No Such Thing As A Fish - No Such Thing As A Safe Robot
Episode Date: May 31, 2019Live from Birmingham, Dan, James, Anna and Andrew discuss underwater dog treadmills, hitchhiking robots, and the late, late Elizabeth Taylor. ...
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Welcome to another episode of No Such Thing as a Fish, a weekly podcast this week coming to you live from Birmingham.
Anna Chisinski, Andrew Hunter Murray, and James Harkin.
And once again, we have gathered round the microphones with our four favorite facts from the last seven days.
And in no particular order, here we go.
Starting with fact number one, and that is James.
Okay, my fact this week is that Hitchbot was a robot invented to see how far human kindness would
take a mechanical hitchhiker.
In 2015, he was left
on the side of the road in Boston
and was found dismembered in a ditch
17 days later.
Yeah, and found in Philadelphia,
which is a city of brotherly love.
I read a headline about it
which said, innocent hitchhiking robot
murdered by America.
And there's CCTV footage, isn't there?
They don't know who the guy is, but he was wearing a
backwards baseball cap.
They saw him starting to beat the robot.
He then rips the arm off the robot,
and he beats the robot with the arm.
I mean, it's a proper savaging.
Yeah.
So actually, there was a few of these robots made.
It started in 2014,
and it was by a guy called David Harris-Smith
of McMaster University
and Frokazella of Ryerson University.
And the earlier ones had gone through Canada, Germany,
and the Netherlands with no problems at all.
They'd gone and seen some amazing things.
But yeah, this guy,
left him off the side of the road in Boston and it did not end well.
The Canadian adventures were amazing.
Well, it just, I mean, for a start, the thing itself was made really cheap.
It was made for less than a thousand dollars.
So it was not a very good robot.
As in the arms that Dan mentioned were swimming pool noodles.
You could only get about three or four good hits with them.
And it had a cake saver over its face.
What's a cake saver?
Like one of those plastic lids
that you put over a cake to save it.
Oh yeah, yeah.
The little see-through, so you can still see the cake.
Yeah, exactly, yeah.
Is that like a helmet?
Yeah, it was designed for,
it was reused as a helmet for a robot.
And it had a car seat.
It was sitting on a children's car seat
so people could put it in their cars.
It did have some good things though.
It had a camera that took regular photos,
which I think maybe is where we got
this CCTV that Dan was talking about.
It had a voice box that would explain
where it wanted to go.
and it had solar panels
but it could also be charged
by plugging it into the car's cigarette lighter socket.
Brilliant.
It was very popular at the time
so you could follow it on Twitter
and there was a thing where it had GPS in it
so people know where it was
and they had to work out how to turn that off
because when people collected the hitchpot
and brought it home,
fans would flock to the house of this person
and they would be inundated
and the adventures were great.
He was picked up by a band called The Wild
who I've not heard
but their members are called Dylan Village
the kid, boozes, and Reese Lightning.
So they sound...
They sound great.
They sound like the guys who chopped him to pieces.
We've got a strong history of abusing robots, haven't we?
It's going to be awful when they become sentient,
because we give them a rush of time.
There are loads of examples.
In 2017, in Silicon Valley, in fact,
a drunk man was arrested after knocking over an egg-shaped five-foot-tall security robot
called Nightscope.
It was really sad.
but the Nightscope, it was called Nightscope K-5 actually,
and it had previously been in the news for running over a toddler's foot.
Oh, okay, so there was...
There was some speculation, it was sort of payback.
Harmed on on both sides.
Yeah.
Well, people get very weird around robots,
because when we were talking about the murder of hitchbot,
everyone in the room felt quite tense.
So there's a robot...
And if people are told to hit a dinosaur robot with a mallet,
they get a bit freaked out, they don't like doing it.
And roboticists, proper robotic...
are quite annoyed by this,
and they say this is just crazy anthropomorphising.
So there's a guy called Noel Sharkey,
and he thinks that we need to get over this obsession
with treating machines like they've got feelings.
And I read this account of him.
To prove his point, at one conference he attended recently,
he picked up an extremely cute robotic seal
designed for elderly care and started banging its head against a table.
