Money Rehab with Nicole Lapin - Introducing: Scams, Money, & Murder
Episode Date: May 2, 2025Hosted by Nicole Lapin the podcast Scams, Money, and Murder dives into the dark side of finance. From cutthroat con artists to billion-dollar scams, and even murder, Nicole will take you through the w...orld’s wildest financial crimes -- or talk to the experts who studied them, and the victims that survived them. Scams, Money, and Murder with Nicole Lapin is a Crime House Original Podcast, powered by PAVE Studios. Follow now wherever you get your podcasts. New episodes drop every Thursday. For more content, follow us on Instagram and TikTok @crimehouse.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Well, you've been hearing a lot on the show that prices are going up pretty much across the board.
And that means for a lot of us, bigger credit card bills. And the last thing I want for you
is credit card debt. So I am thrilled to say there is a better way. You can build credit with money
you set aside and avoid interest or expensive debt with Chime's Credit Builder Card. It's a secured
credit card with no credit check or minimum deposit required. Start building credit with
your everyday purchases and regular on-time payments, all with no annual fees,
interest, or credit check at chime.com slash MNN.
I know that there's so much in the economy
that's beyond our control right now.
And so it makes me feel so much better
that I can have control over my own little micro economy
and do things that will help me and my credit score.
A better credit score can give you access
to lower rates on loans, like for a car or a home,
or even if you're renting good credit makes it easier to secure an apartment or a house.
A good credit score really makes a big difference. Turn your everyday purchases and on-time payments
into steps toward your financial goals with Chime Secured Credit Builder Visa Credit Card.
Get started today at Chime.com slash MNN. That's Chime.com slash MNnn. Chime feels like progress.
The Chime Credit Builder Visa credit card is issued by the Bancorp Bank NA or Stride
Bank NA.
Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply.
Chime checking account required to apply.
Out of network ATM withdrawals and OTC advance fees may apply.
Timing depends on submission of payment file.
Late payment may negatively impact your credit score.
Results may vary.
Go to chime.com slash just slouchers for details.
So I have written, count them, five books now.
But each time I'm in the writing process, I stay at an Airbnb.
I love to stay at an Airbnb.
When I was actually first launching this show, I was at an Airbnb in Arizona.
It was so peaceful.
It was stunning.
I could be productive and comfortable.
The Airbnb was also surrounded by a ton of
javelinas. If you know Arizona, you know they're like wild pig creatures. But honestly, I love
them too. Being away for work, for fun, or both is a
perfect opportunity to host your space on Airbnb. And if you think that hosting is overwhelming,
I have a solve for you. With Airbnb's cohost
network, it's easier than ever before to host. It's also a great way to earn some extra cash,
which I know we all love. Now you can hire a quality local cohost to take care of your home
and your guests. They can do everything from creating your listing to managing reservations
to messaging guests and even providing on-site support. So if you've got a secondary property
or an extended trip coming up
and you need a little help hosting while you're away,
you can hire eight co-hosts to do the work for you.
Find a co-host at airbnb.com slash host.
I'm Nicole Lapin, the only financial expert
you don't need a dictionary to understand.
It's time for some money rehab.
If you love money rehab, and I hope you do, and are a true crime fan, or you just love
a good story, then I have another podcast for you.
Beyond Money Rehab and Health Wanted, I host a third podcast called Scams, Money, and Murder. And I'm going to share a special episode with you today. On Scams, Money, and
Murder, each week I take you behind the headlines diving even deeper to the wildest money crimes
in the news, from cunning Ponzi schemes to high-stake political scandals, even a group
of killer investment bankers. Basically, each week we alternate between telling stories
about gripping high-stakes crimes featuring the most cutthroat people in the financial world and riveting first-person
interviews with the experts and the subjects themselves, the people who really shine a
light on these crimes in a way you have never heard before.
So join me every Thursday as I get you up to speed on the sleaziest, the scummiest,
and the most corrupt financial criminals the world has to offer.
Believe me, your bank account will thank you for it. Just search scams, money, and murder
wherever you get your favorite podcasts.
In the meantime, I am so excited to share an episode
of Scams, Money, and Murder with you today, starting now.
["Scarred and Lied"]
This is Crime House.
There was nothing in our mind where an entire platform in 24 hours and 48 hours could just
vanish.
It's the cycle that is very difficult to get out of.
It could happen to normal people in the blink of an eye. As they say, money makes the world go round.
What many don't talk about is the time it made people's worlds come to a screeching
halt.
Whether it's greed, desperation, or a thirst for power, money can make even the most unassuming
people do unthinkable things.
And sometimes those acts can be deadly.
This is Scams, Money and Murder, a Crime House original.
I'm your host Nicole Lapin.
Every Thursday we alternate between covering infamous money-motivated crimes and gripping
interviews with the experts or those who were directly involved themselves.
Crime House exists because of you.
Please rate, review and follow Scams, Money and Murder wherever you get your podcasts.
And for early ad-free access and bonus content, subscribe to Crime House Plus on Apple Podcasts.
By now, most people have heard of FTX, the crypto exchange that went from being everywhere
to suddenly gone.
Marketed as a safe and easy way into cryptocurrency, FTX raised hundreds of millions of dollars,
ran ads with huge celebrities, and promised financial freedom to everyday investors.
But in late 2022, the empire crumbled when it was revealed that FTX had secretly funneled billions
of dollars in customer funds to its sister company, Alameda Research, money that was then used
for risky bets, political donations, and lavish personal spending. We covered the story of FTX and its CEO Sam
Begman Fried, also known as SPF, and his dramatic fall in a November 2024 episode.
