Let's Go To Court! - 62: April Fools: The Exercise Guru & the Innocent New Yorkers

Episode Date: April 1, 2019

Brooke Taylor was the head of a fitness empire. She was completely gifted. She could make you lose three pounds in one class. But her perfect world shattered when she found her beloved husband Haywort...h Windham shot dead. Everyone thought Brooke was guilty — everyone except a bright eyed first-year law student named Elle Woods. When two young New Yorkers stopped at the Sac-o-Suds convenience store in rural Alabama, the last thing they wanted was trouble. But when the store clerk was shot dead, the pair became suspects. Thanks to a gigantic misunderstanding, Bill Gambini and Stan Rothenstein found themselves arrested for murder. They turned to Bill’s cousin Vinny for legal counsel. And now for a note about our process. For this special April Fools day episode, we chose fake court cases from our favorite movies. We hope you enjoyed it! In this episode, Kristin told the plot of the movie, “Legally Blonde.” In this episode, Brandi told the plot of the movie, “My Cousin Vinny.”

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 One semester of law school. One semester of criminal justice. Two experts. I'm Kristen Pitts. I'm Brandi Egan. Let's go to court. On this episode, I'll talk about an exercise guru who murdered her husband. And I'll be talking about murder, miscommunication, and two nearly identical cars.
Starting point is 00:00:24 All right, here we go. Okay, you ready for this? An exercise guru, huh? I'm very excited. Oh my gosh, me too. Do you have a favorite exercise guru from back in the day? Richard Simmons. Oh, okay. Well, yeah, not a bad choice. My personal favorite. Jane Fonda. Jane Fonda. Of course. Jane Fonda. You used to do the tapes. Hell yeah. My favorite. Uh-huh. Jane Fonda, hips, buns, and thighs. Excellent. And you know the story of when I accidentally returned that tape to Blockbuster.
Starting point is 00:00:55 I don't remember this story. This was so embarrassing. So I would always do Jane Fonda, hips, buns, and thighs after school. And one day, like, we had rented some movie from Blockbuster and needed to go back. I guess I wasn't thinking. Pulled out Jane Fonda's Hips, Buns, and Thighs. Put it in the Blockbuster case. And then, like, later that day, realized what I had done.
Starting point is 00:01:18 And I had to go back to the Blockbuster and tell the guy behind the counter, excuse me, I accidentally... Can I get my Jane Fonda back, please? And then... You know what he did? What? He looked me up and down. He goes, doesn't look like you need it, though.
Starting point is 00:01:36 Oh, no! Gross! I had all the hips, buns, and fads that I needed. And that's the story of how I met Norman. Can we just take a moment? RIP Blockbuster. I loved Blockbuster. You know, we had some good times in Blockbuster.
Starting point is 00:02:01 Yeah, we did. Do you remember when we rented American Pie and we thought we were such badasses? Yeah. Because we were not 13 yet. Yeah. I rented it because I was the tallest. Yep. You would have thought we were scoring cocaine.
Starting point is 00:02:21 Right. Like, we really... As if the kid behind the counter gave two shits. No, you know he didn't because you remember who went on to work at Blockbuster and you know he didn't give a shit. Oh, Dan Jones! Dan Jones, yes! Yes! You know he didn't give a shit when anybody was renting.
Starting point is 00:02:43 All right. Are you ready for a crazy story? Yes. Okay. Buckle up, Brandi. Okay. Wait. It's 2002 and we're in Harvard Law School. Oh, yes. There's this very respected defense attorney who teaches criminal law at Harvard. In fact, Professor Callahan is the best defense attorney in the state of Massachusetts. Really? Yes. Is the best defense attorney teaching? Is that... You know, I don't know if you have like an adjunct thing, but... Okay.
Starting point is 00:03:20 You know. Okay. Everyone wanted to get a summer internship with him, but there were only so many spots and they never went to first year students. But in 2002, Callahan made an exception. He was working on a huge case and he needed all the help he could get. He'd just taken on a new celebrity client named Brookeoke windham she'd been accused of murdering her husband and everyone thought she'd done it yeah and she did like the she did like workout videos right exactly yeah i think i remember yeah if i feel like if you're
Starting point is 00:04:00 into this kind of stuff you've probably heard her name yeah for sure but you probably know her by her maiden name brooke taylor oh yes yes okay 100 so everyone thought she did it including callahan really yes he thought his client was her own defense attorney thought she was guilty yeah that's not great and in conversations with her he'd kind of be all cutesy and like oh oh, well, it's just that the jury won't, but like behind closed doors, this guy was just like, she's guilty. So that didn't matter. Everyone deserves a good defense. So he would defend her the best way he knew how.
Starting point is 00:04:41 Almost immediately, he brought a handful of really talented first-year law students onto the case. In their first meeting as a defense team, Callahan presented the information without much emotion. The defendant was Brooke Windham. Her wealthy husband, Hayworth, was discovered shot to death in their Beacon Hill mansion. It didn't look good. Beacon Hill, man. Shit happens there. I know, I know. The fake Rockefellers live there.
Starting point is 00:05:13 These two had a 34-year age gap. Oh, tell us how you feel about it, Kristen. I am grossed out beyond belief. I do not support this union. To most people, it looked like Brooke was just a heartless gold digger who got tired of waiting for her husband
Starting point is 00:05:34 to die. That's the terrible thing people were saying about her. But the thing is, like, that didn't really make sense because they were both wealthy. Yeah, she had this huge fitness empire. So she did not marry him for the money no the defense team was in callahan's conference room discussing the case when one of the first year students spoke up her name was l woods as soon as callahan mentioned that brooke windham was basically a fitness celebrity, Elle perked up. She said, do you mean Brooke Taylor?
Starting point is 00:06:07 Professor Callahan checked his file and said, yeah, maiden name Taylor. Do you know her? And Elle was like, uh, yeah. She went to the same sorority as me, Delta Nu, and she's completely gifted. She can make you lose like three pounds in one class. Is that real? I think i think so i mean she's
Starting point is 00:06:27 completely gifted wow and professor callahan was like yeah well she's more than likely completely guilty too oh damn she was seen standing over her husband's dead body oh yeah that's not great nope no it looked pretty shitty yeah it's not great at all i'm sorry he was did you say shot to death yes okay all right so hayworth's 26 year old daughter chutney and the chutney yes Rich people names, man. Rich people nonsense. And the pool boy, Enrique, both saw Brooke standing over Hayworth's dead body. She was covered in blood. By that point, he'd been dead for about 30 minutes. So Callahan mused that she'd taken that time to stash the gun somewhere. Uh-huh.
Starting point is 00:07:25 Elle was annoyed. She believed in Brooke. She said, I don't think Brooke could have done this. Exercise gives you endorphins. Endorphins make you happy. Happy people just don't shoot their husbands. They just don't. She's fucking right.
