Horror Stories - 3 Creepy TRUE Gas Station Horror Stories That Will Keep You Up

Starting point is 00:00:00 You said this place was steps from the water. We just haven't found the steps yet. How much did we save? Enough. Enough to get lost! Or you could book a stay with Hilton. Welcome to your oceanfront room. Just steps from the water.

Starting point is 00:00:16 The Hilton sale is on now. Book on Hilton.com or the Hilton app and save up to 20% to get the stay you expected. When you want savings, not surprises. It matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay. Yamava Resort and Casino at San Manuel is California's number one entertainment destination for today's superstars. Catch the Jonas Brothers return to the Yamava Theater stage on April 30th,

Starting point is 00:00:41 the powerful vocals of Demi Lovato on May 17th and the signature Southern Country Rock of Eric Church on July 19th. Tickets on sale now at Yamavat Theater.com, only at Yamava Resort and Casino, celebrating its 40th anniversary. You in? Must be 21 to enter. Hello, everyone, and welcome back. to horror stories. I know many of you use these episodes to fall asleep, so before you drift off, I'd love it if you could leave a comment letting me know where you're listening from around the world. Also, don't forget to like and subscribe if you're enjoying the episodes.

Starting point is 00:01:26 Story 1. I'd been hauling parts for a distributor that specialized in tools out of Albuquerque for a few years. Most of the runs were long stretches down Interstate 40, starting at dusk and wrapping up a few hours after sunrise. March 3rd, 2004, a Sunday, seemed like it would be one of those uneventful nights. Pick up a crate of diesel injectors, drop them in Amarillo, bring back a few returns, and make it home in time for a late breakfast. I'd down too much convenience store coffee on the westbound leg, and around 2 a.m. I started scanning the empty desert for a place to stop. Just inside Key County, a lonely Texaco sign glowed like a red star about a hundred

Starting point is 00:02:10 yards off the service road. The station stood isolated, no motel, no nearby houses, just scrub desert and the distant murmur of traffic on the interstate. A pickup idled at the far pump, but no one sat inside. The main building was a block structure, gray paint faded to a sand-colored wash, a flickering fluorescent hung over the entrance, and a handwritten sign read, Open. Inside it smelled of old friar grease and floor cleaner. Classic rock crackled from a ceiling speaker. Behind bulletproof glass, the clerk sat with a grizzled beard and trucker cap, the kind of face you expect to see in the middle of nowhere.

Starting point is 00:02:51 I paid for gas, grabbed a gatorade, and slid it through the slot under the glass. Got the bathroom key, I asked. Without looking up from his receipt book, he said flatly, Bathroom's out of order, friend. Nobody uses it at night. He finally glanced my way. Pipe burst last month. The company won't fix it.

Starting point is 00:03:11 Sorry. All right, I said. But as I turned, something nagged at me. Down the hallway, the door marked restroom glowed with a strip of warm light beneath the frame. If the plumbing was busted, why keep the light on? I fueled up, still debating whether to drive another 40 miles to Tukum Kari. But the urge to stop one out. I went back inside, walked toward the bathroom.

Starting point is 00:03:36 The clerk's eyes followed me in the convex mirror. The door was locked. A taped sign read out of order. Still, I tapped lightly, just a single knock. Three seconds later, two knocks came back. Same rhythm, deliberate. For a moment, I thought maybe the clerk's buddy was in there smoking, but the hairs on my arms rose.

Starting point is 00:03:58 I tried the handle, solid. I returned to the counter. Someone's in there, I told him. He shook his head. No key. Told you the pipes. I just heard knocking. He lowered his voice.

Starting point is 00:04:14 Vent rattles sometimes. Winds bad this time of night. But out the window, the desert was perfectly still, frozen like a photograph. My gut twisted. I should have left. But walking away meant ignoring whatever was behind that door. I thought of my sister in Santa Fe. How once she'd called me scared because a stranger followed her.

