind of trip is this?Why are you asking the bartender for this?
28:25The bartender goes, you want that BBC?And I was like, yes, it's a drink.It looks disgusting.Okay, it's a great drink for when you're in the islands.Bailey's Banana and Cream, the BBC's, you go there and you drink in a ton of BBC's.It's the whole time you're there.It's a never-ending stream of BBC's when you're in some of these places.Okay, it's a drink, though, is the thing.
28:51So it feels warm for milk in your drink.Cream.I don't know about that in the islands.That feels like that's a weird mix.Donnie, we were, now, Donnie, we were just about to move on.It's not, but that's not, it's cold, though.It's Bailey's been there.It's an iced drink.
29:03It's a delightful drink.You got the BBC.I looked it up.It looks absolutely disgusting.Okay, all right, let's not, okay, forget about the BBC.It's not refreshing.Like, I want a refreshing drink when I want.Okay, run punch?
29:16I, like, one punch?I,I mean, I don't, I'm sorry, I don't dislike it.It's not my drink of choice.I like a pinia colada.I like pinia collada.I like a.You like a what?
29:27What is you?Do you like a peanut collada?I like a pinia calada.I like rum.I just like.No rum punch.I'm not as into a fruity drink because of the sugar.So, you know, like I like more of like a straight up drink.
29:39So Rachel's on the beach.She's hanging out on the beach.Rachel's like whiskey, neat.Basically.Like Rachel's on the beach.Let me see.Like, hey, bring me a vat of vodka right here.Basically.
29:55Basically.Give me a tequila straight up.Tequila straight up.All right.I don't drink that on the beach.All right.I don't drink that on the beach.I'm on the beach.
30:04I like to have a rum punch.You love a, like an umbrella or something in your drink.There's a place in Anguilla called Gwyns.Gwen's has hammocksThey have food insideAnd they also have the rum punchGwen's rum punch is the best run punch in the world to meYou go there
30:25What I'm saying is I could beThis is the dealI could be at GwinsIn AnguillaWith some ribsBecause they do the ribs and the chickenAnd you guysYou guys are too immature for the BBC
30:38OkayBut with a rum punchAnd I could get an alert on my phoneThat says hey new EpsteinFisdine files dropped.I'm going to stop what I'm doingand I'm only to look at the Epstein files.On an island.
30:54Damn.Yeah.That's crazy.Yeah.On an island doing the thing.There's nothing you can do to distract us from this at this point.I'll say this.To take Don Lemon an expert in not only communication,
31:09but an expert in celebrity.an expert in messaging, a guy who's been doing this for so long and make him into a martyris a miscalculation by the Trump administration.I agree.It's the wrong fucking guy to do this to.Don, who has been doing really good work as a journalist, hitting the streets talkingto people, being on the streets in Minnesota, right?who is making a reputation different than his reputation at CNN
31:44where some people were in on Don,but a lot of people are out on them.Remember Don goes to Ferguson.He's got the Gucci on.He goes, it's the smell of weed in the air.Don is now has a people first, issue first platform.And calling out traditional media.And calling out traditional media using what he learned at some of these places
32:07to be a different type of a journalist.So he's on the street in Minnesota.They arrest him, but they arrest a guy who has a legacy media background.Yeah.Who can use this to enhance his platform and actually stand as something that is a magnifying glass of the fascist tendencies of the Trump administration.It's actually a mistake and they did it.They are not in their prime anymore.No, they're too far gone.
32:41I think, and I don't know if they, I'm not going to say that they ever were in touch with exactly what people think or maybe the other side is saying.But they've got so, it's so, their community is so, they're in such a bubble that they're only listening to themselves.And I just don't, I think that they have so, like, for example, it's like whatever Trump says they're going to do.And if they don't, I was listening to somebody talk about this.Like, you're not seeing Pam Bondi as much, right?Right.You're seeing Blanche instead, right?Because they're not liking what she's doing,
33:18because Blanche is doing a better jobin Trump's eyes of executing things.There was a time where they were going to pull backChristy Noem and replace it with someone else.Then Christy Noam cranked it up.So it's like whatever Trump wants to do,nobody's checking him, they're yes people.And this is obviously digging them a deeper and deeper hole
33:36to where they're losing their waste.strategically and just doing whatever Trump wants to do impulsively on a whim. It's why you have aGreg Bovino up on a microphone saying whatever they, whatever he wants to say, and they have toget him out of there. You have, it's why they're in front of people, you saying, don't, I don'tcare what you saw. We're telling you what to believe. It's Trump having for years hating DonLemon and then Blanche going on TV saying he doesn't have an issue with the Don Lemon. The Whitehouse doesn't have an issue. You can go back and look at all of it. They're losing their waybecause they're just doing whatever they can to keep their jobs and to please Trump. That's where
34:16they are right now. Right. Without strategies, what's got them here, they've lost their way.But they used to be really good at the celebrity game. They used to be really good at message making,at branding things. Like all of these little terms that we use, you know, they were good at coming out.and gaming the cultural system.You know, you got basically a used car salesmanin the White House, right?Mm-hmm.You got like a TV star, reality TV star,
34:48all of that stuff,they're just not hitting on this stuff anymore.But could that be because they're turning it up?Like, they were, the fascism and the authoritarianismwas always within all of this.Of course.But it was on the line, right?Like we're doing a little bit here,
35:04we're doing a little bit there.there can be an argument made that says, well, they're doing it for this purpose. Now they'recranking it up to the point where they're really in their fascist groove to where maybe that'swhy it seems like, okay, it was a miscalculation. Because there is no calculations. We're full-blown.We got our fascist hat on and that's the direction that we're moving in. Because that's what this is.There was no way for them to, I mean, they're saying that Don Lemon, this was an organized planattack. Donaldman and the other journalist are reporting what's happening. They're not threatening.They're not forcing their way. They're not coercing anybody. They're not, they're literally reporting
35:48on what it is they're seeing, which is what reporters do. This is why this is going to be interestingto me, because I don't think this is going to go far. But let's just say for some reason,somehow it works its way up. What will the Supreme Court do when it comes to the First Amendment?because the First Amendment, when you really start to get into it,it really doesn't protect reporters as much as it does of allowing, you know,publications to be able to speak on the government.Like that's a case, but it doesn't necessarily protect the individual.So I'm really curious to see how far they take this and how far it will go.
36:24Will they just let a court decide and it just gets dismissed?Or will they keep pushing the issue to try to go after orprevent a Don Lemon-type journalist or any left journalist or any journalist who isn't in line with what they want out there.Once I saw Amy Coney Barrett on Ross Doubt That's show like last year, and I listened to her give a very cogent, clear-headed defense and really endorsement of unitary executive theory.I no longer had any faiththat the Supreme Court would do anything otherthan codifyboth legally and culturally
37:14the president as a king.Just she believes in that.Like she believes in that.She believes in,I told you guys to look it up, a decade old,a decades old interpretation of the Constitutionthat just puts,very, very few limits on the power of the executive.
37:35And so if, I know that this is not directly in the willhouse of that,but it is the president or the executive body through the DOJ deciding who the enemies of America are.Yeah.And how that is expressed, how you can express that you are an enemy of America.Last thing I'll say about this, the people who went to protest in the church, they likely violated the FACE Act.Okay.All right.So here's the deal.
38:09Protests has never been low leverage, at least meaningful protests.Sometimes when you go and you protest, part of your goal in civil disobedience is to show how unjust laws are.or to break those laws in furtherance of your cause.So if you're going to go into a place,if you're going to stop traffic,you're going to go into a place of worship,you're going to do that stuff,that to me is totally appropriate in this situation.
38:44I have no problem with a little civil disobedience.I have no problem with a lot of civil disobedience.I have no problem with most forms of resistance.They're different.Yes.They stopped actual worship.They know what they are doing and they think that it's important because a member of ICE is leading the congregation in their city.Don documenting that.
39:06That is a completely different and separate issue.Him documenting that and doing the work, especially if you watch the stream.If you watch the stream, the way he talked to the protesters, the way he talked to the church parishioners, the way he talked to everyone was from a standard that was journalistic to me.journalistically pure.Okay, before we get to Epstein,let's talk about a couple of video clips I saw.All right, this is Harvey Levin from TMZ.Play it.
39:34This is the playbook that dictators useto destroy democraciesand take the will of the people away.It is as simple as that.Without a free press,you don't have a democracy.And it's real clear that Donald Trump and companydoesn't want a free press.
39:54Okay.That's Harvey.this is AndrewSchultz onbrilliant idiotstalking abouthis breaking pointwith Donald Trump
40:07and look I know I had Trump on the podcastyou know and I'm aware of itexplaining thatbut let me just clarify because I think it is important to say like I know howI had him on the podcast andlike so I when I'm talking out about this I'm not doing it to likeyou know get people to be like oh he's a good guy or whatever like thator trying to get anybody on my side
40:25I understand that this is a horrific event that happened.I objectively want to talk about it.I'm not trying to win anybody over in this.You understand.You know the difference between right and wrong.There's a difference between, like,respecting and honoring the Constitution, the backbone of our country,and then completely shredding it.
