Letters from an American - September 30, 2024

Episode Date: October 1, 2024

Get full access to Letters from an American at heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/subscribe

September 30th, 2024. 100 years ago tomorrow, former President Jimmy Carter arrived in the world in Plains, Georgia. According to the Atlanta Constitution of that date, he arrived just after the worst wind and rainstorm of the year passed off to sea. His home state of Georgia, along with North Carolina and Virginia, sustained significant damage with railroad tracks and bridges washed out, crops damaged, and at least seven lives lost. Today, almost 100 years later, the destruction from Hurricane Helene continues to mount. At least 128 people have died in six states, and many more remain unaccounted for. Roads remain closed, and power is still off for more than 2 million people. In remarks to reporters today, President Joe Biden

called the damage stunning and explained that the federal government is providing all the support it can. He noted that federal help was on the ground before the storm. And when asked if there were more the government could be doing, answered no, and explained that the administration had pre-planned a significant amount of it, even though they hadn't asked for it yet. Biden said this morning he will not tour the damaged areas until his presence will not disrupt emergency response operations. This afternoon, he said he would travel to North Carolina on Wednesday for a briefing and an aerial tour of Asheville after ensuring the travel will not disrupt the ongoing response. He has also said he may have to ask

Congress to come back into session before its mid-November return date to pass a supplemental spending bill. Punchbowl News political reporter Melanie Zanona noted that Congress left disaster aid out of the short-term continuing resolution to fund the government it passed before leaving town. And yet, the hurricane has become the latest topic of disinformation for MAGA Republicans. Social media today is full of accounts claiming that the federal government is not responding to the crisis in Western North Carolina because it prefers to spend money in Ukraine and on undocumented immigrants. Newsmax host Ted Starnes claimed that FEMA's top priority is not disaster relief, but to push diversity, equity, and inclusion. So unless you've got your preferred

pronouns spray painted on the side of your submerged house, you won't get a penny from Uncle Sam. Western North Carolina is just too conservative and too Caucasian for FEMA to care. North Carolina is just too conservative and too Caucasian for FEMA to care. The House Judiciary Committee posted that Joe Biden was at the beach. These posts echo Russian disinformation, and Trump was on board with it. Touring Valdosta, Georgia today as a private citizen where people are still without power amidst the devastation, Trump said he had spoken to Elon Musk to get his Starlink satellites into North Carolina. FEMA has already provided 40 of the systems to North Carolina.

He claimed that Georgia Governor Brian Kemp is having a hard time getting the president on the phone. They're being very non-responsive. Kemp himself told reporters that Biden had called yesterday and he just said, hey, what do you need? Kemp told him, we got what we need. We'll work through the federal process. He offered that if there's other things that we need just to call him directly, which I appreciate that. South Carolina Governor Henry McMaster, a Republican, called it a great team effort. The federal government is

helping us well. They're embedded with us. There is no asset out there that we haven't already accessed. Republican Governor of Virginia Glenn Youngkin told reporters that he was incredibly appreciative of the rapid response and cooperation from the federal team at FEMA. and cooperation from the federal team at FEMA. Asheville, North Carolina Mayor Esther Manheimer told CNBC, we have support from outside organizations, other fire departments sending us resources, the federal government as well. So it's all hands on deck

and it's a well-coordinated effort, but it is so enormous. FEMA spokesperson, Jacqueline Rothenberg, responded to a post claiming that FEMA was refusing to help certain Americans, saying, this is a lie. We help all people, regardless of background, as fast as possible before, during, and after disasters. That is our mission and that is our focus. In contrast, numerous posters today noted that Trump repeatedly withheld federal aid from Democratic governors, including that of North Carolina, after disasters in their states. in their states. After the Trump campaign organized a fundraiser for victims of the hurricane, David Frum of The Atlantic reminded readers that in 2019, Trump was fined $2 million and three of his children were ordered to take classes as a penalty for taking for their own use funds from

charities they ran. When a reporter asked President Biden and Democratic North Carolina Governor Roy Cooper to respond to Trump's accusation that they are ignoring the disaster, Biden responded, he's lying. And the governor told him he was lying. I've spoken to the governor, spent time with him. I don't know why he does this. And the reason I get so angry about it, I don't care what he says about me, but reason I get so angry about it, I don't care what he says about me, but I care what he communicates to the people that are in need. He applies that we're not doing everything possible. We are. I assume you heard the Republican governor of Georgia talk about that he was on the phone with me more than once. So that's simply not true.

