QAA Podcast - Episode 264: Corpse Trade feat Allie Mezei

Episode Date: January 27, 2024

Over the years, we’ve heard Qanon believers loudly protest the alleged misappropriation of human remains – whether they’re being used to supply “adrenochrome farms” or consumed during satani...c cabal dinner parties. As is often the case, the reality is far more disturbing than the conspiracy theory. This week, Allie Mezei joins us to bring us horrific tales from the real ‘tissue trade’, a feud between the bodies of the living and the dead that stretches all the way back to the eighteenth century. Unfortunately, the corpse trade is very much alive, even today, and continues to be a depressing reminder of the ruling class’s war against the poor. Subscribe for $5 a month to get an extra episode of QAA every week + access to our archive of premium episodes and ongoing series like PERVERTS, Manclan, Trickle Down and The Spectral Voyager: https://www.patreon.com/QAA Written by Allie Mezei https://twitter.com/pinealdecalcify Music by Pontus Berghe and Nick Sena. Editing by Corey Klotz. https://qanonanonymous.com SOURCES: https://www.alreporter.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/Dotson-Complaint.pdf https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2024/01/11/us/alabama-prison-inmates-missing-organs-lawsuit/index.html https://abcnews.go.com/amp/US/massachusetts-bill-allowing-prisoners-donate-organs-reduced-time/story?id=96989325 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9996393/ https://www.al.com/news/birmingham/2024/01/alabama-still-cant-find-heart-missing-from-prisoners-body.html https://abc3340.com/news/local/family-says-organs-including-brain-missing-from-deceased-inmate-body-in-noticeable-state-of-decomposition-adoc-uab-st-clair-county https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3162231/ https://evolution.berkeley.edu/the-history-of-evolutionary-thought/pre-1800/comparative-anatomy-andreas-vesalius/#:~:text=Right%2C%20Vesalius%20found%20that%20the,not%20seven%20as%20Galen%20claimed. Peter Linebaugh, the Tyburn Riots Against the Surgeons in Albion’s Fatal Tree https://www.versobooks.com/products/2212-albion-s-fatal-tree Ruth Richardson, Death, Dissection and the Destitute https://books.google.com/books?id=NEuthk74yG0C&printsec=frontcover#v=onepage&q&f=false https://www.oldbaileyonline.org/about/journeytyburn https://doi.org/10.1002/ar.24794 https://scholarworks.harding.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1139&context=tenor https://www.reuters.com/investigates/section/usa-bodies/ https://nfda.org/news/media-center/nfda-news-releases/id/7475/congress-takes-significant-step-to-regulate-body-brokers https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/4275?s=1&r=29

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 What's up QAA listeners? The fun games have begun. I found a way to connect to the internet. I'm sorry, boy. Welcome listeners to the 264th chapter of the QAA podcast, the corpse trade episode. As always, we are your host, Jake Rakatansky, Ali Mezzie, and Travis Vue. Q-N-Followers are often fixated. on the commodification of the human body.
Starting point is 00:00:33 You can see this when they talk about adrenachrome or human trafficking or even the idea that planned parenthood is making purses out of fetuses. But, yeah, that's one that shows up occasionally. While a lot of these scenarios are greatly exaggerated or flat out made up, these theories are a fun house mirror that distorts an actual disturbing reality
Starting point is 00:00:55 involving missing organs, dismembered cadavers, and questionable procurement practices of human remains. So to learn more about this, we brought on our longtime legal correspondent, Ali Mansi, who has brought us the grim, dark tale that stretches back hundreds of years of how people have, you know, plundered corpses for, you know, whatever reason. So, Ali, can you please take it away? On November 16, 2023, 43, 13-year-old Brandon Clay Dotson was found dead in Ventress Correctional Facility in Barber County.
