Letters from an American - February 1, 2025

Episode Date: February 2, 2025

Get full access to Letters from an American at heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/subscribe

Music February 1st, 2025. Throughout now President Donald Trump's 2024 campaign, it was clear that his support was coming from three very different factions whose only shared ideology was a determination to destroy the federal government. Now we are watching them do it. The group that serves President Donald Trump is gutting the government both to get revenge

against those who tried to hold him accountable before the law and to make sure he and his cronies will never again have to worry about legality. Last night, officials in the Trump administration purged the Federal Bureau of Investigation of all six of its top executives and, according to NBC's Ken Delaneyan, more than 20 heads of FBI field offices, including those in Washington, D.C. and Miami, where officials pursued cases against now-President Trump.

Acting Deputy Attorney General Emil Bove Boeve, who represented Trump in a number of his criminal cases, asked acting FBI Director Brian J. Driscoll Jr. for a list of FBI agents who had worked on January 6th cases to determine whether any additional personnel actions are necessary. Clarissa Jan Lim of MSNBC reported that Trump denied knowing about the dismissals, but said the firings were a good thing because they were very corrupt people, very corrupt, and they hurt our country very badly with the weaponization. Officials also fired 25 to 30 federal prosecutors who had worked on cases involving the rioters who attacked the U.S. Capitol on January 6, 2021, and reassigned others. Boeve ordered the firings. of the apparently illegal firing of 18 inspectors general across federal agencies and a purge

of the Department of Justice of those who had worked on cases involving Trump. Phil Williams of News Channel 5 in Nashville, Tennessee reported on Friday that federal prosecutors were withdrawn from a criminal investigation of Representative Andy Ogles, a Republican of Tennessee, for election fraud. Ogles recently filed a House resolution to enable Trump to run for a third term and another supporting Trump's designs on Greenland. On

Wednesday, federal prosecutors asked a judge to dismiss an election fraud case against former Representative Jeffrey Fortenberry, a Republican of Nebraska, Trump called Fortenberry's case an illustration of the illegal weaponization of our justice system by the radical left Democrats. That impulse to protect Trump showed yesterday in what a local water manager said was an extremely unprecedented release of water from

two dams in California, apparently to provide evidence of his social media posts that the U.S. military had gone into California and turned on the water. In fact, water was released from two reservoirs that hold water to supply farmland in the summer. They are about 500 miles or 800 kilometers from Los Angeles, where the fires were earlier this year, and the water did not go to Southern California. This is going to hurt farmers, a water manager said. This takes water out of the summer irrigation portfolio.

But Trump posted that if California officials had listened to him six years ago, there would have been no fires. Shashank Joshi of The Economist called it real mad king stuff. Trump's loyalists overlap with the MAGA crew that embraces Project 2025, a plan that mirrors the one used by Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor

Orbán to overthrow democracy in Hungary. Operating from the position that modern democracy destroys a country by treating everyone equally before the law and welcoming immigrants, it calls for discrimination against women and gender, racial and religious minorities, rejection of immigrants, and the imposition of religious laws to restore a white Christian patriarchy. Former Fox News host Tucker Carlson has been a vocal proponent of Orban's ideology, and J.D. Vance this week hired Carlson's son, 28-year-old Buckley, as his deputy press secretary. Although Trump claimed during the campaign he didn't know anything about Project 2025,

Steve Contorno and Casey Tolan of CNN estimate that more than two-thirds of Trump's executive orders mirror Project 2025. You can see the influence of this faction in the indiscriminate immigration sweeps the administration has launched, Trump's announcement that he is opening a 30,000-bed migrant detention center at Guantanamo Bay, and officials' revocation of protection for more than 600,000 Venezuelans legally in the U.S. and possibly also for Cubans, Haitians, and Nicaraguans. You can see it in the administration's attempt to end the birthright citizenship written into the US Constitution in 1868. It shows in the new administration's persecution of transgender Americans, including Trump's

executive order purging trans service members from the military, another limiting access to gender-affirming care for transgender youth, and yet another ordering trans federal prisoners to be medically detransitioned and then move to facilities that correspond to their sex at birth, an outcome that a trans woman suing the administration calls humiliating, terrifying, and dangerous. The administration has ordered that federal employees must remove all pronouns from their email signatures and, as Jeremy Faust reported in Inside Medicine, that researchers for the Centers for Disease

