Pivot - The Colonial Pipeline ransomware attack and Tesla breaks up with Bitcoin
Episode Date: May 14, 2021Kara and Scott talk about the fallout from the Colonial Pipeline ransomware attack and the gas hoarding that followed. They also discuss Tesla's decision to suspend accepting Bitcoin for car purchases... until it is more sustainable and environmentally-friendly (Scott is skeptical). In listener mail, we get a question about how the global tech industry is being affected by humanitarian crises in India and Tel Aviv. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Support for Pivot comes from Virgin Atlantic.
Too many of us are so focused on getting to our destination that we forgot to embrace the journey.
Well, when you fly Virgin Atlantic, that memorable trip begins right from the moment you check in.
On board, you'll find everything you need to relax, recharge, or carry on working.
Buy flat, private suites, fast Wi-Fi, hours of entertainment, delicious dining, and warm, welcoming service that's designed around you.
delicious dining and warm, welcoming service that's designed around you.
Check out virginatlantic.com for your next trip to London and beyond and see for yourself how traveling for takes forever to build a campaign. Well, that's why we built HubSpot.
It's an AI-powered customer platform that builds campaigns for you,
tells you which leads are worth knowing,
and makes writing blogs, creating videos, and posting on social a breeze.
So now, it's easier than ever to be a marketer.
Get started at HubSpot.com slash marketers.
Get started at HubSpot.com slash marketers.
Hi, everyone.
This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network.
I'm Cara Swisher.
And Cara, after signing a contract for four years with Vox, I've decided that I'm just not comfortable with the environmental impact that the Vox Media Podcast Network is having.
I'm having second thoughts.
Oh, you.
I heard that we have to mine Preet Bharara's insights and that he's consuming more electricity than Argentina.
And after pumping this shit and doing everything I could to garner my own economic gains, I've decided I'm no longer comfortable with the environmental impact of Vox.
What Scott is referring to is Elon, and we will discuss that later.
But he's just decided that they will no longer be accepting Bitcoin after he accepted Bitcoin because of a line.
Oh, wait, and he also just happened to sell a bunch of it right before his earnings call, right?
He got woke.
What a coincidence.
All right.
We're going to get into your allegations.
What a coincidence.
But Preah Bahara does consume more energy than the entire country of Argentina.
Let's establish that situation.
I wonder if we should do an energy profile on you, Scott Galloway.
That would do it.
Are you seeing me right now?
Yeah, you're sweating.
I look like, oh, my gosh.
That's what I'm saying.
People don't see it.
He was working out before this.
I look like Fukushima right now, not in a good way.
Yeah, it's hot there in Florida, huh?
I'm sweating.
It's hot?
I'm sweating.
You live in a place that's warm, that's a warm place.
It's a beautiful day here.
It's 72 degrees here in Washington, D.C.
Oh, you're having your 11 days of spring before it comes 95.
You know what?
It's freezing.
It's been freezing this week.
Really?
It's been freezing.
I've had Maggie Haberman staying at my house.
We had to turn on the heat.
Really?
She's working on a Trump book, but she's-
I got Maggie Haberman staying at my place.
She's my friend.
She's my friend.
She is your friend.
And all you people who want to tweet me about her.
She's smart.
Suck it.
She is smart.
Suck it is what I say.
I'm scared of her.
She's great.
She's great.
Like a lot of people, she's working on a Trump book.
I think her and Frances McDormand should mate, and then we take their children and invade Australia with a super army of the McDormand Habermans.
Seriously.
I'm going to bring that up with her.
That is like bad and ass come together. I know. It's true. It's fair. It's a fair situation. Seriously. I'm going to bring that up with that is like bad and ass come together.
Oh, my God. It's a fair situation. So speaking of which, one of the things I was trying to get
information out of her, which she didn't. She's like a clam. She doesn't give information. She
only just reports it. And I'm like, give me the inside scoop, the skinny Republican leaders in
Congress have voted to oust Wyoming Republican Representative Liz Cheney for her vote to impeach former President Donald Trump for his involvement in inciting the Capitol insurrection and our continued focus on it.
So how does I want to talk about branding?
Because this is a bad branding situation.
I want to know how you would tell the GOP to rebrand itself here.
And how would you advise Liz Cheney to do?
The GOP is a much more difficult one. Let me start with Liz Cheney, Liz Cheney to do? The GOP is a much more difficult one.
Let me start with Liz Cheney, Representative Cheney.
We, when you think about heroes throughout history,
whether it's Abraham Lincoln, whether it's Muhammad Gandhi,
whether it's, I think one of the greatest American heroes
is Muhammad Ali, the thing that makes them heroes
is that they take a stand at extreme cost to their personal well-being, economic livelihood, political futures at a moment in time when it is really hard to do that.
And in retrospect, we look back and say, you know what?
What Ali refused to do in terms of signing up to be kind of a poster child for the Vietnam War, stripped of his medals.
They impoverished him. He had to borrow money from Joe Frazier. And then who do we ask just
24 years later to light the flame at the Atlanta Olympics? We ask Muhammad Ali.
So, essentially, Liz Cheney is going to be lighting the flame at the Olympics in 2040 or
whatever. Look, I believe, and I get politics wrong a lot. Hold on a second. I think Liz Cheney
is now the front runner
for the Republican nomination
in 2024.
To shake out of you.
Here's the thing.
She voted with Trump
90, like,
9% of the time.
And the person
who's releasing her didn't.
And we used to be
quite a moderate.
Now is just mouthing
these ridiculous bullshit
about the election
being stolen.
It's interesting.
What is she,
why is she doing this?
I was talking to my mom's friend,
of course,
because she watches Fox News at home.
She's like,
she needed to shut up.
I'm like,
but she's putting,
like literally it's like whatever the talking point is of Fox News within a
week,
my mother parrots it because it's really fascinating to watch that.
And I was,
and she used to be like,
not like this.
It was,
it's really fascinating. And I was, and she used to be like not like this. It was, it's really fascinating.
But, you know,
it's fascinating
that there's a lot of women
after Donald Trump.
The women are the ones
that are saying,
whether it's Liz Cheney
or Elizabeth Warren,
whether it's Maggie Haberman
who's, you know,
gotten a lot of crap
from Donald Trump,
whether it's Hillary Clinton.
It's really interesting
that none of the others
will do this.
