Pivot - U.K. says Uber drivers are employees, and the future of cyber attacks
Episode Date: February 23, 2021Kara and Scott talk about a U.K. Supreme Court ruling that says Uber drivers must be treated as employees and what that means for the future of the company. Then Kara and Scott are joined by New York ...Times reporter and bestselling author of “This Is How They Tell Me The World Ends", Nicole Perlroth about the danger of cyber attacks in the United States. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Support for Pivot comes from Virgin Atlantic.
Too many of us are so focused on getting to our destination that we forgot to embrace the journey.
Well, when you fly Virgin Atlantic, that memorable trip begins right from the moment you check in.
On board, you'll find everything you need to relax, recharge, or carry on working.
Buy flat, private suites, fast Wi-Fi, hours of entertainment, delicious dining, and warm, welcoming service that's designed around you.
delicious dining and warm, welcoming service that's designed around you.
Check out virginatlantic.com for your next trip to London and beyond,
and see for yourself how traveling for business can always be a pleasure. to get your customers to notice you, Constant Contact has what you need to grab their attention. Constant Contact's award-winning marketing platform offers all the automation, integration,
and reporting tools that get your marketing running seamlessly, all backed by their expert
live customer support. It's time to get going and growing with Constant Contact today. Ready, set, grow. Go to ConstantContact.ca and start your
free trial today. Go to ConstantContact.ca for your free trial. ConstantContact.ca.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network.
I'm Kara Swisher.
And I am one split end away from cutting my own bangs, Kara.
By the way.
Bang is what you should say.
Bang.
Is there a hair on that head of yours?
Have you seen my eyebrows and the amount of hair I have in my ears?
I'm going to start braiding the two together.
Oh, that's a good idea.
You know, let me just tell you, a handsome bald man, Stanley Tucci.
I was watching the CNN special of him wandering around Italy.
He's very handsome.
He reminds me of you a little bit, except he's charming and delightful.
Go on.
You don't move unlike each other.
You're both tall, skinny men of baldness.
Oh, you're tracking my movements.
You're a sexy beast today.
What's going on with you?
Listen, before that, the reason I watched Stanley Tucci is because I watched the Dylan Farrow documentary, Alan versus Farrow.
Oh, shit.
Here we go.
We could only have bald, handsome fun for 10 seconds before we got into males abusing children.
I watched that documentary.
By the way, everybody should watch it.
You know what?
I can't even do it. I've seen it. It's so well done. I haven't seen it, children. I watch that documentary. By the way, everybody should watch it. I can't even do it.
I've seen it.
It's so well done.
I haven't seen it, and I've seen that documentary.
No, you haven't.
This is well done.
Oh, God.
This is devastating.
I have to say, in any case, I then had to switch.
It's going to ruin Hannah and Her Sisters.
One of my favorite movies, Hannah and Her Sisters.
It's just going to ruin it.
You can't watch it anymore after seeing it.
Don't watch the documentary then.
That's all I have to say.
Crimes and Misdemeanors.
Yeah, crimes is a good way to get into this issue
and not misdemeanors.
So wait, back to my quote.
We moved on.
We had to watch Stanley Tucci afterwards
because it was so heartbreaking.
And then we were happy
because he was eating seafood stew.
Italian food, right?
Yeah.
Just like going from a wine,
like there's like in Florence,
there's holes in the wall
they hand you wine out of.
So it's very likable, very handsome.
I have to say.
He'll probably be accused of cultural appropriation or something.
No, he's Italian.
By touring around Italy.
Hello, Tucci.
Swisher's Italian too, by the way.
That sounds very Italian.
I'm half Italian.
Like an Italian cleaning product.
My grandparents were full Italian.
My mother was full Italian.
Get rid of the kitchen grime.
We are people of Italy. My grandfather was born in a town called Felice in Italy.
God, that's fascinating insight. Anyways, back to me. So my statement,
one, what was it? Split end away from doing my own streaming. Yeah, bangs.
That's a quote or that's a line from, have you been watching
WandaVision? No, but I should.
You really should. It's really
interesting. You're one of these Marvel
weirdos. You like that whole thing? I am.
It's a Marvel. There's way too much to get to.
I've been watching
it with my 10-year-old son, and I'm not exaggerating.
We stop. I do
what I hate when other people do. I pause it,
and I'm like, what's going on here?
Who is that?
What's going on here?
I hate when people do that.
I'm like, just watch the goddamn program.
You're not supposed to understand at all.
And I've been pausing it.
We never watch TV together.
That's right, we don't.
What is this?
Are you kidding?
We watch an hour of TV together every week, twice a week.
We talk to ourselves.
That's true.
But I'm talking about like a month.
Well, you and I are going to watch a mutant movie together.
That's what we're going to do.
A mutant movie.
We're going to watch the
mutant movie.
Let me just say.
But anyways, WandaVision, I
think Disney has kind of a
second big hit on its hands.
So I think it's really
interesting.
It's very different.
And there's a lot of really
good actors in it.
There's so much good TV.
I like cross-generational TV
too.
I like being able to watch TV
with my boys. There's a ton of good television. There's nothing to be said about it. There's so much good TV. I like cross-generational TV, too. I like being able to watch TV with my boys.
There's a ton of good television. There's nothing to be said
about it. There's so much going on.
Anyways, WandaVision. Watch it, Cara.
Okay, I shall. Now, enough with the TV recommendations.
Big news today from the Supreme Court.
Denied Donald Trump's bid to block New York's
prosecutors from accessing his taxes.
It's the Al Capone moment.
Dominion Voting Systems is suing the MyPillow guy,
which is a pleasure, Mike Lindell, for more than $1.3 billion. You know, I talked moment. Dominion Voting Systems is suing the MyPillow guy, which is a pleasure, Mike Lindell,
for more than $1.3 billion.
You know, I talked to the Dominion Voting Systems CEO
and he said he was going to do this and then he did.
And now Merrick Garland's up on the...
It's just not a good moment for the Trump people today.
This is a bad Trump time.
But there's a...
I think there's some...
And a little bit of this is aspirational
or confirmation bias,
but I think there really is a very strong sense of the immunities kicking in and talking about unification.
I don't think after something like this you can unify until you hold people accountable.
I think you have trials.
They're still kicking, though.
They're still kicking.
I don't know.
I think there's a decent chance the former president is in real legal jeopardy.
Yeah.
Everyone is saying, oh, he's going to run for president.
I'm like, I don't know.
I think he's in real trouble.
This one's bad.
This one's bad.
Tax fraud brought Al Capone down.
Al Capone moment.
That's right.
It's an interesting question of whether he's still.
He's going to appear this week at CPAC, I think today or tomorrow or something like that.
So he's back blabbing away.
He's going to do the same old act.
But you're right.
Immunities are kicking in.
By the way, Pfizer's COVID vaccine stopped 89.4% of transmissions in Israel.
This is the most important news story of the year.
One of them, yeah.
And this is so exciting.
I've been thinking about this a lot
because there is a narrative that has developed
amongst college-educated, wealthy,
and middle-class households that, okay,
so you know how 80% of people believe
that they're better than average drivers,
which obviously makes no sense. I don't, but go ahead, yeah, all right. Okay, you're in the 20% of people believe that they're better than average drivers, which obviously makes no sense.
I don't, but go ahead.
Yeah, all right.
Okay, you're in the 20% of self-aware.
But essentially, the majority of people have convinced themselves that, okay, I'm in decent shape.
I take care of myself.
