No Such Thing As A Fish - 368: No Such Thing As The Knipper And The Corpse
Episode Date: April 9, 2021Dan, James, Anna and Andrew discuss haemolacria, Olga Chekhova, butterflies and buttered muffins. Visit nosuchthingasafish.com for news about live shows, merchandise and more episodes. ...
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Hello, and welcome to another episode of No Such Thing as a Fish, a weekly podcast coming
to you from four undisclosed locations in the UK.
My name is Dan Schreiber, I am sitting here with Anna Tyshinski, James Harkin, and Andrew
Hunter Murray.
And once again, we have gathered round the microphones with our four favourite facts
from the last seven days, and in no particular order, here we go.
Starting with you, Andy.
My fact is that after his death, Anton Chekov was brought back to Russia in a refrigerated
railway car labelled Fresh Oysters.
Wow.
So was he on ice?
Oh, I don't know if he was actually on ice.
I know that he was, he was pre-chilled, um, before that.
I think, well, he was, he was chilled because the last thing before he died was he had some
champagne, which would have been cold as well.
So, yeah, this is a 1904, he was 44 years old, very young, um, to have completely, you
know, revolutionised Russian literature.
Um, and he was in a spa in Germany because he had tuberculosis, uh, and the doctor arrived
and when the doctor arrived, because things were nearing the end, his tuberculosis was
really bad at this point.
Uh, he sat up straight and he said to the doctor, which is, I'm dying.
And the doctor just said, let's have some champagne because there was this German medical
convention, which was that if you can't do anything for the patient, you just get them
some champagne.
And that means they know what's going on.
And so do you.
Okay.
That's interesting.
But he didn't really speak very good German, right, uh, Tolchekov.
And so I find it quite interesting that he'd picked up this one.
He must have known that he might need that phrase.
He didn't know he was going to die.
So he said before he boarded the train to Germany, he said to his friend, I'm off now.
I won't see you again.
I'm going to Germany to die.
So I suppose he was prepped to check out the, I'm dying phrase, as soon as he got there.
Yeah.
He was a medical doctor, wasn't he?
So he sort of, his whole life was sort of, he saw the little hints of what was going
to happen in his near future.
He thought he would try and go to the spa to sort it out.
It didn't work out.
But what's amazing is he got given this big flute of champagne and he downed it all in
one go and then he sort of laid back.
And after a few moments, that was it.
He was gone.
What an ending.
Wow.
Well, they say that, but I mean, you don't down a massive flute of champagne without
there being at least a little burp at the end.
Do you?
Probably just before he went, there would have been a big belch.
Yeah.
Yeah.
The account that we have is from Allgood Nipper, his, his wife, uh, then widow.
And she sort of says it was very calmer, very peaceful.
And he sort of laid down, turned his head and passed away.
But there are other accounts that were written that didn't come out for years and years afterwards
by another kid who was in the room, who was assisting the doctor.
And as James said, there was a sort of great burpy groan.
Oh, really?
Yeah.
Okay.
Knocks out the poetry of Olga's account.
Oh, Olga declined to mention that.
She was one of Dennis the Menace's pets, wasn't she?
Nipper.
Well, his body then went to Moscow in this train, um, which said fresh oysters on it.
Uh, but when he arrived in, um, Moscow station, there were people kind of waiting for his
body because he was a big famous, you know, hero in, in Russia.
But apparently, um, this is what I read.
Um, when he came back, there was another person who died the same time called General
Keller.
Uh, and the state had organized a big sort of fun for, for his body returning and a
military band and a parade and stuff.
And so a load of Chekhov's fans just started following General Keller's funeral procession
thinking it was Chekhov, which he was in, he was in the refrigerator role where we come
next to it, label fresh scallops and there was a bit of mayhem.
Um, yeah.
It's a comedy.
It's a faulty tower style comedy mixup where you want Basil faulty to expose at the end
what he thinks is a pile of oysters and is actually the corpse of Anna.
You mentioned that because I was thinking about faulty towels already for a different
reason related to Chekhov's death, which is that after he died, they put him in a laundry
basket, which is kind of like the episode, The Kipper and the corpse.
It is.
Wow.
It's based on faulty towels.
And what was his wife's surname?
Kipper.
The Knipper and the corpse.
The Knipper and the corpse.
Oh my God.
Yes.
Are we blowing shit wide open again?
Oh no.
Let's have a week off blowing shit wide open.
Too late.
The Knipper and the corpse.
That's got, there's no such thing as the Knipper and the corpse.
But they couldn't fit him in properly because obviously he was, um, he was a little stiff
by the time they tried to fold him up and laundry is more flexible than Chekhov.
And so he was in a half sitting position in the basket.
Oh my God.
Pretty undignified.
I know.
And it was, it was to hide him from the other guests basically.
It's a bit more dignified than, you know, how you fold laundry by two people holding
each end of it, walking towards each other.
You can't do that with Chekhov, can you?
No way.
It's really nice as a witness account of someone accidentally passing them as they were trying
to sneak Chekhov out in the laundry basket.
Yeah.
And he said, I walked behind the man carrying the body light and shade from the burning
torches flickered and leaped over the dead man's face.
And at times it seemed to me as if Chekhov was scarcely, uh, perceptibly smiling at the
fact that by decreeing that his body should be carried out in a laundry basket, fate had
linked him with humor even in death.
Oh, that's so nice.
Because I was just going to say, I reckon Chekhov would have loved that way of hosting
because he was kind of a comedy loving guy.
He would have really enjoyed that.
And I suppose that, that guy saw the same thing.
Yeah.
Yeah.
He started out as a comedy writer really, didn't he?
Well, he thought he was a comedy writer at the very end as well, but not everyone else
agreed with him.
Yeah.
Very confusing.
Is that the thing where like with the cherry orchard, he was, he was insistent the cherry
orchard was a comedy and the famous director who put on the first production was Konstantin
Stanislavski, who insisted it was a tragedy and staged it as such.
