Jocko Podcast - 48: “I Fought With Custer”, How Ego can Kill You, Avoid the Slippery Slope

Episode Date: November 9, 2016

0:00:00 - Opening / "I Fought With Custer" by Charles Windolph 1:47:17 - Thoughts and Take-aways 1:54:51 - Cool Internet, Onnit, Amazon, JockoStore stuff 2:10:31 - Closing ThanksSupport this ...podcast at — https://redcircle.com/jocko-podcast/exclusive-content

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This is Jocko Podcast number 48 with Echo Charles and me, Jocko Willink. We found General Custer on the bluffs, and near him lay the bodies of 11 of his officers. As a tribute to his bravery, the Indians had not mutilated General Custer, and he lay as if asleep. But all the other men had been most brutally mangled and had been. had been stripped of their clothing. Many of their skulls had been crushed in, eyes had been torn from their sockets, hands, feet, arms, legs, and noses had been wrenched off. Many had their flesh cut in strips the entire length of their bodies, and there were others
Starting point is 00:00:54 whose limbs were closely perforated with bullet holes, showing that the torture had been inflicted while the wretched victims were yet alive. There were 29 enlisted men missing from the field of blood, and they undoubtedly had been taken prisoners and perished at the stake while the Indians were celebrating their scalp dance on the night of the 25th in sight of my camp. Lying almost at Custer's feet was Young Reed, a nephew of the generals,
Starting point is 00:01:30 who had been visiting him at Fort Lincoln and who had pleaded to go on the campaign where this handsome lad of 19 met such an untimely fate. Within a few feet of the general lay his two brothers, Boston and Tom. There was in the whole army no more popular man than gallant Tom Custer.
Starting point is 00:01:54 He was young, handsome, a prince of good fellows and full of that bravery that even characterized the Custer's. He had served with distinction during the war and had fought frequently before been engaged in Indian fights. As we approached him, we were horrified to see that his body had been opened and his heart torn out. Thus, I know that the vengeance of rain in the face had been at work. Several years before, rain in the face had murdered two white men of our fort,
Starting point is 00:02:33 and afterwards boasted of it in the reservation. He was arrested and brought to trial by Tom Custer. But before the time appointed for his case it arrived, the wily Indian had escaped, sending back word to Captain Tom that he would be revenged by cutting out his captor's heart. Rain in the face kept his word by literally tearing out the heart of young Tom Custer.
Starting point is 00:02:59 Near these three brothers and their boyish nephew, Lay their brother-in-law, Lieutenant Calhoun, who had fallen on the skirmish line. Custer's command was completely annihilated. Not one of his men escaping. Good evening, Echo. Good evening. That right there is an excerpt from a book called I Fought with Custer, which is the story of Charles Windorf, who is a young.
Starting point is 00:03:37 young private that fought with one of the other companies in the same seventh cavalry regiment that General George Custer led. General George Custer who was killed at the Battle of Little Big Horn where he fought the Native Americans including our friend Wooden Legg who we heard from on podcast 45. But the opening section that I just read was a actually written by private windoff it is a section of an account that is written by a guy named Major Reno who was one of the leaders of one of the other companies of men at the battle that they include in this book this book called I fought with Custer and this was obviously a brutal battle and my goal as always I shouldn't say as always but
Starting point is 00:04:38 My goal or where I like to focus is not so much on what details happen in the battle, but what details happened with the human nature in the battle, the people, the leadership, the decisions. And we got some good understanding about the Native American perspective from Wooden Leg. but now let's hear a little bit of what it was like for the troopers and I know I use that term on a fairly regular basis but that is a very specific term in a cavalry unit this and at this time a cavalry unit was literally units that they ride horses you know that's what it is mounted cavalry, a soldier in a cavalry unit is specifically called a trooper.
Starting point is 00:05:39 And the word nowadays, it actually is used to cover a lot of different people. You know, armored units use it. Airborne units, you know, when you think of an airborne unit, parachuters, you think of a paratrooper. Trooper being the key word. There obviously, there's police, state troopers, and then obviously there's people that listen to this podcast. But that is what we have here. The cavalry unit and this in particular was the seventh cavalry regiment and
Starting point is 00:06:12 The trooper like I said is this guy Private Charles Windorf who was actually born in Germany And emigrated to the United States. He became a cobbler Like his dad. You know what a cobbler is? People who fix shoes people who fix shoes and you know what he fixed shoes for a while but he didn't like fixing shoes and So what did you do? Join the army. And he ended up fighting in some of the Indian wars. He actually received the Medal of Honor for his actions at Little Big Horn,
Starting point is 00:06:48 and we'll get into those. But let's hear what Private Windorf has to say. I'm going to the book. June 25, 1946. was the last time I saw him alive. Two days later, I looked down on him lying in the White in the Montana Sun. That would have been June 27, 1876. And the following day, I helped him, I helped bury him and his brother, Captain Tom Custer.
Starting point is 00:07:28 They were putting graves alongside one another. It was hard digging there on that high ridge that bordered little bit. It's a long time to remember details and little things. But when you've been thinking back on them all those years, they don't fade away as easily as you might think. They're like burrs. They stick in your mind. People call it the Custer Massacre. It wasn't any massacre.
Starting point is 00:08:01 It was a straight, hard fight, and the five troops who were with Custer simply got cut to ribbons, and every last white man destroyed. I say every last white man because there were one or two crow scouts who claimed they saw the start of the fight and then skedaddled. A crow Indian named Curley said he escaped from the battlefield by putting a blanket over his head
Starting point is 00:08:23 and pretending he was a wounded sue. I don't know whether there's any truth in that or not. I never quite believed it. There's been all kinds of stories about that battle. Even the men who were with Bentine and Reno, and live to tell the tale didn't come anywhere near telling the same stories about what they did and what they saw. Some of them wanted to make heroes out of themselves or of their officers. I only had one pair of eyes, so, of course, all I can tell is what I saw myself.
Starting point is 00:08:56 If it is something that I only heard, I'll be sure to mark it down as that. Interestingly, this is something that we used to see all the time, in that you go out on an operating. and when things happen, two guys, almost nobody will see the same thing. Everybody sees some things a little bit different. And it can be difficult to figure out what's actually accurate. So that's, and he's going back. When he's writing this book, I think it's been 70 years. So when he's being interviewed and he's writing this book, it's been 70 years.
Starting point is 00:09:32 And he's saying he still remembers the details, but 70 years is a long time, long time. and the characters that he just brought up, Bentine is the guy that he worked for, and Reno was one of the other majors. And another word that they use here is troop. Now, this is a word that's, we think of it as an individual. Hey, there's a trooper over there,
Starting point is 00:09:53 or there's a troop. It actually is another term that means basically like a company of guys. Now, you can see it's small, and this is more like a platoon. What they're talking about would be considered a platoon. I would say from reading,
Starting point is 00:10:07 Um, he had five troops with him. Custer did that got killed, you know, about 200 guys. And so we're not talking about a massive group of people in each troop, but that's what they're talking about, I don't know, 20 guys per troop or actually, what would that be, 40 guys per troop for five. And so that's what they're talking about when they refer to the troops. And even they use the word interchangeably and sometimes they'll refer to as companies and sometimes they say troops.
Starting point is 00:10:36 Yeah. So going back to the book here when he's initially in the army and what they're doing, and he talks about what they were doing at this time. It was pretty dull soldiering down there in the south. The regiment was broken up into companies or small battalions, and our job was to smash the Ku Klux Klan and run down illicit whiskey distillers. It wasn't much fun for energetic, spirited young men. And now he's going to talk a little bit about the 7th Cavalry.
Starting point is 00:11:12 As I say, the 7th Cavalry was only 7 years old in 1873, but it had a fine reputation. Everybody in the country knew General Custer. And he was always bragging about what a fine fighting regiment he had. He was supposed to be the best Indian fighter in the American Army. In the Civil War, they'd called him the boy general. And he'd been a dashing popular figure. The regiment had spent its first four years of its life on the Kansas Plains and an Indian territory. The old timers in the outfit could sure tell some blood-curling Indian stories.
Starting point is 00:11:51 They used to say that it was worse than straight death to get captured by the Indians because you would be slowly tortured until you gave up the ghost. They told all of us young soldiers if we were ever wounded in an Indian fight and left behind and in danger of being captured, that we must save our last cartridge to blow out our brains. So that's an interesting point when we remember Woodenleg said
Starting point is 00:12:18 that all the guys in Custer's group ended up killing themselves. And maybe that's a... That very well might have happened. Or at least some of them. Back to the book. By the spring of 1873, the Plains Indians had been largely debased,
Starting point is 00:12:39 beaten and driven to the... the great reservations that had been allotted to the various tribes. It had not been a deliberate government policy, but it had been a cruelly effective one. Treaty after treaty had been broken by the relentless pressure of white men and their civilization, constantly pushing against the ineffective resistance of the red men. Now and again, the Indians had struck back, and as a rule, their angry flare-ups were put down by the army
Starting point is 00:13:09 and then new and drastic treaties would be made and more land taken from them in punishment. The ink would hardly be dry on these new government commitments before the white pressure would be resumed, intrusions made, and once again the bewildered, enraged Indians would strike back only to be subdued by the army and harsh penalties imposed on them. It was a deadly and vicious cycle. The Indian found himself whirling endless. in. So that reminds me of a lot of conflicts where you have you have these things happen.
Starting point is 00:13:50 You know, the white man is putting pressure on the Indians. The Indians don't know what's going on. So they lash out a little bit. What do the white man do then? Go in there, smash them, take more land from them, compress them more. Eventually there's another lash out and you just get this vicious cycle. vicious cycle. In 1864, a certain Colonel Shivington with a regiment of volunteer Colorado cavalry had suddenly moved against a large encampment of Cheyans and indiscriminately killed some 300 Indians. The massacre unquestionably had turned many lukewarm Indians into out-and-out hostiles. This bitterness of the Cheyans was inflamed.
Starting point is 00:14:39 named two or three years later when Custer led his newly formed seventh cavalry against Black Kettle and his band in a sudden attack against their sleeping village on the Washita in Texas. The Cheyennes, who were recognized as the most brilliant Indian fighters of the plains, never forgave either Custer or his seventh cavalry for this whirling attack on their sleeping village in the dead of winter. another big yeah so you know atrocities on both sides clearly i'll talk a little bit about those as well but one of the biggest atrocities beyond the killing of the indians themselves the native americans themselves and those type of atrocities was what they did with the buffaloes because the white man was coming and killing all the buffaloes and i'll go to the book here once the buffalo around whose existence Since the whole economy of the Indian was based, was killed off, the nomads had nothing to do but submit to government control and become agency Indians.
Starting point is 00:15:51 Degraded, whiskey crazed, and beaten. Only the various tribes of the Sioux and the fighting Cheyennes refused to be broken on the wheel of civilization. A few determined leaders such as Sitting Bull, Crazy Horse, Gall, American Horse, Two Moon, White Bull, Spotted Eagle and Chief Hunk stubbornly held out against the threats and blandishments of the whites. But by the spring of 1873, they were beginning to be branded as hostiles. So that's something that I didn't focus on enough when I talked about how the Sioux and the Cheyenne kind of faded. Well, one of the main reasons that they faded was, you know, again, they gave up their guns at a certain point.
Starting point is 00:16:38 but the white man had decimated the buffaloes. And so that was their main way of survival. If you remember from Wooden Leg, that's where they lived. They lived in shelters that were made from Buffalo skins. And obviously they ate Buffalo all the time. They hunted Buffalo. They ate them. They made their weapons out of Buffalo.
Starting point is 00:16:55 Everything that they did was with Buffalo. So when the white man came in and killed all the buffalo, that put them in a real precarious situation. Now we go back to the book talking a little bit about what it was like being the cavalry at this time. Each man would look after his own horse and we'd usually give him a little exercise and a good rub down. A trooper thought a lot of his mount.
