Morbid - Episode 614: Listener Tales 91: HALLOWEEN Edition!
Episode Date: October 31, 2024Weirdos! It's *ACTUALLY* Halloween!!! Join us for a fresh batch of tales brought TO you, BY you, For you, FROM you, and ALLLLL about you! Today we have shadow men throwing ass, ghostly exes,... sinister DIY masks, annoying kids scaring young treat or treaters, and Big Wave bringing it all home for you! AND as a special treat! Check out the VIDEO from this episode available on ALL platforms on 10/31/24!If you’ve got a listener tale please send it on over to Morbidpodcast@gmail.com with “Listener Tales” somewhere in the subject line :)See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to Morbid early and ad free.
Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple podcasts.
You're listening to a Morbid Network podcast.
Listening on Audible helps your imagination soar.
Whether you listen to stories, motivation, expert advice, any genre you love,
you can be inspired to imagine new worlds, new possibilities and new ways of thinking.
Audible has the best selection of audiobooks without exception, along with popular
podcasts and exclusive Audible originals all in one easy app. Enjoy Audible anytime while
you do other things, household chores, exercising, on the road, commuting, you name it. Audible
makes it easy to be inspired and entertained as part of your everyday routine, without
needing to set aside extra time. There's more to imagine when you listen. Sign up for a free 30-day
Audible trial and your first audiobook is free. Visit audible.ca.
Kill List is a true story of how I ended up in a race against time to warn those who lives
were in danger. Follow Kill List wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to Kill
List and more exhibit-it C true crumb shows
like Morbid early and ad free right now by joining Wandery Plus.
Hey, weirdos.
I'm Ash.
And I'm Elena.
And this is Morbid. It's more bad.
Just kidding.
It's special.
I'm just a sad clown, so I'm being sad.
A sad clown.
I'm a sad, sad, girl clown.
And a lot of you probably know who I am, but if you don't.
Who are you?
I'm the lead singer. I'm a mama emeritus.
Oh, honey, I love it.
Yeah, I'm mama emeritus. I decided to keep the high pony.
The high pony, mama emeritus.
You know, oh, I did keep the fuck you.
It's Halloween, y'all.
I can't move too much because then my hat teeters
and I can't move my face.
And also I can't laugh really well.
So this is gonna be an adventure.
It was kind of awesome because Ash laughed earlier
and she went, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh.
And it sounded like a scary clown.
Well.
So there you go.
Well.
It's also, we're getting used to being,
like we don't film a lot. No. So this is an experience. Maybe there you go. Well. It's also, we're getting used to being, like we don't film a lot.
No. So this is an experience.
Maybe we should start, maybe like once a week,
we should just get into a wild ass costume
and just like start.
I think for listener tales, we should just be in costume.
I kind of love that idea.
And just film our listener tales
because we can be silly goofy with those.
Yeah. You know?
I think that would be really fun.
What do you guys think? I think that would be really fun.
What do you guys think?
I'm into it.
I heard you say you're into it, so maybe we should do that.
I'm trying to think of something to clown me.
Like, what do you guys think?
I don't think you're supposed to talk while you mime, but...
I don't think so either, but that's...
That might be the whole purpose of miming.
Well, I'm not a mime, all right? that might be the whole purpose of mime.
Well, I'm not a mime. All right. I'm a freaking clown.
It's true. But you know what? It's listener tales today. It's Halloween.
We're excited. It's Halloween.
A few of you guessed right too, because I posted a photo with my like freaky eye.
I didn't. Hopefully you can see well.
I didn't even post a teaser. Yeah. And a lot of people guessed mine.
I love that. Somebody thought I was David Bowie and I was like valid.
Well, next listener tales. Maybe you should be. You were him from Labyrinth before.
Yeah. Now I needed to be another era. Ziggy. Yeah. Ziggy Stardust. That'd be a fun one.
And then I could be like a famous rocker. Oh, the gears are turning.
I'm just, I have a theme of famous rockers going on.
Yeah. I like that. I like that.
Also happy Halloween,
cause it's legit Halloween right now.
It's Halloween.
It's not Halloween when we recorded this.
No.
But we're in the Halloween spirit.
You better believe.
Oh, we stay in the Halloween spirit.
So it's Halloween now.
Yeah.
Where you are.
It's Halloween where you are in the future.
And in the past, it's not Halloween yet,
but it's Halloween every day in our hearts. So. It's we are it is and that's why we're gonna do this more
often but it's listener tales we're gonna do some Halloween themed listener tales and
of course this is why we decided to make this a fun spooky event that I think we're gonna
do all the time now I think it's gonna be great but so let's get to the tails it's listener
tales it's brought to you by you for you you, from you, and all about you.
Let's go.
All right.
Well, the first one was written specifically for me.
You didn't say that, but I decided it was.
And this is from Kara, and it's fine to use their name.
And it says, a shadow man shook some ass on the stairs.
As soon as we saw this one, I was like, that's for Ash.
I said, thank you.
That is for Ash.
All right. So let's start off by saying,
I'm not sure if my house, 101 years old,
built during Prohibition, is actually haunted
or just something that things pass through.
I have distinct memories during my childhood
of blinds shooting closed on their own
and then periods of time where things were normal.
The biggest and spookiest set of ghostly happenings
happened about four years ago during my senior year of high school, where things were normal. The biggest and spookiest set of ghostly happenings happened
about four years ago during my senior year of high school, right around Halloween.
HALLOWEEN!
Throughout October. Things ramped up over time. It started one night when I was up late
working on a class project. My twin brother came in and told me he was going to go to
bed and walked out of the kitchen where I was. A few minutes later, I heard the distinct
sound of the footrest of our recliner few minutes later, I heard the distinct sound
of the footrest of our recliner being snapped down. So I assumed it's my bro, and he sat back down for
a sec. And I, wait, nothing. No one. Just me and panic shit that suddenly spawned and due to my fear.
I go and check. Yep, he'd gone to bed 10 minutes prior when he told me. Cool, cool, cool. I was
totally fine having a ghost to chill in my living room
and returned to my project.
If I don't address it, it'll stop, right?
That's how all problems in life work.
Wrong.
You don't address it, it'll just go away.
Wrong.
The next week, I'm at our side door about to walk
out to the car where my brother was waiting
to go meet our parents for dinner.
And as I opened the door,
I hear something sprinting through the kitchen toward me. I make terrified eye contact. Nope. With my brother. That clearly
conveyed my inner monologue of, holy shit, I'm about to shuffle off this mortal coil
without my consent because some invisible boogeyman is going to run me down right now.
Before I finally came to my senses and slammed the house door. Somehow this still didn't
spookify me too badly. I'll just keep ignoring it and it'll go away.
Yes.
Nope, wrong again.
Some time passes.
It's now the very end of October
if my memory serves correct.
Buckle up my spooky bitches.
This is where shit got real.
I thought shit already got real.
I kind of felt that way too, yeah.
Well, when I told my roommates this story,
we slept with the lights on for two days.
I need to describe the way my family's house is laid out
for you to clearly visualize what comes next.
I was about to laugh my hat off at you.
I'm gonna laugh my hat off.
Or maybe I'm so scared that my hat just popped off.
She's not gonna laugh her ass off,
she's gonna laugh her hat off.
I'm gonna laugh my hat off.
Well, our kitchen had a back staircase
that links up to the main staircase.
It's super steep and runs right up to the dishwasher. So we don't use it. It's just
storage space for kitchen appliances and Bay fridges.
So Bay fridges. I love a Bay fridge. We love a Bay fridge. Can I side note really quick
when Andrew first got like a home of our own, what the main thing he said to me that he
wanted to do, he said, our house has to be a beverage house.
And I was like, what's a beverage house?
And he said, I always want to have like a bunch
of different beverages.
And you do.
And we do.
We are a beverage house.
You are a beverage house.
Yeah, it was very important to him.
Dream realized.
Dream realized.
I opened your refrigerator the other day and I said,
oh my God, the beverages.
Oh my goodness.
The beverage, the variety.
If anybody wants to sponsor us, we have Elani, we have Olipop, we have Poppies.
We don't discriminate between the good for your tummy sodas.
We have Gatorade for Drew.
We have orange juice most of the time.
We have seltzers for the Mikeys.
We have La Croix.
We have...
Oh, La Croix, sorry.