Oh my God.
It's just a robot.
It's weird, though.
It was someone I think writing in that article saying,
it's bizarre that if you're sitting around a table with someone
and there's a teddy nearby and they seize a teddy and tear its head off,
you'll think they're a psycho.
But if they swat a fly, which is a living creature
that's relatively harmless to any of you,
then it's perfectly normal behaviour.
That's quite a good point.
It's true.
In 2018, some German researchers asked 89 students
to turn off a cute-looking robot called Now,
but they asked it questions first,
but when they tried to turn it off
it was programmed to say,
no, please don't switch me off.
Oh.
And every, sorry,
a third of the humans
took twice as long as normal
to turn off the robots
and 13 of the group
refused to turn it off at all.
Wow.
It said it was afraid of the dark.
It's not real.
Guys.
It's like the end of Blade Runner.
I've got a thing
about how polite humans are to robots.
Okay.
So this is in a reference.
restaurant setting. People were given the chance to order food from a robot. Researchers from
Tuft University, they made a waiter bot and they asked humans in the restaurant to order from
the robot, but they also programmed it not to handle indirect speech very well. Okay, so it needed
to be ordered from, but people are so reluctant to say, you know, they order something.
So I just want to try a little kind of roleplay. James, if you play the participants,
James is the human and I'm the robot here. Okay. Can I have one water? Yes, that is permissible.
Great.
Please tell me your order.
Can I have one water?
Yes, that is permissible.
Great. I'll take one water.
Thank you for sharing that interesting prediction.
Please tell me your order.
Can I order one water?
Yes, that is permissible.
Okay.
Can you bring me one water?
Yes, I am able to do that.
Please tell me your order.
I would like to have one water.
Thank you for sharing.
that interesting fact.
Please tell me your order.
Then there's a 16 second pause.
Can you bring me
water?
Yes, I am able to do that.
Please tell me your order.
May you please bring me warm water?
Yes, I am able to do that.
So can you do it?
Yes.
Please tell me your order.
Can you go inside and get the water for me?
Yes, I am able to do that.
Please tell me your order.
People will not say, I order one water, they just won't do it.
I don't think that used my entire range of acting ability, I was saying.
We're going to have to move on shortly unless there's more dialogue.
Oh, wow, just on humanoid robots.
They've been around for way longer than I thought.
So Japan loves robots now, it's probably the pioneer of robots, but has done for ages.
So in the 17th century, they invented a humanoid robot.
and they're called Caracuri dolls
and I'd never heard of these guys
but they're dolls that were basically there
to carry tea to you
so they worked with quite a simple mechanism
but basically you got a cup of tea
you had a guest round, you wanted to impress them
you got out your robot, you popped a tea
on the tray that the robot's carrying
and this triggered a mechanism that caused it to turn around
and walk over to your guest, offer them the tea
and then stand beside your guests while they drink the tea
in probably quite an intimidating manner
and then when you finish the tea
you pop it back on the tray
and the robot turned around
and walked back again.
That is amazing.
And how long's that from?
That's the 17th century.
They were really probably
from the 17th to the 19th century in Japan.
And there were lots of others
there were some that acted out
sort of medieval scenes,
Japanese scenes, old mythical scenes and stuff.
I have another robot in Japan actually.
It's called Robo v2
and they programmed it to go around a shopping centre
and whenever it bumped into a human
it would be programmed to politely ask the humans to step aside.
And if they didn't move out the way,
it would kind of go in a different direction.
That was all it did.
But then what happened was,
a load of children worked out what was happening
and started making a circle around it.
And then they started shaking it,
punching it, and kicking it.
And the bullying got so bad
that the researchers had to put an abuse evading algorithm
in the robot.
So the robot would scan the area,
and if it saw anyone that was under four foot,
sex as in a child,
then it would quickly run in the other direction.
I do this in chopping senses.
Okay, it is time for fact number two,
and that is Chazinski.
My fact this week is that a Hungarian entrepreneur
has been fined for not
building an underwater treadmill for dogs.
Confusing.
