Passion Struck with John R. Miles - Dr. Peter Yesawich on Elevating Healthcare with Hospitality EP 476
Episode Date: July 4, 2024In this episode of Passion Struck, host Jon R. Miles interviews Dr. Peter Yesawich, Chairman of Hospital Healthcare Partners and Vice Chairman Emeritus of MMGY Global. Dr. Yesawich and Stowe Shoemaker... co-authored the book "Hospitable Healthcare," which explores applying hospitality principles to healthcare to enhance the patient experience.Dr. Yesawich introduces the PAEER model (Prepare, Anticipate, Engage, Evaluate, Reward) as a framework for improving patient satisfaction and overall healthcare experience. The model emphasizes the importance of understanding patient preferences, providing personalized care, and implementing loyalty programs to enhance patient engagement.Order a copy of my book, "Passion Struck: Twelve Powerful Principles to Unlock Your Purpose and Ignite Your Most Intentional Life," today! Recognized as a 2024 must-read by the Next Big Idea Club, the book has won the Business Minds Best Book Award, the Eric Hoffer Award, the International Book Awards for Best Non-Fiction, the 2024 Reader’s Choice Contest by Connections eMagazine, and the Non-Fiction Book Awards Gold Medal. Don't miss out on the opportunity to transform your life with these powerful principles!Full show notes and resources can be found here: https://passionstruck.com/dr-peter-yesawich-on-healthcare-with-hospitality/In this episode, you will learn:The importance of customer relationship management in healthcareThe PAEER model: Prepare, Anticipate, Engage, Evaluate, RewardExamples of how healthcare providers can improve patient experience using hospitality principlesThe concept of serving patients instead of just treating themImplementing loyalty programs and incentives for patientsFranchising opportunities in healthcareUsing data and technology to enhance patient care and experienceAddressing the hospitality deficit in healthcareAll things Dr. Peter Yesawich: https://www.yesawichholding.com/our-teamSponsorsBrought to you by Clariton, fast and powerful relief is just a quick trip away. Ask for Claritin-D at your local pharmacy counter. You don’t even need a prescription! Go to “CLARITIN DOT COM” right now for a discount so you can Live Claritin Clear.--► For information about advertisers and promo codes, go to:https://passionstruck.com/deals/Catch More of Passion StruckWatch my solo episode on Create Work-Life Balance: 9 Simple Ways.Can’t miss my episode withDr. Mark Hyman on the Secrets to Living Young ForeverListen to my interview withDr. Kara Fitzgerald on How to Become a Younger You by Reversing Your Biological AgeCatch my interview with Dr. Mark Hyman on How Personalized Medicine Is Revolutionizing HealthcareListen to my solo episode on 7 Reasons Why Acts of Kindness Are More than Meets the Eye.Like this show? Please leave us a review here-- even one sentence helps! Consider including your Twitter or Instagram handle so we can thank you personally!
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Coming up next on Passion Struck.
In the marketing world, there's a tremendous amount of focus over the last 25, 30 years
in customer relationship management. Generally, that doesn't exist in healthcare. It certainly
doesn't exist in most of those individual practices because the records are primary
clinical. But things like, well, here comes John. And we know that John has already told us that
he can't have an appointment with us on Tuesdays and Wednesdays,
okay, because he has other obligations at work. Well, we don't need to ask him that question
every time he calls for an appointment. We should know that. There should be in the system that says
John doesn't want Tuesdays and Wednesdays, or it would be time of day, or we know that John needs
some assistance with transportation, or we know all those kinds of things, we should know those things.
And as it turns out, all of that information
is generally exchanged in some fashion
between the patient and the provider,
it's just not captured.
Welcome to Passion Struck.
Hi, I'm your host, John R. Miles,
and on the show, we decipher the secrets, tips,
and guidance of the world's most inspiring people
and turn their wisdom into practical
advice for you and those around you. Our mission is to help you unlock the power of intentionality
so that you can become the best version of yourself. If you're new to the show, I offer advice
and answer listener questions on Fridays. We have long-form interviews the rest of the week with guests ranging from astronauts to authors,
CEOs, creators, innovators, scientists, military leaders,
visionaries, and athletes.
Now, let's go out there and become passion struck.
Hello everyone, and welcome back to episode 476
of Passion Struck.
Ranked as one of the top five most inspirational podcasts
worldwide. A heartfelt
thank you to each and every one of you who return to the show every week eager to listen, learn,
and discover new ways to live better, to be better, and to make a meaningful impact in the world.
If you're new to the show, thank you so much for being here, or you simply want to introduce this
to a friend or a family member, and we so appreciate it when you do that. We have episode starter packs,
which are collections of our fans' favorite episodes
that we organize into convenient playlists
that give any new listener a great way
to get acclimated to everything we do here on the show.
Either go to Spotify or passionstruck.com
slash starter packs to get started.
I am so excited to announce that my book Passionstruck
won Best Nonfiction Book at the International Book Awards.
It's also won the Eric Hoffer Book Awards,
was awarded the Best Business Minds Book Awards, and won the gold medal at the Nonfiction Book Awards. It's also won the Eric Hoffer Book Awards, was awarded the Best Business
Minds Book Awards, and won the gold medal at the Non-Fiction Book Awards, in addition to being
selected as a must-read by the Next Big Idea Club. You can purchase it on Amazon or go to
passionstruck.com. In case you missed it, earlier this week I interviewed Amy Lee McCree. In our
episode we explore her latest insights on developing innate intuition, harnessing universal energy,
and enhancing personal well-being. You'll discover in this episode's practical tips from her new book,
Aura Alchemy, and learn how to transform your life from the inside out. Don't miss this
enlightening conversation with Amy Lee McCree. And if you like Amy's episode or today's,
we would truly appreciate a five-star rating and review, and sharing the show with your friends
and family. I know these reviews go such a long way in bringing more people into the
PassionStruck community and we and our guests love to hear from our listeners. In today's episode, I am delighted to have Dr. Peter
Jesiewicz, chairman of Hospital Healthcare Partners and vice chairman emeritus of MMGY Global. Peter, alongside Stowe Shoemaker, co-authored the
groundbreaking book Hospital Healthcare, which delves deep into a fascinating concept.
