Judge John Hodgman - Logging a Case in A-pellet Court

Episode Date: March 10, 2021

Luke files suit against his wife, Alaina. They live in an old, converted schoolhouse in Vermont and heat their home using a wood stove. Luke loves the wood stove, but Alaina would like to replace it with a stove that burns pellets instead. Who’s right? Who’s wrong?Links discussed in this episode:Norwegian Wood: Chopping, Stacking, and Drying Wood the Scandinavian Way by Lars MyttingThe YouTube video from Embers Fireplaces & Outdoor Living about Wood Stoves vs Pellet StovesFREE SPIRITS, the documentary about the about the Turner's Falls, MA commune The Brotherhood of the SpiritThank you to Jonathan Arbogast & Karen Kostan for the inspiration behind this week’s episode case! To suggest a title for a future episode, follow Judge John Hodgman on Facebook. We regularly put out a call for submissions.

Welcome to the Judge John Hodgman podcast. I'm bailiff Jesse Thorne. This week, logging a case in a pellet court. Luke files suit against his wife Elena. They live in an old converted schoolhouse in Vermont and heat their home using a wood stove. Luke loves the wood stove, but Elena would like to replace it with a stove that burns pellets instead. Who's right? Who's wrong? Only one can decide. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman enters the courtroom and presents an obscure cultural reference. Everything is more complicated than you think. You only see a tenth of what's true. There are a million little strings attached to every choice you make. You can destroy your life every time you choose, but maybe you won't know for 20

years and you'll never ever trace it to its source. And you only get one chance to play it out. And they say that there's no fate, but there is. It's what you create. Bailiff Jesse Thorne, please swear the litigants in. Luke, Elena, please rise and raise your right hands. Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, so help you God or whatever? I do. I do. Do you swear to abide by Judge John Hodgman's ruling despite the fact that he makes his own heat?

I do. I do. Judge Hodgman, you may proceed. I actually run fairly cold. Did Hodgman, you may proceed. I actually run fairly cold. Did you know that, Jesse? No. It's very rare that my body temperature will be above 98. I'm keeping it cool in my core temp.

I'm sorry, Luke and Elena. It's nice to see you here on this Zoom where you are in Vermont. I am now back in Brooklyn, New York. You are already seated and you may remain seated for an immediate summary judgment. By the way, hello, Jennifer Marmer. Hello, Jesse. Nice to see you guys. And welcome back to Live Litigants. Luke and Elena, nice to see you as well. So let's get- Nice to see you. All right. That's enough fellowship. Yeah, we've rollicked enough.

Yeah. Let's get into contention mode. For an immediate summary judgment in one of yours favors, can either of you name the piece of culture that I referenced just now? Elena, why don't you guess first? Oh, I missed it. Okay, good. Flashman. I know. Look, it's been a long time.

It's been a long time since we had a live living case. We forget how we do it. You know, it's easy. I almost forgot to even have a cultural reference. So you missed it. That's fine. Fair enough. What's your guess, though?

What would be your guess? She's stunned silent. I think that in Vermont, justice works differently. You just take your issue to ben or jerry you gotta yeah that's right you gotta take it you gotta take it to the court of fish you know gotta take it to mike mike gordon the basis for fish dispenses justice up there in vermont no elena just give me a guess. Any kind of guess.

I'm going to say Flash Gordon. Flash Gordon? Yeah. The comic strip or the movie? I'd say the comic strip. Whoa. Okay. Deep cuts.

Yeah. I would have been inclined to say the theme song from the movie. He's just a man with a man something. Flash. Flash. Ah. Luke, it's your turn to guess. I guess what I'm thinking now, because we're just talking about, we were talking about cults earlier. The Source Family documentary.

The Source Family documentary. Yeah, big up Father Yod. That's right. Yeah. Luke is referencing a pre-show conversation we were having, establishing intimacy, rapport. But that I will punish. Because that guess is wrong. Indeed, all guesses are wrong.

Although that, the Source Family family documentary is a great documentary and in the plugs when we plug our stuff i'm going to plug another documentary about a communal living situation that took me by surprise you already know about it luke because we have this background together stay tuned to the plugs you'll find out about a good one. But all guesses are wrong. That was actually a quote from a movie that I will confess I have not seen. Synecdoche, New York by Charlie Kaufman. And it's a quote about big decisions because this we have a big this is a bigger decision than some of the ones we face on Judge John Hodgkin. This is a serious impact decision. Wood stove or pellet stove.

Because when you are in the cold and dark of winter, say in New England, and the furnace breaks and you don't have a secondary source of heat, you are in big trouble. This is something I've learned the hard way twice. Once in Massachusetts and once in Maine. And something that I happen to know the screenwriter Charlie Kaufman has learned recently once in an unnamed location. I will not explain more because it doesn't have to be in New England that this happened. that it is easy to get used to, depending on where you live and how reliable your heat is,

and to not plan properly for if you lose it suddenly once you have gotten used to it. You all are in Vermont, and so you know, feeling your house go cold is one of the most helpless and terrifying, and it's a shameful feeling too, because you feel like you've really messed up. In my case, I really did mess up. I forgot to have the guy come and fill the oil tank.

That was a mistake that I made. And the oil tank went. I talked about it before. And luckily, we had a wood stove in the basement. And when you're firing that wood stove, the panic that you feel stoking that fire is very, very deep. And if you can't get a fire going or you have no secondary source of heat, then you have to go flee to strangers. Now, in both cases, a wood stove came to my rescue once in Massachusetts, once in Maine. I like wood stoves,

you know, but I'm biased, I guess, but I'm not going to recuse myself because I want to hear both sides, Luke's side and Elena's side. So given that this is very serious and I'm going going to recuse myself because I want to hear both sides, Luke's side and Elena's side. So given that this is very serious and I'm going to make a decision for your lives together, I have some serious questions I have to ask you first. Okay. First of all, Luke and Elena, do you have power currently? We do. Yeah. Because it was a big windstorm.