If you haven't listened to that yet, you can find the link to it in the show notes for this episode.
But today we're diving into the personal side of the collapse.
My guest today is Jake Thacker, one of the many victims of
the FTX collapse. He lost more than $200,000 when the platform crashed. Money he believed
was safely stored on a legitimate exchange. Now Jake wasn't someone who made a bad investment.
He was misled by a company that promised transparency while secretly gambling with user funds behind
closed doors.
He's been incredibly open and honest about his story, and we're so grateful to have him
here to share it with us firsthand.
Well, Jake, thank you so much for joining us.
There is so, so much to talk about.
If somebody has no idea about crypto or FTX or Sam Begman Fried or any of that,
how would you summarize this whole thing in a sentence or two?
It's not a Ponzi scheme. The way that Sam Begman Fried probably would coin it is a venture
gone horribly wrong, but in the eyes of everyone that was involved, it seemed like a total swindle.
An unknown investment scheme and no one had any idea that this could even happen, that
it was even fathomable.
And the story is the precedent of this thing happening.
But really, the end of the day was a venture
that everyone thought was on the up and up
and had the scale of a rocket ship
just to realize it was full of air.
There was nothing substantial there at all.
And I want to double click on all of those points,
but let's start at the beginning.
What was your entry point into crypto?
Was it something that you got into casually?
Were you a serious investor?
What was the deal?
Yeah, no.
In fact, for the longest time,
even when Bitcoin was the first one that came out,
I kind of looked at it very skeptically as well.
It wasn't until the pandemic, really 2021, 2022,
when I got into it.
And it was really more of proximity
to people that were doing it
and had kind of egged me on to just try it.
You never know, kind of the green eggs and ham scenario
of you can't knock it until you try it.
And once I did, it was the training that we were doing
or the communities that I was a part of was fun.
You know, we were creating algorithmic types of bots, grid bots, and so on and so forth to trade in the sideways market.
And it was, it started out as a hobby.
It started out as small amounts, a hundred dollars here, $200 there.
But then over time, as more success came in and I felt more comfortable, it turned into
a real thing and turned into real money and turned into something that I thought I could
pivot a lot of my current portfolio into and was sorely staking at the end of the day.
So during COVID, did you sell off your more traditional investments? Or did you ride it
out? Did you use cash that was sitting on the sidelines for dabbling in crypto? What was your
overall portfolio look like? It was more traditional. Stocks, bonds. Yeah, handful of tech stocks.
I worked for a couple of startups and had gotten equity there and was really leveraging that because it was quite sizable.
But in all honesty, almost everything that I had in traditional markets is about going
into crypto as far as money that I chose to invest.
And when you say that you were using bots to capitalize on a sideways market, like that's
real nerd stuff.
You weren't a newbie investor.
You weren't just dabbling in the market for the first time.
You were in tech.
You had already invested in more traditional vanilla
investments before you got into this.
Yeah, that's fair to say.
And again, the only reason I got into crypto
was because the people that, again, I
was close to my friends, other people
from some of the communities that I kind of wrote in, were doing that.
And that's what I was interested in.
And so that's what triggered my initial stake in the market.
When you first dabble in crypto, I mean, the sort of entryway ideally is Bitcoin.
FTX was more fringe at the time, although they did put a ton of marketing into it, and
we can talk about that.
But how did they first come across your radar?
What initially drew you into FTX?
Initially, we all heard about FTX and we all kind of saw their trajectory just go through
the roof quite quickly.
But in all honesty, I didn't even give them a second thought until it was the beginning
of 2024 when the market started to kind of turn and started to go down.
And a lot of my other assets that I had outside of FTX were down.
The whole market was down. And when that happens, you look at strategies to
optimize margins and look at ways to reduce your costs and increase your gains or sustain your
gains. FTX, their pitch was, we can do all the things that these bigger platforms can do, but we
do it in a better, more efficient way at a lower cost to the consumer. Transaction fees are lower. We have all these other tokens and
assets that are poised to be even more lucrative than some of the traditional bitcoins or ethereums
and so on and so forth. And so it really was that that triggered my engagement with the platform to begin with.
Originally crypto was supposed to be a hedge for traditional assets.
Now we've seen with a little bit of time that crypto investments, especially the bigger
ones move in lockstep with the overall market, not as a hedge to it.
But at the time you thought it could be. That's how it had been sold to
everybody as a new type of currency that can hedge against traditional equity fluctuations
and things like that. But FTX, if anyone's confused, was it a coin or not? It was a platform
analogous to a Coinbase where you could buy and sell. Yeah. Right.
There was a specific coin, but we'll get into that in a second.
Yeah, exactly.
It was an exchange just like a Binance or Coinbase and it allowed people to commoditize on the
market, right?
I want to invest X amount on this coin.
They take your money, they invest it, they supposedly hold it for you, give you access
to your returns.
It's kind of like a Robinhood.
Yeah, or like Fidelity or Vanguard for traditional.
Exactly.
And so again, that's where the biggest hang up was in the crypto markets was we still weren't free of the traditional or institutional ways in which money transferred
and flowed.
And that's to your point of it wasn't hedging or it wasn't in lieu of the traditional markets.
It was in parallel or in tandem because again, at that time crypto was not seen as a quote unquote currency.
And so it had to follow some sort of recognized monetary value in the dollar.
