Murder In America - EP. 69 PENNSYLVANIA - PHILADELPHIA: Murder City
Episode Date: June 20, 2022In today's episode, we tell the story of Gary Heidnik, one of Philadelphia's most infamous serial killers, the gruesome tale of the "Frankford Slasher" and examine a recent mass shooting in detail. Ph...iladelphia is a great city, but it's also one stained by a dark and disturbing past. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
This week's episode is sponsored by Hocum, the new film that critics are calling Damian McCarthy's most unnerving horror yet.
From the director of Oddity, Hocom stars Adam Scott, in a deeply monstrous horror that bloody disgusting called pure nightmare fuel that holds you firmly in its grip.
Don't miss Hocom, the groundbreaking new horror from Damian McCarthy, now playing in theaters.
I really love to get dressed up every once in a while when I'm going out with my girlfriends or on a date night with Colin.
But lately I've been trying to be more intentional with my everyday wear.
And I've found that the best options that work for me are good quality, effortless pieces that will last me forever and they still look cute.
Which is why Quince has always been my go-to.
The thing I love about Quince is that all of their fabrics feel elevated.
Their clothing always fits me perfectly, and I can just throw on anything from theirs, and it looks so put together, but it's so effortless.
Now that the spring season is upon us, Quince makes it so easy to refresh your wardrobe with spring pieces that feel as good as they look.
I love that they always use premium materials like 100% European linen, organic cotton, and ultra-soft denim.
And everything at Quince is priced 50 to 80% less than similar.
brands. They also work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen, so you're paying
for quality and craftsmanship, not the brand markup. I recently have been on the hunt for a good
denim skirt, and so I went to Quince and I ordered their stretched denim miniskirt, and I am
absolutely obsessed with it. It is so cute, I've already worn it several times. I have made a ton of
different outfits with it, and I could not believe the price of it. I actually had to go
back and double check it because it is such good quality, I could not believe how affordable it was.
But that's been my experience with everything I've gotten from Quince. They are so affordable
and their items are amazing. And I know you will love them too. So refresh your everyday with
luxury that you'll actually use. Head to quince.com slash America for free shipping on your order
and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E-D-E-D-R-E.com.
This website.com for free shipping and 365-day returns.
This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp.
Life is a journey.
I know this.
I think we all know this.
Some days feel good and other days feel absolutely overwhelming.
Whatever's keeping you up at night, it's easy sometimes to feel like you have to figure
it all out on your own.
But the truth is, nobody has all the answers.
And no journey should be taken alone.
However, having someone with you to listen, to understand, and to support.
you can make all the difference. I know that I'm a huge therapy advocate I've advocated for therapy
for years, and if you want to give therapy a try, BetterHelp is a great place to start. BetterHelp
therapists work according to a strict code of conduct and are fully licensed in the U.S.
BetterHelp also does the initial matching work for you so you can focus on your therapy goals.
A short questionnaire helps identify your needs and preferences, and their 12 plus years of experience
and industry leading match fulfillment rate means they typically get it right the first time.
And something that I love is if you aren't happy with your therapist match, you can switch to a different therapist at any time from their tailored recommendations.
I've personally used BetterHelp in the past, and I think that if you're on the edge, if you're thinking, maybe it's time to start therapy, I say just go ahead and do it.
There's literally no downside, because you don't have to be on this journey alone.
Find support and have someone with you in therapy.
Sign up and get 10% off at BetterHelp.com slash MIA.
That's BetterHELP.com slash MIA.
The following podcast is not suitable for all audiences.
We go into great detail with every case that we cover
and do our best to bring viewers even deeper into the stories
by utilizing disturbing audio and sound effects.
Trigger warnings from the stories we cover
may include violence, rape, murder, and offenses against children.
This podcast is not for everyone.
You have been warned.
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
It's one of the oldest cities in the United States of America.
It's a city known for its founding fathers,
beer and brotherly love. And if you don't know, Philadelphia is actually where the Declaration
of Independence was signed, the document that began the formation of the United States. But after
being such a notable historical city for so many years, Philadelphia seemingly descended into
madness. Nowadays, it's known as one of the deadliest cities in America. As it saw over 560 murders
in the year 2021, a number of murders only topped by the city of Chicago, Illinois, which recorded
nearly 800 murders in the same year. So today, let's take a look into some of the most
infamous crimes that have rocked this city. Let's take a deep dive into the dark side of Philadelphia.
I'm Colin Brown, and you're listening to Murder in America. So living in Philadelphia is awesome.
I have to say the city has character. Now, Courtney and
and I moved to Philadelphia just a couple of weeks ago. Actually, we're about to hit our two-week mark.
It's been an amazing journey. We've had so many amazing experiences so far just within the first
couple of weeks. We went to a Phillies game the other night. We had so much fun cheering for the Phillies.