Yeah, it's La Croix. I thought it La Croixs. I think it's a debate. I haven't
itched on my face. I want to like smack it but that doesn't work either. I'm just going
to lightly tap it. It's really not helping. It's not helping. No, I'm just kidding. No,
it's on this side. Oh, okay, that worked.
Thank you.
Please leave that in.
Anyway, this took a hard turn.
So our kitchen has a back stair.
Oh, nobody said that, beverages.
So the base of those-
Bay fridges.
Oh yes, excuse me, bay fridges.
The base of those stairs is directly adjacent
to the countertop that has the dishwasher,
the oven, and the sink.
So I'm at the sink washing some pans from dinner late at night. I'm the last one awake. Out of my peripheral vision to
the left, I can clearly see that staircase. It's dark, obviously, as everyone's asleep.
I shit you not. My heart cease to beat as I see a figure at the top of that back staircase.
I freeze, sudsy hands up and all, and hold my breath for a second. Out of the
corner of my eye, I clearly see a very tall shadow figure." She spied with her little eye.
"...bent down with his..." No, this cannot be real. I know it is. "...with his hands on his knees,
ass stuck out, head cocked all the way to the side to stare at me. He is in full twerking position,
ready to shake some ass like a teen at a prom in front of all their teachers and chaperones.
But he has his spooky head tilt, like head turned to the side and cocked so he could
get a good look at little old me.
So hands on the knees, but like a...
He said, hands on my knee knee shaking ass on my thumb chip
post me a pic i can't laugh well let it go you saw it it was good at first well i was not cool with being perceived by this spooky shadow bastard and definitely i did not want to be perceived
and definitely not cool with his spooky ass shaking stance. Side note, I know I sounded like some cool, brave badass who totally wasn't afraid,
but homies, I was about three seconds away from melting into a puddle of fear
and evicting myself from the property immediately.
I don't blame you.
I turn to confirm what I'm seeing and…
Oh! It's gone.
I love that somebody just came to shake ass with you in the afterlife.
That's my favorite. And he didn't even shake ass. He just got in the position.
He got ready to shake ass.
I think then he knew.
He was trying to see if you were ready.
Like he was doing what the ghosties were doing in the Amityville horror.
They were like, are you ready for a dance off? Like the marching band.
I think they were literally like, are you ready for it?
Are you ready? And you said, huh? And he was like, you're not ready for it. And he just got out.
He knew you weren't ready for his twerking. He would have gotten off. It was about to
talk. If you had been like, let's go. He would have been like, okay, let's go.
And that you should have shook ass with me. I don't know how to twerk. But like,
you could have figured it out in the moment. I would have. I believe in you. I would have.
You know, I've literally watched TikTok videos to learn how to twerk. But like you could have figured it out in the moment. I would have. You got to believe in you. I would have.
You know, I've literally watched TikTok videos to learn how to twerk.
Yes, I do know that about you.
And I can't do it.
So if anybody wants to help me out, call me.
Don't call me, but like DM me.
Don't call me.
DM me and teach me how to twerk.
Call me BeBe if you want to teach me how to twerk.
If you want to teach me how to twerk.
Because I love Meg Thee Stallion and she has so many great songs to shake ass to.
Doesn't she do that like eh thing?
Yep.
Eh.
Exactly.
I don't want to put my tongue out and get black all over it.
You got to just like stick it to the front.
Oh, okay.
Do it go.
Oh, I have to do it?
Yeah, of course.
Wait, I don't want to hold on because I have sparkles on my lips.
One, two, three.
Eh.
Yeah!
I love it.
All right.
So I know for a fact this wasn't so...
It's Halloween, guys. Have some fun.
Listen to your tails.
I know for a fact, this wasn't some trick of the lighter, my imagination.
I believe you.
This was a solid figure.
Enough so that I was 100% positive.
One of my siblings was playing a prank on me and just standing there to scare me.
But now there was nothing there.
So I finished washing dishes and went to my bed, forcing myself not to run when I hit the landing on the stairs where he had been. Very coo, casual, mindful of me. Very demure. Very demure,
very cutesy cutesy of you. Weirdly enough, after all that, things stopped for a while. My younger
sister started to experience things though, like her foot being yanked while sleeping at night
after I went away to college. No, no, I try not to think of that when I visit home for our in our shared room. But that's the tale. Now most of my friends refuse to come to my family
home. Oh, I'd come. You're like, I'm there. I'm there. I'll go shake ass with that ghost
once I learn how to work. Yeah. And your friends are scared to come due to a fear that this
spooky twerking tool is still on my stairs. I try hard not to think of him when I'm the
last one up at night, but he hasn't bothered me since. Maybe I ignored him for long enough that he skedaddled off to haunt someone else.
Keep it weird, but not so weird that...
I have to call you out, Kara.
Not so weird that you don't shake ass with the ghost on your stairs.
Kara, I understand that that was a scary situation because like, yeah.
Totally.
But if a ghost or a daemon is trying to have a dance-off with you...
You gotta show him what your mama gave you.
You gotta shake what your mama gave you.
You do.
You have to shake it like a Polaroid picture.
Precisely.
So, you really need to.
But you know what?
I probably would have been scared too and ran out of my house.
So, I would have been too.
That's my real me talking.
So, tough me is like, I don't know, I would have thrown ass.
I would have thrown ass with that daemon. I would ass without time. Wow, Kara, I love that. See, that was my spooky clown laugh again.
I didn't even mean to do it. Oh, I don't like that. I like it. Don't show this to Drew. I think he
would leave. John, I sent a picture to him because he was picking up the girls from school and he
just said, my God. And then she said, when you sent the picture of you and Tobias.
I sent the picture of this and I said, twins.
And he said, totes my goats.
Totes my goats.
And I was like, you're going to be scared when I come downstairs.
Drew said, oh, you a cute little sad clown.
But I think if he heard me laugh like that, he would not like that.
He would say, you're a scary little sad clown.
He would say, get out of my presence.
So my next listener tale is called Halloween Listener Tale, My Ghostly Ex-Boyfriend and
a New Orleans Psychic.
Oh no, Debbie said this is a beautiful tale, but it might make you cry.
Oh shit.
I can't cry.
I'm already crying.
Oh no, Deb Deb.
This is from Chelsea.
Hi Chelsea.
Hi Chelsea.
Hi Chelsea.
I've been watching old episodes of Southern Charm and there's a Chelsea.
Oh, I loved Chelsea. Yeah. And the really terrible Ashley girl was like, Chelsea. When she was trying
when she was trying to explain why she was a dick. Ashley. Chelsea. All right. My name is Chelsea.
Who did? Ashley. Oh, she blocked you on Twitter. yeah. That's hardcore. I know. So this says, my name is Chelsea.
And as I mentioned above, I'm a Louisiana girl.
Hey, Chelsea.
Hi.
Born in and raised just north of New Orleans,
I was raised Catholic.
And while I no longer identify as religious,
I would say I am still quite spiritual.
My Catholic upbringing has left a few imprints
on who I am as a person,
and namely a deep seated belief in a higher power, whatever you want to call him or her, something greater than ourselves, a strong
conviction that there is more to this world and the next than we see and or an understanding
and an openness to signs and messages from the other side.
Yeah, I agree.
I actually love that.
I think that's a beautiful belief system.
That's pretty much exactly what I believe.
Yeah. I don't believe that I'm psychic or clairvoyant in any way, but I've always felt a closeness
or openness to messages from loved ones who have passed on.
And I could write another two or three listener tales just with stories of interactions with
my grandma.
Mama.
Mama.
After her passing.
Okay.
So.
Please write those stories.
Yeah.
I got to hear about mama mama mama More than 10 years ago. I moved to houston texas after grad school to take a job and start building my career
While living in houston. I met and started dating a nice greek boy named teddy
Oh, we love teddy teddy was and still to this day is the kindness person
I have ever met good because I was like we love teddy and then I was like, do we love teddy?
I know I got a little bit nervous.
Or do I have to fight Teddy?
But I'm glad I don't have to fight Teddy.
We would have squared up for you, Chelsie.
We would have, but you know what Teddy?
Good job.
Hey Teddy.
Once upon introducing Teddy to a group of my friends,
one of my friends asked me how it felt to be
the worst person in the relationship.
Oh, you know, we're all out there.
We're all out there somewhere.
I'm the worst person in the somewhere. I'm the worst person
in the relationship. Are you the worst person in the relationship? Yeah, you are. Yeah,
you are. Yeah, don't lie. You're right. We're the worst ones.