Starting point is 00:07:39 While everyone around that table laughed at her. Poor Elle. Her argument, though rock solid, while everyone around that table laughed at her. Poor Elle. Her argument, though rock solid, did not sway the rest of the defense team. So the whole, like, she's the only one on the defense team that is like, I think she's innocent. It's hard to know for certain, but it definitely seemed that way. It seemed that in that room, for sure, Callahan thought Brooke was guilty, and
Starting point is 00:08:07 everyone else, I think they were so busy sucking up to Callahan that Elle was really the only one defending her. A while later, the group went to talk with Brooke in prison. She was adamant. She said, I didn't do it. I walked in, I saw my husband dead
Starting point is 00:08:23 on the floor, I screamed my head off and in came Enrique Enchutney. But Callahan was skeptical. He was like, you were covered in blood. And Brooks said, why would I kill my husband? Callahan was like, insurance? A love affair? Pure, unadulterated hatred believe me the da will come up with plenty of reasons and reasons not just raisins i feel like i said raisins there might be trail mix we just don't know if you're lucky some m&ms yes did i tell you about the time that Kyla and Jay packed for a camping trip and they didn't pack for a mix that had M&M's in it? Norm got pissed. I thought Norm was going to die. Callahan didn't sugarcoat it.
Starting point is 00:09:18 He said, you two had a 34 year age gap. That's not going to look good to a jury. Mm hmm. But Brooks said, then show them a picture of his dick. That ought to clear a few things up. What? Mm-hmm. Ooh, she knew what she wanted. I guess so. After a tense moment, Callahan said, look, I believe you, but I'm worried that the jury won't. We need an alibi. So here's the weird part of this story.
Starting point is 00:09:54 Brooke would not give her alibi. She said she had one. She had one. She wouldn't tell it to anybody. Ooh, must be bad then. Or non-existent, right? Yeah, also true. Later, the defense team was alone, and they tried to sort the case out.
Starting point is 00:10:13 They were like, if Brooke didn't do it, then who did? Elle said, either Chutney or the ex-wife. But Callahan was like, no, that doesn't make any sense. Chutney has a trust fund. She didn't need the money. And the ex-wife was in Aspen at the time of the murder oh so it couldn't have been yeah she was like down in cosmos at the bar so they needed an alibi l got to work this time she went back to the prison alone she brought a gift basket with all the necessities calvin klein 700 thread count sheets the entire
Starting point is 00:10:47 clinique skincare line yeah this stuff you're gonna need in prison aromatherapy candles alufa and the bible and of course by that i mean an issue of cosmo magazine so the sorority girl bible yeah you're gonna need to know 69 ways to please your man in prison brandy wow you tell me that's not a headline in cosmo is the in prison on there no No, no. That's separate. I feel like that's a really limited demographic. Magazines are dying. Sometimes you try to go more niche. So Elle gives her these things and then she kind of gets to the point. She's like, we need your alibi. And Brooke was just like, you know, they're on the prison phones. brooke's like pleading no i
Starting point is 00:11:46 can't tell you it's too shameful here's a transcript of their conversation okay l wait do they know that all of their conversations are recorded uh l seems pretty smart so i don't think that at least all right so no they're on they're in the visiting room. Oh, like talking back and forth. Okay, I gotcha. But I still think somebody listens in on those conversations. Of course they do. Yeah, of course they do.
Starting point is 00:12:12 Okay. L. It could save you. Brooke. No, that's just it. It would ruin me. L. How?
Starting point is 00:12:22 Yeah, what does that mean? Brooke. L. How? Yeah, what does that mean? Brooke. I've made my fortune off my ability to perfect women's bodies with Brooke's butt buster workout. L. I know. You helped me go from a six to a four.
Starting point is 00:12:36 Brooke. That's great. Um. On the day of Hayworth's murder. I was gay. I was a sexist. She was what? I was murder, I was getting liposuction. She was what? I was getting liposuction. L.
Starting point is 00:12:51 What? I was getting liposuction. L. Huh? Liposuction! L. Oh my gosh! Brooke, I know! I'm a fraud.
Starting point is 00:13:08 It's not like normal women can have this ass. If my fans knew that I bought it, I would lose everything. I've already lost my husband. I would rather go to jail than lose my reputation. Oh my gosh! It just shows the difference in times. This was 2002, where I guess you'd get fat removed from your ass. Yeah, now you're getting fat injected into your ass.
Starting point is 00:13:32 Plunged into it. I mean, you personally. I've been trying to get him to move ear cartilage back there. So, Elle understood. She left the prison and the next day went to callahan's office she was not planning on saying anything about brooks about her secret meeting with brook but here's the thing callahan had the visitor's records and he saw that l had gone to visit her shit he's gonna get pissed right so yeah he's like, why'd you go there? And she had to admit she'd gone to get Brooke's alibi.
Starting point is 00:14:09 And he was like, okay, what was it? She wouldn't say. She couldn't break the bonds of sisterhood. Mm-hmm. They took like a sorority oath or something? Yeah. If you're ever charged with murder. I had to be like really sing-songy.
Starting point is 00:14:30 So Callahan was pissed. He goes, screw sisterhood. This is a murder trial, not some scandal at the sorority house. I want the alibi. But Elle wouldn't budge. She didn't give it. No, she wouldn't do she wouldn't wow I really admire that I know me too but now they got to figure out a way to argue this case without an alibi right that's not an easy task uh no it's not yeah
Starting point is 00:14:59 most of the defense team didn't understand why l kept her word to brooke they were like are you crazy and then this super hot douchey preppy guy named warner huntington the third oh fuck rich people names was like you should tell the alibi think Think about yourself. Think about how it would help you. If you tell Callahan, it could be good for your career. Mm-hmm. Okay, so side note, but I think it's relevant. That was really hard to hear because, you know, it was immoral, but also because she was in love with Warner. Oh, my gosh.
Starting point is 00:15:42 So they had, like, a history? They had a history. So as a matter of fact the only reason she even went to harvard was because she was in love with warner wow they dated for a while and l always thought they were going to get married but on the night she was certain he was going to propose he dumped her shit and then he got engaged to this brunette named vivian who was like a dead ringer for selma blair wow i mean that's such a striking like look yes sure yes what was her name vivian kensington rich people names
Starting point is 00:16:20 l followed warner to law school to win him back. And now she was here kicking ass and he was sort of revealing himself to be a super douche. Imagine that. Shocker. If you ask me, he'd been a douche all along. He'd had it in his
Starting point is 00:16:39 heart the whole time. So at any rate, Elle refused to disclose the alibi and they needed to interview Hayworth's ex-wife. She was hiding out in a spa in the Berkshires. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:16:55 So Elle and this guy named Emmett Richmond, who was like an associate he worked with Callahan, went to this spa to interview her. They got there and Mrs. Wyndham Vandermark was laying out.
Starting point is 00:17:07 So picture this. She's got like one of those blue face masks on. She's got the cucumber slices over her eyes. Her hair's up, you know, in like a towel, and she's wrapped in some weird gold foil blanket thing. Here's a transcript of that interview. Mrs. Wyndham Vandemark. So I hear that little tart from California shot, poor Hayworth.
