Horror Stories - 4 Disturbing New House Horror Stories | Real Life Scary Stories

Starting point is 00:00:00 You said this place was steps from the water. We just haven't found the steps yet. How much did we save? Enough. Enough to get lost! Or you could book a stay with Hilton. Welcome to your oceanfront room. Just steps from the water.

Starting point is 00:00:16 The Hilton sale is on now. Book on Hilton.com or the Hilton app and save up to 20% to get the stay you expected. When you want savings, not surprises. It matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay. Yamava Resort and Casino at San Manuel is California's number one entertainment destination for today's superstars. Catch the Jonas Brothers return to the Yamava Theater stage on April 30th,

Starting point is 00:00:41 the powerful vocals of Demi Lovato on May 17th, and the signature Southern Country Rock of Eric Church on July 19th. Tickets on sale now at Yamavat Theater.com, only at Yamava Resort and Casino, celebrating its 40th anniversary. You in? Must be 21 to enter. Hello everyone and welcome back to horror stories. I know many of you use these episodes to fall asleep, so before you drift off, I'd love it if you could leave a comment letting me know where you're listening from around the world. Also, don't forget to like and subscribe if you're enjoying the episodes.

Starting point is 00:01:24 Story one, we had only been living in the house for two weeks when he appeared. My husband and I had just finished unpacking the last boxes, and I was finally starting to settle into a routine. waking up early to prepare lesson plans, sipping coffee on the porch while the first rays of sun lit up the tops of the palm trees in the neighborhood. The area was peaceful, a kind of quiet so deep that it made me realize how tense I had been before. In the evenings we went for walks, strolling along streets lined with jaccaranda trees and immaculate gardens. Neighbors waved and we responded with smiles. Everything was so different from the apartment we had lived in before.

Starting point is 00:02:05 No sirens, no constant banging from the upstairs neighbor, no perpetual city noise. Just silence, and I loved it. It was a Tuesday evening. I remember because that day I had a staff meeting that ran longer than usual, and I barely got home before dusk. I kicked off my shoes, left my bag on the bench by the door, and had just reached the kitchen when the doorbell rang. My husband was still at work, so I wiped my hands on a dish towel and went to answer. A man was there. Mid-40s, neat appearance,

Starting point is 00:02:39 wearing jeans and a plain white t-shirt. Nothing strange. Average build, neatly trimmed beard, no wild look in his eyes. He smiled politely and asked, Is Casey here? It took me a couple of seconds to process it. I definitely wasn't expecting that.

Starting point is 00:02:57 I'm sorry there's no Casey here. We just moved in. His smile disappeared for a moment. That's fine. Sorry to bother you. He turned around, hands in his pockets, walking away slowly without hesitation. I watched him leave, thinking maybe he had the wrong address. That Friday, he came back. I recognized him immediately. I'm looking for Casey, he said again, this time with a firmer tone. She's expecting me. I looked at him confused. I'm telling you, we moved in only two weeks ago. I don't know anyone by that name. His face remained expressionless, but he tilted his head toward the house as if trying to listen to something inside.

Starting point is 00:03:41 That's strange, he muttered. I just spoke with her. I narrowed my eyes trying to understand. When was that? Recently, he replied, vague as always. He shrugged indifferently. Sorry for the confusion. And he left again, slower this time, as if he wanted to leave a message.

Starting point is 00:04:03 That night I told my husband. We were sitting on the couch, a cooking show rerun playing in the background, when he frowned with his arms crossed. If he comes back, I'll talk to him. Three days later, he returned. This time my husband answered the door. He didn't raise his voice, but his stance was rigid. I don't know who Casey is, but you need to stop coming here.