Yes, it was. We're recording this in our timeline. This is March and there was a huge windstorm in the Northeast. And I know that it knocked out power in a lot of places. Did you lose power? Not yet. Yeah. The gusts were like 40 miles an hour this morning. Um, it was negative two when I woke up. So we were almost thinking like, gosh, like we might need to go record somewhere else because we might lose power. Yeah. No. I mean, do you have a generator? We do not.

Okay. Interesting. So next big serious question. Do you have a dog named Lamb Job? We do indeed. All right. We'll put a pin in that. We'll come back to that.

I just wanted to verify that that was true. He's sitting right behind my thing. Yeah, he's sitting right behind your computer. Lamp Chop. He's present. Let the record show that Luke has switched camera view on his tablet to L Lamb Chop lying on a couch under a blanket because I guess it's chilly there. It's a little cold here.

What would the temperature be like in your house, would you say now, in Fahrenheit, if you please? I mean, I know you all flirt with Celsius up there in Vermont, but Fahrenheit, what would you guess? I'd say in the room I'm in, I feel like it's about 62 to 65. Oh, you know, right. I'm a little far away from the wood stove. All right, okay. And Luke, where in Vermont are you? We are in the town of West Corinth, Vermont.

West what now? Corinth. All right, I'm looking it up. Let's see if this is a real town. Some people say Corinth, but that is incorrect. It is Corinth. Some of the locals would say that Corinth is the original way to say it. So I think the record should show.

How do you say it? Well, we don't count. We're not Vermonters. No, no, no. I know. I'm just, Elena, what? Corinth or Corinth? Corinth.th yeah this is a classic battle john you don't know about this this is like who invented the french dip philippe's the original

or cole's i'll call it i'll i pronounce it cornhole that's cornhole vermont that's it's a very good game. It's a great game. I'm not dissing your town. All right. West Corinth, Vermont. I see it here. It's in this triangle between St. Johnsbury, Montpelier, I believe the capital of Vermont.

Correctamundo. Yeah. And then down in the bottom of the triangle just over the Connecticut River is Lebanon, New Hampshire, where David Rees and I once did a show. Lovely, lovely part of the world. Okay, so we know where you are in Vermont. That's fairly far north. That's fairly far north. So let me ask Elena, let me ask you this question.

Why in Vermont are you? Well, Vermont just is. Vermont takes you in and it shapes you. Well you have said that you are not Vermonters. Correct I did start my journey in the northeast. I started in Rochester, New York and I went down the east coast to Asheville, North Carolina eventually where I met my my dashing husband And then we decided we had enough. Let the record show that Luke believes that is him. He raised him. You left Asheville, which is a beautiful, beautiful town in western,

mountain town in western North Carolina, where I also did a show with David Reese, by the way. That would be a place to stay. A lot of people choose to stay in Asheville, North Carolina, but you said, hmm, let's go to Vermont. How'd that happen, Elena? You know, it's something about Vermont. It's magical.

Have you been? Yeah, I've been to Vermont. Yeah, yeah. I've been to Brattleboro. I've been to Burlington. I've been to St. Johnsbury. Probably drove through West Corinth on the way to Lebanon, New Hampshire. I stayed on the shores of Lake Champlain.

What? That's dairy country. That's right. I've been to the Boomerang Thrift Shop in Brattleboro, Vermont. That's right. That's basically Massachusetts. But yeah, I love Vermont. Of course, it's beautiful.

Yeah. But I mean, when did you... Who initiated this move, I guess, is what I'm asking. Oh, God. Was it me, hon? Or you? I mean, I would say you initiated, but we both were like, yeah, let's move back up to New England. I mean.

Where are you from originally, Luke? I grew up in the town of Hancock, Maine. In the town of Hancock, Maine. No kidding. Yes. In Hancock County, Maine. Yeah. I got you, pal.

Closer to Ellsworth than the Hancock points. I'm really trying to lay off the Maine stuff because it was just so Maine-y for so long on the show. I'm really trying to give people a break. It's bad enough that we're doing Vermont now. You know what I mean? Vermont. Vermont's magical.

It sucks you in. Do you guys want me to just list towns in Southern California? Fontana. Torrance. Yeah. City of Industry. Sadly, the federal equal time requirements were repealed under the Reagan administration. Chino Hills.

Rancho Cucamonga. Rancho Cucamong Hills. Rancho Cucamonga. Rancho Cucamonga. Rancho Cucamonga. I understand, Luke, I understand you're trying to establish intimacy and rapport and to win this thing, but I gotta lay off the main where we gotta stay in the Green Mountain State.

Understood. So it was fairly mutual and it's not like one of you got dragged up there by the other's dreams or anything. Yeah, absolutely. It was a very mutual decision. That was a very vocal yes from Luke and a kind of resigned slow nod of the head from Elena. But you said that this was partly your, this is your dream too, correct? Yes or no? Yes. I do love Vermont. Vermont is charming.

I just, I'm so cold and I would love a consistent heat source such as a pellet stove. Right. Okay. Well, let's talk about your home, which is a converted schoolhouse. That was a decision. And it is heated with one heat source. Is that correct? Currently a wood stove. Is that correct? Currently a wood stove.