Starting point is 00:17:30 Emmett. Well, that's what we're trying to prove didn't happen, actually. What's Emmett look like? Is he super hot? He's like, is he going to be like the dark horse? Picture like Owen Wilson, but with dark hair okay so like owen wilson's brother kind of yeah okay all right all right i'm picturing him okay you got him yeah and like okay i mean i kind of want them to get together i was gonna say i feel like something's gonna happen between emmet and l right but in a minute here
Starting point is 00:18:05 she's gonna call him a butthead so you know okay we just don't know what's gonna happen with these two yeah you know so l says do you have any reason to believe that it did mrs windham vandemark well i never actually met the woman but my daughter tells me she can be quite the little bitch. Oh, who's calling my dad. Oh no. Okay. Okay. Where the hell was I? I feel like I hear Norm's voice.
Starting point is 00:18:37 Is he really not here? I mean, the car. Oh, then maybe he is gone. Some, I hear somebody's voice. Like,
Starting point is 00:18:43 yeah. Is it in the next door neighbor? Okay. Do you just, how often do I hear somebody's voice. Is it in the next door neighbor? Okay. How often do you hear Norm's voice? All the time. Is that how you fall asleep? Just a gaming historian video? I just loop them.
Starting point is 00:19:01 Oh, I remember where I was. Okay. Mrs. Wyndham Vandemark. Well, I never actually met the woman, but my daughter tells me she can be quite the little bitch. Ooh! Emmett. Now, did your daughter ever mention anything to you about the relationship between Brooke and Hayworth? Mrs. Wyndham Vandemark.
Starting point is 00:19:23 Well, she did say that they humped like gorillas. Oh my god! I guess it wasn't enough for Brooke. Emmett. Uh, why do you say that? Mrs. Wyndham Vandermark. Haven't you seen the
Starting point is 00:19:39 cabana boy? Oh my god! Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha! This is turning into quite the episode. I think maybe we should stop and explain, depending on what gets cut out of this. So my phone has gone off twice. Yeah. Norman and I...
Starting point is 00:20:00 Have been house shopping for eight million years. Yes, we have. We've been outbid many times because I'm cheap. You are your father's daughter. Oh, God, I am. This is the problem when you're a TJ Maxx shopper. When it comes time to buy a house, you're like, I don't think it's worth that. So we've been outbid many times.
Starting point is 00:20:32 We found this house. That's awesome. Oh, my God. We love it. It's amazing. We love it. Like there have only been two houses that we've ever loved yeah and the first one we didn't get it we still to this day refer to it as the one that got away i mean it had like all kinds of
Starting point is 00:20:53 old charm oh yeah it was so cool i can't even talk about it i cried when we lost the bed yeah and i was even such a creep that i wrote the people who got it a letter like, hey, I don't know what you paid, but I'll pay you more. Like, let's make a deal. And they were like, fuck off. We got a great house. And by that, I mean, they just didn't respond. But so we've been putting in offers on this one house that we love going back and forth. I mean, like I told you you i and i'm sorry i
Starting point is 00:21:27 know this is an overshare nervous pooper christian's a nervous pooper anxiety poops all for days anxiety poops for days um so my dad just called he said it's a verbal yes, nothing signed yet. So, like, I could still take a nervous shit at any minute. Jesus, please go to the bathroom and just do it right there. Well, no, we're podcasting and I take this seriously, Brandi. I'm not going to just get up. So, yeah, the second call was from Norman. Yay! I'm so excited.
Starting point is 00:22:01 You need to get more excited. You're just anxious right now. I'm super anxious because... Get past that. Get so excited. You need to get more excited. You're just anxious right now. I'm super anxious because... Get past that. Get to excited. No, I can't. Here's my thing. I'm always like...
Starting point is 00:22:14 And this has happened every time we've ever gotten a house. It's like, oh my God, we got a house. Oh my God, that's so much money. Oh my God, we totally overpaid. That's the only reason we got this place. So, you know, I'm just a little bit of a mess i'm super excited i i'm excited too good it oh my god it's such a cool house yeah it's really cool okay okay let's fucking talk about fucking wyndham vandermark again sorry we've been
Starting point is 00:22:43 interrupted in her interview for like i don don't know, five times now. That was the weirdest noise I've heard. Did you hear that? Did I hear it? I don't know what that was. It came from your body. I mean, I'm the one with the anxiety shits. Do you have something going on?
Starting point is 00:22:58 No, so Mrs. Wyndham Vandermark, she has her cucumber slices off. And basically what she says is, you know, Brooke is horny as can be. And she was going after the cabana boy. Oh, my gosh. Okay, wait. I don't know if you know this. I don't know if this has been talked about yet. Right.
Starting point is 00:23:21 There must be not that big of an age difference between Chutney and Brooke, right? They're the same age. Oh, shit. Okay. All right. They're both 26. Uh-huh. So just imagine how that might feel.
Starting point is 00:23:36 Uh-huh. Not great. Nope. Not great at all. But Elle knew in her gut that Mrs. Wyndham Vandermark was lying because of her icky brown hair. Oh. That was all she had to go on. Elle must be a blonde. Elle is super blonde.
Starting point is 00:24:00 Soon, the trial started. Things didn't look good for the defense. They didn't have a usable alibi, and Brooke totally looked unsympathetic to the jury. Hayworth's daughter, Chutney Windham, was the first witness to take the stand. She talked about discovering Brooke, standing over her father's dead body. Next, Mrs. Windham Vandemark took the the stand followed by enrique salvatore the pool boy at what age are you a pool man though i don't know that anybody's ever a pool man aren't they always a pool boy you always hear them called the pool boy yeah i mean he didn't let's get Norman's vote on this. Norman.
Starting point is 00:24:46 Norman doesn't even have to be here. And I 100% know his vote is for pool boy. Yeah. Norman refers to himself as a boy. It's disgusting. It's revolting. I love it. I hate it.
Starting point is 00:24:59 I hate it. I feel like I have to pause and tell. So like a couple of weeks ago before baby Henry was born, my mom and sister were over at the house and like, we were talking about maybe going shopping for like last minute baby stuff. And Norman goes, Oh, you know,
Starting point is 00:25:19 target has cute boy clothes. And my mom was like, oh, and you could tell she was thinking like how sweet that Norman is thinking about baby clothes for Henry. And then Kyla started laughing. She's like, just so you know, Mom, he means adult boys. He means
Starting point is 00:25:38 like for himself. As soon as the pool man, pool boy took the stand, the prosecutor held up a blue sequined thong. Oh. She said, Mr. Salvatore, can you tell us what this is? And he said, my uniform. His uniform?
Starting point is 00:26:01 With a blue sparkly thong? Yeah. He cleaned the pool in a blue sparkly thong. What's wrong with that, Brandy? What do you clean the pool in? Why would Brooke have this sexy man clean her pool in a sequined thong? That doesn't sound great. No, it doesn't.
Starting point is 00:26:22 And the answer seemed pretty clear. But the prosecutor asked anyway. She said, are you or are you not having an affair with Ms. Windham? And he admitted it. He and Brooke were having sex. When court broke for lunch, the defense was in shambles. They felt like they had no shot. But Brooke kept defending herself.
