Letters from an American - November 17, 2025

Episode Date: November 18, 2025

Get full access to Letters from an American at heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/subscribe

November 17th, 2025. President Donald J. Trump spent the weekend flooding social media with posts claiming that his economic policies are working and that his 34 felony convictions and the investigations into his 2016 campaigns ties to Russian operatives were illegitimate, and posting angrily about those people calling out his association with Jeffrey Epstein. He even reposted a statement from one of his own lawyers saying, if Jeffrey Epstein had any dirt on Donald Trump, he would have had great leverage in the criminal case against him at the time he died, which perhaps conveys a different message than he intended. Then, after fighting furiously against the upcoming House vote over releasing the

Epstein files the FBI collected as part of its investigation into the convicted sex abuser. At 9.15 p.m. last night, Trump abruptly reversed course, saying that House Republicans should vote in favor of releasing the files because we have nothing to hide. I don't care, he posted. But of course, he does care, as is evident from how deeply he fought the release of the files the FBI collected during its investigation of Epstein, right up until the final signature on the House discharge petition that would force the House to vote on a measure to require the Justice Department to release the files. As Meredith Kyle of People magazine reported, when a female Bloomberg reporter at a press gaggle aboard Air Force One, November 14th, asked him if there

was anything incriminating in the Epstein files. He pointed a finger in her. face and said, quiet, quiet, Piggy. In the hours before House Speaker Mike Johnson, a Republican of Louisiana, swore in Representative Adelaide Grahalva, a Democrat of Arizona, at 4 o'clock on Wednesday, Trump and his loyalists worked to pressure Representative Lauren Bobert, a Republican of Colorado, to remove her name from the discharge petition. She refused. As soon as Johnson swore, her into office, Grahalva signed the petition, teeing up a vote on a bill requiring the release of the files.

On Thursday, November 13th, the people behind the White House social media account seemed to be trying to combat the Epstein story by pushing the image of Trump as a happily married family man. The account posted an image of Trump and First Lady Melania Trump listening to the U.S. Marine Band and Shaddle. Then a video of Trump behind the Oval Office desk, giving a medallion and a pen each to four small children. The caption read, The Best President with a heart emoji. On Friday, November 14th, the White House social media account posted an image of Trump and the First Lady embracing.

Under the caption, I can't help falling in love with you, along with an emoji of musical notes and a heart. Sunday, November 16th, it posted a picture of the two of them striding toward the cameras holding hands, under the caption, America's power couple, with an eagle and an American flag emoji. That Trump's hand is weakening showed on Friday when the leader of the Indiana Senate announced that it would not hold a meeting in December to gerrymander all nine of Indiana's districts to favor Republicans. Currently, the Indiana delegation to the House of Representatives has seven Republicans and two Democrats.

Trump and Indiana Governor Mike Braun have put great pressure on the legislature to redistrict. But even though Republicans hold a supermajority in the Indiana legislature, not enough Republican senators are willing to face the anger of voters to back the plan. Then, over the weekend, rumors spread that as many as 100 House Republicans, would vote in favor of the measure to force the release of the Epstein files. Their constituents are eager for the release of the files, which Trump promised on the campaign trail, and the material already released from the Epstein estate

has been damaging enough that representatives have reason to worry whether the material in the FBI files is even worse, leaving them in the position of having defended that behavior if they continue to cover it up. On Sunday, Representative Thomas Massey, a Republican of Kentucky, told Jonathan Carl of ABC News this week that he was hoping to get a veto-proof majority in favor of the release. This is a big deal. The public outrage over ABC's suspension of comedian Jimmy Kimmel's show in September demonstrated in a much more public

way than court losses had that the administration was not all-powerful. That outcry for forced first ABC's parent company, Disney, and then broadcast station owners Next Star Media Group and Sinclair Broadcast Group, to backtrack and to reinstate Kimmel's show. While individual Republican lawmakers have groused about one or another of the administration's actions, only a few have broken with Trump.

He has generally been able to command loyalty by threatening to sick his supporters on those who step out of line, and by warning that he will support primary challengers against them. Notably, over the weekend, he hammered at one of those lawmakers, his former loyalist Representative Marjorie Taylor Green, a Republican of Georgia, calling her a traitor, wacky, and a ranting lunatic. He said he was withdrawing his endorsement of her and would support another Republican to replace her.