And it's kind of sad because it's the last thing that was put on before he died and Chekhov
was furious.
They hadn't been interpreted as a sort of a farce.
I think it's amazing because you have Chekhov, who's like one of the great short story writers
and playwrights of history.
And then you've got Stanislavski, who's one of the great theatre producers ever.
And you know, he's where the Stanislavski method comes from.
And, you know, when American actors are doing the method, that's basically the Stanislavski
method that they kind of brought over to America.
So you've got two greats who came together and Chekhov wrote this play.
And on the front page, it says comedy, it says a cherry orchard, a comedy.
And then Stanislavski writes back to him going, I think it's a tragedy, mate.
It's like, how can you say that to the writer?
How can you say I don't think it's a comedy yet?
I think it's amazing.
Bold.
And then Chekhov wrote when he first saw this play, he wrote how awful it is an act
that ought to take 12 minutes at most, last 40 minutes.
He has ruined the play for me.
And Stanislavski wrote, the blossoms had just begun to appear when the author arrived
and messed everything up for us.
So it's like these two greats and they just couldn't agree.
I think it's amazing.
That's incredible.
And then in between there is Olga Knipper, who acted in all of Stanislavski's
versions of Chekhov.
And that is how, yeah, that's how Chekhov eventually, so it would be a
situation where he probably didn't want to see the plays, but he had to see the
plays because he was madly in love with this girl and get closer to her.
And because they eventually married after she'd done, I think, four of his plays or
so.
That must have been so awkward, because I think the cherry orchard was after
they were married and she must have been so torn between these two people.
I mean, do you think she would do one scene serious and one scene comedy or...?
Yeah, maybe when Chekhov came into the room, she'd put on a red nose and some
big trees and kind of...
Yeah.
She, bizarrely, she acted in the cherry orchard in 1904.
She was Madame Ranev Skyer, who's basically the main part, controversy over
who was the main part.
So 1904.
And then she did it again, 1943.
Same part.
That's got to be one of the longest gaps between the say role.
She was 36 for the first and 75 for the second.
She outlived him by a really long way because he died in 1904 and she died in 1959.
Do you find the weirdest thing about Chekhov is that, as we were saying before,
he's this huge author and today he's still considered to be one of the all-time
greats.
I kept reading in a few places that just he's sort of under Shakespeare as the
person with the most film adaptions and plays that are on.
And I can't, I haven't seen any of his stuff and I can't think of a single short story.
And I just find that fascinating that I read a lot.
I see a lot of things.
Yet this guy is second to Shakespeare.
His plays got put on a lot, I would say.
And definitely in London, you would get it.
We had tickets to watch The Seagull just before lockdown.
We never got to see it in the end with...
What's the name from Game of Thrones?
Amelia Clark, was it?
Oh, yeah.
Yeah, but yeah.
His plays are excellent.
I love those.
But honestly, Dan, and anyone, he was in my top three favourite writers.
I would sometimes say as my favourite writer, his short stories are heaven.
You'd sit down and read one of those before you read Cloud Your Way
through the Merry Wives of Windsor.
Definitely.
And good news, they're quite short, Dan.
I read log books.
I read log books.
Just saying.
I read just for this, I read what's it called, The Woman and the Dog.
The Woman with the Dog.
The Woman with the Dog or whatever.
Yeah, and I've tried to read it in Russian,
because I'm learning Russian a little bit and I'm kind of OK.
And the standard of writing is quite simple.
It's quite easy to read.
It's like he has lots to say about the human condition and about love
and the way that people react with each other.
But actually, it's in really nice, easy to understand writing.
I can read big words.
I can read big words, James.
We should say that not everyone respected him quite as much.
So Tolstoy hated his stuff.
Tolstoy said that Chekov is an appalling playwright.
But at least he's not as bad as Shakespeare.
He was, comparing the two.
But he also have really hated Shakespeare.
Well, actually, they were good mates, but they Tolstoy and Chekov.
Yeah, they were.
I think he said that right to his face.
He was like, I hate this, but at least it's not as bad as Shakespeare.
And he loved his short stories.
So Tolstoy used to his daughter, Tolstoy's daughter said that Tolstoy
used to make them read the short stories aloud at dinner and his early funny stuff.
And the daughter said that Tolstoy, my father, was usually a good reader.
But with Chekov, he was often quite unable to go on.
So infectious that his helpless fits of laugh to become.
And he was sort of laugh until he cried.
And he I think he was on the people who said, why doesn't Chekov understand
that he's just a great comedy writer?
You know, stick to that.
Right.
And he just knocked about as well.
That's what I love about them.
He decided he wanted to be a writer because he needed to support his family.
And he just it was only over about 20 years that he wrote all these things
like 700 short stories or something.
And they were all literally just like, OK, we'll get this out to the
to the Moscow Times, to the St. Petersburg Times.
Every month or so, you would have at least two or three of Chekov's stories in there.
They'd be all under different pen names.
He didn't know they were all from the same person.
Well, someone who I've become a bit obsessed off the back of Chekov now
is a lady called Constance Garnet.
Now, this is just what a remarkable story.
So it's really thanks to her that we have Chekov in the English language,
as well as Tolstoy and other great Russian writers.
She sat down with a Russian dictionary,
having not spoken a single word of Russian until the age of 29.
And she translated all of these books.
And that is how the English speaking world got introduced to all of these people.
And just a remarkable person.
She is. She's such a weirdo.
She just randomly decided to withdraw and devote her life to that.
And yet changed 20th century literature, I guess,
because all literature was then influenced by the Russian greats.
And she churned it out, too.
She did hundreds of Chekov stories, all of Turgenev, all of Tolstoy's novels,
almost all of Tolstoy, all Dostoevsky.
Oh, my God, I hope she started with Chekov.
Ease her way in.
