Odd Lots - Why the Price of Lumber Has Soared Day After Day After Day

Episode Date: April 26, 2021

It's not often that lumber becomes a national obsession. But this year it has. Thanks to a combination of factors, including diminished sawmill capacity, a renovation boom, and then a homebuilding boom, the price of finished wood has soared to never-before-seen heights. On this episode, we speak with Stinson Dean, a lumber trader at Deacon Trading, to explain why the market has gone so wild, and how the market is structured.See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Thanks for listening to Odd Lots. Follow the show on Amazon Music for more future episodes or just ask, Alexa, play the Odd Lots podcast on Amazon Music. Today's show is brought to you by Vanguard. To all the financial advisors listening, let's talk bonds for a minute. Capturing value and fixed income is not easy. Bond markets are massive, murky, and let's be real. Lots of firms throw a couple flashy funds your way and call it a day. But not Vanguard. At Vanguard, institutional quality isn't a tagline. It's a big line. It's a very big. It's a few. commitment to your clients. We're talking top grade products across the board of over 80 bond funds, actively managed by a 200-person global squad of sector specialists, analysts, and traders. These folks live and breathe fixed income. So if you're looking to give your clients consistent results year in and year out, go see the record for yourself at vanguard.com slash audio.

That's vanguard.com slash audio. All investing is subject to risk vanguard marketing corporation distributor. Hello and welcome to another episode of the Oddlots podcast. I'm Jill Wisenthal. And I'm Tracy Allaway. So Tracy, I'm guessing there isn't much construction of new homes anymore in Hong Kong, is there? There's always some, but we definitely aren't having a housing boom like the U.S. is. Now, it is absolutely crazy what's going on here. There is a housing boom here. There is a renovation boom. People are buying existing houses driving the prices up. People are starting new homes. Like, it's super wild.

What's going on here in real estate? Yeah. So I've seen a lot of stories on this. And then, of course, one of the things I've seen that's been really striking is the price chart of lumber. And that's just been absolutely soaring and is actually like, I see it mentioned in the pantheon of meme stocks nowadays. But of course, you know, lumber is an actually. thing that people use to build homes and other important structures. No, it literally is like kind of becoming a meme stock, like lumber itself.

Like there's like meme stocks and crypto. And now people are making TikToks about the price of lumber. And the line literally is just a straight up for days. We're recording this April 21st. And actually the last two days, I think lumber actually sold off a bit. So maybe, I don't know, maybe there's some sort of peak. I have no idea. But the point for like days and days in a row, the lumber futures market went up, limit up every single day is absolutely wild.

And it's like becoming a cultural thing, how much wood cost right now. Yeah. It's also sort of becoming a moment for, I guess, lumber Twitter, which is a really interesting community. As I think you recently discovered, right, there's a really vibrant conversation around the lumber industry and lumber trading construction, things like that. online. Lumber's having its moment in the sun. And I just have to say, this is our chance to dive into lumber market structure. I've been doing a little bit of research. It is an absolutely delightful market. Like just some of the terms that they use, like stumpage fee, that is such a great word. No, it's great. There's so much good stuff here because it's got its own market structure.

There's the futures market. There's the cash market. There's all these different entities. There's the lumber yards, the sawmills, the forests, the timber, where they sell timber, or turned into lumber. There's the home builders, everything. Just a super interesting market that up until very recently, probably very few people other than people in the industry had thought about. But now everyone wants to learn. And you mentioned lumber Twitter.

It's kind of taking over everything. And the guests we're going to have on today, we recently had them on TV to talk about the lumber market. And I've never posted a clip that got so many views. I think it was literally one of the biggest views ever. Everyone wanted to hear more from the guest. So we had to get them on the podcast to really do a true deep dive into what's going on right now and how lumber market structure actually work. For sure.

Let's do it. All right. So I'm very excited to go. We're going to go deep on the lumber market. We're going to be speaking with Stinson Dean. He is the CEO and founder of Deakin Trading, which is a lumber trading shop that operates all over the country. He's at lumber trading on Twitter. So he's sort of like become one of the preeminent lumber Twitter experts blowing up now here.

Everyone wanted to hear him on Nodlots and now he's here. Stinson, thank you so much for coming on the show. Yeah, thanks for having me. I'm excited to talk potentially endlessly. about all the nuances of lumber. We're going to go super deep on lumber. We're going to go beyond just the charge. But, you know, like, so I have this idea.

I'm an expert on lumber now because I've been paying attention to it for two weeks. I have this idea that there's, you know, there's the home builders, and they buy from the lumberyards, and the lumber yards buy from the sawmills, and the sawmills have a lot of pricing power these days and they, so forth. But why do you give us the sort of like very high-level overview of the different players in this market and also specifically what Deakin trading does and how it fits into the sort of the lumber trading ecosystem.

Sure. So the players in the supply chain, there's the producers on one end and the end users, which would be the home builders on the far end. And it's easier to kind of start with the home builder. So the home builder is going to buy, from what we call lumber dealers.

Okay. Commonly, commonly called lumber yards. Those are the lumber yards that you and I aren't allowed to walk into. They've got the high fences. They're big. There's a lot of activity going on. And they sell only to commercial accounts,

home builders and large contractors. And they sell them framing packages. So it has the OSB and other sheathing and panel goods. It has the framing lumber. Hold up. OSB. What's that? Oh, oriented strand board. That's the sheathing that goes underneath, like your roofing shingles.