Starting point is 00:26:45 She was like, you know, a Delta new would never have sex with a guy who wears a thong. I just liked watching him clean the filter, which I don't understand at all. No, thank you. No,
Starting point is 00:27:00 no. Okay. Perhaps unpopular opinion here but i really think that only like 0.5 percent of the population looks good in a thong the rest of us absolutely need more coverage yeah it's like not a flattering look no do you remember when it was like the law everyone had to wear thongs yes yeah yes the yeast infections. Oh, God. You know, Vagisil had to love
Starting point is 00:27:31 the rise of the thongs. Should I cut this? Is this too much? I love it. Not enough podcasts mention Vagisil, I feel like. It's a real gap that we're filling right now so l believed brooke but she didn't know what to do she walked out of court got in line at the
Starting point is 00:27:55 water fountain and freaking enrique cut in front of her at the water fountain so she's standing there she's so annoying. So she starts tapping her shoe. And as soon as he finished drinking, he spun around and said, don't stomp your little last season Prada shoes at me, honey. Really? Elle's first reaction was, these aren't last season. But then it hit her. Enrique was gay. Gay men know designers. Straight men don't. Yeah. So she ran back into the courtroom to share her theory.
Starting point is 00:28:34 And Brooke was like, yes, he did leave a share tape in the pool house once. Oh, that decides it. But Callahan was not impressed. He thought that Elle was stupid, and so was her theory. When it came time to cross-examine Enrique, Callahan did a pretty shitty job. He was just like, do you have proof of the affair? And Enrique said, only the proof that's in my heart. And Callahan was like, meh, you know, that's not enough. So I mean,
Starting point is 00:29:06 it made no impact. Yeah. The judge was about to let Enrique step down. But Emmett, who was serving as co-counsel, believed Elle's theory. He was like, I want to ask a few questions. Here's how it went. Here's how it went. Emmett, did you ever take Mrs. Windham on a date? Enrique, yes. Emmett, where? Enrique, a restaurant in Concord where no one would recognize us. Emmett, how long have you been sleeping with Mrs. Windham?
Starting point is 00:29:42 Enrique, three months. Emmett, and your boyfriend's name is? Enrique, Three months. Emmett. And your boyfriend's name is? Enrique. Chuck. Exactly. So he just like stuck it in there. Had him like answering questions. Oh my gosh, that's so good. So everyone gasps.
Starting point is 00:29:58 The judge bangs her gavel. Enrique was panicked. So he tried to backtrack. And he's like, I thought you said friend. Chuck is just a friend. And at that Chuck leapt up from his spot in the gallery and he yelled, you bitch! And then he ran out. Oh my gosh, this is like a fucking movie. That evening, after court let out,
Starting point is 00:30:17 Callahan invited Elle to his office. He told her that he appreciated her insight and that he should have listened to her that day. He praised her. He said she was. Yeah, it's. Oh, no. I know where this is going.
Starting point is 00:30:32 Yeah, it's not good. Does he put his hand on her thigh while he is saying all this? More knee area. Oh, great. Yeah. Not good. No. She was disgusted.
Starting point is 00:30:49 not good no she was disgusted she immediately felt like he never he didn't bring me on to this case because he thought he i was smart he just liked the way i looked so she rebuffed his advances she decided to quit she told emmett everything and then it was like no you have to stay you're becoming who you're gonna be but she had her mind made up. She was going to quit the case and drop out of Harvard. So she packed up her convertible, hugged her manicurist goodbye, and cried. That's sad. But a funny thing happened in that salon. One of her law professors was in there getting her hair done, and she spun around in her chair and said, if you're going to let one stupid prick ruin your life,
Starting point is 00:31:36 you're not the girl I thought you were. Oh, my gosh! Yes! So as this was happening, Emmett and Vivian met with Brooke in prison, and Brooke told them she didn't like callahan she didn't care that he was the top defense attorney in massachusetts he did got excited for people who could not see that i was doing a wild hand gesture i like bent my straw like things things are happening he didn't trust her. She didn't trust him. Then Emmett let her in on what was going on.
Starting point is 00:32:09 He said Elle had quit because Callahan hit on her. That was all Brooke needed to hear. She walked into the courtroom that morning for her second day of trial, and she fired Callahan on the spot. Oh, my gosh. As soon as she did that, Elle burst into the courtroom dressed head to toe in pink. Of course she did. Her chihuahua Brewster poked his head out of her handbag. Right away, they ran into a hiccup. Callahan was like, you're a law student. You can't do this.
Starting point is 00:32:40 You're not a practicing attorney. But Elle pointed out a statute that allows law students to represent a client in court as long as they have a licensed attorney supervising them. Wow. Of course, Callahan said, well, I'm not going to supervise you. But then Emmett jumped in. He was like, that's fine. I'll supervise. Oh, my gosh. The prosecution was thrilled. Obviously. Obviously. They're like, that's fine. I'll supervise. Oh, my gosh. The prosecution was thrilled. Obviously. They're like, hello.
Starting point is 00:33:10 Yeah, let the dumb blonde take over. That's great. Things started out really rough for Elle. Chutney took the stand, and it took a while for Elle to figure out exactly what to ask her. Chutney told the jury that she was in the shower washing her hair so she didn't hear any gunshot and when she got out of the shower she discovered her father dead and brooke standing over him covered in blood l kind of stuttered and stumbled she looked really stupid it was painful to buy time she was like uh what had you done earlier that day and chutney said
Starting point is 00:33:47 i went to the gym got a latte got a perm and went home oh brandy oh brandy why why are you reacting that way Do you just love lattes and perms? No, hairstylist here. Okay, drop some knowledge. I can tell you that you can't wash your perm for 48 to 72 hours after receiving it. So did she have a perm on the stand, Kristen? Uh, yeah. Her curls were intact. Uh-huh.
Starting point is 00:34:21 She's fucking lying. Elle thought the same thing. A light bulb went on in her head. She said, Miss Wyndham, had you ever gotten a perm before? And Chutney said, yeah, twice a year since I was 12. Elle turned to the jury. She said, you know, a girl in my sorority decided to get a perm once. We all tried to talk her out of it. Curls weren't a good look for her. Then she politely turned to Chutney and said, She didn't have your bone structure.
Starting point is 00:34:53 Elle went on to explain that her sorority sister, Tracy Marchinko, on the same day she got the perm, entered a wet t-shirt contest where she was hosed down from head to toe. Yeah, I'm familiar with how a wet t-shirt contest works. I hosed down from head to toe yeah i'm familiar with how wet i thought they just hosed down the boobs yeah i mean you're probably right typically i mean never been a part of one uh same thank god i was not a member of a sorority neither was i i hope they're not like a normal i don I don't think so. It's not great. Elle turned back to Chutney.