What if healthcare providers serve their patients
in the same way that hospitality providers serve guests
in hotels, resorts, and restaurants?
It's a thought-provoking question.
Given that both industries share
many common service touch points,
can principles of hospitality be adopted
to enhance the patient experience?
Hospital Healthcare provides a resounding yes,
as they answer. In this interview, Peter is going to share with us the secrets and principles from
the hospitality industry that can revolutionize the way healthcare providers engage with their
patients. We will explore Peter's innovative PAYER model, which stands for Prepare, Anticipate,
Engage, Evaluate, Reward, and learn how it addresses current trends impacting the healthcare
landscape. This episode promises to be an enlightening journey
as we unravel the reasons behind the hospitality deficit
in healthcare and how adopting a hospitality-oriented
approach can significantly enhance patient satisfaction
and overall experience.
So get ready for an eye-opening conversation
that will challenge your perceptions
and unveil a new horizon where the worlds of healthcare and hospitality converge to create an extraordinary patient experience.
Thank you for choosing Passion Struck and choosing me to be your host and guide on
your journey to create an intentional life. Now, let that journey begin.
I'm so excited today to welcome Dr. Peter Jesiewicz,
fashion stroke. Welcome Peter. Thank you, John. Delighted to be here.
Today we're going to be exploring your brand new book,
Hospitable Healthcare. Love the title of it. But before we get into that,
I thought it was good to dive into your background because you
have an extensive one in marketing and communications in the travel and
hospitality industry.
But can you explain how with that background it led you down what I consider to be an unusual
path of becoming a board member at the cancer treatment centers of America?
Dr. Wonderful question.
I'll try to do this briefly for your audience, but going back to my school days, I have a
doctorate in psychology, but I never pursued that with the idea of practicing clinically. I did it with the understanding of applying the principles of
psychology, really a marketing communication. So for about a 35-year period, I built a business
that ultimately became, I think, the largest in the hospitality category, certainly this part of the
world, where we created marketing communications programs for brands that you and your listeners would recognize. Back in the late 90s, however,
I received an inquiry from then the chairman of the company by the name of
Cancer Treatment Centers of America, CTCA to express it briefly, and the
chairman had found me because one of the board members of the company at that time was the president of the Ritz Carl and Nutell Company.
And he had been recruited to the board because the chairman wanted more hospitable kinds of care delivered to his cancer patients.
And he was aware of my work in service marketing, so he persuaded me to attend a board meeting as an observer one day, which was fascinating for me.
I knew nothing about oncology. I knew nothing about the business of medicine.
And I sat in the meeting and I marveled at the fact that the board meeting began with an
unprompted recitation from a patient. And the chairman said, we're going to turn the floor to
the patient. We're going to allow the patient to tell us the good, bad, and ugly on his or her experience.
We're not going to start this meeting until he or she is finished.
And it was a fascinating kind of recitation for me.
And I looked around the room and there were some really impressive people on the board.
And I thought, wow, this is an organization that is committed to that kind of patient-centricity.
There's a lot of merit here.
He had asked me, because of my knowledge of service marketing, to join the board, which I did.
I sat on the board for, I think it was about 16 years, but between 2010 and 2020, he actually
asked me to take the reins of the marketing communications for the company. So I became the
Chief Growth Officer for CTC. And for those of your listeners who don't know that company,
back when I exited, we had five destination hospitals.
I say destination hospitals because the majority of patients
would travel from their hometown to seek care there,
primarily as a result of the complexity of their diagnosis.
And 10 clinics, we were treating roughly
about 15,000 patients annually.
We had, at one point in my career there,
we had all five hospitals achieve
five-star HCAHPS ratings.
We were one of two hospital systems in the country
to do that.
We were consistently rated two hospital systems in the country to do that. We were
consistently rated at 95 plus percent in terms of likelihood to recommend it. That always amazed me
because we're talking about cancer. We're not talking about broken bones and other kinds of
maladies, but many times before the diagnosis of cancer, the outcome is very sad. Yet we would continue to get these remarkable ratings. What I observed there is I looked at the hospitality elements
of the care delivery, and that's a long answer to a great question,
but that basically is what then inspired me and my co-author
to write this book.
And that is we had one foot in hospitality and one foot in health care,
and it became very obvious to us that the
healthcare business could be, the patient experience could be improved immensely through
the adoption of certain principles of hospitality.
Well, we're going to explore that in a second, but I wanted to go back to your marketing
communications background just for a second.
I have a similar background in some ways.
My side of the house was more on the technology aspect of it, but I joined a company called Catalina Marketing.
Sure, if you're familiar with them, but based here in the Tampa Bay area, we
had two sides of our business.
One was Catalina and the other was Catalina Health.
So Catalina, what we did was personalized promotions in the form of both paper
coupons that you would get when you would check out plus digital advertisements
or coupons that were tailored to you.
And it was a really interesting business model.
Unfortunately, the company isn't what it was a decade ago, but we had three years
of data on pretty much every single person in the United States, France, the UK, and
Japan, and their shopping habits across all large Fox retailers,
grocery retailers and pharmacies.
And therefore could really personalize the offers
that we were giving them.
And then the other side, we had this business,
Petaline and Health, where we were doing basically
promotions for big pharma companies.
And what we were trying to do was unite the front and back of house and pharmacies.
But then we developed a capability called total patient management, where we wanted
to be able to provide different messages to a patient, both before they would enter a
caregiver's location, but then afterwards or when they would go to a pharmacy
to enlighten them to remember to take supplements
or do these lifestyle interventions, et cetera.
Does any of that ring a bell with any of the work
that you had done?
Yes.