And the reason she started is because she had a difficult pregnancy in 1891,
where she was kind of confined.
So she thought, nothing else to do except learn Russian.
And she did then 1894.
She just abandoned her husband and her toddler, went to Russia
and hung out with Tolstoy for a bit.
And so like, can I can I start translating your novels, please?
Amazing. Yeah.
And she and she didn't start easy.
You know, one of the first translations was a religious and philosophical piece
by Leo Tolstoy, which was called The Kingdom God is Within You.
I mean, a really hardcore first thing.
And she had terrible vision at the end.
So she kept translating sort of into her late life,
but she would have someone sitting there reading it out while she translated.
So she sort of had assistance alongside her helping her to do it.
And the reason that they became so popular around the world
is because she was she was from a publishing family.
Her husband worked in publishing as well.
And she was able to press them as really cheap books
so people could afford them and they could just get out there into the wild
in a in a way that people could could buy them affordably.
That's that's the real reason that they into the attraction into the wild novels
galloping through the rainforest, I loopery.
I tried to find if there's a single
removals firm in the UK called Uncle Vanya and I can't find one.
Jesus. And I think what a gap in the market that is.
Yeah. Yeah.
What about is there like a really happy tree surgeon called the cheery orchard?
That's good. Yeah.
So many gaps in the market everywhere.
Are these gaps in the market or just terrible jokes?
I would trust a removals firm called Uncle Vanya.
I think these guys are going to look after my books.
OK. His nickname in the UK was Willy Wetleg.
Really? Why?
Florence nicknamed him Willy Wetleg.
Because Willy Wetleg just I don't know why it's
but audiences in the UK were not wowed by early chuck of plays
because they didn't like the lack of obvious plots or clear meaning.
Some of them are quite, you know,
non-committal and there is a definitive answer.
That's right. I read a review in the Daily Express from the time
which said that the cherry orchard was a silly, tiresome, boring comedy.
There is no plot.
The orchard is for sale and certain dull people are upset
because it must be sold. Wow.
It's a decent summary of the plot.
Is it?
So this is coming from someone who, as I say, doesn't hasn't read any of Czech of
was the idea that it was all character studies and just amazing dialogue
and sort of insight into the human condition.
I mean, it's quite a lot of social commentary,
a lot of stuff about kind of aristocracy.
Can we spoil it?
Can we spoil it? The cherry orchard?
Are we going to get in trouble for that?
Oh, I don't think we're going to go for the ending.
This big messed up family is having crazy philosophical debates
and then shagging each other and getting angry and making up stuff like that.
You know, it's like neighbors.
We haven't even mentioned Czechos rifle.
Or Czechos gun.
Oh, yeah.
It's impossible to find out if Czech of actually owned a gun
because whenever you Google the phrase Czechos gun,
it only comes up with a dramatic principle that he kept saying,
which is if there is a gun hanging on the wall in the first act,
it has to go off in the second.
And he said different versions of it, but that's broadly it.
Don't introduce a plot element that's a big heavy thing and then not play it out.
But I kept on trying to find out if he did have a gun.
Yeah, why?
If I haven't, what?
Why?
Why try and find that out?
Yeah, I think that's interesting.
It's relevant.
Did he have a Czechos gun?
Was it real?
Was he a gun?
Yeah.
Was he, you know, could he really talk about guns?
Or had he never seen one in his life?
And he's, you know.
Exactly.
Was he bluffing?
Yeah.
Sorry for trying to do my homework, Dan.
Sorry, sorry.
Yeah, I don't know why I questioned it.
No, I was just curious if there was an extra thing about it
that I didn't realize though.
There's a pointless, here's a pointless fact about Czechos.
The seagull in Russian is Czecha.
It's called that's Russian.
But it's not Russian for seagull.
It's just Russian for gull.
Because actually the play is set in the middle of Ukraine
or Russia, nowhere near like 1000 miles from the sea.
And so, yeah, we just translated it as seagull,
but really it should be gull.
That's probably bloody constant's garnet, isn't it?
Bringing her seagull base, I think.
See, that's a good fact to look into, Andy.
That's the kind of thing you should be focusing on.
That will absolutely delight ornithological fans,
because of course there is no such thing as a seagull.
Yeah.
And there's no such thing as the seagull either.
There you go.
Nice.
Did you guys spot that thing about the theory
that he didn't die of tuberculosis
and how they've been looking into?
They've reopened the case.
They've reopened the case.
Have they ever gotten into it?
Come on.
This was a thing whereby...
Did he drown in a bed of oysters?
Suffocated in some laundry basket.
He supposedly died of a brain hemorrhage.
And this was...
Scientists took some proteins that were on his shirt
and they analyzed it.
And they think what showed up
sort of suggests that the tuberculosis
was a lifelong thing that he had under control,
that it was manageable,
but actually he was suffering from huge pains
of a brain hemorrhage.
And yeah, so they just analyzed...
And this is only a few years ago
that they managed to get these samples.
And that's the new theory.
Dig them up again, together.
Yeah, it's a good question.
It was on his clothes,
so I assume that maybe the clothes must have been saved.
It's relics, yeah.
Got it.
It's not what you want when someone says
of a historical character.
He actually didn't die this way.
What we want is he was murdered by his furious lover.
By his...
By a gun which may or may not have belonged to him.
If they accused his wife of killing him
and she didn't really,
she could say,
I was done up like a knipper.
Okay, it is time for fact number two,
and that is James.
Okay, my fact this week is that earlier this year,
a woman reported that she was bleeding from her eyes
whenever she was on her period.
Wow.
Is it eye euphemism?
No.
Is that... Okay.
None of that sense is euphemism.
You wouldn't say eye is plural, would you?
That's mental.
Yeah.
So, does it...
I mean...
So many, yeah.
I'm just waiting for the questions,
and then I'll tell you, but...
Okay, can you buy eye tampons?
You cannot buy eye tampons.
