Letters from an American - January 7, 2025

Episode Date: January 8, 2025

Get full access to Letters from an American at heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/subscribe

January 7th, 2025. Today, President Joe Biden signed proclamations that create the Chukwala National Monument and the Satitla Highlands National Monument, protecting 848,000 acres, or about 3430 square kilometers, of land in Southern California's eastern Coachella Valley. Under the 1906 Antiquities Act, the President can designate national monuments to protect areas of scientific, cultural, ecological, and historic importance. Yesterday, Biden protected the East Coast, the West Coast, the eastern Gulf of Mexico, and Alaska's northern Bering Sea, an area that makes up about 625 million acres or 2.5 million square kilometers, from oil and natural gas drilling. While there

is currently little interest among oil companies in drilling in those areas, the new designation will protect them into the future. Noting that nearly 40% of Americans live in coastal communities, Biden said the minimal fossil fuel potential was not worth the risks that drilling would bring to the fishing and tourist industries and to environmental and public health. The White House noted that Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris have conserved more lands and waters, more than 670 million acres of them, and have deployed more clean energy and made more progress in cutting climate pollution and advancing environmental justice than any previous administration. At the same time, oil and gas production

is at an all time high, demonstrating that land protection and energy production can coexist. While oil executives blasted Biden's proclamation protecting the coastal waters, Democratic lawmakers on the newly protected coasts cheered his action, recognizing that oil spills

devastate the tourism and fishing on which their constituents depend. The 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, for example, killed 11 people, closed 32,000 square miles or 82,880 square kilometers of the Gulf of Mexico to fishing and has cost more than $65 billion in compensation alone. Biden protected the oceans under the 1953 Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act, which enables

presidents to withdraw federal waters from future oil and gas leasing and development, but does not say that future presidents can revoke that protection to put federal waters from future oil and gas leasing and development, but does not say that future presidents can revoke that protection to put those waters back into development, meaning that Trump, who similarly protected coastal waters when he was president, will have a hard time overturning Biden's action. Nonetheless, Trump spokesperson, Caroline Levitt, called Biden's decision disgraceful and claimed

it was designed to exact political revenge on the American people who gave President Trump a mandate to increase drilling and lower gas prices. Rest assured Joe Biden will fail and we will drill baby drill. Journalist Wes Seiler, who writes about the outdoors, environment and the law, notes that there is a major effort underway among Republicans to privatize public lands to benefit oil and gas industries, as well as other extractive industries, just as Project 2025 outlined. Melinda Taylor, senior lecturer at the University of Texas at Austin

Law School, told Bloomberg Law in November, Project 2025 is a wish list for the oil and gas and mining industries and private developers. It promotes opening up more of our federal land to energy development, rolling back protections on federal lands, and selling off more land to private developers. In September, Seiler wrote in Outside that politicians in Utah have designed a lawsuit to put in front of the Supreme Court. It argues that all the land in Utah currently in the hands of the Bureau of Land Management, 18.5 million acres, should be

transferred to the control of the state of Utah. Those eager to get their hands on the land use the words unappropriated lands from the 1862 Homestead Act to claim that the federal government is holding the land without any designated purpose. But as Seiler notes in in 2023, BLM managed land supported 783,000 jobs and produced $201 billion in economic output. And in Utah alone, the use of BLM land created more than 36,000 jobs and $6.7 billion in economic output

as more than 15 million people visited the state's public lands. Utah realized hundreds of millions of dollars in taxes on that activity. And while it's true that states cannot tax federal government lands, as lawmakers say, the government pays the state in lieu of taxes, $128.7 million in 2021. Transferring that land to the state would sacrifice these funds, and because the state constitution requires the state both to balance its budget and to realize profits from state land, that transfer would facilitate the land's sale to private interests.