I'm a good driver.
I'm probably not going to get it.
But even if I did, and I know a bunch of people who have gotten it and said, oh, it wasn't a big deal.
And then they hear the nonsense junk science that is amplified on Facebook, less so on Google.
On YouTube, I want to just give a shout out.
When I talk about my book, Post-Corona, on YouTube, they take it down because they're like, we don't want anyone talking about corona.
And I respect that. But anyways, on Facebook, where they continue to spread
or where anti-vax content continues to run amok,
and they have done a little better.
Anyways, the bottom line is people have bought into this narrative
that, oh, in a cost-benefit trade-off, I'm going to wait.
Because even if I get it, it's probably not.
I'm probably 0.01% fatality rate.
I'm in that group.
And what this shows, what this shows
is the question you should be asking yourself
is not, are you worried about getting COVID?
The question you should be asking yourself is,
are you worried about someone you love getting COVID?
And if you are, if you are, even if you've talked yourself into believing you'll be fine, doesn't matter. You,
you, you need to get this vaccine. This is about, this is about not being a fiber in the web of
death that is, that is snaring our most vulnerable. 89.
Let me just say, some people think the Biden administration is too negative and it's causing more of that anti-vax.
Too negative?
Well, they're being like, be careful, it's not working.
We're still in trouble.
The problem is, they've got to keep warning people not to...
Yeah, they don't want anyone to get relaxed.
Relaxed.
And at the same time, they're encouraging it and they're making it possible.
1.7 million vaccines,
way above what they said they were going to do.
So it's a real interesting question.
I mean, David Leonard-
It's a lot more than that.
Something like 14, 15% of America
has already been vaccinated.
No, no, I meant 1.7 million a day.
Oh, excuse me.
Whatever the number they're doing a day,
or a week, I think it's a week, sorry.
But one of the things that's really interesting
is that Fauci was on the thing saying,
keep your mask on. You have to have masks
until 2002.
And then they're saying things are getting
better, and then the herd immunity is getting
closer.
35% of people
are immune because they had COVID.
Another 12% to 14%
have had the vaccine.
They got to get to an 85%.
Anyway, you do feel like today is a freezing day in DC,
but the temperature is rising today.
And all this week, it's going to be in the 50s.
And I have a feeling, I just, I cannot take it anymore,
this winter and this COVID and everything else.
I think people are at that moment.
So they've got to keep in control of the face masks
and things like that at the same time.
Feel hopefulness at least and want to take the vaccine in order things like that at the same time, feel hopefulness at least and
want to take the vaccine in order to move that along faster. This is so exciting though. If you
think about it, it's not only, you know, I mean, my biggest fear has been my kids' grandparents,
one of them is immunocompromised. And I thought, okay, this is how she dies.
One of us gets it, we get a flu.
Okay, we're fine, a headache, a flu, whatever.
And then there's always a non-zero probability
it'd be a long hauler.
I know some young people who have contracted this
and are still dealing with it.
But the majority of the people I know
have gotten through it.
But then you give it to somebody, my friend's father,
a close friend, David Lister,
father was a pediatric surgeon, David Lister, father was a
pediatric surgeon, lived a fantastic life and passed away from this and probably had a few
more good years. So this is not only about, again, the question isn't about, do you want to get COVID?
The question is, do you want anyone you love to get COVID? And this shows that the narcissist,
what I call playbook of, well, I'm going to wait. Well, that dog doesn't hunt anymore.
Do not wait.
Get in line.
It's so interesting because there's a whole, you know, who gets in line and stuff like that.
I still obviously haven't gotten mine because I'm not up yet.
But the idea of line waiting is really kind of, I think it's frustrating to a lot of people.
At the same time, you have to wait in line.
As I told you, I have some relatives that jumped the line and I just don't want to speak to them i just don't want to speak to them
and then other people are guilty because there was a friend of mine who was eligible for the line
and was thinking about not taking it it was i forget what why they were eligible it was either
they were a teacher or something that was totally legit uh whatever state they're in but then they're
like well my grandfather hasn't gotten it yet.
And I'm like, well, you're in the line, whatever the line's rules are.
Get it.
Get a needle in your arm.
That's what I say.
Get it.
Get it.
As quickly as possible.
If you're in the line and you're being fair.
If you're a vaccinated tourist or you're jumping the line unfairly, you're an asshole.
And take pictures of you getting it to make people like you more comfortable with it.
The number of people who claim they're going to get it has gone up because what's happened is now that, I don't know,
55 million people have received a vaccine, and there's been very, very few.
I mean, like no instance.
I mean, this is like odds are not only greater being eaten by a shark or struck by lightning.
Your odds are about the same of being struck by lightning while being eaten by a shark. All right. Speaking your odds are about the same as being struck by lightning
while being eaten by a shark.
All right, speaking of immunities kicking in,
we're going to talk big stories.
Big stories.
The UK's Supreme Court has ruled
that Uber drivers are not self-employed.
The ruling essentially means
that the UK Uber drivers need to be treated
like employees and not gig workers.
That includes paid time off and minimum wage.
Uber's share price has dipped in the United States following the news.
It's unclear how the UK ruling will affect Uber's business model overall.
When Uber listed its shares in the United States in 2019,
it's filing the Securities and Exchange Commission included the section on the risks
if they would have to classify drivers as employees in compensating them.
So, Scott, is this like GDPR for gig workers or not? That was
the law that changed things around privacy, et cetera, in the US, changed globally. But what
do you think is going to happen? I think this is, again, it goes back,
I think this is directly related to the Facebook Australia fight. And I think the rest of the world, their immunities are kicking in sooner because they don't – they get all of the downside of big tech and a fraction of the upside.
And the notion that also reflects well in the UK where money hasn't perverted politics as much as it has in the U.S.
Right.
Where a proposition in the U.S.
This is a law.
This is legal.
This is judges.
But go ahead.
Yeah, $150 million to the AB5 and then $3 million against it. Guess which ballot, which side won.
But I think, look, there's just no getting around it until we, if we want to wait for the government
to catch up and have a new classification of work, we're fine. But until then, until then,
new classification of work are fine. But until then, we want to err on the side.
Billionaires have increased their wealth from $1.9 trillion to $4 trillion in the last 10 years.
Minimum wage has exploded from $7.25 to $7.25. And yet we have a company that's figured out a way to skirt even those minimum wage laws with software called Uber, called Lyft. The gig economy is, there's a cancerous part of it.
And if we're going to err, if we're going to err,
and maybe it's clumsy and maybe we need a new classification, fine.
But the fact that a guy or a gal turning on software
to drive people in the back might make at least minimum wage,
I mean, is that really a threat to capitalism?
Is that really? It's definitely a threat to their business. I mean, you know, I mean, is that really a threat to capitalism? Is that really?
It's definitely a threat to their business.
I mean, you know, I mean, I think it has iterations
throughout the, like to DoorDash, to everything else.
There's a real struggle between things
that consumers really like, like fast delivery
or cars on demand and stuff like that.
And what it actually costs.
And when Uber was initially,
when they were doing those $4 across the city things,
I don't remember when you'd take it and it would cost like $6 or something like that.
I literally was like, I just paid $4 Uber.
It did not cost $4.
It did not.
It cost me $4, but not society, not the driver.
This is just bullshit.
Like someone somewhere is paying for my ride.
Order that little black dress from H&M and decide how much that's costing society.
I think about it a lot.
I think about it a lot.
We have this.
We have fetishized the consumer in our society.