No.
Oh, well, then I feel really sorry for that.
Is it the same blood
that's kind of travelled through the body
and up out the eye?
Okay, that's...
Like, if you squeezed her by the tummy?
That started off as a reasonable question,
so I'll answer it.
So, there is a thing that can happen
called vicarious menstruation,
and it seems to be a kind of hormonal thing.
We're still not exactly sure why it happens,
but it means people can bleed
from different parts of their body
when they're on the period.
So, people have been documented as bleeding
from the nose.
That's quite common, like nosebleeds.
The nipples, the intestines, the skin,
things like that.
It's extremely, extremely rare,
but earlier this year,
this is a report in the British Medical Journal,
there was a 25-year-old who visited an emergency room
and she was having blood coming from her,
like near from her tear ducts
when she was on her period.
And there's also a thing called hemo-lacrea,
which can make blood come out of your eyes.
There's lots of different things that can cause that,
so that could be caused by, you know,
abnormality in the sinuses,
problems with the tear ducts.
There's lots of things that can cause that,
but the doctors went through everything
that that could have been
and realised it couldn't be any of those things,
and they think that this is vicarious menstruation
and hemo-lacrea put together.
And this is the first time that it's ever been reported
in any medical journal.
Now, it seems to be quite benign,
they can't see any other problems from it,
it's just the thing that happened.
They gave her some hormonal therapy
and it has gone away,
so it seems to be a hormonal thing
like the vicarious menstruation would be.
But that's it, this is the thing that happened.
Extraordinary.
So it's not her womb wandering around her body,
we're not about to say Aristotle was right.
We're not going to say that.
Oh, that would have been the biggest shit
to blow wide open of all, everything.
Apparently, I've read that there was a 1995 study
that found that 18% of fertile women
do have some blood in their tears.
Is that right?
Trace amounts of blood, yeah.
There's 7% of pregnant women,
8% of men, 18% of fertile women,
and then postmenopause, no women have it.
Oh, I see.
That's a little study, but interesting.
So you can cut down that phrase, blood, sweat, and tears.
You can just say blood and sweat, or tears and sweat.
Yeah, definitely.
That's good, that's going to save us all some time.
Well, I did also say that some people can sweat blood
due to vicarious menstruation,
so you could just say blood.
Oh, great.
Much easier.
If anyone ever says to you blood, sweat, and tears,
just go, it's tautology mate.
Do you think, and I'm sure you don't,
that groups of women living together
start to experience synchronised menstruation?
Oh, it's what people say, but...
I think.
I've read things that say that that's not true,
but anecdotally, so many people,
whenever I've said that to them, have said,
well, it is true, so I don't know what you're talking about.
Yeah, I saw that as well.
It's medically, according to the reports, not true.
I know so many women who've told me that
that's what's happened with them.
So, who do we believe?
I think the larger, more recent studies
which say it doesn't happen.
I thought, I reckon that's what they were saying
to Aristotle back in the day, weren't they?
They're saying, I've spoken to lots of women,
and they say that their wombs do not move around their body.
And they're like, nope, nope, this is what the scientists say.
Studies have shown.
Yeah, I think the largest and longest studies
have found no evidence for it.
There is plenty of random overlap
that might be seen as synchrony
if you look at it through a shorter time window.
So, there are plenty of reasons
why you might think it is happening.
But no, I think it's confirmation bias.
I think it just overlaps enough
that every four months that happens,
and they go, oh my God, we must be synchronizing.
Right, okay.
But it does happen with lions, that's the key.
So, maybe everyone you've asked has actually been a lion.
Do you guys think, and I don't think you do,
but do you think that bears are attracted to menstruation?
Attracted how?
Just as in section.
Come closer to what?
Yeah, yeah.
Well, Fenella's cousin was once told to escape a forest
because the guide found out she was menstruating.
It was like, you've got to get out of here now.
And they just left to run around to just...
Yeah, she had to leave the wood at her husband's stage.
And she was like, no, it's a good camping trip.
She's never found again.
She's now living in a gingerbread house.
Wow.
Really, that's amazing.
And did she get attacked by a bear?
No, because I have a feeling James is about to say that that's a myth.
Well, it is a myth, but I'm still a bit worried about this guide.
Oh, when they just say anyone who's menstruating,
get out of here now and you're on your own.
There was a study relatively recently done where 15 used tampons
were presented to male black bears that were feeding in a garbage dump.
And they found there was no reaction from the bears.
At least they had the courtesy not to go, oh, get out of my face.
But all this study says to me is that bears prefer garbage dumps
to use tampons.
It doesn't necessarily mean that.
But yeah.
Could be the second best thing on the menu.
A lot of different tribes think that periods will attract dangerous animals.
I think the Wari people of Brazil,
the women wouldn't be allowed to go into the forest
when they were on their periods
because jaguars would be attracted to them.
And they weren't allowed to have sex either,
because then jaguars would be attracted to the men who were out hunting
because they'd have sex with someone.
Oh, wow. It's like it follows.
It's like it follows cracking film and a niche reference that some people will get.
But they also have another really cool practice, these guys.
Or this is actually a thing I was reading in the 60s about them.
So it might have changed.
But whenever a mother was on her period,
her whole family, her husband and children,
all painted themselves with red food coloring.
Wow, that's amazing.
That is such a good idea.
Weird, right?
I think we should bring that in.
Wow.
Kind of a hassle, a bit messy.
You could paint.
And food coloring only comes in those tiny, tiny vials.
Yeah.
So what you could do is paint yourself
in the new Pantone shade called Period,
which they brought out relatively recently.
It's very red.
It's very, very red.
It's not blood red.
It's just red red.
But they brought it out according to them,
so people can own their period with self-assurance
to stand up and passionately celebrate
the exciting and powerful life force they are born with
to feel comfortable to talk spontaneously and openly
about this pure and natural bodily function.
And by having some red paint, that will help us to do that.
