PBS News Hour - Full Show - January 6, 2026 - PBS News Hour full episode

Episode Date: January 7, 2026

Tuesday on the News Hour, President Trump presses U.S. energy companies to revive Venezuela's derelict oil industry, but barriers stand in the way of accessing the country's vast reserves. The Venezue...la operation puts a changing U.S. foreign policy on full display. Plus, five years after the assault on the Capitol, the fight continues over how Jan. 6 is remembered. PBS News is supported by - https://www.pbs.org/newshour/about/funders. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Good evening. I'm Jeff Bennett. I'm the Navaz is away. On the news hour tonight, President Trump presses U.S. energy companies to revive Venezuela's derelict oil industry. But barriers stand in the way of accessing the country's vast reserves. The Venezuela operation puts a changing U.S. foreign policy on full display, with threats of intervention and an effort to assert more influence in the Western Hemisphere. And five years after the assault on the U.S. Capitol, the fight continues over how that fateful day is remembered. There was a multi-pronged attack of disinformation, radicalization, and violence to overturn the election. Welcome to the news hour. The divides opened by the Trump administration's weekend operation. to remove Venezuela's leader Nicolas Maduro widened further today. European leaders denounced increasingly aggressive statements by Mr. Trump and top officials about an American seizure of Greenland, a territory of NATO-Alli, Denmark.
Starting point is 00:01:15 Late today, the White House press secretary shared a statement with the PBS News Hour saying, quote, Greenland is a national security priority of the United States. The president and his team are discussing a range of options and, of course, utilizing the U.S. military is always an option. Meantime, as Nick Schifrin reports again tonight, in Venezuela, tensions and concerns are running high. As Venezuela heads toward an unknown, future, one family mourns the past.
Starting point is 00:01:46 Jose Gonzalez says his 80-year-old sister Rosa was a kind woman, impeccable in her conduct, and one of the few civilians killed in the Friday night raid to capture Nicolas Maduro. The family says the attack destroyed her Caracas apartment and inflicted a fatal wound. It caught us all by surprise. We never thought it would be like this, this way. But it happened, and it's something unavoidable now. A now unavoidable new future for Venezuela without Maduro, but his police state remains intact.
Starting point is 00:02:18 Today we filmed these scenes in Caracas, where normally bustling streets are relatively quiet. neighborhoods are closing early, and police are everywhere. Residents are scared because while Maduro is gone, Venezuela is still led by his lieutenants, new president, Elsie Rodriguez, sworn in yesterday by her brother Jorge, at least publicly defiant, alongside Maduro's son, U.S. sanctioned Nicolas Ernesto. I am convinced that with unity and more unity, with unity and more unity, we will prevail. They may have kidnapped Nicholas and Celia, but they did not kidnap the conscience of a people who have decided to be free.
Starting point is 00:02:58 His father sits inside this Brooklyn detention center, and today was taunted by President Trump. He gets up there and he tries to imitate my dance a little bit. But he's a violent guy, and he's killed millions of people. But there is little laughing in Europe today, especially Greenland. The world's largest island has been part of the Kingdom of Denmark since 1720. Today, it's a self-governing territory inside the NATO ally. It is also geographically in the Americas and a crucial missile defense site, the shortest
Starting point is 00:03:31 route between the United States and Russia, not to mention rich in rare earth minerals and potential offshore oil and natural gas. The real question is, by what right does Denmark assert control over Greenland? White House Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller on CNN last night. The United States is the power of NATO. For the United States to secure the Arctic region to protect and defend NATO and NATO interests, obviously Greenland should be part of the United States. That drew a furious reaction from some of the U.S.'s closest allies, Polish Prime Minister
Starting point is 00:04:05 Donald Tusk. No member of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization should attack or threaten another member of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Otherwise, NATO would lose its meaning. Danish Prime Minister Mette Fredrickson. If the United States chooses to attack another NATO country militarily, then everything stops. And today, Fredrickson and Tusk, joined by France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and the U.K. in a statement, quote, security in the Arctic must therefore be achieved collectively
Starting point is 00:04:36 in conjunction with NATO allies, including the United States, by upholding the principles of the U.N. charter, including sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the inviability of borders. The approval of the Charter of the United Nations. For 80 years in viability of borders has defined the post-World War II order, but the Trump administration now suggests that might makes right. We live in a world, in the real world, Jake, that is governed by strength, that is governed by force, that is governed by power. As for power in Venezuela, a person familiar confirms to PBS NewsHour, the CIA assessed opposition
Starting point is 00:05:17 leader Maria Carino Machado would not be able to hold the country together. To counter that administration souring, last night on Fox News, she added a sweetener. Did you at any point offer to give him the Nobel Peace Prize? Did that actually happen? The Venezuelan people, because it's a surprise of the Venezuelan people, certainly want to give it to him and share it with him. But for President Trump, the coveted Peace Prize appears no longer the focus. Instead, it's extracting Venezuela's maximum value. For the PBS News Hour, I'm Nick Schifrin. President Trump says the U.S. government could subsidize any effort by American companies
Starting point is 00:05:54 to rebuild Venezuela's oil infrastructure, something he told NBC News could take as little as 18 months. It comes as multiple outlets report the White House plans to meet with top U.S. oil executive soon. The president has made no secret that a major goal of this weekend's operation was to pry open Venezuela's vast oil reserves for foreign investment. We're going to have our very large United States oil companies, the biggest anywhere in the world, go in, spend billions of dollars, fix the badly broken infrastructure, the oil infrastructure, and start making money for the country. Despite sitting on more crude than any country on earth, Venezuela produces just 1% of the world supply. And its total output has dropped some 70% since the late 80%. since the late 1990s, a result in part of crippling U.S. sanctions and internal dysfunction. Right now, just one American oil company Chevron operates in the country under a special
Starting point is 00:06:55 license that allows limited production despite U.S. sanctions. Venezuela first nationalized its oil industry in the 1970s and further consolidated control under then-President Hugo Chavez in the mid-2000s, when it forced international oil companies to transfer majority control of their operations, to the state-owned oil company. To help us understand the dynamics at play and what could come next, we're joined now by Francisco Manali, professor and director of the Latin American Energy Program
Starting point is 00:07:25 at Rice University. Thanks for being with us. Thank you. So President Trump is pushing this idea of the U.S. reimbursing American oil companies for expenses in Venezuela, and he says oil operations could be up and running in 18 months.