Starting point is 00:01:28 Alabama. After his family was alerted to his death by the prison, Mr. Dotson's mother and his daughter spent days attempting to collect his remains so that they could hold a funeral. According to the complaint filed by Dotson's estate in federal court, Mr. Dotson's body was returned to them a week later in a state of severe decomposition. Concerned that there may have been foul play involved in Mr. Dotson's death or the handling of his remains, the family retained an autopsy pathologists. From the complaint they filed. The Alabama Department of Corrections, or an agent responsible for conducting the autopsy and transporting the body to his family, had inexplicably and without the required permission
Starting point is 00:02:04 of Mr. Dotson's next-of-kin, removed and retained Mr. Dotson's heart. Brandon Dotson's heart is still missing. Oh, no. Yeah, it's pretty bleak. According to reporting, Ivana Hoyenkiv at the Atlanta Constitution Journal during a January 5th, 2024 hearing in federal court, five people. The warden of the prison, the commissioner and chief deputy commissioner of the Alabama Department of Corrections, the director of the Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences,
Starting point is 00:02:33 and the head of autopsies at University of Alabama, Birmingham, all testified that they did not know what happened to Mr. Dodson's heart, or where it might be. Angelo Delamana, the director of the State Department of Forensic Sciences, said that in a standard autopsy of an inmate, a prisoner will have their internal organs removed from the body, and then they will be sectioned, in which they will be sectioned, in which samples are removed for testing regarding cause of death. The organs will then be placed in a special biotazard bag
Starting point is 00:03:00 and return to the bodily cavity they were taken from. He couldn't give a reason that these organs wouldn't be returned to the body at the end of the autopsy. They find out that the guy performing the autopsy is made of straw. He has partnered with a lion, a man made out of tin, and a young woman who has been kidnapped by a tornado. Ooh. Isn't it the scarecrow who says if I only had a heart?
Starting point is 00:03:27 No, it's the tin man. I think that one's the tin man. The scarecrow wants the brain. Okay, okay. So I fucked up the whole reference, the analogy, the joke. It's bad, but we're going to leave it in. Well, there is a missing brain later. Oh, really?
Starting point is 00:03:39 Oh, no. Okay. I will recycle this joke 35 minutes into the episode. Mr. Dotson isn't the only inmate to die in an Alabama prison and be returned to his family with their organs gone. According to reporting by Chris Boyette at CNN, the family of 74-year-old Charles Edward Singleton, who passed away while incarcerated in 2021 in Alabama's Hamilton-aged and infirmed center, received a similar horrific surprise.
Starting point is 00:04:06 A funeral director informed Mr. Singleton's daughter, Charlene Drake, that Singleton's body arrived at the funeral home in a noticeable state of decomposition, and that his internal organs, including his brain, were all missing. Jesus. This, like, reminds me of the scene at the beginning of a wrap. When they send Richard Manley, the photographer, back to the town of Knaiva, and they open the coffin and his body is just like totally decimated because the spider, you know, hitched a ride from South America or Venezuela, I believe it's from. Anyways. Yeah, it's just gruesome.
Starting point is 00:04:41 It's completely gruesome. So what's going on here? The least nefarious explanation would be gross incompetence and a shameful disregard for the dignity of the incarcerated by. the Alabama state prison system. This is certainly a possibility as prisons are hotbeds of medical neglect and often outright human rights abuses. It is believable and even likely that the remains were negligently handled during routine autopsies. But many of those who heard the news about the missing organs suspected something more sinister. Speculation about what might have happened swirled on social media. One user posted, these prisons are not even trying to hide
Starting point is 00:05:17 what they're doing. This was responded to by another user who said, in Alabama, The organ trafficking? Getting a brain transplant from a prisoner just to keep your loved one alive sounds like a good horror film. Ironically, I wonder if Jordan Peel's movie Get Out had premiered yet because that's literally the premise and it is a pretty good horror movie. Another user responded to this saying, Murdered Prisoner found with his organs gone? Organ harvesting for big bucks, obviously, some of the darker cyberpunk stuff is starting to come true. Another user on the site formerly known as Twitter quickly connected the missing organs in Alabama
Starting point is 00:05:55 to propose legislation in Massachusetts from early 2023, noting it seems like there's some lobby out there that really wants the organs of prisoners for some purpose. The reference legislation is an act to establish the Massachusetts incarcerated individual bone marrow and organ program introduced before the Massachusetts State Houts by representatives Carlos Gonzalez and Judas Garcia, both Democrats. The bill would allow prisoners to shave between two months and a year off their prison sentence if they donated their organs or bone marrow. After harsh criticism from the public and human rights groups, sponsor Gonzalez
Starting point is 00:06:32 backtracked and said he would rework the bill to remove the incentives for donating. Gonzalez made a statement to ABC News, staying that he never intended to establish a quid pro quo, and that the bill had only been created to remove red tape that prevented prisoners from donating organs and marrows to their family members in need. As of recording, no version of the bill has passed the Massachusetts house. This is crazy. So essentially, they were trying to come up with some kind of program that was like, hey, you want to get out of prison a couple years earlier, a couple months earlier.
