Judging Freedom - Ray McGovern: Does Putin Trust Trump?

Episode Date: March 17, 2025

Ray McGovern: Does Putin Trust Trump?See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Hey there, Ritual here to give a big shout out to you for making it through the hectic holiday season. The magic of those family moments? That was you. And now there's new milestones to prep for in 2025. This new year, check clean, quality pregnancy nutrient support off your to-do list with Ritual. We've done the research to create science-backed pregnancy support like our prenatal multivitamin,

natal choline, and fertility support, all designed to be taken alongside each other. But don't just take our word for it. They're also third-party tested for microbes and heavy metals and clean label projects certified. So, whether you're trying, thinking about trying, or already there, we don't have to tell you that prioritizing yourself can be the hardest part. That's why we're helping you get started today with 30% off a three month supply for a limited time

at ritual.com slash podcast. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. you Hi everyone, Judge Andrew Napolitano here for Judging Freedom. Today is Monday, March 17th, 2025 in the West. It is St. Patrick's Day. How appropriate to talk to Ray McGovern on St. Patrick's Day.

He'll be with us in just a minute on does Donald Trump trust Vladimir Putin? Does Vladimir Putin trust Donald Trump? But first this. Markets are at an all time high. Euphoria has set in. The economy seems unstoppable. But the last administration has buried

us so deep in debt and deficits it's going to take a lot of digging to get us out of this hole. Are you prepared? Lear Capital specializes in helping people like me and you grow and protect our wealth with gold. Did you know that during Trump's last presidency gold rose 54% to a record high? If that happens again, that puts gold at $4,200 to announce in his next term. Don't wait. Do what I did. Call Lear at 805-11-4620 or go to learjudstnap.com for your free gold ownership kit and special report $4,200 gold ahead. When you call, ask how you can also get up to $15,000 in bonus gold with a qualifying

purchase. Call 800-511-4620, 800-511-4620 or go to learjudgenstnap.com and tell them the judge sent you. Ray McGovern, welcome here. Top of the morning to you, my dear friend. And the balance of the day to yourself. Oh, thank you. Thank you. That's the classic response. I learned those one-liners when I was a law student at the University of Notre Dame, the moniker of which is the Fighting Irish. But to matters more relevant and contemporary, and before we get to Putin and Trump and Trump and Putin, big picture. Can Steve Witkoff, the president's emissary to Gaza and Ukraine and can Marco Rubio the Secretary of State be honest brokers, honest intermediaries

when the United States is a co-belligerent with the Israelis against the Palestinians and with the Ukrainians against the Russians? The answer is no, no. Now with respect to Witkoff, he speaks for the president. Putin will take him more seriously. Even after their most recent meeting where I'm reliably informed that Witkoff was kept waiting for several hours

before he was given an audience with Putin. Even after that, we saw that the Russians were saying, well, there's some good grounds for optimism, and Trump himself described that session as positive. So what are we going to glean from that? The matter of trust is, in my view, irrelevant. There is no trust. There can't be any trust. There's got to be a deal that can be verified, okay? Doverei, no proverei, well, the doverei meaning trust, that's gone by the board. There have been too many times where people have been diddled, where people have been deceived,

and people have been really angry about that. Now, the Russians have to realize that this time they need something big, and they need something from Trump himself. Will they get it? Doesn't matter. Doesn't matter. They get it. They ceasefire, for God's sake. They're just going to keep... Actually, my information is that they really creamed some of the main control centers in Kiev just yesterday, and they're moving on course. So Putin's in the driver's seat. Trump will finally get it into his head that, look, that is the case. We have to do the kind of deal that is eminently verified. We have to put the Europeans aside and read them the riot act. Send the Secretary of

Defense again to tell them, look, you put people into Ukraine, you're crazy, because we're not going to support you, we're not going to defend you, and you're not going to be able to invoke article five with NATO NATO Charter. So the whole thing really is up in flux, but it you know, Trump is transactional Putin is also the rub is that the trust is gone, but there are There are agreements that are possible as long as so long as they are verifiable and that Puchin for his part can reassure his admirals and generals that are always always looking over his shoulder look this time if they cheat or if they renege if there's another if there's another deception here, we'll know within two days and we'll react accordingly. That is possible. As a matter of fact, I think that's probable, but it's going to take a little

bit more time for Trump to realize that he can't send neophytes like Rubio to do a man's job. Rubio to do a man's job. Uh, Witkoff may be able to do it. Trump will have to do it himself. I understand that he had put you will be talking on the phone this week. You know, you led right to what I was going to ask you next. And that is who would, in your understanding of, uh, of the mentality, who would the Russians rather deal with, uh? A sophisticated negotiator who has the constant ear of the president like Witkoff,

or a pseudo politician, former, maybe still, Neocon with no experience, but who is the lawful secretary of state of the United States like Rubio. This podcast is sponsored by Talkspace. You know when you're really stressed who is the lawful secretary of state of the United States, like Rubio. This podcast is sponsored by Talkspace. You know when you're really stressed, or not feeling so great about your life, or about yourself? Talking to someone who understands can really help. But who is that person? How do you find them? Where do you even start?