Starting point is 00:07:40 Is that the case? Well, I don't think that it's, clear exactly what he means. But, you know, Venezuela would require about $100 billion of investment to go back to the levels of peak production, as you mentioned by the end of the 1990s. But that will require a complete overhaul of the institutional system. It would require legitimate government. You know, it will require long-term horizons for investors. Investors have been burned in Venezuela many, many times by contract reneging and changes in the tax system and this control by the national oil company.
Starting point is 00:08:22 So I think it will take some significant amount of time for those investments to come. So on that point, is there a genuine appetite among U.S. firms for that kind of capital investment in Venezuela given the political risk, given the sanctions history, and the overall market dynamic? Well, I think we have to distinguish. For example, Chevron is already in Venezuela, and they have a profitable operation. If they can export to the United States with a license and use part of the cash flow that they generate to reinvest in Venezuela, as they're doing now, they will continue to invest in Venezuela. And that's sort of the easiest sort of source of increase in production. But other companies that are not in the country, like say Conoco, or
Starting point is 00:09:10 Exxon that are owed money by the Venezuelan government, they will have to, first of all, look for opportunities, see the contracts, how they are offered, what is the fiscal regime, a variety of things, and then they will have to analyze if the political risk make it worth it to sink billions of dollars before they see the first revenue. And finally, there might be some smaller companies that are willing to go into fields that are currently operated by the national company and that already have all the infrastructure and just make a quick buck by investing in some, in drilling some wells. But that's not going to make the big difference that we're talking about, that recovering the oil industry of Venezuela. And Venezuelan oil, as I understand it, is predominantly heavy crude. How compatible is it with U.S. refinery capacity, especially along the Gulf Coast?
Starting point is 00:10:06 Actually, it's very compatible because the refineries in the Gulf Coast were optimized to process that type of oil because Mexico and Venezuela were supposed to be increasing production in the 1990s. And so the U.S. has mostly light oil and the other source of heavy oil, which is Canada, it cannot get easily to the Gulf Coast. There is no infrastructure because Keystone XL was never built. So the refineries in Texas and Louisiana are really eager to get some of the heavy oil that Venezuela produces. A question about the president's rhetoric. He so often says that Venezuela stole America's oil, so it's only fair that the U.S. gets a piece of it now. Here he is in his own words. We built Venezuela oil industry with American talent, drive, and skill, and the socialist regime stole it from us during those previous.
Starting point is 00:11:02 administrations and they stole it through force. This constituted one of the largest thefts of American property in the history of our country. Is there any basis to the way he frames that, whether legally or historically? Yeah, well, it's hard to understand exactly what he refers. If we talk about the nationalization of 1975, those were concessions that were going to expire in 1983. And the government basically brought that, uh, changed in the hands of the government by eight years, and they were fairly compensated. In fact, all of the countries did something similar. Saudi Aramco is the result of a very similar process of nationalization, of a much bigger
Starting point is 00:11:47 oil industry. So I don't think that that could be considered theft in any way. Then he might be referring to when Hugo Chavez forcefully renegotiated contracts and made the national company. majority shareholder. That's when two American companies, Exxon and Conoco, left the country, sued for arbitration, and they were awarded some significant amount of money that Venezuela has to pay them. And a lot of that debt is outstanding. Venezuela hasn't paid it. So what Venezuela has with the U.S. companies is a debt of about $12 billion that has to be paid as many
Starting point is 00:12:29 other debts. Venezuela owes $150 billion to a variety of creditors. Bottom line, if foreign companies, especially U.S. firms, return in force, what would the domestic implications be for ordinary Venezuelans? Well, it depends a lot if it's successful in terms of bringing the necessary investment to recover the oil industry. I don't think that will happen if there is no significant institutional change that brings credibility and a legitimate, uh, you know, legislation, etc. And so if that doesn't happen, there will be no sustained economic recovery. There will be a minor recovery that will benefit a few firms, but will have very
Starting point is 00:13:13 little impact on the average citizen. Francisco Manaldi of the Latin American energy program at Rice University. Thanks again for being with us. Thank you. In the day's other headlines, President Trump warned his fellow Republicans today that if they don't put in a strong showing in this year's midterm elections, he'll be impeached. Mr. Trump was addressing a meeting of GOP lawmakers at the recently renamed Kennedy Center. He described Democrats as mean and smart, highlighting what he sees as the stakes in the upcoming vote. You've got to win the midterms, because if we don't win the midterms, It's just going to be, I mean, they'll find a reason to impeach me.
