My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark - MFM Minisode 63
Episode Date: March 26, 2018This week’s hometowns include a creepy dentist and cash found under a tree.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-...sell-my-info.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
We at Wondery live, breathe and downright obsess over true crime and now we're launching the
ultimate true crime fan experience, Exhibit C. Join now by following Wondery, Exhibit C on
Facebook and listen to true crime on Wondery and Amazon Music, Exhibit C. It's truly criminal.
Welcome to my favorite. I don't want to do that anymore. Let's never do that again. Let's never
do it again. Hi, this is my favorite murder the mini episode. That's right, you send us your stories,
hometown murders, weird people that you've experienced as a child, weird people your grandparents
experienced as grandparents, you fucking found on the street in a garbage in the walls of your house
that's being torn down all of it. Shit you found in your brain when you were picking through it
with your therapist. That's right. You know, please no fictions. No, that's for your other that's for
your fan fiction website. We don't we want the real stuff. Yeah, it's key. Yeah, unless we don't know
that that's fiction. I mean, how will we know? Hold on real quick. The microphone's falling off
of the table. Yes. Finally, something happening. Action adventure. Steven shoots over from his
Indian sitting Indian style position over on the floor. And suddenly he's there. He's there.
Screwing in screws. And then I'm holding it up. Highly technical and yet coffee table based
microphone system. And we're back. I was there the whole time. You're in it and seamless pattern
narrating. Yes, making it clear to everyone navigating. Okay, I'm ready for fun for funds and
giggles for funds and giggles. Okay, well, I'm not gonna this is if something I've found but I'm
not going to read you to listen to spoilers look. Yeah, but they tell you pretty quickly. Okay.
Hi, everybody. My wife and I are emailing to tell you about the weirdest thing we have ever found
an arm off the coast of Japan last summer. It's called found a human arm is the time.
So good, good withholding that right until the big reveal. My wife, Angela and I were
stationed with the military in northeast Japan for two years. We loved taking our dog to the
Pacific coastline and love to walk on the elevated seawall that was erected after the
devastating tsunami in 2011. Wow. And the seawall was roughly 20 feet above the waterline. It was
surrounded by concrete wave breakers. The wall provided a nice barrier, blah, blah, blah,
occasionally. Nice barrier. Ocean Marina, etc. Occasionally you would see a fisherman, blah,
blah, blah, blah. So there's just weren't a lot of people there while details, etc.
Anyways, as we were walking down the seawall, Angela looked down and saw a glove with a
fucking human arm sticking out of it. Oh no, a gloved arm. Fish and worms were picking at it.
It was an obvious Caucasian slash Asian flesh and even from 20 feet away, but we couldn't
reach it. So naturally we took a turn. Reaching out for the arm. Reaching out for a disembodied
arm. Just a little further. It's reaching back for you. She's holding his jacket. He's leaning
out. Sorry, is the arm in water? And in a glove. Yeah. I think it's sticky. Okay, see here's the
thing. Now it says, it sent pictures attached. And this is when I turned to Stephen and said,
oh my God, please, did you see them? Yeah, it's like floated. It's like almost like bobbing,
like a buoy. Straight up and down. Straight up and down in the water. Like over here, over here.
Yeah, yeah, like waving. A bobbing buoy. Yeah, and it says attached. And I was like,
I don't want to see those. And then you said you saw them and I was like, are you okay, Stephen?
I mean, the photo they took, they must have tried to ensure that it wasn't graphic because you
just see the glove part. You don't see anything else. Okay. What was it, an upsetting glove?