Starting point is 00:04:36 on a trip. You don't turn your back on that kind of feeling. I sat in my van and dialed 911. The state police dispatcher asked for the mile marker and details. I think someone's locked in the bathroom at the Texaco off Route 392. Clerk won't open it. I expected a sigh, but she said they already had patrols nearby and would send them over. The weight stretched into 15 long minutes. The pickup at the pump didn't move. The clerk kept scribbling in his book. The coffee churned uneasily in my stomach, but the need for a restroom was gone, replaced by something colder. I imagined a kidnapped kid, a woman overdosing, somewhat abandoned. The mind always paints the worst when silence fills the room.

Starting point is 00:05:23 Finally, flashing blue lights swept across the lot. Two New Mexico State police cruisers rolled in. The clerk stepped out of his booth before the officers even reached the door, hands were raised like he'd rehearsed it. I watched from behind my windshield as they exchanged words. Too casual, too quick. Then they headed to the hallway. The clerk followed, jingling a ring of keys he'd sworn he didn't have. I climbed out, lingered near the ice freezer. One officer knocked on the bathroom door. Silence. He pressed his ear against it, then held out a hand for the keys. The clerk fumbled, tried three or four, shaking his head as though none fit. His hands trembled. The taller officer

Starting point is 00:06:08 signaled his partner, who radioed for backup. Then the first extended a baton, wedged it against the knob, and shoved. The old metal door gave way on the second hit. Something clattered inside. Then came the smell. Not rot, thank God, but stale sweat and ammonia. The officer shouted for paramedics. I edged forward just before they blocked my view. She was lying on her side by the mop sink, ankles chained with a bike lock, wrists tied, duct tape across her mouth, brown hair plastered to her face. Her eyes flick toward the sudden light, unfocused. I froze. People imagine they'll rush in, play the hero. In reality, you go rigid, mind refusing to process. The second officer pushed me back. Paramedics rushed in moments later. I V already primed. I caught her name over the

Starting point is 00:07:03 Medics Radio, Laura Martinez, 29. Two weeks earlier, a woman by that name had vanished after leaving her night shift at a nearby resort. Last scene driving a silver corolla later found abandoned off a 25. Same photo that had been pinned up at gas stations across the state. The clerk, name tag reading Devon, was cuffed against the cooler door. He kept repeating. I was just keeping her for somebody, that's all. He sounded annoyed more than scared. When they shoved him into the cruiser, he looked at me through the glass. For half a second, his face shifted. Not guilt, not fear, but resentment. Like a gambler caught hiding an ace. The officers took my statement by the pumps. I told them about the knocks, the excuses. The sergeant, Juarez, nodded, said I probably saved Laura's life. With dehydration and infection, she wouldn't have lasted much longer. When the adrenaline ebbed, I climbed into my van, hands shaking so bad I dropped the keys twice. The station looked ordinary again.

Starting point is 00:08:08 The same flickering sign, the same desert silence. But every corner seemed poisoned, steeped in malice. I skipped Amarillo, radioed dispatch, and drove straight back to Albuquerque with the stereo off. Don painted the Sandia Mountains pink while traffic flowed east. drivers oblivious to what that night had meant. For Laura, for me, she survived. The Albuquerque Journal later reported she had a fractured wrist, malnutrition. But she lived.

Starting point is 00:08:39 She told detectives Devin had picked her up in Santa Fe after a fight with her boyfriend outside a bar. He offered a ride, spiked her soda, and kept her captive while accomplices planned to sell her car and identity. Police tied him to two other disappearances the past year. Those women never turned up. Some nights between Gallup and Grants with the highway black except for my headlights, I replay those two knocks on the metal door. I wonder if she chose that rhythm, or if it was all she could manage bound in chains. I wonder how many drivers stopped at that station while she was locked inside.

Starting point is 00:09:14 How many believed the pipe story, how many walked away. Now I won't stop at remote stations unless I see the restroom key hanging from a hubcap-shaped fob behind the counter. Old trucker superstition, it means the clerk hands it over without excuses. When friends ask why I obsess over locked doors, I tell them about March 3rd, 2024. I say there's nothing supernatural out there on the highway at night, just people. And sometimes that's far worse. Before moving on to the next story, if you're visiting our channel for the first time, Don't forget to subscribe and hit the bell so you don't miss our upcoming horror stories. Story two.