40:42And this is completely shredding it.And now they're realizing that people have noticed it.And now they're trying to backtrack it.By the way, he's been wiping his ass with the Constitution.Sure.I've been on record a million times saying like whenever he's saying we should terminate theConstitution to overthrow the results of an election.She's like that got to be disqualifying if you
40:58run up for the president. So here's a pretty example. So it's likeI know that there are people sounding the alarms aboutthis. When I saw these last few weeks in Minnesota,I didn't think was possible to happen in the United States of America.I'm being 100% serious. To white people.No, to anybody. But you've seen ithappen to black people. Exactly. Yes. Yes.To white people. It's okay
41:14to say that. No, no. No, it is.No, no. No, no. I don't know. I mean, I didn't knowthat this was possible to happen in the United States of America.And when I'm specifically talking about with this situation here and like not only this one, but also what we've seen ICE doing, like entering homes without warrants.Okay.So a couple of things here.I saw our friend Jimmy Kimmel post that is important to let people in that are realizing that what they are seeing is wrong.even if those people were not on the right side of the election or have a past of being in proximity to Trump.
41:58Another person, Ryan Garcia, the boxer, broke with Trump, citing his faith and the Epstein allegations.Ryan said, anyone that was involved in anything to do with that island and what they were doing, I just can't support that in any way.Children need to be protected.everyone knew better justice for all.What are your thoughts about,we're talking more specifically about,you know, what's going on with these guys?What was your thoughts about what Jimmy says
42:25or what anyone says that you need to let peopleinto a coalition that's standing against fascismeven if they're only coming to it right now?So I'm not against what Jimmy Kimmel said,but I'm also not going to be fooled, right?You know, you're not going to fool me twicewhen it comes to this.I hear what you say.
42:46what you're saying. I'm going to watch what you do. There are people who say that, you know,Trump's never going to get out of office or he's going to try to run for a third term. But let's justtalk in the space of he's two terms and he's done. Your issue is what Trump is doing now. He's done.I'm not hearing you talk about specifically the administration. I'm hearing you talk about Trump.I'm not hearing you talk about J.D. Vance or maybe the next person who might decide to run in in Trump'splace and who the GOP decides to make the, the, the one to represent the Republicans in thepresidential election. That is what I need more of. I need you to be upset because I, you know,I hear Andrew and I'm critical of Charlemagne a lot, but I will give him a lot of credit for this.
43:32He held his feet to the fire and said, you're shocked because it's happening to people who looklike you. You need to acknowledge that. It's personal. It's hitting home. You're not used to this.you've been hardened or, you know, it's been watered down for you to continue to see black and brown people this happen to, but not necessarily for people who look like you.I there have been, and we kind of talked about this earlier on the podcast, yeah, this what's happening in Minnesota has been a wake-up call for a lot of people, but it's been happening in our country.And authoritarianism has existed in so many other ways. Education, women's rights, people of color.voting,like so many different thingshave been affected
44:16by the Trump administration,but this is the thing.Are you mad just because of what ishappening in this particular incidentand to who?Or are you recognizing a patternthat is problematicthat is associated not just with Trump,
44:31not just with this administration,but what this party is willing to do?So I hear you and that's great.And I'm not saying,well, look where we are now.I'm not that person, so that's why I accept what Jimmy Kimmel is saying.But at the same time, I'm waiting to see how you're going to continue on talking about these things.Are you recognizing some of the other things that I mentioned?
44:53And how will you vote in the midterms and the next presidential election and beyond?That's what's important to me.And I'm not seeing it.I'm seeing them mad about this.So Jimmy's right.First of all, Jimmy's right.Jimmy's right because you don't want to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.So Trump won.
45:20Trump is the executive that is running the country.What happens is people see the way an executive runs the country and they go,I don't like the way the country is being run.My economic situation isn't changing.On top of that, people that I share my community with,Even if I had thoughts about those people that were racist and xenophobic, you see something, you go, none for me.That's the way it's always been done.The way change has happened has always been with coalitions that were broader than your group of people that could say, this right here, no good.
45:58Let's try something new.Whether or not that will lead to a lasting political shift from those people, who knows?There are a couple of people that exist in American society.When I say a couple of people, I mean, there's a cohort of people that exist in American society that aren't really as handcuffed or aligned to one side of political ideology as you would think they are.These are people that kind of vote along, I guess, not vibes necessarily, but what they see in the moment that they're in.The reason why I always like to have conversations with people about what kind of world they want to live in.What kind of society, me and we're talking about this with Ashley, do you want to live in is because that hardens your belief in the American political reality.That's something that then becomes oriented around principle.
46:55The principle about people being free, about expression, by people's right to health care, people's right to housing, about dignity for people.That is something that should be durable to me across generations and across different political movements.Now, we could also talk about the interpretation of that.What's dignity to me might not be dignity to you.We might need to negotiate that societally.There's something else here, though.And this is the thing to me that is more, I don't want to say, not necessarily even corrupting.The thing that's more
47:35HmmprecariousThe thing that's moreI don't know how I want to put thisLeave this all in as I search for this wordConcerningI'll put itIn this situation
47:56I know both of these guysRightI know both of these guysThey're not fire breathing dragonsI know we feel like they areI know you guys feel like they areI know they're notThey're not fire breathing dragons
48:07They're not.Harvey first.Harvey and I's relationship wasn't just boss to employee during my time at TMZ.It wasn't.I had an affection for Harvey Levin.That is difficult for people to hear.I understand that.I did.
48:30My father was very sick even during the time that I was at TMZ.Whenever my dad was sick,I needed to go.I needed to take care of things.I'm gone.I have a breakdown in the office.I literally pass out in the office.Talked about this before.
48:46I pass out in the office.They're all kinds of things.No one knows what's going on with me.Right?I got stressed out in the whole deal.No one knows what's going on with me.I pass out a battery of tests.Like looking at me, checking up on me, all of that stuff.
49:05All come from like Harvey,can cause. See this neurologist. See this psychologist. Therapetic yoga. All it is. All around. All of thatstuff, right? The battles that I had inside TMZ and anybody that has worked there, Lauren, Nina,anybody tells you the type of battles that you will have inside the TMZ, at least at the time that I wasthere as a self-respecting black person, you're going to have those battles. You're going to have them.I almost left TMZ because they wrote a fucked up headline about Marion Barry.And in my entire time there, that was the time that I was pushed the most by the editorial leadership there.Because I go on Twitter and I say, hey, keep complaining, keep getting in their face.
49:56I get a call from Harvey, Harvey goes, you're not an editorial voice on the site.I'm like, black people are mad.If black people are mad and you would think that I would be the person,that will go to them and tell them to not be mad,you don't really know me that well.But what happens after that,and this is maybe a low bar for me,maybe it's different for me now,
50:17what happens after that is we have that conversation on the show.So on Monday, me, Harvey,the guy who produced the,and wrote the headline to the Marion Barry piece, right?We all have that conversation on TMZ Live.The whole time I was there,I was never told what to say.I was never told what not to say.
50:38I was never in any way said,Van, you're going too far.Never.Like when something was done inside the officeand I had a problem with it,I go there and we talk about it,a lot of those battles I won,some of them I didn't win.
50:51There's one thing that changedthe nature of Harvey and I's relationship.And that was Donald Trump.This is a fact.Now, Donald Trump comes to power 16.The Kanye thing happens 18.anybody that worked there at that point knows that there were a couple of times whereone time that people will remember that Harvey and I ended up having a shouting match in the office.
51:19I thought his support for Donald Trump at that point,I legitimately thought his support for Donald Trump, who was his friend,and even the way TMZ handled a lot of the Donald Trump stuff,I thought that was beyond him.I know that that seems naive to a lot of,lot of people. I thought it was beyond him.Like, that was something at that pointthat was my nigger wake-up call.
51:45My nigger wake-up call wasshit, right?Shit. This is a threat.I see it. This is a threat.I see this guy. I see the way peopleare respond to him. I see the way people are, and I wasn'talone. If anyone, if anyone thinks that there were a bunch of peoplein that office that weren't pissed off about that,
52:06they're wrong. I wasn't alone.at all.Like, it was legitimately for me, like,God damn, for real.Like, I could not believe it.Credit where credits do.Or, like, being fair.It took Harvey very little time
52:27to jump off the Trump bandwagon.It took him very little time.The first time Kanye comes to TMZis the whole slavery was a choice thing, right?Kanye came back.Ken TMZ again,people don't remember that.During that time, me and Kanye didn't have any
52:44conversation, right?We didn't talk at all.Harvey and him talked.And Harvey asked him at that pointif he would take the MAGA hat off.So this is like,this is like after that.This is like, I mean,
53:01this is a couple of years into Trump.There were a couple of things that Trump had donethat I guess had pissed Harvey offand, you know, had him peel off.support. The reason why I'm saying this is not in any way to give you guys a full picturebecause of what I believe to be the, what I believe to be what's at the heart of both of theseconversations, Andrew and Harvey, and why the Miakopa or the change of heart is,Not the thing that I really believe is under this is this being transactional.
53:50That's the thing that scares me.Harvey Levin, during the time that Donald Trump was becoming a national political figure,had a television show that he wanted to do.Trying to get a television show off there.That show was called Objectified.And what happened on this show, what was supposed to happen on the show what the show was aboutas you walk somebody through your house or whatever,their house, you walked them through your house.
