Pivot - Kirk Suspect Motives, TikTok "Framework" Deal, and Tucker Carlson Plays Detective
Episode Date: September 16, 2025Kara and Scott unpack the rage and division following Charlie Kirk’s assassination — and who’s fueling it. Then, the Trump administration touts a “framework” for a TikTok deal. Plus, Paramou...nt makes a play for Warner Bros., OpenAI reshapes its partnership with Microsoft, and Tucker Carlson pushes conspiracy theories. Watch this episode on the Pivot YouTube channel.Follow us on Instagram and Threads at @pivotpodcastofficial.Follow us on Bluesky at @pivotpod.bsky.socialFollow us on TikTok at @pivotpodcast.Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or email pivot@voxmedia.com Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
During the Volvo Fall Experience event,
discover exceptional offers and thoughtful design
that leaves plenty of room for autumn adventures.
And see for yourself how Volvo's legendary safety
brings peace of mind to every crisp morning commute.
This September,
Lisa 2026 XE90 plug-in hybrid from $599 bi-weekly at 3.99%
during the Volvo Fall Experience event.
Conditions apply, visit your local Volvo retailer
or go to explorevolvo.com.
Did you lock the front door?
Check.
Close the garage door?
Yep.
Installed window sensors, smoke sensors, and HD cameras with night vision?
No.
And you set up credit card transaction alerts,
a secure VPN for a private connection,
and continuous monitoring for our personal info on the dark web?
Uh, I'm looking into it.
Stress less about security.
Choose security solutions from TELUS for peace of mind at home and online.
Visit tellus.com slash total security to learn more.
Conditions apply.
one and sip and two and sip and three and sip oh hey i'm just sipping tim's all new protein ice latte
starting at 17 grams per medium latte tim's new protein lattes protein without all the work at
participating restaurants in canada it's exactly what we need at this moment i have to tell you it brings
together maga and lesbians in a way that's really satisfying i don't know how they did it
From New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network, I'm Kara Swisher.
And I'm Scott.
How's it going?
What a week, huh?
Yeah.
How was your weekend?
It was good.
A lot of really interesting stuff.
And then took my mom out to lunch yesterday with my ex-wife.
That was nice.
That's nice.
How is Megan?
She's good.
She's really been lovely to my mother, I have to say.
That's nice.
Yeah.
And then just getting ready today for all the week because there's a big week ahead.
And a lot of news and a lot of news.
and a lot of news. What did you do?
You know, I had one of those really lovely, but somewhat bittersweet weekends.
It was my son's 18th, and he had some friends over, and, you know, it's just, so I spent
most of the weekend, like, looking through old photos of him and, like, trying to hold back the tears.
It's just wild, how fast it goes.
18. That's a big birthday.
It is a big birthday.
He doesn't have to listen to you anymore.
Well, that happened on his third birthday, but, yeah, but in England, they can drink, and he invited
over a bunch of his friends.
He goes to this great school, and he has great friends in his house, and they just came over, and, you know, they had two beers and acted like they'd had 12 beers.
I think it's more the Pavlovian effect than anything, and they're just such smart, good kids.
A couple of them are trying to get into Cambridge and Oxford, you know, they're at that age.
And another one is interesting.
One of them has decided he's going to go to the Gulf.
He's this kid who just sees all this opportunity in the Gulf, and he wants to move to either Riyadh or Dubai.
And, you know, they're just such lovely young men.
And my son seemed really happy.
So, I don't know, it's just very nice, very rewarding.
What was your word of advice, your 18th?
I remember, I mean, it's probably a little different with a dad and a son, I have to say.
But I remember when they both turned 18, it was a big deal.
21 is also a big deal.
Yeah.
My advice has been to my oldest and also a little bit to my youngest is that, you know,
I talk a lot about what makes a man.
And I said, manhood, there's a lot of males who get older and never become men.
Most of them.
Sorry.
Yeah.
Okay, fair enough.
But in the delineation, when you become a man, is this idea of surplus value.
And that is, you take a lot of love from your family as a kid.
At some point, you do what you're doing.
You're taking lucky out.
You're adding surplus value.
You're adding much more value to Lucky than she is to your life, quite frankly.
That's pretty much.
But also, Kara, you're...
That's a deficit.
You're making a lot of money and paying a lot of taxes.
You're creating more tax revenue than government services you've absorbed.
That's surplus value.
Yeah, I'm a man.
I am a man.
But that's my point.
My point is at some point, you notice people's lives.
You absorb more complaints than you complain.
You, you know, you do more cleaning around the house than people cleaning up after you.
You provide more emotional support at some point.
Then you're a better father to your kids than your dad was to you.
So I'm really into this idea of surplus value, and, you know, at what point do you get there?
At what point do people, he lives in a little house at his boarding school with 40 other young men,
at what point are you seen as somebody that is, you know, adding more to the house than you're taking?
Right.
And it's okay to occasionally lean on people, and that doesn't mean don't be vulnerable.
It doesn't mean don't be a stoic because I think being a good friend means occasionally opening up to people because that's what friends wrong.
Friends want people that occasionally need them, right?
Right? A hundred percent. Both ways.
100 percent, yeah.
One thing I noticed with Louis, he was always giving a little more to his friends than they were to him, and we had a long talk about it.
I was like, you need to ask for things because he's one of those guys, right?
Let me fix it for you kind of thing, which is good, but it's also important to take at various points in your life.
I find there's hacks around.
I mean, first off, I've met people who say I pride myself on never asking anyone for anything.
And I'm like, well, then you're never going to be that close to anybody because
people don't want to be charities. People don't want to be your patient. People want to
occasionally have the opportunity to help you. And I like the idea, and one of my hacks is,
when you ask someone how they're doing, let them respond and then stop and say, no, really,
how are you doing? And then another hack is to say, I'll go first, I'm struggling at work.
Oh. Or I'm in a bad place with my wife right now. Or I've got this thing.
acting up, I was just diagnosed with, you know, high blood pressure, it's got me totally fucking
freaked out. When you pause and say to someone, no, really, how are you doing? And then say,
this is what's going on with me, you literally, it's like pulling, it's like opening the doors to
a lock of a million gallons of water. The moment you're willing to kind of sort of open up,
especially as men, and say, you know, fuck, I'm worried about money. Is my, Scott, Scott.
How are you doing?
I'm actually, okay, so the honest answer is...
No, we have to ask the second part.
You have to say fine, and then I...
Okay.
Oh, I'm fine, Kara.
How are you?
How are you really doing?
Ever since this Kirk thing, I have been extremely online, and I think it is taking a toll on me.
I think I am disassociating from reality and relationships.
I have been so going down rabbit holes around this shit, and it is taking a toll on me mentally.
Oh, wow.
And that's fine.
That's probably a natural part of the cycle.
But the last five days, quite frankly, have been awful.
I have this.
You had.
We talked yesterday.
I have this eerie feeling that this is very ominous, that this is different.
When January 6th happened, I was angry.
I was embarrassed.
But this feels different.
This feels as if it's sort of a cauldron or a crow showing up or a black cat.
Oh, wow.
Black swan.
And the black swan, something black.
And I don't know.
I have trouble dissecting my own anger and depression.
as I get older or what is probably better than most people's spidey sense about cultural and
societal norms, but as it probably should have been in the last four or five days have just not
been great. How are you? I have hemorrhoids. I asked for something from you yesterday. I said,
I want to be on your planes, guys. That's what you're focused on. I like that. Which part of the trip
should I join you for? And I'm like, oh, okay, no problem. I'm here for all of it. I asked. He's told
to ask. You're not a charity. I am good. I'm actually, I feel less, look. You're able to
disassociate pretty well. Here's what I didn't disassociate. I look at history. That's what I do.
And we're going to talk about this more and the thing is I put on from Hairspray, you can't stop,
you know, can't stop the beat, that song. And I've played it. Like it's, you know,
the Hairspray is about an integration of a TV show in Baltimore. It's by John Waters, obviously,
hairspray. And I put it on and I listened to it three times. I was like, you know, it's a really
good song. And that's what I do. I was like. Hairspray? That's your answer? Hairspray?