It was a great experience. We had hot dogs and drinks, and it was great. Courtney and I have tried so
many great food places. We've biked around the city with our bikes. We've had, honestly, an amazing time.
tell you all online. Philadelphia is by far one of my favorite cities in America and it's truly got
its own energy. But that's what I love about it. Philadelphia is a city in its own. You know,
there's nothing like Philly. And that's why we wanted to move here because it's got its own character.
It's got its own energy and we love it. Courtney, what do you, I mean, after this week,
have to say about living in Philly? I have absolutely loved Philadelphia.
I'm not going to lie, I was a little nervous at first coming here just because I've never lived anywhere other than Texas.
And I actually had never even been on the East Coast besides New York.
So I didn't really know what to expect.
But it definitely has exceeded all of my expectations.
The area that we live in is so cute.
There's a ton of things to do, great restaurants.
And yeah, we've really, really enjoyed it.
But even though Philadelphia is one hell of a city that so many people call home, it's extremely
violent. Last year, in 2021, Philadelphia saw over 500 murders, the highest amount of murders
the city has seen since the year 1990. So something is happening here, but what's shocking
is that a substantial number of these murders go unsolved. There are no convictions, there's no justice.
The killers are allowed to almost roam free. Even living,
here for just a few weeks, we've seen how crippling the crime in the city can be. First, there was
the mass shooting that occurred at a popular hangout spot, South Street, just a stones throw away from
where Courtney and I live now. South Street truly is your average all-American road. It's a part of the
city filled with bars, music venues, cheese steak shops, and stores. One would never expect that it would be
a venue for such shocking violence, but just a few weeks ago. On June 4, 2022, it was. That night,
hundreds of people filled the sidewalks and roads on South Street, drinking, celebrating,
enjoying their weekend. It was a Saturday, a night of the week where people head out,
dress up, and get down. But that night would take a drastically dark turn when two friends
named Rishon Vareen and Gregory Jackson took a walk down South Street. At around 11.30 p.m. that
evening, Rishan and Gregory passed by somebody that they seemed to know, a man named Micah Towns.
As they passed Mika, Gregory and Rishon began to engage him physically.
and after a short period of fistfighting, Gregory Jackson pulled out a pistol and shot Micah Towns.
Now, Gregory Jackson and Micah Towns both actually had permits to carry.
So after being shot, Micah pulled out his weapon and began returning fire.
Here's some audio from the shooting. Warning, this is graphic.
In total, 17 shots were fired during this initial fight.
When this occurred, three other men named Quedere Dukes Hill, Najee Whittington, and Karan
Garner, who knew the three that were fighting, pulled out their own weapons and began firing as well.
Immediately within moments, South Street was plunged into utter chaos.
Eleven people were injured that night, victims who ranged from teenage girls to older men,
and three people died.
Gregory Jackson, one of the men who seemingly initiated the argument, passed away from
his injuries that night, along with two innocent bystanders who were out on South Street
enjoying their weekend.
The other two victims of the shooting were a man.
named Chris Minners, a 22-year-old who worked as an advisor for second and sixth-grade boys
at one of Philly's oldest educational institutions, who was out that night celebrating his
birthday, and 24-year-old Alexis Quinn, a health aide who loved to help others. It took a while
for authorities to apprehend the suspects behind the shooting, but there are currently two people
in custody and two men who have had charges filed against them. It's also come out in the news
that one of the guns used in the mass shooting was a ghost gun. A ghost gun is a
essentially a weapon that you can build at home. You don't need a background check to purchase the
parts. A miner can purchase one. They're completely untraceable as they don't come with serial numbers.
And if you have the proper parts, you can build a functional ghost gun in just under an hour.
And a ghost gun works exactly like a real gun that you'd buy to shop.
According to bradyunited.org, a ghost gun is defined as a weapon that is constructed by individuals
using unfinished frames or receivers, the piece of the firearm that contains the operating parts of
the firing mechanism, and which are the part of the gun regulated under federal law.
However, when a frame or receiver is unfinished by a small fraction, it is unregulated.
Ghost gun kits include all the necessary component parts to turn the unfinished frame or receiver
into a fully functioning gun, which, once assembled, looks, feels, and functions like a traditional
gun.
whether a handgun or assault weapon and is just as deadly and dangerous in the wrong hands.
If you don't think ghost guns are a problem, let's just take a look at the statistics.
In 2017, three ghost guns were recovered by law enforcement in the District of Columbia.
In 2018, 25 ghost guns were recovered in the same area.
In 2019, 116 ghost guns were recovered, and at least three of these guns were eventually connected to homicides.
Just two months into 2020, 38 ghost guns had already been recovered,
which suggests that over 220 ghost guns were recovered in total in 2020.
This is a shocking and staggering statistic.
And no matter your stance on gun control issues,
I think we can all agree that having weapons out on the street
that are completely untraceable and require no background check
and have no age limit are dangerous.
The study that I just read to you was from the year 2020.
And if you think that this ghost gun problem
is limited to just one part of the U.S., well, you're dead wrong.
Let's take a look at Philadelphia, for example.