Is that right? So our home is currently heated with a wood stove and baseboard heat as backup heat. So we have the baseboard heat as a source of heat for, you know, if someone throws out their back, you know, as in the past seven days. If someone throws out their back, you know, as in the past seven days, or, you know, it's three o'clock in the morning and we don't want to wake up to stoke the fire, we have to rely on the backup source of heat, which would be the baseboard propane heat. Oh, okay. You have a backup propane situation. We do, but I don't know if you know the difference between the price of propane and more natural sources of fuel, such as wood or pellets. I understand where you are steering the direction of this conversation, and I appreciate it. You would like to get a pellet stove. Now, I think we all know pretty much what a wood stove is. For those of you who don't know, we have evidence that has been shared.

The photos of the wood stove in their converted schoolhouse will be available on the Judge John Hodgman show page at MaximumFun.org, as well as on our Instagram at Instagram.com slash Judge John Hodgman. Let's take a look at the evidence just so I can describe to people who don't know what an in-house natural wood stove might be. It looks like you would imagine there's a photo of it here. It's a squat little piece of cast iron that has swing out doors. It's sitting in the middle of this room, which I presume is fairly central in your house. Is that right? That is correct. Can I speak on the stove briefly? Yeah. Why don't you speak on the stove and then we'll move on to the pellet stove option. Tell me about your wood stove. The company that made it is called Vermont Castings. The model of the stove is called the Vigilant 1977. It was made in 1977. And part of why we landed in the town of uh west corinth

is because elena has not only one but two sets of aunts and uncles that live here in corinth the wood stove came out of one of her uncle's barns. Got it. And so, yeah, it is, you know, a piece of history, a piece of the family. And it opens from the front, which is pretty standard for wood stoves. Right. One of the reasons why I like this one so much is it has a top loader as well, which is really not as common. as well which is really not as common yeah so this is a vigilant 1977 cast iron box on a couple of on four legs on top of some soapstone or some other kind of non-burnable material on the floor it's got swing doors in it you put wood in there you close the doors and the smoke goes up this long stove pipe that goes into that then takes a turn into the chimney it looks like a like you

would see in a comic strip, not, not flash Gordon, but you know what I mean? I would say it's a little small for it, but looking at the picture, I could imagine a witch kicking a child into it. And so you love this wood stove for history.

The fact that it has a family connection to Elena's West Corinth avuncular family or whatever, that it came out of a barn. So real artisanal stove here. Real 1977. Was it stuff full of vintage vinyl when you got it out of that barn? Covered in macrame. Yeah. It's covered in something. Yeah.

You put it in? Did you put it in, Luke? I did with the assistance of cousins and uncles when we moved into the schoolhouse. It looks real good. It looks like a real witch kicker, as Jesse says. But how does it do for heat? I'll let Elena take this one. Well, I'll tell you that the heat is nice.

It does produce heat. It serves its purpose. I would say that a wood stove is an adequate source of heat, but a pellet stove is a consistent source of heat. And the quality of the heat doesn't change, in my opinion. of the heat doesn't change in my opinion well you did not send in a photo elena of the pellet stove that you would like to get i was certain you were going to say you didn't send in a photo elena of the quality of the heat yeah nor did you send in a photo of the heat so it falls to you i'm afraid to paint a word picture for the listener who there are a lot of people who know uh what a what a vigilant 77 uh cast iron wood stove out of

vermont what probably looks like but pellet stove may be a little bit more esoteric to the average listener get in your converted schoolhouse and teach us a pellet stove looks just like a wood stove if you want it to. They do make some really cool modern versions of pellet stoves these days. But a pellet stove can look very traditional as well, if that's the style that you're going for. You could do a cast iron even, or a glass door so that you could see the fire going nice and beautiful behind that glass door. So a pellet stove looks very much like a wood stove. The heat quality, very comparable to a wood stove. What is it? I'm helping you out. What does it burn?

Pellet stoves use compacted wood. So instead of carrying in giant armfuls of logs of pounds of wood, you carry in some pellets that are compressed wood pieces. You then put into a little canister in this stove that looks just like a wood stove still, but you're putting tiny compressed wood particles instead, which then produce less ash once they've burned. They also burn for 10 or more hours, really. Without stoking or feeding or putting more pellets in. Yeah, all the effort that goes into maintaining a wood fire. It's quite laborious. Wait, so you literally wake up at three o'clock in the morning to stoke the fire?

I think the first year that we lived here, we did. And I have to interject. I will allow it. All of this talk about the stoking and all of the work that goes into feeding the fire. I mean, I am the one who tends to the wood stove. I order the wood. I stack the wood. And I keep the wood stove stoked.

And I keep it cleaned out of ash. I've taken it on as pretty much my full responsibility. Objection? Elena, you have an objection. I would like to point out that I am very willing and able when I am capable physically of helping to tend to the wood stove. I am recovering from endometriosis, which is part of the reason that my husband has taken on the burden of the wood stove. Well, I hope you're feeling as okay as possible. Thank you. And I would like to also point out that in the event that my husband's back was not at its best, you know, if someone's back were prone to being thrown out, for example, then the other partner takes on more of the labor of the wood stove.

It's give and take. Counselor, let's not be coy. Are you saying that Luke is a fragile man who's about to break at any moment? Did you say his back problems? I think that, yeah, I will let Luke speak for himself. You know, when I carry in wood, I carry in, you know, pretty decently large armfuls of wood at a time. What answer to what question is this? Yes or no, Luke?

Do you have a trick back or no? I work on a farm and I've thrown out my back on two occasions. Two occasions. How recently? Within the past how many years? Within the past one year. One year, threw out your back twice. That is correct. And has the house gone cold as a result? The house has not gone cold as a result. What do you do on the farm, Luke? You get up on some hay bales and spin some classic vinyl? We throw some hay bales around. I take care of cows and sheep and grow vegetables and run a farm stand.