But I think if we all painted ourselves red,
we'd definitely be able to do that.
Yeah, yeah.
I feel liberated already to paint my wall in period.
That makes a big difference if you go to a property website
and they say, well, this, of course, is a period property.
A lot of period features.
Oh, my words.
Sharks also don't go for menstruation.
They know they like fish, it turns out.
I mean, this is a thing that is also thought,
I think, like the bears.
They've got a great sense of smell, Sharks.
And if you are menstruating and you're in the water,
maybe you're going on a swimming with Sharks experience,
it might lead to trouble.
It turns out, really, they're like the chemicals in fish blood.
And they have good enough nose to detect fish from human blood.
And also menstrual blood is mostly not blood.
It's mostly the lining of the womb.
It's secretion.
There's trace of blood, but it's not...
Yes, yeah.
So feel free to go swimming with Sharks.
If you're hanging out on the edge of the water,
worried about it, don't be.
Has anyone heard of the sanitary products known as sphagnakins?
No.
No, they sound a bit scandy.
No, it's not scandy.
The name comes from what they were made of, sphagnakins.
Swags?
Oh, like sphagnamos.
They're moss, aren't they?
Sphagnamos.
So they used to have the sphagnamos girls,
which were images that they used to advertise sanitary products
made from Andy's favourite material, moss.
Wow.
There you go.
Oh, my god.
The sphagn...
The moss girls.
Yeah, they were known as the sphagnamos girls.
Wow.
When were these ladies around?
Uh, it was the middle of the 20th century.
Is there anything more?
I can't...
Moss can't do.
Is there any...
There's nothing moss can't do.
Lovely.
One thing that's quite a hot potato in a lot of countries
is the tampon tax.
And in Germany in 2019,
there was something that was actively done about it
in order to raise awareness.
So it's taxed as a luxury good.
This is in 2019 at 19%.
Which is ridiculously high in comparison
to so many other things say like books,
which are only charged at 7%.
So there was a brilliant book that was released
called The Tampon Book,
which had inside of it 15 tampons,
which were sold so you could buy them for much cheaper
than you would a normal pack of tampons in the tax sense.
And they sold 10,000 copies once they released it.
So it was sort of becoming a best-selling book
in its own right.
But yeah, tampon tax has been a horrific thing
that we've still not solved.
Didn't the UK just pass something though, which...
Yeah, I think they have just passed it, haven't they?
In the UK.
I know you get free sanitary products in schools.
That's a very recently in the UK now.
You do have to be a pupil.
Damn it.
I say this for a better experience, all right?
Have you got any moss?
Has anyone got any moss?
You're standing on the school gates.
We're on the school roof scraping on.
Okay, it is time for fact number three,
and that is my fact.
My fact this week is that touchscreens
can now be operated using muffins.
Wow, finally.
Wow, okay.
So this is a discovery by a scientist in Belgium
called Florian Heller,
and he realized that the electrical field
of a capacitive touchscreen
could be altered by using different materials.
So usually it would be your finger
or it would be a type of metal, hence styluses.
And he discovered that if you used
a fresh out of the oven muffin
that the moisture was enough
and the humidity was enough
that it could be electrically conductive
to this particular type of screen.
So we can recognize it being touched.
And that's the kind of one that you have on your phone.
Most of them will be capacitive, aren't they?
Yes.
I did then spend most of my research time
going around my bedroom
seeing how many objects work.
Me too.
Actually, not around your bedroom.
Around my house.
I did wonder what you were doing in here.
There was nothing surprising.
It's not very exciting.
I mean, it's obviously stuff that, you know,
conducts electricity.
You know, although I was quite excited
that my spider plant does.
So if my spider plant became conscious,
it could hack into my phone.
Okay, let me give you some examples
and see if you can guess whether they work.
A grape.
Yes.
Yes.
Yeah, all right.
Plum.
Yes.
No.
Oh, I think you're kind of right as a group
because it did work, but it did work very well.
A piece of alpaca poo.
No.
Oh my God, you opened up our trophy
in order to test this?
A year or so ago, we got an award in Vienna,
which was a small vial of alpaca poo.
I opened it up and took up one of the little
currents of poo and tried to use my phone with it.
Did it work or did it not work?
I'd say yes, there was a current with your current.
Yeah.
It did not work.
Ah.
It did not work.
Too dry.
For sure.
An egg.
Which bit of the egg?
The scrambled boiled.
Yeah.
Just an egg.
Just an egg from the fridge.
Oh no, no way.
No.
Not in shell.
Not in shell.
You're right.
Dump egg.
No, I don't think that's a good comment.
I'm going to say yes.
Oh, definitely.
Yeah, I think yes.
Put a bit of water on the egg and it works.
So anyway, thanks for listening to my TED talk.
That's things that...
Wow.
What an insight to your brain that you went from egg to
damp egg.
Most people would have moved on to the next object.
But one thing that's really interesting,
and I did try this in my house,
but actually I read it on the internet,
is a battery.
So if you try and use a battery to operate your phone,
it will only work if you use the negative side of the battery.
And if you use the positive side of the battery,
it won't work.
And that is the explanation, really,
of how these things work.
Because you have a tiny little electrical difference
in your finger.
And that's what the phone can tell.
It's very, very slightly charged to your skin.
And that's how it can tell the difference.
So there's not a current...
It's not like there's a current,
obviously, running from the ground through you to your phone.
No, it's like, if you have static electricity,
because you've been walking on a carpet,
or you've been rubbing a lot of balloons against you or something,
then you get a little shock.
Well, that shock actually happens all the time.
You always have that kind of tiny difference in electricity
in your body.
The inside of your body is positively charged,
and the outside of your body is very slightly negatively charged.
And that's what the phone can tell.
So it's just connecting a circuit.
It's like putting the crocodile clip on the circuit
when you're at school.
Your finger is literally connecting that little circuit.