Talkspace. Talkspace makes it easy to get the support you need. With Talkspace, you can go online, answer a few questions about your preferences, and be matched with a therapist. And because you'll meet your therapist online, you don't have to take time off work or arrange child care. You'll meet on your schedule, wherever you feel most at ease. If you're depressed, stressed, struggling with a relationship, or if you want some counseling for you and your partner, or just need a little extra one-on-one support, Talkspace is here

for you. Plus, Talkspace is here for you. Plus, Talkspace works with most major insurers, and most insured members have a zero dollar copay. No insurance? No problem. Now get $80 off of your first month with promo code SPACE80 when you go to Talkspace.com. Match with a licensed therapist today at Talkspace.com. Save $80 with code space 80 at Talkspace.com. Yeah, you know, I don't, I don't understand why Rubio did that stuff there, you know, the 30 day ceasefire. It makes absolutely no sense. Did he not go back to the NSC and then vet that and say, is this a good idea?

Or what is it feasible? Can it, you know, I don't know why he did that, but he did it. So one has to reason that Putin's looking on these characters, not only Rubio, but that fellow General Kellogg. Don't listen to them. They don't seem to know what they're doing. Let me talk to Trump this week, and that's what's going to happen. And hopefully they'll deal with this Kursk thing because there are from seven to ten thousand Ukrainian troops encircled now. What happens? On Friday Trump says these people are encircled? Mr. Putin, could you please treat them kindly? to please treat them kindly. Next day, Saturday, Zolinsky says, eh, not in circle, my troops are not in circle.

That's a lie, that's a Vladimir Putin lie, says Zolinsky. Now, I don't have any information what's happened today. But I don't think the Russians are gonna obliterate those people. It's a real holding card. They can keep encircling them. Their access back to Ukraine is broken off as far as I'm informed. So they can play with that.

That's a card in Putin's hand. And how he reacts to Trump's plea, please be nice to these guys. Well, you know, they're terrorists. They invaded our country and they kill a lot of women and children. Right, right. This incursion into Kursk, which is Russia, this invasion and conquering, albeit temporarily and in a limited way, Russian territory, has been a disaster for Kiev, has it not? the knowledgeable and encouraged Zelensky to do this stupid thing. They weren't on the planning, they knew about it months before, and they did it anyway. It's a fool's errand. Why would they want to? Well, I think that the best explanation is they hope to capture that nuclear power plant there in a coolish script. That might be a bug in check. It was clear they wouldn't capture that nuclear power plant there in a coolish script. Like that, that might be a bug in check.

It was clear they wouldn't get that in the second day. So now why did the Russians, that was August. Why did the Russians wait till now? Because it's not about territory. It's almost easy to say, look, Ukraine invaded us. Now we're gonna clean them up. We're gonna take our own damn time because it's about killing Ukrainian troops And that's what we're doing hand over fist and that's what they did do to these cracker Jack

Ukrainian troops would draw it off the line in the in the Netsk to fight this fool's errand in this fool's errand in in in quarters so it's gonna be interesting this week things happen so fast how how Putin reacts to Trump's plea please be nice to these guys and Putin's reaction yeah please could you have him surrender please I will be nice to them if they stop shooting at us. Right, right, right. Alistair Crook told us this morning that Marco Rubio, Mike Walsh, and Vladimir Zelensky actually signed the so-called ceasefire agreement and are almost presenting it as a take it or leave it to President Putin. Now, Rubio cannot be that naive as to think that signing it would make it more attractive. I would think signing it would make it less attractive.

