Lighthouse Horror Podcast - I Made A Strange Deal For Money. Now I'm Forced To Sell My Daughter | Scary Stories

Episode Date: August 11, 2023

Am I losing my mind?  Story from ChaosSlave51 Make sure to check out more of their work at u/ChaosSlave51         Original Post: I sold my first born to the fay, and they are coming to collect : r/nosleep                Original YouTube link: I Made A Strange Deal For Money. Now I'm Forced To Sell My Daughter  For more stories like this one, check out my YouTube channel: Lighthouse Horror | YouTube  Patreon: Lighthouse Horror | Patreon Sound Effects: Freesound Zapsplat  Music: Lucas King - YouTube Myuu - YouTube  Incompetech Thank you for listening to this scary story! If you enjoyed this new creepypasta story, please check out some of my other horror stories. We'll be uploading new scary stories, new true stories, and new creepypasta stories every day!

I squeezed the gun in my hands and obsessively checked the eight chambers. It was still loaded, the same way it was five minutes ago. Satisfied for the moment, I hit it in my pocket again. Having a loaded gun in the baby's room, I bet you could be arrested just for that. Arrested and divorced, and I would deserve it. From anyone else's point of view, I was just crazy. But maybe if you listen to my story, you'll see that I have a very good good thing. good reason to be this afraid.

It started not too long after my 21st birthday. I took a bus to Atlantic City without the rest of the boys. I decided they were the ones holding me back from one of those crazy nights you see in the movies. I would go, gamble, find a party, and have a hangover to which I would compare every other hangover I ever had. Things didn't go as planned. It's amazing how fast $300 goes in AC.

Well, maybe it would have gone further if I didn't discover my special relationship with drinking and gambling. It was only 11, and I was making my first trip to the ATM. By 1 a.m., I'd not only emptied my debit card, I'd also used up the 20 in my pocket for the bus ticket home. I did not have a way to get back to my flat. But worse, I no longer had my share of the rent for Monday. If you guess this was not the first time I'd done something less than that.

smart, you may be right, and there was going to be a good chance I was going to be thrown out. I sat in a side alley thinking of a plan as my head swam. I'd have to spend the night stumbling around here, the beach, and the casino, and then call my parents in the morning to buy me a ticket home. After that, I'd have to figure out how to borrow money to make rent. Can I bomb a cigarette? Came a voice, and I realized someone had sat down next to me.

was a large man with an unmistakable smell of whiskey surrounding him like a cloud. He had a huge growth of black hair that tangled into a mess on his head, reminding me of overgrown ivy. His huge beard covered most of his face, but through the gap that was his mouth, I could see at least two glistening gold teeth. For a moment, I considered trying to sell him the cigarettes, but then thought better of it. The dollar was not going to make any difference.

A little good karma could go a long way towards getting through the night. I pulled out my last two and a lighter, handing one to the man. Not your night? Asked the man taking a long puff. No, no, lost everything. This city. He looked at me long and hard and then showed me his gold teeth. It'll take everything from you.

It's a living thing, you know. to be fed. Well, I have nothing left to give. I don't even have the bus fare home. He took a long measure of me. Do you want to make one more wager? Maybe get out of this clean. I told you, I don't have anything left.

A car passed, and I got a better look at my alley mate. He wore an old, dark, green suit, soaked in mud and whatever else. His teeth, every single one, was a different shade of gold. And his eyes. In a moment of light, I thought they were green with vertical elongated pupils. How about you wager something? From your future. My future.

I'm not betting money I don't have. I'm not that stupid. Not money. He said as he moved closer to me. The smell of alcohol and piss was overwhelming. How about you, wager? Your first born. I laughed, even though nothing was funny.

I don't have children, I said. That's why it's a wager. A gamble. A risk. The man's voice pierced me to the core, and I felt as if I was prey in the eyes of a predator. If you have children, the first is mine, and you can go home like this night never happened. Um, I hesitated. This was crazy, but as I looked at the man, I knew some truth deep inside.