Starting point is 00:10:01 I never thought a quiet stretch of desert highway could rob me of sleep, but the summer of 2024 proved me wrong. Every night shift I covered at the old Sanaco station on US 285, about 12 miles south of Vaughn, New Mexico, made the darkness feel a little heavier. I worked alone, locked inside a prefab boot that rattled whenever prairie winds struck the tin roof. My hours ran from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. and most shifts I served fewer than 20 customers. Beyond the orange sodium lights, coyotes howled, moths battered the windows. Radio stations faded into static long before midnight. It should have been monotonous,

Starting point is 00:10:42 but the desert at night always felt as if the world were holding its breath. On Monday, August 12th, that monotony cracked. I remember glancing at the register clock just after the late night news announced, the next day's heat advisories. At 2.40 a.m., a faded Greenford Taurus veered off the road, rolled past both gas pumps, then rejoined the asphalt without stopping. Its headlights were dim, the rear passenger hubcap was missing, and a long scrape stretched across the passenger side. I figured it was just a lost traveler and went back to cleaning the coffee station. Still, the image stuck with me. The driver hadn't hesitated, hadn't tapped the brakes.

Starting point is 00:11:24 like fueling had never even crossed their mind. The next night, the Taurus came again at exactly the same time. Same lazy loop through the lot, tires brushing the hardened dirt, before vanishing back into the dark. On the third night, I waved, hoping the driver might roll down a window and ask for directions. But the car only swung close enough for its high beams to light up my chest before gliding off. I thought I saw a glint in the side glass, but no face. Just a diffuse glow from the dash.

Starting point is 00:11:57 That unsettled me more than the visits themselves. By Thursday I was waiting for it. Leaning on the counter, pen and hand over the shift log, ready to note a pattern, because patterns bring comfort in places like this. Sure enough, two 40 sharp headlights cut across the pumps and vanished again. I wrote it down. Green torres circles lot.

Starting point is 00:12:20 But the act gave no relief. When I showed the note to Manny the morning close, He laughed and said maybe it was a deputy practicing turns. I reminded him county patrols drove white broncos, not rusted 90s sedans. Many only shrugged. The next week played like a broken record. Every night but Sunday, the torus appeared at 240. Once it lingered at pump four for a second.

Starting point is 00:12:46 Another time the headlights flickered as if the battery were dying. Curiosity beat out caution. On Tuesday, August 20th, I stepped out. and jogged toward the sedan waving. Whoever sat behind the wheel never looked at me. The car floated by, engine purring low and even, then sped off. In the glow of its taillights, I noticed the plate lamp was dead. That's why I still couldn't read the numbers.

Starting point is 00:13:11 Desert storms always announced themselves with the smell of ozone and distant rumbles. On September 3rd, a stormline rolled up from the south, dragging a curtain of dry lightning that painted the prairie violet. Around 2.30, static prickled through the booth's metal siding, and for once I welcomed the distraction. At 2.40, right on schedule, the Taurus emerged. This time it stopped at Pump 4 and stayed, engine idling unevenly. Five minutes passed. Warm rain began to patter on the concrete. Ten minutes, and the car still sat running. Windows opaque, wipers screeching over a windshield caked with red dust. I grabbed my flashlight, stepped up to the skyed. I grabbed my flashlight, stepped into the damp air and walked toward it. My throat dried with each step. At the driver's mirror

Starting point is 00:13:59 I heard the click of the lock. The door creaked open slowly. The dome light never came on. The front seat sat empty, sagging into torn gray upholstery. No keys in the ignition, though the engine still hummed. My beam caught the dash just in time to see the speedometer needle jump from zero to twenty, then dropped back. Every hair on my body bristled. I stumbled back, heart pounding. The door slammed shut as if a driver had shoved it. Headlights flared, the wheel turned a quarter, and the torus rolled off alone, steering itself onto the highway.