In 2019, the Philly PD seized 95 ghost guns.
In 2020, the same department seized over 250 guns, over doubled the amount from 2019.
And in 2021, there were 570 ghost guns taken off the streets.
This means that every single year, the amount of these dangerous, unregulated, and
and untraceable murder weapons is doubling in major cities, and this is a big problem.
But the shooting on South Street just a few weeks ago was just the tip of the iceberg here in Philly.
Just that weekend from Friday, June 3rd, 2022 to Saturday, June 4th, 2022.
There were 10 different shootings in the city, 10 shootings, almost overnight.
And as is the case with most shootings in big cities, most of the perpetrators of those crimes have yet to be brought.
to justice. It's absolutely insane. I mean, when you think about it, Philly saw over 560 murders in
2021. That's on some days, two or more murders a day. Of course, the police aren't going to be able to
solve all these cases. How could they? There are just too many victims, too many crimes,
too many injustices that happen daily for a large magnifying glass to be applied to all.
And not all of these murders are strictly related to gun violence. Take, for example,
the double homicide that occurred in Philly in May of this year.
I'm going to read to you an article from News Station NBC10 in Philadelphia, written by contributor
David Chang, published on May 18, 2022.
Investigation is underway after the decomposed Kensington neighbors and paramedics responded to a call
reporting two bodies inside a property along the 3,000 block of North Ruth Street, shortly after
7 p.m. Police and medics entered through the back of the home and found a man and woman lying
next to each other inside a bedroom on the second floor. Police said both victims had large
lacerations on their necks. They were both pronounced dead at the scene at 7.26 p.m. It appears both of
them had their throat slit, Philadelphia Police Chief Inspector Scott Small said,
the two victims have not yet been identified, but both appeared to be in their 30s or 40s,
according to Small. Police also found a bag of clothing that may have belonged to the woman.
Investigators said both victims appeared to have been dead for at least one day. These
bodies have been here longer than one day because he also found surferred someone entering or exiting
this problem investigators also discover individuals to use the drugs do drugs drug paraphernalia
almost a full month later and there are no developments in that case i couldn't even find an article
that discussed who these two people were that were found murdered it seems that the police have yet to
even identify the victims this means eerily enough that there are killers here in philadelphia that still
roam these streets nightly. Whether they use guns, knives, or other weapons, these people are still
killers. And the city is so overworked, so overcrowded, that it appears that even identifying
victims and crimes can sometimes be a lengthy process. But this violence is definitely not only related
to the modern era. Let's go back in time for a second, to Philadelphia in the 1980s, when serial
killers roamed these very streets. And we're going to tell you the story of one of the most
depraved killers in Pennsylvania history, who committed his string of crimes right here in Philly.
But first, let's take a commercial break. So Courtney and I love Audible. With our schedule and how
we're always on the go, seriously, I'm leaving for New York City today. We've been in Philly two weeks.
We don't have a lot of time to do the things that we want to do, like reading or listening to
podcasts, and that's why we love Audible.
Audible offers an incredible selection of audiobooks across every genre,
from bestsellers and new releases to mysteries and thrillers, motivation, wellness, business, and more.
And you'll discover exclusive Audible originals from top celebrities, renowned experts, and exciting new voices in audio.
As an Audible member, you can choose one title a month to keep from their entire catalog,
including the latest bestsellers and new releases,
and all Audible members get access to a growing selection of audiobooks, audible originals,
and podcasts that are included with membership.
You can listen to all you want and more get added every month.
So I love listening to Audible on airplanes.
That's like my biggest thing.
I will download a couple podcasts and audiobook.
And when I'm on the plane, it's offline.
And I can just sit back, relax, and listen.
It's so easy.
It's so easy to download the books.
And they have so many amazing books.
Audible is truly the way to go if you love audio entertainment.
So let Audible help you discover new ways to laugh, be inspired or entertained.
New members can try it free for 30 days.
Just visit audible.com slash state or text state to 500-500-500.
That's audible.com slash state or text state to 500-500 to try audible free for 30 days.
Audible.com slash state.
It's a great service.
You know, we love it.
And yeah, go check out audible.
You're missing out.
Let's get back to today's story.
If you're a true crime fan, then you probably already know that the next.
1980s was a very dark time here in the United States. There was a lot of murder and depravity,
and that was definitely the case here in Philadelphia. Back then, this city was a lot different.
And after moving here, we wanted to take a look at Philadelphia's history and some of the infamous
murders that took place along these streets. There are a number of stories we could tell you about,
but we put together some murders that stood out to us.
The first was a man named Gary Heidnick,
who was easily one of the most infamous killers in the history of Philadelphia.
Gary was born on November 22, 1943, in East Lake, Ohio.
And from the start, his life wasn't great.
First of all, Gary suffered from a lifelong problem of bedwetting.
According to Gary himself, when he was younger,
and he would accidentally wet the bed, his father would get really angry.
And instead of helping him, he would make Gary hang his wet bed sheets from his bedroom window.