More often than not was the one that we use in the US, an exchange or wallet,
and in some instances, a place to store money or coins or tokens that you had
acquired and weren't ready to put on the
market or weren't ready to pull out of the exchange and put into the traditional
market and so forth. And typically when you're looking at getting into any
product, face cream, you know, a lip balm, I don't know, and they are advertising on
the Super Bowl
and they have all these celebrity sponsors,
you think it's really cool.
But when it comes to finance,
I personally like my finance so, so boring.
And in hindsight, it's easy to say that
the type of marketing they did would raise eyebrows
because we know what happens next.
But did that for you at the time
or did that help you trust them more
or think that they were flesh with cash and nothing could go wrong?
You know, honestly, it put them on the radar for me,
but it didn't really give me pause for a couple of reasons,
not so much as all the flash and the glitz and so on and so forth.
But for instance, I worked for a company called Under Armour.
Tom Brady and Steph Curry were both athletes of Under Armour.
I had the lovely pleasure of meeting both several times.
And it sounds very cliche, but I trusted them and therefore I knew that they had invested in this platform and that as they have
financiers and managers to guide them with their money and how to invest it
wisely and what seems legitimate and what doesn't, I kind of wrote on that.
I said, well, if Steph's in there, if Tom's in there, it can't be that bad.
And my initial approach to the platform was not to use it as a trading platform.
It was just to hold funds.
I needed a place to hold funds and be able to access them quickly without incurring all
these large transaction fees.
It was supposed to be temporary.
It wasn't something in my long-term strategy. It was a short-term solution given the current market fluctuation at the time.
And I think myself and a lot of others sadly saw the perception and saw the optics as more
legitimized because of the actors involved and probably should have been more diligent in our vetting. But at the time, everything worked. There
wasn't really any red flags either. The platform for itself
works exactly as it was pitched and there were any issues up until
November.
Yeah, for sure. It makes so much sense. You look at Tom Brady and
Steph Curry and they have huge brands and probably teams to
do due diligence and vet the things that they endorse or promote.
It makes all the sense in the world.
How could you have known otherwise?
You do say though you have a theory as to why things then blew up so quickly.
Can you walk us through what you think really happened? Well, again, this is, if you know anything about, and this is getting into more of the
political side of what we're experiencing on current day, present day, there's a group called
the PayPal mafia. They've been toying around with this thing called the network state forever and
wanting to break down the barriers of traditional government and society and whatever it is that
their philosophy is, that kind of thing. I saw SBF as, and this is more retrospective than it was
at the current time, of somebody that really wanted to participate in that. Because the one aspect to their scheme,
whatever it is, was they didn't have a way to siphon off money.
You can have Internet, you can be anywhere in the world, the Internet.
You can have enough money to build
platforms out in the middle of the ocean if you want.
But you still had to use traditional banks.
Crypto changed all of that.
And on March 6th, 2025, Trump signed an executive order
establishing the first crypto treasury or reserve,
whatever the title is.
He also invested heavily in this company called Praxis,
which is part of the whole PayPal mafia thing.
And so all these indicators were that he wanted to be part of that group, was willing to give
over billions of dollars in order to do that.
And it fit kind of the motif of why he originally said he started FTX and his principles of
kind of a decentralized collective, right? And everyone gives to everyone
and so on and so forth. And that's what my thought is because again, no one has ever
a question why did he start this? It wasn't nefarious at the beginning.
Yeah, he had a thing called effective altruism, right? That's delightful. And again, in all intents and purposes, despite all the marketing and that kind of thing,
it was doing that. Like the platform did better things than some of the other ones. It was holding
up to, quote unquote, its true mission or philosophy in some respect. But again, I think
the Alameda and the FTX, whatever they're
doing with Alameda, whatever that was for, again, I think
ties back into some of his inkling to be part of that crew
and whatever it is that they want to try and accomplish, I
think drove a lot of that and it ended up blinding him to his
responsibility of,
I started this company, there was millions of people involved, there's billions of dollars
involved. I can't just neglect that at this point. But by that point, it was too far gone.
Funds were not there. So there were a lot of green flags for you. There were these famous athletes who put their name behind it.
There was the PayPal mafia.
There was, you know, Forbes 30 under 30.
Like they were doing all the big marketing things.
They checked a lot of boxes.
In hindsight though, were there any red flags
or gut feelings that you had
that you pushed aside at the time?
I pushed aside the juvenile nature of the platform.
Although people didn't seem to have an issue with it and it seemed to be trying a larger
following in community day after day, month after month, it still wasn't as robust as
some of the larger players.
But money, it does weird things to people and it makes you
rationalize things that you wouldn't normally rationalize in situations where you didn't think
you were going to lose it. And that's prospect theory, if you're familiar with that, if
we value loss more than we value gain. And that's what drove a lot of, I think, people to start to look at FTX more
legitimately in, again, 2024, when the market was, I mean, Bitcoin was tanking.
I think by June or July, it was the lowest it had been and almost the inception of
Bitcoin, but that was probably the one that I look back on and say the lack of longevity and
established order within the marketplace was something I probably should have been more
concerned about.
Totally.
In hindsight, it's always 2020, but there were a lot of young founders at the time that
didn't go to jail, to be fair.
How much ultimately did you end up investing in MTX and over what time frame?
So it was relatively quick.
It was up to about 250k at one point.
I was able to get a little bit out over before the whole implosion happened.
206, 207k total.
