Mind of a Serial Killer - Jimmy Hoffa Pt. 1

Episode Date: January 12, 2026

Before he became the center of one of America’s greatest unsolved mysteries, Jimmy Hoffa was a tough kid from the Midwest who learned early that respect had to be fought for. In this episode, Killer Minds traces Hoffa’s climb from overworked warehouse teenager to the most powerful labor leader in the country — and the dangerous alliances he forged along the way. As his influence grew, so did his enemies, drawing Hoffa deeper into corruption, violence, and the grip of the mob. Vanessa Richardson and Dr. Tristin Engels explore the psychology behind Hoffa’s hunger for control, the moral lines he crossed, and the rise that set the stage for his dark and unforgettable fall. If you’re new here, don’t forget to follow Killer Minds to never miss a case! For Ad-free listening and early access to episodes, subscribe to Crime House+ on Apple Podcasts. Killer Minds is a Crime House Original Podcast, powered by PAVE Studios 🎧 Need More to Binge?  Listen to other Crime House Originals Clues, Crimes Of…, Murder True Crime Stories, Crime House Daily and Crimes and more wherever you get your podcasts! Follow me on Social Instagram: @Crimehouse TikTok: @Crimehouse Facebook: @crimehousestudios YouTube: @crimehousestudios To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Hi, Crime House community. It's Vanessa Richardson. Exciting news, conspiracy theories, cults and crimes is leveling up. Starting the week of January 12th, you'll be getting two episodes every week. Wednesdays, we unravel the conspiracy or the cult, and on Fridays we look at a corresponding crime. Every week has a theme. Tech, bioterror, power, paranoia, you name it. Follow conspiracy theories, cults and crimes now on your podcast app, because you're about dive deeper, get weirder, and go darker than ever before. This is Crime House.

Most of us are told that if we work hard, it'll eventually pay off, maybe in the form of a promotion, a raise, or at least a little respect. Unfortunately, the world doesn't always work that way. Some people work hard their whole lives and never catch a break. Jimmy Hoffa knew this better than anyone. When he was just a kid, Jimmy realized that respect and fair working conditions weren't always a given, you had to fight for them. And as he got older, that fight turned him into one of the biggest union leaders in America. Suddenly, Jimmy found himself with an immense amount of power and influence.

But power like that creates enemies, and sometimes those enemies don't just want to see you fall. They make sure you never get back up. The human mind is powerful. It shapes how we think, feel, love, and hate. But sometimes it drives people to commit the unthinkable. This is Killer Minds, a Crime House original. I'm Vanessa Richardson. And I'm Dr. Tristan Engels.

Every Monday and Thursday, we uncover the darkest minds in history, analyzing what makes a killer. Crime House is made possible by you. Follow Killer Minds and subscribe to Crimehouse Plus on Apple Podcasts, for ad-free early access to each two-part series. Before we get started, be advised this episode contains discussion of depression and suicide. Listener discretion is advised. Today we begin our deep dive into the world of Jimmy Hoffa,

one of the most powerful labor leaders in American history, whose mysterious disappearance remains one of the country's greatest unsolved cases. Jimmy rose from humble Midwest beginnings to become one of the most influential people, in the country. But his hunger for power and control eventually put him in the crosshairs of the very people who helped him get there. And as Vanessa goes through the story, I'll be talking about things like how early hardship and loss shaped Jimmy's obsession with control and respect, the psychology behind his moral justifications and why he believed corruption was a part of doing business, and what might have gone through his mind in the days leading up to his disappearance.

And in these episodes, we'll be asking the question. Why would someone want to kill Jimmy Hoffa? Before he became one of the most talked about unsolved mysteries in America, Jimmy Hoffa was just a kid who knew the value of hard work. James Riddle Hoffa was born on February 14, 1913, in Brazil, Indiana, to his working-class parents, John and Biola Hoffa. He joined his two older siblings, Billy and Jeanette, in a small, crowded home, where money was usually tight.

His father worked long hours as a coal miner, and his mother took odd jobs like washing laundry to help make ends meet. A year after his birth, Jimmy's little sister Nancy was born, making their small rural home even more cramped. The hafas didn't have much, but they did have grit and a shared belief that hard work could build them a better life.

Eventually, it paid off. Viola managed to turn her small laundry business into something steady, washing and drying clothes for wealthier families in town. With her income and John's mining job, the hafas were finally able to move into a larger middle-class home. Everyone pitched in to keep things running. Jimmy and his older brother, Billy, helped their mother by picking up and delivering laundry for her clients while their sister, Jeanette, handled the washing and ironing. John was often away for work, but when he was home, Jimmy loved how he always made time to play with them and take them fishing.

