NPR Music - And the Oscar for Original Song goes to...

Episode Date: February 18, 2025

With Oscar season here, we review the nominees for Original Song and Original Score, prognosticate who will win the statues on March 2, and look at the Academy's biggest snubs.Enjoy the show? Share it... with a friend and leave us a review on Apple or wherever you listen to podcasts. Questions, comments, suggestions or feedback of any kind always welcome: allsongs@npr.org Hear the songs in the All Songs Considered playlists in Apple Music and Spotify.See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.NPR Privacy Policy

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Hazel, you know, there is a lot to envy about your life. I don't know if you've ever thought about this. I have actually. I've thought about it a lot. Yeah. I thought, yeah. So much. But there is one thing that I am particularly jealous of. What are you jealous of?
Starting point is 00:00:16 Well, it's the way that, and you've told me this, it's the way that you have carefully calibrated your entire adult life to see as many movies as possible. I have, yeah. I have designed my life. to see all the movies that I possibly can, as many as I can. The world is my oyster. It really is. I'm so jealous. There was a time, you know, before all the things that sort of suck up my nights and weekends.
Starting point is 00:00:42 Now, there was a time when I would see a movie or a couple movies in a theater every week. And I really miss it. I do see movies at home, but, you know, it usually will take me several nights to watch a movie because I can only watch maybe 30 minutes or 45 minutes at a time, and then I get interrupted with something. Like, it took me a week to watch The Irishman. Well, that's a very long movie. But yeah, sure, I get it.
Starting point is 00:01:08 Well, one of the things that I've always loved maybe most about films is the music. The original scores, the songs. And it is Oscar season. And on this episode, we're going to talk about the nominees for the best score and best song who we think will win, who should win, and who got snubbed, lots of snubs this year, I think. A lot of snubs. So many snubs.
Starting point is 00:01:29 Let's just start by running down the nominees for Best Score. There were five films. One of them is the three and a half hour long era-spanning drama called The Brutalist. This one also took me about a week to get through. And it has an equally sprawling score by the composer Daniel Bloomberg. We'll talk about our predictions and the snubs in a bit. But straight up, I will say that of the nominees, this is by far my first. favorite. I would agree. When I saw this movie in theaters, and it did have an intermission,
Starting point is 00:02:49 it is such an insane epic movie about like immigrating to America and the aftermath of World War II. And it's this movie about American industrialism and trying to be a self-made man in this country and sort of the darkness that comes with that and what you have to sacrifice. And this score really lives up to the intensity of the film. It just, it has this big, sweeping epicness that is, I feel like no other movie this year sort of contains. Yeah, it's very grand. It's very gothic. You know, the film follows an architect and his wild vision that kind of spirals out of control.
Starting point is 00:03:31 So steel and concrete, you know, those sorts of things figure into the story a lot. And the score kind of sounds like that. It's almost mechanical, but also organic. Yeah. Even the music they were hearing right now, there is this sort of like you feel like you're on a train. You feel like you're in the belly of a ship and the gears are turning and, you know, and then the score has these really incredible moments where it has these like big swooning kind of brass moments that honestly kind of, it kind of reminded me of the score to chariots of fire a little bit.
Starting point is 00:04:01 Oh, interesting. Yeah, I can hear that. Yeah, this sort of like swinging upwards sense of promise to the score and just it works so well with the story. I actually thought of the shining. when I listen to it. Yeah. Because you know, another theme of the film is madness. And there's a real undercurrent of horror in the score that reminded me of what Wendy Carlos and Rachel Elkin did for The Shining. Also too, like, you know, this score, which as you said, was composed by Daniel Bloomberg.
Starting point is 00:04:49 When I was looking at his list of bands and projects that he's done, I was like, oh, he was in Yuck. Like he was the frontman of Yuck, which was an indie rock band, you know, from like the early tens and it's just really interesting to see the turn that his career has taken because this score just feels as an introduction to him as someone who scores films just really impressive. Yeah, I was a Yuck fan and did not realize that Daniel Bloomberg was now. I mean, they broke up a few years ago. Yeah. And I was super bummed about that, but I didn't keep following Daniel Bloomberg and didn't
Starting point is 00:05:20 know that he was scoring now. But great one. The Brutal List from Daniel Bloomberg. All right. Next up, the Wild Robot, the animated film from DreamWorks. Chris Bowers is the composer for this one. I love this score. I feel like it is so playful and futuristic, and it's funny, I was listening to it, and I was like, man, I really love the percussion on a lot of these songs.
