NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal - Ranking (Almost) Every NFL General Manager
Episode Date: May 26, 2025Gregg Rosenthal is joined by Patrick Claybon to rank every non-first-time General Manager in the NFL. Find out who goes first overall (01:55) and where Les Snead (08:40), Brett Veach (13:20), Jerry Jo...nes (31:20), Omar Khan (44:50), Ryan Poles (51:42), Mickey Loomis (55:20), and every other GM gets taken off the board. Note: time codes approximate. NFL Daily YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/nflpodcastsSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
This is an I-Heart podcast.
Hey, everybody. Daniel Jeremiah here.
And I'm Bucky Brooks.
On Move the 6th, we take you inside the game from breaking down college prospects and NFL rookies
to evaluating team building philosophies, coaching trends, and how front offices construct
winning rosters.
We study the tape, talk to decision makers, and give you a perspective you won't find
anywhere else.
It's everything you need to understand the why behind what happens on Sunday.
Don't miss it. Listen to the Move the Sticks podcast on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
I'm Marcus Grant.
And I'm Michael Florio, and together we host the NFL Fantasy Football Podcast.
Ready to dominate your fantasy league this season?
Then you need the NFL Fantasy Football Podcast, your ultimate source for player news, draft tips, and winning strategies.
Whether you're a rookie manager or a fantasy vet.
We've got the insight to help you crush your opponents.
Listen to the NFL Fantasy Football podcast on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Toyota, the official automotive partner of the NFL.
Visit Toyota.com slash NFL now to learn more.
Welcome to NFL Daily, where my kind of Memorial Day is all about ranking decision makers in the NFL.
I'm Greg Rosenthal. I'm here in the Chris Wesleying podcast studio. And I'm joined by Patrick Claibon. And it is time. Patrick, how long have you been at the company? I have been at the company since October of 2013. Okay. Wow. 12 years in almost. Totally. That is amazing. And you've reached your most important day at the company because we're throwing you into the fire. We are going to determine who are the best NFL.
decision makers right now.
I have waited for a very long time to be a part of the rankings apparatus.
Okay.
And I am here and I'm ready as people are, you know, celebrating their holiday in which way
that they want.
I want them to get into this exercise as well and go through the thought experiments that
we did and try to come up with rankings of your own and tell us where we're wrong.
I mean, I feel a little bit of sarcasm there.
There are some people that turn their noses up at rankings.
they don't like love them as much. I enjoy it. I enjoy making them. I enjoy consuming them.
And yes, it is a perfect Memorial Day. Get out on the beach and either listen to rankings or do some
ranking. So we're going to talk about the GMs, the decision makers, no matter what their title is,
we're not going to count the guys who haven't had a chance to go through a complete year. So that's
James Gladstone of the Jaguars, Mike Borganzi of the Titans, Darren Mugi of the Jets and John Spytec
of the Raiders. I believe that's it.
So we're going to rank the rest of them.
We had a random drawing before the show of
who is going to get the first overall pick.
It feels like an obvious one.
Patrick won the drawing. Who would take you?
With the first pick in our 2025 GM draft,
I would like to select Howie Roseman of the Philadelphia Eagles.
And it feels chalky because it is.
I tried to develop a metric using the weighted,
adjusted value on pro football reference on the draft page for players, which it's going to
skew towards the guys who have been drafting players the longest because it's a cumulative
thing. Like if you draft Callais Campbell, you've got every collective season that Callais has had.
But in that metric in looking at the trades, the decisions, even if you want to ding him for
taking Carson Wince, he ultimately trades Carson Wince, trades that same.
Sam Bradford pick.
They were able to make the AJ Brown trade.
You can't argue with the results of having,
they're being on the cusp of one Super Bowl,
keeping this team rebuilding the roster in one season and one draft,
essentially.
Getting back to the Super Bowl,
the coaching decisions,
it's,
it's Howie for me.
Yeah,
this is the easiest part.
I kind of wanted to get that first pick just because I,
I was curious and I'll ask you after make my pick,
you know,
who you would take second,
because it seems like it's Howie and then it's a big fall of.
I did this exercise annually.
on the website
and I would mix it,
you know,
how we would move up and down
depending on the year,
certainly,
but the last time I did,
it was before the 20, 23 draft,
and he was number one overall back then.
And I'm looking at this of like,
if I could draft a GM
to run my team,
who would I draft?
And he's the guy
who has the most flexibility.
One thing I think he's done really well,
I think doesn't get as much attention
is he's gotten a lot of veterans
who are like just about to pop off
and hit their prime.
Hassan Reddick was one.
Javon Hargrave was one.
Zach Bonn is the most recent one.
But he's not afraid to then keep them
at like a higher rate like Bonn.
And so that's offense,
awesome.
And I looked in the entire defense
are how he draft picks,
by the way,
right now,
the entire starting defense.
And most of the offense,
they're actually,
it's mostly homegrown guys.
It's A.J. Brown.
It's Sequin.
I mean,
another guy picking up
at the right time of his career.
And it's guys that they've grown
inside the system.
All right,
number two.
I am going to take
Brad Holmes
of the Detroit Lions
would have you have taken him
ranking is very similar
great okay
very similar
no that was tough
I had about
four guys that
I wouldn't argue with
if you if you took
second overall
you know here's the thing
with Holmes
the last time again
that I did the GM draft
I will be I mean
the GM rankings
I'll refer to this a little bit
he was seventh
and at the time
I was like
he might be getting
a little bit of a push where
like if you only have a couple years to look at
then you're more likely to have a good couple years
but it's tough to sustain it and keep it going
and he's only done better the last couple of years
we went through the position groups
me and shook ranking
and like they might have the best offensive
line in the league certainly among them
the best safety group best running backs
like they've done a good job planning for now
planning for the future they've had some heat checks
but ultimately like what more can
you do then build this team. If you're a GM and you're going into what this is year five for him,
you want a slow progression. And like they've, you could, you could do a college course on how to
build up a team. And Brad Holmes would be the best professor. Yeah. And I understand people may
have depth concerns considering what happened. I don't think it was a, it should be celebrated that the
lines were able to accomplish what they did. Yeah. Considering the amount of injuries that they had last
season. And you mentioned the chances. I value chances higher here, like taking shots. Because my,
my thoughts with acquiring talent is you have to try to acquire the unique talent. You can't have a
certain form. It's like, I understand. Like to Mayor Gibbs, for instance. Yeah. Like you have your,
Pete Carrolls. Like, we want this height and weight at this position. Like, Sean,
Payton feels that way as well, right? Like, you have your designated, designated guidelines for, for players.
but sometimes players don't fall within those parameters.
And you take a shot out of them.
And that's what I like Brad Holmes in that.
It's funny because the golf trade was a win-win.
And yet, just from the lion's side of things,
it's one of the best transactions in retrospect of the last decade.
That they got a franchise quarterback and then plus some just to take them.
It worked out pretty great for them.
All right.
You're up number three.
With the third pick in the 2025 GM draft,
I am taking Jason Light of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers,
sustained success.
