Letters from an American - October 20, 2024

Episode Date: October 21, 2024

Get full access to Letters from an American at heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/subscribe

October 20th, 2024. I had hoped to write tonight about the Farm Bill, which Eric Hovde, running for the Senate from Wisconsin, although it's not clear he lives there, could not talk about in the debate between him and incumbent Senator Tammy Baldwin on Friday. I'm not an expert on the Farm Bill because I'm not in the U.S. Senate at this point in time, Hovde said, so I can't opine specifically on all aspects of the Farm Bill. The Farm Bill is one of our most important pieces of legislation. It establishes the main agricultural and food policies of the government, covering price supports for farm products, especially corn, soybeans, wheat, cotton, rice, peanuts, dairy, and sugar, crop insurance, conservation programs, and nutritional programs for 41 million low-income Americans, including the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, formerly known as food stamps. It must pass every five years, but it's been held up by Republican extremists in the House and is now in limbo. One would think that anyone running for

Senate should know it pretty well, especially in Wisconsin, where in 2022, farms produced $16.7 billion in agricultural products. Perhaps this is why the Wisconsin Farm Bureau Federation has endorsed Baldwin, the first Democrat in nearly 20 years to receive their support. But I cannot take tonight to explain the really quite interesting history of the Farm Bill and why it contains our nutrition programs, because the real story of today is that the Republican candidate for president is not mentally able to handle the job of the presidency, and Republican leaders are trying to cover up that reality. These two stories are related. That same quest for power that appears to be driving Hovde to seek a Senate seat without These two stories are related. year old candidate has lost the mental capacity necessary for managing the most powerful nation

in the world, including its vast stockpiles of nuclear weapons. The United States has guardrails to prevent an incapacitated president from exercising power. The question of what to do when a president was unable to do his job was not really a major question until the post-World War II years. While presidents before then had been weakened, notably Woodrow Wilson had had a stroke, medical care was poor enough that those presidents who sustained life-threatening injuries tended to die from them fairly quickly. to die from them fairly quickly. At the same time, the difficulties of the travel necessary for a national political career made politics a young man's game, so there really weren't rumblings of mental incapacity from age. But Republican President Dwight Eisenhower had seen the grave damage military leaders could do when they were incapacitated and unaware of their inability to evaluate

situations accurately, and knew that the commander-in-chief must have a system in place to be replaced if he were unable to fulfill the mental requirements of his position. Eisenhower took office in 1953, and two years later, he suffered a heart attack. Vice President Richard Nixon and members of the Cabinet agreed to a working plan to conduct business while the president recovered. But Presidential Assistant Sherman Adams noted that the crisis left everyone uncomfortably aware of the Constitution's failure to provide for the direction of the government by an acting president when the

president is temporarily disabled and unable to perform his functions. When Eisenhower went on to need an abdominal operation and then to have a minor stroke, concerns mounted. As Congress discussed a solution, Eisenhower took matters into his own hands. He drafted an informal agreement that he presented to Nixon. If the president became temporarily unable to do the duties of the office, the document gave to the vice president the power of acting president. The need to figure out what would happen if modern medicine could keep alive an incapacitated president became apparent after the assassination of President John F. Kennedy in 1963. Not only did the question of a president's incapacity have to be addressed, so did the problem of succession. Vice President

Lyndon Baines Johnson was falsely rumored to have had a heart attack, and both the Speaker of the House and the President pro tempore of the Senate were old and doubted that they could adequately fulfill the duties of the presidency themselves. Congress's solution was the 25th Amendment to the Constitution, providing a system by which either the president or, if they were unable to realize their incapacity, members of the executive branch would transfer the powers of the president to the vice president. Eisenhower enthusiastically backed the idea that the nation should have coverage for a disabled president. To anyone paying attention, it is clear that Trump is not in any shape to manage the government of the United States of America. He is canceling interviews and botching the ones he does sit for, while falling asleep at events where he is not actually speaking.