54:19You picked up objects and you gave the story of these objects.There's an interview through like what you have in your crib.One of Harvey's ideas.The pilot of that show is Donald Trump.Now, what Harvey wanted to do was have Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton be the pilot of the show.Hillary's people, I guess, wouldn't do it.Donald Trump decided that he would do it.Donald Trump and Harvey Levin's relationship had gone back a little bit like before my time at TMZ.
54:57If you guys have been reading the news, you know there are all kinds of relationships that you had to have at TMZ and relationships that he did have, right?But you need a story.Donald Trump is a big time figure in the press.Those are the types of guys that would know each other.the proximity and to Donald Trump,the treats and the gifts that came along with thatwas enough, at least in my opinion,for Harvey to make decisions that I thought were irresponsible
55:28even for TMZ.Like it's one thing about being in a placewhere, you know, all of this stuff is in scandaland the place is culturally insensitive and all of that stuff.Look, you're there, you're there.but when there is an existential threatto what I believe is the social and political fabric of Americalike there always is
55:55and there was a going along with thisbecause it made business sensethat was a problem for menot that the stuff before hadn't been a problembut that was like goddamnnot TMZ is not what I thought it wasit's like even you I did not think that you would go this farRight. Didn't think that you would go this far.
56:19Schultz, same thing to a degree.I went back this weekend and I listened to when Trump was on there.That interview with Donald Trump on Flagrant has 9.7 million views.I don't know if it's the biggest interview that they've ever had on Flagrant.Okay.Interviewing the president, I don't have any problem with that.Yeah.If Donald Trump wanted to come on here.
56:45we would do it.Yeah.Right.The interview itself is an abomination for someone as consequential as Donald Trump,for someone post-January 6th that tried the stuff that Donald Trump tried for the threatthat Donald Trump posed to democracy for things that Donald Trump had already been sayingon the campaign trail, the way that he was talking about.undocumented people,
57:21all of that stuff.The seriousnessof who he isand the moment that we were inis not at all addressing that interview.That is a softballcaked out bullshit interview.It is.
57:37Now,here's the deal.Every interview that Donald Trump didwith a guy like that,that is what came of it.Aiden Ross interview.I went back and watched it.Like Joe Rogie interview.
57:54I went back and watched it.The reason being is that Donald Trump wouldn't do an interview.I don't know anything about this, but I bet that there was some sort of coordination about what it was okay to talk to him about before he went on there.He wouldn't do an interview for an hour and a half or two hours that didn't do anything other than Launders.who he was. He wouldn't do that interview. He wouldn't do it. The reason why even in thethe flagrant interview, he talks about, you know, all different types of press that hedoesn't like, calls him to face the nation. We're talking about face the nation. That is becausethose people, at least to a degree to maintain their journalistic integrity, have to hold
58:40Donald Trump accountable. They have to ask him about things that he might have said. They haveto get into it. There's some parts in the flagrant interview whereAndrew talks about how he doesn't believe that undocumented people are the scourge of the earth.There are other parts where he says America is a great country.It's always a great country.But, I mean, there are questions in there is like, do you feel like Roe versus Wade?They got rid of it too quick.Now that Barron's going to be single.
59:05Like Donald Trump as a father, all of this stuff.It's without a doubt, without a doubt a fantastic interview for someone who had dramatic.ideas on how to change American society,on how to realign American society around what he wanted to look like.He wanted to look like.And it is not met with any seriousness at all.The reason why you would do an interview like that,which Flagrant doesn't do,
59:39because you can watch Pete Buttigiegieg on Flagrant,you can watch Zora and Mamdani on Flagrant.They're going to have their fun,but they also are going to talk about thingsthat center around these people's policies,their beliefs,and how they think that the world should work.They're going to interrogate that with these people.
59:57They do it all the time.The reason why you do the interview with Donald Trumpand you don't do that with himis because the interview is good for business.It makes you a bigger podcast.It makes you a more serious podcast.It changes the way people look at you.Another thing about that.
01:00:14From what I understand and know,Kamala Harris was offered the chanceto go and sit down with Flagrin.She did not do it.I think that Mark Cubanas a surrogate or a spokesperson personfor the Kamala Harris campaignended up doing that, right?
01:00:30I think that Mark Cuban ended up doing it.I wish you would have gone.Yeah.I do wish she would have gone.I wish you would have gone.My overall point saying all of thisis if this stuff is transactional,is if this stuff,
01:00:46is not based in any principle whatsoever.If this stuff is just aboutwhat you can get from doing something,this episode is brought to you by Spectrum Business.Fast, reliable internetmeans everything for your business.And even this podcast, that's why I trust Spectrum Business.It keep companies of all sizes connected with internet,
01:01:08advanced Wi-Fi, phone, TV, mobile services,plus 24-7 U.S.-based support.Millions of business owners already trustspectrum business. So visitspectrum.com slash business to learn more.Restrictions apply.Services not available in all areas.For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms,
01:01:28every choice matters.Tramphia offers self-injection or intravenous infusion from the start.Tramphia is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein everyfour weeks, followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks.If your doctor decides that you can self-inject Trimphia, proper training is required.Tramphia is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn'sdisease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis.Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them, and liver
01:02:03problems may occur.Before treatment, get checked for infections and tuberculosis.Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu-like symptoms, or need a vaccine.Explore what's possible.Ask your doctor about Tramfaya today.Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit Tramphiagiaradio.com.Ficked.All right, Matt Bellany is on.
01:02:26Bring Matt in.We got to talk to you guys about something real quick because Melania just dropped.I saw an interesting tweet from Matt.Matt Bellany is, he does the town podcast here on the Ringer.Gives you the ins and outs of Hollywood.You know who's on that podcast with Matt?Produces that.Craig Horibick.
01:02:44You know Craig?No.You don't give a fuck about him.Okay.Matt's on the show.Matt, how dare she?How dare she say that about Craig?Craig Horrible.
01:02:53Matt, did you hear those words come out of my mouth?Absolutely not.Hi, Matt.Thank you for joining higher learning.No problem.All right, I know this is the busy season for you.It is award season, but we want to talk about Melania here.Now, we land base at the movie and talked a lot of shit.
01:03:12It seems as if.Melania overperformed some projections for it.It was projected around five.It looks like it came in around eight.What are we?No, seven.Seven.It was adjusted down.
01:03:27It was adjusted down.Okay.Matt, I saw a tweet from you.And I speak bellonone, baloney ease.Okay.I speak Matt.Okay.Did I read a tweet from you in the correct way that you're maybe calling
01:03:44a little bullshit on the validity of the audienceturn out for Melania or is that wishful thinking from me?It seemed like you point to a couple places where it did welland said that maybe there was something else going on.Okay.You're reading a little bit into it because I don't have proof.But what I do have is that this movie performed very unusually.And that could be a legitimate response to the movie.
01:04:10Obviously, it's going to perform better in red state.areas than it is in Blue State areas.It overperformed amongst the national theater chains.There's three big theater chains that account for more than half of the theaters in this country,AMC, Regal, and Cinemark.It far overperformed in Regal cinemas than it did in AMC, which is traditionally the leader,which could suggest that maybe there was some block buying of tickets with the Regal chain,but it also note that the regal chain
01:04:45tends to have theaters in redder areas,places like Florida, places like Orange County, California,rural areas.AMC is much more of a inner city, kind of big city theater chain.So that could account for it as well.But what we do know is that Melania performed bestin places like Orlando, Florida, West Palm Beach,Maricopa County, Arizona,
01:05:12Dallas, Houston.These are not traditionally the places where movies perform best, but this is not the typicalmovie.Yeah.So is it considered a success because it did better?I know like before people were like it's going to be $1.5 million.So then it hits $7 million.They're saying, and I don't know if this is true, you're the expert in this, that it's the
01:05:36highest grossing documentary in like this decade or something.So in business terms, in business terms, does that deem it as success?Okay.So that's a very complicated question because, yes, if you take out concert docs like,Beyonce and Taylor Swift, yes, it is the best performing documentary in a decade.So great, win for them.But this movie was not made or promoted like a typical documentary.First of all, Amazon paid $40 million for the rights to make this movie and a subsequent
01:06:09docu series as they're going to release about Melania.So that is far more than most documentaries costs.Most documentaries cost less than $5 million, and if that.So that's first part.Second part is Amazon committed $35 million to market and release this movie, which is farbeyond what a typical documentary will get.Something like the RBG movie that came out a few years ago, that got like less than $10 millionin releasing cost.
01:06:39It might have even been less than five.So do you consider $7 million opening a success when the marketing budget was more like a typical mid-budget thriller or even a more IP-driven movie?I think you have to consider those factors when you consider this movie.And I would say that it's not a huge success with those financials attached to it.Is there a possibility that there was press on the projections on Melania that then activated the conservative zeitgeist in America and they went, we have to go see this movie?Yeah, I think there are a number of things that were both timed and not timed that helped this movie.First of all, they scheduled the premiere on Thursday that it came out so that everyone would see it and be like, oh, if I liked Dau,Donald Trump and Melania, then I'm going to go to this movie.
