Just Creepy: Scary Stories - Wilderness Horror Stories That’ll Make You Stay Out of the Forest

Episode Date: March 9, 2026

These are 2 Wilderness Horror Stories That’ll Make You Stay Out of the ForestLinktree: https://linktr.ee/its_just_creepyStory Credits:►Sent in to https://www.justcreepy.net/Timestamps:00:00 Int...ro00:00:18 Story 100:43:08 Story 2Music by:►'Shadows and Dust' by Scott Buckley - released under CC-BY 4.0. www.scottbuckley.com.auBusiness inquiries:►creepydc13@gmail.com#scarystories #horrorstories💀As always, thanks for watching! 💀

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:11 Own it all. Pay off your home, travel for life, drive a Ferrari. In celebration of the world premiere of the Monopoly Big Board Buckslot machine by Aristocrat Gaming, Yamava Resort and Casino at San Manuel is giving one person a $1.6 million dream package. The biggest prize in Yamava's history. Club Serrano members can earn daily instant prizes and secure a spot in the finale May 29th.
Starting point is 00:00:30 Don't pass go and own it all. Only at Yamava, celebrating its 40th anniversary. You win? Details at Yamava.com must be 21-20. Please gamble responsibly. Monopoly is a trademark of Hasbro. Hasbro is not a sponsor of this promotion. Hey, honey, it's mom.
Starting point is 00:00:43 Did you know if we switched to Verizon, we can get four phones for $0,000 plus four lines for $25 a line? Call me back. Me again. That's just $100 a month for four lines on unlimited welcome, plus four phones, no trade in needed. Call me. It's mom.
Starting point is 00:00:59 America's Best Network, Verizon, that's the one we're talking about. I'll send you text. America's Best Network based on Route Metrics, best overall mobile network performance, U.S. second half, 2025. Four new lines on a limit and welcome and auto pay. See Verizon. for details. I'm writing this here because I can't go to the police with what I actually think happened.
Starting point is 00:01:28 I already gave my statement, we all did. And what I told them was the truth, just not all of it. The parts I left out are the parts that don't make sense. And when you're sitting across from a detective in a fluorescent lit room at the McDowell County Sheriff's Office, and they're asking you why your friend is gone, you don't start talking about things that don't make sense. You give them GPS coordinates and timelines and you describe what gear he was carrying and what he was wearing.
Starting point is 00:01:56 And you say, I don't know a lot because you genuinely don't. But I need someone to hear the full version, even if it's just strangers on the internet. My name is Jess. I'm 29 and I work as a veterinary technician at a small animal clinic in Roanoke, Virginia. I've lived here since I graduated from Virginia Tech in 2017 with a biology degree I've only half used. I'm not an outdoorsy person by nature. I grew up in Virginia Beach, spent my childhood at the ocean front, and didn't see a real mountain until I was 18. But when you move to Roanoke, the mountains kind of absorb you. The Blue Ridge Parkway is right there. The Appalachian Trail is right
Starting point is 00:02:39 there. Everyone hikes, everyone camps. You either join in or you spend every weekend alone, and when I was 22 and knew in town and didn't know anyone, I chose to join in. That's how I met the group. There were six of us who became close over the years, though people drifted in and out. The core was me, Tyler, Hana, Corey, and two others, Mackenzie and Diego. We'd been camping together at least four or five times a year since 2018. Nothing extreme. We weren't backcountry survivalists or anything.
Starting point is 00:03:15 We did established campgrounds, state parks, the occasional overnight on the Appalachian Trail using lean-toes and shelters. We had a shared Google Doc where we tracked trip ideas and gear lists. We had a group chat called Touchgrass Enthusiasts, that was 80% memes and 20% actual planning. Tyler was the one who always pushed us to go further. He was 31, worked in IT for Carillion Clinic, and had this restless energy that I think came from sitting in front of screens all. day. He was the one who'd suggest we skip the campgrounds and actually hike in somewhere. He was the one who bought a water filter, then a hammock setup, then a full ultra-light kit. He wanted to do a section of the Appalachian Trail every year. He talked about through hiking constantly, researched it
Starting point is 00:04:03 obsessively, but never actually pulled the trigger because he couldn't get enough time off work. I liked Tyler. We all did. He was funny in that dry, self-deprecating way where you weren't always sure if he was joking. He'd say something like, I think a bear could definitely kill me, but I'd make it weird for the bear. And you'd laugh, but also kind of wonder if he'd rehearsed it. He was generous with his gear, always lending stuff out. He remembered everyone's food allergies. He was a good person. I need you to understand that because of what I'm about to tell you. We didn't abandon him. We didn't leave him behind out of carelessness or selfishness or anything like that. What happened was.
Starting point is 00:04:44 was more complicated than that, and I've spent 14 months trying to figure out if there was a single moment where we could have done something different, and I keep landing on the same answer, which is that I genuinely don't know. The trip was in October of 2023. Tyler had found a spot in the Linville Gorge Wilderness in western North Carolina, down in the Burke and McDowell County area. He'd been talking about it for months, called it the Grand Canyon of the East, which is apparently a real thing people say, and showed us photos on his phone at every hangout until we all agreed to go. The plan was a three-night backpacking trip, Thursday through Sunday. We'd hike in on Thursday afternoon, set up a base camp, do day hikes Friday and Saturday exploring the gorge, and hike out Sunday morning.
Starting point is 00:05:32 McKenzie couldn't get the time off, so she dropped out early. That left five of us, me, Tyler, Hannah, Corey, and Diego. Hanna is my closest friend in the group. She's a middle school art teacher, 30 years old, Corey an American, has this calm presence that balances out everyone else's chaos. Corey is 28, works at a brewery in Salem, and is basically a golden retriever in human form. Diego is 30, a paramedic, quiet but solid, the kind of person you want around when things go sideways, which, as it turned out, was prescient. We drove down Thursday morning, October 19, 2003. In two cars. Tyler and Corey and Tyler's Subaru, and me, Hanna, and Diego in Diego's truck. It's about a three-hour drive from Roanoke, and we hit some traffic around Marion,
Starting point is 00:06:26 so we didn't get to the trailhead parking area off of Kisler Memorial Highway until almost 1.30 in the afternoon. The weather was perfect, mid-50s, clear sky, the leaves were at peak color. The mountains looked like they were on fire with oranges and reds. I remember standing in the parking area, adjusting my pack straps, and thinking this might be the most beautiful place I'd ever been. Tyler had planned our route. We were going to hike down the Pine Gap Trail to a spot near the river, where he said there was good flat ground for camping. The descent was supposed to take about two hours. He'd printed out a topo map and marked our campsite with a red X, like we were pirates looking for treasure.
Starting point is 00:07:10 That was such a Tyler thing to do. The hike down was steep. Linville Gorge is no joke. The trail drops something like 1,600 feet in under two miles, and the terrain is rocky and rooted and uneven. Corey slipped twice and said, I'm fine. Both times in that aggressive way that means you're definitely not fine,
Starting point is 00:07:31 but also not hurt enough to stop. Hanna was quiet, focused on her footing. Diego set a steady pace at the back. Tyler was up front, practically bouncing. narrating the whole descent like a nature documentary host. Look at this, look at this, he kept saying, stopping to point at rock formations or particular trees. This gorge is like 400 million years old.
Starting point is 00:07:56 The quartzite here is some of the oldest exposed rock on the East Coast. Cool, Tyler, Corey said. Can the 400 million-year-old rock hold my weight? Because I'm about to fall on it. We made it to the river by about 3.45. Tyler's campsite was real, a flat sandy area near a bend in the Linville River, tucked between rhododendron thickets and hemlock trees. It was sheltered and private.
Starting point is 00:08:23 You couldn't see the trail from it, and you couldn't see the rim of the gorge above. It felt like being at the bottom of a massive stone bowl, the walls rising up on either side, dark with shadow even in the afternoon. I loved it and was also, on some level I didn't fully acknowledge, uncomfortable. There was something about being that deep in a gorge that felt like being swallowed. The sky was a narrow strip of blue above us. Sound behaved strangely down there. The river was constant white noise, but other sounds seemed to arrive from weird directions,
Starting point is 00:08:58 bouncing off the rock walls. A bird call from behind you would sound like it was above you. Your own voice felt muffled, dampened, like the gorge was absorbing it. We set up camp. Tyler and Corey shared a two-person tent. Hana and I shared mine. Diego had his own one-person setup that he could pitch in about four minutes, which he never let anyone forget.
Starting point is 00:09:22 We got a fire going by about 5.30, eight freeze-dried meals for dinner. I had the pad tie, which tasted like slightly spicy cardboard, and sat around talking as the sky darkened overhead. That first night was fine, better than fine. It was one of those evenings where the conversation just, flows, where everyone's relaxed and happy to be away from their phones. We had no signal down in the gorge, and their jobs and their routines. Tyler did his impression of our old college professor, Dr. Kimball. Hanna told a story about a kid in her class who'd drawn a portrait
Starting point is 00:09:57 of her with three arms and insisted it was accurate. Diego just sat back and smiled, and occasionally added something that made everyone crack up because it was so unexpected coming from him. We turned in around 10. I fell asleep fast, which is unusual for me when I'm camping. Something about the river sound, maybe, like the world's most expensive white noise machine. Friday was our first full day in the gorge, and it started great. We hiked up river in the morning, scrambling over boulders and wading through shallow sections where the water was so clear, you could count individual pebbles on the bottom. Tyler was in his element. He kept getting ahead of us, and then waiting on a rock like a mountain goat, grinning.
