Prime Crime: Solved Murders - Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin Pt. 2

Episode Date: March 16, 2022

Captain Schaack was dismissed for withholding that his partner, Dan Coughlin, was connected to the murder of Patrick Cronin. New detectives on the case uncovered an elaborate scheme involving a secret... group of Irish revolutionaries. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Due to the graphic nature of this murder case, listener discretion is advised. This episode includes dramatizations and discussions of murder that some people may find offensive. We advise extreme caution for children under 13. It was 1898 in the midst of a brutal Chicago winter. The owner of a popular saloon worked the taps on a quiet afternoon. He hoped customers would make their way through the winter chill. He enjoyed the company of his patrons. after all, many of them came to see him, a minor, albeit notorious, celebrity.
Starting point is 00:00:42 The sound of the door caught his attention. A uniform detective shuffled in from the cold. The middle-aged officer slid onto a stool at the empty bar with a grunt. Then he settled his narrow eyes on the bar owner. The man behind the bar cast a blank expression, then grinned. He shared a past with the officer who now sat across from him. They'd been partners and shared secrets that cast a ripple effect through their lives and their community. As the men looked at each other now, some of those memories resurfaced.
Starting point is 00:01:20 It all seemed so distant as they assessed each other's graying hair and grown-out bellies. The bar owner scanned the detective's eyes and wondered if his former partner might still have some questions. But as he wiped a beer mug clean, he resolved to take. take certain things to the grave. Welcome to Solved Murders, True Crime Mysteries, a Spotify original from Parcast. I'm your host, Carter Roy. And I'm your host, Wendy McKenzie. Every Wednesday, we step into the world of true crimes' most fascinating murder cases
Starting point is 00:02:05 and tell the tale of how real-life detectives close the case. You can find episodes of Solve Murders and all other Spotify originals from Parcast for free exclusively on Spotify. This is our final episode on the 1889 murder of Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin. Last week we covered the hunt for the missing Cronin
Starting point is 00:02:28 and the gruesome discovery of his mutilated corpse. This week we'll cover the hunt for the killers and the truth behind the secret society's conspiracy. We'll end with a jaw-dropping conclusion to what was known as the trial of the century.
Starting point is 00:02:45 We have all that and more coming up. Stay with us. On May 22nd, 1889, the search for Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin had ended in tragedy. The 44-year-old's corpse was pulled from a sewer drain in a rural part of Lakeview, a Chicago neighborhood. The decomposing body showed signs that multiple attackers bludgeoned, slashed, and stabbed the doctor to death. Lead detective on the case, Captain Michael Shack found himself in the middle of a tangled Webb. He believed that the killers were part of a secret Irish group known as Clan Nagale,
Starting point is 00:03:29 of which his partner, Dan Coughlin, was a member. Coughlin's involvement with the group came out after Cronin's murder was confirmed, but Shack was still uncertain whether the secret society was involved in the doctor's demise. Either way, the lead detective withheld the information about Coughlin's membership from the chief of police, putting his own career at risk. Two days after Cronin's body was discovered, there still hadn't been any arrests. Agitated, Shack opened his morning paper, then dropped his coffee mug to the floor. The stable owner, Pat Dinnon, who had rented the horse and wagon to Dan Coughlin,
Starting point is 00:04:09 gave an interview to the Chicago Times. Dinnon revealed Coughlin's involvement and explained that Cronin was seen in the same horse and wagon the night he was murdered. The reporter called the situation a police. cover-up. Shack rushed to the station, but it was too late. The police chief was already in his office with several other important men in the community, as well as everyone involved in the investigation, except for Shack and Coughlin. But then Coughlin arrived and entered the chief's office. Shaq knew what this meant, but all he could do now was wait. He took a seat outside the closed door of the office. After two,
Starting point is 00:04:52 Two hours, Coughlin re-emerged alongside another officer. The officer gripped Coughlin's arm and led him away. Shack then heard the chief call for him from inside the office. When the detective entered, he saw the chief leaning over his desk with his hands folded. You knew about the horse and wagon? I had reason to believe it wasn't the same horse. Anyway, I lead the investigation, not the papers. Our department looks like a decision.