But at certain points it had fluctuated up a little bit above that because of
transferring from
finance and coinbase, which I also had wallets with
due to the timing of kind of
Coins, right? So this coin is up. This coin is down. I'm gonna transfer some now
I won't lose as much in the transfer like won won't get these big transfer fees, so on and so forth. So by the time November hit, I had
pretty much stopped all movement because I had enough. And what I was using FTX for was really
more of a wallet, a bank to store money or coins that I was going to then cash
out on to pay back some of the debts that I had incurred while upping my investment
in crypto.
So leveraging certain assets that I had, knowing that I have to pay them back, and I didn't
want to wait on that.
I did very well. I was able to save face in light of the
downturn in the marketplace.
So yeah, it was about 250 was I think probably the max that I ever had on there,
but I wasn't trading on the platform.
I didn't ever buy any of their tokens that they offered.
I didn't use the exchange to invest in any other of the coins or tokens.
It was simply just a storage place knowing that if I'm going to take out a
little bit here or there over the course of the next few months, because my goal
was to take it all out in December, pay off substantial debt that I had, and then
continue doing what I had been doing in the past, and maybe look into using it as
some sort of subsidiary
platform. Not my primary. I really like Binance. I really was leveraging them pretty effectively.
And I don't know if that answers your question, but it was a good chunk of change. But I had
in total that year alone, probably lost about 800 upwards upwards of like 800K. You can see the market turned down and some other factors when Bitcoin also
had some issues in June as well.
So.
I see.
So outside of what you had in FTX, the market was going down.
There were some leverage issues, it sounds like.
So you were just in the red in general.
And so the max you had in FTX was 250, you
were able to get like 45k or so out at the time. What was that like? Was there some delay
or hurdle?
Oh, no, no, no. This was right before November. So I had transferred some out because the
market started to kind of track back up a little bit. And so I was going to try and use some of that, that it pulled out from FTX to
make up a little bit of losses that had incurred over the summertime.
And so that came out around beginning of October, end of, end of September.
So I'd have to go double check that, but it was before November, uh, because
when November hit and everyone scrambled to
try and figure out what was going on, I, myself, many others hit transfer,
transfer funds out, okay, great.
And then it just, it was like that spinning wheel of death.
It just sat there and nothing happened.
And it, in even some instances, but I would log in, it would say, transfer complete.
And you didn't see it?
No, it was not transfer complete.
It's just transfer.
Their side said, the system said,
we sent the proper messages to have the transfer be completed,
but there was no money.
There was no mechanism to actually send anything.
And then it was just gone.
And it was just a black hole.
You couldn't even, we'd go to the website and it just had their spinning logo.
So this is when things start getting fishy and start crumbling.
Yeah, this was November 8th, November 9th, because it was abrupt. I mean, there
were some leading indicators, right? And that kind of thing. But in all honesty,
myself and others,
and again, retrospect,
probably should have been paying more attention,
but there was nothing in our mind
where an entire platform in 24 hours and 48 hours
could just vanish and be gone.
No money, no insurance, no backups, no nothing.
Like that had not happened yet. No money, no insurance, no backups, no nothing.
That had not happened yet.
Similar to FTX, in June, Coinbase had to freeze assets or freeze trades for a few days because
of some liquidity issues.
They needed to transfer out some of what they had invested in, get some liquidity, put it back into user accounts,
so on and so forth.
So they had X trades for a few days.
Myself and I think others were thinking that's probably what's happening here is that they
have over leveraged themselves.
They need to dial it back.
They need to sell off some of whatever they were messing around with in order to have
the liquidity pool be exactly right for the
amount of volume that was being traded on the platform.
So you thought that it would freeze for a few days and come back.
Exactly.
And it did freeze, but forever.
It never came back. And so it sounds like the group of friends you had were all bullish on FTX at the time.
When you first saw the spinny wheel of death, I'm assuming you started texting friends and
what did they say?
They had the same issue?
Or how did this spread?
I primarily used a tool called Bitsgap. And there's a community there that I had been
involved with. And they were kind of like ex-day traders and more kind of hobbyists
than anything else. No one was like serious, serious, this is our job. This is what we
do on a day-to-day basis for our well-being and our paychecks, but they were all very smart and had been in traditional
markets for many, many, many years.
And I probably was more of the anomaly.
There was probably four or five others out of a group of a few thousand that actually
had jumped into FTX and just decided to toy around with it.
So I immediately obviously got on the forum,
the message board with them and said,
hey, are you guys having issues?
Yes, we're having issues.
And then that spiraled to texting other people
just that I knew that traded crypto,
are you using FTX?
Are you able to get access?
But in reality, I didn't have a strong network of people
that were FTX experts or were predominantly
using it as their primary exchange.
And so I myself was left with a lot of question marks and trying to keep up with all the news
that was going back and forth.
It was this one day, it was that one day, and there was the bankruptcy.
The website went up, the Kroll bankruptcy website went up and
he's originally checking that out and filing a claim and it was total chaos.
And then the interviews started to roll in and, uh, you know, the story kind of
evolved because what I knew, I knew in that first NPR interview was even two
weeks and so much happened in the timeframe of the initial platform.
And then the next day, bankruptcy filing to then a month later, or even into January of
2024, where people really started to get the landscape of how serious this was and that
there was no money that it wasn't hidden.
It wasn't mismanaged to the point where they had siphoned it off into all these other things and we just had to go to these other things.
It was up in smoke.
It just evaporated.
And that was not something anyone else thought of either that, okay,
platform can collapse.
Okay, great.
That can happen.
But then $10 billion worth of assets can just disappear as well.
Where did it go?
Who did it go to?
How did it happen?
Why are these people going to cough it up?
And how do we find it?