This was humiliating because the entire neighborhood was then able to see that he wet the bed.
And this wouldn't just happen in his childhood.
Gary would continue to wet the bed throughout his adult years.
And as you probably know by now, bed wedding is usually an early.
indication of psychopathy. When Gary was younger, he was very standoffish with other kids
in his grade, and he may have come off as rude to a lot of people. At one point, a girl in
Gary's grade asked him if he had completed the homework that was assigned by their teacher
the day before. But instead of answering her question calmly, Gary was insulted. He turned to the
girl, yelled at her, and stated that she wasn't worthy enough to talk to him.
And although most people that met Gary thought he was rude and unsociable, he was actually a very, very smart guy.
Some would even call him a genius.
Gary had an IQ of 148, with the average IQ in the United States only being 98.
And this IQ would help him while he committed his crimes later in life.
At the age of 17, Gary decided to join the United States Army, and he served there.
for 13 months. However, although he was graded an excellent cadet by his drill sergeant,
Gary was rejected from all of the positions within the army that he applied to and was eventually
diagnosed with gastroindinitis and mental illness. After serving for a while, Gary was transferred
to a military hospital here in Philadelphia, and it was at this hospital where he was diagnosed
with schizoid personality disorder.
This diagnosis came with an honorable discharge from the military.
After his time serving in the armed forces, Gary became a licensed nurse.
He also attended college and worked at a hospital.
But his rude behavior and general apathy towards patients he was working with
eventually got him fired from his position at the hospital.
In the year 1970, Gary's mother, after being done,
diagnosed with bone cancer, committed suicide by drinking chloride with mercury.
In just a year later, in 1971, Gary founded and incorporated his own church, which he
called the United Church of Ministers of God, a church which he ran out of his own house.
Gary began this church with a deposit of $1,500.
But eventually, his church had earned over $5,000.000.
which would be worth over $1.3 million today.
The church was doing really well.
Gary had found a way to cope with the death of his mother,
and he seemed to be happier on the outside.
But deep within, he was suffering.
During this time, Gary had a son with a woman named Gail Lincao.
His son's name was Gary Jr.,
but he never really seemed to care about his son and he never visited him.
visited him. He also had a daughter with a woman named Anne Jeanette Davidson, who was mentally
disabled and severely illiterate. But just like with all of his other relationships in life,
Gary's relationship with Anne Jeanette was far from perfect. In fact, this relationship specifically
was atrocious. You see, shortly after the birth of their daughter, Gary was arrested on a very serious and very
personal charge. Apparently, Gary had kidnapped Ann Jeanette's own sister, Alberta, from the
mental asylum which she called home. And after the abduction, he had raped her. Now, usually the
news of a pastor abducting and raping a child is shocking for most people. But it wasn't very shocking
for Gary's friends and family. For years, he had been living above the law. And this certainly wasn't
his first encounter with the police. In 1976, Gary was slapped with his first legal charge
after he apparently shot a tenant who was renting a house that he had put on the market.
The bullet had grazed the tenant's face, and Gary was charged with carrying an unlicensed
pistol and aggravated assault. Then, two years later, in 1978, Gary was arrested for the
abduction and rape of Alberta Davidson. When he committed the crime, Gary had visited Alberta
in the Penn Township Mental Institution, and he was able to sign her out because he was a trusted
family member. But after he took her from the institution, Gary brought Alberta into his home
and he locked her into a storage room in his basement. During her captivity, Alberta was sodomized,
raped, and she contracted gonorrhea from Gary. Now eventually, authorities found Alberta and Gary was arrested.
After his sentencing, he spent three years in various mental hospitals. But before his eventual arrest
in 1987, Gary attempted suicide at least 13 different times. Some of those suicide attempts took place
in the mental hospitals, where he was confined during his life.
sentence for the horrific crimes against Alberta. It should be noted that Gary's brother Terry
also spent some time in mental hospitals during his life. We're going to come back to this story
right after this commercial break. Aren't you tired of going to the mall and trying on 50 different
bras but none of them fit? I have a ton of small chested friends who are constantly having this
problem. Traditional bras usually have cup gaps or are stuffed with unknown.
natural padding because industry standards are designed for 36 C bras.
But Pepper bras are specifically designed for double A to B cups.
So our smaller chested women no longer have to struggle to find a bra that fits.
Customers everywhere love Pepper.
It's the bra that sold out 15 times last year.
In total, Pepper has sold over 1 million bras.
Their mission is to inspire women to embrace the flat and
flattering with bras that celebrate your body exactly as it is. No more cup gaps and no more unnatural
padding to make you look two sizes bigger. Now we are all about body positivity and I love this brand
because they are celebrating women that struggle finding a bra that fits them and there's nothing more
annoying than trying to find something and it just doesn't work. So that's why we love pepper
because they're inclusive and we love that. Get 20% off your first order.
when you go to wearpepper.com slash murder.
That's W-E-A-R-pepper.com slash murder.