And this is her.
I have to figure out everyone's like, what's her game?
And I don't quite understand it.
I think part of it is she actually believes what she's saying.
And the other part is she doesn't want the Republican Party to be a Trump party of Trump.
Oh, I don't know.
I think it's simpler than that.
I think there's never the wrong time to do the right thing.
She is more powerful than the two senators
in Wyoming because there's no one there. There's only one representative, and the last name is
Cheney. And she is being advised. She is being advised. The person whispering into her ear
is arguably the brightest political mind of the last century. And that is the guy that convinced
the New York Times to endorse the geopolitical catastrophic decision of the last 50 years,
and that was us going into Iraq under false pretense.
And that man is Dick Cheney.
She is fucking playing chess and shithead McCarthy
and his band of lame insurrectionists are playing checkers.
She is betting, and this is a good bet,
that the guy who lost all three houses of government, that the guy has every AG after him in the world, that the guy when the next election comes around is going to be an obese 78-year-old man who's going to be utterly distracted with his own legal woes, that his currency is going to go down.
And into that void will be the people who had sack and said, I am standing up for the Constitution and Republican values.
This is, I mean, she literally has now jumped out ahead in my view.
She's appealing to the middle now.
She really is appealing to independents.
She's appealing.
Although, look at what Lindsey Graham said.
This is a real branding exercise because Lindsey Graham says they can't win without.
They can't win right now.
Right.
It's going to change. It's
a bet on the future. It's a bet on the rising or falling stock of Donald Trump. And the reality is
right now, Liz Cheney is shot out ahead of DeSantis and Nikki Haley is the front runner
because, you know what? She's right. She's right. And every day she's going to get more and more
right. And we're going to look back and say, who did the right thing, gave up her gold medals and her economic livelihood to do the right thing?
Those are our heroes.
She may lose in Wyoming.
I don't think she cares.
Then she runs for president.
She said she's going to go to every person in Wyoming and explain her decision to them.
That's powerful, I think.
That'll take three, four days.
But, well, there's Bob over in Toshiba.
You know what?
She doesn't mind.
This woman doesn't mind throwing down i i got
issues with liz jane let me just say i think what she did to her sister was appalling but you know
look my mother was terrible but the kids are more cred she's a true conservative she really is like
that's like i'm not actually you know what i'm not going to give her a hard time because my own
my own mother did that so you know i i see it i've seen You mean a hard time of being a bigot to a family member? Being gay. No.
But let me just say, this is a fascinating moment for branding.
And the GOP brand is really, it'll be interesting to see what happens with this brand.
Because they're going all Marjorie Taylor Greene and not Liz Cheney.
It's really, it's a choice.
You know who's going to help the GOP out of what seems like an irreparable brand issue?
The Democrats.
We're just outstanding at snatching defeat from the jaws of victory.
We're going to have AOC insult Andrew Yang for doing something that involves Ramadan because he said something supportive of Israel.
And we're going to create interesting warfare.
I think the Democrats have been doing pretty good.
We'll go after each other.
I think they've been pretty good stepping out of the way.
Give us time.
I know, but I'm just saying, I feel like Biden's been like, I'm just sitting over here doing
things like go with him.
He's doing great.
He's, it's interesting.
Although my mother said there's a shadow presidency going on in case you're interested.
That's what's going on over at Fox News.
Who's the shadow?
Who's the shadow?
Susan Rice.
Not Kamala, Susan Rice.
Really?
She's not the shadow.
She's not the shadow. Whatever not the shadow whatever anyway another another
area that's interesting speaking of controversial statements uh your friend we work ceo a sandy
mathrani said those employees who are uberly engaged in the company want to go to the office
too there's a time at least those are at least engaged or very comfortable working from home
this was an interesting statement of course the, the guy who read it, he got killed on Twitter.
He kind of opened himself up.
This is a Wall Street Journal article that he was in.
What do you think about that?
I think he's probably like,
there's going to be an interesting back to work, not to work.
There's all kinds of countries.
A woman from, ran the Washingtonian,
got everyone pissing, get back to work
or get in line or get out of line.
What do we think about this? I think it's still going to be a hybrid situation, but
what do you think, Scott? So, disclosure, I'm not friends with Sandeep,
but I have done some work with him and I think he is one of the brightest minds in real estate. I
thought he was a genius choice for WeWork. I texted Sandeep last night and I said,
you missed this. You got it wrong here. Because what you fail to realize here
is that, and what you're going to get attacked for, is conflating engagement with a lack of
encumbrance. And that is a woman at home taking care of a kid because their school is doing remote
work, which is Latin for, hey, moms, you're now in charge of educating your kid. And let's be
honest, it's always the mom. It is. And there are some people who really need that flexibility.
And the reality is the people who want to get back to work, or what I found, is mostly young people who want to get out of their shitty little apartments, want to meet friends, mentors, you know, want to work hard, want to meet, you know, they want to be part of that social.
But to conflate engagement with your ability to get into work is just a very tone-deaf statement.
And the worst thing about it—
Especially when you're selling office space, but go ahead.
Well, and I said this to Sandeep.
This is a brand issue, and that is you want to ladder the person.
Right now, he wants to be the really sober, thoughtful, mature CEO.
He wants to be the immunity to the megalomania bullshit that was Adam Neumann. And here's the
thing. Sandeep has a great story. What is office space going to need to be post-pandemic?
You're right. You have said this. This is why I brought this up.
What are you going to need? What do tenants want right now? They're going to want flexibility.
They don't know how much office space they're going to need. What are they going to want when
people do come back into the office? They're going to want something really nice and communal
that facilitates interactions. What else are they going to want something really nice and communal that facilitates interactions.
What else are they going to want?
We need a WeWork little...
Short-term flexibility.
Can we get a little tiny
WeWork office
and just lock ourselves in there?
All their competition
has been cleared out.
People want to focus
on their core business,
not real estate.
You're right.
WeWork has a fantastic story.
It was a careless thing he said.
He should think...
You know what?
Sandeep is one of those guys
that is like 98% of the time so right that I think he was poorly advised here. I would go to, I think his head of
communications, his head of comms or whoever plays this story should be just taken out to the, you
know, taken out to the backyard. This was a really tone deaf thing to say from a guy who is literally,
he's one of the three, him, Hamid Moghadam, and I'll come up with
a third, maybe Sam Zell, are the biggest brains in real estate. You got this one wrong. But anyways,
as you know, I'm bullish on WeWork. Listen, people who work from home,
I have worked from home for 20 years, 20 years. I hate the office. I've always hated the office.