It was very challenging for me because again, the community that I, um, normally
messaged in,
they didn't have a ton of insight.
And so I tried my best to try and go find resources.
There are some people also that have been interviewed
or the course of all of this that I had reached out to
and gotten their two cents on and that kind of thing.
But there were a lot of people that were left on their own
without questions, without any resources.
And maybe the few people that they did know that had used the platform
didn't have any other information either.
They had the same questions with the same lack of answers.
And so you could have had 10,000 people texting in one group and it would have
all been the same, would have been a lot of frustration more than it
would have been proactive.
Because not only were the interviews coming out,
you mentioned NPR, but the tweet,
the story played out on Twitter, basically.
I mean, I don't know if you were a big Twitter guy
before this, but did you see all of it come out?
Like you mentioned that you're a fan of Binance.
That was SBF's competitor, CZ.
I won't say his full name.
I will for sure butcher it.
But he tweeted, you know, as part of Binance's exit
from FTX equity last year,
Binance received roughly 2.1 billion USD equivalent
in cash BUSD and FTT, which is FTX token.
Due to recent revelations that have come to light, we have decided to liquidate any remaining
FTT on our books."
Did you see this come out real time?
I didn't see it come out in real time.
I saw a post about it.
I think it was on Reddit, actually.
Somebody had posted it there because I don't have Twitter.
So I wasn't trolling the Twitter feeds or anything like that.
But I did see that that was my biggest red flag that things were wrong.
Because again, by dance was someone that knew what they were doing, how to do it,
regardless of any nefarious activities that they were involved in or not.
They had been around, they had played the game. They knew how to manage upturns, downturns in the market, so on and so forth.
I respected that.
It was a huge sign that if they are not confident in an investment of that size and magnitude,
there's something very wrong. Because again, they had been talking for some time
and SBF had hinted at partnership or some sort of investment from Binance, which would
have raised their profile significantly. There was the tweet also that SBF put out about
everything's fine, liquidity is fine. I didn't see that until maybe a few days after
it came out because I didn't have Twitter. Then when the implosion happened, people obviously came
back to that saying, why didn't he say this? And so on and so forth. So I didn't see that in real
time. Even if I had the question of why did Biden all of a sudden just shake it and say, hey,
without rhyme or reason, we are simply just liquidating everything.
Not like, hey, we're going to pause.
We're maybe going to do this in phases.
It was, we're out.
We're not saying anything.
Good luck.
That was a big message in the marketplace. Yeah.
I mean, for you, did you think this could spread to more of the financial system?
I mean, it sounds like you lived through 2008.
Did you have a moment where you thought the whole system could implode?
Of course.
Yeah.
My first thought was, how does this affect the market? How does this affect the
legitimacy of all the other platforms? And are they doing the exact same thing? And do they
equally have cash on hand to make good on all of their users or creditors? I immediately thought
that. And I immediately stopped trading, pulled out any of the remaining
assets that I had or as much as I could at the time.
Because again, there were some restrictions because the run on the bank was definitely
a real concern, I think, amongst the other platforms.
It took a few months, but finally I had divested everything I had in crypto, which at that
point was not a lot and had got it back into a traditional
bank account.
And after that, I haven't jumped back in and clearly things are operating fine for the
most part.
The market has had that recovery and had a fabulous year this year for the most part.
And maybe I missed out, but at the time, it was not in a position to even consider that.
It was, since ships on fire,
everyone for themselves kind of a thing.
When do you think it really sunk in
that the money was gone?
Because I'm sure at that point,
there was a ton of adrenaline, get the money out,
get it into a traditional bank, move as quickly as possible,
try to salvage anything you possibly can.
So when was it that it finally hit you?
It was probably a couple of weeks.
I can't remember the exact date.
It was the first week in December.
I had given the first NPR interview, and it made me think, you know, I really should go
check, I should go back through and I should be seeing if I can get
out on the platform, seeing what's really there versus not there.
Cause they were transfers on the end of Bitcoin and finance that said
pending, that there had been something that had triggered a notification that
said there's a transfer pending.
And I figured because of that, eventually the system would get sorted
out because at this point there's still
a huge doubt in everyone's mind that
the money is completely gone.
But it's just trained and that it's a
system issue and that they need to reconcile
this versus this and there's just a lot of movie pieces and it's a system issue and that they need to reconcile this versus this.
And there's just a lot of movie pieces and it's taking time.
The bankruptcy had been filed.
So obviously the legal entities need to get involved and verify things.
So it was definitely that first week in December when I sent a message to, I think it was Coinbase
support and said, are these going to go through?
And they said, no, as far as we know that these are just system
triggers when an event happens.
There hasn't been any other data sent through or any other meta tags
suggest that these are legit.
And if you want, we can cancel them out.
But the likelihood of them coming through is nil at this point.
So once I was like, okay, it's really just gone.
And that realization was very stark because at that point it wasn't, I've lost some money.
I'm going to have some.
It was zero.
I don't know how many people have had that happen before, but I had never had that happen
in any other adjustments that I had, whether it was a bet, whether it was something from
my youth or anything like that.
Never from a fairly decent amount to zero in less than three weeks and with almost no
recourse of recovery.
It was mind boggling, but it was also terrifying at the same time.
I can only imagine.
So just to sort of zoom out, at this point, you had a bunch of other losses and other
investments.
FTX had gone under.
You basically had nothing. There was no hidden bank account or brokerage
or something for you to live on.
What was, I mean, you're going into the holidays too
at this point to December.
What was that like for you?