Starting point is 00:04:27 The man remained silent. This time there was no apology, no smile, just an empty stare fixed on my husband's face as if he wanted to memorize it. Fine, he said at last. He turned and left. We thought that would be the end of it. We were wrong. A week later, I noticed a car parked in front of the house, always at the same time. Around 9 p.m. Engine off lights off an emotionless figure in the driver's seat. The first night I ignored it, assuming it was someone waiting to pick someone up. happens all the time. But the next day it was there again, and the next. Always the same car,

Starting point is 00:05:09 a dark sedan with tinted windows completely still. One night I stood at the upstairs window for 20 minutes watching it. The silhouette didn't move once. No smoking, no looking at a phone, nothing, just sitting. I mentioned it to my husband who said he hadn't noticed, though I could tell he started paying more attention afterward. A few days later I went out to water the plants at dusk. As I passed the side yard, the motion sensor light flicked on. There was no wind, no raccoons, nothing, just the dry click of the bulb warming up and casting long shadows against the fence. Another night we found the back gate completely open. My husband swore he had locked it earlier that day. We checked the fence, no signs of damage or forced entry, just an open gate in that

Starting point is 00:05:57 strange silence that seemed to be watching us. I couldn't relax anymore. I stopped sitting on the porch. I kept the curtains drawn all day. I started locking the bedroom door at night, even with my husband home. I filed a non-urgent online report. It took several days for them to respond. The officer on the phone was polite but clearly unconcerned. It's probably just a misunderstanding, he said. Maybe a delivery driver or someone looking for a friend who used to live there. We'll send someone by from time to time. That didn't reassure me. One Thursday night I was home alone, grading papers at the dining table. My husband was working late, covering a hospital shift. I had my laptop open, half a sandwich on the plate beside me,

Starting point is 00:06:46 and was halfway through a student essay on Romeo and Juliet when the doorbell rang. It was 9.30. I stood up slowly, cautiously. The house was silent, the hallway to the front door sunk in darkness. I switched on the porch light before approaching. I waited a few seconds and cracked the door open. No one was there. I stepped outside just enough to look around. That's when I saw it. Mud on the welcome mat, thin streaks and footprints, just a pair. They didn't lead back to the walkway. They veered off toward the side yard. I slammed the door shut and locked every bolt and chain. Whispering, I called my husband, hiding in the downstairs bathroom.

Starting point is 00:07:30 He stayed on the line, telling me to breathe, to stay quiet, and to call the police. I did. Twenty minutes later, two officers arrived. They searched the yard,

Starting point is 00:07:41 the fence, the porch, nothing. One of them stayed with me and asked what the man looked like. I described him as best I could. He nodded slowly. I think I know who it is. He used to live here.

Starting point is 00:07:55 He was evicted for certain issues, What kind of issues, I asked. He hesitated. I can't tell you officially. But if he comes back, don't open the door. Just call us. When my husband got home, we searched the house room by room. Nothing broken, nothing missing. But there was something in the air, a feeling that whoever had been there hadn't tried to get inside. He just wanted us to know he was still around. Later that week I pulled out the purchase documents for the house and combed through them carefully. Nowhere did the name Casey appear. Only the seller's name. Even so, that name stuck in my mind. We installed security cameras, changed routines. We didn't answer the door to strangers,

Starting point is 00:08:42 let calls go to voicemail, avoided walking the dog after dark. For a while, nothing else happened. The car stopped showing up. The light stayed off. house started to feel like ours again. Until one morning I opened the door to collect a package and froze. There was no box, just a sheet of paper taped to the door. In thick red capital letters it read, tell Casey I will find her. I always do. I never knew Casey, but somehow I became her shadow. Story two, I moved into the house in July of 2020, right in the middle of lockdown. Everything was strange then. Empty streets, the world at a standstill.

Starting point is 00:09:30 And even though everyone was isolated, I felt I needed to be even more alone. I had just ended a long relationship that should have been over months earlier. Work had gone fully remote, and my apartment lease had ended. Eugene had that calm, laid-back vibe. It was accessible, full of trees and trails. And I thought that if I was going to be stuck somewhere to rebuild myself, it should at least be a place where I could really breathe. The house I found was a craftsman-style bungalow from the 1930s

Starting point is 00:10:01 on the edge of the University District. In the photos, it looked charming and in person it wasn't bad. Two bedrooms, original hardwood floors, tall windows flooding every room with light, and a porch that wrapped around the front and one side of the house. The porch looked amazing in the pictures, though in reality several boards were rotted and it needed a good power wash.

