Letters from an American - December 9, 2024

Episode Date: December 10, 2024

Get full access to Letters from an American at heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/subscribe

December 9th, 2024. The sudden collapse of the Assad regime in Syria yesterday took oxygen away from the airing of President-elect Trump's interview with Kristen Welker of NBC's Meet the Press. The interview told us little that we didn't already know, but it did reinforce what we can expect in the new administration. As Tom Nichols pointed out after the interview, when Donald Trump ran for the presidency this year, he wasn't running to do anything. He was running to stay out of jail. The rest he doesn't care about. Nichols was reacting to the exchange that began when Welker asked the president-elect, do you have an actual plan at this point for health care? Trump answered, yes, we

have concepts of a plan that would be better. Still just concepts? Do you have a fully developed plan? Welker asked. The answer, nine years after Trump first said he would repeal the Affordable Care Act and replace it with something cheaper and better is still no. He went on to add, I am the one that saved Obamacare, although he spent his first term trying to weaken it. Trump also reiterated his plans for revenge against those he perceives to be his enemies. He told Welker that when he is president, the Department of Justice should pursue and jail the members of the House Select Committee to investigate the January 6th attack on the

U.S. Capitol, more commonly known as the January 6th Committee. He singled out committee leaders Representative Benny Thompson, a Democrat of Mississippi, and former Representative Liz Cheney, a Republican of Wyoming. But it was in his insistence on one specific lie that Trump was the most revealing. He told Welker that there were 13,099 murderers released into our country over the last three years. They're walking down the streets, they're walking next to you and your family, and they're very dangerous.

This statement sets Trump up to be a strong man who will save America from great danger, but it is a lie that has been repeatedly debunked. It originated in the September, 2024 letter from Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, to Representative Tony Gonzalez, a Republican of Texas, listing 13,099 people convicted of homicide as being non-detained. But it was in his insistence on one specific lie

that Trump was the most revealing. He told Welker that there were 13,099 murderers released into our country over the last three years. They're walking down the streets. They're walking next to you and your family, and they're very dangerous. This statement sets Trump up to be a strong man

who will save America from great danger, but it is a lie that has been repeatedly debunked. It originated in a September 2024 letter from Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, to Representative Tony Gonzalez, a Republican of Texas, listing 13,099 people convicted of homicide as being non-detained. As Alex Noorasta of the Libertarian Cato blog explains, non-detained does not mean free

to roam the streets. It simply means that those in prison for homicide are not currently detained by ICE. Once they have served their sentences, they go back into ICE's docket to be deported, unless their countries of origin don't have repatriation agreements with the US, a condition that affects a very small number of people. Releases of criminal migrants into the US drop during the Biden administration from the numbers released during Trump's term.

In addition, as Norasta points out, the 13,099 figure covers at least 40 years. Welker tried to correct Trump. The 13,000 figure I think goes back around 40 years, she said. No, it doesn't, Trump insisted. It's within the three-year period. It's during the Biden term.

Trump was intent on making Welker and the television audience accept an egregious lie, despite the fact it has been thoroughly debunked. His insistence echoed his determination in January 2017 to make the American people accept his lie that his inauguration crowd was bigger than that of his predecessor, Barack Obama, although we can see with our own eyes that he was lying. He was demanding we reject our own

experience and instead let him define how we see the country. Trump built on a history of narrative shaping that ran through the Republican Party. In 2004 a senior advisor to President George W Bush famously told journalist Ron Suskind that people like Suskind lived in the reality-based community, believing that people could find solutions to problems based on their real-world observations. But such a worldview was obsolete, the aides said. That's not the way the world really works anymore. We are an empire now and when we act we create our own reality. We're history's actors, and you,

all of you, will be left to just study what we do. America's right wing has been able to shape reality in large part because of the 1996 advent of the Fox News Channel, or FNC, the brainchild of Australian-born media mogul Rupert Murdoch. Shows on the FNC used clear, simple messaging with colorful graphics that told a story of an America overwhelmingly made up of white, rural folks who hated taxes and an intrusive government and would do fine if they could just get the socialist Democrats to leave them alone. To spread the new channel, Murdoch initially offered $10 per subscriber to each cable company