I guess not just financially, emotionally and physically.
Yeah, I immediately got in touch
with a debt restructuring
company because I had essentially told my debtors
or creditors that I was planning to pay back
what I had leveraged at the end of the fiscal year.
That was kind of an expectation.
And they had a broker to deal with me understanding
that it was a short-term loan, essentially, that
was going to be paid back in quick succession.
So they were fine with allowing me to go on this.
Not related to FTX.
You just had a loan, right?
Yeah, I used that money to invest more heavily in crypto in general, not necessarily FTX.
So I immediately knew I was going to have to work with them and I was going to need
professional help that I wouldn't be able to do that on my own.
So I met with the debt collection company.
We worked out a plan and their job is to work with people that you have debt with, your
creditors and so on and so forth to come up with reasonable
repayment structuring plans and so on and so forth.
And I had my job.
I worked at a company called Lume at the time and was doing fairly well from a career standpoint.
And it was going to be extremely tight, but it was going to be manageable.
I would be able to do it if nothing else happened.
Well, it wasn't until February when the tech layoffs happened and I got laid off from my
job that things really got serious.
And at that point, debt collection wasn't an option.
And I thought, okay, what are the real options here?
Bankruptcy was one of the first things that somebody recommended.
It's not something that I had ever considered myself having to do, needing to do, or having
to consider it all in the course of my life.
I had liked to think that I was pretty financially prudent and that something like that was not in my
future.
But it was.
And I had opted to do chapter seven, personal bankruptcy, but that is a qualification process
that takes quite some time because they look back at your history and they say, okay, if
you were here at this point and you're now
here, why can't you do this or why couldn't you do this or what happened?
And so my bankruptcy lawyer essentially said, you can't file right away.
We can get everything ready, but we have to wait at least eight to 12 months because you
won't qualify.
There's a very specific bar that has to be met and unfortunately, if they wouldn't look back right now,
you have had some tough times,
but you still wouldn't qualify.
And so that started this essentially two year journey
of not getting any income, not having full-time work,
and having to scrape by in order
to meet the qualifications to file.
And then some events that happened after filing that truck things out
in February, March got out of it.
I mean, and when I say got out of it, got out of the bankruptcy, got out of the
foreclosure, any of the financial obligations
and responsibilities I had prior to FTX.
It's been that long.
I told the crew on Thursday that my mother was nice enough to buy me some groceries at
a fancy store that we have here called New Seasons.
I don't ever shop there anymore because a piece of food costs $50.
It's a very privileged thing to be able to go there. I just remember thinking eating
almond and realizing this is the first time my refrigerator has been full of locally sourced
whole foods like vegetables and fruits and that kind of thing. It was two and a half years.
like vegetables and fruits and that kind of thing, it was two and a half years. That was a sad and also humbling realization that just kind of put together.
But it sums it up quite aptly in the sense of the catalyst of FTX, the job markets being
laid off, going through all the proceedings to situate myself in a place where I can't even begin
to start to rebuild. And that's essentially where I am right now. And it's taken not this
long.
Wow. So it's safe to say that you went through a hard mental health time. Were you depressed?
I don't think I was. In fact, I got the comment a lot that how are you
handling this so well? And I don't have a straight answer for that. I didn't
really think about it that much or try and pin it down. I just kind of said,
let's just keep going, let's keep going. I just slide it into the tunnel, like
don't give up. And that's really what kind of drove me. In fact, this place that
I'm in right now is not my condo that I had owned. I recently moved in the last two months.
I'm essentially living here for free and person that owns this, uh, is actually
in Europe for the next few months and was nice enough to let me squat here.
Uh, while he's off doing fun things, I guess.
Um, but it was extremely challenging, but the challenge also brought a lot of
opportunity for me to
discover and question. I'm kind of an analytical person and I can now understand and appreciate the
kind of institutional
process in which once people find themselves in a position of bankruptcy or insolvency, that the mechanisms and agencies in place to help lift people up or to support also are as detrimental as anything else. And it's the cycle that is very difficult to get out of if you don't have the
resolve or even the sliver of resources to be able to do it.
And I felt compelled to try and understand that and fight that in some
instance, many times failure.
And so it wasn't just, you know, the FTX and losing my job.
It was fighting some of the bankruptcy trustees.
It was fighting some of the court proceedings when it came to the foreclosure and how that
all played out and spending money that I didn't have, other people's money to go to court
and try and fight some of these things and just get laughed out of the courtroom essentially.
So it was a humbling experience, say at least, not that I didn't invite some
of it myself, but I don't wish it upon anyone. And regardless of the trigger, whether it's
FTX or not, there is a systemic issue in the country that allows you to be able to file
for bankruptcy, but then does not allow you to necessarily come out of that or essentially benefit from the
opportunity to do that in a way that moves things forward, in my opinion.
In all honesty, the reason why I said I didn't think bankruptcy was for me is because I thought
these people were lazy.
I thought they were irresponsible.
There is a whole stereotype of things that I had thought people with bankruptcy
in that realm of losing things or having to be in that situation, the kind of character
they were, just to find myself in there and to be extremely humbled and humanized to realize
that it's going to happen to anyone.
I shouldn't say it probably can't happen to the PayPal mafia crew, but it can
happen to normal people in the blink of an eye and I wish that they were a better
solution and it's frustrated.
That was probably the thing that drove me the most is why is it like this?
Why are there no resources?
Why can't I get questions answered?