I think I'm more productive than most people. Same for you. You produce from everywhere.
I got this wrong. I used to tell people in my company, you have to come into work. And
occasionally I would let, especially working mothers or people taking care of their parents,
sure, you can work from home one or two days a week, but I've always been one of those people
that we need to bump off of each other. We need to be in the office. I used to have,
talk about unpopular, I used to have 8 a.m. Monday morning meetings for the entire firm
in New York.
And New York is not a morning place, and people hated me for it.
And I hired a CEO.
I hated for it, even later.
The first thing the CEO did was cancel those 8 a.m. Monday morning meetings.
Well, it's just ridiculous.
I think that you should be intentionally bringing people together.
I think there's some really important things that people should do together as a group.
Walt and I used to throw parties and take people to do cool things.
That's what we used to do.
Not just dumb trips, but really we did stuff as a group that was very, not like falling exercises or things like that.
But we thought about that a lot in terms of how people came in.
There is a benefit for people going in and people, because it engages people with each other and creates relationships.
But you could be very, this could be a really good time for companies.
Lastly, Amazon won its appeal in the European Union over a $300 million tax bill from 2017.
The court ruled that EU regulators had failed to prove the company got a legal advantage from tax rulings.
Big blow to Marguerite Vestager, the head of the European Commission on this issue.
She's been trying to use money and taxes to hold these companies
accountable. But this is a legal fight, obviously. Whatever. She's fearless. She has great hair and
she knits. She's a gangster. She'll be back. Not the last of her. This is a ground war with
these companies. Yeah, this is like you said, this is literally one battle in a long war.
And the reality is we all focus on the tax rates of corporations. It has nothing to do, tax rates are almost unimportant. It's all about
tax code. Amazon has registered $10 billion, no, $10 billion in profits over the last, I'm sorry,
20 billion in profits over the last 10 years. It's either 20 or 10 billion, and their tax rate
has been 4.5%. And I think people are just fed up and they go,
if the most profitable, most successful companies in the world are paying, and 90 of the Fortune
500 paid zero tax, including FedEx and Nike. And it's like, well, if our most successful,
profitable companies aren't paying any tax, who is? And the answer is small and medium-sized
businesses that don't have representation in
Washington can't afford 400 tax accountants to navigate this tax code. So, I think people are
really fed up. We need to- Yeah, I think it's a good topic for Democrats and Republicans.
And worldwide. Well, one of the biggest tax cuts we could have in our society or unlocks would
just be simplicity. And that is to say, okay, here's the tax rate and everybody pays it.
And it would be a really-
A little more complex than that for poor people.
Anyway, go ahead, sorry.
I'm sorry, repeat that?
It's a little more complex than just that
because it has impacts.
I'm not an expert, but I've heard people say this
and then I've heard very good arguments
that it has to be a little more complex.
But go ahead, sorry.
Well, what would be complex about 0% income tax
up to $50,000, 50 to 520, and then anything over 20, 40%, and you're done. No tax. All tax deductions
are just a maze such that only wealthy people can get through it. It's also a pain in the ass for
people with money too. And you want to talk about an unlock? The brightest, other than you, the
brightest person I work with is a woman who works at a law firm who helps with my tax planning.
And I'm like, Jesus Christ, you should be solving world hunger or building the next app.
I have an advisor such that, Mamie, she's the best.
She's smart as can be.
It's such an incredible waste of human capital.
I shall tell her that.
Well, it's true.
We've invented
incredible professionals to solve problems of our own making. And complexity is nothing but
a tax on the poor because they don't have... If you know how to navigate by stars, you want to
have boat races at night. And the rich have figured out a way to have all boat economic
races at night where poor people who don't have the GPS to navigate this tax code get screwed.
Simplicity of our tax code.
That was a metaphor I wasn't expecting.
There you go.
Boating at night.
Yo-ho, yo-ho.
That's a very elite argument.
Us with yachts can do the thing.
Yeah, super yachts.
Those who don't have super yachts.
Super yacht.
You would like a super yacht.
We've discussed this before.
I got seasick.
You know, neither of us are getting a super yacht, no matter how rich we get.
We're not good on boats. All right. We're going to go I got seasick. Neither of us are getting a super yacht, no matter how rich we get. We're not good on boats.
All right.
We're going to go to the big story.
Speaking of super yachts require a lot of gas, we're going to the big story.
Let's talk about updates on the Colonial Pipeline cyber attacks.
A major East Coast pipeline for jet fuel and natural gas is back online after a six-day shutdown caused by a ransomware cyber attack.
But it'll still take some time before it's fully operational. But the shutdown has already sparked panic buying and
hoarding those overwhelmed gas stations in the Southeast. There's a picture of a woman putting
gas in a plastic bag, which was a delightful video to see. Gas prices have soared above $3
because of the shortage. This attack follows a string of other ransomware attacks, which you
and I have talked about, including SolarWinds. That wasn't ransomware, but, and Microsoft Exchange Server. These were
other attacks, not necessarily ransomware attacks. But there's a lot of attacks going on,
and ransomware is among the many. They both were tied to nation-state actors. The most recent
attack seems to be a criminal group, as Nicole Perlroth said to us. There's all kinds of reasons
for doing it, whether it's to make money, whether it's to create discord, whether it's a nation trying to do other things.
So what do you make of this?
And it's affected, you know, people just immediately moved into the I'm going to grab all the toilet paper mode like they did in the pandemic, which, of course, you didn't need to do and created really problematic situations.
course, you didn't need to do and created really problematic situations.
This is, I think this is really one of the existential threats to our commonwealth and could pretty easily escalate to something very frightening.
And what struck me was the people responsible for those statements, they have a name, supposedly
they're out of Russia, apologized and said that they're going to pull back.
They didn't realize the ramifications of what they did.
And they're trying to act like they're a nation state and they're going to pull back. They didn't realize the ramifications of what they did. And they're trying to act like they're a nation state
and they're putting out diplomatic statements.
And, you know, if I were Biden, I would have said,
you know what, thanks for that.