We've decided whatever the consumer wants, whatever the end consumer wants, that's how we should dictate antitrust law or consumer laws.
And it's like, no, we have people who are thoughtful, who will look at the supply chain, who will look at emissions, who will look at carbon, who will look at child labor, who will look at minimum wage laws,
and will step in when there's externalities that arise.
And unfortunately, unfortunately, big tech is very smart, very well-resourced,
and steps in with charming individuals and lobbyists to suppress that intervention called regulation around externalities.
Capitalism is not an organic state.
If it doesn't sit on a bed of empathy,
you end up as a Central American nation with a rich-
You're full of them, Dave, fetishizing consumers' bed of empathy.
It's the edibles.
Do you sleep on a bed of empathy?
No, I slept on edibles, and I think I'm still tripping a little bit.
But essentially, if we don't have people in all this bullshit narrative
that, oh, you're against capitalism.
The whole point of capitalism is we intervene to adjust around externalities.
And a huge externality around a class of people called Uber drivers.
And not all of them.
A large portion, maybe even the majority of Uber drivers when you talk to them, like it.
They say they like it.
They provide flexibility.
They do.
But there's a percentage of them
that should be making more money
and they should be passing those costs
onto the consumer,
even if it makes it a smaller business,
even if Uber isn't worth more
than Ford and General Motors.
That's okay.
That's okay.
That's our job to make sure that capitalism,
we continue to do well by doing good.
I'm, anyways, go UK.
Go United Kingdom.
Go United, but you're a shareholder of Uber.
How would you play it?
How would you play this?
The situation of beds of empathy
and fetishizing computers.
I would get out ahead of it.
And you know what?
Dara Khosrowshahi should be credited
with what was probably the most strategic
and deft acquisition of last year.
Their acquisition of the food delivery company was Postmates.
Who did they acquire?
One of them, Postmates, yeah.
Yeah.
So, look, he has pivoted his business and diversified it and said,
okay, instead of the novel coronavirus taking wind out of my sail,
I'm going to put more wind in my sail.
And he took an inflated currency, in my view, I think Uber's dramatically overvalued.
Yeah.
And used that.
Still an employee problem. I guess they wouldn't be. Delivery people really aren't thought of as employees, are they? inflated currency, in my view, I think Uber's dramatically overvalued. Yeah. And use that.
And what do you do when you have a fully- Still an employee problem.
I guess they wouldn't be, delivery people really aren't thought of as employees, are they?
It's interesting.
But that was a great move.
So I think that was probably one of the better acquisitions.
If I were Dara, I would try and get out ahead of it.
And I would say, we're going to, I mean, quite frankly, you should pull a Brian Chesky, where I'm a shareholder, and say, we're going to get out ahead of this. And I would say we're going to, I mean, quite frankly, you should pull a Brian
Chesky where I'm a shareholder and say, we're going to get out ahead of this and position a
company around its stakeholder. There's a face the music issue on employees and a face the music
issue on advertising. And, you know, interesting, Cory Doctorow had a really amazing thread on
Twitter. I recommend it. I was going to read the first part. There's an old Irish joke whose
punchline goes, if you want, get there. I wouldn't to read the first part. There's an old Irish joke whose punchline goes,
if you want to get there, I wouldn't start from here.
That's basically how I feel about the so-called
Australian link tax and Facebook's retaliation.
Let's start with the fact that it's not a link tax.
Then they talk about the arbitration and stuff like that.
Let me read it.
They design their system so publishers leak intelligence
to them, then they exploit the leakage
to gouge the publishers further.
It hurts advertisers, readers, and publishers,
and it's a result of a legal, collusive, corrupt ad technology duopoly.
And the existence of an advertising duopoly,
meanwhile, is a result of a lax antitrust enforcement.
Facebook and Google were permitted to execute
a long string of anti-competitive mergers
in acquisition producing the hyper-concentrated market we see today.
The obvious remedy to this situation
is to break up the monopolies.
That is off the table for now.
40 years of neoliberal orthodoxies
and monopolies are efficient.
Breakups don't work.
So we're left yanking on other policy levers.
Anyway, these are the two areas, I think,
this idea of owning markets
and how to deal with employees
that are going to be the big ones for tech to deal with.
Yeah, and I think there's an investment strategy here.
For the first time, my investment advice for the last 10 years has been
don't buy anything that's not an unregulated monopoly.
Amazon, Apple, Facebook, and Google, there's no need to buy anything else.
And I'm actually personally about to make two investments,
and I make usually one to two investments a year.
And I think there is a,
my big thing is dispersion. But I also think that content and a healthier web ecosystem is a great
place to invest right now. Because I think a lot of people, including consumers, their elected
representatives have decided, okay, we need a less toxic web. And also, also, I think a decent
place to invest right now,
and I'll talk more about this
once the investments close
because I like to disclose,
I think content
and news
and local news
are about to
have their day in the sun
after getting the shit
kicked out of them
for the last 20 or 30 years.
I'd like to hear about
where you're going with this.
Okay.
Anyway,
so what would you,
would you buy Uber?
If you didn't call it a menace economy and a not lying on a bed of empathy, what would you do?
I don't know.
I haven't looked at, I just, I look at the stock and I think, wow, this is really fully valued.
I think Dara is a really talented strategic executive and I think it was a great acquisition.
I wouldn't want to be on the side of a gig economy company that still has employees working for less than minimum wage.
I just don't. Even if it's only 10% of them, I just wouldn't want to. That to me feels really
offensive. Minimum wage should be what they should be paying, $15 an hour. How about you? Would you
buy Uber? I don't buy any of them, so I don't really have to worry about my, you know. But,
I have a very small FOMA greed thing going on. So I go, oh, I should have taken that job at Google.
And then I'm like, oh, those assholes.
You know what I mean?
That's what happens.
It happens with all of them.
I was offered jobs at all of them.
So I'm always like, oh, I really couldn't be in Fiji right now on my yacht.
You in Fiji on a yacht.
I'm just saying.
Yeah, that would happen.
I could be.
I could have.
I literally was offered jobs.
I would have been very wealthy. And then I'm like- I know, but that's not what you would do with your money. That's I literally was offered jobs. I would have been very wealthy.
And then I'm like-
I know, but that's not what you would do with your money.
That's ridiculous.
You're right.
I would attack the right wing.
But in any case, every time I do that
and I realized that I really was there
and actually not just was there, but had the offer
and then I didn't take it.
And it's a dozen times it's happened.
I'm like, I don't want to work for those assholes.
Like it's just, it just kicks in.
My, I don't want to work for those assholes. It just kicks in.
My I don't want to work for those assholes is stronger than my greed and FOMA about money.
I just can't sustain interest in it in any way.
I have plenty of money.
Anyway, Scott, we're going to take a quick break. And when we're back, you'll be joined by New York Times bestselling author Nicole Perlroth to talk cybersecurity.
She has a new book that's really scary.
Pearl Roth to talk cybersecurity. She has a new book that's really scary.
Fox Creative. This is advertiser content from Zelle.
When you picture an online scammer, what do you see? For the longest time, we have these images of somebody sitting crouched over their computer with a hoodie on, just kind of typing away in the middle of the night. And honestly, that's not what it is anymore.