I'm being told what to do, but I'm not being told why. I don't have an advocate outside of paying someone
to help me get through the process to try and solution something different or understand like,
hey, is my situation worthy of this versus that? That's probably what drove me at the end of the day. So in other words, you're saying that the system around bankruptcy that's in theory
put in place to help people out of a bad situation makes it harder to get credit or to get a
new place, which is why it sounds like you're staying with a friend or to rebuild financially,
which is where you were stuck.
And while you were going through this, FTX was also going through bankruptcy.
Were you able to get any of the funds through their bankruptcy process?
Were you part of any of the class action lawsuits?
I didn't partake in any of the class action lawsuits simply because I had enough going
on in my personal life that it
wasn't something that I had to headspace for.
In fact, I needed to be away from that and not be involved.
I did file a claim.
However, that was very early days before things changed, before the new name came
along, I'm still a little unclear about some of the FTX subsidiaries
and now new holdings and that kind of thing.
And they're obviously still experiencing major issues
because payments have not been going out as they promised.
At least I haven't seen them anyway.
I did file a claim.
I did not want to not try to recoup some of the funds that I had
lost.
For their bankruptcy.
For their bankruptcy, right? So you could get your authentication and verification
done, which has been an issue. I have not done that yet. Again, they extended the deadline
to June 1, so I'm probably going to do that here the next month or two just to play the game. But I did mine and then I kind of washed my hands of it and I didn't want to partake in
it.
I watched a little bit of the trial and obviously heard the verdict and was like, that's great.
Fantastic.
Like, justice is served, I guess, but it didn't have an effect on me.
It didn't have an effect on what I was dealing with, what I was going to have to deal with and the challenges that I was facing, you know, in the months that I knew were coming up.
And so, you know, honestly, I don't know if people are going to see all their money again.
They say they are, but if you go and look on the website, the amount of claims that they have, the amount of motions that have been filed just within the past couple of months is insanity.
It's going to take years.
I mean, they have the money, great.
That's one thing.
Getting it to the entities that are needing it, sorting out all of those claims, because
there's hundreds of thousands of them, I think it's just going to take forever.
You've spent a lot of time thinking about all of this, I'm sure, living through it.
What are your thoughts now on Sam Bingman Fried?
My thoughts now are almost worse than they were before in the sense of everyone painted
him as this mastermind villain.
I don't see that now.
I see it as a spoiled kid who had parents that were able to guide him.
He went to prestigious institutions that enabled him access to the likes of Peter Thiel and other investors that would fund him. For all intents and purposes, he had no interest in crypto before starting FTX.
If you go back and look at his tenure at MIT, he didn't ever prophesize,
I'm going to build the next crypto exchange.
Now, he prophesized some of his other philosophical ambitions and that kind of thing,
but it wasn't necessarily crypto platform.
It was some iteration of freeness and community, but it wasn't necessarily that.
So I see him as a privileged white male like myself, able to build and get incredible access to initial funds to scale and perpetrate something
that he personally wanted to do.
Whatever that is, and I kind of alluded to what my theory is, that's to be unknown.
But he didn't start this for the betterment of mankind, people kind.
He was selfish.
He had an agenda.
What that agenda is hard to say.
I mean, obviously there was some legitimacy at the beginning.
There was an intention to do this.
It wasn't a Polly scheme.
It wasn't a scam.
It wasn't, you know, I'm going to pull the rug out from you at the very last moment.
There was the intent to provide for the most part. But I think that he deserves
every minute in jail, sitting in his cell with P. Diddy and the likes. They're good
riddance. They deserve each other.
If he was sitting here now and you had a chance to speak to him, what would you say?
I probably wouldn't say much. I have not a lot of words for someone like that, but I would say that regardless of whatever
restitution he has to pay back, whatever time he has to do to make good on his crime and
that kind of thing, I hope he's haunted by the fact of the detriment to people, right?
The hundreds of thousands, 400 plus thousand users on the platform
that were affected by this, not the big investors.
I'm talking about people that had their life savings of 50,000 K or less, or
complete and utter, um, enveloped into the platform, just destroyed, right?
Lives completely destroyed.
I mean, my situation is not perfect, but some people literally, they either retired or were
planning to retire now they can't retire and has messed up their life, has messed up their family's lives, has messed up their children's lives. Like generational impact.
I hope that that haunts him because it's the only restitution really that the victims will get
if they get any money back anytime soon or if they get the full value.
It's a little too late, right? The damage has been done.
or if they get the full value, it's a little too late, right? The damage has been done.
He was, of course, sentenced to 25 years in prison.
Do you think that was justice?
And if not, what does justice look like to you?
Well, I think it's justice in the fact
that regardless of the amount of time, which clearly was done as a precedence
for nefarious characters that may have plans of doing something like this in the future
or are currently in the marketplace and doing things that could be considered fraudulent
or affecting the market and consumers of crypto and the currencies and the tokens and the innocent
that just want to partake in a proactive and positive way.
I don't think justice was served in the sense that time in prison with these types of crimes
doesn't create a state of what I would call civic restitution for the people that were impacted.
Sure, they could file bankruptcy and they could find the money and maybe get it back
to people.
But as I said, there is a precipice of time that is really essential for that to really
matter.
For people's lives to be not irrevocably changed.
There's been a lot of great coverage about the case and about him and about the situation,
but not about the systems and the institutions that manage this and manage the blowback of
it and are supposed to be in charge of rectifying and resolving these types of things.
I think that's where the justice fails.
And that's not necessarily something you can pin on him, but I would rather
see him spend less time in prison and have to help with this in some shape or
form, right, be on the hook for making this work and happen, and even if it's
going around door to door to the victims and apologizing or something along those
lines, then, you know, hiding away in a cell and that kind of thing.
