Predictive History - The Story of "Civilization", "Secret History", "Game Theory" and more - Civilization #26 - Constantine's Monotheistic Revolution

Episode Date: October 7, 2025

Civilization #26 - Constantine's Monotheistic Revolution ...

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Okay, so good morning. We are doing monotheism today. And I will show you that the first monotheistic religion is Christianity. And monotheism actually marks in intellectual revolution in human history. And it really created conditions for modernity, the lives we're living today. All right, so let's get started. And I want to review Christianity and what we're living. Christianity and why it grew so fast. So if you talk to Christians, they have a very easy and coherent explanation for why Christianity would come to dominate Europe.
Starting point is 00:00:41 So let's look at the Christian tradition. So it's called the Christian tradition, which is to say we don't have much evidence that this is true, but this is what Christians believe and what they tell each other. So in the Christian tradition, Jesus came from heaven to redeem humanity from our evil ways. He sacrificed himself, and after he sacrificed himself, he started a new beginning in human history. He was resurrected, and then he went before his apostles and told them to spread the good news. the gospel that he has come and he will return and then he will bring paradise with him. Okay, so there were 12 apostles plus Paul and they went all around the world to spread the good news. Paul became the apostle to the Gentiles which meant that he was trying to bring in everyone into the new religion of Christianity. to show their authority and to show that they are actually the true apostles of Jesus,
Starting point is 00:02:01 they are all martyred, okay? Martyr them. Meaning that you know that they were telling the truth because they were persecuted. They went to India, they went to the Lavant, they went everywhere to spread the good news, and they interacted or they challenged the traditional world. religious authority, the pagans of that area, and so they were killed. They were stolen to death, or they were executed. And after they died, their students would continue their legacy. And these students would become head of the local church they set up. And they became known as the bishops. And for all this time, they were being persecuted by the Romans and by the pagans. But
Starting point is 00:02:52 But because of their faith in God and because of the miracle that is God, they would eventually triumph and they would spread throughout Europe and the Middle East and Egypt until they became a very dominant force. Eventually the Romans said, if you can't beat them, join them. And the first Roman emperor to convert was Constantine. So Constantine was the first Roman Emperor to become a Christian himself. And then a later Roman Emperor would make Christianity the official religion of the Roman Empire. And this would create the Catholic Church.
Starting point is 00:03:35 The Catholic Church is called so because Catholic means universal, or the one and only. And the Catholic Church, with the creation of Catholic Church you had a new idea called orthodoxy or right thinking and then so one mission of the Catholic Church was to do us to combat heresy or challenging orthodoxy to make sure that everyone stayed on the true path okay and so this is the official history told by the Catholic Church and what Christians believe today but as we discuss in our class historically that's that what happened okay so let's go over let's review what we discuss in this class so Jesus I argued was a religious genius and he
Starting point is 00:04:44 his idea would be what we call Nazism today okay and unfortunately he got unlucky and he ran into the Roman governor of Judea called Pontius Pilate. Pontius Pilate had a problem. He was trying to enforce the imperial cult. The imperial cult basically just means to think of the emperor as God. And so think of a cult of personality.
Starting point is 00:05:12 His pictures, the statues were everywhere, including coins. And the Jews hated that because for them, that went against a religion. The first commandment is, you should have no God before me, Yahweh. You shall not worship. false gods and so Pontius Pilate was having a very tough time dealing with the Jews
Starting point is 00:05:32 he's throwing the Jews and the Jews said well if you don't if you don't get rid of this religious cult then you have to come kill all of us okay and so Pontus pilot had to back down he lost face and he killed Jesus he crucified Jesus as basically a middle finger to the Jewish people right but because he did that what he didn't expect is it would make Jesus into a national hero, a martyr. And so his followers became called the poor of Jerusalem. They established a church in Jerusalem, and they were supported by the Jewish leaders, and they were called the poor of Jerusalem. They were led by Jesus' brother James, the just. These people will eventually become the Ibionites. This is
Starting point is 00:06:26 important for us because the Ibnites will actually spread to Arabia where they will help develop a new religion called Islam okay so from the Ibinites we will develop a new religion called Islam the poor got a very got along very well with the Jewish people because they just saw themselves as a branch of Judaism as following the law of Moses but in a more but in a manner that could conform to how Jesus saw the world. Then you had a man named Paul. And Paul was a Roman citizen, and he was part of the Roman elite, and he had a problem.