Starting point is 00:10:24 I didn't care. After all, it was mine. Or at least it would be as long as I rented it. And it was peaceful. I thought I'll stay here for a year, maybe two, reset everything and get my life back on track. There was only one detail I didn't like, the attic. Or more specifically, the attic door.

Starting point is 00:10:45 It was in the hallway ceiling, one of those square panels with a cord dangling down to pull. From the first day it never closed completely. One corner always hung slightly down, as if it didn't quite fit. I assumed it was warped wood, normal for an old house. But what really stood out was the temperature. Every time I passed through that hallway, it felt like I was walking into a bubble of air different from the rest of the house. All the rooms stayed cool, sometimes even chilly at night.

Starting point is 00:11:15 But right under the attic door, the air was hot, stifling. and it wasn't just heat. It was humid like when someone has just stepped out of a steaming shower. The first night I noticed it immediately. I walked beneath the attic door and stopped because I could feel it on my skin, like warm breath. I kept the thermostat low, the ceiling fan on in the bedroom, and the windows cracked. Still, no matter the ventilation, the hallway always had that damp, stagnant heat. I told myself it had to be an insulation issue,

Starting point is 00:11:48 that the attic trapped heat and condensation. That made sense. I always try to find a logical explanation for what unsettles me. But the truth was, the door remained ajar. Never fully open, never fully shut. And I found myself checking it more often than I wanted to admit. On the way to the bathroom, before bed, quick glances just to be sure it wasn't hanging lower than before. Then little things started happening.

Starting point is 00:12:18 things that on their own wouldn't have bothered me, but together started to get under my skin. The first was the cereal box. I always keep it in the cabinet, but twice I found it sitting on top of the refrigerator. I thought maybe I had been distracted, maybe tired, but then I began noticing that in the morning the refrigerator door would be open. Not wide, just enough for the light inside to stay on, as if someone had opened it, looked inside and forgotten to close it. I live alone. I always have. And I'm almost obsessive about those little details, so seeing the fridge ajar didn't sit well with me. A few days later I saw my sneakers by the front door flipped upside down, not kicked or shoved aside, perfectly turned over, toes pointing toward the wall. I hadn't even worn them that day. That's when I started taking photos, small things, my keys, my shoes, the cereal box. the position of the blinds. I snapped a quick picture before bed so I could compare in the morning. I didn't tell anyone. I didn't want to sound paranoid, but I needed to be sure. A week later, I was in bed around 2.30 a.m. half asleep scrolling through Twitter. The house was dead quiet,

Starting point is 00:13:37 no wind, no traffic. And then I heard it, clear as day. A cough, dry, short, like someone clearing their throat. It came from directly above me. My house is one story. There's nothing above except the attic. I shot upright. My phone slipped from my hands onto the blanket. I didn't move again. I just stared at the ceiling, waiting for footsteps, movement, anything. But nothing came. I didn't sleep the rest of the night. I stayed awake, ears straining, waiting for the sound to return. It never did. The next day I called my friend Josh. I didn't tell him everything, just that I thought someone might be messing with me.

Starting point is 00:14:23 He laughed, probably an opossum or an attic goblin. Leave it some peanut butter and make peace. I laughed too, but without conviction. I couldn't let it go. I started reading stories about people finding squatters living in their attics or walls. Turns out it happens more often than you'd think. Some of them stayed in other people's homes for weeks before being caught. I knew I had to check.

Starting point is 00:14:49 The next afternoon I grabbed a flashlight, a broom handle, and a kitchen knife just in case. I opened the hatch and pulled down the folding ladder. The heat hit me like a wall, thicker than ever. The smell was worse too, sweat and garbage. I climbed a couple of rungs and shone the flashlight inside. Empty. No furniture, just exposed beams, fiberglass. insulation and dust, but the air felt used as if someone had been breathing it. I didn't climb all the way up.

