Media Storm - ARCHIVE What is the refugee 'crisis'? Plus: Media Storm Series 5 announcement

Episode Date: January 30, 2025

Media Storm is returning next week! Series 5 will begin on Thursday 6th February - and there are now TWO episodes of Media Storm every week. Every Thursday, we'll be dropping Media Storm's News Watch - where Mathilda & Helena will run through the main stories of the week, picking apart the most unhinged headlines to help you make sense of the mainstream media. Every Friday, we'll release our regular episodes - our deep-dives into a topic that we think has been misrepresented in the mainstream media. And we'll do that with the most important (and most overlooked) people in the story - the ones living it.  Until then, here is one from the archives: Media Storm's first ever investigation about the so-called refugee 'crisis'. With headlines reporting ‘record numbers of migrants’ reaching the UK in dinghies, Media Storm headed across the Channel to find out why they’re coming. The UK claims that accepting asylum seekers creates a ‘pull factor’ and encourages more people to come - we look at whether this is really what’s causing the crisis. Plus, we've republished our conversation from last series, where we busted the biggest myths about refugees with two people who have lived experience - Journalist Osama Gaweesh, and Afghan journalist, newsreader, and women's rights activist, Zahra Shaheer. Make sure you have your notifications on so you can join us, TWICE weekly, from Thursday 6th Feb for Series 5! Follow us: Helena Wadia (@helenawadia) Mathilda Mallinson (@mathildamall) Media Storm (@mediastormpod) Support Media Storm on Patreon. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

This episode is brought to you by Peloton. A new era of fitness is here. Introducing the new Peloton Cross Training Tread Plus, powered by Peloton IQ. Built for breakthroughs, with personalized workout plans, real-time insights, and endless ways to move. Lift with confidence, while Peloton IQ counts reps, corrects form, and tracks your progress. Let yourself run, lift, flow, and go. Explore the new Peloton Cross Training Tread Plus at OnePeloton.ca. What a run! This champ is picking up speed.

But they found a lane. Menominal launch into the air! Absolutely incredible! Air Transat! Fly the seven-time world's best leisure airline champions, Air Transat. Hi Media Stormers, it's Helena here. Just coming on here to say that Media Storm is returning next week. And you're getting two for the price of one, meaning there will now be two episodes of Media Storm every week. Every Thursday we'll be dropping Media Storm's News Watch, where Matilda and I will run through the main stories of the week,

picking apart the most unhinged headlines to help you make sense of the mainstream media. And boy, do we need that now more than ever. Then every Friday will release our regular episodes, our deep dives into a topic that we feel has been misrepresented in the mainstream media. And we'll do that, of course, with the most important and most overlooked people in the story, the ones living it. We also wanted to tell you that Matilda has taken part in a four-part Channel 4 documentary that begins on Monday, February 3rd.

It's a series about immigration and understanding the lives of refugees. It's exploring the topic that made us start this podcast. On our first episode back next week, I'll be asking Matilda, about the show and why she decided to take part in it. Until then, we thought we'd republish Media Storm's first ever investigation about the so-called refugee crisis, followed by a conversation recorded on World Refugee Day last year. You'll hear Matilda and I do a little quiz in this introduction. Now, this was recorded in late 2021, so the numbers have changed a bit since then.

And since we recorded this first episode, the world has been battered by new wars and new Millions more have been made refugees, but the UK still remains at the bottom of the pile of our opening quiz. When it comes to how many asylum seekers we take in compared to our population, in 2024 we were 19th on the wider EU rankings. The vast majority of refugees stay close to home and the poorest countries take the highest shares. So to welcome new listeners and re-welcome loyal listeners, here's our first ever investment. And we can't wait to begin Media Storm Series 5 from next week. Thursday 6th and Friday 7th of February.

Put it in your diaries. Have you ever seen Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? Multiple times. You know, to get into the chair, contestants have to race to put items of a certain category into order. Mm-hmm, fastest finger first. Is that what it's called? Why am I coming off like a huge Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?