Here we are. That's awesome. He was joking, but he was 100% right. Whatever traits I imagine
God uses to judge the goodness of a person, selflessness, loyalty, patience, et cetera,
Teddy was off the charts in all of them.
That's John and that's true.
Teddy for life, that is.
That's Teddy.
["Jingle Bells"]
Have you ever wondered what goes into making this podcast?
It's all about thorough research and paying attention to every single detail.
Thankfully, I've learned to do this and more with Masterclass.
With Masterclass, you can learn from the best to become your best.
For just $10 a month, an annual membership with Masterclass gets you unlimited access
to every single instructor.
And you can access Masterclass on your phone, computer, smart TV, or even in audio mode.
You can use behavioral science to read others from FBI criminal profiler John Douglas, uncover
the truth with Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Bob Woodward, or successfully negotiate any
situation with FBI hostage negotiator Chris Voss.
I use this and you should too.
When I found out that John Douglas taught a class, I was like, yup, I'm in.
And he teaches a class how to think like a criminal profiler.
In where I work, I meet a lot of different people in a lot of different situations.
And I thought it wasn't a bad idea to be able to get in people's minds a little bit and
to understand what people really want from me.
When I saw that he had a specific session on how to spot a liar, I said, oh yes, let's
go.
And it's honestly helped so much and it's just really cool to hear from somebody with
such expertise.
Right now, our listeners get an additional 15% off any annual membership at masterclass.com
slash morbid.
That's 15% off at masterclass.com slash morbid. That's 15% off at masterclass.com slash
morbid. Masterclass.com slash morbid. My god, life is stressful between work every single day,
finances, some of you people have kids, I got my mental health, all of that stuff. You're just
trying to juggle all of it. Well, start your morning with Ritual Stress Relief.
This product uses first of its kind technology
to support the body's natural cortisol response
so you can take on the daily juggle.
Because let me tell you, before Ritual,
I was about to lose my dang mind.
My cortisol must have been in my eyeballs at that point.
I love Ritual and I feel like the Stress Relief blend
actually really works. The Stress Relief Blend actually really works.
The Stress Relief Bio Series technology is designed to optimize the release of a trio
of clinically studied ingredients to help the body manage stress. The juggle is real.
Don't just respond to stress, get ahead of it with Stress Relief from Ritual. Get 25% off your
first month at ritual.com slash morbid. Start ritual or add stress relief to your subscription today.
That's ritual.com slash morbid for 25% off.
["The Last Supper"]
After dating for about a year,
I woke up one morning to find Teddy
having a full-blown seizure beside me.
Holy shit, the turn.
Yeah, that took a quick left. After months of testing,
doctors visits and additional seizures, always at night and always in his sleep, we would
find a brain tumor lodged in his right temporal lobe. We quickly scheduled surgery and the
tumor was removed successfully and identified as benign. Oh good. But unfortunately the
seizures continued and when they did,
I was always the only person there since they only happened that night while we were sleeping.
He lived with them. I can't imagine that. I really can't.
No, you're an angel.
He lived with them and managed his condition with medication as best as he could.
I'm a strong believer that just because something isn't forever doesn't mean it wasn't real.
My relationship with Teddy is an example of this.
After almost 3.5 years together, life was pulling the two of us in different directions.
We broke up and went our separate ways, both sad but with nothing but love and respect
in our hearts for one another.
I moved back to Louisiana and he stayed in Texas.
The fact that you still say he's like one of the most kind people you've ever met is
like such a mature relationship.
It really is.
Fast forward a year and a half and I was dating the man who, spoiler alert, is now my husband
David.
Who?
Who?
Hey David!
Day day.
Day day.
Day day.
We were on our first big trip as a couple in Mexico when I received a phone call from
my best friend back in Houston.
Oh no, my heart is about to sink.
When I answered, she asked to speak to my boyfriend. It struck me as weird, but I handed
over the phone. When David hung up, I knew exactly that something was wrong. David then
had the devastating task of telling me that Teddy was gone. He had passed in his sleep
as a result of a seizure. He had been alone.
That's awful.
I'll tell you one thing, ladies.
It takes a strong man to watch the woman he loves
grieve openly and savagely over another man, but he did.
That's another good one.
David for life. Another great one.
He held me while I sobbed and screamed and blamed myself.
If I had only been there, if we hadn't broken up,
I could have saved him. When I told
him I didn't know what to do with myself or my thoughts, he asked me to tell him about Teddy.
What a human.
I got a full body.
Like what an amazing man. We spent that entire night talking about my ex-boyfriend,
with David giving me all the space and support I needed to not crumble into oblivion. I knew after
that night that I would marry David. Hell yeah you did. That's awesome.
Whew, okay. You're probably like, bitch, get to the spooky part, which is exactly what
I'm doing now, but you needed the background context.
Fair, fair enough.
And I appreciate you telling us.
Yeah.
The months following Teddy's death were weird, heavy. It sounds insane, but I could feel
him.
That doesn't sound insane.
That doesn't sound insane at all. Strange things were happening in my house, never threatening or scary, but I could feel his presence.
Lights would flicker, an untouched book on my bookshelf became mysteriously dog-eared to a particularly meaningful passage.
That's beautiful.
Damn.
Elaina would be so mad.
She literally won't let me borrow her books because I dog-ear the pages.
It's true. I don't dog-ear pages. I can't handle it.
You're insane.
I'm a bookmark, really.
She is.
I like my books to be in the right condition.
I think they look well-loved if they've been dog-eared a lot.
No.
Not for me.
It's a great debate.
I was going to say it's a great personal debate.
We'll do a poll.
Yeah, we will. Except I might lose that one.
I don't know.
I don't know. One time when I had a fever and chills, my AC broke making my house a toasty 83 degrees.
Oh, I would die.
Oh, God.
That's horrible.
Once my fever broke and the chills went away, the AC turned back on like nothing had happened.
It's just like Teddy to be taking care of someone from the afterlife.
Wow.
Halloween night of that year.
Halloween.
Halloween.
I happened to be back in Houston on a business trip.
I was invited to celebrate
with some of my and Teddy's mutual friends and headed over to their house for dinner.
That night, a wicked thunderstorm came rolling through Houston, knocking out the power at
their house and generally upping the spook factor since we were now dining by candlelight.
All through the evening, our host had music playing in the background via her phone. At
some point, her phone stopped working,
and try as she might, the music would not come back on. We chalked it up to the storm
messing with service and continued our conversation in silence for another 30 minutes or so. Eventually,
as we knew it would, the conversation turned to Teddy. As the storm continued to rage,
we discussed how much we all missed him and agreed on the general tragedy of the situation.
I confessed the guilt I was carrying around, how if we hadn't broken up, I would have likely been there to intervene.
I told them about the weird experiences I was having in my house and that's when our
host's phone started playing music again, on its own.
Stop it.
A completely different song and genre than it had been earlier. The song was a newer
one I had heard in passing but never really listened to the lyrics until that moment. We all sat in silence while the
song played, each listening to the words and listening at each other with, in looking at
each other with wide eyes. It was happier by Bastille. I love Bastille.
Oh my God, I have goosebumps.
If you're unfamiliar, the lyrics are, to paraphrase, lately I've been thinking I want you to be
happier. Even though I might not like been thinking I want you to be happier.
Even though I might not like this, I want you to be happier. And so that means I'll have to leave.
Oh my God. My goosebumps have goosebumps.
I was just, I felt that.
Holy shit.
The song is about a couple who is breaking up because they know what's best for them,
even though they are heartbroken. But the guy acknowledging that he's going to walk away so that
she can be happier. Everyone in the time, I'm like about to cry. Literally everyone in the room was
looking at me, some with goosebumps on their arms, some with tears in their eyes. And it was clear
that they were all interpreting the same message as I was. Teddy was telling me that it was okay,
that he heard me, that he didn't blame me, and that he was going to back off with the ghosty shit
since it was freaking me out a bit lol.
I immediately felt a weight lift off my shoulders.
After that night I did not feel his presence around me anymore.
I felt that he had moved on to wherever he was supposed to be.
I didn't hear from him again until two years later in October 2020 in the midst of the
pandemic David and I were engaged and tentatively planning
our wedding. Thanks, COVID. My spooky witchy bachelor at extravaganza, which was originally
planned in Salem, Massachusetts. Oh, it had to be canceled due to travel restrictions.