Starting point is 00:14:05 I'll get impeached. President Trump also urged House Republicans to be flexible in their push to block federal funds from going to Obamacare plans that cover abortion. That says he pressed Republicans to reach an agreement on the expired health insurance subsidies saying it would strengthen the party's position on the issue of affordability. Meantime, in Wyoming, abortion will remain legal after that state's Supreme Court struck down. two laws it found unconstitutional. That includes the nation's first ban on abortion pills.
Starting point is 00:14:35 The justices sided with Wyoming's only abortion clinic and others who argue that adults have the right to make their own health care decisions. The ruling means the state remains one of more than two dozen states across the country, plus Washington, D.C., that allow abortions up to 20 weeks of pregnancy or later. Wyoming's Republican governor says he'll push for a constitutional amendment banning abortion that would go before voters this fall. In Iran, at least 36 people have now been killed amid ongoing protests over the country's struggling economy.
Starting point is 00:15:08 That's according to an outside human rights group which says that more than 1,200 others have been detained. Video emerged today of protesters clashing with security forces in Tehran's grand bazaar, long a hub of Iran's economic and political life. Authorities reportedly fired tear gas to disperse demonstrators who had been staging a sit-in. Elsewhere in the city, business owners say they're scrambling to make ends meet as high prices scare off would-be customers. Sales have dropped off very badly. Last year, at this hour, my shop was packed with customers. Now sometimes I wait one hour before a customer shows up. Market conditions are not good at all.
Starting point is 00:15:53 Activists say the protests have now spread to more than 270 locations. across Iran since they erupted more than a week ago. Ukraine's Western allies say they made progress today towards security guarantees for once a peace deal is signed with Russia. Ukraine's President Blodemir Zelenskyy signed a draft declaration alongside the leaders of France and the UK following a day of talks in Paris. The framework outlines NATO-style security guarantees, including a future deployment of multinational forces and ceasefire monitoring led by the U.S. For the first time, U.S. Special Envoy, Steve Whitkoff, and President Trump's son-in-law, Jared Kushner, appeared in person for a meeting of what's called the Coalition of the Willing. Kushner said today was, in his words, a very big milestone.
Starting point is 00:16:40 This does not mean that we will make peace, but peace would not be possible without the progress that was made here today. If Ukraine is going to make a final deal, they have to know that after a deal they are secure. They have obviously a robust deterrence. backstops to make sure that this will not happen again. Important details like specific commitments and troop numbers have not been finalized. President Zelensky has acknowledged in recent days that some support may come in the form of weapons or intelligence. Also in France today, winter weather is causing havoc on the roads and in the skies.
Starting point is 00:17:16 The French capital may have looked pretty under a fresh blanket of snow, but French authorities say at least five people have died nationwide, most of them in road accidents. The snow also closed six airports in France, while in the Netherlands, Amsterdam's International Airport grounded some 600 flights. Meantime temperatures plummeted in the UK to well below freezing, closing hundreds of schools there. On Wall Street today, stocks posted solid gains thanks largely to technology stocks. The Dow Jones Industrial Average rose almost 500 points or nearly 1%.
Starting point is 00:17:50 The NASDAQ added around 150 points. The S&P 500 also closed in positive. territory. Republican Congressman Doug LaMalfa of California has died. The former rice farmer and state lawmaker was first elected to Congress in 2012. He represented Northern California's first district along the Oregon border. LaMalfa's death further reduces the Republican majority in the House to a margin of 218 to 2.
Starting point is 00:18:16 2.3. We'd just like to ask for a moment of silence. Democratic lawmakers took a moment to remember LaMalfa at a panel today. marking the anniversary of the January 6th attack. No cause of death was immediately provided. Doug Lamalfa was 65 years old. And celebrated Hungarian director, Bela Tar, has died. Beginning with his 1979 film Family Nest,
Starting point is 00:18:41 Tarr created his own distinct style, slow-paced, sprawling, and darkly comic. Some critics called 1990s. his masterpiece. It clocks in at more than seven hours. Such works made him an icon of art house cinema. In a statement, the Hungarian Filmmakers Association said Beilatar died after battling a long and serious illness.
Starting point is 00:19:10 He was 70 years old. Still to come on the news hour. A look at the ongoing disinformation efforts five years after the January 6th assault on the U.S. Capitol. And threats of U.S. intervention placed multiple countries in the Western Hemisphere on edge. edge. This is the PBS News Hour from the David M. Rubenstein studio at WETA in Washington, headquarters
Starting point is 00:19:34 of PBS News. It has been five years since a mob of President Trump's supporters stormed the U.S. Capitol to try to disrupt the certification of the presidential election that he lost. Today, a much smaller but ardent crowd of his supporters returned to the site of the 2020. 21 insurrection, marking the 1st, January 6th since then, with Trump back in the White House, and most of those involved now fully pardoned for their actions on that day. White House correspondent Liz Landers spent the day covering the demonstration marking this milestone. Hundreds of people reenacted parts of a day that ended in violence and bloodshed.