01:07:38So that, you know, that's a typical strategy when you have a movie that you want the premiereto promote it.Secondly, a lot of those headlines that came out that week about how poorly the film waspre-selling, I think that does motivate people to buy tickets.And we saw on the data, we saw a surge on Wednesday and Thursday of pre-sales, likely because ofthose headlines and also because Donald Trump was promoting it as well and a lot of people take theircues from Donald Trump. I didn't really see anything on social media. It's probably my algorithm,but I'm curious if there was like maybe just this buying up of seats where like did you see anything
01:08:22of empty theaters or like there was a lot of anecdotes a lot of anecdotal evidence about that.Nothing totally solid. I saw some theaters in Florida.that all the theaters were bought upexcept for two seats in every theater during a day,which is somewhat suspicious.It means that someone maybe was buying all of themexcept two to keep them openin case somebody wanted to buy real tickets.
01:08:49That's totally anecdotal,not evidence of any kind of conspiracy about this.But this often happens with these faith-based movies.This is not unique.You know, Obama's America or,Sound of Freedom, or some of these movies that are specifically targeted towards a conservative faith-basedaudience, they will buy up a bunch of seats and give them to church groups or give them to seniorcitizens or things like that to try to get out the vote. And there was this whole thing with Sound
01:09:19of Freedom where if you saw the movie and liked it, you were supposed to pay it forwardand buy tickets for other people to see it. Now, I don't know that that happened to a meaningfulextent here, but we saw the demos on the movie, and the demos were pretty striking.72% of the audience was 55 years and older.So this movie was skewing way older.It was skewing way more female, more than 70% of the audience was female.So older white women were driving this.We have the race breakdown as well.
01:09:5175% of the audience is white, 11% Hispanic, 5% Asian, 2%African American and 8% other.Wow.Not a lot of black people see in this movie.Yeah, not a lot of, we're not going out to see that, man.Shout out to us.We're sticking together.So there's been a lot of talk about the somewhat unusual business behind the movie
01:10:16when we're talking about the cost of the film.And you talked about that a little bit, whether or not this was essentially a bribe fromJeff Bezos and Amazon.to the Trump administration to get on their good side.Your thoughts on that.Well, here's what we know.We know that the Amazon bid was way higher than any of the other bidders for this movie.Disney was interested.
01:10:45I believe one other company was interested.I forget which one.Amazon's bid was far higher.Now, they would argue that regardless of what this movie does in theaters,it's going to be a high performer on Prime Video.And Amazon, you know, they want hits, and this will be a performer for them.We have not seen numbers.It's not going to hit the service for a few weeks.
01:11:06But they would argue at least that they are going to get value out of this.I personally think $40 million is an outrageous amount to pay for a documentary like this.Even a vanity piece, even the top people, which are usually music stars, like Billy Eilish got,it was reported, I believe, $30 million out of Apple for her movie.and that was considered like the high mark for these kinds of documentaries.And those are the kinds of things that her fans will all show up and watch it.And that's a big win for Apple Music.This one was even more expensive than that.
01:11:41And this is not something that is going to have a huge lifespan.I don't believe.There's going to be a lot of looky-lose that go to the service to watch it.But it's not something that's going to have value for a long time,especially since it's so timely.It's based on 20 days around the Annoy,and the news cycle has sort of already moved past that.But you know what?
01:12:04Amazon did what they did.It's no secret they want to get in good with the president.All of these media companies are doing things like this.Disney paid off a settlement over ABC News.Paramount has paid off to settle the CBS News 60 Minutes litigation.They're all doing it.Amazon's just doing it in the form of documentary.What's the docu-series that you mentioned?
01:12:30You said that there's an accompanying docu-series, Amazon's doing it?What on earth could it be about?Because everything I'm reading about this Melania movie,it's like they say the camera's just following her walking.She's walking more than she's talking in this movie.Great question.We don't know what that is, but it's coming.They have said from the beginning that this is not just a payoff for one movie.
01:12:52They're getting more out of this.Don't know what that's going to.to feature whether, you know, Trump or Baron Trump or any of the other relatives are going to be in it.I have not actually seen Melania yet, but apparently the other Trumps are not featured.Donald's family are not featured in it. I was, I've been told that I am in it briefly.They discussed me emailing them for comment about the $40 million price tag. I have not seen it toverify that, but I've been getting texts a weekend about it. Um, you know,Over at Skydance slash Paramount slash CBS, all that stuff, a lot of talk about how the politics of the administration are at a crossroads with media itself about Barry Weiss and a takeover over at CBS, about the Ellison family and how they were able to get Paramount and all of that.
01:13:49How effective do you feel like the Trump administration is being at?subjugating and capturing these gigantic media companies to act in the way that he wantsthem to act. It seems as if they're having some success on those fronts.Oh, yeah. I mean, yeah, Trump is absolutely winning his war on the media. And right now,the Ellisons are trying to buy CNN. So if the Ellison's get CNN and do to CNN what theyhave done to CBS News and put in this, you know, Ombudsman that's more conservative, put in someonelike Barry Weiss, who is going to try to, you know, move the channel more right, then that's a bigwin for Trump because CNN's been one of his nemesies from the beginning.
01:14:37You know, other media companies as well, I feel like there's a chill at these big mediacompanies in what they are willing to do against Trump because they know that he's going toweaponize all the elements of government against them. And look what happened to ABC withwith the Jimmy Kimmel mess, where the SEC was threatening,or at least we believe they were threatening,to go after their license over some jokesand comments that Kimmel made about Charlie Kirk.And that turned into a whole thing where they suspended Kimmel
01:15:10and they ended up having to bring him backand it became a real scandal for the company.And that's just something that would neverhave taken place even five years ago,even under the first Trump administration.He's so aggressive in this stuff in the second,term that these media companies have taken notice.I have to talk about Brett Ratner,
01:15:32because I feel like we're not putting enough attention on him directing this movie.You know, he made news this weekend, not just for directing this movie,but for also being in Epstein Files, photographed and all of that.Great timing there.Perfect. Perfect.What does his involvement signal with just being a part of this movie and signal with the film?And then also with Hollywood and Congress.controversial, I guess, directors.
01:15:57Does it, do you think that this means that this is a way for him to get back?Do you think, I mean, or is it just like a one-off?And, you know, we'll see him.We kind of talked about the last episode, but a runoff with maybe Rush Hour 4.Like, what does this say in general, just about this type of director and their relationshipwith Hollywood?I would not say that within Hollywood, Brett Ratner is back.I mean, he has effectively leveraged this relationship with the Trump's.
01:16:25He has connections via people that are in his circle.They have a shared interest in Israel.The Trumps have gravitated towards people that have been, quote, unquote, canceled.They see it as a way to kind of stick a finger in the eye of the liberal media by embracing some of these people.This movie, I think it doing okay and not totally flopping certainly doesn't hurt him.And he leveraged those relationships to get Trump.to pressure Paramount to release Rush Hour 4.And that was the big impediment to getting that movie made.
01:17:03The way it works is Warner Brothers let the property be shopped to other studios.But the caveat was that they needed a release in 3,000 theaters in order to okaythat this movie could be made by another entity.Paramount's giving them those 3,000 theaters,which is triggering the financing for the movie,which is triggering Ratner's ability to get it made.So this whole, you know, pressure campaign from the Trumpsare directly benefiting Brett Ratner on this movie.
01:17:36Does it mean that he's going to get another studio assignment?No.If Rush Hour 4 comes out and it's amazing and does $500 million at the box office,will it be back?Maybe.You know, Hollywood tends to respond to money,but do we think that Rush Hour 4 is going to gross $500 million?I'm not prepared to predict that.
01:17:58Well, I'll tell you this.I'll ask you this about Brett and because I think that's a good question and about the movie.The movie itself will be in a really precarious situation if the project of the film is seen as a Trump propaganda piece.So just so we know so our audience.But I don't think it is.I mean, I talk to someone who's read the script.It doesn't have anything to do with politics.There is a trafficking storyline.
01:18:27I think they are planning to shoot in Africa a little bit.They are planning to shoot in Saudi Arabia,which brings up a whole separate set of issues.The financing is coming from outside the country, I am told, mostly.But it's not like this is a piece of Trump propaganda.Who knows, maybe Donald Trump will ask to be in the movie,which would politicize it even more.But this is a $100 million action movie,
01:18:51bringing back Chris Tucker and Jackie Chanand they hopeit will be an all audienceblockbuster type movie. Not sure.It's been 17 years.Been a while.Last one.I guess this was my question.
01:19:05Do you think that,you know, because I'm assuming Brett Ratneris back as director.He's certainly back.It's one of his properties.Okay.Do you think that this filmcould be tricky
01:19:18for Chris Tucker and Jackie Chanshould be.Who are going to, to a lot of people, be seen as part of favor doing for Donald Trump.Do movie audiences look at stuff like that on the whole?Let's get out of the political Rachel Van bubble.Do you think people in other places that might be spiritually against Trump are going to go,I can't see Rush Hour 4 because the president wanted this movie.Brett Ratner's on it.