And who knows, maybe he will get pardoned by Trump and that'll be just
the icing on the cake if that happens.
But I think the system did what the system was designed to do.
I don't think the system is designed in a way that really is an advocate for the
victims in these types of scenarios.
So because the system hasn't changed much, do you think this can happen again?
In some respects, yeah.
I don't know of this miraculous collection of scenarios that just collate into one massive
kind of fallout.
I don't know if that could happen again,
because there's probably triggers and flags in place
on all primary changes now that would prevent that from happening,
or they're very cautious about that happening.
Their attention is so focused on this now,
that they're not focused on the next thing that could happen.
And of course, it's just a matter of time.
Yeah, it's like when you go to the airport
and you now take off your shoes.
I don't think we're gonna have any shoe bombs
anytime soon, but that doesn't prohibit something else
potentially from happening.
Same in the financial world.
So not another FTX,
but something else could potentially happen
with people listening and getting into different kinds of investments,
especially now when the market is low, some say that it's a good time to get in instead of get out.
Do you have any advice for somebody who's thinking about investing in crypto today?
I'm not an investor and I'm not a financial advisor, but I have heard plenty of people
say and give me advice of an investment is never secure.
It is never realized until it's realized.
And all you can do is ensure that you're comfortable with what you are investing in and that you have done enough of the
research and vetting that you can minimize as much risk as possible that is
known because what's unknown is unknown.
And the end of the day, it's a personal choice.
And I would never tell somebody not to do it because of my experience,
because it was a time and place.
And it could be years before something like that happens again, if it could, but
at the same time, it could be beneficial.
They could profit from it.
It's really their own personal approach to that risk assessment.
And I would say for me have the caution as much that threshold is much higher than it
would be two, three years ago, but that doesn't preclude it from being like
any other investment, there aren't the benefits to be realized.
There are definitely the pitfalls, but that's the same with property these days.
That's the same with the traditional stock market.
So nothing is safe.
these days. That's the same with the traditional stock market. So nothing is safe. It's just how comfortable you are and how willing you are to potentially go down that journey and
see what happens.
To be fair, some investments are safe and principle protected and bonds and things like
that. So if you want lower risk, there are some options, but you're saying, you know,
be vigilant, don't mourn paper losses, which is easy to
do.
The two days that are most important are the days you buy and the days you sell and everything
else is kind of noise.
Everything else is death and taxes, right?
Death and taxes.
Would you get into this space?
Would you invest again or have you completely stepped away?
I actually was just looking at it the other day.
Obviously, I hadn't done an interview in a while
and was poking around and pulled up the old Bitscap community
and said hey to everyone and that kind of thing.
And they were like, Jake, where you been?
It was like doing some stuff.
So I, myself, can't be too much of an alarmist because at some point or another,
I probably will.
I certainly will probably consider myself to be, from an investor standpoint, few here,
just a few there.
Just, again, I enjoyed the challenge of it and the strategy and analysis. That's still something I think is tangible
and can happen without having the world fall out from under you and that kind of thing.
So yeah, at some point I could see myself right this second. No, I have other things
to focus on, but if I get back to a place where I have some stability and some walking
around money, then yeah, absolutely.
And finally, is there anything else you'd want other victims to know, especially someone
who might feel alone or frustrated by the system and the bureaucracy and all the hoops
you have to go through to even try to get anything back?
I would say try. Definitely try. I'm a bad example on the sense that I should have done more for my own cause,
for my own case, but because I was dealing with other things, I was
trying to too upset and too disgruntled to really be an advocate for myself.
But if you find yourself in a situation like this, there are more people now, I would say, readily
available and willing to jump in and assist, whether it be lawyers, whether it be advocacy
groups, whether it be communities, whatever the case may be, than there have been in the
past.
And so there are more resources available now for victims of such types of crimes, especially I would say the crypto markets and that if you feel like that has happened or
you've definitely have been impacted by it, then don't just write off your losses.
Like fight for it because there is the potential to get your, some
portion of your pie back for sure.
If those organizations haven't been cut by Doge.
Right, that's a fair point.
Touché to that.
Jake, well, thank you so much for sharing your story with us.
It takes a lot to speak about this openly and honestly.
It is something so personal and painful.
And I know your honesty will definitely
resonate with a lot of people.
So thank you.
Yeah, absolutely.
Thanks for having me.
I appreciate what you guys are doing. [♪ music playing.
Thank you so much for listening.
I'm your host, Nicole Weppen.
Scams, Money and Murder is a Crime House original.
Join me every Thursday for a brand new episode.
Here at Crime House, we want to thank each and every one of you for your support.
If you like what you heard here today, reach out on social media at CrimeHouse.
Don't forget to rate, review, and follow Scams, Money,
and Murder wherever you get your podcasts.
Your feedback truly makes a difference.
And for ad-free listening, plus early access
and bonus content, subscribe to CrimeHouse Plus
on Apple Podcasts.
Scams, Money, and Murder is hosted by me, Nicole Lapin,
and is a Crime House Original powered
by PAVE Studios.
This episode was brought to life by the Scams, Money and Murder team.
Max Cutler, Ron Shapiro, Alex Benedon, Stacey Warnker, Sarah Kamm, Paul Lebesquen, and Victoria
Asher.
Thank you so much for listening.
Thanks for watching.
Be sure to subscribe to our channel for more videos like this.
We'll see you next time.
Bye!