So plan B was a bachelor at Halloweekend here in Louisiana, which is still fucking cool.
I think that might even be better. Yeah. Complete with outdoor social distancing friendly activities for a small group of my closest friends.
One of these activities was hiring a real life French quarter psychic medium to come read tarot cards for us as part of our glamp out at our farm north of Nola.
Oh my God, this is incredible.
Why didn't you invite me?
Why didn't you invite us?
The open air was a good setting for group activities and the sweeping live oaks were an excellent backdrop for some witchery. I'm obsessed. I feel so cozy.
Just thinking about that. It feels like a book. The psychic began by reading tarot for everyone
in attendance and this lady was the real deal. As in I sat down and was crying with the first
three sentences out of her mouth. First thing she said to me before even touching the cards was,
your people on the other side are very loud.
They're telling me that you're worried you won't be able to have children.
And they're telling me that that's not going to be a problem.
It will happen almost immediately.
Oh my God.
This woman did not know me.
She had no way of knowing that I've known since I was 16
that I have a condition that could impact my fertility
and that knowledge had hung over me like a dark cloud every day of my life. Spoiler alert,
she was correct.
Yay!
So you didn't have any issue. That's amazing.
What's wild too, that's weird that you had that feeling that you were worried about it.
I also had that feeling from a very young age.
Yeah.
And it's like I knew it and I did have trouble.
I know. It's wild, but then I
got my babies. Now after reading Tarot, she transitioned into a mediumship session where
she opened herself up to messages from the other side. After a few messages for some
of my friends, all of which were scarily accurate, she suddenly said, I'm feeling the presence
of a young man and he's showing me a teddy bear with a T on it. I immediately went cold. Teddy's
last name started with a T and one of his nicknames was Teddy T. She proceeded to tell
me that he sees everything happening in your life and he's so happy for you. He supported
my marriage. He likes David. She also added, he wants you to know that there's nothing
you could have done to prevent what happened to him. Even if you had been there, it was over so quickly and he wasn't scared or in pain."
Oh, that must've been like such a weight off your shoulders again.
Seriously. She finally said, he wants you to know that you are the love of his life
and he's so grateful for that.
I'm going to sob right now.
Literally.
I had to close my eyes so that they wouldn't start forming tears.
It's like actual tears.
Yes.
Let me tell you the sobs that left my body.
It truly felt like the most beautiful gift of closure.
Knowing that he was okay, knowing that he was happy and happy for me, it's an experience
that has stuck with me and will be with me forever.
I now see Teddy as one of my guardian angels up there conspiring with my mama and papa.
Oh, mama.
Watching over me and my beautiful growing family. David and I did indeed
get pregnant almost immediately after our wedding. Our son was born two days after our first
anniversary and we are currently expecting our second son, Chelsea. David continues to be an
amazingly supportive partner and father to our children. We still talk about Teddy, remember
his birthday every year and we travel up to New England together to attend Teddy's sister's wedding a few years ago, where he
bonded with Teddy's dad and stayed up until 4 a.m. drinking with Teddy's best friends.
That's amazing. I love that.
David's my favorite person ever.
David rocks.
David now loves Teddy's family as much as I do, and we try to see them regularly. His
family will be a part of our children's lives, and I plan to share his story with my sons when they are old enough to understand.
I think this is the most beautiful listener tale we've ever received.
Truly. I hope they see it as an example of finding a beautiful silver lining around life's
darkest clouds. Proof that people come into our lives for a reason and that not all love
stories end with forever. Some love stories end in this world,
but go on into the next. And I hope they see their father as an example of an incredible
emotional maturity, a paragon of non-toxic masculinity, and an illustration of the kind
of supportive partner they should strive to be one day. Wow. Yes. Amazing. Thank you if you've made it this far into reading this rather lengthy novella.
We can't all be bestselling novelists, Selena.
I love you.
But I felt this story had to be extracted from the inside of my head and put to paper.
I have attached some pictures to this email so you can put some faces and names and add
some color to the story.
Why are you all so beautiful?
You and Teddy are the cutest things I've ever seen.
And so are you and David and your child.
And you and David and your baby.
Wow.
Oh.
And they made it to Salem last year
and you got to go to the Ropes Mansion.
You got to go to Alison's house.
Stop it.
I love it.
Oh my God, these are great pictures.
And your pups.
Winona and Reba.
Winona and Reba?
Winona and Reba.
Not sad, just sleepy.
Oh my God, I love it.
Honestly, Chelsea, that story was one
of the most beautiful stories we have had in Listener Tale.
So thank you for that.
Gorge, gorge, gorge.
You and David forever, Teddy forever.
I'm gonna remember that story forever.
That was an amazing story.
Thank you for sending that.
It was beautiful.
All right, my next one is Listener Tale,
Trick or Treat or Clowns. I love it. Hey was beautiful. All right, my next one is listener tale, trick or treat or clowns.
I love it.
Hey, yo, this is from Megan.
Megan. Megan.
I don't know why I said it like that.
Oh. Oh, she did it.
Now we'll work on the head tilt next.
Yeah, the tilt.
Wow, that just made me really happy.
All right, to properly tell this story,
I got so bossed in there. To properly tell this story, I got so bossed in there.
To properly tell this story.
It's rubbing off on me. What were you saying today that you like couldn't unbother?
Pultegeist.
Pultegeist. She couldn't stop saying Pultegeist. All right. To properly tell this story, I
need to start with the setting. This happened in 2014 on the spookiest day of the year.
One, two, three.
Halloween.
My family had moved about an hour away
from our old house in 2013.
The new neighborhood we moved to was known for Halloween.
So much that people drove to trick or treat there.
Oh, hell yeah.
Were even more known for Christmas,
which leads to a lot of traffic during the holidays.
But everybody passed out candy
and loads of people decorated.
To give some perspective, we would buy a bag of candy
every single time we went shopping in September and October just to have enough to pass out before
the night ended. And sometimes that wasn't even enough. Wow. I want to go to there. I do too.
At the time of this particular Halloween, I was about 11 and my older sister Erin was around 12.
So we were still at the age where trick-or-treating was something we looked forward to.
We invited my sister's best friend who lived an hour away to spend the night trick-or-treating was something we looked forward to. We invited my sister's best friend, who lived an hour away, to spend the night trick-or-treating
with us since the neighborhood was so known for being the spot to go. Naturally, we had
to coordinate costumes or what was the point. Erin and her best friend were Tweedle Dee
and Tweedle Dum, but instead of fat suits, they were tutus and suspenders.
I love that.
I love that. That's great.
Ah, it was Alice and wore a little blue dress with a white apron and had a black bow tied in my hair.
It's horrible.
We all looked very cute and unassuming,
which is- Very cutesy cutesy.
Very demure, very mindful,
which is probably why we looked like easy targets that night.
Uh-oh, I'm scared.
Now, to understand what happened,
I'm gonna give you a quick and simple layout
of the neighborhood.
We lived near the end of a long street
that connected to two major streets in the neighborhood.
Keep in mind that we had moved there recently and
weren't super familiar with the area. However, it was very safe and my mom, who
always supervised us outside, thought it was fine for the three of us to go alone
while she stayed and passed out candy. She helped us pick an easy route of three
streets that formed a triangle. We would walk on the main street close to our
house and then take a turn onto a street parallel to ours.
From there, we would turn onto the other main street
that connected to the one we lived on
just to make our way back.
Even though this was a safe neighborhood
and the route was simple,
I was pretty terrified to go alone.
We had never done that, never done that before,
let alone in a new neighborhood.
I was always the child who could hardly bear
to be out of sight of an adult.
That's literally your middle.
Yeah. My sister on the other hand relished in the opportunity to have no supervision and she and her friend were excited your oldest. Yep
The night started off pretty normal. It was still light out when we left
But by the time we had gotten to the second main road, it was dark
We amassed a good amount of candy by that point and we're about to turn back onto our street
However, this is when things got a little strange.
In a quiet suburb, a community is shattered by the death of a beloved wife and mother.
But this tragic loss of life quickly turns into something even darker.
Her husband had tried to hire a hitman on the dark web to kill her.
And she wasn't the only target.
Because buried in the depths of the internet is The Kill List, a cache of chilling documents
containing names, photos, addresses and specific instructions for people's murders.