For a while, life was good. The family had stability, and it felt like things were turning around. But that feeling was short-lived. In 1920, when Jimmy was just seven, his dad died as a result of his brutal work in the coal mines. Losing a parent at a young age is profoundly destabilizing, especially in families already facing poverty. In those systems, the parent isn't just a caregiver. They're a source of structure, financial stability, and protection.

and when that disappears, it can feel like the world is unpredictable to a child and that no one's coming to save them. And as a result, children often step into adult roles far too early. They can try and compensate for the loss by becoming more helpful or competent or indispensable to the family system. And that can create heightened vigilance, a strong need to control their environment, and mistrust in systems that have repeatedly failed them. It also complicates grief. A child Jimmy's age doesn't have the emotional language or developmental tools to process a loss like that, the way that adults do. So grief gets expressed behaviorally. Some children shut down, others power up.

Hoffa appears to have done the latter. Those early adaptations like taking charge, becoming the stabilizer cleaning to loyalty, fearing abandonment, and needing to be the one who keeps everything afloat, tend to crystallize. And later in life, they show up as defining traits, traits like assertiveness, control, leadership, and a worldview built around self-reliance above anything else, which we will definitely see in Jimmy as you take us through the story. John's sudden death shattered the family and left Viola to raise four children on her own. And as you said, Dr. Engels had also forced Jimmy to grow up a lot faster than most kids his age. After John's funeral, Viola told her children the hard truth. They didn't have anyone to rely on, and that meant everyone needed to help out even more. Without John's income, the Hoffas went from scraping by to completely struggling.

Medical bills had piled up from his illness, and some nights Jimmy and his siblings went to bed hungry. Even though Viola had her laundry business, the Midwest weather didn't always make it easy to run. Back then, there were no electric dryers, so everything had to be hung outside. and between the rainy springs and freezing winters, it didn't always work out. So Viola started taking extra jobs when she could, cooking at a local restaurant and ironing sheets for the hospital. Watching his mom struggled to hold it all together left a mark on Jimmy. He saw firsthand that sometimes the hardest working people end up with the least to show for it.

Eventually, in 1924, Viola had to make a big decision. She packed up the family and moved them to Detroit, where she found a steady job on an assembly line at an auto parts plant. But the move wasn't easy on her kids, especially Jimmy. He got bullied by the neighborhood kids and teased at school for being a quote-unquote hillbilly from a rural area. But instead of backing down, Jimmy fought back, literally. He often found himself with a busted lip and black eye, but fighting became his way of earning respect and proving he wouldn't be. controlled by anyone. Being uprooted like this, after such a profound loss and economic hardship likely reinforced the belief that the world was unpredictable and even unforgiving. And before

Jimmy had a chance to restabilize from that upheaval, he was met with ridicule and bullying by his peers. His response, fighting back, suggests that he somehow came to believe that the only way to survive in an unpredictable world was to be stronger than whatever threatened him. And in that context, that belief is adaptive. There is nothing inherently wrong with developing emotional toughness or learning to defend yourself because resilience matters. Kids push back against bullies all the time, physically or otherwise, and that's not something that should be immediately pathologized. The issue isn't that Jimmy defended himself. It's when that strategy doesn't remain confined to childhood conflicts or confined to moments that truly require protection.

with Jimmy, the more he fought back, the more he understood how dominance worked, the more he liked the feeling of power, and the more he overcorrected for the years he'd spent feeling vulnerable or targeted. How does this bullying and being labeled an outsider affect Jimmy's self-image and maybe his eventual drive for respect? I think it hits at the core of identity formation. Jimmy grew up in economic hardship. In society, tends to marginalize impoverty. kids before they even understand what that means. They're viewed as outsiders or less them, and that message creates deep insecurity, especially when peers reinforce it through ridicule or exclusion. It tells a developing child, you don't belong unless you prove otherwise. And in response, kids often develop one of two internal narratives. Either they accept the label that's been

put on them like the labeling theory suggests, or, they construct an identity that is the absolute opposite of it. And I think with Jimmy, he chose the latter. He doubled down on dominance instead of vulnerability. And that transformation became central to who he was. He refused to ever be vulnerable on the outside again as part of his identity. After plenty of bruised knuckles, Jimmy eventually earned what he'd been fighting for. Respect.

The other kids stopped messing with him once he proved he could hold his own, and for the first time, he could walk home from school. without looking over his shoulder. That sense of toughness made Jimmy feel more like a man than a kid. A feeling he'd been chasing ever since his dad died. He wanted to be the man of the house and help his mom in any way he could.

