NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal - J.J. McCarthy Traded, Baker Out 3 Weeks and Achane Out for season with Ian Rapoport

Episode Date: September 28, 2026

Gregg Rosenthal and Ian Rapoport react to news from around the NFL including the Vikings trading J.J. McCarthy to the Giants, Baker Mayfield's status for the Buccaneers, the Giants losing Brian Burns for the season, the Dolphins losing De'Von Achane for the season and more!NFL Daily YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/nflpodcastsSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

This is an I-Hart podcast. Guaranteed Human. The Hard Rock Bet Casino app is here, Ontario. And with a name like Hard Rock, you know you're in for an experience you can only get here. Exclusive games, an exclusive progressive jackpot, and the kind of trust and security you can only get with Hard Rock. And now you can enjoy the things you can only get here anywhere.

Hard Rock Bed is here, Ontario. Download the app. Roll with us. Must be 19 years of age or older to play. Ontario only. Please play responsibly. Concerned about your gambling or that of someone close to you, visit connectsonterio.ca. I'm Brett Coleman.

And I'm Trevor Sikkimam. If you love football and want to understand what's really happening on the field, check out our show, NFL Pro. Every week we break down the biggest plays, trends, and matchups using exclusive next-gen stats insights and NFL content you will not find anywhere else. Whether you're new to football, a fantasy football fanag, or a diehard fan. NFL Pro will help you analyze the game like a pro. Listen to NFL Pro on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcast.

Hey, I'm Mike Yam. And I'm Trevor Sycambe, and together we host the NFL Fantasy Football Show. Are you ready to dominate your fantasy league this season? Because if you aren't locked in with us on the NFL Fantasy Football Show, you're already playing from behind. Whether you're a first-time player or a grizzled vet chasing another championship, we give you the advantage and the confidence you need to make every move counts. Listen to the NFL Fantasy Football Show. show on the IHard Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcast.

Whether you're a seasoned NFL fan or new to the game, there's one place to keep up with all of it, the league's newest podcast, the NFL report, hosted by me, Andrew Siciliano. It is your home for everything football, breaking news, expert analysis, game picks, and hear from your favorite players too. Join me at an all-star cast of experts for everything you need to know from around the league. Get new episode to the NFL report Monday through Friday all season long. Listen to the NFL Report podcast on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome to NFL Daily, where a J.J. McCarthy train means an expert podcast. I'm Greg Rosenthal here on a surprise daily buzz edition of the show.

And we've got our friend Ian Rappaport. And we're going to go through the biggest items of news on what's been the busiest Monday so far of the season. And we've got to start, Ian. you're coming off Maccify. You're going to go on ESPN. You're going to go on NFL network. But we got you here for now. We've got to start with J.J. McCarthy.

Fifth round pick to the Vikings. Why did the trade happen now versus, let's say, a week ago or next week, some other time? I think a couple things. One, as soon as it became clear that Jackson Dar was going to miss the foreseeable future, the Vikings kind of started receiving phone calls from the Giants. John's kind of sprung into action here. And, you know, because they came back from L.A. so late, which was like Tuesday at like 7 p.m. or something like that,

it basically delayed the trade a week. So they kind of dug in when they knew the results of the MRI, probably Wednesday. And it's like, all right, we're not going to make the trade on a Wednesday. So let's just sort of delay it a week and see how James does. James was fine. But I don't know that anyone could watch the performance at, James had and say, all right, he's going to lead the Giants to the playoffs. It was fine.

They won, but, like, it was still a lot of stuff out there. And so they continued to look into JJ. And I think last night, either late last night or early this morning, the trade got finalized. It's going to be official when he passes his physical. And then he'll come in and the Giants will have a backup quarterback. Where it goes from here is going to be really interesting because J.J. McCarthy has become a little bit of a sort of pariah. Everyone thinks it's funny. You know, he had the memes in the locker room and he's been injured a lot.