Starting point is 00:35:30 She said, why is it that Tracy Marcinko's curls were ruined when she got hosed down? Chutney didn't hesitate. She said, because they got wet. Elle had her in a trap. Everyone knows that the cardinal rule of perm maintenance Is that you're not supposed to get your hair wet For at least 24 hours after getting a perm And Brandy says 48
Starting point is 00:35:52 That's right And since Chutney had had roughly 30 perms in her lifetime She should know that And since she wasn't in the shower washing her hair She would have heard the gun go off And she would have gone immediately down to see what was happening. And if that had happened, she would have caught Brooke with the gun still in her hand. Tears welled in Chutney's eyes. Finally, she lost control. She shouted, she's my age. Did she tell you that? How would you feel if your father married someone
Starting point is 00:36:21 who was your age? Elle fought back. She said, you, however, did have time to hide the gun, didn't you, Chutney, after you shot your father? Chutney, I didn't mean to shoot him. And then she points over at Brooke and she goes, I thought it was you walking through the door. Oh my gosh. The crowd gasped. Chutney was immediately taken away and charged with murder. You know, justice is so fast. Yes. And the judge immediately dismissed the case against Brooke and everyone cheered. Where are they now?
Starting point is 00:36:55 Yeah. You might ask. Yes. Did Emmett and Brooke hook up? Well, Emmett and Brooke. I meant Emmett and Elle. What twist? So Elle graduated from Harvard, and she was voted by the class to be their commencement speaker.
Starting point is 00:37:13 Afterward, she got a job at the top law firm in Boston. Nice. Good for her. Yeah. Vivian dumped Warner. She and Elle are now best friends. vivian dumped warner she and l are now best friends warner graduated from harvard without honors without a girlfriend and without any job offers good super douche l's manicurist paulette married a ups guy why am i telling you that i don't know It's just good for you to know. They're expecting their first child, a daughter
Starting point is 00:37:45 named Elle. Emmett quit Callahan's law firm and opened his own practice. And you're not going to believe this, but he's proposing to Elle tonight. Oh my gosh! This very
Starting point is 00:38:02 evening. This very evening? Yes. Oh my gosh. I loved that! Crazy very evening? Yes. Oh my gosh. I loved that! Crazy story, huh? It's so crazy. Hard to believe. It is hard to believe. All right.
Starting point is 00:38:16 All right. Are you ready to talk about two Ford Tauruses? Two Ford Tauruses. No, these are nearly identical cars. Oh, excuse me. But that's not all. There's murder and miscommunication. Oh, love it.
Starting point is 00:38:32 All right. It's 1992. It's 1992. Bill Gambini and Stan Rothstein were driving through rural Alabama in their 1964 mint metallic green Buick Skylark. Beautiful. Yes. This is like the sticks.
Starting point is 00:38:59 It's super rural. And these are two New York guys. They had both just gotten scholarships to ucla and they were driving across country okay it seems to me like they're taking a weird route yeah alabama yeah maybe they're doing like the super scenic route i guess so so they stop to pick up some road snacks at the sack of Suds convenience store. Combos and Twizzlers? Combos and Twizzlers.
Starting point is 00:39:30 We haven't talked about this. Oh, yeah. Yeah, we got to explain. So we have been having weekly movie nights. To, you know, broaden my horizons. Yes, Kristen doesn't watch movies. She hasn't seen anything. So Norm and I are taking it upon ourselves to-
Starting point is 00:39:43 I've seen Legally Blonde. blonde oh you have yeah oh yeah so since you haven't seen anything we're we're uh norm and i are enlightening you we're showing you the ways of the world and we're showing kristen a different movie every week so last or i don't know some week last, last week, this week, whatever, we watched Road Trip and we had road snacks while we watched it. So the funny thing was, like, you know, Norman was obsessed with, like, the road snacks. So we got combos, we got Twizzlers. But then we got to your house and he was like, we have to order a pizza. And then we didn't eat the road snacks. We didn't eat the combos at all.
Starting point is 00:40:25 Who's going to eat pizzeria combos when you've got pizza? A pizza. By the way, I've never had combos before because they look like dog treats. They're so good. I'm not going to say they're so good. They're a good car snack when you're on a road trip. Did you know that they're sponsored by NASCAR? They are? Doesn't that make a lot of sense? They're literally a road trip. Did you know that they're sponsored by NASCAR? They are?
Starting point is 00:40:45 Doesn't that make a lot of sense? They're literally a car snack. No, I, you know, I did enjoy them. Yeah. Okay. So these two guys, they're at the Sack of Suds. They're getting just like, they buy like 20 items. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:41:03 They get out to the car. 20 items? Yeah. I don't know. just ballpark okay they get out to the car they get in they drive away and one of them realizes it's um it's it's bill he realizes there's something in his pocket he reaches down it's a can of tuna he had had his arms full and he was like about to drop the can and so he'd stuck it in his pocket while he walked up to the counter okay to set the stuff out to pay and he'd forgotten it was in there so he'd inadvertently stolen this can of tuna from the sack of suds oh not really sure that tuna's a great car snack no it's not i'm sure
Starting point is 00:41:48 it was a convertible which does change things a little bit because if we're talking about a closed car i'm gonna fucking murder whoever is eating tuna in the car on a road trip. Okay. You guys, last week, Brandi and I were driving to lunch. I sneezed in the car. I thought you were going to kill me. Okay. It's more about just like sneezes in general. I don't, obviously you can't control a sneeze. No.
Starting point is 00:42:20 I mean, what do you want me to do? No. But like when you're in, lots of stuff sprays out when you're sneezing. And we were in a very confined space. I don't know. You've got a pretty big car. It is spacious. However, there is no car that will ever be spacious enough for me to feel like really good about someone sneezing in it.
Starting point is 00:42:45 Are you worried that it'll affect the resale value? Do you think like somebody's going to be like, has this car been sneezed? Clearly this car has been sneezed in. No, I just don't like it. I mean, have you ever had somebody sneeze next to you and get just like a little mist off of it? Oh yeah, it's the worst.
Starting point is 00:42:59 It's the worst. But I guess I didn't expect like, you know, as I was winding up for the sneeze, I saw your whole body changed. I can't even help it. I can't even help it. And I was just like, oh, my God. I just it's like a whole thing with me, like sneezes and mucus and all. I can't handle it.
Starting point is 00:43:19 Love it. Love every minute of it. I cannot handle it. I do not. Anyway, how dare you sneeze in my fucking car? So they are. He realizes that he's inadvertently stolen this can of tuna. Whoops.
Starting point is 00:43:37 You know. Oh, yeah. Not a huge deal. They're already on the road, right? All of a sudden. Yeah, they're on the road. All of a sudden there's police cars everywhere. They're pulled over.
Starting point is 00:43:46 They're arrested. They're like, we know what you did back there at the Sack of Suds. And he's like, oh my God, all of this over a can of tuna? That's even worse. I'm picturing like a
Starting point is 00:44:03 grocery bag full to an end. Is it in the cans or is it out? Oh, it's out, baby. So, Bill and Stan are taken to the police department. And the police are being a little bit weird about it. They're not really telling them what's going on. They're separated. They're put in two different interrogation rooms.