John, Vermont is dairy country. You know what they call that work? Backbreaking work. Backbreaking work. Yeah. I enjoy the work and I enjoy the work that goes into tending to the wood stove as well. Let's take a quick recess. We'll be back in just a moment on the Judge John Hodgman podcast. You're listening the Judge John Hodgman podcast. You're listening to Judge John Hodgman. I'm bailiff Jesse Thorne. Of course, the Judge John Hodgman podcast always brought to you by you, the members of MaximumFun.org. Thanks to everybody who's gone to MaximumFun.org slash join. And you can join them by going to MaximumFun.org slash join. And you can join them by going to MaximumFun.org slash join.

The Judge John Hodgman podcast is also brought to you this week by the folks over there at Babbel. Did you know that learning, the experience of learning, causes a sound to happen? Let's hear the sound. Yep, that's the sound of you learning a new language with Babbel. We're talking about quick 10-minute lessons crafted by over 200 language experts that can help you start speaking a new language in as little as one, two, three weeks. Let's hear that sound. Babbel's tips and tools are approachable, accessible, rooted in real-life situations,

and delivered with conversation-based teaching. So you're ready to practice what you've learned in the real world, and you get to hear this sound. It's not just like a game that pretends to teach you a language. It's also not a rigid, weird, hyper-academic chore. It is an actually productive app that actually teaches you while you are actually having a nice time. And you get to hear this sound. Here's a special limited time deal for our listeners right now. Get up to 60% off your Babbel subscription, but only for our listeners at babbel.com slash Hodgman.

Get up to 60% off at babbel.com slash Hodgman spelled B-A-B-B-E-L dot com slash Hodgman. Rules and restrictions apply. The Judge John Hodgman podcast is also brought to you this week by our pals over at Made In. Jesse, you've heard of Tom Colicchio, the famous chef, right? Yeah, from the restaurant Kraft.

And did you know that most of the dishes at that very same restaurant are made with made-in pots and pans? Really? What's an example? The braised short ribs. They're made-in, made-in. The Rohan duck.

Made-in, made-in. Riders of Rohan. Duck. What about the Heritage Pork Shop? You got it. Made-in, made-in. Made-in has been supplying top chefs and restaurants with high-end cookware for years. They make the stuff that chefs need. Their carbon

steel cookware is the best of cast iron, the best of stainless clad. It gets super hot. It's rugged enough for grills or an open flame. One of the most useful pans you can own. And like we said, good enough for real professional chefs, the best professional chefs. Oh, so I have to go all the way down to the restaurant district in restaurant town? Just buy it online. This is professional grade cookware that is available online directly to you, the consumer, at a very reasonable price. Yeah. If you want to take your cooking to the next level, remember what so many great dishes on menus all around the world have in common. They're made in Made In.

Save up to 25% this Memorial Day from the 18th until the 27th. Visit MadeInCookware.com. That's M-A-D-E-I-N cookware dot com. Elena, you are young people, right? You're in your 30s, early 30s? Oh my goodness. Thank you. Yes.

Right. Okay. And you're up there with Lamb Chop and Luke has thrown his back out a couple of times, but for the most part, he keeps the fire going. I really need you to just tell me why you're not comfortable with the system as it is. Maybe I could show you something. All right. I'll allow it. It becomes uncomfortable physically when things such as this are found in, this is a piece of

moss for those of you who aren't sure. This is moss from a piece of wood that I found in a clean pant leg as I put it on this morning. For the record, let me let the listeners who are listening to this audio podcast know a woman in Vermont just held up a little baggie with some vegetable matter in it. This is something that has happened before. It's not that unusual. Let me just show you this little piece of vegetable matter in this little baggie in Vermont. All right.

So you put that in an evidence bag. That's moss from the woodpile that you found. That ended up in my pant. In your pants. And this is not an infrequent occurrence, unfortunately, Your Honor. So it's gross is what you're saying. It's a little painful at times when they are more sliver sized. We do have a photo of the woodpile, which you submitted, Luke, as evidence.

And this is a very handsome woodpile, I have to say. Thank you. I've taken a lot of pride in it. Yeah. You have a very well-constructed looking shed that is closed on three sides, top most importantly. I think it's more of a lean-to. All right. I'll call it what I want.

It's a shed, wood shed, because a lean-to would be less permanent. Hey, Luke, stick to dairy matters. less permanent. Hey Luke, stick to dairy matters. It is keeping us sheltered from the snow and rain. Snow right now. Open on one side. What direction is that

side facing? Luke, do you happen to know? That is the north side. Interesting that you would have it pointing towards the north, the open part towards the north. What was your thinking there? Did you build this woodshed? The woodshed was on the property when we moved in. Oh, okay.

And it wasn't used for wood before kept started keeping the wood there before i was keeping um wood on uh on pallets on the other side of where we park our cars so i get about um five to six cords of wood a winter oh and a cord is technically like a truck bed's worth of cut wood. No, technically a cord is 128 cubic feet of wood. A stack that is approximately four feet high, four feet wide, and eight feet long. Luke, you know probably that I hate to repeat myself, but stick to dairy matters. So you had been stacking your wood on pallets and then you're like, I'm going it in that shed that was just your innovation or did you read a book um i more word of mouth garnered information from other vermonters yeah did they ever tell you to turn that shed around so it's

facing south i would love to but it might not be as easy as it sounds. It's not a rotating shed? No. Like Hank's Look Around Cafe. Sorry, then. That's my mistake, then. You're absolutely right. It is a lean-to. If it doesn't rotate, it's a lean-to. If it's on a Lazy Susan, it's a shed.

