Last Podcast On The Left - Some Place Under Neith / Episode 1: Shelly Miscavige Part I - The Commodore's Messengers
Episode Date: March 17, 2021Some Place Under Neith is a deep dive exploration into cases of missing women. Producer and stunt woman Natalie Jean and comedian Amber Nelson laugh maniacally as they burrow into these fascinating st...ories and find out how we all can help.Brought to you by The Last Podcast Network.Art by @chaos_magic
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Some place underneath.
Hey Amber.
Hello Natalie.
Does anybody ever call you Ambular?
No, but they call me Smelson.
Smelson? But you smell lovely.
Is it because you smell good?
Because my name is Amber Sophia Nelson,
and Amber Sophia Nelson sounds like
a little pageant girl that went missing.
You are not. You are from the south,
so I could see you being a pageant girl,
but you did not go missing fortunately for us.
You weren't a pageant girl, were you?
I did one pageant,
and I was very bad at it.
I did it to please my mother,
because she's the queen of beauty pageants,
and a lot of women in my family are just
incredibly beautiful and poised, and I was not.
I was very spooky,
and I had sticks in my hair,
so I did it.
But you're still beautiful and poised.
Thank you. It took many years of training
and trying.
I wish you still had sticks in your hair.
I say put them back in.
Thank you for coming along on this journey.
Welcome to some place underneath
Episode 1.
You're really helping me out here.
I'm a little fascinated by
dark stories and mysteries,
particularly when
a woman is involved,
and I've been reading
so much about it that I needed to talk
about it, because I feel like justice
is not being served very often.
No, it's not.
I try to help and also
just talk about these stories
because I don't feel like they're being told,
which is what the meaning of the title is.
People go missing all the time,
and it's a shame when they're just like,
oh, they went missing, but if you went missing,
wouldn't you want someone talking about you,
looking for you? I would.
And it's hard, especially when it's adults,
because there's all these sort of
things that come into play with that where
maybe they don't
want to be found, or maybe
it's their prerogative to go missing.
They want to hide. Right.
In that case, hopefully I'm not talking about somebody
who's trying to hide from somebody.
We've found you. No, I was hiding from the government.
No.
No, I won't say, mostly we'll be talking about that.
The reason I'm starting with this episode,
it's one of the most
onerous, maddening,
prolific cases,
and that's of Shelly Miskovich.
It's great, a lot of people know about it,
and they're like, oh, wow, she went missing,
but yeah, it's one of those cases
that really, I think, embodies
what I want to do with this show,
which is to talk about a story
where we've all just nodded in agreement
that this woman is just kind of missing,
and then we move on with our day,
which there's a lot of challenges to this,
and I know, and also talking about her
is also going to address
other things that are problematic
in Scientology beyond the obvious things,
that being
that there are technically other missing
people in Scientology.
Her name is the most famous because she
is at the top of the
pyramid, but there are people
who haven't been seen
by anyone but Scientologists in decades.
Yeah, they're family, they have to cut off their family,
and that's when you know you're in a cult,
when they're like, be with us, don't, anybody
who says you can't be with us, just cut them
out of your life. Yeah, there's a lot
of warning signs, but it's really interesting
that I've never been in a cult, but I was,
you know, in destructive relationship,
shall we say, and it's
sometimes so hard to see it until you're
right outside of it, and you're like,
what the fuck was that? Oh, yeah,
yeah, oh, he was punching the wall? Yeah.
He was punching the wall, and I was blaming myself for that?
And I was like, well, if I just don't do that,
he won't punch the wall anymore. It's my fault,
it's my fault. Yeah, so
sometimes it's really hard when you're in there, and I get it.
So it's really, it's not a, you know, pointing
finger situation, except at
David Miscovich, I will point
all of my fingers at him, especially
my middle one. And my toes.
I'll point my toes at him. I'll point my toes right at him.
But, you know, this is
a fascinating cult.
I'm just going to call it a cult because it is,
and it's a high-control subculture,
basically. So it's very
uncomfortably easy to erase
a person from existence within
side of one of those units.
And they own a lot of things, Scientology. Do you know
they own the Arclight Theater? Yes.
That's my favorite theater. Yeah, they own
a lot. They don't have that many people
anymore, but they have a ton of money.
They're real estate, which is the money baby.
Yeah, that's where you got to take
it from Scientology. You got to invest in some
real estate if you get some cash, you know.
Oh, man. They just have huge, like
buildings of people. And I was talking
to my friend and she says that her
like a friend of a friend went into the Scientology.
She hasn't seen them in forever because
during COVID, they all got locked
down and like, they can't leave.
They're in masks all the time.
And I'm a very social person and like talking
to people, you know, and then this van
pulls up and all these people come out and they're getting
all these to-go orders for their friends.
And I'm like, hey, was that sandwich place
good? What's going on? Is that sandwich good?
And they refuse to speak to me and she's like,
they're the Scientology people.
I actually, because we have a newer
Scientology building
near where we live in Los Angeles.
And for the first time in three
years, I saw people going into it
the other day, which made me sad
because usually it's completely empty.
They have tons of empty buildings
around the country. So weird. No one goes
in or out. No. It's
their shells to keep their
tax-free status, which is a big
problem. I also
myself went
and visited Goldbase from the
outside because I was really curious about it.
And I'll talk about that later on in the
series that we're doing.
That is really one of the things that I'm going to talk
about a lot on the show, which is
within the freedoms of our country
we have also
given people free reign to basically
abuse the idea
of spirituality and religion.
And Scientology is right at the top of
that where they
in order to get tax-exempt status, they became
a church. They called themselves a church
and started adding crosses into their imagery
and calling things
church words in order
to get this state.
Well, my friend, my friend, he was an Uber
driver.
A close friend, Juan.
But he's from Mexico and he said
people who come from Mexico
usually don't speak that great of English
and are usually very Catholic. So they see
these crosses and they go in
there thinking it's Catholic and they go in and get
God. Yep, exactly.
I mean, that was kind of part of
part of the scam.