Oh shit, I haven't done that either.
Oh.
You expect the...
police at your door any moment now.
I hope we have all done this
because this person got in trouble.
They got a fine of
140,000 euros
this person and it's because
years ago in 2008
this business one said that
he needed 140,000
euros of funding
from the EU's Rural Development Fund
to develop a hydrotherapy treadmill
system for dogs. Now this is a genuinely
important thing for animals that have been
wounded. Don't laugh. It's
crucial for dog recovery.
The only thing is, he never did any of that.
The officers were investigated. They were overrun with
weeds. No one was using them. Six months
after the EU payments were made. This investigation
opened and he's finally been
investigated and given a suspended prison sentence
for never building that treadmill.
And a fine, which is actually a very lenient
fine, really. It can't be essential
for dog healing. Otherwise, no dog
would ever have survived any injury
before the invention of the underwater dog treadmill.
You've got to do it.
So hungry at the moment,
is run by Victor Orban.
He has taken money to make a 4,000 seats
of football stadium in his home village
where he grew up called Felkshoot
and the population of that town
is about a thousand.
So it's four times bigger than the number of people
who live there. He's also made a vintage railway
between his two childhood villages.
He took two million euros of EU funding
for this railway and they claimed
that there would be 2,500 to 7,000 passengers
using it every single day
and in the first month
there were 30 passengers
and it's just him going back and forth
I think it might be
he is football obsessed Orban isn't he
so this railway line was connecting
the football stadium that he loved
to this other little village
but he played semi-professional football
while he was doing his first stint as Prime Minister
in the fourth division of their league tables
but still decent
he's said to watch six football games a day
which is a lot for someone who's
running a country. And his first trip of war when he was Prime Minister was to see the World
Cup in Paris and people say that he has not missed a World Cup or Champions League final since.
He's been in the news recently, or rather his government has, because they have a new campaign
about having lots of children and it's a sort of pro-fertility campaign to get the population numbers
up. But unfortunately, the stock models that they used for this campaign, you may have seen this
in the news, were the two people involved in the distracted boyfriend meme online?
No way
So they were trying to present a couple
who were very happily in love with each other
But really, we knew the truth
That he was a distracted boyfriend
And it has no idea what we're talking about
Not on social media
So it's not a happy couple
A meme is kind of an image or a video
That goes on the line
Okay
It all goes back to the 1980s
I'll look it up afterwards
Yeah
So treadmills
Yeah
Treadmills at times are animals
Are always using treadmills
They've been used, treadmills were used for animals before they were used for humans even.
And actually, they were really important for horses in farming.
They have been for hundreds of years.
So in the 19th century especially, before things were properly mechanized, then farm machinery was basically horse operated.
So you had threshing machines, which would be these big machines, which kind of separated the grain from the corn,
and they'd go round and round in one building.
And the way they'd go round around is you just have two horses on a treadmill trotting along it all day long.
So they're pushing it?
They're operating the mechanism
So they're on this treadmill
It's connected to a bunch of pulleys and cogs and stuff
And then that's turning the wheels around
It just feels very hard
The idea of in a gym
Pushing a treadmill along with your feet
It is very hard
Like if the treadmill's off
For you to push it along
No no I was yeah sorry
I was thinking the first proper use for humans of it
Was in jails obviously back in Oscar Wild
Famously when he was in jail
Had to do the step treadmill
Which they used to employ to have no purpose
Other than for hard labour
and Oscar Wilde suffered so much from it.
He died two years after he got out of jail,
which they think is largely to do with the treadmill.
It is quite amazing, though, isn't it?
It was basically the hardest kind of punishment
you could get apart from being killed
for probably about 100 years,
and now people do it for fun?
Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah.
They were massive as well, the prison treadmills.
They started in Brixton.
That's what Brixton was famous for 200 years ago
was having a tremor which could fit 24 people on it
at the same time, side by side.
Wow.
Yeah.
Sorry, it was kind of like a game of...
Did you guys ever play 10 green bottles?
No.
Did anyone ever play that?
I know the song.
God, maybe it's not a thing, except in my family.