Starting point is 00:15:20 I convinced myself it wasn't necessary. I had seen enough. That night I set up my phone on a tripod aimed at the attic door. I left it recording, kept the hallway light on, and tried to sleep. Every creek in the house made me jump. The next morning, as soon as I woke up, I checked the video. Six hours of practically nothing. I went through it first. frame by frame, and then, at 3.47 a.m. it happened. The attic door moved. First a faint tremor, then it opened slowly, carefully without a sound. A bare leg appeared, then a hand gripping the frame. A thin figure began to descend the ladder. No shoes, pale skin. I couldn't see the face. The light was behind them, but the silhouette was unmistakable, bony slow. They stepped out of frame,

Starting point is 00:16:13 I froze the video. My body went cold. Then I ran to the kitchen and vomited. I called the police. They arrived quickly, two officers. I showed them the video. One raised his eyebrows, the other asked if I had checked the attic. They climbed up with flashlights and gloves. Ten minutes later, one called the other over. They had found a rolled-up foam mattress, an empty jar of peanut butter, two water bottles, and a spiral notebook. notebook was filled with drawings, all of me, in pencil, crude sketches made from strange angles, through windows from above, from behind the couch. One showed me eating at the table, another watching TV, another sleeping. The officers said they'd lift fingerprints, file a report, maybe check neighbor's security cameras, but they didn't seem optimistic. According to them, the guy had probably already left. That same day I packed a bag and left. I spent a week at Josh's place before hiring movers to get the rest of my things.

Starting point is 00:17:19 Now I only rent apartments on upper floors. I don't even consider places with attics or basements. Too risky. I used to think of myself as a rational person, but there's nothing rational about knowing a stranger was watching you sleep from your own ceiling. Story three, I bought the house with that rush you only found. feel when you think you've finally cracked the secret. It was going to be my first real flip. A place I'd live in for a while, remodel little by little, and then sell for a nice profit.

Starting point is 00:17:55 I called it a transition space, not permanent, just something in between where I was and where I wanted to be. On the outside, it seemed perfect. Mid-century charm, red brick with ivy climbing one side, and a massive oak tree in the front yard that tossed down leaves like confetti every time the wind blew. Inside it was an old house creaking here and there, but nothing I hadn't seen before. I had walked through properties with floors warped like waves and ceiling sagging like stretched fabric. This one just had character, hardwood floors, original trim, a working fireplace, and a sunroom that glowed gold in the afternoons. I moved in during the first week of October. Cool mornings, golden light, sweater weather, the kind of

Starting point is 00:18:43 bottom you wish you could bottle. I spent the first days painting the kitchen cabinets and sketching out plans for what I'd fix with my next commission check. It was during the second week that I noticed the hatch. It was in the hallway closet beneath a loose board that shifted every time I stepped inside. I stored cleaning supplies there and always felt that uneven dip under my feet. One day I pulled everything out, rolled up my sleeves and lifted the board. Beneath it was a square of wood painted the same color as the floor. No hinges, no handle, flush with the rest of the boards, but not nailed down. Someone had taken the time to make it blend in. That night I grabbed a crowbar from the garage and pried it open. The sound was unforgettable, like the house exhaling.

Starting point is 00:19:31 Dust blasted up into my face, thick and suffocating. I shone my flashlight and saw steps, not a staircase, irregular wooden steps descending into a crawl space. I should have waited for daylight, but curiosity has always been my worst flaw. I went down. The air changed, cooler but not cold. It smelled of mold and something waxy. The space wasn't what I expected, much larger than usual, deeper. I could stand without stooping. The floor was mostly dirt, but in the center someone had laid down old boards. forming a kind of platform. On top were dozens of burned down candles, reduced to stubs, melted into the wood, arranged in an almost perfect circle. In the middle a pile of dried petals,

Starting point is 00:20:20 around them clumps of hair, some long, some short, and barely visible under a thin layer of dust. A Polaroid photo. I picked it up, wiped it clean with my hand. It was the living room, the same one I had been standing in minutes earlier. The photo looked old, faded, but the furniture arrangement was identical to mine. And I knew I hadn't copied anything from the previous owner. I hadn't even seen the listing photos until after I moved in. In the middle of the room in the picture was someone, a person wearing a mask, not Halloween, not store-bought.