I was not going to survive the night here. He was the first in a long line of those who prowled these streets at night. Okay. I guess you can have my first born. If you can get me home with all the money I lost. Smart boy. The man replied. Yeah, very smart. I thought to myself. I don't want children. So smart that I'm pretending to myself that some drunk in an alley is going to get my rent money back. Check your pockets, boy.

I reached into my pockets and fumbled past my empty wallet for a moment. Then I pulled out the only other thing in there. Somehow, I still had a $1 chip. This is going to get me home. Take it to the wheel. Play 13. Then 17. I was going to say something else, but I turned my head to a noise.

Two cats fell into the alley fighting. When I turned back, the old man was gone, with only an empty bottle of whiskey where he sat. As I said, one dollar was not getting me home. I walked back into the casino, it was now mostly empty, only the terrifying night crowd of truly those having nothing to lose. I realized I was one of them. I didn't hesitate. I just walked up and dropped my chip on 13.

And then as the ball stopped spinning and the wheel. came to rest. I had $35. That was enough to get home. I felt sweat run down my body. In a moment, everything felt so real and so fake. I could not stop. Something deep inside screamed not to do it, but I moved the little pile of chips to $17. I cashed out over $1,000. I was up for the night, I paid an Uber to get me home. The gun was heavy in my hands, and I realized I had it out of my pocket with my finger too close to the trigger. I was not going to have children until I met Kara.

I was 23 and just done with college. She had freckles, huge blue eyes, and the kind of smile that could make a man do anything. We got married. We had a girl, Nora, and then I had two women in my life I'd do anything for. I tried to never think about that night in Atlantic City, not until I met the gold-toothed man again. She's twenty days out of the womb. I spun around as I was exiting a pharmacy, making a late-night diaper run.

Next to the door sat a homeless man smoking a cigarette. I'd quit nine months ago, but could still feel the irritation and desire of a long-lost vice. What? I asked. Almost not sure he was talking to me. Twenty days. In twenty more, we will come. We will take what is ours.

You will pay your debt to the Emerald Eyes. As it is midnight now, it will be midnight then. We will take what is owed. I spun at the man. Listen here. I lost the force out of my voice. I could see his cat pupils and I could see his golden smile. I'll pay you.

You gave me a thousand. I'll give you five. Yes, you will pay me. We will be there in twenty days. I was going to say something else, but another man exiting the store bumped me. When I looked back, there was just an empty bottle next to some rags. It's 11.30 now. In 30 minutes, I may find out if lead is as good as iron to stop a fay.

1158. I looked at my gun and drew back the hammer and then slowly set it back. I traded my first born to some creatures beyond this world, but this was a gun. not a moment to be completely reckless. They would be here to collect in less than two minutes. I had the doors and windows locked and covered. The door to the nursery was also closed. My wife was asleep. I planned very carefully, so tonight would be my turn to be awake. Nora was sleeping in her crib in the center of the room. I sat three feet away with my back to the wall, just far enough to have full visibility and freedom of most.

motion, just close enough, that I could reach her in one step. I thought again to myself how crazy I was, holding a loaded gun almost facing my infant. But I also knew that all my locked doors and precautions wouldn't mean anything. I saw the large gold-toothed man disappeared twice. I didn't think things like doors concerned him. Midnight. It was the mirror. I didn't know how they were going to come in.

But I wasn't surprised that it was the full-length dressing mirror. At exactly midnight, the surface of it went black and then bubbled like a pot ready for pasta. When it was done. The new image wasn't of the room. I was expecting gold teeth, but something else stood on the other side. It was a white, slender figure. It had to duck its head down to get its antlers through the oculus and into the room. It had a goat face, stood upright, hooves on its feet, but human hands, covered in coarse white fur.

It looked at me and spoke, with a clarity that the goat snout had no right to have. It sounded condescending and bored. Does that mean you are not? No, I am not. I tried to sound brave and determined, but the words came out breathless. And as such low standards. I'm willing to make some sort of compromise. I said, I felt like my heart was going to come out of its chest.