Oh, can I have the music? Do you know how the music go? Obviously, you know how the music goes. Obviously, it's my favourite show. Why are we singing it? We'd have to pay for it. Yes, very much. Today we are talking about immigration.

People entering countries without papers in order to claim asylum. So asylum seekers. I'm going to give you five European countries. And I want you to put them in the order of who annually is getting the most asylum seekers, and I'm basing this off the most recent annual figures. In no particular order, your countries are the UK, France, Germany, Spain and Greece. Okay, Greece gets the most, then the UK, then Germany, then Spain, then France. No.

Am I close in any way? Almost the exact opposite. What? Okay, Germany gets the most. Followed by Spain, then France, Greece, the UK. Wow. The UK is actually getting significantly fewer than half of what France is, which is quite surprising, right? Very surprising.

If you were to believe everything you read or see or hear in the media, you would get the impression that the UK is completely overwhelmed with asylum seekers. I used to work in the jungle, which is the refugee camp in Calais. And one of the things everyone would always ask me is, why is everyone coming to the UK? The truth is, they're not? I mean, try this, okay? Try to put those countries in order of who is getting the most annual asylum seekers relative to their population. So I'm going to put the UK a little bit lower down because of what I've just heard. So I'm going to go for Germany, France, the UK, Spain and then Greece.

Okay. I'm trying to think if you got any of those right. Greece goes straight to the top. Wow. Then you have Spain, Germany, France, and way down you have the UK. How come that is not reflected in what we read and what we see? People talk about the UK as if it's El Dorado, but it's more like a last resort. I get the question, why come here?

But maybe what we should be asking isn't why does everyone want to come here. What we should be asking and what papers aren't. really asking is what is preventing them from seeking asylum somewhere easier? Well, let's find out. I'm off to Calais to ask asylum seekers what is pushing them to make that crossing. And I'll see you back in the studio with a special guest to discuss everything around this media storm. We will be taking back control. Our asylum system is fundamentally broken. How have we become this country who stand by while the refugee crisis is wrong because there are a few wretched souls on the other side of the world doing if the perception is that they're losing

control on immigration that could prove fatal welcome to media storm a news podcast that starts with the people who are normally asked last i'm matilda malinson and i'm helena wadia this week's investigation el dorado why do refugees love the UK Headlines about channel migrants often start on our horizon, but the real news story lies beyond. On the outskirts of France's coastal towns like Calais and Dunkirk lie ramshackle refugee camps. If you want to understand why people are coming,

there's one place to start. The jungle. Oh shit. I'm just heading very off-road. to me, a Kurdish man who's going to take us to his campsite. If I'm struggling to drive on this road, imagine what it's like sleeping on him. Salam. It's muddy.

He introduces himself by his full name, Jalmer Ali Mahmoud, then tells me everything I see will soon be destroyed by police. People are cold, he says. They cannot have less than they have now. But he insists he's happy because he's out of Kurdistan, his home nation, which falls within Iraqi territory, and where he fears he'll be killed for political dissent. Now I can't see my picture, my back, Kurdistan. He's just showing me photos of his back with clear torture, injuries. This is in Kurdistan. You were jailed.

Yeah. Would you claim asylum in France? Never. Why not? I think police, Kurdistan, with police France, not different. If 10 years I am in jungle, I don't want asylum France. If 10 years I am, I live in jungle. But one tent in jungle, better vela in Kurdistan.

A tent in a jungle is better than a weather in the forest. Yes, of course. Of course, because in Kurdistan, I am near die. I don't like to leave you. sad. No problem. Sometimes my mother, she said, she said, I can go back to Kurdistan. You, my son, I need your love.