Starting point is 00:14:36 I barricaded myself inside the booth, bolts drawn, eyes glued to the safety glass until its taillights vanished. At dawn, Manny found me hunched over the DVR console, replaying the feed. Even in grainy footage, the cabin looked as empty as I'd seen it. At 252, the driver's door opened, hung a jar for 13 seconds, then shut again. The car idled 30 seconds more than drove off on its own. Mani whistled, said I should send the clip to his cousin who loved urban legend podcasts. I wanted a logical answer.

Starting point is 00:15:11 I saved the file to a thumb drive, called the Torrance County non-emergency line, and ate a stale cinnamon roll while deputies took their time showing up. They were polite but spent more minutes joking about. haunted cars than taking notes. One suggested filing it as abandoned vehicle. The other guest maybe someone had rigged remote controls to spook travelers. Still, who would waste gas on a prank at a forgotten desert station? They left with nothing promised but a line in the daily dispatch email.

Starting point is 00:15:41 Insomnia became routine. Afternoons I lay in my cot behind the Vaughn grocery, replaying the clip on my phone, pausing on the frame where the tourists crossed beneath the canopy. It should have looked empty, yet the shadows on the windshield felt too dense, as if something pooled there. Unable to drop it, I called a friend in Santa Fe's DMV office. I'd finally caught the plate, N. M-413 WLT. She rang back after closing, registered to a woman named Marianne Hall of Roswell. Registration expired March 2020. Same month the car was declared totaled after a rollover near Santa Rosa. salvage yard crushed it that December.

Starting point is 00:16:23 The fact that a scrap car long destroyed was still visiting my pumps froze my blood. On my next day off, I drove to Santa Rosa. Robbie, a salvage yard worker, pulled up the intake photo. Same torus, roof-crushed, windshield spider-webbed. He swore they cut it and compacted it years ago. When I showed him the video on the dusty office computer, he shoved his chair back so fast it screeched. He muttered something about it.

Starting point is 00:16:50 stolen plates, but even he couldn't explain how a demolished car's tags were riding around hundreds of miles away. September slid into October. The nights cooled, the sky sharpened into brittle stars. Each night shift carried the same inevitability, the silence right before 240. The torus never missed. Some nights had idled only seconds, others long minutes savoring the tension. I sought proof to steady myself. On October, On October 2nd, I taped a sign to pump four, out of service. Two nights later, the Torah stopped there anyway. Headlights fixed on the warning.

Starting point is 00:17:30 It stayed until 250, then rolled off. That night I decided I wouldn't last until Christmas, no matter what my regional manager wanted. I put in my notice for Halloween, figured at least it would make a neat ending for someone retelling the story. On October 12th, a brief outage killed the station lights for 10 seconds. When they flicked back, the sedan sat one foot from my booth, driver's door ajar, seatbelt dangling like a limp arm. I stayed locked in until dawn.

Starting point is 00:18:01 By then I didn't care about ridicule, only about surviving alone with a machine that moved without a soul. I begged corporate to replace me early, but nobody wanted graveyard shift. So Halloween it was. The air was brittle that night. Fog rolled off the prairie, low enough that the lamps looked like crowns glowing white. By midnight the highway was a river of ink. At 1 a.m. I stepped out with coffee just to hear something besides my own breath. Coyotes howled west, then fell silent.

Starting point is 00:18:34 The fog muffled my boots. Looking back, the booth floated in haze, cut off from the earth. By 1.30, power died completely. Poulbs hissed and went dark. Coolers silenced. Only the DVR and its battery light remained. I lit my flashlight, its beam swallowed by the fog, and tried the ceiling switches. Nothing. The out-of-service sign flapped in the dry wind. I counted the minutes. 2.39, then 2.40. Beyond the lot of faint glow pierced the veil. Dim yellow headlights slid toward Pump 4. The Taurus entered soundlessly, no