Was it a menacing glove? I mean, it looked like it was a glove. Like somebody's trying to cover
up evidence. Like they were trying to like protect like a plastic glove. Going to clean the dishes
kind of glove. Dishwasher glove. Oh, like a hair dyeing glove. Oh, did it have a long,
it didn't stop at the wrist. It went down. Yeah, it went down. And oh, now I know exactly what you
mean. Okay. We took a picture, thought about what Karen and Georgia would do, looked around for a
body and then ultimately we went home. Good. Don't stick around for a body. Just if you see one in
your, in your purview, fine. They, they looked around real quick. Yeah, no body. Don't go into
caves. Goodbye. We would have called the cops to, this part's fucking funny. We would have called
the cops to get someone to the scene, but outside of ordering sushi or beer, our Japanese was subpar
at best. So we didn't call. And in all honesty, we knew it was our last night in Japan and finding
a body part just sounded like a lot of paperwork when all we wanted was a night of ramen and maybe
a little karaoke before our flight the next morning. You fucking asshole. American. Wait,
but then the guilt settled in. Oh, nice. We called the American police officers attached to our base
and told them we found an arm. We reported to the, we reported to the station, wrote our statements,
completed paperwork and as predicted ended up back at the scene with age, Japanese cops,
the military police and a translator. The translator told us a disfigured body or a
porpoise was found earlier that day in the same location. Oh no. And then they write,
since when are humans fucking mixed up with porpoises? When they're burnt to death, when they've
been skinned, when any number of horrible porpoise like disfigurements that just popped into my head.
Thank you. In the meantime, the arm had drifted 50 meters, but it was still intact despite the
marine life. The Japanese police formed the cutest human chain to retrieve the arm. Oh,
that sounds scary. Once they determined it was a real body part, they made us leave the scene.
Oh, good. To this day, we don't know the story behind the arm, but believe it was ultimately
linked to the Yakuza, the Japanese mafia known for cutting off body parts. Stay sexy, watch your arms
and don't get murdered. See you in London in May, Katie and Angela. Oh my God. That is...
First of all, the idea that they were just like, we can't get involved with this creeper work.
I want ramen. I don't want it. So funny. Which I understand. I think a lot of people probably do
that. They're just like, oh, this is a thing. Someone else will find this. But the difference
between a to the wrist glove and a almost to the elbow like medical glove is such a huge creepy
difference. You're up to some other weird shit altogether. It's like that to me reminds, I guess,
probably from the beginning of The Simpsons where it's like, is somebody that handles nuclear rods
getting killed by the Yakuza? Well, I figured it would have been part of the tsunami, like how
shit just always kept washing up and even bodies washed up. But it doesn't sound like it. I don't
know. Yeah. It's, I mean, just like bobbing up and down. Oh, no. I just realized as we were talking
about that, or as you were saying that, I always say how I don't, I just don't care about mafia
crimes as an area of true crime. Yeah. Real interested in the Yakuza. Yakuza is a different
story for you. Interesting. That was Georgia's friendship voice when she pretends to care about
what I'm talking about. So that's different than you do like the Yakuza. Something is wrong with
me because that's my truly interested in my friends and stuff. That was you being truly. Yeah. What
am I doing wrong? Was it my face? No, I think I feel like it was like camera ready. So that's what
you give a shit about. Yeah. Tell me more while I fall asleep. Oprah ask. Oh, I'll go up here
in this part. So you went swimming this way. Tell me more about that. Okay. I did go swimming.
All right. Ready for this? Yes. My creepy dentist. Okay. I have to go to the dentist at 8am tomorrow.
You're a hot dentist. 8am. That's too early. Isn't it? I better brush my hair. Teeth too. Oh,
yes. Teeth. I always forget that. Okay. Hi, Karen, Georgia, Steven, and animals. I started listening
to MFM a few months ago and recently finished my binge of the entire back library. So now I'm
limited to waiting for your new episodes each week. Wow. Hi. Sorry. I was inspired to finally
write in with my hometown murder story thanks to Karen's dentist experience in this week's
minisode. In stark contrast to Karen's handsome dentist, my childhood dentist was creepy as fuck.
Oh, no. The dentist's office was in the basement of a house. No, don't do that. Talk about your
fucking long gloves. Yeah. That's a long glove situation. Super dark and creepy looking. So
much wood paneling everywhere. Oh, dear. And he always wore these really old school dentist shirts
that honestly reminded me of a bowling shirt. What's a dentist shirt? Oh, yeah. I think it's
those like cotton ones, either blue or white that like the collars like it looks like a Nehru
almost. What's the what are the Mock Turtle Mints? Oh, a priest's collar. I don't know.