Starting point is 00:05:22 I assured the press no police were involved in the murder, and now I learn about Cawflin? What exactly did he say? That he and Patrick O'Sullivan are both members of a group, Clan de Gale, and you let him speak to the press about Alexander Sullivan? Get out of my sight, Jack. You're off the case. Jack was removed from the case and publicly disgraced. His decision to keep Coughlin's clan membership secret was the... the final nail in the trust his superior officers had in him. Shack and Coughlin's corruption was a massive blow to the reputation of the Chicago police.
Starting point is 00:06:03 While the press had embarrassed them, the police were determined to get to the bottom of it all and redeem themselves as best they could. The chief had already assigned several other detectives to the case, so around the same time he let Shack and Coughlin go, those detectives got to work. The new detectives began with someone who'd recently roused their suspicions, local ice house owner Patrick O'Sullivan. They had their eyes on Patrick because of wounds found on Dr. Cronin's corpse. Some appeared to be inflicted by a tool resembling an ice pick.
Starting point is 00:06:39 Not to mention, Cordelia Conklin, Cronin's friend and a key witness, believed Patrick was somehow involved. detectives knew that Patrick was stubborn about speaking to authorities, but they summoned him to the police station anyway. Cough it up, O'Sullivan. Tell us what you did to the good Dr. Cronin. I assure you, Detective, I'm but a humble ice merchant.
Starting point is 00:07:04 I don't know anything about this murder business. And you don't know anything about Clan de Gale. Ain't that right? This ain't the right time for nonsense, buddy. We've got a witness who told us you're a part of this thing. Witness? I don't see help. I've got nothing to do with any of this. There's no way you could have a witness. You call him me a liar? You can't do that. I called you a liar first. Now tell us which one of your secret clubhouse boys helped you ice the dock, and you might escape the hangman's noose.
Starting point is 00:07:35 I told you, I had nothing to do with this. You should be looking somewhere else. Hey, maybe my neighbors had something to do with it. Neighbors? What neighbors? The Carlson's. They own a rental shack by my ice house. Suspicious things tend to go down there. Maybe you should check them out instead. Yeah, we'll take a look, O'Sullivan. But I don't think this is the end of it. You're free to go.
Starting point is 00:07:59 For now. Based on O'Sullivan's tip, Lieutenant Herman Schutler and Captain E.H. Wing rode to the rural area where the ice house sat in a row of buildings. When they arrived at the remote neighborhood, the abandoned rental cottage immediately caught Chutler's eye. He thinks that last cottage there?
Starting point is 00:08:22 Yes, sir. That's the one. It belongs to the Carlson's. Looks empty. Huh, suppose it is. And that's Patrick O'Sullivan's ice house? Yeah, don't point. Don't want to spook Patrick too much.
Starting point is 00:08:36 Strangely, that's just to look at something right near his place, isn't it? Indeed it is. Let's find out what he thinks he's hiding. Hey, is that blood? I think it is. The men noticed a trail of dried blood leading into the empty cottage. While Wings stood back in horror, Schutler threw his weight against the rental house door.
Starting point is 00:09:03 They burst open, and what the police saw inside paralyzed them. The floor and the walls were covered in blood. Someone had tried to paint over the gory mess, but they could see the visible signs of a struggle. Broken and blood-soaked furniture were scattered. across the room. In the center sat a damaged rocking chair. The officers searched high and low for anything that might be relevant to Cronin's murder. Then a glimmer caught Schutler's eye from under the wash stand.
Starting point is 00:09:37 He bent down and picked up a key. The key raised more questions than it answered because it didn't fit anything inside the cottage. Schutler sighed and slipped it into his pocket. Resolute, the detectives continued searching and soon found a receipt for the purchase of all the furniture in the cottage. Evidently, the furniture came from a shop in Chicago. This is it, isn't it? This is where Cronin was killed. I want to hear what the Carlson's have to say about this. Agreed.