Starting point is 00:10:42 Corey brought a flask of bourbon, and we passed it around at a swimming hole, where the water was shockingly, painfully cold. Diego actually got in. The rest of us watched from the rocks and called him insane. We got back to camp around three in the afternoon, and that's when Tyler said he wanted to explore something he'd read about. There was supposedly an old homestead foundation somewhere on the east side of the gorge, upslope from the river, dating back to the 1800s.
Starting point is 00:11:11 He'd seen it mentioned in a trail forum and wanted to find it. It's not on any official map, he said, pulling out his phone even though it was useless for signal. He'd screenshoted the forum post. But this guy said it's about a 30-minute bushwack from the river, due east from where Pine Gap meets the bottom land. There's supposed to be a stone chimney still standing and some foundation walls. Hanna didn't want to go. she said she was tired and wanted to read by the river.
Starting point is 00:11:40 Diego said he'd stay too. He had a blister forming on his left heel and wanted to deal with it. Corey was game, and Tyler looked at me with those eager eyes and I said, sure, why not? I wish I hadn't. The three of us, Tyler, Corey and me left camp around 3.45. Tyler had a bearing on his compass and was confident about the direction. We crossed the river at a shallow ford and started uphill. through the rhododendron, which was dense. I mean dense. The roady thickets in Linville
Starting point is 00:12:13 Gorge are legendary. They call them rowdy hells, because once you're in them, the branches tangle above and around you, and you can't see more than a few feet in any direction. It's like being inside a living tunnel. We pushed through for maybe 20 minutes, gaining elevation, the gorge wall steepening around us. Tyler was using his compass and counting paces. Corey was behind me, breathing hard, occasionally swearing when a branch snapped back and hit him. The light was getting strange. It was still a couple hours before sunset, but the canopy and the gorge walls combined to create this dim, greenish twilight that made everything look slightly underwater. Then Tyler stopped. There, he said. I came up beside him and looked.
Starting point is 00:13:00 There was a clearing, not natural, but old enough that it had mostly grown over. And in the middle of it, a stone chimney, just standing there, alone, maybe 12 feet tall, covered in lichen and moss, with no house around it. Folks knew the Colonel approved of his new honey-chilly crisp and jalapeno ranch sauces the moment he tasted them and said, that's right, no notes, just absolute silence. Turns out some flavors don't need explaining. They just need dipping. It's saucy season at KFC. With new honey, chili crisp and jalapeno ranch, get dipping with a boneless bucket today.
Starting point is 00:13:43 Prices in participation vary. Chronic migraine, 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more, can make me feel like a spectator in my own life. Botox, Onabachycinin A prevents headaches in adults with chronic migraine. It's not for those with 14 or fewer headache days a month. It's the number one prescribed branded chronic migraine preventive treatment. Prescription Botox is injected by your doctor.
Starting point is 00:14:05 Effects of Botox may spread hours to weeks after injection causing serious symptoms. Alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems or muscle weakness can be signs of a life-threatening condition. Patients with these conditions before injection are at highest risk. Side effects may include allergic reactions, neck and injection site pain, fatigue, and headache. Allergic reactions can include rash, welts, asthma symptoms, and dizzyness. Don't receive Botox if there's a skin infection. Tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions, including ALS-Lugherics disease, myasthenia Gravis or Lambert Eaton syndrome, and medications. including botulinum toxins, as these may increase the risk of serious side effects.
Starting point is 00:14:39 Why wait? Ask your doctor. Visit Botox Chronic Migraine.com or call 1-800-44 Botox to learn more. The foundation walls Tyler had read about were there too, but they were barely visible, just low ridges of stacked stone half buried in leaf litter and earth. It was cool. It was eerie. It was the kind of thing that makes you think about the people who lived there. 150 or 200 years ago, what their lives were like, and then you realize you're standing in the gorge in dimming light and it stops feeling cool and starts feeling heavy. Someone lived here, Corey said, like he was processing it out loud, down in this gorge, before roads or anything.
Starting point is 00:15:21 Mountain people, Tyler said. He was already walking the perimeter of the foundation, stepping carefully. They lived everywhere. Some of these homesteads were occupied into the early 1900s. I walked up to the chimney and put my hand on it. The stone was cold, colder than the air, and slightly damp. There was a smell near the base of it, not the clean organic smell of forest floor, but something sharper, mineral, like wet iron.
Starting point is 00:15:51 I pulled my hand back and noticed a dark discoloration on the stone at about waist height, height, a rough smear that could have been anything, old soot, mineral deposits, lichenstain, but it looked, and I know how this sounds, it looked like a handprint, a big one. Fingers spread wide, pressed into the stone, and dragged downward. Guys, look at this, I said. Tyler came over and examined it. Probably just iron oxidation from the stone, he said. This is all local quartzite and some granite, lots of iron content. It looks like a hand, I said.
Starting point is 00:16:31 Yeah, he said, tracing the shape without touching it. It does. That's creepy. I love it. He took a photo with his phone. No signal. But the camera still worked. Corey took one too. I didn't. I don't know why. I just didn't want a picture of it. We poked around for another 15 minutes. Tyler found what he thought was a root cellar.
Starting point is 00:16:53 A depression in the ground near the back of the found. foundation with some stone lining still visible. Corey found an old glass bottle, pale green, half buried. He held it up like it was a trophy. Tyler found something else, too, near the chimney base, a small pile of stones that didn't look like they'd fallen from the structure. They were arranged, stacked deliberately, smallest on top, in a neat little cairn about eight inches tall.
Starting point is 00:17:22 Okay, that's recent, Tyler said. somebody's been here. Hikers, I said. People build cairns on trails all the time. We're not on a trail, Jess. We bushwhacked to get here. This isn't on any map. He was right, and the cairn didn't look weathered.
Starting point is 00:17:40 The stones were clean. Let's head back, I said. I was trying to sound casual, but something about the place had gotten under my skin. The light was getting dimmer. The chimney cast a long shadow across the clearing, and there was a sound, or rather there wasn't one. The forest around the homestead was quiet, not peaceful quiet, empty quiet.
Starting point is 00:18:04 No birds, no insects, no breeze in the canopy, just the faint rush of the river far below. Tyler wanted to stay longer. There might be more foundations further up, he said, could be a whole community. It's going to be dark in an hour and a half, I said. and I don't want to navigate those roady hells in the dark. Corey backed me up. Tyler reluctantly agreed, and we started back down toward the river. Here's where things started going wrong.
Starting point is 00:18:34 We couldn't find our path back. Tyler had his compass bearing, and we were heading due west, which should have taken us straight back to the river. But the rhododendron seemed denser than before, the slope steeper, the terrain less familiar. We hit a rock outcropping that none of us remembered passing on the river. way up. Tyler adjusted the bearing and we pushed on. But after another 15 minutes we hit a drainage gully that definitely hadn't been on our route. We're off, Tyler said, staring at the compass.
Starting point is 00:19:04 We need to go more northwest. Are you sure? Corey asked. He was getting nervous. I could hear it in his voice. The river is below us. We just need to go downhill. So we went downhill. The slope got steep enough that we were grabbing trees and roots to control our descent. The rhododendron closed in overhead until we were crawling through it in places. My hands were scraped, my pack was catching on every branch, and the light was failing fast. It was probably about 5.45 or 6 at that point, and down in the gorge, surrounded by canopy, it felt like dusk was collapsing into night. We heard the river before we saw it, and when we finally broke out of the rhododendron onto the rocky bank, we were at least a quarter mile downstream from our camp. The river looked different
Starting point is 00:19:54 here, wider, shallower, with a long gravel bar. Tyler oriented himself, pointed upstream, and said, this way. We followed the riverbank in the fading light. It should have been a simple walk, just follow the water upstream to camp, but the bank kept forcing us up and over obstacles, house-sized boulders and tangles of downed trees from some old flood. By the time, time we saw the glow of Hanna and Diego's fire through the trees, it was nearly full dark and I was shaking, though I told myself it was from the cold. Where were you guys? Hanna asked as we stumbled into camp. She was sitting by the fire wrapped in her sleeping bag, a book on her knee. Diego was filtering water. Got turned around coming back from the homestead, Corey said, dropping his pack.
Starting point is 00:20:43 Tyler's navigation skills need work. My navigation was fine. said, but he was smiling. He didn't seem bothered. He seemed energized, actually, in a way that struck me as slightly off. His eyes were bright. He immediately started telling Hana and Diego about the chimney, the foundation, the cairn, the root cellar. He showed them the photos on his phone. We should all go tomorrow, he said. It's incredible. You can feel the history. I could feel something, I said, and I meant it as a joke, but it came out flat. We made dinner. We sat around the fire. Tyler was different that evening.
Starting point is 00:21:23 Not dramatically different. Not in a way that anyone would have flagged as a problem. But he was quieter during group conversation, and then suddenly more talkative, jumping between topics. He kept going back to the homestead. Who lived there? What happened to them? Why was there a cairn?
Starting point is 00:21:41 He pulled out his phone and scrolled through the screenshots of the trail forum, reading passages aloud. This one guy says there were going to be. graves near some of the homestead sites, Tyler said. Unmarked, sometimes just fieldstone markers. Cool dinner conversation, Tyler, Hana said. No, listen. He says some of the old families who lived in the gorge didn't leave voluntarily when the Forest Service took over. They had to be removed, like forcibly. Some of them refused to go. There are stories about holdouts living in the gorge into the 1940s and 50s, completely off the grid. That's sad, Diego said quietly.
