Horror Stories - 6 Most Disturbing TRUE Babysitting Horror Stories Too Terrifying to Forget

Episode Date: December 14, 2025

The Most Terrifying Nights on the Job — 6 Most Disturbing TRUE Babysitting Horror Stories takes you inside real encounters that turned an ordinary babysitting shift into a nightmare. These stories come from babysitters who found themselves face-to-face with strange noises, unsettling children’s behavior, eerie figures at the window, stalking strangers, and moments where something felt dangerously wrong inside the house. Told in a calm, immersive tone, each story slowly builds tension while keeping the listener drawn into the atmosphere. Perfect for horror fans who love real-life chilling stories, dark nighttime vibes, and soft-spoken narration that makes the fear feel even closer. After hearing these, you’ll never look at babysitting the same way again. #TrueHorrorStories #BabysittingHorror #DisturbingStories #ScaryBabysitting #RealHorror #CreepyStories #HorrorNarration #SleepHorror #NighttimeStories #BabysitterTales 6 most disturbing true babysitting horror stories, true babysitting horror stories, scary babysitting stories, babysitter nightmare stories, creepy babysitter encounters, disturbing babysitting events, horror stories babysitting, real scary babysitting tales, creepy house horror stories, eerie babysitting experiences, soft spoken horror, scary stories to fall asleep, babysitting gone wrong, real life horror babysitting, disturbing true stories, nighttime babysitting horror, babysitter survival stories, creepy children horror stories, stalker babysitting tales, strange noises horror stories, terrifying babysitting encounters, horror narration babysitting, babysitting fear stories, creepy babysitter nights, paranormal babysitting stories, real spooky babysitting stories, chilling babysitting accounts, dark house horror tales, unsettling babysitting stories, spooky real encounters, babysitter horror compilation, true creepy narratives, fear-filled babysitting shifts, horror lovers stories, calm horror narration Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Own it all. Pay off your home, travel for life, drive a Ferrari. In celebration of the world premiere of the Monopoly Big Board Buckslot Machine by Aristocrat Gaming, Yamava Resort and Casino at San Manuel is giving one person a $1.6 million dream package. The biggest prize in Yamava's history. Club Serrano members can earn daily instant prizes

and secure a spot in the finale May 29th. Don't pass go and own it all. Only at Yamava, celebrating its 40th anniversary. You win? Details at yamava.com must be 21-20. Please gamble responsibly. Monopoly is a trademark of Hasbro. Hasbro is not a sponsor of this promotion.

Hey honey, it's mom. Did you know if we switched to Verizon we can get four phones for $0, plus four lines for $25 a line? Call me back. Me again. That's just $100 a month for four lines on unlimited welcome. Plus four phones, no trade in needed. Call me.

It's Mom. America's Best Network, Verizon. That's the one we're talking about. I'll send you text. America's Best Network based on Root Metrics, Best Overall Mobile Network Performance, U.S. second half, 2025. Four new lines on a limit and welcome and auto pay. See Verizon.com.

for details. Hello everyone and welcome back to horror stories. I know many of you use these episodes to fall asleep so before you drift off, I'd love it if you could leave a comment letting me know where you're listening from around the world. Also, don't forget to like and subscribe if you're enjoying the episodes. Story 1. When I was around 15, I accepted a babysitting job for a family who lived right across from my high school.

They had three children, two boys and a girl. Their mom knew me because the oldest sometimes hung out with my younger brother. She had just started working longer hours and so at her husband, so she asked my mom if I'd be interested in giving them a hand. The pay was good, the house was close by, and I figured it would be pretty straightforward, so I said yes. Even though I had hardly ever babysat before, it didn't take long for me to realize I was in over my head.

It wasn't that the kids were bad, but they were a whirlwind in ways I had. hadn't imagined. The oldest pretty much kept to himself, glued to the Xbox or finishing homework, but the younger two left me exhausted. The girl was completely obsessed with horror movies, and I had to keep an eye on her all the time because she thought it was fun to recreate what she saw. More than once I had to quietly hide the kitchen knives after catching her with one in her hand, saying she wanted to act out a scene. The youngest wasn't far behind. He had way too much energy, and once he even tried to set the Christmas tree on fire for fun. I was used to restless

kids because of my cousins, but taking care of these three made me feel like at any moment I was going to have to call 911. Every time they started to misbehave, I would threaten to call their mom, and usually that was enough. Over time, however, I noticed that mentioning their dad got a much faster reaction. As soon as I said his name, they calmed down immediately. I didn't think too much about it because I assumed he was simply the stricter parent. The strange thing was that I hardly ever saw their dad. I had only glimpsed him from afar a couple of times and knew he was a big man. But their mom always described him as kind, so I never thought there was anything unusual about him.