I feel like the forces of retrograde, which are always there, are particularly desperate and
strong today. Right? Like, it's like Mercury in retrograde or whatever you call it. It's like
right wingers in retrograde. And I think that they are desperate to turn back the clock on every
single thing. And as they become more desperate, they get more vicious and violent. And that's a worry.
At the same time, you can't stop the beat. I just don't want to say you can't. You can't. You can't.
History has shown again and again. They try it and they never win. And so we'll talk about this
a little bit more. This is getting very intense. But just to press pause on that, you said something
really powerful, and that is something that does give me comfort is I do start reading a lot about history.
And for all the people saying, this feels like it's going to be a civil war, we have been much closer.
I mean, there was the actual civil war, but since then, we have been much closer to civil war than we are now.
Yeah.
People forget 20,000 former World War I veterans marched on Washington to protest the economic conditions of the Great Depression.
And a young general gave the order to fire on those veterans.
That young general, by the way, was Douglas MacArthur, who would go on to be a World War II hero.
hero, the civil rights movement, there was much more anger on both sides. So the notion that I think
people who don't have a sense for history who believe that, or even just logistically, how would
civil war happen here? Because you think, oh, it would be the red states declaring war on the blue states.
The red states can't afford to declare war on the blue states. They're takers. They get so much
fucking money from the federal government as a means of channeling additional surplus revenue from
blue states. It's like there might be an increase in political violence, and we'll talk more
about this, but the Civil War, one, historically, we're nowhere near the same temperatures
we've been several times before, as bad as it might seem, and two, logistically, it just
doesn't make sense how it would unfold. Yeah, they still are so enthusiastic about their
retrograde behaviors. But anyway, we got a lot to get to today, by the way, and this is, why don't
we just get started on this? First, we have some competition as we tape. J.D. Vance is hosting the
Charlie Kirk show over on Rumble. He announced on X, it would be an honor to quote,
paid tribute to my friend. Charlie Kirk's a suspected killer, 22-year-old Tyler Robinson,
is expected to be formally charged this week. He's currently not cooperating with authorities. I think
he's in that, fuck that mode, since he did what he did, that seems, as we Scott and I have talked
about, to be terminally online. Robinson's motive is still unknown. There's a lot of speculation
and misinformation floating around. Utah Governor Spencer Cox shared some details over him
saying Robin was indoctrinated with leftist ideology
and spent much of his time on the deep, dark internet.
I don't know.
Cox is saying that Robinson had a roommate and romantic partner
who was transitioning.
Again, they're not providing any details.
So I'm not going to believe anything,
including what Cox said.
I think he is trying his best
and he's getting enormous pressure from Trump.
But when asked it was irrelevant to motive,
Cox said that's what we're trying to figure out,
though FBI director Keffield shared a link
to a Fox News story about it on X.
I mean, literally, make your own announcement.
Cash Patel, if you don't mind, rather than doing stuff like that. What an idiot he is. So we don't know
his motives at all. Again, as Scott and I've been saying, let's find out. Obviously, when you move to murder,
there's something very deep and tragic going on and also possibly mental illness too. Talk about,
you just talked a little bit about your overall thoughts in terms of what we know and don't know. And since you've
been down a rabbit hole, I just don't, I'm not going to believe anything until a trial. That's my feeling. I just don't. I don't trust
Cash Patel in any way. I think people are grabbing bits and pieces for their own. You know,
the bullet was trans. No, it wasn't. The shooter was trans. No, he wasn't. Oh, his roommate is trans.
Well, I don't know. And so I'm going to go with the, and I don't even know what has anything to do with it.
Like, that's the other thing is, that's the really key part. So your thoughts?
It's clear what's happened here. Governor Cox made the mistake of acting like a leader.
Agreed.
And trying to take down the volume and not engage in the violence.
entrepreneurship, that the president and some people on the left, but mostly people on the right,
have engaged in to find an opportunity around violence to create advantage at the expense
of potentially fomenting more violence. So let me go to the notion. Let's assume his roommate
was transitioning. Okay. So the fuck what. If he had been in a relationship with a white girl
in a sorority at ASU,
does that mean this is the Republicans' fault?
I mean, who the fuck cares?
What does that have to do with anything?
With anything?
I agree.
His grandmother was like, we're Maga.
I'm like, I don't care.
That has nothing to do with it.
Thank you, Grandma.
And this all goes,
what's so frustrating for me about this is look at the data
and to try and figure out who the real culprit is,
such that we can stop this or reduce it the likelihood of it happening again.
98% of mass shooters are men, mostly young men.
Almost every act of political violence, of course, here's my rabbit hole.
Let's just talk about the right, mostly the right, but also the left,
is doing everything they can from interpreting the font on these bullets to who their roommates are,
to find evidence, to cherry-pick evidence, to try and show that it's the,
other side of the political spectrum's fault. And this is the bottom line. This kid, he was
22, was raised in a Republican household, registered, unaffiliated. And I'm not sure, but I don't think
he's voted yet. No, he didn't vote. Okay. Thomas Matthew Crooks, the person who shot Trump and
Butler, registered Republican. And when he was 17, he gave 15 bucks to a voter registration tribe
that used Act Blue.
Luigi Mangione, he was more mission and policy-oriented,
and so much as he'd taken on corporate greed and health care as his cause,
but he didn't come across as partisan or of any left or right-aligned political movement.
Vance Luther Bolter, age 57, the alleged killer of the Minnesota political figures,
he was more politically oriented, but ultimately no more politically engaged
than the stereotypical angry uncle at a thanksgiving who rants.
Cody Allen Balmer, age 38, arrested after the attempted arson and to kill attempted murder of Governor Josh Shapiro.
No political associations beyond some angry social media posts.
David DuPage, age 42, attacked Pelosi's husband with a hammer, broke into Pelosi's house, very online and immersed in conspiracy content, but again, not a member of any group.
And so each side is trying to blame the other, and then media tries to play referee to get their ratings.
But this is the bottom line.
What do we have in common across all these acts of violence?
They are almost always young men,
and they are almost always not political extremists,
but extremely online.
So if you just want to reduce, how about we just reduce violence,
including political violence, including mass shootings,
let's figure out how we get more young men
to engage with guardrails in the form of relationships,
more male mentorship, more males in high school,
in high school, more economic opportunity, more safeguards, and how about we hold the rage
machine that is driving 40% of the S&P's value, how about if we hold them to the same standards
we hold every other media and say, if you elevate content that has been directly correlated
to rage, which results in violence, mostly violence against themselves, social media creates
a lot of violence against themselves among young girls, a lot of violence of young men against themselves, but also with young men, sometimes, and I don't mean to pathologize young men who are extremely online. Most of them will not pick up a gun, but some of them do.
That's right.
So if anyone is interested in actually reducing the violence, they're going to talk about removing Section 230 protection for algorithmically elevated content and providing more opportunity and more empathy and, quite frankly, more love and relationships for young men.
Yeah, I'm going to interject.
I would say they don't want to do that.
Groups do not want to engage in this sort of sharks versus jets kind of situation that's going on.
And it's like, I have to say one thing I picked up my mother's phone, she had, she's somehow gotten on some Trump group things. Her texts were full of the most heinous efforts to get money. Charlie's a martyr, Charlie's this, you must fight the left who's trying to kill us. It was so upsetting to read her text. I deleted every single one of them. I tried to block them all. It was such, and her email was worse. It was all these like efforts. And, you know, it's fine.
J.D. Vance can go on his show, but they're all doing it in order to raise money for themselves
and to push their cause. This is just grotesque what they're, like, same thing with Donald
Trump Jr. Like, they're all trying to push. They literally are walking over this guy and using
him as like a way to raise money, a way to get people mad, a way to get political advantage.
I mean, it's grotesque at this point. Like, have they forgotten their friend died or something
like that. I just find it really strange. Like the stuff on my mom's phone was so disturbing, Scott.
I couldn't, I was sort of like, and then you have someone like Elon Musk who is making it worse.
Democrats are the party of murder?