Starting point is 00:22:21 It's more than sad, Tyler said, and there was an intensity in his voice that made me look at him. The fire was reflecting in his eyes. These people were connected to this land in a way we can't understand. Generations, they knew every rock, every hollow, every... Tyler, I said, You okay? He blinked, looked at me, smiled, but it was a second too late. Yeah, yeah, sorry, just geeking out. He laughed, I'll stop. He didn't entirely stop, but he dialed it back, and we moved on to other topics, and by the time we went to bed around 10.30, things felt normal enough. Hanna and I were in our tent zipping up our bags when she said, Tyler's being weird. He's excited about the old house, I said. You know how he gets. Yeah,
Starting point is 00:23:09 she was quiet for a moment. That homestead sounds creepy, though. It was. The cairn part bothers me. Me too. We went to sleep, or Hana did. I lay there for a long time listening to the river and the fire crackling down to embers and the small sounds of the forest at night. At some point, I don't know exactly when, but it must have been around one or two in the morning. I woke up to the sound of a zipper. Close.
Starting point is 00:23:36 Then footsteps. Someone walking through camp. I lay still listening. The footsteps moved away from. from the tents toward the river. They were quiet, deliberate, not stumbling or urgent, just someone walking with purpose. I told myself it was someone going to pee.
Starting point is 00:23:54 Normal camping thing. I almost went back to sleep. But something made me unzip the tent and look out. Moonlight. The gorge walls were silver blue above us, and the moon was almost full, sitting in that narrow strip of sky. I could see the campsite clearly, the dead fire, the bear bags hanging from.
Starting point is 00:24:13 from their line. Diego's tent, Tyler and Corey's tent. Tyler and Corey's tent was partially unzipped. The flap was hanging open. And there was Tyler, standing at the edge of the river, not doing anything, just standing there, facing the water, his arms at his sides. He was in his base layer, long-sleeve shirt, shorts, no shoes. The river moved around the rocks in front of him, silver in the moonlight. Tyler, I called softly. He didn't. didn't respond, didn't move. I stepped out of the tent, slid on my camp shoes, and walked toward him. The ground was cold. The air was cold.
Starting point is 00:24:52 When I got within about ten feet of him, I stopped. Tyler, hey. He turned his head, slowly, like he was waking up. He looked at me, and for just a second, for just one terrible second, his expression was completely blank, not confused, not sleepy, not anything, blank, like his face was a mask that hadn't decided what to be yet. Then he smiled. Hey, Jess, sorry.
Starting point is 00:25:19 Couldn't sleep. The river's beautiful at night, right? You scared me. Sorry. Go back to bed, I'm fine. I almost did, but I stood there for another moment, and in that moment I noticed something. Tyler was facing the east side of the gorge,
Starting point is 00:25:35 not looking at the river, looking up the slope, toward the homestead. What are you looking at, I asked. nothing, just listening. To what? He was quiet for a few seconds. Then, you ever notice how the gorge changes sound at night? During the day it's all river and birds and wind.
Starting point is 00:25:57 At night the river gets quieter, like it's being absorbed by something and you can hear deeper sounds from the rock. You're freaking me out. He laughed softly. Sorry, I'm being weird, going back to bed. He walked past me toward his tent. He patted my shoulder as he passed, and his hand was ice-cold, not chilly from standing outside cold, cold like he'd been holding it in the river.
Starting point is 00:26:23 I watched him climb back into his tent and zip it up, and then I went back to mine and lay there for a long time, heart beating too fast, telling myself it was nothing. Saturday. Our second full day. I woke up around 7.30 to Diego making coffee on his jet boil. Hanna was already up, sitting by the relit fire. Corey emerged from his tent, yawning. Tyler was the last one out, and when he came out, he looked rough, pale, dark circles.
Starting point is 00:26:54 He said he'd slept terribly, which I believed. We had breakfast, oatmeal, coffee, granola bars, and discussed the plan for the day. Tyler wanted to go back to the homestead. He said he wanted to look for the graves the forum post mentioned. Nobody else was enthusiastic about this. I'd rather hike the gorge rim trail, Hanna said. The views are supposed to be amazing. We can do that tomorrow on the way out, Tyler said.
Starting point is 00:27:21 The homestead is right here. We might not get another chance. Tyler, there's nothing up there, Corey said. It's a chimney and some rocks. There's more. I know there's more. We barely scratched the surface. There was an edge to his voice, not angry, but insistent, urgent.
Starting point is 00:27:41 Diego looked at me. I looked at Hana. We had one of those silent group conversations where everyone's thinking the same thing but nobody wants to be the one to say it. How about this? Diego said in his calm paramedic voice. Tyler, you go check out the homestead. Take whoever wants to go. The rest of us will do a day hike along the river. We meet back here by four. Nobody's out after dark. Tyler agreed. Corey said he'd go with Tyler, which surprised me. I think he felt guilty about complaining the day before. Hanna, Diego and I would do the river hike. This is the part. This is the decision. I've replayed it so many times that the memory has gone soft around the edges, like a word you repeat until it loses meaning. Tyler and Corey went east, up the slope,
Starting point is 00:28:29 into the rhododendron. Hanna, Diego and I went north along the river. We split up around 9.15 in the morning. The three of us had a nice hike. The gorge was stunning, in the morning light, the rock walls glowing warm gold where the sun hit them. We found another swimming hole, saw a water snake, ate lunch on a flat boulder overlooking a small waterfall. Hana took photos for her students. Diego told us about a particularly absurd EMS call involving a man who'd superglued his hand to a lawnmower. We laughed. We didn't talk about Tyler being weird the night before, but I could tell we were all thinking about it. because every so often the conversation would hit a natural pause,
Starting point is 00:29:14 and someone would glance east, toward the slope, toward the homestead we couldn't see. We got back to camp at 3.45. Tyler and Corey weren't there. 4 o'clock came. No Tyler, no Corey. 4.30. Nothing. 5 o'clock.
Starting point is 00:29:29 The sun was getting low over the gorge rim. Diego tried shouting, Tyler! Corey! His voice echoed off the rock walls and came back fractured, distorted. No response. They probably just lost track of time, Hanna said, but she'd stopped unpacking her bag. She was standing, looking at the east slope, arms crossed.
Starting point is 00:29:50 I'm going to walk downstream and shout, Diego said. They might have come down to the river at a different point. He left. Hanna and I stood in camp. Jess, she said quietly, last night I heard Tyler get up. I know, I talked to him. No, not then. After that, I heard him get up again.
Starting point is 00:30:08 It was really late. maybe three or four in the morning. I heard his tent zipper and footsteps, and they went toward the slope. East. I heard him going through the brush. My skin went cold. Did he come back? I fell back asleep.
Starting point is 00:30:23 He was in camp this morning, so I assumed. Diego came back at 5.20, alone. He hadn't seen or heard them. His calm, paramedic demeanor was starting to show cracks. We should go look, he said. But I don't want all of us going up there in the dark. We're not splitting up again, I said immediately. Agreed. We all go, or nobody goes.
Starting point is 00:30:47 We all went. We crossed the river at the same Ford Tyler and I had used the day before and started up the slope. Diego had a headlamp on. Hana had hers. I had mine. Three beams of light cutting through the rhododendron as we climbed. We called their names every 30 seconds. Tyler, Corey, Tyler, Corey. The gorge ate the same. sound. It took us about 25 minutes to reach the homestead clearing. I recognized it by the chimney, standing pale and ghostly in our headlamp beams, the foundation walls, the root cellar depression.
Starting point is 00:31:23 Everything looked different at night, sharper, more angular, like the ruins were more present in the dark than they'd been during the day. Tyler's pack was there. Sitting on the ground near the chimney base leaned upright against the stone. His trekking poles were beside it, collapsed. His water bottle was on top. It was like he'd set everything down neatly, deliberately, and walked away. The cairn I'd seen the day before was gone. The stones were scattered, but there were new ones. Three new cairns, arranged in a rough line between the chimney and the root cellar depression.
Starting point is 00:32:00 Each one about a foot tall, perfectly stacked. Corey! Diego called. His voice was tight now. Corey! From somewhere, I couldn't tell where the gorge was doing its acoustics thing. We heard a voice, faint, ragged. Here, I'm here.
Starting point is 00:32:18 We followed the sound north of the clearing, past the foundation walls, through a thicket of mountain laurel, and found Corey sitting on the ground with his back against a tree. His headlamp was on, but the beam was weak, batteries dying. He was holding his left arm against his chest. His face was streaked with dirt and dried tears. Corey, Diego said, dropping to his knees. What happened?
Starting point is 00:32:42 Where's Tyler? Corey looked at us. His eyes were wide and glassy. He was shivering. It took him a long time to speak, and when he did, his voice was hoarse like he'd been screaming. He went in the hole, Corey said. What hole? Hana asked.
Starting point is 00:32:57 The cellar, the root cellar. He was digging all day. He found something underneath, an opening, like a passage in the rock. He kept digging and it got bigger. He was using a stick, then his hands. He wouldn't stop. I told him to stop, and he wouldn't stop. He said he could hear them.