Great. Okay. Keep going. And that, for the record, is even worse of a shortage, or at least from a pricing perspective, than lumber. It's really insane. But it's like the most common kind of 4B8 sheet you see on the in cap at Lowe's when you walk in. Okay. The point being the lumber dealer buys in bulk all of these different products that go to build a house and then they put them together in smaller housing packages, a little bit of each, and deliver it to pads and job sites, right? So the lumber dealer buys in bulk all these building materials, and the bigger the lumber dealer, the more likely they buy direct from the producer.

So I would say most of the lumber that goes into a home was produced at a sawmill and sold directly to a lumber. and then put on a flatbed truck for a framing package to the home builder. So it's pretty efficient in that way. But it's a highly volatile commodity where there's frantic scrambles for supply. There's scrambles of oversupply where you're scrambling just to get rid of whatever product you have. and there's all sorts of breakdowns in the supply chain. So it sounds easy, hey, Canada, Canadian salt mill to lumber dealer in Houston, Texas, to homebuilder. But the reality is that lumber purchased in Canada had to, you had to make that purchasing

decision eight weeks before you actually get the lumber. And so you're having to anticipate what are my lumber needs two months from now. And when the market gets really hot, it's like, like you're 12 weeks out. And these lumber dealers and the buyers that work for them are often in a really impossible decision to forecast. And they all get their heads together and they try to forecast how much lumber do we need. So in between the sawmill and the lumber dealer, there's several different types of wholesalers and or middle middlemen type folks. And that's where I fit in. And I said on the show, I look at myself as a liquidity.

provider because the market is illiquid as a physical market and a futures market. So it just gets scarce very fast or oversupplied very fast. So I can stand in the middle and provide liquidity to sawmills that have a backlog of inventory, or I can provide liquidity to a lumberyard that misbudgeted 10 weeks ago and needs prompt would tomorrow because where I sit, I buy lumber from Canada and, you know, eight weeks later, I have it in anticipation of someone needing it over the next 30 days because they'd misforecast eight weeks prior. Right.

Okay. So that's where I sit. And there's not a lot of us because I take a tremendous price risk. The second I agree to buy lumber, I have risk on. it won't ship to me for two to three weeks if the mills are shipping on time and it'll take three weeks if the rail lines aren't running slow to actually get it and then another 30 days to market it. So I have risk on for a significant amount of time. The other type of wholesaler at our supply chain, and this kind of rounds it out, we call them a transit

wholesaler where they buy the rail car and they immediately try to sell it to a lumber dealer before it ships. And they'll, you know, typically like right now, mills are selling for June production. So a wholesaler could buy a handful of cars for June, and then they have six weeks to find a destination for it. And that's kind of the, and that's more common.

There's less risk. They try to kind of sell it before they pay for it. And that's, that's more or less their model. So you laid out the, ecosystem really well for us. Talk to us about how, I don't want to say how bad things are at the moment, but, you know, how intense the price surge has been, what the scramble for wood is actually like, and where in the ecosystem those pressure points are coming from? It's a short squeeze.

It's from the dynamic of the sales model that lumber dealers, I think, I don't know really how they did it before the recession, but coming out of the recession, they'll commit to deliver lumber 60 to 90 days out sometimes. Sorry, just to be clear, when you say the recession, do you mean the last recession, like the 2008, 2009 one? I just want, right. Yeah, okay. The great one. Yeah, you're right. Sorry, keep going. No, no, well, which was, which was the epicenter of the housing crash. Right, right. And since then, the model has been, and maybe this was model before, I wasn't in the industry, but they commit to these sales, let's just say 90 days worth of sales, the most inventory these folks can hold is 45 days because of cash constraints and kind of how they manage your inventory.

When they're bullish, they'll go 45 to 55 days. When they're bearish, they'll work their inventory down to 30 days. And if you think about that, you're 50% covered. And you got 90 days worth of commitments and 45 days worth inventory. So they're buying on the open market. They have their average cost of 45 days worth of inventory. But then they got to cover the next 90 days or excuse me, the next 45 days. And when they don't cover that aggressively, maybe they dial it back to 30 days worth of inventory.

Anticipating a dip. Well, the dip doesn't come, didn't come, which we were all anticipating, me included in Q1. We stayed kind of flat at $1,000 for six weeks. And it felt like things were going to crack to the downside. But the mills were able to hold out. I think they were able to sell the Canadian market. They were able to sell to Asia. And this kind of standoff, the mills won.

So now you got 90 days of commitments, 30 days worth inventory. You got a lot of ground to make up with your purchases. And I think that's what's happening right now. is you got to get you got to cover your commitments eventually they're going to get covered eventually they're going to buy enough wood cover get the lumber out the door they're going to have made a ton of money on the inventory they had on the ground they're not going to make as much money on these open market purchases where they're scrambling the cover and those two dynamics or those two profit margins will average out and i think ultimately they'll be okay but what's happening right now is

there's commitments that need to be covered. And we've all waited too long to get those covered. So basically you have the lumber yards and they, you know, if they don't deliver the lumber they promise, they're, you know, they've defaulted. So to avoid that, they have to cover those shorts. Let's talk about the mentality, you know, like coming out of the great financial crisis, I have to imagine that just sort of like numerous players in the industry got totally wrecked. And I remember for years. People talked about, oh, housing is never really going to come back the way it did. And then, of course, we had the crash last March, and a lot of people got deja vu. But then we saw, okay, we got some people started renovating their homes. And that caught people by surprise, but people didn't think that would last. And then, okay, the winter's going to come, then didn't slow down. So talk to us about, like, the role that essentially diminished expectations, permanent pessimism, and fears of the going fears of another shoe dropping, how that contributed to the yard not carrying that much inventory? Yes. So it's such a great point. And I can speak confidently about my market. And I think I can say that