This podcast is the true story of how I ended up in a race against time to warn those who
lives were in danger.
And it turns out convincing a total stranger someone wants them dead is not easy.
Follow Kill List on the Wondry app or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can listen to Kill List and more exhibitshibit C true crime shows like Morbid
early and add free right now by joining Wondry+.
Check out Exhibit C in the Wondry you'd want your own children defended. Whether you're facing a drug charge, caught up on a murder rap, accused of committing war crimes,
look no further than Paul Bergrin.
All the big guys go to Bergrin because he gets everybody off.
You name it, Paul can do it.
Need to launder some money?
Broker a deal with a drug cartel?
Take out a witness?
From one dream, the makers of Dr. Death and Over My Dead Body, comes a new series about
a lawyer who broke all the rules.
Isn't it funny how witnesses disappear or how evidence doesn't show up or somebody
doesn't testify correctly?
In order to win at all costs.
If Paul asked you to do something, it wasn't a request.
It was an order.
I'm your host, Brandon James Jenkins.
Follow Criminal Attorney on the Wondery app
or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can listen to Criminal Attorney early and ad free
right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app
or on Apple podcasts.
["Wonderful Music"]
As we were about to turn back onto the street,
from the corner of my eye,
I saw a lone trick or treater across the street. He was dressed in all black clothing and wore a Halloween clown mask
that covered his whole face. Scary. I don't like that. This by itself wasn't unusual,
but what was strange is that he didn't have a bag to hold candy. Oh yeah, no. Instead,
he had a baseball bat. Nope. I thought to myself, huh, that's odd. Huh. Huh. But he was on the other side of the
road. So it wasn't a problem. Well, actually it was a problem because pretty soon after noticing
this person, I realized he wasn't alone. Trailing behind us was another person in all black and
wearing that same clown Halloween mask obscure and it is obscured his whole face. This person
didn't have a bat, but instead was simply dragging a golf club along the
sidewalk behind him.
What the fuck?
Where are, where is any help?
What's happening?
I'm scared.
I, mom, pick me up.
I'm scared.
The rest all happened very quickly.
It was dark and I don't know where they came from, but in the blink of an eye, the two
people turned into three, then four, then five, then suddenly ten people were dispersed
around the street.
What the fuck?
All wore the same clown masks and had bats or golf clubs.
The ones on the other side of the street crossed the road and came towards us.
At the same time, the ones on the street got closer to us and started forming a circle.
No.
We were surrounded.
There were at least three on each side
to the left and right of us,
a few behind us and one in front.
They were dragging their clubs
and banging their bats on the concrete.
Ew, what assholes.
Like truly.
Like fuck you guys. Get out life.
What is particularly strange
and something I do not understand to this day
is that the street was empty.
I was thinking about this whole time.
Yeah, I'm like, where is everybody?
Is there an adult to help you? This was the
most popular neighborhood to trick or treat in. However, besides these strange boys and
the looming darkness, we were the only ones on that street.
Was this some like weird elaborate hazing ritual that your neighborhood had?
Oh my God, maybe that'd be fucking awesome. That they were like, welcome to the neighborhood.
We're going to scare the shit out of you. We want to see if you can fucking hang.
Were they just waiting for someone to walk by when the street was clear?
Were they hiding?
Did they have some sort of signal?
Yeah.
However, the answers to these questions were irrelevant because the reality was they were
getting closer by the second.
If I reached out, I could touch one before my arm was even fully straightened.
Oh no.
Oh, that's too much in my personal space.
Yeah, of course it is.
Get out of my fucking bubble.
No, get out of my fucking bubble. No, get out of the fucking bubble.
Get out.
I remember how I said that I was scared to go and my sister wasn't.
Yes.
This is where that shifts.
Erin and her friend who were in front of me slowed down and came closer to me.
We were all frazzled with a look silently asked each other, what do we do?
For some reason that alludes me to this day, the dominant emotion that I was
feeling wasn't fear, but anger.
Looking back, I should have approached the situation
with more caution, but I was pretty pissed.
I would be too.
And I kind of loved that you were pissed.
In my mind, these had to be neighborhood boys
picking on the little girls wearing tutus and dresses
and just trying to scare them.
So fuck them.
So I immediately decided that if they were gonna try
to get a rise out of us,
the best thing we could do was not give them one.
I whispered to my sister and her friend, keep walking.
And we did.
What they didn't know was that we were on the street we lived on, so we just had to
outlast them.
Unfortunately for us, they kept walking too.
What?
I want to junk punch.
Every single one of them.
These little fucks.
So hard for you.
And hit them with their golf clubs.
Yeah.
Like, ugh.
It almost looked like a security detail for a celebrity, except, you know, the fact that
they were threatening us.
Except a very weird one.
Yeah.
Kind of like paparazzi, actually.
In a situation like that, logic is the first thing we abandon.
We certainly had cell phones and could have called for help, but we just kept walking.
Besides, even if we got our phones out, they were close enough to just grab them. After what felt like several minutes, but I'm sure it was only a moment, I switched tactics.
I must have heard this from some television show, but I turned to the closest one on my left and
said in the most intimidating voice at 11 year old girl dressed as Alice in Wonderland could muster,
voice an 11 year old girl dressed as Alice in Wonderland could muster.
I will cut you.
Oh my God.
I'm obsessed.
I will cut you.
Honestly, I would have ran.
Honestly, I would get the fuck out of there. I'd be like, I believe it.
I believe it.
Cause anybody dressed as Alice in Wonderland.
Saying I'm going to cut you right in their face.
That's scary.
Yeah.
You did the right thing.
I will cut you.
That's right.
She said, this is embarrassing, but I hope it makes you laugh. It's not embarrassing. You should not be thing. Oh, cut you. That's right. She said, this is embarrassing,
but I hope it makes you laugh.
It's not embarrassing.
You should not be embarrassed.
Be proud. It's iconic.
I needed them to know that we were not scared
and what they were doing wasn't working,
so they should just give up.
It didn't deter these boys,
but it served to un-confidence.
Get a life. Get a life.
It didn't deter these boys,
but it served to un-confidence to my sister and her friend.
They continued to walk,
and when they got close to the masked person in the front, they just pushed him
out of the way. With our heads up, but not making eye contact, we continued because what
else was there to do really? We could start to see other trick-or-treaters in the distance.
Our luck changed then and just as quickly as they came, these masked boys were gone
without a trace."
What?
They just left?
They just like poofed into the air?
So they just menaced you? And then left? And then left? They just like poofed into the air? So they just menaced you?
And then left?
And then left? Fuck them.
Don't ruin somebody's Halloween like that.
I'll find them.
I will and we'll junk punch every single one of them.
Dressed like this.
Dressed like this. How scary would that be?
Yeah.
That would show them.
Clown me clown.
Clown me clown. Are you ready?
I love it.
The dread was replaced by a flood of relief and we were safe again. After that, I don't
think we resumed trick-or-treating and just went home for the night.
Oh, that's a bummer.
I know, I'm sorry.
I understand it.
I will continue.
We did tell my mom what happened while we were treating Candy in the kitchen. She wasn't
thrilled that we engaged with them, but wasn't too worried. It did sink in later that night,
to me at least, how that situation could have gone so differently.
Yeah. I can't say I was particularly traumat least, how that situation could have gone so differently.
I can't say I was particularly traumatized,
but that was the last year I went trick or treating.
Oh, that makes me sad.
You were 11?
Yeah.
Oh, that makes me really sad.
Dude, I was like 15 when I stopped trick or treating.
I got to the point where people were like,
we're not kidding you.
We're not, you're like, you're too old for this.
However, Halloween remains my favorite holiday
and I celebrate it every year.
Good.
Thank you for reading this
and I hope everyone keeps it weird
but not somewhere that you surround children
and try to scare them by banging baseball bats
and golf clubs because that's just not cool.
P.S. I retold the story to my mom as I was writing this
and she seemed confused and said,
was it really that bad?
Didn't some boys just follow you?
I suppose that when we told her at the time,
we left out a lot of details.
I guess. And when I recounted it like this, we left out a lot of details. I guess.
And when I recounted it like this, she was appalled.
She said how I didn't know about the weapons
or the clown mask and said that if she did know that,
she would have been on the hunt for these boys' parents.
Okay, oops.
I knew that had to be a missing link there
because I was like, if my kids come home and tell me
that a bunch of boys with weapons and clown masks surrounded them.