Twelve states have now joined Utah's lawsuit, arguing that federal control of unappropriated land within states impinges on state sovereignty, and they are asking the Supreme Court to take up the case as part of its original jurisdiction. As Seiler noted in a May article in Outside, Chief Justice John Roberts has expressed an eagerness to revisit the legality of the Antiquities Act that presidents use to protect land, as Biden did today, suggesting he would be willing to side with the states against the federal government. Project 2025 also calls for Congress to repeal the Antiquities Act. In Wes Seiler's newsletter yesterday, Seiler noted that the new rules package adopted for the 119th Congress makes it easier to transfer public lands to state control. The rules strip away the need to justify the cost of such a transfer and to offset it with budget cuts or increased revenue elsewhere. In a press conference today, Trump said he would rescind Biden's

policies and put it back on day one and complained that the 625 million acres Biden protected feels like the whole ocean, although the Pacific Ocean alone is almost 38 billion acres more than Biden protected. Also today, Trump announced that a developer from Dubai, DemEMEC Properties, will invest at least $20 billion in the US to create new data centers that support artificial intelligence and cloud services. Trump claimed that the company's chief executive officer, Hussein Sajwani, is investing in the US because of the fact that he was very inspired by the election. But DEMEC has been connected to Trump for a while. is investing in the US because of the fact that he was very inspired by the election.

But DEMAC has been connected to Trump for a while. Sejwani attended Trump's first inauguration, and a company tied to former chair and current board member of DEMAC, Farooq Arjomand, paid $600,000 to the key witness for the House Republicans seeking to dig up dirt on President Biden. That man was Alexander Smirnoff, who in December 2024 pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI when he claimed Biden had taken bribes from the Ukrainian company, Burisma. Data centers are notoriously high users of energy.

They consume 10 to 50 times as much energy per floor space as does a typical commercial office building, which might have something to do with why Trump's team is so eager to increase American energy production, even as it is already at an all-time high. Trump has promised companies that invest a billion or more dollars in the U.S. that they will get expedited approvals and permits, including those covering environmental concerns. But if the larger story of this moment is the plunder of our public resources for private interests,

Trump's press conference in general seemed to have a different theme. It was what CNN perhaps euphemistically called wide ranging as he abandoned his America first isolationism to suggest using force against China as well as U.S. allies Denmark, Panama, Mexico, and Canada, which would destabilize the globe by rejecting the central principle of the United Nations that countries must respect each other's sovereignty. He wildly suggested that the Iran-backed Lebanese paramilitary group Hezbollah was part of the January 6, 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol,

and that his people were part of the negotiations for the return of the Israeli hostages. Trump's performance was reminiscent of his off-the-wall press conferences during the worst of the coronavirus pandemic, which tanked his popularity enough to get his team to stop him from doing them. Trump might have chosen to speak today to keep attention away from the arrival of the casket carrying former President Jimmy Carter to Washington, D.C., where it was transported by horse-drawn caisson to the Capitol, where Carter will lie in state in the rotunda until his Thursday funeral at Washington National Cathedral. The snow and frigid weather were not enough to keep mourners

away and Trump has already expressed frustration that Carter's death will mean that flags will be at half staff for his own inauguration. But he might also have been trying to demonstrate that the transition from Biden's administration to his own is taking his time and energy in order to add half to the argument his lawyers made yesterday. They demanded that Attorney General Merrick Garland prevent the public release

of special counsel Jack Smith's report about his investigation into Trump's attempt to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election. Because making Trump respond to the media frenzy the report will stir up, would take his attention away from the presidential transition. Trump managed to defang most of the legal cases

against him by being elected president, but he apparently still fears the release of Smith's report. Today, Judge Eileen Cannon, whom he appointed to the bench, and who dismissed the charges against Trump in his retention of classified documents, issued an order preventing the Department of Justice from releasing the report. Constitutional law professor Lawrence Tribe noted that the order has no legal basis and ought to be reversed quickly, but these days nobody can be confident

that the law will matter. The presidential immunity on which Trump apparently is relying has also failed to protect him from being sentenced in the election interference case in which a Manhattan jury found him guilty of 34 felonies. In civil discourse, legal analyst Joyce White Vance explained that Trump wants to stop the sentencing process because it triggers a 30-day period for Trump to appeal. Once the appeal is concluded, she explains, the conviction is final. Trump was apparently hoping to hold off that process and buy four years to come up with

a way out of a permanent designation as a felon. It didn't work. Today, appeals court judge Ellen Gessmer rejected his attempt to stop the sentencing. It will go forward on Friday as planned. Letters from an American was produced at Soundscape Productions, Dedham, Massachusetts. Recorded with music composed by Michael Moss.