I understand people may think like,
oh, you get Tom Brady and everything.
It's not just Tom.
You had to kind of rebuild that roster
and keep it together.
And also, I did value
the fact that you get honesty
and communication from a GM
where it's not like,
you don't get any cringe comments
from the guys that are going to be taken earlier here.
Like things just make sense.
And the adjusted value number
like ends up being, you know,
my matchwork makes no sense to anybody, including me.
But over 10 years, it is 14.2.
Okay.
In comparison to like somebody like John Schneider, who's at 16, but that's 15 years.
He's been there for a long time.
He's acquired a lot of very good talent.
He's been able to keep that talent.
It hasn't had a lot of success elsewhere.
And that's why I'm taking him here.
That is bold and strong.
No, I think I would have taken him 30.
We are a Jason light draft.
The problem is, you know, you look, and the Bucks haven't won that many games,
the last three years and you know we're picking him over guy over organizations to have one more
games but ultimately I think his his his drafting his is his baker move the offensive line
building up offensive I like that you kind of included that he'd be a good hang or that he'd
represent you well that is important well yeah because I think in terms of relating with not just
media but players as well people respect honesty and you don't want to be doing gamesmanship
It's like, well, we're not going to negotiate through the media.
Like, it's not that particular conversation.
You can be honest and answer a question and also have a good faith negotiation.
I don't see why those things would be contradictory.
Honestly, it's maybe part of the reason he helped get Tom Brady down there.
I had to look up where is he from?
Because he's a funny guy.
He's like, I was like he seems like he'd be from New England, like a kind of a sarcastic New England type.
But no, he's from Nebraska.
Shout out to Jason Light.
Number three, big climb, by the way, you know, back when.
I did it. He was in the middle of this draft. So he's had a very strong couple of years,
but I'm with you. I like how much his veterans want to stay there. I'm taking less Sneed
fourth overall. Now, like a lot of the GMs, it's a combination effort. I mean, they all are
to some degree. I do think Sean McVeigh is very important in player acquisition in
addition to less Sneed. But what Sneed has shown he can do, because remember, he was with
Jeff Fisher back in St. Louis, is he's shown that he can adapt and fit what he's going to do
to what his coach needs. So to me, that is an asset and a point in his favor. And I lean more
heavily on the last few years, ultimately, because that's who I'd want now, who's doing well
with the league as it stands right now. And it's tough to do any better than Jared.
versus Steve Avula, Byron Young,
Kobe Turner, Pooka Nakua
the last few years in the draft.
And it's not like he's been any slouch
and filling holes in terms of free agency
and obviously getting Stafford and all that either.
So he's a strong number four.
And I think a part of things that may get underrated
is Sean McVeigh as a coach as a human being
also requires a little bit of management as well.
Yeah.
And like managing that relationship where it's like
is Sean McVeyer going to be doing media?
Is he going to be continuing coaching?
You're a part of a franchise move from Los Angeles,
from St. Louis to Los Angeles,
like all of these things.
And you get this, right, the memes, the F, the Picks shirts.
But then he comes around and he has like a couple of the best drafts in recent memory
where he's doing all these things.
And the numbers wound up to be 12.6 over a very long amount of time.
But that's good, right?
no it's the highest the highest number uh did wind up being uh john schneider just because of the volume of
years and you know you get russell wilson and and and all those guys i think um oops they didn't have
many picks for a while exactly and he made that strategy work the fact that they that they so clearly
had a strategy to load up on a ton of picks the last few years and then that they've hit on so many yeah
and so he was he was he was high on nine as well and you know i'm running out of my my top
picks.
Great, great hair as well.
Shout out to Thomas Dimitraf because Lesneed gives him a lot of credit.
He's from the Thomas Dim Trey, who was a great GM back in the day,
hasn't been in the league a while, but I'm sure he's very proud of less.
Also from, you know, you follow Alabama.
Shout out to the folks on the lake.
And at one point was a Troy Trojan.
So me and Lesneed.
All right.
You're the number five overall pick.
I am going to Buffalo to drag.
draft Brandon Bean, and ultimately, you can make the arguments like, oh, you draft the
space alien. Yeah, everything's going to look great. Nobody thought that this was going to be
what Josh Allen turned out to be. There's supporting and developing a player and surrounding
him with enough talent, especially the Stefan Diggs move as well to get him that player during
that point in his development and it you know he over eight years in terms of adjusted value
averaging among the picks gets up to 15.3 okay which which for that time frame is almost as
close as you can get and his buffalo bills have been as close as you can get multiple times
where bounces of a ball bad plays weird decisions have ultimately resulted in their runs ending
I think this is a great spot to get him
and so I will take him
I think it's fine
I have three names
ahead of him so it's not like
I have him buried
I think the top of his drafts lately
haven't been good enough
like the he hasn't got enough
primetime talent now they're always drafting
at the back of the first round
and it's not like Dalton Kincaid
for instance like a bad pick
but sometimes I feel like
it's like their style of defense
they're like good not great
and it's a lot of goods
And Dana Jeremiah always says, like, they're searching for doubles, you know,
because the doubles sometimes turn into a home run.
They're searching for that.
I feel like the bills have a lot of like singles to doubles.
And they've settled into having a really good offensive line.
Again, I gave extra points for that.
And so he deserves credit.
It took him a while to get there.
But I had him a few spots lower.
I can feel one fan base when they see these rankings being upset.
So I'm actually going to go off my board and make it.
Oh, wow.
To appease an upset fan base?
somewhat. I'm just moving them up one spot.
They're going to be happy to hear that.
I don't think Brett Veach should, well, they don't actually.
Not only do I disrespect your GM, I also think you know.
I don't disrespect them. I have Brett Veach next.
And in, on my original rankings, I had him sixth and I just kind of want him to be, to be sixth here.
And, uh, you took Bean too early. So he, he, you know, he's got the Super Bowls.
And he goes, oh, yeah, well, he's got my homes. Yeah. He was even more than Brandon Bean.
I think synonymous with that pick because maybe it's just after the fact trying to take some credit.
But by all accounts, was pushing hard for that Mahomes pick throughout.
So he gets credit for Mahomes too.
But more importantly, I think they've done a good job managing how the salary cap's going to work,
how many players you can't have to pay, being flexible, changing depending on the year.
They do a really good job finding the right defensive backs for Steve Spagnolo.
They don't necessarily, like, value offball linebacker.
And so they found really good, cheaper ways with these mid-round picks
or a Drew Tranquil to, like, fill those type of holes while spending big money.
They obviously fixed the offensive line a few years ago.
Now it's taking on, you know, some problems there at left tackle and they aggressively go for it.
I think the Tyreek trade worked out as well as, you know, could possibly work.
I think he needs his wide receivers and his left tackles to hit right now.