01:19:51that at all part of the calculation here, in your opinion?I think it is a factor, and it's important to note that neither Jackie Chan or Chris Tuckerhas a signed deal to return for this movie.They are talking to them.I have reported that.But there's two issues here.First, the Ratner issue.I mean, don't forget, this is a guy that has been credibly accused of some pretty horrible
01:20:12behavior with women.He's denied a lot of that.And second, there's a Trump issue because maybe you would be perceived as a, you would beperceived as like furthering the Trump agenda because he wants this made. I think within Hollywood,the Ratner issue is a bigger issue because a lot of these canceled directors have not been ableto get movies off the ground because the stars won't work with them. They don't want, you know,Woody Allen's not getting a huge cast like he used to because he has effectively been canceledin this country. He's working overseas. He's doing mostly overseas actors. And I think Brad
01:20:47Radner does fall into that category. However, this is the only big franchise that Jackie Chan andChris Tucker have. And if they want to revive it, this is sort of what they need to swallow and,you know, be okay with. And they do have a personal relationship with him. Everything I've heard is thatit's a good relationship. And, you know, maybe they're okay with it. I know. I like, would you say,we're in our bubble. I feel like most, and this is why I keep bringing up Brett Ratner. I don't thinkmost people realize who he is as a director, what his past is, one, that he was directing Melania'smovie and then what the past is with it. And I think that the same thing, you'll have peoplethat'll be so excited about the rush rush hour coming back, that they'll look past that and think
01:21:40that those are two separate things just for the entertainment value of it. Or they might not even knowcare.Yeah.You're not a public-facing person.It's much different when someone's a star and you have to look at them and you have toendorse them by going to the movie.And it's, you know, someone behind the scenes, most people don't even know who the directorof movies are.
01:22:02That's me.That would be me.Last question.Appreciate the time.You guys got to listen to the town.One of my favorite pods.And then go watch the studio on Apple.Okay.
01:22:13MattPlease don'tMatt figuresInto the studioOn AppleBig partLike it's notThey just
01:22:21They brought you backAnd you're in thereA couple of timesBut then in that episodeYou're likeOne of the main plot pointsIn the fucking showLike you
01:22:29I'm the villainYeah you're the villainYeah you're the villainOf the showAll rightI knowLet's talk about thisSinners
01:22:3516 AcademyAcademy AwardnominationsBellanyMattThe townIt's not happeningIt's not happening
01:22:43I'm sorry.How many do you think sinners will win, Matt?How many?Oh, you want me to give you a number?Give me, give me like a, not like.You know what?I can't go down the full list, but I don't think it will win picture.Okay.
01:22:57I don't think it will win director.Okay.I don't think it will win any of the above the, you know, the acting awards.I do think it will win original screenplay for Ryan Coogler, which is a great Oscar to win.Typically, if you go back and look,Some of the best movies of the past 30 years did not win Best Picture, but one original screenplay.You know, if you remember, Get Out, one original screenplay.Right.
01:23:24If you remember Pulp Fiction.Black Klansman, that was adapted, but yeah, Black Klansman.Black Klansman, one adapted.Right.So no shame there, and it'll be a great Oscar for Kugler.But I think that the one battle after another cohort is going to be stronger.And that, I think, is because the Academy.is so international now.
01:23:45Even if you look at the box office for sinners,sinners was a gigantic hit in this country,far less so overseas.And the politics and the cultural stuff in the moviejust plays way better to American audienceswho are much more familiar with the history of black Americans.It just, and I think that because the academyis so much more international,
01:24:10it will favor that,one battle after another, they're over. That's my personal choice. But it could win a number of belowthe line. Certainly going to win score for Lubid Gorenson. He's won all the precursor awards.I think it could win some like production design and some of the more, you know, costume design,some of those kinds of Oscars for the work that's been done. There, Ruth Carter is a big name withinthe academy. She's the costume designer on Cinners and she won for Black Panther. So I could see herwinning again. So it's not going to go home empty-handed, but I think I think it's going to lose the bigones to one battle. Maybe cinematography. Sure. Like autumn, we've had her own name. Maybe same. Okay,
01:24:51before you, what are the things? Although that sequence at the end of one battle with the road,that is a very showy cinematography sequence. It's totally overrated. Okay, listen.Okay, okay, before you go, just do one thing for me. Uh, explain above the line below the line topeople. It's jargon that we understand, but some of our audience might not understand what youmean. It's very simple. It's the guilds, the unions that are for actors, directors, and writers.The people who typically are above the line. The line is the title of the movie. On a poster,when you see above the line, that's those types of talent. Below the line is the people that youdon't see on a movie, like the production designer, all the craftsmen and, you know, all the craftsmen
01:25:38and women that work on these movies.And, you know, producers are not a union,but they often are considered above the line as well.And it's just a denotation within the industrythat has sort of seeped into the business.For instance, you know, for tax credit purposes on movies,you're not allowed in California to deduct above the line expenses,which are primarily the actors and directors.
01:26:04And that's because they don't want to be seenas subsidizing Tom Cruise's salary.Right. So it's more for the production costs and below the line expenses.But it's just a term of art that's used within the industry.Right. Basically, any shit you could get famous for doing is above time.Yeah.Unless you're like the number one.Unless you're like John Williams.
01:26:26John Williams.He's below the line, but he's famous.Louvreig.Hans Zimmer, all of those people like that.Yeah.Yes.Or even someone like Ruth Carter.Ruth Carter is pretty famous.
01:26:35She's pretty famous.Yeah.She's pretty famous.Matt.The Tower.Three times a week?Three times a week, man.We're on the treadmill.
01:26:42Three times a week.Craig Horubick,Rachel doesn't know who he is.He's a producer of the town.Matt Bellany,thank you for joining us on Higher Learning.Thanks for having me.No problem.
01:26:52Thanks, Matt.Talk about something.I want you guys to listen to something.All right.Uncle Van's got to admonish you guys a little bit.Who you talking to?Just talking to the people in of itself.Okay.
01:27:06I have to.Uncle Van has to admonge you guys a little bit.Now, look at what they did.Melania coming out and being a success was important to them.Now, maybe they bought a whole bunch of ticketsand cooked the books on Melania.Could happen.We'll know about the second weekend.
01:27:28We'll know.It's going to drop off on the second weekend.I can't wait.Motherfucking fat rat.One million?Half a million.It's going to drop off, okay?Maybe it doesn't.
01:27:40Who knows?We've had conversations before on the pod about the fact that when movies come out,not just movies but other things when they come out,and they are specifically meaningful to you for a social reason.Even when we go back to Buzz Lightyear the movie where they show the same-sex kissor movies that deal in queer culture.Queer themes, movies that deal in black culture, black themes, sinners, great job, everybody showed out.Big, splashy, showy movie.
01:28:22Michael B. Jordan, Ryan Cooleer, vampires, dancing, Haley Steinfield, Darylindo.That's different.There's a movie coming out that my home boy's made called Ricky.Okay.And I'm going to tell everybody I need to go see this movie.my man Sterling produced this film.It's about stuff.It's about stuff, recidivism, prison,
01:28:46all of that stuff.Ricky's coming out.All right, besides that.I've said beforethat it's very importantto be animated about these films succeeding.Back in the day, Red Tales came out.I never saw Red Tales in the theater.
01:29:02Me neither.I went to see Underworld.but I bought two tickets to Red TailsWhy did I buy two tickets?I saw Red Tails later on.Why did I buy two tickets?It's important.Now, I'm not saying that it's you guys is social duty
01:29:18to spend money on stuff that is going,that is socially, I'm not saying that.I'm not saying it's your social dutybecause money, not everybody has disposable incometo buy tickets for a movie they're not going to see.Right.All right.And what you should do is go see the movie and experience the art anyway.
01:29:38Not everybody has that.But what I am saying is when these movies come out, if they don't do well, they're not going to make them.And I know that you guys feel like, oh, my God, they should make them all anyway, no matter what, Disney should double down, come back, do it again because it's the right thing to do.That's just not how it works.And I really want you guys to understand that.If it's at all possible, I'm not telling you to be an activist every single moment in your life.But if it's at all possible to support something that is under particular attack from the right,like that Buzz Lightyear joint was, go out and see it if you can because what they say after is go woke, go broke.
01:30:24And then the ticket sales tell the story of that particular issue.And the corporation, which is a soulless behemoth that is made to feed you.itself, we'll learn the lesson that the shit that you care about, audiences don't want to see it.Yeah. Whether that's fair or not.No, no, no, it's true. It's true. Obviously, I don't, you know, about as well versusthe movies with you, but another movie we talk about that we haven't in a while that endedup getting a sequel because people came out and they went out and saw it and they supportedit and it was one of those movies that you talked about where it's like, we need more movies
01:30:57like this where you can just bounce around and do nothing. Like, you know, it's just followingyou throughout your day.People being people is one of them days.And it has a sequel now.Has a sequel.Not as a sequel.Because people went out, supported it.It did well.
01:31:11Guarantee, if they hadn't, we wouldn't.Guarantee, as fantastic as sinners is,I don't think if it had the box office successthat it would be sitting here breaking recordswith 16 nominations.They couldn't deny itbecause, of course, it was a masterpiece.But they couldn't also deny the success
01:31:31that it had in the box officebecause at the end of the day, it's a business.It's about the money.And it's about everything.Just try it.Try the little black business, right?Ruby jeans, juicery.They held me down during the pandemic.
01:31:52Try it.Lany Smith, actively black.Try it.Just try it.Just see if you can try it, you know.If you can, not all of you, but some of you,because they're going to,They're going to support they shit.
01:32:06Yeah.They're going to support they shit.They're going to make sure that they shit.They don't want to compel the world from a decency standpoint.They want to say, look, we want.So sometimes we have.This episode is brought to you by WeatherTech.Everyone knows winter is the MVP and make it a mess.