If changed government, I go back to Kurdistan. If not change, I can't. I am dying. Jaume is not alone in his fear of French police. Over in Calais, I meet a group of Sudanese refugees, both men and boys, making a fire for the night. Yesterday, there was a group of Sudanese refugees who went to this lorry service station near the jungle. They call it the station of the devil. A security guard let his dog loose and he chased them, bit someone and drew blood,

while another man fell and broke his leg running away. I asked the UK to take all the Sudanese and refugees from the jungle. Being here is an unbearable struggle. We need rest. Please, with whatever way possible, save us. from this situation, from these unleashed dogs, these unsanitary conditions, the police brutality, please, please, please, save us from this injustice. It seems the UK's hostile border policy may not simply be keeping people out, but in some

cases, cattling them in. You see, it's the UK that pays for most of this, spending nearly a quarter of a billion since 2014. I sit down with Chloe Schmidt-Nielsen from human rights observers to understand this policy. The French official policy is one of daily violence to exhaust. What kind of violence are we talking about? What has your organisation documented? Beatings inside police custody, tear gas leading to hospitalisation, dislocated shoulders, they're closed on, their phones smashed,

their shoes stolen often as well. just a horrific level of police brutality and cruelty. These are, you say, being perpetrated by state officials. Yeah, it's not just individual racist police officers. It's because there is a general system of impunity at the border. As long as the goal at the border is to stop people from going where they need to go, then it will be done through violence. So what do you think the solution should be, if not,

this militarized response? The solution that I can think of, at least, is to open the border in the same way that, I mean, we don't see any camps between France and Germany, and why is that? Because there's no border controls. So it's that simple. But by open the border on the channel,

what does that mean? It means allow people to take the ferry like everyone else. So for a lot of listeners, this would seem like a very radical policy, but maybe when you've seen the extreme, violence that you have, as a result of securitized borders, you will be led to more extreme conclusions. Exactly. Backlogs at the border affect locals too. While we're here, let's see how they feel. I want to help these people, because all of us could be in the same situation,

but they still have to respect the country in which they are staying. Sometimes they just break the window of abandoned buildings and go inside it. My name is Pascal. My name is Pascal. My heart is with these people who are in pain and are starving. I'm here to support them. My name is Stephanie Dumont. It's a bit annoying when the migrants block the port on the motorway, which has happened in the past. Some are kind, some are not, but that's like the French. As a country, I do think we're becoming more and more racist. Of course, some people do apply in France. Of course, some people do apply in France. and then they get rejected. Either their fake refugees, as some politicians and media claim,

or safe countries simply aren't offering enough spaces for everybody. The consequence, overspill. My name is Ali Reza. I'm 28 years old, and I'm Iranian. I went to Germany and I applied for asylum in Germany. It's so amazing. I don't know why. In nine months, they send me a letter. you must go back to Iran we understand that there isn't

any reason for you to stay in Germany while I know my life is in danger in Iran after that I applied for asylum in France they said no you must go back to Germany everybody in an English citizen I see in some

Twitter pages your economical migrants or something like this but we don't have any other way I'm not idiot to cross the channel while I know it's dangerous. I know it's dangerous. But when I don't have any other ways, how can I do? You know, being homeless, being homeless, while you had a place in your country, you had a normal life. We had respect, we had everything. You're just thinking about go, go, go, go, go.

Greece, go, Germany, go. France, go. Here is not your place. Can I ask, when did you learn to speak English? My mother told me, you must learn a second language. For the moment, English is the most important language in the world. Do you speak any French? Yes, a bit. And do you speak any German? Yes, I do.

And do you speak any Greek? Yes. That's very impressive. Yeah. Actually, I don't know if you know about Prophet Solomon. There is a story in Koran about Prophet Solomon. and he could speak all of the languages and also, even with the bears, with the animals.

I would like to learn all of the languages. It's so fun. Oh, bonjour. Como tell you? Blah, blah, blah. Hello, bigots. Allis good. Yasas, Tikhanis.

Very good. A whole met me. France isn't the only safe country in Europe that people are coming from. Ezra in Bahir, who are using pseudonyms to protect their children, are seeking refuge from Iraq. There, it's square zero of the UK's asylum process. For them, it's a huge step back. They were in Austria for five years,

and they had hope, Ezra tells me. Going to school, learning German, making friends, they stayed through xenophobic abuse through years of limbo. They stayed even when something really tragic happened. The accident happened, this mistake, happened 26th of December. 2017.