Everyone knows. And I could be wrong about this, but whatever I decide, whatever I decide with regard to your fate, I'm going to recommend right now a book called Norwegian Wood Chopping, Stacking, and Drawing Wood the Scandinavian Way. Do you know this book, Elena? You made a little look of recognition. No, but I'm fascinated by your knowledge and will take note. Thank you. Oh, well, the court accepts your flattery and it will get you everywhere. It's by Lars Mitting.

And this book, look, I know I said I wasn't going to mention Maine, but a couple of summers ago, this book burned its way through every household that we came in contact with in Maine. Everyone was talking about this book primarily for the Scandinavian style of wood stacking because everyone was talking about their book primarily for the the scandinavian style of wood stacking because everyone was talking about their wood stacks all of a sudden and all the science of stacking logs in order to dry them and season them in particular the beehive method the round method you know what i'm talking about luke you i see you nodding i i don't know around but i've seen people do them in like a pyramid. Yeah.

No, I'm again. I know what my words mean. Round is what I'm talking about. Luke, shut your cheese hole. Holy cats. These round stacks. You look looking up also called a Holshouser in Germany. But in the Scandinavian countries, they stack their wood in a big round beehive

with wood in the middle. And the reason for that is to increase airflow to dry the wood as efficiently as possible. And my guess would be, and I could be wrong on this, and I look forward to your letters, of course I do, Hodgman at MaximumFun.org. But if you didn't have a lean-to, if you had a classic shed on a Lazy Susan and you turned that thing around to the south, to your southern exposure, and get some sun on that wood, that would be a good idea. Just a thought for you. I do get our wood already dried and seasoned. Oh, I'm sorry.

I didn't realize that you were cheating. Oh, I see. See, I thought turn was because you loved this thing this whole project so you're buying seasoned wood eh i guess that makes me a poser and you say five or six chords a winter that is correct and and what is your home insulated with? Paper mache? What are your walls made of? We're currently, I actually had a crew over yesterday to do attic insulation. So we're working on getting our house weatherized. By attic insulation, do you mean a roof you're putting a roof on? Elena, I've avoided it for as long as possible but now i would like you to explain your propaganda that you sent in in the evidence you sent a poster uh advocating for the purchase of a pellet stove

it says pellet stoves are awesome tell me why pellets what it says at the top of this flyer that i presume was was handed to you by some cult leader at the farmer's market. And now you can't stop thinking about this. I would just like to point out that the infographic has much more information, not just about the anatomy of a pellet here. The fact that a pellet is also at times made of things such as sawdust, waste paper or residual forest waste. So there are wonderful environmental impacts.

It's a 0% carbon footprint with a pellet stove as well. How is that true? Because you aren't emitting the same emissions with a pellet stove as you are with a wood stove. According to this, the EPA rates it as an 85% efficient heat source. I've heard of pellet stoves before. I've seen them advertised and I've seen dealerships around New England and stuff. And I spent a lot of time doing some homework this morning. That was a lot of fun for me, actually.

I don't really don't like doing homework. homework this morning that was a lot of fun for me actually i don't really don't like doing homework um but i enjoyed looking at people comparing wood stoves to pellet stoves particularly uh there's a really charming youtube of a guy at embers fireplaces and outdoor living in denver colorado as he gets a fire going in a pellet stove and in a wood stove and he's a very sweet guy check that out he spends a lot sweet guy. Check that out. He spends a lot of time complaining about the sound of planes going overhead, which is really very adorable asides. But essentially, it's a box that looks like a wood stove.

It's fed by pellets in a hopper. There's an auger in there, which is like a screw that drops pellets in at an even rate to keep it burning at a consistent temperature that you choose. There's a fan that blows hot air into your world so you will be warm. There's also, I believe, an intake fan. And the pellets themselves, as your propaganda broadside points out, are recovered bits of forest waste and sawdust and you know recycled wood it's it's not like trees which are made in a factory this is really natural stuff these pellets and you get them in big bags and you and you feed them into there and and it's it's a because of the

nature of the stove it's uh i did check i did check out independently of the link that you sent me, Elena, you and I were thinking the same way. I did go and check out energy.gov because energy.gov, the federal agency, Department of Energy, has a whole article about wood stoves versus pellet stoves. And you're absolutely right. They are very efficient and low polluting compared to a, let's just say, a vigilant 77. And those are all good reasons to get a pellet stove. Did I make the argument fairly, would you say? Thank you. Yes. I think you summed that up very well, Your Honor. All right. Luke, these are some compelling arguments for a pellet stove. If I were to rule in Elena's favor, how would you feel about losing the Vigilant 77? What does

having a wood stove mean to you emotionally? You know, I like being able to keep busy. I like the lifestyle that we live up here, which is not, you know, it's not always easy, but I enjoy that kind of labor. It keeps, you know, it keeps my mind occupied and it brings me joy. Just like, you know, work the work that I do on the farm with my hands. the work that I do on the farm with my hands. And, you know, if we're talking about like, you know, the, the prices for, you know, pellets versus wood, you guys were, you know, giving me some guff for getting my wood, you know, cut, dried and, and seasoned, I could get get whole logs delivered and it would be cheaper. And I do have the equipment on the farm that I could use to cut our wood with, but the amount of time that it would take me wouldn't, you know, would, would take away from my time of being able to enjoy, you know, my enjoy the the time by the wood stove because i love you know doing

crossword puzzles reading playing nintendo by the wood stove i mean i i love it spending spending time with your wife probably you should throw that spending time with my wife yeah spending time with my wife by the very romantic wood stove. Do you feel, Elena, that you are a wood stove widow? Are you not getting enough quality time with Luke? You know, I think our quality time would be just as well spent next to a pellet stove with that beautiful kindling fire behind the glass doors. I have a couple.