But I didn't feel comfortable with him falling any further.
yeah there was there there was times where it's like you have this tremendous opportunity
because you have patrick mahomes in the problem of this career and they were just kind of
trying to squeak by at other spots that were a little frustrating right it's hard it's so
isn't it impossible it's because of the salary cap to be good everywhere so the fact that
they've won at least 12 no they did win 11 games in 23 but you know at least 12 12 11 or more since
2018 yeah that's pretty strong yeah and the you know the the numbers the numbers also uh bear that
out where he he winds up right in between uh jason light and the play the the GM i'm going to pick next
okay and it's not all about the draft either we're talking free agency we're talking trades and
i think beach has been pretty flexible and doing well in those areas as well although let's be real
Andy Reed has close to as much power, and I think say in terms of the personnel as almost any coach on this entire list. So Andy Reid gets a shout out here. And when we say Brett Beach, it's sort of a stand in for Brett Beach and Andy as a team. All right, you're up. And I think that goes for my next pick, which will be John Lynch of the San Francisco 49. Wow. Who, again, some of these years were shocking to me that it's eight years for John Lynch in Santa Clara coming in 12.3.
a little bit behind less need and in terms of the talent acquisition.
Of course,
they get a big boosts, right?
They found a starting quarterback,
the very last pick in the draft.
Some of the contract management stuff has taken a while,
but they ultimately get it done.
Might be ownership there too.
Yeah.
So that could be related.
But when you're a contender for an extended period of time,
you are,
I guess some folks aren't like,
we just discussed
Bean, right?
And his acquisition strategies,
which I think that they've taken shots,
but the 49ers have absolutely taken shots.
And that era may be over now,
but I do give them credit
because to be that close for that long
is something worth celebrating.
Yeah.
And I think that when you look at the 49ers
over the last handful of years,
it's still true now.
It was true last year even when they won six games.
One of the first things you think about
them is, wow, that's a really talented team. And so you got to give, you got to give the GM ultimately
and Kyle Shanahan. Again, Kyle Shane Han has a lot to do with this. I've been so, I've always felt
like their relationship. It was an arranged marriage and they've really made it work. And I'm,
I'm actually impressed that it has stayed together as long, and a little surprise that it stayed together
as long as it has, but very talented guys. They're good at finding guys that work on the offensive
line, maybe a little, I don't know.
I give Kyle Shannon maybe more credit than most coaches, but John Lynch was seventh,
by the way, back in 2023.
So he was right at the same spot.
It almost deserves its own podcast on how we would separate the coaches from the GMs and
these things.
I was surprised that you didn't take that your Ravens is Eric DeCosta next.
I think they've done a good job rebuilding on the fly while winning a ton of game.
they have changed their roster each offseason, really for the last three off seasons,
especially the two before this one, about as aggressively as any team had to because they just had
guys aging out. And he actually hasn't had great drafts, Eric DeCosta. I don't think. We'll see
what your numbers say. He had that Kyle Hamilton draft with Linderbaum, which was fantastic.
But otherwise, it's been pretty mediocre, which is why, you know, for me, he falls this far,
although I had him a little higher on my list. But he is good. I think at,
getting guys at the margins to help his team, whether it's a veteran that you add to the mix
last minute or just little additions, mid-round picks, stuff like that, I think he's a very
solid GM. Well, yeah, he's solid. I did have him a couple of spots down. Some of that was probably
lingering frustration over the Lamar deal where I felt like the window could have been extended
and you could have gotten that deal done earlier instead of waiting for the Eagles to make the
Hertz offer and being like, this looks good, I think there could have been a more competitive
offer made earlier on in the process in the process.
People forget how crazy it was two years ago. Remember the Falcons were like, nope, we don't
want Lamar Jackson. Remember Lamar Jackson requesting a trade? It was dark days. And all that
was very unnecessary to me. As well as the public conversation about the difficulty of the
negotiation when it's like you make an offer, the player decides if he wants it or not. It's even
less difficult when there's there's no agent involved uh you know depending on who they're working
for most often themselves but there's there there was that and i think don't get patrick going on
his anti-agent screens one of one of my favorites people are probably sick of it uh at this point
it comes out to six years uh nine point three uh okay on the scale where it's um you have to give
him credit for the trade for roquan um yeah you know pque ends up leaving and going to
to the Steelers there, but he makes the Roquan trade.
Core pieces of the team look good.
And it's, you know, they're going to have a chance every year.
The most important reason for that, he flirted with not having on the team anymore
to save how much money I don't know.
Right.
And technically that he did draft Lamar Jackson, at least.
He was there.
That is maybe like a small demerit on the Costa that Ozzie is literally over his
shoulder still.
Because if you see at the Combine, there's Ozzy.
But they're a combination, so they all get credit.
De Costa was 13th on my list, by the way, a few years ago.
You're up next with the 9th.
I know I'm going way off of your board.
I'm going to have to defend this with passion.
And I will.
I will take Terry Fontno.
Oh, my God.
I will.
Stop it.
I will.
See, now we can't send out the, you know how they've been sending out like a list with
the rankings, and I have been afraid that something like this would happen. I can't send
this list out now that has fontad O'9. I literally have him like 20. I am sure that you do. I am sure
that you do. And I am sure that you also have Mickey Loomis at the very near the bottom, if not,
if not the absolute bottom of our exercise. Yeah, that's true. And so are we giving Mickey Loomis
credit for 2017? I'm not.
anymore. I'm saying who I want to hire right now. I don't want to hire Terry Fonno. He hasn't done
well. Why would Terry Fondano be nine? Because I wanted to come in this with a clear eye,
develop a metric. And he has assembled in four years, 10.29, you know, scoring higher than
Eric DeCosta, relatively scoring higher than a lot of people on this list by acquiring very, very good
talent that has played and played early and had success.
And I think that, of course, the albatross is going to be this contract that I feel doesn't get done without ownership involvement to the extent that you draft a quarterback.
Yeah, that you draft a quarterback immediately after the deal because, like, that was something that the boss wanted.
Yeah, but it's not all about drafting.
It's about everything that they do.
Well, yeah.
It becomes more difficult to do everything when you've got all this money devoted into a quarterback that was literally in recovery.
like post-surgery recovery when they got the deal done.
I just mean if another GM on draft day is saying like,
hmm, where can we get a good deal from?
Who's going to give up too much in a in a pick?
I'm calling Terry Fontenow.
He's given up that extra first-round pick.
He's been there for four years.
So a big thing for me is a GM in their third season.
You want some proof of concept of what you've done.
And right now he is entering year five.
They've had a losing record every time.
He botched the first head coaching hire.
And so I'm putting that on him ultimately.
The second one, like, we'll see how that goes.
He has the Kirk trade.
The high picks have been fine.
I wouldn't say, like, we'll see on PennX.
Pitts has been not a good pick.
London has been a very good pick.
And Bejohn's been a good pick too.
So, you know, that's about what you would expect.
Maybe a little better than you would expect.
He brought in Jesse Bates.
It's not all terrible.
But I knocked him big time.
for not going after Lamar Jackson
and for going for Deshaun Watson.
And I don't care if it was ownership
I'm putting Terry Fontno in that big bucket.
Yeah. And again, it's the difficulty
of separating the owner and in terms of...
They wanted Deshaun Watson.
They didn't want Lamar Jackson
and they haven't had a winning record.