we're more conservative than others because of what we went through in 2006, 7, and 8. And what we ignored in 2006 and 7 and paid the piper. 2008, and we really were one of the sectors that really never still haven't reached and eclipsed our peak, you know, if you just look at housing starts. And it was pretty devastating, as you can imagine, for everyone involved. And so a lot of people got cleaned out. And if you survived and you're still around today and you survived 12 years ago, it's because you're extremely conservative, right? You hold a lot of cash. You don't put your neck out too much. You don't, you're, you're slow to reinvest, you're slow to hire, you're slow to expand, you're slow to buy more

trucks because what if, right? It's such a fear. And ultimately, you're also slow to buy a bunch inventory. You want as little inventory as possible in case the bottom falls out. So that's, that's very fresh even all this time later in everyone's mind and again the names that are around right now are around because they were able to scrap scrape and survive being the epicenter of the the great financial meltdown and so there's just a characteristic of these legacy names and the folks who run them that they're just conservative and the same with the homebuilders you're listening to the home builders they're paying down debt and they're not aggressively going after land and they're playing it safe.

And it's like, what are we doing here? We have this massive housing shortage. But you can just feel how hesitant everyone is to believe it. So me included last March, I was like depression. This is bad. Stock market sold off, lumber future soloff. And I mean, I was quoted in the Wall Street Journal that April saying, no one's thinking about buying a new home.

That's the last thing on anyone's mind. And so we all de-risks. We sold down our inventories to almost nothing. The sawmills, if they had any extra inventory on the ground, which they typically operate with, to fill in the gaps and smooth out the supply chain in case there's a weird production run glitch, they can pull from the inventory, fill the car, and get it gone. They sold those stacks down to pavement. Lumber dealers, sold their inventory down to nothing.

middlemen and liquidity providers, same thing. Like, none of us wanted the risk on. So then, you know, we started the rebound. And the short of it is, prices went from 250 on the future screen to 350 to 450 to 500. And we're all thinking, oh, this is the top, like, 500 is historically a great price. And in 2018, we went to 655. And that was the top. So we get to 650, 655.

Like, this is it. There's no way. and then 700, 800, 900,000 by September. And those last $300 were just backbreaking for the industry. High prices cure high prices. But in our industry, high prices raise concern and people get really scared that it's just going to crash. So everyone was slow to believe in the recovery.

So no one invested in inventories effectively. The mills didn't invest in inventories. Lumber dealers didn't invest in inventories. prices are too high. I'm going to wait for them to come down. This can't possibly last. So that hesitation to lean in and to put risk on perpetuated the situation that we're in that has been such an acute run up. We'll talk about larger structural issues supporting the price of lumber. But what happened in this happening right now, I think is ultimately from the scars of the Great Recession and the conservative nature of our industry not wanting to put risk on

via lumber inventories. Today's show is brought to you by Vanguard. To all the financial advisors listening, let's talk bonds for a minute. Capturing value and fixed income is not easy. Bond markets are massive, murky, and let's be real. Lots of firms throw a couple flashy funds your way and call it a day. But not Vanguard. At Vanguard, institutional quality isn't a tagline.

It's a commitment to your clients. We're talking top-grade products across the board of over 80 bond funds, actively managed by a 200-person global squad of sector specialists, analysts, and traders. These folks live and breathe fixed income. So if you're looking to give your clients consistent results year in and year out, go see the record for yourself at vanguard.com slash audio. That's vanguard.com slash audio, all investing in subject to risk vanguard marketing corporation distributor.

Well, so what would it take to actually change that? conservative mindset or maybe another way of putting it is what would it take to make the industry more flexible and better able to respond to change? Is it just a function of, you know, trees taking a long time to grow and taking a while to transport that means you have this sort of like longer lead times that feeds into that forward planning? I don't know the answer to that question. I hinted at the larger structural problems. The Canadian forests are where the problems are. The Canadian government a few years ago decided we are logging these too fast,

and we're just not going to have the forests if we keep going at this pace. So they reduce what they call the annual allowable cut, the AAC, annual allowable cut. Before they had expanded that AAC because there was a bunch of what we call beetle kill trees out there from this pinewood beetle infestation that most folks have heard of it, but it was devastating. It was ravaging forests up there. So they opened up the forest for logging

to get those trees cut while they're still harvestable. You can still use them for lumber. You still find blue stained lumber in the stores. Some people use that for decorative reasons, but a lot of houses built in the 2010-2020, 20 have blue stain studs on them. And those are beetle kill logs, which is also a thing in the U.S. So they opened up logging to a much faster pace to harvest the trees before they

rotted and that you couldn't harvest them in the lumber and also reducing the fire risk of having dead trees in your forest, right? And, you know, there's a long discussion about why is there a pine beetle infestation. Why is it so bad? A lot of that points to the winters not being as cold for as long to kill those beetles off. But ultimately, it leaves the forest vulnerable to fire. So they wanted to get in there and coal as much of those as they could. So if you look at lumber prices, they're pretty flat.

And you look at the publicly traded lumber sawmill companies, pretty flat pricing, not a lot of dividends, really low returns over, over 10 years on just their stock price. It was not a great business to be in. We were just flooded with lumber partially because we were overproducing because we got these beetle killed trees we got to take care of. That changed in 2015 or 16. They reduced the AAC and that's set by the Canadian government, who they call it the Crown land.