One of the things that I think we highlight in the book
is the sophistication in the hospitality business
that has evolved over time in terms of understanding the preferences and the behaviors of customers
and then translating that into how you anticipate and serve patients in healthcare, whether
it's the kind of thing you described which is profiling previous behavior to, I don't
want to digress, but it's one of my favorite topics,
loyalty. Let me cite a statistic for you that I think very few people in health care know, and
that is if you look at the percentage of adults who seek a treatment of any kind from a hospital
or a hospital system in this country, and the percentage who return to that system or hospital
within a five-year period for any other type of service, that's about 42-43% of the population of patients.
That means that there's a 60% attrition rate from year one to year five in
healthcare that would never happen in hospitality.
And the reason for that is exactly what you just described.
And that is they track behavior, they track preferences, they act upon those preferences,
and they reward that behavior.
Again, not to digress, but one of the things we have fun with in the book is
we ask the question, why do health care providers not have loyalty programs
and frequency programs?
Why?
And now you've read the book, we open with this fictitious patient
who gets a colonoscopy by his PCP.
And we chronicle all the challenges he has in getting
that done.
And then six weeks later, he and his wife decide to go to
Vegas for a weekend.
And we chronicle that whole experience.
And at the end of that, we disclose the fact that when
he looks at his visa bill, after he gets back from
Vegas, he discovers he got 2,500 reward points.
And we ask the question, why didn't he get reward points for his colonoscopy?
And when I say that to clinicians, they all work, and you get these wild expressions,
and some are offended by that.
But I say, no, think about that.
Why would you not create programs that advance loyalty?
To your point, John, those techniques came from hospitality.
That's where frequency programs were born.
It was in the airline business.
It was United Airlines and ultimately American.
My car wash down the street has a frequency program.
Why is it?
Anyway, you get the point.
But so those techniques were born in hospitality and have yet to infiltrate health care.
It's interesting. This past year I've had on two distinguished people from the hospitality arena.
One was Will Gidera, and he's published a new book this past year called Unreasonable Hospitality.
And then I had on Jeremy Fall, who opened up 14 restaurants.
And one of the things that they both described to me
in their interviews was that there's only so much you can do
within the four walls of a restaurant.
The most important thing that you can bring to life
is the experience that someone has when they're there.
And it's an interesting way to think about health care
because you typically don't walk into your doctor thinking
about having an experience because most of us have not had a pleasant one when we visit our doctors,
so to speak. An interesting point and I love to start this conversation with people who are
interested in the topic by asking them a question, and that is, have you personally ever had a healthcare experience
that went wrong?
And everybody has a story, most of us have multiple stories,
but then I stop them and I say, well, think about
what caused that, and rarely is it the clinical outcome.
That's not what went wrong.
It's the way the healthcare service was provided.
And that takes us back into the realm of hospitality.
And in the book, we introduce a model that we've created called the payer model.
Now, you'll get a chuckle out of that as you listen as well,
because when you say payer to people in healthcare, head's turn.
But our payer is P-A-E-R, and it stands for prepare, anticipate, engage, evaluate, and reward.
And those are the five steps in a hospitality that we, and we actually
provide very actionable kinds of recommendations in the book, whether
it's a PCP, a multi-practice office, whether it's a hospital system, where
they could actually import those techniques.
Because we know that in the hospitality business,
one of the things they do exceedingly well
is they prepare for arrival.
So they know more about you.
They know your room preference.
They know your seat preference.
They know your pillow preference.
All those kinds of things.
And one of the things that frustrates consumers
of health care so much is the requirement of the clipboard
and filling out all the information.
And they say, well, gee, I was just here three months ago, why do I have to do this again?
Well, I realize that there are reasons for that, but there are also reasons to circumvent that,
and to do this in a way that is a little more consumer-friendly.
But I guess the point I'm making is that our model has been crafted
around the idea of taking demonstrated
principles of hospitality in those areas. How do you prepare, anticipate, engage, and
so forth. And for each of those, demonstrate a typical experience that a
healthcare patient has and how they could really improve the patient
experience. Now the one thing I would mention too is one of the objections I
hear appropriately from people, in particular who read the
book who say well this is great but hospitality is a need service and we're
in the excuse me is a want service we're in the need service right so that you
don't come to the hospital out of out of choice. Well that may may not be true, depending on the reason for
visit, but there's so many elective procedures, and if we talk about all the other kinds of
procedures that are non-emergency in nature, where there is an element of choice for patients,
all of these principles we believe apply.
Well, let's dig into that a little bit more deeply, because you said in the book that
you had conversations with 25 leading hospitality and healthcare professionals.
Were there any insights from these conversations that particularly stood out to you or shaped your approach?
Yes. And let me give you the kind of the grand perspective. The insight that came from those interviews, and by the way, I purposely attended multiple
patient experience conferences since we started this process,
just as an observer, to listen to the luminaries
in that discipline.
And here's the big insight.
Everybody agrees it's a problem,
the patient experience is a problem.
There is no agreement on the solution to the problem.
And so what happens is the dialogue tends to focus on, well, we know that people are
upset with surprise billing and we know that we're upset with wait times and we know that
the list goes on and on, but rarely do we hear in our interviews, or have I heard in
my attendance at these conferences, a very specific list of actionable steps
that a healthcare provider could provide
to go ahead and address those.
Let me give you one example, if I may,
because in the book we talk about the hospitality deficits,
and that's the term that we use to describe the problem.
And the way we calculated, Brad, as we went out,
I think it's John, and we did, rather than have two guys
with an opinion, we went out and we did a national survey
of 1,200 adults.
And it was the insights that came from that survey
that fed the content of the book.
But in the survey, we identified 22 points of service contact
that are common to both healthcare and hospitality. Examples would be how easy or difficult it is to get an appointment,
for example. Another example would be whether or not you know the cost of the
service before it's rendered. Those kinds of things. We have 22 points of
engagement and we looked at those for hospitals, we looked at those for walking
clinics, physicians offices, lodging, and dining and restaurants.