Watching her struggle didn't sit right with him. So he decided it was time to do his part. By the time Jimmy was in middle school, he was already working odd jobs like sacking potatoes for a local grocery store, painting fences or raking leaves. Every penny he earned, he gave straight to his mother. Viola appreciated the help, but she also knew how important school was.

She pushed Jimmy to keep his grades up, and she had her own way of making sure he did. If he or his siblings slacked off, the punishment was drinking a spoonful of castor oil. It was an old-fashioned remedy-turned-discipline trick that supposedly built character, but mostly it just made you sick to your stomach. For Jimmy, just the threat of it was enough to keep his grades. hovering at a B average. But by the time he turned 14, Jimmy started to think that he wasn't meant to be a student.

He hated the idea of being stuck in a classroom, unable to earn real money while Viola struggled. So after finishing ninth grade, he told his mom he wanted to work full time. Viola encouraged him to stick with school, but ultimately let him make his own decision. So when his sophomore orientation rolled around, Jimmy decided to skip it and look for a job instead.

He found one in a department store called Frank and Cedars and earned $12 a week working mostly as a stockboy. Jimmy loved the work and things were going well until 1929 rolled around and the Great Depression hit. Jimmy was just a low-level worker and he could sense a layoff was imminent. So he tried to get ahead of it by getting into the food business. He figured even when times were tough, people had to eat. He eventually found a night shift job at a Kroger grocery warehouse, unloading train cars with food and goods. Jimmy knew he was lucky to have steady work,

but it didn't take long for him to see how badly grunt workers could be treated. He worked about 80 hours a week, but was getting paid for only 48. His manager fired people without warning, sometimes for no reason at all. Jimmy noticed it always seemed to be. happened to the ones who needed the job the most, like men with sick wives or children to feed. It made him sick to watch, but he also knew better than to speak up. At a place like that, one complaint could get you replaced before your shift even ended. So he kept his head down

and continued to work, but the longer he did, the more the unfairness of it all aided him. One night at work, Jimmy got to talking with a co-worker in his 30s named Sam. Sam had been around long enough to know the system was rigged against the little guy, and he brought up the idea of unionizing to Jimmy. He thought that if the warehouse workers organized, they could protect themselves from being fired or exploited. Jimmy loved the idea, and it made him think about his own childhood. If his dad had been part of a union, maybe things wouldn't have been so hard on the family after his passing. After talking, Jimmy and Sam started paying attention to who was being mistreated, and whenever someone got yelled at or threatened,

they'd talk to them during breaks and plant the seed of solidarity to slowly build trust. Then in the spring of 1931, things finally reached a breaking point. Two of 18-year-old Jimmy's coworkers were fired just for taking a lunch break, and everyone realized they could be next. Jimmy decided it was time to act, so when a shipment of perishable strawberries arrived, he told everyone to stop unloading them. When Jimmy set down the crate he was unloading and walked away from the train, all 175 of his coworkers followed. They stood together facing their angry managers and refused to lift another box.

So this is a defining moment when you think about how he had been treated up until this point. He had felt powerless all through childhood and even through his adolescence. He struggled with loss, financial instability, food insecurity, being uprooted, bullied, and dismissed. And at work, it was just a continuation of those violations. Another series of unpredictable experiences that he himself went through and witnessed. He's taken a stand against bullies before and gotten some reprieve in the sense that he was able to walk home without having to look over his shoulder. But now he's taken a stand as an adult and 175 other men, many of whom are much older and are more seasoned and have more to lose than he does, followed him in

solidarity. That's an enormous corrective emotional experience. In one moment, he goes from the kid who had to fight to be respected to a young man who could mobilize an entire workforce. This is the moment that I believe Jimmy likely cemented the idea that control isn't just protection, it's purpose. And once he had that realization, I think it fundamentally shifts how he saw himself and how he decided to show up in the world going forward. With thousands of pounds of expensive strawberries waiting to spoil in the warehouse, time wasn't on management's side. Jimmy had leverage and demanded a meeting with the higher-ups within 24 hours

or no one would go back to work. His demands were met immediately, and eventually he won a small raise for the entire crew. Just like that, 18-year-old Jimmy had loved. led his first strike, and he loved it. It made him realize that maybe he could change things for even more people. What Jimmy didn't know was just how far that power would take him,

and how many enemies he'd make along the way. After the Strawberry Strike, 18-year-old Jimmy Hoffa didn't just walk away with a win, he walked away with a reputation. Soon after, he was elected by his coworkers as the vice president of their newly formed warehouse union. fighting back had worked, and Jimmy craved the feeling of doing it again. Over the next few years, he leaned into his new organizing role,

arguing with management, pushing for better treatment, and refusing to back down. Eventually, Kroger fired him for being too disruptive, but Jimmy refused and said he quit instead. In the end, it didn't really matter. Union leaders across Detroit already knew his name and saw his potential. In 1932, Jimmy found a new organizing job, this time with truck drivers. The group was called the International Brotherhood of Teamsters. The Teamsters represented the people who kept the country moving, truckers, freight handlers, and warehouse workers.