It's like putting the damp egg on the...
Stop saying damp egg.
So when you don't have...
Because sometimes your finger doesn't work on your phone,
and it's really annoying.
And is that due to your having more dead skin, for example?
So if you've got really thick skin, does that damage it?
Yes, Andy, do you have zombie fingers?
Some people have this.
I don't, but if I was a lumberjack, for example, I might do.
Yes.
If you're working for my company, Cherry Archard.
Exactly.
You'd need to get yourself a stylus.
What is zombie fingers, Anna?
Well, it's for lumberjacks.
It's particularly suffered by lumberjacks
and guitar players as well, have it.
And yes, if you've got very callous fingers
or they're very dry, so they're not conducting as well.
The recommendation is lick your finger.
Or if you are one particular...
Just use a damp egg.
Just use a damp egg.
You can't quite get...
Because it's not very pointy, is it?
One woman got a refund on her Chromebook
because she insisted that it just did not respond to her fingers at all.
Okay, so I didn't know this.
This is really cool.
When they were making the iPhone,
they still didn't have the keyboard touch screen
worked out the year before it was launched.
And they developed this technique
to work out what you're going to type next
to kind of predict it.
So if you hit T on your phone, the phone...
They know that you're likely to hit H next
because of the word the, for example.
And there are all these probabilities they can work out.
So when you've hit T, what they call the hit region
around the letter H on your phone keyboard,
it grows a bit.
So it stays the same size to your eye and on the screen.
But beneath it, the technology knows that...
So there's this hit region around H, which swells a bit.
And then once you've hit T, H, the hit region around E
will swell a bit.
So there's this quivering, pulsating map that we can't see.
What if you wanted to write Tug or something?
Like, does it mean you're more likely to make mistakes
with more unusual letter pairs?
I think that's what it means.
But fortunately, we don't write Tug much.
So there are no words other.
There are no words that we give TG, I don't think.
No, I might try typing TG on my phone now.
What if you were typing the word cat gut?
That's got a T in the G.
00:35:13,160 --> 00:35:13,480
Nice.
Brilliant.
Why I should type that more often than the word the?
Do you know who invented the touchscreen?
It was a man called Bent Stumpy.
No.
Bent Stumpy.
What a first name for Mr. Mr. Stumpy.
He was an engineer at CERN, and he was working with someone
called Frank Beck.
And Frank Beck asked Bent Stumpy to solve the problem of
to build some hardware for an intelligent system,
which in just three console units would replace all the
conventional buttons and switches.
Sorry, I was just reading that.
But basically they wanted to get rid of all the buttons
and switches and replace them with a new system.
And Bent Stumpy went away.
And a few days later, he came back with three different
solutions.
One was a tracker ball.
One was a programmable knob.
Don't know exactly how the knob was programmable.
And the other one was a touchscreen.
Wow.
Really?
Yeah.
He should be the Steve Jobs of the time.
They probably said to him, listen, we'd love to make
you global famous, but the name's just not going to work,
mate.
No one's going to buy this product.
And he wouldn't give it up.
He wouldn't give up the name.
No.
Stumpy is S2.
S-T-U-M-P-E.
I think it's Stumpy.
It could be Bent Stump, I'm not sure.
I think Bent Stumpy.
Much better.
That was the only option he offered them.
He was like, OK, I'll make it Bent Stump, my final offer.
The first time that was used was in air traffic control,
right, when that came along.
And then it just wasn't using anything else for 30 years.
So it was in 1960, literally the mid-60s, 1965.
And air traffic controllers used it and they called it
a touch-wire display.
And it must have been so advanced in 1966 as an air traffic
controller, there was one wire that's attached to a computer
that's getting information about when all the planes are
landing and what time and what platform or whatever runway
platform they land on.
And then the other end of the wire would connect to the screen.
And then the bottom of the screen, wherever you touched it,
would touch a specific bit of wire that would transmit
information back and forth.
And they were doing this for 30 years.
And yet it wasn't until really the 80s, the LA 80s, 90s,
that it was incorporated into other tech.
It's amazing to think that Jimi Hendrix could have used
a touchscreen if he had worked in air traffic control.
But he couldn't have, because he was a guitar player,
so they wouldn't have worked with him.
Oh, my God.
Brilliant, yeah.
Stuff on muffins or that?
Ooh, if you've got, yeah.
So the British Museum might have been established
as a result of a muffin.
What?
So you might know that the British Museum was established
by Sir Hans Sloan after he died.
All of his collection were put into this new museum
because he had been collecting these loads of weird things
like antiquities, rare books, all sorts of stuff.
He kept them in his house.
And then when it got too much in his house,
he bought a house next door and put it all in there.
And he had loads of friends,
loads of famous friends who would come and like have dinner
with him and have a look at his amazing stuff.
But once he was visited by Handel,
and Handel apparently put a buttered muffin
on one of his rare books.
And Sir Hans Sloan was absolutely furious about this.
And he was like, I can't have the place
where I have my dinner parties in the same place
as the place where I have all my rare stuff.
So he bought a new place out in Chelsea
and he put everything in there.
And it became a little museum of its own rights
rather than a house.
And then it was all the stuff from there
that became the British Museum.
Wow.
That's awesome.
Well done, Muffin.
Do you think Handel was just being very ahead of his time
and trying to operate what he thought was a kinder?
Touch screen muffin.
Okay, it is time for our final fact of the show.
And that is Anna.
My fact this week is that in 2012,
Southwest Airlines agreed to fly a single butterfly
2,000 miles after it overslept and missed its ride.
It's adorable.
It is.
What a good service to have offered.
This is a problem with this butterfly.
A spotted by a woman called Marilena Manos Jones.
She was in Albany, New York.
And she saw in her garden a monarch butterfly.
And she happened to be a butterfly expert.
So she knew that it was well,
she was watching it from like metamorphosis stage.
And she knew it was metamorphosing too late.