Ezra had to go to hospital for a chronic illness. They didn't let Bahia in the ambulance with her, and at this time, Ezra spoke no German. And then they performed an emergency operation, a warning that this interview is distressing. First four months, she was not move anything from her body, just ahead. After six months, she just started to move a toe. Ezra was left paralyzed.

Two, three times she tried. to kill herself. Sorry. I needed the bathroom. They told me to go myself, but I couldn't move, and they didn't believe that I couldn't move. They said I was lying.

My hijab fell off, and I asked for it to be put back, but no one responded. No one did it. They just didn't care. They took off all my clothes to run tests. Then they left the room and I asked them to cover me or to put my clothes back on and they didn't.

They just left me like that until the morning. Two and a half years later, Austria rejected their asylum claim. We lost her health. We lost her rights. Some people, they say a political decision. and other people they say they have just enough number from asylum people but they not care about the human rights

this is the point that's how they ended up in a dingy on the channel you move country to Austria from Austria to Germany from Germany to France from France on the sea to UK

this is hard we thought about healthy of my wife and future for me children. We don't have rights in our country. We need building our life. We're not waiting to take something. No, no, never. I need to build the future of my children. I need to make my wife healthy. If it's possible, I can work and that's it. We're not asked about something impossible, just a human right for people.

opening a new chapter and living in safety, Godfriening. There's one more story I want to tell you, and I'm sorry for the overload, but understanding what is really meant by a broken asylum system is a lot more complicated than many media imply. This is the story of two Afghan sisters, separated by borders. Sonia, a British citizen, brought to the UK by her husband long ago, An Atier, a 16-year-old girl, she is fleeing forced marriage to a 70-year-old man.

She said to me, they sold me, and I will kill myself on the wedding day. We're using their first names only to avoid attracting their family's attention. Sonia has tried everything to bring Atier over, but the Afghan resettlement scheme hasn't responded to her appeal and the UK's child resettlement scheme ceased last year. I sit down with Sonia to call her sister, who's in hiding. Please, answer my phone. The last time you heard from her. This morning, hopefully, if anything happened to her,

I won't be alive anymore. The guilt that I haven't done enough for her. Finally, we got through. Doni, as the one of me that I'm from her to find out of her. Yeah, she's saying the reason that I don't want to go out of my room. I'm scared that the people that I've been sued to them, they find me. She's saying, I don't know what else to do. I'm just my only hope is to be with you.

Etienne mutes herself so we don't hear her crying. She's just turning 16, but deep down of her size, she's very far. very depressed. And also in Islam, the girl should not die virgin. So what they do first? They take your virginity and then they kill you. Just help my child. I am not going to call her my sister. She has only me. I think there are three things to understand. Firstly, few are making B-lines for the UK. For many, it's a last resort. Secondly, to apply for asylum, you almost always have to get here first, illegally.

And thirdly, compared to other wealthy European countries, not that many people are coming. So why do we think they are? And is the media responsible for this myth? Perfect. One man who thinks so is Professor Joseph Taye, calling us now from the University of Ghana. So this is a belief that is heard by many people in the global north. The media has then put out that narrative. Say there is a mass exodus to Europe.

And people are even thinking that if we are allowed, everybody will move to Europe. But this is not true. It's coming from the fact that they are seeing only just a small side of the issue, only those arriving. They don't see the other side. where other people are moving to. These are some of the things that need to be decolonized or need to be reformulated.

That brings us to part two of our podcast. Thanks for sticking around. With Amex Platinum, access to exclusive Amex pre-sale tickets can score you a spot trackside. So being a fan for life turns into the trip of a lifetime. That's the powerful backing of Amex. Presale tickets for future events subject to Availability and vary by race.

Terms and conditions apply. Learn more at amex.ca. Slash yanex. Did you lock the front door? Check. Close the garage door? Yep. Installed window sensors, smoke sensors, and HD cameras with night vision?

No. And you set up credit card transaction alerts, a secure VPN for a private connection and continuous monitoring for our personal info on the dark web. Uh, I'm looking into it. Stress less about security. Choose security solutions from Tell Us for peace of mind at home and online. Visit tell us.com slash total security to learn more.