So the way to think about this is we have a 5 by 22 matrix
study and we had 1,200 observations in each cell.
We do all the analytics and we come up
with this concept of deficits.
So here's the example.
The number one source of dissatisfaction,
the hospitality deficit for adults in America, according to our
work today, is not knowing or understanding the cost of the
service before it's provided.
So we all have examples of that, whether it's going to
the local dentist or you're not made aware of the cost of the
treatment, whether it's, and I'm talking about
non-emergency procedures.
Certainly it applies to many emergency procedures.
How about things like an annual physical?
I mean, we all have many examples, but we have no idea what the cost of the service
is going to be in healthcare.
We certainly know what it's going to be in hospitality.
So the question is, what do you do with that insight?
Well, I was giving a presentation a couple of weeks ago and a CEO of a large health system
in New York came up to me and said, okay, smart guy, tell me what we should be doing
to address that because we know it's a problem.
People complain about that all the time.
I said, well, let me give you this idea.
I said, next week if you have to take your car to the repair shop, are they going to
give you an estimate?
They said, well, sure they are.
I said, you're going to have to approve that estimate before they do the work, right?
When you check the cost of a flight from New York to San Francisco, are you going to know
the cost of that?
Well, of course you are.
Anyway, you get the appointment.
I said, why don't you do this?
When you confirm an appointment, this is not emergency procedures, when you confirm an
appointment for a patient, why don't you give them with that confirmation a pro forma estimate of the cost of the treatment
or service that's going to be provided with the disclaimer that that may be adjusted based
on the examination, the tests that are going to be performed and so forth.
But at least, and by the way, you know what that's going to be because the insurance company,
you've already negotiated the contract and you know what the reimbursement's going to be for that.
So why don't you go ahead and just give me that range estimate,
and even if it's going to, if the actual cost is going to vary slightly,
which you'll disclose the reason why, what you've done immediately,
and by the way, the copay requirement of the patient, what you've done immediately is you've diminished
that hospitality deficit dramatically.
So now people go, oh, it's gonna cost me
between six and $800.
So then they can decide what it is they'd like to do
with that information.
So he said, it's interesting.
I said, well, you can have all of that information.
And obviously it requires some software
and some discipline to do that.
I said, why don't you do that?
So we never thought about doing that.
And anyway, there's an example
of kind of the thing I'm talking about.
And that's the number one source of this deficit.
Now, naturally it can be the system
would have some complications and debug and so forth.
But I offer that up as a practical example.
It's funny, John, a number of these podcast interviews that I've done with hosts such
as yourself, they all say, you know what, I got a bill the other day from my dermatologist
that I didn't expect.
I got a bill that everybody got a bill they didn't expect.
Now, I'm not talking about surprise billing, It's a whole other discussion, but I'm talking about
unexpected bills, and I guess you get my point.
And that is, I think the way to manage that in our
payer model is go ahead and give a pro forma estimate
the time the appointment is confirmed.
I thought maybe an interesting way, Peter, to go
about demonstrating your payer model was for me to give you a real life example.
We've got a fictional one, Roger, in your book, but I thought maybe we'd give you one from my life.
Love it.
And then you could go through, after you hear what happened to me, how if they applied the pair model, it could have been a different experience.
Good.
So, I get most of my services through the VA since I'm a veteran.
However, oftentimes they don't have the capacity to do everything in routine services that
they need to do for us, so they give us something called community care.
So, I was sent to community care for a neurology department.
So what ends up happening is the VA sends over a fax to the clinic. This one happened to be a place
called St. Anthony's Neurological Clinic here in St. Petersburg. And then that clinic is then supposed to receive that information and then
contact the patient so that they can do an intake. In my case,
I was told by community care that they had sent the information and I waited one week,
waited two weeks, didn't hear anything, went back, called community care again, and they said, well, it sounds
like you're going to have to initiate the process
with St. Anthony's.
So then the only way to initiate that process is to
call them.
So the first 15 times I called, I could not get
through to a human person because it would hang up on
me or even
even answered the phone. Then when I finally did get through I waited for
over an hour to talk to a human who said that they hadn't received anything from
yay and that I needed to have them resend it again. So after playing this
game for a bit I found out that if you call in the morning,
you have basically no chance of getting a human on the phone.
But if you call later in the day between three to five, you've got a much better
opportunity.
So after going through this cycle multiple times, I eventually got the appointment
set up.
Once you get into the system, I found it to be very
straightforward.
The doctor was great.
The treatment was actually provided much better than the
VA did it and in a much more, uh, advantageous and quick
way for me because I'm in and out of the office with about
20 minutes, which was great.
Where this takes an hour to an hour and a half at the VA.
But then about three, four weeks later, I get the bill in the mail.
And luckily the VA is paying for it.
But this is a procedure that if you would go to most places would probably run you
700, maybe at tops a thousand dollars. And they were charging the VA $700, maybe at tops $1000.
And they were charging the VA $3,800 for it.
Obviously the VA is only accepting a fraction of that.
But the price tag was just shocking to me.
But interestingly enough, after I had gotten the bill, I actually got a
satisfaction survey about the whole procedure and it outlined
the experience and then never received any feedback from it.
That's just my personal example.
In your peer model, what interventions could you have done across the prepare, anticipate,
engage, evaluate, reward?
Oh, I could give you many.
We probably don't have enough time on your show to go through even past the P in the mug.
But no, I mean, your comments, John, unfortunately are not atypical,
the kinds of experiences that many of us, myself included, by the way, have had seeking health care.
And I'll go back to my comment earlier when I said,
when I ask people, can you think of a healthcare experience
gone wrong, it's not the clinical outcome.
I mean, you just confirm that in your experience,
if I've heard you correctly, you were pleased
with the clinical intervention and presumably
with the clinical outcome.
It was all of the elements that surrounded that,
which is the delivery of care,
which are hospitality elements
that produced the kind of horrific experience
that you'd, and the frustration that you had.