So often when the caterpillars go into their chrysalis stage,
they'll sometimes wait out too long, emerge late.
They'll emerge a bit damaged, a bit unhealthy
if they're slow to develop.
She expected it to be like this and a lost cause.
But it came out big, hearty, healthy, she said.
And she knew that its swarm mates had already flown south
because that's what they do for the winter
to get some warmer climate.
And so she panicked and she thought,
well, this guy isn't going to survive the winter
up here in New York.
So she rang up Southwest Airlines, obviously.
And she said, can you carry this guy to Texas, please,
where it can cross the border into Mexico
and join its friends.
And they agreed.
So what did they, they didn't give it a seat and, you know.
I think they made it share her seat, which is,
I guess you do that with babies, don't you?
Yeah.
You can put them on your lap.
If there's a problem with the flights when you're flying,
you have to put your own gas mask on
before you put your butterflies gas mask on.
That's absolutely right.
Would have been hell to put a gas mask on it
because it was wrapped in about 17 different layers.
So they packed it up in this like glass scene,
which is like very light transparent paper
and an envelope made of that with a damp piece of cotton.
Then they put it in a Tupperware,
then in another container with an ice pack
to keep it cool and calm, stop it panicking.
And then they put that container into a bag
that was padded out with layers of newspaper and towels.
And it sat on her lap and flew all the way down to San Antonio.
And then popped out, joined its friends
and flew further south into south Mexico.
Do we know it made it?
Or did, do we just have records up to the point
at which she released this butterfly and then.
It got eaten by a bird immediately.
Exactly.
She released it and then we believe it probably survived,
although we don't have confirmation
it hasn't sent any postcards.
But did she have to find the swarm in this bit of America?
So she just let it off assuming
that it would cross the border on its own and finish the.
It knows where to go.
It's a big risk.
No, I get that, but it's sort of not seeing it to its,
you know, if you're trying to return it.
It has to be a point at which you give up on this story
and you give up on the butterfly.
This is not practical.
You can't fly all the way to the swarm.
It's like one of those easy jet flights,
sometimes to get to Barcelona.
You have to go to an airport that's 200 miles from Barcelona.
Everyone knows that.
Yeah, I think I'm with you, Dan.
She's lazy.
You've got it.
You've got to see it through.
He could just be cropping up a bar in Texas still.
I think she's actually gone above and beyond what was required.
And I think if we all did this, it would, you know,
forever a disaster.
It would just exactly what Greta Thunberg would say.
You know, we're talking about one single instance
where she did three quarters of the trip.
Yeah.
And has no idea if it paid off.
There's no end to this story.
I don't think she should have done it either, Dan.
No, I know.
So why do three quarters?
It makes no sense.
I think that this is a wonderful heartwarming story
that Pixar needs to get on immediately.
You know, the butterfly that's left behind in cold New York
and has to get to...
Sounds good.
Yes.
Yeah, it will be good.
Has a champion who says,
I'll get you there,
but then only get some three quarters of the way there
and says, all right, off you pop, wherever you want.
That's a twist halfway through.
That's the low point.
Yeah, most of the way through the film.
In all those films, there is a low point,
like where Paddington leaves his family temporarily
in Paddington I
or when Paddington is sent to prison in Paddington II.
Or I could go on.
You can get, we must have said before,
that you can get butterflies that drink tears
of animals, but also humans.
But you also get blood feeding, sweat feeding,
and tear feeding butterflies.
So for these butterflies,
that woman who was bleeding out of her eyes,
it must have been...
It's a banquet.
It's a banquet.
It's a three course meal.
It's one of those world buffet grills
where you have 20 different cuisine stars
all served at the same buffet.
Exactly.
The blood ones are quite interesting
because they will actually pierce your skin.
Like to get your blood,
generally not with humans,
generally with other animals,
although it can happen with humans.
What they think is they evolved from
fruit eating moths and butterflies
and they would pierce the skin of the fruits
to get at the juicy stuff inside
and they evolved into
blood drinking moths and butterflies.
So will they just be drinking the blood
of little ants and stuff?
Usually.
No, they'll drink proper mammal blood for sure.
It's only the males who do it.
And it's same with tears actually.
Only males will drink the tears of animals.
And that's because they're trying to get the sodium
from the animal,
which can be in the blood or in the tears.
But the females,
they get the sodium directly
from the male during mating.
So they don't need to get it from the other animals.
They get it through the...
Yeah, second hand.
They get second hand sodium.
Yeah.
I read this amazing thing
about monarch butterflies,
which astounds me,
and this is part of actually
their big migration that they do
when they're going south.
And it is the fact that
they have to, at one point,
in this huge journey,
they have to cross Lake Superior.
And Lake Superior,
biggest lake in the world,
it's ginormous
and that is a huge moment of the trip
where they really have to go gung-ho on it.
And this really odd thing happens
that biologists have been looking into
for quite a long time,
which is they all fly
in this sort of straight line
and then out of nowhere,
they take a turn to the east
and they fly east for a while,
and then they turn back,
flying south again.
And they haven't known why,
and they're still not completely sure,
but the latest theory
is that it's a memory of the past
from old days
when they were traveling down,
and there used to be,
there must have been,
a jutting out mountainous bit
in Lake Superior.
And it's a memory that
this is where we take a right.
I remember when we used to go on holiday
when I was a kid,
and my dad would drive us
many, many hundreds of miles
to where we were going on holiday,
and he'd always be driving around going,
I'm sure there was a service station around here.
Exactly.
So they think there was something there
that was blocking the path
for generations and generations,
and then it went,
but they still in their head go,
oh, this is where we take a right
to get away from the blocky thing,
even though nothing is there.
There would be evidence, wouldn't there,
that there had been a mountain here or something?
Yeah, I mean, there would be right,
you'd think,
but they can't explain.
They just don't know why
they take a right there.
That's amazing.