I think the individuals in charge
of these institutions were the ones
responsible for the DeShan Watson fiasco,
including the one that took the blame in Cleveland for it.
But there's...
It's just if we haven't seen proof of concept for Atlanta and the team that, like, we both
agree that Jason Light belongs in the top echelon of these GMs.
Yeah.
And they were right there with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers during the season in which they had
to start a rookie quarterback late.
So like, how is that not proof of concept?
I get that you, you don't want to just rank vibes.
I'm okay.
Like, I don't look at it as vibes.
I look at it as taking all the information that you have.
and trusting that you can mash it all up
and then come up with kind of what's an opinion
and take some things out of context.
I would say what's the best thing about the Falcons
the last handful of years?
I would say the offensive line.
Fontno had nothing to do with that.
So that's like the one part of the team that was good.
He hasn't been able to build up a good defense.
They were starting Taylor Heineckee and Desmond Ritter dog.
Right.
Well, that's partly on him.
He's entering year five.
I, man, it's tough.
he you got you want to see some a better proof of concept than fontenose had after four years a big season
in Atlanta Greg is going to turn me into a bird how could be the biggest falcons fan in the world
yeah I have uh I have him at 23 ranked 23 we got we got to pick up the pace I got to make a pick
no don't be sorry I mean do be sorry that you took fontano I'm loving my brian kuducans value
here at number 10 had him eighth overall a couple years ago
Again, a guy who I think has shown an ability to find a good offensive line,
like finding really good players in the second, third round, man, that is like one of the
toughest things to do and they've done it consistently. So that is a great base to
build up. They need to transition from kind of being that team that's the youngest team
in the league every year and being a little more talented. He's had six first
rounders right now, Patrick, on his defense. You would want the defense to be better than it is. And
you'd want to have better overall players considering the investment there. So that's a little bit
of a knock. But overall, you give them credit for the Jordan Love Pick and give them credit for a lot
else. So I like Goody here at number 10. Yeah. They've put a lot of talent in a lot of places almost.
And also they've been able to make moves in free agency. You're still shaking your head.
I am. I am because I'm just thinking, I'm just thinking about the way I'm going to have to couch this
in a tweet. Or if we like, uh, if we make, uh, if we make.
a board we got to put a big asterick one controversial Patrick made this pick it doesn't count yeah
sure I'm being me yeah no I it's it's not it's not mean to me it just I look at I look at talent on
the roster that's the same conversation we're having about Brian Gutikens to where it's like
ultimately like how he's the only one that can take the credit to being good right now like
Brett Brett Brecht as well like those things the it's fair if if the Falcons go 12 and 5 this year
They're rolling. I expect Patrick to order some sort of like Terry Fontno T-shirt.
I don't know if we could do that. Let's take a quick break and we'll move on from the top 10.
What's up everybody? Daniel Jeremiah here.
And I'm Bucky Brooks. On Move the Sticks, we take you inside the game from scouting reports and player development to team-building philosophy's coaching trends and how front-off
construct winning rosters.
Every week, we study the tape,
talk to decision makers,
and share the insights you won't find anywhere else.
It's the kind of conversation that connects the dots,
from college football prospects to the NFL stars of tomorrow.
We break down the draft,
analyze matchups,
and evaluate how teams put it all together on game day.
Plus, we dig in the coaching strategies,
roster construction,
and the trends that shape the league year after year.
Whether you're a die-hard fan
or just love understanding the game on a deeper level,
We give you the full picture.
If you want insight that goes beyond the box score, this podcast is for you.
Don't miss it.
Listen to the Move the Six podcast on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Hey, this is Matt Jones.
Now, I'm Drew Franklin.
And this is NFL cover zero.
We're just here to try to give you an NFL perspective a little bit different.
Did you see the Colts Pretzel?
That was my other big takeaway from that game.
What was that?
Oh, my.
We think NFL coverage should be informative and entertaining.
And twice a week, that is exactly what you're going to get.
Listen to NFL Cover Zero with Matt Jones and Drew Franklin on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcast.
Toyota, the official automotive partner of the NFL.
Visit Toyota.com slash NFL now to learn more.
I'm Marcus Grant.
And I'm Michael F. Florio.
and together we host the NFL Fantasy Football Podcast.
Ready to dominate your fantasy league this season?
Then you need the NFL Fantasy Football Podcast,
your ultimate source for player news, draft tips, and winning strategies.
Whether you're a rookie manager or a fantasy vet,
we've got the insight to help you crush your opponents.
Listen to the NFL Fantasy Football Podcast
on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
Toyota, the official automotive partner of the NFL,
Visit Toyota.com slash NFL now to learn more.
Back on NFL Daily.
Studio still shaking with the reverberation.
Most controversial thing.
The pick heard around the world.
Some people see it's not really even appropriate to do on Memorial Day that you're,
you're not respecting the troops by making the final pick.
I've been accused of many things, Greg.
Let's go number 11.
Who do you got?
Now I don't know what this system.
See, if we wanted to really get off track,
this may be a sign where you've got to combine the analytics side
with the common sense side.
You know, the two sides.
That's what's being done here, Greg.
You can't totally rely on the analytics.
That's what's being done here.
Just because you disagree.
Doesn't mean that's not what's being done.
I will go down by the numbers to the next pick.
No, because this is.
was my rankings. I will take Nick Casario here, who is assembled a 9.1 over four years,
where it feels like Nick Casario has been in Houston for at least nine years. I was shocked to find
out. It's been how many head coaches that it's only been for. And yeah, if not for the precipitous
turnover and head coaches, maybe it would have been a little higher had they actually been devoted
to winning football games before now. But I just think,
it's a very good roster.
It suits the coaching staff very well.
And these players, some of them, you know,
haven't had success elsewhere.
They've come to Houston and they've been able to accomplish some things.
And so I like the way this team is built.
Yeah, that's a great call that they've helped to make other teams players.
That's a great sign of a good coaching staff and a good front office.
Yeah, you know, I'm not going to lie.
He had me.
He had me in the first few years.
I thought he was a bum
Casario.
But they got two rookies of the year,
the year after that,
their secondary is outrageously good.
Lasseter, Bullock, Petrie, Stingley,
all guys that Casario drafted.
He drafted Nico Collins in the first draft.
The De Nio Hunter pickup was good.
I'm with you.
Adam Peters is going to be my pick
here at number 12.
This one's tricky.
He's only been there for a year and a half,
but I think you can only grade on what he's done.
And Jane Daniels gets the most credit for that.
But Adam Peters, you know, he took Jane Daniels.
I mean, he had great options between him and Drake May,
but he took Jane and Daniels, obviously, a franchise changing pick.
But a lot of good moves around the edges.
The Santer still pick was good.
Finding guys kind of like Bobby Wagner and Dorrance Armstrong
and Frankie Louvre, who could just step in right away.
So what can you really say?
I didn't like his picks.
subjectively, I mean, his free agent pickups this off season, but I really didn't put much
into that because we don't know how they're going to work out. So I think it's unfair to put
on him that I didn't really like love him. They might work out great. So I put him here at 12.