And, you know, there's just a lot of things that the internet, rightfully or wrongfully, has sort of laughed at. What's interesting to me is he is really talented. Like, I remember when the Vikings had a joint practice with the Patriots. And some of the Patriots people I talked to were like, that guy was the best player on the field. And I was like, okay. And he's had moments like that. So I expect him to start eventually for the Giants this season. How he's going to do, I have no idea.

But like it's really, really interesting to me now. Yeah, it is. And he's only 23 years old. I have to question, I don't know when that joint practice was, but the evaluation skills of the Patriots. It wasn't this year. It was last year. I mean, Drake Mays on the field.

Give me a break. It was the second. It was the second. They had two joint practices and it was the second one. First one, he struggled. Second one, he was great. But that's sort of what it's been like, honestly. Yeah, and he's been injury prone.

You're being charitable, and that's what the insider does when it comes to evaluation. Sometimes on James Winston's performance, he hasn't looked great, but it was bad. It was bad weather. We'll see if that gets any better. He only started 10 games. It is amazing to just think about the JJ McCarthy era right now. Josh Rosen struggled big time as a rookie burst round. He got traded after only one season for a late two.

Trey Lance could not have struggled anymore. He got a four. They were ready to get off of J.J. McCarthy, obviously, and just take whatever they were going to get for him because a fifth round pick is not much and their quarterbacks aren't playing really well. Do you think the Baker injury and some of the other situations around the league almost pushed the Giants to move a little faster here? And before we move off at JJ, like, do you think of this?

He's 23 years old as more of a short. short-term fix or someone, you know, we'll have to figure out his fifth-year option after this season. But just, you know, he's another quarterback to add to the mix and darts coming off a serious injury. And could this be a mid-to-longer-term idea? I would say if the season ends and J.J. McCarthy is the starting quarterback of the Giants who are in the playoffs and they have to have the conversation

about who their quarterback of the future is, then it is the greatest year they could ever have imagined. I know it's a problem, but that's a great problem. I don't know that that's going to be the case. But like, you know, if you look at just the pedigree, like if J.J. McCarthy was coming out and Jackson Dar was coming out of the draft, my guess is the evaluations would be somewhat similar. I mean, JJ was drafted earlier than Jackson Dart.

So my guess is the evaluations would be somewhat similar. So could it be a long-term thing? I doubt it. but it could be a thing where the Giants say we have a backup quarterback for the next two years or it could be a thing where the Giants say he led us to the playoffs. Jackson is our guy and we are now going to take this

and trade someone who we use a fifth on and trade him for a two. That could happen. Like there's a lot of good outcomes here for the Giants. Yes, they do not want to be losing Jackson Dart for the season but this at least makes it better for us in terms of content. I mean, people have their feelings.

feelings about J.J. McCarthy. The Michigan folks are out there pointing out, look, he's 27 and one when he's coached by a Harbaugh. Do you think the brother situation? No one's pointing that out. I mean, Josh Dubot of the Associated Press pointed out. I did not come up with that on my own. My friend Tracy Sandler calls him my perfect JJ, you know? I mean, people believe in JJ in an almost biblical Tebow-like way, and now he's going to have a chance to play for a team that's two and one. Yeah, you were asking basically, like, did the Harbaugh thing make this happen, right? Mm-hmm. I don't really know, I mean, it sounds ridiculous, but I don't really know that that was like the deciding factor.

Like, they did all the work on him coming out and obviously liked him enough to trade for him. It's also like, you know, if John Harbaugh liked him enough, they would have offered more than a five. Like, I think it's just, it feels more like a flyer than anything else. The other thing I would say as far as the compensation, like it's weird that Tray Lance went for more, but it's also like this is what the price was. I mean, this is what someone was willing to pay for him. I mean, there's not a lot of teams who would have traded for him

and given up anything real. So like, my guess is he outplays the pick. But if he's just a backup the whole year, then a five is probably right. Yeah, he's young. the play hasn't been overly encouraging, although he's had moments. The injuries are a problem.