Oh, boy. kindling fire behind the glass doors i have a couple oh boy how many of a couple do you have points or comments or whatever's because i'm pretty much ready to make my decision i have three points they're short short points you know i've been defending the the wood stove but i have points about the pellets of two i don't think that they look cool. I think that they look like kind of like uncanny valley versions of wood stoves. They're kind of tacky and the pellets that you guys talk about that they come in like 50 pound bags. So, you know, if we're worried about me, you know, hurting my back, I'm just as likely to, you know, hurt my back while schlepping around these large bags of pellets. And it looks nowhere near as elegant as my wood stack in the shed lean to would look, the bags of pellets. What are the bags made?

What are the bags made of? I would assume plastic. Yeah. Where do you get them? Where do you get them from? Is there a, is there a pellet stove dealer nearby? I don't know,

but I get our wood from a guy that's. Elena says yes, but tell me where you get your wood from. Paul pool in 15 minutes down the road. I'll let you, I'll let you buzz market. Paul pool and wood, wood lot. Elena, where are you going to get your pellets to from pellets or us?

Actually, I have a coworker who told me about where they get their pellets from. That place uses recycled materials to wrap the pellets with. It's a recycled plastic. And then we also have a plastic recyclery at our local transfer station. So we could easily recycle the plastic. How far away is your pellet dealership? Closer or further away than Paul Pool? It's probably about 10 minutes farther, 15, something like that. Luke, how much property do you have there? We have one acre. You have trees on it? We do. Okay. I have one acre you have trees on it we do okay i have one final note about the pellet stove i'm sorry all right i'll i'll hear it this is my uh this is my like i feel like it's my ace in the hole because i haven't shared this part of my argument with elena either um oh boy everybody

even elena's to be surprised. As we were talking about the wind storms this morning, we do lose electricity pretty frequently up here. And I believe one large element of the pellet stove's hopper mechanism is uh powered by electricity so you know the auger is powered by electricity and the fan that that shoots the air out is powered by electricity there's also a circuit board in there that uh that is uh not only electrical but um requires maintenance on a regular basis because when you put electronics next to high heat for a long period of time that's a problem well this thing's got it's got to plug into the wall right doesn't the whole stove that usually is a sign that is usually is a sign that something requires electricity

that's right yeah you have propane baseboard heat is there a furnace somewhere uh there is yes it heats our our oven and our hot water right as well right and so when the when you lose electricity because you don't have a generator, what happens to that furnace? Uh, that ceases to function. It ceases to function. Interesting.

Interesting. Yeah. And the wood stove, uh, would not cease to function and, and does not cease to function. Luke, you're a charming person.

I've never seen someone who was losing a case so badly come back so hard. That was incredible. Thank you. That was incredible. I mean, that was one of the greatest saves I've ever seen in the history of Judge John Hodgman. I was hoping he hadn't put that one together. I am open to a provision in your ruling, your honor, that we also must require a generator if we are to go the route of a pellet stove. That would rather decrease the amount of savings that you would enjoy.

It sure would. It's a factor. Yeah. Luke, you had an unrelated experience with the big chicken barn. Is that correct? That is correct. That would be main content, correct? That would be.

That would be. All right. So we'll save that for the surprise post credit sequence. I think I've heard everything I need to in order to hear my decision. I'll be back in a moment. I'm going to go stoke my fire, warm up, and I'll be back in a moment with my decision. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman exits the courtroom. Luke, how are you feeling about your chances? I feel like my final argument was pretty sound, but I know that there is a precedent to not rule for the husbands. Well, there's a precedent that the husbands are wrong.

That's true. I wouldn't say that it's something that we're forcing on the situations. Something the situations are forcing on us. That's very true. Elena, how are you feeling about your chances? Well, I gotta say, I was feeling very confident up until the last there. Well, we'll see what Judge Hodgman has to say about all this when we come back in just a second on the Judge John Hodgman podcast. Hello, teachers and faculty.

This is Janet Varney. Hello, teachers and faculty. This is Janet Varney. I'm here to remind you that listening to my podcast, The JV Club with Janet Varney, is part of the curriculum for the school year. Learning about the teenage years of such guests as Alison Brie, Vicki Peterson, John Hodgman, and so many more is a valuable and enriching experience, one you have no choice but to embrace, because yes, listening is mandatory. The JV Club with Janet Varney is available every Thursday on Maximum Fun or wherever you get your podcasts. Thank you, and remember, no running in the halls! if you need a laugh and you're on the go try s-t-o-p-p-o-d-c-a-s-t-i hmm are you trying to put the name of the podcast there yeah i'm trying to spell it but it's tricky let me give it a try okay if you need a laugh and you're on the go call s-t-o-p-p-p-a-d-i it'll never fit no it will let me try if you need a laugh and you're on the go try s-t-o-p-p-p-d-c-o-o oh we are so close stop podcasting yourself a podcast from maximumfun.org if you need a laugh and you're on the go. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman re-enters the courtroom

and presents his verdict. So I turn to some people I know who live in cold climes and live with wood stoves and pellet stoves as part of their lives. If you were listening last week, in anticipation of this case, I threw to Joel Mann, our wintertime and sometimes summertime producer over there at WERU in Orland, Maine. I said, wood stove or pellet stove? And he said then, and he reiterated in his text to me now, pellet stove. Because of... And then he sent me a bunch of spider emojis because he's scared. Because he said last week, he's scared of spiders living in the woodpile.

And ticks. and ticks and moss and all kinds of vermont junk that can find its way in the woodpile you never know do you know my uncle-in-law ted and his woodpile had a red squirrel living in there inside the house and he liked it he fed the squirrel it was not a good idea not a good idea and then i turned to david leblanc who until about a year and a half ago was our very very dear friend still is but was our neighbor across the road in western massachusetts and david leblanc in Western Massachusetts. And David LeBlanc has a home. This is not as far north, obviously, as West Cornhole, Vermont or anything, but this is pretty, you know, they have winters there, real winters, not far from Brattleboro.