They own the forests up there. And I am not a deep expert in these licenses. and tenure, but the mills and the logging companies are allotted timberland to harvest. They control basically the pace of what they can harvest. So they just cut what you're allowed to cut. So the mills, there's these mills all over in the bush up in Canada. And if there aren't enough logs to keep them going, and then lumber prices were low and the returns were low, like these mills started getting shut down.

And that was mostly in 2019. Lumber prices were very low. Housing market was mediocre. Second half of 18 into 19. And it just devastated the industry. Like it was really sad. Like main employers, lumber towns just like devastated. The main source of employment in this tiny town is shuttered. Now, of course, we're missing that supply. I don't think all of them would still be here. I think the log supply was going to ultimately shut down several of those. mills anyway. But now here we are. Less logs to cut and harvest. Less mills to do it with. And you have an industry, a sawmill industry that really has had mediocre returns for 10 years. And now here's their moment to maximize. There's so many different strands I want to pull on. But let's keep talking about the sort of the relationship between the sawmills and the tree growers, the forests. Some reports have said, oh, so there's plenty of trees, the real issues, at the, just the sawmill capacity, as you just described. I've seen others say, actually,

there isn't as many trees as people think because a lot of the trees that are available, they're in the south, and those trees aren't really great for building homes. Maybe they're like better for cardboard boxes of the e-commerce industry or something like that. So are there a lot of trees available and then also like how do the uh the trump tariffs play into it um no there's not a lot of trees available okay to build to build homes as we build them today okay the plate material which is kind of the horizontal laying lumber and the studs in between them behind your dry wall is is most likely a Canadian species piece of wood and that's how we build homes there's a there's certainly a lot of in the U.S. in the Pacific Northwest that is interchangeable with Canadian spruce,

but they don't produce as much as the Canadian lumber mills do. And that is the way we build homes. We don't build homes with southern yellow pine from the U.S. South. You could, and I guess you can, but it's a different stick. It's heavy, wet, dense, crooked, twists, a lot of waste on the job site. You can't store it. So it's like we'd have to change what we do. So yes, there's a ton of trees in the U.S. South, but we don't build houses with trees from the U.S. South.

We build houses from trees from the Pacific Northwest in Canada. And particularly Canada, as we just talked about, they're getting more and more scarce. Because they just made the decision. And you talk to most Canadians, they don't disagree with this decision. It's like you've got to stop logging at this pace where the forest won't be here. So it's not really a point of contention up there. taken as fact. And I'm not going to argue with them. So I don't, you know, I don't want the force to go away and go away. And they told me, I thought it was 30 years. It takes 80 years to grow a

Canadian lumber tree. Okay. So they got a, they had a hard decision to make and they made it. And we're all going to have to adjust. So given that long lead in time, I mean, 80 years to grow a is the solution to the squeeze on the demand side rather than the supply side, because it feels like you can't fix the supply issue anytime soon. Yeah, amen. I've been saying that. That's kind of been my narrative. Once prices went to 700 and they kept going, I was like,

something's wrong here because these mills have never seen $700 in their life. And we still couldn't find lumber. Like, why aren't they producing more? And there used to be an old adage. When I was taught in the lumber industry, the sawmails can always outproduce the market. And I had a bad habit of doing so. So when returns got good, they turned the switch on and they produced a ton of lumber and crush price. And I kept waiting, kept looking around, like, why aren't they doing this?

Where's like this hidden inventory? I keep hearing about 750, 800. why aren't they selling futures you know they're not showing up as as uh hedgers in the cfTC report 900 950 i'm like something's wrong and clearly the supply side can't fix this clearly they just can't like they it would it would be criminal of them i mean like maybe fiduciary wise if they were like secretly not producing as much as they could when lumber hit 7, 8, 9. It's just, and folks were like, oh, they're hiding it, and there's more that we don't know

about. But they're publicly traded. They can't do that. And it would be a complete shift from all their past behavior. So it is not a supply side fix, not in the near term. So, yeah, it's a demand side. And it's high prices, cure high prices. And we have not found that equilibrium or that tipping point where we start slowing demand.

because of high lumber prices. And it's astonishing. It makes you think maybe lumber should have been more expensive for a lot longer. So I'm glad you mentioned the futures market because we haven't really gotten into that. But something, you know, we had this long streak of like limit up, limit up every day. Talk to us a little bit about the relationship between the futures market and the cash market and how you use both and how they slip and how tightly aligned they are. Give us a little overview of the future market, yeah, and its relationship to the whole thing.

So I'm like full disclosure, highly dependent and a huge user of lumber futures. Okay. That's how we run my business. And I don't care if they go up or down. I care that it's easy to execute and get in and out. So I care about liquidity. The lumber futures is one railcar of lumber, priced Prince George, British Columbia in U.S. dollars. So the number you see on the screen is per thousand board foot,

which is a volume measurement. And a two by four eight, I think there's like six board feet and a two by four eight stick. You can build like four to five houses out of one futures contract worth of product. It's a it's a large volume. But that's how our industry traits lumber by rail car, especially out of the Pacific Northwest and Canada. Being a cash and futures trader, I can tell you that it's highly effective, highly correlated, but convergence and which would be the cash or spot price converging with the futures price at expiration, it happens every contract. It's a physically delivered contract, so it has to happen. And the correlations are really high. The problem, when you look at it, you know, people see the volume and or the open interest.

So when we were going locked limit up on this run, there'd be 150 trades on the screen on the front run. And people would point that out. And I would say, that's about 130 more trades than what was happening in the cash markets. The cash markets were there was no market. There was no market for wood. There was no wood to be found. So the only alternative was to buy lumber futures for your purchase. Because again, these folks are making purchasing decisions today for wood they're going to need eight to 10 weeks out.