Control and Prevention must scrub from their work any references to gender, transgender, pregnant person, pregnant people, LGBT, transsexual, non-binary, non-binary, assigned male at birth, assigned female at birth, biologically male, biologically female. Faust notes that the requirements are vague and that because most manuscripts include demographic information about the populations or patients studied, the order potentially affects just about any major study, including studies on COVID-19, cancer, heart disease, or anything else. Those embracing this ideology are also isolationist. As soon as he took office, Trump imposed a freeze on foreign aid,

except for military aid to Israel and Egypt, abruptly cutting off about $60 billion in funding, less than 1% of the US budget, to the U.S. Agency for International Development, or USAID, which provides humanitarian assistance to fight starvation and provide basic medical care for the globe's most vulnerable and desperate populations. The outcry, both from those appalled that the U.S. would renege on its promises to provide food for children in war-torn countries, and from those who recognized that the U.S. withdrawal from these popular programs would create a vacuum China is eager to fill, made Trump's new Secretary of State Marco Rubio say that humanitarian programs would be exempted from

the freeze. But that appears either untrue or so complicated to negotiate that programs are shutting down anyway. Senator Chris Murphy, a Democrat of Connecticut, appears to be beside himself over this destruction. Let me explain why the total destruction of USAID matters so much, he posted on social media. China, where Musk makes his money, wants USAID destroyed.

So does Russia. Trump and Musk are doing the bidding of Beijing and Moscow. Why? The U.S. is in full retreat from the world, he wrote, and there is no good reason for it. The immediate consequences of this are cataclysmic. Malnourished babies who depend on U.S. aid will die. Anti-terrorism programs will shut down and our most deadly enemies will get stronger. Diseases that threaten the U.S.

will go unabated and reach our shores faster. And China will fill the void. As developing countries will now only be able to rely on China for help, they will cut more deals with Beijing to give them control of ports, critical mineral deposits, and so on. U.S. power will shrink. U.S. jobs will be lost. Murphy speculated that billionaires like Musk who make money in China or someone buying all that secret Trump meme coin would benefit from deliberately sabotaging 80 years of US goodwill on the international stage. And that brings us to the third faction, that of the tech bros led by billionaire Elon Musk who according to

year-end Federal Election Commission filings, spent more than 290 million dollars supporting Trump and the Republicans in 2024. Musk appears to consider colonizing space imperative for the survival of humanity, and part of that goal requires slashing government regulations as well as receiving government contracts that help to fund his space program. Before he took office, Trump named Musk and another billionaire, Vivek Ramaswamy, to an extra governmental group called the Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGGI, but Musk has assumed full control over the group, whose

mission is to cut the federal budget by as much as $2 trillion. Musk is interested in the government for future contracts, although a report from January 30th, when Musk's Tesla company filed its annual financial report, showed that the company, which is valued at more than $1 trillion and which made $2.3 billion in 2024, paid $0 in federal income tax. Today, Musk's ex-social media company became a form of state media when the National Transportation Safety Board, or NTSB, said it would no longer email updates about this week's two plane crashes, one in Washington, D.C., and one in Philadelphia, and that reporters

would have to get their information through X. Musk's goal might well be the crux of the drastic cuts to federal aid, as well as the attempt last week from the Office of Management and Budget to pause federal funding and grants to make sure funding reflected Trump's goals. After a public outcry over the loss of payments to local law enforcement, meals on wheels for shut-ins, supplemental nutrition programs, and so on, the OMB rescinded its first memo. But then White House press secretary Caroline Levitt immediately contradicted the new memo saying the cuts were still in effect. The chaos surrounding the cuts could have been