His usual threats didn't work. Dozens of House Republicans, Republicans still said they were going to vote in favor of releasing the Epstein files. So to get back in front of the party, Trump suddenly called for lawmakers to pass the measure, later telling reporters he would sign it if it came to his desk. Lawmakers who just hours before had maintained they would vote no suddenly switched to yes, indicating that Trump still commands many of them. But his change in direction makes it far more likely senators to too will vote to pass the bill. Tonight, Trump loyalist, Senator Tommy Tuberville,

a Republican of Alabama, said he would vote for the measure. Likely realizing a vote against it will hurt him in his upcoming campaign for governor, which is quite something considering Alabama's previously strong support for Trump. Don't hold your breath for the release of the files, though. Trump's post saying he didn't care about the release

included the qualification that the House Oversight Committee can have whatever they are legally entitled to, suggesting he will continue his stonewalling with the help of the Department of Justice. Remember, all the congressional machinations are only to force the release of the files. He could release them himself any time he wanted to.

On Sunday, Trump posted angrily about the Indiana Republicans' failure to do his bidding. Calling those Republican, opponents of redistricting rhinos, or Republicans in name only, and accusing them of depriving Republicans of a majority in the House, a very big deal. He went on. It's weak Republicans that cause our country such problems. It's why we have crazy policies and ideas that are so bad for America. He blamed Braun for not working the way he should to get the necessary votes and said, Any Republican that votes against this important redistricting,

potentially having an impact on America itself, should be primaried. He singled out two senators, one of whom had not publicly said he opposed the bill, saying if they didn't do their job and do it now, let's get them out of office ASAP. Hours later, one of the senators was the victim of a swatting incident, in which the police department received an email falsely saying someone in the home had been harmed, a malicious action designed to prompt police to launch a massive response to a potentially dangerous situation, thus putting the victims in danger. Trump seems to be losing his iron grip on the Republican Party.

Although Steve Peoples of the Associated Press reported yesterday that White House officials and U.S. officials and other Washington, D.C. leaders say there is no affordability problem in the country. Trump is popular, and the way to win in 2026 is to stick with him. Not everyone is so sure, especially after the party's big losses earlier this month in elections across the country. On Monday, November 11th, Fox News Channel personality Laura Ingram pushed Trump on issues that have cost him support. Although consumers have expressed concern over rising prices, Trump insisted that prices are way down. Ingram asked, are you saying voters are misperceiving how they feel?

She took on the administration's recent call to address housing costs by issuing 50-year mortgages, noting that the proposal has enraged your mag of friends, who recognized that such a mortgage would benefit banks over buyers and nearly double the time it would take for Americans to own a home. Don't forget, MAGA was my idea, Trump defended himself. MAGA was nobody else's idea. I know what MAGA wants better than anybody else, and MAGA wants to see our country thrive.

Yesterday, Trump defended right-wing podcaster Tucker Carlson, who has been under fire for his interview platforming white nationalist Nick Fuentes. Fuentes traffics in racism and sexism, and has openly admired Hitler, insisting that many of the Republicans currently in office are too moderate. When the head of the Heritage Foundation,

once thought of as the intellectual heart of the modern Republican Party, supported Carlson, at least six people resigned from the foundation, expressing dismay at the direction it was taking. Today, Representative Jared Golden, Golden, a Democrat of Maine, announced that a bipartisan bill to repeal Trump's executive order stripping the union rights from federal workers now has enough votes on a discharge petition

to bring it before the House. Golden and Representative Brian Fitzpatrick, a Republican of Pennsylvania, introduced the bill in April, but Johnson refused to bring it up. In June, Golden launched a discharge petition to force it to the floor. Democrats and three Republicans signed the petition, but it was still two votes short of adoption. Today, Republican lawmakers Nick LaLotta and Mike Lawler of New York signed it, bringing the number of signatures on the petition to 218. Enough Republican members have joined with the Democrats to override,

Johnson and challenge Trump's executive order. Letters from an American was written and read by Heather Cox Richardson. It was produced at Soundscape Productions, Dead in Massachusetts. Recorded with music composed by Michael Moss. Thank you.