And every step of the way, those are manageable.
And as I say in the book, for each of those,
we have probably four or five very specific actions
that a healthcare provider could take to prepare, to anticipate, to engage, and so forth.
Really, I'm pleased to hear that you were asked for some feedback. I'm dismayed to
hear that you never heard back from them, but in our book you may recall that one
of the things that we asked the 1,200 respondents was, do providers in health care ask for feedback and the majority don't, which is
also very interesting. And the contrast with hospitality is vivid. Last night,
we had dinner with no friends and I booked a reservation on OpenTable two
days ago. This morning, before I even got out of bed, I have an email, OpenTable says,
tell us about your dining experience.
The same is true with many service providers
that are relentless.
We just took a vacation a couple of weeks ago.
TripAdvisor has sent me multiple emails
requesting feedback on the same trip
because I haven't responded yet.
Now, I get to the point where we say, okay, enough's enough.
But my point is that the whole hospitality culture is, tell us more about how we did,
which by the way, cascades into another aspect of the payer model and how consumers are seeking
information about providers.
We're all going online and looking at position ratings
and hospital ratings and so forth.
And what's really interesting is that the amount of ratings
and the quality of ratings available in healthcare,
particularly on providers, individual providers,
is very limited compared to what it is in hospitality.
The example we give is,
if you have an anniversary dinner booked
in a restaurant in Tampa and the entree is cold
or the service is lousy or whatever, and you complain
about that, immediately they fix it on the spot typically.
But you might go home that night, go online, and erupt
in terms of how you would critique that restaurant experience.
That doesn't happen in healthcare.
You know, people don't, they don't diss their providers.
They don't diss the physicians and the clinicians.
And we have a whole section of the book
where we explore that psychology,
because it's a very interesting psychology.
And I think we understand why,
but what that does is that it really diminishes
the amount of kind of objective information that's
out there for consumers to help make those choices.
But anyway, long answer to a great question, but we could deconstruct your whole experience
and I could give you very specific action items for the payer model that would be that
the VA, unfortunately the VA has a reputation for being less than responsive.
And I know that they're working diligently to try to improve that and applaud that.
In fact, I had the pleasure of meeting the gentleman who's in charge of the patient experience at the VA a couple of weeks ago.
And I can tell you that he is absolutely focused on trying to improve that.
But it's like turning a cruise ship. It's particularly an effort. Well, I think the problem at the VA,
and I think it's the same problem that you have
in the civilian world, is that the whole way
that the system, at least in the United States, works
is everything is protocol-based.
Meaning, the way the whole system treats you
is instead of looking at the tree and the trunk,
they look at all the leaves and the branches. And I think it would be a much different experience if
you had, almost akin to functional medicine, someone looking at the whole person. This is what
the primary care provider is supposed to be in the VA, but they're so overwhelmed they can't do it.
But I understand. providers supposed to be in the VA, but they're so overwhelmed they can't do it. So you end up going to all these different providers that they send you to and unfortunately
there isn't an interconnected system and from an IT standpoint, master data system that's
tracking this so that providers who are providing these other services are prompted not
only prepare for you but to anticipate what the visit is going to do and then
to adequately engage in it. And I think having looked at this from a lot of my
experience in Fortune 50 companies is part of the issue with the healthcare system and
where it differs from a lot of the major businesses that people are familiar with is when people
think about Lowe's, they think about Lowe's as a retailer.
Well actually, Lowe's is a big data company.
You would ask Lowe's, what is the one thing that differentiates them from True Value or Ace Hardware,
Home Depot, it is the underlying data that they have, not only on the products that they carry,
but most importantly, on the individual shopper who comes in the store
and or visits the website or calls up the call center.
I think that is an extremely critical factor that these
hospital systems, health care centers, individual offices
don't think about the data that they have at their disposal.
It's the same thing that Amazon does. Amazon has all these different capabilities.
When at its core, it's a data company.
Yeah, you've also got obviously regulatory issues
you have to deal with too in health care
that make it a little more complicated,
not to the extent that it's not possible,
but it does add a layer of complexity
when you start to profile preferences for patients.
But you're absolutely right.
And then there's the interconnectivity,
because the health care business is firewalled by provider.
And that is most providers are not national in scope,
as they are in hospitality.
They don't have a common database.
So if you travel from Tampa to Atlanta
and you stay in a Marriott, the people there are
going to know you as well as the people in San Diego at the Marriott.
They have the database that informs them.
That doesn't exist in the healthcare.
Again, there's some regulatory reasons, but another reason is the structure of the industry
right now.
One of the guys that we interviewed in our book was a gentleman by the name of Mike Levin,
who was legendary in hospitality, is the guy who grew the Holiday Inland brand. And he grew that
into a brand that I think eventually had like 4,000 units or something across the world.
And it was master franchising and understanding how to standardize service delivery throughout
the system. And the point he made to me, which I
agree with, is that there is a wonderful opportunity for franchise development
health care that really hasn't been explored because there's some wonderful
brands that have reputations that would be highly franchisable. Now the
concern, and we did this at CTCA by the way. We had many inquiries from individual health systems that wanted to import CTCA clinics
for quality care into a hospital or even create a hospital.
And the biggest challenge that we had was ensuring the quality and the consistency of
the care delivery.
And I realized that in healthcare, that's a lot more difficult than it is in
the hospitality. But the principle's still there. The principle's the same. And so one
of the things that we state in the book is we think this is going to change because we
think that one of the destinies in healthcare is there will be more franchising. There will
be more national systems. And there's a consolidation that will be underway, driven by cross-containment
in the clarion physicians and all the other things. But anyway, the parallels to us are very obvious.
Well, if you just look at a company, Chick-fil-A, who my brother works for, the amount of data that
they have on the stores and the ability for them to understand when a
individual store is performing well or when it's not is amazing to me.
They have, as you did, they have so many points of service that they look at to examine how well a particular store is doing and then they have all kinds of
interventions that they can do.