Conditions apply. Welcome to the Media Storm Studio. We're so thrilled to be joined today by two special guests. Our first guest is a journalist and TV anchor based in London. He has written for the Guardian Newsweek Middle East Eye and the African Arguments. He's the editor-in-chief at Egypt Watch and host of the podcast Untold Stories. He is a refugee, a former dentist and an advocate for refugees and asylum seekers' rights.

Welcome to the studio, Osama Gawish. Thank you for having me. Our second guest is a journalist and newsreader who worked in Afghanistan for more than a decade. Following the Taliban's rise to power in August 2021, she fled to the UK where she has volunteered and worked with the Refugee Council, BBC Afghan, the International Rescue Committee and more. She is also a former Refugee Week ambassador at IMEX, the charity which offers training,

coaching and mentoring to those with both lived and learnt experience of migration. Welcome to the studio, Zara Shahir. Thank you for having me. Happy World Refugee Day and thank you both for joining us. The first topic we want to discuss is language. A word that so often follows refugee or migrant in our media is the word crisis. A humanitarian crisis is typically defined as an event that critically threatens the health, safety, security or well-being of a community.

We find it telling that in most cases when our media describes the refugee crisis, the crisis they seem to be referring to is not the hundreds of millions of people who have been displaced from their homes, but the tens of thousands trying to come to hours. Is the term crisis accurate when we talk about the UK's refugee crisis or what do you think crisis should refer to in this context? This term is definitely a good term that we can use for a refugee crisis because it highlights the urgency. It highlights the need that refugees need help, they need support, like the same as we have economic crisis. When there's some problem, all governments think how to find a solution through diplomatic relations with other countries.

It's the same with the refugee crisis. they need to think why the refugees forced to flee what was in their country they must stop the war and conflict in the countries that the people had to flee and come for safety.

So the term crisis is accurate when we're describing the refugees who are forced to flee their home but unfortunately I guess in our media they often use the word crisis about the amount of refugees coming to the UK. To be honest I disagree with Zahara

because describing people as crisis is not fair. We can talk about economic crisis. We can talk about border crisis. We can talk about inflation crisis. But we can label people as crisis. I describe this as racist label because people are not crisis. People force it to flee. People force it to have this horrible journey.

The media here in this country and in Western media, to be honest, they use this crisis to labor refugee, They are a threat. So I think we need to reconsider describing people as crisis. Well, I think actually while we're speaking about language, I think we should move one step further and actually talk about some of the terms that are used so frequently in the media, but often really like never thought about with any kind of detail.

As mentioned in the introduction, we celebrate World Refugee Day today. And it's the anniversary of the 1951 Geneva Convention, which laid out an international definition for refugees. This definition is someone who is unable or unwilling to return to their country of origin owing to a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion. But this is not the definition used by media outlets who reserve the term refugees for people whose request for asylum has been approved by a host country.

Instead, we use terms like migrant, asylum seeker, illegal immigrant. What is the problem with this differentiation in language between the legal and the literal meaning of refugee? Some terms and walls can make us confuse. It brings confusion to the audience. I'm against illegal migration. There is no illegal migration because people forced to flee. They don't choose to come for a better life. They come for safety.

Some people choose to come through safe routes. Some people, there's not safe routes for them to come. It's in the media job. They should use the proper terms to make it clear for the audience and for the people to understand. And they can imagine themselves as a refugee. If we call it like illegal migration, it's not fair for a person who forced to flee and lost everything. And we call them illegal migration. it is, in my idea,

it's not something fair with refugees. I totally agree with Zahra and we both had prominent job in our country for origin. She was a prominent speaker and I was a prominent dentist. I was a manager of a hospital. So if you asked us a few years ago,

do you think you need to move to the UK to seek asylum and to be a refugee? I said, what? No, I'm happy with my country. I'm happy with my job. I'm happy with everything here. We didn't look or think about a better life. We just looking for safety.