Starting point is 00:44:29 And the sheriff, I mean, this is a small town. So the sheriff comes in and talks to Bill. And he's like, we know what you did. And he's like, I swear it was an accident. Like, I really did not mean to. I, you know, it really was not intentional. And he's like, what do you mean it's not intentional? How do you accidentally?
Starting point is 00:44:57 And he's like, I mean, I really I really don't know. And this just goes on. And there's just like there's clearly a miscommunication happening. don't know and this just goes on and there's just like there's clearly a miscommunication happening yes all of a sudden the sheriff is like so what made you do it and he's like what do you mean what made me do it right and he's like you shot the clerk oh and bill is stunned because he has been like really admitting that he did something this whole time. Like he's like, yes, I did something, you know, by accident. Oh, no. He's admitting to stealing a can of tuna.
Starting point is 00:45:30 Right. And now he finds out that they're accusing him of shooting the clerk. Oh, my God. The sack of suds. And so the sheriff's like, you shot the clerk. And Bill goes, I shot the clerk. No, I shot the clerk. I shot the clerk i shot the clerk okay no could be a question right he's clarifying a question or is it a confession no it's not a confession oh my god
Starting point is 00:45:57 i don't know he said three times kristin i shot the clerk, and more incredulous every time, right? I don't know. According to the sheriff, confession. No. Yep. No. So Bill is charged with first degree murder. Oh my God. And his buddy Stan is charged with accessory to murder.
Starting point is 00:46:22 They're both arrested. They're taken to jail for holding. They're put in the same cell. But it's like, it's kind of like, like a pod. Like there's other, right.
Starting point is 00:46:34 There's other side characters available, but they're the only two that are in it at this point. Gotcha. But Stan is fucking losing his mind. He's like, someone's going to come in this, in one of these bunks and they're going to ass rape us. He's sure that they're getting ass raped that night. Well, that would be a grave concern.
Starting point is 00:46:56 It would be. So Bill's like, we're going to be fine. You know, I called my mom. I totally forgot. My cousin just passed the bar in New York. He's going to come down. He's going to represent us. Well, did he pass the bar in Alabama? He did not, but Kristen, he's an attorney and he's free.
Starting point is 00:47:20 But you have to pass the bar in the state where you're going to. You have permission to argue a case. Can you perhaps. OK. So they're just in jail just waiting to be ass raped, be ass raped, figure out what's going on. This like they can't believe this crazy miscommunication like obviously they know they didn't shoot any clerk but somehow they went to the sack of suds and shortly after they left the clerk was shot to death right and the store was
Starting point is 00:47:59 robbed right and they don't know anything that's all and they don't know anything they know that they stole a can of tuna and that's it so So while they're sitting in their cell one day, this guy comes in and Bill is asleep in the bunk and Stan sits up and he's like, oh God, oh God, it's a, it's a new one. They put somebody in with us. And this guy is real rough. He's like a real like New York type. He's got a leather jacket on how many new york types do they have in this alabama prison i know right yeah yeah okay it is it is odd so he takes his jacket off he starts rolling his sleeves up and he's like so what do you think like should i do you first or should i do him first no yeah and he's like losing his
Starting point is 00:48:46 mind he's like this is it this is when i get ass raped and so he starts like to try and shake bill away because bill's sleeping and he rolls over it's bill's cousin he's there to interview them so that he can start preparing his their. Okay. This lawyer has jokes. Classic miscommunication. Oh, wait, so he wasn't actually... He wasn't even meaning, like, yeah, no. He meant like, should I interview you first or should I interview him first? Excellent. So Bill's super grateful that his cousin, Vincent Gambini, has come down to Alabama to argue this case for him. He's slightly concerned because his background is in personal injury law and he's just passed the bar. I mean, how do you even have a background
Starting point is 00:49:45 in anything at that point? And he's never argued a single case in court before. I would be concerned too. Well, Stan is like, fuck this. Absolutely not. I'm taking the public defender. Uh-huh. So some time passes.
Starting point is 00:50:02 They've done their preparations for court. The trial is here. The public defender has been great. Like, he's very buttoned up. He's, you know, got everything together. Right. Stan's feeling really great about it. Meanwhile, Bill's like, fuck, I mean, I guess I got to go with my cousin, right?
Starting point is 00:50:20 Right. My cousin Vincent. Yeah. Yeah. right my cousin vincent yeah my cousin vincent came all the way here from new york i can't tell him that he's not allowed to argue this case right so it's the first day of trial and fucking vincent up I think he preferred Vinny like most people called him Vinny. Sure. So Vinny has been having a rough fucking time in Alabama.
Starting point is 00:50:51 He can't sleep every night. There's something he keeps moving to like different hotels and stuff because like at one. I mean, this is a small fucking town. This is very rural. As I said, one night a fucking train rolls through at 4 a.m and wait the whistle wakes him up so he went down at this particular hotel and asked the asked the front desk person like is that something that happens every day and the guy's like oh no and he's like oh good okay great so then he stays there another night the next morning. Same thing. Uh-huh.
Starting point is 00:51:31 Train comes through, fucking loud ass whistle, wakes him up, and he goes back down to the front desk and he's like, you told me that that was, you know, that was very unusual. Uh-huh. And he's like, oh, yeah, it is. It was late. It usually comes through at 3.30. So like, it's just things like that just keep happening the next place he stays it's like right next to like a hog farm and like they feed the hogs every morning at 4 a.m and it's loud as fuck problem after problem right the problems don't stop there he shows up in court and immediately has problems with the judge. Judge Chamberlain Haller.
Starting point is 00:52:08 Haller, Haller, Hallier. I don't know. His name's Chamberlain. Okay. Which I like. Yeah, sure. Yeah. Go with it.
Starting point is 00:52:14 I'm here for it. And he and Judge Chamberlain are not getting along. I don't think I'm allowed to call the judge by his first name. What if when it sounds like a last name... It does sound like a last name! So that's not the only problem though. The prosecutor
Starting point is 00:52:35 very good friends with the judge as you might expect in a small town. Yes. So the judge doesn't like anything about Vinny. He doesn't like the way he dresses. He doesn't like the way he talks. He has a New York accent.
Starting point is 00:52:53 He showed up in court in slacks and a sweater and a leather jacket. And the judge was like, absolutely not. Will you ever show up in my courtroom like this again? Whoa. ever show up in my courtroom like this again whoa if you show up dressed like this again i will find you in contempt of court and you will go to jail damn yeah okay so he's like our vinny's like okay i gotta get a suit you know whatever so vinny also has a potty mouth and he like let a couple f-words slide in court and stuff like that and just really not good really really off to a terrible start with the judge so the trial's underway the public defender gets up to make his opening argument i don't know if it's his opening
Starting point is 00:53:40 argument or if he's actually interrogating his first witness um i didn't actually write that down so i believe they call it questioning questioning his first witness excuse me he gets up remember i told you he's been buttoned up this whole time he's dressed very appropriately for court sure um stan is really feeling great about his representation he gets up and he And he, under the pressure of court, has the worst stutter on the planet. And he can't even get out a single word. Oh, no. Yes. And so he has to like sit down and Vinny has to get up and start questioning.