I mean, good job because we're watching
the next team documentary right now and that only
lasted for a few years. Scientology has really
dragged this out. But part of
having a large sect, a lot of times
is females are very hard to
account for. And I mean like
cis-born females, I'm going to try to never
misgender during this
podcast. But if I do, I apologize
and I'm going to work on it.
But they're really just
the females within these kind of communities
are often expected to live
work and kind of exist solely
within their tiny microcosms. So
sometimes it's really hard to even clock
their existence. Yeah. Do they
even have a social security number? Right.
Which is terrifying. Yeah.
Because then there's no rules. Just right.
Is that the
Outback Steakhouse? I think so.
So it's just like Outback Steakhouse.
In those scenarios
I want to talk about what consent looks
like. Because say in the case
of Shelly, she hasn't been seen
publicly since 2007.
She hasn't been seen
on documented video since
2004. And whenever
a missing persons report was filed by
Leah Remini in 2013, which was
documented on her show
detectives allegedly made contact with her.
What? Yeah. And they
claim that upon being interviewed, she said
she was fine and she asked to be left alone.
Within that, there are
several problems.
One being if a grown adult
says she's happy and doesn't want to be
bothered, should we just
leave her alone? It sounds like we should, right?
But it's more complicated than that
for when I'm not really
convinced that the detectives actually saw
her. And that's just a complete opinion
that's speculation. But
a lot of times the LAPD
and the system within Los Angeles has
been pretty corrupt because of money. And there's
a lot of different
points where it looks like
Scientology has sort of
paid off authority figures
for things. So that's just a
complete speculation. I don't know. I don't
know anything about that.
But also, the other side of that,
this is basically what this series
is going to be about, is that
we know her name and we know that she's
missing. But I didn't know really anything else
about her. No. But also, according
to their culture, are we brainwashed?
Whoa!
But I say you're brainwashed
if you can't, like, go to the grocery
store and get a sandwich. Well, yeah, that's when
Consent comes into play with this because
they can crow all day about
us being brainwashed into the society
or whatever. But we still have the choice.
If we want to go
hiding, we can.
If we want to move
somewhere, we can. And then we can still talk
to everyone we've ever known. Yeah. But if a culture
tells us, no, you can't do that. You can't
go to the grocery. You can't go look at that.
You can't wear that. Then that's
that's a problem. Right.
And so when she's saying she's consenting
to her imprisonment
but has never had choices
in her life to, like,
have an orgasm or
like been day drunk at a less
than Jake show, you know?
If you've never had those
opportunities, do you even
understand what consent is?
Yeah. I mean, you want to go back to the prison.
Like there was this kid from North Korea
who escaped the camps
and I saw an interview where he was like,
I want to go back because I don't understand this
world. Totally. He didn't understand money,
furniture. He's like, what is this? What do you mean
you trade these bills for these things? Yeah,
you go back. Exactly. And as we'll get
into, she didn't ever
have experiences outside of Scientology
essentially. So
it's why I felt the need to look into her
life and have a bigger discussion
about what consent looks
like in this situation.
I've heard a lot of men say, like,
women, once they go to college and once
they do these things, then they don't want to come back to
traditional values. I'm like, well, then
maybe, maybe then
that's not a good thing. I mean, I like traditional
values. My family's very conservative, but
if you go off to college
or go off to the big city and you don't want to come
back, I mean, maybe that says something about your
life. Yeah. And also
if you go off into
the big city and you decide you don't like it and you
want to go back, that's great.
That's great. Good for you, whatever.
Go raise a family. There's nothing wrong with
that. It's certainly, in essence, it's
wonderful. But that's how
America survives. That's not
everybody should be an artist in New York.
You know, go back to your hometown.
There's too many of us, frankly. I'm
nauseated by us most of the time.
But, yeah,
you have to be able to discern
what that means on your own
and to make that decision
on your own and not with
threat of going to hell or whatever
other, you know,
consequences there would be from
other people in your life. Should there be
a checklist? You know, like, have you had an orgasm?
Do you
have a pair of heels? Have you ever
cut school and
you know, gotten on the train
and shop lifted an
incense stick? Yeah, you ever taken
your car and drove two states over
and lied to your family and said you just went
to Walmart? Yeah, you need to make a couple
mistakes in there and see for yourself
what that means and, you know,
I feel like it's important
to mention that I'm
certainly not suggesting the way I
live is the way other people
should live. I can't recommend very much
of my life to anybody. No, same here.
Yeah, and if you want to have a family
and be whatever you want,
it's your life. Exactly. That's your
consent, you know. Right.
So, Shelly herself seems to have disappeared
into this lexicon of
various unaccounted
forecrimes of
the Church of Scientology and we know
about a lot of them, but she
is a human being who is,
if still alive, kept locked away in
a dark corner whether or not she considers
herself a captive.
There's a lot of speculation she's being held
in a particular compound
in California owned by the Church
and I myself needed to experience
that with like all of my senses
because I've heard of it, and I've seen
photos and everything, but I wanted to see it.
So, I went there
and I'll talk about that experience.
You went there? I did.
Wow. Yeah. Do you get on the train?
You got in a car? I got in a car.
So, they probably got your license plate.
Oh, I got a rental. Oh, there you go.
I was super paranoid about it
and Henry was laughing at me and I was like,
I don't want them to trace us to our house
even though I don't think they have the power
to do that, but... I don't think
Scientology has guns themselves.
They'll hire somebody with guns, but...
And back when they were still more secretive
and there weren't a million people trying to call
them out, it was easier to trace everybody,
but now that it's out there so much,
I'm just one of many voices, so
I'll get to that. We'll talk about that
a little later, but I want to start at the beginning
because I need to reverse engineer
her life to understand
how this happens.
So, the very obvious first thing
is if... Who's Shelley Miscovich?
Well, we know her as the wife
of the current chairman of the Board of Scientology,
David Miscovich.
If you do not know what Scientology is,
I do not recommend listening to this first.
You probably should go
read up on it. There's literally
an endless
barrage of information about Scientology.
I think they think
the Earth of Xenard...
Xenu. Xenu, Xenu,
and then we all, you know... I like Xenard better, though.