Starting point is 00:07:10 He was part of the Jewish diaspora, and because of the religious fanatism in Jerusalem, that was creating conflict between the Romans and the Jewish diaspora. The Jews believe the Romans were evil, and eventually a Messiah will. emerge from the ranks from the house of David who will lead them in the final victory against the Romans so Paul saw Jesus as an opportunity to basically divorce the Jewish diaspora from the Maasianic Jews okay that's why he created a proto-Christianity because what he believed what he taught is Jesus is the Messiah but rather than a prophet of war, he's a prophet of peace.
Starting point is 00:08:02 And so he basically of an opportunity for members of the Jewish diaspora to assimilate themselves into Roman society. If you consider yourself a Jew, then you believe in the Messiah, who will return and fight against Romans. But if you believe that, then eventually the Romans might come and kill you. So what Paul said is, if you believe in Jewish. Jesus, you can still be Jewish, because Jesus was Jewish, and this is a Jewish religion, but you will be part of the Roman Empire now, rather than part of just this very parental religion.
Starting point is 00:08:41 But what's really important for us to understand is most people refuse to follow Paul. Okay, only very small minority people actually follow Paul. Most people who believe in Jesus were following the Abinites. There's also other groups of people who believed in Jesus. For example, the Gnostics, which we discussed before. And also, you had these mystery cults. Mystery cults were the most popular form of religious worship, which meant they were just like small groups of people
Starting point is 00:09:17 who practiced the religion secretly. And what made these mystery cults special was they're focused on group religious devotion and worship. And they were trying to achieve a sense of oneness, unity. They were trying to be a gotitarian. They were trying to be anti-hieroccal, okay? And what made them interesting was they used psychedelics a lot. They used drugs a lot in order to achieve a spiritual,
Starting point is 00:09:55 sense. And a lot of them start to believe in Jesus because Jesus could be easily incorporated into a religion. So you have these different early Christian groups around. But what we know is that eventually Paul's group, which again is the smallest of these groups, would eventually triumph. Okay? The question then is why? Why is it that Paul's Church, which was the smallest of all these different denominations of early Christianity, why would they triumph in the end? Okay. First of all, the dominant group were obviously James the Just and the poor, right?
Starting point is 00:10:38 Well, what happened was this? From 66 to 73 C.E. The Romans fought a major war with the Jews. And during this war, three things happened. The first thing that happened was the temple was burned down. Remember, the temple is important because it is the site of religious worship for the Jewish people. It's the equivalent of Mecca today.
Starting point is 00:11:09 So when Jews in the diaspora, when they prayed, they prayed in the direction of the temple. Well, now you have a problem because the temple has been burned down. So now you have to redefine what it means to be a Jewish person. And as it happened, Paul had a new definition of what it meant to be Jewish person. You believe in Jesus as a Messiah rather than make sacrifices at the temple. Second thing that happened that was very convenient for Paul in the Romans was James and his group were wiped out. Not everyone was killed, but the majority of them were wiped out.
Starting point is 00:11:50 Their denomination in Jerusalem was targeted and they were extinguished. So this is important because, remember, the major authority figure at this time is James the Just. He because he's the brother of Jesus. If he's dead, there's no more authority. Therefore, Paul can claim, as he does, to be the real authority. The third thing is, that's important, is that basically scares the Jewish diaspora. It scares members of the Jewish diaspora, and a lot of them now see Paul's Church as a very good alternative. They're afraid of what, they're afraid that the Romans might target the diaspora, and so to show their allegiance to the Romans, but still to, but they still want to maintain the Jewish identity, so a lot of them start to join Paul's Church.
Starting point is 00:12:53 Not a great deal, okay, but an increasing number. This would just start one of three major wars between the Romans and the Jews. Okay? There would be two more major wars, and both wars, a lot of Jews would get killed, a lot would get enslaved, and this would drive more participation into Paul's Church. Okay? So a lot of Jews are now joining Paul's Church because of these wars. The church was seen as an escape mechanism for diaspora Jews from these wars.
Starting point is 00:13:28 Does that make sense? All right. The other thing about Paul's church and why became dominant is it mirrored the social structure of the Roman Empire. So the Roman Empire, the social structure is called the Patra Familius. And this is basically the idea of patriarchy. There's one man, the father, who is in charge of the entire household. And the household is basically a small empire onto itself. You have the immediate family, okay?
Starting point is 00:14:04 So you have the sons, the children. You also have the free man. So these are slaves who are freed to work in the household, and then you have the slaves, okay? So they were in charge of their own household, but they also had clients, okay? The client, the patron-client-client relationship. In Chinese, we call this a whole-tie, right?
Starting point is 00:14:29 So someone who would sponsor your business. And the goal of Roman society was to have as many clients as possible because this gave you the idea of faiths, okay? Or what at that time was called dignitas. Dignatast. Social prestige. The more clients you had, the more people who obeyed you, the more dignitas you had.
Starting point is 00:15:00 Okay? So the Paul's church was a hierarchy as well modeled on the Pater Familias. So at the top was the bishop. Okay. And the bishop was in which was something called dogma, which is like how Jesus is to be understood. And this is important because the problem with most early Christians is they were egalitarian, which meant that you could have your own interpretation of Jesus. But in this church, which is hierarchical, only the bishop or the person in charge had the right interpretation,
Starting point is 00:15:42 and you had to follow his interpretation. This allowed the church to scale out into other churches, right? But much more importantly, after you reach a certain size, it may take. sense for the church to participate in the patron-client relationship of the part of the family families which meant that they would now invite a local aristocrat to become the bishop and if that would happen the local bishop would then convert his entire network and become christian right and the aristocrat would agree to do this because it allowed him to more quickly scale out and expand his patron-client network.
Starting point is 00:16:40 The church became a mechanism for him to expand his social network and political power. Eventually, Christianity would reach a point where it actually challenged the authority of the emperor himself. Because remember, throughout history, the nobility was always in conflict with the king, the emperor. And now that the nobility was able to better organize because of the structure of the church, the emperor saw it as a problem. So there were some persecutions, local persecution, not global, not imperial persecution of Christians, there's some local persecutions of emperors because of the power struggle. But eventually emerged an emperor named Constantine, and he had fought a very bitter civil war
Starting point is 00:17:41 in order to reclaim the throne. And as we know from our history, from our reading of history, great kings always want to introduce new religions to consolidate their authority, okay? So think of King David introducing the new religion of Judaism. Think of Augustus introducing the Inniad to the Roman people.
Starting point is 00:18:15 So Constantine wanted to introduce a new religion to unify the empire and to consolidate his authority. And that became the Christian religion. That's why he converted it to become Christian. And so he began to sponsor the beginning of something called the Catholic Church. And guess what? He was the first pope, or the head of the Catholic Church,
Starting point is 00:18:36 the first head of the Catholic Church. But now that you have a Catholic Church, you now have the idea of orthodoxy orthodoxy and that's a problem because remember throughout this history there are many divergent forms of Christianity and so the Catholic Church began a process of eliminating all its competitors until it became the most dominant but the problem with orthodoxy is that a lot
Starting point is 00:19:20 of Christian history is made up. This is made up on the spot. And so there are a lot of contradictions. The major contradiction, one of the major problems in Christianity is, okay, Jesus came from heaven to sacrifice himself, right? So what is the relationship between God and Jesus? Like who is Jesus?
Starting point is 00:19:44 Real? And this is a fundamental problem in Christianity. It was a fundamental problem back then, and it still remains a fundamental problem today. So throughout this time, there have been different solutions, different theories proposed to solve this problem. What's the relationship between God and Jesus? There's also something called the Holy Spirit, which we haven't really discussed, okay? But think of the Holy Spirit as the expression of God on earth. So when God wants to do something on earth, for example, he wants to move this table,
Starting point is 00:20:21 He does it through the Holy Spirit. Okay? So the Holy Spirit is the expression of God on earth. It's what we interact with. When we pray, we pray the Holy Spirit rather than to God. Okay. So there have been major different theories proposed to explain the relationship between God, the Holy Spirit, and Jesus.
Starting point is 00:20:46 Okay? So let's look at them. The first theory is called modalism. Modelism. It's the idea that God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit are the same being, but they are in different modes. So the metaphor is, think of water. If it's really cold, water becomes ice. If it's really hot, water becomes vapor.
Starting point is 00:21:19 Now, water, ice, and vapor are the same being, but they're in different forms. and that's the idea of modalism. Jesus, God, and Holy Spirit are the same thing would express differently in different times. But this is logical, but this creates a problem because if you actually read the Bible,
Starting point is 00:21:44 you will see some passages where Jesus prays to God, right? That doesn't make any sense because why would you pray to yourself? So it's a theory, but it's not a great theory. Another theory that's popular is called partialism. Partialism. And the idea is that God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit are parts of a higher being. So think of the ocean, right?
Starting point is 00:22:17 There's one ocean that covers the entire planet, but has different parts. For example, there's a Pacific Ocean. There's the Atlantic Ocean. There's an Indian Ocean. And that's the idea here, where God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit are just parts of a higher being. But then the question then becomes, then what is this higher being? So again, this makes sense. But it's not a great theory, okay?
Starting point is 00:22:43 The last theory I want to talk about is the idea of Arianism. An Arianism was created by a religious teacher named Arias. And this understanding was, look, if God created Jesus, thing that means God came before Jesus which means God has to be superior to Jesus okay so God is a higher being than Jesus Jesus is still great but God is the superior being and again not great okay but it makes sense all right so there's this huge controversy as to the nature of God and the nature of Jesus. And so what Constantine does is in 325 CE he orders all the bishops of the Roman Empire to converge in a place called Nesia, the Council of Nesia.
Starting point is 00:23:42 And during this conference they have to figure out what the nature of God is. So these are all the bishops from the various churches. And the four major churches of course are Rome, Alexandria, Antioch, and Jerusalem. And they're all there trying to figure out what the nature of Jesus and the Holy Spirit and God are. And this is a solution. And this is a solution that even today normally can figure out, okay? But this is a solution. There are three beings, God, Holy Spirit, and Jesus.
Starting point is 00:24:24 They are not the same thing. They're separate. They're not equal. which are three different entities, but they're all God. Okay? This is called the Holy Trinity. And this is the major idea underlying Christianity today. God, Jesus, and Holy Spirit are not the same thing.
Starting point is 00:24:55 They're not equal. But they're all God, okay? This is called the Godhead. So let's try to figure out what's going on here. Why do they pick this theory? Okay, first of all, what we do to understand is these first three theories, modalism, partialism, and erinism are really stories. There's stories of who God is. This, the Godhead, it's an equation.
Starting point is 00:25:43 Now what's the difference? Well, in a story, you can personalize it. You can put yourself into the story, and you can talk to it. to God and therefore you can interpret the story the way you want to interpret it and therefore you can argue about the story with others right that's what stories do but you can't do that in an equation like how do you put yourself into this equation you don't belong anywhere right this system is closed off to you you're excluded from it you can't enact with the Godhead therefore you cannot argue here you understand
Starting point is 00:26:31 There's no room for argument. There's no room for interpretation and argument. There's no room for debate. That's the first major advantage of the Godhead. You cannot debate anything because there's nothing to debate. You either accept it or you don't accept it. There's nothing in between. Second thing is before we understood faith as something that you experience personally.
Starting point is 00:27:03 You can talk to God, you can feel God. But with a Godhead, it's something that you have to believe. Okay? You have to believe in miracles, which forces the idea of faith as blind obedience. Okay, do you understand? Faith is something that you have to, before the Godhead, maybe something that you have to experience for yourself.
Starting point is 00:27:27 Now faith is just blind obedience. You have to accept this as it is. You have to memorize it. It's like mathematics. When you go to math class, you're not going to math class, class you're not asked to figure out why the proofs work yet this is just memorize the proofs and the third thing about the godhead is it's exclusionary meaning exclusionary just means that you can't put any other
Starting point is 00:28:01 theories in here if you look at these three theories motorism partial and erinism you can actually put them together okay they're not contradicting each other they're not fighting against each other they're different but you actually put them together whereas with this equation it's exclusionary it cannot you cannot put any other theories into it and that you cannot put this into any other theories all right and so what this means is this we put these three things together something that you have to accept you cannot debate it something that forces your blind obedience something
Starting point is 00:28:46 that is exclusionary okay it creates a new idea in human history called monotheism monotheism and this is a new radical idea in human history never before could we imagine something called monotheism there before there were some religions with one god right but this one god would also interact with other gods or this one god would create new gods but the idea of monotheism is there's only one god and that's it and this is radical in human history so let's try to figure out monotheism okay and by the way monotheism it's I think it's a very hard I do understand so it's okay if we don't really understand it today but over
Starting point is 00:29:42 the next few months as we explore the impact of monotheism on society we'll be a better understanding of okay all right so let's look at monotheism the first thing we're understanding about monotheism is if we memorize this form and you are forced to memorize this formula. Your understanding reality changes. Okay? And there's only one way to understand reality that makes it true. And the understanding is this.
Starting point is 00:30:13 God is nothing and everything. Okay? Does that make sense? There's only one way that reality is structured that makes this statement true. God is Holy Spirit and Jesus, but God is not Holy Spirit and Jesus. And the understanding of reality is, God is nothing and everything. Meaning God is everywhere and nowhere at the same time. Meaning that God is all of reality.
Starting point is 00:30:50 What this tells us is this. Symbols become reality. The symbols of reality, The representation of reality becomes conflated into reality itself. And then if we do that, this creates three new ideas that become the underlying basis of modernity. And these three new ideas are capitalism, science, and the nation state. Before, we didn't have these three ideas, capitalism, science, and the nation state.
Starting point is 00:31:35 But now we do. because we have come to believe that symbols are reality. We have come to believe that God is nothing and everything. So let's look at this, okay? What is the underlying basis of capitalism? Money, right? So let's talk about money, okay? Because I think money is the best way to understand this idea that God is nothing and everything.
Starting point is 00:32:16 So you and I go back in time. And we ask the people there, what is the basis of wealth in your society? And they might say gold or silver. And we ask, why is that the case? Why is gold and silver the basis of wealth in society? And they say, well, because gold is beautiful. You can make jewelry out of it. Also, it's very hard to get gold.
Starting point is 00:32:47 If you go mine it, and it's very hard to mine it, and also it's rare. Okay? So you're like, okay, that makes sense. Yeah, gold can be the basis of wealth, okay? Now, let's imagine some people from a thousand years ago, they transport, they, to our classroom, okay? And they ask us the same questions. What's the basis of wealth in your society?
Starting point is 00:33:12 And we say money. And then they ask, what is money? And then we say, well, money are, you know, paper that the government prints. And then they're like, okay. But that, but wait, wait, wait, wait, that makes no sense because the government can print as much money as it wants. And we're like, yeah, that's right. And you're like, but, and how do you, how do you trust the government? How many trust you're not to print like 20 trillion dollars today?
Starting point is 00:33:50 How many of you just come to behave itself? We're like, we don't know. And they're like, then why do you think money is valuable? Do you understand? So why do we think money is valuable? Because we have, we believe money is God. Because money is nothing and everything, because the symbol have become reality you understand okay now the question then is why do we
Starting point is 00:34:32 believe this crap why do we what do we believe money is God what do we believe money is valuable because the pavonautism is that it destroys other realities okay it crowds out realities the first is it symbols become reality secondly is that it crowds out realities because before in human history we believe there were many realities there was a spiritual reality there were many spiritual realities and in these in those realities money didn't really matter okay but now with modernism we've destroyed those other realities only the material reality exists but not only that but for modernism to work it has to expand
Starting point is 00:35:34 until becomes true it's a self-suffer system Self-fulfellate prophecy, okay? So aggressive expansionism. Not only will expand, but it has to destroy those who criticize it, okay? So in society, you are not ever allowed to ask a question, wait, what if money has no value because the government can print as much money as it wants?
Starting point is 00:36:06 You are not allowed to ask this question. You are not allowed to think of this question. You're not allowed to imagine the possibility of this question. Okay? So that's what Monotheism is. There are three main characteristics of monotheism that has enabled it to create the world that we live in today. Okay?
Starting point is 00:36:30 First is it destroyed the idea of symbols. Symbols are now reality. Money does not represent wealth. Money is wealth. Second is the idea that it has destroyed all realities, except for the mature reality that we live in today. You are not allowed to think of spiritual realities. In school, we do not teach the idea of a spiritual reality,
Starting point is 00:36:59 even though in our hearts we know it must exist. The third is the idea of aggressive expansionism. It is always expanding, because only by expanding can it be true. And that's why the two major monophistic religions of our time, Christianity and Islam are so violent. They're the source of most major wars throughout human history. So we think capitalism, science, and the nation state are really good things. But why?
Starting point is 00:37:39 Let's look at science. Science only concerns itself with the material reality. So if you can't see it, it doesn't exist. But then this creates a problem because science refuses to engage in hard questions. One question that I think is very interesting is what is thought, what is consciousness, how do we think? And science, the response of science
Starting point is 00:38:13 to all these questions is, don't think about it, it's not a problem. And you're like, wait a minute, consciousness is what makes this human. We can't figure out what consciousness is, then we'll never know what it means to be human. And science response is a human being are just the sum of biological parts. You are just your brain and your head and your eyes and your arms put together. Because that's what we can measure. But the question of what is consciousness, how do we imagine things, how do we understand things?
Starting point is 00:38:50 Science doesn't know. And it refuses to engage in this problem. One more point about symbols. So one thing that you're taught in school, which is not true, is we're so much more sophisticated than ancient civilizations. Because ancient civilizations had these superstitious beliefs like gods, okay? Like Apollo and Athena. And like obviously they don't exist.
Starting point is 00:39:32 So the fact that these ancient humans believe they exist demonstrates how stupid they are. But here's the thing. If you go back to these societies and you were to analyze thoroughly how they understood Apollon, Athene and other gods, you would understand that they didn't actually believe these gods existed, okay? But they believed these gods were metaphors and symbols for forces in nature that could influence our... lives okay does that make sense okay so for example take the idea of hatred and vengeance well hatred and vengeance would become mess with manifested in gods like strife okay and nemesis okay nemesis strike and the ancients believe
Starting point is 00:40:36 this was a better way to understand the world they understood that these forces were so powerful that we couldn't really control them therefore we must be conscious of these forces and control them better ourselves and unfortunately today we believe that because these gods don't exist there are just symbols then hatred and ventures don't really exist either they're just states of mind they're just emotions and you can just you can just pretend they don't exist and then you're fine okay the word we use for this is positive psychology right have you study positive psychology is the dumbest idea in the world okay it's the idea
Starting point is 00:41:20 that if you think you're happy then you're happy whereas the ancients thought that these were external forces and we have to work hard to tame them or to understand them and I think the ancients had a much more thorough and understand thorough and nuanced understanding of reality than we do another idea that we don't have today is evil Right? The ancients, okay, struggled with the idea of evil. What is evil? Where did it come from? And what's a very popular book at that time is something called the Book of Enoch? And the book of Enoch explains why there was a great flood. Remember in the Bible, there's this flood that wipes out of humanity.
Starting point is 00:42:19 Ona Noah survives, right? So the book of Enoch tells a story of why, you know, God had to destroy the world. So after God create the world, his angels, called the Watchers, saw humans, and they thought that humans were stupid and evil. So they came down to better manage us, okay? But then they started to lust after women, and they start to have children with these women. And these created giants, okay, called the FLM.
Starting point is 00:42:55 The Nephahem, okay? Sorry. Nephilim. And these were giants. And so we human just saw them as like God. So remember the epic of Gilgamesh. Well, Gilgamesh was a Nephem.
Starting point is 00:43:11 And so we started to make sacrifices and pay tributes to these giants. But over time, these giants became more, more greedy. And so they started to devour us and fight amongst themselves. And so now God, up in heaven,
Starting point is 00:43:26 He recognized this problem, so he creates a flood to destroy these Nephlehem, these giants. Okay? So now they're wiped out. But because they are born of angels, they are immortal. And so they become these evil spirits, these evil spirits that roam around the earth, and they try to create chaos. There's one great king called Solomon, King's David's son, and he disson. He discovers these evil spirits, and he captures them with a ring.
Starting point is 00:44:06 But these evil spirits recognize that we as human beings are all flawed. So they tempt him with a beautiful woman. And Solomon wants to have sex with her, but she says, to have sex with me, you must worship my God. And so Solomon agrees. And he becomes controlled by these evil spirits. Now after Monoivism, after the Catholic Church, they banned the book of Enoch. Because obviously if you're a powerful person, you don't want, you don't want order to
Starting point is 00:44:42 people thinking that you can be tempted by evil. If you're in evil spirit, you're going to go tempt powerful people, right? Because it is the most advantage to you, and the powerful people are most easy people to tempt because they love power. So today we're not allowed to ask the question about evil. what it's evil come from? Why are people evil? You're not allowed to think of, think it, okay?
Starting point is 00:45:08 So modernism is chronicing out different realities and possibilities from us. And we live in a world that I think is, I think we live in a world that even though we are much more wealthy and technologically advanced, we are much less sophisticated than than in historical times. All right?
Starting point is 00:45:42 So let me conclude by summarizing what we discussed and explain what monotheism is and the consequences on our lives because of monotheism, okay? Okay, so the first thing is back throughout most of human history we humans believe that gods are everywhere
Starting point is 00:46:10 every day we're interacting with gods because we believe in spiritual realities okay so and again gods are metaphors so this is premarterm this is modern now what do we believe we believe that money is God we structure our lives around the idea of money
Starting point is 00:46:38 when do we come to school to get a good grades so that we can get in a university Why? Because we need a job to make money. Why? Because buying things will make us happy. That's what everyone believes. God is money. Money is gone. And the ultimate consequence of this in our lives is life is alienating. Think about the number of depressed people in the world.
Starting point is 00:47:05 Depression is a new idea. It didn't exist before. Think about the number of people who live depressing lives, who are unhappy, who are angry. who are, who just hate themselves in their lives. Second thing that we believe throughout most of human history is spiritual reality is real. There's a higher plane. There are high dimensions. There are the spirits who roam in these dimensions.
Starting point is 00:47:42 When we die, we will enter these spiritual realms. And therefore, we must prepare for entry in, to the spiritual realm by living spiritual lives on earth. Spiritual reality is real. Now today we only believe that material reality is real. And only material reality is real. When we die, we're nothing. We came from nothing, we live our lives,
Starting point is 00:48:15 when we die, we become nothing. That's pretty depressing. So what this means for our society is, facts matter more than truth. In school you learn facts, you don't learn truth. It doesn't make sense. In science class, you're learning facts. You're not learning truth.
Starting point is 00:48:42 There's a huge difference. Facts are things that happen in the world. Truth is how the world works. There's a difference. You don't learn how the world works in science class. You just learn things that happen in the world that happen to be true. Now, last major consequence is this.
Starting point is 00:49:02 Pre-modern, we believe that slavery was the worst evil okay if you believe in spiritual realities and you believe that when you die you will just ascend to the spiritual realm then you want to live your best life on earth you don't want you don't be a slave but now what are you taught you're taught dying death is the worst evil the worst that how can happen to you is dying death because you die you become nothing so what does this mean it means we are all slaves okay if you're afraid of dying you can't live your best life you're not going to take risk you're not you're not
Starting point is 00:49:59 you're not going to ask questions you're not going to explore we are all slaves every one of us because we are afraid to die okay as you think about it monotheism uh sorry monotheism uh sorry monotheism is what creates the world we live in today and how, and it explains why we live the lives we do today. All right. Now, what's important for us to understand is this is not an instant change, okay? This is something that will have to be fought over
Starting point is 00:50:38 for about a thousand years. Because monotheism, this godhead, it is such a strange idea that people refuse to believe it. This is a minority religion at that time. But again, because this is a religion that must expand, it will eventually triumph and create the world we live in today. But only by killing millions and millions of people in these religious wars. So from the first day, from the day the Catholic Church was built,
Starting point is 00:51:09 it was engaging in crusades and inquisitions against people who refuse to believe in this orthodoxy. Right? Okay. So I know this was a lot to take in, all right? But are there any questions that you have? That's right. Okay, so I argue that we are less sophisticated than before.
Starting point is 00:51:50 Because before, everyone was very intuitive and very imaginative, meaning that they could imagine themselves living in different realities at the same time. There's a physical reality that you experience, But then there's also this high dimension, the spiritual reality, that you could feel. So, for example, if I were to fight with you, okay? If we had a fight, I would experience that. But I could also see maybe this God behind me pulling my strings, and the God behind you pulling your strings as well.
Starting point is 00:52:27 Okay? So when you read the Iliad, there are all these other realities that exist on top of each. other the reality that we live but also the higher reality with a gods negotiate amongst themselves and again this is a metaphor a symbol for these structural forces that govern the universe does that make sense all right so so when I mean sophisticated I really mean much more intuitive and much more imaginative than than we are today okay what made us lose the ability to imagine right okay well it's these three things really
Starting point is 00:53:17 capitalism, science, and the nation state. Right? Do you understand? Because with capitalism, what it teaches us is that money is the only good, the highest good. So it crowds on other things, like, for example, love of each other, interconnectedness. If you are a mother who loves your child, guess what? It doesn't matter. But if you think about it, the most beautiful thing in the world is a mother. loving her children but because of capitalism we're taught better than exists because you cannot financially exploit it you can't measure it okay then you get science science is the ultimate religion because everyone believes it has to
Starting point is 00:54:08 be true it's objective but what you will learn next semester okay we won't do this semester but What we will learn next semester is the idea of objectivity, okay? Objectivity. It doesn't exist. And this is something proven, okay? This is something that elite scientists know, but which no one else, but like which we don't really understand. Objectivity doesn't exist.
Starting point is 00:54:44 In fact, what elite scientists now know, and this is very strange idea we will explore next semester is the universe reality it is a collective um it is a collective hallucination do you understand we'll learn this next semester okay but the idea is that the universe is what we imagine it to be it doesn't exist on its own does that make sense okay but we believe it exists on its own because of science all right so when you go to science class you think you're learning the truth but you're actually learning a religion that hinders you from imagining other realities okay and of course the nation state the nation state now is like
Starting point is 00:55:41 God right who are you well you're you are a Chinese citizen but before we did think like that we just saw ourselves as members of a community and it could be a global community okay and you could have many identities but now If you're a Chinese citizen, you're not an American citizen, because you're in competition with each other. Does that make sense? So these are the three underlying ideas of the reality we live in today. And this wasn't true before. So this is a hard idea to understand, but next semester will become clear and clearer.
Starting point is 00:56:23 Okay? Any more questions? Okay. All right, so, good.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.