01:32:26You don't need WeatherTech floor liners in the summer unless you hit the beach or go camping.Then you'd want a cargo liner or a road trip goes sideways.ketchup goes rogue, ice cream drips.Yeah, you'd be pretty happy about those weather tech seat protectors.So just to be clear as the mud, you're inevitably going to step into the summer.You don't need weather tech unless you plan on doing summer.Visit weathertech.com today.This episode is brought to you by Sweetgreen.
01:32:54The day doesn't ask for permission.Lunch window?Gone before you saw it coming.You deserve a break that actually satisfies.Sweet Green's new wraps have got you.Real ingredients, zero shortcuts, everything you love in one hand.Think green goddess chicken, garlic aoli, crumbled bacon, corn salsa, 40 grams of protein.Made to keep up with whatever comes next.
01:33:17New sweetgreen wraps hit different.Order now at order.com.I have to do that.I have been waiting for the Paul Robson era, like for the talk, the, the talk,the, how can I say?I've been waiting for there to be intellectualand cultural investigationon the whole of this man for a while.
01:33:46Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.And of all the figures,Howard Bryant joins us today on higher learning,and we're just gonna, like,I'm just gonna express this feeling.Of all the figures that,have been lost to time in a really interesting way.My father was obsessed with this man.
01:34:10Like obsessed with him.My father is the furthest thing was, should I say,the furthest thing from a socialist that you could ever.He was obsessed with what happened to him.And yet, in no real way has there been the big splashy biopic,the time when we talk about,the deep, deep penetrating documentary.I've watched a couple of them.
01:34:32But like, why do you think that is?And what made you want to dive into this story and talk about this a little bit?Yeah, well, first of all, thanks for having me on.Love your show.Love all of what y'all do.We were just talking earlier about that.I disagree immediately with the very first thing that you just said in terms of being lost to history.I think it answers its own question.
01:35:00He wasn't lost to history.He was erased from history.I mean, this is active.That's the thing that made me real interested in him was there are people who get lost to time, right?I mean, time goes on.Some people get replaced by other things, right?I mean, we talk about Michael Jordan, but we don't talk about Dr. Jay that much anymore.And if you were there, you know Dr. Jay deserves way more than he gets.
01:35:23But Paul Robson, this was an active destruction, active.And I think one of the reasons why we are at where we're at, even though this is the 50th anniversary of his death, is because so much of the black establishment wanted nothing to do with him.If the black establishment doesn't want anything to do with him, then the white establishment is going to follow.And I think that when you go back and look at the relationship that Robeson had and Du Bois as well, but especially Robeson had with the NAACP and with the Urban League and with the fact that, you know, the, the, the, the, the, the, you know, the.the distancing, the isolation, I think that it made it really, really clear that if he didn't,if he wasn't going to be reclaimed by black people, he wasn't going to be reclaimed at all.And I was talking to Spike, you know, Spike Lee about this.And I told Spike, I said, you are the one, in my opinion, you and Chuck D are the ones most
01:36:20responsible for the elevation of Malcolm X.When I was in college, Malcolm X was a villain.And it was only in the 80s.Malcolm X hadn't been.And I said, if it wasn't for the music and if it wasn't for the movie and the merch and the hats and the ability of a new generation to reclaim him, then he still would have been framed by white America.And it wasn't until that movie and it wasn't until that period, the Afrocentric music and of the hip-hop movement where he got reclaimed by us.And now he is a legend to everybody.And that hasn't happened for Robson.
01:36:56He never got that.The book is Kings and Ponds, Jackie Robinson and Paul Robeson in America.Just wanted to make sure it's just been released.Howard Bryan has joined us.Just wanted to say that.No, yeah.My question is about the title.And it's so interesting you bring up Malcolm X because it reminds me of we've had Dr.
01:37:14Ponell Joseph on the show and the sword and the shield and how, you know, we were taught a certain way about these two public figures.But he talks about him in another way, gives more background, and then shows a link between them,what you're doing in this book with kings and pawns, if you could talk about the choice of thattitle and then how both of these men kind of function as kings in American culture, but alsoas pawns with the government.Yeah.Well, the first thing is, I'm a big chess fan.I'm a big chess player.
01:37:43That was the first thing, is I couldn't help but think about that metaphor while I wasworking on it.So,Paul Robson is the most famousblack man in America.We talk about Jackie Robinsonintegrating baseball in 1947.Paul Robson integrates Broadway
01:38:00in October of 43.Shakespeare performances ofOthello had always beenwith white actors in blackfaceuntil Robson in the United States.And yet, the double V campaignis also taking place in 1943where the black press is like,
01:38:16we're not going to do the way we did itin World War I, which is we suppress our pursuit of black rights during the war effort.Now we're going to do both, double V campaign, victory at home, victory abroad.So we're going to go out there and we're going to go fight for the country, but we're alsogoing to fight for ourselves.So they are boycotting different establishments.And baseball's next.Baseball hasn't integrated.
01:38:40There hasn't been a black player since Moses Fleetwood Walker in 1884.And the black press is coming for baseball.And so baseball, knowing that this is happening, who do they go and get to shield themselves from black protest? Paul Robson.So Robeson is actually now in a lot of ways being manipulated. He's the first pawn to, you know, so he's actually in a lot of ways pitted against the black press, even though they have the same aims.And during that meeting, Robeson says, do not pit me against my brothers here. We are on the same page.then we get to1949Paris Peace Conference in April 49
01:39:21Robeson gives a speechwhere essentially he's the precursor toMuhammad Ali where he says look I don't have a problemwith the Soviet Union we as black peopledon't have a problem with the Soviet Union our problem isright here which is no different than whatAli is saying about the Viet Cong 20 years laterin in Vietnam
01:39:38but after hesays that and the Associated Pressmisquotes him and you knowit comes out as it's unthinkable that that any Negro would fight, you know, against the Soviet Union.Now we do what we always do. And what do we, you know, you see it here. Any black man who's going tocriticize another black man in public is going to have a job for life. So what do they do? They go andfind Jackie Robinson to testify against Robson. So now you've got Jackie in a place he didn't evenwant to be. He didn't want to testify. This was not something he wanted to do. But he also felt a
01:40:14responsibility. And it's a real interesting thing because I feel the same thing is happening today.There's a great conversation taking place in the black community right now about whether or notthis moment is ours. Like, you guys voted for Donald Trump not once but twice. We held up our end.This is in our fight. Let's sit this one out. This was a similar conversation taking place in the late40s. But Jackie took a different position. Jackie's like, no, this is mine too, right? I got a pieceof this. We have a say in this. And so, and there were a lot of people telling Jackie, why wouldyou testify in front of the most notorious government body in history against another black man?And Jackie's position was, was that we have a say in this. And he was also very concerned as well
01:41:01as he said that he felt, and this is where the NWACP abandoned Robson, that if we get associatedwith communism, if we get associated with the Soviet Union and all that Cold War stuff, then thewhite allies we have now are going to abandon us. So we have to do something. And so Jackie isin this position where he is, you know, in service of segregationists who didn't even, who wouldn'tshake his hand. And then, of course, you get Malcolm X, who was like, no, the real pawn isn'tJackie and the real pawn isn't Robson. The real pawn is us. The real pawn is us thinking that we're goingto get an affection, a rights, a citizenship, that's never coming. So to me, the title was all of thethings. It was, you know, it was Robson being used. You know, people thought he was being used by the
01:41:55Soviet Union. It was Jackie being used by these segregationists. It was us, you know, constantly,or the NACP, you know, going after Robson. And then five years later, when you get to Brown versus BoardBoard of Education and the civil rights movement, these very same.people who isolated Jackie, I'm sorry, who isolated Paul, are now being called communists. And then,of course, the king's piece of the title is, these are our giants. These are the people who arethe best of what we've been. And it really is a Harry Belafonte line where he always referred to Paul Robesonas one of our kings. So that's really where the title comes from. Ropeson's life and hisaccomplishments are astounding. Unbelievable. There's no way to, there's no way to put it other than that.
01:42:40when you look at every step of the way in his life,his athletic achievements, his scholastic achievements,his achievements in entertainment,he is, it's,it baffles your mind to see just how much talent was in one man.He goes on to kind of break the mold in every way that,that one person could.I want to stick on one part of this.
01:43:08Is it possible that Robs and Socialism,the fact that he had an affection for the Soviet Union and whatever he saw as society inside of it being, the fact that he, although the communist term was thrown at him and very publicly in the interview where he had to correct a reporter says, hey, you're saying that, not me, but he was an avowed socialist. He did have a political view that was at cross purposes with the American capital.capitalist movement at that time. That one reason why he might have been erased from history,he doesn't fit the mold of an American hero in the same way that Jackie Robinson or some of theother ones might, that achieved so much inside of what Americans consider to be safe, political,and economic views. All the above, 100%. I mean, and that's, and that is one of the questionsthat I wanted to get at in the book as well and didn't get anywhere near as deep as I wanted to. ButOnce again, this idea that democracy and capitalism are linked, they're not.