Starting point is 00:17:23 And a cavalryman would have to be a pretty mean, would have to be pretty mean who didn't take good care of his horse. If we got a good chance, we'd steal him a little extra oats or hay for individual mounts. My horse at this time was named Pig. That wasn't his real name, but I called him that because nothing could keep him from rolling in a mud hole when he was being watered after we'd come in from a long ride.
Starting point is 00:17:48 He was fast and he could show his heels to most of the horses in the regiment. I thought a lot of him, but the army condemned him after we'd been beaten in the Dakota country a year or two, after we'd been in the Dakota country a year or two. I'll tell you later about the horse I rode in the Battle of Little Big Horn. But one more thing about pig. Two or three years after the army sold him, I saw him in a contractor's six-horse team in the Black Hills. He looked so poor and abused. I'd have bought him from that contractor on the spot, but I didn't have the money.
Starting point is 00:18:22 I went up to him and petted him. He knew me all right. He knickered and looked at me as much to say, come on, please, Charlie, get me out of here. I had ridden old pig thousands of miles, and more than once he had saved my life. I pretty near cried when I saw him that time in the Black Hills. Big connection. You know, we see that nowadays with the guys that work with dogs and the military working dogs,
Starting point is 00:18:52 which are awesome animals. And those guys get majorly connected to those dogs. Yeah, man. She's like horse where it's just, there's a lot of times where it's just you and him in the fighting situation. It's just you and him. It's like, dang, you go through so much together, up to downs. For sure.
Starting point is 00:19:09 I can't even imagine the emotion of that situation. Back to the book. It was at the Yankton that I first saw General Custer. He was not far from six feet tall. He must have weighed around 180 pounds. He was energetic and it was mighty hard to wear him out. I've heard people say that when he was at West Point, he was the second strongest man there. As I remember him at the time, he was wearing long hair, something like Buffalo Bill used to wear. He had a big wide-brinned Western hat and long military. mustache. His hair and mustache were yellow, tawny colored. I suppose would be the right way to describe them. He had on high Wellington boots. They were the kind that came up to the knees with the front three or four inches higher than the back. They were popular among officers at the time. General Custer wasn't the kind to mix freely with the men. In those years there was quite a gulf between the officers and the enlisted men. Some of the officers were, friendly and easy going with their troopers, but there was always a gulf. Custer struck me as being
Starting point is 00:20:20 aloof and removed, noted. It got to be gossip among the troopers that some of the officers didn't set so very well with the general. My captain, Colonel Bentine. So there's something that I'm going to point this out. Some of these, including General Custer, these guys have been promoted during the Civil War. So General Custer had become a general during the Civil War, but after the war, they got demoted. They got put back down and rank because they shrank the armies. They shrank the army.
Starting point is 00:20:55 And so, for instance, General Custer at this time was, he had been a general in the Civil War. Now all of a sudden he's a colonel. So he got put down and rank. And it's the same with, he's talking about his boss, Windhoff's boss, Windoff's boss was a guy, named Captain Bentin, but they call him Colonel Benton because he was a colonel during Civil War.
Starting point is 00:21:19 My captain, Colonel Benton, was one of those folks who didn't belong to the general's inner circle. I suppose you could say about half the officers in the regiment were close to Custer and the rest were not. I repeat that Benton was distinct, was distinctly not an intimate of Custer. I heard all sorts of reasons why that was true. There was one report that Benteen had turned bitter because Custer had pulled out after the battle of the Washington, December 1868 in Kansas, and it left Major Elliott and 17 men to their fate. A day or two later, they were all found killed, scalped, and mutilated.
Starting point is 00:21:58 There was a story that Custer and Ben Tene had some hard words over that. But of course, I don't know how true that old story is. So, there you go. Ben Tine thought Custer let some guys hang out to dry, had to confront him about it, and Custer didn't like that at all. And now they got some stuff that they're at odds about. And speaking of that event where these 17 men were killed,
Starting point is 00:22:30 in this book, they have an excerpt that's a letter from an army officer that got published in a newspaper about that event. And I'm going to read it. The bodies were found in a small circle, stripped as naked as when born and frozen stiff. Their heads had been battered in, and some of them had been entirely chopped off. Some of them had the Adam's apple cut out of their throats. Some had their hands and feet cut off, and nearly all had been horribly mangled. In a way, delicacy forbids me to mention.
Starting point is 00:23:08 They lay scarcely two miles from the scene of the fight. Who can describe the feeling of that brave band as with anxious hearts beating? They strained their yearning eyes in the direction whence they help should come. What must have been the despair that when all hopes of sucker died out nerve their stout arms to do and die? Round and round rush the red fiends, smaller and smaller shrinks the circle. but the aim of that devoted gallant knot of heroes is steadier than ever, and the death howl of the murderous redskin is more frequent. But on they come and masses grim, with glittering lance
Starting point is 00:23:58 and one long, loud, exulting whoop, as if the gates of hell had opened and loosed the whole infernal host. A well-directed volley from their trusty carbines make some of the miscreants real and fall, but their death rattles are drowned in the greater din. Soon, every voice in that little band is still as death, but the hellish work of the savages is scarce begun, and their ingenuities are taxed to invent barbarities
Starting point is 00:24:31 to practice on the bodies of the fallen brave. Some psychological warfare going on there. clearly we know that the troopers at this time think you don't want to get captured by the Indians and the reason that they think that is events like this mutilated bodies everyone killed no court or given now going to what some of the other officers were like I'm going to talk about captain benton here's what captain benton was like back to the book most of the time we were in the field captain benton commanded a squad Usually he'd have one or two companies besides his own H company. He was a wonderful officer. He let the first sergeant pretty much run the company. Hmm. Little decentralized command going on.
Starting point is 00:25:30 He wasn't always interfering and running the details. So he wasn't getting in the weeds. He wasn't a micromanager. I served under Bentin for 12 full years, lacking only those three days. One of the best descriptions of Captain Bentin is that penned by the the late major general Hugh L. Scott on page 454 of his interesting book, Some Memoirs of a Soldier. I found my model early in Captain Benton, the idol of the 7th Cavalry on the Upper Missouri in 1877, who governed mainly by suggestion. In all the years, I knew him, I never once heard him raise
Starting point is 00:26:13 his voice to enforce his purpose. Think about that. Never once heard him raise his voice to enforce his purpose. He would sit by the open fire at night, his bright, pleasant face framed by his snow white hair, beaming with kindness and humor, and often watched, often I watched his every movement to find out the secret of his quiet, steady government that I might go and govern likewise. For example, if he intended to stay a few days in one camp, he would say to his adjutant, Brewer, don't you think we had better take up our regular guard, Mount Wallen camp? And Brewer always thought it better, and so did everyone else. If he found this kindly manner was misunderstood, then his iron hand would close quickly down, but that was seldom necessary. and then only with newcomers and never twice with the same person.
Starting point is 00:27:15 So this is just complete example of indirect leadership. Hey, do you think it be good if we're going to stay in this camp? We should put our camp guards out. What do you think? Of course. There you go. So you make it happen. I didn't give you an order.
Starting point is 00:27:29 I actually let you get some ownership of it. It's actually now your decision. It's not even my decision anymore. That's a really good example of some solid leadership. here's what it was like to be in the cavalry it was wonderful to be young and to be riding into indian country as part of the finest regiment of cavalry in the world we were mighty proud of the seventh it just didn't seem like anything could ever happen to it now i'm going to go through they're riding out they're they're working the planes and i'm going to go through a little
Starting point is 00:28:11 battle on the plains where custer's in charge general george custer's in charge The general started So did the Indians They had a good start And General Costa resolved Not to pursue them too far away from his men After a sharp short race He stopped on the plane
Starting point is 00:28:28 Keeping well away from the suspicious woods When he stopped The Indians stopped It was evident that they would not be so audacious Without a conscious Without a consciousness of strength somewhere For ways that are dark and tricks that are vain
Starting point is 00:28:48 the heathen Sioux is almost as peculiar as the heathen Chinese and I actually had to go and do a little research on that one there's a poem that's
Starting point is 00:29:02 it's about Chinese migrant workers and interesting you can go and read about this poem it's called the heathen Chinese and if you read the poem you realize that he's trying to describe that they're playing cards
Starting point is 00:29:17 with a couple of the people working on the train are playing cards of the Chinese guy and as they're playing cards they're kind of treating the Chinese guy like he's ignorant but he's actually winning and when they accuse him of cheating there's a fight and it was actually the white guy that was cheating
Starting point is 00:29:36 one of the other white guys that was cheating so the guy that wrote the poem had written the poem with the intention of showing hey these people are smart and they're trustworthy. But because of the name, it got read and misinterpreted a lot. The title of the poem you mean?
Starting point is 00:29:52 The heathen Chinese, you know, that's not a very positive, positive name. At least that's kind of, I did some very quick research on that just to figure out what it's all about. And that's sort of what I gathered after a quick, uh,
Starting point is 00:30:07 quick research, meaning I googled it and read a few articles to figure out what's going on. No, it's, in, um, in a Hawaiian pigeon. When we say Japanese, we say Japanese. Oh.
Starting point is 00:30:20 Portuguese is Portuguese. Hmm. Chinese? Chinese. Maybe some kind of a... Maybe some relationship. Some connection there. I don't know.
Starting point is 00:30:28 All right. Back to the book. This time, the trick was indeed vain. They were fighting with no novice. As soon as General Custer saw the Indian Dodge, which was to use these men as a decoy to draw him into the woods, he immediately sent his orderly back to Captain Moyland, to order a platoon to dismount.
Starting point is 00:30:48 Before the order could get back, 250 mounted Indians drawn up in a line of battle came out of the woods in fine military style. The 7th Cavalry could hardly have done it better. With painted faces, heads decorated with ribbons, they sallied out with loud war wolves. General Custer, putting more confidence in the feet of his thoroughbred than the voice of his rifle against 250 Indians,
Starting point is 00:31:11 turned back to his command, calling out to his brother to throw out a dismounted line. Lieutenant Custer had anticipated the order and was already dismounting his men. That's awesome. So these guys worked together. He goes to give the order. His brother's already on it.
Starting point is 00:31:28 They ran forward and took places in the grass. The Indians opened a heavy fire, which was quickly answered by our men with their sharp carbines. In a dismounted cavalry fight, every fourth man is usually detailed to hold the horses. But being short of,
Starting point is 00:31:44 fighting men and the reserves being several miles back with the train, General Kuster ordered every six men only to hold the horses, and the rest to join the skirmish line. The Indians, having three times as large a force, and seeing the cavalry dismounted, followed their example and dismounted. From their advantage of numbers, they were able to extend the skirmish line clear around from river to river so as to enclose the cavalry in a semi-circle with the woods and the river at their back. They're getting flanked. Finding that the horses were exposed to fire, General Custer ordered them to be led further
Starting point is 00:32:22 into the timber. Now, some other things take place, and I'm going to fast forward a little bit through the story. The Indians, having lost two men, were more cautious in their advance, and finding that they could not, with their heavy rifles, drive the cavalry into the woods, had recourse to another favorite weapon. they fired the grass in four or five places, meaning they set the grass on fire. So you imagine you're hiding in the grass, and then all of a sudden they're setting the grass on fire.
Starting point is 00:32:53 Fortunately, there was little or no wind, and the grass was too short and too green to burn well, else this new weapon might have proved formidable indeed. The fire, however, raised a blue curtain of smoke, forming a corner segment between the fighting arcs, Failing in their attempt to raise a great fire, the Redskins used this smoke line as a mask for their rifles. Advancing under cover of this curtain, they would pour a volley at our line and retreat. A little bit of cover and move happening. Our men soon discovered the Dodge and laid equal claim to the curtain. The Indians, abandoning this position, began to draw in their men.
Starting point is 00:33:35 Now, General Custard said to Captain Moylan, let us mount and drive. them off the men immediately mounted and advanced as skirmishers on a trot finding this was not fast enough a charge was ordered the men eager for the order gave a loud yell and put their horses into a full gallop nearly 300 and number the sight of 80 cavalry men coming toward them like mad caps was too much for the Indians they turned like sheep and scattered in every direction battles battles on the planes small unit tactics very similar to the small unit tactics that are used today. We use smoke.