Starting point is 00:06:19 And then I saw that Chris Bowers, who did the score, worked with the group Sandbox percussion, who is this percussion group who kind of uses, you know, unconventional instruments, like glass bottles and planks of wood and cowbells and things like that. and I really sort of understood the sense of adventure and wonder. I thought it's an incredible score.
Starting point is 00:06:41 Yeah, I really like this one too. I'm a big Chris Bowers fan and generally love his work. He does the music for Bridgeton, that TV series. I really like, he did King Richard. I really liked what he did for that. So many other great scores that he's done. And I agree, there are some really wonderful moments in this Wild Robot score. It supports the story really well.
Starting point is 00:07:00 I think my biggest issue with it, and it's one that I've, frequently have with a lot of the best score nominees for the Oscars is that maybe a little too safe, it kind of stays between the lines a little bit too much for me. You know, I'm always looking for something that's super unconventional. Yeah. And this one's just a little bit too sort of traditional Hollywood score for me. But I do think it works really well with the film, and I do enjoy his work. Well, let's talk about one that decidedly does not have a traditional Hollywood score, and that's the film Amelia Perez, maybe the most polarizing film nominated this year.
Starting point is 00:07:49 And we could talk more about that, but the score is by Clement Ducal and Camille. So Amelia Perez is the most nominated film this year. 13 nominations, including Best Picture, along with Best Score, and Best Song. We're going to talk about those in a little bit. But despite all of its nominations and all the buzz, I say it's polarizing because a lot of people really, really didn't like this film. Yeah, me included. I did not like this. Yeah, I did not care for it either. It had some moments. I mean, but you look at Rotten Tomatoes. It's got a score of 17% from the audience.
Starting point is 00:09:05 Oh, wow. Yeah, I mean, the critics, critic scores around 72%, but still not great. A lot of write-ups and reviews talking about how problematic the film is. But tell me what you thought about the music. Yeah, I mean, I think one of my problems with the film overall is that I feel like it's very very difficult. very kind of tonally bizarre to me. I feel like there are moments where it's very dark, but it's sort of played for laughs. And then there's moments where it's very kind of playful. And there's very little coherence to the film. And I feel like listening to the music of it, the score and the songs that we'll talk about later, I feel like it's also incoherent, basically.
Starting point is 00:09:45 You know, a lot of this score, which I feel like there's very little of in the film because it is a musical and so much of the music of the movie is sort of songs, dialogue set to music. I just feel like it doesn't match a lot of the moments in the movie and I feel like, you know, I understand the techniques that they're using. Kamey uses a lot of her like layered vocals in the score. There are these kind of moments of dark, vocoded vocals and synths. And I just felt like the score sort of lended itself more to a horror film. And, you know, Amelia Perez, whether you liked it or not, it has these moments of resilience and hope, and there's like a heroine in the film.
Starting point is 00:10:28 And I don't know, I just felt like the score just didn't capture what was really happening in the movie. Yeah, I like a really big swing in movies when it comes to music. I like it when a filmmaker takes chances, subverts expectations, which Amelia Perez does over and over again on multiple levels. You know, if a film suddenly becomes a musical, or it starts off in one genre and becomes a completely different genre, I'm down with that. I'm usually game to go along, but exactly what you said, there were just too many disconnects for me between the music and the story and the subject matter. It just did not come together for me. Yeah, I mean, I think the thing with Amelia Perez is, you know, across all of the music, the score, the original songs, there isn't a coherent language.