Starting point is 00:33:19 Hear who? I asked. He didn't say who. He just said them. He said they'd been calling him since last night. He said the gorge was talking to him. Jess, he wasn't, he wasn't right. His eyes were wrong. He was talking, but it wasn't all him talking.
Starting point is 00:33:35 Some of the words were him and some of the words. them were. I don't know. They were coming from somewhere else. Diego was checking Corey's arm, which was swollen at the wrist. Is it broken? He asked. I think so. I fell when I was running. Corey's voice cracked. He went in the hole, Diego. He crawled in head first, and I couldn't see him anymore, and I could hear him laughing. He was laughing and it echoed and it went on too long. The echo went on too long. This cellar is like six feet deep. There shouldn't be an echo, and it went on for, he stopped, swallowed. I ran. We went back to the root cellar, all four of us, because none of us were willing to stay behind. Diego went first. He crouched at the edge
Starting point is 00:34:21 of the depression and shone his headlamp down. The root cellar was maybe five feet deep, lined with dry-stacked stone. At the bottom, on the far side, there was a gap. The stones had been pulled away. Recently, roughly, some of them cracked and displaced, revealing dark space behind them. A hole in the earth, maybe two and a half feet across and two feet tall, big enough for a person to crawl into. Tyler's phone was on the ground at the bottom of the cellar, face down. Tyler! Diego shouted into the hole. The sound went in and didn't come back. Not even a whisper of echo. He shouted again, nothing. I will never be able to adequately do that. I will never be able to adequately described the silence that came out of that hole. It wasn't just the absence of sound.
Starting point is 00:35:08 It was the presence of something else. A thickness, a weight. It felt like the hole was listening to us the same way we were listening to it. The air coming out of it was cold, not cool underground cold, but cold in a way that felt intentional, like breath. We need to go in, Diego said. No, I said, absolutely not. He could be hurt. He could be stuck. Diego, you don't know what's down there. You don't know how far it goes. We have no rope, no gear, nothing. If you go in there and something happens, we're all screwed. She's right, Hannah said. Her voice was barely audible. We need to get help. We need to hike out and get search and rescue. Corey was crying, quietly, steadily. His broken wrist
Starting point is 00:35:55 cradled against his chest. I should have stopped him, he kept saying. I should have grabbed him. Diego stood up. He stared at the hole for a long time, then he said, Okay, we go back to camp, pack up, and hike out at first light. One of us stays awake at all times in case Tyler comes back on his own. That's what we did. We went back to camp. We packed.
Starting point is 00:36:20 Nobody slept, despite the plan for shifts. We sat around the fire all night, barely speaking, listening to the river and the gorge and the occasional sound from the forest that made all four of us go rigid, and stare into the dark. Twice during the night, I heard something from the east slope, not Tyler's voice, not anything I could identify. A low sound, rhythmic, like breathing, but vast, like the gorge itself was inhaling and exhaling. I told myself it was wind moving through rock formations. I told myself that over and over, Hana heard it too. I know because each time she reached over and grabbed my hand without saying a word.
Starting point is 00:37:05 At around 4.30 in the morning, still full dark, Corey said, Something's at the tree line. He was pointing east toward the slope. We all looked. Three headlamp beams swept the edge of the rhododendron where it met the riverbank clearing. There was nothing there. But the rhododendron was moving, swaying, not like wind. There was no wind.
Starting point is 00:37:29 Like something was moving through it, slowly, parallel to our can. camp, staying just inside the thicket. We could hear branches creaking and leaves rustling in a line that traveled from our south to our north, maybe 50 feet away, over the course of about two minutes. Then it stopped. Tyler? Diego called out. Nothing. Tyler, if that's you, come into the camp. Nothing. Then, and this is the part I've never told anyone, not the police, not my therapist, nobody. There was a sound from the thicket, a voice, Tyler's voice, but wrong. The pitch was right, the timbre was right, but the cadence was off. It was like someone who'd learned to imitate Tyler was speaking words they didn't
Starting point is 00:38:14 fully understand. It said, I found them, come see, it's incredible, I found them, come see, I found them. It repeated, three times, exactly the same intonation each time, like a recording being played on a loop. Nobody moved, nobody breathed. The voice stopped. The rhododendron went still. I don't remember the rest of the night in detail. I think my brain has blocked some of it. I know we stayed awake. I know we kept the fire huge,
Starting point is 00:38:44 burning through most of our remaining firewood. I know that Hana at one point whispered that wasn't Tyler, and Diego said, I know, and nothing else was said about it. At first light, about 6.45, we broke camp. Diego helped Corey with his pack, carrying most of the weight. We left Tyler's tent, Tyler's gear, everything of his, right where it was. We hiked up the Pine Gap Trail faster than should have been possible with a man nursing a broken wrist, and we were at the trailhead by nine.
Starting point is 00:39:14 Diego drove straight to the McDowell County Sheriff's Office. We reported Tyler missing. Search and rescue was organized. A team went into the gorge that same afternoon. They found the campsite. They found Tyler's gear. They found the homestead, the chimney, the roof. root cellar. They found the hole. Here's what they told us. The hole opened into a narrow crawl
Starting point is 00:39:37 space that extended roughly 12 feet into the rock before tapering to a gap too small for a human to fit through. The rock was solid quartzite. There were no branches, no side passages, no cavern beyond. A 12-foot dead-end tube in the rock, barely big enough to crawl through, ending in a crack a few inches wide. Tyler was not in it. There were scuff marks in the dirt consistent with someone having crawled through it, but the passage simply ended. They brought in a geological survey team and a cave rescue specialist. The specialist confirmed the passage was a dead end. No way through. No hidden openings. No other exits. Tyler's phone was recovered. The last photos on it were from Saturday afternoon. Photos of the homestead, the chimney, the cairns. The last photo,
Starting point is 00:40:30 time stamped at 3.22 in the afternoon, was of the whole. Just darkness. Tyler's headlamp beam illuminating rough stone walls tapering into black. The police interviewed all of us separately. We told them what happened, minus the voice in the rhododendron, minus the feeling, minus the parts that didn't make sense. They searched the gorge for 11 days. Dogs. helicopters, ground teams, nothing. Tyler's car was still at the trailhead. His wallet was in the glove compartment. His bank accounts were never accessed. His phone was there. His pack was there. He just wasn't. They told us eventually that their working theory was that Tyler had experienced some kind of mental health crisis, a psychotic break, possibly triggered by stress or sleep deprivation,
Starting point is 00:41:19 had crawled into the passage, gotten disoriented, and somehow exasement. the gorge on foot in an altered state, that he was probably somewhere in the surrounding wilderness, possibly deceased from exposure. They continued searching off and on into early 2024. Nothing was ever found. Corey's wrist was broken in two places. He had surgery and three months of physical therapy. He doesn't camp anymore. He doesn't hike. He quit the brewery and moved to Richmond to be closer to his sister. We don't talk much. When we do, we do. We don't don't talk about Tyler. Diego is still in Roanoke, still a paramedic. He's the only one of us who went back to Linville Gorge, once, alone, about six months after. He told me he went to the homestead.
Starting point is 00:42:07 He said the three cairns we'd seen that night were gone, but there were new ones. Seven of them, arranged in a semicircle around the root cellar. He didn't go down into the cellar. He didn't look at the hole. He took photos, turned around, and left. He showed me the photos. In one of them, if you zoom in on the chimney, there's a mark on the stone that wasn't there before. A dark smear at about chest height. It could be mineral staining. It could be lichen. It looks like a handprint. A big one. Fingers spread wide. Hanna moved to Asheville last year for a teaching job. We face time every couple of weeks. She told me recently that she's been having dreams about the gorge. In the dreams, she's standing at the edge of the edge of her. She's standing at the edge of her. of the root cellar, looking down, and the hole is bigger than it was, much bigger, big enough to walk into, and from inside the hole she can hear Tyler's voice, clear and normal, and completely him, saying, Hana, come look at this, you have to see this. She says in the dream, she always wants to go, she always wants to climb down, she wakes up right before she does. I haven't been back, I haven't
Starting point is 00:43:23 dreamed about it, but I hear things sometimes, late at night, in my apartment in Roanoke, sounds that don't belong, a rhythmic, low, breathing sound that comes and goes, like something vast is inhaling and exhaling just behind the walls. My vet clinic is in a building that's been standing since 1912. The walls are plaster over stone. The stone is local, court site. I check Tyler's mom's Facebook page every day, she posted this morning. A photo of Tyler at eight years old, gap-toothed and grinning, holding a fish he'd caught at Smith Mountain Lake. The caption said, Day 426, My sweet boy, I will never stop looking for you. I thought about commenting. I thought about sending her a message. I thought about telling her what really happened that night in the
Starting point is 00:44:16 gorge, the voice in the rhododendron, the way the whole seemed to breathe. The cairns that keep appearing. I didn't. I won't. Because the truth is worse than not knowing. The truth is that her son crawled into a 12-foot dead-end passage in solid rock and never came out the other side. And that's not something you tell a mother.
Starting point is 00:44:38 That's not something that fits into a police report or a search grid or a go-fund-me. That's something that just sits in you like a stone at the bottom of a gorge. And you carry it, and you don't talk about it, and you hope that someday it gets lighter. It hasn't yet. If you've been to Linville Gorge and you found an old homestead with a stone chimney on the east slope above the river, and there were cairns around it that you didn't build, leave. Don't look at the root cellar.