Starting point is 00:34:22 We use smoke in Ramadi. We have smoke grenades. What do you use those for? Set up a little curtain so people can't see you when you're moving. And you'll notice also there was some aggressive action. It's that aggressive action. Both sides. When they got aggressive, they started doing better.
Starting point is 00:34:40 When you start getting, when your opponent becomes the aggressor, you start getting put on your heels. You've got to stay aggressive. default mode now talking a little bit about what it was like when they were back in camp so they weren't out on the road all the time they weren't out in the planes all the time sometimes they'd be back in camp they had their they had bands they had some of them had their wives there they had good food and you know basically good stuff going on they had pretty relaxed time but it was always let's prepare we're going back out in the
Starting point is 00:35:17 field so they're back out in the field here general custer who as usual was riding ahead with a couple of troops came upon smoldering campfires that showed that three Indian TPs had recently been there. He sent Bloody Knife ahead with several Indians. So that Bloody Knife, you're going to hear his voice throughout here. Bloody Knife was Custer's right-hand man. He was an Indian scout. Soon they galloped back with the information that they had located the Indians. Custer surrounded the little camp and brought back four bucks with him.
Starting point is 00:35:50 to our camp. The head was a minor chief named one stab whose squaw was a daughter of red cloud. Custer promised them food if they helped them. But they seemed to be in a hurry to leave. And before they could be checked, they mounted their ponies and were off. Custer sent troopers after them, but the only one they could catch and bring back was one stab. He was told he would be given all the bacon, sugar and coffee that two ponies could carry if he'd act as a guide. He agreed. So again, I guess the reason I wanted to bring that up is it shows that there was Indians working on both sides and there was Indians that went from back and forth between sides
Starting point is 00:36:37 depending on, you know, depending on what the situation is, depending on how they got bribed. But, and also, you know, we know that there was wars between the Indians, you know? So that's why sometimes the Indians team. teamed up with the soldiers, the American troops, and went and got after it with them. Yeah, is that because they got, when you say bribe, like they got kind of enticed with civilization. Well, no, I'm talking about that was a straight up bribe right there.
Starting point is 00:37:03 They're talking to one stab and they say, hey, one stab, will you help guide us? Well, I don't know if I feel comfortable about that. Okay, we'll give you all the bacon, all the sugar and all the coffee that you can carry on two horses. He says, all right, cool, I'm in. Yeah, and if they're warring, you know, if that's kind of their enemy in a way, you know, you know? Yeah, let's do it. Yeah, maybe he was just getting some food out of what he would already like to do. Yeah, and what is it, the enemy of my enemy is my friend.
Starting point is 00:37:29 There you go. There you go. Now, in the Black Hills, they think that they find gold. They think they find gold in the Black Hills. And this is just a good comment here about, I guess you could say it's about material desires. Gold to most men mean sudden wealth, big times. Whiskey and gambling and women. It means fortune and adventure and all the things they never had.
Starting point is 00:37:59 The gold fever is like taking dope. You're helpless when it strikes you. Be careful that material greed. I once read about how everyone who touched an Egyptian king's tomb was doomed to die of violent death. Seems to me that the Indians must have put some curse like that on the white men who first touched their sacred Black Hills at this time. Custer got a lot of notoriety from his Black Hills expedition and the discovery of gold. But he never had any luck after that.
Starting point is 00:38:45 Now, getting just a cursory look at the politics of what were happening at the time. An attempt was made that summer of 75. to buy the Black Hills from the Indians and make legal this onslaught. But the Indians were in no mood to believe anything the commissioners told them. And it was impossible to make a deal of any kind. A feeling of utter despair and despondency
Starting point is 00:39:11 cast its spell over even the friendly reservation Indians. Maybe the radical thing sitting bull and crazy horse and gall and two moons and the other wild chiefs far back in the buffalo lands around the powder and the big horn were preaching, maybe they made sense. The free Indian was doomed. They were all to be made reservation Indians.
Starting point is 00:39:34 That meant all the colorful old life would be gone forever. The buffalo hunts, the feasts, the sun dances, the visiting, and the pleasant horse-stealing wars. All the old life would be no more. Maybe those radical chiefs were right. Maybe they'd all be better to make one big battle against the whites. It would be better to die a free Indian than live as a degraded, helpless treaty Indian. So evident was the hostile feeling that in the fall of 1875 that an order was submitted by the Commissioner of Indian Affairs, Edward P. Smith, to the Secretary of the Interior, Z. Chandler, who in turn submitted to the Secretary of War, General Belknap.
Starting point is 00:40:22 A subsequent communication from the Secretary of Interior to the Secretary of War dated December 1st, 1875 read as follows. I have the honor to inform you that I have this day directed the Commissioner of Indian Affairs to notify said Indian Sitting Bull and the others outside their reservations that they must return to their reservations before January 31, 1876. and if they neglect or refuse, so to move, they will be reported to the War Department as hostile Indians and that a military force will be sent to compel them to obey the order of the Indian Department. There it is. To compel them. Yep, there it is.
Starting point is 00:41:11 And how, you know, that's, that's, that, you have to be wary of your government having so much. power and leaving yourself defenseless in these situations I think we learn a lot from the Indians from the Native Americans on that back to the book general Custer was not at for Abraham Lincoln when we arrived there in late April 1876 of course that aroused a lot of talk and suspicion when you jiggled all those rumors down you got about this We were soon to start a big expedition up to Yellowstone
Starting point is 00:41:58 to round up the hostiles and drive them back to the reservations. If they would not go peacefully, we were to make good Indians out of them. There was a lot of suspicious talk going around all over the place. Custer was still in the east, so Custer had gone back to the east, and you could hear a hundred tales of how he was being kept away from the expedition because he had got under the skin of President. Grant. A lot of the troopers didn't much care for Custer, but it looked as if Major Reno would command the regiment if Custer didn't arrive. And most of us didn't know or care a great deal about
Starting point is 00:42:37 Reno. Of course, we knew that he had been a colonel of a Pennsylvania cavalry regiment at the end of the Civil War, but he had never fought Indians. And he didn't seem to be very popular with either the men or the officers. If I remember correctly, he was a West Pointer. and was three or four years ahead of Custer. It was pretty clear that there wasn't much love lost between the two men. Politics. Total politics. And sometimes people in the civilian world, they don't realize this stuff happens all the time.
Starting point is 00:43:08 This is politics, crazy politics in the military. And just this kind of stuff right here. Oh, you're senior to me. Oh, you made the other guy mad. And now we're going to get pulled up. I'm going to pull you off this operation. I'm going to let this guy go on the operation. This is just so typical of the military.
Starting point is 00:43:23 unfortunately. And you know what? It's not just typical to the military. It's typical in any company, any business, any team. There's always going to be these political things that are happening.
Starting point is 00:43:33 I mean, occasionally you get to a great organization that really limits that. I shouldn't say it's everywhere, but it's very, very common. Yeah. And, you know, someone just asked me on Twitter, you know, hey, it's really political. I'm not really good at politics.
Starting point is 00:43:48 You know, is it something that I should actually try and engage in? Yes. Yes, it's going to, you have to. If you're in an organization, that's a political organization, and you want to make things happen, you want to implement changes, yes, start figuring out how to play those games. Yeah. Oh, you don't, you're not a political person, cool, become one. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:44:08 Because what you want to do is you want to do a good job. You want to do a good job and whatever it is that you're doing. And sometimes that requires that you play those games. So play the games. Get good at them. Back to the book. Everything was uncertain in those late April. and early May days while the regiment was being whipped into marching shape.
Starting point is 00:44:30 We had a few recruits, a bunch and a bunch of fresh young horses, so there was plenty to do to break in both of them. One thing that people get wrong about the recruits was that about half of the 150 new men we had were men who either had civil war experience or had already served a five-year hitch in the army. Most of the rest were plenty green. A good many of them were German boys. They made fine soldiers once they were trained.
Starting point is 00:44:55 I think it was about May 10th that General Custer suddenly showed up. General Terry was with him. Terry was of slight build and wore whiskers. He was a gentle, kindly man who never strutted or roared. Nothing at all like the quick-moving, dashing young Custer. Terry was a brigadier general of the regular army, and so he ranked Custer by two grades. Word ran around camp that General Terry was to command the whole expedition, but that Custer was to have his old regiment. Custer was as happy as a boy with a new red sled.
Starting point is 00:45:29 He put a lot of zip into us. Now Custer, this political stuff that he's dealing with, it's still going on. It's still happening. And I'm not going to go through the details of it, but he's somehow seen as an agitator or an enemy of President Grant. And so he actually gets ordered off. So he goes back out, takes back over the regiment, starts whipping people into shape.
Starting point is 00:45:58 He's going to work for General Terry. President Grant says, no, actually, come back. You don't get to do this. And Custer decides he writes a dispatch to be sent directly to the president of the United States. That's kind of crazy. We didn't do much communications with the president from my task interview. here we go back to the book and oh wait here's so here's what he actually sent is awesome that's what's beautiful about history this is what custer actually sent and and grant grant president grant
Starting point is 00:46:36 was a guy that was you know went to west point as well he fought in the mexican-american war he retired after that was retired from the army but then the civil war started so he went back in the army as a general and he fought it. Shiloh and Vicksburg and actually generally surrendered to President Graham. So this guy's a warrior and here's what you're going to hear Custer kind of appeal to that. Here we go. I have seen your order transmitted through the general of the army directing that I not be permitted to accompany the expedition about to move against the hostile Indians. As my entire regiment forms a part of the proposed expedition, and as I am the senior officer of the regiment on duty in the department, I respectfully but most earnestly request that while not allowed to go in command of the expedition, I may be permitted to serve with my regiment in the field.
Starting point is 00:47:42 I appeal to you as a soldier to spare me the humiliation of seeing my regiment march to meet the enemy, and I am I. not to share its dangers. It was too much for the hero, the hero of Appomattox. Custer was to have back his beloved regiment. So Grant gives in and says, okay, you can go. You're not going to be in charge, but you can go. And so they roll out on this expedition. And here's the description of what that felt like.
Starting point is 00:48:20 You felt like you were somebody when you were on a good horse with a carbine dangling from its small leather ring socket on your saddle and a cult army revolver strapped on your hip and a hundred rounds of ammunition in your web belt and your saddle pockets you were a cavalryman of the seventh regiment you were part of a proud outfit that had a fighting reputation and you were ready for a fight or a frolic so these guys had some pretty good morale rolling out they did some hard training when they were in camp and now they're ready to get after it talks a little bit about Custer he describes Custer I can almost see him myself in my mind's eye he was wearing a broad Western
Starting point is 00:49:07 hat with a low crown and a wide brim it was grayish in color he'd had his long yellow hair cut just before we left and he had on a buckskin suit with fringe he had two short bill barreled bulldog revolvers and a Remington sporting rifle carried in a scabbard. It's my recollection that he carried a hunting knife in a fringed buckskin case. So that's, I mean, you know, straight up
Starting point is 00:49:38 rock and roll stars of the 70s wore fringe on their outfits, right? So Custer is a, he's a character. He's definitely a character. Back to the book, when the regiment was formed in Kansas in 1866, the general that went, the general went to a lot of trouble
Starting point is 00:49:56 to have each, troop mounted on distinct colors. I thought this was awesome, so I included it. He's talking about what color horses they had, and each troop had a specific colored horse. I can still call them off even at this late date. H, my own troop rode blood bays. B, D, I, and L also were mounted on bays.