When Jimmy joined, they had a few hundred members and barely any money in the bank. But it didn't stop him from hitting the ground running. He started visiting truck stops, knocking on cab doors, and talking to drivers about joining the union. Over the next few years, the Teamsters membership exploded. Jimmy grew the group to more than 5,000 and helped build up a union fund of thousands of dollars, something that was no small feat during the Depression. Even though Jimmy was young and ambitious, he was also a little impatient. He wanted results, and he wanted them fast. With the rapid growth of the Teamsters, came attention from people already involved in the union who saw what Jimmy was doing. One of

of those people was unlike anyone he'd ever met before. His name was Angelo Melly, and he was a Detroit Mafia boss with deep connections to the Teamster Brotherhood. For years, the mafia had relied on truckers and freight workers to help move illegal goods. It's possible that Jimmy was introduced to Angelo through a woman named Sylvia Pagano. Jimmy had been dating Sylvia casually, and she had a lot of mob connections in Detroit. Between his rise in the Teamster, and the fact that Jimmy was always so kind to Sylvia's young son Chucky, she probably saw a lot of promise in him. Now that Jimmy was involved and rising in the ranks quickly,

Angelo knew he needed to get Jimmy on their side. So Angelo offered Jimmy protection. He told them that if the companies he was negotiating contracts with pushed back or tried to strong-arm him, the mob would handle it through intimidation or violence when needed. In return, the mob wanted to re-exam. retain their influence within the Teamsters. It was a deal that Jimmy couldn't resist.

He convinced himself it was for the greater good and that the more power the Teamsters had, the more people he could help. Jimmy's decision to partner with the mafia sounds altruistic the way that he's rationalizing it to himself, but realistically, this was driven by his own internal need for power and control. By this point, he wasn't just rising within the Teamsters,

he was becoming a public figure, and with that kind of visibility comes mounting pressure. The higher he climbs, the more he had to protect what he built. Jimmy was fighting corporations and executives who were powerful and even hostile. And to stand up to men like that, he believed he had to be just as powerful and intimidating as they were. And he learned very early in life that dominance is the key to survival in an unpredictable and threatening world. Now, from a psychological standpoint, this was a reinforcement of his values. We also have to consider how Jimmy perceived the situation from a conflict resolution lens.

So from his perspective, declining the mob would have been a lose-lose scenario. He'd forfeit the additional intimidation and leverage that they could provide while also risking offending a powerful criminal organization at the same time. Historically, people don't say no to the mob without consequences. Now, accepting the offer, on the other hand, allowed him to frame it as a win-win. He gained more power, stronger backing, better contracts for union members, and an elevated reputation, all while keeping the mob aligned with him rather than against him. So this almost certainly played into his decision in the end because it was insurance for him. Okay, how and when does power reshape someone's moral compass?

It's not something that happens overnight. It happens gradually, but it does happen. It often starts when accountability drops, and that occurs often because people in their life also enable them out of loyalty or even fear. Also, when a person's inhibition weakens, rules start to feel flexible and ethical lines become suggestions to them. And that's when it's time to be concerned. When power meets insecurity, that's also a sign because research shows that when someone with authority feels threatened, when their status, identity, or influence is at risk in their mind, in their perception, they're more likely to justify things like hypocrisy or retaliation or taking risks that they would never have considered before. And it's not out of greed, but out of fear. And when empathy starts to

weaken, those are the moments that power really has reshaped someone's moral compass and perhaps even the compasses of the people in their immediate orbit as well who are enabling them and helping them along the way. Once Jimmy's relationship with the mafia was in place, it didn't take long for lines to start blurring. The mob would ask for small favors, like rerouting trucks to serve their own interests, sometimes to steal the goods inside, other times to move something off the books. In Jimmy's mind, it was just part of doing business.

All that mattered was that he was helping people, and part of that was that. helping the mafia out sometimes too. But even with all the success he had going, Jimmy still felt like something was missing. A family. Things between him and Sylvia had fizzled out, but he was still friends with her and maintained a relationship with her son, Chuckie, too. Once Jimmy got a taste of what it could be like to be a husband and father, he wanted it for real. Shortly after ending his relationship with Sylvia, Jimmy found the love he'd been looking for in 1936 when he met 18-year-old Josephine Joe Pawsi Walk at a laundry worker strike. The moment he laid eyes on her, he knew she was the woman for him.

