Letters from an American - May 19, 2025

Episode Date: May 21, 2025

Get full access to Letters from an American at heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/subscribe

The House Rules Committee will take up the Republicans' omnibus bill this week. Illustrating their confidence that the American people support this 1,116-page measure enacting much of MAGA's wish list, the committee has set its meeting for Wednesday, May 21st, 2025, at 1 o'clock in the morning. The Republicans are trying to advance Trump's entire agenda, from massive logging on public lands to slashing Medicaid in one giant bill under a process known as budget reconciliation, which means it cannot be filibustered in the Senate. That means it needs only Republican votes to pass.

But even Republicans are deeply divided over the measure. While far-right Republicans insist cuts to the social safety net are not deep enough because of the massive deficits the measure's tax cuts for the wealthy and corporations will create. Other Republicans recognize that Medicaid cuts are hugely unpopular. According to a KFF poll released May 1st, more than 75 percent of Americans oppose such cuts. Katie Edmondson of the New York Times counts 12 swing state Republicans who don't want drastic Medicaid cuts, and 31 hardliners who do. House Speaker Mike Johnson, a Republican of Louisiana, can afford to lose only three Republican votes on the measure.

Nicole LaFond of Talking Points Memo reported today that Trump will go to Capitol Hill tomorrow to talk Republicans into voting for the measure. Right on cue, the administration served up another issue to draw attention. Trump lawyer Alina Habba, who is now serving as the interim U.S. Attorney for New Jersey, announced that Representative LaMonica McIver, a Democrat of New Jersey, will be charged with assaulting, resisting and impeding law enforcement officers. On May 19th, McIver was one of three Democratic representatives from New Jersey who, along

with Newark's Democratic Mayor Ross Baraka, went to the Delaney Hall Immigration and Customs Enforcement Facility in Newark, New Jersey for an oversight visit. Such visits are permitted by law as part of a Congress member's oversight responsibility. As a mayor, Baraka was not covered by the law permitting congressional oversight. He waited outside the facility's gates in a public area. Masked agents tried to arrest him there, and as Perry Stein, Jeremy Roebuck, and Liz Goodwin of the Washington Post reported, video released by the Department of Homeland Security showed

MacGyver rushing after the agents and shouting to protesters outside to surround the mayor. The video shows a crowd of people jostling and MacGyver's elbows possibly making contact with a masked officer in the crush of the crowd, but no one breaks stride. MacGyver says she was the one assaulted by ICE officers. In a statement about charging MacGyver, Habba said, "'It is my constitutional obligation to ensure "'that our federal law enforcement is protected

when executing their duties. Charging a congressional representative after an event in which no one was injured is a dramatic move indeed. But the Washington Post reporters noted that, as of 10 p.m., no charging documents were posted in federal court, and a spokesperson for MacGyver's legal team said neither she nor her lawyers had seen any charging documents.

In a statement, MacGyver said she and her colleagues were fulfilling our lawful oversight responsibilities, as members of Congress have done many times before, and our visit should have been peaceful and short. Instead, ICE agents created an unnecessary and unsafe confrontation when they chose to arrest Mayor Baraka. The charges against me are purely political. They mischaracterize and distort my actions and are meant to criminalize and deter legislative oversight. I look forward to the truth being laid out clearly in court. Congressional Democrats are condemning this attack

on their colleague. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries of New York, Whip Catherine Clark of Massachusetts, Caucus Chair Pete Aguilar of California, Vice Chair Ted Lieu of California, and Assistant Leader Joe Noguise of Colorado, issued a statement saying, the criminal charge against Congresswoman MacGyver

is extreme, morally bankrupt, and lacks any basis in law or fact. Haba's statement is a blatant attempt by the Trump administration to intimidate Congress and interfere with our ability to serve as a check and balance on an out of control executive branch. House Democrats will not be intimidated by the Trump administration, not today, not ever.

And they pushed back warning everyone responsible for this illegitimate abuse of power is going to be held accountable for their actions. At the same time, the Department of Justice announced it was dropping all charges against Baraka stemming from the attempt to examine the ICE facility. Ten days ago, Habba broke the Department of Justice rule that it would not comment on ongoing investigations by posting that Baraka had committed trespass and ignored multiple warnings from Homeland

Security investigations to remove himself from the ICE detention center in Newark, New Jersey this afternoon. He has willingly chosen to disregard the law. That will not stand in this state. He has been taken into custody. No one is above the law. That will not stand in this state. He has been taken into custody. No one is above the law. Except, apparently, those who stormed the US Capitol on January 6th, 2021. Ellen Feuer, Devlin Barrett, and Glenn Thrush of the New York Times reported today that the Department of Justice is considering settling a wrongful death lawsuit

with the family of Ashley Babbitt, whom a law enforcement officer shot and killed as she tried to break into the Speaker's lobby outside the House floor. The amount they are considering, the journalists report, is $5 million. Reports that Walmart will raise prices because of the tariffs have Trump officials panicking. Walmart is the largest retailer in the United States, with a 2023 retail revenue of $534 billion. Higher prices there will hurt poorer Americans, particularly those in rural areas, the demographic most likely to have supported Trump in the past.