Judge, it's my view that it was a big mistake to let Rubio or any other American negotiate with the Ukrainians. This is the Ukrainians against Russia. I don't know what got into their head that they'd start this thing out. Clearly Rubio is from Hungary when it comes to appreciating what a ceasefire is, but sounds good to him, right? And the Ukrainians are so, oh, this is what we need. And so he went with now signing it. It was so vague. I mean, there were no particulars in it. I can see where it would be. I said,

oh, yeah, I'll sign it. See how it goes over. Now, the big thing is it did go over okay with Putin. In other words, he said, this is rubbish. No, he said, well, of course, of course we want to negotiate, but these are the conditions. And meanwhile, his spokesman, Peskov, said, there's grounds for optimism. This is going to come out all right. That's after Woodcock talked to Putin. So there are grounds for optimism. It's just going to take a long time. And Putin is going to have to get used to the fact that there are all kinds of people speaking for this already unpredictable president that we have. All right, well, so what will happen?

President Trump said last night he's speaking to President Putin tomorrow, Tuesday. What will happen when they speak? I assume they'll see each other, so it's a video call. And I assume others will be see each other so it's a video call and I assume others will be in Each of their rooms. There'll be a lot of people in with President Trump and a lot of people With President Putin will Intel Be with Trump and if so who I?

Imagine that it's also gabbered might be there and that of course would be a good thing. The important thing to emphasize here is that Blinken and Sullivan won't be there. Thank God. He'll have people that by choice are extremely loyal to him And so it's really what Trump says that goes here. I think, and I think the evidence is persuasive, he wants to do a deal here. I think Putin does as well, but it'll have to be on Putin's terms.

Trump has no cards to play, or maybe a pair of deuces to four aces in Putin's hand. So, you know, I think he's going to be transactional enough, if you will, to recognize that. And, you know, I think this is going to come out all right, even though the Europeans are trying to throw the, put the kibosh on it by saying that, whoa, we're going to have peacekeepers. This is crazy. What I think Trump should do is send Pete Hecset, the defense secretary, back to Brussels and say, hey, didn't you hear me the first time? Didn't you hear me? You sent troops into Ukraine. You're on your own. Don't expect us to come to barely help you get real trouble? I don't even think of invoking Article 5 of the NATO Charter.

It ain't going to happen. We're not going to. And so what are you going to do? That ain't going to happen, quote Bill Burns. And yet means yet. No means no. We're not sending more troops in. But look, we know what the conditions are

that President Putin is going to insist on. Secretary Lev Ruff articulated them the conditions are that President Putin's gonna insist on. Secretary Lavrov articulated them to Larry Johnson and me a week ago today. He had previously stated them many times as nothing novel or personal to us when he articulated them. President Putin has articulated them many times

as recently as last week in response to the Rubio take it or leave it. There have to be elections because the Russians consider Zelensky to be illegitimate. I think that's a little problematic. The Ukrainians really are the determining factor of who their leader is and they interpret Ukrainian law. However, the Ukrainians say he's illegitimate. NATO is totally permanently forever off the table. The four oblasts are part of Russia and the remainder of Ukraine is neutral. I can't see Zelensky agreeing to that if he expects to wake up

the next morning, can you? No, he's got real problems with the proto-Nazis that are very influential still in here. And bear in mind that the twin objective of the Russians, denazification as well as demilitarization. So, yeah, it really depends on what Puchin thinks. And, you know, I think Puchin is not going to be diddled again. There have been a whole series of betrayals in the Russian mind. And when Lavrov recited a whole list of them to you and Larry Johnson, that was just an incomplete list. There are several other grievances that the Russians legitimately

have, including being diddled by the likes of Angela Merkel and Ho Lung from Paris on the Minsk agreements. Mearsheimer, John Mearsheimer, often says, look, the Mearsheimer thing, the Minsk agreements were Putin's best guess, and now he best bet, and now he admits, you know, I was naive. I was wrong in thinking that these Westerners would honor their commitments. That's big. That could happen again. Let's go over to Israel because I want to ask you a question about a young woman that was killed there a few years ago.

Eventually, we want to get to that question. I know the issue is close to your very big and warm heart. Israeli society is deeply divided today between the right-wing religious fanatics who want Israel just for religious Jews and the secularists who want Israel to be a liberal democracy with equal rights for all. I don't know how these two views can be reconciled. Do you? That doesn't beat the hell out of me as we I wish we'd say. I don't think it can be. I was really interested to

see how Alster broke down the division here. It's the eschatological, religious extremist view that would just as soon have a war. You know, the end of the world, the end of lots of people and the more practical people who think, well, maybe we are just trim our sails here. It's big enough what we've got and what we occupied in 67. Let's live with that and make sure

we don't make any more enemies. Now, I guess it's coming to a head on Wednesday when the Shin Bet fellow, the head of the FBI equivalent in Israel, is either fired or he's not fired. And there's a whole big judicial argument about that, as Alster Crook pointed out earlier today. Before we came on air, I teased you because I'm wearing a green necktie and I don't see any visible green on you and you showed me your bracelet. My bracelet, which I can't find now. All right. I've been wearing a little green.