We had an military coup and then start targeted every activist in the country. So we forced it to leave. The only place we got is here. And we tried and struggled to find a new life, a new job. And we pay a taxpayer. And we are, as any British citizen in this country, we're not overload in this country. No, we're adding value to this society. So this should be the way the media treat with us,

who in the Western countries experience a war in 2022, when Russia invade Ukraine. I didn't remember any ministry media or any outlet, even with the deployed or the other, labeled the Ukrainian as illegal immigrant. It was asylum. No, no, no. It's Ukrainian refugee and this is our commitment in the country

and there is safe routes for Ukrainian. So there is safe road and we are respecting the white refugee. I think this is another hypocrisy. Do you think that we as a society are almost scared to call it racism? Do you think we call out the fact that it is racism enough? I think it is racism and it's intentionally doing this. The covering of media of refugee stories like victims or criminals. There is no midpoint between both.

a victim and we we sympathize with you oh my god and that's it and the other thing you are a criminal you are illegal you come from nabot we will send you to rwanda so there is a midpoint between two he is a human pain she's a human pain just treat with him like this yes and this brings us i think very neatly onto what we want to talk about next which is this kind of disproportionate distribution of positive refugee stories in our media and negative refugee stories in our media. Now, we did some searching and we did find some positive but vastly more negative stories about refugees in general. Most of the stories were about the poor conditions that refugees live in, the record number of displaced people or the number of so-called channel migrants. What is

the impact of this coverage, this consistent negative coverage about refugees? There's a lot of negative news about refugees and show the refugees how dangerous they are in the host country. Like nowadays in Germany, there's all news about Afghan refugees. One Afghan refugee called the police officer. And a lot of Afghan refugees deported back in Afghanistan in this situation. Because what happened? They never thought about the other angles of the accident, how it happened. I'm not going to support that Afghan man. He's a criminal. but the government's changed their policies against refugees and they become stricter to make strict the law against refugees.

Yeah, I think this covered, this negative coverage, it's like a collective punishment for the whole refugee in this country. You are a refugee, so we will punish you by negative coverage. In the early days of 2020, we had very sad news that three members of the frontline NHS doctors have died. And the surprise was that they were refugees. refugees from Sudan and Somalia. Yes.

So this was a good example. For everyone in the ministry, media, these are the refugee in this country. The other one is the brilliant Hassan Akad, the Syrian refugee who won't Pafta, who crossed the border, who came from Syria, and then he volunteered as a worker in the NHS in the first wave of COVID. This is what the refugee can do to this country. They are a part of this country. They want to be a part of this country. They want to feel belongings to this country because they can't look back. They can't go back.

There is no Syria. There is no Egypt. There is no Afghanistan for many of us now because we can't go back. We can't return to our homeland. So if we have a chance, we will do. But we can't. So this is our new country and we are belonging to this society. We want to add values to this society.

When we were searching to find, you know, how many positive versus negative stories there were. It was very interesting because when we were searching the term refugee on individual news sites, we'd find a varied selection of stories. When we search migrant, almost all of the coverage was negative or about party manifestos,

so about policies. We've mentioned a few times about positive stories, and one story we did see this week was this. Former refugee becomes Northern Ireland's first black mayor. This is, of course, a really great story. It's a success story. However, often we see kind of two extremes with refugee stories. Either they're kind of, you know, faceless, nameless people crossing the channel

or they're successful refugees that beat the odds. You know, they're the first mayor, they're an Olympic gold medalist, they're a BAFTA winner. What does this say about how we value refugees? I think we need in the mainstream media to focus not on the successful stories only or in the refugee as victims and so on. No, we need to focus on the job, the history, the positive points of this man or woman or girl or whatever in his homeland or her homeland. Just raise this, highlight this, telling the people in the UK that we have a good man, we have a good girl, we have a good woman. They were brilliant in their homeland and they will do the same in this country.