Starting point is 00:10:11 Let's hang on to the key and receipts to bring back to the station. The two detectives then marched to the Carlson's home and knocked on the door. When the couple answered, they seemed to... startled but unsurprised. Schutler demanded they explain themselves at once. Bacarleson seemed relieved to tell their sight of the story. Apparently they knew about the bloodstains but were too afraid to go to the police. However, now that the officers had discovered the scene themselves, the couple talked. They said that on March 20th, about a month and a half before Dr. Cronin went missing, a man who went by the name Frank Williams rented the
Starting point is 00:10:53 cottage. William seemed a little shifty, but he claimed his siblings were going to move in with him once they arrived in Chicago. This convinced the Carlson's to lease to him. Furniture soon arrived at the cottage, and after that the couple saw little of Williams. However, suspicious-looking people regularly filed in and out of the house. One strange man even wanted to pay rent on behalf of Williams, saying that Williams had to take care of a sick relative in another state. The Carlson's were suspicious and refused to accept this deal. By early May, the cottage sat empty, save for the furniture. When they mentioned the situation to their neighbor, Patrick O'Sullivan, he surprised them by offering to pay Williams' rent if the man never returned. Hoping they could rent the cottage to
Starting point is 00:11:46 someone else, the Carlson sent their son in one day to clean up the rooms. That was when he discovered the gruesome scene and told his parents. The officers thanked the couple, then rushed back to the station. They shared their newfound evidence and witness testimonies with their colleagues, who prompted them to seek the help of a medical examiner named Dr. Brandt. Brandt visited the scene at the cottage to collect blood samples. He compared these to the blood stains in the trunk that was found in Lakeview after Cronin went missing. His findings set the police force into high gear. The samples matched. From there, detectives set out for the Chicago furniture shop and demanded information about the furniture from the cottage. The shop owner looked through some records and revealed that
Starting point is 00:12:39 those pieces were purchased in February months before Conan's murder. In addition, the purchase list included a large trunk, just like the one police found in Lakeview. But according to the shop owner, the items weren't originally delivered to Lakeview. They went to three different rented rooms right there in Chicago. The detectives felt the trail heat up. If the person who rented those rooms was the same person who bought the furniture, then they could be tied to the rental cottage and therefore the bloody incident. They rushed to the apartment building and called on the landlord.
Starting point is 00:13:18 The landlord said that a man calling himself J.B. Simons rented the units, which was the same name as the person who had bought the furniture. On March 20th, a rent collector was sent by because Simons failed to pay the rent. But Simons wasn't home, so the collector returned the next day. The collector peered into one of the units through the keyhole. He noticed the room was empty. All the furniture had suddenly been moved out. The landlord let the detectives into the apartment.
Starting point is 00:13:49 They paced the bare floor and scanned the naked walls. Then they noticed the window. One detective pushed it open and stuck his head out. He squinted out into the midday light and scoured the city street below. What the detective saw floor. The apartment overlooked the Opera House block, the same building where one of Dr. Cronin's offices was located. Someone had been watching the doctor months before the murder. But there was still a big mystery left to solve.
Starting point is 00:14:23 The detectives had no idea who J.B. Simons was or how to find him, if that was even his real name. In the meantime, the detectives hurried back to the station where the evidence was stored. They shoved aside boxes and found the large trunk. Then they grabbed the key that was found in the cottage. One of the detectives took a deep breath, jammed the key into the trunk's lock, and... It was a perfect fit. The police now had proof that this trunk had carried a body out of the cottage. They were certain the doctor had been killed there.