That's right. You wouldn't know. I wouldn't know. We call them priest's collars all the time.
Okay. I feel like I'll never forget what his mouth looked like because I had to stare up at
his creepy face twice a year for my entire childhood. And then a few more times a year when
he did my braces in high school. Fast forward to the summer of 2002. I just moved away to college
and get a call from my mom telling me that my dentist shot and killed his wife in the dentist
office with a shotgun. The wife worked there too as the office manager was always super nice,
crazy. I had to wonder if the incident was a self-fulfilling prophecy because the dude's name
was Dr. Rambo. No. No wonder I was creeped out by this guy my whole life. He was crazy and turned
out to be a killer. He represented himself at trial. Oh, God. After firing his lawyer, parentheses,
red flag, and he claimed that his wife was attacking him and that he acted in self-defense.
Yeah, right. But he shot her in the back. So we're not we're not laughing because someone got shot
in the back. Oh, my God. No, he's a fucking lunatic monster. Yes. Why would you even why would you
go down that road to only prove yourself wrong? Seriously. So that is obviously BS. He was convicted
and put in prison from prison. He filed a civil suit against the family to gain possession of the
weird list of personal items from the estate, including a wooden duck, a collection of ceramic
horses, a trumpet, and their wedding album. So bizarre. Wow. I hope one day I find a dentist
handsome enough to make me forget about Dr. Rambo, wife killer. But to this day, every time I schedule
an appointment, I think of him. Thanks for being the best podcast ever. And of course, SSDGM Chrissy.
Wow. That's hilarious. Don't go to any professional thing in a basement unless it's a professional
basement makers basement. Right. You're checking and you only and you don't go all the way down. You go
to the top step. Yeah. You do you bend over at the waist. You look around and go. Thanks. Great.
And you haul us back those babies basements there. Remember like maybe this was like an 80s thing,
but like how how a lot of hairstylists would be like would have that in their house that like your
mom would go to like down to the basement. Yeah. That's what makes me think of that. Yeah.
Yeah. We there was also a couple people in my high school whose parents had like
rumpest rooms in the basement. Yeah. So one of the worst drunk party presentations I ever gave
presentation. I love I love a professional drunk hair and giving a drunk presentation.
Well, I'm here buddy. So next up we have Karen Kilgara. Hi. You know me. She's going to give a
presentation. Here's the presentation. I smoke gloves and I try to kick someone.
So you know that my favorite thing is like on TV is when people pretend to be drunk. So you doing
anything you just did made me. Is that true? Yeah. I can't. I don't care if it's the worst
sitcom. I will laugh my ass off at some terrible actor who's being pretending to be drunk. It's
my favorite thing to do. It just turns out. I love fake drugs. I spent so much time in Georgia.
Can I tell you a secret? Just to tell you a quick secret. I spent all my time like this.
You shut up Stephen. Whoops. I spiked it. Sorry. Okay. What was your your best drunk
presentation? I can't remember. It ends in a blackout. I had a bunch of what they used to call
cuckoo juice when I was in high school. It's called cuckoo juice. It's called jungle juice.
It's called what's it? There's one called like the suicide or whatever. Is that one they melt
sherbet and put in vodka and whatever? They basically mix Hawaiian punch and all the liquor
in the parents don't do that. So you take normally would normally take four drinks. Yeah.
Only takes one drink. It's like a long island. Nice to you. Yeah. Very bad. And you put on a
you put on a what does Vince call it? What does it call it? You put on a it's not presentation.
It's not presentation. It's some fucking Vince horror. That's so funny. A clinic. You put you
put on a fucking clinic and how to how to be a drunk person. Full on this was I actually got it
out of my system very early because this is the one where I got so drunk me and my friend. I've
told you the story about my friend Christine. Yeah. And listen Karen is a recovering alcoholic or
not. I'm not laughing at anything about this. You gotta laugh. I did it to myself and I'm not like
trying to make you feel bad in any way. You can't. There's nothing left in there to feel bad.