We're going to drone your ass.
I mean, this has to be, we have to punch back here.
And if in fact our suspicions are correct
and that it's nation states using some of these groups
to fight a proxy war
and create discord, I think we need a cold war. And that is we have to hit back pretty hard and
come to some sort of detente where when these attacks happen, we're holding you responsible
and we're going to do our best to respond thoughtfully, meticulously, and two to five
X the damage. Because at some point, you're going to see a hospital system lose power.
Oh, they're doing that.
They're attacking hospital.
This has been, that's what Nicole talked about,
hospital systems, all kinds of,
there's a lot of very vulnerable high surface areas
that they need to, like they have held,
hospitals has been among the biggest attacks
from ransomware people who are doing this.
But this is going to be, as we talked about last week, I think this is going to be the Achilles
heel or the entry point into where crypto gets regulated because this is what people demand.
But this is really, this is frightening. I think all of us know, you know, I've been hacked a
couple of times in the email where people do phishing, co-op someone's email, and then send a message to our CFO saying, pretending to be the CEO, say, send $22,000 or they're going to shut our service down.
I just got one while we were sitting here. A Bank of America card.
But the really scary stuff is the state-sponsored stuff where they're just really trying to wreak havoc. I mean, there's just not getting around
it. It's a form of terrorism. It is. And it can be economic. It can be for other reasons. There
was attacks on water systems. See, this combines ransomware with infrastructure attacks. And I
think Nicole was more concerned about that. And she felt like the Chinese and Russians are very
deep within our infrastructure systems. And a lot of them are state and local. So, you know,
we have a high surface area of attack in this country in terms of what you could do. And a lot of them are state and local. So we have a high surface area of
attack in this country in terms of what you could do. And this is just one example of many, many,
many systems that are interconnected and affect lots of people. And then of course, people,
because they're people, respond in the incorrect way, start hoarding and doing stuff like that.
It wreaks havoc around these things. Someone, I think it was George Conway, put up a picture of his,
he was plugging in his electric car.
I know you have an electric car too.
And he said, I'm hoarding electrons,
which was, I think a lot of people
who have electric cars
did a little lap around the block about that.
And it gives you, it thinks about it.
We need to move into something where
we're not dependent on pipelines and things like that. Obviously, that's a bigger issue.
But these systems need to be girded in ways that they have never been, and they're so vulnerable.
But look what we had. It's sort of the perfect storm of bad things. One, in America, as citizens,
we have failed to acknowledge, we bought into this screed from Reagan that government
is not important, and it's a tax
and it's full of bureaucrats and stupid people. And the reality is no private firm is going to
have the incentive to make the requisite investments in protecting our infrastructure
unless we think long-term. And we stop neutering and diminishing the importance of government.
Two, we've had literally incompetence running the government up until
about, you know, three months ago. That takes a toll. And then you have what I'll call a
democratization of technology where we kind of, we didn't have a monopoly on it, but we had a
near monopoly on it for a long time. And now, you know, the Chinese and the Russians and these,
they have their own tech now.
Well, and a lot of it from us.
You know, I mean, that's what Nicole's book was about, is these marketplaces that now
exist, these dark marketplaces where people can do all kinds, all method of cyber attack.
They take so many different ways.
And I think it's truly, we are so vulnerable to cyber attack in ways that I think we're
not even, we haven't even begun to understand in the way we're, and as we add more things to jack ourselves into the system,
it really, one of the things,
Colonial Pipeline is advertising a manager of cybersecurity.
I can't believe they didn't have one.
Or didn't they? Or what?
It's sort of like, what?
Like, you don't have that person working for you?
All right.
But that's where I go.
The other place I go is, and that is,
I get a lot of
questions from younger people on what are the opportunities in terms of sectors and career.
If I were, say, 24 years, 24 or 34, and I didn't have a college degree, and I wanted to go for
a certification that would give me a great on-ramp into a good career, absolutely cybersecurity.
Cybersecurity. Agreed. Cybersecurity. certification that would give me a great on-ramp into a good career absolutely cyber security cyber security agreed yeah and it's it's exciting for young people because that is the kind of thing
where if you get into a decent a decent program and there's a lot of them that aren't that expensive
and get some sort of certification over six months 12 months 24 months you can get a really good job
like yeah a lot of people but yeah i don't know i agree vocational it can be like i i have nothing Like plumbers. So, yeah, I think there needs to be tremendous vocational training. But for people who don't want to work with their hands or don't want to be in what I'll call vocational work, I think cybersecurity is going to be a fantastic place to develop skills.
Smart idea.
Anyway, this is just very clear.
This is going to happen over and over again.
Well, you don't need a college degree necessarily.
This is going to happen over and over again.
Let's just be clear.
Read Nicole Perlewalt's book.
You'll be terrified. Her book is called This Is How They Tell Me The World Ends. Okay. All right, Scott, time for a quick break. We'll be right back talking about Tesla moving away from Bitcoin and a listener mail question.
Fox Creative.
This is advertiser content from Zelle.
When you picture an online scammer, what do you see?
For the longest time, we'd have these images of somebody sitting,
crouched over their computer with a hoodie on,
just kind of typing away in the middle of the night.
And honestly, that's not what it is anymore.
That's Ian Mitchell, a banker turned fraud fighter. These days,
online scams look more like crime syndicates than individual con artists, and they're making bank.
Last year, scammers made off with more than $10 billion. It's mind-blowing to see the kind of infrastructure that's been built to facilitate scamming at scale. There are hundreds, if not thousands, of scam centers all
around the world. These are very savvy business people. These are organized criminal rings. And
so once we understand the magnitude of this problem, we can protect people better.
One challenge that fraud fighters like Ian face is that scam victims sometimes feel too ashamed
to discuss what happened to them.
But Ian says one of our best defenses is simple. We need to talk to each other.
We need to have those awkward conversations around what do you do if you have text messages
you don't recognize? What do you do if you start getting asked to send information that's more
sensitive? Even my own father fell victim to a, thank goodness, a smaller dollar
scam, but he fell victim. And we have these conversations all the time. So we are all at
risk and we all need to work together to protect each other. Learn more about how to protect
yourself at vox.com slash Zelle. And when using digital payment platforms, remember to only send money to people you know and trust. What learnings have shifted their career trajectories? And how do they find their next great idea?