We need to deal with these people with proudly. Sometimes refugees can be change makers in other countries, in the host country, why they don't think positive about it. They only think about, like, some people think in the UK, refugees are coming here, taking our jobs. They also do work hard. They bring changes in this country. They pay tax, everything. So they are also working as a human, as a citizen of this country. You've mentioned Rwanda a couple of times, and I just want to ask about that quickly. When the government's Rwanda deportation scheme was announced, there was outrage about how callous and dangerous the whole idea to send refugees to another country and

potentially unsafe country was. I want to know that first of all, were you surprised when the government created the Rwanda deportation scheme? Did it surprise or shock you in any way? Both. Surprise and shocked me because I came from this continent. I came from Africa. I know well Kagami presidents. He's like Egyptian presidents. He's like Libyan late presidents Gaddafi. And they are authoritarian leaders. And we all know what authoritarian leaders do to its people, to their people, persecution, injustice. And every single topic, the media here advocate against and we need to respect to human rights. There is no human rights in this country. We all know this. But the government here is proud to do this. And this is something even against the British values. When I arrived in the UK, I was new in this country and they said they were going to send refugees in Rwanda. And I was thinking, if they send me in Rwanda with my two children, is there any kind of good facilities for my children to learn? Is there any rights as a refugee

that I have in the UK, it is the plan is wasting the people's life. We don't value your time. We don't value your life. I think we move from dealing a mistreat the refugee in this country to export our racism

coverage to other countries. For example, I'm originally from Egypt and you know in Egypt the national media are fully owned and controlled by the general intelligence where the President's son is working. And who When people start to advocate for refugees and asylum seekers in Egypt,

the national media owned and controlled by the General Intelligence said, look to Britain, they are sending refugee to Rwanda. This is a country of democracy. This is a country of human rights. This is the idol of you. So we need to do the same as UK. So congratulations to the government. You are exporting this racism and this mistreat to refugee to authoritarian leaders in the Middle East.

That's a very incredible point. Thank you. How much do you think that the decisions to ramp up immigration control are made in response to media pressure or media negativity? A lot. It's not only the media's job that they just cover the news. It has a lot of impact. Whatever we say today, when people hear these words, they keep in mind and they think about it. It's the same with policymakers. When they listen to them. to the news, they see the impacts and they make their decision. And I think here there is a good statement I've learned the first week I arrived to the country. Refugee is not your enemy. Your enemy is the regime that make this refugee. The ministry media here need to understand this. Refugee didn't cause the inflation to increase.

Refugee didn't make the NHS salary law. They didn't force Britain to leave the European Union. Refugee are not the problem of any of this. The government here in this country and some political parties with their pathetic policies and their support and backing authoritarian leaders in the Middle East, they are the problem. They are making this refugee

and they are making this problem to this society. Just please understand this. We are not a problem. focused, positive reporting does exist, and we found an increase in this recently, likely because it is Refugee Week. In the BBC this week, Refugee Week aims to bring communities together, Council calls for volunteers to help refugees, cathedral given new status for supporting refugees. However, a lot of these stories still don't speak to actual refugees. World Refugee Day is specifically focused on the inclusion of refugees, and yet our media sets

a terrible example by failing to include them in the coverage about them. Research from 2021's London College of Communications Refugee Journalism Project shows 64% of news broadcasts about refugees, migrants and asylum seekers do not feature a refugee migrant or asylum seeker voice. You are both journalists. To start, Asama, could you tell us about the importance of hiring refugees as journalists? Yeah, I need to highlight the importance of the refugee journalism project. I owe this initiative and I say thank you to Vivian and all the staff in the refugee journalism project

because they helped me a lot. They put me on the right start in this country to just be a freelancer to write training for one year attending a mini workshop with Plumberg, The Guardian, BBC, and then a fellowship for six months in two media news outlet in the country. So a huge experience. It's helped you to build your self-confidence as a journalist in this country to help you to improve your language

so you can overcome the language barrier and to introduce you probably to the industry here. And does the language barrier contribute to a lack of refugee voices in UK media? It needs much work from us to just learn language and then learn how to run. right, but it needs a lot of work to be done from the industry as well. Just help these people