Starting point is 00:15:02 The culprits were the only things left for them to find. But victory wouldn't come that easily. Up next, the police are beaten to the punch. The I-5 Strangler, the Southside dentist, the Berlin Butcher, meet the many faces of evil in the Spotify original from Parcast, serial killers. Every Monday and Thursday take a journey through the origin, evolution, and madness of a real-life murderer, exploring the reason, reasons why they lived to kill. Using extensive research and details you won't hear anywhere else,
Starting point is 00:15:50 serial killers takes an in-depth look at the horrors beyond the headlines. With hundreds of episodes available to binge and new ones released weekly, get to know the killers, crimes, and cases that left an indelible stain on history. Follow the Spotify original from Parkast, Serial Killers. Listen free, only on Spotify. All. Pay off your home, travel for life, drive a Ferrari. In celebration of the world premiere of the Monopoly Big Board Buckslot Machine by Aristocrat Gaming, Yamava Resort and Casino at San Manuel is giving one person a $1.6 million dream package. The biggest prize in Yamava's history. Club Serrano members can earn daily instant prizes and secure a spot in the finale May 29th.
Starting point is 00:16:38 Don't pass go and own it all, only at Yamava, celebrating its 40th anniversary. You win? Details at Yamavad.com must be 21-20. Please gamble responsibly. Monopoly is a trademark of Hasbro. Hasbro is not a sponsor of this promotion. I knew about investing, but I really didn't know how to go about it. Meet Corey, a wealthfront client. With Wealthfront, it could put money in, and it would automatically distribute it into a diversified portfolio. Then it starts to compound. The compounding compounds on the compounding. Just let it wrong, and it's great. Over one million clients trust wealthfront. Get started at wealthfront.com.
Starting point is 00:17:08 Client was paid $1,000 for their testimonial, creating a conflict of interest. Outcomes vary. Investment management and advisory services provided by wealthfront advice. LLC and SEC registered investment advisor. Investing involves risk to principle regardless of the strategy used. Has performance does not guarantee future results. Now, back to the story. On May 25th, 1889, Detective Michael Schack had run out of time in the hunt for Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin's killers.
Starting point is 00:17:34 Shack's partner, Dan Coughlin, was arrested for withholding his connection to the crime, a secret that Shack himself concealed. Shack was replaced by other detectives, who took over the case and quickly, important new leads. For one, these detectives had learned that Coughlin and Patrick O'Sullivan, a suspect and owner of an ice house, were members of the same secret Irish group known as Clan Nagale.
Starting point is 00:18:03 That information, along with the discovery of a likely murder scene near the ice house, was all authorities needed to charge Patrick as part of the murder conspiracy. A couple of days later, after Patrick Henry Cronin was laid to rest, with an enormous funeral procession, police arrested Patrick O'Sullivan. Now he and Dan Coughlin were in custody, but both men claimed innocence and revealed no other information.
Starting point is 00:18:32 As the next step, a coroner's inquest was assembled. A vital precursor to a murder trial, the six-man jury would identify suspects and piece together the murder timeline. About a week after the arrest of Patrick O'Sullivan, the jury began hearing witness testimonies. Days of testimonies revealed crucial information. It seemed that Cronin had died as part of a Clan Nagale conspiracy,
Starting point is 00:18:59 and it was revealed that the notorious Alexander Sullivan was, in fact, one of the group's leaders, but the police still needed more information. And soon they got it. A man named Luke Dillon joined the courtroom. Unlike other witnesses who only gave broad strokes, Dylan was ready to spill everything. I am a member of Klanigale, and I am certain that Alexander Sullivan is the man behind Dr. Kronin's death. Did Sullivan carry out the murder himself?
Starting point is 00:19:35 He at least orchestrated it, and he will get away with it if you're not diligent. He's gotten away with far worse. Why did Sullivan want Kronin dead? Dr. Cronin wanted Sullivan reprimanded for crimes against his own people. The jury sat in silence, as Dylan described Clan Nagale's history. He explained that Clan Nagale was a secret group of Irish revolutionaries based in America. Together with Irish rebels overseas, they fought a guerrilla war against England to win Ireland back its freedom. And as Alexander Sullivan rose to power, their tactics escalated.
Starting point is 00:20:14 The clan began to send Irish Americans to England. Their job was to carry out what they called the dynamite war in which they executed bombings in England. Sullivan himself was behind a number of bombings, including one in London that injured innocent people. The dynamite war was costly, both in terms of money and human lives. Most of the attacks ended in failure, and even the ones that succeeded led to it.