One afternoon, the youngest threw a massive tantrum after I told him that was enough. I ended up calling his dad to step in. That day he was getting off work early and told me he would go see. straight to the house. By the time he arrived, the boy had locked himself in his room, crying his eyes out. When his dad walked through the door, I finally understood why the kids didn't dare defy him. He had to duck a little to get inside and standing next to him. I felt like I was half his height. I awkwardly apologized for having called him, but he downplated and said it wasn't a problem. We ended up talking for a while as I picked up the living room. He asked about my schedule in which

days I could watch the kids. And I answered politely, still a bit nervous. Nothing seemed out of place in that moment, but I couldn't shake how imposing his presence was. It was only later that I understood something wasn't right. Apparently, the oldest son later told his mom that he didn't want her leaving me alone with his father. He said that during that brief visit, his dad had been staring at me far too intently. At the time, I didn't notice it. But looking back, it makes sense that the boy was so uneasy that afternoon. A few days later, their mom canceled my next babysitting shift. She apologized overtaxed and said she would still pay me,

so I went by the house to pick up the money. When I went in, I noticed she seemed tense, but she smiled, made light conversation about school, handed me what she had promised, and I didn't think much of it. That changed the following week. I came home one afternoon and found my mom pacing around the living room,

crying while my stepdad tried to calm her down. She hugged me as soon as I walked through the door and kept asking me if I was okay. At first I was confused, but then she told me what had happened. She had been trying to reach me earlier, but my phone had died, and when she couldn't get a hold of me, she panicked. I found out that the kid's dad had been arrested after killing someone. During the interrogation, he admitted he beat his wife, and there were rumors that he had a thing for girls who looked a certain way. Small, dark-haired, and pale-skinned, which at the time was exactly how I looked. Hearing that made my stomach turn. I couldn't stop thinking about the night I sat on the couch next to him, having no idea how dangerous he really was. My mom was still in shock,

hugging me like she was afraid to let go. Needless to say, I stopped working for that family immediately. I went back one more time to return a book I had borrowed and seeing their mom broke my heart. She looked exhausted, but she was trying to put on a brave face for her children. She thanked me for my help, gave me my things along with more money than I expected, and very gently told me it was best if I kept my distance from the family, so I wouldn't get tangled up in the mess. People had already started harassing her and the kids because of what her husband had done. Even now, years later, I still think about them. I stayed in touch with the kids for a while, especially the oldest, because he had an awful time at school because of his father's actions.

I still get chills when I remember how close I was to that situation and how easily everything could have been so much worse. Story 2. Growing up, my family wasn't just close. We felt intertwined. Almost everyone lived within walking distance clustered around a big park in our small Texas town. That same park would later become associated with some pretty notorious murders.

But back then, it was simply the heart of our family's world. Weekends meant big gatherings, cousins running everywhere, aunts and uncles dropping by. And I don't think there was a single week where we didn't see each other. My mom always said that's why she almost never had to worry about finding the babysitters. There was always a family member available to watch us. That's exactly what makes this entire story so strange. Some time ago, I was sitting with my brother and my mom, and I brought up a family member. some nightmares I've had my whole life. They always follow the same pattern. Me as a little girl,

running through my childhood home, desperate to escape while something horrible seems to be chasing me. It's not something I can clearly see. I just feel it behind me, reaching out to grab me. And right before I reach the front door, I always wake up. These nightmares feel connected to something real, specifically to some blurry memories I have of a babysitter. The problem is that those memories don't feel normal. They're vivid in certain details but completely hazy in others. For example, I can picture the setting but never her face. I remember she was a middle-aged woman,

but if you asked me what she physically looked like, I wouldn't be able to describe her. There are two particular episodes that really stayed with me. One, every time I got into trouble, She would make me sit outside on the back porch, wearing only shorts and a t-shirt, even in the middle of winter. I can see myself there, teeth chattering, too scared to complain because I knew it would only make things worse. The other memory is the one that still unsettles me. She had a game she loved and that I hated.

She would turn off all the lights in the house, tell me I couldn't eat or watch TV until I found her, and then she'd hide somewhere in one of the rooms. When I finally worked up the courage to look for her, she would jump out of her hiding spots screaming at me, as if it were the funniest thing in the world and chase me all over the house. I was so little I didn't know how to react. Most of the time I ended up curled up by the front door, waiting and wishing that she would eventually stop. But she never came out until I gave in and started searching for her. There's one scene that stands out more sharply than all the rest. I remember walking down the hallway desperate because I was starving, checking room after room.