Starting point is 00:20:18 Truth matters to this group. Followed by the prosecution and then pardoning of more than 1,500. participants. Officially, this was a memorial event for Ashley Babbitt. The Air Force veteran shot dead while trying to enter through a broken window in the Capitol and for others who were lost that day or in the weeks after, including a police officer. Babbitt's mother, Mickey Whithoof, spoke to the crowd. So glad that people are not losing sight of the importance of that day. It's a day Congress let us down and continues to let us down. Just after 1 p.m., exactly five years after President Trump concluded his remarks at the ellipse,
Starting point is 00:21:00 telling protesters to fight like hell, the crowd set off for the Capitol. Among those taking part in the day's events was Enrique Tario, the former leader of the crowd boys, sentenced to 22 years in prison for seditious conspiracy and other charges. What do you do January 6th over again? I know you weren't here in D.C. that day, but you were considered one of the masterminds of what happened. you do it again? I would definitely do everything I did again because I'm not guilty of that crime. Again, I'm sitting here pardoned.
Starting point is 00:21:31 If I wanted, if I told you, yes, I did it. You know, I wouldn't face it repercussions, but I'd be lying to you. You were found guilty though by a jury of your peers, right? Well, they're not a jury of my peers. I mean, they had bias, right? They showed bias. Outside the Capitol, they laid flowers for those who died. Among those commemorating the day was Guy Reffitt and his wife, Nicole.
Starting point is 00:21:56 Guy was a member of the militia, the Texas Three Percenters, seen here in 2021 on the steps of the Capitol being sprayed by police officers. He was the first rioter to go on trial, sentenced to more than six and a half years in prison for civil disorder, obstruction of an official proceeding, and entering a restricted building with a firearm. So this is January 6th. These are the hostages. Approximately 1,500 for a pardon. Yes. Full pardon. On the first day of his second term, President Trump pardoned or commuted the sentences of everyone charged, whom he called hostages. That I didn't really do anything worth what I got convicted of. That four-year sentence wasn't justifiable. So for going and standing on the steps of the Capitol building and not going in the,
Starting point is 00:22:47 building not breaking anything not stealing anything not assaulting anyone getting assaulted by police officers that at the top of the stairs 15 feet away and then leaving and going home was I trust passing I didn't see any barriers when I got there there was over a hundred thousand people on the property those barriers were nowhere to be seen what happened on January 6th became a family affair ref its wife Nicole helped lead today's ceremony today is the day to honor those that died and to celebrate those Americans that stood up. Guy's arrest and conviction has also caused riffs in his family, including with his son.
Starting point is 00:23:24 It's destroyed my family in a bunch of different ways. Jackson Reffat tipped off the FBI about his father's actions and told me, while he doesn't regret that difficult decision, we're scattered and apart. And it's been really hard to reconnect over these years. Have you spoken with your father since he was released from prison? I've sent him birthday messages, you know, and happy Father's Day. But that's been about it. The only time I've really talked to him was when I called him in prison, and that was very brief. But even then it's just been scary, you know, I'm not worried that he's going to, you know, break down my door, strangle me through the phone.
Starting point is 00:24:07 It's just a worry that things aren't ever going to get better at this. rate. It's been quite a strain. But like I said, you know, we've been able to stay strong and we're able to start rebuilding our relationship with our love. I'm waiting for him to be comfortable to, you know, come to holidays and things he was definitely, he thought it was going to happen this year. But he had his nerves and everything about it. But it is a work in progress. I think a lot of families are. But there was a lot of love there. So I know it's going to end up for the refits today's event was a reminder that many remained sharply divided over the false belief that the 2020 election was stolen the actions on January 6th and what came after I'm grateful to
Starting point is 00:24:56 get out but I think there was there's problems with the pardon but there's also good things with the pardon the problem with the pardon though is that there were bad actors there that day some people did really bad things I don't think everyone should have received a partner and i believe there are still some people that are waiting on a pardon that well it's the washing of everything it's uh just completely validating all of these people i mean all of these people they more or less fell for something um a con if you want to use that word i would um with no nothing in return to reward um but these people have been endlessly validated with a pardon. And that validation they never really received before.
Starting point is 00:25:44 Like, imagine the kind of action that a lot of these people might feel now that they've been pardoned. In the five years since January 6th, there has been a widespread fight over the story of that day. Congressional correspondent Lisa Desjardin was inside the U.S. Capitol and witnessed the storming firsthand. She has this look at the half-decade battle over the narrative. In the crowd storming the Capitol on January 6th, an unlikely character, an Idaho grandmother, has become one of the most well-known. I was hoping we stormed the Capitol. That's the voice of Pam Hemphill. You can see her insecurity camera photos of the crowd and inside the Capitol.
Starting point is 00:26:28 Prosecutors said she egged on rioters. You just come in. Just days earlier, Hemp Hill posted on Facebook about the rally, the fight for America is real. is real. In a photo, she posed with a gun and the caption, On My Way to Washington, January 6th. Now, she sees all that as part of a lie. The brainwashing that happens to you that the Democrats want to turn this into a communist nation.