designed to make it difficult for opponents to sue over them. This method of changing government priorities through impoundment is illegal. Congress, which is the body that represents the American people, appropriates the money for programs and the president takes an oath to execute the laws. After President Richard M. Nixon tried it, Congress passed a 1974 law making impoundment expressly illegal. But the on-again, off-again confusion

appeared at first to stand a chance of stopping lawsuits. It didn't work. A federal judge halted the funding freeze, suggesting it was a blatant violation of the Constitution. But then, yesterday, Elon Musk forced the resignation of David A. Liebrich, the highest ranking career official at the Treasury Department. Liebrich had been at Treasury since 1989 and had risen to become the person in charge of the U.S. government payment system that disperses about $6 trillion a year through Social Security benefits, Medicare, Medicaid, contracts, grants, salaries for federal government workers, tax refunds, and so on, essentially managing the nation's checkbook. According to Jeff Stein, Isaac Arnsdorf, and Jacqueline

Alamany of the Washington Post, Musk's team wanted access to the payment system. Senator Ron Wyden, a Democrat of Oregon, demanded answers from Trump's new Treasury Secretary, Scott Besson, warning that, These payment systems simply cannot fail, and any politically motivated meddling in them risks severe damage to our country and the economy. I am deeply concerned that following the federal grant and loan freeze earlier this week, these

officials associated with Musk may have intended to access these payment systems to illegally withhold payments to any number of programs. I can think of no good reason why political operators who have demonstrated a blatant disregard for the law would need access to these sensitive, mission-critical systems. Now though, with Musk's people at the computers that control the nation's payment system, they can simply stop whatever payments they want to. Wyden continued by reminding Besant that the press has reported that Musk has previously been denied a high-level clearance to access the government's most sensitive secrets.

I am concerned that Musk's enormous business operation in China, a country whose intelligence agencies have stolen vast amounts of sensitive data about Americans, including US government employee data by hacking US government systems, endangers US cybersecurity and creates conflicts of interest that make his access to these systems a national security risk. This afternoon, Wyden posted that he has been told that Besant has given the Department of Government Efficiency full access to the system. Social Security and Medicare benefits, grants, payments to government contractors, including those that compete

directly with Musk's own companies. Josh Marshall of Talking Points Memo posted, This is more or less like taking the gold from Fort Knox and putting it in Elon's basement. Anyone who gets a check from Social Security or anything else, he can cut it off or see all your personal and financial data. Pundit Stuart Stevens called it the most significant data leak in cyber history. All three of these factions are focused on destroying the federal government, which after all represents the American people through their elected representatives and spends their taxpayer

money. Musk, who is an unelected adjunct to Trump, this evening gleefully referred to the civil servants in the government who work for the American people as the opposing team. But something jumps out from the chaos of the past two weeks. Instructions are vague, circumstances are chaotic, and it's unclear who is making decisions. That confusion makes it hard to enforce laws or sue, although observers note that what's going on is illegal and a breach of the constitutional order. Our federal government rests on the U.S. Constitution. The three different factions of Trump's MAGA

Republicans agree that the government must be destroyed and they are operating outside the constitutional order, not eager to win legal victories so much is determined to slash and burn down the government without them. Today, Senior Washington Post political reporter Aaron Blake noted that while it is traditional for cabinet nominees to pledge that they will refuse to honor illegal presidential orders, at least seven of Trump's nominees have sidestepped that question. Attorney General nominee Pam Bondi, Director of National Intelligence nominee Tulsi Gabbard, now confirmed Defense Secretary nominee Pete Hegseth, Small Business Administrator nominee

Kelly Loeffler, Veterans Affairs Secretary nominee Douglas A. Collins, and Commerce Secretary nominee Howard Lutnick all avoided the question by saying that Trump would never ask them to do anything illegal. FBI Director nominee Cash Patel just said he would always obey the law. Letters from an American was produced at Soundscape Productions, Dedham, Massachusetts. Recorded with music composed by Michael Moss.