I eventually ended up in my parents' bedroom, and then I saw her. She was lying on her back under the bed, peeking out from beneath the bed skirt. I couldn't see her expression, but I swear I felt like she was smiling at me. She started crawling toward me with an unnaturally fast movement, and I panicked. I screamed and ran. That's where my memory cuts off completely. I've never been able to recall what happened afterward. For most of my life, I didn't talk about this.

I convinced myself that maybe I had dreamed it, since the memories came in fragments. But when I was in my 20s, I finally mentioned it while talking with my mom and my brother. My mom looked genuinely confused and told me she had never hired a babysitter for us. She reminded me that because we were so close-knit, it was always family who took care of us. That description of a strange woman didn't match anyone.

My mom looked unsettled, but also sure that she had no idea who I could be remembering. Then my brother spoke up, and that's when everything got heavier. He said he remembered her too. Not everything, but enough. He remembered seeing me being sent outside into the cold, sitting there shivering thinking it was cruel. He also remembered the game, although in his mind it was more like watching from the sidelines than actually taking part. He said it was almost like she only picked me.

He didn't remember her face either, but he did remember how terrified I looked. What shook me was that he was able to fill in pieces I had forgotten. He said I would get into trouble because I made up stories and used my imagination a lot. And when she realized things weren't true, she would punish me by sending me outside or playing that horrible game. He admitted he always felt helpless,

like there was nothing he could do to stop it. We didn't talk much about it after that. My mom remained firm in saying she had no idea who this person could have been. And with how protective she has always been, I believe her. I'm left with this uncomfortable gap between what I remember and what could have actually happened. Sometimes I wonder if it's just the way a child's brain misremembers things. Other times I'm not so sure. Story 3.

I spent most of my childhood in a quiet Midwestern neighborhood, away from the busier part of the city. Our street curved toward a wooded area, which gave it a feeling of privacy and safety. And we all knew each other well enough that parents rarely worried if the kids played outside until it got dark. When I was 11, I had just finished one of those basic babysitting courses at the local rec center and was eager to prove I was responsible. Since I had two younger siblings, word spread quickly that I was finally old enough to babysit. One of my first real jobs was for some friends who lived directly across the street. They had two kids, both younger than me.

And I remember feeling nervous but also excited that they trusted me at last. The parents told me they would only be out until around 11, which reassured me because my own family was just across the street in case I needed help. Luckily, those kids made things easy for me. Their routine was so well established that they even turned down the chance to stay up late or have an extra snack. They insisted they had to brush their teeth and go to bed. After tucking them in, I went back downstairs to the living room and settled in with their old Labrador Alex. For what I imagined would be a few quiet hours of television.

I was always impressed by their house. The mom had decorated everything herself. and the back of the living room was an entire wall of windows looking straight out into the woods. The couch was positioned with its back to the glass, so while I watched TV, I couldn't help but notice the dark forest behind me reflected in the screen. At one point something pale slid past the glass. I told myself it was probably just a deer, but being alone in a big house with nothing but trees behind me made my stomach tighten. Alex perked up and followed me into the kitchen when I decided to call my mom just to hear her voice and calm myself down. The phone was on the counter and from where I stood I could still see the living room in the windows. As I talked to my mom telling her I thought I'd seen something outside, Alex curled up at my feet.

My mom soothed me the way moms do, reminded me that everything was fine and told me I could call back if I needed to. After hanging up, I stayed there for a while, sitting on the floor and petting Alex. I still didn't feel entirely comfortable being so close to those huge windows. That's when I saw it. A small point of light shining between the trees. At first I thought it maybe it was someone walking with a flashlight along a trail. But the way the light swayed steadily getting closer made my breath catch. In less than a minute, it was clear that whoever was carrying that light wasn't on any path.