Xenard's
the unattractive brother of Xenard.
I'm Xenard.
Aw, man, he never gets anything.
So,
yeah, there's so many resources
to look this up, but, you know,
it was created, the very, very, very
brief synopsis that was created
by a man named Lafayette Ronald Hubbard,
who goes by
L. Ron Hubbard or LRH.
He was a science fiction author, and
he also science fiction authored
most of his life and made up who he was.
He was a con artist, all around
flim flamman, and he founded
the Church of Scientology in 52.
So, it's been going
for almost
three quarters of a century.
He knows what he's doing. Good business.
He really did, and I think one of the
keys to keeping a cult
going past the original
leaders, you needed a second psycho
to come and step in
to continue it on, which is what
happened with David.
You just got to find somebody beating a horse
with a hammer, and you're like, aha, that's my predecessor.
You know, it's not that far off,
except David really took
the reins of that horse, and L. Ron
didn't really hand it to him as much as David
took it as he was dying.
So, basically, Shelly
and David, her husband, were both
legacy kids.
Really, Shelly's life is so guarded because
of her childhood
she had. I had to basically
read, like, 10 different Scientology
books and just, like, kind of go through
and, like, pluck out of these tiny little
facts from people who
kind of knew who she was as a kid.
Because her parents were in Scientology, too, right?
Yeah. So, they taught that
they, ooh, it's like a long line
of being poisoned. Absolutely.
Well, kind of credit these books as I go through,
and I also want to credit Tony Ortega,
who is one of the leading
researchers on Scientology. He
has been working on revealing this
before most people knew what Scientology
was, so he has a lot of content out there.
But let's just get into this. So,
Michelle Diane Shelly Barnett
was born on
January 18th, 1961
in Dallas, Texas, and raised
any family of Scientologists.
Shelly's father, Maurice Elliott Barnett,
who went by Barney,
was born April 30th, 1930.
He was apparently a handyman
and sort of a
off-and-on guy who struggled to find
work a lot.
There's not a ton known about him,
and he died in 2007,
which is the last time Shelly was seen
by anybody. Interesting. So, you think
her parents would be a little more up in the
system if she married the big hauncho guy?
Well, her mother,
whose name is Mary Florence Barnett
Miller, who was known as
Flo Barnett at the time. She was
born in Missouri on
June 7th, 1933,
and it looks a lot like it
points to she was sort of
the person who brought everybody else in her family
into Scientology. So, she found it,
and then kind of just
drug Barney along.
As women do. I know.
It's always the woman in the relationship
that pulls people in religion.
So many people, like the mother passes
and the dad's like, I'm not going to church anymore.
Every time.
Well, I guess this is going to be a lot of men
in hell, isn't there?
Oh, sorry. I shouldn't have laughed so hard.
So,
she, I think
we can kind of discern that she was
the forebearer. She was the leader
of this, bringing the
family into Scientology. Flo,
a very 1930s name, by the way. It really is.
And again, there's not
a ton of information about who she originally
heard about Scientology from.
But somehow she got in there.
Scientology wasn't until the 50s, right?
Yes. And she's born in the 30s.
She was in her 20s.
She was an adult. She was an adult.
There was no, yeah, basically
when I say legacy kid,
the first rush of
Scientologists came in the early
60s, the late, late 50s
when he was sort of shifting over
from writing Dianetics
into actually creating this cult.
So, she had four daughters
with Barney, and
they were Clarice, Michelle,
Camille, and
Metary.
Yeah. I don't know that name, but I kind of like it.
Lafayette and Metary are both Louisiana names.
Those are the towns in Louisiana.
I wonder if there's some sort of
connection to Louisiana or Cajun culture?
I mean, definitely southern culture.
Acadians. I know Acadians came
from Canada, and then
scooted all the way down to Louisiana,
and so there's a big Acadian culture
down there. Maybe something with Canada.
I don't even know what Acadians are.
Yeah, it's like this whole group of people.
They came from Canada, and they just boot, scoot, and boogie
all the way down to Louisiana, and they live a lot.
A lot of them are in Lafayette, and they created
Zydeco music.
Oh, got it, got it. They're missing women in there?
They hide women?
Probably in the swamps. That's the best way to hide a body.
Oh, my God, the swamps are filled with missing women.
We'll try to find them, though.
Mettory, regardless.
She died as a baby.
So she, yeah,
she just passed away very young.
They were all born in Texas.
So all of those kids,
even though Flo was born in Missouri,
they were a Texas family.
And like I said, it was really hard to gauge
exactly how her family fell under
the LRH spell.
But they went in whole hog.
They were in it to win it.
So a lot of this information about
the younger years I got from
a woman named Janice Gillam Grady's
books series called
Commodore's Messenger.
She grew up
around Shelly
and her older sister Clarice
in the late 60s,
and she was also a Scientology kid.
So this is where I'm getting some of this
sourced. This is the first
known mention I can find of this family
at all. She mentions
in her first book, Meeting the Barnets in UK
in 1967,
she says,
with mom now gone from the house,
dead red and at our guest room to help pay the bills,
Flo Barnet, an American woman,
came to stay with us while doing her auditing training
at St. Hill.
St. Hill is, by the way,
in West Sussex in the UK.
That was one of the locations where
Elron was kind of housing people
and training them for a time.
So her oldest daughter Clarice,
aged 10, came with her.
They're two younger daughters, Michelle, known as Shelly,
and Camilla, back behind in Texas.
Clarice did not attend school,
so instead she stayed at home alone reading
while waiting for Terry and me to arrive home from school.
So...
So she didn't go to school?
I guess back in the day, it was kind of like
you were hot shit if you graduated high school.
Presidents used to be like, this is Tommy.
He graduated high school.
And I think especially for females,
but there wasn't a lot of schooling going on here.
So essentially, Flo
came, a lot of...
Scientology, you can see from this,
it drew people from all over the place.
So we have Americans, we have people in the UK,
Janice Grady's family is Australian,
and so these people
are kind of flocking to him already
in the UK to this big compound,
this big, huge, pretty house
compound that he got called St. Hill
that he acquired.