Starting point is 00:11:17 to me, like a musical language or mythology. You know, I think they pull in a lot of different genres and sounds and styles into the music of the movie. And so when I'm looking at it overall and I'm listening to it overall, I just, I feel like it really just doesn't come together for me the way that most of the other scores in this category that we, that we're talking about do. Yeah, I agree. Okay, we've got a couple more nominees that we want to talk about, including composer Volker, B, Baxter, Bertelman. Some people know him for the work that he does under the name Haushka. He is nominated this year for the score he did for the film Conclave. You know, as much as I love scores and as often as I listen to him before I even see the movie, I very often will go in having no idea who did the score and not really paying that much attention to it. And if it's a really great score, there will usually be a moment where it does get my attention so much so that it takes.
Starting point is 00:13:17 me away from the story for a moment and I think, well, this is interesting. And there was a moment like that when I was listening to this score where it really got my attention. And for this, I think it was the simple little moment when the strings do that little bin, that... Yes. It's... Yes. Yeah. And so I did look it up and then I saw, oh my gosh, of course, it's Volker Berylthaman, because I have really loved his work in the past. He won an Oscar for his score for Alquite on the Western Front. But what did you think? I have to say when I saw Conclave in theaters, I didn't walk away thinking about the score the same way that, say, when I saw the Brutalists in theaters, like, I left the theater and I was like, man, that score was definitive and incredible. But when I listened to the score for Conclave in the lead up to doing this episode, it really kind of crept up on me how effective it is. Because, you know, Conclave is a movie about, you know, a bunch of cardinals locking themselves in the Vatican to try to elect the new Pope. It's this kind of, you know, tense, gossipy film, claustrophobic film. And this score really ratchets up the tension so effectively.
Starting point is 00:14:26 And I can hear it, as you said, in that moment with that kind of, like, long, yawning string section, but also that kind of like quick, rapid fire, like, da, da, da, da, da, of the score. Yeah, I wrote the word claustrophobic down, too, because it feels like the walls are closing in, which is kind of a theme in the film as well. And the way those strings bend kind of feel like a question mark. And there are so many questions hanging in the air throughout the film. I would not be unhappy if this one won. Me either.
Starting point is 00:14:57 And I think it's interesting to talk about this score after talking about Amelia Perez because I think that this is a score that has really mapped out its mythology and really mapped out its world so well. And I was reading an interview with Bertelman and he was talking about, he really had this kind of feeling of tradition. Like he really wanted to sort of give himself this classic container to work in. And I feel like in a way, like the Conclave score, I can hear that sense of tradition and the regalness of the score in it.
Starting point is 00:15:32 But also a sense of experimentation. Yeah, I agree. Conclave is the film from Volker Bertelmann, his third nomination. All right, we've got one more film that we want to talk about. It's one of the biggest films from last year, Wicked, the film adaptation of the musical Wicked from John Powell and Stephen Schwartz. So anytime a musical gets nominated for Best Score, I'm always so confused. Yeah. Because on the one hand, it's like, well, wait a minute.
Starting point is 00:16:54 All these songs have existed for years and years and years. They were written for the original stage production. But in this case, there's also a whole original score written just for the film outside of all of the musical songs that everyone knows. Yeah. It is kind of confusing to me why Wicked Score was nominated, because if you look at the rules, a score can't be eligible if it's been diluted by the use of pre-existing music, which I think maybe that's, you know, that's sort of depending on what you think dilution means. But also, a score can't be eligible if it's been diminished in impact by the predominant use of songs or any music. not composed specifically for the film. When people think of the music of Wicked,
Starting point is 00:17:44 they're thinking of all of the classic songs from the musical that have obviously existed for years before the movie came out. Right. And so this score, you know, I think it's like a lovely, serviceable score, but to me it's just connective tissue that sort of unites the big ten-pole songs,
Starting point is 00:18:07 which occur so frequently in the film. And so it is a little confusing to me why this score was nominated just because I feel like this score is so secondary to so much of the other music in the movie. And maybe that's rude of me to say, but I just, you know, there were other scores that could have been nominated
Starting point is 00:18:30 in this category, and I'm just a little confused why wicked score. You know, the songs, I guess the songs you can't nominate, because they're already existed, but yeah, it's confusing to me. Yeah, I mean, the rules have changed a lot over the years. A lot of people, of course, know John Williams for Star Wars and all this big blockbusters, but the first Oscar he won was for Federer on the Roof, which obviously was a musical and stage production before it was turned into a film.