Starting point is 00:26:53 They would always say, the same thing. Pam, don't listen to Democrats, whatever you do. They'll lie to you about everything. So you start believing all that. I got pulled into all the propaganda. But five years out, the battle still raided. still rages about January 6th, with recent comments like these from some on the right.
Starting point is 00:27:11 Most people in America are still buying the lie that like, oh, January 6 was a terrible thing. Trump supporters did some bad stuff, no. You remember what we were told about January 6th, January 6th, that it was an insurrection, the worst attack ever on our sacred democracy. And last January 6th, George, Georgia Republican Congressman Mike Collins said thousands of peaceful grandmothers gathered
Starting point is 00:27:40 in Washington, D.C. to take a self-guided, albeit unauthorized tour of the U.S. Capitol building. Hemp Hill was that grandmother, part of the mob, recording everything she saw, marching up the street, clashes with police, climbing the steps of the east front, and walking through the halls of the Capitol. There were a lot of people who, as we've gotten farther from January 6, have said things, including it wasn't violent, no one broke the law. What did you actually see compared to what people are saying?
Starting point is 00:28:16 We know they're delusional. Of course it was violent. They all had the attitude. It's our house. We can do what we want. We own it, you know, this arrogant, violent attitude. The video is indisputable. More than 140 police officers were seriously injured on January 6th.
Starting point is 00:28:38 There were brutal battles on the steps and in the center of the Capitol. Yes, some rioters followed the mob and mostly walked around, but even they, and I spoke with them, were there for an illegal takeover of the Capitol itself. Initially, some Republicans saw the event as a reckoning. There's no question, none. President Trump is practically and morally responsible for provoking the events of the day. This is January 6th. But in the years since, President Trump personally has worked to recast January 6th, pardoning
Starting point is 00:29:16 nearly all involved, including many who assaulted police, creating a narrative that they were patriots for believing his lie about the election. We freed the people. They were treated so badly. the people from January 6, who are largely, and there's always exceptions, but largely great patriots for this country. And Republican leaders now look the other way. Everybody can describe this however they want. If you could, you would argue that those people didn't pay a heavy penalty having been incarcerated and all of that. That's up to you.
Starting point is 00:29:45 But the president's made a decision. We move forward. I think it's as dangerous as any narrative we've ever had. Denver Wrigelman was a Republican member of Congress until three days before the storming of the Capitol. A former Air Force intelligence officer, Riggleman later served as a staff member on the January 6th committee and wrote a book, The Breach, uncovering and detailing what happened. I would say 30 to 35 percent of the population and believe the election was stolen. I think they will always be like that. And I really think at this point, people like me who are based in data and facts and who are an expert on January 6th, we were trying to reach a smaller and smaller percentage of the population to make them see what happened that day. It was a multi-pronged attack of disinformation, radicalization, and violence to overturn the election.
Starting point is 00:30:32 Why do you think so many Republicans support this idea that it wasn't that bad, however you want to cast that? Because they want to win elections. I mean, there's a reason they're having hearings on space aliens rather than looking at what happened that day or acknowledging what happened that day. Plus, they're looking at fundraising and polling in their districts. Trump is probably still over 70 to 75 percent
Starting point is 00:30:54 and more of the Republican-based districts. It's simply that. Publicly, Republicans in Congress dispute this. They say their view of January 6th is about gathering facts. And last year, House Republicans did launch a new subcommittee to investigate it. But privately, many Republicans admit to me that January 6th is something they see as a historic threat. Today at the Capitol, Democratic lawmakers who were there spoke to what they saw. If I close my eyes, I can still hear the thundering sound of the moment.
Starting point is 00:31:26 mob and the pounding of the door of the House chamber. I can still feel the sense of sheer terror as we struggle to fit on our gas masks and crawl on our knees towards the only open door at the opposite end of the gallery. But Republican Wrigelman worries that too many are still ignoring the worst truths of January 6th. What you're saying is that they want to look to the future. The issue is that the past is an incredible indicator of what can happen in the future. future. And if we're not looking at elections in 2026 and 28 and what can happen based on
Starting point is 00:32:01 these faulty belief systems or that violence can't happen again, you better damn well be looking at it. This is not a minor example of political violence in American history. It's the major one, I would say, after the Civil War itself. How that's going to play out over the long term, I think, is very much still being contested. Stephanie McCurry is a history professor at Columbia University. She says clashing versions of U.S. history aren't uncommon, like narratives about the reconstruction era of the late 1800s and the actions of the Ku Klux Klan. When I think about that as a kind of cautionary moment for what we're in now, the thing I worry the most about is how I saw that clan narrative offered as a raw partisan position in defense of an incredibly
Starting point is 00:32:46 violent racist organization. And then I saw it emerge in full. film and in written scholarly history, the Klan version became the history of Reconstruction. That narrative took hold until the civil rights movement displaced it. But McCurry sees something distinct with January 6th. I think we're in a dangerous moment because we have never seen a case before. I think we're one side of the contested narrative is being propagated by the president and who has made it a loyalty test for his regime. Which brings us back to the pardons, Trump issued, for those.