Wait, can I interrupt you?
I know exactly what you would do.
She would do.
Yep.
Whenever Alina's mad, she always crunches.
Ready?
And it's always so good.
And that would be, I'd be like, we're off.
I'd be like, ladies stay at home.
And I'd be like, mama and dada are gonna go.
Call TT, I'm going.
We're gonna go make some
friends in the neighborhood. Oh, I would. And then we would never see those boys again. Like,
when I tell you like the rage I had for you in that moment, I wanted to fucking strangle these
boys. That's just so necessary. Don't ruin someone's Halloween. Halloween is supposed to be fun.
And people need to consent and being scared. Don't be a dick.
Just be cool. Don't be all, like, uncool.
Don't do that. And definitely don't fucking scare kids.
Like, what the hell? Get a life. Let them live.
Like we said. She stresses Alice in Wonderland.
I know. Like, let her live.
Go... Ugh.
They did their costumes together for this.
Yeah. I'm not impressed by them.
That don't impress a me much.
If you're listening, boys who did that, I'm not impressed.
Oh, they're not listening because they are not this cool.
No, they're not.
They are losers.
They're not this cool.
They're not this cool.
This is so cool.
They are not on this level.
Cosplay equals cool.
Are you on the level?
No.
No, you're not.
The answer is no.
You could never be.
All right, mine is entitled,
How I Thought I Was Going to Be Killed
by a Paper Maché Mask Wearing Psycho.
Whoa.
And it's by Bea.
Hi, Bea. I love that name.
And it says, Like the Bumble.
Like the Bumble.
It says, hello lovely ladies of all that is,
all that tis dark, weird and spoopy.
My name is Bea, Like the Bumble.
A family nickname, which you are more than welcome to use
as I consider you and all other weirdos listening as family.
I love that.
You are our family.
I discovered your absolute gift of a podcast
at the beginning of 2022,
and it has kept me laughing through many a commute
and hard times.
Seriously, you guys remind me so much of me and my sister,
which is a huge comfort
since we live on opposite sides of the Pacific. Damn.
Oh, I could never.
I know I could never.
Thank you.
One time I was going to move to New York and we just couldn't even handle it.
Couldn't do it.
Yeah.
Couldn't do it. Thank you for all you do. You two are delights. Never change your badass
bitch in ways.
We won't.
I love it.
We won't.
Total side note, Ash, I'm a Libra. So is Mikey.
Mikey's a Libra.
Which makes us air sign besties.
We are air sign besties.
I can't really decide how to segue from that to my story, but here we go. I'm not a writer like
Elena. Cue Ash sharing the link to The Butcher and the Wren.
tinyurl.com slash The Butcher and the Wren. I don't know if that still exists. Don't go there.
But it's there. Congrats, Elena. Can't wait to read it. Update. I got it all downloaded
on my Kindle and ready to go. So I hope this is not too convoluted. Thank you so much. Be for life.
The tale begins five years ago on Halloween. I know I'm writing and sending you this in
July, but the spirit store that lives in my heart can no longer be contained in this withered
summer husk of a body any longer. I'm obsessed with you. I've never related to a sentence
more. Truly. In a small town on Japan's southern most and largest island, I hope I say this right,
Kaiyushi? Kaiyushu? I believe it's Kaiyushu. Yeah. I will leave out of the prefecture and town
as I still live here and don't want to cause any potential embarrassment for parties involved.
I will call it Goldfish Town because as the nickname may suggest, it is famous for breeding
around 30 different varieties of goldfish. Woo, woo, Goldfish Town because as the nickname may suggest, it is famous for breeding
around 30 different varieties of goldfish.
Woo-woo, Goldfish Town represent.
That's really cool and random.
That's awesome.
That's the funnest fact.
So a bit of background.
The first time I came to live in Japan, I was working as an ALT, Assistant Language Teacher.
I worked at two elementary schools and one middle school helping teach English in the
classroom.
In the classroom.
In the classroom. It was a wonderful experience and such a privilege working teach English in the classroom. In the classroom. In the classroom.
It was a wonderful experience and such a privilege working with the students and teachers.
Aw.
Goldfish Town always had two alts and we split the schools as there was a total of two middle
schools and four elementary schools. There was some quick maths for you ladies,
which I will not be doing again. The alt departments were literally right next to each other,
so me and the other alt, code name E,
were super besties. We always hung out, shared meals, had many a laps and a cries in each
other's apartment. She is still a bestie to this day. I ride or die, a ride or die bitch,
which you'll definitely see in this story. A final person to mention is our supervisor,
Nom de Plume, spelling French. I loved it. Nom de plume.
Okay. The sweetest woman alive and who we literally referred to as our Japanese mother.
She's super kind and friendly and always made sure we were looked after. Nom de plume.
Mama.
Okay. So let's get into the dirty deets. What happened on Halloween five nights ago?
Do tell.
Five years ago.
What happened on Halloween five nights ago?
Five nights ago. That makes no sense.
I just got white on my finger.
Oh no.
Halloween in Japan is more of an adult holiday.
Going out drinking, going to costume parties, which is fun, but we don't get little ghoulies
and goblins running up to our doors screaming for the sweets or else threatening tricks.
I kind of love that actually.
See, I want, I need the trick or treaters.
No, I love the trick or treaters, but I hate driving on Halloween night because I get so
nervous.
Yeah, I just won't.
Well, I have to.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Just won't.
Yeah.
Our apartments were on the second floor and buildings facing each other, a literal minute
walk and a lot of huffing upstairs.
This Halloween, we had both planned quiet evenings, me at home reading cozy mysteries
for my October mystery readathon, drinking cocoa, the nectar of fall and E at
the gym being a ripped goddess. So I love how different both of your things were. We
didn't have any plans to meet up that night. And other than E, anyone else coming to my
door is a big, it's going to be a no for me dog moment. Yes. Yes. Yeah. Our apartments
were around 20 years old, but thankfully had a modern doorbell system camera where there was some, when someone rang the doorbell, I could see who it was
on the screen in my kitchen. Foreshadowing. Well, that's cool. Quite handy for dodging
the Jehovah's Witnesses. Yes, they're out here. No shade, just as I said, I'm a millennial
hermit crab who wants to chill in her shell in peace. Oh, I feel that. I feel that. So
I'm home alone at the my kitchen table drinking cocoa, enjoying my book, feeling the Holy
Halloween spirit when the doorbell rings.
Knowing it's not E, I think maybe I was getting some trick or treaters, panicking that I
would have to share some of my time of the month, all the months, stash can't chocolate
with them.
But what I see freezes my blood.
On the screen is a person.
I can't tell the gender as their clothes are baggy.
And the fact that they are wearing a large paper mache, spelling French again, you did
great. Head. The head has painted on wide staring blue eyes, a small neutral mouth slightly
open and dark brown hair parted to the side. Very serial killer style. I hate it. Very
not cutesy cutesy. I stopped breathing because I'm afraid whatever's on the other side of the door will hear me. The doorbell rings
again and I can see the head move closer to the door cam like it's looking through the
peephole. Get the fuck off my property. I slowly slide over the table where I left my
phone. After grabbing it, I wait until my little door cam goes dark and I hear footsteps
or see down the stairs outside. I think I stood there for a good five minutes, my ears straining to hear anything, but feeling like the whole
world is silent and only I exist.
Oh, that's beautiful.
That is beautiful. You are a writer.
I run back to the screen to take a picture of the figure to send to E telling her not
to worry, I'm alive, but this thing was at my doorstep. And if she could come back from
the gym, I would love her forever. Like the true queen she is, she immediately called me saying there she'd be there in 15 minutes and to stay put
with a knife in hand. Next, I messaged our supervisor Kay the photo. Now I know, I know
at this point you guys are all screaming to call the police.
I was kind of thinking it in my head a little bit.
I was.
But I wasn't judging you yet.
I wasn't. But honestly, I didn't know what constituted an emergency in Japan.
Fair enough, fair enough.
And where my Japanese is conversational, how do I explain that a soul sucking paper machete
demon stood outside my door?
Valid.
Hard things.
Yeah. What happens when a hacker uncovers hundreds of murder plots targeting people all over
the world?
Each of them posted on a hitman for hire site on the dark web, with their photos, habits
and intimate details all used against them.
What happens when they learn that the threat is coming from the person closest to them?