The couple fell in love quickly and married just six months after meeting. After the wedding, Jimmy threw himself completely into building a stable life for them, working tirelessly with the Detroit Teamsters and eventually welcoming two children, a daughter, Barbara, born in 1938, and a son, James, born in 1941. It didn't take long before Joe realized Jimmy was a bit of a workaholic, but she didn't mind. She was always there to tend to Jimmy when he came home after a long day on the picket line, and even when he found himself bruised and battered after a disagreement, which happened a lot. Joe knew the company Jimmy kept could be rough, but she also knew he

was fighting to make things better for every working man and woman. At home, he was a doting father and devoted husband. But at work, Jimmy was focused on one thing, more power, more influence, and more leverage for the union. But as the 1940s progressed, even the Teamsters couldn't escape being divided as the world inched closer to a second World War. Anti-communist fears were quickly rising, even inside the labor movement, where some members leaned far left. Some organizers Jimmy had liked, respected, and worked alongside were, over. about their communist sympathies, but the mob was decidedly pro-capitalist. So when the national Teamsters leadership, and even the federal government moved to crack

down on a group of Minneapolis union leaders tied to communist circles, some of which were Jimmy's friends, he decided he wasn't going to get in the way. Nine Teamsters were arrested and charged with espionage under the Smith Act, which made it a crime to advocate overthrowing the U.S. government. 18 of them were convicted and sent to prison. Jimmy eventually saw it as a positive because their removal cleared the path for him to rise even higher within the Teamsters.

Well, this is a common crossroads for ambitious leaders. When someone feels their safety or status is threatened, the brain tends to prioritize self-preservation or any kind of personal attachment or bond with another person. It isn't necessarily always malice. It's something else. Fear of losing influence and the desire to stay on the right side of power, especially with the mafia, can override loyalties. But also in some people, the only loyalty they understand is to themselves. Jimmy likely understood that staying aligned with the teamsters could jeopardize his own future. So he distanced himself. And like we talked about, that's the moment when power and ambition can begin reshaping someone's moral compass. Not dramatically, not overnight, but in small decisions like this where self-interest edges out loyalty and previous ethics. And once that shift starts, it becomes

easier to justify the next step up the ladder. Does gaining power through someone else's downfall, like in this case, make it harder to ever give that power up? When someone rises to power because another person fell, for example, that power often feels less secure. There's a fear that it could disappear the same way it appeared in the first place. And that fear makes it harder to let go. It's not just about ego, it's about the worry that stepping back might put them in the same vulnerable place the other person ended up. So, yes, when power comes from someone else's downfall, people often hold on to it a little bit more tightly. After the arrests in Minneapolis, the union grew even more under Jimmy's leadership, from a few hundred thousand to a half a million members.

And when the U.S. officially entered World War II, factories were running around the clock to support the military and young men across the country were being drafted. The Teamsters became more crucial than ever, responsible for keeping food, goods, and supplies moving across the nation. Jimmy saw it as an opportunity. He claimed his work with the union was essential to national security, an argument that allowed him to avoid the draft and stay right where he wanted to be in control. By the early In the 1950s, 39-year-old Jimmy had climbed all the way to National Vice President of the Union. With that promotion came access to the union's pension fund, the retirement savings of millions of working Americans.

Jimmy knew he was the one who helped balloon the account to what it was, so he didn't feel bad about using the fund as a private loan system for the mafia, who in turn used the money to build and finance casinos and hotels in Las Vegas. In 1957, Jimmy got what he'd been working toward for years. He became president of the Teamsters, overseeing more than 1.5 million members. There was no doubt about it. He'd become the most powerful labor figure in the country. And his union members loved him.

He delivered higher wages and safer conditions, not to mention reliable pensions. But behind the scenes, Jimmy had learned a thing or two from the mob, and he allegedly began taking money from the same trucking companies that he was supposed to be negotiating against. This was a direct violation of labor laws meant to protect unions from corruption. Let's talk about how he came to develop a warped sense of right and wrong. I mean, we've talked a little bit more about how the moral compass can be warped from power. But when someone rises as quickly and as publicly as Jimmy did, they can become insulated by the praise around them. their choices start to feel justified simply because they're effective or admired by the people