I tried to take a deep breath. If I just dropped dead right here, it wouldn't help anyone. Sheehan and I doesn't get your weapon in my experience. This means you- It was right. Win or lose here. If I had an accidental firearm discharge in the nursery, through protective services or divorce, I would not keep this child. We can be reasonable here, and we can make a deal.

Or you could make me do something unreasonable. You gave me a thousand dollars and I can return it to you with fair interest. The disdain in its voice for the last word was palpable. We gave you. I had one more bluff. One more unthinkable thing. Even saying the words sent tears to my eyes. I didn't care. I wasn't going to end this day without having tried everything.

Maybe I can't kill you, but I can kill the child. If you don't negotiate with me, you can go back to your emerald eyes empty handed. I'll shoot the child and then myself, and then you'll have nothing. The world went blurry and my hands were shaking. I could feel tears running down my face. I didn't know if I was screaming and if my wife could hear me upstairs. I tried to steady myself to gather my will and show this goat that I had the determination. Your hand.

If you Chean may be dead. Why should I believe you? I cried. You, miss. I raised the gun. And put it to my head. The metal felt cool and almost pleasant to the sweaty skin. I steeled myself and tried to pull the trigger.

I felt the hammer slowly rise as I squeezed until it reached the point of break. I let go and the gun didn't discharge. I held it in my shaking hand and I dropped it to the ground. I didn't have it in me. I had big words, but I couldn't do it. That's the thing. The goat smiled, pulling back its lips and revealing its almost human teeth. You're all.

I crumpled where I stood. I watched another figure stepped through the mirror, a large man with gold teeth. Sheehan spread his fingers in a gesture, and a darkness filled me, made of magic and despair. The world around me grew black. Kara, my wife, found me in the morning. You fell asleep here watching her. She said, you were so cute. I looked to the crib, not knowing what to expect. Was I asleep? Did I dream at all? There was something shaped like my little baby in there. Kara kneeled down and picked it up. Oh, she's being fussy today.

I stepped over, blinking my eyes to look at my daughter, wrapped up and swaddled, was a little thing. It had inhuman blue skin and no hair. Its ears were long and pointed, full of fur. When it saw that I was near it, it opened its eyes, and it looked. right back at May. They were gold pupils on a sea of black. It smiled at May, showing rows of sharp needle teeth. She must be hungry, Kara said, revealing a breast from her robe. She held the creature to her, but then jerked it away.

Ow! I must be really tender. Honey, could you make a bottle? I'll try breastfeeding later. The thing in my wife's arms looked at me and laughed. To enjoy the taste of this human. It cackled at me. Ha, ha, she's laughing. Kara gently rocked the bundle in her arms. Look at her. She's laughing for the first time.

I left the room. This wasn't over. I may have lost my will at that moment. but this wasn't over. Maybe I was the only one who could see the monsters, but I will walk to hell and back, and I will have my daughter back. It has been over one week since the Faye took my daughter. In its place, they left a blue goblin-like creature called a changeling. No one but me can see that something is wrong.

My wife still cares for it like it's our own child. child, and I can feel myself slipping into madness. I know this is my fault. I made the deal for my first born to get myself out of a moment of trouble at a young age, but I don't deserve this hell. Nora was a quiet child. Kara and I quickly fell into a rhythm of feeding and changing her. The changeling screams anytime it doesn't have someone's attention.

moment now, someone has to be with it. And often it screams, even if we have it in our arms. It doesn't eat when it should eat and pukes its yellow bile on everything around. It defecates a green liquid whose stench makes me puke. It mocks me any time I'm in the room. It tells me of the suffering my daughter will face in the emerald eyes court. And it picks me apart as a human being, knowing every flaw I hold in my heart. Perhaps if I knew life would be like this, I would have been able to pull the trigger and save my little girl. The worst part is I have to play along. I have to pretend to soothe the baby as it laughs at me and tells me that I'll crack. I'll give in, and then when I'm gone, it'll be free to ravage my wife as it pleases."