Like I wish I wish you could pull those heart strings. They're gone. I just love your stories.
Okay. Yeah. I'll just say at this one and this did happen. I had come up out of the
rumpest room of the basement. I saw my cousin Mike in the hallway. The next thing I knew
I was pulling my face off of his white sweater and looked and I saw my own eyes on his sweater.
I had been crying on his shoulder in the hallway and then came to and was like what's going on
and looked down and I'd cried my own eyes onto his sweater and I was like all right see you later
and like just tried to get away before he recognized that I had ruined his like forensic
sweater and forgot why you were crying. It wasn't crying inside anymore. That experience was had
never happened. Oh no. Really a disaster artist. That was the same night that I that party was
I really did it up all at once and then me and my friend Christine went to my parents house. We
were supposed to be spending the night at her mom's house and I don't think her mom was supposed
to be home but instead he told the girl who's gave us a ride home to go to my parents house where
they were having yep they were having a dinner party with my aunt and uncle. Oh no. Whose cousin
you just whose kid you had just cried upon? No. Different. Different one. That was Mike
in to Giovanni. Not a blood relative but his mom and my mom were best friends in high school. So
he was a cousin. So he's my cousin. Yeah. But I realized as we were walking up the front door
oh this is my house. So I turned to Christine and go we're gonna go in and we're gonna run up the
hall go to my room and I thought in our dining room was like right by the front door is like
ranch style. So we that's we tried to do that. We just opened the front door and ran up the hallway
and slammed my bedroom door. So then my sister I'm positively destroyed. My sister comes and opens
my bedroom door because she wasn't at the party we were at and she's looking at both of us and
we're both laying on my bed like laughing our asses off. And my sister goes oh my god you're so
fucked. And then walks away. So then I was like wait why. And then I'm like oh no I'm at home
and I'm really shitfaced. Yeah. And then my mom came in and I was like it my friend Christine did
this thing that is straight out of a John Hughes movie. I had those closet door the doors to my
closet like pushed open like that. Yeah. And they were closed at the time. My mom opened the door
goes oh no you girls are so drunk. And my friend Christine puts her arm up like she's gonna lean
against a wall and goes Karen's pretty drunk Mrs. Kigler but actually I'm okay and then pushes the
door open and falls into my closet. And it was so over the top. It's too classic. It's so my mom
started laughing and had to leave the room because she was trying to act mad but we were like
we were like two girls doing a bit of being drunk. I am never having a child simply because I do not
ever want to have a teenager. No. It's so dark. We were the worst people. The worst. Well I just
watched Lady Bird and I was like nope pass our pass on that one. Don't ever want to have this.
I mean don't want myself in the future. Yes exactly right. You have to basically have a mirror
of yourself that's giving you the shit you gave your mom. Yeah. No. Probably times time. Or just
write a fucking movie about it if you're a fucking girl which this is awesome. Let's see wait. Just
win an Oscar and get out of your system and don't actually do it. And then pay your mom back.
Looking for a better cooking routine with meal planning shopping and prepping handled. Hello
Fresh has you covered. Hello Fresh makes home cooking easy and affordable so you can stay on
track and on budget in the new year. Hello Fresh meals are convenient seasonal and delicious.
Stay cozy all winter long with classic comfort foods available weekly. Why stop with just dinner.
Now you can enjoy Hello Fresh's expanded menu of quick lunch solutions weekend brunch simple
side dishes and amazing desserts. Karen January is going to be my month for Hello Fresh. I am so sick
of takeout. I miss cooking so much I haven't lifted a knife or a pan since like early fall.
So I can't wait to get back in the kitchen and Hello Fresh makes it so easy and also
makes it so that my food tastes good which is hard to do on my own. It gives you everything
everything you need. So get up to 20 free meals with purchase plus free shipping on your first
box at hellofresh.ca slash murder 20 with code murder 20. That's up to 20 free meals plus free
shipping on your first box when you go to hellofresh.ca slash murder 20 and use code murder 20. Goodbye.