So in that franchise model, I think there are a lot of advantages where in share numbers you could have much more sophisticated
systems that could add value to how a franchisee would need to operate so that
it was done in a uniform way across all the different branches. So I think there
are some great opportunities for that.
But when you're talking about small one-off primary care physicians or maybe
you go to an orthopedic center that's got maybe four or five partners in it,
how do you take that model where in a franchise you could blow this out and how would you see this working for these individual providers who provider brand. There are so many specific suggestions in the payer model
in the book that practice could adopt that would have a very positive impact
on the patient experience. So again going back to the five steps, how do you
prepare in terms of exactly what we're
talking about a moment ago?
As you know, in the marketing world, there's a tremendous amount of focus over the last
25, 30 years in customer relationship management, CRM, database development, looking at preferences,
the kind of things you talked about before.
Generally that doesn't exist in healthcare.
It certainly doesn't exist in most of those individual practices because the records are
primary clinical, but even though the data are there, but things like, well, here comes
John and we know that John had already told us that he can't get an appointment, have
an appointment with us on Tuesdays and Wednesdays, because he has other obligations at work.
Well, we don't need to
ask him that question every time we call for an appointment. We should know that. That should be
in the system that says John doesn't want Tuesdays and Wednesdays, or it would be time of day, or we
know that John needs some assistance with transportation, or we know all those kinds of
things. We should know those things. And as it turns out, all of that information is generally exchanged
in some fashion between the patient and the provider. It's just not captured. It's not
captured and recorded and analyzed and then used to, again, prepare.
Again, the one that we all smile about, but it's very frustrating, is that the checklist
and the, I say the checklist, the, you know what I'm talking
about, the, what am I trying to say, the check board, the clipboard, where you have to fill
out the information.
Oh yeah, the clipboard.
You've filled that out five times before.
But I mean, even things like, here's another source of deficit for many patients, and that
is they don't really have much knowledge about either the
examination they're likely to have, the treatment they're likely to have, or the
providers. So what they do is they go online and they go to Dr. Google and they
go to WebMD and they try to accumulate this information. Well why wouldn't a
small practice like the one that you've just described say, okay along comes
John, he has an appointment next Thursday 2 p.m. and he's coming in for the following reason. So what we should do is we are
send him with the confirmation, maybe a little 45 second video clip and we can
record these things in advance and it might come from the clinician or come
from the nurse that you're about to see. John, hi, my name is Sarah and I'm the lead
nurse and we're looking forward to seeing you next week. It takes 30 that you're about to see. John, hi, my name is Sarah. I'm the lead nurse at the da da da da da.
And we're looking forward to seeing you next week.
It takes 30 seconds to do that.
Append that to the email and send that to you.
So now, all of a sudden, you're matching a name and a face.
There's more of an element of personalization to that.
And by the way, you can catalog all these too.
So we say John's coming in for a physical.
Well, rather than do a long email that says, don't eat or drink anything from midnight prior, put that in a little video and just attach
stuff to the confirmation send that. Or maybe it's a little bio on the one of the five clinicians
that you're going to see. And here's Dr. Miles. Well tell us he has a he paints for a hobby and
he's got two kids and he's you know where I'm going'm going. All of that is very easy to do. You just need the systems
And so when your appointment is confirmed, guess what?
You feel a little better about what you're gonna do who you're gonna see
And that's all hospitality
The best hospitality providers go so far
as to contact you before you arrive.
They send you an email and say,
John, we're looking forward to your arrival on Tuesday.
Is there anything we can do for you in advance?
Now, Holiday Inn doesn't do that.
Some of the four-star and up providers
do that as a matter of routine.
Well, you would definitely thank your concierge doctor
if you had one of those would be doing things like this.
Not too many people knew, but you're right.
Yeah.
Would it be nice if we all did?
The whole premise behind that, John, is hospitality.
That's the premise behind concierge medicine.
Obviously, the clinical aspect has to be superb, but it's all about access.
It's about access, convenience.
It's not being rushed in terms of the exchange.
That's all hospitality.
And it's funny because when we talk with a practitioner,
it's an interesting idea, but that really doesn't work in health care.
We say, oh, think about concierge medicine.
Then they say, well, that's elitist.
That's elitist.
We're a not-for-profit system.
And I say, wait a minute, everything in our
book applies equally to a patient on Medicare as it does to a patient with a Cadillac, Blue
Cross insurance, everything.
And if you go through the book and you look at the recommendations, that's absolutely
true.
So what we're recommending is not elitist. It's not concierge medicine.
But these are things that can be done for, to say, patients who are on government insurance,
Medicare or Medicaid.
They still want to be greeted a certain way.
They still want to know if there's a cost involved.
They still...
Anyway, you get the idea that all of these principles apply the same way.
Yeah.
To me, one of the...
If you were going to do something such as loyalty program,
something like that, one of the ways I think you could make it work, thinking out loud
here, is there are a number of companies who have worked with major corporations
to help give employees an incentive to take advantage of wellness programs such as going to a gym.
Right.
Definitely right.
What I would see is you could have a way where since a lot of people, let's just go through the example that people are getting their medical either through a credit card they're using or through the company by if
a person betters their health by doing wellness things, then does wellness checkups or the
standardized care they could be given points. That's absolutely right. If you're aware, there's a company that's doing that right now by the name of ShareCare,
S-H-A-R-E Care, and it was founded by the general founder of WebMD, and they're based
out of Atlanta.
And what they do is they sign up major corporations like I think Coke is a client and so forth.
And they offer this program to their employees. And that's precisely the idea.
And that is to the extent that they adopt a more healthy lifestyle
kinds of behaviors, what happens is they earn credits, rewards,
that in that example, they're using travel, by the way, as an incentive.
So if you can demonstrate that you're on the right path to a healthier lifestyle,
that one of the currencies that you can use is travel redemption.
But that's probably more the exception of the rule.
To your point, it could be people who are offered complementary screenings
in exchange for the certain behaviors.