David LeBlanc's home is heated entirely by, guess what, a wood stove, entirely. No backup. Yeah. Or I should say the backup is the wood stove because the wood stove just you burn wood in it and it works he built his own house however and it is tight as a tick not the kind that sneaks into a wood pile the kind the metaphor that means it's very very well insulated and they have big windows facing to the south and david LeBlanc is very pro-wood for a lot of the reasons that we talked about today

that Luke, you brought up at the last second, right? Which is that the pellets are made somewhere. They come in bags that need to be recycled. The pellet stove needs electricity. So if your power goes out and you don't have a generator, then you're stuck and you don't have that heat. All of those arguments. And also the natural pleasure of stacking wood and the tactile element of having wood and cutting wood and burning wood and everything else. And they've got a glass fronted wood stove. I've seen it. It's very pretty. but the thing that struck me is that i asked him how how this is whole

sorts of heat for the winter you know how many cords he burns per winter two and a half wow two and a half cords that is half of what you are burning because i will give you this, Elena. The Vigilant 77 is a piece of junk. The Vigilant 77 is not vigilant at all. It is totally distracted as it is letting heat seep out of all the cracks that I can see in this photo. The Vigilant 77 is too small. The Vigilant 77 is too old. Jesse Thorne, you were going to say something earlier about wood stoves. Sorry, the dog came in the shot.

I'm sorry. The dog is... Lamb chop, what are you doing lamb chop lamb chop is hearing justice lamb chop is hearing justice coming down and i don't blame lamb chop for coming in lamb chops just checking in to make sure luke's okay i know lamb chop came in to lick the tears off of lu Luke's face. And I'll tell you what, Lamb Shop is lucky that those tears aren't frozen icicles, because the Vigilant 77 is an old piece of iron, and I know old things are supposed to be great.

But I know that Jesse knows. Jesse, you were going to point something out earlier, and I asked you to hold on to it for a second, which is what about wood stoves? Wood stove technology has come a long way in recent years and recent decades to the point where, you know, wood stoves are no longer just a big chunk of metal that you throw wood into. They're sophisticated appliances designed to maximize the efficiency of heating and the efficiency of the fuel use. Yeah, they've got all kinds of baffles and secondary air sources. And by this, I mean tubes, not mechanical stuff that can break down. They are sophisticated compared to the Vigilant 77, but there's still dumb boxes that you burn fire in, but you burn that fire much, much, much more efficiently.

The Department of Energy itself, energy.gov, will attest there are wood stoves that definitely rival that 85% heat efficiency of a pellet stove. And you can get them with catalytic converters in them that will really reduce pollution. Totally comparable. Totally comparable in terms of heat efficiency and even in air pollution. Totally comparable. Totally comparable in terms of heat efficiency and even in air pollution. And they have them with glass and you can see the wood burning nicely. And I saw what that guy was showing me at Embers Fireplaces and Lifestyle in Denver, Colorado, that side-by-side comparison, I saw that pellet stove burning. It's not pretty.

It was not pretty. I'm sorry. Humans have been looking at fires burning for as long as we've had fire because it is a beautiful thing to look at. And they've been looking at beautiful fires burning while playing Nintendo since the early 1980s. It's true. It's true. And you have a fan that makes noise.

You're heating your house by convection heat, whereas a wood stove is radiant heat. And I regret to inform you, Elena, that the technology of the wood stove has caught up with the convenience of the pellet stove. And indeed, a good new wood stove can have a nine to 10 hour burn without being touched. My friend, David LeBlanc, leaves that burning overnight. And it's in, it was, hang on, listen to what he just, listen to what he said. This is a true thing he said to me. There was a 20 degree Fahrenheit below zero wind chill last night, and we get up in the morning and the house is 70 degrees and the wood stove is just ashes.

It just burns overnight. So Elena, you are correct. The Vigilant 77, with all of its attendant sentimental attractions, it's junk. Throw it away. If you are going to invest in a new appliance, and I believe that you have to do it, I will resort to my bias and Luke's love for wood and say, make it a wood stove. You moved to Vermont.

Pallet stoves are for retirees. I'm sorry, you're not there yet. I don't like to say this, but it's true. Your young people have moved to Vermont. Luke works on a farm.

This is the lifestyle you chose. Yeah. Luke, if I rule in your favor, though, you've got to earn this. Yeah. Now, look, you've got to earn this. Yeah. Now, look, I don't want to represent like I'm out there chopping wood. That has not yet happened.

We get green wood delivered, but it's cut for fireplaces. And then we stack it. Or I should say my wife leads the stacking because it's her passion to stack these beehives and they look amazing. to stack these beehives and they look amazing. And there is something so, so special about laying down wood in the spring that you know you're not even going to touch until this winter or maybe the next winter. When you are heating with wood in a place like Vermont, you are directly helping local companies,

not that the pellet dispensary is some kind of predatory Walmart or anything. I don't know what they're all about. But Paul pulls 15 minutes down the road. He's counting on you to buy that wood. You can buy more wood from him. You can buy green wood from him earlier in the year and I bet get a better price. And then stack it. And then season it.

Read that book, Norwegian Wood, not the Murakami novel, which is also called Norwegian Wood, which is great. I'm talking about the one about stacking wood and the feeling of connection. I'll just read you a quote that I'll leave you with this. This is a quote from Ruben Knudsen in this book, Norwegian Wood, Chopping, Stacking, and Drawing Wood the Scandinavian Way. And he stacks these beehives of wood in his house there somewhere in Scandinavia. I don't remember where.