Ten green bottles and you all line a bed, ten of you,
and then one green bottle accidentally falls,
and you fall out of the bed.
Oh, yeah.
Anyway, it was kind of like a less fun version of that,
because...
We were called that, like, ten in the bed
and the little one said,
all over.
Yes, same idea.
Yeah.
So, this treadmill was like that.
What are these families that you guys have got?
Bottles in the bed.
I can see where the alcoholism is coming.
But the way they would take breaks is the person,
there would be, what, 12 people on a treadmill or something?
And the way you take a break is you'd nudge the guy off
who was on the furthest left,
and the person to the far right would jump on again,
and they'd get to walk around to the other side of the treadmill,
and that would be their sort of few minutes of break.
Yes, it would be 60 minutes that you would be,
and you'd get 12 minutes per 60 minutes of break.
Just on horse treadmills, quick.
Oh yeah.
So one of the first ever trains
was powered by a horse on a treadmill.
What?
So this was a...
Sorry, can I just ask?
Why do they have...
Why are they not...
Horses not just pulling these things
rather than being on treadmills?
So what you mean?
The trains or the...
Yeah, the trains.
Because you don't need a smooth road for the horse.
Okay.
I mean, you do need a rail for the railway.
But...
But it makes it...
Yeah, so...
Yeah.
Was that an answer?
Yes, it's an answer.
It's not the best possible answer.
I guess your train just can't suddenly
just take a left and disappear to someone,
some other bit of England.
Yeah, exactly.
That's a really good point.
Yeah, exactly.
So it's a control thing.
There you go.
Good answer, Dan.
Never thought I'd say this, but thank God Dan was here for you.
So it was called the Cycloped,
and only two of them were ever built, unsurprisingly.
And this was, it was at the same time
as Stevenson's Rocket,
which was the train that we did end up using
was developed.
It was in the same set of trials
where everyone brought their own train
and they said, let's see what works.
But I read it could go faster
than Stevenson's rocket.
Really?
I really could go at five miles an hour.
I think Stevenson's rocket
went really slow as well, though, didn't it?
I thought it went at six miles an hour
maybe Stevenson's rocket,
so maybe they were really close in the race.
But I don't understand.
So the horse is on a treadmill
and then what's that powering
to make the train move?
It's like your plow thing.
No, but the plowsing stays in one place, which is how that works,
because the cogs are all attached to it.
It's a threshing machine.
It's a threshing machine, so it's in one room.
Whereas the train is going to run away from you,
and then you're just on a treadmill,
and the train's at the other end of the field.
No, it's on the train.
Oh, it's on the train.
Oh, my God.
Dan, to the rescue.
That makes perfect sense.
Yes.
Well, they did this exact same thing with boats, didn't they?
With ferries in the 19th century.
And these were very popular.
They started in 1791, a guy called John Fitch built the first one.
And it was basically before ferries were steam-powered.
They would look a bit like a catamaran, but with those two shelves on either side.
But on those shelves, there would be two or three horses on each side.
And they were trot along, powering this treadmill, which turned the pedals around,
which turned the paddles round, which powered the boat.
And the only problem with them was that it was a really...
issue if the horses on the left side went faster than the horses on the right side because your
boat just went round in circles. That's amazing. So there was a study in 2015 that looked at people
having treadmills in the office. This is a new thing, isn't it? So the idea is that being sitting
down in the office all day is not good for you. So what if you had a treadmill? And it found that people
who used a treadmill desk for two hours every day had significantly better blood pressure and
slept better at night, which is quite good.
unfortunately they performed worse on almost all aspects of their job
including the ability to concentrate
and the ability to type
they were substantially slower in all tasks and more error prone
we know someone who does that for their job
they've just been fired haven't they
Roger Highfield
he was the editor of new scientists for many years
and he used to edit new scientists on a treadmill
and yes he is no longer there
He works for the science museum now
But yeah, for many years, new scientists
was edited on a treadmill.
You know there's a treadmill for ants?
Is it?
Yeah.
Scientists have invented a treadmill for ants
to test, I don't know, something or other.