Starting point is 00:45:04 Don't dig. Don't listen to what the Gorge is telling you, because it is telling you something, and whatever it's saying is not for you. And the people it said it to before did not come back to tell anyone what it meant. Tyler, if somehow, impossibly, you're reading this. I'm sorry we left. I'm sorry I didn't go back.
Starting point is 00:45:25 I'm sorry I can't explain what happened to you in a way that would make anyone come looking in the right place. Because I don't think the right place exists on any map. I don't think the right place exists at all. My name is Sarah and I am 27 years old. I grew up in Oregon, on the west side, where the trees crowd up against the road and you can drive for 20 minutes without seeing a house. I live in Portland now, but when people ask where I am from, I still say Oregon, and I mean the woods part.
Starting point is 00:46:04 I mean the part where it rains nine months out of the year and the moss grows on everything, and you learn to keep your headlights on it too in the afternoon. I trust the woods. I do not mean that nothing bad happens in them. I mean they feel normal to me, and when something feels normal, you stop paying attention to the parts that should scare you.
Starting point is 00:46:23 I am writing this down because I kept telling myself I would stop thinking about it, and I have not. It has been months, and I still check my locks three times before bed. I still sleep with the bathroom light on. I still cannot hear someone knock on my door without my whole body going tight. It happened on Friday, November 15, 2025. I know the exact date because I had taken the day off from work, and I wrote it on my wall calendar in thick black marker, so I would not schedule anything over it.
Starting point is 00:46:55 Cabin weekend. Phone off. Reset. I circled it twice. I had been running on nothing for weeks. I work in a medical office, front desk, and even on a slow day you absorb other people. You sit there and they tell you about their pain
Starting point is 00:47:10 and their insurance problems and their fear. And you smile and you nod and you type things into the system. And then you go home and you are supposed to just be fine. I was not fine. I started waking up with my jaw clench so hard my teeth ached. I started getting anxious at the grocery store for no reason. I would stand in the cereal aisle and my heart would be going fast and I did not know why. I started leaving dishes in the sink because even a small chore felt heavy.
Starting point is 00:47:40 Not heavy in an interesting way. Just heavy. So I booked a cabin near Detroit Lake, not a resort, not one of those places with a hot tub and twinkle lights on the deck. a plain cabin in the woods with a fireplace and a small kitchen and no neighbors close enough to wave at. I wanted quiet. I wanted the kind of silence where you can hear yourself breathe and nothing else. The listing looked normal, wood siding, a porch with two chairs, tall fir trees on every side, a gravel driveway. It was called Pine Ridge Cabin. The host name was Kevin. His messages were friendly but short.
Starting point is 00:48:19 Here are the directions. Here is the directions. Here is the. lockbox code. Do not feed the wildlife. That was basically it. The only thing that felt slightly off was that the address was vague. The listing gave the nearest town and the county. Then it just said Detroit Lake area. I told myself that was common for rural places. Some of those cabins do not even have real addresses. Some of them are on forest service roads that do not show up on Google Maps. I have been to places in Oregon where your phone just gives up and says no results found. I packed on Thursday night. Two changes of clothes, boots, a rain jacket, a bag of groceries, and my laptop, even though I had promised myself I was not going to open it.
Starting point is 00:49:03 I put a paperback on top of everything. I told myself I was going to read it. I knew I was not going to read it. Friday morning I left Portland after the sun came up, which in November means around 7.30. I took Interstate 5 south and then cut east toward the mountains. The sky was low and gray the whole way. Rain came in thin sheets across the windshield. The farther east I got, the fewer cars I saw.
Starting point is 00:49:28 The trees got taller and thicker and the road got narrower, and everything looked wet and dark and rinsed. In Detroit, I stopped for gas and coffee. The gas station was the kind that also sells fishing bait and bags of wood pellets, and has a handwritten sign about firewood prices. There was a man behind me in line, older, ball cap. carhart jacket. He glanced at my phone screen when I pulled up the directions, and he said, You headed up the lake? Yes, I said. He nodded once. You staying at one of the rentals? Yes.
Starting point is 00:50:04 He looked at my car through the window, then back at my face. You by yourself? Yes, I said. And this time I wished I had said no. I wished I had said my boyfriend was meeting me there, or my sister was coming up later or anything. But I said yes, because that is what was true, and I did not think fast enough. He hesitated, then he smiled, but it was not a warm smile. It was the kind of smile people give when they are deciding whether to say something they know will sound strange. Watch for downed branches, he said. Roads get slick up there, folks get stuck. Thanks, I said. I walked out with my coffee and sat in my car for a minute. I put my hands on the steering wheel and I just sat there. That conversation was nothing. People talk. People warn each other. That is normal in small towns. But something about the
Starting point is 00:50:57 way he looked at me, the pause before the smile, the way he said folks get stuck. It sat wrong in my chest. I felt noticed. I did not want to be noticed. From Detroit, I followed the directions Kevin had sent me in the app. They were specific in a way that actually made me feel better at it. I was at first. Some things work better together. Like Nars's soft mat, complete concealer and radiant creamy concealer. Soft matte complete concealer erases
Starting point is 00:51:24 and blurs imperfections with full coverage. Then, radiant creamy concealer evens and brightens with a luxurious texture and radiant finish. Two concealers. One, flawless look. Perfect for a no foundation base. NARS, better together. Visit
Starting point is 00:51:40 Sephora to shop now. This spring, Uber Eats, has covered, whether you're celebrating mom, dad, or your favorite grad. Not all of us are great planners, and with the Uber Eats gift tub, you don't have to be. Send flowers, perfume, champagne, or just their favorite meal straight to their door. Gifts arrive in as little as 25 minutes, and you can add a personalized video message for that additional so-not-last-minute touch. So this spring, get a leg up on gift-giving with Uber Eats. Last-minute gifts that land every time. Must be 21 or older to purchase alcohol. Product availability varies per regency app for details.
Starting point is 00:52:14 Turn at the bridge. Follow the paved road until it narrows. Stay left at the fork with the green gate. Pass a sign that says no shooting. Keep going until the gravel turns to broken asphalt. After the second cattle grate, look for a mail post with a metal pine cone on top. The driveway is right there. It took about 40 minutes of steady climbing. The road got narrower.
Starting point is 00:52:41 The trees got thicker. My phone signal dropped from, one bar to nothing. My music cut out in the middle of a song and I just let it stay silent because the quiet felt appropriate. The rain got heavier. It was loud on the roof of my car. I could feel the road getting softer under my tires. I kept driving because I did not have another plan. I had driven two and a half hours to get here and I was not about to turn around because my phone lost signal. The last stretch was a logging road, full of ruts and puddles. I passed the no-shooting sign. I crossed one cattle grate, then a second one.
Starting point is 00:53:18 Twice I had to slow way down for fallen branches across the road. Once I had to stop completely, get out, and drag a thick limb off the path with both hands. The rain soaked through my sleeves in about ten seconds. My boots sank into the mud, and when I got back in the car, I was wet from the elbows down and breathing hard, and I had the first clear thought that I had come too far without seeing another vehicle. Not a truck, not an ATV. Nothing. Just me and the road and the trees and the rain. Then I saw the mail post with the metal pine cone. Right where Kevin said it would be. I turned into the driveway. The cabin came into view slowly through the trees.
Starting point is 00:54:00 Dark brown built low to the ground. There was a porch with two chairs and a small table, a stack of split firewood under a blue tarp. One window facing the driveway and another on the side. No lights on. No other built. any where near it. The woods came right up to the back of the cabin, close enough that branches were touching the roof. I parked and turned off the engine and sat there. No birds, no wind, just rain, steady and dull and constant. My car engine ticking as it cooled down. I told myself to stop being weird about it. I grabbed my bag, walked to the front door, and found the lockbox hanging next to the doorframe. The code Kevin sent me opened it. Inside was a brass key. That should have been the end of whatever I was feeling.
Starting point is 00:54:48 A normal rental, a normal key. Everything matched. I unlocked the door and went in. The smell is what I noticed first. Not rot, not mold. It was wood smoke, old pine, and something faintly sour underneath that I could not identify. The cabin was colder than I expected. The air felt stale and closed.
Starting point is 00:55:10 The way a room gets when nobody has opened a window in weeks. A small living room opened in front of me. Couch, armchair, coffee table, rug, stone fireplace. A narrow kitchen to the left. A hallway to the right leading to the back of the cabin. There was a lamp on an end table by the couch. I reached over and flipped the switch. Nothing happened.
Starting point is 00:55:34 I tried the overhead light in the kitchen. Nothing. Power outage, I thought. Common out here after storms. Then I saw the thermostat on the wall. It was old, with a small digital display. It was on. The display was glowing.
Starting point is 00:55:50 So there was power. I went back and tried the kitchen light again. Nothing. I opened the fridge, dark inside, not running. I found the breaker box next to the fridge. It was labeled in neat handwriting. All the switches were in the on position, every single one. I stood there for a minute just looking at it.
Starting point is 00:56:10 The thermostat had power, but nothing else did. That did not make sense to me, and I do not know enough about electrical systems to explain it. I told myself there was probably a generator backup for the heating system or a battery or something. I told myself I was not an electrician and I should just deal with it. I set my bag down in the living room and walked farther into the cabin. On the wall near the entrance to the hallway, there was a framed map. It showed the Detroit Lake area with trails and forest roads and points marked in red ink. I leaned in and read the names, Brightonbush, Blowout Road, North Sandiam, Opel Creek Wilderness.