That's Ian Mitchell, a banker turned fraud fighter. These days, online scams look more
like crime syndicates than individual con artists. And they're making bank. Last year,
scammers made off with more than $10 billion. It's mind-blowing to see the kind of
infrastructure that's been built to facilitate scamming at scale. There are hundreds, if not
thousands, of scam centers all around the world. These are very savvy business people. These are
organized criminal rings. And so once we understand the magnitude of this problem,
we can protect people better. One challenge that fraud
fighters like Ian face is that scam victims sometimes feel too ashamed to discuss what
happened to them. But Ian says one of our best defenses is simple. We need to talk to each other.
We need to have those awkward conversations around what do you do if you have text messages you don't
recognize? What do you do if you start getting asked to send information that's more sensitive? Even my own father fell
victim to a, thank goodness, a smaller dollar scam, but he fell victim and we have these
conversations all the time. So we are all at risk and we all need to work together to protect each
other. Learn more about how to protect yourself at vox.com slash Zelle. And
when using digital payment platforms, remember to only send money to people you know and trust.
Do you feel like your leads never lead anywhere and you're making content that no one sees
and it takes forever to build a campaign? Well, that's why we built HubSpot. It's an AI-powered customer platform
that builds campaigns for you,
tells you which leads are worth knowing,
and makes writing blogs, creating videos,
and posting on social a breeze.
So now, it's easier than ever to be a marketer.
Get started at HubSpot.com slash marketers.
Moving on, we have a friend of Pivot.
Nicole Perlroth is the New York Times cybersecurity reporter and the New York Times bestselling author of
This Is How They Tell Me The World Ends.
It's about cybersecurity weapons race, essentially.
Nicole, welcome.
Thanks for having me.
So, you know, one of the things, we've talked before many times about this, and you write a
lot of stories of what happens. Talk about why you decided to write the book, because we're in
the middle of a huge attack, the SolarWinds attack. We'll get to that in a minute, and the role of
FireEye and Microsoft in this. But talk to me about why you decided to write this book.
FireEye and Microsoft in this, but talk to me about why you decided to write this book.
So the short answer is I had been covering these major attacks and I kept seeing my name in the footnotes of other people writing books. And I just had to kind of give myself a pep talk and say,
you know, you know these attacks better than anyone except for the people on the ground
write a book. So that's why I wrote the book.
And I crammed everything in from the last seven to 10 years of reporting. And then I sent it in,
and then this giant SolarWinds attack happened. So in some ways, it's the prelude to SolarWinds.
But why I chose to focus specifically on the cyber weapons market is I had seen over and over
again that regulation was not going to get us out of this.
You know, businesses were just incentivized to get their product to market.
Government was incentivized to keep a lot of the software vulnerable so they could preserve
their espionage advantage and their battlefield preparations.
And as individuals, security is so annoying.
We don't like turning on two-factor authentication. So I wanted to focus on the incentive models and
see what the incentive structures were and how they could possibly pull us out of this.
So you're saying that they want to get the software out to serve people who don't want
to deal with issues of security. And then the government likes it, that U.S. government especially lets this sort of gray
market go on and attack these software programs we all use every day.
Yes. And I had heard murmurings of this gray market, but it still blew me away that the U.S.
government, you know, these agencies charged with keeping us safe, were paying hackers, some of them all
over the world in Europe and Israel as young as 16 or 15 years old, to turn over a vulnerability
in software that we all rely on and then never tell a soul, lock them up in NDAs and then
increasingly classification levels. And maybe that was okay two decades ago when Russia
was using one piece of software and we were using another, but we all use the same software now.
Whether you know it or not, we all use Microsoft Windows. And so I was fascinated by this idea that
our own government would preserve a vulnerability in Microsoft Windows so it could spy on Iran or so it could get into
Iran's centrifuges and take them out one day.
And increasingly, we're rolling that.
Yes, this was Stuxnet.
And increasingly, we're rolling all that software into our things and into our power grid and
into our water treatment facilities.
And so it seemed like the stakes were getting higher and higher,
but no one even knew that this secret market
for vulnerabilities existed.
Right, I'm gonna ask one more question
and then Scott will jump in.
Solar winds, explain it to people.
This is the biggest attack that has happened
on the United States government and companies.
Yes, so solar winds is probably the most pervasive attack
we've seen on our systems.
And we only learned about it. And
this is the part I think really is key. We only learned about it, not from our government,
not from the NSA, not from Cyber Command. We learned about it because FireEye, a security
firm, was itself hacked. And then in unwinding its own attack, it realized that these hackers
had come in through technology made by SolarWinds, an American company that makes software that just allows IT administrators to see what's
on their network. And that software, that visibility software was used by more than
400 of the Fortune 500 and some of our most sensitive government agencies like
the Department of Energy, which oversees our nuclear labs,
Treasury, Commerce, State, Justice, and Homeland Security, the very agency charged with keeping us
safe. The problem is that they've been in our systems for so long, we think since at least
March of 2020, that they had vast opportunities to plant more backdoors and more applications.
And it will be a very long time before we uncover every single one of those. So essentially what's
happened here is the Biden administration just inherited a communication system it cannot trust.
Now, the good news is we think this was espionage. We think they were after emails,
strategy planning documents.
The bad news is Russian actors, not the one we think was guilty here, the SVR, but other Russian actors have used the same technique for much darker purposes, like wiping data, paralyzing networks.
This is ransomware attacks.
Yes.
And in one case, shutting off the power in Ukraine.
In Ukraine. All right, Scott.
So just, I had never really looked at that. I think that's fascinating that companies and people are not only competing against bad actors, they're competing against the government. That's such an interesting insight. So thank you for that. The question I have is can you give us a state of play around competence? If
you think of every nation state that has its own cyber warfare and cyber defense resources,
give us a sense for handicap the league. Who's kind of best to worst among call it the G20 or
non-G20? Who are the Tom Brady's and the people who just don't know what
they're doing? Such a good question. So, you know, we, I think, remain the world's top cyber
superpower. What we did with Stuxnet were us, you know, us being the NSA and Israel,
hacked into an Iranian nuclear facility 10 years ago, jumped from the window systems into the industrial controls
and spun those centrifuges in some cases so fast that it destroyed the uranium and in some cases
slowed them down to a trickle and did it in a way that it looked like a natural accident.
No one has ever come close to that. That is still to this day, 10 years later, the most sophisticated
cyber attack we've ever seen. Other countries who are capable of doing that include Israel because we did it with
them. And then I would say just below them, if not tied, are Russia, China, the United Kingdom,
and maybe France or Germany. But then below that is this huge wide gap. And then you have the actors
who really want to do harm or really want to exploit financial systems for profit like North
Korea. And 10 years ago, they were way behind us. They had the intent to do harm, but they didn't
have the capabilities. And what this market has done, the one that I'm writing about, about
purchasing these capabilities from hackers and these vulnerabilities in code that you can use for espionage, but
also destruction, what that market has done is closed this capabilities gap substantially.
So Iran is not where the NSA is, but what they've learned is they can do just as much
damage with rudimentary code that just wipes out the data at Saudi Aramco,
which they did a few years ago, where they replaced it with an image of a burning American
flag.
And so, the gap is closing.
And the other thing I would say is, yes, we are the most advanced cyber superpower, but
we are also among the most targeted nation states on earth because we have systems of
most interest.
And we are the most vulnerable
because we're the most wired. And we don't seem to understand that this philosophy at Facebook
of move fast and break things, get as much out there as possible, be first to market.
It has really harmed us when it comes to security. So, we have some work to do on defense,
but we are still way far ahead on offense.
Just offense alone doesn't work.
Right, so defense.