Party murder. He just was like, he's putting out lists of people who said, who said negative
things about Kirk. He's done like a number of things. We have to stop these people. We have to,
and now the words are de-indocrinate. We have to, it sounds like fucking Russia. Like, it's really
disturbing. Let's move to that because people across the country are getting fired, suspended,
or investigated over a post criticizing Charlie Kirk after his assassination. Washington Post columnist
Karen Attia just shared a little while ago that she's been fired over her blue sky posts,
which are at best, nothing, like seriously, nothing that she's done here has in Jeddah. They're waiting
to fire her. That's another story. But far-right activists have been doxing people, they say,
are celebrating Kirk's death. Then they're just decided.
deciding what a celebration is and what's not just regular criticism.
Defense Secretary Pete Hags has ordered his staff to identify military personnel who mocked Kirk's killing so they can be punished.
These are the free speech warriors.
These are the people that went on and on about.
So cancel culture they use to their advantage.
And now they are doing cancel culture in full.
They are the most cynical non-free speech people I have ever encountered.
And it's really astonishing how quickly.
they move to this. Thoughts?
Well, again, it's term I like,
it's violence entrepreneurship,
trying to reap capital and advantage
from an opportunity where you see violence.
And another thing we're just not talking about
is the CCP and the GRU are having a field day.
And do your own research here.
Go on TikTok or go on threads or Instagram
or on Facebook or on Twitter.
And when you see something really inflammatory,
from either side, look at the
the comments. The algorithms elevate content that gets a lot of comments because every comment
results in the person, the people who respond to the comment coming back, and that's another
impression, another ad, more shareholder value. Look at the really heinous comments that would
likely incent and do motivate more comments, more Nissan ads, more shareholder volume. Click on the
profile. It's someone with 38 followers. Yes, exactly. Guess what? If I were in the GRU,
in the CCP, and I couldn't beat us economically or kinetically,
might I decide to do what is happening now and divide us internally,
make that call come from inside of the house?
Putin has talked about this very specifically.
And by the way, the Nazis talked about it.
I mean, they have done a great job of convincing us.
No, the threat isn't massive energy,
a willingness to kill millions of their own people,
technology, the largest consumer economy in the world,
India, China, and Russia binding together to push back on our interests, we've decided no,
it's some young white liberals saying really heinous things and they are heinous things.
So let's elevate that content or let's listen to senior advisor Stephen Miller claiming that it's
civil war against the Democrats.
Let's elevate that content by filling up anything with those feeds with bots with comments
that take that content beyond its organic reach on its own.
And what Governor Cox initially said, go out and touch grass, go out and touch people, because generally what you find is...
Well, with their consent, but go ahead.
Just go touch people.
Go out. Go out. I don't think that's right. I think we need to be more affectionate.
But anyways...
I understand, but you should really ask.
And I also think we need a lot more sex and a lot more alcohol.
Trust me, kids, the risk to your 25-year-old liver of alcohol is dwarfed by the risk of social isolation.
I go to conservative places. I meet a lot of people.
In person, it is shocking how lovely people are.
I get it.
I agree with you.
But I'm just saying it's being for, you've got, speaking of you going down a rabbit, you
have to get offline.
Like, Elon Musk literally just tweeted.
Someone said, I am now 100% confident that some guy I'm named Aestetica, that Charlie's
assassinations was carried out by Charlie's, because he's a friend of his, right?
It was carried out by radical left wing transgender terror cell.
Let's get into the evidence.
And then Elon Musk tweeted seems likely.
Now, Elon, I'm sorry your kid's trans.
and you have this reaction.
I'm not sorry your kid's trans.
I'm sorry that you're such a jackass about it
and such a strange, twisted person.
But to do things like this,
just to create this,
I think they believe there's a transgender terror cell,
which there isn't, but fine.
There's no evidence.
The only evidence we have on mass shooters
is the following, the overwhelming evidence,
is that there are young men who are disenfranchised.
This isn't about division.
It's about the disenfranchised.
This isn't even about,
I would argue it's not even about political extremism.
It's about being extremely online.
Yep.
And you and I agree on this.
You could get around the most hostile table of political,
you know, you could take Rachel Maddow and Tucker Carlson,
these shooters, these folks committing this political violence,
they are less politically affiliated than those two.
These are people who have not connected to others
and have easy access to weapons, to guns,
And have no judgment.
And go extremely online and don't have a good friend.
Don't have a romantic partner.
Don't have in-person work.
Don't have a male role model to say, something's going on with you.
What's going on?
What are you thinking?
Where are you spending your time?
No, that's not right.
Come to my church group.
You're going to see how good people are from both political spectrums.
Hey, have we been thinking about getting in better shape?
I noticed you're acting strange lately.
What's going on?
You know how much we care about you, right?
Are you all right?
It's a case of lack of mammalia.
If you put an orca in a tank alone, it goes fucking crazy.
Most animals.
The worst thing you can do to a dog is leave it alone.
And then when you put it in a tank where they start pumping in sound waves to make the orca go crazy
because whoever pumps in the sound waves can make billions or trillions of dollars in shareholder value,
which is effectively what's going on.
40% of the S&P right now is represented by companies that have an extra.
economic incentive to divide us. And instead, we want to find, dissect the font on a fucking
bullet so we can blame the other side. It works so well. Let me go back to Spencer Cox because
people are like, you shouldn't like him. I'm like, I'm going to a little bit, okay? He has kept up
his criticism of social media, since you're doing it right now, calling it a cancer. In an appearance
on Meet the Press, he appeared to be taking notes from you, Scott Gallo. Let's listen.
I think anyone can change the trajectory of this.
It truly is about every single one of us.
And I can't emphasize enough the damage that social media and the internet is doing to all of us, those dopamine hits.
These companies, trillion dollar market caps, the most powerful companies in the history of the world, have figured out how to hack our brains, get us addicted to outrage, which is the same type of dopamine, the same chemical that you get from.
taking fentanyl, get us addicted to outrage,
and get us to hate each other.
I'm seeing it in real time since the tragic death
of Charlie Kirk.
I'm seeing it in every corner of our society.
The conflict entrepreneurs are taking advantage of us,
and we are losing our agency,
and we have to take that back.
We have to turn it off.
We have to get back to community,
caring about our neighbors,
the things that make American great,
serving each other, bettering ourselves,
exercising, sleeping,
all of those things that this takes away from us.
Conflict entrepreneurs.
I love that.
You should steal it.
Conflict.
That's exactly what they are.
100.
And the same conflict entrepreneurs, may I point out, people like Elon and Jeff Bezos, who owns
the Washington Post, are shutting down actual free speech, which people should be able to do.
Thoughts?
At what point do we get serious about this problem?
It's, the media has a vested interest in pretending the referee and getting, and, and,
getting more clicks and more views.
And notice how quiet big tech has been on this.
They know what's going on.
They know, I mean, it's really.
They'll try to shut down Cox, you know that.
Anytime you arbitrage one substance into another,
you have externalities.
The greatest arbitrage in history has been fossil fuels to energy.
You can't build a hospital without massive fossil fuels.
The externalities there, carbon, are obvious.
The externalities of turning attention into shareholder value,
the externality there is rage. These guys know it. They know what's going on. They know that they
profit off of this divisiveness and this rage. They're not bad people by commission. They didn't
set out to do this. They are bad irresponsible Americans by efforts of omission. They are
ignoring and obfuscating what is going on here. They know what's going on. And also the illusion
of complexity has been weaponized here. There are common sense.
People are bereft and throw up their arms and say,
it's only going to get worse.
Bullshit, there are absolutely common sense solutions here.
No social media, under the age of 16, no smartphones in schools.
They have banned phones in I think about 19 states.
And that's what a lot of teachers telling me
that kids can't wait to get to their phones
even when they ban them, right?
That's even a problem.
That's okay, but at least they're not.
Yeah, agree.
I don't think my kids are capable of any longer sitting through a two-hour movement.
sitting through a two-hour movie because of the way their brains have been rewired.
And again, it's political.
I don't care.
In the next six hours, there's going to be more gun dust in America than there will be in the UK over the next 12 months.