surrounding them. And to Jimmy, that was more than 1.5 million people. And of course, not all of them are in his immediate orbit, but 1.5 million people are benefiting by the things that he's doing. He was delivering real wins for his members. And that kind of reinforcement can make a person believe that they're doing the right thing, even when the behavior itself, like what he's doing here, crossing legal or ethical lines. It's also common for powerful people to redefine the meaning of harm. If no one close to them seems upset, if the results still look good, and if the system around them is tolerating it, then illegal actions like this can start to feel normalized or minimized, almost like it's part of the job. And in that mindset, the person doesn't see themselves as

doing something bad. They see themselves as doing what's necessary. So Jimmy's, influence reshaped how he interpreted his own behavior. And the mafia also influenced his own behavior. And once that shift happens, in addition to the shifts that we've seen happening gradually, the line between right and wrong, like we talked about, continues to become easier to step over without noticing, especially with the amount of people around him that continue to enable or encourage or even teach him ways to continue stepping over. that line. By the late 1950s, Jimmy wasn't fighting corruption. He was part of it. And now that he was on top, more people were paying attention. And according to the mob, it was too much attention.

They preferred to operate in the shadows, while Jimmy's growing fame was starting to drag them into the spotlight. Worse than that, they thought Jimmy seemed to enjoy being at the top. And the more power and loyalty he built within the Teamsters, the more it looked like he might might stop taking orders someday and maybe even start giving them. Around the same time, the U.S. government launched a committee to investigate labor corruption. Senator John McClellan and his Chief Counsel Robert F. Kennedy quickly honed in on Jimmy after hearing rumors about his shady dealings, like using union funds for personal gain and letting the mob pull strings behind the scenes.

By 1959, 141 Teamster officials were under investigation by the the FBI, including Jimmy. But instead of backing down, he doubled down, insisting he hadn't done anything wrong. Still, he wasn't taking any chances. By 1961, Jimmy made sure to give himself a 50% salary increase and pushed through a rule requiring the union to cover all legal fees for its leaders. At that point, it was clear the federal government was closing in, and Jimmy knew he better set himself up in case he needed it. He acted just in time because one year later, the feds officially caught up to him, and Jimmy Hoffa found himself someplace he never expected, in handcuffs. In 1962, 42, 49-year-old Jimmy Hoffa found himself somewhere he never wanted to be, awaiting trial. The U.S. government

had charged Jimmy with secretly partnering and profiting from, a Nashville trucking company, in exchange for giving them favorable labor terms, which was a clear violation of the law. If convicted, Jimmy was looking at hefty fines and possibly being barred from working with the Teamsters ever again. But backing down wasn't in his nature, and he was confident he would be exonerated. At the time, Jimmy was working on closing the biggest deal the union had ever seen to get every single long-haul transport truck driver in North America under a single contract. With that deal on the line, it's no wonder Jimmy decided to call in some favors. His camp reached out to at least two members of the jury and offered them bribes to make sure the verdict went his way.

One juror was offered $10,000 cash, while the other was offered help getting a promotion at work. Jimmy spent decades building his reputation, his career, and power. That can create a sense of entitlement in the belief that rules shouldn't apply because the person sees themselves as too important, too effective, or too central to the system to fail. And in Jimmy's mind, protecting the union's big contract and protecting himself may have felt like the same mission. Briming jurors is a clear manipulation, obviously, and it's very illegal. But for someone in his position, it can feel like a solution rather than a crime. Power can narrow a person's focus to outcomes instead of ethics. If they believe there's too much at stake, they can convince themselves

that controlling the process is justified. So this is about preserving the world he had built, and the belief that he alone knew how to keep it moving. So in that mindset, manipulating a jury becomes less about breaking the law and more about making sure things go the way they should go, according to Jimmy. Do you think this kind of behavior suggests narcissism, or is it more about survival and maybe a fear of losing control. Behavior like this can certainly look like narcissism from the outside, but it isn't always rooted in personality traits. True narcissism is an enduring pattern that typically shows up in adolescence or early adulthood. During those early years, for Jimmy, he was focused on providing

for his family and fighting for workers' rights. He was focused on equality. He wasn't focused on seeking superiority, with Jimmy, any ego-driven behavior that he exhibited seemed to emerge much later in life. So while he certainly shows some narcissistic traits at points of his life, what we're saying so far, at least in my opinion, is more consistent with someone reacting to a high-pressure environment in trying to maintain control for safety and survival, not necessarily someone driven by a pathological need for admiration. But again, Again, I've never met him, clearly. So this is based on the limited information we have and educational only.