Is it like, so just a really, really tiny treadmill?
It's a little plastic ball
and you put them on top of the ball
and you have to tether them to a thing above
so that they, you know, say don't wander off.
Yeah.
Bike mission impossible.
They get lowered down.
And then they start, yeah.
And it's to test how they navigate and where they stop
and where they try and find their way.
We need to move on in a second.
On corruption.
Some quick thing on corruption.
In Nepal, they have invented some bribe-proof trousers.
Which they're handing out to all officials.
How does that?
They just don't have any pockets.
Okay.
It is time for fact number three.
And that is my fact.
My fact this week is that the late actress, Elizabeth
Smith Taylor, who was notorious for always being late,
arranged to arrive at her own funeral 15 minutes late.
That was in the sort of the arrangements that she did with her PA.
She said, this is my thing and I want to make sure that I keep that even in death.
Were people pissed off?
Did they leave?
Were they like when she turned up sort of checking their watches and sighing?
Do we know?
No, I think it was probably everyone knew.
They were like, this will start 15 minutes late.
Okay.
It's on the sheet.
So she was a late one.
She was also, another thing that she did wrong in her life
was she was a shoplifter.
Was she?
Elizabeth Taylor.
Really?
She was a one-time shoplifter.
She once shoplifted a copy of A.A. Housman's Shropshire Lad from Foils.
So big-time criminal.
The reason she did it is because, as probably you all know,
she was married to Richard Burton twice,
and Burton boasted her about how good he was at stealing from foils.
and so he said, I do this amazing thing.
It's so clever.
I go into the bookshop,
and I go up to the till and I buy one book,
and I get the receipt,
and I ostentatiously leave it poking out of the book.
And then I pick up six or seven more books on my way out,
and because I'm walking out with the receipt, poking out with the first,
they just assume that I've bought them all.
And so she thought, I'm going to fucking try that.
And so she stole her husband as a drop she lad,
and was really pissed off with her,
and said, why did you bloody well do that?
And then he said, that was the last thing she ever stole except husbands.
Oh. She died in 2011, and when she died, the New York Times ran an obituary for her, as they would.
But it was written by a guy called Mel Gussau, who was a theatre critic, and he had himself died six years earlier.
But it was so good that they ran it anyway. And I think there wasn't many events of her life to update on in those six years.
Wait, so he'd written the obituary before she died.
Before he died.
Obviously before he died. Obviously before he died.
At the start of the obituary writing process, no one would.
was dead.
Yes.
By the end of publication,
everyone involved was dead.
Yeah.
I suppose the thing
I'm trying to emphasize
is that it's interesting
people write obituary
six years before the person
who's obituary it is,
is dead.
Yes.
That's quite common, isn't it?
It does happen, yes.
So I was just saying a very obvious
fact that we all knew,
and that's, uh,
let's press on.
But they do.
Well, you had your moments in the sun
about ten minutes ago.
I knew it was going to come crashing down.
It's always.
Funeral requests.
So there are various funeral requests
that people have made sort of things they wanted to happen.
Heinrich Hein, the writer,
he left his estate to his wife
on the condition that she should get married again
and he said,
so there will be at least one man to regret my death.
Oh, yeah.
Slam.
Gosh.
How did he die?
Was it with a bread knife in the back?
George Benetrol, he had the best last request I've ever heard.
He left money in his will and he said,
right, I'm leaving a parcel of money
and I want it to go towards reforming the English alphabet
into one that is phonetic
and has minimum 40 letters.
Imagine getting that task from George Berich as well.
He was massively committed to that, wasn't he, his new alphabet?
And it did not work.
I was reading about Bruce Lee's funeral.
Oh, yeah.
So Bruce Lee, obviously, he died very young.
And his funeral, the Paul Bearers at his funeral,
who carried the coffin were Chuck Norris,
Steve McQueen, James Coburn, George Lazenby.
How cool is that?
That is...
Well, I mean, he's the fifth best bond.
Come on.
What?
None of the other four replied to the invitation, hey?
I think that's embarrassing, quite frankly.
He was the best bond.
That's very cool.
But check this out.