Invest 30 minutes in an episode today.
Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
Published by Capital Client Group, Inc.
Okay, Scott, we're back.
Tesla CEO slash SNL host Elon Musk announced that his company would no longer be accepting
Bitcoin as a payment for vehicles for the time being due to environmental concerns.
It's not clear why he wasn't concerned before when it was very well known.
Following his announcement, as much as $365.85 billion was wiped off the entire cryptocurrency market, although there has been some bounce back already.
In his announcement on Twitter, Musk was citing concerns over Bitcoin mining's environment impact and fossil fuels burned into the mining of cryptocurrency.
He did add the company intends to start using Bitcoin for transactions again as soon as mining is made more sustainable and that he'd be looking toward other cryptocurrencies.
Of course, they announced back in February that it purchased $1.5 billion worth of Bitcoin.
Fascinating.
Scott, please just go on.
Well, okay, so-
This is an issue. I've talked about this, by the way, with Beeple and everything else,
but go ahead. Go ahead.
So let's acknowledge there are environmental issues, and there's a really interesting
discussion, a worthwhile discussion around the electricity consumption of mining for crypto.
But they didn't seem to want to have that conversation in February. These issues
were present in February when they purchased one and a half billion and then put in his profile
the term Bitcoin. And then before the earnings, when they were going to miss earnings, decided
to sell some of those gains that he had catalyzed by being a big promoter of Bitcoin, beat his
earnings. And now all of a sudden, after selling and showing $100
million plus profit, he's decided that he's uncomfortable with the environmental impact
of Bitcoin. And what you have here, I think this is a big deal because this is an individual who
18 months ago put out a tweet that said, I have funding secured to take the company private at
$420 a share and the stock shot up. It ended up,
there was no truth to that. That is probably the most textbook case of market manipulation I've
ever seen. And the SEC decided it's important that we have innovators. He's creating a lot of value.
He's doing important work. Let's slap him on the wrist with a $10 million fine and hope that it
doesn't happen again. Well, guess what? He is now saying, to the moon with Dogecoin.
And then on SNL saying it's a hustle and it loses a third of its value.
And then saying, putting Bitcoin in his profile and Bitcoin shoots up.
And then saying, I'm uncomfortable.
And then putting out thoughtful statements after he sells it.
Saying, I'm worried about the environment.
You are now talking about thousands if not hundreds of thousands of people who are losing sleep at night wondering what the fuck is this guy going to tweet in the morning?
Yeah, the thing is, this is interesting.
Dieter Bohn from Verge said, are crypto markets too prone to massive multi, multi-billion dollar swings in value based on seemingly tiny pressures?
Or is Elon Musk too influential on those markets?
Yes.
I think that's right.
100%. Another one, someone wrote, good morning to everyone except Elon Musk,
which I thought was funny. But there's all kinds of reaction. It's another person's Elon Musk
comment about Bitcoin. It's like saying a Tesla uses way too much energy rather than just ride
a donkey instead. People are losing their beloved minds, but they hung on his every word on the way up. You know what I mean? Which is, I think, sort of like two bad boys. You were
thrilled when you were going, go Elon. And then he does this. You shouldn't rely on him and it
shouldn't have this much thing because it begins to look like sort of this pump and dump thing,
which I think is what you're essentially saying. But it's an interesting point. Everyone loves a
market manipulator
as long as they're manipulating the markets
to your advantage.
And market manipulation, according to the SEC,
the language is really vague.
But in essence, it's when you put out information
or take actions that have nothing to do
with the fundamentals,
such that you can either pump and dump
or they call it poop and scoop, right?
Talk a stock down so you can swoop in and buy it.
Poop and scoop?
Is that a technical term?
Poop and scoop.
That's the opposite of pump and dump.
Okay.
And I'll tell you, if it comes out that he has purchased Bitcoin after this thing dropped,
I believe at the SEC right now, I think their heads exploded when they saw that statement.
And you know what this is a failure of?
I think when you tell innovators they're Jesus Christ, they're inclined to believe you.
You have said that, yes. This is a real failure. This is a real failure of the fiduciaries. It's an incredible
failure of his board of directors. It is clear his board of directors, remember, do you remember
in like the 70s? They don't care. Trust me, I know them. They don't care. That's my point. But
do you remember in the 70s, they had like the world's greatest athlete and they used to go,
okay, the LA Dodgers versus the New York Yankees, and they'd all do
like tug of war and sprints. They should have the world contest of who are bigger bitches,
the directors from Facebook or the directors at Tesla. They let their CEOs show such a lack of
regard for other stakeholders. And literally, Elon Musk is brilliant.
He could put someone on Mars.
He could electrify the world
and catalyze a real dent in climate change or emissions.
And instead, you know what?
He might get taken down by this at a minimum.
At a minimum.
This is going to be a big distraction because he keeps going up to the SEC, Cara, and waving his middle finger in their face.
He does indeed.
So, interesting.
He put up, besides the one tweet he did was Tesla and Bitcoin.
And he goes, energy usage trend over the past few months is insane.
And then he put another chart about Bitcoin.
And then he did a poll.
Do you want Tesla to accept Doge?
about Bitcoin. And then he did a poll, do you want Tesla to accept Doge? 78% said yes,
versus 22% who said no. And they had 4 million responses, which was interesting.
I think it's just this idea of relying on a single person is really problematic. Let's just be,
let's be clear. You're exactly right. But one of the fundamental components of healthy markets is no one individual or organization has too much influence.
Yeah.
You know, the markets are meant to be a thousand points of light that spit back an amalgam of all of our emotions.
And anyone who tries to control the market to gain their own power usually gets hurt, whether it's the Hunt Brothers in steel or, I'm sorry, in the silver market.
And we have an individual now basically moving markets by 1010 or $20 billion in directions that tend to benefit him.
This is, I'm telling you, the SEC right now, there are a bunch of SEC officials and lawyers in a room right now going, okay, we probably have to do something here.
Yep.
Yeah, it's interesting.
It's an interesting situation because they really haven't been regulating this in any way.
It'll be fascinating.
I think what's good about it, here's what's good about it.
People are talking about this energy thing.
Now, of course, there's all these people arguing there is no energy problem here.
There is an energy problem.
And now they're like screaming at each other on Twitter over what the problem is and that it's a fake story and on and on and on.