This is, if we want to get serious, there are a variety of programs, more after-school programs, national service, more men in primary education, more money for young people, such that they're more economically secure and they start mating.
8 million houses in 10 years, such that people have something to look forward to in a way to save money and don't feel is hopeless.
Also, let me just take a page out of the right.
We have orientation at universities for a week.
We have increasingly spent more time at orientation talking about mental health and saying, look, if you're feeling bad because you get your first D,
if you're feeling bad because you haven't had a lot of experience with relationships and someone breaks up with you, that is a normal part of life.
And what has happened over the last 20 or 30 years is because kids are so sheltered with concierge parenting and with social media, you might feel hopeless.
It's not hopeless.
Trust me, we've all been there.
You need to reach out to someone.
There is something to the notion that these kids have turned to this oppressed or oppressor ideology and are going on the hunt for people that say certain things.
I do think that's changing stuff.
Well, I hope so.
And now it's the right that's doing it.
Just let's be clear.
I actually don't agree, Carol.
One out of three people on campus now believe that political speech and certain words are violence and can warrant actual violence.
And it is mostly from kids who are strongly on the left.
I think that's changing.
Hold on.
Let me finish.
College should be a safe place physically.
It should be a dangerous place intellectually.
Yes, agree.
And we have to tell these kids, and I've seen this firsthand, I've seen them turn on each other.
There's like two or three kids who are brave enough to support Trump in my class.
and everyone turns on them.
We are supposed to say provocative, offensive things.
Okay, can I make a point there?
Yes.
If they want to do that, then they should be strong enough to defend it.
Like, that's actually a good thing to be turned on.
Agreed.
Right.
Critical thinking.
Let's debate it.
Let's debate it.
Let them have it.
Like, but I have to say, one of the things you accused the left of, not you, one
accused it, is like, oh, they're shutting things down.
The people that are actually banning, getting people fired.
Agreed.
And the free speech warriors.
And it wouldn't be so irritating that they were such,
free speech warriors lecturing us, you know, someone like Chris Rufo, the rest of them are now
using cancel culture oppositely. And it's just, it's typical. We have to move on, but conflict
entrepreneurs, Governor Cox has that right. That's what they're trying to do. And unfortunately,
because this is a dopamine hit, we're drug addicts, we are addicts. But you've already seen his
narrative change. And quite frankly, Governor Cox stick to being a leader. You can see, you know what
happened. Over the weekend. He tried to go back again. Over the weekend, Trump called him and said,
sign up, motherfucker, and all of a sudden he's saying that there was certain leftist ideology.
No, there isn't.
Certain leftist tendencies.
He may have had a roommate that was going through transition.
Who cares?
Why would you even bring that up?
Doesn't matter.
Doesn't matter unless there's, no, it doesn't matter.
It doesn't matter at all.
This is a young man.
He was dating someone that went to a gun range.
As clearly is the rights fault said no Democratic governor ever in the midst of this type of violence.
Ever, ever.
Nothing about his grandmother.
Great.
His grandmother is MAGA.
We're not blaming her.
I don't care.
Right?
Exactly.
He likes Sidney and her family is MAGA.
It must be a conspiracy from the right.
Yes, exactly.
It's exhausting people.
Just pull yourselves out of it.
Okay, let's go on a quick break when we come back.
Fromp teases a TikTok deal.
We'll see.
As a founder, you're moving fast towards product market fit,
your next round, or your first big enterprise deal.
But with AI accelerating,
how quickly startups build and ship.
Security expectations are also coming in faster,
and those expectations are higher than ever.
Getting security and compliance right can unlock growth,
or stall it if you wait too long.
Vanta is a trust management platform
that helps businesses automate security and compliance
across more than 35 frameworks like SOC2, ISO-27-001,
HIPAA, and more.
With deep integrations and automated workforce
built for fast-moving teams, VANSA gets
you audit-ready fast and keeps you secure with continuous monitoring as your models,
infrastructure, and customers evolve. That's why fast-growing startups like Langchane,
writer, and cursor have all trusted Vanta to build a scalable compliance foundation from the start.
Go to vanta.com slash Vox to save $1,000 today through the Vanta for Startups program
and join over 10,000 ambitious companies already scaling with Vanta.
That's V-A-N-T-A-com slash Vox.
to save $1,000 for a limited time.
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn ads.
Sometimes the best B2B marketing doesn't fail
because of your message, it fails because it never reaches the right people.
You can have the sharpest creative, the most persuasive offer,
and a campaign you're proud of.
But if it lands in the wrong inbox or shows up in the wrong feed, it's wasted.
So if you want to reach the right professionals,
you should check out LinkedIn ads.
LinkedIn has grown into a network of over one.
billion professionals and 130 million decision makers worldwide. And that's exactly what sets
it apart from other ad buys. It's not just about reach. It's about reaching the right people
in the right context and LinkedIn is where business actually gets done. You can target your buyers
by job title, industry, company, rural seniority skills, and company revenues you can stop
wasting budget on the wrong audience. It's why LinkedIn ads generates the highest B2B
ROAs of all online ad networks. Seriously, all of them. You can spend $250, $250,000.
on your first campaign on LinkedIn ads
and get a free $250 credit
for the next one.
No strings attached.
Just go to linkton.com slash scott.
That's LinkedIn.com slash scopped.
Terms and conditions apply.
Support for this show comes from Vanta.
Here are a few things that are probably essential
to your company's survival
in the modern world.
Internet access.
A tax ID, a great snack pantry.
Well, here's something else that's essential.
Trust.
In today's fast-changing digital world,
proving your company is trustworthy isn't just important for growth it's essential that's
why vanta is here vanta helps companies of all sizes get compliant fast and stay that way with industry
leading AI automation and continuous monitoring so whether you're a startup tackling your first sock
two or iso 2701 or you're an enterprise managing vendor risk vanta's trust management platform makes it
quicker easier and more scalable vanta also helps you complete security questionnaires up to five times
faster so you can win bigger deals sooner.
The results, according to a recent IDC study, Vanta customers slash over $500,000 a year
in costs and are three times more productive.
Establishing trust isn't optional.
Vanta makes it automatic.
Visit vanta.com slash pivot to sign up for a free demo today.
That's V-A-N-T-A.com slash pivot.
Scott, we're back.
President Trump says the big U.S.
China trade deal in Europe is going, quote, quite very well. Who knows? He posted on
true social that the two countries have reached a deal on TikTok that will make the young people
very happy. I don't think he named TikTok, but whatever. That's what he was talking about.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, meanwhile, is calling the, quote, framework of a deal,
which always makes me, like, wonder what the hell's going on. Parent company Bite Dance is
supposed to sell U.S. assets or face a nationwide ban by Wednesday the 17th, which is just a few days.
Trump is saying he'll talk to Xi Jinping on Friday.
All of this comes as trying to accuse
invidia violating antitrust law.
I don't know.
Everyone who's near this deal tells me it's such a fake deal.
It's such a like they're really not separating them.
It's really not going to be anything but a lot of fakery on top of what it is.
And then they'll give some pretty stuff to Larry Allison,
who seems to be winning all day long.
Your thoughts?
I just think it's bullshit.
I think this is a fake story.
Let me use the Trump.
Fake news.
I just don't.
You don't do it with conviction.
I don't buy it.
I don't know.
It's fake news.
It's from, yeah, sure.
Okay.
Sure.
Until.
They're just trying to stave off that deadline.
Yeah.
It's an excuse to not ban TikTok because Trump has decided that TikTok, the CCP, when they're about to be banned, said,
I left the algorithm to be positive Trump,
and then somebody on his team came back and said,
oh, no, TikTok's good for us.
And all of a sudden, he now likes it.
And one of his biggest donors who gave him nine figures
is one of the biggest shareholders in TikTok.
This is pay for play, and he thinks it's good for him.
So he didn't like it until he liked it.
And also, this represents a breakdown in government
because this was a law passed by both houses,
signed into law, and we've decided just not to do it.