So while they were filming...
Sorry, when Bruce Lee died,
they were filming Game of Death,
which eventually became his final movie.
But he'd only made about 30 minutes of footage
that was usable for the film,
and they were largely...
fight, an iconic fight with Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, the basketball player, is one of those...
He fights a basketball player.
Who plays a kung fu guy.
Oh, I see.
He's not just beating up a random basketball player.
It seems like plucking low-hanging fruit at that stage of this career.
I think if you're fighting a basketball player, you mostly go for the low-hanging fruit, don't you?
But so, as a result, they had to scrape around for extra footage to use.
And bits of the footage included Bruce Lee's funeral itself.
So they used the actual footage to help the plot line go along.
How did that help the plot line go along?
Actually, I haven't seen the movie yet.
There's a suggestion in what I've read
that they've actually used a picture of him passed away
in the open casket as well.
Really?
Wow.
Yeah. But then for the rest of it,
they had a few stunt doubles, but they obviously needed his face.
So they just had paper cutouts of him,
sort of cardboard cutouts that were slightly nudged
so you could see his head moving a bit.
and largely the movie is just a cardboard cut out of him.
Wow.
Just on celebrity funerals.
A very famous celebrity funeral back in the day was that of Rudolf Valentino,
so the huge silent movie star.
He died in 1926 when he was 31, and 100,000 people went to his funeral.
There were these massive riots outside the funeral parlour,
and people were struggling, climbing over each other to get a glimpse of him.
It was an open casket.
And there were these four guards who looked,
there was his claim at the time
that Mussolini had sent four fascist guards
and remember it's 1926,
they didn't have the connotations they do now,
four fascist guards.
They were widely seen as friendly and good guys back then, I believe.
But actually they'd been hired as actors
by the funeral parlour to make it seem more dramatic.
But his girlfriend, Valentino's girlfriend,
was a woman called Polar Negri,
and she really handed up.
So she fainted on his coffin during the funeral,
just fainted on top of it,
came around, said,
The sad thing is he just proposed to me,
and therefore I'm actually basically his widow.
And then she fainted again.
She fainted multiple times.
The coffin made this five-day trip from New York to California,
and she accompanied it the whole time just constantly fainting.
Dozens of times in five days.
Yeah, I read that because there were so many fans going to the casket,
they were worried that it might damage the body.
And so the people who were in charge of the funeral,
there was a company called Campbell's.
They put a wax model in its place
because they thought that it would get damaged.
Really?
Wow.
Something quickly on lateness, maybe.
So people who are chronically late,
according to a new report,
have better mental and physical health.
They live longer and they're more successful.
Really?
Apparently.
This is because late people
tend to be both optimistic and unrealistic.
and having especially an optimistic outlook
can give you a better mental health
and a better physical health
and lower your rate of death.
That's nice.
I do find lateness across culture
is quite interesting
because people get so angry.
I'm chronically late
and I think it's going to shorten my life
because it's so anxiety-inducing.
But people get so angry about it
in our culture.
You're a selfish, evil bastard
who doesn't care about other people.
Guys, guys.
I said those words in the heat of the moment.
and I regret them.
But then if you go to Brazil, for instance,
the culture is completely different.
So there was a blog by a writer
who lived in Brazil for a few years
and she said she was invited to her first party.
She turned up about five minutes
after the time the party started.
And the host, it was like she knocked on the door
and had to get the host out of the shower
and it was extremely awkward
and she sat around for about two hours
thinking what's going on
and everyone turned up about three, four hours later.
And then she spoke to a professor
about it afterwards and the professor said
in Brazil, turning up on time,
for a party is almost as awkward as turning up to a party
where you haven't been invited at all.
It's a massive faux pas.
And they have a thing in Brazil called aura inglazer,
which means turning up on time,
and it means keeping the English hour,
as in you fucking turned up at the aura englazer,
you loser.
Yeah.
We need to move on to our final fact of the show,
and that is Andy.
My fact is that Mexico has a national championship
of double entendres.
Yeah.
And it's a big one.
Yay.
So,
buckle up.