Or what is the psychological profile of a father
who would murder his own son and wife
all to hide a drug addiction and years of embezzlement?
How do we understand the actions of the most complex and twisted minds?
From cases of serial killers, relationships turn dark
to manipulative scammers preying on the insecurities of regular people.
Wondry's Exhibit C is your partner in crime. Listen to the best of True Crime by following
Exhibit C on the Wondry app or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to hit True
Crime shows like Kill List and Killer Psyche early and ad-free right now by joining Wondry
Plus.
Kay also called immediately and said she and her husband were on their way over. Thankfully, they live five minutes away, so I didn't wait long to get a message saying they were coming up.
And I will never forget them coming up the stairs. If I hadn't been so scared at the time, I would have left.
Kay, my five foot tall supervisor, is running up the stairs calling for me, followed by
her six foot three husband, cigarette dangling cavalierly out of one side of his mouth, and
a golf club slung casually over his shoulder.
Fucking icon.
A king.
That's what you use a golf club for.
Not to scare little kids.
No.
To save people.
To protect a girl.
Yeah. Does anyone else smell a potential ghost hunting, demon slaying show pitch here?
Yes. I kind of do. Oh my God. I would make a great show. You should do that.
He's always got to have a cigarette or like a toothpick hanging out of his mouth.
Yes. Yes.
Anyway, back to the paper machete waking nightmare. I told them that I had no idea
who this person was and showed them the picture, which they agreed was really fucked up. By that time, E had returned home and also came roaring
up the stairs ready to slap this kindergarten craft project gone wrong. I assured her I
was okay and said she should check the door cam to see if they came to her door too. They
hadn't. Since she hadn't been visited by crafty killer TM, I spent the night at her
place. Over the next few weeks, I was on high alert. I
was always waiting to hear the doorbell ring and see that face again, but whoever it had
been never came back. And I eventually settled down a bit.
That's when they strike.
Fast forward to before Christmas. Ian and I were having a small Christmas party with
our goldfish town alt senpai, a term of respect used for a person who is usually older, more
experienced than you at life, job, et cetera. I like that. School, et cetera. Senpai, a term of respect used for a person who is usually older, more experienced than you at life, job, et cetera.
I like that.
Senpai.
V and her husband, H, that's who they were.
There was a period there.
V was the predecessor at my school, but she still lived in Goldfish Town and had met and
married her husband there too.
We had decided on doing a potluck dinner at our apartment and everyone arrived with plenty of yummies in tow.
Oh, love that.
Exactly. As long as you know the people.
If I know your kitchen, I'll eat it. If I haven't seen your kitchen, I'm not eating
it.
As we got to prepping, we were just chatting and catching up when E brings up the Halloween
incident about how creepy it was and how scared we had all been. After that, dinner was almost
ready and we were about to sit down when V's husband started whispering to her in Japanese.
I'm nervous.
I couldn't really hear what they were saying, but she then said louder in English, I'm sorry,
just say I'm sorry. By this point, E and I were blatantly dropping those Eves and asking
if everything was okay. When V's husband said, I'm sorry, on Halloween, that was me in the
mask.
Shut up. I love that it came up at a Christmas dinner.
And that he was like, I don't know.
And the wife was like, say sorry.
She was like, you fucking apologize.
Just say fucking sorry.
I was fucking dumbstruck, gobsmacked, flabbergasted, and other big shocked words. I couldn't fucking
believe it. It was you?
Why?
Why did you come here on Halloween wearing
that mask? H went on to tell me that he and V had made Halloween goodie bags and wanted
to give one to me and E. I love that it was like a good time thing.
It was so pure. And you were scared for months.
It was so pure. The reason he didn't show up to E's place was because he didn't know
which apartment she lived in. My apartment actually used to be V's old place in her alt days, so he was
hoping that I would tell him when I answered the door for my treat. But why that terrifying
DIY serial killer face? When a witch's hat or Dracula teeth would have gotten his trick
or treat intentions across just fine.
Honestly.
Apparently, the mask is from one of his favorite movies a movie called Frank starring Michael
Fassbender who plays our lead singer in a band and he wears the mask because he gives him the confidence to perform due to his mental health issues
I don't think I have ever I can ever see that movie because of how much the mask scares
the living shit out of me.
It is scary.
They attached a picture.
But you know what?
H said it's very moving.
It sounds like it would be.
I attached a picture of the mask from the movie, but H's was handmade, which somehow
made it more terrifying.
Yeah, that usually does happen.
Apparently H really wanted to participate in Halloween revelry and now there was, were
enough Americans to do it.
We all had a good laugh about it and honestly, I'm glad we could solve the Halloween mystery.
Sorry to pull the spoopy rug from under you ladies, but I hope it gave you some good
goosebumps and laughs. Thanks for reading my story and I hope you keep it weird,
but not so weird they make your own paper mache head from an obscure Michael Fassbender film
and try to drop off Halloween treats in a country that doesn't really celebrate Halloween, thus scaring the living shit out of you. Weird.
Oh my God.
Love you. Bye.
Also, I don't know if we can zoom, but this is the mask.
That would fuck me up.
That's so scary.
That would fuck me right up.
Yeah.
Right the fuck up.
Right the fuck up.
B, that was so good.
And picture that homemade.
No.
B, I would have been shitting my pants along with you. B, that was so good. And picture that homemade. No.
B, I would have been shit in my pants along with you.
B, I would have died.
I love that that's like a rock star's mask.
I love it.
And he's gotta figure out the band ghost.
Oh my God.
All right, last one, you guys.
Last one.
Last listener tale is, listener tale, Halloween.
Halloween.
The time my dad attacked my friends and I with a chainsaw.
Oh fuck. Yay. Oh, fuck. I didn't see that coming.
All right. Hey, spooky bachachos. I love bachachos. I used to say that all the time.
You did? Yes. I got to bring that back. I've been obsessed with you girls for years and I have yet
to find another podcast and podcasters I love as much as you. Thank you. We have a lot of great
network shows. I go back and re-listen to multiple episodes,
some because you cover them so well, some because they are hilarious. Carl. And most because I just
love the sound of your voices. My toddler calls you the ghost girls because he hears you talking
in the car, but he can't see you. That's adorable. I love that. When I discovered your podcast,
I came home and told my husband, I have found my spirit besties.
Oh, I love that.
Thank you.
We are your spirit besties.
And I made him listen to multiple episodes.
He looked at me and said, well, when are we moving?
Because he's supportive like that.
I love him.
I'm very much a mix of the two of you.
Ash, Stevie Nicks is also my fairy witchy godmother.
And Elena, I too hate the heat, love all things spooky and haunting and suffer from migraines,
bitches. Hell yeah, bitches.
Hell yeah.
I truly feel like I'm hanging out with you girls when I'm listening to your show and
it fills my social cup.
I love that.
Thank you.
Man, you really are meant to be our bestie.
You are because we don't really love, we don't have like-
My social cup is like a shock glass.
It's like so easy to fill.
Yeah.
All right.
So on to my story.
This is a story so many of my friends
know or friends of my friends know, and they still talk about it to this day and our old
age as we reminisce about our youthful shenanigans from early high school and even middle school
elder millennial. Well, what younger millennial not Gen Z. No offense. Gen Z still millennial.
So let me know. Like, isn't that what you're doing? No, it's Still millennial. So millennial. No.
Like, isn't that what you're technically?
No, it's just millennial.
It's just the younger years.
It might be a millennial.
So millennial is made up.
That's not a real generation.
Yeah, there you go.
I'm going to fight you.
Before we get into the details, I must give you some backstory on where the morbid, scary,
movie-loving, terror-chasing Halloween devotion comes from in my family.
My grandma, Marge.
Marge! I love that, Marge. My dad's mom was a huge horror fan and collected pretty much
everything she could horror themed, from stickers she put in sticker books to cups and even a
Chucky doll that moved on its own. Okay, Marge is awesome. Marge forever. Marge forever. Yes,
I shit you not and I have cousins to back me up on this, but that's for another time. That's
awesome. I saw some horror movies way too young, as this, but that's for another time. That's awesome.
I saw some horror movies way too young, as did a lot of my family members on my dad's
side.
He was one of five kids, so it's gotten pretty large with the kids having kids and then those
kids having kids.
And it has started many traditions.
Even though my grandma Marge passed away when I was still pretty young, I'm sorry, my family
attributes our love of the spooky spooky to her as it's trickled down our family line.