Starting point is 00:54:23 Yeah, it's really bad. Stan ends up having to fire him because he can't even question anybody. Yeah. So the trial's going along and it's not looking good. Right. The prosecution brings forth three eyewitnesses who can say that they saw a green 1964 Buick Skylark pull in to the sack of suds. Two men with white men with dark hair matching Bill and Stan's descriptions get out of it, go in, and then a short time later come running out and one of the
Starting point is 00:55:07 eyewitnesses remembers hearing shots fired right before they shot saw the two men come running out it's really not looking good yeah so vinny is super stressed well yeah things are not going his way. That's terrible. He ends up actually being thrown in jail a couple times. What? Just because of arguing with the judge and stuff. Yeah, he said, unfucking believable to the judge. Yeah, that's not good.
Starting point is 00:55:33 Yeah, you can't say it to the judge. No. So, all of a sudden, though, things start clicking for Vinny. He's going to pull this off, Kristen. How? Those eyewitnesses. Okay. So, the first one. This little old woman He's going to pull this off, Kristen. How? Those eyewitnesses.
Starting point is 00:55:46 Okay. So the first one, this little old woman with these really thick glasses. And she says that she saw the two men enter the store, heard the shots. A short time later, the men came running out, drove off in their 1964 mint green Buick Skylark. So he's like, how far away? So she's on a stand. Yeah. And Vinny's like, OK, tell me how far away your home is from the sack of suds. And she says, oh, about 100 feet.
Starting point is 00:56:22 And he says, OK, now I see that you're wearing glasses. How long have you worn glasses? And she said, oh, since I was a little girl. And he said, OK, now over that time, have you gotten new prescriptions? And she said, yeah, I get a stronger prescription, you know, every couple of years. And so Vinny's like, well, do you think maybe it's time for a new prescription now? And she's like, no, I see just fine. And he's like, okay, let's test it out. So he goes up to the stand and he gives her the end of a tape measure to hold on to it she holds on to it and he backs up 50 feet he's got this tape measure strung all the way across this courtroom but he goes all the way back to the doors so it's 50 feet so half the distance
Starting point is 00:57:17 okay that she said her home was from the sack of suds and so she he says okay i'm gonna hold up my hand you tell me how many fingers i'm holding up so immediately the judge fucks this up yeah because vinny holds up two fingers and he asks the woman to tell him and the judge says to the court reporter mark the record let the record show that he's holding up two fingers so many has to be like hold on okay let's try this again witness and only the witness yeah please tell me how many fingers i'm holding up so now i believe he holds up four fingers yeah yeah and she says two oh and so he keeps his fingers held up and he walks closer and closer and closer to her until she can finally see the correct number of fingers that he's actually holding up.
Starting point is 00:58:14 And she's like, he says, what do you think? What do you think now? And she said, I think it might be time for a new prescription. Yeah. So, okay. Oh, that's good. It's good. That's really good. It's really good.
Starting point is 00:58:29 Yeah. So first witness, eyewitness taken care of, no longer credible. Second witness, this real country guy. He also lives close to the Sack of Suds. And he said he was sitting in his living room and he heard the shots and he looked out and he saw the two men run out of the sack of suds and get in a mint green buick skylark and take off and he positively identified stan and bill as those two men from his living room he was able to do this okay so vinnie goes up to the stand and he starts laying out pictures for this witness. And so the first one, he hands it to the witness and he's like, tell me what's in this picture.
Starting point is 00:59:16 And he says, a window. And Vinny's like, yeah, good, good. All right, next one. And he's like, and but he's like yeah good good all right next one and he's like what's this one and uh and he's like that's the screen on my window and so then he's like all right all right we're we're doing well we're doing well he's like what about this one what's all that what's all that brown crusty stuff and he's like the witness like looks at the picture and then looks at vinnie and he's very confused and he pauses for a second and he's like dirt and he's like very good excellent excellent we're we're doing well we're doing well and he hands him another picture and he's like what's this and he said those are the bushes in front of my window and shows him another picture what's this that's the tree right outside my window great excellent he shows him another picture uh-huh what are all these little things
Starting point is 01:00:18 on that tree and the guy looks at it and he's like again he's a little bit confused and he's like The guy looks at it and he's like, again, he's a little bit confused and he's like, uh, leaves? He's like, excellent. Exactly. Exactly. They're leaves. And so then he puts it all together, Kristen.
Starting point is 01:00:41 He's like, you're telling me that from sitting in your living room, you looked out your went dirty window with a rusty screen through these bushes through that tree and through all these leaves uh-huh and you saw those two men run out of the sack of suds oh that's awesome yes That is awesome. Yes. And so next witness down. Done. Yep. The third witness said that he he saw two men matching the defendant's descriptions. He was sure that it was the defendants walk in to the sack of suds. He made himself breakfast and then when he was ready to eat his breakfast he saw those men again running out um and he heard the gunshots
Starting point is 01:01:34 and so then he's up there and he's like okay do you think it's possible that you saw these two men walk into the sack of suds. They went in there. They bought their items. They left. And then another car, nearly identical, pulled up. Two completely different men walked in and shot the clerk, robbed the store, came out, and then left. And that's who you saw leaving the store.
Starting point is 01:02:07 Mm-hmm. And the guy said, absolutely not. And Vinny says, how can you be so sure? Yeah. And he said, there wasn't time. And he said, OK, well, how long was it between when you saw the men walk into the store and when you heard the shots and saw them run out? And the man says, five minutes. He said, five minutes.
Starting point is 01:02:34 OK, so you made your entire breakfast in five minutes? And the man said, yeah, it only takes five minutes. And he said, oh, OK. No. What did you have for breakfast? And the man said, eggs and grits. Mm-mm-mm, no. And Vinny says, huh, I like grits.
Starting point is 01:02:55 I never had grits before now. This has been a thing. Every breakfast that Vinny has ordered when he's been in this Alabama town has come with grits. And he's like, what the fuck is this? They're so good. They're Alabama town has come with grits and he's like what the fuck is this they're so good they're so good I love grits yes so so Vinny's like oh yeah I really like grits too uh do you make instant grits and the witness is like offended he's like no self-respecting southerner eats instant grits yeah and like a light bulb goes off for vinnie and he's really feeling now he's like wandering oh yeah the core of his strut and his stuff
Starting point is 01:03:36 and he's like okay so you're telling me that you saw the men go into the store. You put on your grits. And then by the time your grits were ready, only five minutes had passed. And you saw them come out. And he's like, the witness is like, yeah, of course. And he's like, hmm, anybody who's ever made grits before can tell you that it takes 20 minutes to cook grits. What do you have? Some kind of magic grits before can tell you that it takes 20 minutes to cook grits. What do you have? Some kind of magic grits? Yeah. Do the laws of physics cease to exist in your kitchen?