Starting point is 00:18:58 There used to be, very briefly, an awards specifically for musicals. It was Best Original Musical or Comedy Score, and it was, introduced as an award in 1995, but pretty quickly discontinued in 1998. I will say I really like the work of John Powell. He is one of my favorite composers. He's done a lot of big blockbuster films like The Born Identity, and he did the Han Solo film, part of one of the Star Wars films. My favorite, though, is a score that he did for the Michael J. Fox documentary that came out a year
Starting point is 00:19:30 or two ago. Still a Michael J. Fox movie is what it was called. And you should totally check that out. Lots of really cool, interesting things that he does in that score. But this is maybe a good time for us to make our predictions on who we think is going to win because I'm kind of thinking Wicked might pull it out for best score. I feel like the Academy cannot resist. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:19:52 They love musicals and everything about it. It checks so many boxes for them, you know, a beloved story, a beloved franchise, you know, beloved cast, a feel-good family-friendly movie, a massive Hollywood production. I don't know. I will not be surprised if it wins. I will be disappointed if it wins because I just, I mean, it just feel like I want a score that marks new territory and carves new path. And I think that conclave will win. I think Berdelman has won before. And I feel like the brutalest score, as much as I love it, I think it might be a tad too out there for the Academy to award.
Starting point is 00:20:34 I feel like their score. Tasting tastes can be a little conservative, but I would love to be pleasantly surprised, but I think Conclave will win. So if you had to say who should win, you'd pick the Brutalist? I think the Brutalist should win. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:20:50 I agree completely. Yeah. Okay. Before we get to the best song nominees, though, let's talk snubs real quick and the scores that they missed. Well, the biggest snub is Dren Rezner and Atticus Ross for their score for challengers, which is a huge hole to me. I'm very confused. Those are two people who have won twice for Best Score in the past for the social network and Seoul.
Starting point is 00:21:44 They also won the Best Score Award for Challenger this year at the Golden Globes. And like multiple critics associations have given them awards for Best Score this year. They were also nominated at the Grammys. I just feel like that is a score that aside from being my favorite score of the year, or of movies that came out last year, like aside from my personal preferences, it has been recognized in so many places. So for it to not even be nominated at the Academy Awards,
Starting point is 00:22:16 I am really confused. Absolutely baffling. I not only assumed they'd be nominated, but that it would win. Yeah. Before the nominees were now, I couldn't believe it. I was also surprised that Hilder Guna Docher's score for the second Joker movie didn't get a nomination.
Starting point is 00:22:33 She won for the score that she did for the first Joker film in 2020. But one, I think that they really missed this year, and I doubt it was even on their radar, was the score for Baby Girl done by Christabel Tapia DeVier. Oh, it's so cool. He, you know, I talked about Christopal Tapia DeVier last fall when we did that episode on horror film scores because he did the smile films, which I really loved.
Starting point is 00:23:21 He is just so wildly inventive. He comes up with sounds that you can't identify. identify. He does the most interesting things with them. And it's all over this baby girl score. I love it. I kind of just feel like the academy, they saw Wicked. They saw Amelia Perez. And they were like, those are musical movies. Those are movies filled with music. So we have to nominate the scores. And it's like, well, you don't have to. There are other scores out there. So I don't know. There's just something kind of lazy about the score category this year to me.
Starting point is 00:23:54 Yeah. I felt the same. All right, let's talk about best song nominees. One of the biggest changes this year is that the nominated artists will not be performing the songs. Yeah. During the ceremony. Yeah. So the Academy has decided this year, as you said, not to include performances of the original songs that are nominated in the broadcast. Instead, the Academy said that they want to spotlight the songwriters through, these are
Starting point is 00:24:25 words, personal reflections and behind the scenes insights, and that there are going to be music moments in the ceremony, but they're not going to be those kind of performances that we know and expect. Obviously, songwriters have been mad about this. Diane Warren, who's nominated this year, spoke out about that and isn't very happy. It's not totally crazy for the Oscars to not include performances of original songs during the broadcast, because in the past, sometimes they've switched it up. Like there was one year where Beyonce performed three different original songs, and like she certainly didn't perform those songs in the films that were nominated. And so they cut things, they move things around. But I think this year, it seems kind of weird to me,
Starting point is 00:25:11 not to do original performances, especially, you know, as much as we might not like Amelia Perez, Amelia Perez is nominated for two songs. Like, I, I don't know. To me, it kind of feels like the Academy wanted to ditch the original song nominee performances to kind of make way for other musical moments of their own choosing in the show. Like there's kind of a rumor that Ariana Grande and Cynthia Arevo might perform a wicked thing during the performance. That's just a rumor. I don't know.