Yeah. It's ridiculous. By the way, Scott Dessent is starting to really irritate me on so many levels. He's like such a suck-up and such a like he's punching people. I don't like that much either. I don't care if it's Elon he's punching. I don't like him punching anybody. Well, I thought violence was never the answer, Kara. That's correct. I know. I just find it so like, ugh. Anyway, yes, Scott and I will believe it when we see it and we think it's probably a lot of nonsense and that you aren't going to be protected from the CCP with this gang. That's for sure. Open A is also making.
is a big moves on the way to becoming a for-profit company. This is something I've been trying
to do. Musk has been trying to stop, that they're finalizing terms for a new agreement with
Microsoft. Microsoft is expected to take roughly a 30% take in the reorganized company. OpenA.'s
nonprofit parent will also hold an equity stake valued over $100 billion. But attorneys general in
California and Delaware say they still have serious concerns about user safety, good for them,
and want to see improvements before signing off on restructuring. What do you think about this?
I assume there'll be an IPO, correct? That's the way it looks like it's.
Once they get this through, this idea of essentially a for-profit company with a vague nonprofit hanging over it.
And again, Musk still has legal challenges to a lot of this, and he has a lot of allies still.
I think it would be so interesting to see what Open AI's legal bills are and what's happened to the cadence of those legal bills.
Because there are so much money on the line, and this thing is so, just as there's technical debt, you know, you come into an organization and they've invested so much in old mainframe technology that,
I was on the board of Yellow Pages Company, and they said when we've actually fired the CIO was when he came in and basically said, you know, it's going to take us 18 months to reconfigure the technology.
It's like, it's a fucking Yellow Pages company. This isn't a cloud company. And he kept going on about technical debt.
So the term technical debt means preexisting investments make it just really difficult to sort of untangle everything and expensive.
I would love to know what the legal debt is at OpenAI, and that is this company has such an unused.
corporate structure that they are trying to unwind and how much they've invested in legal
work. I would love to know how much they're using AI. They must be spending $10 or $20 million a
month on lawyers right now. I would love to know, as a case study, if and how they're deploying
their own AI to reduce their own legal costs. That's a funny. But what about an IPO? I assume if this
gets through in the restructuring gets through, which probably will, given the money at stake here,
Because they're spending money all over the damn place.
They got to get cooking on the making of the money.
It's a really interesting question because there are 3,700 publicly traded companies right now.
That is down by 50% since 1997.
It's down 17% just since COVID.
Because every time there's an acquisition or a bankruptcy or a take private, it's like in China now,
there are more people dying than there are being people born.
So the same thing.
There are more companies coming off in the next.
NASDAQ and the SMP then are going on. And we'll talk more about this. Some of it say it's
regulation, but more than anything, a company like Open AI, I think Open AI just did a secondary
where they gave every employee like a $1.6 million bonus. They can raise capital. They can acquire
companies and they don't have the regulatory burden of being public. So unfortunately, unlike in 2003,
when Google goes public, it effectively was $2 a share and gives retail investors the chance to 100x their
money. There's so much money in the private markets that effectively, as long as the company
is still jamming, its current investors and private market investors and institutions, which
tend to be wealthier Americans, say, no, no, no, no, we want to hold on to all that juice
ourselves. So increasingly, you would have never had a company like Open AI worth a half a trillion
dollars having not gone public. So what does that mean? It means the retail investor no longer
has access to these great growth companies. And these guys have less incentive to go public. And
typically when they do go public, it's the following. All right, the smart guys who really know
our company have decided there's not much upside left here. We got to find a group of people
who will turn this into a meme stock. Oh, I know, public market investors. Right. Just like
what's happening with Tesla. So all of the juice, you know, the juice has been squeezed by the time these
guys go public. Now, does that mean there's still not opportunity in the public markets? No,
there probably still is. But you would have never, it used to be it took a company seven years to go
public. Now it's 14. The really good companies are staying private because they can get everything
they need in the private markets now. So we'll see. This is the seventh most valuable company in the
world, I think, right now. I know. It's not public. It's crazy. The only one that I was thinking that
was really valid, but never went public. It was Mars. Remember, the Mars people never. The Mars family,
Also, it used to be a company called Bechtel, and then before that, my biggest client in the 90s was Levi-Strausson Company.
Yeah.
And these were not, like, big companies, because the only way you could attract employees, make acquisitions, all of that good stuff, was to be a public company.
All of those things are now available in the private markets.
So, I mean, we'll see what happens, but they definitely probably will go public, presumably correct.
That's my, I'm assuming they will at some point.
when that moment passes.
I want to mention a bizarre moment
from Tucker Carlson's interview
with OpenAI CEO Sam Altman last week.
Carlson brought up a conspiracy theory
about the death of an Open AI whistleblower,
which is being pushed by Elon Musk, by the way,
suggesting it was murder, not suicide,
as authorities had ruled.
Let's listen.
I don't think we should say,
well, he killed himself
when there's no evidence
that the guy was depressed at all.
I think, and if he was your friend,
I would think he would want to speak to his mom.
I did offer him.
She didn't want to.
So do you feel that, you know, when people look at that and they're like, you know,
it's possible that happened, do you feel that that reflects the worries they have about what's happening here?
Like, people are afraid that this is like...
I haven't done too many interviews where I've been accused of, like...
Oh, I'm not accusing you at all.
I'm just saying his mother says that I don't think a fair read of the end.
evidence suggests suicide at all.
Well, now, thank you, Inspector
fucking Cluso. What are you talking about?
This is like, this was the craziest thing.
Like, don't you think we should entertain
conspiracy theories that there's a cult in, you know,
there's a murderous cult inside of Open AI?
I mean, I don't know why he sat down.
I couldn't understand why he would talk to this guy,
given I get why he would, but ew, ew, the whole thing was really strange.
Tucker Haulson's gotten really strange.
everything else. First off, Tucker Carlson now appears to be a fully credentialed psychiatrist
around self-harm. Yeah, also a detective. Because he's decided that this guy does not
qualify as one of the 25,000 people who every year decide, I'm really down, I'm really depressed.
And oh, by the way, there's a gun upstairs. I know what to do. Okay, first off, this is just all
about money. And that is Tucker Carlson, who I think is a bright guy, decided, oh, I know how to get this
to be a Ted Cruz like viral moment and be number one instead of number four in podcasting
and make more money, I'll create a rumor in front of one of the most powerful people in the
world that he's a murderer. That's what he's saying right here. Yes, he is. That's what Sam was
like. I've never been accused of murder. He's saying, I think you murdered this guy in some sort
of thriller. And let's go back, aside from the fact that while I think Sam Altman might be a
sociopath, and that is ignoring the harm of AI because there is so much pressure on him to live up
to the incredible expectations. And that is not a nice thing to say, but I have a lot of fact
patterns around all these guys who in their hush tones, pretend to give a flying fuck, and then go on
to build character AIs with no guardrails that result in real harm. I think, I believe, that
there is no, that economically, it would be really stupid for Sam Altman to put out a hit
on one of his employees.
Yeah, I would agree.
For a lot less money, he can give money to Charles Schumer and to Senator Cotton
and make sure that there's no legislation that gets in the way or slows down AI or show up to a dinner
and say, gee, President Trump, your big orange cock is like nothing I've ever seen.
And it's so huge.
Apparently, it's little in mushroom shape, but go ahead.
And you're such a great kisser.
It is so much easier and low risk for Sam Alt.
to pursue legal means of economic success and to order a hit on one of his employees.
Sam Altman is already a billionaire.
He would never risk spending the rest of his life in prison.
He would never risk the economic implosion of putting a hit out on his own employees.
And Tucker Carlson, in my opinion, no one should go on that show if they're going to be falsely
accused of being a murderer for clicks.
Agreed.
I agree.
I think it's crazy that he sat there.
I actually texted him, I'm like,
so you're a murderer. Good to know.
It's just ridiculous.
Like, this guy did this.
Anyway, we don't believe he's murder,
just officially.
All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break.
When we come back, Paramount Skydance
tries to shake up Hollywood with a new deal.
Support for the show comes from MintMobil.
We all procrastinate, totally understandable.
Why do something now when you can just do it later?