Starting point is 00:20:57 It looked handmade, papier-mache over burlap, with hollow black eyes and no mouth. empty. I backed away, left the space open and went upstairs. I sat on the couch and stared at the photo for a long time. In the end, I shoved it into a kitchen drawer and tried to convince myself it was just some weird relic left behind by a former owner. The next day I noticed my dog Bentley acting strange. He's a rescue, calm but with sharp instincts. He approached the closet door, sniffed, whined, and then refused to go back. I called him, tried luring him with a treat, but he backed away and lay down at the far end of the couch. That's when I started to think maybe something really was off.

Starting point is 00:21:42 In the days that followed, I caught a faint smell coming from the closet, a mix of extinguished candles, wet leaves, and paint. Constant, I thought, maybe I had stirred up mold, but when I checked, there was nothing growing. The space looked the same. I kept telling myself to let it go. old houses have smells but every night i thought about that photo a week later i was in the sunroom watching tv bentley was asleep beside me i went to the kitchen for water and when i came back the photo was on the counter the same one from the crawl space i hadn't taken it out no one else had keys i hadn't touched it i grabbed bentley locked myself in my bedroom and bolted the door the next day i called a contractor

Starting point is 00:22:31 friend Keith and asked him to check out the strange space. He came in the afternoon. I showed him what I'd found. He didn't say much. Just nodded, crouched down and went in with a powerful flashlight. Minutes passed. Then more. I called out to him. No answer. I was just about to grab another light when I finally heard his voice. You should come see this. I went down carefully. Keith was at the back wall shining his light on the beams. There were scratches, deep ones, not random marks. Parallel lines carved over and over with determination. Some formed crude figures, circles, axes, symbols I didn't recognize. That night I didn't sleep. I left every light on. Bentley never left my side. And around two in the morning I heard a soft creak like the hallway board

Starting point is 00:23:24 just outside my door. I didn't dare look. I stayed frozen, eyes wide, flashlight in hand. The next morning I sealed the access. I laid down new boards, nailed them shot, painted over, and dragged a heavy sideboard across the entrance. Then I listed the house for sale. I didn't tell the agent what I had found. I know it wasn't right, but I needed to close that chapter. Weeks later I was showing another property across town. Modern bright, no history. Just drywall and uniform floors, as sterile as it gets. As I wrapped up, my phone buzzed, a security alert. I had forgotten to disable the smart cameras in the old house. Notification. Motion detected. I got into the car, opened my laptop, and pulled up the live feed. My heart pounded as the

Starting point is 00:24:16 image stuttered and froze, but I saw it clearly, a shadow, not coming from outside but from within. The camera caught the silhouette of something moving toward the sealed crawl space, and just before the feed cut to black, it disappeared. I slammed the laptop shut. I didn't even think about saving the footage. I never went back. Not to confirm, not to close. Some houses don't want to be renovated. Story four. I bought the house after a promotion, my first real one, the kind that comes with its own office, a title change, and a raise big enough to finally stop sharing walls with strangers. The house was a reward to myself, a small, gorgeous historic gem in one of Richmond's oldest neighborhoods, tucked between two Sycamore-lined streets, with brick sidewalks and front

Starting point is 00:25:13 porches that had seen generations pass by. I had worked for years for this. Endless hours, case after case, sleepless nights preparing depositions and trial briefs. At last, it paid off, and that house felt like a physical marker of everything I had achieved. I was single, financially stable, and for the first time living somewhere I could truly call mine without feeling like I was occupying someone else's idea of a home. I moved in mid-October. The leaves were turning. The air had that dry, smoky bite. and for once I felt like I was exactly where I was supposed to be. It was quiet, mostly older folks and a few families,

Starting point is 00:25:54 the kind of place where everyone waves while walking their dog and says things like, if you need anything, let me know. The day after moving in, I was unpacking dishes in the kitchen when the doorbell rang. It was a woman, maybe in her early 60s, holding a Tupperware of cookies. Welcome to the neighborhood, she said brightly. I'm Claire. I live right over there. She pointed to the yellow house next door. She seemed friendly, lively in the way older women sometimes are after living decades in the same house. We chattered a bit, and I thanked her for the cookies. She lingered a while, glancing around as if taking inventory.