This is what you have to look forward to. Yes.
Side note, after she passed away, I for some reason wanted the Chucky doll. And my dad's
response was, well, don't come crying to me if it comes after you in the middle of
the night.
Your dad sounds awesome.
Needless to say, that five year old did not take the doll and now sits in my aunt's basement
in Atlanta. Now this spooky devotion hasn't stuck with every family member, but most of us share the love of Halloween and all the things that encompass that.
Now to the meat and potatoes and yams, wink wink, hush, of my story.
The yams!
We're on the yams. Growing up an only child, my dad was like, fuck that multiple sibling
shit. My parents always allowed me to have friends over, mainly because it kept me entertained
and out of their hair, but I digress. My parents' house became a spot that all of my friends knew they could come to over
the years, show up unannounced and just chat, have spur of the moment playdate or sleep
over, or even a large gathering of friends.
Oh, your parents are great.
I know, that's awesome.
Halloween was always hosted at my house and my parents went all out.
Yes.
Decorations, treats, so many pizzas, snacks, scary movies. Hello, Blockbuster, galore.
It was always a blast.
We would do haunted hay rides, spooky cave walks,
Trail of Terror, haunted houses, you name it.
They took me and truckloads of my friends to it.
Oh, I love them.
Best parents ever.
I can't wait to be a parent like that.
Oh, I can't wait.
One of these particular Halloween weekends
was when I was a freshman in high school.
A large group of my friends and I went to see the new Texas Chainsaw Massacre in theaters, followed by
multiple movies at my house with all the fixings. We rented, yes rented, the original Texas
Chainsaw movies amongst others and hunkered down in my parents' basement, lights off
of course, and got cozy. Now picture it. One of those huge comfy couches and giant chairs
that could fit like
four people on it and even more people on the floor. And I'm sitting on the end of
the couch closest to the wall and tiny window that peeks outside. After a while, I thought
I heard something outside and asked, did anybody else hear that? Of course, they all said no.
It was probably just the movie since we were watching a chainsaw movie and I thought I
heard a chainsaw. Duh, that'll do it. I just shook my head, thought I was hearing things and kept watching the movie.
A few more minutes later, I heard the noise again,
but it was very clearly not the movie.
And my head snapped to the tiny window above my head
where I could tell it was now pitch black outside so I couldn't see anything.
So I said, seriously, you guys didn't hear that?
And they said, no, Adrian, you're dumb and you're trying to scare us.
There's nothing there. Third time's the charm. A few more minutes later, I heard this whirring noise again. And this
time my bestie, Elise, also heard it. At this point, we paused the movie and all anxiously
awaited to hear the sound again. Nothing came. Quick side note, earlier in the evening, my friends
and I were talking about the shit that always happens in scary movies, like let's split up or
let's hook up or let's go investigate. All the classics, right? Yeah. So my buddy Alex jokingly said, let's go investigate.
And we all ran up the stairs that led right out the back door to our driveway and backyard.
Keep in mind, there are at least 10 of us, if not more. And Elise and I are the last
ones out the door. It's pitch black and incredibly quiet. And we immediately regretted
this decision as they do in the movies. Of course. Our backyard was wide open to the other
yards. Snow fences and the driveway wrapped around the house with lights on the side that
were currently off. As Alex and a couple other brave dudes walked slowly around to look down
the driveway, slam goes the back door behind me and click goes the lock. Moments later,
the lights on the side of the house switch on, and in the driveway is a giant six foot four man with a mask and a chainsaw slowly hobbling towards us, ready
to tear us all apart in the calmest manner.
I'm obsessed with this.
It was as if a small drip of water landed among ants as we all went in different directions.
Some screamed and ran through other backyards, some frozen terror.
And some of us, like Elise and I, tried to frantically get back in the house,
but it was locked.
I love that you discovered in that moment
who everyone was in the horror movie.
Like you can, the debate is done.
You know who, like it's no longer like,
oh, you would be the person who does this in the horror movie.
Like, nope, you would be the person
who runs in the next yard.
I would run into the next yard.
That's your best bet.
As we were all trying not to pee our pants
and vomit the insane amount of junk food we consumed
and many of us had dispersed, the man takes the mask off and with a giant grin,
my dad starts laughing hysterically. Your dad. Forever. Your dad. I'm obsessed. I love him.
My heart starts to slow a smidge as my mother unlocks the back door and is also laughing
hysterically. Yes! Both very, very proud that their plan was so successful. My heart starts to slow a smidge as my mother unlocks the back door and is also laughing
hysterically, both very, very proud that their plan was so successful.
As they should be.
Your parents for fucking ever.
Elite.
That is couple goals.
That is top notch marriage and top notch parenting as far as I'm concerned.
I'm so, so obsessed with that.
Wow.
My brother did this.
To your ex and my ex-boyfriend after watching Texas Chainsaw Massacre, actually.
Incredible. Yeah.
It took a bit for all my friends to gather back up at my house, as you can imagine.
One of the guys lived on the block behind me, so he literally just went home.
He ran home.
To resume our evening. But it was safe to say my dad set a precedent that night,
and it was one that none of us have ever forgotten. My dad, known as Big Wave
around town, is always someone people remember and recognize, and this just solidified his
legacy. Now that I have kids of my own, I have some goals to reach, and at some point,
I have to top this.
LS. You got to.
KS. I'm still friends with several of the people from that night, and we all like to
talk about it and tell the story to relive the trauma of my dad scaring us shitless to
this day. Even those that weren't there know this story and now know who Big Wave is.
KS & BG Big Wave for fucking life.
KS & BG Big Wave. Big Wave. Big Wave.
KS & BG Anyways, that's my tale. I hope you enjoyed it.
KS & BG We did.
KS & BG We did.
KS & BG And I hope Big Wave gave you something new to aspire to.
KS & BG Love you, witches.
KS & BG Big Wave is my new goalpost.
KS & BG Big Wave. Big wave, honey. Five ever.
Big wave for life. Big wave. Guys, those were awesome. Oh my God. That was so much fun.
What a beautiful mix of terrifying, hilarious, and so touching. I'm so glad that we got
to get all dressed up and hang out with you guys. And we're definitely going to do this
again because this is just too fun.
It's too fun to read these tales.
I love this as other people.
I'm already thinking about what I'm going to be.
Me too. I'm already thinking about it.
So hopefully this is the beginning of something fun.
And we hope you guys liked it.
And you know what?
We hope you keep listening.
And we hope you keep it weird.
But not so weird that you don't throw ass with the shadow man,
because why wouldn't you throw ass with the shadow man? Not so weird that actually do But not so weird that you don't throw ass with the shadow man because why wouldn't you
throw ass with the shadow man? Not so weird that actually do keep it so weird that you have a
ghostly ex boyfriend who like talks to you through a New Orleans psychic because that was the most
beautiful thing I think I've ever heard in my life. Don't keep it so weird that you show up to
somebody's door with a paper mache mask on to give them keep it so weird they're gonna give them a
treat but like don't keep it so weird that you don't tell them who you are because that was so scary.
Keep it so weird, don't ever keep it so weird
that you're following little girls on Halloween night
and trying to scare them.
Fuck that, I'll kill you.
And always keep it so weird that you're on big waves level.
Never ever sink below big waves level.
Big wave, big wave, big wave, big wave.
Eh.
Happy Halloween!
We love you! I hope that was caught on film.
We gotta start the fucking episode like that.
Did you just hear her stomach?
It literally-
Yes. It sounded like a lava lamp.
The fuck?
If you like morbid, you can listen early and ad-free right now by joining Wondery Plus
in the Wondery app or on Apple podcasts. Prime members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music.
Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at Wondery.com slash survey.
So tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at wondery.com slash survey. In the upcoming episode of Killer Psyche, we will be diving deep into the unfolding
case of accused Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuerman.
Heuerman is awaiting trial for the murder of three women, with many more victims still
being linked to him.
Now a recently released tell-all bail application
goes into unusual details and lengths to keep him locked away,
revealing shocking updates about the case.
Listen as we take a closer look into the newly revealed evidence and charges,
bringing new insight into what we already know about the case
and what may have motivated him.
Follow Killer Psyche on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcast.
You can listen to Killer Psyche and more Exhibit C true crime shows like
Morbid and The Kill List early and ad free right now by joining Wondery Plus.
Check out Exhibit C in the Wondery app for all your true crime listening.