Starting point is 00:25:44 It is consistent with some of the other things they've been changing up in recent years. You know, instead of showing clips of an actor's performance, that you hear the actor reflecting on the role, or they'll have somebody else talk about why that actor is important to me. You know, they've been trying to mix it up, but I was pretty stunned to hear this because it's certainly one of the things
Starting point is 00:26:04 that I've enjoyed most about watching the Oscars. And I think for a lot of people, it's the only reason they tune in is to see those performances. So, yeah. Yeah, I feel like the Academy wants those performances when they serve, like, ratings purposes. Like, obviously, I'm just Ken.
Starting point is 00:26:21 was incredible. And so I don't know. I could see the Academy looking at the original song nominees this year and being like, well, we'd rather have a wicked thing or we'd rather have Timmy. These are just speculations. Timmy play Bob Dylan music
Starting point is 00:26:38 because he was really good at doing that in SNL. So I don't know. I'm just kind of being a cynic for what the Academy Awards wants from a show at the end of the day. Yeah. Okay. nominees in the song category. Let's start with the song by Diane Warren. You mentioned her because it just isn't the Oscars unless Diane Warren is nominated for best song. This one's
Starting point is 00:27:03 called The Journey. It's performed by the singer Her and it was for the film The Six Triple Eight. All the times you thought you never make it through felt just like the world just turned his back on you. Didn't stop you. All the time you thought you never make it through. It felt just like the world. Times you could have given any given up. Times you didn't know if you were strong enough. Diane Warren nominated 16 times for a best song Oscar. 16 times for a best song Oscar. How many has she won?
Starting point is 00:28:19 Zero. Zero. None. She's won none. Well, she's not going to win with this song. You don't think? Because I kind of thought, I mean, I'm not in love with it, but it feels like a solid contender to me. I mean, I think it's a contender, for sure, but I just think it's kind of lazy.
Starting point is 00:28:40 I don't know. I just feel like this, you know, Middle East. Midlaesi isn't the word. It's just kind of like completes the Oscar song assignment for me. You know, it's this, it's this ballad about, you know, people thought they could hold you back, but you're stronger than that, and you can get through this. And, you know, her is an incredible vocalist and performer, but I just, this song is not wowing me. To your point about it, sort of meeting all the requirements for an Oscar nominee in this. category. It has that classic ballad sound, kind of an earworm melody and chord progression. It's very stirring and it fits the film sort of perfectly. But all of these things I'm saying are also,
Starting point is 00:29:26 and at least for the kinds of stuff that I'm looking for in a nominee, are also kind of strikes against it. And it's so consistent with a lot of the nominees in the song category every year. Yeah. It's a Warren special, you know? Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Yeah. All right, let's talk about Amelia Perez again because in addition to the score, it has two tracks nominated for Best Song. The first is Me Camino performed by Selena Gomez. So I will say as much as I didn't like this film and the score overall, I do think that there were some good songs in it. I do like me Camino. I think it's in a scene that is maybe one of the more popular moments in the film.
Starting point is 00:31:02 You know, it's maybe just because it's a rare bright spot, there's a bitter sweetness to it. Yeah. There's this kind of nice synchronized dance that goes along with it. And overall, you know, it's one of the more uplifting moments in the film. And I should say, too, as much as I rag on Amelia Perez, the performances in the movie are great. Like, Selena Gomez is great. Zoe Salada is great. And I think Selena Gomez is great on this song.
