Joe Rogan Experience Review podcast - JRE 491 Week in Review: John Mellencamp, Johnny Knoxville, Damon & Affleck

Episode Date: January 19, 2026

For more Rogan exclusives support us on Patreon patreon.com/JREReview www.JREreview.com For all marketing questions and inquiries: [e-mail] Follow me on Instagram at www.instagram.com/joeroganexperiencereview Please email us here with any suggestions, comments and questions for future shows.. [e-mail]

Welcome to the quick Rogan review of the week, where we break down Rogan's episodes of last week with a short summary, fan reactions, a rating out of 10, so you have an idea of which episode you might like the most so you can go back and listen. Up first, episode 2438, John Mellencamp. This was the quiet heavy wake of the week. Much slower pacing, much more reflective. Melanchamp spoke openly about family, mortality, regret, and love, including emotionally heavy discussions around his daughter's health,

struggles. Rogan largely stepped back there, which was the right move, letting the conversation just kind of breathe. There was some heavy, heavy points there. This episode won't trend on TikTok, but it lands deeply if you're into kind of the reflective headspace. It's the kind of episode that sneaks up on you emotionally, especially if you're a parent or thinking about legacy. This is rogue and it is best as a listener. No debate, no ego, just space for somebody to tell the truth. The online feel and vibe,

a smaller audience, but very loyal, described as sad but beautiful, and I'd agree. Some fans said they had to pause and they needed to come back later. Comment of the week didn't expect to get emotion or during this episode. Another fan said, this is why long-form podcasts matter. And another, not background noise, this deserves attention. Overall rating, 8 out of 10.

8 out of 10 for this one. Quiet, meaningful, and emotionally grounded. High rating for this. This is honestly kind of a stack. week in a lot of ways for great episodes but if you have the time that one is it's up there with a must listen for me it's just a really good episode a little different for kind of Rogan feel and it just kind of the pacing and the emotional aspect of it for me really good yeah just definitely a good episode moving on the legend that is episodes

2439, Johnny Knoxville. Of course, he's doing the new fear factor. Makes sense that he would come on. And Johnny, of course. I mean, the king of jackass. We all know and love him. If you grew up watching him and all his shenanigans, I mean, I think there's a place in many people's hearts for Johnny and what he put himself through for our entertainment. This episode was pure controlled chaos, you know, in the best way. Knoxville brings that rare mix of recklessness, humility, and surprising self-awareness. Plenty of stories about insane stunts,

injuries, pushing limits, and the weird psychology of willingly putting your body on the line for entertainment. Unusual stuff. What made this episode better than a standard jackass highlight reel was how much time they spent on aging, pain and identity after the adrenaline stops. Knoxville doesn't glorify it.

He's honest about the cost, and it's clear. I mean, imagine the toll that all those stunts must have taken. This one also plays well with Rogan's long-running interests in risk-taking fear and why certain people chase extremes. There's something very human here about realizing your body is an infinite and figuring out who you are once the chaos phase ends. I mean, both these guys are getting older. Joe talks about it a lot, even he was aware of it even back in his taekwondo days,

just knowing, hey, I don't want to keep taking head kicks. It's not going to work out well for me in the future if I get, you know, enough brain damage. I think it took a bit longer for Johnny to figure that out, but to be fair, he was getting paid a lot of money to, uh, to injure himself, you know. Online feel and vibe, extremely positive, you know, across the board. A lot of nostalgia energy. People were surprised by how thoughtful Knoxville was, and you will hear that in the episode. Comments of the week, didn't expect Johnny Knoxville to be this self-aware. I agree. This episode made me laugh and feel old all at the same time. Jackass was fun. This conversation was better. It was good, I have to say.

Episode rating, 8.5 out of 10. 8.5 out of 10, one of the most entertaining lessons of the week. Again, like I said, it's a strong week. A strong week with some good conversations. And listen, it's not like these are just massively mind-blowing episodes. There's just something really good about the week. And in a lot of ways, it's just because it doesn't come with that kind of like regular, what we've been seeing a lot of, that political energy, the AI stuff, the kind of doom and gloom in politics thing going on. This was just a lot of storytelling.

You know, there was some good themes. I don't know. You feel it out for yourself, but there was some great elements to the week. Next up, episode 2440. Matt Damon, Ben Affleck, movie legends. Obviously, Matt Damon, the Bourne movies, and so many other great flicks. Ben Affleck, well, I liked him in Armaged. That's an old movie now.

Been in loads of shit. The town, he was Batman. He wasn't a terrible Batman, actually, I thought. But no Christian bail, I will have to say. No Christian bail. But yeah, this was a classic high-profile mainstream JRE episode. Two lifelong friends, a huge career,

and a ton of shared history. I mean, they've known each other since like high school, I think. The conversation leaned heavily into creative longevity, Hollywood evolution, and what it's like sustaining relevance without burning out or losing your identity. A lot of subtle moments here about friendship over the decades, especially how they've supported each other through career highs, flops, reinventions, and personal growth.

There's also a quieter, undercurrent about aging in public, legacy, and choosing projects more intentionally as they've gotten older. This wasn't a hot take episode. It was more reflective, more successful adults talking sharp type of thing, but still engaging if you enjoy process, discipline, and long-term thinking. This is a good example of Rogan as a campfire conversation. No chaos, no controversy, just curiosity and life perspective from people who've been at the top for decades. You know, the online feel and vibe generally positive, but also split. Fans who love storytelling really enjoyed it.

Rogan Purist said it felt a little safe. you know um i don't know what that really meant maybe it's not like rogan should have been pushing back or like pushing them too hard i mean he's usually just very kind of cordial and polite with a listers and you know my overall take is matt damond i think was very good on the podcast i think he is good on podcasts he was thoughtful uh quite witty spoke fairly slowly and with good intention. He was clear. Affleck was kind of interrupted a little bit more.

A lot of what he said didn't have a ton of depth. He just talked a lot. And I don't know. They had very different styles on the episode. But overall, another. fairly high rating. I'd say high rating. Episode rating 7.5 out of 10.

Solid, rewatchable, not legendary, but a valuable episode. And it definitely a must watch if you are a fan of them. Themes across the week, aging, identity, reinvention. Every episode this week touched this kind of in different ways.

Damon and Afflack, longevity and choosing wisely. Knoxville, surviving and recklessness, Mellencamp, legacy and family. There's a clear throughline of what happens after the peak and how people redefine meaning. Less chaos, more reflection. Compared to some recent weeks, this batch leaned less political, less combative, and more personal.

For some fans, that's a relief. It was for me. For others, it feels slower. There was a lot of that online, a lot of feeling of like a bit of a slow week, bit boring. I don't really know what people were wanting for that, but that's a lot of what the comments were. But it creates space for depth, I felt, overall.

Overall online reaction, general sentiment, positive, steady, and quite a mature week. No major controversies, strong appreciation for emotional honesty. Some fans saying not every week needs to be explosive. I agree. This was a grown-up Rogan Week. Weekly summary and ratings, most entertaining Johnny Knoxville, most emotionally impactful, John Mellingkamp, most mainstream appeal,

Damon and Afflack, overall weekly rating, 8 out of 10. 8 out of 10 is a strong Rogan week. I'll tell you that right now. It's not a viral week, but solid, listenable, thoughtful stretch

that reminds people why long-form conversations still work. This wasn't a chaos week. It was a reflection week. And honestly, after years of noise, sometimes that's exactly what lands.

Hope you enjoyed this quick review. Look out for longer reviews later in the week. We'll probably do, I think we're probably going to cover Matt and Ben this week. But we might do some others. So stay tuned. Thanks guys. Later.