Yeah. It makes sense at 12. The number, it's right. For one year, it was the best one year you could
possibly have, right? So you get, you get a quarterback, you go to the NFC championship game. He starts
every single game.
That's going to skew things.
Like if you made this a 10,
if he had that level of success,
the numbers,
I know the numbers make sense to nobody.
He'd be like 30 points ahead of everybody.
He'd be the greatest.
Yeah, GMO of all time.
If he had that every year,
if he drafted Jayden Daniels every year.
And that's going to be a possible.
Like,
yeah.
Like nobody might have that level of success.
Like,
it was almost like,
in terms of value,
like Puka had a similar level of season,
but that's not even at the quarterback position.
So it's crazy.
Yeah.
See, you,
you were looking at the entire,
tenure. I'm definitely leaning a little more towards lately, so I'm curious who you're going with
next. I am going with the owner of the Dallas Cowboys. Okay. And Jerry Jones. It is, he would be
significantly higher in terms of talent acquisition, uh, because I couldn't even do the full math on
his tenure because that would be crazy and the numbers would be, uh, just wouldn't make any sense.
But, but just in terms of the recent value in all of these players, he should be higher. But the,
the way that these contract decisions get dragged out and they'll go into the they'll go into a year like
having money to spend and not spend it there's some questionable things but the the talent that has
been on the roster during this window has been good enough uh to to to contend for a super bowl they
haven't they haven't done it but all you can all you can hope to have is the ability to do that and
and i think you know despite being the person who signs all the checks uh they've been able to do it yeah
item 10th last time around.
I definitely had him a few spots lower than you,
but nothing crazy.
Similar negatives to you.
His hot streak in the draft has ended, though.
And so, like, that's a big deal.
He had the Parsons draft with,
you know, Diggi Zua was in that draft.
But the best picks in the last three drafts or so
is Tyler Smith, like Ferguson.
Like, we got to see some more results out of these recent picks.
I did like the pickings move, though.
So I think that that's fair.
Overall, they've done a good job bringing in high-in talent.
Man, I really struggle.
I do, like, go off vibes a little bit, and I'm on the clock here,
and I'm looking at my board, and it says one thing,
and yet sometimes you've got to be on the clock to feel what's really in your heart,
and I want Sean Payton and George Payton now.
I don't want to wait around any longer.
I think Sean Payton and George Payton are bringing a level of performance,
professionalism that I'm feeling comfortable with. Now, is it Peyton or Patton? I keep forgetting.
It's Peyton. They're both Peyton. Yeah, it's George Payton, but they're not spelled the same.
Yeah. Look, he brought in Russell Wilson. That's a pretty big knock on him. And so they haven't had a lot of picks since Russell Wilson because they lost so many in that trade. But they hit on Bo Necks. They hit on Riley Moss. And then I really like some of the free agency moves that they've made, Zach Allen, Jonathan Franklin Myers. Payton was there. George
Payton when they drafted Quinn Miners, who's turned into an all-pro. And what you see with
Sean Payton, and this is where I think his ability to merge personnel and coaching matters is like
some of the mid-round guy, like he'll add like a Marvin Mims. He's going to find a role for
Marvin Mims, I think, to be a contributor and a productive player. I know he's a young player,
but just as an example of like he's going to find roles. So I like him in this spot. I wouldn't
want him in the top 10 or anything, but I think he's like a floor razor. Yeah.
It slots in and there's a, it gives me an opportunity to take a GM that I didn't think
that I would be drafting, but I'm taking, I'm going to take John Schneider.
That's who I just passed.
Here, after 15 years, the numbers come up to 16.1, but again, when you have that amount of time,
it's going to, it's going to lift the numbers up.
Like, again, Jerry Jones would have been way off of this list.
I mean, looking back where it was Bruce Irvin, Russell Wilson, and Bobby Wagner,
in one draft.
They didn't have a lot of picks
that year,
but through a stretch,
like they get Richard Sherman
the year before,
assembling one of the more notable units
that we'll remember
from this entire era of football
and the Legion of Boom,
where I know Pete was a huge factor in that,
and judging by the way things
have gone in the past few years,
they probably had very different visions,
but they were able to collaborate
and make it work,
and this feels like a good spot for it.
Yeah, I wanted to rank
lower, frankly, but
then I looked at the drafts lately
and you got to give
him credit. Like, Devin Witherspoon and
Jackson Smith and Jigba, that's a great draft.
The Charles Crossboy, Mafei,
Rik Willen. Now I know Pete's still there at that
point. You know, there was a slump before that,
but the offensive line,
you got to hold against him. But he
he's made some good pickups like Leonard, Williams, Ernest
Jones were good pickups. I think
the first, you know, they should have kept Gina Smith,
so I'm kind of knocking them for that,
but I also think
it's hard to separate
like who gets credit for Gina
so I would give more to
peak your out
I think that like
when I want with Sean Peyton though
like over Schneider for instance
there is something about he's
he's now the man there
in a way that I'm not like
fully comfortable with
who's a survivor
he's like feeling himself
and I think I want like some of these other guys
instead I don't know why
because of it just just off vibes
man this we're in the middle
of the draft it's tricky
you can get people feeling different types of ways
about Duke Tobin of the Bengals
that he could be
at the very close to the bottom of this list
or closer to the top
because of what he's been working with
in Cincinnati, it's a difficult situation.
I think that right in the middle is okay.
His offensive line fix
really has just only gone okay.
You've got to blame him a lot
for what's happened on the defense
because they've put a ton of resources there,
a ton of swings.
Hasn't totally worked.
I think over his entire
higher stretch run, he probably would be ranked a little higher for me. But I think I'm leaning,
I'm not really giving much credit to something well, you did seven, eight years ago at this point.
I'm thinking more about the last handful of years. And they've been mediocre. I think they need to
do better building around Joe Burrow. Yeah, this was a spot where I was considering Duke Tobin as well.
I know that, you know, there's frustrations with the, the Trey Hendrickson deal. But he didn't even mention
Duke Tobin
my name
it was like
it was a coach
you know
some communication issues
it is in his availability
and talking about his contract
and I understand that
they got the T
and Jemar deals
to deal with
what's very nebulous
what Tobin
like Tobin is
Tobin is clearly
running the draft
but I think this is more
of an ownership
right team than most
not you know
not as much as the
the Cowboys
but closer to that
than most teams
out there. They're old school, the Browns.
Yeah. All right. Teams send us
power percentages for decisions
so that we can know.
I will go to our
relatively newer guys
and take Monty Austin Fort.
Okay. Of the Arizona Cardinals.
It's almost like you're looking on my
sheet. That was next. I thought that would be cool.
Well, I mean,
do you want him? I'm just going to take...
I don't want to run a foul of your list
as I have. Oh, stop. Notably earlier.
Stop.
where it's I've committed a crime.
I feel bad.
No,
don't feel bad.
Not for me.
You know,
I'm fine.
Terry Fano may want to come after you,
but Jason Light might,
you know,
he'll be happy.