So buying a May futures contract in March, like that aligns with what they would be doing in the cash markets. So the cash markets and the futures markets are really mirror each other really well in that they're highly illiquid, highly volatile. one of my observations has been the consolidation of our industry from sawmills to lumber dealers. Not so much home builders because they're not buying real cars with lumber from sawmills. That's not how they operate. So lumber dealers and sawmills make the market. They're the ones moving rail cars all across the country. They've been consolidating since the Great Recession to the point where there's basically four or five.

major Canadian producers and there's basically three or four maybe five major U.S. lumber dealers and so that's five asks and five bids and they always get these massive standoffs and you can imagine if your bid ask is hundreds of dollars apart well when someone blinks the whole market makes this hundred dollar move because you heard this rumor that so-and-so made a block purchase and now the mills are off the market and there's no more open market wood to buy. And it's because there's not a lot of bids and ass in the cash markets. And the futures markets kind of represent the same thing where the folks who taught me

lumber cash markets when they started, there was a bunch of independent mom and pop lumber yards. and there's a bunch of family-owned legacy sawmills dotted all around Canada and Pacific Northwest. So you could information arbitrage just by working the phones and find a sawmill that is behind on the market pricing, find a buyer that didn't understand the market has moved because you're just making 30 calls to the buy side, 30 calls to the cell side every single day trying to find the market. So you could just do this information arbitrage and like you just make a killing and you're back to backing most of it. So you're not even taking the price risk.

Well, now there's five and there is no information arbitrage. Like you can't find an inefficiency in pricing because there's only five of them and say them on the buy side. Like you can't find anyone sleeping. They all know exactly where they're at. They all know exactly where the mill stand. So there's no way to find a busy lumber yard owner who's worried about a truck that's late, you know, not paying attention to lumber prices. And you can goose them for 10 or 20 bucks per thousand because they're not paying attention.

Like that doesn't happen anymore. We have professional, extremely sophisticated and very smart, centralized buying floors at these dealers that buy at their corporate headquarters for all their locations across the country. and they're extremely smart and savvy and crafty. Like these guys are very, very good at what they do. So it's hard to understand what decisions they're going to make because they represent hundreds of yards where 20 years ago, hundreds of yards represented hundreds of yards. So there's just all sorts of different inefficiencies.

So that dynamic, that consolidation dynamic, has made it harder to trade lumber because there's just these massive moves. And it makes futures mirror what's happening in the cash markets. I'll often say if you think futures is crazy right now, you should see what's happening in cash markets. There are days, there have been days during this run. You call the sawmill. They don't answer the phone. It's like, we've got nothing to sell. Like there's nothing for sale. So what are you going to do? You got to buy lumber futures. to at least get something on so you can get a delivery in June. It'll ship to you in mid-May.

It'll take a few weeks to get to you. And so that's why we see these squeezes and these big limit moves at the open of the market because they call the saw mills five minutes before and they're what we call off the market. They're not even showing any inventory to sell. This is a really dumb question, but what's the normal state of the lumber? future's curve. Is it contango or backwardation? It's typically in contango, yes. I did a study when I was launching the business over 20 years. There's typically a $5 carry, $5 contango in the market on average. And the highest backwardation we'd ever seen was in 2018,

I think it was $40, something like that. And that was crazy, crazy. at the time. And the biggest carry we've seen was later the same year. It was a $45 carry or contango, where the front month was a $45 discount to the next contract 60 days out. It only takes 12 bucks per thousand to store it. And the market was paying you $45 to store it in the second half of 18. And now we have a $130 invert. Last contract, we went up over 200. The biggest one was in September when this whole thing got kicked off, we had a $300 invert. So it is way out of whack, but representative of the cash market. Eating well shouldn't be complicated, but somehow it turns into recipes, prep, cleanup, and half

your Sunday gone. Factors solves all that. These are fresh, ready-to-eat meals designed by dieticians, delivered to your door, and ready in just minutes. No prep, no cleanup, no excuses. And it's not just about convenience. You're getting real food, balanced nutrition, and zero artificial stuff. Meals that help you stay on track for all of your goals without the grind of doing it all yourself. Grilled chicken, roasted veggies, steak plates, postables. They taste like something you get in a restaurant, but they come out of your microwave in two minutes flat. If time, cost, or effort have been holding you back from eating better,

Factor just took those off the table. Right now, get 11 meals, free shipping, and free sides for life. Hurry, this offer won't last long. Go to FactorMeals. C.A. and use code fit. That's 11 meals, free shipping, and free size for life, but only with the code fit at factoramills.ca.

Factor, Canada's number one ready-to-eat meal delivery service. Visit Don Valley North Lexus for interest rate reductions of up to 3% for lease and finance rates, resulting in lease rates as low as 0.9%. Plus delivery credits of up to $1,500, only until April 30th. Visit dawn valley northlexis.com. So you talk about how, like, it's hard to get an informational edge in the market.