Starting point is 00:56:51 Someone had drawn a circle around a section of land near where the cabin would be, and then crossed through it with two lines. Not an X exactly, more of a cross. It looked personal, not decorative, not something a rental host would frame for ambiance. Below the map was a small wooden shelf with a guest book and a pen. The guest book was thick, the pages slightly yellowed at the edges. It was open to a blank page, waiting. I picked it up and started flipping backward through the entries. Most of them were normal. Names, dates, comments about the
Starting point is 00:57:25 view or the fireplace, or how quiet it was. A few people joked about seeing deer in the yard. One person complained about mice in the walls. Another thanked Kevin for being a responsive host, normal stuff. The kind of thing you write in a guest book because you feel like you were supposed to. Then I found an entry that made my stomach drop. It was dated Saturday October 20th, 2025. The handwriting was messy and pressed hard into the page. You could feel the grooves of the pen on the other side. It said, if you hear knocking after dark, do not answer, do not open the door, do not look out the windows, keep the lights off, stay away from the back room. We made that mistake. We are leaving at first light. There was no signature. I read it twice.
Starting point is 00:58:17 My eyes went over every word again, and I stood there in the dim cabin holding the guest book, and I could feel my heartbeat in my fingertips. It was too specific to be a joke, not in a guest book, not written with that kind of pressure on the pen. People do not press that hard when they are being funny. I turned the page. The next entry, dated the very next day, was totally normal. A couple named Josh and Amber wrote about enjoying the rain and making chili for dinner. They signed their names and drew a little heart. Regular people having a regular weekend. I kept flipping, looking for anything else. A few pages later, I found another one. Friday, November 1st, 2025. Two weeks before my visit, something is wrong with this place.
Starting point is 00:59:02 Kevin will not answer the phone. There is someone outside. If you read this, do not stay, leave. No signature. The entry after that one was a cheerful note about hiking near the lake. My fingers were cold. My hands were cold. I set the guest book down on the shelf and told myself all the things you are supposed to tell yourself. People get scared in the woods. People hear things and their imagination fills in the rest.
Starting point is 00:59:29 Maybe someone heard a branch fall on the roof and panicked. Maybe some teenagers used the cabin and thought it would be funny to write something creepy in the guest book. Teenagers do stuff exactly. that stupid. But the words there is someone outside did not read like a joke. They read like someone writing fast because they were scared, and they wanted whoever came next to know. I looked around the living room again. The curtains were thick and dark. The windows were small. The fireplace was big, big enough to heat the whole room. The hallway was dark, and I could not see the end of it from where I stood. I walked down the hallway. There were two doors on the right side and one on the left. First door on the
Starting point is 01:00:08 right was the bathroom. Small, clean enough. Towels folded on a rack. A bar of soap on the sink. A shower with a plastic curtain. Nothing weird. Second door on the right was the bedroom. A queen bed with the covers pulled tight. A dresser against the wall. A small window with the curtains pulled closed. The door on the left was shut. I reached for the knob and turned it. Locked. I tried again, harder. Twisting and pushing. Locked solid. Rentals have locked closets. Owners keep their stuff in there. Tools, extra bedding, personal items. This was normal. I told myself this was normal. I went back out to the living room and found a binder on the coffee table. House rules. Checkout instructions. Emergency contacts. I flipped through it. Most of it was standard.
Starting point is 01:01:01 No smoking. No food left out. Take your trash with you when you leave. The emergency contacts listed Marion County Dispatch and Detroit Ranger Station with phone numbers. At the very end, there was a printed note with no name on it. Cell service is unreliable in this area. There is a landline on the kitchen wall for emergencies only. I looked over at the kitchen wall. There was a phone mounted there. Beige, old, the kind with a cord that curls.
Starting point is 01:01:31 I had not noticed it when I walked in. I picked up the receiver and held it to my ear. ear. No dial tone. Nothing. Dead. I put it back on the cradle. Then a sound made me jump so hard I bit the inside of my cheek. A knock. Not on the front door, on wood, close, inside the cabin. I froze where I was standing. My breath caught in my throat and my heart started pounding and I could feel the blood in my ears. It came again. Knock, knock, knock from the hallway, from the locked door. Then again, faster, three in a row. Knock, knock, knock. My skin went tight all over. I took one step toward the hallway, and then I stopped because I did not want to be closer to that door. Every part of me did not want to
Starting point is 01:02:15 be closer to that door. I backed up until my legs hit the couch. The knocking stopped. For a long moment there was just rain. I made myself move. I walked to the front door, checked the lock, and pulled the deadbolt. My hands were shaking, and I missed the bolt the first time and had to try again. I picked up my phone, no signal. I turned airplane mode on and off, still nothing. I opened my messages and watched them not load. No help there. I went to the window by the front door, and I was about to pull the curtain back,
Starting point is 01:02:47 just a quick look, just to see if anything was outside. The guest book words hit me. Do not look out the windows. I let go of the curtain. I stood in the middle of the living room with my jacket still on and my boots still on, and I did not know what I was doing. My brain was going in circles. Someone could be in the locked room.
Starting point is 01:03:08 Someone could be under the cabin. Someone could be messing with me on purpose. Or it could be the pipes. It could be the house settling in the cold. It could be a raccoon or a squirrel or something in the walls. But it sounded like knuckles. It sounded like a person knocking on a door and waiting for someone to answer. I walked to the fireplace because I needed to do something with my hands.
Starting point is 01:03:31 I pulled the screen aside. The firebox was clean. There were logs stacked next to it in a box of matches on the mantel. I lit a fire, not because I was cold, because fire meant light, and light meant I could see, and the cabin's power situation was not something I could count on. The flame caught fast, and the smell of smoke rose, and the crackling filled the room, and it was the first sound in that cabin that felt normal. I forced myself to unpack, groceries in the fridge even though the fridge was not running, bag in the bedroom, boots by the front door.
Starting point is 01:04:09 I tried to keep my breathing even. When I walked back into the living room, I noticed something I had missed before. A small circular stain on the rug near the couch, darker than the rest of the fabric. Whatever had spilled there had soaked in and never fully come out. I crouched down and touched it. The fibers were stiff. I brought my fingers to my nose, that faint sour smell from when I first walked in. My stomach turned over and I stood up too fast and the room tilted for a second.
Starting point is 01:04:37 I told myself to stop. I told myself to eat something and calm down and stop looking for things to be afraid of. I made a sandwich. I ate it standing in the kitchen because sitting down at the table felt wrong and I could not explain why. I just wanted to be on my feet. I kept looking toward the hallway. Nothing happened for a while. The rain kept going.
Starting point is 01:05:02 The fire burned low and steady. The cabin stayed dim, except for the orange glow from the fireplace. It was the only real light in the whole place. Around 4 or 4.30 in the afternoon, the sky outside got darker. November in Oregon. The sun drops early and the woods outside the windows turned into a solid dark wall. The rain sounded heavier. or maybe it sounded the same and I was just more aware of it.
Starting point is 01:05:29 I tried the lights one more time. Nothing. I tried the faucet. Water came out, cold and clear. That worked. I went to the bathroom and flushed the toilet, just checking. It worked. Then standing at the bathroom sink washing my hands, I heard something new, a soft dragging sound, not a footstep,
Starting point is 01:05:49 something sliding, something heavy being pulled across a surface. From above me, I looked up at the sea. The cabin had a low attic space probably. Old cabins out here usually do. Squirrels get in there. Raccoons get in there. That was the obvious explanation. The dragging sound stopped, and then something tapped once directly above my head. One single tap. It was precise and it was exactly where I was standing. My throat tightened. I turned off the bathroom light switch, even though it was not doing anything, and I stepped back into the hallway. Silence. I went into the bedroom, closed the door behind me, and sat on the edge of the bed. I put my hands on my knees and tried to breathe through my nose. I tried to think clearly.
Starting point is 01:06:37 I told myself, you drove into the woods alone, you are exhausted, you read two scary notes in a guest book, and now your brain is looking for threats everywhere, because that is what brains do when they are primed for danger. You are scaring yourself. Then I heard knocking again, not from the locked room from the front door. Three knocks, evenly spaced, patient. I did not move. A few seconds passed, three more knocks, harder this time. I stood up slowly. My legs were stiff and my knees ached from sitting so tense. I took a step toward the bedroom window and then stopped myself. Do not look out the windows. The knocking came again, and then a voice, a man's voice, calm, clear, right outside the front door. Sarah. He said my name the way you would call someone in from the backyard.
Starting point is 01:07:24 casual, easy, no urgency. Sarah, he said again. My whole body went cold. Nobody had used my name on that road. I had not told the man at the gas station my name. Kevin knew it from the booking, sure. But why would Kevin be standing outside in the rain knocking when he had given me the lockbox code and the key?
Starting point is 01:07:45 That did not make any sense. Sarah, the voice said, right up against the door now. Open up. I backed away from the bedroom door without meaning to. and bumped into the dresser. My hip hit the corner and pain shot through me, but I did not make a sound. My mind ran through every bad thing this could be. I grabbed my phone and held it up.
Starting point is 01:08:05 No signal. The screen just stared back at me, useless. The knocking became pounding, hard. The door rattled in its frame. Then the voice changed. A different voice, higher pitched, strained. A woman's voice, young, and she sounded terrified. Please.