So there's this thing in Mexico called Albuhr,
which is a play on words,
and it's almost always sexual.
And there are lots and lots of different ways
that you can make things sound slightly rude.
And you combine words to make new meanings,
or you use words with similar sounds.
And they have a competition every year
to find the best Alboreros,
or wordplay masters, in the country.
Can I give you an example of an albara, what is the difference between a chair and an octopus?
The octopus has tentacles and the chair touches backs.
Actually, it works better in Spanish.
No, does it?
Because touching backsides or touching bums is tentacolos and tentacles is tent.
I've really fucked this up.
Yeah.
That's great.
I don't know if you'd win that championship.
It's really intense.
So you have...
Someone gives you an al-Bur,
and then you have five seconds
to come up with another one in return
playing off what they've said to you,
or you get knocked out.
Like time chess.
Do you hit like a...
It's like time chess, exactly.
That's so cool.
And so for many, many years,
it was dominated completely by men.
And then suddenly,
this one lady,
Lordez Ruiz came along.
And she's been the reigning champion
for years and years.
No one can do anything to outdo her.
Yeah, like over 20 years, isn't it?
Yeah, she's the queen of...
of Alba.
Yeah, which is amazing
because it's a massively male thing,
quite misogynistic thing.
Women were kind of excluded from it.
It's like lots of men making incredibly crude jokes
often at women's expense.
And yeah, she's penetrated that circle.
So...
But yeah, it has quite a long history, doesn't it?
This sort of word battles and battles of wits.
So there's a thing called flighting,
which I don't know people know about,
but basically this is traditional battles of wits,
which have been going on since at least the things.
5th century. And these were basically an exchange of insults. And it was a form of entertainment
historically. It was largely a Scottish thing. And very famous lasted a thousand years from the
5th, the 16th century. So over a millennium. And one of the famous flighting incidents was this event
called the flighting of Dunbar and Kennedy. And this is in the 16th century and it was a court
flighting. So it was done for James IV, I think, to entertain him. And it was,
these two characters insulting each other
and it was the first time anyone ever called someone else a shit.
Really?
Surely the first time we have on record.
First on record called a shit without a wit.
That's good.
I've got a few more lines from it.
So this is one little verse that one person would say.
Gray visaged gallows bird out of your wits gone wild,
loathsome and lousy as wet as a crest.
Since you with worship would so fain be styled.
Hail Monsignor, your baldrope below your dress.
It's good, isn't it?
There are some other examples of this kind of flighting
and rat battle and kind of stuff like that.
So the Iwi people in Ghana,
they had a type of poetry called Halo.
And again, it's a way of judging disputes
and it's a way of insulting each other.
But you said that you had five seconds in this other one.
In this one, you have a couple of weeks
in between insults.
And instead of just kind of coming up with ideas
off the top of your head,
you do actual research
into the family history of your enemy.
And you look into what their grandparents did
or their great grandparents did
and find the best nuggets that you could use against them.
Would you go around sort of interviewing their best friends
going, would you say he's a bit of a dick?
I've been looking up innuendo in general.
And so there was a thing about a butcher in Staffordshire.
He was asked by the,
This is this year, I think, he was asked by the police
to remove signs outside his butcher's shop
because he said he advertised a big fresh cock,
which is basically a single entendre this guy's got.
And he also offered on a sign
the chance to have your rump tenderized before you leave.
And the Guardian reported that arguably more offensive
was his flagrant use of the green grocer's apostrophe.
So police appear unwilling to take action over that.
And they had this whole thing about, you know, innuendo.
So there's a comedian called Stephen Bailey.
And it's all about context and who's making the joke.
So Stephen Bailey is a stand-up who has a lot of explicit material.
He's gay himself.
And the Guardian reported that Bailey's show contains explicit sexual material.
But again, it's all about context.
The same jokes told by Roy Chubby Brown or the late Bernard Manning would sound aggressive,
whereas Bailey's ejaculations are far easier to swallow.
Super.
So bad.
There's a book actually
called Away With Words
which is written by a guy called Joe Berkowitz
who,
and these are basically puns
that we're talking about
and he travelled around the world
visiting pun contests.