And he says, it's a part of the great yearly cycle of things. And wood lets you feel as though you're part of it all. A log that is heavy and damp puts you in direct touch with spring. It's a harbinger, a kind of preparation, a hint of something good in the winter that lies ahead. But there's nothing sentimental about it. I never shed any tears about burning the perfect log. It's not such a bad idea to have this kind of relationship with something that is as fleeting as life itself. And I'm telling you right now, Ruben Knudsen is a liar. I bet he's shed a tear over burning the perfect log. It's a beautiful thing. It's a perfect log that you seasoned.

I'll tell you one thing no one's ever done. Shed a tear over burning a pellet. And certainly, certainly no one's ever jumped up and down with joy when their electricity goes out and their pellet burner can't heat the house anymore and they got to switch over to propane. You don't have to get a generator if you get a wood burning stove. And for that reason alone, I would say go ahead and do it. But mostly lean into the beauty of the life you have chosen. Elena, I'm sorry, I'm finding in favor of Luke with the obvious caveat, get a good one and do a better job. This is the sound of a gavel.

Judge John Hodgman rules that is all. Please rise as Judge John Hodgman exits the courtroom. Elena, how are you feeling? A little deflated, but I'm glad we'll be investing in a more efficient future and a more eco-friendly one at that. Luke, how are you feeling in triumph? eco-friendly one at that. Luke, how are you feeling in Triumph? Triumphant. I feel good. I feel good. I am humbled by John's friend who only uses two and a half cords of wood. I mean, it's like, I know I'm stacking way more wood than I need to be. And so, you know, we only recently bought our house. So I'm really working on doing what I can to make it as, you know, efficient heat wise and, you know, on my own body as possible. So yeah, you know,

getting a better, a better wood stove is definitely the right route to go. Luke, Elena, it's been a pleasure to have you on the podcast. Thanks for joining us. Thank you. It's been an honor. Another Judge John Hodgman case in the books. Before we dispense swift justice, we want to thank Jonathan Arbogast and Karen Koston for the inspiration behind this week's episode title, Logging a Case in a Pellet Court. If you would like to name a future episode like Judge John Hodgman on Facebook, We regularly put out our calls for submissions there. You can follow us on Twitter, at Jesse Thorne and at Hodgman.

Hashtag your Judge John Hodgman tweets, hashtag JJHO. And check out the Maximum Fun subreddit. That's MaximumFun.reddit.com if you want to chat about this episode. We're on Instagram, at Judge John Hodgman. Make sure to follow us there

for evidence and other fun stuff. We're also personally on Instagram at John Hodgman and at put.this.on. Our producer is the ever-capable Ms. Jennifer Marmer. Now, Swift Justice, where we answer your small disputes with quick judgment. Scott says, I think unsalted saltines should be called eans. This annoys my wife. There's nothing inconsistent between those two sentences. That's it for this week's episode.

Submit your cases at MaximumFun.org slash JJHO or email Hodgman at MaximumFun.org. Remember, no case is too small, as we just learned. We'll see you next time on the Judge John Hodgman podcast. Post-credit surprise sequence. Hey, everybody. Listener Natalie, as you've been waiting to hear, chimed in with a third set of lyrics to Jess Fox's Garlic on My Fl my flap steak song. I want to thank all of you who sent in lyrics, especially those of you who sent them in and sang them. The contest is over. Natalie, please write me at Hodgman and Maximum Fund dot org and claim something off the Max Fund store dot com website for me to send to you.

But without further ado and and without and any further post-credit surprise sequences after this song, don't even listen after this song. Just turn it off. There will be nothing after Natalie's rendition of Garlic on My Flapsteak. And now, coming to you acapella from the Circle City. This one's going out coast to coast, podcasting from Australia to Greenland, and all you rollicking litigants at sea. We got fresh garlic on the flap steak in our pan. Save some for Gene Grigio and Joel the main man. And in summertime and fun time, Monty too. It's fresh garlic on the flap steak. Judge John Hodgman style to you.

Fresh garlic on my flap steak. Come on through. I ain't scale it justice just for you. Satsumas and scallops on the side. The court will be in session nationwide. A podcast or a kitchen, either is fine. We've got disputes to settle and the crocs is mine. So with Jennifer and Jesse and Summer Lord, fresh garlic on my flap steak, that's my court. 500 cases have gone by by From hot dogs to robots to pizza and trash And all these weird dads are sweeter than pie I might have some Kung Pao chicken while

my skillet gravy thickens Sources have systems And friends and neighbors, maybe even their cousins They all have grpes with an obscure reference And August is wrong, I'm judging folks of all types Abide by my verdict, win or defeat Swearing by whatever, have a seat This rollicking boat trip has been quite a ride. It's better in the courtroom, come inside. Tell me your stories and I'll tell you more. No specificity of narrative is a bore.

The sound of my gavel from winter to fall. Fresh garlic on my flap steak, that is all. Wait, did you say scallops? Okay, Luke, it's a surprise post-credits sequence. You have a story about the big chicken barn in Ellsworth. You have 30 seconds to tell it. Get ready and go. When I was a punk teenager, I stole a magnet from the big chicken barn in Maine.

The magnet has been on my fridge ever since then, and I feel really bad about it. The only reason I stole it was because it was in a box of magnets for sale, and I didn't want all the magnets. I just wanted the one. It has a picture of a sheep on it, and it says, lay dirty. With two seconds to spare one of the greatest stories on judge john hodgman of all time please take a picture of the magnet and send it to us oh there you go that's time's up for you luke thanks luke and elena bye

maximumfun.org comedy and culture artist owned audience supported