Starting point is 01:08:24 Please open the door. I stood absolutely still, one hand gripping the phone, the other hand and a fist at my side. My brain said, this is a trap. Another part of my brain said, but what if someone is actually hurt? What if a woman is out there in the rain and she needs help and you are in here doing nothing? I could not see anything. I could not check. I could not verify a single thing.
Starting point is 01:08:50 The guest book came back to me, sharp and clear. Do not answer. Do not open the door. door. The pounding stopped. Rain. That was all. Then something scraped across the porch boards, slow, heavy, not footsteps, something being dragged, the sound of weight moving across wood. I pressed my back flat against the bedroom wall. The scraping stopped. And then very softly from just outside the front door, the man's voice said, I can hear you breathing. I clapped my hand over my mouth. My eyes burned and tears came fast and I just stood there trying to make my lung stop
Starting point is 01:09:24 because he said he could hear me and I believed him. A laugh came through the door, short, low, not loud, not a crazy laugh, just a small sound of amusement, the sound of someone who was not in a hurry. Then footsteps, off the porch, down the steps, into the wet gravel, moving away. I stood there for a long time after that. I do not know how long. I was waiting for the next sound, and the next sound did not come, and the waiting was almost worse. I crept out of the bedroom, moving slow, keeping away from the front windows. I went to the entry in the dim orange light from the fireplace and pressed my ear close to the door. Rain. That was it. I did not know what to do. I did not want to stay in the cabin. I did not want to go outside. Those were my only
Starting point is 01:10:13 two options and I hated both of them. I looked at the binder again. I looked at the wall phone. I picked up the receiver, no dial tone. I held it to my ear anyway and listened, willing the deadline to wake up. Nothing. I put it back on the cradle. The phone rang. It was a loud, harsh, old-fashioned ring, the kind that vibrates through the whole phone, and I flinched so hard I stumbled backward and almost fell. My elbow caught the counter in pain went up my arm. It rang again. I stood there staring at it. The phone that had no dial tone was ringing. It rang a third time. I picked it up. Hello? My voice sounded thin and wrong. Static. Just static for a second.
Starting point is 01:10:56 Then a man's voice, calm, close, clear. He sounded like he was in the room with me. Sarah, he said. I gripped the phone harder. Who is this? You should not have come, he said. I looked around the cabin, the hallway, the locked door, the ceiling. My body wanted to run, but inside a cabin there is nowhere to run to.
Starting point is 01:11:17 Where are you? I asked. A pause. In the back room, he said. My throat closed up. I stared at the locked door. door at the end of the hallway. My hand was shaking so badly I had to press the receiver hard against my ear to keep it there. There is no back room, I said, and my voice cracked on the last word. There is, he said. You just do not have the key. Another pause. Then quietly, he said.
Starting point is 01:11:43 Do you remember the spot near Opel Creek where the water turns black? My stomach fell. I felt it drop inside me. I had been there. Once, years ago, with my My dad, not on a group trip, not as a tourist. My dad was the kind of person who went places where there were fewer people, not more. We had driven out near Jawbone Flats when I was maybe 12 or 13 and walked along the creek. I remembered the cold. I remembered the moss covering everything. I remembered my dad telling me to watch where I stepped because the rocks were slick with it.
Starting point is 01:12:19 I remembered standing near a pool of water that was darker than the rest of the creek, noticeably darker. And my dad saying, Do not drink from that one, not there. He did not explain why, and I did not ask. That was not a memory I had ever told anyone. I had not written about it anywhere. It was not on the internet.
Starting point is 01:12:39 It was just a thing that happened between me and my dad on a random day in the woods when I was a kid. Who are you? I whispered. The static hissed. Then he said, Your father used to call you Saray. I grabbed the edge of the kitchen counter because my legs were going weak.
Starting point is 01:12:54 My dad called me that, not all the time, mostly when he was in a good mood, when he was making breakfast on a Saturday morning or showing me how to tie a knot or telling a joke in the car. Sarr, short and easy. Nobody else ever called me that. My dad had been gone for eight years, not dead, not officially, just gone. He disappeared when I was 19. He went out one morning to do what he always did, which was drive into the woods, and check on some spot he liked, or just be out there by himself for a while.
Starting point is 01:13:26 He told my mom he would be back by dinner. You said this place was steps from the water. We just haven't found the steps yet. How much did we save? Enough. Enough to get lost. Or you could book a stay with Hilton. Welcome to your ocean front room.
Starting point is 01:13:44 Just steps from the water. The Hilton sale is on now. Book on Hilton.com or the Hilton app and save up to 20% to get the stay you expected. When you want savings, not surprises. It matters where you stay. Hilton, for this day. This episode is brought to you by Netflix's remarkably bright creatures. What if a Pacific octopus held the key to a mystery that could heal your heart? Well, that's Tova's reality. An elderly widow working at an aquarium. Tova forms an unlikely friendship with the crumudgeonly Marcellus, whose remarkable intelligence leads her to a life-changing discovery. Watch remarkably bright creatures
Starting point is 01:14:20 with your remarkable mom's this Mother's Day weekend. Only on Netflix May 8th. He did not come back by dinner. He did not come back that night. His truck was found two days later off a forest road east of Eugene. The driver's door was open. His keys were on the seat. There were no footprints in the mud around the truck that made any sense.
Starting point is 01:14:44 The ground was churned up and smeared, and the search team said it looked like something had gone wrong, but they could not tell what. Search and rescue looked at. for him. Dogs, volunteers, a helicopter. They searched the woods for six days. They found nothing. Not a jacket, not a boot, not anything. After a while, people stopped saying when he comes back and started saying if. And then after more time they stopped saying if, and just looked at me with that face people make when they are sorry, but also tired of being sorry. I swallowed hard. My throat
Starting point is 01:15:22 hurt. My father is dead, I said, because that was what I had decided I needed to believe in order to get through my days. The man on the phone said, he is not. My vision blurred. The kitchen went soft around the edges. Stop, I said. Stop doing this to me. A sound came through the line, not a laugh, something tired, something worn out. Listen, he said, do not open the front door again, do not go to the windows. Stay away from the hallway. Put more wood on the fire. Keep it going. They do not come near light. Who is they? I asked. No answer. Just static. Then he said, If you try to leave, they will follow you. If you stay, they will come anyway. You have one chance and it is before midnight. I stood there holding the phone and my brain was falling behind.
Starting point is 01:16:12 I could not keep up with what was happening. Why me? I whispered. You have your father's face, he said. and his voice changed when he said it. Something raw, something I could hear break. They have been waiting, he said. The line went dead. I held the receiver to my ear and listened to silence. Then from the hallway, the locked door clicked.
Starting point is 01:16:35 Not a knock, not a tap, a click. The sound a lock makes when it turns. I lowered the phone slowly. The cabin felt colder. The fire cracked behind me and the sound was small and it seemed fragile now. I took a step back, then it was a step back. another, keeping my eyes on the hallway. The knob on the locked door turned. Very slowly. I could see it in the dim light from the fireplace. It turned to the right, then stopped, then turned back. I did not
Starting point is 01:17:02 see a hand. The door did not open. The knob just moved on its own. Then from inside that room, I heard breathing. I know how that sounds. I know people will read this and think I was imagining things, but I am telling you what I heard. It was steady, rhythmic breathing. Inhale, exhale, inhale, exhale. A person's breathing, not the creek of wood, not an animal rustling, a person behind a closed door, trying to be quiet, not quite managing it. I backed into the kitchen and grabbed the biggest knife from the block on the counter. I held it out in front of me with both hands. My fingers were slick. I was aware of how I looked. A woman alone in a dark cabin holding a kitchen knife. No phone. No car that I trusted to start. No plan. The breathing continued.
Starting point is 01:17:55 Then the voice from the front door came again. The man's voice. But it was not outside anymore. It was in the hallway. Sarah, it said. My heart hit my ribs so hard I thought I might pass out. The hallway was dark, but the fireplace light reached part of it. The locked door was still shut or close to shut. I could not tell if it had moved. Sarah, the voice said again. Softer now, coaxing, patient. I did not answer. I stepped backward until I felt the edge of the couch behind my legs. Then from the ceiling above the living room, the dragging sound came back. Slow, heavy, directly over my head, something moving across the attic floor. And then behind me, in the kitchen, the microwave beeped. I spun around. The microwave display was on, glowing green,
Starting point is 01:18:45 showing a time. I am not going to write the numbers down because I have a rule now about not putting certain details from that night into writing, and because seeing that time still makes me feel sick. What matters is that the time it showed was correct. It was the exact time it should have been based on the clock in my car from when I parked. The microwave should not have known. The power had not been working. Nothing in that kitchen had been on. The microwave beeped again. Then the stove light started flickering.
Starting point is 01:19:19 On and off. On and off. Fast, not random. Rhythmic. On off, on off, on off. The cabinet doors rattled once, all of them, at the same time, and then stopped. I stood there with the knife raised over my head, and I was breathing so hard I could hear myself.
Starting point is 01:19:37 and I was trying not to scream because I was afraid that if I started screaming, I would not stop. The hallway voice said, Come here. I moved toward the front door, not to open it, just to get away from the hallway and the kitchen and whatever was above me. My brain wanted distance from all of it. I kept the knife up. My foot hit something on the floor. I looked down. A key. Brass. Old. Slightly green at the edges. It was lying on the rug near the shelf with the guest book. It had not been there before. I would have seen it.