to integrate with you, help these people to overcome this language barrier. Because we are talking here in the industry about the diversity, the inclusion. Okay, these topics are brilliant, but please do these topics on the ground. Hire more refugee journalism and be patience with their language, train them and develop their skills. And you will get a lot of of things because we have an area of experience. No one in this country, even a correspondent, can write about Afghanistan better than Zara,

or about Egypt better than me. Even a correspondent live in Egypt or Afghanistan for many years. No, I've spent 28 years in Egypt. So I know every single angle of this society. Absolutely. Sarah, I wonder what helped you maintain your journalism career

when you had to flee to the UK? When first I come in the UK, I was in the hotel for six months. and spending trauma, stress, anxiety. And everyone was teasing me. A journalist is coming from Afghanistan and they were saying, oh, you can go to McDonald's and wash the dishes

because you can't do anything with the language barrier, first of all. And I was thinking the same, okay, if I want to live in this country, what job should I do? And I was only thinking about washing the dishes or just walking a dog. Nothing else.

But refugee journalism project helped me. It's very difficult for a journalist. to throw away her pen, don't write anymore, it's very important to hire them. And they have better experience and also they have better understanding with lived experience. I can cover about Afghan women very easy, very easy. If I want to interview an Afghan woman about a thousand days that the schools are closed in Afghanistan, million of women are ready to come and to be interviewed by me. But if an English journalist wants, she's...

She will find it's very difficult to find even one person for an interview. It's very difficult. So it's better to support refugee journalists as well. Experiences the mother of the knowledge. You raise such an important point and probably the key theme of Media Storm because sometimes at Media Storm we get called up by outlets like BBC Today program looking for refugees that they can interview. And this would be great, except that their line of institutions,

interviewing often puts refugees off from wanting to speak because they are only asked about their trauma. And we believe that refugees should be invited to not share their trauma, but their expertise, their expertise by experience. Clearly, you know, you've seen that this happens in the media. Have either of you had experience of this? Yeah, I collaborate in 2021 with the European Center of Journalism. We put together a toolkit for refugee journalist, how to cover refugee stories. We put some advice that just consider the mental health because these people been through a horrible experience, maybe the experience death many times, threats, maybe they had nightmares.

And for myself, I myself spent many years with the same nightmare that I've been arrested in the airport, I'm being deported to Egypt, I'm in jail. So considering mental health for these people, It's a crucial point for them in the early stage and any new country. I think it's a fatal mistake for any journalist to go deeply with this point. If the refugee want to tell this story, okay, respect his willing and go ahead. But rather than just don't go to these issues a lot. And also sometimes we can put others at risk.

Like I have my family back in Afghanistan. when I share my story I know it has a big risk for them maybe Taliban come and arrest my family because it happened with me. It happened with me because I was sharing my story

and when they had the house searching, they find out about the house whose house is this and what's she doing. She said that she's a British spy not a journalist. Welcome to the team. They said that same thing.

It's very important when we want to share us to our story, be careful to think about other's life as well. One of the Egyptian mouthpieces, he always called me shamefully a refugee, the shameful refugee, Osama Gawish, okay? And I'm taking this opportunity to say, I'm proudly a refugee and I respect to every single refugee in this country or in the world because they are here. human being. It is not a shame to be a refugee or asylum seekers. You are looking for your safety because this authoritarian leaders made your life in danger and put your life in danger.

So you will be a stupid man to stay and let them kill you or jail you. No, we are here. Zara mentioned at the beginning, we need to be alive. And here we go. We are alive in the country. And yes, we are a refugee and we are proud. And even if you're alone We don't think about only ourselves We think about our family Everyone has a family Like myself

I have two children I need to look after them They need me I know it hurts me It's painful How I left my life behind And I had a good life I was so happy with my life

In Afghanistan And I'm trying my best To break down the language barrier To learn to improve my language And to work As Osama mentioned just be patient with their language barrier. Give them chance.

We can support them. If I have a lot of English community to speak with them every day as a job or somewhere as friends, I can improve it soon. We're human. When humans want to do something, they can do. Everything is possible.

But they need time. Thank you.