To get 20% off your first order, go check it out, guys, a great company, and you will absolutely love it.
Now back to our show.
Years after founding his church, Gary joined a matrimonial service, which matched up willing brides with eager potential husbands.
And to Gary's surprise, he met a woman named Betty Didso from the Philippines.
According to him, it was love at first sight, and both Gary and Betty were smitten.
Eventually, Betty made the long voyage over from the Philippines to the United States,
and she married Gary in Philadelphia, but it wouldn't take long for the marriage to deteriorate.
The two had only been married for a few weeks before Betty was.
caught on to Gary's deep deceptions and violent abusive behavior. She would eventually file for divorce.
And afterwards, she claimed that Gary physically assaulted and raped her throughout their entire
relationship. She also stated that at one point she caught him in bed with three different women.
Betty also said that Gary used to force her to watch while he had sex with other girls.
And eventually, with the support of the Filipino community, Betty left Gary and headed back to the Philippines.
Unbeknownst to Gary, however, he had impregnated Betty, and she gave birth to his son.
Gary was angry, to say the least.
And it made him even more angry because the only reason he found out about the child was when he received a request for child support payments.
And it was here, shortly after their marriage fell apart, when Gary began his blood-soaked crime spree.
In November of 1986, Gary kidnapped a woman named Josephina Rivera.
After kidnapping Josephina, he brought her back to his house, which was the church headquarters.
And it was there where he kept her chained up in a pitch-black pit in his basement.
But this one victim wasn't enough.
Just one month later, Gary kidnapped another four women from the North Philadelphia area,
and he locked them all up in his basement.
After they were all chained up and secured, Gary then proceeded to torture, rape, and beat
the women mercilessly for months.
One of the girls named Sandra Lindsay, who had been captured by Gary, eventually died
due to a combination of injuries related to her torture, starvation, and a high fever.
After Sandra died, Gary proceeded to dismember her corpse,
and after encountering some problems with dismantling her arms and legs,
he stored her extremities in his freezer and put a label on the body parts that read dog food.
According to Gary, after chopping up her body,
he boiled Sandra's head in a pod on his stove.
and he roasted her ribs in his oven.
While he was cooking Sandra's body parts,
neighbors who live nearby complained to the police
about a rancid odor emanating from 3520 North Marshall Street,
Gary's address.
But the police would never go searching the home that day,
and they had no idea that four women were chained up
and dying of torture and starvation.
And that's because Gary had an excellent explanation,
for the police as to why his home smelled so rotten that afternoon.
I'm cooking a roast, he stated.
I fell asleep and it burnt.
Several victims of Gary's crimes later stated that he had ground up some of the unused parts
of Sandra's body, and he mixed the shredded human flesh with his dog food and served it
to his other victims. So allegedly, he forced the women who were in prison to eat
some of their fellow captives, corpse. In addition to the rape and physical beatings and starvation,
Gary also electro-shocked his captives. In fact, electric shock was his preferred form of torture.
On one particular day, Gary forced three of the women he was holding captive into a pit that
he had dug in the basement. He then ordered the women to fill the hole with water. It was dark
and musty down there.
There was barely any light in the basement, so the women truly had no idea what was to come.
Eventually, after the pit was filled with water, the three victims were soaking wet, and
Gary pulled out an extension cord that he had stripped and exposed himself.
He then demanded one of the victims, Josephina, aid him in shocking the other girls.
And having no other choice, Josephina held the wiring onto the chain.
wrapped around the naked women who were sitting in the water pit.
She watched in horror as her fellow prisoners were shocked.
Screams filled the air, water splashed everywhere,
and smoke filled the room from the victim's bodies.
After all was said and done, one of the captives,
a woman named Deborah Dudley was dead,
and soon after Gary loaded her body into his vehicle
and took a midnight drive to dispose of her corpse in the nearby Pine Barrens in New Jersey.
Shortly after the deaths of his two victims, on January 18, 1987, Gary abducted another woman named Jacqueline Askins.
Jacqueline was the youngest of the captives at just 18 years old.
And years later, when interviewed for a news report in Philadelphia, she stated that while she was held hard,
hostage, Gary had violently wrapped duct tape around the mouths of all of his victims while in the basement,
and he would frequently stab them at random and their ears with a sharp screwdriver.
Gary liked the power. He enjoyed the control that he had over these women, and for a man who was a self-proclaimed minister and messenger of God,
he wasn't exactly carrying out God's work while committing his crimes.
It was now March of 1987.
Gary had successfully hidden from the police four months,
and he was hungry for another victim,
and it wouldn't be long until he found her.
Her name was Agnes Adams,
but this time Gary was sloppy.
The day after abducting Agnes
and forcing her into his basement of horrors with the other victims,
Gary allowed her to leave, to visit her.
her family. Interestingly enough, after Agnes told him that her family would be worried about her
disappearance, Gary decided to drive her to a nearby gas station. He told her he would wait there
while she went and talked to her family for a little bit, but she had to come right back.