Kara thought Nora was sick, and we took her to the pediatrician. I prayed that while the changeling could defeat human sight, modern medical test would somehow see through the glamour. The doctor told us that we had a perfectly healthy child, if a bit underweight, and that this kind of fussy period was normal. I even made us go to church. Maybe the changeling could not enter hallowed ground, or perhaps the priest would sense the taint of evil.

He looked right at the little goblin and told us what a pretty baby we had, as the changeling spouted blasphemies. My only free time was in the bathroom. There, with every moment I could steal I was on my phone learning about the fay. The goat sounded like the visit it was making was routine. I couldn't have been the only one. We were not peasants alone on farmland to harass. We were a people connected around the world by knowledge.

I learned words like changeling and glamour. I learned mythology that I could firsthand tell was not true. The changeling did not fear the cross or iron. Cold iron. That was the last thing to perhaps try, but I had no idea where to get some. I also read a lot about postpartum depression and other parental psychosis, new parents losing their minds, and trying or succeeding in murdering their children. Was it the Faye, or was I being taken by the madness?

This had to end one way or another. I put together one plan, one Hail Mary. I gathered what I thought I'd need from eBay, and I told my wife she should take a weekend with the girls. I'd watch the child, and a little break would go a long way for our marriage. I waited until noon on Sunday the moment I thought furthest from the midnight these creatures preferred. I had my last ingredient ready, as I set the false infant in its carrier in the middle of a cleared living room. What are you doing, you little excuse for a man?

your wife finally left you?" It said. No. I was calm. I sat down my phone and started recording the changeling. We're going to try something new. What do you think of these cute baby mittens? I asked. It squirmed, but being recorded, did not fight any more than an infant would as I pulled the little things over its hands. Are you insane? Are you recording yourself being insane? No. If you won't do anything weird, I won't do anything weird. I said, and then I pulled out a flask

and poured it on the changeling as it squirmed. Holy water, what is your plan? I do not care about your Lord or Holy Water. No, but I didn't notice you would not drink baby formula when I added some to the mix. I think it only hurts you if you get it inside. I replied, So what are you going to do now? Cut up your child on video? You're insane, you know. You'll go to prison. Do you know what they'll do to you in prison? Prisons are full of beings like me who do not take well to attacks on their kind. Or maybe there is no fay.

The creature continued. Maybe you are insane. Did you think of that? Do you see what you're about to do? You're about to stab your own baby. Don't you think it's much more likely that you've lost your mind than that fairies are real? I figured that out too. I said, smiling.

And then I walked to the kitchen. I returned with a big plastic cage and set it on the ground. This is Shiagmarfour. Am I pronouncing that right? A meow came from the cage. You brought a cat? The creature sounded a little concerned the first time it lost that shrill in its voice. Not just a cat, actually.

I began. A twenty-pound Maine Coon, named, do tell me if I'm translating this wrong, Faye Slayer. I opened the cage, and the gray feline stepped out and stretched its long back. Huh. It says here, great with children. This is a trial adoption just for a week. If I'm crazy, well, it's about to go over there and sniff you. I'm going to get a very cute video.

Or maybe I'm not. And he's about to tear out your throat. No, no. The creature said as I held the cat back by the collar. I am here for your benefit. I'm here so you don't have to explain what happened to the baby. My benefit. You are a nightmare.

I will be good. I will be quiet. It said. I really thought the little guy sounded genuinely scared. Here's what we're going to do. I'm going to keep the cat. And if you speak again without being asked or do anything to upset me or the misses, I'm going to forget to close the door to the baby room.

And the cat is going to tuck you in. And then I'm going to clean out your cuts with this. I waved the flask. Yes, yes, I understand. Yes. said the changeling. But there's more. If you want to survive the day, you are going to tell me how to cross the mirror.

No. The creature said, You're mortal. There are rules against that. And what good will it do? These little tricks will do nothing to Sheehan. You are nothing to the court of the emerald eyes. I picked up the cat and brought it close.