So Flo brought Clarice
to this place
with her, and that's Shelly's older sister.
And Janice
who wrote these books is closer to Clarice
in age.
This is really how I'm getting a lot of this information.
You might be asking, did not one of these
people get out and can tell us anything
about what happened?
And yes and no, like I said before,
Barney died in 2007, and he'd also
they'd been divorced for a while
and he had removed himself from all
of it and kind of lived his own life, and he quietly...
He quietly died. He's probably like, this is crazy.
Yeah, he was eventually just like,
oh no, no thank you.
And Flo,
we'll talk about this later, she died in a very
suspicious suicide in 1985.
Really? Yeah.
Oh, like a shotgun, but...
Yeah, a long gun, three
shots to the chest and one to the head
and they called it a suicide.
No! Yeah, yeah.
It's crazy. Sometimes like, it's just
easier to file something as missing
than to research. So I have for like
read reports where it's like, oh the
woman was hog-tied and shot in the back
of the head. Suicide. Natural causes.
Yeah. Yeah, totally.
We'll talk about that when we get to that
that era, but yes, it's
questionable at best.
So, and then with the other
members of the family, Clarice, still at the
core of Goldbase, which is one of their main
locations they have now, which I also visited
and I will talk about later. She is still inside.
Her ex-husband
and former Sea Org member, John Brousseau,
has spoken out on Leigh
Show and other places about his personal
relationship with Clarice,
but not really much about Shelly.
But her ex-husband is out
and is an outspoken anti-scientologist.
Okay. Clarice is
also mentioned in Mark Headley's book
Blown for Good, another ex-scientologist
as sort of a resigned
slave at Goldbase.
He said that Clarice, her older sister,
is just sort of like going through the motions.
But technically, she's also missing because
nobody's seen her in decades.
I just like, eyes have nothing
behind them, just picking up boxes
and putting them on the other side of the room.
For sure. And then Camille,
the other sister, sometimes she's referred
to as Camilla, I'm not sure which one it is.
She's completely removed herself from anything
to do with Scientology and also her family.
So she's alive, but she has
I imagine in fear of the church
just like, I want nothing
to do with this. I won't talk.
Nobody want, find me.
Leave me alone. Just living in the woods.
Definitely not somebody who should be like, let's go find her.
Exactly. That is a missing
person I feel like who has made her
statement on, please leave
me alone and don't fucking come near me.
Yeah, she's in the woods, fishing.
I hope she's having a great time, you know.
She wasn't as involved anyway,
but I did find documents saying
that she had been declared clear in
82, which clear
if you're not familiar, there's, oh my
god, the fucking. The terms.
The terms, the
acronyms, the initialisms.
It's mind melting and it's really
I feel like how they keep people in because
I cannot keep them
straight in my head. My brain refuses
to remember them because it's so
asinine and redundant. Yeah, well
I was like at somebody's house and
they were like staying with
somebody and the people they were staying
with were Scientologists and they had a child.
So I picked up this child Scientology
book and another thing about a cult is
it gets you, you can't speak plainly on
your own words. You have to speak
with their dialect and take
one word and replace it with this word
and you might not think it's a big deal
but it kind of is when it all adds
up because words train your brain.
Yeah. I was looking
at it and the girl was like, you have to put that away
and I was like, why?
And she's like, because if they see you
they're going to get mad and I was like, it's a
child's book. If I can't
look at it, then that's their problem.
I want to see a child Scientology book.
That sounds fascinating. It was fascinating
and they're like, you can't look at that. And I was like,
wait a minute, I can't look at this. I'm going to see
what these kids are learning and they got super weird
and I was like, I hate you.
Good. And also if you're
afraid to show people what you're teaching
your kid, that's, that is a warning sign
also. Yes. Wow, that's fun. I wish
I could see that book. I mean, I don't, I don't
think you can order that on Amazon.
You know, probably is one on eBay.
Probably. We have the whole
Dianetics. We have a bunch of the
level content because all of that
stuff has come out. But one of the, I think
one of the things that really helps people
stay in a cult is that dialogue,
they have that vocabulary, their
own language makes you feel special
and different and above other
people. You've gone clear. Right.
So you are now
essentially higher up being in a lot
of ways. So with flow,
I mentioned that she had brought her child
to the UK location.
Like so many parents who found their way
into Scientology, she became increasingly
distant from her children
according to Janice Grady.
And Elron himself
believed very grossly
that children and adults were all old
Thaetans. Thaetan is
like your spirit essentially. Yeah, you would
have children around him all the time, right?
Yeah. Surprisingly, he was not a touchy.
He wasn't a molesty
by all accounts. A lot of people think
it's because his penis didn't work. Oh,
is he like a Michael Jackson type?
Kind of someone who
love kids, but there's no real
actually, I think he hated kids, which
is why he wanted them to act like adults,
which is what he did. So he encouraged
and sometimes demanded family
separate to achieve different goals for the
org that even if someone was your
child in this life, they may have been your
parent in a previous life.
Therefore, you didn't need to worry about raising
them because they were already old.
Well, the family unit is
one of the strongest units
and that's why a lot of cults,
they separate the families because
if you're a mother, then my husband
and my children are above
you. I'm going to take care of
my newborn before I take care of this leader.
Right. And they can't have that. No. They're
first. Nope, exactly.
And they say after her pilgrimage
to the UK, Flo had
had her two daughters in LA with her at
the Celebrity Center, which still exists.
People never saw her
engage with her children whatsoever. And that's
sort of encouraged. You hear that over and over again in these
books. People who had parents and family
inside of Scientology, they didn't
see them very often. So you're
already seeing the setup for the transition of
Shelley being fully detached from her parents.
And also you can snitch on your family
too. Like if they do something wrong.
Oh, yeah. Some wrong thing.
The whole process of Scientology
is pointing out other people's mistakes.
Yeah, because then you get elevated
higher if you point out somebody else's mistakes.
And also anything you do
somehow is somebody else's fault
at the same time. It's very confusing.
So the Sea Org
is where we're going to go next because
this is really what
developed Shelley as a human being.