01:44:17It's just an economic system.Robeson was 100% anti-capitalist.The stuff that Robeson was talking about back then, we talk about now, he used the same phrasingin the 1930s, the 99% against the 1%.He was a person who was fighting for universal healthcare.He and Henry Wallace back in the 30s and 40s.And so there's no question.He's not Jim Brown, you know, empowerment zones, black capitalism, completely anti-capitalist, very much clearly anti-capitalist and did the, and was doing the numbers.
01:44:51There's no way that we're going to be able to compete with the amount of wealth that we've already lost.And he was very, very clear. Robson was very, very clear about this idea that just because I made it doesn't mean we're good. We're not good.You know, he would say constantly, I have cousins and family members who can neither read norright.So what good is my success, which runs very counter to the way that we look at the world today?We've got a handful of black celebrities who are doing extremely well, black professional,you know, few of us who were doing really, really well.And therefore, that's proof that it's all good.
01:45:27And Robson was exactly the opposite of that.For people who may be reading the book or maybe listening to the podcast and Robson,and maybe a lesser known figure to them,how do you want audiences to maybe reimagine his legacyor maybe the word isn't reimagined since you said it's been more of an erasure?How do you want them to know his legacy?Yeah, I think, but whenever you're working on a project,the very first thing that you're really thinking about is how much does the reader know?
01:45:57Am I giving them something that they don't know?Are they reading this going, I already know this, I already know this,give me something new?every time somebody said to me, what are you working on? And I said, I'm doing a book onJackie Robinson, Paul Robson, in the Cold War. People were like, who's Paul Robeson? So the veryfirst thing for me was just knowledge of self, knowledge of who this person was. And as Van wassaying, this man is a, he's not just a scholar, concert singer, opera singer, stage actor,Hollywood actor, one of the greatest college football players of all time.
01:46:32He played in the NFL.He played in the NFL.He, and also, you know, was a Columbia law as well.I mean, so all of the above.And I think I want people to think about that in terms of, in terms of his accomplishmentand who he was.But I really want people also to think about how does it happen that somebody that,important could be that erased. And also for us to take it upon ourselves to not let our own kings
01:47:07be erased and our queens be erased. That take it upon yourself to find out more about who thesepeople are. Can I just follow up really quickly? To the last part of what you said, I was going to say,do you think that we as a culture bear some responsibility? Of course. Okay. Always. I mean, always. I mean,I mean, I always think about this, especially now.We're under assault right now.I am so happy that y'all have your podcast, that you do what you do.We are under assault.Our education system is under assault.
01:47:40We are othered in our own country in terms of what is being taught.Look at the laws down in Florida about not teaching black history, about erasing black books,about, you know, looking even what's happening in Philly in terms of taking down the slavery exhibit at the Liberty Bell and Independence Mall.all of these things, this is an attack.If we are not going to educate ourselves,they're not going to educate us,they didn't educate us anyway.I mean, thinking about how much
01:48:07did I actually learn about any of this in school.I was embarrassed when I went down to Phillywhen I was in college,when I went to Temple,because Robson had only been dead 10 years.And in Philly, that's a huge name.And so his name existed, but I'm like,just like I knew who he was,
01:48:23it didn't know what he was, didn't know what happened.And so absolutely the place where we're in right now could not be more dire in terms of how we are where we're positioned and what we're going to be able to say in this culture.So yeah, it's on us.Robson's father was a slave.I guess I'll say again, Robson's father was a form.enslaved person, okay, that then raises a son that goes on to achieve all of these thingsto become a superstar in American culture.But then by the end of his life, I want to talk a little bit about Jackie Robinson and the
01:49:13intersection here in a second, but by the end of his life, almost is driven to a point ofmental instability by the attacks on his character.Do you see through lines to current figures in American culture, black American culture,nonstop critiques and attacks that either drive them away from the fight or destabilize them mentally,emotionally and financially to where they're no longer a part of the conversation?Sure, it's a continuum.And it's been happening, it happened before Robson.It happened during.
01:49:50It happened after.And one of my favorite characters in the book is W.E.B. DeB. DeB.Du Bois, who is, you could make the argument he's the greatest scholar that we've produced in terms ofhis scope. And also the thing that I love about him in this book and just in his life is if you'reborn during the right time, right, incredible things happen. He was born in 1868, three yearsafter the Civil War. He's alive for Robert E. Lee. He's alive for, he's alive. He overlaps as an adultwith Harriet Tubman, Frederick Douglass, Booker T. Washington, William Monroe Trotter,Jackie Robinson, Malcolm X. Muhammad Ali. Because he's alive and he lives till he's 95. He dies in
01:50:321963, I think a day or two before the march on Washington. And after the government had taken hispassport, just like it had taken Robesons for almost a decade, he moves to Ghana in 58. He nevercomes back. And when he dies, I mean, to the point about this continuum, continuum, continuing,of destabilization. I mean, what does he say when he dies? I was never a man. I was I was never anAmerican. I was I was black in a country that did not want me. And this is the top of what we'veproduced in terms of accomplishment. And this is what he's saying about his life. So absolutely. So oneof the things, and Jackie, same thing. One of the things that I was thinking about in addition toreally wanting to elevate them was how do you have these people
01:51:20who have done everything that this country has asked us to do and are held up as proof of whatyou can do and what you can accomplish.How do they at the end of their lives find themselves where they were, where Jackie Robinsonat the end of his life pretty much says when I, you know, I don't salute the American flag,I don't acknowledge it.When I see a car with an American flag on it, I assume the guy behind the wheel is not my friend.I mean, this is the best of what we've produced.And yet this is where they find themselves.
01:51:54So I really wanted to explore that.Yeah, Jackie Robinson expressed regret about that testimony in front of the committee.Can you talk about, like, how did you assess his evolution with his political thinking over his life?Well, I think that one of the questions that I'd had was once again the embarrassment of not knowing the story.story as well as I needed to. He was pushed into it by Branch Rickey. Branch Rickey is one of thesecomplicated characters. Branch Rickey is at the meeting in 1943 when Robeson addresses the baseballowners. And when that meeting ends with the black publishers and with Robeson, they want toadjourn the meeting. They're like, okay, we're done. We did, we did our thing because the goal wasn't
01:52:40enlightenment or moving toward integration. The goal was to shut the protest down. That was goingto be taking place.But one guy in that meeting, Branch Rickey is like, hey, are we going to talk about the delegation that just came here?So he did the thing, right?He's the complicated conservative, anti-communist, anti-New deal guy who did the thing anyway.So how much credit do we give Branch Rickey?And Jackie is placed in this arena because of his loyalty to Branch Rickey.He's not an anti-communist.
01:53:15I mean, he's an American.He was the guy, you know, my country.right or wrong, you know, the way his wife, Rachel, who by the way is still alive, Rachel Robinson will be 104 in July.But yeah, he was there because he felt an obligation to be there. His employer was telling him to be there. He felt he owed Branch Ricky.And so he, by the end of his life, it was sort of like, why did I do this? Because of the lack of progress. And he begins to find outwhen he testifies against ropes and they're calling him an American hero, then he's advocatingfor black rights and baseball can't wait to get rid of him. And then he goes and aligns himselfwith Eisenhower and Nixon and the Republicans because he's a conservative, independent,
01:54:03but conservative. And then he finds out they don't care about civil rights. He's sending telegramsto the White House about what's happening in Birmingham and what's happening in Little Rock.And they're not doing anything. So you can see his evolution. And thenyou've got a new generation of black protest.You know, the Stokely Carmichael's of the world,you know, the Black Panthers.And they're looking at Jackie going,you're an Uncle Tom.
01:54:27You're the sellout.And he's like, after everything I fought for,I'm the sellout.And so you can see where his evolution isthat I'm doing what you're all asking me to do.And it's just not moving.And yet he remains in the fight.I found him,
01:54:45I the flattening out of Jackie on this, I actually found him to be even more fascinating because he he wasn't the kind of guy who he didn't have all of the political savvy that he needed because he believed. And then you find out these people don't care about what I care about. But he stayed in the fight. And I had a lot of respect for him to that. The book is Kings and Ponds, Jackie Robinson and Paul Robeson in America. Howard Bryan has done just.incredible work over the years.I'm going to ask one more question.This cycle, you said something earlier.You said, and I don't want to misquote you,what did you say earlier about being a black manand getting another speaking against other black man?What did you say?
01:55:35Yeah, I mean, the black personwho criticizes other black people in publicwill have a job for life.We'll have a job for life.Okay.So I'm going to rely on,the wisdom of somebody who I've admired for a very long time, right?That's a really interesting arguments, a really interesting conversation that we continuously
01:56:01have.The times in which it's appropriate to call somebody out, call somebody in, about things thatyou feel like might be harmful or things you feel like they might be misinformed on.and the times when that dissension is being used as a sword to decapitate a movement.That's right.Now, we can have all kinds of conversations about what I call the bigger nigger theory,which is if you have a black man that is doing something,the one thing that they always do is go get a bigger nigger to come and say,
01:56:41don't listen to him, listen to me, and also go buy this thing.Okay.How do we get out of this?How do we do this in a way that is, to me, uplifting, it's useful.It's not based in dissension or war or likes and clicks.we've had the conversation about, I don't know,if it's whoever it is versus whoever else.Yeah, how do you get out of that?