Starting point is 00:19:12 gravel crunch, engine off, window sealed. It stopped right in front of the sign. The pump hose slipped free, fell to the pavement, swung as if guided by an unseen hand. The driver's door opened. A hot breath of air drifted out, smelling of dust and coolant. I crouched behind the counter, gripping the dead flashlight until my knuckles hurt. From somewhere inside the booth came footsteps on vinyl. Slow, deliberate, heel, dragged toe. Candy bars razzed. in their rack. Another step. Something brushed the lottery stand. I held my breath until my ribs ached. The air tasted metallic. The steps stopped behind the counter. Two knuckles tapped the laminate above me. Not a summons, more a patient reminder that I'd been noticed. I pressed my

Starting point is 00:20:03 forehead to my knees and stayed still until a gray line of dawn broke in the east. When I stood, everything looked normal. The lock still latched, yet my shift log lay open on the counter, on the page where I'd first written about the torres circling the lot. In the margin, a black, greasy print, larger than mine, stained the paper. I cleared my locker in minutes. By 8 a.m. I was on a bus to Albuquerque, last paycheck unclaimed. Since then I've moved twice. The thumb drive with the video stays buried under winter socks in a drawer I rarely open. Still some nights at 2.40, my body tuned to that hour. I replay the file. The camera shows a sedan rolling into an empty lot, stopping at a pump, then pulling away driverless. There's no glitch where it fades.

Starting point is 00:20:54 It simply drives forward and vanishes past the frame, like a thought slipping away on waking. Local news still runs bits about phantom cars on the interstate. In December, a State Patrol dash cam caught what looked like the same torus drifting between lanes near Klein's corners. The trooper lit up his siren, but by the next hill, the car, and its heat signature, were gone. He later said he figured it had pulled into the scrub, though no track showed in the dust. I want to believe state lines mean something, but three nights ago, gassing up at a loz near Delhart, Texas, my phone read 238. A pair of faint headlights wavered down US 54, we've weaving like the wheel needed steadying. I paid 20 bucks, left with the tank half full and drove

Starting point is 00:21:41 home 13 miles without checking the mirror once. Now I wake at 2.40 every night. The world stays silent, and in that silence I swear I hear the far off drone of an old engine. Not too near, not too far to place. I tell myself it's only in my head that the Torres stayed behind in New Mexico, circling a lot that means nothing to me anymore. But when the hour comes, my heart pounds like it did behind that counter. I remember the footsteps, that patient knock, and the greasy mark in my log. It reminds me that in the desert, roads don't end. They just keep stretching into the dark, waiting for someone like me, alone in a forgotten station, listening to the motor of something that no longer belongs to any human hand. Story three.

Starting point is 00:22:35 I used to think the worst that could happen on a late-night road trip was a blown tire or caffeine crash. That belief changed on a damp Friday in July, 2023, somewhere between Kansas City and Topeka. When a 10-minute gas stop became a memory I keep dissecting every time the clock nears midnight. My wife, Laura and I had spent the day loading a rental van with her grandmother's furniture in Overland Park. The plan was simple. Drive through the night to Denver before the weekend traffic, crash at her brother's apartment, and unload in the morning. By the 10th, time we merged onto I-70 heading west, the sun was gone, and storm clouds were piling over the Flint hills like bruises. Lara dozed in the back with her knees curled up, earbuds in.

Starting point is 00:23:22 Classic rock whispered from the dash, too faint to cover the low hum of the highway joints. Just after 1145 p.m., the fuel alarm chimed. I remembered a Philip 66 in a little town called Paxico, one of those exits with a single street light and a silo that pretends to be a skyline. line. The place was open 24 hours, and I needed coffee as badly as the van needed gas. Two minutes later, the red and black sign appeared, flickering against the low clouds. I slid under the fluorescent canopy, pulled up to Pump 6, and shut off the engine. The air smelled of spilled diesel and wet dust. Bathroom? Lara mumbled. I nodded toward the store, kissed her knuckles, and stepped out. A cross from me at Pump 3 sat a lone sedan, a gray Nissan Altima with South Dakota plates,