You talk about how sophisticated these sort of big players are. So I have like sort of two related questions. One, what is your edge? I mean, like essentially, like, where does your, I don't know, alpha is the term, where does your premium come from in such an efficient market? And B, what is the role now of relationships in the industry that you as a trader might have your relationship to the sawmills, to the lumberyards, how important is that in the sort of the current structure of the market? So for me, I talk about being a liquidity provider. If you can manage your risk and provide

liquidity in an illiquid market, there's a lot of reward there. And if you can reduce the risk compared to the reward, you can do pretty well. I just take on a lot of physical lumber risk where I'm buying real cars of lumber. I get them unloaded. I put them on the ground in different markets across the country, waiting for someone to need something right away because their lumber budget was off on their inventory. And I'll use futures to manage the downside risk. So when futures go up, like I have massive margin calls, but the way it works, hopefully, is your cash value is moving up faster and further than your futures losses. And you can imagine if there's a scramble for wood and the mills will get you wood in eight weeks and I can get you wood tomorrow

folks pay a premium for that to get it tomorrow and get it in. I also sell in truckload quantities. So I'll charge a higher price, but they're not committing to a car load. There's four trucks for every one car load. So they can swallow one higher price truck, get it in, get it out, and kind of go hand to mouth in that fashion. So I'll I'll be able to provide. just in time inventory at a higher price, but it may not move their average cost that much because it's one truck versus a car load. That's something I learned from grain traders. I basically use a grain elevator business model with risk management, basis, seasonality. And it's pretty basic an ag. Like you won't find folks who quote you flat price corn. They're going to tell you it's

20 over Des Moines or something or 20 over Chicago futures. Because everyone's hedged because they're not crazy. And in Lumberds, it's just different. Folks use futures as a physical proxy. They use futures to speculate, even if they're in the physical marketplace. So that causes a lot of inefficiencies in futures, which allowed me to arbitrage, you know, the cash value versus a hedge I can get off. And those windows were open and closed and it works both ways.

So we had this massive sell-off yesterday in Futures, and that was beautiful for me because nothing changed in the cash markets at all. In fact, cash went up $80. And futures went down, $45, $48 from the day before. And so, like, that was a weird, speculative move that did not match fundamentals. And I was able to arbitrage that and make good money. And, you know, it goes against you too. Sometimes it'll make a speculative, non-fundamental move to the upside, and I'm kind of locked out of the market.

I could buy more. Typically, that would be a recipe. If futures are up and the cash market didn't go up with it, then cash is cheap and futures is expensive. I'll sell the expensive thing and buy the cheap thing. But don't always work that way. So often I just kind of get locked out. I can't price competitively because I have hedges that are working against me. But that's the life of a hedger.

And I just make modest, I mean modest, at least consistent margins and up and down markets. I don't really care if the market goes up or down. I just care that there are spikes in demand and scarcity in my markets that I can fill. You get my hedges off and then wait for another opportunity to restock. So yes, where is the edge now? and it's not making 60 phone calls a day. It's being big. It's having access to the mills.

It's having access to that information at the mill level. And it's being a big customer that an already big producer wants to pay attention to. You have to be big. The producers won't pay attention to you. You're not worth their time. And it's not like personal, but like they got to move a bunch of wood. They're a massive company. and they got to face another massive company.

So if you're big and you move a lot of wood, that's the edge. And if you are small, you got to go through a buying group or buy on the secondary market from folks like me. So that now is the edge. And I think that's what you're seeing in consolidation. One of the motivations was for the buy side. But another factor of consolidating another benefit is I think you're going to see pricing power are facing the home builders, that power dynamic is going to change because all of a sudden these vendors are getting big enough to say, we're not going to do 90-day pricing.

Because the home builder used to say, okay, you won't this other lumber yard, they'll do it. And they wouldn't do it. And they wouldn't care if they lost money. They just got a huge home builder as a customer, right? Now the home builder is going to start seeing there's less options. And if they're not going to give me 90-day pricing, there might not be another lumberyard to give me 90 day because now those lumber yards own each other. And there's going to be a power shift and how that risk is managed. And just today, we saw some comments from Home Builders via Ali Wolf

on Twitter. She said they're no longer locking in prices when there's just dirt. They're offering homes for sale once they got the lumber literally on site so they know what the cost is. And then they can market up. That used to not be the case. Homebuilders had a pretty good run where they did not have price risk. And I think, you know, these contracts and how they're priced, I don't have visibility to them and they're proprietary. But I think we're seeing a risk transfer back to the home builders because they're losing supplier options. So the size now is where the edge is. I want to ask you about the home builder response. But before I do, you mentioned this idea of moving lumber just then. And I imagine that when you're dealing with, you know,

big amounts of a physical commodity, whether it's logs or sheets of wood or whatever, transport costs can be pretty high. And one of my pet themes for the year is this idea that economics doesn't actually do a great job of appreciating transport costs and, and taking into account shocks to those. And we've seen a lot of shocks in transportation this year. So I'm just wondering how that has affected the business, if at all. Are you seeing gridlock or a shortage of truckers, things like that? You know, there was a big pinch in truck, truck drivers, truck availability, and it made a lot of headlines.

I think it was 2018, 19, like with the signing bonuses, and they're trying to recruit long-haul truck drivers. Because a lot of lumber is moved. Like, I move all of my lumber from my storage facility to my, customer via a flatbed that I go find an open on the open market, the trucking market on the quote board, the load boards that have online and tell them what I'm going to pay. For lumber, it delays shipment. Prices have gone up, I'd say 20% from two years ago from typical lanes that I would sell consistently. Prices are now 20% higher than they were a year ago, pre-COVID.

But the liquidity of trucks has vastly improved. I think that push for hiring drivers and investing in more trucks, you're able to get trucks more easily than you were a year and a half ago two years ago. Now, that's just me and my little niche. And I'm sure there's data that might point otherwise. But in my experience, there's more trucks to move loads. I get all my loads moved in one or two, three days. It's pretty rare that I get stuck a week out, but that was happening all the time. Now I'm remembering in 2018, massive logistics issues with trucking.