What is the significance to that bracelet that transcends March 17th? Yeah. Well, Judge, and you'll you can relate to this because you're almost as old as I am, not quite. In the Catholic theology is something called a sacrament and a sacramental. A sacramental is simply an external object that gives grace, okay? And this bracelet that Craig Murray, Rachel's dad gave me 21 years ago, it simply says Rachel Khoury, her date of birth, and then March 16th 2003, three days before the invasion of Iraq by US and UK forces. He said that, look, you can have this. And I've been wearing it ever since.

Why? To remind me, you know, it's a sacramentalist. It gives me the grace of courage. So when I'm in the Senate and I'm seeing that my former colleagues are all applauding the appointment and nomination confirmation of a person responsible for the first torture site in Thailand, Gina Haspel. I look at this thing, well, if Rachel Curry could stand up before a Israeli bulldozer to

protect the house where she was staying, where Palestinian families live from being demolished, I can stand up, easy enough and just say, look, you guys know what you're doing. You know she's a torturer. Well, then something happens to her. That's okay, you know? So there she is. That's what she faced.

Now, she had three companions from the international group that she was with. they watched all this. They watched the bulldozer get the okay from higher authority. They watched it go over her, and they watched him back over her, okay, to break her back, and she was dead on arrival at the hospital. Now, there she is, Rachel. Her dad and mom

marked her anniversary of her death yesterday with suitable and very cool, very very somber but not extreme language. I think we need to to know that people like that are fair game, whether they be US citizens or not, fair game like those sailors on the USS Liberty back in June 1967. 34 of them killed, 174 wounded by the Israelis deliberately. No apology. So my point is simply, the Israelis learned in 67 and then again, and right before the invasion of Iraq,

that they could get away with murder, literally, and Americans, even if they're murdering Americans, well, the administration will not give a rat's patootie about what happens, they'll even make apologies and cover things up. That happened to me actually. I was on a flotilla. There's Craig and what's her name? Cindy. Craig and Cindy Corey up I guess what yeah where Rachel had been living in Rafa. So Rachel was 23 years old. It's 22 years since then. I've been wearing this bracelet up there it is. It's my shirt.

Let's see it Brad. Gotta say that it's truly green. There it is. Well, yeah, yeah, so I'm wearing some sort of green today, but it's a Samba green and You know, I started to say when I was on the US boat to Gaza a US chartered boat the year after the mommy How many memora was was riddled by bullets by the Israeli Navy and an American citizen killed? We were told, look, the NSC has decided that you're not going to have any protection from the US government, so forget about that if you're going to go on this. And I said, wow, that's strange. Now, Craig Murray, my friend in Britain, said, you know, McGovern says that the NSC has made it clear

They're not gonna do anything and that they're just as soon see Corpses come home in coffins from this US boat to Gaza This Alice Walker was with us So what happened was this great checked with his own sources in the State Department? That exactly the same thing. And he wrote a piece, he said, you know, McGovern is pretty reliable, but I'm probably exaggerating.

You know, no, I got the same information. There's just as soon see this happen because this would be good for their relationship with guess what? Israel lobby, which just recently put the kibosh on the appointment of a very, very strong candidate to be deputy to Tulsi Gabbard as director of national intelligence. Their influence is all over the place. They don't mind people getting killed, even if they're Americans, because they'll be covered up. and they don't mind throwing their weight around to prevent

people from occupying positions that don't even require a Senate confirmation. That's the strength of these guys. Now what's going to happen in next week? A lot will happen. A lot will depend on whether Trump is transactional and can be transactional against people who are eschatological. That's going to be a big one. The first thing you need to understand. Eschatological meaning pertaining to the end of days. End times, yeah. Yeah. Graham McGovern, thank you.

Thank you, my dear friend. Thank you for your big heart. Thank you for your personal courage. Thank you for the insight and unique, if I may, Irish touch you bring to this show, whether it's St. Patty's Day or any other day. We'll see you on Friday with the pseudo-Irishman Larry Johnson. Happy St. Patrick's Day.

I'll get to all. Back at you. I did to all. Back at you. Thank you, Ray. And coming up shortly, the pseudo Irishman at 1130, Larry Johnson at two o'clock, Scott Ritter at three o'clock, Professor Jeffrey Sachs, Judge Napolitano for Judging Freedom. MUSIC you