Agnes obviously agrees to these conditions. But instead of going to her family's house,
She immediately walks over to her boyfriends and tells him about what she had gone through.
Her boyfriend wanted to initially confront Gary for his actions, but he ultimately decided to call the police.
The officers quickly rushed over to Agnes's boyfriend's house, and it was there when they saw the chains around her legs.
Agnes quickly told the police that she was kidnapped and that her captor was waiting at the gas station for her.
The police quickly made their way over and placed Gary Hydenick under arrest.
During his trial, Gary attempted to plead insanity, but it didn't work.
He was declared mentally competent and was subsequently sentenced to death.
On July 6, 1999, the night before his death, Gary enjoyed his last meal,
which consisted of two cups of coffee and two slices of cheese pizza.
And the next morning, July 7th, he was put to death by lethal injection,
and his body was cremated.
Gary Heidnick was the last person executed by the state of Pennsylvania,
and his dark legacy continues to haunt the city of Philadelphia to this day.
But there's still one more killer we want to discuss,
someone who we believe has never been brought to justice.
But first, we're going to take a quick commercial break.
Now, I have a personal connection to this company because gem multivitamins is absolutely amazing.
And I actually set my mom up with gem multivitamins.
She ordered them and she texted me freaking out how she loved them so much,
how good they taste, how good they've made her feel.
So this company we believe in and we truly love them.
and I love the product.
So, I mean, I've taken vitamins before
and I haven't gotten much out of them.
But that's why I love Gem,
because it's finally vitamins that are real food.
And Gem is the first real food, whole food, multivitamin.
Gem Daily Essentials come in bite-sized cubes
and provide a comprehensive blend of over 15 superfoods,
botanicals, probiotics, vitamins, minerals,
and more concentrated in one tasty bite.
The Gem Bite is your first true non-synthetic multivitamin alternative,
featuring only plant ingredients,
and delivering over 15 key vitamins, minerals, and herbs for energy, mood, focus, and beauty.
It's your daily nutrition and one delicious bite.
So what we love about Gem is that it's not synthetic.
It's real food that's absorbed into your body for maximum bioavailability, and it fills
the nutritional gaps in your diet.
And Gem is delicious.
There are so many amazing flavors, like I said, my mom loves the taste of Gem, so I'm
sure everyone online will, too, just like Courtney and I have.
And if you want to try it out, you can get 30% off your first order.
you go to DailyGem.co.
That's DailyGem.com slash murder to get 30% off your first order.
Once again, that's daily gem.com slash murder.
Now, let's get back to the story.
So with my YouTube channel, the paranormal files, everyone online probably knows that, you know,
I like to focus on stories that need justice.
We've covered stories of lynchings that were never recorded.
I've started petitions to.
try to get monuments erected for people who were victims of racial injustice.
And with the Texas killing fields, we tried to look deeper into the story, to investigate
out there at the killing fields to see if some of that energy is still there.
And now I'm not claiming in any way here that every murder scene is haunted.
It's not like that.
I think that there's an energy that gets left behind from these horrible crimes, and that's
really what it is.
But that brings me to a story that I am dying to cover here in Philadelphia,
a story that I think has left stains all across the city, the Frankfurt Slasher.
Now, back in the early 2010s, there was a serial killer in Philadelphia named the Kensington Strangler.
That's an interesting story, but that's not who we're talking about here.
Back in the late 1980s, at the exact same time that Gary Heidnick was abducting and torturing women,
another serial killer was haunting Philadelphia.
This guy was much more proficient, much more prolific,
and was more highly skilled with what he was doing,
and he most likely got away with all of his crimes.
It was 1985 in the neighborhood of Frankfurt Philadelphia.
At the time, Frankfurt was an area ridden with crime.
Small businesses in this community were struggling to survive.
Bars were raking in dough,
and prostitution and drug sales were spiking in the area.
In fact, Sylvester Stallone,
reportedly chose Frankfurt as the setting for his film Rocky because it was at the time
such a rough area that he could rise above. And things in Frankfurt weren't getting any better
from here. August 26, 1985, the body of a 52-year-old woman named Helen Patton is discovered in an
empty trail yard. It had been a beautiful day that morning. Transit workers at a septa train yard
in the city of Philadelphia had been starting their day, drinking their early morning
coffee when they stumbled upon the corpse. Helen had been beaten, raped, and mutilated. And after being
sexually assaulted and stabbed 47 times, the killer had pulled Helen's blouse up to expose her breasts,
had spread her legs apart to expose her genitalia, and had practically cut her inner organs out
from her body. A massive slash on her abdomen had literally exposed her intestines and other organs
to the elements. It was a grotesque scene.
And this was just the beginning of the Frankfurt slasher's disturbed reign of terror on this part of the city.
No arrests were made in connection to the murder of Helen Patton.
And for months, people in Frankfurt were left to wonder,
was this a one-off act of violence?
Or was there a predator out there in the shadows,
waiting for another victim to cross their unlucky path?