They were coming straight toward the house. I froze. My eyes were locked on that single swing glow until it reached the yard. Then the beam swept across the living room. When the light landed on me, my chest clenched. It was so bright I couldn't even squint against it. The beam shifted, tilting upward until it illuminated a face outside the glass. With the shadows cutting across it, all I could see were deep eye sockets and the sunken outline of cheeks.

lit from below in a way that made it impossible to recognize the person. My hand stayed suspended, useless over the phone as tears began to roll down my face. I couldn't scream. I couldn't even crawl away. I just sat there staring. The person moved the flashlight back and forth, sometimes sweeping it over me, sometimes lighting up their own face from below. After what felt like an eternity, the light went out all at once. In the darkness that followed, I finally managed to move. I jumped up, hit redial, and debated whether I should grab the kids and hide with them in the upstairs bedroom,

or get them out of the house and run across the street. Before I could decide, a loud crash shook the door that led to the garage. I almost dropped the phone. They pounded again, harder this time, and over the noise a voice shouted my name. At first my brain didn't process it, but then I caught the word. It's dad. Open the door. I stumbled over still shaking and opened it. My dad nearly fell in laughing his head off. Apparently my mom had sent him over to check on me and he thought it would be funny to shine the flashlight at the living room window so I'd know it was him. He didn't realize how terrifying he

looked until he saw my face through the glass. He couldn't stop laughing but I didn't find it funny at all. To this day, that moment when the beam of light hit the windows is one of the scariest things I've ever experienced. Story four. When I was around 13, I started babysitting in my neighborhood to earn some extra money. Most of the jobs came through referrals from my dad's work. He's a lawyer. And people usually trusted me because I looked younger than I really was.

One night I was hired to watch two kids, a boy and a girl, ages seven and nine. Their parents seemed strict but reasonable. They gave me a long list of rules before leaving and joked, like adults sometimes do in that weird way, that I wasn't allowed to have any boys over. I was a lanky, awkward teenager, so the joke stung more than it should have. The parents hadn't even finished backing out of the driveway when the girl started singing in this eerie sing-song voice. Now we're alone. I forced a laugh to lighten the mood, but before I could say anything, the boy followed up with something much worse. Something I couldn't believe a kid that age would even repeat.

I froze trying not to react too strongly and quickly changed the subject, but my stomach was already in knots. From there, the night was a mess. They tried to watch shows I knew their parents would never allow, like South Park. When I told them no, the girl offered to go into another room to play video games instead, clearly trying to get rid of me. I kept them in the living room trying to follow the parents' rules, and I started making dinner because they told me to prepare sandwiches.

That's when I heard a sharp crash. I rushed back and found a broken glass on the floor, and the girl staring straight at me while I cleaned it up. No apology, no reaction, just watching me. I threw the pieces in the trash and tried to move on, but the tension kept building. Not long after, the boy suddenly screamed like he'd hurt himself. I ran over, but it was obvious he was exaggerating.

While I was trying to figure out what injury he was pretending to have, I realized the girl had slipped out of the room. When she came back, she had an expression on her face that made my skin crawl. A second later, the boy was miraculously healed, and I understood they were messing with me. I served them their food and brought their drinks, but when I returned, they were just staring at me, smiling. Their sandwich is untouched. I asked what was going on, and they answered in unison. We're waiting for you to eat yours. Something in me said not to trust it.

I opened my sandwich before taking a bite, and what I saw nearly made me drop it. Tiny shards of glass scattered between the lettuce and the bread. Glass I knew I had already thrown away. My hands shook as I looked at them. They were still sitting there with wide smiles like it was some kind of game. I snapped.

I started yelling about how incredibly dangerous that was, but instead of crying or denying it, they burst out laughing. And it wasn't childish laughter. It was low, deliberate, unsettling in a way I still don't know how to describe. They seemed completely unfazed by what they'd done, and that was what disturbed me the most. I called my older sister sobbing and begged her to come over. She showed up and took over for me. When the parents got home, we left without saying much.

I never took another job with that family. Even years later I still think about how premeditated it all was and how two kids so young could do something that cruel without the slightest hint of remorse. Story 5 When I was around 14 I agreed to babysit two siblings from a family at my church. I had watched them before, so their parents trusted me and the kids were always excited when I came over.

That particular night was going to be a long one. because the parents would be out at a church event until well past two o'clock in the morning. I wasn't even charging them, because I wanted to help, and at that age, the money didn't matter much to me. They lived in a small ground floor apartment, two bedrooms at opposite ends, a narrow kitchen along one side, and a little living room with sliding glass doors that opened onto a tiny patio. The evening itself went by normally. I managed to get the kids to bed after a bit of resistance. a couple of story books, and a few pleas from them to stay up longer.

When they finally fell asleep, I finished my homework and then rummaged through their small collection of VHS tapes and DVDs, since they didn't have cable. I chose the land before time and left it playing in the background while I tried not to fall asleep. Around 2 o'clock in the morning I heard knocking at the front door. I assumed it was the parents coming home earlier than expected. They had a key, so I stayed home. the couch, but the knocking didn't stop, and there was something about it that put me on edge.