Starting point is 00:31:25 I will say that listening to the song, I did feel like it was a little generic. Like, I couldn't, at one point, I couldn't tell if it was plagiarizing something I had already heard, or if it was just so generic that it sounded like something I had already heard. But I don't know. I like the message of this song, you know, and what it does for her character in the movie, the sort of declaration that she can't be held down and she's going to do things her own way, even if people judge her for it. I will say that I read that out of all the songs in Amelia Perez, most of them were written and recorded before the shooting of the film and that this song
Starting point is 00:32:07 was the one that they recorded after shooting. And I don't know, I kind of am. speculating that in the process of making the movie, they were like, we got to have Selena Gomez sing a song. And like, she needs a song, which is true. She does need a song. Yeah. But yeah, I don't know if it's giving, out of all the songs from Milia Perez and in this
Starting point is 00:32:28 category, I don't think it's Oscar worthy. Yeah, I think between the two of them, the other one is the one that is the stronger contender. It's called El Mal and it's performed by Zoe Zoltano. You know, his son's and family to chingad and what they're going to those cadaveres. Ah, ha, ha, ha, ha. You mentioned how great some of the performances were in the film.
Starting point is 00:33:39 I thought Zoe Zaldana absolutely crushed this in the film. It's the best scene in the movie. Yeah, and I think we're not talking about. We're not talking about this part of the Oscars, but I think she probably will win the Oscar for her performance overall. Yeah, I mean, when I was talking earlier about the overall incoherence of Amelia Perez's music, the score, a lot of the music,
Starting point is 00:33:57 you know, a lot of the songs in Amelia Perez sort of just felt to me like dialogue, kind of sing-song, like dialogue kind of just lazily set to music. And I think the thing that I appreciate about El Moll, where I don't think it's like a perfect song, it feels like a song. feels like a clear moment in that movie. And you can kind of take that song out of the movie and it really kind of stands on its
Starting point is 00:34:22 own two legs. I think it's kind of erratic. Like I don't really, is it a rock song? Is it a rap song? There's a lot going on in it. But I think Zoe Salada's performance, her vocals in it, like really make it. I don't know, really make it successful to me. And I think that it is the song that's going to win the Oscar for sure.
Starting point is 00:34:43 Yeah. I agree. You know, in this scene. Zoe Zaldon is she's in a kind of a club or dining hall. She's basically taking down every single person in the room, kind of moving between the tables. And it is an incredible performance. And I think to your point, it is probably that performance
Starting point is 00:35:01 that's going to elevate this song and to the point where it's going to win more than just the song itself. It's the full package. All right, there are a couple more song nominees we need to talk about, including one from Elton John and Brandy Carlyle. called Never Too Late. So this one Even greener
Starting point is 00:36:07 He'd be a all Lones If it's never too late For a moment To soon This one was for the documentary About Elton John Also called Never Too Late
Starting point is 00:36:29 I'm a lifelong Elton John fan You know he's done some of my All-time favorite songs He's had some Definitely He's had some clunkers He can certainly be
Starting point is 00:36:40 Hit or miss As incredible as some of his work is I think he has a habit of getting super schmaltzy and overly earnest. I feel all of that in this song. By far the best thing in it is Brandy Carlyle. Yeah. She's doing a lot of heavy lifting this song. I do feel like this is a clunker. There's one moment in it that I kind of wish they had elevated more or explored more, which is kind of that line about like the years making jokes of all of us and kind of letting
Starting point is 00:37:10 this. I was like, I kind of wanted more of that playful energy in the song, but overall, it kind of just like the Warren and her song, it just feels like it's checking a lot of Academy Award Oscar ballad boxes to me. I mean, the Academy cannot resist a legacy artist. Yes. You know, and this comes very late in Elton John's life and career, you know, and it does score, or provide the score in part to a very remarkable story. But I'm with you. It's just, again, it's just sort of a little to paint by numbers for me. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:37:48 All right. One more song, though. And this is from the film Sing Sing. The song is called Like a Bird performed by Abraham, Alexander, and Adrian Gisada. I try, fly, fly, fly. I'll give you my word. I try, try, try. Fly like a bird
Starting point is 00:38:36 Fly, fly, fly, fly. I give you my word. I'm a faith, but you're going to see. But no bridge to that my way. Carging the beach. I am not wildly in love with this song, but it is by far my favorite of the nominees. I'm same. Totally with you.