that carried it. That right-wing echo chamber has expanded until it is now so strong that nearly 70% of Republicans falsely believe Trump was the rightful winner of the 2020 presidential election, despite the fact that the FNC had to pay more than $787 million to Dominion voting systems for defamation after it lied to viewers about that election. Trump has built on that Republican narrative to create a fantasy world that is badly out of step with reality. It's not easy to see how he will reconcile his vision

with real world events. He and his supporters might try simply to tell voters that they have done what they promised and hope that story sells. When Trump threatened to put a 25% tariff on goods from Mexico, until Mexico stopped undocumented migrants from crossing the border,

Mexican President Claudia Scheinbaum told Trump that encounters at the Mexico-United States border have decreased by 75 percent between December 2023 and November 2024. Trump then simply told reporters that Scheinbaum had agreed to stop migration through Mexico and into the United States, effectively closing our southern border. And his supporters trumpeted on social media that Trump had closed the border with one phone call. But convincing people of an alternative reality might be harder with issues closer to home.

Trump has vowed to place a tariff wall around the US, for example, at the same time he has promised to bring down the price of consumer goods. Economists of all stripes say that ultimately, consumers pay the price of tariffs, Welker told him on Sunday. I don't believe that, Trump answered.

He might not believe it, but producers do. Car manufacturers, as well as major shopping chains, have warned that tariffs will force them to raise prices. On other issues, Trump will have a vocal and established opposition. After his threat to go after the members of the January 6th committee, former representative Liz Cheney said in a statement, There is no conceivably appropriate factual or constitutional basis for what Donald Trump

is suggesting. Here is the truth. Donald Trump attempted to overturn the 2020 presidential election and seize power. He mobilized an angry mob and sent them to the United States Capitol where they attacked police officers, invaded the building, and halted the official counting of electoral votes. Trump watched on television as police officers were brutally beaten and the Capitol was assaulted, refusing for hours to tell the mob to leave. This was the worst breach of our Constitution by any president in our nation's history. Cheney called for the release of the evidence and grand jury material special counsel Jack Smith assembled so all Americans can see Donald Trump for who he genuinely is and fully understand

his role in this terrible period in our nation's history. Nobel laureates generally try to stay out of politics, but today more than 75 of them in medicine, chemistry, economics, and physics wrote a letter to senators urging them not to confirm Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Trump's pick for Secretary of Health and Human Services. They object to Kennedy's stand against the scientists and agencies he would oversee. They noted that he has no credentials or relevant experience, and that he has opposed life-saving vaccines, promoted

conspiracy theories, and attacked the Food and Drug Administration, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and the National Institutes of Health. Putting him in charge of the Department of Health and Human Services, they write, would put the public's health in jeopardy and undermine America's global leadership in the health sciences in both the public and commercial sectors. There is also the chance that the Fox media empire will not effectively push a right-wing narrative much longer. The Murdoch family is in a struggle over control of that empire after the eventual death of the 93-year-old Rupert.

He and his eldest son, Lachlan, want to lock the company into its current political slant, but at least two of the three of Murdoch's other children who are set to inherit the company do not share their father and brother's politics. Rupert has been trying to change the terms of the family trust to cement Lachlan's control of the empire, but today a commissioner

in Nevada ruled against him. Edward Helmore of The Guardian noted that the decision likely means that even if the children do not take the media empire in a different direction, divided leadership will weaken the right-wing message. Almost 30 years after the Fox News Channel began to shape American politics with a fictional narrative,

a different Fox media empire would almost certainly disrupt the right-wing bubble. A lawyer for Rupert and Lachlan Murdoch said they will appeal the decision. Finally, Pennsylvania law enforcement officials today arrested a strong person of interest in the shooting of UnitedHe Care Chief Executive Brian Thompson. Tonight, a court document shows 26-year-old Luigi Mangione has been charged with murder. Letters from an American was produced at Soundscape Productions, Dedham, Massachusetts. Recorded with music composed by Michael Moss.