Yeah, he'll be happy.
Yeah,
the foul goods are trash.
Mickey,
I'm sure you're a good friend as well.
We'll love it.
I don't know how Dan Morgan will feel.
But yeah,
if we're talking about Moni Awesome for it,
it needs more data for him and some of the,
you know,
the guys I have in this range.
but I think taking that situation
and going in with a new coach
and trying to figure out
how to handle your quarterback situation
and all these things
bringing us this
this search bar of a defense
that we're starting to learn
a little bit more about
I like the free agent acquisitions
as well this year
so it makes sense
I'll take money here
I really like their off season
I'm trying not to put too much weight on that
because we haven't seen how it's going to work out
but I really like their draft
they've hurt me before
I like their off season
I like that he's gotten contributors
in the draft like Paris Campbell was a good one
and some of the guys in the secondary
like Max Melton
and Michael Wilson
and who's Garrett Williams
like they got these guys that aren't household names
search bar
but I think he's done a good job
like I don't
he's entering year three
so this is like the push year
but there's not much you can really fall
in Montiason for it
I think that's good
I don't want you to feel like
you can't just draft
as if no one's watching
as if I'm not watching
This is not, I don't want this to be,
this is what we're doing.
Like, I'm listening on audiobook to this kind of tell-all memoir about Facebook.
And it's amazing.
It's by Sarah Wyn Williams.
It's incredibly written.
She's a very trustworthy narrator.
And everything that you could possibly think,
how bad it would be to be in the inner inner circle of Facebook.
Mark Zuckerberg, it's, it's worse than you think. Does it go over Myanmar? Um, it is about
foreign relations. It hasn't gotten there, but that was her job. So it, I, I, I maybe haven't
gotten to that part, but yeah, it is electric for a nonfiction book. Anyways, it's not unique to
Facebook, but I think it was true, uh, among her bosses, you know, how, how little everyone
would say honestly to, to the bosses, especially Cheryl Sandberg, uh, back in the
I don't want to be the Cheryl Sandberg or Mark Zuckerberg of NFL Daily, where you're not just drafting who you want to draft.
No, as evidenced by recent history, that is what I'm doing.
And, you know, go Falcons.
We have a special guest producer here today, Chris Bobona, in the chair.
Did you follow the reasoning at all of what I was talking about with the Facebook memoir analogy?
well yeah because obviously Patrick always is like on the NFL lines he doesn't like want to branch out
and you being like Facebook Zuckerberg are always on him okay maybe I was just trying to say like
did that come through is that too much of a but you got to let Patrick out let oh wait that's what
we don't want to do that um I mean it depends to a degree I want Patrick to continue to work
here at NFL media and with me as like long as
possible. And so we don't want to let them totally out. But Terry Fon, though,
it's like mostly. The book is called Careless People, by the way. And it's been a
big time bestseller, better than I could have expected. All right. Next up, this is where the
list, it gets tough for me. I'm going to go Joe Hortiz. Just so far, so good. I kind of,
I just like the cut of his jib. He's the Chargers GM for those.
who don't know. Good in front of a microphone.
I think it's made a lot of really like sound
decisions so far.
They found some late round picks
at cornerback.
Cam Hart's heaps still that I like.
I think their first round picks have been solid.
They got a little more aggressive.
I'm not crazy in free agency this year.
It's more just an incomplete,
but so far so good.
And for what it's worth,
like the guys that they brought in
contributed to a team that improved quite a bit.
So Harbaugh obviously gets the most
credit for that, but he's right there with Jim Harba. Yeah, it makes perfect sense, uh, especially with like
the potential to, for things to change, like Monty and as well as Joe Hortiz are just kind of right
there. Right, which is maybe I should have put him lower, but I don't know. I was just like, so far his
batting averages is good to me. All right, you're up next. In terms of winning, uh, things have been
pretty good for the Minnesota Vikings, uh, here as of late. So I'll take Quesi, Odofo, Mensa. Um, it's,
I understand like if you're talking about draft value there's been some trades that have kind of limited things like in my metric right when you have like a Dallas Turner as well as a first round quarterback that's not going to play it you know you're not able to get any value for those guys but there is potential for those things to change and you know at this point we wouldn't be talking about Sam Darnold starting
like being a surefire starter,
getting the contract that he got
and dethroning Gino in his position,
if not for, you know,
this front office's efforts as well as,
you know,
Kevin O'Connell obviously plays a role,
but they work together.
So I'm sharing the credit and the value there.
Yeah, honestly,
I'm laughing because I sort of forgot about Questi
and I would have taken him earlier.
Now, I think,
judging by the coach, you know,
draft that we had,
like I took him fourth overall.
Questi wouldn't have been close to that height.
It wouldn't have been in my top 10
because his drafts ultimately have been below average on, by and large.
Yeah.
I would say, like, if we were going vibes and I didn't try to look at numbers on this,
I would have had Quessie way higher.
But free agency, they took, they got Jonathan Grenard.
They essentially like let Hunter walk and got Grinard a younger player who I think fit
the scheme that they have.
Not that he's better than Daniel Hunter, but he came in at less money and was a really good
free agency pickup.
Van Ginkl, great pickup.
I think he deserves some credit for that.
But yeah, some of their better, like, young players are...
Blake Cashman was another pickup.
He probably should have gone, like, a little higher.
Apologies to Quessie.
But, yeah, this is fine.
What are you going to disrespect?
The other people are around here.
I'll take Omar Khan now.
Only three drafts running the Pittsburgh Steelers.
The more that you hear from reporters,
I think Mike Tomlin has as much personnel
power as he's ever had. He's probably had always a little more than we realize when he worked
with Kevin Colbert. But that was someone that had been in the organization for two decades. And now
he's working with a younger GM. So I think Tomlin has a big hand in these drafts. And lately they've
been good. I mean, it's kind of crazy he's this late because like Joey Porter Jr., Keanu Benton,
Herbig, you know, they've gotten some good offensive linemen and Zach Frazier and McCormick. We'll see
about Fautano.
He's got to see
how Brojik Jones
whether he's healthy.
But the drafts have been
pretty good.
They don't do a lot
in free agency.
They made the DK trade,
which overall I like.
The quarterback position
obviously is a huge negative.
And so he pays for that.
If it wasn't for the quarterback,
if he had,
I'm trying to think of like,
like,
if he had traded for Gino Smith
a couple years ago or something,
and they had to fix the quarterback position
to like an above average level
a couple years ago,
he'd probably be in my top 10.
but that's a pretty big knock on the team.
Yeah, you've had a very long time to develop a plan at that position
and other teams have found their quarterbacks.
Some have found multiple quarterbacks during that time frame,
and you need to address it.
All right, let's take a quick break,
and we're going to wrap up the draft after this.
What's up, everybody?
Daniel Jeremiah here.
And I'm Bucky Brooks.
On Move the Sticks, we take you inside.
Inside the game, from scouting reports and player development, to team building philosophies, coaching trends in how front offices construct winning rosters.
Every week, we study the tape, talk to decision makers, and share the insights you won't find anywhere else.