You're essentially saying the reason we're robbed
is because that's where the money is.
That's where, whether it's ransomware attacks
or if you're trying to do malevolent things
like what happened in Florida on a grid,
because there's all kinds of flavors of this.
There's malevolent, there's just money,
there's just espionage,
and then there's just
wreaking havoc or trying, like misinformation, which is a whole nother, you know, the misinformation
and disinformation campaigns by the Soviet Union and, I mean, Russia and others. Talk about defense,
because this is one of the issues you and I have spoken about. We just, we have, in the Biden
administration, there is now Ann Neuberger, who is leading the way in terms of dealing with this, but it's on an emergency level.
And I wrote a column recently about this, which I also quoted you in, where they missed it in the Trump administration.
I think one of them called me and said, we didn't miss it.
I go, well, you missed it.
I don't think you didn't miss it.
Maybe you knew about it.
You didn't tell anybody.
I don't know.
But how did that happen?
How did our defenses fall so badly?
And is this the solution to do it on an emergency basis every time rather than have a central command?
Like, because there's so many different players.
There's Paul Nakasomi.
There's this.
There's this person, this person.
What do we have to do to have better defense?
Well, it's a really good question with a really hard answer.
I mean, what Russia did with SolarWinds is they got our number.
They exploited our red tape brilliantly because what they did was they got into SolarWinds,
which is an American company software.
They got into SolarWinds clients through their software update mechanism.
But where they set up their command and control
was in New Jersey using servers from GoDaddy and from Amazon. And that's where the NSA can't look.
The NSA cannot look into these domestic systems. That's how we are set up. So in a lot of ways,
Russia just used our constitution against us like they have with misinformation and
disinformation, where they've used our First Amendment against us.
So this is a really hard problem to solve for.
One of the things that the Trump administration did is they rolled out this executive order,
which basically says companies like Amazon and GoDaddy have to report which foreigners are registered under their systems, in part because clearly we were blinded by this attack by Russia.
I don't know if that's going to be enough, and I don't know what the American tolerance is for going any further, especially after all the discussions we had with Snowden,
Edward Snowden, the contractor who leaked the NSA documents. So it's a really hard question
to solve for, which is why in the book, I say, let's just start with baby steps here.
Let's take inventory of what's in our systems. Let's know what software touches our systems.
Let's know how much of it is American made. In the case of SolarWinds, a lot of that software was built in places like Belarus,
you know, where we just don't have the same visibility or maybe the same level of security.
A lot of the victims didn't even know they used SolarWinds.
A lot of the tools that make its way into software like SolarWinds is open source.
These open source protocols that are often just one dude sitting on his couch operating on a volunteer budget.
So let's take inventory of how much software is making its way into these critical and sensitive systems.
And then let's talk about how to secure it, whether it's making sure it has multi-factor
authentication, making sure we're doing code audits and penetration tests, making sure
individuals understand that it should be mandatory to have to turn on two-factor authentication
and to use different passwords because they're all gone. There's no point in even in some ways
discussing the higher up things when we can't even get the basics right.
And the basics would wipe out 70 percent of the threat.
It wouldn't stop solar winds, but it would get us to a much better place than we are right now where hospitals are getting ransomware at all the time.
Schools are getting locked up and taken offline.
You know, everyone's using, you know, phishing for fraud scams political and kind of geopolitical espionage, and then there's corporate espionage, which is basically China planning spies inside companies and saying, hey, send us the IP for this company, and we're going to figure out a way to knock it off.
And my understanding is that the resources allocated to corporate espionage has grown, has exploded
exponentially because money is very powerful in terms of geopolitical power. And when you see this,
when you see this ransomware, at the end of the day, isn't there an entire industrial complex
dependent upon small and medium-sized businesses remaining to be vulnerable, such that big companies and big tech can cash the register or ring the register or go public.
And there's a disincentive to protect small and medium-sized businesses
because this is an enormously lucrative industry for big tech.
Yeah, it's such a good question.
Kara and I have talked about this before.
You know, where this is all going is mom and pop businesses, small and medium-sized businesses, do not
have the resources to hire the top security engineers.
They don't have the money to put in place the intrusion detection tools and the network
monitoring tools and all of the fancy stuff you can buy from FireEye and CrowdStrike.
So that's not the case at Amazon and Google, right? Most of their security teams these days are like mini intelligence
agencies. They're all former NSA, CIA, Australia, UK, GCHQ analysts and operators and hackers.
They have huge intelligence agencies within their businesses
looking for this stuff, which means you are better off as a medium, small, medium-sized business
in using Amazon Web Services or the Google Cloud than you are trying to manage all your data with
some server in the back office. And what that means is precisely what you just said, Scott,
which is the business is drifting to the big players because the small players just don't have the resources
to protect their data.
And in a lot of cases, that is why ransomware is hitting these small, medium-sized businesses
and not just businesses, but municipalities, small, medium towns that just oversee these
tangled webs of outdated software, and they don't monitor
who's accessing what, and they don't have two-factor authentication on, so they're really
ripe, easy targets for ransomware. I want to talk specifically about a platform, and I want to tell
you that I would say I'm paranoid, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong. And you tell me if I have a tinfoil
hat on or there's any logic to my fears here. When I started being very openly critical on Twitter of Putin, I started finding that a lot of people came into my feed with a very basic, Scott, love your work.
It's always the same thing.
Love your work, but on this one you have it wrong.
And then slowly but surely.
And when I also, and the threat is internal, started criticizing the septic tank, which is the portfolio of some VCs in San Francisco, all of these bots started showing up. Or if I say Tesla is overvalued, and now my feed is littered with accounts that say very, very disparaging things, and it seemed in a methodical way to be attacking my credibility,
quite frankly. And I click on them, low follower count, and can't find a person here.
I'm under the belief or the notion that if I were in the GRU, that the most cost-effective weapon
would be to identify 1,000, 10,000, 100,000 people who are anti-Russia and just slowly but surely attack their credibility.
And so my question is, is that going on to the extent I think it is?
And two, what do you think?
I think Twitter should have identity.
And I think this First Amendment cloud cover bullshit that what about the journalist in the Gulf reporting on human rights?
I'm like, you know what?
I think we could probably figure that out.
It's pretty easy to see when someone is reporting legitimate news and when they aren't. Is the problem is absolutely out of control as I think it is specifically on Twitter.
And what do you believe should be done around identity or forcing identity on these platforms?
Well, one caveat here I would say is there's a lot of enthusiastic Tesla.
Oh, no, that's internal. Yeah. I don't know if that's the Russians, but I agree with you. I think
Twitter has vastly underestimated what we call sophisticated chatbots these days. They're much
more sophisticated than they were in 2016. They recognize natural language and they can respond in natural language.
And they're taught to search for keywords or, you know, tweets critical of Putin and
come after you.
That is very, very real.
I have talked to former Twitter security folks who say that is one of the reasons they quit
because Twitter was not adequately addressing
the bot problem. And they've come a long way, but they're nowhere near where they need to be.
Also, I have the same problem. I've had things where I've said anything critical of Russia or
tried to attribute a Russian disinformation campaign. And next thing I know, people are
tweeting out cartoons with my face on it walking into a gas chamber.
I mean, really heinous, anti-Semitic stuff.
This is a big problem.
Yeah.
So, I mean, in some ways, yes, I agree with you.
It's the same tradeoff that we always talk, you know, be careful what you wish for.
But yes, my knee jerk reaction is we need better identity on Twitter.