And it's irresponsible. Economist Paul Krugman noted, we've all become desensitized, but it's amazing how at this point the Trump campaign rests entirely on denouncing things that aren't happening. An imaginary bad economy, imaginary runaway crime, and now an imaginary failure of Biden and Harris to respond to a natural disaster. In Florida, though, Governor Ron DeSantis says his state does not need more federal help. We have it handled, he said. DeSantis might be eager to downplay the damage to the state, in part because in May he joined other Republican leaders in an attack on Biden's actions to address climate change. DeSantis signed into law a new Florida measure that erased any references to climate

change in state law, where they had been included in a 2008 climate change and renewable energy package then backed by the state's Republicans. The new law prohibited cities and counties from approving restrictions on energy policy, relaxed regulations on natural gas pipelines, and state and local governments from taking environmental concerns into consideration in their investing policies. DeSantis also rejected more than $350 million in federal funding for initiatives to promote energy efficiency and $320 million for reducing vehicle emissions. Like DeSantis, the authors of Project 2025 claim that those working to address climate change are part of the climate change alarm industry, which is harmful to future U.S. prosperity.

In fact, the U.S. economy is booming, in part thanks to the climate change initiatives begun under the Inflation Reduction Act, which have prompted both domestic and foreign investment in alternative technologies. Biden approached the need to address climate change as an opportunity to create good jobs, including union jobs, in the United States. With those investments, economist Mark Zandi wrote yesterday that the U.S. economy is one of the best performing economies in the past 35 years. Economic growth is rip-roaring, with real GDP up 3% over the past year. Unemployment is low at near 4%, consistent with full employment. Inflation is fast closing in on Fed's 2% target. Grocery prices, rents, and gas prices are flat to down over the past more than a year.

Households financial obligations are light and set to get lighter with the Fed cutting rates. House prices have never been higher and most homeowners have more equity in their homes than ever. Corporate profits are robust and the stock market is hitting a record high on a seemingly daily basis.

Zandi noted that there are blemishes, low-income households are struggling, there is a shortage of affordable housing, and the government is running large budget deficits. As always, things could change quickly. But in my time as an economist, he wrote, the economy has rarely looked better. North Georgia, the area represented by MAGA Republican Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene, is one of the areas that has been revitalized with new solar panel manufacturing funded by the Inflation Reduction Act. Yet Phil Mattingly and Andrew Seeger of CNN reported on Friday, September 27th, that while voters there like the strong economy, in this year's election, they say they still plan

to back Trump, who has called Biden's green energy initiatives a scam and vowed to claw back any money still unspent from the Inflation Reduction Act. Aaron Zittner, John Camp, and Brian McGill of the Wall Street Journal today called attention to this paradox, that people in counties that vote for Trump are significantly more likely than those that vote for Democrats to rely on federal government funding. This is in part because they are older and thus receive Social Security and Medicare, and in part because they live in areas hollowed out when industries there left. These are the areas the Biden-Harris administration have targeted for investment. The authors note that these government-funded pro-Trump counties are clustered in the swing

states that will decide the election. About 70% of the counties in Michigan, Georgia, and North Carolina rely significantly on government income. So do nearly 60% of the counties in Pennsylvania. In other news today in Georgia, Fulton County Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney struck down the state's six-week abortion ban, which prohibited abortions before many women know they're pregnant, as unconstitutional. A government investigation recently showed that two Georgia women died after being unable to obtain abortion care in the state shortly after Georgia's ban went into effect. In a searing 26-page decision, the Republican appointed judge wrote that the state cannot force a woman to carry a fetus that cannot live on its own.

Women are not some piece of collectively owned community property, the disposition of which is decided by majority vote. Forcing a woman to carry an unwanted, not yet viable fetus to term violates her constitutional rights to liberty and privacy. violates her constitutional rights to liberty and privacy. This is your world.