It's the kind of conversation that connects the dots, from college football prospects to the NFL stars of tomorrow.
We break down the draft, analyze matchups, and evaluate how teams put it all together on game day.
Plus, we dig in the coaching strategies, roster construction, and the trends that show.
shape the league year after year.
Whether you're a diehard fan or just love understanding the game on a deeper level,
we give you the full picture.
If you want insight that goes beyond the box score, this podcast is for you.
Don't miss it.
Listen to the Move the Six podcast on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
Hey, this is Matt Jones.
I'm Drew Franklin.
And this is NFL Cover Zero.
We're just here to try to give you an NFL
perspective a little bit different.
Did you see the Colts Pretzel?
That was my other big takeaway from that game.
What was that?
Oh, my.
We think NFL coverage should be informative and entertaining.
And twice a week, that is exactly what you're going to get.
Listen NFL Cover Zero with Matt Jones and Drew Franklin on the I Heart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcast.
Toyota, the official automotive partner of the NFL.
Visit Toyota.com slash NFL now to learn more.
I'm Marcus Grant, and I'm Michael Fulrio, and together we host the NFL fantasy football podcast.
Ready to dominate your fantasy league this season?
Then you need the NFL fantasy football podcast, your ultimate source for player news, draft tips, and winning strategies.
Whether you're a rookie manager or a fantasy vet, we've got the insight to help you crush your opponents.
Listen to the NFL Fantasy Football podcast on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcast, or wherever,
you get your podcasts.
Toyota, the official automotive partner of the NFL.
Visit Toyota.com slash NFL now to learn more.
Back on NFL Daily, we have drafted 20 men whose job it is to draft to be evaluated.
Not so easy when the shoes on the other foot, huh guys?
You don't like being picked late.
Turn that microscope on yourself, look into yourselves.
I do feel bad.
You know, somewhat bad, but this is what happens when you get to the end of these lists.
I felt this way about the coach too.
I was like, we're in pretty good shape.
Like, I don't think the next few GMs are, for the most part, have done like a terrible job.
It's kind of like having a late night show, as Jimmy Kimmel, I heard one say, like, if you still have the show, that's a success.
So like, if you are a GM, that's a success.
And especially a couple of these have been around a little while.
That's a success for them.
Yeah, your job is to keep your job.
And a lot of times, you know, we've got some person, you know, people think personalities are
exclusive to players. Managing relationships with ownership is probably an important part of the
job. And if you, you know, if you have a job, you know, that that's what, that's what people like
to do. Well, the older you get, you realize that's so much more important or telling for who
gets put forward or sticks around. Like, sucking up to bosses really helps. I would like to take
Chris Greer.
who has amassed 13.7 on my metric for a very long time since 2016 where you've
get a lot of good players who contribute. The problem is some of those players wind up
contributing in places that are not Miami. One notable example would be of, you know,
they make the trade from, of Micka Fitzpatrick. They get a first round pick. They ultimately
take Tua in the first round there, but that wasn't the pick that they traded.
It took Austin Jackson with that.
They took Austin Jackson with the Minka Trade first round pick.
And they've been contenders.
They've assembled a good team just haven't.
Maybe three or four wins, which is crazy over the course of these years, could have
changed his position in my rankings a whole lot.
But I think relative to the rest of the ones that are.
available? I like getting Chris Square here.
Yeah, this is around where I had him as well. I had him 15th last time.
I think the hardest thing to measure here would be you need to have the sum of your parts
be, you know, the team be greater than just the sum of their parts. And I think they would be
the opposite of that. I think they've made a lot of moves that individually look like they worked
out pretty well. But overall, this organization has always been a little less than the sum of
their parts to me. And so I think that's on the GM a little bit, like a lack of a coherent plan,
like going from one thing to the next to the other and maybe it doesn't all totally add up,
even though like Jalen Ramsey made sense and Tyree Kill made sense. Like all these made sense and
yet they don't, it doesn't all come together. Which is why these like Mika Fitzpatrick,
Andrew Van Ginkle, Christian Wilkins, like all of these guys who wind up being contributors elsewhere.
Like you had the ability to take them, but you should you should be able to make that work.
Right, like, by it, according to the local reports,
they really wanted, like, Kaleas Campbell back this year,
and that was going to be an important player for them,
and they didn't get him back.
And so if we're going to give credit to a Jason Light
for making an atmosphere where players want to stay
because they like the organization, the situation,
we sort of have to give the dolphins a little bit of a knock.
But Chris Greer hanging on.
I think they need to win this year for him to feel good.
I'm going to go Chris Ballard next.
infamously in my own mind, I ranked him number one overall, like back in 2016 or
I forget what year it was where I thought they had the most talented roster in the entire
NFL. Do we have a graphic from that? Because I'll put that up with if you try to
shan me for my Terry Fonton. I mean, it's, it's pretty, it's pretty embarrassing. He was 18th
the last time I did this exercise. So it had faded. We'll see the offensive line,
which has been a strength and was probably Ballard's,
you know, the best thing that he did now doesn't look as good.
The weapons, which were bad, now look pretty good.
On paper, I think this team kind of makes sense.
I'm not like in love, like, his public persona,
sometimes a little prickly or condescending.
And the relationship with the coaches and the,
and the fans and stuff has been up and down.
So that's a little bit of a negative to me, too, for Chris Ballard.
Yeah.
I'm right there with you
the idea of making your quarterback try
extra hard by bringing in Daniel Jones
and kind of it's like
exclusively Richardson's responsibility
I didn't yeah
I direct anyone that's curious
I mean you could go to NFL.com or you could
go to an side.com article
from April of 2021 which says
king of the draft Colts Chris Ballard
named best drafting GM in the NFL
and yeah that was
by me.
So, you know.
Got him.
He had a good run and I might have overrated him there.
Number 22, you're up.
I will take Ryan Poles at number 22.
Just purely based off of liking the, I see the vision more so than some of the remaining
choices, where I probably could have in hindsight, probably could have taken a, a,
a better GM.
Regret while he's on the clock.
That's rare.
I think it's fine.
You turn the card in.
I think that would have been my pick
for what it's worth,
which isn't much.
Yeah.
The options get limited
down here at the bottom.
Yeah,
the hiring of Iber Fluse
is something that it takes,
it takes its skill to survive.
And that was his guy.
He really wanted Eber Fluse.
So that's a negative.
And who knows,
right?
there was a very, very interesting article, I believe, around December about the influence of
agents on the coaching searches, where, again, you know, my particular soapbox might have come in.
And so, but again, we don't know who's ultimately making all these. It's the general manager's job
to hire in these spots. And I do believe, based on this offseat, this has been the best
Ryan Poles offseason
that does warrant a little
more belief than previous years.
15 and 36 overall
since he took over as GM
so not a lot of progress.
Some good draft picks were like
Kyler Gordon
and Gervyn Dexter.
He picked up Montes Sweat
and Tremaine Edmins and Free Agency.
This is a team that's better on paper
than they've really ever been
on the field.
But they're pretty solid on paper.