01:57:16You have to have these talks,but at the same time,it seems as if we're in this eternal nonstopsense of war with each other,and we can't focus on the thing.The issue becomes about Colin Kaepernick versus Jay-Zand not Colin Kaepernick in what he's doing in the NFLor Jay-Z and what he's doing,
01:57:38with reform or whatever.Like we keep having these same conversations.We can't get on the same page.What's the elixir to this from you?Yeah. It's a great point.And I think, well, let's put it this way.There are two points.Point number one.
01:57:54You, especially us now, where media runs very, very quickly.I mean, internet time is warp speed, right?Of course.How many times do we not talk about things?Jamel and I talk about this all the time,about I have a feeling on this.Jamel Hill.Who is that?
01:58:12Exactly.You know,kind of an anonymous figure.Yeah.But, you know.I'm going to look into her.You say that?I'm going to look into her.
01:58:21I'm going to see what she's up to.Yeah.I don't remember how to spell her name, but I think she's important.You said Jamel?Jamil.Is it Jamili?Oh, it's Jamel.Okay.
01:58:32Yeah, I'm going to look at her.I'll see what she's got going on.We talk about this all the time.And I'm like, look, something goes down.Do I feel like, like,writing about this? Do I not feel like writing about this? One of the calculations in decidingnot to talk about this is you know that whatever you say, they're going to take what you sayand twist it and weaponize it against you. So that's a calculation that we are always battling
01:58:54with. Who's going to take your words and turn them into something that they weren't? That's thefirst thing. But the real thing is, I think the real answer to the question is, who are you in serviceof. If you're in service of yourself and you have a sense of self and you understand the arenathat you're in, not just how you feel, but the arena that you're also operating in, I think thoseconversations can be had. And I think those conversations can be defended and I think they can berobust and I think they can be as hard as they need to be because they're hard and they need to be had.But like in the case of this book or in the case of some of these other instances that we have today,if you're in service of people and you're being used, that's a totally different thing.
01:59:44You are allowing yourself to be weaponized. And it's a subtle difference, but it is a difference.I mean, I don't feel like I have any problems talking about things that I want to talk about because I'm not in service of anybody.I mean, now, does that mean I want to have a conversation about sinners versus one battle after another right now?Maybe not at the moment.But absolutely, I would love to have that call any time.Let's talk about that.But at the same time, you know that in retrospect in doing this research, Jackie Robinsonwas in service of, of a right wing that wanted nothing to do with black people except to demonize
02:00:28them.In fact, the only reason he was testifying in a hearing that was essentially called communistinfiltration of minority groups. So it was essentially a test of black loyalty. Proved to us thatyou're loyal to your own country. It's a setup. He did it for his reasons. But once again, to me,the bottom line is, you know, before you do and before you say anything, who are you in serviceof, right? Do you know, are you being used? And if you're not, if you're not sure,silence is an option. That last one is tough. Wraith, you got anything else?I guess as a follow-up, it's like when you look at athletes of today, do you see the
02:01:10legacies of Robinson and Robson in some of today's players? And if so, like with who? Orin what league do you see it? Or is it even possible with what you just said? Yeah, it's going to bereal interesting. It's going to be real interesting to see because post-COVID and now Trump 2.0,this is a different environment and it feels different. It's going to be interesting. I'm interesting tohow you guys operate this year. This is the 10th anniversary of Muhammad Ali's death in June. This is the10th anniversary of Colin Kaepernick taking a knee this August. The question that I asked at the end ofmy 2018 book about athlete protest and athlete activism, the heritage back in 2018, was whathappens when the protester becomes the power? These guys are the power now. And how long can you
02:01:59how long can you straddle that? How long can you, are we giving credit to Dwayne Wade for owning, you know, a percentage piece of the Utah Jazz or Serena Williams owning a piece of the Miami Dolphins or Shaq when he had a piece of the, you know, the Sacramento Kings? That's not the same lineage of Paul Robson, Jackie Robinson and Bill Russell. That's business. That's very, very, very different. And yet we celebrate that as if it is part of the same legacy,when it's not.And so the real question is,does that, you know, is that tree,has it broken off into something totally different?And I suspect that it has.And the question is going to be really how many,how many of these athletes?
02:02:51And do we need them?That's the other piece is that,you know,when you go to the 1800s before Robson,when you get into DeBois,the people who are our thinkers,We need more thinkers.Do I need a basketball player telling me where we should be going?
02:03:07I mean, that's the real issue.But we concentrate on them because they're the ones who made it.The black athlete, especially to me, is the most influential, most successfuland most visible black employee this country's ever produced.That puts a responsibility on them that they really shouldn't have.And so let's find out what we do with it, especially now.when black people and are in black journalism especially is under full on assault right now.Howard Bryant, thank you for joining us on higher learning, brother.
02:03:40Oh, my pleasure. Thank you.Before we go, I want to play, I want to play this audio for you.This is Shakari Richardson.It was arrested.She's driving 100 miles an hour in North Carolina.I would wipe that smile off your face.I'm charging McAnonaghanors with Orange County Sheriff's Upshire being stopped for dangerous,excessive speeding.
02:03:54I understand my tire at the back is like literally on 29.So you're driving at 100?Hold on, hold on, hold.You're driving at 104 miles an hourand a 65 mile an hour zonewith subpar equipment,flashing people to get out of your light,out of your way,
02:04:09following too close,using every lane to pass everybody,cutting me off,passing a car on the inside shoulderwith their hazard lights on.You're going to jailfor dangerous success of speeding.I'm so sorry,
02:04:20I did not mean to do that.My phone,I didn't even know my car to speeding.That's why they give you a speedometer.I totally understand.I could wait a kid just like,I really do not want to go to them.No.
02:04:29Most people don't, but you got to think about that before you do the speech.I need your license, your registration, and your insurance.All right, so she ends up going to jail.Mm-hmm.What do you think?Do I think she shouldn't have gone to jail?Is that what you're asking?No, I'm just asking.
02:04:45Chikarie Richardson is kind of a knucklehead, right?Well, she's young.She's got money.She's driving.She got pulled over with this driving and Aston Martin.Oh, get me.So it seems like, I'm not excusing it.It seems like she was just, like, out just.
02:04:59I mean, at that age, I'm sure that there was a time where I was driving excessivelyor speeding excessively at a time too.She got caught.I think, you know what I thought about this?Yes, she's speeding.Yes, she's wrong.She's pleading.Like, please don't take me to jail.
02:05:18Obviously, she's got a lot to lose.This isn't her first time in trouble with the law within the last year.She and her boyfriend, she was detained for hours at the airport,for an issue with her boyfriend,and he refused to file charges.Then, and with this instance, he was behind her,pulls over, when he sees her get pulled over,not gets into it with the police,
02:05:45but like what refuses to show his ID,blah, blah, blah, blah, long story short,he gets arrested.They search his car, drug paraphernalia.I think that they need to leave each other alone.That was my takeaway from this.The two of them keep getting in trouble together.They both have so much to lose.
02:06:08They're both extremely talented athletes.I just, we.Incredible.As you're preparing, you know, for this summer to race and the next Olympics,I just, you're doing more harm to each other than good.I just, like, see, they keep finding their way to trouble.I just want the best for themIt doesn't seem together
02:06:32That they're getting the bestThe best of each otherBut they really do love for each otherHe was down for her tooHe was like no I'm not going to show you my arrestWhy are you pulling her over?Why are you over?I get it I get it
02:06:44They clearly love each otherFeels a little toxicHe's bringing her downI didn't say he was bringing her downHe was bringing her downI didn't say he was bringing her downI mean she was the one that got caughtthat was charged with
02:06:59this is my thingattacking themI think it's actually okaythat she is a knuckleheadyeah she's youngyeah I think it's okayI think it's time to saythat she's a knucklehead though
02:07:15because these got you got these youngreckless you got these young knucklehead athletesright and you knowwe talk about them all the timebut I think it's okaythis came out and I waswasn't really surprised about this.My heart went out to her because I could tell the fear that she was operating under.
02:07:34The cops are there at the same time.It's like she's going to go to jail.That mug is coming out.Y'all don't know the power of that mug.They'll go crate.Take this from, we talked about TMZ before.Take this from that mug, the thought of that mug, that's what gets people going.It's not the arrest.
02:07:54The arrest is one thing.You could deal with that.That mug is what people.don't want. They do not want that fucking mug. That muggy is crazy. Right. So to me,I look at this. I'm like, yeah, this is something I would expect her to be involved in.She kind of, and she's in a knucklehead face. Maybe she's come out of it. I just want her story. I agree.Like, it's young. Like, who knows what I would do with sponsorship and fame and power and money.Like, you just don't know. So I'm not going to judge her for that, but man, I just want the
02:08:22stories about her to be about her success and how meaningful it is for her and what she's,overcome as an athlete, a gold medalist,rather than, here she goes again.Knucklehead shit.I think they need to break up.So if they break up, you think it'll change.They both just keep getting in trouble together.I don't know if it'll change, but like...
02:08:47All right, we're out of here, man.Take thing caps off, but, okay, first of all, for we do.Thank you to Matt Bellany.Thank you to Howard Bryant.Take your thing caps off.Do not stop learning.I'm Van Lee Jr.I'm Rachel Lindsay.
02:08:57Make sure you guys vote for us.NAACP Awards.NWACP award.Nice.
There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click any sentence in the transcript to leave one.