The other element for lumber is, and it's the biggest transportation cost is the rail freight from the Pacific Northwest to Atlanta. So the futures contract is priced FOB, Canada, British Columbia. $120 per thousand board feet gets it to Atlanta, 120 to 130. If you're in Atlanta and you want to do the math, you're not paying the futures price. You're paying the futures price plus 120 to get it there, plus the handling to get it undone. And then if it's got to move from distribution facility to a store, you know, that's another 20 to 30 bucks per thousand board feet. And what we've experienced in lumber is the CN and the CP rail lines obviously dominate rail origination out of Canada. and the CN is the biggest mover of lumber out of Canada.

And the sawmills or the seller controls freight. So I'm always buying delivered Atlanta, delivered Dallas, delivered Baltimore. That's my price. I don't face the rail line. I don't pay them. I don't book rail cars. I pay a delivered price. And the sawmills have contracts with the rail lines.

None of us are privy to have a certain amount of cars, you know, each week, each month. depending on what they think their needs will be because they don't want to have more cars contracted than they need. So you can imagine sometimes they under budget how many rail cars they need and we'll get bottlenecked and there's not enough rail cars

moving across the country because I'm making this up but because two months ago they misinterpreted, they misforecasted how many rail cars they're going to need in June. So one thing that strikes me is there's only one national price, as you describe it. Like when I think about the oil market, obviously we talk about like West Texas intermediate,

but I can like go on the Bloomberg. And there's like there's dozens. I don't know like dozens of actual oil prices everywhere around the country. And they tend to correlate, but they're all slightly different because it's slightly grade or it's a different logistical network to get there. But as you describe it, there's like one price of national price of lumber. and then you add on a cost of transportation, depending on how far it has to go, whether it's to Dallas or Baltimore and Atlanta or whatever.

So how does that change the lumber trading game, the singularity of their just being the one price? You know, to me it makes it easier and less, there's less arbitrage opportunities because I know in grains and an energy when I was around those traders' local basis. that was an information arbitrage, and you could point, the market would get so inefficient that you could rail it to Kansas City and then truck grain to Tulsa instead of railing it to Tulsa because the rail to Tulsa, there's a spike in rail freight, right? We don't experience that in lumber because the sawmills control the freight, which for me is kind of a nice perk that I don't have to deal. deal with that and I don't have to have a logistics person manage all those things. But it's

interesting because if Phoenix is blowing up the sawmills and buying a bunch of lumber, they're driving up that FOB Prince George Price. So if you're in Dallas or Atlanta, you're kind of at the mercy of how busy is it in Phoenix because they're bumping up everyone else's price. And that That dynamic is unique, I think, to lumber, and that's because the shipper controls freight. And that's also because the shipper controls freight, they are the importer of record. So they're actually paying the tariff instead of the buy side, which I think is unique for imports. You know, it's hard for me. I don't have a ton of experience in other commodities.

But in a way, I think it makes it more efficient. And I know for me running my business, it really simplifies things. the other side of that sword is some of those situations where I was talking about you cannot bid up freight to get the product because you need it so badly. Like it is very finite. Like there is no price you can pay because you don't control the rail cars. You can't tell the CN I will pay two, three, four X, whatever it is because I got to have the product. So it causes major issues in peak lumber season, shipping seasons.

And if you look at lumber shipment seasonality, it's big in January and February. And then there's another bulge in the fall. And if there's a shortage of rail cars, there is no open market wholesaler of rail cars that you can go to to get your lumber from A to B. Like you're at the mercy of the sawmills contract with the rail cars. So that will drive up price on the futures contract. more than anything, it drives up prices for local basis for someone like me who has it. So lumber yards have learned this over the years, and they try to anticipate and buy before there's a rail shortage and load up on inventory ahead of time so they don't get starved out

from lack of contracted rail supply. And I think that was from the traders that have been doing this longer than me, that transition happened about 20 years ago. And I imagine it's because the rail lines just wanted to face a bigger player who they could just deal, do volumes with versus onesie-twosies little lumber yards. So I have a really basic question, but who is making money from the price rise in lumber? Because I get the sense from this conversation that even though we've had this big surge, it sort of made things difficult for everyone. And there's no one in the lumber ecosystem who's like making out like a bandit at this moment in time. Yeah, that is very true. The sawmills are doing great. I mean, unbelievably great. And it's long overdue.

And I'm happy for them. I think we were going to grind higher to a price like this eventually. but COVID, you know, did its thing and we did it all at once. And the reason I think that was because that's what the Canadian experts that I work with and the folks who cover that sector have been telling me for a while. Like, it's coming, it's coming. We're reducing the cut. And eventually prices are going to be astronomically high. It just happened very quickly.

And it also happened after it sell off the $250 low and now we're at $1,300. basically 12 months later. So the mills, for sure, easy answer. After that, because the rise has been so sharp, it's going to compress margins for vendor, lumber dealers and home builders that kind of have that forward price lock dynamic. But prices have been this high for six plus months. We know then that these prices have been able to have been marked up

and sold over the past couple quarters. So higher prices generally are more profitable and we love it as an industry. How we got there is not ideal. But if we stay here, everyone's going to make a lot more money. Everybody just because a 25% gross margin for a lumber dealer, according to publicly traded financials on $1,300 lumber is a lot better than $600 lumber, right? So if we're higher for longer, everyone's going to do very well. This transition into it is fairly painful.

but I am of the belief that the floor for this market, because the market's going to stay volatile. It hasn't been volatile if it only goes up. That's not volatility. That's just one direction. You needed to go up and down. Eventually, folks will get covered and they'll get the lumber they need and roll over.