If anything, the way that the Vikings handled the situation and the reporting around him and maybe their lack of belief in him, I think hurt that price tag. I'm not going to ask you about Brian Burns, but since we last tape, we have found out through you,

through your reporting, he is going to miss the season with a torn ACL. That is a massive loss for them. They are 31st in pressure rate right now. They have one sack on the entire season. So their pass rush has been a bit of a, problem. I'll get to that in a bit after we say goodbye to Ian, but I do want to hear from you on Baker Mayfield before we let you go. What are you reporting on Baker Mayfield? I know Todd Bowles spoke at the

podium. It's a dislocated thumb. They had an MRI. Where is that at? And what do you think the timeline is for him to return? Okay. Got good news on the MRI. No fracture. I was told no ligament and cartilage damage. Now, you know, I watched the thumb bend the wrong way. So like my guess is are some strains there, which you know, you can talk about what damage is or isn't. It's, you know, Bull said he thinks about three weeks. I would say in medical terms, it was two to four, which is best case scenario. I mean, that's really like, you know, torn ligaments in your throwing thumb could be like, we'll see you next season.

You know, I mean, that has happened before. He's got to be able to grip. That's going to make it tougher. So I would say if he's back after missing three games, that's, you know, that's a lot of, you is a totally fine outcome for the bucks. The other is, this is also going to be really interesting. Like, we've seen this before where, you know,

a team is high on their backup quarterback, and then it goes out and plays, and you're like, oh, now I get why he's the backup. The former Kansas starter, Jalen Daniels, is really interesting. He won the backup job for the bucks. There are some people who really, really like him. I have no idea what he was going to be.

In the building, you're saying? In the building? In the NFL. Like, this is a lot of people. guy has some fans. And, you know, in like the Nate Tice's of the world, like that realm. So I don't know.

Maybe he's good. I'm like, it's another one. Like this, you know, is, would you rather watch Baker Mayfield? You would. But there's some really interesting quarterback things over the next couple weeks. As backup quarterbacks go, I am fascinated to watch him. He won that backup battle. Now you could say the backup situation that they had that he's competing against.

Maybe Jason Light, the GM. you know, wishes he had someone more experienced. But yeah, even when Jail and Daniels came in and threw that Hail Mary, I was like, that looks good. Next three games are against Green Bay at Dallas, not the toughest defenses in the world. And then Pittsburgh would be the third one. That'd be a tough matchup.

I'm thinking more big picture. What do you think about this Buccaneer situation? Winless, Todd Bowles coming off a disappointing 2025. Jason Light, you know, just invested in Baker Mayfield. like this has a chance to go sideways and how do you think the Baker injury impacts you know the job status of these guys? I don't know that it does

because you could sort of argue either way. Like to go well, you know, this team is, I don't know, let's say they go one and two. So, oh, well, this team is, you know, with Baker out. It's like, oh, well, they're, you know, one in five. It's like, well, yes, but they were 0 and 3 with Baker. So like whatever argument you could make, they've struggled.

Todd Bowles basically fired as a. entire staff this past year. When you do that as a head coach, what you do is you put the spotlight on yourself, right? I mean, if things go bad, you're generally the next to go. It's like when you change coordinators, then you do it again, it's like at some point it's like, it's me. So that's the kind of season it is in Tampa. I think, you know, he's got a win.

I think there's a lot of coaches like that. We saw 10 fired last year. I don't think that's a surprise. But I mean, if it continues to go this way, then it could be a bad outcome. That said, I think they're better than this. So my guess is they rebound, even without Baker. But yeah, I mean, it's the kind of, you know, they're going to have to perform. They really are.

And I think there's a bunch of teams in this situation. Yeah, I think I saw a stat. And I know we're not into gambling here on the show, but they have not covered the points spread in 13 straight games. That shows they're not meeting expectations. You know who's meeting expectations? It's Ian Rappaport. Look, I texted you to see if you could come on.