So maybe it's lung cancer screenings, prostate screenings, breast screenings.
It could be a couple of yoga classes.
It could be cooking classes in the hospital kitchen
to demonstrate how to enhance the nutrition of the food.
All kinds of things that don't involve travel
or some kind of illegal incentive,
because you can't have any cash equivalent
or something like that.
But they can promote a healthy lifestyle
and reward that, and reward that.
Very important, given what I showed you before,
is 60% attrition in terms of people going back
to the same health system for another health care service.
I mean, as somebody who came out of hospitality,
when you look at that attrition rate,
you say, that's incredible,
because that means they have to continue to find new patients. hospitality when you look at that attrition rate, you say, that's incredible.
Because that means they have to continue to find new patients.
When I was at CTCA, we put as much emphasis on developing the relationships.
Now, obviously in cancer, your goal is to cure the cancer, not necessarily to create
repeat relationships, but through the relationships we had with family members
and physicians who made referrals and so forth,
they could see the progress that we would make
with patients.
That was very beneficial, as opposed to treating
every patient as a transaction,
which is the way it happens, unfortunately,
in a lot of places.
So they go out and they spend more money on marketing
to try to find a new patient,
as opposed to in a less challenging
disease. One of the things we know is when we get older we require more health care. As a provider, wouldn't you want to have that relationship
with somebody who's in their 40s and 50s and 60s? Anyway, that's the idea, but that doesn't happen in health care.
Peter, I think I'd like to get you to go through some hypotheticals with me.
So the first one would be how could a provider use the principles of hospital healthcare
to view a patient instead of treating them, serving them? Great question. Controversial question, by the way.
And I appreciate you raising the question,
because we try to make that point in a responsible way
in the book.
And for the benefit of your listeners,
let me just maybe elaborate on that.
We say that one of the reasons the hospitality industry
enjoys so much higher guest satisfaction and so
much higher loyalty than healthcare is they have discovered that as long as you
treat guests equally you can serve them differently. An example, if you're a member
of the frequency program in a hotel chain, you might go to a special counter to register,
so it's a shorter line.
Or you might get an upgrade on your accommodations
when you're checking.
Same is true in the airline business.
Same is true in the restaurant business.
So everybody is treated the same way.
It's just that they have identified different cohorts
of their customers that they serve differently.
As a result of that, as consumers, we've come to acknowledge that that's the way of the
world, right?
So we said, well, why is that guy in a different line than I'm in?
And the answer is, well, he has a different relationship with the provider that affords
him that privilege, and I accept that.
Now, in healthcare, that's kind of an asthma, right?
So you have that conversation with a hospital CEO
or somebody that say, well, you can't do that.
And our assertion is you may not be doing that now,
but you will be doing that in the future.
And that is as long as you treat everyone
clinically the same, everybody has the same quality
of clinical intervention.
There is an opportunity to serve patients differently.
So what does that mean?
Less wait times.
I have, I just finished an annual physical
here at the Cleveland Clinic
down in Weston, Fort Lauderdale.
And I go to their executive health program.
I'm fortunate enough that I can afford that
and I want to pay for that. And so when I go into their executive health program. I'm fortunate enough that I can afford that and I want to pay for that.
And so when I go into the radiology waiting area
to get my chest x-ray
and there are 30 other people seated there,
I go right in.
I don't wait for 45 minutes.
And I don't think anybody objects to that.
No, they don't know why that happens necessarily,
but the fact of the matter is
that I paid for that privilege. I'm going to get the same quality of the scan.
The person who's waited 45 minutes will get the same quality of the scan interpretation
that I get.
The only difference is that they've had to wait a little longer to get it.
That's a matter of choice.
That's a matter of consumer choice.
So the point I'm making is that I can give you multiple examples of that, but the point I'm making is that, I can give you multiple examples of that, but the point I'm making is that I think healthcare providers,
and by the way, the best illustration of this
is what we talked about a moment ago, concierge medicine.
So some providers are going, wait a minute,
as long as we treat everybody the same way,
we can serve them differently.
And they've carved that out and said,
well, there's a cohort that we identified.
And people can decide if they want to pay the premium for that privilege or not.
That's a matter of choice.
We assert in the book that that is one of the fundamental principles that has been identified
and refined in hospitality that has enabled them to maximize the financial
performance of their service because people are paid for that privilege.
And we know that's the case with concierge medicine where people pay a
premium for that access. So anyway that's a great question and so the
question is well how do you do that? Well let's say it's not concierge medicine.
Example would be, let's say somebody has to return
to the same clinic once a month
for whatever treatment it might be.
Wouldn't it be better if you had maybe
a different registration area for them
where they don't have to stand behind six other people
who may be first time patients in the clinic who are gonna get caught up
in all the administrative requirements.
And just, that's a simple idea.
So maybe you separate kind of registration areas
where you have one that acknowledges returning patients
and you have one that is for first time patients
and kind of thing.
The same would apply to preferential appointments.
So access to preferential appointments. So access to preferential appointments.
And this gets to be a little complicated
by giving the example,
because I think it's very relevant.
One of the other great revelations in service marketing
has been the concept of variable demand and yield management.
And the best illustration of that is you go online
and you check an airfare today,
and it might be different tomorrow.
And what's happened is the system has calculated the demand
and said, well, we can sell these seats at this price
and we're gonna sell them at a different price tomorrow.
You go on a website for a hotel and it says,
well, if you wanna come Tuesday night,
well, we're gonna charge you this.
If you wanna come Friday night,
we're gonna charge you that.
So this whole concept of demand,
variable pricing by demand
doesn't exist in healthcare. We say, well why not? I mean shouldn't it? So if I'm a
patient, if I say the expression we use is in the airline business we say tell
us what you want to pay and we'll tell you when you could fly. The same is true
in the hotel business. Tell us what you want to pay, we'll tell you when you can
go. And people go, that's that's great, because maybe I really
want to go on Friday night unprepared to pay the premium.