Starting point is 00:33:22 who stormed the Capitol largely in his name. Of the more than 1,500 people whom he pardoned, Pam Hemp Hill rejected the offer. I would not be a part of that. No way. You'd be a slap in the face of the Capitol Police, that's for sure. The rule of law. But I broke the law.
Starting point is 00:33:40 You don't pardon somebody that breaks the law. She has gone from Maga revered to Maga reviled. On social media, Pam now pushes back at Proud Boy Leaders who dispute January 6. June 6th, some family have disowned her, but the memory of that day and her sense of responsibility have not changed. And I spent two months in prison over Trump's lies that the election had been stolen. I've been a little angry, you know, that this has even happened. Hopefully some other people will just maybe listen to my story and say, look, she's right. I got to do some research
Starting point is 00:34:17 and not just listen to what I'm hearing in media and on Twitter. And it's part of my amends. It's one thing to say you're sorry for being there, but you have to do the footwork to prove it. Today, Hemp Hill returned to Capitol Hill, testifying alongside Winston Pangeon, a former Capitol police officer who defended the building five years ago. I was called a traitor,
Starting point is 00:34:40 violently assaulted in the line of duty, punched in the face, pepper sprayed, and thought, I'm going to die here. die here on the steps of the U.S. Capitol. Hemp Hill addressed Pangeon directly. I am truly sorry from the bottom of my heart for being part of the mob that put you and so many officers in danger. And Lisa Desjardin and Liz Landers join us now. Lisa will start with you.
Starting point is 00:35:09 The U.S. Capitol is still living with the aftermath of January 6th. What does this latest effort by Republicans to minimize what happened on that day? What does that mean for lawmakers and for the Capitol police officers who protect them? That's right. The Capitol Police and the Metropolitan Police of Washington, D.C. are really those caught in this rhetorical crossfire. A plaque honoring them and commemorating their fight to protect the Capitol on that day. By law was supposed to be installed on the west front of the Capitol. And for years, it has not gone up.
Starting point is 00:35:43 Now, House Speaker Mike Johnson, through a spokesperson to us, said that now it cannot go up because of logistics. They say some 3,000 names would have to go on it. They haven't figured out how to do that. And that may well be a real challenge. However, why has it taken years to even acknowledge that there was a problem here? Why hasn't there been a real effort underway to get that plaque up? I don't need to remind viewers that Capitol Police face real hand-to-hand combat for many of those hours on Capitol Hill. some of them by themselves. National Guard backup did not come for a long time. And now they also feel
Starting point is 00:36:19 somewhat abandoned by some lawmakers here in the Capitol as well. And Liz, as we saw, you covered that demonstration today. Tell us more about what unfolded and what you saw. Yeah, Jeff, there were about 100 or 200 or so of these January 6 defendants along with their family members and their supporters who came to Washington today and kind of recreated what had happened on January 6th. They expressed gratitude to President Trump for pardoning them. Of course, that changed many of their lives after some received quite long sentences. Also, both Enrique Tario and Guy Reffitt said to me that they do not regret their actions of that day, of that day, that they would do it all over again. And one theme we heard too over and over again, Jeff, is this frustration from these January Sixers that the Department of Justice and the FBI has not gone after the Biden legal system.
Starting point is 00:37:12 to prosecute those people that had prosecuted them. A lot of talk of retribution. President Trump did not commemorate the day. He mentioned January 6th only briefly in remarks to House Republicans. What did he have to say? Yeah, he mentioned this only in passing today. He did not officially commemorate January 6th. He mentioned this at the Kennedy Center while he was speaking to House Republicans
Starting point is 00:37:37 complaining actually about the media coverage around January 6th. The White House, though, did launch a new part of their official government website today that has a timeline recreation and trying to recreate the narrative around January 6th, talking about things like calling the protest here peaceful, also saying that the participants were patriotic protesters and repeating that false claim that the election was stolen. Lisa, how are Republicans on the Hill reacting to this discipline? information from the White House these lies about what transpired on January 6th. I can tell you what they're doing today, which is trying to ignore it. I spoke with the
Starting point is 00:38:22 majority leader of the Senate, John Thune, as he spoke to reporters today. He was asked twice, once by me, to react to that website. And in particular, on that website, the claim by the Trump White House, that Capitol Police were to blame for January 6, that Capitol Police provoked January 6th. He was asked first about it, and Senator Thune just said, well, we, Capitol Police do a good job on a daily basis. I asked him again, but what do you think about this claim that blames Capitol Police? And he really did not respond to it instead just saying, we support Capitol Police. Capital police officers, I speak to, say that is not support ignoring that kind of accusation against them. Lisa Desjardin, Liz Landers, our thanks to you and the team there outside the U.S. Capitol and inside the U.S.
Starting point is 00:39:10 Capitol. Thanks. Returning now to our top story tonight, the ongoing fallout from President Trump's decision to forcibly remove the president of Venezuela. President Trump and his aides are now speaking of a foreign policy where pressure and the use of military might can be applied both to adversaries and potentially allies. Nick Schifrin is back now with two conversations looking at a pivot in America's place in the world. President Trump has outlined a muscular aggressive doctrine focused on the Western Hemisphere.