Hey I'm Mike Corey the host of Wunderies podcast against the odds. In our next season
three masked men hijack a school bus full of children in the sleepy farm town of Chautilla
California. They bury the children and their bus driver deep underground planning to hold them
for ransom. Local police and the FBI marshal a search effort but the trail quickly runs dry
as the air supply for the trapped children dwindles a pair of unlikely heroes emerges.
Follow against the odds wherever you get your podcast. You can listen ad free on the Amazon
music or Wundery app. Stephen fucking knocked it out of the park this week with the print
up. So do you want to hear these stories aren't saying about finding something finding cash under
a tree or about a ghost or do you want to hear about let's see here. I'm going to read you this
one. I don't like cash under a tree cash under a tree. I put my my under a tree. I buried my
purse. You have to help me find a person. I buried it. I didn't want anyone to touch my purse. I buried
it. You have to find it. I don't remember which tree. Why are there no trees at this party?
I get a sworn. Why are you crying now? Okay. Hello everybody. Thank you so much for your
podcast and for starting this wonderful MFM community. Thank you. I mean it really was our
pleasure. Our pleasure. I've been a long time listener and fan of the podcast. I've always
wanted to submit a hometown murder. However, I've never had a personal story matching a
minisode request until now. Imagine my surprise when in minisodes 60 you asked for stories about
quote big piles of money you just kind of found. Yeah. Remember when you said that just so casually
or just big piles of money you just kind of know who doesn't want to hear that story. Well,
that's exactly what happened to me during my junior year of high school. What the fuck? I grew up in
Tucson, Arizona and my friends and I used to hang out a lot at a park by our high school.
One day as I was walking in the park with my friends I looked down and saw about 10,
$50 bills on the ground. Whoa. I didn't believe the bills were real and I felt like I was having
an out of body experience when I reached down and picked them up. It happened to me when I was a
little kid in town $100 on the ground. I was like, this can't be happening. Did you? How old were
you? I was like four or five. I was like one of my earliest memories. Shit. I reached down and
picked them up. I took a few steps forward and saw a pile of about 10 more bills under a tree
and I picked them up too. I stuffed the bills in my bag and my friends and I hid behind a dumpster
to count the cash. I'm not sure why we thought a dumpster was the safest place at the time.
It turns out we, it turns out I had picked up, ready for this, $1,100 in cash just sitting under
a tree. Fuck. Yeah. No brown paper bag or a briefcase or drug blazer or anything.
We walked around the park in a moral quandary about whether we should turn the money in and to
whom. No way we were handing $1,100 to teen lifeguards at the Lost and Found. No way. Or if I
should keep what was probably drug money. While we walked around the park, I could feel the money
burning a hole in my bag. Then three hefty big men rolled out of a car and started scouring the
ground. They made eye contact with me and I swear they could see the money in my purse.
I called the police right away and turned the money in. The police could not believe I would
turn in the money. Honestly, I think they thought I was kind of stupid. But they booked it and told
me that if no one claimed the money after 90 days, it was mine. My friends and I counted down the
days and about a month after I found the money, the police posted a notice in our local newspaper
describing exactly where the money was found. Three steps from the sidewalk, two steps to the
left at the base of the first tree you see. We knew that anyone could read the description and
claim the money as their own, so I gave up hope. Still, I went to the police station on the 91st
day after finding the money and lo and behold, it was still there. No. The police chief came out
and thanked me for being a good Samaritan and handed me the cash. I kept it into this day.
It's been the best $1,100 I've ever found. Wait. She kept it and never spent it? No, I don't know.
Thanks for all you do. Stay sexy and don't get murdered. Okay. It's been the best $1,100 I've
ever been. That's so brilliant. Wow. What a like uplifting story that people didn't go and just
take money that wasn't theirs. Yeah. But also, I bet the cops knew it was like drug money. So
they're like, well, we're going to tell everyone where exactly where it is and whoever comes in
here is a fucking drug dealer. Yeah, that's true. Yeah. That's true because that's why no one claimed
it. Yeah. Nobody's going to be dishonest. They're like, yeah. And they're like, oh, we did a quick
wipe and it has cocaine all over it. Okay. This one, the subject line is, should I do,
okay, wait, I'm going to do this one. Okay. And I'm also going to, I'm going to withhold the subject
line like you did. Great. For spoiler reasons. Okay. Hi friends, F-W-E-N-D-S. All right. Already
off to a bad start. I mean, simply unacceptable. This must be a good one if you still are chosen.