Starting point is 00:39:09 Yeah. And I think it's my favorite of the nominees because it doesn't sound like an Oscars ballad that's painting all the numbers. Like there's something really kind of like earthy and rooted and natural to this song. This feels like a song that I could hear on the radio. This feels like a song that I could hear outside of the context of the movie, outside of the context of being nominated.
Starting point is 00:39:32 And I also just, you know, its message is quite simple. This idea of being a bird stuck in a cage. You know, the movie is about incarceration and, you know, but it works for me. Yeah. I think it's got a really nice mix of folk. gospel and it's a very pretty song and like you said it works even outside of the context of the film uh for me it's not going to win no uh because uh of everything that you just said it's just it's like it does not check enough boxes i think for the oscars i would be i would be
Starting point is 00:40:04 thrilled if it did win and going back on seeing these songs perform live this would be such a great one to see them do live you know i would so love to see a performance of this i know All right. So if we talk predictions, we both agree. I think it's going to be El Mal. Yeah. That'll win. Yeah. I think, you know, I don't want to get into all the different controversies surrounding the film Amelia Perez. People can read about those. I think it's going to tank a lot of the nominations that it got. I think maybe Zoe Saldana could still win best supporting actress. But I think this is one area where they'll kind of, I know, consolation prize for the film. Their alma bone. Yeah. I 100% agree. This is how they'll give it something. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:40:48 And if you talk about who should win of the nominees, you'd go with like a bird? Yeah, I think so. Yeah, I agree. We'd love to see it surprise everyone. But in a year of so many misses and snubs, let's talk about some of the more glaring ones that we think they missed this year. Well, I think one song that they missed is this song called Claw Machine by the artist Sloppy Jane. featuring Phoebe Bridgers. And it was a song on the soundtrack from a movie called I Saw the TV Glow.
Starting point is 00:41:18 That movie had a soundtrack of mostly original songs written for the film from a wide range of indie rock, indie pop artists. And this song, Clah Machine, is sort of the central song of the movie. It's so beautiful. And, you know, this movie, I Saw the TV Glow, I don't think it would have ever been on the Oscars Radar, Academy Awards radar, but what this movie does with its soundtrack and with music, I really think is award worthy. Yeah, I don't know if the fact that it had a cover song on it.
Starting point is 00:43:03 There was one cover song out of all of them, and there was one song that existed before the movie was made. But I agree, I think it's the biggest snub in the song category this year because there were just so many tracks to choose from, too. I know. I mean, claw machine is near the top of my short list, but. But I really love the song Writing Around in the Dark by Florist. That's one of the songs on there.
Starting point is 00:43:24 I love the Kingwoman song, Barry. None of these check any of those boxes we mentioned earlier, right? I mean, so I would love for them to surprise us some year and nominate some stuff like this. But they won't. But they won't. Hope dies last, yes. But you know, we talked about the film Challenger's, that score and how it was totally. snubbed. It also includes a song that everyone thought would be nominated called Compress
Starting point is 00:43:55 Repress. So this is also by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross. And, you know, there's so much just sweaty tension in this film. And this song just perfectly captures it, I think. Yes. I think, as I previously said, Trent and Atticus have been snubbed in all of the categories this year. And I feel like they deserve to be nominated for this song. as well. All right, well, we'll go out on this thumper from Trent Resner and Atticus Ross. Do you have an Oscar watching party or get together with friends and you'll make predictions and everything?
Starting point is 00:45:17 I am having an, I'm doing an Oscar party where we're going to watch. And, yeah, I'm going to, I don't know if we're going to make, it's not that formalized, but yeah, I always watch the Oscars with friends. Yeah. I've gone to parties where someone's had ballots printed up. No. And we like check, yeah, yeah, yeah, go all out. I don't do that anymore.
Starting point is 00:45:36 My wife and I do, though, just before the winner's announced, we'll say who we think it's going to be. Oh, yeah, that's the extent of the work that I'll do. I'm not doing more work than that. Yeah. All right, thanks so much, Hazel. Thank you. And for NPR music, I'm Robin Hilton. It's all songs considered.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.