Starting point is 00:50:21 C, G, and K had sorrels. A had coal blacks. and Lieutenant Edgeley's E-Troop had gray's. We used to call E, the band box troop. M-trop was the only troop that had mixed colors. The whole band rode white horses. I remember the drummer had a horse that would run away every time he mounted him,
Starting point is 00:50:45 except when he put his drum on him. Then that old horse would stand still as a wooden horse. It was a fine regiment right enough. And there wasn't a man in it who didn't believe it was the greatest cavalry out. in the entire United States Army. That actually is, when I hear about these guys talking about the horses,
Starting point is 00:51:07 we actually had little relationships like that with our Humvees. We'd name them, you know, we named our Humvees. Yeah, we named our Humvees various names. We used to have, when we used to do a lot more water work before the war started, we would, we actually named our outboard motors than they had little, my, one of my, the guy that handled the outboard motors in my second platoon, he was all into it.
Starting point is 00:51:37 And his nickname was Zulu. But Zulu, he was all into these motors. And he had every motor had a name and he kept these detailed logbooks on how many hours and when the maintenance was done all that. And when we came back from one deployment and we were going to go do another deployment, we came back, they said, hey, you know, you guys, guess what? Good news. We got all new motors. and we're going to issue you whatever it was. We had eight outboard motors.
Starting point is 00:52:02 We're going to give you all new motors. You know, come and turn yours in and we'll send those off to wherever, get repaired or going to go into the garbage can. And you know what Zulu said? He said, I want the new motors. I got my motors.
Starting point is 00:52:17 I know where they've been. I know their personalities. The motors have personalities. Well, the motors have personalities. Motor nalities. Yeah, they had personalities. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:52:28 motor nalities and he wanted to make sure he had a relationship with those motors and you want to give them up going back to the book they're they're starting to be out on patrol and they're marching up what's called the rosebud h and the five remaining troops headed down the powder and eventually arrived at the southern bank of the yellowstone the wagons had a tough time and it wasn't until custer had taken a troop and scouted out a good road that the heavy wagons could make it custer was mighty good at this kind of work. He had a nose for scouting and finding the best trails. It was June, it was noon on June 22nd when we broke camp and started our march up the rosebud. This, just before we packed our mules, Bentine ordered us to take an extra supply of salt.
Starting point is 00:53:23 That meant we might be living on mule or horse meat before we got back. I suppose we all knew by this time that we'd be hitting it into dangerous country. but as I look back I don't believe many troopers were very worried we knew there'd be some hard fighting but a soldier always feels that it's the other fellow who's going to get it never himself that morning word spread about the camp the mail was going to be sent back home and that this would likely be the last chance to get off letters of course I didn't have anybody to write to but the officers and many of the men heard least scribbled letters to their dear ones And as they go to mail off these letters, they're on a boat.
Starting point is 00:54:08 The troops are on a boat, and they've barely gone 50 feet with these letters to get them mailed off when the boat was overturned. And all three men disappeared along with the mail sack. Now here's the orders that they get as they're going up. These are actually the orders to Custer. And again, what's awesome is these are documented. This isn't the hearsay. These are documented orders. Colonel, the Brigadier General Commanding, directs that as soon as your regiment can be made ready for the march, you proceed up the rosebud in pursuit of the Indians whose trailed was discovered by Major Reno a few days since.
Starting point is 00:54:48 It is, of course, impossible to give you any definite instructions in regard to this movement. And were it not impossible to do so the department commander places too much confidence in your zeal, energy, and ability to wish to improve. pose on you precise orders. Pretty, so he's giving him, hey, look, here's my general idea. He's giving me some commander's intent, but he doesn't want to give him anything too specific because he knows he can't, he hasn't always going to be in two days. What's going to be happening up there? He will, however, indicate to you his own views of what actions should be and desires
Starting point is 00:55:26 that you should conform to them unless you should see sufficient reason for departing from them. So he gives them his orders, but he gives them. some pretty good leeway to work through. And that's why there's some, there's some discussion on whether or not Custer disobeyed. It's, and there's, it's a long discussion probably with no one could ever come with a solid conclusion on because there was some,
Starting point is 00:55:51 there was definitely some, some leeway in, in the orders and those, that was the leeway that I just read. Then the orders continue to go on, but I'm not going to go into those minor details of them. Back to the book, we hit the trail at 5 o'clock sharp that second morning. These guys are up pretty early.
Starting point is 00:56:11 Probably had to get up like, I don't know, 4.30 to get on the road before 5 o'clock. Around noon, we began past signs of big Indian camps. As I remember, we made around 33 miles that day. The next day, we rode hard too. There was no foolishness. Custer had a bunch of re and crow scouts ahead with him. And he kept them covering the ground far off both flanks of the column. We were an Indian country now, right enough.
Starting point is 00:56:45 So that's very common. We'd still do that today. You have a main element moving in a formation and out on the flanks, maybe some high ground. You have other smaller elements that can protect your flanks and see if there's any problems up ahead. In one place we halted there had been a sun dance lodge. The scalp of a white man was still hanging from the ridge pole. Getting in an Indian country.
Starting point is 00:57:13 It was around 8 o'clock when we got orders to saddle up. We marched about 10 miles when we were halted in a sort of ravine. We've been told to make as little noise as possible and light no fires. There'd been no bugle calls for a day or two. The sun was at our back, so apparently we were headed straight west now toward the little big horn. I later learned that the Indians called it greasy grass. I never did know why. About the time General Custer came back from his scout, word went around that the Indians had found a box of hard tack that had dropped from one of Captain Yates' mules. Two or three troopers who had been sent back
Starting point is 00:57:53 to pick up the box had reported seeing two hostels trying to open it with their tomahawks. This meant that the Indians held us, had us under observation. Apparently, Custer had figured on hiding the command in the ravine
Starting point is 00:58:07 during the day and then attacking the big Indian village on the little big horn at daybreak the next morning. So they're, they know that the Indians know that they're there,
Starting point is 00:58:23 is why I included that. And you're going to hear that kind of over and over again. Custer's thinking they're going to surprise them and everyone's telling them, we're not going to surprise them. They know we're here. It was Sunday morning June 25th.
Starting point is 00:58:36 We were still more than 12 miles from the Little Horn and the Indian village, but the Indians knew where we were and all about us. I approached as near that now so he sees a conversation going on and it's actually Custer and Ben Tien and they're having a conversation with a couple people including some of the scouts and he kind of goes over and does a little ease dropping. As I approached as near as seemed respectful and while I was waiting to catch Ben Tien's attention I couldn't help but overhear part of the conversation. Charlie Reynolds, the famous White Scout,
Starting point is 00:59:13 who was never to see the sunset that day, was talking. And I heard him say that there was the biggest bunch of Indians he'd ever seen over there. Finally, I heard Bentine say to Custer, hadn't we better keep the regiment together, General? If this is a big camp, as they say, we'll need every man we have. Custer's only answer was, you have your orders. So you can see, again, Custer, he's not listening to people, scouts, reconnaissance units, and his other officers that are with him.
Starting point is 00:59:54 And this is sort of the classic, you know, hey, I've got to, I disagree with your plan. Shut up and do it anyways. You have your orders. That's a classic example of that. We were tired and dirty and hungry. Our horses hadn't had a good drink of water since the day before, and we weren't much better. off. We knew right enough that this was the day. This was it. This was what we've been training and working for all these years. Captain Bentin used to say the government pays you to get shot at.
Starting point is 01:00:28 And I suppose the dumbest, greenest trooper in the regiment figured that this day he'd get shot at plenty. Here was the 7th cavalry, with a total of some 600 men split up into four outfits. apparently the Indian scouts and experienced old guys guides knew that there were several thousand of the hostels but it was it is my belief that Custer and most of our officers thought they'd have to whip somewhere between a thousand and fifteen hundred and they expected most of these to be poorly armed and poorly led from experience they figured the Indians would fight only a rear guard action while the women children old men and pony herds got away but in place of a maximum of 1500 Indian warriors it developed that there were possibly twice that number about to face Custer's total of 600 so that's the report that they're getting and it's it's there's a little bit of controversy about what how many Indians were there but it was a lot and here here we go this I'm going to jump forward to another section and talking about Custer and did Custer, the name of the chapter is did Custer, and it's sort of
Starting point is 01:02:00 an appendix, so it's not part of the story, it's after the story, but it talks about did Custer refuse advice from his scouts? How many Indian warriors were camped on the west bank of the Little Bighorn that Sunday morning of June 25th? Against the real figure, how many did Custer think he would have to fight? Did Custer refuse to believe the estimated number of warriors his scouts told him he would have to fight? Did he fail to follow the advice of his experienced guides and interpreters. One of the best accounts of what the guides thought about the number of Indians and the chances of Custer closing with them is contained in the excellent book William Jackson,
Starting point is 01:02:38 Indian Scout, by James William Schultz. Willard Schultz. It is worth careful reading. And here's a couple excerpts from that. On the third day, we struck the trail of the hostels, the one that Reno had found several days before. Said Bloody Knife. Now remember, Bloody Knife is
Starting point is 01:02:59 Custer's, you know, main scout. They're tight. Said Bloody Knife. My friends, this big trail proves what we heard. That the Ogallala,
Starting point is 01:03:14 the Minniconju, the Sansark, and the Titon Sioux have left their agencies to join Sitting Bowl and Crazy Hurs. horse. I am sure that even this trail does not account for all that have left their agencies. There surely are other trails. And trails two of the Cheyans and the Arapahos. Bloody Knife continued. It is, as I have told Longhair, this gathering of enemy tribes is too many for us, but he will not
Starting point is 01:03:50 believe me. He is bound to lead us against them. They are not far away. Just over this ridge, they are all encamped and waiting for us. Crazy horse and sitting bull are not men without sense. They have their scouts, too, and some of them surely have their eyes upon us. Well, tomorrow, we are going to have a big fight, a losing fight. Myself, I know what is to happen to me. My sacred helper has given me warning that I am not to see the set of tomorrow's son. Sad words, those, they chilled us.
Starting point is 01:04:27 I saw Charlie Reynolds nod an agreement to them and was chilled again when he said in a low voice, I feel as he does. Tomorrow will be the end for me too. Anyone who wants my little outfit of stuff, pointing to his war pack, can have it now. Lieutenant Varnum, who was in charge of the scouts, came over and said that it was General Custer's plan
Starting point is 01:04:51 to attempt a surprise attack on the camp of the enemy. Said bloody knife, We cannot surprise the enemy. They are not crazy. Without doubt, their scouts have watched every move we have made. Convinced at last that we could not possibly surprise the enemy, General Custer ordered a quick advance with the scouts and himself in the lead. We had not gone far when Bloody Knife and his two rees joined us and reported that on the other side of the ridge,
Starting point is 01:05:28 they had found the day-old trail of many more enemy going toward the valley of Little Bighorn. They were excited and said to Custer, General, we have discovered the camp down there on the little big horn. It is a big one, too big for you to tackle. Why there are thousands and thousands of Sue and Cheyenne's down there. For a moment the general stared at him angrily, I thought, and then said sternly, I shall attack them.
Starting point is 01:05:57 Classic ego maniac right here. Sorry, but that's what this is. Yeah. Custer gave orders for attack upon the camp. None of the scouts had been far in the lead, and they all came in. Rees and Crows and whites and Robert and I, we were a gathering of solemn faces. Speaking in English and the sign language, too, so that all would understand, Brewer described the enemy camp. It was, he said, all of three miles long and made up of hundreds of lodges, hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of lodges. Above it and below it and west of it, there were thousands of.
Starting point is 01:06:36 and thousands of horses that were being close-herded. With his few riders, Longhair decided to attack the camp, and we were going to have a terrible fight. We should all take courage, fight hard, make our every shot a killer. He finished and none spoke. But after a minute or two, bloody knife looked up and signed to the sun, I shall not see you go down behind the mountains tonight. And at that I almost choked.
Starting point is 01:07:05 I felt he knew his end was near and there was no escaping it. I turned and looked the other way. I thought that my own end was near. I felt very sad. So there's the full account of these, all the scouts. Some are, you know, some are white, some are Indian, Native Americans, different tribes. And they're all telling them the same thing. This is not a good plan.