Yeah.
Wow.
That's so cool,
the species evidence of a previous mountain
that must have been missing for a while now.
It must be some thousands of years.
Where's it gone?
Yeah.
That's very cool.
I wonder who's in charge of the sat-nav there?
Who's jabbing the muffin at the sat-nav?
I don't like jabbing the muffin at all.
That's a phrase.
So how many butterflies do you think
there are in the Natural History Museum?
Dead ones, I mean.
Okay.
I guess.
Three.
A thousand.
Oh, come on.
Three thousand, three.
Twenty-five.
It's fifty thousand.
Fifty thousand.
You're going to have to go quite a lot higher than that.
Oh, okay.
Five hundred thousand.
A seven million.
Keep going.
A hundred million.
Oh, no.
Yeah, you went too far.
There are eight million,
seven hundred and twelve thousand dead butterflies
and moths in the Natural History Museum.
They're in the glass-fronted cases
that if laid out on the floor,
they would cover around thirty football pitches,
which is about ten times bigger
than that ship that got stuck in the Suez Canal.
Oh, my word.
Which at the moment is a very on-topic reference,
but probably in two weeks time,
everyone will have forgotten it.
The collection began with Walter and Charles Rothschild,
who are amateur entomologists,
and they gave more than two million butterflies
to the Natural History Museum.
It's too many.
You don't want that many.
Well, maybe, but Walter Rothschild
used to say that of the two million,
more than two million butterflies,
he didn't have a single duplicate
in his entire collection.
Oh, come on.
What?
It can't be true, right?
I've got, like, packets of football stickers
with a duplicate in the same packet.
It can't be true.
Two million with no duplicates.
Amazing.
Wow.
That's so good.
Absolutely rubbish.
Some of them have bullet holes in them, don't they?
Because this is how they used to collect butterflies
in the olden days.
Yeah, even at the turn of the 20th century,
even though they were still doing it.
So the specimen that the Natural History Museum has
are, for instance, the largest butterfly in the world.
Was collected by Shotgun in 1906
by a guy called Albert Stuart Meek,
who sounds not very meek if he's going around
machine-gunning butterflies down.
How big was it, Anna?
Because you can get quite big butterflies, right?
This one has a 20-centimeter wingspan,
and the biggest of its kind has a 26-centimeter wingspan.
That's big.
That's very big.
Quite big.
It's a biggie.
Still, it feels like a Shotgun would obliterate it.
They use special ammo.
I mean, I'm sure you could just get a net.
It feels like using a sledgehammer to crack a nut,
but they use special butterfly-friendly ammo,
not friendly to the butterfly itself,
but friendly to the shape of its wing.
There are people who aim to wipe out butterflies,
like the New Zealand government.
They are the first New Zealanders of the first country
to eradicate a butterfly within its own territory deliberately.
A single species, or...?
A single species called the Great White Butterfly,
which they eat the rare cresses of New Zealand.
I didn't know that was a problem in New Zealand,
but get this, out of 79 Kiwi cresses,
57 are at risk of extinction,
and these bastard butterflies were eating them.
So the New Zealand government said,
no, we are going to destroy this butterfly in New Zealand,
because it's plenty of allows around the world.
So they conducted 263,000 searches.
They offered a bounty of $10
for every dead Great White Butterfly you turned in.
What if you don't like bounties?
Then you get a galaxy, or a twirl.
And they released wasps that hunted them,
and they did this for about four years,
this savage butterfly hunt, and they found no more.
They declared that they had won.
Right.
Makes them sound like really bad guys,
and I'm happy, because the New Zealand government
has got a lot of good press the last year and a half,
and it's about time someone brought them down
as butterfly murderers.
Yeah, what year was this?
Is this pre-Jocinda,
or is this going to be a stain on her career?
No, this is 2010 to 2014,
I think that the campaign was happening, so...
It didn't sound very Jacinda.
It's not a stain.
It's the rare cresses.
Think of the rare cresses that are on the verge of extinction.
Cress.
Of all the fucking things,
you can kill a butterfly by some cress.
I've only got a surplus of egg sandwiches without it.
Just very quickly, back to the original fact,
2012 was when this story happened,
when the butterfly was taken by plane.
It was a bit of a big year for taking singular animals
that were migrating and were left behind in the news.
So there was a story in England, this also in 2012,
a cuckoo was found badly injured in a garden
and was transported by British Airways,
along with the person who found it, to churrin,
to join the migration of the other cuckoos
that had already set off.
And they knew that it was the last of the cuckoos to fly away,
because it was tagged.
So while the butterfly was being flown almost to Mexico,
this cuckoo was being flown to churrin
to meet up with the migrating cuckoos.
And then over in Russia, again in 2012,
there was a migration of endangered Siberian white cranes
that weren't quite finding their way.
So Vladimir Putin got into a motorized hand glider
and dressed up in garb that sort of emulated the white crane
and tried to steer them unsuccessfully, unfortunately.
But he was flying above them,
trying to get them to follow him and start migrating.
But then Putin said, you, Crane.
And then they misrepresented it
and ended up going into Crimea.
Very strong.
Animal!
OK, that's it.
That is all of our facts.
Thank you so much for listening.
If you'd like to get in contact with any of us
about the things that we have said over the course of this podcast,
we can be found on our Twitter accounts.
I'm on at Shriverland, James.
At James Harkin.
Andy.
At Andrew Hunter M.
And Anna.
You can even podcast at qi.com.
Yep, where you can get our group account,
which is at no such thing,
or you can go to our website, no such thing as a fish.com.
All of our previous episodes were up there.
Also, check out all of the videos
from our 20-hour comic relief marathon.
They are now all online, all 35 videos.
Have a watch and please do donate to the cause.
If you can, comicrelief.com slash fish
is where you'll find our Just Giving page.
It would really help some people out.
All right, we'll see you again next week, guys,
with another episode.
Goodbye.