The bribes that Jimmy offered seemed to work, because when the trial ended, it resulted in a hung jury. Jimmy had managed to avoid a conviction, at least for the moment. But the government was dead set on putting Jimmy behind bars, and it didn't take long for an informant named Edward Grady Parton to speak up about the bribery that had taken place. Edward was a local teamster, but he was also a paid government informer. When he overheard Jimmy talking about his plans with the jury, he immediately snitched.

In 1963, federal prosecutors slapped new charges on Jimmy for jury tampering. Now, the feds had all the evidence they needed against Jimmy, and no matter how hard he tried, there was no way out. On March 4, 1964, Jimmy was convicted and said, sentenced to eight years in prison. But he was able to defer his incarceration for a while. He immediately appealed the conviction and was able to remain free on bail and still be in charge of the Teamsters. And during that time, he actually did win that groundbreaking contract for the long-haul truckers, uniting every one of them under something called the National Master

Freight Agreement. But none of Jimmy's appeals got him anywhere. In fact, during the same time, he found himself convicted in a second trial in July of 1964 on charges of conspiracy and wire and mail fraud for improper use of the Teamsters' pension fund. For that new conviction, he earned an additional five years deferred on top of his pre-existing eight-year sentence. That meant Jimmy Hoffa was looking to spend the next 13 years in a cell. Despite the conviction, it didn't change how the men and women he represented felt

about him. In 1966, Jimmy was elected to a third term as Teamster president, alongside his mentee, Frank Fitzsimmons, as VP. Still, winning a third term couldn't change reality. With no way to avoid it any longer, in 1967, Jimmy officially started serving his sentence at a federal prison in Pennsylvania. Even though he was now behind bars, he had no plans of giving up control of the Teamsters. His VP Frank had been named acting president, but Jimmy expected things to run exactly as they had before. In his mind, Frank was just a stand-in, someone who would take his orders and keep the seat warm until he was released. But it didn't take long for things to change. Once Jimmy began serving his sentence, Frank started to pull away. Before long, it was clear he wasn't interested

in letting Jimmy call the shots anymore. Being president of the Teamster, was Jimmy's identity. And despite the criminal activity that he'd done while in the role of president, it clearly wasn't enough to erase what he'd also given his members. Like you said, they reelected him even though he was heading to prison for crimes against them. That kind of loyalty is powerful. It reinforces his belief that he was the one holding everything together. But once he entered prison, the reality shifted. His control and authority weakened and the one, person he trusted to hold the line, which is his VP and mentee, started moving away from him and taking his power. For someone like Jimmy, that is a deep personal betrayal. And psychologically,

that would likely trigger anger, shock, fear in a very real sense of vulnerability. Feelings Jimmy has worked hard to avoid since childhood. It challenges his sense of judgment, his relationships, and certainly his place in the hierarchy that he himself built. And given how he's historically responded to losing control, which is overcorrecting and pushing harder, he's likely going to have that same pattern. We're going to see that same pattern repeat itself. Do you think Jimmy's identity would have started to unravel at this point? Yes, it absolutely could. But I think someone like Jimmy would not let that happen quietly. Like you said, backing down wasn't in his nature. Someone like him who defines himself by dominance and control,

he's more likely to lean harder into his identity of dominance and control first as an effort to reclaim that control. A losing control of the teamsters hit Jimmy hard. He saw Frank's behavior as betrayal and he hated the idea of losing the power he'd spent decades building. Once he was in prison,

Jimmy tried to hold on to whatever influence he had left by keeping in touch with a few loyal mafia contacts. But eventually, even though, Those ties started to slip. High-ranking mobsters realized that Frank was easier to deal with than Jimmy. Frank rarely pushed back and didn't challenge them. He also didn't seem as interested in power. Frank was someone the mob could easily keep in line, whereas Jimmy always wanted to be above them.

Prison also put Jimmy face to face with someone he already had bad blood with, a man named Anthony Provenzano. Anthony was a former Teamster official and mob associate, served. time at the same facility. The two men clashed constantly as inmates, especially when Anthony asked Jimmy for help accessing his pension money and Jimmy refused. It was something Anthony took personally and he was convinced that Jimmy's refusal came down to him being racist against Italian Americans. Despite the ongoing feud, Jimmy did his best to stay busy in prison and got up to what he always did. Organizing. He raised grievances with guards,

threatened lawsuits, and even got involved in prison reform efforts. But through it all, one thing never changed. Jimmy was determined that once he got out, he'd take back control of the Teamsters. That chance came in December of 1971, less than five years into his sentence. His release came through a commutation from President Richard Nixon, who reduced his sentence to time served. Many believed it wasn't out of generosity, but politics. Nixon, a Republican, was preparing for re-election the following year, and after Jimmy walked free, the Teamsters, a massive voting group, endorsed him for president.