I don't see the same level of vitriol or bots or disinformation on LinkedIn.
LinkedIn is a much-
Because of identity, 100%.
Yes.
And it's not an ad-driven model.
Subscription and identity.
And what do you know, people?
Anyway, I'm sorry, Nicole.
No, it's true.
I've just noticed it just with my book coming out.
The conversations on LinkedIn are nuanced.
They're pleasant,
they're thought-provoking. Twitter is horrible. Yeah, exactly. But then I don't know what to do
about the journalists in the Middle East and how to solve for that. But Saudi Arabia, we caught them
planting spies at Twitter, literally planting employees at Twitter.
So they're working their way around it anyway.
And also Twitter has a profit motive to keep it going, to ignore it.
Yeah.
One of the things people have said is let's get rid of trending topics because that really drives a lot of these bots.
And in Facebook groups and in Facebook certain rules around groups, which is the same thing.
All right, I have one last question for you.
This is how they tell me the world ends.
How does the world end for us from a cyber point?
If you had the worst case scenario for you, what is it?
Well, the worst case scenario
is sort of where we already are.
Oh dear.
You know, where our intellectual property-
Don't one minute to midnight me.
You're one minute.
You and I should,
you and I should roll.
You and I are the same.
Other than you being
more educated
and more credible,
we have the same view
of the world.
Yeah.
Well, so they're out
to get you, Scott.
I like the glass
half empty kind of guest.
Okay.
All right.
Go ahead.
Rock on, my sister.
Rock on.
Yeah.
Okay.
How does it end?
No, I mean, we are, Russia's in our government networks. They're in our grid. They've gotten into the
power plants. We've seen them break into nuclear plants. Our hospitals are getting ransomware.
China is making off with our intellectual property. And our water treatment facilities
are now getting hacked. The reason
the worst case scenario is just one more minute away is because no one has actually used these
accesses to turn off the power yet. But it doesn't mean it's two clicks away. So that's why, you know,
this is how they tell me the world ends. It's time to just really wake up. Because what are we
waiting for? Are we waiting for them to turn
off our lights? Are we waiting for this geopolitical trigger? Or do we want to do something
right now? And I think the answer is we probably should start doing something right now.
So Ted Cruz may be a victim. No, I'm kidding. He's not at all.
Oh, God. Oh, God. Why?
No, because Texas. It seems to be the weather in that case, at least.
Oh, right. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, how interesting. I mean, I've been talking about what would be the threat if the power got turned off
or the drinking water supply was contaminated.
And it turns out it wasn't a cyber attack.
It was just this underinvestment in winterizing.
But, you know.
Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
That's what it would look like.
Yep, 100%.
Anyway, Nicole, thank you so much.
Her book is This Is How They Tell Me the World Ends.
It's so worth it.
It reads like a thriller.
Is there going to be a movie?
There's a TV show.
I can say that now.
This will be my big announcement.
Oh, wow.
I'm telling you.
Freaking news.
FX optioned it, so it'll be a TV show.
So who's going to star as you?
I don't think I'm going to even be in it.
They're making it much more interesting.
Okay.
She plays all the like.
I love her.
She's really good.
Jessica Chastain.
Oh, yeah, yeah.
She's in a lot of these.
Such a babe.
She's such a babe.
All right.
Oh, God.
You're just like Scott.
I don't see looks, Nicole.
She's just a very impressive, intelligent woman.
You are like a Scott lady.
It's terrible with a lot better hair.
In any case, Nicole, thank you so much for coming on.
Congrats on the book, Nicole.
Thank you. Thanks a lot. Thank you. So fun talking to you guys. In any case, Nicole, thank you so much for coming on. Congrats on the book, Nicole. Thank you.
Thanks a lot.
Thank you.
So fun talking to you guys.
Likewise.
That was Nicole Pearl Roth.
Scott, I knew you would like her.
I did, yeah.
She's a cyber brilliant reporter.
And she reinforces my paranoia, which I like.
Oh, great.
Perfect.
All right, they are out to get you, Scott.
They really are.
We'll be back after this for wins and fails.
Scott. They really are. We'll be back after this for wins and fails. powered customer platform that builds campaigns for you, tells you which leads are worth knowing, and makes writing blogs, creating videos, and posting on social a breeze.
So now, it's easier than ever to be a marketer. Get started at HubSpot.com slash marketers.
The Capital Ideas Podcast now features a series hosted by Capital Group CEO,
Mike Gitlin. Through the words and experiences of investment professionals,
you'll discover what differentiates their investment approach,
what learnings have shifted their career trajectories,
and how do they find their next great idea.
Invest 30 minutes in an episode today.
Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
Published by Capital Client Group, Inc.
Okay, Scott, wins and fails.
Do you have any?
Do you have any?
Yeah, I always have them, and I literally develop them as I'm talking to you.
Here's a fascinating win.
This is not really a win or a fail.
I just discovered all these girl singers.
You know, I'm aware of Selena Gomez and the rest of them and Britney Spears, et cetera, and things like that. But I'm thinking
of interviewing someone. I'm trying to think about whether it's, I think, Jojo Siwa, who is this,
she was on Dance Moms. She wears a thing in her hair, a bow in her hair all the time. She's really
kind of crazily a capitalistic something.
She's selling shampoo and stuff like that.
Well, she just came out as a lesbian and she's doing it with the same cheerleading enthusiasm
she does in selling shampoo or dancing or dances.
And so I'm fascinated by her.
And I just think she's a win on some weird level
because she's got my attention.
I can't even explain it.
I have absolutely no comment on that.
I know that.
Well, she's in that genre of Britney Spears, but
different. What's her name again?
I'm sorry. Jojo Sua.
How do you say her last name?
S-I-W-A.
And recently,
a rapper attacked her. This guy named
DaBaby. DaBaby.
When you say attacked, what do you mean? He's had
some line in one of his songs
that attacked her.
It's just fascinating.
I love all this pop stuff.
I'm very interested in the pop stuff.
Fail?
John Corrin just did it at the hearings for Merrick Garland,
bringing up the Steele dossiers again.
I mean, honestly, these people.
Someone said it's like the mixtapes of the right wing.
It's Hillary's emails, Hunter Biden, the Steele dossier.
They've got to get a new act.
And if Trump comes back tomorrow and doesn't have some new material, I think we need to move along.
Okay.
Thank you.
What are yours?
So, my win is the news around, not only the news that 89% of people who are, I don't know, was it a reduction of 89% of transmission once you had the vaccine?
Yeah, 89 in Israel, yeah.
So that is incredibly, that's just wonderful news that further supports the vaccines. Our numbers are plummeting too since people have been getting it.
Well, that's my actual win is that distinct of all the well-documented and warranted deficiencies
in how we've handled the novel coronavirus. We are, as a percentage of
the population, vaccinating, rolling out the vaccinations as well or better than every nation
in the world except for five. Better than Canada, better than Japan. There's just a small number of
nations, including Israel and the UAE and a few others that are doing a better job. And a lot of
it is, A, we have tremendous manufacturing capability. Pfizer and Moderna are producing the vaccines here in the U.S. You do have to give
Operation Warp Speed and the previous administration some credit for committing a billion dollars to
these companies. So they bought a ton of vaccine early. And then our healthcare workers are
frontline workers. So our win is we are, I don't want to say we're not getting ahead of this thing,
but we are vaccinating at a great rate. Americans are embracing their brothers and sisters and
getting their brothers and sisters off this beach of death, if you will. So, I think the vaccine
rollout, credit where credit's due, is really starting to get momentum. And I think, according to a lot of people,
you're going to see, you know,
the infrastructure every day, not only,
I mean, if you loosely break it down,
and it's vaccines and then the distribution system
that actually inoculates or vaccinates people,
each of those things is getting better every day.