Starting point is 00:24:14 the trunk smeared with road grime. Its driver stood with his back to me, hood up despite the warm bathwater thick air. He was the only other customer. Inside the clerk leaned on the counter scrolling her phone. I unscrewed the tank cap, slid my card, and pressed regular. As the pump clicked alive, I heard it. Three muffled thuds like knuckles wrapping. on a hollow door. They came from the Altima's direction. The hooded figure froze, then reached for

Starting point is 00:24:43 the nozzle. Another round of knocks followed, faster, urgent. I glanced sideways. He was still facing away, but he turned his head just enough for me to catch his profile, pale skin, sharp cheekbones, eyes that caught the canopy light like glass. He stared straight at me. Everything all right, man. I tried to sound casual, but my voice felt hollow. No answer. He hung up the nozzle without pumping a drop, slid behind the wheel, and slammed the door. The knocking stopped. The sedan screeched in reverse, headlights sweeping across my knees, then shot toward the exit. I memorized the last two plate letters. C-Z. A heartbeat later, its taillights vanished down County Road K-92, swallowed by the dark. The world went silent except for the gurgle of gas filling my tank.

Starting point is 00:25:37 Rain began to fall, warm scattered drops that spotted the concrete. I yanked the hose early, paid for 22 gallons, and hurried inside. The clerk, a college kid in a Washburn University sweatshirt, raised an eyebrow as I tried to find words. That guy in the Altima, I said, voice shaking. Something was banging inside his trunk, like someone knocking. She blinked, glanced at the empty pumps, and reached for the store phone. There's a sheriff's substation when exit west, she said.

Starting point is 00:26:10 I'll call. She dialed before I could add more, gave dispatch the partial plate, the direction he left, and my account. When she handed me the receiver, the operator took my statement, promised a patrol would check the area, and asked me to keep my cell nearby. Back in the van, Laura clutched her coffee like it might spill if she breathed wrong. The rain thickened, drumming on the windshield. I merged onto I-70 replaying that stare, the sudden silence, the knocks. We drove 20 uneasy miles before blue lights filled the mirror.

Starting point is 00:26:46 Relief surged. Maybe they'd found the Altima. But the cruiser flew past us with its siren off, vanishing into the dark. At 12.32 a.m., my phone rang with a Kansas number. I put it on speaker. Mr. Henley, this is Deputy Armstrong Wabon, County. You reported suspicious activity in Paxico? Yes. We located a Nissan Altima abandoned on Moorhead Road about seven miles from the station. Keys still in the ignition. No driver.

Starting point is 00:27:17 Lara covered her mouth. Armstrong continued. There's unusual damage inside the trunk. We'd like you to come to the scene for a formal statement while it's fresh. I want her to refuse to keep heading west, but something in his clipped urgent tone made sense. saying no, feel wrong. Send me the location, I said. The pin dropped north of a place called Keene. I followed a two-lane road arched over with oaks. The storm erased the horizon. High beams cut only 30 yards ahead. Lara muttered this was a mistake, but curiosity and duty pulled us on. Ten minutes later, strobing lights bounced through the trees. Two cruisers and an ambulance churned mud by a trailhead sign reading Slow Creek Wildlight.

Starting point is 00:28:02 area. An officer in a rain slicker waved us in, Armstrong by his patch. He led us past yellow tape down a spur where the Altima crouched like a wounded animal. The trunk yawned open under floodlights. The smell hit me first, iron, dry, and metallic. The trunk liner was ripped out, foam scattered like entrails. Long scratch marks scored the underside of the lid, some downward some sideways deep enough to bear steel splintered fingernails lay on the stained carpet a crimson smear stretched from the latch across the weather strip bile rose in my throat armstrong shone his flashlight on the gouges fresh he said whoever was in there fought with everything they had rain streaked laura's hair and neck i recited the gas station encounter twice while another deputy recorded they asked if i'd if i'd I'd seen anyone else in the car, heard voices, smelled anything odd. No, I said, just the banging. And that look, I added the plate fragment and the South Dakota registration.