It was a major shift for the union, which had always backed Democrats. Upon his release, Jimmy received a $1.75 million payout from the Teamsters' retirement and family protection plan, which he'd helped create years earlier. But freedom wasn't enough. Jimmy wanted to return to organizing and reclaim his place at the top of the union. There was just one problem. Nixon's commutation came with a condition. Jimmy was banned from engaging in any union activity until 1980.

Jimmy was convinced it had been added at Frank's request, and maybe even the mob, who wanted Frank to stay in power. But as he always did, Jimmy put up a fight, filing lawsuits to overturn the restriction. However, none of them worked and the ruling stood. For the first time in decades, Jimmy Hoffa was truly powerless. He had no choice but to take a lower-level management job with a local Detroit Teamster chapter. Remember those internal messages Jimmy carried from childhood, that you're only worthy if you prove yourself.

For him, power wasn't just a position. It was evidence that he mattered. It was part of his identity. Vulnerability, on the other hand, meant to, worthlessness. So in this moment, he's stripped of influence and he's likely seeing himself as failed and disposable. That creates a mix of humiliation, fear, and disbelief, emotions that Jimmy would do almost anything to avoid. And historically, like I mentioned, he managed those feelings by overcorrecting. He pushes harder. He demands more. He asserts himself even louder. And this

moment was no different. But now he'd just spent five years in prison. It may not sound like a lifetime, but psychologically and politically, it's more than enough time for the world to move on without you. When I worked in prisons and with people who were newly released, they would often talk about how disorienting it was to reenter a world that had changed in ways that we don't even think about. I'm talking about clothing styles, technology, even the way job applications are submitted. These small shifts can feel huge when you've been sequestered from everyday life for years. So Jimmy wasn't just returning to the same world that he left. He had some functional denial that kept him from seeing how much the landscape had shifted like the union's direction,

the mafia's patience, and the limits of his own influence. And his obsession with power served a purpose. It helped him cope with the shock of losing everything by giving him one target, to focus on. And that's getting it all back and getting his place restored. It was a massive fall from grace for the man who at one point controlled the largest labor union in America. But Jimmy never stopped believing in the value of hard work. He held out hope that he'd one day be able to claw his way back into power and even threatened to expose how much control the mafia had over Frank. So he decided to start laying the groundwork and reaching back out. to people he'd once been close to,

even the mobsters who were no longer interested in him to try and get back into their good graces. In July of 1975, he scheduled a lunch meeting with Anthony Provenzano, the same mafia associate he'd butted heads with in prison, hoping to put their past behind them. Jimmy wanted the meeting because Anthony had ties to a powerful Detroit mob figure named Anthony Jacaloney. If Jimmy was ever going to reclaim control of the Teamsters,

he needed to rebuild those connections and get back in their good graces. Jimmy arrived for the meeting at a restaurant called Macus Red Fox in Bloomfield Hills, Michigan, around 2 p.m. He waited for the two anthony's to arrive, hoping the meeting would be productive. But the men never showed up. After an hour, it became clear that Jimmy had been stood up. He was frustrated and embarrassed and called his wife to let her know what happened and that he was heading home. It was the last phone call he ever made. Moments later, Jimmy Hoffa disappeared forever.

Thanks so much for listening. Come back next time for the conclusion of our deep dive into Jimmy Hoffa. Killer Minds is a Crime House original powered by Pave Studios. Here at Crime House, we want to thank each and every one of you for your support. If you like what you heard today, reach out on Instagram at Crime House. And don't forget to rate, review, and follow Killer Minds wherever you get your podcasts. Your feedback truly makes a difference. And to enhance your listening experience, subscribe to Crimehouse Plus on Apple Podcasts.

You'll get every episode of Killer Minds ad-free, along with early access to each thrilling two-part series. Killer Minds is hosted by me, Vanessa Richardson, and Dr. Tristan Engels, and is a Crimehouse original powered by Pave Studios. This episode was brought to life by the Killer Minds team. Max Cutler, Ron Shapiro, Alex Benadon, Lori Marinelli, Natalie Pertsovsky, Sarah Camp, Sarah Batchelor, Marky Lee, Sarah Tardiff, and Carrie Murphy. Thank you for listening. Looking for your next listen? Hi, it's Vanessa Richardson, and I have exciting news. Conspiracy theories cults and crimes is leveling up.

Starting the week of January 12th, you'll be getting... two episodes every week. Wednesdays we unravel the conspiracy or the cult, and on Fridays we look at a corresponding crime. Follow conspiracy theories, cults, and crimes now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or wherever you listen.