But what might come back
to bite you is Procrasta saving. That's when you put off something you know could save you
money that's losing out on money in your pocket now and in the future. Mintmobile's best deal of
the year will stop your procrastist saving in its tracks. 50% off unlimited premium wireless
for new customers. That's 50% off for new customers. Plus, all Mint mobile plans come with
high speed data and unlimited talk and tax on the nation's largest 5G network. You can use your
current phone and phone number on any Mint mobile plan and bring along all your existing contacts.
don't miss out on three months of unlimited premium wireless from MintMobil for $15 a month.
But hurry, because this deal ends September 22nd.
Quit stalling and start saving when you make this switch.
Shop plans at mintmobile.com slash pivot.
That's mintmobile.com slash pivot.
Upfront payment of $45 required, equivalent to $15 a month, limited time,
new customer offer for first three months only speeds me slow above 35 gigabytes on a limited plan,
taxes and fees extra seeing MintMobile for details.
Support for the show comes from HIMS.
There's a lot of opinions out there about how to take care of yourself.
Sometimes it can be way too complex and confusing.
Do this.
Take that.
Don't take this.
Other times, it can be overly simplified,
like a one-size-fits-all treatment with present dosages and zero flexibility.
It's time to reimagine health care with the flexibility you want
and answers tailored to your specific needs.
The way they do it, at Hymns and HERS.
Hems and HERS is reimagining health care with you in mind.
They offer access to personalized care for weight loss, hair loss, sexual health, and mental health,
because your goals, your biology, and your lifestyle are anything but average.
No membership fees, no surprise fees, just transparent pricing and real care that you can access from anywhere.
Feel like your best self thanks to quality, convenient care through HIMS and hers.
Start your free online visit today at HIMS.com slash pivot.
That's H-I-M-S-com slash pivot.
To find your personalized treatment options, not available everywhere, prescription product,
require provider consultations. See website
for full details, important safety information
and restrictions.
They got Willa. They got my daughter.
I need to find her.
Willa!
From acclaimed director, Paul Thomas Anderson.
You can save that girl.
On September 26th, experience what is being called
the best movie of the year.
This is at the end of the line. Not for you.
Leonardo DiCaprio, Sean Pan, Benicio del Toro,
Tiana Taylor,
Let's go!
Here I come.
One battle after another.
Only in Peter, September 26th.
Experience it in IMAX.
You can't hide.
Scott, we're back in the small ball area.
As I predicted last week, Paramount Skydance has been praying for a mostly cash bid for Warner
Brothers Discovery, backed by the Ellison family who's richer than ever.
For those trying to keep score at home, Paramount itself was just acquired by Skydance last month.
And Warner Brothers Discovery has plans to split into two six.
separate companies, one with the big studio and streaming properties, the other gets the live
cable networks. Currently, Warner Discovery has double the market cap of Skyden. It's a lot of money.
It's $30-some billion. This would be for all of it, so not to split it up. Obviously, they want
the Warner Brothers studio and streaming properties. I'm not sure why they're not waiting for the
split. The bid hasn't been submitted. We'll see it with the FCC things, although that guy's a
toadie to the Trump administration. And if L. Ellison wants it and there, so we'll get it.
You know, we'll see. There'll be other bidders, presumably Comcast and some others, if there are bidders, in fact, thoughts?
This is huge. I mean, because there's so much news, this would have been huge news, it's been drowned out.
Warner Brothers Discovery, who has the highest paid investment banker in history, their CEO convinced a bunch of investors to buy Warner Brothers from AT&T, and in exchange for destroying a massive amount of shareholder value has taken out about.
a third of a billion dollars. He's the most, maybe with the exception of Chamath Polyhapatia,
he's the most well-compensated investment banker in history. Now, what you have here is in the
last five days, the stock is up 55%. It's had its best week in history. Why? Because Larry Ellison
figured out there should be a number two to Nvidia, stopped doing stock buybacks, made a massive bet
on being the number two infrastructure provider in AI
and announced an agreement where open AI
was going to commit to $60 billion a year
and compute from Oracle, despite the fact
it's only running a $10 billion a year.
And in one day, Larry Ellison increased his net worth
$130 billion.
So we can afford this easily.
Larry Ellison could buy three Warner Brothers
with the gain in wealth he registered in one day.
And this is where it all heads,
and I think it's fucking fascinating.
and I wish I had the time to do more about this,
but instead I'm spending a ton of time
trying to talk about young men
and its relationship to online speech and everything.
Anyways, I went to go see the Fantastic Four.
I hope there is never a sequel or a superhero movie ever again.
I just, I hate these superhero films.
Yeah, this one didn't get good reviews.
Superman did, but go ahead.
Anyways, I love Vanessa Kirby.
I think Pedro Pascal is a movie star,
and my son loves superhero movies.
So we went.
And like all 15-year-olds,
or not all. My son makes me stay through to the very end because these goddamn movie makers
always have an Easter egg at the very end. Do you realize how long the credits went on for?
A long time. I've done it. I've done it, my friend, with my sons. Okay. So I typed into AI,
approximately how many people worked on Fantastic Four. Somewhere between 12 and 1,500 people worked on
that film. And I got screenshots online. It had things like costume design, Sweden, and it
had 20 people. This is what's going to happen. They're going to roll up these companies. And then at
some point, Larry's going to go, say to his son, all right, I gave you a bunch of money to plan
traffic. Now it's time to get serious. Are they going to do that through innovation or new types
of movies? No, this is what they're going to do. That movie probably costs $200 million to make
before even marketing. He's going to go, we're very good at AI. We have the best AI infrastructure,
cloud, relationships with LLMs. I need you, David Ellison, to come here, and we're going to figure
out how to take a $200 million film and produce it for $20 million by going through each line
item. Let's say costume design. 50 or 60 people, we're going to use AI, the agentic layer,
that speaks to AI-enabled fabricators in China,
and we're going to need three highly-skilled costume designers
to basically put in long prompts that use 3D imaging
and all sorts of shit to basically get the costumes made
with three people, not 20.
And they're going to go through each of these things
that have 30, 40 people,
and they're going to reduce it to three or four.
And it's going to happen at Ellison's company
with the help and the urging of Dad at Oracle.
Yeah.
And then with TikTok involved with it, too, the whole thing.
And that's interesting, you thought this was like a nothing burger, small ball.
You always is like Paramount, who cares?
But do you think this is a big deal?
Or you just said it's...
In the world, the media it is.
But when I say small ball, if Larry Ellison had 15 kids, he could give each of them a paramount.
Yeah.
With the economic gain he had in one day.
Yeah.
So there's the economy, and then there's the economy, which is AI.
I mean, everything is being driven.
Who would have thought?
You're about to see costume designers, 70% of them get their real estate's licenses in Hollywood
because Oracle announced its best earnings in history.
This is impacting everything.
Well, see, others will try to get this.
Comcast will try to go for this.
Maybe Amazon.
I don't think they can afford it.
That's the thing.
He's so fucking rich.
This is the thing, Kara.
These are shitty businesses.
Yeah.
And they're declining.
And I put together, I was approached by a group.
Here's two examples of companies that are going to get the shit kicked out of them with AI.
Gartner has this amazing business where if you're a small regional bank trying to figure out should we use Azure or AWS, you call a stay-at-home mom who's learned everything about cloud companies who lives in Madison, Wisconsin.
She makes 200 grand a year.
She works from 7 in the morning to 3 in the afternoon answering questions from clients.
And Gartner charges first national of Oklahoma $120,000.
Now that person, the CTO, and they do a good job.
It's an amazing business.
Stock has tripled since 2017.
They do an amazing job.
Now, the CTO at First National of Oklahoma has figured out if they type in a thoughtful prompt,
they can get pretty much the exact same answer back for their $20 a month, you know, GPT5 Pro subscription.
And since the beginning of the year, Gartner's stock has been cut in half.
And I think it's, I, AI is going to come after that business.
Only fan. I was approached by a group of people that said we're putting together an investor group to buy only fans. Why are they selling? Because to do 60 minutes of video cam with a live creator costs anywhere from $300 to $1,200 depending on the popularity of that creator. AI is going to start to create AI girlfriends that get closer and closer to the thrill of watching a live person talk dirty to you or whatever.