Starting point is 00:20:44 injuries and arrests. Some clan members began to speak out against the entire operation, but Sullivan remained committed to it. Sullivan had also promised to look after the families of men who were killed or captured in this line of duty. But over time, it became clear that he wouldn't offer anything to the clan's widows and children. This caused Clan Nagale brothers to question his worth as a leader, many spoke out. Among these voices was Patrick Henry Cronin. The doctor sought to have Sullivan removed from power and became the face of this campaign.
Starting point is 00:21:24 Dylan paused to assess his audience's reaction. The jury appeared shocked to hear how deep the rabbit hole went. Dylan pressed on. The dynamite war wasn't Sullivan's only sin. By this time, he was already president of the Irish National League, and Dr. Cronin believed that he'd embezzled $100,000 from the group. Cronin started sending letters and talking with other members of the Klan,
Starting point is 00:21:49 telling them the truth about Sullivan. What was Sullivan's response to all this? Well, he denied it. And then he charged Dr. Cronin with treason, slander, and violation of the clan's constitution. And what did Cronin do then? He persisted. He wanted everyone to know of Sullivan's corruption,
Starting point is 00:22:08 so he continued his campaign to remove Sullivan, from power. For that, Sullivan wanted the doctor to pay. First, he started spreading rumors that Kronin was a spy. And that's how he created ground for his next move, to kill Kronin. The six-man jury sat speechless. Dylan's testimony had shed light on events that law enforcement probably wouldn't have learned on their own, and the river of information didn't stop there. Soon after the hearing, two more names relevant to the case came up, John Beggs and Martin Burke. They were also members of Clan Nagale and Associates of Sullivan's.
Starting point is 00:22:53 The inquest jury ultimately concluded that Alexander Sullivan, Patrick O'Sullivan, and Dan Coughlin were involved in Cronin's murder. On the night of June 11th, Alexander Sullivan was arrested. However, just days later, his defense team argued that no concrete evidence linked him to the murder. And his wealthy friends paid his bail. He would not see prison walls again without a more substantial break in the case.
Starting point is 00:23:21 Even though Sullivan walked free, the news of his arrests sent shockwaves. The U.S. government declared that secret societies were at danger to the nation. Not to mention, the press began leaking Clan Nagale's operations and membership. This significantly weakened the secret brother of, law enforcement now faced the added battle against public opinion.
Starting point is 00:23:46 In an effort to stay on top of their investigation, they paid another visit to the Carlson's to show them a picture of a man named Martin Burke, one of the suspects whose name cropped up after the inquest. The Carlson's immediately recognized him and confirmed that this was their former renter who went by the name Frank Williams. As it turned out, Burke had fled to Canada
Starting point is 00:24:10 but authorities were able to track him down and arrest him. The detective didn't think that Burke would be able to hire a lawyer for his extradition case since he was a working-class immigrant, but on the day of the trial, he was proven wrong. Burke had a lawyer. Even though Burke was ultimately ordered to return to the U.S., Schutler felt this was a troubling sign of things to come. Someone was watching over this case. It seemed that even in Canada, the long, shadowy hands of Alexander Sullivan pulled the strings. As law enforcement felt the dark cloud of organized crime rise above them,
Starting point is 00:24:50 the rest of the world turned their attention to what became known as the trial of the century. A handful of Klan Nagale members would be tried for the murder of one of their own, and their leader sat safely on his throne. To many, the outcome of the trial would determine where real power was found, among order or lawlessness. Up next, the trial of the century begins. Now, back to the story. In August of 1889, the trial for the murder of Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin began. Since the inquest, Alexander Sullivan had not only been let out on bail, he also avoided any charges
Starting point is 00:25:41 Cronin's friends in the press suspected corruption that Sullivan had bribed his way out of trouble. Although the suspected architect of the murder had escaped justice, a handful of his cohorts would be tried together. This included ex-detective Dan Coughlin, Iceman Patrick O'Sullivan, and three others recently accused. Clan-Nagale members Martin Burke and John Beggs, plus a small-time crook named John Coonzie. jury selection was a two-month battle due to personal bias and alleged bribery. Shadowy hands offered cash up to anyone who would argue in favor of the defendants. The figure behind those bribes was wildly speculated by the press and public to be none other than Alexander Sullivan.