This, just as cuts to funding for food programs by the U.S. Department of Agriculture in March, programs started during Trump's first term, have slashed the amount of food available to food banks. A USDA spokesperson said in a statement, there is no need for new programs, but perhaps more efficient and effective use of current. So Republicans today continued their campaign

to pressure Walmart into, as Trump put it, eating the tariff costs. On CNBC today, Senator Bill Haggerty, a Republican of Tennessee, suggested that Walmart leaders need to think hard about raising prices. I think they're going to be very careful about how they do this. I know they've received some criticism from the president," he said, adding, "...they should know the president has been working very hard with China to make sure

we get this thing addressed as quickly as possible. Nora Eckert and David Shepardson of Reuters reported that Subaru of America said today it will also be raising prices by between $750 and $2,055 on several models because of current market conditions. Executives recently told investors that the tariffs are expected to amount to $5 billion. Eckerton-Shepardson reported that Ford raised prices on three models produced in Mexico by as much as $2,000. Finally today, because I actually plan to take tonight off and so I'm not prepared to cover some very important legal developments,

and I'm putting them off until tomorrow, so I get them right. Eric Lipton, Maggie Haberman, Adam Raskin, and Eric Schmidt of the New York Times reported the backstory to the Qatari offer to give a 747 to Trump. The planes serving as Air Force One are over 30 years old, and Boeing has a contract to build two new jets by 2024,

a deadline far in the rear view with no new planes in sight. Apparently, Trump was angling for a new plane and put officials up to buying one. They identified eight options, one of which was the Qatari plane, which Qatar had been trying to sell for at least five years, in part because of the enormous cost

of operating such a plane. Qatar sent the jet to Florida at a cost the reporters estimate to be as much as $1 million on February 15th for Trump to see, and he loved it. At that point, discussions turned from purchasing the plane to accepting it as a gift. Although it was apparently not the Qataris who changed the terms, they were still expecting

to sell it to the United States. A Qatari government official told the New York Times reporters that no decision had yet been made about a transfer rather than a sale. And Pentagon officials estimate that getting the plane repaired and ready for a president would cost at least a billion dollars. And yet, administration officials lined up to say that a $400 million gift from a foreign government to a U.S. president was just fine, despite its explicit prohibition in the Constitution. On Sunday, Treasury Secretary Scott Besant told CNN's

Jake Tapper that Qatar giving a plane to Trump was like France giving the Statue of Liberty to the U.S. or England giving the country the Resolute Desk. These comparisons are not only wrong, but an offensive skewing of the real history of those gifts, which were intended to reinforce democracy, freedom, and the international cooperation of nations that value those principles. It was the people of France who raised the money to send the Statue of Liberty, whose official name is Liberty Enlightening the World,

to the United States to honor political democracy and freedom at the nation's 100th anniversary. The people of the United States, in turn, raised the money for the statue's pedestal. There was never any question about it being a personal gift to President Grover Cleveland. He would have refused it if such a thing were suggested, and Congress would have impeached if such a thing were suggested, and Congress

would have impeached him if he had not. If the story of the Statue of Liberty is the story of the universal principles of democracy and freedom, the story of the Resolute Desk is one of diplomacy. After a famous British expedition to discover the Northwest Passage disappeared in the 1850s, a rescue expedition of five ships, including the HMS Resolute, set sail to find survivors. The Resolute became trapped in Arctic ice in April 1854, and her captain and crew abandoned the ship. When the ice thawed, the Resolute broke free and drifted south, where an American

whaling ship found it in 1855. The captain, James Buddington, claimed it under the right of salvage. At the time, tensions between the U.S. and England were high, and Congress decided to purchase the Resolute from Buddington, fix it up, and send it back to England as a gesture of goodwill and friendship from the American people. After the work was done, a U.S. naval officer and crew sailed the Resolute to England, where Queen Victoria and Prince Albert accepted it on behalf of all of Great Britain. The Royal Navy used the Resolute as a supply vessel for the next 23 years. When the ship was decommissioned in 1879,

the British government launched a public competition to design a piece of furniture that could be made of its timbers to give back to the United States. The winning design was a desk, and it arrived in the United States as a gift for President Rutherford B. Hayes in 1880, bearing a plaque that recounted the history of the Resolute. The plaque noted, Majesty Queen Victoria by the President and people of the United States as a token of

goodwill and friendship. This table was made from her timbers when she was broken up and is presented by the Queen of Great Britain and Ireland to the President of the United States as a memorial of the courtesy and loving kindness which dictated the offer of the gift of the resolute. Letters from an American was written and read by Heather Cox Richardson. It was produced at Soundscape Productions, Dead in Massachusetts. Recorded with music composed by Michael Moss.