Unfortunately, just a few short months later,
the people of Frankfurt's questions would be answered.
January 3, 1986, Anna Carroll, a 68-year-old woman from South Philadelphia, is found murdered
inside of her own home. Although she had only been stabbed six times as opposed to the
47 stab wounds that Helen suffered, Anna was also found nude below the waist, with her blouse
pulled up to expose her breasts. Her corpse was also posed in a lewd position, and her abdomen
had been stabbed and sliced from her breastbone to her pubis, exposing once again her organs.
Like Helen, Anna was also a well-known patron of the bars and establishments on Frankfurt Avenue.
Two murders in just a few months, with the same M.O.
There has to be a killer on the loose, right?
Well, the Philly police didn't treat it like that.
In fact, they publicly stated at the time that they didn't think that the murders were connected.
Even after the third Frankfurt Slasher murder, which took the first Frankfurt slasher murder,
which took place on Christmas Eve when 74-year-old Susan Olsaf was killed in her own apartment
after being stabbed six times. No true connections were made. It was only after a fourth victim,
Jean Durkin was found murdered in the area when the police finally began to admit that there may be
a serial killer operating in the Frankfurt area. It was at around this time when the local newspapers
began picking up on this story and started referring to the shadowy killer as the Frankfurt
slasher. This killer seemed to be targeting primarily Caucasian women who lived in a small
area, who had a history of mental illness or drug dependency and oftentimes worked as prostitutes.
And although there was a sense of panic in the city, life still went on, but the bodies
kept stacking up as well. In the same month that 28-year-old Jean Durkin was murdered,
29-year-old Catherine Jones was also killed in a very similar fashion.
Later that year, 66-year-old Margaret Vaughn was brutally slain.
Then, a few months later, it was 30-year-old Teresa Scurtino.
Well, all of these murders were occurring.
The police had narrowed in on a few suspects and had released a suspect sketch.
According to this drawing and from witness reports,
the suspect in the slayings was a stocky, middle-aged white man who wore glasses with short hair and sometimes a hat.
The slasher, according to what authorities had learned and believed at the,
the time, posed as a counselor to women and offered guidance for people who had strayed from the
proper Christian path. One of the suspects was a man who at one point rented an office in a church
nearby Frankfurt Avenue, who was known to frequent bars in the area and was often seen
talking to down and out-of-luck women. But as the authorities were closing in on this suspect,
he disappeared. I mean, he was gone. It seemed as though he had skipped town, moved out of state,
and had taken on a new identity.
And seeing that the murders were getting so much attention in the press,
at this point, the killers seemed to take a break,
a break which lasted a little over a year.
But he wasn't done yet.
April 29, 1990,
Carol Down is found brutally murdered behind a fish market in Frankfurt.
And this time, the police had a solid suspect.
On the night of the murder, some witnesses had placed a 39-year-old man
named Leonard Christopher at the scene of the crime.
Leonard actually worked at the fish market behind which Carol's body was found at the time.
And some witnesses had seen him walking with the victim on the night of the crime.
And one person even claimed that they had seen Leonard walking out of the alleyway
on which the victim's body was found the night of the murder at around 1 a.m.
And told authorities that Leonard had been,
sweating profusely at his shirt over his arm and a rambo knife was tucked into his belt.
And apparently, these eyewitness statements were a non-examination.
Enough for the Philadelphia police.
They swooped in, arrested Leonard, and charged him with the murder of Carol Dowd.
And to them, the Frankfurt Slasher case was then wrapped up with a nice little bow.
But it wouldn't be so easy.
You see, well, Leonard was in jail, awaiting trial.
The ninth victim of the Frankfurt Slasher was found, freshly killed.
The victim was 30-year-old Michelle Martin.
Michelle was, once again, found nude from the waist down, had her blouse pushed up to show
her breasts, and she had been stabbed a total of 23 times. Now, Michelle had been dead for only two
days, which meant that unless there was a great copycat killer out there, the Frankfurt
slasher had struck again recently, while the lead suspect in the case had been in jail. But even
though Leonard claimed that he had been with his girlfriend on the night of the murder, and the murder case
against him was entirely circumstantial, meaning there was zero physical evidence. Leonard was
convicted for the murder of Carol Dow and was sentenced to life in prison, and thus the Philadelphia
PD solved the case. I'm putting air quotes around solved here in case you don't know. Now obviously,
there are so many things wrong with this conviction. Not only was Leonard convicted purely on
circumstantial evidence, but the sketches of the Frankfurt slasher himself were all of a white
middle-aged male, and Leonard was black. Never mind the multiple suspects the police
least had identified earlier, and the man who rented the room from the church who disappeared before
he could be questioned. At the time, Leonard Christopher was their man, and in the eyes of authorities,
Leonard Christopher was the Frankfurt slasher. Sadly, though, Leonard, from the time that he was
arrested until the time that he was convicted, claimed that he was innocent. And a few short
years later, after telling people from prison that he was innocent and didn't do anything,
he died in prison from cancer. Obviously, there have been so,
so many wrongful convictions throughout American history. And here at murder in America, we believe that
Leonard Christopher was indeed most likely innocent and that the Frankfurt Slasher may still be out there.