But then again, Tuesday's fine, because I
can save $100.
Well, the same scan that I'm going to get in radiology,
I mean, the cost of that is pretty much fixed.
Would it make sense to think about pricing some
of these services in healthcare such that you provide patients with an
opportunity to be served differently? As long as we treat them all the same way.
Yeah, so there's someone who says, I don't want to wait three weeks for an appointment.
I want an appointment next week, okay?
Those are available and what happens is you adjust
the cost of the appointment accordingly.
Now people say, well wait a minute, that's not fair.
Well I'm not sure what's not fair about that.
At the clinical, at the treatment is consistent
regardless of how people see it,
but understanding that there are different
cohorts of patients to be treated differently.
Now that's controversial and I acknowledge that, but we think it's inevitable in healthcare
that it will go that way.
For reasons that I think I've just hopefully articulated.
Peter, I've got a final question for you.
You mentioned throughout the episode today that many of the recommendations in your book
will be easy to implement,
while others could be more difficult or even more controversial like the one we just covered.
Could you provide an example of a more challenging recommendation and why you would like the healthcare industry to consider it?
I think it goes back to the one that I mentioned earlier in our discussion,
this issue of knowing the price of the service before it's rendered.
It's the number one source of aggravation dissatisfaction
for healthcare patients.
It's easily addressed.
I'm not gonna say it's completely solvable,
but it's certainly addressable in a way
that I think minimizes that frustration and anxiety
that people have when they don't know
the cost of the treatment,
as demonstrated by the example I've provided,
and that is that healthcare providers basically know,
I'm talking about non-emergency,
they know, even for emergency,
they know the cost of the service they're going to,
but healthcare providers generally know
the cost of the service that they think
they're going to provide before they provide it,
because all that's negotiated by contract with payers.
They know that.
And for the most part, that's hidden from patients, which is one of the reasons why
Trump back in 21 created that requirement for hospitals to post the cost of, I think
it's now about 300 common procedures so consumers could shop for them online.
And that's been a challenge to get compliance there.
Anyway, so my answer is I think that is the single greatest source of this frustration
aggravation.
It is solvable.
It's not going to be 100% accurate.
But if I were to tell you, John, that the procedure you're going to come in for would
cost you between $500 and $700,
as opposed to not telling you anything.
And then you get a bill for $680.
In those two scenarios, where are you going to be most comfortable?
And I would submit that it's going to be with a general knowledge, or maybe if the bill
wasn't $7 or $680, it was $725, a little higher than the estimate.
The fact of the matter is you had a little bit of a heads up
and a bearing on what the cost is likely to be,
and that diminishes a lot of the anxiety that people have.
Plus, it helps them make a choice.
Because we've all heard stories of people shopping MRIs,
and they're all real.
And if people had more access, transparent access
to that kind of pricing,
I think it would begin to diminish some of that frustration
that they feel as a result of not having access
to that pricing.
Yeah, you could look at it just,
if you do a car mechanic and get in multiple estimates
on what it's gonna cost to fix it.
That's the way.
Well, Peter, if a listener wanted to know more about you
and the book, where is the best place for them to go and do it?
Go to our website, hospitablehealthcare.com,
and it's not hospital health care, it's hospitable health care,
if you pronounce it correctly, but I hear some people say,
oh, it's hospital health care.
It's hospitable health care.
The reason for that is for most people, that's an oxymoron.
They go, what? And that's an oxymoron.
They go, what?
And that's why we have, by the way, the subtitle, which is just as important, hospitable healthcare,
just what the patient ordered.
We have a lot of fun with that because if they struggle with hospitable healthcare and they
go, everybody's heard the expression, it's just what the doctor ordered, this is just
what the patient ordered. So they can go to hospitablehealthcare.com.
Peter, thank you so much for taking the time with us today.
It was such a great interview and I was so glad I could have it.
It's been fun, John, and I hope you and your listeners
benefited from that and I've appreciated the opportunity.
Thank you.
I thoroughly enjoyed that interview with Dr. Peter Jesiewicz,
and I wanted to thank Smith Publicity and Peter for the honor of appearing on today's show.
Links to all things Peter will be in the show notes at passionstruck.com. Please use our
website links if you purchase any of the books from the guests that we feature here on the show.
And if you like books, you can go to passionstruck.com under the Passion Struck Podcast page,
and you'll see a whole list of hundreds of my recommended
books, each of which that I've read and recommend to my audience.
Videos are on YouTube at both our main channel at John R. Miles and our clips channel at
passion struck clips.
Please go and join over a quarter million other subscribers.
Advertiser deals and discount codes are in one convenient place at passionstruck.com
slash deals.
Please consider supporting those who support the show.
I'm at John R. Miles on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, and you can also connect with me on LinkedIn.
Are you curious to find where you stand on the passion struck continuum? Then sign up for our
new passion struck quiz, which you can find on passionstruck.com. It'll take you just 10
minutes to complete. It's only 20 questions and you can find out where you are on your journey
to becoming passion struck.
You're about to hear a preview of the passion struck podcast interview that I did with speaker
and executive coach, Vinny and Kelly, who reveals the transformative power of intentionality,
a feelings first approach to living and leadership.
Learn how prioritizing feelings over outcomes can help you reconnect with yourself, reclaim
your power and unlock infinite possibilities in both your personal and professional life.
I really love the word grounded because it really connects to what happens when you don't live in the comparison world.
You practice presence, and this is one of the key intentions of intentionality is practice presence over comparison.
When we're present, we are now living here and now, we're grounded,
and we're not living in this fictitious story of the future or the past, which is where
the ego hangs out. And the only place that our true divinity lives is here in this present
moment. And when we drop into the present moment, we allow some intelligence and insights
to start coming through us. And that's where the greatness really lies.
Remember that we rise by lifting others, so share the show with those that you love and and insights to start coming through us, and that's where the greatness really lies. Go out there and become passion strut.