You're doing Macfee, you're doing all this other stuff. You said, text me back at 125. I said, is that a yes? And you said, no, text me back. I had to find out. And you made it happen. Do you miss us here at NFL Daily? You're in L.A. all the time.

You never come and say hi. I'm in L.A. for, I think, 18 hours a week. That's crazy. I miss you guys only a little. I see you guys on the Twitters and on the other podcast realms. You seem to be thriving. You don't seem to miss us very much. I mean, I don't even know what us is.

We're all in the same building. You know, they're serving the same food for dinner on Sundays. You guys are separated? No one's ever given me food. I get their three in the morning on Sundays. I've never had me food. Well, that's your problem. You're working too hard.

Appreciate you, Ian. Good luck with the rest of your hits today. That was Ian Rappaport. And we do have some other news I want to get to. So we're going to say goodbye to Ian and let him go on your day. And I will just make one final point here on the J.J. McCarthy story, which is they need their defense to play better than it has played,

or this offense won't really matter at all. Brian Burns is, if not their best defensive player, you know, it's him or Abdul Carter. And the two of them, and Burns only played as a situational pass rusher on Sunday. They just haven't been as productive as you would want, converting pressure into sacks. 31st, like I mentioned, in pressure rate. It's a thin defensive line.

You saw the big names and I got seduced by those big names. And yet, if you look at the production right now, they've been a little disappointing. They're playing it safe on defense and they are going to need to be much better to support James Winston or J.J. McCarthy.

I also don't want to give Kevin O'Connell a pass on this old J.J. McCarthy thing. I feel like at some point, Kevin O'Connell just pointed the finger and, you know, just started blaming things behind the scenes, at least in terms of sourced reporters, on J.J. McCarthy's maturity. All that's probably true. But Kyler Murray and Carson Wentz aren't exactly getting it done right now, and he's going to have to show that he can create a better offense with whoever

is at quarterback. When it comes to the Bucks, Todd Bowles cracks me up after the game on Sunday. And he did say Baker would be out at least three weeks. And so he wasn't saying exactly three weeks, but at least three weeks. We'll see. I think he's trying to be conservative. I trust the end that it's probably two to four. Green Bay and at Dallas in theory are winnable-ish games for your backup quarterbacks, but both those teams are looking at Jalen Daniels and thinking we are going to win this team against a team that is now 0 and 3 and can't do much right. And the expectations, the bar is so low and Todd Bowles is part of the reason that it's so low. Funny thing, we're on three and we're a game at a first place.

So we have to get our stuff together. We got to reach down and do more to a coach, to a person, to a player. We got to do more and figure out what we can do more and how can we be better and come back tomorrow and get ready to go. You know what? We don't do enough on the Sunday night recap show, standings analysis. There is not a winning team in the NFC South right now.

Falcons are thinking, we're in it. Saints are thinking, we're fine. Panthers have a big time injury that I'll get to now. J.C. Horn. Ian was actually the first person to report it. And J.C. Horn is the best cornerback, not just on the Panthers, maybe in the division. Certainly one of the best in the league has the long-term contract to prove it. He is going to miss the season with a torn quad. He is going to get a second opinion and is hoping to avoid surgery. But it sounds like this one has all been decided. And that is brutal for a team that I already thought was thin.

in the secondary. And when I went to go look at the snap counts on Sunday, I noticed that Mike Jackson, their other very good starting corner in a free agent year, only had 15 snaps in that game. It's because he suffered a groin injury. And we don't know about his status moving forward. They're starting cornerbacks in that game

were Will Lee and Caleb Evans, who kind of a journeyman, who just came from the Vikings, Will Lee, not a lot of experience. You got a rookie, Zaki Wheatley. You're playing at safety. Luther,