I think it's complicated.
And, you know, guess what?
Cryptocurrency, welcome to the real world.
And this is how it works.
And so the influence of Elon on this stuff
is far too vast.
When you saw that number dip,
like it was,
even when he said the hustle thing with Dogecoin,
it was,
I just feel like they love him on the way up,
hate him on the way down.
And something,
it means that one person,
it's just like the decision
of getting Trump off of these platforms. As much as I like the decision of of getting trump off of these
platforms as much as i like the decision two people decided right in the whole planet of earth like
who's whether president's going to be able to say something it was the right decision but just two
people were involved and this case one person involved exactly this is where we are we have
someone manipulating financial markets who happens to be the CEO of Tesla, an innovator.
You know who's saving us from arguably the biggest menace in the world right now, Mark Zuckerberg?
Not our legislators, not attorney generals. The person saving us is Tim Cook. And by the way,
I cannot tell you how happy I am around that one piece of data that came out two days ago
that when consumers are presented
with the choice to opt in to Facebook's apps, which includes tracking, Facebook having the
ability to track them on other apps, a whopping 6% are opting in. And Facebook, who's 900-person
comms person, the way they respond is to tell Zuckerberg to go on and say, you know, this is awful. People don't want to pay $1,200 for a phone, and it's very cynical.
But here's the thing. When I walk into an Apple store, they give me the choice to spend $1,200
on a phone. And like most legislative action, whether it's the DOJ, it's not the actual action,
it's the scrutiny. And I think the majority of America didn't realize
that when they're on the Facebook app,
when they leave the app,
they're still being tracked
by surveillance capitalists called Facebook.
And 94% of iOS users with this new update are saying,
you know what, I am not down with that.
This is so wonderful.
You know what they are?
They're fucked.
The people who decided,hold on, hold on. Give me some running room here. Hold on here. The people who decided, you know what? The key steps to tyranny are to weaponize the media, then the economy, and then the military. We've weaponized media. Let's go after the economy with Diem and Libra. Guess what, guys? You're fucked. The individual who in a meeting told Mark Zuckerberg that Instagram for kids
was a good idea,
you're fucked.
The photojournalist
that will accompany
Sheryl Sandberg
in her domain-aught-meets-world-economic-forum
trips and photo diary,
all of it,
guess what?
You're fucked.
I mean, this company, finally,
I have been waiting for this.
We'll see.
I am woman.
Hear me roar
by the way apple made a really stupid move this week they hired an ex-facebook executive named
antonio garcia martinez who is a who's a lot who's a lot he wrote a book called chaos monkeys i and
i've had him on my shows a couple times i had him i did when he came up book i like that book well
except for some of it had some really awful comments in it.
And so Apple hired him and then just now apparently is not hiring Adam.
He's quite, I was surprised that they apparently didn't know what was in the book.
And, you know, look, if you like the book, you like the book,
but Apple should have read it before they hired him just so they could deal with it.
I remember reading the book and thinking it was funny.
Let me read you a section.
Most women in the Bay Area are soft and weak, cosseted and naive despite their claims of worldliness and generally full of shit.
I'm sorry, is that about most women in the Bay Area?
Yeah, this is Antonio.
Oh, that's not good.
This is Antonio.
Let me just say it.
Go listen to my podcast.
If he had just taken the word women out, he would have been right.
Right.
Okay.
They're self-regarding entitlement feminism and ceaselessly vaunted their independence.
But the reality is, come the epidemic plague or foreign invasion, they become precisely the sort of useless baggage you'd trade for a box of shotgun shells or a jerry can of diesel.
Jesus Christ.
He's a lot.
Wait, is this the one where he says, enter into the chaos monkey cage of entrepreneurship?
Is that the one?
I don't remember.
Anyway, Apple said, Apple, we've always strived to create an inclusive, welcoming workplace where everyone is respected and accepted.
Behavior that demeans or discriminates against people and who they are is no place here.
I just am like, did you not read?
I literally had him on the podcast.
People have written about this.
That's bad.
Look, he's an interesting character.
He also has written appalling and horrible things, and they should have read it and made a decision.
He was going to work in the app store and app news advertising team.
And have they already backtracked and not ever sent him the offer?
According to 9to5Mac, yes.
Yes. Yes.
To be clear,
I think there's a lot of very talented people at Facebook that should go on to
have outstanding careers at other firms.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I just can't,
I think this is an Apple file.
It isn't looking,
he is what he is and they shouldn't have done that like this.
He'll of course become a cancel culture warrior now and anti-cancel culture,
but he already was.
But here we are.
He has to own that statement.
That's pretty rough.
It's not only rough, it's pretty stupid.
The book is full of it, full of it.
He and I had this most testy of interviews,
although he's quite brilliant in many ways too.
I'm turning you in for shells, all right?
Shotgun shells?
I would sell you for a jerry can of diesel, my friend.
I'm sorry if I had to.
I get it.
I would take down Scott G i got away for i would
i would for a snickers bar if we were in a situation and i needed a snickers bar you would
it is a great snack ladies here he is he's yours or men or whatever i would sell you to anybody for
it for a snickers bar that's what would happen so just so you know anyway twitter just just so
we're clear twitter knows you love the dog Twitter knows you love the dog. Twitter knows you love the dog.
And I would sell you for a Snickers bar.
Whenever you say that, everyone's like, that's just not true.
I wouldn't sell you for a payday, but I'd sell you for a Snickers bar.
Anyway.
Remember that?
Okay, Scott, let's move on to listener mail.
Roll the tape.
You've got, you've got.
I can't believe I'm going to be a mailman.
You've got mail.
Hey, Karen, Scott.
It's Matthew here for Melbourne.
The question I have is around the humanitarian crisis which is unfolding in India right now. Right now, I haven't seen that much
commentary around the impact that it's going to have on India's ICT industry, given that it
actually runs the back office for a lot of large organizations in the world, such as Goldman Sachs
and Standard Chartered. I was wondering what your thoughts would be. Cheers. Bye.
Cheers. I love Melbourne. It's one of my favorite cities.
Melbourne. Melbourne, the tagline. San Francisco, but less shitty.
Yes. It's such a great city.
It is a great city.
It is. It looks like San Francisco.
It feels very San Francisco-y.
It is. It's a lovely city. I've had such a nice time there with my son.