Starting point is 01:04:17 And the witness has like totally clammed up at this point. Yeah, he's embarrassed. He's like, I don't I don't know. Mm hmm. And so Vinny's like really railing it on. And now the prosecution, the prosecutor has stood up and he's like, object, object. The judge is banging his gavel. And then he just keeps saying over and over again.
Starting point is 01:04:42 Do you think you may have been wrong about the time do you think you may have been wrong about how long the men you saw enter the store were in there and finally the witness is like yes i may have been wrong oh yes so good so good so good okay next witness down yeah so he's discredited three witnesses who can place Bill and Stan at the scene. Right. But his version of what he's putting forth is so unbelievable. He is telling the jury that he believes that Bill and Stan drove up to the sack of suds, went in, bought their snacks, drove up to the sack of suds, went in, bought their snacks, left. And then another car, nearly identical, also drove up, entered the store, shot the clerk, and then ran off. So that these witnesses have seen two different cars that just look almost identical.
Starting point is 01:05:44 And he has no way to prove it yeah until his star witness okay okay okay so vinny has this girlfriend she's a hairdresser after my own heart um and she's fucking amazing she's hilarious like she's beautiful she's fucking amazing. She's hilarious. She's beautiful. She's got this amazing hair. Are you just describing yourself right now? Maybe. She's super smart and funny. So she has been with Vinny for 10 years. And their deal was that they would get married after he won his first case. Only he couldn't pass the bar bar so he never had a case
Starting point is 01:06:27 so she's like i'm they've been arguing this whole time like she's done but she's like this genius mechanic because she grew up in a family of mechanics her dad all of her brothers are all mechanics and so vinny one night is looking it's like the last night of the trial. He's got to put forth some kind of something to prove his version. Yeah. He knows it's true, but he's got to make sure the jury knows it's true. Yeah. And he's looking through these pictures that his girlfriend has taken. And there's a picture of tire tracks from the scene.
Starting point is 01:07:04 And the tire tracks, there's something very specific about them. Like they go up on a median and one tire stays down, but the tracks are the same. And that's when Vinny realizes that there was something very specific about this car that could not possibly have been a 1964 Buick Skylark. What was it? Oh, wouldn't you like to know? Yes, I would.
Starting point is 01:07:28 Why don't we let his girlfriend tell you? So he calls her to the stand. Uh-huh. And she's pissed at him. Yeah. They've gotten into fights this whole time that he's been there. Right. She's had to bail him out of jail for being, you know, in contempt of court multiple times.
Starting point is 01:07:43 So she will not answer his questions. Her name's Lisa. So Lisa is like on the stand and like he's walking up and asking her questions and like showing her pictures and she's literally like turning away and won't make eye contact. He has to ask the judge to force her to answer and force her to take the picture. Ask the judge to force her to answer and force her to take the picture. And so he shows her the picture and he's like, asks her, you know, you know, basically, could these tire marks have been made by a 1964 Buick Skylark? And she looks at it and she looks at it.
Starting point is 01:08:20 And then for her, too, like it's like a light bulb comes on and she's like, no, they couldn't. And he's like, I don't understand. Explain. Uh-huh. And she said a 1964 Buick Skylark had a solid axle so that if this car went up on a curb, the tire that was still on the ground would have tilted out and the tire marks would not be even because the axle wouldn't allow for like it's it's a solid axle. Yeah. But there is a car that looks almost identical to the Buick Skylark, the Pontiac Tempest. the Pontiac Tempest, which had the same length, same width, was available in metallic mint green.
Starting point is 01:09:19 And it had a split rear differential that would allow the tires to operate separately from each other. So if one tire went up on the curb, the axle would shift a bit and the tires would remain even. Whoa. Yes. So there was no way that the 1964 Buick Skylark made the tire tracks leaving the scene. The prosecution is shocked. Yeah. Their whole case has just fallen apart. Uh-huh.
Starting point is 01:09:50 But Vinny had one more surprise left. He called the bailiff to the stand. What? Why? Yes, because he had had him do an errand for him. Okay. On a break from court. so he calls the bailiff to the stand and he he had already told the bailiff what he needed and the bailiff kind of begrudgingly
Starting point is 01:10:17 did it but he comes in he's got this piece of paper and he's like so tell us what'd you find out and the bailiff's like well on a hunch i decided to check surrounding towns and it turns out that on the day of the shooting at the sack of suds a pontiac tempest metallic mint green was pulled over in a neighboring town no two men in it and a gun in the glove compartment and the exact amount of money that was stolen from the Sack of Suds. Well, well, well. So the charges were immediately dropped
Starting point is 01:10:55 for Bill and Stan and Vinny won his first case! How weird. In both our cases, the charges were dropped on the spot. Immediately, right? Isn't that so crazy? Justice was so fast. And then you just get to walk out of the courtroom right everyone cheered yes everyone did cheer yeah yeah it was pretty amazing yeah um i'm just really like i just feel really great for vinny i mean he
Starting point is 01:11:19 really needed that win and lisa too like she really loved vinny and now they're they were they got married after that that's awesome yeah that's awesome yeah and she was super cute like really kind of like picture marissa tomei got it yeah but like 20 years ago yeah like 20 years ago marissa tomei yeah yeah super funny super good looking should become clean. Do you think? Do you think people have picked up on it already, Kristen?
Starting point is 01:11:49 I hope to God they have. April Fools! This was so much fun. It was so much fun. These have not been real cases. If you have not picked up on it already Kristen told us the plot of legally blonde and I covered my cousin Vinny I'm sorry my cousin Vincent no so this was your idea you came up with this idea like a long time months ago I was like I've
Starting point is 01:12:17 got this idea for April Fool's I think it was fun I love April Fool's yes I know you do I've never I don't do April Fool's stuff so So I was inspired by you, Kristen. I'm a very inspiring person. Not enough people tell me that. And then a hero comes along with the strength to carry on. That's enough. We'll stop. For your benefit.
Starting point is 01:12:44 You know what I want to know yeah i want to know from people how long did it take you to figure it out yeah please give us your feedback let us know at what point you picked up let's let's not get our egos involved like no like you don't be honest like if it if it took you 20 minutes took you 20 minutes it's not an iq test but no this was super fun super fun i loved it i hope you guys have enjoyed this cute little bonus episode was it cute i think it was cute i think it was adorable super adorable like a little bunny or like a child in a beauty pageant. Oh! No, I think that's horrifying. It is. If you enjoyed this episode,
Starting point is 01:13:28 please, you know, join us for our regular episode, which will be out in a couple days. And it'll be real. Yeah. Real cases. That's right. Real people, real cases.
Starting point is 01:13:37 Wait, what's that from? It's the People's Court, right? People's Court, right? Yes. Podcast adjourned. And now for a note about our process. For this very special episode, we took scenes from our favorite movies and pretended they were real.
Starting point is 01:13:54 So we owe a huge thank you to those movies. For this episode, I got my info from the classic legal thriller, Legally Blonde. And I got my info from award-winning courtroom drama, my cousin Vinny. Happy April Fool's Day!

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.