Still, I'm going to stop you.
So 500,000 deaths we passed.
I mean, so unnecessary, the amount, and when you compare it. Agreed. This is going to stop you. Still, 500,000 deaths we passed. I mean, so unnecessary
the amount when you compare it. Agreed.
This is going to be looked at, studied
forever, like who didn't get it and why.
A century. The other countries like
us just didn't die at the rates we
did. And so, therefore, either
we're a sickly group of people here in the United States
or we're a bunch of assholes.
Well, the answer is yes.
We are, I mean, the reality is we are overweight
and we are, but it wasn't our physiology
that really hurt us.
It was our arrogance and anyways, and our competence.
But we've spent a lot of time talking about that.
Yeah.
The vaccine rollout in America is, on a relative basis,
is actually going really well.
That's my win.
And then my fail is,
I think the continued war on the poor
as evidence are manifested in what's happening in Texas
with these utilities that are demand priced
and they sign up people.
And there's instances where it's taken
out of your checking account
and there's senior citizens
who've seen their electricity bill
go to $7,500 for a week.
And what choice do you have?
It's like, well, I could either freeze to death as a 75-year-old retired cross-card.
People have.
And so you've had these seniors and low- and middle-income people literally wiped out.
Little kids.
And essentially, it's just the same war.
And that is we want to disparage government and infrastructure.
Why?
Because if you can't afford heat but you're rich, you can get heated by the Ritz-Carlton and Cancun.
You can go buy that heat, right?
So, any reduction, a disparagement of government—
That was a Ted Cruz reference for people who haven't been paying attention to that fatuous popin' joke.
Thank you for that.
for people who haven't been paying attention to that fatuous pop and jay.
Thank you for that.
If you, when you cut funding,
and granted, I actually think that crisis
is a terrible thing to waste.
I think I'm not in favor of giving states
and local governments bailouts
unless it goes directly to schools,
because I do think a lot of states,
including California, including New York,
have to have some tough conversations
with how they spend people, specifically unions.
I do think there just needs to be more efficiency. But having said that, generally, when you disparage and underfund
and start this greed against government, and not only that, investments in public infrastructure,
that really is just a transfer of wealth from the poor to the rich, because it's poor people
that need a train running every 15 minutes to get to work. It's poor people that need to know,
and middle-income people that need to know
that electricity isn't going to go to $7,500 a week
if a crisis hits.
Yeah, you know, they didn't cut the numbers in New York.
They haven't cut into transit, which was interesting.
I don't know if you saw that.
There was threats to cut into transit,
and then they didn't.
Yep.
Well, that's good news.
A lot across the country, which is interesting.
I do think there's going to be,
I know you don't think it should go to state and federal to which is interesting. I do think there's going to be,
I know you don't think it should go to state and federal to deal with them.
And a lot of them have done a little better than they thought.
I think a lot of municipalities, including D.C.,
thought they had a much lesser tax base
than they thought, and now they're getting a little bit.
And then so they sort of had these drastic cut things,
scenarios, and I know in D.C.
I think they have $500 million more
than they thought they were going to have.
This is so fascinating.
It is interesting.
You know what's happening in New Jersey
and Manhattan, New York?
Tax revenues are up.
No, this is in D.C.
I think it's across many municipalities.
I think it's in California.
There's all kinds of things
where it's not quite hitting the bottom line
as much as they thought it would.
Maybe over time it certainly will,
maybe if they don't recover economically.
But one of the things, as I told you when I interviewed someone last week with this idea of COVID learnings, like what do we learn from this? And I think this is going to be
one of the things is if we really look, this is such an opportunity to look at every facet of
society and understand the failures, why they happened the way they did, what was the cause of
them. I mean, it'll be argued forever and used politically,
but rather than doing the reductive political thing is like,
Trump, you killed us, or, you know, Biden, you saved us,
this kind of thing, which they're going to do, and that's fine, whatever.
We have to really look at, like, what actually happened.
I'm excited to see, you know, what people like Raj Chetty come out with, all these economists
in terms of what it's going to do
and then how it's going to change because things like
telecommuting, you can see
there's going to be more of it.
There's obviously, and it's been
even though we all hate Zoom, I think
we're going to continue to do it.
Telehealth is another area that I think is going
to progress really fast.
But teleschool, no.
Has anyone written a book on this, on who the winners and losers are post-COVID?
Sounds like you should.
Thank you.
Yeah, post-corona.
But I think even more so, study the actual numbers.
Who's that lesbian who's the cheerleader who just came out?
Who's that?
That's what I want to talk about.
It's so confusing.
I hate when lesbians don't fit in their
presupposed genres.
Stereotypes?
I really,
it's like,
oh,
now I have to come up
with another genre
of lesbian.
I think it's dangerous
to make stereotypes.
Do you own a Subaru?
Do you own a Subaru?
I did.
I had one.
I loved Subaru.
I did.
I did.
I did for years.
That's ridiculous.
I had a Subaru.
Of course I did.
I had children,
but that is the chosen
of my people
not that there's anything
wrong with that
they're great cars
no I don't believe
in stereotypes
it's just like
it's such an interesting
world now
in a way it didn't
used to be
there's the sporty lesbian
there's the angry lesbian
there's the
anyway sorry
you're both of those things
I'm not
so
just angry
and
and skirting the edge
of cancellation.
Here he is.
I find the lesbians are much less harsh on me.
They are.
They don't care.
You know, they're like, yeah, you're funny, whatever.
Whatever.
Come to our conference.
Yeah, whatever.
That's right.
We'll beat you up if we need to.
No, it's straight white women that have decided they're outraged for everybody around me.
Anyways, and tech bros. Even the tech bros don't like me lately.
I know, what is that? That's interesting. It is interesting.
Everybody likes me.
I can confirm that is not
true. Anyways,
but what you said before was really interesting.
Do you know what the tax revenue
in D.C., New Jersey State,
and New York State? The tax
revenue is up.
Up, that's what I said.
It's up.
And that was such a shocker because all we hear about
is wealthy people moving to Texas and California
to take advantage,
to realize their capital gain
and have lower taxes on it.
And I think it's got to be a function of the stock market.
I think it's got to be the capital gains,
the taxes they're getting
from an explosion in the stock market.
What'll be interesting, what'll be interesting, Cara, is what happens in 24 to 36 months when things normalize and the tax base, because so much wealth has left these states, what happens then?
That's when you're going to see a fiscal crisis.
It should be interesting because right now, suddenly, I mean, I have this other house that I couldn't sell at the beginning of COVID.
Everybody wants to buy a house now.
Like, it's really interesting.
There's this weird pent-up demand for things, which we'll see where it goes.
We'll see where it goes.
Everyone does want to get out.
You can feel it.
You can feel it.
We are going to have.
Okay, we're going to have.
We're in the last mile of this.
We have a trillion dollars that has not been spent in stimulus.
We have $500 billion in additional savings for families because they're not going to Disney World
or to Chipotle or wherever.
You have a trillion and a half dollars
waiting on the sidelines.
You have so much emotion, people waiting to get out.
It is gonna be the roaring 20s for 24 months.
It's gonna be Sodom and Gomorrah.
I don't know what you would call it.