So this is interesting. This is an important thing. India is a critical part of the technology
stack of our world and everything else. And not just
back office. They do a lot of innovations.
India is not just the back office
of the rest of technology, although there's a lot of that.
But it does do that.
And so, it's a real
it is interesting to wonder what
is going to be the effect. I haven't seen much coverage
of this. The same thing with
Tel Aviv and tech as the war
escalates in Palestine and Israel.
These are major tech centers for a global system, India particularly.
So, you know, it'll be interesting to see what happens. It happened when China,
the beginning of the pandemic, we are so globally interconnected from a tech point of view.
It's a good question.
Scott?
I think there's just an enormous opportunity.
I think one of the most visionary moves of the 20th century,
and we don't recognize or acknowledge
how much peace and prosperity it has kept and catalyzed,
was that we made this visionary, generous, bold investment
in our enemies, and that is we borrowed money
and rebuilt Japan and Germany. And I think there's a geopolitical move here. You said this. Unprecedented opportunity.
India is about to become the swing vote for the world economically, politically. It's an
incredible nation, more PhDs than any other nation in the world. English speaking, it is a democracy.
I love the way you put it. That's an important part of the tech stack.
I'm going to use that. I think that's a brilliant way to summarize how important India has become.
I think we are now starting to play offense. We had the lowest infection rates in the last
year yesterday, which is just wonderful food, wonderful news. I think an incredible opportunity
for us, we have been playing defense for the last four years because of all these self-inflicted wounds, would be for us to say, we are going to
go on the offense here, and we're going to use our incredible supply chain, our innovation,
and our generosity, and we are going to storm the shores of India with Americans and with vaccine.
And then if they want it, we're going to do the same thing in Brazil. These are the two nations
that right now are incurring the most death, disease, and disabilities.
They think there's literally probably millions of infections every day.
And they think at some point there might be 100,000 plus deaths a day in India.
And this would be an opportunity for us to do the right thing, marshal our resources, marshal our courage.
By the way, everyone's affected there, the entire society.
And then it has iterations all around the world. It's in our resources, marshal our courage. By the way, everyone's affected there, the entire society. And then it has iterations all around the world.
It's in our self-interest to do so.
A hundred percent, but it's an opportunity.
But Modi, boy, he was so powerful.
He looks like this is-
Yeah, he looks terrible now.
He's hiding.
I don't, it's really,
we're trying to figure out how to do something here.
But, you know, the guy who does the vaccine,
I think it's called the Serum Institute there,
sort of escaped to India, excuse me, to London.
The CEO and is saying, oh, I'm coming back.
But, you know, he's under a lot of pressure.
He was supposed to be rolling out this vaccine.
But they were just woefully underprepared here in terms of things.
And even in this country, even though we still have issues, it's getting better and better and better in lots of states.
country, even though we still have issues, it's getting better and better and better in lots of states. And it's really, it is an opportunity for us. It's an opportunity, especially India,
which is a critical company, a country to the world economics, and especially in tech.
There's four countries that are the sort of the linchpins of this, and it's the US, obviously,
the sort of the linchpins of this and it's the u.s obviously uh china india and um and israel and so we have to think really hard about this i there's no i'm not even going to start going down
the israel israel palestine road that's a that's a very different situation but here we can actually
affect change in a really meaningful way i think you're right i think you're right look we we saved
we we so tremendous courage and bravery and resources and, you know, just brilliance, logistical brilliance when we stormed the shores of Normandy.
We should storm the shores of India and Brazil right now with vaccine and volunteers and healthcare professionals and capital and create and really strengthen and cement those alliances in Latin America and in the Near East.
This is a huge opportunity for us to do the right thing, but also to do the smart thing in terms of
cementing alliances. I think it's a huge opportunity for us. We're in a position now to
start getting, we're really in a position now, and this is incredibly exciting news, to get off our
heels and onto our toes and join hands with other people across the world and do what we do because we are Americans.
Yeah, I agree.
I agree.
I think it's really important.
Okay, one more quick break, and we'll be back for predictions.
I want a good prediction, Scott.
I really want a good prediction from you.
Support for this show comes from Constant Contact.
You know what's not easy?
Marketing.
And when you're starting your small business,
while you're so focused on the day-to-day,
the personnel, and the finances,
marketing is the last thing on your mind.
But if customers don't know about you,
the rest of it doesn't really matter.
Luckily, there's Constant Contact.
Constant Contact's award-winning marketing platform can help your businesses stand out,
stay top of mind, and see big results. Sell more, raise more, and build more genuine relationships
with your audience through a suite of digital marketing tools made to fast-track your growth.
With Constant Contact, you can get
email marketing that helps you create and send the perfect email to every customer and create,
promote, and manage your events with ease all in one place. Get all the automation, integration,
and reporting tools that get your marketing running seamlessly. All backed by Constant Contact's expert live customer support.
Ready, set, grow.
Go to constantcontact.ca and start your free trial today.
Go to constantcontact.ca for your free trial.
Constantcontact.ca Support for this podcast comes from Anthropic.
You already know that AI is transforming the world around us,
but lost in all the enthusiasm and excitement is a really important question.
How can AI actually work for you?
And where should you even start?
Claude from Anthropic may be the answer.
Claude is a next-generation AI assistant,
built to help you work more efficiently without sacrificing safety or reliability. From Anthropic, maybe the answer. Claude is a next-generation AI assistant,
built to help you work more efficiently without sacrificing safety or reliability.
Anthropic's latest model, Claude 3.5 Sonnet,
can help you organize thoughts,
solve tricky problems, analyze data, and more.
Whether you're brainstorming alone
or working on a team with thousands of people,
all at a price that works for just about any use case.
If you're trying to crack a problem involving advanced reasoning, need to distill the essence
of complex images or graphs, or generate heaps of secure code, Claude is a great way to save time
and money. Plus, you can rest assured knowing that Anthropic built Claude with an emphasis on safety.
The leadership team founded the company
with a commitment to an ethical approach that puts humanity first. To learn more,
visit anthropic.com slash clawed. That's anthropic.com slash clawed.
Okay, we're back for Predictions, the Weekend of the Pawness, Prediction for the Days and Weeks Ahead.
Before you start,
I would like to offer our condolences
to Senator Amy Klobuchar,
who was recently on the show.