Starting point is 00:39:52 It refutes the restrained foreign policy, part of his winning campaign in 2016, and redefines America first in the context of a 19th century foreign policy of regional domination. To discuss that, we get two views on this Trump doctrine. We began with Ambassador Todd Robinson, who served as ambassador in Guatemala and as the top U.S. diplomat in Venezuela before being kicked out of the country and was an Assistant Secretary of State in the State Department. Thank you very much, Ambassador Robinson. Thanks so much for having me. To the news hour. Here's the Trump administration theory in Venezuela today that now President Delci Rodriguez
Starting point is 00:40:26 can deliver an environment in which the U.S. can invest in and benefit from a newly refined oil industry and that the opposition, Maria Corina Machado and Mundo Gonzalez, are not capable of uniting the country. Can that new U.S. policy work? I don't think so. I think, first of all, Maria Corrina Machado and Edmundo Gonzalez, represent the will of the Venezuelan people. People forget that there were elections not too long ago.
Starting point is 00:40:59 Ordinary Venezuelans went out and risked their lives to vote for change in Venezuela. And I think it's incumbent upon this administration and the international community to respect the will of the Venezuelan people. And can Delci Rodriguez deliver the investments that the president is talking about? in terms of U.S. oil companies in Venezuela? I think it's possible, but we seem to forget that it's not just about Delci and her brother, Jorge Rodriguez. Diosdavo Cabello and Padrino Lopez, the defense minister, is also another major figure in the country. So I think it's very, we're rolling the dice.
Starting point is 00:41:43 The administration is rolling the dice. The alternative argument, though, is that wouldn't it be rolling the dice worse if the United States had done some kind of regime change with an occupation force to actually install democracy at the point of the gun. I mean, that seems to me something that very few Americans would have supported. Well, what I would say to that is Venezuela is a large country. It's hard enough to control the whole country just from Caracas. I think it's going to be virtually impossible to do, as the president has stated we're doing run things from either a boat off the coast of Venezuela or from Washington, D.C. Literally gunboat diplomacy, that's what we're talking about. Which broadens us out
Starting point is 00:42:30 to the Don Roe doctrine, as the president has now embraced his new version of the Monroe Doctrine, with direct military threats in the last few days against Mexico, Colombia, and even Greenland, and a more general threat against the Cuban government. The administration says it needs Greenland for national security, and that more locally it needs neighbors who can better tackle drugs and migration. What is the region here when it listens to that language? I think what they're hearing is this is going to be more about what the United States wants than what the region wants. And we seem to forget that we need countries like Mexico and Colombia if we're going to be serious about the fight against narcotics trafficking,
Starting point is 00:43:16 in the region. More broadly, I think our partners in the international community have to be wondering what we're talking about when we're threatening Denmark in Greenland. Denmark is a NATO ally. They fought with us in Afghanistan. I think they must be both confused and a little worried about what they're hearing. And back in Latin America, you know, the administration argues that it does need better partners, it needs these governments to work harder on drugs and work with the United States. Could there be a positive impact to any of this pressure? Well, again, you know, I don't think pressure works. We, during my time in international narcotics and law enforcement, we worked very closely with these countries. Columbia has always been
Starting point is 00:44:08 one of our closest partners. For every dollar we spent on training and equipping the Colombians, the Colombians spent three. They were net security providers in other parts of the world on our behalf. Same with Mexico. Because of the proximity, because of our historic relationship with Mexico, we need them to do more on the fight against narcotics trafficking, but they've done a lot, and I don't think pressuring them is going to make them do more. Ambassador Todd Robinson. Thank you very much. Thank you. Now, for a separate viewpoint, I'm joined by Andres Martinez-Fernandez, a senior policy analyst
Starting point is 00:44:52 for Latin America at the Washington-based Think Tank, the Heritage Foundation. Thanks very much. Welcome to the News Hour. Let me start with you where I started with the ambassador, and let's talk about the Venezuela approach. Do you believe that this approach of relying on Delphi Rodriguez, the now president of Venezuela, to deliver some kind of environment in which the U.S. can go in, revitalize the oil industry, pull out that oil. Do you think that can work and not relying
Starting point is 00:45:20 on Maria Carina Machado and the opposition? What President Trump did by capturing Nicholas Maduro was upsetting a status quo that had existed for years in Venezuela and favored continuity for the regime. And now that he has been removed, this is a deeply weakened regime with which we can confront a series of tools, as we have been using, however, they're going to be much more effective, I think, in the aftermath of this operation. And eventually, I think, I do think that we are going
Starting point is 00:45:56 to be able to press this regime's remnants towards the direction of ending its weaponization of drugs and migration against the United States, and also confronting the fact that it has acted as an operating base for our most dangerous extra-hemispheric enemies, including China, Russia, and Iran. And along that path, I do think that we're going to see the restoration of freedom, stability, and democracy for the Venezuelan people. But how can you get democracy back when the president essentially disparaged Maria Karina Machado the other day, despite the fact that this administration has endorsed the Mundo Gonzalez as the rightful president of Venezuela.
Starting point is 00:46:42 I'm sure that this administration would be happy if Maria Karina could just tomorrow assume power with the wave of a wand in Venezuela, but that's just not possible and would likely require a significant force of U.S. military personnel backing her and occupying Venezuela, which is not on the cards right now. We need to press the remnants of the regime.