I'm still going. It's got to be really fucking good. I think, I'm assuming it's a she and I bet you
she did it on purpose just to bug me. But we're still going to go through with it because this
story, so now we're in it. Okay. This story involves no deaths, sinkholes or found items,
but it's creepy nonetheless. Okay. Great start. Two of my girlfriends and I went to see suicide
squad against strike 19. Just kidding. On Sunday afternoon, when it came out, wow, day out,
we were maybe 45 minutes into the movie when I went to the bathroom. When it came back,
I noticed a pair of shoes beneath our seats as I started to enter the aisle. I stopped,
looked at my friends and pointed down in confusion. As I realized, it was not just shoes,
but a human being. They didn't know what was going on. I grabbed my cell phone and had a moment
of thinking, okay, I'm either about to find a dead body or something bad is about to happen.
Before I flipped the flashlight on, I flashed the light onto what was a full grown man
face down on the movie theater floor directly beneath us. What? Before I could say anything,
he started to move out and acted as though he was grabbing his cell phone and he mumbled something
like I lost my phone. I was just looking for it. As he stood up and then promptly bolted out of the
theater, we all looked at each other in utter disbelief. I sat back down with them and we
had the longest what the fuck moment of our lives during suicide squad. My girlfriend said
that she thought she had felt movement and something touching her while we watched and she'd
brushed it off, but now we freaked the fuck out or now freak the fuck out. We immediately went to
tell management. We had told an employee what happened and he literally said, oh, that guy again.
And grabbed a manager. The manager told us that this had happened before our minds were blown
and we ended up calling the cops to come here our story and check in on the theater. They also
gave us free movie pass. Yeah. As we did not want to go back in, not only because we were in because
we were shook, but also because Suicide Squad was one of the worst things they've ever sat
there 45 minutes up. They were kind of stoked. Hilarious. Okay. We couldn't get the incident
off our mind. So I ended up making a post about what happened on the subreddit for our city.
It blew up with comments making a local news station asked to report on the story. My girlfriend
ended up meeting them outside the theater to do a short segment up for the evening news. I also
got comments with links about this exact thing happening in other theaters in the same city
and a link to a man's photo and history of arrest records for voyeurism. This dude has been arrested
several times in the past for things like this, including hiding under a woman's bed in her
fucking house while she hung out in there. He generally looked like a person I saw. I don't
want to know that happens. I mean, he generally looked like the person I saw emerged from under
our seats, although I couldn't be 100% sure because we were in a dark theater and it all
happened so quickly. If I could go back in time, I would have jacked him in the face and made a
scene. So he would have fucking gotten caught. But at the time, I had no point of reference
for what was happening because it's all capitals so fucking weird. And I thought it might have
been an injured person or something. I mean, yeah, your brain can't wrap around that. It's also
who would be that close to a movie theater floor? That's what I was thinking too, like talk about
unfamiliar crumbs and fucking stickiness. How did he get up that fast when it is just pure goo
down there? Yeah, yeah, like he didn't stick to it. Okay, so here's the end. I have no idea what's
going on with this person now, but thank God nothing worse happened to us. I hope he has gotten
help or can get the right help for that sort of thing before it escalates to something much more
terrible. That's very good. Can you imagine if I hadn't gone to the bathroom and discovered him?
He be Gibi's all over SSD GMD. What was he doing though? Like you can't do like upskirt shots
or anything like that down there. Well, but she like he may have turned, he may have been laying
face up. But looking at what the bottoms of seats? Well, maybe if their butts are sticking on the
back of something. But like maybe he turned when he knew she was coming back because he would look
bad if he was facing up. Oh my God, I mean, it looks okay if he's facing down. It's I mean,
people put like baby diapers down there. My friend, yeah, my friend Danny was an usher
in a movie theater and he was like, I found a full diaper in there on the ground one time.