Starting point is 00:26:35 Then she made a comment that unsettled me, while looking at the living room. I see you kept the rug. Good. It suits the room. and kept the rug. It came staged with the sail. I had my own, though it looked somewhat similar. Maybe that was all it was. But she also mentioned the curtains. Those green ones upstairs block light really well. Always thought they were underrated. I hadn't told her which bedroom I was using, and I hadn't even opened those curtains since arriving. I figured she must have been friends with the previous owner, maybe helped with the sale, or maybe she was just overly observant. Nothing to worry about.

Starting point is 00:27:16 A week passed, then another. I was still settling in, hanging pictures, establishing routines, discovering the best local takeout. I worked late, came home after dark, eight leftovers on the couch with the TV playing something mindless. I saw Claire often, always in her window. Morning night didn't matter. Sometimes she waved, sometimes she didn't. Once I waved first and she didn't respond, she just saw. stared. Then things got stranger. A letter arrived addressed to me, but with my name misspelled.

Starting point is 00:27:51 Not random, but as if someone had only heard it spoken and never seen it written. The envelope wasn't handwritten. It was typed on cheap paper with no return address. Inside, only a real estate flyer. Nothing else. Another day I came home from work to find a folded piece of paper stuffed into my mailbox. No envelope, no sender. Just a single line. You look better than the last girl. No signature. It gave me chills. I tried to tell myself it was a joke or old neighborhood gossip,

Starting point is 00:28:23 but I couldn't shake the feeling that someone was watching me. Claire never said anything inappropriate, never stepped on to my property, never crossed any demonstrable line. But her energy was wrong. It was the way she looked at me too long, too still, as if always waiting. Once I caught her standing in her window,

Starting point is 00:28:44 window at 3 a.m. I couldn't sleep, went for water, and when I pulled back the curtain just a bit, there she was. No lights on, just her pale silhouette framed in the glass. I mentioned it casually to a colleague over lunch. She raised an eyebrow and told me to install cameras just in case. I bought them that same night. Then I called a law school friend who had gone into cybersecurity. I told him everything and half joking asked him to sweep the house. He came a few. He came a few days later with a portable detector. We went through the living room kitchen bathroom, then the bedroom. There's something here, he said. He pointed the device toward the vent above my bed. Inside was a micro camera. You couldn't even see it until he shined a light directly

Starting point is 00:29:31 at it, no bigger than a screwhead, completely silent with no obvious wiring. I reported it immediately. Police came, took statements, filed a report. I handed everything over. I handed everything over. the note and my camera recordings, which at that point only showed Claire standing at her window, always at her window. They got a warrant and when they searched her house they found dozens of printed photos. All of me, labeled and dated, me watering the plants, me watching TV, me eating dinner, me sleeping. There was also a list titled What She Does and When, with times and notes. 7.15 a.m. shower. 9.30 p.m. sits on the left side of the couch. Tuesday takes out trash. Police said previous owners had also filed a complaint, but it hadn't gone anywhere, apparently dismissed for lack of solid evidence.

Starting point is 00:30:28 Claire didn't deny it, but she didn't explain either. She said she liked keeping track of the neighborhood, that she had a good memory for details, that she never meant harm. They didn't press charges. Not enough evidence to meet the legal threshold. I installed blackout curtains, changed the locks, moved my bed to the opposite wall. Claire never spoke to me again, but every night I saw her face in the window. Motionless, unblinking, just watching. It wasn't the house that made me feel unsafe. It was the space between the blinds.

Starting point is 00:31:04 If any of these stories gave you chills, leave a like on this video and share it with a friend who loves a good scare. Do you have your own creepy experience when moving into a new home? Tell me in the comments or send me an email. I'm reading everything. Make sure to subscribe so you don't miss the next batch of unsettling tales. Stay safe, stay alert, and remember. Always trust your instincts. Thanks for watching and I'll see you in the next nightmare.

Horror Stories - 4 Disturbing New House Horror Stories | Real Life Scary Stories

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.