Starting point is 01:07:32 So back to the book, apparently Custer had planned to stay in hiding in the ravine. We had reached a little after 10 o'clock that Sunday. And then attacked the village at daybreak the next morning of the 26th. That would more or less have dovetailed into Terry's idea of boxing the Indians. But when he found the hostile scouts had discovered his column, he figured there was nothing to do but attack it once. Now, we get a little report here. from a guy named Sergeant Daniel Knaip,
Starting point is 01:08:19 who had barely turned 23 at the time of the battle. In Knaip's own account of the fight published in the magazine of the Historical Society of Montana, he said, when we got to the top of the bluffs, the Indians had disappeared, but we were in plain view of the Indian camps, which appeared to cover a space of about two miles wide and four miles long on the west side of the river.
Starting point is 01:08:42 We were then charging at full speed. This camp is two miles wide. That's a map, two miles. Two by four. Two by four miles. And you got 600 guys. And actually, they didn't even, Custer doesn't have 600 guys. He got 200 guys.
Starting point is 01:09:01 Reno and his troops were again seen to our left, moving at full speed down the valley. At the site of the Indian camps, the boys of our five troops began to cheer overconfidence. Some of the horses became so, excited that the riders were unable to hold them in ranks and the last word i heard general custer say we're hold your horses in boys there are plenty of them down there for all of us again now we have total overconfidence in the situation we think we're going to win this is going to be fun oh there's a
Starting point is 01:09:32 two by four mile big camp no big deal i got 500 guys with me so this is where the force is split up and custer goes off to attack it seems like he goes about a mile away, mile and a half away. And again, I'm going to make the same statement that I said when I talked about the battle with when we did the wooden leg podcast. I'm not trying to historically reconstruct the battle right now. There's plenty of books that do that. So I'm just kind of assembling the broad design of what's happening.
Starting point is 01:10:08 So now the forces split up. Reno and Bentino kind of have troops and holding, but they're starting to get a little firefight themselves. we saw a second figure in uniform riding towards us. He was trumpeteer martini of my company who had been assigned that morning as a special orderly trumpeteer to General Custer. I learned afterwards that he had a message from Custer to Ben Tene
Starting point is 01:10:31 that had been scribbled out on a field order pad and signed by Lieutenant Cook the adjutant. It read Benteen, come on, big village, be quick, bring packs. P.S. Bring pack. That's the note that they get from Custer. Sounds like Custer might have, once he split off, things started going sideways real quick. They, again, Bentine and Reno have their troops
Starting point is 01:11:04 start now getting engaged in a firefight. Back to the book, we could hear heavy firing now. Before long, we passed several Croweer rescouts, driving a few head of Indian ponies, and they shouted soldiers and pointed toward the bluffs that were rising towards the north. We knew that we were close to the valley of Little Big Horn and that somewhere in this neighborhood there was hard fighting going on. Bentine ordered us to draw pistols and we charged up the bluffs at a gallop,
Starting point is 01:11:30 expecting at any moment to run into hostels. When we reached the brow of the first set of rolling hills, the river valley suddenly opened up below us to our left. It was a sight to strike terror in the hearts of the bravest men. Down there in the valley, maybe 150 feet or more below us, and somewhere around a half a mile away, there were figures galloping on horseback and much shooting. Farther down the river, there were great masses of mounted men. We suspicioned were Indians. We were going at a fast clip ourselves, and we had no more than caught the swift glimpse of this tragic battlefield below when we saw mounted and dismounted soldiers on a knoll of a hill to the northward.
Starting point is 01:12:15 We swiftly rode towards them. So these guys are seeing this massive battle take place. They're kind of on the high ground. He talks about here what kind of weaponry the Indians had. For my part, I believe that fully half of the warriors carried only bows and arrows and lances. And that possibly half of the remainder carried odds and end of old muzzleloaders and single-shot rifles of various vintages. Probably not more than 25 or 30% of the warriors carried modern repeating rifles. That sounds pretty close to what Wooden Legs said.
Starting point is 01:12:54 They said they mostly had bows and arrows. Some guys had rifles, but it was mostly bows and arrows. And one other point. Indian boys from 14 years old up accompanied the warriors and took part, especially in the later stages of the fighting. The soldiers, incidentally, were armed with single shot 45-70 caliber Springfield carbines and accurate and deadly weapon up to 600 yards. But when fired rapidly, the breach became foul,
Starting point is 01:13:21 and the greasy cartridges often jammed. It could not be removed by the extractor. This meant that the empty shell had to be forced out by the blade of a hunting knife. This very fact was responsible for the death of many a trooper this hot Sunday and may actually have been the indirect cause of the great disaster. Weapons getting dirty. Weapons getting hot and dirty. Got to take care of your weapon.
Starting point is 01:13:44 It sounds like this was beyond that. them just taking care of their weapon. Sounds like it was a design issue as well. Reno had crossed the river and had his troops in line of columns of four with the Indian scouts on his left. Soon Indian horsemen were seen riding madly to and fro in the valley and shortly the southern end of the Indian camps came into view. Reno now had his three troops and scouts thrown out in a skirmish line covering possibly
Starting point is 01:14:16 the full width of the narrow valley. So they see the enemy. Now they get online. That's a very common thing. If you can picture this, you've got your guys in a column. If you're in a column of three, three columns, and you see the enemy ahead of you, how many people do you think can shoot?
Starting point is 01:14:34 The three. The three at the front. So that's why you keep hearing this idea of a skirmish line. And it's the same tactic that we use now. Oh, we got enemy at front of us. Cool. We're going to get online. They call it a skirmish line here.
Starting point is 01:14:45 We would call it a get online. Like the old. They spread out and get online. So now they get, they got 50 guys. Cool, they have 50 guns online instead of three. Yeah. Realizing that this charge toward the Indian hordes would end in almost certain disaster, Reno now ordered his troops to dismount and fight on foot.
Starting point is 01:15:05 Even before this order came, scores of Indians had swung to the southwestward and pressed against the crow and re-scouts. These were forced to give way. Things were looking bad for Reno and even. ordered his skirmish lines to fall back to the edge of a heavy grove of cottonwoods that followed a bend in the river and jutted out halfway across the valley. The horses were led into the woods while a thin line of men held three sides of the grove. Some 90 men were holding not less than 250 yards of line. Hundreds of mounted Indians were now half-circling the skirmish line,
Starting point is 01:15:39 riding in close, firing from under their ponies' necks and then galloping away. Reno's men were now either firing from a prone position or using the bank of a dry creek bed as a barricade and rifle rest. So Reno's guys are now getting basically surrounded. In taking up this new position, Sergeant O'Hara of Troop M had been killed, the first man on the skirmish line to die. Apparently, Reno had a fairly defendable position, and some people think if he had pulled in his lines and consolidated his position, he might have held out here for an indefinite length of time. or at least as long as his ammunition lasted. But the savage yells, the heavy firing, the smoke and dust, all, and fear, all combined to fog his judgment. Suddenly Custer's favorite scout, Bloody Knife was shot through the head and his brain scattered all over Reno.
Starting point is 01:16:34 Then the scout Dorman fell, and Charlie Reynolds was shot through the head. Reno, figuring that his only chance lay in getting to high ground across the river, shouted for his men to mount up in company formation. Two troop commanders heard the order, and amid the confusion and excitement, had their men mount up and line in column of force. The third troop, G, under Lieutenant McIntosh, himself part Indian, who had been adopted by General McIntosh, was in the woods and did not get the order until the two other troops, with Reno riding at their head,
Starting point is 01:17:08 were racing upstream trying to find a place to cross the river. All order and discipline were gone. So they're surrounded. Things fall apart. He's basically saying we got to retreat. We got to get out of here. And the assessment was that maybe they were in a defendable position. They could have held there.
Starting point is 01:17:27 Who knows? Who knows whether that's true or not? Nobody will ever know how any man escaped alive from this mad retreat. All we are sure of. is that the charging troop broke through the cordon of mounted Indians and followed a buffalo craft to the river. Here, they somehow managed to jump their horses over a four or five foot bank, plunge across the stream, and scramble up a narrow trail to the steep hills to the east.
Starting point is 01:17:57 Hundreds of Indians fired indiscriminately into the panic-stricken soldiers, and the wonder is that any trooper escaped. No motion picture could be as fantastic as this wide, milling of frightened men and horses. Again, just to remind you that this is what's happening with Reno and his group, they don't know where Custer is right now with his crew of 200 guys. Back to the book, in all 26 troopers and scouts and three officers were killed, either in this ride through the Indian gauntlet or back at the edge of the woods.
Starting point is 01:18:34 of the 19 men left behind, 17 crossed the river, and reached Reno Hill on foot within two hours. Lieutenant Derrudeau and Private O'Neill did not join us until 36 hours later. They came right through where I was on guard. It was now somewhere around 3.30 in the afternoon. Reno, shaken and unnerved, had reached the hilltop and here his frightened troopers were joining him. he was whipped and completely disorganized. This is a rally point. And if you have a pre-designated rally point
Starting point is 01:19:15 and you say, hey guys, look, you see this big hill over here? If everything goes to hell, we get all jumbled up, go to that point. It doesn't sound like he actually pre-brief that because that would have been a, you could have just said, hey, back to the rally point,
Starting point is 01:19:30 you could have given a very clear order. If you're trying to not really know where you're going and you're saying retreat, well, you don't do it in a very organized fashion. So pre-plan some contingencies. Now they get in this position and Reno, like I said, is in rough shape. Back to the book. Cool, capable Bentine, more or less assumed command. Major Reno had just come through a terrible experience and at the moment was glad to have
Starting point is 01:20:02 Benteen his junior take over. Quickly Benteen dismounted his own three troops. and ordered us to form a skirmish line. Reno's men had expended most of their ammunition, so we were told to divide ours with them. We had Bentine's 120 men intact, and there were around 60 men who'd been fighting in the valley with Reno. And even before we got the kinks out of our legs
Starting point is 01:20:27 from our long hours in the saddle, we were asking each other, where's Kuster? What had become of Kuster and his five troops? Apparently, Custer was now much farther on to the northward, and in this moment was hotly engaged, but no one was certain. All we knew was that he had disappeared with almost half the regiment. We could hear the sound of distant firing echoing through the hills and valleys from that direction. Custer must be down there.
Starting point is 01:21:01 So this is happening. They're in the skirmish position, and they're starting to try and get reorganized. back to the book The wounded men who could mount were put on horses But the others were carried in blankets By details of six troopers on foot It takes a lot of people to carry a down man Downman
Starting point is 01:21:20 It takes a lot of people to carry a down man And in this case it takes Six people to carry one down man Nowadays we weigh a lot more We got we got all of our guns We got body armor It's hard guys are heavy Pretty soon
Starting point is 01:21:37 it looked as if the Indian masses were coming towards us. It didn't take long to realize that this was true. Here we were stretched out all over Hell's half acre, a troop on this hill knob, another in this little valley, and over there a third troop. Behind at a slow walk came pack trains, the wounded men, and the rear guard. Reno and Bentine both sensed danger and order to withdraw. the advanced troops were dismounting and fought as skirmishers in the center in a slight depression
Starting point is 01:22:13 the horses and mules were staked and an inadequate little field hospital was established but it was impossible to shield the men and stock from the Indians firing from a hilltop off to the east Indians got some high ground on them can't stop them what are you going to do they got high ground you can't hide animal after animal was killed and the men were hit. It was tough not to be able to do something about it. We'd hardly got settled on our own skirmish line with H men posted at 20-foot intervals
Starting point is 01:22:46 when the Indians had all but completely surrounded us. And the fighting began in earnest. There was no full-fledged charge, but little groups of Indians would creep up as close as they could get and from behind bushes or little knolls opened fire. They'd practiced all kinds of cute tricks to draw our fire. Maybe a naked redskin would suddenly jump to his feet. And while you drew a beat on him, he'd throw himself to the ground.
Starting point is 01:23:14 They're under this attack for a pretty good amount of time. And then finally, the sun went down that night like a ball of fire. Pretty soon the quick Montana twilight settled down on us, and then came the chill of the high plains. There was no moon and no one ever welcomed darkness more than we did. We felt terribly alone on that dangerous hilltop. We were a million miles from nowhere, and death was all around us. All through that short black night, the orgy went on down below in the river valley.