Starting point is 00:29:11 Armstrong's jaw tightened. Stolen yesterday in Sioux Falls. Owners safe at home. The forensics team finished photographing the trunk. One muttered Jesus before slamming it shot. No one living or dead had been found in the woods. Trackers would start at dawn. At 2.10 a.m. Armstrong released us. The rain had thinned mist. He asked us to stop by the Alma Sheriff's

Starting point is 00:29:36 office the next afternoon for a written affidavit. We promised, then left. Lara cried silently in the passenger seat. My fists ached from gripping the wheel. We traded drivers near Selina. Dawn bled pink behind shredded clouds. Neither of us spoke until the radio, at seven, announced an amber alert. Missing teen Jessica Keller. Sixteen brown hair five feet four inches. The report noted chipped blue polish on her right hand. I thought of the broken nails scattered in the Altima's trunk and pulled over to keep from vomiting. Denver blurred past in a haze of exhaustion and dread. We unloaded like automaton's nodding through small talk with Laura's brother. Every slam of a door in the apartment lot made us jump. Sunday morning Armstrong calls.

Starting point is 00:30:26 called again. Search teams had found tracks leading into slow creek, but rain erased them a quarter mile in. No suspect, no victim. The car would go to the state lab. Regional headlines blared, abandoned car, signs of struggle. Online theories swirled, cartel hit, trafficking ring, runaway prank. I kept off the phone. A week later, we returned the van. That night I replayed the memory of his hooded stance, those unblinking eyes cold and curious, like studying an insect. Every thud echoed in my skull, demanding help I hadn't given. Mid-September, a detective called, Prince and the Altima matched a parolee from Oklahoma, Daniel Phelps, priors for assault and kidnapping. He'd missed a check-in since June. Pond shop receipts placed him in Wichita three days before we saw the car. Still no trace of him

Starting point is 00:31:22 or the girl. By October, Cottonwoods burned gold along the Missouri. Laura began sleeping again. I pretended. Sometimes detectives called, asking me to redescribe Phelps's posture, his stare, any limp jewelry. Memory betrayed me, each retelling thinner. On Halloween morning, hunters found a shallow grave two miles from where the Altima sat. Inside was Jessica Keller, wrapped in a motel shower curtain, wrists bound with tape. The coroner ruled she died the night we heard the knocking. Cause asphyxiation. Her photo in the grainy frame of the hooded man at the gas station filled Kansas newscasts for days. I quit my job that December. Driving at night drenched my palms and sweat. Family trips happened only at noon. Still insomnia stuck. Near midnight I'd paced the

Starting point is 00:32:16 apartment in the dark, listening to the faint hiss of traffic six-floor. below. Sometimes I swore I heard a soft knocking rise from the street. Three thuds, a pause, three more. Always three. I'd cling to the window sill until sunrise. Armstrong kept in touch through spring 2024. Sightings of Phelps popped up in Montana, Oregon, each one colder. The FBI believes he prowls truck stops preying on runaways. The knocks we heard were Jessica's last plea. I've rewound the what-ifs until the tape broke. What if I'd slammed on the trunk, forced a confrontation? The clerk might have hit the panic button. Jessica might have lived. Then I remember Phelps's stare, the calm way he drove off, like any interruption was just a bump in

Starting point is 00:33:05 the road. Maybe he had a gun. Maybe I'd be dead too. This July marks two years. Lara and I now live in Fort Collins closer to mountains than highways. She'd teaches ceramics. I work days at a hardware store. Most nights end with wine, a movie, and the illusion of normal life. But at 11.45 p.m., I always feel the pull to check plates under the street lamp. Some nights a dusty sedan idles by the curb. Trunk turned toward me. Exhaust curling like a question. I tell myself it's a neighbor, a delivery driver, a coincidence. Then the silence blooms thick, accusing. And in that hush, I swear I hear three knocks, firm and desperate, followed by the slam of a trunk that will echo in my head for the rest of my life.

Horror Stories - 3 Creepy TRUE Gas Station Horror Stories That Will Keep You Up

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.