Not illegal either.
And the guys, the folks that own only fans are like, we're out.
We have seen the future.
I mean, you're going to see so many.
So much of this stuff.
So many interesting places.
And here's the issue, moving to solutions.
This is going to create so much economic value.
Here's an idea.
Any company that does over a billion in profits, we have a progressive tax structure of, say, 40%,
and we figure out really thoughtful retraining and apprentice programs that people can sign up
and say, I see the writing on the wall, you know, I've always wanted to be, you know, I've always
wanted to be, who knows, I've always wanted to be a, Christ, a therapist, I've always wanted to be a
nursing, I've always wanted to be, do something in, in, with my hand, whatever it is,
retraining, right? But instead, we're like, let the thoroughbreds run and let the shit shake
out where it is. That's right. That is correct. Guess where we are. We, he, he,
Eleanor Allison is now Trained Daddy from Gilded Age.
That is what's happened here.
And we'll see how that goes.
It's not going so well for Train Daddy right now.
That was almost as good as your, what was that?
You were making a reference to that 50s musical, the Sharks and the, what was that?
The Sharks and the Jets, West Side Story.
I'm very culturally.
Oh, my God.
Could you be any older?
Oh, stop.
Train Daddy.
Gilded Age is very popular.
I'm sorry to tell you that.
Is it?
It's owned by, Warner Brothers, by the way, speaking, which you will now own Train Daddy.
Oh, is that the one with Cynthia Dixon?
Yeah, Cynthia Nixon.
Yeah.
Ms. Simpson, yeah. Miranda.
Well, anyway, we'll see if they get it.
I can tell you one thing, Karas Wisher will not be working for the Ellisons.
Let me just make that statement right now.
Anyway, one more corporate Jacob very quickly.
Trump is now suggesting that U.S. public companies should no longer report earnings quarterly, but every six month.
I don't think you might like this idea.
I didn't hate it.
I don't, but maybe not.
No, shareholders should know what's happening at companies, although then people focus on the short term.
Your thoughts very quickly.
I do like it.
It's a response, and the reality is.
is that there's a fine line here.
One, there's too much administrative
and very costly burden on public companies.
It costs two or three million dollars
at least a year just to be public.
More than that, CEOs, CFOs, IR professionals
spend two weeks of their life every 12 weeks
managing the earnings call
and trying to figure out the right words
and legal liability and the fallout from the markets.
So it makes sense that the administrative burden
should lessen.
Having said that, one of the reasons our markets
trades at 26 or 27 times PE and every other market trades from 22 to 12 is because of the
regulatory burden, orphans and widows are less likely to find out they own stock in Enron
when they buy a company in the S&P versus a company. I was pitched by a hedge fund 10 years ago
that said all we do is find fraudulent companies in China and they're everywhere because
the regulatory standards and they have gone up the last 10 years weren't as high. So the whole
idea of these regulatory standards is when you buy a company in the S&S.
and P500, it may go down. It may not have a good future, but there's not, there's much less
likelihood of outright fraud because of these regulatory constraints. Now, good private
companies, every company I've run or been an investor in that's a good company, we do effectively
what is an earnings call every three months. However, it's not the same level of regulatory burden.
What I think is, what I think is going to fill the void of the Delta, quite frankly, and this is
an opportunity, is some sort of AI good seal of approval. And that is, okay, company X,
if you send us your financials and let us tap into your APIs, we're every three months
going to put out a rating on the financial health. Basically, these companies every three months
are to signal growth and also to make sure there's not fraud. I can see an AI good housekeeping
seal of approval, better business viewer, rotten tomatoes, which has become an arbiter of whether
you want to waste your time that says it doesn't look as if this company, similar to a Fitch
or a Moody's or an S&P, it doesn't look as if there is fraud here. It's got a 2% rating of fraud,
not 99. Well, that calls for more scrutiny then, not less. You like six months or do you not
like six months? Oh, I like it because the reality is the administrative burden, it goes back to
what we said previously. There's two few companies that are public and there's two few companies
for retail investors to pick from. Part of the reason companies are not going to
public is because of what has probably become burdensome regulatory oversight. Now, it's a fine
needle to thread. You do want some disclosure requirements. I believe that AI will create a level
of disclosure and fraud protection should you decide to engage in with it. They could give you a
good housekeeping seal of approval that it's unlikely fraud is taking place here. And there will be
hopefully more public companies. Because the reality is, if you can bet on whether there's civil war,
what you can right now in Polly Market,
should we really be infantilizing investors
and not letting certain companies go public for risk
or a belief that we need to protect them?
Jesus Christ, people can bet on the Super Bowl
on their phone right now.
So if, you know, it's gone overboard.
We need more public companies.
We need retail investors to have access to more companies.
Okay, okay.
I do like it.
I thought you would like it.
I thought you would.
I actually do, too,
because the short-term thinking of all our companies
is really problematic, I think, in a lot of ways.
That's a bigger problem in the United States in America, but still.
All right, one more quick break.
We'll be back for wins and fails.
Summer's here, and you can now get almost anything you need for your sunny days delivered with Uber Eats.
What do we mean by almost?
Well, you can't get a well-groom lawn delivered, but you can get a chicken parmesan delivered.
A cabana?
That's a no.
But a banana?
That's a yes.
A nice tan.
Sorry, nope.
But a box fan, happily, yes.
A day of sunshine?
No.
A box of fine wines?
Yes, Uber Eats can definitely get you that.
Get almost, almost anything delivered with Uber Eats.
Order now.
Alcohol and select markets, product availability may vary by Regency app for details.
Pumpkin is here at Starbucks, and we're making it just the way you like.
Handcrafted with real ingredients like our real pumpkin sauce and rich espresso,
sprinkled with pumpkin spice.
It's full of real flavors you'll keep coming back for.
Made just for you at Starbucks.
Hi, this is Bella Freud.
Each week on Fashion Neurosis, I interview highly creative people in the world of fashion, film, art, sport, literature, and music.
The format of the show is that my guest lies on the couch and I sit in a chair like an analyst.
I know.
I ask questions, quite simple things that revolve around how we reveal or hide things through what we wear,
how we do or don't draw attention to ourselves.
This week I welcome Amelia D'Moldenberg, the host of the YouTube series Chicken Shop Date.
One of my friends came up to me, I remember, like on the early days and said,
do you mean to dress frumpy on the dates?
I said, Frumpy! This is my wardrobe.
Find fashion neurosis on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails.
Would you like me to go first?
Please.
Guess what's coming back, hunting wives, and they did the funniest?
I know you were going to say the L word or something.
No, that is maybe coming back.
The hunting wives is coming back for season two, and they did, I have to say, Malin Ackerman.
What is that? What is the hunting ones?
Oh, you need to watch it.
Just watch it, and then call me.
I don't watch TV anymore.
Wait, is that the one with Charlie's Tehran and someone else make out?
No, that's another one.
There's plenty of lesbian things, material going on these days.
But, no, it's this, it's Maga Christian gun-toating lesbians.
So there you go.
Maga Christian gun-toting lesbian.
Whatever.
In Texas.
Just what you said there, I'll see it twice.
Exactly.
So it's coming back to you.
And they did the best, Malin Ackerman and Brittany Stowe did the funniest announcement using
like a cell phone conversation that was very hysterical.
And congratulations, ladies.
And I'm hoping to interview the creator of it because it's just such so funny.
It's exactly what we need at this moment, I have to tell you.
It brings together MAGA and lesbians in a way that's really.
really satisfying. I don't know how they did it, but they did it. That is my win. My fail is
Donald Trump and his incessant lies and especially Pulte, Bill Pulte, who is just a nepo baby
imbecile. They accuse this woman Lisa Cook of mortgage fraud, it turns out. It's bullshit.
Oh, it's bullshit. Fuck you, Bill Pulte. Oh, my God. Stop it. She registered it as her vacation home.