Ransom is another one. I don't blame anyone if they're not familiar with these guys. We've got rookies. We've got guys who have barely played in the NFL. And it takes you back to the Panthers preseason where they suffered so many injuries, especially on defense. And you do wonder if this team is going to be able to compete. And it does make you think when it comes to Todd Bowles,

maybe he's right. Like, I don't know who's going to win this NFC South. I would put the Saints now as the favorites because this injury to J.C. Horn and we'll see about Mike Jackson is really, really impactful for them. Another team, not a lot of high expectations of the Miami Dolphins. Ian and the other insiders reported, Devon A. Chan is going to miss the season with a torn ACL. Absolutely brutal. We hinted at that overnight on the recap show, but we didn't know for sure.

If you're in fantasy leagues, I think Jalen Wright actually might be the pickup. He missed week three, but he was the backup. He's a little more explosive than Ali Gordon. Either way, those guys are going to split carries. I would pick up Jalen Wright. I will pick up Jalen Wright in one of my leagues because I could use a running back and you never know. But this has been the worst running team or close to it

in terms of success rate, even with Devon A. Chan. This is a team that's really not getting it done on either side of the ball. And the running back usually suffers in that situation. So sad news there for Devon A. Chan. Also sad to see that Jack Besh has a broken forearm. The Raiders wide receiver will be out. We'll see how long that takes. Sometimes you can return within the same season.

Sometimes it's a six to eight week injury, we will see. And we'll wrap up just by sending our thoughts to Leo Chappelle. The Washington commander's linebacker, we talked about getting stretched off the field. He suffered a fractured neck. And that is one of the scariest worst injuries you can possibly hear in football. Jordan Schultz did report that he's expected to make a full recovery, whether that means playing football again. I don't know if that's what that means,

but either way, he did have movement in his extremities. He is without question going to miss the rest of this season, and the commander's entire team is really banged up before heading to London. But we obviously hate to see all these injuries, but especially a serious one like that. We'll pop in occasionally on these Mondays when our great producer Eric Roberts lets me.

I think he likes it. I think he likes to just work, work, work. He's an absolute grinder. So we'll call that Daily Buzz. We'll do it on Mondays that makes sense. Like on Mondays where we see J.G. McCarthy traded to the Giants. We know we're seeing J.J. McCarthy this year, maybe sometime in prime time. Hit that music, Eric.

Let's get out of here. It's going to be good for content. And you know what? The Giants are two and one. You never know. The schedule's pretty easy. They might stay in the mix for the rest of the year. You know who else is in the mix?

Jordan Rodriguez and myself, we're coming back. On this feed, Monday night football will be live on YouTube. You'll catch us in your ears after that, Eagles and Bears. I'm Brett Coleman. And I'm Trevor Sycamam. If you love football and want to understand what's really happening on the field, check out our show, NFL Pro. Every week we break down the biggest plays, trends, and matchups

using exclusive next-gen stats insights and NFL content you will not find anywhere else. Whether you're new to football, a fantasy football fan or a die-hard fan. NFL Pro will help you analyze the game. like a pro. Listen to NFL Pro on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcast. Whether you're a seasoned NFL fan or new to the game, there's one place to keep up with all of it, the league's newest podcast, the NFL report hosted by me, Andrew Siciliano, it is your home for everything football, breaking news, expert analysis, game picks, and hear from your favorite players too. Join me at an all-star cast of experts for everything you need to

know from around the league. Get new episode to the NFL report Monday, through Friday all season long. Listen to the NFL Report podcast on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Hey, I'm Mike Yam. And I'm Trevor Sycambe, and together we host the NFL Fantasy Football Show. Are you ready to dominate your fantasy league this season? Because if you aren't locked in with us on the NFL fantasy football show,

you're already playing from behind. Whether you're a first-time player or a grizzled vet chasing another championship, we give you the advantage and the confidence you need to make every move count. Listen to the NFL fantasy football show on the IHeart radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcast. This is an IHeart podcast. Guaranteed human.