Starting point is 01:23:53 It struck fear in our hearts. Just as the mystery of Custer's disappearance made our blood run cold each time we tried to solve it. Where was Custer? What had happened to him? So down, they're up there, they're hiding, it's dark, They're scared. They got wounded. And all they hear down in the valley is the Indians going crazy, the rhythm of the tom-toms, the wild victory dance.
Starting point is 01:24:17 They can hear all this. Back to the book, they're talking about Custer. They could not all be killed. Not lucky Custer and those five-gallant troops who rolled with him. Why had he abandoned us? In those three bloody hours before darkness had saved us, we had no less than a dozen men killed and three times that number wounded. He's actually saying, man, where was Custer? Here we were getting crushed on the battlefield
Starting point is 01:24:44 and Custer's not there to support us. Where'd he go? Now, during the night it rains a little bit and finally the sun starts to come up and just as the sun starts to come up and starts getting light. Back to the book, Jones said something about taking off his overcoat. He started to roll on his side
Starting point is 01:25:06 so that he could get his arms and shoulders out without exposing himself to fire. suddenly I heard him cry out he'd been shot straight through the heart a minute or two later another bullet from the hilltop torn to the hickory butt of my rifle splitting it squarely in two
Starting point is 01:25:25 I was plenty mad because my army carbine wouldn't let me return the compliment so he just got shot in the rifle stock actually happened one of my guys in Ramadi one of my guys got his his rifle stock got blown up by an RPG I see him come falling out of a sniper position And he's got his slaying his weapon is in two pieces
Starting point is 01:25:47 I'm thinking oh Lucky to be alive Along about this time Our 30 or 40 wounded men began crying out for water H troop held the hill here on the southwest There was a draw that ran down the west side of the hill to the river It was rough and exposed and it looked like a dead cinch that anyone who tried to work his way down that draw to the river would be killed. Indians concealed in the bushes across the river were firing up at us and they had every
Starting point is 01:26:20 foot of this draw and riverbank covered. But we had to do something for those men who were up wounded crying for water. Finally, Bentine called for volunteers. I think there were 17 of us all together who stepped forward. He detailed four of us from H who were extra good marksmen to take up an exposed position on the brow of the hill facing the river. We were to stand up and not only draw the fire of the Indians below, but we were to pump as much lead as we could into the bushes where the Indians were hiding, while the water party hurried down to the draw, got their buckets and pots and canteens filled, and then made their way back. So we got a little cover and move happening, obviously. It just happened that the four of us who were posted on the hill were all
Starting point is 01:27:07 German boys, Geiger, Meckling, Voigt, and myself. None of us four were wounded, although we stood exposed on that ridge for more than 20 minutes, and they threw plenty of lead at us. Several of the water party, however, were badly wounded, although we kept the steady fire into the bushes where the Indians were hiding. Each of us was given a congressional medal of honor. You don't think about that. You don't think about it. You're actually going to need water. You run out of water. You're going to get guys dehydrated and die, so now you're going to risk people's lives to go get water. Bentine had been walking up and down the line,
Starting point is 01:27:46 urging men to hold fast not to waste their fire and to keep cool. I remember saying to him, Colonel, you better get down, sir, you'll get killed. Don't worry about me, he answered grimly. I'm all right. He sure lived a charmed life that day. But things looked bad, and finally,
Starting point is 01:28:03 Benteen hurried to the north side of the lines and asked Major Reno for reinforcements. He made it clear that the Indians were about to charge his line, and that if they were able to sweep over it, the whole outfit would be destroyed. Reno told him to take as much of M-trop as he could gather. Those men certainly look good to us. Soon after they came up, Captain Bentin led the charge. Yelling and firing, we went at the double quick and the Indians broke and ran. When we had cleaned them out for a hundred yards ahead of us, we hustled back to our holes. Once again, we
Starting point is 01:28:35 settled back to the business of getting fired at with men hit at intervals, with men hit at intervals, and with the poor horses and mules taking a terrible beating in their hollow. It must have been a long time, long about this time that Bentin called me to attention and made me sergeant. We had one sergeant, two men killed and 12 wounded in age troop alone. So once again, we see some aggressive and we also see some focus of forces, right? We see some prioritize and execute. Hey, we're going to get overrun. Our biggest problem right now is we're going to get overrun.
Starting point is 01:29:09 So you know what? Hey, Major Reno, give me a bunch of guys. and we're going to go do an aggressive assault and take care of this number one priority. So let's focus our forces on that. Here we go. And that's what they did. They got aggressive and got after it.
Starting point is 01:29:23 Back to the book. The gun fired almost ceased and some of us left our trenches and stood in little groups on the brow of the hill. Then something happened that I'll never forget if I lived to be a hundred. The heavy smoke seemed to lift for a few moments
Starting point is 01:29:36 and there in the valley below we caught glimpses of the thousands of Indians on foot and horseback with their pony hordes with our pony herds, dogs and pack animals, and all the trappings of a great camp, slowly moving southward. It was like some biblical exodus, the Israelites moving into Egypt's,
Starting point is 01:29:56 a mighty tribe on the march. We thought at first that it must be some trick that the Indians were only moving their families from danger and that the warriors would soon return and try to overwhelm us. Patiently we waited in our little trenches. The long June afternoon dragged, dawn the firing had all but ceased the smoke in the valley had blown away and the last indian had gone then reno
Starting point is 01:30:24 ordered the whole camp to move as close to the river as possible we would get as far as way as we could from the terrible stench of death there was plenty of water now for the wounded and towards the evening the company cooks made us the best meal they could at least we had hot coffee and plenty of bacon and soaked hard tack It was our first meal in 36 hours. Then night came down. We were weary, but while those on guard were awake and alert, the rest of the command slept. But it was an uneasy sleep.
Starting point is 01:30:58 We still had heard no word from Custer. We began to suspicion that some terrible fate might have overtaken him. What it was, we could only guess. The sun was well in the sky that next morning of the 27th, and we saw dust rising slowly from the valley northward. So then they get approached by a young officer that had been out scouting what was happening. A young officer flung himself off his horse. He was Lieutenant Bradley chief of scouts.
Starting point is 01:31:35 Early this morning, scouting in the hills on the east side of Little Horn, Lieutenant Bradley had come across a battlefield dotted with the white bodies of dead men. He had counted more than 190 dead. He was certain that Custer was among them. Apparently no white man had escaped. one or two Crow Scouts, notably young Curley, had reported at the steamer far west at the junction of Little Big Horn and Big Horn the day before. There had been no interpreter on hand, but Curley had convinced the officers that all white soldiers who rode with custard had been killed. At dawn, Lieutenant Bradley had a few men and a few men had started out to search for the field of tragedy.
Starting point is 01:32:16 Curly was right. No soldier or white man had escaped. A little later, the slight figure of bearded General Terry with his staff and a small escort arrived on the hill. There were tears running down his cheeks when he spoke. I think most of us had tears in our eyes too. More than 200 of our comrades that had met a violent death. And now, naked and unburied were lying in the hot Montana sun, three miles northward. so they go out to recover the bodies or bury the bodies
Starting point is 01:32:56 they're on patrol back to the book suddenly we caught glimpses of white objects lying along a ridge that led northward we pulled up our horses this was the battlefield here Custer's luck had finally run out
Starting point is 01:33:12 from the way the men lay it was clear that the first one troop had been ordered to dismount and fight as a skirmish line. Then a second troop had been posted a little further on and to the east. Then a third troop and a fourth. And finally, there on the knob of a hill lay some 30 bodies in a small circle. We knew instinctively we would find Custer there. We rode forward at a walk. Most of the troopers had been stripped of clothing and scalped. Some of them had been horribly mutilated. Custer was lying a trifle to the southeast of the top of the knoll where the monument is today i stood six feet away
Starting point is 01:33:57 holding captain bentin's horse while he identified the general his body had not been touched save for a single bullet hole in the left temple near the ear and a hole on his left breast he looked almost as if he'd been peaceably sleeping his brother tom lay a few feet away he was terribly mutilated Scattered over the field were the swollen bodies of the dead horses, but there were not many of them. It seemed clear that the Indians sweeping up from the draws and coolies on all sides had stampeded the mounts while the men were fighting dismounted. From every direction, hordes of crazed Indians must have attacked with the wild courage that their desperation and hate gave them. Nothing could check their mad charges. Captain Bentine found a bit of wood.
Starting point is 01:34:48 hollowed out a hole, found an empty shell, wrote Custer's name on a bit of paper and placed it in the shell and shoved the deep in the hole in a piece of wood. Then he pushed this into the ground at Custer's head. He would make sure that the burial party would identify Custer's body. The following morning we went back to Custer Hill and buried as well as we could the naked mutilated bodies of our comrades. It was a gruesome task. Custer may have made a mistake to divide his command that Sunday afternoon of June 25th, but the gods themselves were against him. It was the Indians Day.
Starting point is 01:35:41 And I'm going to go back to finish this up to the section of the book that we started at. And that is this account from Major Reno, who we know a little bit more about now. but I think that the way he wraps it up and they actually did a massive trial a big trial for Reno and they found that the actions that he took were not negligent he might have made some calls that might not have been the best tactical calls
Starting point is 01:36:14 if you look back on it but he he was basically cleared of any wrongdoing clearly clearly I think it's pretty clear that Windolph thinks you know he broke and he lost control of his troops and then bentin kind of took over and got things squared away okay clearly clearly windoff was also a huge fan of bentine so he might be spinning that story a little bit in that direction but i do think that reno i think that him looking back on the
Starting point is 01:36:47 incident and he kind of wraps up his assessment of what happened and what went wrong that day And also, I think, for lack of a better word, that there is a warning of sorts in this. So here's Reno. After much reflection, I've concluded that several great blunders were the direct causes of the Custer massacre. It is an established fact that Custer disobeyed the orders of the general in command of the expedition, for instead of waiting to meet General Gibbon and General Terry on June 26 at the Rosebud and then cooperate with them in their concerted plan of action as he had been directed, as soon as he struck the trail of the Indians, he followed it until he came upon the Indian village June 25th.
Starting point is 01:37:41 Then, without attempting to communicate with either Terry or Gibbon, and without taking the trouble to ascertain the strength or positions of the Indians, he divided his regiment into three separate battalions. An act which nothing can justify, and dashed against the Indians, thus recklessly driving his own and my commands into an ambuscade of 5,000 sous. Nor did Custer take into consideration the unfed and exhausted conditions of the men and his horses, and he entirely ignored the fact that the Indians were key vivay and ready for the attack at noon, whereas it would have been an easy matter to surprise them very early in the morning. The only explanation for such conduct on the part of so brilliant an officer as Custer undoubtedly was otherwise was his great personal ambition.
Starting point is 01:38:45 He had fought himself partially disgraced because he had been superseded in command of the expedition by General Terry, and it was well known that he was resolved, if possible, to carry off all the honors of the campaign. For being in command of the only cavalry regiment attached to the expedition, he knew the brunt of the fighting would necessarily fall on him, and he made it no secret of his intention to cut loose from Terry where there was fighting to be done, and to carry on the campaign on his own hook.
Starting point is 01:39:22 Absolutely insensible to fear. He was so reckless and daring in the extreme. and driven by an intense desire to distinguish himself by some brilliant exploit. He made his headlong dash to a horrible death without the most causal regard for the maxims of military prudence. Even now, after the lapse of nearly ten years, the horror of Custer's battlefield is still vividly before me. And the harrowing sight of those mutilated and decomposing bodies crowning the heights on which poor Custer fell will linger in my memory till death. And I think that's a pretty clear warning. And of course there are military lessons to be learned from this account of the Battle of Little Big Horn maintain the element of surprise.