It hissed as it looked at the goblin. I put my hand into my pocket and dropped little bits of iron around the baby carrier. I am not going to ask again. You will tell me how to pass the mirror and you will swear on your immortality to tell me the whole truth. You will speak it thrice and you will be bound to your word. The ingredients I needed were weird, but not ungetable. As soon as I'm ready, one of these dark midnights, when the barriers between our worlds are thinnest.

I'm going to get my daughter back. I spent the last week going through herbalist and mystic shops looking for the ingredients that I needed, but now I had the mixture. I again found a night my wife was asleep and prepared to do the ritual. I crushed all the herbs into a powder and a mortar and dropped them into a glass full of unmulted whiskey. It took me a few tries to force the concoction down. I hadn't had this much alcohol in one glass since before I was married.

Then as the warmth of the drink filled my body and the foul taste of the herbs danced in my mouth, I waited for the mirror. I didn't think it was going to work. I thought the little goblin found some cheat or out. from the deal we made. Maybe this concoction was just poison, and I was going to drop dead right here. Against the odds I set in my mind, the mirror began to boil just like before. I clenched the gun in my pocket. It was better to not need it and have it than to need it and not have it. At the same time, I was already feeling a daze. I was more likely to hurt myself

with that thing than anyone else. I needed to come in as a guest. I wasn't going to get anywhere by force. With a sigh, I hid the gun in a drawer. Then, with no more ways to hesitate, I took a deep breath and stepped through. I think I was expecting a forest. Every storybook ever had the fay hold in some deep woods. Where I found myself instead was an old smoked-up rum. The clouds of tobacco were so thick that they obstructed vision more than a few feet away. The smell pulled at my insides and begged me to light a cigarette. I don't know how with all the stress I'd still not had one since she was taken. I looked around trying to get some sort of bearing. I stood on a cheap carpet with a disgusting mix of faded, colorful shapes and stains of all shades

of brown. There was so much noise that it took me a long time. time to process what I was looking at, all the talking, clinking, and ringing bells. I was somewhere in the middle of a row of machines. At each one sat a person, their eyes transfixed. All in their own rhythm, pulled giant levers on the side, and watched wheels tumble inside to show numbers or cherries. I was looking at old slot machines, the one-eyed bandits. Around the machines walked the staff. Some had drinks or cigars on their trays. They were all animals on their hind legs, not unlike the goat. One stopped offering me a drink, but I already had too much and waved them on. Suddenly I heard a choking noise. I turned around to see an older

man behind me grasp his chest and dropped to the floor. I looked at his machine and read out 0-0-0. From the smoke emerged three wolf-headed employees. They were dressed differently than the waiters. Without hesitation, they dropped to all fours and began devouring the man. The other patrons seemed to give this no mind at all. I turned my head and tried to walk forward. This was not my fight.

A head were roulette tables. I paused at one. the once green felt was soaked in blood, and the field had a kidney laid out on red. The wheel came up black, and the camel-looking creature scraped the organ off the board into a bucket. A man at the table's side and stuck his arm between the buttons on his shirt. After rummaging around, he came up with a brown pulsating mass in his hand. a pause, he plopped it, still bleeding, under red again. I didn't stay long enough to see how this spin fared. I walked and walked, but this casino had no start or end. Just an

endless row of gambling devices and gamblers slowly being digested in the yellow smoke. I felt it in me, too. I felt I'd inhaled enough nicotine to have smoked a pack. The old endless craving in the back of my mind was finally satisfied, but I knew it wanted more soon. All around, one logo was repeated on everything, from the machines to the drink glasses. The emerald eyes. Both of the first E's drawn as an eye with gemstones. This was a machine destined to consume humanity. The alcohol quickly flowed to my brain.

Thinking became more and more difficult. At least it was giving me courage for what I had to do. I kept walking, or maybe now stumbling around. There was no time, no space. I was just lost. And then I felt an arm on my shoulder. Startled, I turned and saw Gold-toothed Sheehan. I thought you were not dumb enough or brave enough to do something like this.