But if they've been selling forward, $900, $1,100, $1,100, $1,200 lumber, $900 purchases are extremely profitable. for them. And this idea of, am I going to get caught in a short squeeze again? Shame on me. So I think you're going to see bigger lumber purchases on these dips so they can be well supplied and have the product because that's ultimately it's driving this behavior. It's not the price. It's having the product on hand to fulfill your commitment to the builder. So higher for longer means these prices get normalized, a gross margin on a higher price, is ideal for everybody involved.

The transition to get there obviously is painful, but I think at the end of the day, for this housing cycle, it's a great thing for the industry. Stinson, this was fantastic. I loved learning about this totally new market structure and hearing your perspective on it. Really appreciate you coming on Adlaught. Yeah, hey, I appreciate it.

Hope folks learn something and happy to contribute. Thanks so much. Yeah, I think they definitely will. Thank you so much. Tracy, remember a recent episode with Sam Bankmanfried, the crypto guy? Yeah, sure. I kind of been thinking about that a lot, actually, with like the, with the lumber conversation. And his whole story is about, no, I'm serious. Like, his whole stories is like, okay, like, you bought this and then like you sold it, transferred it to someone in Japan and stuff like that. But I feel like all the interesting markets essentially involve, I guess they involve legwork. Like they involve like putting in the work to like, well, this sells for this and this place and this sells for this and another place.

And you have a relationship with this and you get to some size that you can do it. And it feels like even though like we kind of joked in the beginning, like Lumber is kind of a meme stock or it's kind of a crypto. Like they're kind of our similarities in market structure, I feel like. Is that contrived? No, I mean, I think it makes sense that markets with arbitrage opportunities are more interesting. And certainly they're going to attract people who are quite keen on making money. But again, like making that money does involve having some sort of edge or informational advantage or some sort of ability, for instance, to arbitrage the price of Bitcoin in South Korea versus somewhere else in the world.

So there is that. The other thing that this reminded me of is our conversations around COVID and just this idea that the coronavirus sort of accelerated all these previous trends that were already underway. And if you think about lumber, Stinson was describing the supply issues in Canada, the pine beetle infestation and the fact that Canada was sort of becoming more conservative about how much wood it was actually chopping down, that seems to have gotten worse over the prehistation. over the past year or so. And so it feels like a lot of this was on its way, but because of COVID, the impact has just sort of, you know, multiplied. Yeah, and that's the other thing. Like, you know, the population of the United States has grown a lot

because that's what populations do. The home buying population is growing. And like people have, like, talked for a long time about how the U.S. was just, like, underhoused. And the scars, and I love that point you made, about the scars of 2006, 7, 8, continuing to linger over the industry, linger over the industry. So it's kind of like we're getting this like shock therapy for the housing market overall where we knew we've been underhoused for years and suddenly we're like trying to like make up for that underhousedness in like the span of like a year or two. And so you get you get these like super like painful periods like we're seeing right now.

Yeah. It also makes you wonder if we're going to flip from being super conservative. in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, to everyone being scarred by the under supply issues in 2020, 2020, 2021. Like, for the next decade is lumber just going to be this huge market and everyone's

ramping up production? Well, that's what he kind of was hinting at at the end, right? Because, like, well, no one wants to get short anymore. Like,

basically, if you think of all the lumber yards, is having just been like got brutalized in the short squeeze. And now that becomes the new thing that scars them. then maybe you start to get this other correction, you're going to start to get more building and more investment and more capacity, which would probably be ultimately good for the economy rather than shrinking. Yeah, more houses at least. Okay, shall we leave it there?

Yeah, let's leave it there. Okay, this has been another episode of the Odd Lots podcast. I'm Tracy Alloway. You can follow me on Twitter at Tracy Alloway. And I'm Joe Wisenthal. You can follow me on Twitter at the stalwart. Be sure to follow our guest on Twitter. Stinson Dean, he is under the handle at Lumber Trading.

You really want to check out all of Lumber Twitter. It's a really good spot. Follow our, it really is. It's great. Follow our producer on Twitter, Laura Carlson. She's at Laura M. Carlson. Follow the Bloomberg head of podcast, Francesca Levy at Francesca Today. And check out all of our podcasts at the handle at podcasts.

Thanks for listening. You can get the news whenever. you want it with Bloomberg News Now. I'm Amy Morris. And I'm Karen Moscow here to tell you about our new on-demand news report delivered right to your podcast feed. Bloomberg News Now is a short five-minute audio report on the day's top stories. Episodes are published throughout the day with the latest information and data to keep you informed. Yes, there are other products like this from a variety of news organizations, but they usually rerun their radio newscasts throughout the day. That's not what we do. We create customized episodes that can only be heard on Bloomberg News Now.

And we don't wait an hour to publish breaking news. When news breaks, we'll have an episode up in your podcast feed within minutes. So you're always getting the latest stories and developments. Get the reporting and the context from Bloomberg's 3,000 journalists and analysts we're all over the world. Listen to the latest from Bloomberg News Now on Apple, Spotify, or anywhere you listen. What separates good leaders from transformational ones? I'm Jessica Chen, and in season two of Leading By Example,

we'll sit down with executives like Grace Chen of Bertie Gray to find out. It's important to understand where you spike, but also really acknowledge where you don't and find people who can fill those gaps. Listen to Leading by Example, executives making an impact on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts.