Pop Culture Happy Hour - We Fantasy Cast The Traitors

Episode Date: February 18, 2025

The Peacock reality show The Traitors continues to be a delightful mix of treachery, foolishness, and Alan Cumming's outfits. In the United States, the cast is made up exclusively of so-called celebrities. So today on the show we're fantasy casting who we think should be on the next season of The Traitors.In the run-up to the Oscars, Pop Culture Happy Hour is watching all 10 best picture nominees – and you're invited to join us! Sign up for the NPR Movie Club newsletter series and tell us what you thought of the movies you watched this week. Subscribe to Pop Culture Happy Hour Plus at plus.npr.org/happyhourSee pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.NPR Privacy Policy

The reality show The Traders, now in its third season, continues to be a delightful mix of treachery, foolishness, good and bad strategy, and Alan Cummings outfits. But with the way they're ripping through our supply of reality stars, are they going to run out of good casting ideas? No, no, they are not, because we are here with some fresh inspiration. I'm Stephen Thompson. And I'm Linda Holmes, and today on NPR's Pop Culture Happy Hour, we are fantasy casting, the next season of the Traders. Joining us today are our fellow co-hosts, Aisha Harris.

Hello, Aisha. Here and ready for murder, my friends. And also, Glenn Weldon, hello, Glenn. Hi, greetings, Linda Holmes. Very good. I appreciate the fact that both of you went with the accent. Went at the accent. Yes, yes, yes. Herald ourselves against the accent.

I love it. So the traders exist not only in the United States, but in several other countries as well. It streams here on Peacock. And the cast this year included 23 celebrities, including four survivors, four Real Housewives, representatives of the Bachelor, Tom Sandoval from La Faire Vanderpump Rules, a former WWE wrestler, Zach Efron's brother, Britney Spears, ex-husband. And I am not making this up. The aristocrat. Host Alan Cumming takes them through a game where a small number of secretly appointed traitors among them meets in private to figuratively murder members of the rest of the group and the whole group meets together to banish somebody who they think is a traitor.

So basically the traitors are trying to keep it a secret that they're traitors and the rest of the players who are faithfuls are trying to identify and banish the traitors. if that makes sense. Not every version of the traders around the world relies exclusively on celebrities or celebrity-ish product, but it's not really surprising that that is how we do it here. In celebration of that fact, we decided that we would get together and each suggest someone that we would cast if we were in charge of putting together the group for a future season. Stephen, I'm going to start with you. Who did you choose to go on the traitors? Okay, so thinking about this assignment made me think about the secret ingredients that make the traders great.

It's not just dazzling traitor play. It's not just master strategists from other reality shows. It's not people who turn out to be great at strategy that you wouldn't expect to be great at strategy like Pilot Pete from the Bachelor or Zach Efron's brother this season. it's not just people reading social cues and setting strategic traps. Part of why I love the traders is that they know to also cast people who have no idea what's going on. As much as I love watching someone like Surrey Fields from Survivor or Pilot Pete from The Bachelor turn out to be great at the traders, I also love watching people where you're basically watching someone lose at Tic-Tac-Tow against a simple barnyard chicken. My version of fantasy casting the traitors is to tap into America's Strategic Oaf Preserve to find the next Ryan Locti, the next Tom Sandoval, the next mostly harmless lunk who's going to bug his eyes out and be like, I knew Boston Rob was a traitor after like six episodes where Boston Rob was obviously a traitor.

So my pick next in line from the Strategic Oaf Preserve, former NFL tight end, Rob Grunkowski. Oh. Okay. I have no idea who that is. That's a good idea. Basically, Gronk's whole deal.

You've seen him in commercials and whatnot. He does these USAA commercials. And his whole persona is that he's kind of a wide-eyed man child. To me, Grank doing battle with survivor strategists and duplicitous housewives. The fact that they call him

Gronk and it really seems appropriate kind of gives you the feel of the guy. I mean, it reminds me of Kronk from M. person of group. Of course. And honestly, that's not too far off persona-wise. They're actually pretty similar. But anyway, like, watching him do battle with people who are actually good at the traders would be TV gold. And I'm, I would be stunned if they haven't already driven a dump truck full of money up to his house to get him to join the next cast. Yeah, it's very believable.

Also, to me, the more you set this up as an archetype, the more you can surprise people with folks who appear to be dummies but are actually great at the game and might actually be great at being traitors. You would never make Gronk a traitor, I don't think. This is where I would offer a bonus recommendation, former running back Marshawn Lynch. Oh, yes. I know him. Oh, see, yeah, he'd be good. Too smart, I think. Too crafty, I think. But this is the thing. So you make him a traitor. This is the thing. This is why I think people would think he was part of the strategic oath preserve, but actually he's not only very funny, but I think he would be good at being a traitor.

Well, and I will say there was an improv comedy show. I don't know if you remember this on Netflix where they were doing like a crime of the week. It was Will Arnett. Yes. It was like a bunch of comedians and Marshawn Lynch. And the funniest thing about it was that the person who fared the best in the improv, I thought, was Marshaun Lynch.

So the relationship between reality shows. contestanting and improv is, you know. There's some overlap. So I get it. I'm with you. Stephen, not only do I think you have successfully predicted the next season of this show. I got to say, Marshaun Lynch is going to be a lot better TV than Granc.

That's just my instinct. They're very, very different. But I think one way you sneak Marshaun Lynch in as a traitor is by setting up the archetype of the oath. I'm just saying, in general, I love oaths on traitors. I want gronk next, and then I want Marshaun Lynch, who is actually no oath. I get that. I just love to watch a guy get confused.

Your criteria is mouth breather. Yes. That's true. All right. I love that pick, Stephen. I love that pick. And I love, namely, Marshaun Lynch. Aisha, who did you choose?

Okay, so let's be real. I started watching Traders with Season 2, and my reality TV does. Diet is not the same as what usually shows up on Traders. So especially this current season, I knew absolutely no one on this show. I didn't know a lot. Yeah, I was familiar with Baba Drag Queen. And, oh, actually, once Wes came on, I was like, oh, Wes, yes, I watched the challenge for, like, far too long. So that's it.

And the joy of the show, I think, is that, like, I don't have to know because everyone is a type and you learn the type within the first episode and you know who they are. Absolutely. So it was a little tough for me to kind of figure out, okay. Who would I think, like, let me reach back into the recesses of my mind when I was watching more of these types of reality shows. Back when I was watching, you know, surreal life, various rock of love, flavor of love, whatever, from VH1, that era. Charm School. Yes, Charm School. And I finally landed upon none other than Tiffany Pollard, aka New York.

Oh, sure. From the first couple of seasons of flavor of love. Now, she was. the breakout star of that show, she was unhinged in her commitment to being the winner. And, oh, I should set this up for people who probably do have no idea what I'm talking about, Flavor Flav, who recently has had a Renaissance, a resurgence in the culture and who I actually thought of first for this. And then I was like, Flavor Flav's too good for this show.

I don't want him in this reality show world anymore. Leave him out of it. But on that show, which was a kind of spinoff of a show of. the surreal life because he was on that show, he was trying to find a woman to date him and, you know, become his, his girlfriend or whatever. And Tiffany was nicknamed New York and she became the one person who was like, I'm going to be the bad woman in this house. I'm going to be. She was the Omarosa, except it was less fraught because there were lots of other black women. She wasn't the sole black woman.

So there were lots of different types of black women. So it was like, I was okay with it. It's fine. She had many infamous moments, including one of the other contestants claiming that her friends said that she reminds them of Beyonce. And part of why I think that she would be good on a show like traitors is because do I think that she would necessarily be good as a traitor or a faithful? The problem is that she was known for being sort of the bad person, the one who doesn't give any cares about what anyone thinks of her is proud of that. And I think when you come onto a show like traitors, oftentimes people are going to think that you're probably a traitor, which is not helpful because then they're all going to be gutting for you. But also, if you're a faithful, people are still going to think you're a traitor.

And then it's like, oh, like, how do you play this? I don't know if she'd be actually good at this game. But what she would be good at is giving us at least two to three episodes of just pure gold of entertainment. And the same way, Steve, and you like watching the Oafs go, you know, try, like just talk themselves. into the complete wrong person. I love when we have a little bit of like, you know, some diva behavior. And we have some, like, the housewives, I think they get an unfair wrath. They're often not that bad.

Like, everyone kind of gangs up on housewives in a weird way. But I think it would all kind of maybe turn to Tiffany. And let's be real. She's grown at least. She's done other, you know, reality shows. I think she would provide the comedy, the gold. I think, you know, maybe a comparable former, you know, traitor guest was probably like maybe Fadre. And Fadra actually turned out to be pretty good as a traitor. She was fun to watch. Yeah, she was

fun to watch. I think we need that. I think we need Tiffany. We need someone who like is going to give off the cuff comments who actually might get very confused as well, but in a different way than the Oaves. And we'll just like bring a little bit of fun to the game in a way that like we haven't quite seen before. So I want New York. I want Tiffany Pollard. I miss her. I like this pick. I like this pick, too. I think that era of like MTV and VH1, like, reality shows is a very, like, specific moment that the fact that there was not only Rock of Love, but then there was Rock of Love bus. Like, yes.

I'm glad to see that branch of reality shows represented because it hasn't been. If we can pinpoint a traitor behavior, and I think that's an open question, but if you can, it's the sewing of chaos. And Tiffany, that is her metier. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Is the very air that she breathes.

Love that. Love that. All right. Tiffany Pollard, thank you very much, Aisha Harris. The best way to explain my pick is to remind you that we once had a comedy series, the beginning of which went. She was working at a bridal shop for washing queens. The boyfriend issued her out in one of those crushing scenes. Yeah.

She's pretty busy. I am not suggesting we get. Randrusher. What you need to know is it in the song and she says, Taylor, boyfriend kicked her out in one of those crushing scenes. The boyfriend was played on the nanny eventually by a stunning blue-eyed actor by the name of Jonathan Penner. And Jonathan Penner then went on to appear three times on Survivor. One of my all-time favorite Survivor contestants. He played Survivor three times. He played Survivor. And it wasn't the very beginning. He played in the 13th season. No, he played Cook Islands. Cook Islands, which is the famous, Separate the Teams by Race.

Oh, God. Yes. And then he was again on the 16th season, fans versus favorites. He went home early with an injury. That season, very, very sad for me. And then on the 25th season, which was in the Philippines. He never won, but particularly in Cook Islands, he very much changed the direction of that season. And the thing about him is he is ruthlessly practical and logical.

while also having no patience for people who are jerks. And that combination has always been irresistible to me. Without getting too into the weeds, what happened in the Cook Island season is that Jonathan was part of an alliance that was the theoretical majority. But he found out that because of one of the game's little quirks, this immunity idol that they have, if they voted the way that they plan to, his majority group, it might backfire and he himself might be voted out. So he prevailed on his team. He said, we have to change the plan. we can't do that because I will end up getting voted out if we do this. They blew him off. They thought he was just being paranoid.

They said, oh, you know, and he was very conflicted about what to do. And I found his ways of describing it very funny. And I brought a clip. Oh, yes. Either way, people are going to be pissed. Either I'll have betrayed the Rero people and I'm a complete bastard or I didn't jump over to the I two people. And I'm a complete bastard who screwed them twice. I don't know what I'm going to do.

Is that a New York accent? I'm detecting. I assume. It sounded very New York. The result was that he did switch sides to protect himself. He voted out a member of his own team. I mean, he definitely was very imperiled by the situation, but he also just really didn't like the people who were on his own team because they were jerks. So he flipped. His team got very angry, in part because they were sure that the person he thought had the idol didn't. unaware that that person had actually showed the idol to Jonathan.

So he already knew they had the idol. If I didn't throw in with them, they all would have voted for me. You all would have voted for Yule and it would have bounced off Yule and hit me. Yule, you know, doesn't have the idol. Yule does have the idol.

He showed me the idol. I don't know what you think you're talking about. Oh, those little loser noises where it goes, so the thing that makes us one, So the thing that makes this wonderful for traitor's purposes is that the person in that clip who is saying he doesn't have the idol is one parvety shallow. Survivor later decided was a genius and a brilliant player, and she had a couple seasons where she played very well. Yes.

However, in this season, she was completely just defeated soundly by specifically this move by him. I very, very much like him. He is a guy. I did, like, meet a couple times at Survivor parties back when I used to cover Survivor. He's a lovely person. But more to the point, I just think he's a really fun presence in something like this because he is incredibly strategic, but he also gets on people's nerves. Yes.

So he's irritable and emotional, but he's also very good at sitting down and playing out strategy. And I don't even know if I would want him to be a traitor or a face. I would love watching him on this show. He sounds like he'd be better as a faithful, to be honest. He might very well. Seems like the type who might be able to convince other people, like, here's what we need to do. That is very true. And people would probably think he was a traitor because he kind of has this reputation for being, like, slippery.

I think more than he actually is. I think he would make a great faithful who gets recruited as a traitor part way through the season. Oh, yeah. So my vote goes to the great Jonathan Penner, one of my very very. favorite survivors of all time. And if we can have Boston Rob on, we can definitely have Penner on. Oh, definitely. Yeah. Glenn, I have a feeling that you have something epic in store. I don't know what it is. Well, I mean, y'all remember, I was kind of worried when this topic was pitched because the only reality show I watch is drag race. And drag queens are already in this

mix, right? It wouldn't be a breakthrough. I wouldn't shatter a ceiling. And I thought, well, if this is fantasy casting, I want to lead into the fantasy, right? So here's a hint. The initials KF. Any of guesses? KF. Middle initial T. Oh, my gosh. Last name, frog. Oh, first name is Kermit. I thought we're still talking about drag queens. Kermit T. Frog.

Now, hear me out. There would be some legal and logistical hurdles to clear. Peacock is NBC Universal. Kermit is Disney. They don't play well together. Logistically, you'd have to creatively shoot the entire season so you don't see the puppeteer, or the Muppeteer, I guess. How is he going to do challenges?

He's at the bar a lot. He's at the bar lot. He's at the barline. You would need to dig a pit that the Muppeteer could stand in at the round table. And, you know, every time he has to write a name on a chalkboard, you'd have to cut away. You know, allowances would need to be made. I'm not saying it would be easy. And, you know, in the physical challenges, he probably couldn't hold his own, you know, unless they involved riding a bicycle or playing the banjo.

I do think he would be great on this show. And when I pitched it to our producers, Liz and Jessica, they were like big time pilot Pete Energy. And I get it right. Contestinal on Season 2, we already talked about, affable, amiable, also a good player. And that's his whole thing, right? Affable, amiable. So you don't make him a faithful. That's the rookie move.

You make him a traitor. Consider, what does he do for a living? He stands at the very center of chaos. He'd keep a cool head. What he would do is he would win people over, especially these people, because he is a enthusiast, right? So every D-list reality show star he meets in that castle, he'd go up to them and he'd treat them like they're his very special guest star, and then he'd say their name, and then he'd go, yay! And now all these people are narcissists, so they would eat that up, they would come to trust him.

Some other negatives. He's given to self-pity, that whole, it's not easy being green thing. And that is, you know, dude, that is your privilege talking. And Lord knows if he tries to whip out a banjo, he'd be that guy at the party, and he'd make some enemies. So I was thinking, maybe not Kermit, maybe some other Muppet. But everyone I came up with, I had reasons to shoot them down. So pitch me, pitch me some Muppets here. I think, I mean, I would say Miss Piggy.

Yeah, sure. Like, yeah. I was thinking animal is basically the grunk. Sure. Certainly mouth breathers. But I think piggy, fossey, and animal in three different ways are all extra. And extra doesn't get you very far in the show. Sure.

Because it's got to be Kermit because he is humble in a castle full of people with very inflated senses of selves. There's even a meme of him in a hood in like a cloak with a hood. Think of the memes. Anytime anybody is gossiping and throwing out ideas, you just cut away to a shot of Kermit sipping tea. And all of America is going to be pointing at the screen like earlier, DiCaprio. And speaking of memes, yes, Stephen, there is anyone who has seen Muppets' most wanted knows. He looks great in a black cloak. Talent brings their own wardrobe.

Producers love that. So Kermit. Kermit all the way. I am going to say some of the issues that we have talked about with the logistics could be solved if instead we go to Big Bird. Big Bird would be let around by the nose. Big Bird would not be good TV. Big Bird is a born follower. The thing with Kermit is that I think it would be interesting to see him on the show.

I don't think he would make a good trader. I would automatically assume he was a traitor because it just seems like, of course, you're going to make him a traitor. And, you know, we've seen that happens sometimes where people assume the nice person or the sweet one is like they're just like, oh, they have to be like. Or they're always psychinging each other themselves out. Like, well, the traitor wants us to think this or whatever. Granted, oftentimes they just wind up not picking Boston Rob again for like the fifth time. And it's like, what are we doing? I guess I'm trying to think of like who would be best at defending themselves at the roundtable.

Because that's something you have to take into consideration as well. And I do think Kermit would be very entertaining to watch try to defend himself. He's got a good take. He's got a good like shocked face. Yes. Like his mouth kind of wrinkles up and I could totally see that. I mean, I also wanted to just throw out really quickly like Statler and Waldorf could be interesting chaos. I thought about that too.

Like as a team maybe. Yes. Yes. I think you're on to something there. I think that's a good idea. And I mean, any of these options would allow us the promise of Alan coming interacting with any of these Muppets. And I would watch that for sure. That's the other pro-Miss Piggy argument is.

The Miss Piggy and Alan Cumming Hang, I think, needs to happen. Also, like Miss Piggy and Tiffany Pollard together. Yes, please. Let's make that pass. Yeah, that makes sense. I agree. Miss Piggy and Grunk, also good. I mean, listen, I think I am forced to conclude that we just have an abundance of good ideas, and we're just going to have to wait probably several seasons for them to get around to using all of them.

It's safe to say. All right. Well, we want to know who you want to be in the next season. of the traders. Find us at Facebook.com slash PCHH. That brings us to the end of our show. Aisha Harris, Stephen Thompson, Glenn Weldon. Thank you so much for being here. I consider you all faithfuls. Thank you.

Thank you. And just a reminder that signing up for Pop Culture Happy Hour Plus is a great way to faithfully support our show and public radio. And you get to listen to all of our episodes sponsor-free. So please go find out more at plus.npr.org slash happy hour or visit the link in our show notes. This episode was produced by Liz Metzger and edited by Jessica Reedy and Mike Katzif. And Hello, come in, continues to provide our theme music. Thank you for listening to Pop Culture Happy Hour from NPR. I'm Linda Holmes, and we'll see you all next time. Do not get banished before then.