Yeah. Why do they like boat so much?
Explain to me that. He's a dork.
Mm-hmm. He lied. He had
he has stolen valor too. He claimed
to have all of these medals and stuff. And
he was, I believe, enlisted
for a while that he created
this whole Elrond that is he created
this whole persona that he had
like been on these battleships
and he shot all these people and won all these
medals and stuff. Even though it's easily
traceable that he didn't. He didn't.
But also boats, you can go on the water
in maritime law. Yeah. You can get away with anything.
Well, that is part of the reason he ended
up doing that as well.
This was in 67 when he created Sea Org.
So he was telling people
it was because he was going to
hand off Scientology to other people.
And he was going to go ship back into
adventures. He wanted
to go sail the seas and
discover new things like he used to in his
past life, which is all lies.
But so he wanted
to start going back into that life. Partly
also you find out later, shockingly
it's because he was in a bunch of financial
trouble with the government and he was trying to hide.
Mm-hmm. But he didn't say that
at the time, of course. On these boats
he created a fleet and it started out
with one boat and then he had two and then he had three.
And when he was creating
that one of the easiest ways to get
a lot of the work done on these old broken
boats that he found was to get
child slaves to come and help him.
So ultimately
the Sea Org brought on children and teens
to essentially be raised, groomed
and made to work by him on
a boat full time. Awful.
A lot of them did not come with
their families either. They did not
attend school at all.
He during this time changed
from being called his name to
insisting on only being addressed as Commodore.
So these ship
kids were known as Commodore's messengers.
Oh my god. They had some
adults on the ship too who were doing
they were not sailors. He basically
brought in just people from land and was like
you're gonna be the person who steers.
You're gonna be the person who fixes the
poles. I'm surprised it didn't sink.
I mean sailing across the oceans
about the hard work. They
almost did a couple times but basically
part of Scientology is like
you can't figure this out. You're an idiot and you're
bad and you're
so it's almost not motivating in a sense
that if you're psychologically
drilled into believing you have to learn how
to do something, sometimes you just do. You will
learn it. Interesting. So these kids
they're just like 10 years old being like oh captain
my captain. They started out
so Janice Grady the woman who wrote the book
she was one of the very first kids who ended up on this boat
and she was I believe 12 at the
13 maybe at the time when she got on
there ended up being younger kids
a lot of them were between 13
and 17 years old eventually
and most of them were women. Yeah
women girls. Girls. Didn't you say there was like
a little kid that like crawled out of a hole?
Oh yeah I'll tell you that story
and so in LRH's
words himself this is what
he says. He wrote in
an actual I don't think it was a book I think it
was probably some one of the many many
manuals he's put out in
Scientology and Your Children. He wrote
they are and let's not overlook
the point men and women
a child is not a special species
of animal distinct from men
a child is a man or woman
who has not attained full
growth. Wow that's
brilliant Alon thank you so much for that information
any law which applies
to the behavior of men and women
applies to children and then
later on in different flag order
that's like Sharia law shit too. Oh yeah
so and in later on he also
says and I want some other document
a feyton is simply a feyton
body size has nothing to do
with it. The trouble with children is that
it is a generality that that's
the way children are. A suppressive
is a suppressive whether he is big or small
we don't have suppressives in this
York whether they are big or small
big or small upstats get upstat treatment
and SP's get declared
do you know what half of those words men Amber?
No that's part of the fun. Yes
their own language and they all just think they're so special
learning to speak this language
and they all just declare SP's declared
yeah so
here's a couple stories about
what happens to the kids on these boats
I want to set this up because I want
people to understand the environment that Shelly
was walking into and because
we have limited information about her herself
this is the environment she was
raised in. Groomed in let's say
back on the Royal Scotsman
which is one of their boats a cute little
six year old girl named Angela was one of
the May arrivals. Angela
had done something that caught the Commodore's attention
Ron looked at children as
adults and little bodies regardless of age
and thus capable of acting like adults
the Commodore labeled Angela
a suppressive person and ordered
her to be sent to the chain locker
the chain locker is the part of
it's like where the
chain is housed for the anchor
so it's like when you release the anchor
the chain unravels inside
of this little room and so dangerous
well
this is all from Janice Grady's book and this she continues
I did not know that she was there until
one meal time when I went to the poop
deck where we were mustard and saw a skinny
little girl climb out of the hole
that the anchor chain comes out of
she was filthy and hungry crying for her mother
I took her with me to find her mother
in the blowdecks and at that point I made a
firm decision that I planned to never do
anything resulting in myself being thrown
in the chain locker so
Janice herself is a kid at this point
and she sees this and a kid's reaction
is well
I have to do whatever I can to never be in there
instead of going oh this is super fucked up
yeah because you're also so tiny
like how can you be like
get the boat home right now
I have a gun you know
right totally and as a kid too
if you're being literally bred on
pirate waters you don't know
what human rights are yeah you don't know
oh my gosh here's this other one
too I want to read real quick here
this other experience she watched
this child named Derek
so Derek was a three year old
adopted son of
someone on the boat named Felice
he was the cute boy probably the only black
person on the ship at the time
Felice like my mother was a very dedicated
Scientologist to a fault
instead of being a mother who stood up for her child
little Derek was ordered to
the chain locker for having chewed up some telex tape
telex tape is how they used
to communicate it was like
pretext message
telex tape was about three quarters of an inch
wide and long with little
coated holes in it when put into
a telex machine it translate the message in
readable form Derek was even smaller
than Angela and he could have easily gone down
the chain onto the anchor hanging from the
after the ship over the harbor or he could
have climbed up and out like Angela did
instead Derek remained in the chain
locker crying in the dark for hours
for his mother who did not come
when anyone was assigned to the chain locker
they were assigned a condition of enemy
for which the formula is find
out who you really are every
day the master arms went to the chain
locker and called down to Derek who
are you Derek replied
my name is Derek
Queen because she did it with
the list after a few
because he's three after a few
tries the master arms let him out
but would have preferred Derek to say he
was a thing an immortal spirit
not a body not a mind and not
a name Felice later left
the ship with Derek as she was transferred to