Starting point is 00:26:31 This rumor troubled local law enforcement, who had already come to believe that Sullivan was secretly pulling the strings of the case. Once a jury was finalized, witness testimonies began. The court heard from people, including Dr. Cronin's long-time friends and witnesses to his final hours, the Conklands, members of Clan Nagale, and medical experts. Their testimonies, as well as research that's taken place since, helps us formulate an understanding of Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin's final hours. While some of these details remain shrouded in mystery, this is our best. best guess for how the murder took place. By February of 1889, Cronin showed no signs of giving up his crusade against Alexander Sullivan.
Starting point is 00:27:22 For this, Sullivan started a rumor that Cronin was a spy for the English, in a group such as Clan Nagale, whose sole mission was to liberate Ireland, an English spy deserved nothing less than death. Sullivan ordered Martin Burke to rent out the Chicago apartments using the fake name of Frank Williams. Burke watched Cronin's office across the street and recorded his schedule. Originally, Burke had probably planned to kill Cronin when he was alone in his office. But on that busy Chicago street, anyone could hear the sounds of a struggle. So Burke and Sullivan found a more secluded location.
Starting point is 00:28:03 For this, Sullivan reached out to, other members of Clan Nagale. The ice man, Patrick O'Sullivan, suggested the cottage next to his business. So on March 20th, Burke rented the Carlson cottage and had the trunk and other furniture delivered there. Then he, Patrick, and Sullivan planned their attack. In late April, Patrick offered Cronin a paid retainer ship to care for his workers. That ensured he could get Cronin to come to the ice house.
Starting point is 00:28:33 Cronin agreed to the offer, and on May 4, Dan Coughlin rented the horse and wagon from Dinnon. At 7.30 p.m. that same night, someone, possibly a man named Charles MacDonald, came to Cronin's office and summoned him to the ice house. Cronin packed his things and left with the stranger. Cronin entered the Carlson's cottage to find Sullivan and his cronies waiting for him. At this point, it's possible that Sullivan, and accused Cronin of being a spy, and Cronin denied the accusation. In any case before long, one of the men clubbed Cronin in the back of the head. Cronin collapsed to the ground, and all the men fell on him with knives. Patrick, terrified but loyal, clumsily stabbed at Cronin with his
Starting point is 00:29:25 ice pick. Soon Cronin lay lifeless in a pool of blood. The men stripped the doctor's body naked, but none would touch the Catholic medallion that hung from his neck. They locked Cronin in the trunk, but in the bloody mess, one of them dropped the key under the washstand. Then they loaded the trunk onto the wagon. They traveled to the storm sewer
Starting point is 00:29:48 about a mile away. Perhaps at this point they realized they didn't have the key, so they smashed the trunk open with a shovel. Finally, they delivered Cronin into his murky tomb. However, the defense would have likely poked holes in this version of events. After all, there was no evidence that put any of the
Starting point is 00:30:10 men in the cottage that night, and nothing proved that Sullivan orchestrated the murder. Plus, Sullivan wasn't even on trial. Former Detective Michael Shaq also provided testimony. However, it was aimed mostly at protecting himself and Dan Coughlin. While he did admit to knowing Coughlin was a member of Klan de Gale, he wouldn't confirm how he knew it. Further, it's unknown why Patrick O'Sullivan tipped law enforcement off about the Carlson's rental cottage in the first place. Perhaps he was trying to pin the crimes on the couple, or maybe, albeit less likely, he just wanted all the madness to end. Many questions were left unanswered, and it would still be some time before the court came to a decision. Finally, on my...