He lies incessantly, even when hosts point out that his claims have been debunked, and cannot answer a question or follow a train of thought. And his comments of the weekend, calling the vice president a s*** vice president, telling a woman to get your fat husband off the couch to vote for him, and musing about a famous golfer's penis, indicate that he has no mental guardrails left. indicate that he has no mental guardrails left. Today, in what apparently was designed to show Trump as relatable and to compete with the story that Vice President Harris worked at a McDonald's when she was in college, Trump did a photo op at a McDonald's in the swing state of Pennsylvania,

where he took prepared fries out of the fry-o-lator. It was an odd moment, for Trump has never portrayed himself as a man of the people, so much as a man to lead the people, and the picture of him in a McDonald's apron undercuts his image as a dominant leader. But in any case, it was all staged. The restaurant was closed, the five customers were loyalists who had practiced their roles, and when Trump handed food through the drive-thru window, he did not take money or make change. Now I have worked at McDonald's, he said afterward. I've now worked for 15 minutes more than Kamala. The fact that someone on Trump's campaign leaked to Politico that he is exhausted is almost certainly a sign that people

down the ranks are deeply concerned about his ability to finish the campaign, let alone run the country. But party leaders continue to stand behind him, raising echoes of their staunch support during Trump's two impeachment trials. In 2019, the House of Representatives impeached Trump for his attempt to coerce Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky and pervert the security of the United States to steal an election. The evidence was so overwhelming that Senator Ted Cruz, a Republican of Texas, noted, out of 100 senators, you have zero who believe you that there was no quid pro quo. None. There's not a single one. But Republican senators, except Mitt Romney, a Republican of Utah, who voted to convict on one count, nonetheless acquitted Trump.

This is not about the president. It's not about anything he's been accused of doing, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, a Republican of Kentucky, told his colleagues. It has always been about November 3rd, 2020. It's about flipping the Senate. Trump's second impeachment by the House in January 2021 for incitement of insurrection ended similarly. In the Senate, McConnell refused to change the schedule to enable the Senate to vote before a new president was inaugurated, thus giving himself, as well as other Republican senators, an out to vote against conviction on the grounds that Trump was no longer the president. to vote against conviction on the grounds that Trump was no longer the president.

Seven Republican senators joined the Democrats to convict, but 43 continued to back Trump. In a speech after the vote, McConnell said he believed Trump was responsible for the January 6, 2021, attempt to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election, but that he would have to answer for that behavior in court. But nearly four years later, Trump has not had to answer in court because the Supreme Court, stacked with his appointees thanks to Republican senators, has said that he cannot be prosecuted for crimes committed as part of his official duties. While the courts sort out what counts as official duties, he is, once again, the Republican nominee for president. Leaders are standing behind him despite the fact he is demonstrating deeply concerning behavior.

When President Joe Biden decided not to accept the Democratic presidential nomination after his poor performance in his June debate with Trump, Republicans demanded that Vice President Harris and the Cabinet invoke the 25th Amendment, despite the fact that Biden's job performance continued to be exemplary. We learned later that during the time of the debate, he was negotiating a historic prisoner swap involving multiple countries to free 24 prisoners, including Americans Evan Gerskovich and Paul Whelan. Nonetheless, that one poor debate performance was enough for Republicans to condemn Biden's ability to govern the nation. Senator Eric Schmidt, a Republican of Missouri, told the Fox News channel that Joe Biden has decided he isn't capable of being a candidate. In so doing, his admission also means that he cannot serve as president. But Trump has been lying that immigrants are eating pets, calling voters fat pigs, basing his economic policy on a backward idea of how tariffs work, calling for prosecuting his enemies and making the civil service, military, and judiciary loyal to him, and praising a famous golfer's manhood,

hardly indications of a man able to take on the presidency of the United States. of a man able to take on the presidency of the United States. And yet, with regard to his mental acuity, Republican leaders offer only crickets. Soundscape Productions, Dedham, Massachusetts. Recorded with music composed by Michael Moss. This is the world.