Los Angeles where her Derek continued to be
neglected getting into more trouble as he
grew older as mother continued to dedicate
her time to Scientology by auditing others
oh my god what a horrible
mother this is
I mean she needs to go to jail
there's so many people who should have gone to jail
during this time period what does he do
and is he okay I don't know
we should see where Derek is
I feel bad for this little boy
three and you put stuff in your mouth
because that's how you learn about the world
and then they threw him in a dark hole
yeah and they were trying to at three
already tell them
that he was not who he was
completely just trying to
erase this kids will
and ability yeah so
this is how it was on the
ship it's not a wild jump
to conclusion that this was part of the way he controlled the minds of the young
and how it would have been relatively
easy to mold Shelley's brain into whatever
he needed especially if her
particular genetic makeup was keen
to lean into the doctrine which some people
were way more into it
and some people rebelled against it because that's just human nature
you know and
Grady herself in this book acknowledges
that while technically they were being shown the world
because they did they sailed
all over the world she saw like 10 countries
before she was 16
and she was being trained how to like run a
ship
she was also not given a choice
and in many ways they were
they had like a toddler's understanding of how the
world worked because LRH was always
telling them about how
the police system and the government was corrupt which
they are yeah but
instead of telling them to then make their own
decisions about things and use critical thinking
he said you can only trust me
I'm the only person who can help you
and so they were isolated entirely
on water and at the whim
of LRH and he could
teach them whatever he wanted so she
memorized dynetics she could spout off anything
from there but she also in her early
teens could barely string a paragraph
together in writing
and that's another way to keep people in control because
when you write especially your own words
then you have a connection with your inner self
for sure no yeah he didn't
like want any of that happening ever
she writes in her book well with very few of us educated
in civics cultural or government
affairs political operations we had no clue
about how the world or governments operated
in different countries we had come from or that
we visited we did not know anything
about human rights or civil rights I did
not even know that as I had any rights
as a child or a citizen
so if children are born into Scientology
and do not receive proper education it
stands to reason that we would not be aware of
any violations of human rights such as
child labor laws and the like yeah
and so of course she's Shelly
Miskovich you might have seen her you might have not
but she says I'm okay right now
exactly this is how that happens
so Shelly's going to enter
the scene here now the sea org
started in 67
Shelly's older sister Clarice
comes in around
70 maybe 69
so the woman who wrote this book
Janice Grady she was closer
Clarice's age but they also
there at this point there was about
between 5 and 10 young girls
on this ship many of whom
without their parents Shelly
herself would come to this ship
this main ship the Apollo
around 1972 she would
have been between 11 or 12
at the time so she was joined
by Shelly Clarice
was joined by Shelly she had two
sisters on the ship the rest of their family was not there
so now that this has been
established the Commodore's messengers
these young girls they wielded
a huge amount of power on the ship
they were essentially considered the mouth
piece for LRH
so they would basically
run the ship for him where he
would be in his quarters and they would go
back and forth they yelled at
adults because they were considered adults
by him little girl sea captains
yeah they really were which
and that sounds like kind of the funnest part
of this job but this is also
what they had to do I mean sometimes
little girls are mean like if they yelled at
a 12 year old who's never been disciplined
and taught empathy yelling at me
I'd be like oh I guess I gotta move the thing
then you know I feel like
I would have enjoyed that part of this
experience but there's also
other things they had to do
not sex
fortunately good didn't they have
like little weird outfits oh they did
yeah a little
bit later on and in this story
they just because they weren't wearing
real uniforms at the time and then
eventually he let them choose
their own outfits which
surprisingly are like
crop tops and knee-high socks and like
daisy tubes
the game wardrobe I'll show you pictures
I'll post the pictures on Instagram also
they became like the leaders of the
ship essentially and
he was also in ill health at the time
he was on a lot of drugs even though
he promoted never using
substances and he they always
do at the end towards the end of their life
call leaders usually end up addicted to drugs
continue the megalomania and
like their own internal persistence
brain saying
you're not actually what you say
you are and you have to lie to yourself over
and over again as you get older it gets harder
you have to start taking drugs to do it
so that messengers had
assumed many little extra tasks on his
behalf they would
wash and comb his hair
when he went to the bathroom
this is uh Jana speaking we would lay out
his clothes powder his socks and shoes
and fold everything ready to get him
dressed everything had to be right because
if it wasn't he would yell at us and we didn't want
to upset him the last thing we wanted to do
was upset him when he came out of the shower
he would be in his underwear two of us held
his pants off the floor as he stepped into them
he didn't like his trouser legs
to touch the floor god forbid that should happen
we pulled up his pants and buckled
his belt although he zipped them
so don't worry about that
we put on his shirt
buttoned it up we put his cools in his shirt
pocket tied his cravat
and combed his hair at the time he'd be
standing there watching us run around him
then we'd follow him out on the deck carrying
anything you might need cloak hat binoculars
ashtray spare cigarettes
anything you could possibly think of wanting
we felt it was an honor and a privilege to do
anything for him the messengers were all
potential high school cheerleaders in appearance
pretty blondes with even white teeth
and red lips pert little breasts straining
against not at halter tops oh this is
actually a quote from the barefaced messiah
a different book bare midriffs tight hot
pants long tan legs bobby socks
and platform sold sandals they had
devised the uniform themselves with the
Commodore's approval and it gave them
maximum opportunity to flaunt their pubescent
assets
to advantage
I remember being like 13
and being like yeah I want to wear a
craptap you know yeah and my parents
having to be like no no you
wear a shirt that covers you
and they'd be like mom I can do what I want
sure especially on the job I also think
that there's a big difference if you are
deciding to do those things or if an adult
is encouraging
you to dress like a slut it's
I'm sorry I shouldn't say a slut
I didn't mean that I don't know why I just
said that that's some weird nine days back
in my brain thing that just came out
because I dressed very
you know bare
times in my life I still do
but I think there's a huge thing psychologically
if it's something you're choosing as a
kid to do as opposed to like an older
person an adult being like
yes wear less clothes oh I