Starting point is 01:20:11 I would have stepped on it earlier. Someone had placed it there. I stared at it. The man on the phone had said, You do not have the key. Now I did. The hallway voice said, take it. I did not pick it up.
Starting point is 01:20:24 I backed away from it because the idea of that key being offered to me felt worse than the locked door itself. It felt like someone wanted me to make a choice, and the choice was wrong, matter what. I was being steered toward something, and I could feel it, and I did not want to go. The sound above me shifted, moving toward the center of the living room. The front door handle jiggled, outside and inside, both at the same time. The cabin surrounded. I was in a box and something wanted me to pick which wall to walk into. I made myself focus on the
Starting point is 01:20:58 simplest thing I could think of. Get out of the cabin. I remembered there was a back door in the kitchen. I had seen it when I first walked through. A plain door with a small window set into it. I did not want to go back into the kitchen, but the front porch had someone on it. The back door was the only other exit. I took a breath and walked into the kitchen, knife first. The stove light was off now. The microwave was dark. The air was heavier in there, damp and thick with that sour smell. I got to the back door. I did not pull the curtain a side. I did not pull the curtain a to look through the window. I just reached for the deadbolt. The landline rang. I flinched so hard my elbow cracked against the counter again, same spot, and the pain was sharp and immediate.
Starting point is 01:21:45 The phone kept ringing. I stared at it. I was shaking all over. Not just my hands, my shoulders, my jaw. It rang a second time, a third. I did not answer it. On the fourth ring, the receiver lifted off the cradle by itself. I watched it happen. I was standing four feet. away and I watched the receiver rise up, the curly cord stretching, as if someone I could not see picked it up. Static poured out of the phone, loud, filling the kitchen. Then the man's voice came through louder than before, and he sounded scared now, not calm anymore, urgent. Sarah, do not go out the back. My throat tightened. Who are you? I said, and I hated how small my voice sounded. A pause. If you hear my name you will know, he said.
Starting point is 01:22:33 I do not want riddles, I said, and I was angry suddenly because fear can turn into anger when you have been scared long enough. I just want to leave. You can, he said. But not that way. The hallway voice called out again. Closer now. Sarah. I looked toward the hallway entrance from the kitchen.
Starting point is 01:22:52 The darkness there was wrong. It was too dark. The fireplace was still going, but the light was not reaching the hallway at all. Tell me your name, I said into the phone. Static. Then softly, Mike. Everything in my body stopped. That was my father's name, Michael David Mitchell.
Starting point is 01:23:10 Everyone called him Mike. My mom called him Mike. His friends called him Mike. I called him Dad, but I knew his name was Mike because it was on all the forms, and all the documents, and all the missing person reports. I could not breathe for a second. The knife in my hand felt too heavy to hold. No, I whispered.
Starting point is 01:23:29 Sorry, the voice said, and it was not warm and it was not playful. It was broken. It sounded like someone forcing words out through pain. Listen to me. They used my voice on you before. They do it to bring you close. Do not follow it. Do not open that room. Do not take the key. The hallway voice said, take the key. The dragging sound from above moved again, toward the kitchen. I held the receiver tighter. Dad? A long pause. Then very quietly, I am sorry. The line changed. Not dead, but different. A new sound came through, a faint thump, then another. Then I heard my father's voice, but he was not talking to me. He was talking to someone else.
Starting point is 01:24:12 Low, pleading. Not her, he said. Please, not her. My legs gave out and I grabbed the counter and held on. A different voice cut in, harsh, unfamiliar. It is time. The receiver slammed itself back onto the cradle. The phone rang one. more time, then went completely silent. I stood in the kitchen shaking from head to toe, knife still in my hand, staring at the phone on the wall. Behind me, in the hallway, the locked door opened. The sound was small, a soft creak, then a pause, then slow footsteps, one at a time, coming out of the room and into the hallway. I did not turn around. I could not make myself turn around. My muscles locked and my brain was screaming at me to run, but I could not decide
Starting point is 01:25:01 where to go, and so I just stood there. A smell drifted into the kitchen. Wood smoke and wet earth and that sour note, stronger now. Close, right behind me. A hand touched the back of my neck, not hard, not grabbing, just fingers resting on my skin, cold. I did not scream because my lungs would not fill with air. A woman's voice whispered in my ear, so close I could feel her breath on my skin. Sarah. We already have you. She sounded calm.
Starting point is 01:25:32 She sounded bored. My body moved before my brain decided anything. I swung around with the knife, hard, fast, swinging at whatever was behind me. There was nobody there. The kitchen was empty. I spun toward the hallway. Empty. But the locked door was open now, just a crack.
Starting point is 01:25:51 I could see the gap, darkness on the other side. The key was still on the rug. in the living room. I could see it from the kitchen doorway, catching the firelight. From the ceiling above the kitchen, something thudded once, hard, the sound of weight hitting the floor in the attic space. Then I heard a new sound, scratching, not from above, from below, under my feet, under the kitchen floor, something was moving under the cabin. I could hear nails or metal scraping along the underside of the floorboards, and it moved in a line, tracking, following my position. The scratching stopped directly under where I was standing, then a soft tap, tap, tap, tap,
Starting point is 01:26:32 against the bottom of the floor, testing, feeling for me. I ran. I ran through the living room, past the guest book, past the key on the rug, past the couch, straight for the front door. I did not care about the pounding from earlier. I did not care about the man's voice. I needed to be outside. I needed space. I needed to not be inside this cabin anymore. The second I touched the deadbolt, the front door handle turned from the other side. Someone was right there. Someone pushed against the door. I shoved back. I put my whole body against it. The door shook in the frame, and I could feel the force on the other side, steady and strong. A voice outside, the man from earlier, Open up. I screamed. I screamed so loud my throat tore. Not words. Just sound. I stumbled back from the door and looked for another way out. The back door. My father had said do not go out the back, but the front door had someone on the other side who was stronger than me. I ran into the kitchen. Heart going so fast my vision was pulsing at the edges. I grabbed my car keys from the counter where I had left them. I do not know why. Instinct.
Starting point is 01:27:45 I threw the backdoor deadbolt, yanked the door open, and ran outside. Cold air hit my face, the smell of wet leaves and fur needles and mud. The darkness was total except for the faintest gray in the sky. The porch light above the back door flickered once and went out. I ran off the back steps and into the yard. My boots slipped in the mud. Rain soaked my hair and my clothes in seconds. I ran toward the front of the cabin where my car was parked in the driveway.
Starting point is 01:28:14 If I could get inside the car and lock the doors, I would have a barrier. I would have a place to think. When I came around the side of the cabin, I could see the front porch. Someone was standing on it. A man, tall, wearing a hooded raincoat. He was facing the front door, standing still, not moving. When I appeared at the corner of the cabin, he turned his head toward me. I could not see his face.
Starting point is 01:28:39 Just the dark shape of the hood in his shoulders and his hands at his sides. He took a breath, steady, calm, and he said, There you are. I ran. I sprinted for my car. Through puddles, mud splashing up my legs, lungs burning. I reached the driver's door, yanked it open, fell into the seat, slammed the door, and locked it. My hands were shaking so badly I could barely get the key into the ignition. I turned it.
Starting point is 01:29:06 The engine did not start. The dashlights flickered once, weak, and died. Dead battery. and I turned it again. Nothing. Not even a click. I sat there in the dark inside my car with rain hammering the windshield and my breath fogging the glass and I thought, This is it.
Starting point is 01:29:25 This is where it happens. I looked up through the windshield. The man in the hooded raincoat was walking toward my car. Slow. No hurry. He walked the way someone walks when they know exactly where you are and exactly what you can and cannot do. Behind him, at the edge of the edge of the edge of the edge of the edge of the edge of you. of the woods, something stood still, a shape, pale, too tall, too thin. It was not standing the way a person
Starting point is 01:29:53 stands, it was not right. The shape of it was wrong, and I could not make my eyes understand what I was looking at. It did not have the proportions of a human body. It was there, and it was still, and it was watching. Another shape appeared next to it. Same wrongness, same stillness. I found Fumbled with my phone. Still no signal. I pressed the emergency call button. Call failed. Call failed. The man reached my driver's side window. He leaned down. Close enough that I could see the outline of his nose under the hood. Close enough that I could see the shape of his jaw. He smiled. I saw his teeth. He tapped my window with one knuckle. Gentle. Tap, tap, tap, tap. Come back inside, he said. I shook my head. I shook my head. I was crying. Tears and rain on my face and my hands locked around the steering wheel so hard my
Starting point is 01:30:48 knuckles hurt. He tapped again. You do not want to be out here with them. I swallowed. My throat was raw from screaming. Who are you? He laughed. Short. You already know. He lifted his hand and pointed, not at me, over my shoulder, toward the cabin. I turned my head. In the living room window, behind the curtain, a face was pressed against the fabric, a pale oval shape. A pale oval pushing the curtain outward. I could see where the eyes were. I could see the fabric stretch. Then the curtain moved, breathing. The back door of the cabin, the one I had run through, swung slowly closed, by itself. The porch steps creaked. Something was coming down them. I looked back at the man. His smile got wider. They do not want you to leave.
Starting point is 01:31:35 How many discounts does USA auto insurance offer? Too many to say here. Multi-vehicle discount. Safe driver discount, new vehicle discount, storage discount, legacy. How many discounts will you stack up? Tap the banner or visit usaa.com slash auto discounts. Restrictions apply.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.