You liars. They just, they raise a, this is what they do. They raise a lie and then they, and then
it's not true, but they've caused damage along the way.
do not care about the truth. And that is, Bill Pulte, in any other place, so would Cash Patel,
so would Pete has said, so would Cristiano be fired for their incompetent, their rank incompetence.
But as long as they salute at the leader, dear leader, they're going to stay in their jobs.
But that guy is really a heinous piece of shit. And let me tell you, Bill Pulte, call me up.
Come and to visit Caroswisher, because what you did to this woman is reprehensible. And I know why you're
doing it, but it's grotesque. And at some point, this has to stop. Maybe it doesn't, but it should
stop. Anyway, that's my, that's my fail. So funny, I don't know, one of my favorite movies is a movie
called Hannah and Her Sisters. Yes, yes. And there's a scene, Max von Seido as having an affair
with a much younger woman, I thought was one of the most beautiful woman, and I'm dating myself with
Barbara Hershey. Yeah. And I always remember that movie, oh, God, what was it with Bet Midler?
beaches thank you and i just thought it was hilarious i was joke that of course one of them gets
cancer and dies and everyone's crying at the end and i thought if bett midler was dying there would be
there wouldn't be a tear not so i love that bet midler oh no no when it's the hot sublime beautiful one
that dies the cancer everyone's crying now betmiller is a is a national fucking treasure i'm not i'm not
making a statement on bet midler i'm making a statement on how looks this we are anyways but in the
movie Hannah and her sisters, Barbara Hershey wises up and decides that she's going to leave Max von
Sito. And he's like, he's panicked and he's upset and he's like, you're my link to the outside world.
I feel like you have become my cultural link to the outside world. I watch Premier League football.
Other than that, I don't turn the TV on anymore. Trust me on the hunting wives. Go ahead.
No, I take your recommendations. I just wrote down the hunting wives. Anyways, okay, so my fail is along the
lines of government and competence.
One of the most storied best brands in government institutions,
one of the best institutional brands in the world
is the FBI.
I've known some people who've worked to the FBI.
And universally, they're these low-key people who literally
reek of competence and humility.
Confidence, that's correct.
They are the last people to go on social media
and start saying, I have a suspect in custody,
and then have to go back and say, oops, the FBI,
typically doesn't speak.
They speak with arrests, indictments, and prosecutions.
That is how they communicate.
And with a workforce of incredibly talented people
who could make a lot more money elsewhere
but decide they want to serve their country
and what is the elite of the elite
of our law enforcement until fucking Cash Patel
who is, there are so many reports inside of the FBI
about what a bumbling idiot this guy is,
announcing they have a suspect before it's confirmed
and having to walk that back.
Firing competent people because they're a woman
or person of color.
Go ahead.
And then the ultimate contradiction
of the speak softly but carry a big fucking stick
that is the FBI is he goes on national TV
and says, and says, and my friend Charlie,
you know, rest now, my friend, he said,
rest now, we have the watch.
I will see you and buy.
I'll holla.
Dude, if this, first off, if this is your friend, you should recuse yourself from the investigation as every FBI director would have done.
Yep.
And this is not, I don't, people have the right to own their grief and miss their friend.
I get that, brother.
They're so performative.
Good for you.
And I think it's important that men say how much they're going to miss their friends.
That's not what the head of the FBI does.
That is the last thing that...
He's a podcaster.
That is so opposite.
The children's book author.
That is so opposite of the FBI brand.
It's this, have you no sense of the history of the FBI?
No.
No.
This guy makes Jay Edgar Hoover look like great.
They are just quietly very good at what they do, tracking down bad guys.
They don't go on social media.
No, they don't.
Anyway, the continued incompetence and erosion of some of the best institutional
brands in history run by people who are more there for personal satisfaction than operational
excellence as evidenced by RFK Jr. and now Cash Patel, who has no business running one of the
finest institutions, one of the best brands in the world. My, that's my fail. My win is New Mexico
announced that they're going to basically have universal child care and distinct of the morality
of it. I'm not going to go to like, you know, mothering is the hardest job in the world. I've never
bought that. Fine. Okay. It's a difficult job. Most people are pretty decent at it. I've never
bought this notion. It's the toughest job in the world. Let's just look at the economics of it.
When you give people universal child care, it stimulates labor force participation, particularly among
mothers, who, by the way, are increasingly more educated and in higher demand for information
economy like jobs. It reduces poverty and income inequality, right? Because child care costs can
push working families into poverty or force them to no longer work. It boosts disposable income
and consumer spending because typically the person going to work when you have the scale of universal
child care such that it costs less for good care, then they have this positive arbitrage where
they have more money because when you send a highly qualified woman into the workplace,
she makes more money than the cost of good child care at scale when you get universal
child care. It strengthens the child care sector as employers pay better, facilities improve,
it creates jobs. It improves future economic outcomes via better early childhood development,
which means less remedial education, higher earnings, etc. The return on investment, study
show, distinct of the morality and all the stuff about the toughest job in the world.
It is the toughest job.
I'm going to keep my mouth shut.
It's one of them.
Go ahead.
Well, okay, but the majority of...
Literally, both my kids were sick, separate weeps, and Amanda and I are about to, like, fall over dead.
But go ahead.
I get it, but 90% of parents manage, in my opinion, to do a pretty good job.
This is a different conversation for a different day.
Yes.
But if you look, just...
There was a study at the Wharton School at Penn, and it found that child care expansion,
and universal child care increases GDP by 0.1% relative to, even if you were to deficit finance it,
even if you were to borrow money to pay for universal child care, you get a positive return on that
investment. We are the only G7 nation that doesn't offer. So I'm not going to make, I don't want to
make a far left argument around how difficult it is and mothering and mothers need help. All I'm
saying is, okay, let's go for the money. More money. I like your argument.
Let's create economic growth, more shareholder value, more household income, more Netflix, more trips to Disneyland, more money to take care of our parents.
What is a way to get there?
How do we get a positive return on investment from the government?
Universal Child Care.
I like it.
High standards.
High standards.
Ensure that you're getting your money's worth.
Every other Democratic nation does it, too, by the way.
And it pays off.
So my, anyways, my fail is Cash Patel undermining one of the great brands.
in institutional history, the FBI, and my win is this new universal child care program
being implemented in New Mexico, which creates economic benefits and economic growth.
Let me say a woman governor there.
Men can do this, too, by the way.
It doesn't matter.
Do you hear the stress of my voice?
I sound like I'm ranting.
I know.
You are ranting.
That's okay.
You know what?
It's been a hard week.
It's been a hard week.
We want to hear from you.
Send us your questions about business tech or whatever's on your mind.
Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 8555.
5-1 pivot.
Elsewhere in the Kara and Scott Universe,
I recently spoke with Cristobal Valenzuela,
the co-founder and CEO of Runway AI.
We talked about how Hollywood is using AI
and why it's not necessarily a job killer.
I didn't agree with this, but let's listen to him.
Technology will change jobs all the time.
Look at the history of film is a history of technology.
It has changed many times before
through many of the decades we've seen,
and it wasn't really about the jobs
as much as, like, the people doing the jobs.
And so if you're hiring people, if you're a guild member,
if you're in a union, like, well, help your people understand how to use these tools,
like train them, get them on board with the latest,
understand how they can upskill what they already know.
I think it changes a little bit of the perspective,
and I think that's been my position so far.
I think it allows us to work alongside them in much more productive ways.
He's making a good case, but we'll see.
Did he bring his crack pipe with him?
Okay, okay.
That's the show. Well, he's selling, anyway.
Okay, that's the show. Thanks for listening to Pivot.
And be sure to like and subscribe to our YouTube channel.
We'll be back on Friday.
Scott, read us out.
Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Zoe, Marcus, Taylor Griffin, and Corinne Ruff.
Ernie Intertod engineered this episode.
Jim Mackle, edit the video.
Thanks also to Drew Burroughs, Missaverial, Dan Shalon, and Kate Gallagher.
Nishakuroz, Voxmeda's executive producer podcast.
Make sure to follow Pivot on your favorite podcast platform.
Thank you for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Box Media.
You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com slash pod.
We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things, tech and business.
How do we grow our economy?
Simple.
Universal childcare.