I grabbed the baseball bat that was leaning against the wall and kept my eyes fixed on the door. That's when I heard a voice, soft, sing-song, and strangely high-pitched say, Oh, darling, that's not going to help you. I froze. I turned toward the patio door and realized I hadn't closed the blinds. There was someone standing outside looking straight in at me. I could barely make out that the figure was short and heavy set, but the way they were just planted there made my heart race.

I bolted to the kids' room praying they were still asleep and shoved the dresser in front of the door. The old apartment didn't have a cordless phone, and I didn't have a cell phone yet, so I stayed there with the kids staring at the room's only window. That's when a shadow passed across the glass, blocking the little bit of streetlight coming in from outside. The knocking started again, this time on the window, and the same woman's voice called out.

Come on, honey, I won't hurt you. Just come out. The thud of her fist on the glass sounded so loud I thought it was going to shatter. The kids woke up crying and I tried to calm them down even though I was terrified myself. Suddenly an angry male voice shouted from outside, Hey, who are you? It was the kid's father. I heard hurry. footsteps and then nothing. Moments later the parents were at the front door and then pounding on the bedroom door and I pushed the dresser aside as fast as I could to let them in. Through tears I explained everything as best I could and they called the police. By the time the officers arrived the stranger was gone but

the bushes near the patio were clearly cut and crushed showing where she had pushed her way through. I babysat for that family one more time before they moved a few months later, but after that, I never took another babysitting job again. Even years later, every unexpected knock on a door makes me freeze for a moment because it throws me straight back to that night. Story 6. This didn't happen to me directly, but to one of my closest friends when we were teenagers. I remember the way she told it stuck with me, and I'm going to retell it as best I can. She was around 14 at the time and had agreed to babysit for a family friend who lived the way out in the country. Their house wasn't in a neighborhood, but on a large piece of land,

with woods on one side and open hills on the other. The home was a long single-story bungalow with several doors leading outside and a big wraparound porch that went almost all the way around the structure. She had put the child to bed early and was alone in the living room, flipping through to kill time until the parents came back. The house wasn't very well lit, just a couple of lamps on, so most of the rooms were in semi-darkness, and the windows reflected the glow of the TV. Since it was winter, everything outside was covered in snow, which made the night strangely quiet. After she'd been sitting there for a while, she started to hear faint creaking sounds, like footsteps moving along the snowy porch. Given how rural the area was, she didn't think much of it at first.

She assumed it was a deer passing by, or maybe a coyote. Both were common out there. But a few minutes later, she heard another sound, the metallic rattling of a doorknob turning somewhere at the far end of the house. She muted the TV immediately and sat perfectly still, trying to make sense of what she was hearing. The footsteps came again, this time from the opposite end of the porch, slowly making their way toward the side of the house where she was.

Her back was to one of the doors, so she couldn't see it directly. Then the handle behind her started shaking violently. She turned around and saw the dark silhouette of a man pressed up against the glass, yanking hard on the doorknob as if he were trying to force his way in. She bolted out of the living room and ran straight to the child's bedroom, where she found him crying. He was already awake, and between sobs asked her if she had heard the noises too. She realized that in her panic she hadn't grabbed a phone, so she forced herself to go back into the hallway, heart pounding, and hurriedly switched on every exterior light she could find.

Inside it was still dim, but outside the porch was suddenly fluttered with light, casting long shadows across the deck. That's when she noticed something that chilled her even more. Fresh footprints pressed deeply into the snow, circling sections of the porch. With the phone finally in her hand, she locked herself in the child's room and called her dad. Crying and stumbling over her words, she told him what was happening. He told her not to move while he grabbed his shotgun and headed out there. After hanging up, she called the child's parents as well. She explained what was going on, hoping it was just a relative who had shown up unannounced.

But they assured her it couldn't be anyone they knew. They lived too far out of the way for someone to just drop. by. Their explanation, if it can even be called that, was that maybe an owl had landed on the handle and moved it. Even though that didn't make sense to her, she was too scared to argue. They called a neighbor to come over and keep her company until her father arrived. When he finally got there, he checked the property top to bottom. By then, the intruder was long gone. The homeowners came back about an hour later, still clinging to their owl theory, which my friend never believed. The police were never contacted, no evidence was looked at, and the whole thing

was brushed aside. She told me she never accepted another babysitting job in that house again, and I don't blame her one bit.