That was actually picked 23.
I led you astray.
And we are 224.
We have four more to go.
I'll go with Elliot Wolf here just because
there's not...
He had a disastrous draft other than Drake May,
but they did get Drake May.
Pretty big asterisk.
Pretty bad free agency period his first time around.
The way that they handled the offensive line,
it was all bad.
Also, I think he's lost a significant amount of power.
I don't truly believe he is the GM in a way that really
And that would be true of anyone else on this list, but he has the title. So, does he have the title?
I don't even know anymore. The Patriots, being Patriots, like, ultimately, like, I don't even believe that Elliot Wolf is running this personnel department, but he is the guy who's doing the interviews and on the podium afterwards right now, which is messy.
So that's part of my skepticism. But I think it's, I think it's Mike Ravel. And I think it's Mike Ravel's guys that he brought in that actually might have more juice than Elliot Wolf.
Oh, I don't know.
Just because he hasn't done that much,
I'll go L.A. Wolf, and he delivered me,
Drake, so that made me be happy.
All right, number 25.
At a 1.8, W-AVA, my tortured metric,
Dan Morgan, after one year, you know,
it's really not enough info to get into.
I do, I do see some sort of a vision.
I was surprised, but I've been talked into
the Ted McMillan pick where I really thought
they needed to go defense.
And, yeah, I like him more than the remaining choices.
So I'm going to take them.
Yeah, he's just a will see.
You can't really kill him.
His drafts so far don't look like amazing,
but he literally only had won the free agency period.
Like, I kind of liked what he did this year,
but he's just sort of a,
we almost shouldn't have ranked Dan Morgan
or maybe Elliot Wolfe,
just because they haven't been around long enough.
It's tough to evaluate.
Mickey Loomis has been around a long time,
and this is where I'm leaning into the last few years.
I'm really only just grading him on the post-Shaun-Payton era.
Like, he used to rank pretty high,
high on my list.
Like, he would be in the top 10 sometimes, you know, top 15.
They had some great drafts.
Right now, he's just aiming for the middle, hanging on to players, I believe, too long,
having a weird obsession that ended up being unrequited with Derek Carr, like, and Dennis
Allen, just bad, not who you want running your team.
Because he was around it long enough to make a handful of amazing draft picks and he won a
Super Bowl title. That's why he gets ahead of just the last couple guys on this list for me.
But I'd be fine wherever you put him at the back end. At this point, I think, I don't know.
He's not even, he's just a figurehead. I don't even know what's going on.
And with our last two, I do know where you stand on this. I have seen one, you know,
Andrew Barry's shot in. We have Joe Shane and Andrew Barry are on the only two people left.
Kevin Stefanski and Andrew Barry sitting there with the owner at the draft literally looming over their
shoulder. Leans me to take Andrew Barry here. Okay. And maybe it's more of a Joe Shane thing.
But I just think that the big boss is making so many of the decisions regarding everything that it's almost
impossible to evaluate either one of them, even when you consider that Stefansky won the coach
of the year somehow. Now, he traded away so many picks for Deshaun Watts.
And, you know, the Watson trade alone would just have me put them last.
But second of the last, it's close enough.
They have had draft picks.
And the last three drafts, I was looking it up.
The best player from those last three drafts are either, is like Greg Newsom or Martin Emerson?
Like, they haven't brought in talent via the draft.
So that's on him, too.
His first ever draft pick, I'm big on the first draft pick setting up on.
I don't know why I'm into this in general.
And his first was Jedrick.
Will's, which to me is so typical of them, which is like, it looked pretty good at first,
and then it just hasn't worked out in the long run. And that's how I feel about, about Barry in
general. But the difference between Barry and Shane was, Barry wasn't on hard knocks,
giving the impression that just like not a lot was going on that made you feel like he was
an asset as a general manager. I think that's fair. I think people in the least,
watching that show agree with me
and I heard from them
like that just like really
this is what's going on
that that's my feel on Shane
he had a pretty good draft though last year
yeah it gave us it gave us a level of insight
and to the counter of Andrew Barry
the owner actually wanted
it seemed like wanted the player
and he was like no this is my decision
and that is why considering the results
I understand the last draft gave us something
to be you know gave people something to be excited about
but considering the extended amount
results. Well, and the Daniel Jones contract is not as bad as the Watson trade, but it's,
it's bad in a really significant way, in a different way, to self-evaluate that bad and hamstring
your own organization after you've already had them there with that coach is tough to survive.
But he has, and he's got one more year here to make it look better. We got to the end. It's kind of a
bummer for these guys at the end, but you know, someone's got to come in last. No, and somebody can,
game. And they can put this up
on a metaphorical bulletin board, maybe
like on a Windows desktop, right?
And motivate them. They'll try extra
hard now because we've been critical.
Or the opposite. Fontno
could see that someone believes in
him out there and he wants to prove
us right. Because now it's us.
Well, we get, the motivation goes both ways
because you don't believe. And your
lack of belief has more value.
It doesn't matter. Ultimately, when we put out
the graphic, it's NFL daily. Like, we
are a team, Patrick.
and while I came at that pick pretty strong,
now we've got to support,
we've got to support him.
I can't, I can't be sniping to the media behind the scene.
Oh, no power struggle?
I can't be like an unnamed source to Jordan Rodrigue of the athletic that like,
hey, Patrick really blew it with this pick.
I had nothing to do with that pick.
That was all Jimmy Haslam.
Yeah, you can write a book about it and get some quotes from my dad
and then have an NFL.com article promoting your book written by nobody.
I hope we can recover as a friendship, as podcast.
I think we'll be all right.
We'll be good.
That's it for our rankings of the GMs.
And yes, if you notice, we're kind of doing this weekly.
We're going to keep that up.
We're going to get into the positions next.
I am really looking forward to that and really looking forward to the rest of this week.
We will have Colleen Wolf and Jordan Roderig back in the studio.
for our next show, for Patrick Claibon, for Terry Fontano, for Questi.
We did kind of, I kind of forgot Questie. I apologize.
We're making amends when it comes to Terry Fontenow because football is back.
Hey, everybody, Daniel Jeremiah here.
And I'm Bucky Brooks.
On Move to Six, we take you inside the game from breaking
down college prospects and NFL rookies.
To evaluate team building philosophies, coaching trends, and how front offices
construct winning rosters.
We study the tape, talk to decision makers, and give you a perspective you won't find
anywhere else.
It's everything you need to understand the why behind what happens on Sundays.
Don't miss it.
Listen to the Move the Sticks podcast on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever
you get your podcasts.
I'm Marcus Grant.
I'm Michael Florio, and together we host the NFL Fantasy Football Podcast.
Ready to dominate your fantasy league this season?
Then you need the NFL Fantasy Football Podcast, your ultimate source for player news, draft tips, and winning strategies.
Whether you're a rookie manager or a fantasy vet, we've got the insight to help you crush your opponents.
Listen to the NFL Fantasy Football Podcast on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
automotive partner of the NFL. Visit Toyota.com slash NFL now to learn more.
This is an IHeart podcast.