Her father died yesterday,
and she had a great statement about him.
He was actually a journalist,
and he had Alzheimer's.
It was after a long struggle with Alzheimer's
that he died,
and she said,
even to the end, as he lived the final chapter of his life with Alzheimer's, It was after a long struggle with Alzheimer's that he died. And she said, even to the end,
as he lived the final chapter of his life with Alzheimer's,
he was still singing songs and telling incredible stories to my sister,
Megan and me.
Klobuchar said he loved our state.
He loved journalism.
He loves sports and adventure.
And we loved him.
I thought that was lovely.
I didn't know that.
I,
you know,
the first thing that pops into mind is it must've been a source of just
tremendous comfort for him to have such an impressive daughter.
Yep, yep, yep, yep, yep.
It was interesting.
She was a calmness.
I think she's, I'm having increasing amounts of respect for this senator, I have to say.
I think she handles herself rather well and has really, as we've gotten to know her, has been a really interesting political figure.
It's interesting to think of her and Liz Cheney as sort of running against each other in some fashion, presenting different visions of our country, but at the
same time, really interesting. Anyway, your prediction, I predict she's going to run for
president again and possibly have a lot of success. All right.
So in the next, I always get the timing wrong. I was going to say the next seven days,
so I'll broaden it to the next 30 days. The SEC, our regulatory agency, is going to initiate action or announce scrutiny around
market manipulation as it relates to cryptocurrencies. And they may not even use Elon Musk's name,
but it'll be clear who they're talking about. This is unhealthy. It's created
insecurity in the markets. And the SEC is sort of, I think at this point, been like, okay,
you know, at some point, at some point when someone keeps, keeps mocking us and keeps waving
their middle finger in our face, we've got to do something. We're going to see action. What we're
also could see, what we also could see, because this individual is fearless and has shown an ability to create markets in crypto,
we may see a Tesla coin or a Musk coin or a Musk-backed or endorsed coin.
Oh, interesting.
Because Elon Musk, like all these innovators, is very good at keeping score.
They all wake up in the morning and they say,
hello, wealthiest man in the history of the universe.
And I think he sees an opportunity, and this is unfortunate,
but I think Elon Musk could probably increase his wealth
$10 to $50 billion in six months by launching and supporting Bitcoin.
You kept thinking an Amazon coin was coming out.
Well, supposedly they're experimenting with that in Mexico.
But there is crypto, market manipulation, SEC,
is about to become much more prevalent in the news in the next 30 days.
He's good at outrunning them, though, I'll tell you that.
He's good.
He's real good at outrunning them.
It's a fair point.
We'll see.
It's a fair point.
I don't know.
We'll see.
He's a very compelling public figure in negative and positive ways.
Anyway, that's a good one.
Okay, I'm going to write that one down.
I'll put that in my little book of Scott predictions.
There you go. And if you become more valuable than write that one down. I'll put that on my little book of Scott predictions. There you go.
And if you become more valuable than a Snickers bar, I'll let you know.
Okay.
Cherry can of diesel.
Cherry can of diesel.
I trade you in for a Snickers.
For a Snickers.
You know, he was probably getting, but what an asshole to do that.
I mean, whatever.
Whatever.
You know what?
He wrote it.
Our producer bought some Dogecoin. And now she's like, her emotions. Yeah. to do that i mean whatever whatever you know what he wrote it our producer our producer
bought some dogecoin and now she's like yeah her emotions yeah rebecca how do you feel how do you
feel rebecca what how do you feel about this how do you feel about your doge oh miserable miserable
miserable we told you not to i know i know i i mean like, I didn't put that much into it, but yeah, it's still money. And like, I can't believe, you know, on the show we've talked a lot about and Scott talks a lot about Robin Hood's effect on, you know, young men's emotions. And suddenly I'm looking at the Robin Hood app, like buy, sell, trade.
Yeah.
You know, like it's, it is, I get it.
Stay away from those. Well, the thing is,
Rebecca, you can take some consolation in knowing that the people who own and run and benefit from your usage of Robin Hood are mendacious fucks. Love to hear that. So you got that going for you.
You listen to Robin and Daddy on this one. Log off of Robinhood. Log off. Log off of Robinhood. Tinder while you're at it.
Log on to public.
No margin.
No options.
40% women investing, not trading.
80 to 95% of people who day trade lose money.
You can listen to a podcast I did with the CEO this week.
Well, how'd that go?
Well, why don't you listen to it?
Why don't you invest in our relationship?
Jesus Christ.
Because you listen to anything I do?
Yes.
Literally anything I do? No, I don't. But that's besides the point. By the way, did you see my No I do? Yes. Literally anything I do?
No, I don't.
But that's besides the point.
By the way, did you see my No Mercy No Malice blog last week was literally on how Elon Musk
has too much influence specifically over crypto and energy?
Oh, great, and here it happened.
You've been saying this.
And I said, if he pushed, I did some analysis.
Do you realize if Elon Musk's activities have pushed Bitcoin up over $4,500, that probably
wipes out all the energy savings of every Tesla on the road.
Let me just say, he's like a successful Trump in many ways.
Anyway, all right.
Don't forget, if you have a story in the news and you want to hear our opinion or submit your questions at nymag.com slash pivot, Scott, read us out.
Today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanis.
Ernie Andretat engineered this episode.
Thanks also to Drew Burrows.
Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts.
Or if you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify or, frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts.
If you liked our show, please recommend to a friend.
Thanks for listening to Pivot from Vox Media.
We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
Your mom and dad will not be around forever.
Leave nothing unsaid. Leave nothing unsaid. For all the talk around its revolutionary potential, a lot of AI systems feel like they're designed for specific tasks,
performed by a select few.
Well, Clawed by Anthropic is AI for everyone.
The latest model, Clawed 3.5 Sonnet,
offers groundbreaking intelligence at an everyday price.
Clawed Sonnet can generate code, help with writing,
and reason through hard problems better than any model before.
You can discover how Clawed can transform your business
at anthropic.com slash clawed. and it takes forever to build a campaign? Well, that's why we built HubSpot.
It's an AI-powered customer platform that builds campaigns for you,
tells you which leads are worth knowing,
and makes writing blogs, creating videos, and posting on social a breeze.
So now, it's easier than ever to be a marketer.
Get started at HubSpot.com slash marketers.