Starting point is 00:47:10 regime in that direction to the opening of a path towards democracy and stability. And Maria Karina could very well be a part of that at a certain point when we are able to see that restoration. But the reality is we're not there yet. Let's zoom out and let me ask a question about the region and Ambassador Robinson's last point, which is that pressuring Colombia and Mexico, the two countries that we need cooperation from in order to tackle drugs is counterproductive. What's your response to that? When we contrast and look at the approach by the Biden administration to both of these countries,
Starting point is 00:47:54 which was entirely hands off and to look the other way at the degradation of the security environment and security capacities, pulling back, particularly in the cases of Colombia and Mexico, pulling back operations against the cartels and guerrillas. All of this was done with the United States, not putting any pressure on these governments, these leftist governments, and had destructive consequences for both countries. And we're not going to continue that, clearly.
Starting point is 00:48:28 Doesn't the region hear when it hears the Don Roe doctrine, doesn't the region respond with thinking about the darkest days of U.S. policy toward Latin America in the 19th and 20th century and is therefore less willing to cooperate? No, I don't think so. I think the region, what we're seeing increasingly, particularly with the slate of elections over the past several months, is that voters and this new group of leaders across Argentina, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Honduras, they are calling
Starting point is 00:49:07 for U.S. engagement and cooperation to confront these challenges. Because again, they are the people who have suffered in many ways most directly from that absence of U.S. engagement in confronting these threats, which has allowed them to metastasize to these terrible proportions that we're facing now. And finally, in the time we have left, how does threatening a territory of a NATO ally, perhaps with the U.S. military, serve U.S. national security interests? Yeah, I don't know that this is a military threat. I think what President Trump is expressing is the strategic importance of England for the United States. I think that there's a way to do that amicably.
Starting point is 00:49:50 And if that's pursued, I'm sure it will be done so with that in mind. Andres Martinez-Fernandez. Thank you very much. Thank you. Taylor Irvine is a photojournalist from the Flathead Reservation in Montana, whose work focuses on nuanced portrayals of life in native communities. Her recent project examines the U.S. government-imposed system that defines native identity through fractional measures of ancestry.
Starting point is 00:50:26 Tonight, she shares her brief but spectacular take on questions of belonging. For a long time, I was really hesitant at photographing natives and regalia, seeing those images and seeing all in those images. really appreciate to tell the other side of the story. You know, not the still-work, not disappearing, not sad, not vulnerable, but this powerful communities that are doing great work and have amazing people in them. I grew up on the Flyhead Reservation.
Starting point is 00:50:53 It's in Northwest Montana, is trying to buy big mountains, a lot of forests, a lot of trees. Growing up, I didn't think that you could be a photographer. I think that was, like, a career that you could actually make money living off of. When I left home for college, I was in a class that was a prerequisite. It was called Media History and Literacy, and there was a chapter on photography. When I'd seen those photos from 9-11, the impact those photos had on me decades later
Starting point is 00:51:17 and how I felt when I seen them really inspired me and when you want to do that too and tell stories from my home that reached people in the same way. The power of photography, to connect people, and to make us realize, like, we're more, like, and different. One of my goals is just to photograph native as being people. Grab a community, part of a larger world, and so show me. The other side of what Native America looks like from somebody who's from Native America was really important to me. My project reservation mathematics, navigating love in Native America, focuses on how the government ecosystem of blood quantum affects who natives marry, who they have kids with, who they choose to fall in love with, who they choose to spend their life with, and how this number dictates one of the most intimate choices that we have.
Starting point is 00:52:01 Every native when they're born, they're assigned a fraction at birth. And that fraction is called blood quantum. It's how much native they are. Each tribe has an amount that you have to be to be involved in that tribes. So my tribe, it's a quarter. But it's tricky because my parents are two tribes. I'm on this crow. My dad has said, let you food me. And so when I was born, they had to pick which tribe to put me in.
Starting point is 00:52:19 They chose my father's tribe. And that immediately cut my quantum and half. And so I'm 7.16s, which means if I want my kid to be enrolled, they have to be a quarter. So I need to find someone from my tribe to date. Otherwise, my kid won't be rolled. And so it's this kind of unique pressure where if I don't find someone to date within my tribe, than my tribe will, then I'll probably be partly responsive to my child and extinct.
Starting point is 00:52:39 When I started this project, it was really hard because blood quantum is not a real number. It's not a real thing that exists. And so how do I photograph something imaginary with something that was really challenging for me? I got really lucky because my siblings were all expecting at the same time. My brother with a partner who's not from our tribe, my sister with a partner who is from our tribe, and my other sister with a partner who's from our tribe. When people look at the photos, I want them to feel connected to the person. I want them to think, like, oh, that could be me,
Starting point is 00:53:06 that could be my sister, my brother. Putting people in other people's shoes is kind of why I got into this and why I love photography. I think you don't have to even speak the same language to understand what's going on in a photo. And so I hope people are able to kind of put themselves in different culture for a second or two. My name is Taylor Irvine, and this is my brief
Starting point is 00:53:23 but spectacular take on photographing Bluff One. You can watch more brief but spectacular videos online at pbs.bts.org slash news hour slash brief. And that is the News Hour for tonight. I'm Jeff Bennett for all of us here at the PBS NewsHour. Thanks for spending part of your evening with us.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.