love it like that's weird
it's gonna do something weird to your brain
yeah especially when you get to be an adult
you know and then you can go either way
I've definitely seen it where people are like don't touch me
yes and humans should have touch
or it's just like everyone touch me
and you should have privacy
I know just you know
a little bit in the middle somewhere
it's probably good yeah yin yang
yeah so that was described in bare face
messiah which is a book about
Elron Hubbard's life and all the lies
he told it was also noted
he would openly say that
he was basically breeding
children this is a quote
of his in the book bare face messiah
yeah it was an indirect quote in the book
he said it was an idea he had picked up
from Nazi Germany he said Hitler
was a madman but
you should know as soon as somebody
says Hitler was really bad
but like you should just go walk away
from that person forever but
nevertheless a genius in his
own right and the Nazi youth was one of the
smartest ideas he ever had with
young people you had a blank slate
you could write anything you wanted on it
and it would be your writing that was his idea
to take young people and mold them into little
Hubbard's he said he had girls
because women were more loyal than men
yeah again back to the religion
women are always like I want to believe
in God because usually men are like no I
am the God exactly I mean
and that's definitely what LRH did
as these girls grew older
they were on the ship and they were starting
to get married off to some of the younger boys
on the ship and a lot of times including
Janice's own sister
she was not permitted to have her family there
so he when Janice's sister
was getting married on the ship
she asked if she could have her dad come on the ship
and give her away and Elron was like
taken aback by it he was so hurt
that she would ask for her
birth father because they had barely
spent time with him
so she didn't she apologized
and let Elron walk her down the aisle
and her family wasn't there for the wedding or anything
wow
what a piece of shit
I mean it's not great
this is the broader sense so this is
really like I was saying the experience would have been
like for Shelly when she came on
from the get go Shelly was utterly devoted
to Hubbard Janice recalls
and socially awkward and shunned by the rest of her
Commodore's messengers all teenaged girls
so Grady is supposed to
put out a third part of
this Commodore's messengers series
which has not come out yet but it would have been
when Shelly was growing up
it sounds like it's good position for her
because if she's super awkward around her teammates
then how can she make friends
and it seems like Elron Hubbard
he don't want no friendships
so she was just around him the whole time
so that's probably her awkwardness
the crux that actually did her well
and she just ended up being one of those kids
who her makeup
made her kind of enjoy this process
as much as you could at eleven
when you're shipped off to a boat
and you want to do it around with an ashtray
yeah you just like send your kid
with an old guy on a boat
who among us has not done that with one of their kids
Jesus
this is from the Daily Mail
she did an interview with them about this time period
because they did a brief interview with her
about Shelly being missing
she said and Shelly was also
a couple years younger than Janice
so she still was also seeing her from a little bit
afar even though she was around for it
she said Shelly was not one to
step out of line
she was always kind of in the background
she was very loyal to Hubbert
but she was not one that you could say
take this project and run with it
because she wasn't experienced enough
or had enough street smarts about her to make her own decisions
because she was eleven I would assume
yes and an entrepreneur
like I took the bus the other day
and I saw this sign that said
entrepreneur school for kids
and I was like no you're raising assholes
entrepreneur school for kids
you're raising for yourself absolutely
but like I don't know
read a book with a class
like have something to talk about this
a shared experience
I don't think you need to teach a kid
how to buy and sell cars or something
okay so here's a little snippet
about their education levels
Shelly was not Janice said well educated
she probably went to fifth grade
maybe and that was it
because when she came to the ship
they did not have school
they had three hours of reading
writing and arithmetic but that doesn't teach you
anything about critical thinking
or really how to exist as a human being
so she learned basic
reading and writing
and she graduated from fifth grade
maybe that is her entire education level
and David Miskovich himself
I'm going to talk about him in episode two
about his upbringing
he himself only had a tenth grade education
but when you look at that
he's had two times as much education
as Shelly
so he's a real learned man
in her life
she did not go to middle school
in this article Shelly gained a reputation
among the other girls for being moody
and for taking so long over her hair
makeup and outfits that often
when the rest of the messengers were going ashore
on a liberty or leaving the ship
they would simply leave her behind
so she was just taking forever brushing her hair
and didn't know what to wear
and she was also younger
did she ever get off the boat?
I hope she got off the boat by herself
not by herself
she did eventually get off the boat
because they stopped doing the boats
and they made Sea Orga a land thing
but she was still trapped essentially
she was just trapped on land instead of on a boat
she probably felt crazy walking on ground
I mean, yeah, I don't know
if you develop sea legs as a child
do you just land feel weird to you?
I don't know
yeah, walking bow legged and all crazy
so you can get a sleep on a water bed for sure
you definitely do
looking back, she admitted
Shelley was a lot younger than the rest of us
so she did have that disadvantage
but she didn't have a very good relationship
with the core messengers
so during that time, she was kind of isolated
even within that group
because she was a little bit younger
and when you're a teenager
two years is a huge gap
where you're just like, ooh, this baby
this gross baby
I guess in that world, they still considered her
a full grown adult
but you can't take that adolescence out of an adolescent
no matter how hard you try
you're still going to be a shitty teenage girl
you can't do anything about that
but as I mentioned, they started to
pair off a little bit
they didn't encourage people
to get married young
but you kind of were encouraged
because couples could get more work done
they didn't actually encourage having babies very much
he actually didn't like kids
which is weird, you would think a cult would want
lots of children to continue
and it's weird, I think for Elron
he might be different in the sense of
he wanted his life to be catered to
he didn't really give a shit about what happened
ultimately, he wanted to be taken care of
so all of these people were literally
just like his servants
making sure his pants didn't touch the ground
totally, and he got
all these people to put these ships together for him
so he could sail around on them
they got rid of the ships
in some places that he could
be comfortable in, he has mansions
everywhere that are still waiting for him
there's like six or seven different places
where they have
the house is completely ready for him
whenever he returns
some of them are still waiting for him
so we can go probably sleep there
and is anybody going to know?