He pushed my shoulder and spun me hard. When I looked around again, I was in a different room. This was a bar with animal patrons shuffling in and out. Behind the bar stood a short, thin man in a bright green suit and top hat. His eyes were two giant green gemstones. He put down a glass he was cleaning and looked at me. So what's your poison? I wanted to start with something aggressive, but I bit my tongue.

I was not going to intimidate the things here into doing what I want. I don't want to drink. I said softly. I think I had enough. I just want my daughter back. Ignoring my words, he pulled out a green bottle and poured me a shot of a thick liquid. I somehow knew that I had to drink it to continue the conversation. He waited for me to set the shot glass down before talking.

And how are you going to trade for that? You add your chance to end your life and break the contract. Now your heart has less beats than hers and your liver can take less drinks. How are you going to offer something of greater value to the Emerald Eyes? There must be something you want. There must be something I can give. A man isn't born with all his value just to lose it over time. There must be some value acquired throughout one's life, I said.

How poetic. The bartender laughed. Mortals get so poetic when they grow desperate. I will tell you one thing. I have a soft spot for anyone who makes it this far. Most people simply accept their fate. Most people cut their losses. But not you.

You will double down again and again. You think the game is not fixed against you. You think sooner or later, the wheel will spin red. I don't want to gamble. I don't want any arrangement where I don't have my daughter back. Ah, I see. Well, let me take a look at you. There is one thing you have more valuable than a girl.

Here is the game. If you let me have it without knowing what it is, it's a deal. I will not give up my life, I said, and took a deep breath. My daughter will have a mother and a father. I will not give up anything that will take away from her happiness. I will not let Kara think I killed myself. Besides that, take anything you want, and do it because I'm not leaving otherwise. If you are a good man as you think, it will have no effect on your daughter's happiness.

He poured me and then himself a shot. Let us see Ovidia. We drank and looked into each other's eyes. In his shining gemstones, I only saw myself. And it made me feel disgusted. I broke the gaze first as I coughed. The alcohol and nicotine was too much, and I had to do my best not to throw up right there. As it is said, it is done, spoke the emerald eyes.

And be forever banished from the realm of Thay. I woke up in my daughter's rum. There in her crib lay a perfect little baby. Noro woke up with me, looked at me, and smiled. I rushed over and picked her up. I didn't know if to laugh or cry. I felt no different than I was before. I didn't care what the fay took from me.

It was worth it. You fell asleep watching her again. My wife said, walking into the room. She walked over, took the baby, and then fixed me with a stare. I smell booze, and are you back to smoking? Is this what you do all night when you tell me you'll watch Nora? You sit here drinking and smoking in her room. I looked at my wife, and I didn't understand.

She was the same woman. She was my wife, but she was different. Nothing to say for yourself. And you think I've not seen you keeping that gun out of the safe? You promised you were going to keep it locked up. I can't even look at you right now. She said, taking the baby and going upstairs. I wanted to defend myself, but I couldn't.

What could I say? I was too drunk to get a coherent sentence together. I didn't even understand who she was. I realized then that I didn't love her anymore. I sat watching the empty crib. I still had something. I still loved my daughter. If I could still feel something, that means this wasn't over.

Maybe I could fall in love with Kara again. How could I not love the mother of my child? I didn't know. I felt sick to my stomach and full of self-pity. I put my hand to my pocket on instinct, finding it empty. I had not had a pack there for nine months now. I looked at the half-empty whiskey bottle near the mirror and considered if I should pour it down the drain. I was older now. I had self-control.

I didn't need to do those kinds of things. The cat came up and rubbed against my leg. Perhaps he was the real face layer after all, because I felt something shift inside myself. For a moment, I felt like I didn't give something up, but instead was cursed. That somehow made me feel better. Like I could free myself and things could go back to how they were. I knew one thing, though. If I had to do the last three weeks over again, I wouldn't do them any other way.