Letters from an American - October 10, 2024

Episode Date: October 11, 2024

Get full access to Letters from an American at heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/subscribe

October 10th, 2024. Hurricane Milton made landfall yesterday evening as a Category 3 storm just south of Sarasota, Florida. Before the hurricane hit, 38 tornadoes swept across 13 counties in the state, putting about 1.26 million people under a tornado advisory. With the hurricane came high winds and water, including 10 to 20 inches of rain in the Tampa area. And, although it was not the worst case scenario people feared, 11 people are dead and about 3 million are without power because of the storm. The Federal Emergency Management Agency has been on the ground since before the storm hit. In election news today, the Atlantic endorsed Vice President Kamala Harris for president. This is only the fifth time since its founding in 1857 that the Atlantic has endorsed a presidential candidate. It is the third time it has endorsed Trump's opponent. It also endorsed Lyndon Baines Johnson in 1964 when he ran against extremist Arizona

Senator Barry Goldwater. And in 1860 it endorsed Abraham Lincoln. The Atlantic's endorsement of Harris echoes its earlier endorsement of Lincoln, not only in its thorough dislike of Trump as one of the most personally malignant and politically dangerous candidates in American history, an echo of its 1860 warning that this election is a turning point in our history, but because both endorsements show a new press challenging an older system. In public notice today, Noah Berlatsky listed the many articles claiming that Harris is avoiding the press, including most recently a social media post from Politico's playbook that read, after avoiding the media for nigh on her whole campaign, Kamala Harris is still

largely avoiding the media. Berlatsky pointed out that Harris has taken questions from reporters as she campaigns and has sat down with the National Association of Black Journalists, CNN, Spanish language radio station Euphoria, and Action News in Pennsylvania, and did a presidential debate with ABC News. Earlier this week, she appeared on 60 Minutes. With Trump refusing to participate in another presidential debate, Vice President Harris today accepted CNN's invitation to a live televised town hall on October 23rd in Pennsylvania. In the announcement, Harris Wall's campaign chair, Jen O'Malley Dillon, noted that Trump has confined his recent appearances to conservative media. Indeed, Trump backed out of a 60 Minutes interview and has

appeared only on the shows of loyalists. And yet, Berlatsky points out, he is not receiving similar criticism. Indeed, observers note that Trump has tended to get far more favorable coverage than his mental slips, open embrace of Nazi racism, fantastical lies, and criminal indictments deserve. In a piece today, Matt Gertz of the media watchdog Media Matters reports that five major newspapers, the Los Angeles Times, the New York Times, USA Today, the Wall Street Journal, and the Washington Post, produced nearly four times as many articles about Democratic candidate Hillary Clinton's email server in 2016, in the week after then-FBI Director James Comey announced new developments in the story. Then they did about

the unsealing of a new filing in Trump's federal criminal indictment for alleged crimes related to the January 6th insurrection earlier this month. None of the papers ran even half as many Trump indictment stories as they did on Clinton's server, Gertz wrote. Indeed, every paper ran more front page stories that mentioned Clinton's server than they did total stories that referenced Trump's indictment. The former president continues to benefit from news outlets grading him on a massive curve, Gertz wrote, resulting in relatively muted coverage for his nakedly authoritarian, unfathomably racist,

and allegedly criminal behavior. On Tuesday, October 8th, Ian Bassin and Maximilian Potter of the Columbia Journalism Review outlined Trump's longstanding attack on the U.S. media as fake news, an attack that is ongoing and obvious. Just today, he threatened CBS and all other broadcast licenses because they are just as corrupt as CBS and maybe even worse. licenses because they are just as corrupt as CBS and maybe even worse. Bassett and Potter note that in his attacks on the media, Trump is following the pattern of authoritarians like Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban, who attacked media critics with audits, investigations, and harassment until he drove independent media from the field. They also note the observation of Timothy Snyder, a scholar of authoritarianism,

that power is often freely given to an authoritarian in anticipation of punishment, what Snyder calls anticipatory obedience. And yet, in the past in the U.S., when the media has appeared to become captive to established interests, new media have begun to give a voice to the opposition. In the 1850s, when elite enslavers stopped the circulation of newspapers and books calling for abolition, they prompted an explosion of new media that expressed the sentiments of those opposed to the expansion of human enslavement. Editor Horace Greeley led the way with the New York Tribune in the 1840s. He was keenly aware of the importance of the new press and, as an early convert to the Republican

Party, led his paper to become the anchor of a string of new Republican newspapers across the North, including the Chicago Tribune and the New York Times, that spread the party's ideology. The Atlantic Monthly's endorsement of Lincoln in 1860 was part of that movement, and poet James Russell Lowell, who wrote the endorsement, mocked the idea that the press should avoid causing trouble. We are gravely requested to have no opinion or having one to suppress it on the topic that has occupied caucuses, newspapers, president's messages, and Congress for the last dozen years, lest we endanger the safety of the union. In a democracy, it is the duty of every citizen to think. Harris has nodded to established media, but as Berlasky points out, there is very little payoff

for her in focusing on those venues, since those audiences are generally already quite attuned to politics and are looking for new developments and scandals. In contrast, winning in 2024 means turning out new voters by finding new venues that offer them a political voice. Harris has recognized that media shift by focusing her media appearances on podcasts like Call Her Daddy, radio shows like Howard Stern's, and television shows like The Late Show with Stephen Colbert and The View. Campaign staffer Victor Shai noted that, based on averages, Harris's appearance on Call Her Daddy reached 5 million people, The View 2.45 million, Howard Stern 10 million, and Stephen Colbert 3.2 million. In all, 25 million or more

people that traditional media do not reach. Shai also called attention to the fact that on October 9th, the campaign live streamed an Arizona rally by Minnesota governor and Democratic vice presidential candidate Tim Walz on the World of Warcraft Twitch stream. The Atlantic nodded to the free thought on which the magazine was founded in 1857, when it came out strongly for Harris today. It is endorsing Harris, it said, because she respects the law and the Constitution. She believes in the freedom, equality, and dignity of all Americans. She's untainted by corruption, let alone a felony record or a history of sexual assault. She doesn't embarrass her compatriots with her language and behavior or pit them against

one another. She doesn't curry favor with dictators. She won't abuse the power of the highest office in order to keep it. She believes in democracy. These, and not any specific policy positions, are the reasons the Atlantic is endorsing her. Letters from an American was produced at Soundscape Productions, Denham, Massachusetts. Recorded with music composed by Michael Moss. Letters from an American was produced at Soundscape Productions, Denham, Massachusetts.