Starting point is 00:31:02 Sunday, December 16th, the courtroom re-adjurned for the closing of the trial of the century. The accused men filled their seats before the judge. All of America awaited the jury's word. Then a juryman stood to address the judge and the court. The entire country held its breath. For John Beggs, we find him not guilty and acquitted of all charges. For Patrick O'Sullivan, we find him guilty and sentence him to life in prison. For Martin Burke, we find him guilty and sentence him to life in prison. For John Coonzie, we find him guilty and, as a minor accomplice, we sentence him to only three years. For the defendant, Dan Coughlin, we find him guilty and sentence him to life in prison.
Starting point is 00:31:58 Shaq stood from his seat. He was stunned. around him spectators grew agitated. No one could believe that every man was spared the death sentence. Their crimes were too egregious. Apparently, one of the jurors had refused a death sentence on moral and religious grounds. Perhaps he felt that this sentence was a way of restoring peace and nonviolence. However, the public felt deflated.
Starting point is 00:32:27 The fervor of the case had overtaken many, and these sentences didn't provide the closure they'd hoped for. After all, Alexander Sullivan also remained free, and the community still faced the issue of corruption within their policing system. But the story wasn't quite over. In January of 1890, John Coonsie was released on a $5,000 bail. Some of his trial mates weren't as lucky, however. Two years into their prison sentences, Patrick O'Sullivan,
Starting point is 00:33:02 and Martin Burke both died from tuberculosis. Clan Nagale never recovered from the humiliation. As a result of the trial, many Irish Americans in Chicago felt ashamed to learn about the clan conspiracy. In this disappointed mood, they even canceled the city's St. Patrick's Day celebrations in 1890. Although Alexander Sullivan was never charged for Cronin's murder, he was believed by most to be the man responsible.
Starting point is 00:33:32 A magazine cover cartoon had even depicted his face surrounded by little murderers with knives, clubs, and bombs. He kept his life, but his reputation disintegrated. Dan Coughlin's story did not end in prison. His lawyers argued that at least one juror had a pretrial bias in the case against him. So Coughlin returned to court in January of 1893. The retrial went in his favor, and by the next year, he was a free man. He opened a saloon in Chicago.
Starting point is 00:34:06 It's possible that people ventured there to seek out the owner who was once tried in the trial of the century. However, five years later, Coughlin fled Chicago after an arrest for jury bribery. He hid from authorities for eight years under a false name in Alabama. Once caught, he escaped yet again, ending up on a banana plantation. in Honduras. His old partner, Michael Shack, died of complications from diabetes and rheumatoid arthritis more than a decade earlier in 1898. Cofflin kept his secrets and lived the rest of his life free until his eventual death in 1910. Neither he nor Alexander Sullivan live long enough to see Ireland become a free nation. Thanks again for tuning in to Solve Murders. We'll be back next Wednesday
Starting point is 00:35:06 with a new episode. For more information on this case, amongst the many sources we used, we found Blood Runs Green, the murder the Transfixed Gilded Aid Chicago by Jillian O'Brien, extremely helpful to our research. You can find all episodes of Solved Murders and all other Spotify originals from Parcast for free on Spotify. We'll see you next time.
Starting point is 00:35:30 If we live till next time. Solve murders, true crime mysteries is a Spotify original. original from Parcast. It is executive produced by Max Cutler. Sound design by Michael Langsner with production assistance by Ron Shapiro, Trent Williamson, Carly, Madden, and Freddie Beckley. This episode of Sol of Murders is written by Daniel William Gonzalez, with writing assistance by Sarah Batchelor and Giles Hofsef. Fact-checking by Claire Cronin and research by Mickey Taylor. The amazing cast of voice actors includes Tom Bauer, Cameron Nicodd, and Lath Walsh Slagher. Solve Murder stars Wendy McKenzie and Carter Roy.
Starting point is 00:36:19 Their names have become larger than life. Their crimes, some of the most heinous in history. Their stories examined each week on the Spotify original from Parcast, Serial Killers. Every Monday and Thursday, journey past the headlines and into the minds and motives of the murderers who forever changed the face of history. Follow the Spotify original from Parcast, Serial Killers. Listen free only on Spotify.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.