It's gonna be- It's be I want to go on a vacation
it's going to be
so out of control
I have to say
what did I do last night
looked at where I could go
for Christmas
like somewhere great
and I'm like
I'm getting the big one
and where does
I got to be honest
I'm doing the same thing
where does Kara Swisher
want to go that she thinks
is somewhere great
for the holidays
Hawaii
I love Hawaii
oh you love Hawaii
that's right
I love Hawaii
I don't even just Hawaii speaks to me I love Hawaii Hawaii I, you love Hawaii. That's right. You love Hawaii. I love Hawaii. I don't even just, Hawaii speaks to me.
I love Hawaii.
Hawaii.
I'm going to Hawaii.
And I'm getting the big one.
Hawaii speaks to you.
I'm getting the big one.
Hawaii speaks to you.
Does it take you to another place?
I love it there.
I don't know what it is about that.
It's beautiful.
There's certain places.
Is there somewhere like that for you?
I just, the minute I went there, I felt like I was home.
It sounds crazy.
Vegas strip clubs speak to me on a very emotional level.
On a very soulful level.
Scott will be appearing nightly in the big penthouse at the Caesars.
My favorite.
I think Italy.
I want to go back to Italy.
Oh, yeah.
Well, watch Stanley Tucci, your doppelganger.
That's right.
You watch him.
I appreciate you say that.
That guy's handsome.
I mean, it's awesome.
Yeah, he is.
He looks good.
He wears a suit well.
Everyone looks good in this thing.
It makes you long for better businesses.
Is it European porn where they just show how beautiful a city is? It's literally European. That's exactly what it is. He looks good. He wears a suit. Well, everyone looks good in this thing. It makes you long for better businesses. Is it European porn where they just show how beautiful a city is?
It's literally European.
That's exactly what it is.
You're like, why am I not driving?
If you like Euro porn, I've got a show for you.
Oh, we already talked about Killing Eve is total Euro porn.
Oh, yeah.
They take a city and they take fashion in that city and they just put it on display.
Okay, fine.
But this is just pure.
Pure.
That's food porn, right?
I'm not into food. That's the only problem. Chianti. Okay, fine. But this is just pure. Pure. That's food porn, right? I'm not into food.
Here's a nice glass of Chianti.
Let's go.
All right.
This is such a nice feeling.
Let's go to Italy.
Can we have a pivot event in Italy?
Yeah.
Actually, I'm not dying to spend more time with you, but I would like to get to know Amanda better.
So maybe send her.
You stay home with the Subaru and the kids.
I want to take Amanda and the new one.
I want to take your little one.
She's a cutie.
She is a cutie.
She's welcome.
She is a cutie.
She's got a lot going on.
I'm very excited.
That is a win for me in 2020, 19, and 21.
Anyway, Scott, that's the show.
We're leaving on a happy note.
Look at that, how we are.
Here we are trying to bring hope to the world.
That's our job.
We'll be back on Friday for more.
There's a lot going on this week.
We'll be back sort of slagging people
as soon as possible.
By the way, speaking of which,
we're going to talk on Thursday.
I did an interview with Sasha Baron Cohen
yesterday on my weekend.
You're kidding me.
No, 90 minutes.
I don't think we'll use all 90 minutes.
Well, I'm sorry.
Sasha Baron Cohen.
Oh, it's so great.
We're going to have him on our show.
Oh, no, wait.
Let me guess.
You had him on your other podcast.
That guy is my fucking hero.
And you take him on Sway?
Jesus Christ.
You know what?
He doesn't give many long interviews.
I'm not talking to you.
He's not coming on.
We're doing the credits.
Hit me for 20 minutes.
I'm not talking to you.
I will get him now.
I am not talking to you.
No, you're talking.
That guy is literally my role model.
Well, you're going to love this interview.
He went.
He talked.
Okay. I'll be sure to tune in.
Jesus Christ.
All right, enough of that.
Sasha Baron Cohen went on your podcast.
I've been working on that for years.
It's a long podcast.
He doesn't want to do these 20-minute ones.
He wanted a long amount of time to talk, and that was an hour.
We'll get him on.
We will get him on an event we're doing, okay?
We're going to do an event, and I'm going to put you on stage with him.
How about that?
Gosh.
If he'll do it.
That guy's a total gangster.
He is.
He's fantastic.
He's very funny.
He's very funny.
Fearless, creative, socially conscious.
Yes.
Ridiculously hot wife.
Not that I've noticed, nor does that add a criteria for being a gangster.
Okay.
All right.
I'm sorry.
We're going to talk about Sacha Baron Cohen, and you don't have to listen to it. We'll have clips and everything. Sorry, Scott. I don't
know what to say to you. They all want to come on the sway. The sway is the sway. It's what it is.
I will get him. I get lots of people here. Don't you worry about it. Anyway. You're probably going
to get that woman who just came, that cheerleader who just came out of the, that's who we get.
That's who we get. Glee meets Golden Girls meets, I don't know, meets the L word.
You kidding?
We have great people.
Give me a break.
Anyway, go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit your questions.
That's right.
We had Bill Gates.
Oh, no, that was Sway, too.
That was Sway, too.
Okay.
Anyway, anyway.
And we have someone talking about cybersecurity.
Well, it's just fucking Easter here every day.
It's an Easter parade here every day.
Send in a question about envy.
Envy and fear and loathing.
I'm the other family.
I'm literally the other family.
Like every other weekend you swing by and you bring a pair of Adidas for me and a Bane skateboard.
I'm the other family.
I'm literally the other family.
I'm not going to tell you who's coming on to sway really soon, but it's big.
There's a lot of big ones.
I'm going to read us out.
Today's show, producing more with less because one of us is not invested in this podcast,
but still, nonetheless, turning chicken shit into chicken salad is Rebecca Sinanis,
who produced the show.
Annie Nintertod engineered this episode.
Thanks also to Hannah Rosen and Drew Burrows. Make sure you're subscribed. Chicken shit into chicken salad is Rebecca Sonanas, who produced the show. Annie Ninja Todd engineered this episode.
Thanks also to Hannah Rosen and Drew Burrows.
Make sure you're subscribed.
If you liked our show, please recommend it to a friend.
Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media.
We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
The question isn't whether or not you want to get COVID. The question is whether you want your loved ones to get COVID.
Get vaccinated. 90% reduction to get COVID. Get vaccinated.
90% reduction in transmission when you are vaccinated.
This is a wonderful day for America and for the world.
Also, nice bang, Scott.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Support for this podcast comes from Anthropic.
It's not always easy to harness the power and potential of AI.
For all the talk around its revolutionary potential,
a lot of AI systems feel like they're designed for specific tasks,
performed by a select few.
Well, Claude, by Anthropic, is AI for everyone.
The latest model, Claude 3.5 Sonnet,
offers groundbreaking intelligence at an everyday price.
Claude Sonnet can generate code, help with writing, and reason through hard problems
better than any model before. You can discover how Claude can transform your business at
anthropic.com slash Claude. Support for this podcast comes from Klaviyo. You know that feeling when your favorite brand really gets you.
Deliver that feeling to your customers every time.
Klaviyo turns your customer data into real-time connections across AI-powered email, SMS, and more, making every moment count. Over 100,000 brands trust Klaviyo's unified data and marketing platform to build
smarter digital relationships with their customers during Black Friday, Cyber Monday, and beyond.
Make every moment count with Klaviyo. Learn more at klaviyo.com slash BFCM.