And the biggest one is the O. Henry Punoff
in Austin, Texas.
Started in 1978
and it's the world championship of punning.
And so they have on-stage referees during this
and referees can immediately disqualify someone
if they use what they consider
subpar wordplay.
And so I think it as something like that would be, you know, if you use like excellent,
if you're talking about an omelette or something.
I imagine that would get booed off stage.
What, because you're slightly tweaking?
No, I think it's just like you think that's really shit.
That's like not up to the standards.
It's like if someone does an underarm serve or something in tennis.
But he said he was going through the best puns he heard in the contest.
And sadly for this pun to work, you have to know there's a kind of cherry called a Bing cherry,
which I didn't know.
What kind of cherry?
A Bing.
Bing.
It's in Chandler Bing.
Okay, okay.
He said the best pun he heard was,
I went to go shopping for cherries and microphones the other day.
Boda Bing, Bada boom.
Yeah.
I mean, you still did have to explain it before we started.
Well, the economist did a thing where they said actually
some of the best puns you do have to explain
because they're quite complex and layered.
And it used the example of the one about Mahatma Gandhi
who walked barefoot a lot and often fasted,
which led to bad breath,
thus making him a super callous, fragile,
mystic hex by halitosis.
Sometimes it's worth the build-up.
We're going to have to wrap up very shortly, guys.
Oh, I found a couple of weird fiestas.
This is a Mexican fiesta.
So they've got incredible fiestas over there.
But I did find a British equivalent,
which I think is one of, I would like to go to this.
There's a Sussex pub called Lewis Arms,
and it hosts every year the World P-throwing Championships.
And the record at the time of recording is 44 meters,
for throwing a single pea.
And I think that's amazing.
That's incredible.
Not with your bare arm.
Yeah, with your bare arm throwing a pea.
Because obviously they, you know,
there's a lot of air resistance.
There's a lot of air resistance.
It's not that they're heavy or hard to throw.
But so the winner, the 2015 winner, Graham Butterworth,
he said, you've got to make sure you pick a pea that has few indents
because that affects its aerodynamic qualities.
But I think it's really impressive because it's impossible to tell where they land.
So that's the real challenge.
talent in the pea-throwing championship.
And they have pea spotters all the way along the route
assessing where the peas land.
Wow.
That's so good.
That does not sound like a full-time job.
One of the competitors said,
I was the first to throw,
so I was briefly the world champion,
although it did not last long,
but it was nice while it lasted,
basically fundamentally failing to understand
what being the world champion means.
I found a guy who, well,
I found a competition,
which is the French pig squealing championship,
and the idea is,
that you just have to squeal as, well, it's kind of on the tin, isn't it?
It's the French pig squealing championship.
So you're making the squeal, you're not making a pig squeal, right?
Yeah, you yourself are making the squeal.
So people come up and they start squealing.
And there's a guy called Noel Jamet, and he has won it twice for his excellent pig squeals.
He comes dressed as a pig as well to sort of really...
Method, very nice.
And he's, yeah, he's won it twice.
He's won twice as well, the international championships for the pig grunter.
the agricultural shows in 2007-2008 and it's a big thing in France I say it's big it's not big
there's also the weird festival that I like championship that I like is the Naki-Sumo
baby crying festival in Japan so I didn't know about this this is in Tokyo it takes place in a temple
although there are other versions around Japan and the idea is that you bring your baby as a parent
you bring your baby to this festival and it will get paired up with a sumo wrestler who tries to
make it cry and the one who makes the baby cry the most is the winner and the sumo
has various tactics so one thing they might do is they might wear a scary mask to make the baby
cry although apparently often they just repeatedly shout the word cry in its face okay that is it
that is all of our facts thank you so much for listening um in contact with any of us about the
things that we have said over the course of this podcast
we can be found on our Twitter accounts.
I'm on at Schuyberland, Andy.
At Andrew Hunter, I'm at James.
At James Harkin.
And Chisinski.
You can email podcast at QI.com.
Thank you so much, Birmingham.
We'll see you again. Goodbye.
