Letters from an American - April 30, 2024

Episode Date: May 1, 2024

Get full access to Letters from an American at heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/subscribe

April 30th, 2024. This morning, Time Magazine published a cover story by Eric Quartalessa about what Trump is planning for a second term. Based on two interviews with Trump and conversations with more than a dozen of his closest advisors, the story lays out Trump's conviction that he was too nice in his first term and that he would not make such a mistake again. Cordelessa writes that Trump intends to establish an imperial presidency that would reshape America and its role in the world. He plans to use the military to round up, put in camps, and deport more than 11 million people. He is willing to permit Republican-dominated states to monitor pregnancies and prosecute people who violate abortion bans. He will shape the laws

by refusing to release funds appropriated by congress as he did in 2019 to try to get ukraine president volodymyr zelensky to smear hunter biden he would like to bring the department of justice under his own control pardoning those convicted of attacking the u.s capital on january 6 2021 and ending the u.s system of an independent judiciary 2021, and ending the U.S. system of an independent judiciary. In a second Trump presidency, the U.S. might not come to the aid of a European or Asian ally that Trump thinks isn't paying enough for its own defense. Trump would, Cortalessa wrote, gut the U.S. civil service, deploy the National Guard to American cities as he sees fit, close the White House Pandemic Preparedness Office, and staff his administration with acolytes who back his false assertion that

the 2020 election was stolen. To that list, former political director of the AFL-CIO, Michael Podhorzer, added on social media that if Trump wins, he could replace Supreme Court Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and 40-plus federal judges over 75 with young zealots. I asked him, don't you see why many Americans see such talk of dictatorship as contrary to our most cherished principles? Cordelessa wrote. No, Trump said. I think a lot of people like it. Time included the full transcripts and a piece fact-checking Trump's assertions.

The transcripts reflect the former president's scattershot language that makes little logical sense but conveys impressions by repeating key phrases and advancing a narrative of grievance. The fact-checking reveals that narrative is largely based on fantasy. Trump's own words prove the truth of what careful observers have been saying about Trump's plans based on their examination of MAGA Republican speeches, interviews, Project 2025, and so on, often define themselves accused of a liberal bias that makes them exaggerate the dangers of a second Trump presidency.

The idea that truthful reporting based on verifiable evidence is a plot by liberal media to undermine conservative values had it started in 1951 when William F. Buckley Jr., fresh out of Yale, published God and Man at Yale, the Superstitions of Academic Freedom. Fervently opposed to the bipartisan liberal consensus that the federal government should regulate business, provide a basic social safety net, protect civil rights, and promote infrastructure, Buckley was incensed that voters continued to support such a system. that fact-based public debate would enable people to choose the best option from a wide range of ideas, a tradition based in the Enlightenment, because such debate had encouraged voters to choose the liberal consensus, which he considered socialism.

Instead, he called for universities to exclude bad ideas, like the Keynesian economics on which the liberal consensus was based, and instead promote Christianity and free enterprise. Buckley soon began to publish his own magazine, The National Review, in which he promised to tell the violated businessman side of the story. But it was a confidential memorandum written in 1971 by lawyer Lewis M. Powell Jr. for a friend who chaired the Education Committee of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce that insisted the media had a liberal bias that must be balanced with a business perspective. economic system is under broad attack, Powell worried not about the communists, new leftists, and other revolutionaries who would destroy the entire system. They were, he wrote, a small minority. What he worried about were those coming from perfectly respectable elements of society, from the college campus, the pulpit, the media, the intellectual and literary journals, the arts and sciences, and from politicians. Businessmen must confront this problem as a

primary responsibility of corporate management, he wrote, launching a unified effort to defend American enterprise. Among the many plans Powell suggested for defending corporate America was keeping the media under constant surveillance to complain about criticism of the enterprise system and demand equal time. President Richard Nixon appointed Powell to the Supreme Court, and when Nixon was forced to resign for his participation in the scheme to cover up the attempt to bug the headquarters of the Democratic National Committee in the Watergate Hotel before the 1972 election, he claimed he had to leave not because he had committed a crime, but because the liberal media had made it impossible for him to do his job.

liberal media had made it impossible for him to do his job. Six years later, Ronald Reagan, who was an early supporter of Buckley's National Review, claimed the liberal media was biased against him when reporters accurately called out his exaggerations and misinformation during his 1980 campaign. In 1987, Reagan's appointees to the Federal Communications Commission abandoned the fairness doctrine that required media with a public license to present information honestly and fairly. Within a year, talk radio had gone national, with hosts like Rush Limbaugh electrifying listeners with his attacks on liberals and his warning that they were forcing socialism on the United States. By 1996, when Australian-born media mogul Rupert Murdoch started the Fox News Channel, or FNC, followers had come to believe that the news that came from a mainstream reporter was likely left-wing propaganda.

that came from a mainstream reporter was likely left-wing propaganda. FNC promised to restore fairness and balance to American political news. At the same time, the complaints of increasingly radicalized Republicans about the liberal media pushed mainstream media to wander from fact-based reality to give more and more time to the right-wing narrative. By 2018, both sidesing had entered our vocabulary to mean the media or public figures giving credence to the other side of a cause, action, or idea to seem fair or only for the sake of argument when the credibility of that side may be unmerited. In 2023, FNC had to pay almost $800 million to settle defamation claims made by Dominion voting systems after FNC hosts pushed the lie that Dominion machines had changed the outcome of the 2020 presidential election, and it has since tried to retreat from the more egregious

parts of its false narrative. News broke yesterday that Hunter Biden's lawyer had threatened to sue FNC for conspiracy and subsequent actions to defame Mr. Biden and paint him in a false light, the unlicensed commercial exploitation of his image, name, and likeness, and the unlawful publication of hacked intimate images of him. Today, FNC quietly took down from its streaming service its six-part mock trial of Hunter Biden, as well as a video promoting the series. Also today, Judge Juan Merchan, who is presiding over Trump's criminal trial for election fraud, found Trump in contempt of court for attacking witnesses and jurors. Merchan also fined Trump $1,000 per offense, required him to take down the nine social media posts at the heart

of the decision, and warned him that future violations could bring jail time. This afternoon, Trump's team deleted the social media posts. For the first time in history, a former U.S. president has been found in contempt of court. We know who he is. And today, Trump himself validated the truth of what observers who deal in facts have been saying about what a second Trump term would mean for the United States. the spokesperson for the Biden-Harris campaign, released a statement saying, not since the Civil War have freedom and democracy been under assault at home as they are today because of Donald Trump. Trump is willing to throw away the very idea of America to put himself in power. Trump is a danger to the Constitution and a threat to democracy. Tomorrow, May 1st, is Law Day, established in 1958 by Republican President Dwight D. Eisenhower as a national recognition of the importance of the rule of law. In proclaiming the holiday today, Biden said,

America can and should be a nation that defends democracy, protects our rights and freedoms, and pioneers a future of possibilities for all Americans. History and common sense show us that this can only come to pass in a democracy, and we must be its keepers. Bye, Michael Moss.