He'd most likely be around 65 to 70 years old right now. He might be your next door neighbor
in Wyoming. He could be the friendly man down the street in your neighborhood in California.
Or he could be a co-worker in Texas. You never truly know. Hell, the Frankfurt Slasher might even
still be in Philadelphia, enjoying the fact that he got away with one of the city's most notorious
crime sprees. But until we get more evidence in this case, asking, who was the Frankfurt Slasher,
is a question that will never truly have an answer. And that's why I want to film a documentary
about the murders. In the next month or two, Courtney and I are going to attempt to interview
survivors of the slasher, relatives of family members, and ex-Philadelphia police officers
while we produce our documentary about this string of crimes. Because trust,
me. There's a lot of the story that I had to leave out. And soon enough, we're going to be posting
that documentary on my YouTube channel, The Paranormal Files. Also, if you guys want to watch a great
true crime documentary, our film about the Texas Killing Fields, which was episode number two of
murder in America, is available to watch on my YouTube channel The Paranormal Files now. The video
actually just hit a million views last month, and we're so happy to have touched so many lives
with that movie. In fact, we just filmed a part two to the Killingfield's episode, because
just a few months ago, they found another body there. And that's going to be premiering on the channel
at the end of this month, along with a mini series about murder in Texas. So if you're into the
macabre and you love what we do here, go subscribe to the paranormal files on YouTube as well.
Philadelphia, one of America's oldest cities. Nowadays, one of America's most violent and most
colorful. Courtney and I love Philadelphia. There are so many amazing people that live here, so many
amazing places to visit and so much amazing history to experience. But late at night, while walking
these streets, you can't help but wonder, was somebody killed here? Just the other night,
Courtney and I actually found out that one of the Frankfurt Slashers' victims' bodies was discovered
just a couple hundred feet from our apartment's front door. It's crazy. We're definitely going to
be telling more Philadelphia stories in the future, but it makes me wonder, what's the history
of your city? Was there an infamous murder that took place in your town? Do you have a connection to
true crime? Let us know on our Instagram at Murder in America. We're dying, no pun intended,
to hear from you all online and learn about your history with murder. Send us a message, comment on our
post. Let us know how crime has touched you. Because after all, murder is everywhere. You never know
when, how, or if it's going to happen.
and there's really nowhere in the world where you're truly safe.
So always keep your eyes open.
Watch behind your back, lock your doors.
Because in this world, especially in the United States,
there are too many victims and too few arrests.
Good hair days do more than we give them credit for.
When your hair feels healthy, you show up differently.
You feel more confident, more relaxed,
and you're not constantly checking the mirror.
Nutraful supports hair health from within
and delivers results over time.
So your hair becomes something you enjoy, not something you stress about.
Nutraful is the number one dermatologist-recommended hair growth supplement brand,
and it's the number one hair growth supplement brand personally used by dermatologists.
And Nutriful's hair growth supplements are peer-reviewed,
NSF certified for sport, and clinically tested.
It's obviously not a one-size-fits-all approach,
and Nutraful offers multiple formulas for men and women,
tailored to different life stages, like postpartum or menopause,
and lifestyle factors such as a plant-based diet,
so you get support for your hair that's actually right for you.
And adding Nutraful to your daily routine is easy.
You can order online with no prescription needed,
with automated deliveries and free shipping to keep you on track.
Plus, with a Nutraful subscription,
you can save up to 20% and get added perks
like a free Headspace membership to support your hair health journey.
I know Courtney and I both have been using Nutraful shampoo and conditioner for years now,
and we've been using their supplements for months.
We figured at one point,
Why not try their supplements because we love their shampoo and conditioner so much?
And yeah, it's one of those never looking back situations.
But you can let your hair become one less thing taking up space in your head and see thicker, stronger, faster growing hair with less shedding in just three to six months with Nutraful.
For a limited time, Nutraful is offering our listeners $10 off your first month subscription and free shipping when you visit Nutraful.com and enter promo code MIA.
That's NutraFold.com, spelled N-U-T-R-A-F-O-L dot com, promo code M-I-A.
Hello, everyone.
It is Courtney, and it's actually just going to be me today on the outro.
Colin is out filming right now, but we just want to thank you guys for all of the love and support.
You guys have been incredible.
We know the last few months have been kind of crazy with the scheduling and release dates,
but y'all have been so understanding throughout our move and all.
of the craziness going on in our lives. So we love you. Thank you for understanding. And soon enough,
we will be back and running as normal. But we love you guys. If you want to follow us on Instagram,
our Instagram is Murder in America. And you can also follow us on Facebook.
Make sure to listen to next week's episode. I have been working so hard on an insane serial killer
story. And you guys are going to love it. So we love you guys. And we will love you guys. And we will
see you next week.