Starting point is 01:40:41 Keep your forces unified as much as possible. Take and maintain the high ground. To rule we should always follow. Trust your reconnaissance units. You've got them out there. Listen to them. Make sure your troops are rested and fed and have water. But beyond those fundamental military tactical lessons,
Starting point is 01:41:10 I think it becomes quite clear that there is another enemy that we must always be on the watch for and that is ego ego we have to keep our ego in check
Starting point is 01:41:31 you have to watch out for it guard against it getting control of you and interfering with your decision making process now I always say this this doesn't mean that ego should be banished it absolutely has a very positive side as well. It drives us to push hard.
Starting point is 01:41:54 It drives us to do our best. And a guy like Custer, who personally led cavalry charges at the Battle of Gettysburg that were critical in stopping, flanking actions from Confederate troops, an action that no doubt was fueled by courage and bravery but also was fueled at some level by ego because ego is a driver of our actions and sometimes it can be a positive driver of our actions but it has to be balanced has to be balanced by humility and open ears and an open mind keep the ego in check
Starting point is 01:42:46 and I'll tell you something else I'll like your ego another lesson from this is that you have to keep your emotions in check and you heard the brutality that was committed in these wars on both sides
Starting point is 01:43:06 both sides anger and fear and frustration those result in an essence on both sides and on both sides there were truly horrific acts of savagery and that's an extreme example this whole story is an extreme example of
Starting point is 01:43:38 both those both the ego and the emotional mayhem that are shown in this example are very extreme but also think about how they relate to your everyday life how often do you let your ego get in the way of making the right decision how often do you let your emotions drive your decisions how often do you go to war because of your emotions and because of your ego how often do you go to a war because of them and what I'm saying is stop get control of your emotions and get control of your emotions and get control of your ego and put them in check so you aren't escalating to situations where you savage your enemy or your friends or your coworkers or your peers or your family or
Starting point is 01:44:45 whoever you do nothing in those situations to further your mission in life but instead you just distract and detract from reaching your real goals learn from this particular battle see what the emotions and ego do and find a better way de-escalate to build coalitions with people instead of building blood feuds work with people instead of working against people lift people up instead of casting them down what that is is leading that is what true leadership is and that is what a true leader does. So go out there. And I think that's all I've got for tonight.
Starting point is 01:46:14 Just a brutal situation that this is. I actually pull up some other quotes too. In the beginning of the book, I talk about some of these massacres that were considered committed by the soldiers in some of these raids. and this is one right here John S. Smith from his congressional testimony
Starting point is 01:46:42 This is from the Sand Creek Massacre by the way I saw the bodies of those lying there cut all to pieces worse mutilated than any I ever saw before the women cut to pieces with knives scalped their brains knocked out children two or three months old all ages lying there
Starting point is 01:47:02 from sucking infants up to warriors by whom were they mutilated by United States troops. And again, my point in bringing that up is that it's the escalation of emotions and the escalation of ego and I'm going to pay them back and we so often drive ourselves to these situations in everyday life. I mean, obviously not to this scale. But how do we overcome that? and I think you've got to concentrate on keeping your ego and your emotions in check.
Starting point is 01:47:45 Yeah. Yeah, and there's also that slippery slope factor where, like, remember the one, I think it was, I think it was Milai, where we're talking about the slippery slope. And kind of one thing leads to another where if you kind of look at the end, the result, you're like, no way, I would never do that. I would never be in that situation. but it starts like with one little thing you know so from one step to the to the next step
Starting point is 01:48:15 or for one little step where you slide or on the slippery slope it's like that's easy you know where it's like all right one guy gets mad he slaps this guy you know or even I mean it goes really with anything with a slippery slope anything like cheating on your diet I don't know it it does and what we're really talk about is what's the cure to the slippery slope it's the discipline It's maintaining the discipline.
Starting point is 01:48:39 It's maintaining the personal discipline of what you're talking about. Like, yeah, it's a slippery slope. Going down the donut slope. Yeah. Right? We don't want to do that. But on top of that,
Starting point is 01:48:48 you get into a leadership situation. Absolutely. It's a slippery slope. And you give that little bit. You think, oh, you know, it's no big deal. I like that guy. Hey, he's got a little angry. That's okay.
Starting point is 01:48:58 But everybody else saw that happen. And now you're just allowing this to happen. And it's only going to escalate. But it's so. And think about this. Think of how easy it is to Stop that one thing and say, hey, Echo, what are you doing? Come over here.
Starting point is 01:49:11 Hey, look, we don't hit prisoners. Stop what you're doing. Yeah. Get it together. If you're mad, go over there, take a breath. Yeah. That's pretty easy for me to stop. Now what happens when you shoot somebody?
Starting point is 01:49:22 Now we have, you know, we have a major incident. Now you're going to jail. I mean, it's a totally different thing. I could have stopped that very easily in the beginning. Yeah. Or I can have major issues to deal with in the end. Yeah. like this I mean this is more like the slippery slope situation but not war nothing like that
Starting point is 01:49:41 but you know how like I don't know financial guys right though they'll they'll be like hey I'm gonna do in I don't know investments you know you hear about this where they'll be like okay I'm gonna collect this money from my quote my people you know my clients and then I'm gonna invest it right and then hey I'm just gonna grab this little bit I'll pay it right back oh yeah next thing you know you're gonna level seven Ponzi scheme Yeah, see that, and that's the thing, that's the slippery slope where when you start, even before you like start to slip or whatever, when you start, you think of, okay, where I am right now and going to prison for the pond disease. Yeah, you never would have. You're like, no way.
Starting point is 01:50:20 No way. I'm going to, you know, I've seen. Have you ever read? Is that sounds like that would really be the psychology of people that do that? Like, I bet a lot. Well, I don't know because I've, are you, is this a specific example that you read about or something? No, no, no. Or you're just kind of assuming that that's what the mindset is.
Starting point is 01:50:37 Yeah, well, I had read about like the slippery slope situation. And really it's like two perspectives. One is like when you're in the mix and the next step or down the slippery slope, the is always totally understandable. No one's going to run, you know, sound the alarms. I mean, I bet if you looked at the Bernie Madoff where he had that giant, I would have to read about it. But it would make sense to me that your assumption is correct.
Starting point is 01:51:03 In the beginning, he wasn't like, you know what I'm going to do? I'm going to rip off a bunch of people. Right. I bet in the beginning he said, you know what? I got these good investments. I'm going to get these people to buy in. And then he goes, you know what? I didn't quite make what we were going to make.
Starting point is 01:51:14 But I'm just going to go ahead and take some of these other people's money and just distribute it. Yeah. So everyone's kind of happy. Yeah. And you know, that's where it starts. Yeah. And then you realize you can get away with it and you go on down that road. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:51:29 That's ego, by the way. Because that's just ego because you're like, I don't want to admit to everybody. buddy that, hey, I didn't make the money I promised you. So you know what I'm going to do? Double down. Double down. Yeah. But the two perspectives is kind of the thing where when you're in the mix, that one step is
Starting point is 01:51:46 like that's hard to see in a matter of speaking. It's hard to see because you're like, ah, why should I, you know, this guy came in 30 seconds like. So what I'm going to do, reprimand him in front of everyone? Come on. You know, like really, you know, so no one's, you know, that's easy to understand. but every last employee never coming in on time. You're like, no way.
Starting point is 01:52:09 Impossible. No way. When I started this company, no way I would ever let that happen. But here's the thing. It will happen with that, you know, because of that.
Starting point is 01:52:17 Because each little step is hard to see. You can't see it. That's why it's like, this is the rule and straight up. So, you know, sticklers of, you know, people like when they're sticklers on the rules.
Starting point is 01:52:26 Yeah. It's kind of like, I guess maybe like socially the norm is like, yeah, he's a sticklies of tight wad, whatever, you know? But I will say this though There's some value to that
Starting point is 01:52:35 There's also the way to lead Like when you heard about Bentine Benton wouldn't have called a guy out like that But he would have just given him a look Right right Don't you think it's a good idea Don't you think it's really important That we are on time
Starting point is 01:52:48 Yeah yeah yeah You know we wouldn't have called him out in front of everybody You reprimanded him But he still would have been a leader He still would have led And that's the That's what we want to do Yeah
Starting point is 01:52:56 So I guess we'll Yeah Save the question Questions from the interweb for next time. Hey, Native American names are the coolest, man. They do have the coolest names. Yeah. But if I had another son, I think I'd name him Bloody Knife.
Starting point is 01:53:16 Oh, right. Or what was the other one? Quick stab or something. One stab. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Native Americans definitely knew how to put their names together. So what you, like, what's the, what's the formula?
Starting point is 01:53:27 It's like, oh, it's some significant thing that this guy did, and we'll just call him that. Well, you remember wooden leg, because his name was eats from the hand. And then they changed it from eats I think it was eats from his hand or eats from the hand Once he proved that he was actually a a badass warrior His dad said because he had he had requested the name from his uncle right from his uncle because they could both they could both walk They could both walk the distance long and never give up and so he requested that name and when a once they fought it to bit a little big horn He introduced his son as this is my son wouldn't leg Yeah, yeah
Starting point is 01:54:02 my Sarah before they were like hey I wonder how the Native Americans get their name I know how they just when they do something significant they just they just give it to them they don't make up a name surrounding it that's their name what they do so her friend Abby she smoked a lot at the time so her name was Abby smokes a lot legitimately no that's her Native American name but but in the warrior culture it's way cooler You know what I mean? Yeah. Like dances with wolves. I mean, that's probably not warrior culture. You ever seen that movie dancing? I have seen that movie. There was a long time ago.
Starting point is 01:54:44 That was when I still went to movies before I just found them all kind of lame. It's old school for sure. Yeah. All right. Well, I guess with that, how about you talk about how we can. Get in the game. Getting the game. Get in the game.
Starting point is 01:55:06 And a little support the podcast maybe would be nice to learn how to do that. If you want to support the podcast, you can do it. And this is how. Yeah, there's some cool ways. If you don't know already, I would say with supporting this podcast, support yourself. I think that because if you're incapable, or, you know, if you're not capable of supporting yourself, how can you support a podcast? Well, how can you support others, right? That is a true.
Starting point is 01:55:34 That is a true part. By the way, we got mixed reviews from the last podcast. I had said something along the lines of, hey, does this take too long? Yeah. Actually, we didn't get mixed reviews. I think the only reviews we got were positive. Now, there might be some people that just didn't say anything because they were trying to be kind and gentle. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:55:51 So that's fine. They press stop right now. The rest of the people that are kind of like the little deep in the game. They're deep in the game. Yeah. And that's a good. Well, in a way, and there were some good points that they brought up because, I forget who said it, but they were like, there's some nuggets in there.
Starting point is 01:56:11 Yeah, no, we don't stop trying to learn while we're talking about things that help us, right? Correct. We're still trying to figure some stuff out. Yeah. There's some nuggets of information in there that might be dropped at any time. Yeah. And even if not, that's part of the reason. in why I put the guide, you know, on YouTube.
Starting point is 01:56:34 Oh, yeah. So, you guys are done talking about this stuff. So just turn it off. So it's like, oh, whatever, the internet stuff, I'll just skip that part. Yeah. You can skip it and it'll tell you where to skip to. Both options are there.
Starting point is 01:56:47 Yeah, yeah, yeah. Because some people might just want to take everything they can from the podcast. That's why I put, you know, the timestamp for all the subjects. Yeah. Because, you know, look, I like to assume. that every 100% of the people, everybody 10 out of 10, like every single word of the process.
Starting point is 01:57:11 And they like every single subject and they like, I like to think that. But in the event of that not being the case, I don't want them to be all this while. I got to sit through, Echo talking about, you know, Amazon click-throughs and on it, you know, so they have the option.