No. So stop it people. I mean, any others that have to be read, have it one more. Yeah. How about
listen, these are all really funny today, aren't they? Okay, aren't they? I'm not going to tell you
the name of this one because it's really okay. Hey, Karen, Georgia, Steven and associated nonhuman
creatures. I've been waiting with this story for ages because it's just weird enough that you would
appreciate it, but it's not murder. I'm so glad that hometowns have been opened up to just general
weirdness. I think it's a good idea. Is there a murder to this one? Yeah. Which one? The dentist. Oh,
right. Yeah. There we go. Okay. I went to a small close knit college where not much exciting happened
until the footlicker came into town. Dude, this is like a serious body parts episode. It is. The
title is Rogue Footlicker on campus. What you need to understand is that one of the dorms consist
of clusters of dorm rooms that all share a living room. The rooms themselves locked with the door
to the living room does not. Trust me, this is important. So one night a girl was sleeping on
the couch in one of the living rooms and she woke up to a man she didn't know licking her feet.
She obviously freaked the fuck out and her friends came and chased him away,
but the dude came back and was looking at her through the window. This happened after the
outer doors to the building had been locked for the night. So to have access, he either knows
someone who lived there or lived there himself. It's a small campus. So you would think that
someone would know who he was, but no witnesses recognized him. We all look up the next morning
to an email warning us that a footlicker was loose on campus and to be on the lookout,
but he was never apprehended. It's been six years and the footlicker has passed into campus legend
along with the one armed Amish man who they say used to wander around campus. Stay sexy and wear
socks if you sleep on the couch, Kelly. Oh man. Who the one time footlicker? Yeah, that's,
but also that's so bold. Like your crime is, it's such a high risk crime. And like you got chased
off and you came back. You came back. So you're, there's something going on. Yeah. You're really
drunk. He put on a fucking drunk clinic for real. I would hope that he's just like, you know what,
I gotta go for it. Yeah. I just got to express myself. Do you think the one armed Amish man
lost it in Japan? I'm just saying this could be the button. Oh my God. This could be what we're
looking for. It all fucking wraps together. I start like getting red string and fucking
clear. What do Amish gloves look like? What do Amish gloves look like? Exactly. What do Amish gloves
look like? Do they go all the way to the fucking elbow? They have, they, they actually, they go to
the wrist, but then there's a beard from the wrist to the elbow because their arm is. Good night everybody.
Send your weird shit to my favorite murder. If you have. A Gmail. Name some new shit. If you
have a Gmail. Is that what you said? No, I said a Gmail. Oh, if you have a Gmail. No, I was going
to say if you have found a person in a place where they don't belong, you would love to hear that
story. A hundred percent. Right. Yes. Yeah. That could be the new fold-in. That's the new one. Every
week we add a new fucking weird element. And also let's bring those money piles forward everybody.
Money piles, fucking appendages that don't belong where they're from. Any kind of body or body part
in a place that doesn't belong. There's a place in Canada. I know we're going to get a ton of like
messages about this, but there's a certain bay in Canada where they body parts keep showing up.
Right. Shoes with feet in them. It's like shoes with feet and nothing else, but I think they've
disproved that it's anything like. There's theories. But I don't think. Yeah. But it's basically,
it's like drowning victims that get eaten entirely by most animals. Oh man, we were on such a high
note. It's such a bummer. Well, this is a bummer based podcast. It's not called my favorite happy
stuff. My favorite best memory. This is my favorite story about a girl that got her foot licked and
then the guy came back and stared at her through a window. Well, a fucking Amish guy with a Japanese
missing arm was walking around. Get out of here. What are you listening? If you fucking
don't want this. Stay sexy. And don't get murdered. Goodbye. Hey, Elvis. Want cookie?
Oh, yes. He was waiting. He's like, don't make fun of me.