oh yeah, they have hired security
everywhere around their locations
so you could do one of those
hide out
and put it in the fridge, no one will know
I actually think that they'd be one of
some of the hardest buildings to get into
for absolutely no reason
there's like nothing going on inside
but they have so much money, they can just hire security
and a lot of times they have
the Sea Org is a group of slaves
so a lot of times the Sea Org members just have to go
do security duty on empty buildings
yeah, you don't pay them
during the 60s and 70s
all the people who have defected
and who are talking about it
they made $10 a week or something
for their time
I noticed something interesting in LA
because their uniform is usually a white shirt
and black bottoms
and I've done some catering stuff here
especially when I first moved to LA
and they were like, no, all black
do not do white shirt, black bottoms
and I was like, why?
because they don't want us looking like Scientologists
but it also works for Scientologists
because it sort of makes them
accessible in a way where
it's just caterers, it's probably fine
yeah, white shirt, black bottoms, I wish they had a cooler outfit
because I've seen some beautiful looking young women
and I'm like, girls, show off that body with a dress
I mean, they still make them wear
sailor outfits
they are still cosplaying sailors
now, even though they don't have ships anymore
that they operate on
and they still use sea terms and stuff
it's a whole ass thing
so they were starting to pair off
and there was a small group
they didn't get to see any other adolescents
even when they would go to shore
in different countries, they'd have
their little time to be on land
they weren't meeting people
it wasn't a thing where you could meet somebody
and then text each other
there was nothing, you are on
shore somewhere
yeah, you're in the Moroccan markets
but holding hands and don't talk to anybody
I mean, literally there's parts of her book
that are that exact scenario
and you can barely speak English yourself
let alone other languages
even an English speaking person
they'd be like, what are you talking about
dianetic
you've gone clear, excuse me
yeah, they're like, you guys are weird
get out of here
and ultimately this is around the mid 70s
they started having troubles
his government troubles would not escape him
no matter how much he sailed
and so the ships became kind of their own issue
people were questioning who these boats were
with all these children on them
even back then, they're like
are you running a sex ring
or what's happening here
are you the CIA, there was all these questions about the boat
so eventually he had to kind of come back
to the states and
bring the sea org to land
and that's when clear water
became the mecca for
Scientology, they basically brought the ships
back to Florida and
set up base in clear water and to this day
that's where they are
but they still call it the sea org
their main core, their most dedicated people
their literal slaves are
still there and
this is when David comes into the scene
he comes in and we're going to
get into how David became a part
of this whole thing in part two
we're going to wrap up just by saying
Janice Grady says
there was a group of younger girls and there was
not a big selection of guys
the two best guys were probably Dave
Miss Gavage
and Mark Yeager who went on
to become a different executive
one was short and one was tall
Dave is the short one, he's like 5'4
aww and Tom Cruise is tiny too
I know, I think that's why they're best friends
aww they're like two knuckles fighting
oh yeah
but there wasn't a big selection of guys
and I remember a bunch of the girls competing to get Dave
and Shelly
wins the prize at the end of the day
so
next week we're going to get into
how David ended up
in this situation, there's a lot more about him
because his father defected
he had to escape
he wrote a book about the experience
and also his niece, his brother's
daughter escaped
and she wrote a book about their life
and sometimes escaping this thing
it isn't necessarily like
a jeep ride through the jungle with a gun
and sometimes just
escaping is a mental snap
of just saying I don't want this anymore
and just walking out of the gates
which is harder sometimes
especially because in Scientology
a lot of them feel as though
they can't do that and there's a whole
entire wing of Scientology
dedicated to following
people who try to defect
so they do actually have to
sometimes even though in the
grander scheme they could physically
just walk out and go
help me, I'm being held captive
yeah
but nobody ever does that
they have to like sneak out with like a bag over their head
they do, there was actual
escapes in that way including
David Miscovich's own father
how to do something kind of similar
to that
and it makes sense because
your whole family, the people you love
your friends are all connected to this so it feels weird
to just give them the finger
and run out screaming into the street
yeah, I mean it'd be like if I went into Scientology
like everybody would be like
you're crazy, I'd probably have to sneak in there
yeah
exactly, they're all trying to get out
you're trying to get in
so yeah, that's the rough beginning
of Shelley Miscovich's life
we're going to talk about how
good old Dave got into Scientology
and then how they met
and where it went from there
how did she win the prize, this awkward little girl
I'm excited
I know, it's so thrilling
she's such a lucky lady
well thank you Amber for joining me
thanks for having me, this was absolutely
so fascinating
yeah, it's fucked up man
yeah
and I like delving into the minds of these people
excuse me, like why people make decisions
because you can look at it from the outside
and be like that's crazy
but if you delve into the psychology
how they were raised, how their parents were raised
it starts to kind of make a little sense
yeah, which is basically why I created the show
because
if I can't look into
how this happens
I will myself go insane
truly madly insane
and everyone will suffer
and there's a lot of missing people
there's like, I think state lines
a lot of police don't report
back to each other so
there's a lot of serial killers out there right now
more so one of the bigger risks
which we'll have many episodes about
is social media has made it
easy for kids to go missing
because of predators having
easy access to them
and it's technically harder now
to become a serial killer than it ever was
because there's so much tracing
however, it's much easier
to get access to children
that's why YouTube recently turned off the comments
for kids shows
because people go in there and they're like
hey little boy, little girl, you know
we're gonna have a whole bunch of discussions
about issues on YouTube, don't worry
so yeah, thanks for joining us
please come back
and hear the rest of Shelly's tale
we can finally
help her out of this if she wants to be helped
and I don't know how to
make that decision whether or not
she even knows if she wants help but we're gonna try to figure it out
we can open the door but are you gonna walk out of it?
come on Shelly, get out of there
get out of here, come have an orgasm with us
oh my god, can imagine how much fun
she'll have the first time and have
like a little cocktail
take her to a jazz bar
oh my god, ride a roller coaster, fuck sake
Shelly, come out
alright, we'll
see you, I'm Natalie Jean
and you can find me at the
Natty Jean on random
you know, all the shit
I'm Amber Nelson and I'm Amber Smelson
on Instagram and Twitter
she smells great, bye!
www.castnetwork.com