Starting point is 01:57:25 I think that's important. Yeah. We're all here. We're working together. I feel like we're all in this together, you know? We don't need the one guy being, hey, I have a different opinion. Then you I have that right and then now I got to sit through the stuff that you guys like
Starting point is 01:57:36 You know what I'm saying? All right well I think we're taking care of both sides of sure so and to do that you know of course Like I said you support yourself supplementation if you're into it and here's the thing where I didn't Think that like krill oil was supplementation here's the thing it is and it helps because that's You're you're now on the crew I'm on the krill oil and it's and I've reaped its benefits and My wife's dad was talking about krill oil from oh dish oil no not fish oil fish oil is good don't get wrong it's
Starting point is 01:58:06 outstanding but guess you know what's better krill oil is what he would say all the time I'm like yeah yeah he's kind of you know one of these health like guys and um the old man was right the old man was right yeah so um yeah curle oil from from on it of course
Starting point is 01:58:22 that's the main one they have like the quality the quality stuff don't get the cheap stuff no don't and he one might think oh yeah Yeah, of course. I'm not going to go get the cheap stuff. Like what, but here's the thing.
Starting point is 01:58:35 And so with supplements, like there is cheap stuff. There's like stuff that straight up doesn't work. Like you might as well be taking like chalk condensed into pill. It's true. Absolutely true. Chalk, you said. Yeah. Okay.
Starting point is 01:58:47 Don't do that. Because it's not like, I don't know, something about it being a supplement. It's not regular. I don't know something. But on it is all legit. Like it has the literature, all that stuff like where they get it. Even the krill oil is like. You're so excited about where the krill oil comes from always.
Starting point is 01:59:01 That's a deal. Like I said, we're all in this together. You're about to tell us about the environmentally friendly ships. See, you love that. That was kind of a cool video too.
Starting point is 01:59:11 You can see. Yeah. No, I like that. That obviously left an impression on you. Big time. And for you to say something's a cool video, that's a pretty good compliment.
Starting point is 01:59:17 Yeah. You kind of like cool videos and make them. At least we hope that you make them. I tell myself. Yeah, sure. Because a lot of times we don't make them. You don't make them. Sometimes you make one every three months.
Starting point is 01:59:28 Then how do we feel about that there in the world? We don't feel really good about it. it yeah all right there you go i mean um i okay you know i take your point fully but back to the krill oil it's good anyway what else the krill oil worry bars uh shroom tech for performance you know if you if you want the edge that sounds like kind of commercially but but for real if you want the edge if you want you can do alpha brain too alpha brain cycle that mental mental edge yeah anyway and you can get 10% off you can support your wallet, which is good to.
Starting point is 02:00:05 Go to onit.com slash jaco. Also, a cool way, good way, legit way, doesn't cost you anything. Way to support this podcast, reinforce this podcast, and be in the game. Let's face it. It's much better to be in the game. In the game, fully.
Starting point is 02:00:23 And here, how's this? And this is on a side note from this. So, you know, like, you know, like people will go to, like, a motivation. motivational seminar or something, you know, like this, or or listen to a motivational speech. My motivational seminar would be three minutes long. Yeah. So there's this like party of brain where, you know, it's seek something and then you get the payoff and then it's it's basically a sense of satisfaction.
Starting point is 02:00:50 So you seek no more. So you're satisfied. So people seeking inspiration and motivation, they'll go and they'll go to a speech or a seminar or something like this. and they'll consume the speech or the motivational video or whatever. But they're spectating. Yeah, they're watching it. They're spectating. Yeah.
Starting point is 02:01:09 The speech, sure. Yeah. So the whole, really, the big picture should be, I'm going to get, see this speech, motivation, video, whatever. I'm going to be inspired, motivated. Now I'm going to go take action, right? But to take action, you still have to have a need, you know, that needs to be satisfied. But people, they'll, they'll view or, you know, whatever, consume.
Starting point is 02:01:30 the speech. And they will be satisfied because they see the speech. And they don't take action. And here's the thing. The next speech that comes into town or the next motivational video on YouTube, you know, how does the next one? Or the next time, whoever the person is, I don't know, Tony Robbins or whoever, next time they're coming to town, they're going to go for that good stuff that they got last time.
Starting point is 02:01:52 They left real satisfied with, you know, hearing that, you know, viewing that speech. They go, they do it again. They get that satisfaction. Action still taking no action by the way Not good So it's like it's a weird It's a messed up cycle Well I think the big difference there is
Starting point is 02:02:05 And that's is that those Literally you're watching Yeah And you're spectating Yeah as opposed to Getting in the game Yeah and see That's a big difference
Starting point is 02:02:16 That was really my whole point Where You know I'm gonna listen to you You're not saying Like I mean you are saying Get After but you're not saying You can do it
Starting point is 02:02:26 You're not saying that kind of stuff You know like And I know I'm not know it goes I'm actually I'm actually not saying you can do it I'm actually saying do it yeah exactly right but that's the thing so really the whole message whatever it may be you know I don't don't eat donuts all this stuff is the big message here is don't eat donuts I think 100% right there's a bunch of messages but the key there to the the whole message is you got to do it it's not like you can do it you know and you're like yeah I can do it I feel good about that fact I'm good
Starting point is 02:02:57 but this is like you got to do you got to go out and do that you know you can't just watch you can't just watch okay I think I'm convinced you know I'm ready to get the game I'm saying that's the difference and so you're saying that Amazon free d Amazon shopping click through the website jocco podcast dot com little Amazon link it definitely helps and also we're all going to be all up on Amazon for Christmas yeah for the holiday season for whatever it is you're going to celebrate when school's off for two weeks and you got to buy a bunch of people presents yet during that time period that's a good time to support the podcast doesn't cost anything you click through amazon and you make your purchases the key there is to remember it like you need some kind of cue
Starting point is 02:03:40 put in your bookmarks or something like that some kind of cue that's good that's the key right there i think the rest is just it just kind of you know takes care of itself anyway and then you can subscribe of course on iTunes and youtube and stitch Google Play. Yep. Yeah. Wherever you might get your podcast from, subscribe. Yeah, just subscribe.
Starting point is 02:04:04 Write a review. Write a review, yeah. Yeah, those are good, man. The reviews. Yeah, those are solid. I like when people get creative. I encourage that. For sure.
Starting point is 02:04:15 For sure. And then, of course, of course, look, if you wear t-shirts, if you wear hoodies, drink coffee or tea of any kind or white tea anyway
Starting point is 02:04:32 jocco store.com you can buy some cool shirts if you think they're cool look at them there's going to be more to them than meets the eye just looking at them but if you like how they look maybe look into that one but here's the thing though I'm making like it's so mysterious like oh there's all these layers
Starting point is 02:04:50 how I always say it's on the hoodie one side says discipline other side says freedom if you look if you pay attention there's a little equal Yeah. And it's a barcode. Yeah. That's made into equal sign.
Starting point is 02:05:02 Someone hit me on Twitter said, hey, you're talking about the layers. Is this equal sign a layer? You know? Yeah. Like, is this a little hidden thing. Hey, you're going to leave us here in suspense? Yeah, it is a hidden thing.
Starting point is 02:05:15 It's not that big of a deal. But it's a small deal. It's like a double, like, okay, here it is. So the font, right? Yes. Joko chose the font. Yes. Before any of this thing started, Jocko,
Starting point is 02:05:29 I chose the fun. Yeah, because I made the Jocko podcast, despite you being a massive, you know, skills with all those programs that do all the design and you have a great graphics mind and all that stuff. Despite all that, I just made the little thing, the little Jocko podcast symbol. And I made it on PowerPoint. And when it came time to pick the font, I chose this font called OCR. optical something recognition yeah optical because for in my mind I'm always like okay part machine right I'm part machine so this font can be read by machines yep that is why that is why I use this font yeah so yeah and you can look at that I think I don't know if
Starting point is 02:06:17 you told me to look it up but you said it you're like oh yeah it's cool it's like oh dang so I looked it up and yeah sure enough it's it's the first font that they made that computers can yes that's right that is what it is why I chose it I'm like guys deep. So I'm like, all right. So the barcode is just kind of yet another thing. Like the computer is going to be reading your shirt kind of thing. You're a machine. Yeah. Well, you're wearing them. You're a machine readable thing. You're a machine. Yes, yes. You're wearing it. That's what it is. So you can't get rid by computer. So that's kind of the little layer. I mean, that's just more of like a fun thing for sure. Small layer. But anyway, yeah, again, Jocco's
Starting point is 02:06:56 door. That's where all the stuff is. Cool rash guards. Hey man, we made the claim 19% improvement. That is yet to be refuted so far. You know, as far as feedback that I've been getting, anyway, if you want your improvement. Because you know what, you know what, though? I think that there is legitimacy. Like, actually fully...
Starting point is 02:07:15 Somebody put an article on today about how it compresses the muscle increases circulation, so you actually get the legit improvement. Hey, Brett, I don't know all the science behind it, you know? But... Bro science. Yeah. No, but you know what is?
Starting point is 02:07:27 You know how you're saying, you know, when you put on, like, a uniform. Oh yeah, you or you get a little this is a ritual, back to the ritual conversation. Yeah,
Starting point is 02:07:37 kind of and it's like almost like a, it's weird like when I was young when I played football is 11 years old and we got new shoes. Football season's here, new shoes. Oh, I couldn't wait to go to practice.
Starting point is 02:07:48 I'm gonna be faster. After a few months, man, my shoes are dirty. I hate practice, but you get new shoes, you want to go practice. You get new workout gear.
Starting point is 02:07:56 You're like, dang, I'm gonna go. You get a new rash guard. You want to go. training your new guy you get a new guy you want to train yeah so that's kind of that's maybe a factor as well there's a little placebo yeah placebo placebo sorry placebo factor yeah that's I call it getting after it so yeah jocco store dot com with some women's stuff some women's t-shirts coming out soon oh we now now that you say that they better be actually coming out I know I think
Starting point is 02:08:26 my my clock is counting down my Debbie clock. Debbie gave me like a countdown. Oh, and the deadline. A deadline. A straight up deadline. She gave me one month. She's leading up the chain of command.
Starting point is 02:08:37 Yeah. Yeah. Respect. Respect on the. You can also get some jocco white tea. If you want to drink some tea, that tastes really good. If you haven't tried it yet,
Starting point is 02:08:48 it doesn't taste like tea. And it doesn't taste like anything else. It tastes like something really good. So give it a shot. And a lot of people have replaced every other beverage in their diet with jocco white tea and on top of that we got a little something new
Starting point is 02:09:04 coming out that can be used for tea or for coffee or for milk or for cream and it's a big old mug so those are going to be on amazon and the mug it's just a big black mug and um then written on the mug is it just says get after it so yep you can you can get one of those it also says approved It was approved In fact, by me So you get those mugs And they're pretty cool And then also you get the book Extreme
Starting point is 02:09:37 Ownership which I wrote with my brother Late Babin And Pick it up You know what? What I dig is when people buy it For themselves and then Three days later after they get done reading it
Starting point is 02:09:49 They buy four more for the people That are on their team And then they buy one for their boss And then they buy one for the five people That are in their peers team and they just spread the word because they want to make their life easier by having people
Starting point is 02:10:03 getting after it all around them and taking extreme ownership and if you do want to kind of keep cruising with you know with Echo Charles and myself you can find us actually on the interwebs on the interwebs
Starting point is 02:10:18 on Twitter on also on Instagram and also we are Kind of all up on the Facebook. Facebooky. If you want to get that, Echo's at Echo Charles.
Starting point is 02:10:34 And I am at Jocko Willink. And I guess finally, thanks for listening tonight. Everybody that's out there in uniform, serving. Work with some police this week. I work with some fire departments this week. Awesome. Thanks for what you do. Thanks for your service.
Starting point is 02:10:58 Thanks for protecting the homeland. Folks that are overseas, thank you for what you're doing. Stay aggressive. Stay ahead of the enemy. Keep getting after it. And then to all the troopers that I'm meeting all the time. In every industry, every industry you could imagine,
Starting point is 02:11:23 that are out there making things happen, turning and burning day to day. crushing things whether it's some massive project that you are completely devoted to doing and doing it perfectly or you know what there's plenty of people that hit me up and they say hey you know what I got to do a bunch of stupid administrative tasks today and guess what I'm gonna line them up and I'm gonna crush them so wherever you are on today on that spectrum line them up and crush them so until next time this is echo and jocco out

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.