Starting point is 00:07:04 Just give us pieces of your body. Give us a kidney. Give us your marrow. This is like something out of squid game. You know, it's like the kind of insidiousness that you only see from corporations in like, giant movies, but apparently also a reality as well. This is like a Robocop universe nightmare in which, you know, the overclass, you know, they plot to whenever they need a fresh fusion of organs, you know, they round up enough people who are then pressured into giving up what they need in order to, you know, live forever or
Starting point is 00:07:35 whatever. Mr. Dotson's family does not say that they think that his heart was harvested for transplant. Instead, they allege in their lawsuit against a number of state entities that they believe that Mr. Dotson's heart may have been taken or even sold without his consent for the purpose of use in medical research. Right now, we do not know what happens, but I believe that suspicion is unfortunately a very realistic one. In their complaint, Mr. Dotson's family cited a finding by a group of medical students at the University of Alabama, Birmingham, that in 2018, a disproportionate amount of the number of specimens they encountered during their medical
Starting point is 00:08:12 training originated from individuals who died in prison. The medical students found that the wardens of Alabama prisons could sign off on the remains of deceased inmates being used for teaching, education, and research, often without the inmate or their family's consent. During a November 2018 meeting, a UAB administrator admitted that one-third of the samples in the pulmonary lab came from incarcerated individuals, a wildly disproportionate amount compared to how much of the general Alabama population is in prison, which, according to the Prison Policy Institute is 938 per 100,000 people.
Starting point is 00:08:48 I do have to say here, as of right now, despite Mr. Dotson's estates' allegations, there is no evidence currently available that the University of Alabama, whatever its policies and practices are, ever handled Mr. Dotson's remains. UAB denies any involvement in the tragedy
Starting point is 00:09:03 and they're trying to get dismissed from the lawsuit. According to ABC News, Mr. Singleton, the man whose brain was missing, family claims that UAB performed the autopsy that removed his organs, but UAB is not commented on that allegation. I hope that Mr. Dotson and Mr. Singleton's families get answers and restitution for the pain and violation
Starting point is 00:09:23 they've been made to feel by the state of Alabama and its prison system. Regardless of what comes to light about what happens here, the family's fears that their loved ones were exploited for the remains is based on literal centuries of appropriation of the bodies of the poor, the incarcerated and the underclass, in the name of medical science and progress. This real-life horror story is often facilitated and encouraged by the state and taps into common fears about exploitation and dehumanization.
Starting point is 00:09:50 Anatomy and the poor. A history. In the late medieval period in Europe, the understanding of the human body was based not exclusively, but still largely, on treatises from classical antiquity. The foremost authority was the work of Galen of Pergamon, a Roman Greek physician, who had lived in the second and third century A. D. Galen's scientific writings on human anatomy combined Aristotelian philosophy with observations he made from his own extensive dissections of animals, mostly monkeys, dogs, and pigs. His treatises
Starting point is 00:10:22 were full of sharp observations and certainly were the best of their time, but for reasons you might imagine, they were deeply flawed. Furthermore, because a lot of the writings had been lost when the Western Roman Empire fell, many of the treatises in use in Europe for education were Latin translations of Arabic translations from the original Greek, Soviet probably negatively impacted the quality of what was on the page. Yet for over 1,300 years in Europe, and also in much of the Islamic world, Galen's writing remained at the core of medical study almost entirely unchallenged and unchanged. The paradigm finally shifted in the 16th century when a Flemish anatomist named Vesilius, working in Padua, published DeHumani Corporus Fabrica, or on the fabric of the human
Starting point is 00:11:08 body in 1543. Written to correct and expand on the work of Galen, observations about human anatomy in Dehumani corporous fabrica were gathered from methodological dissections of human bodies, mostly those of executed criminals. To illustrate Vasari state of anatomical understanding caused by a millennia of depending on translations of translations of a guy who literally lived in ancient Rome, here are some of the things that Vesalius discovered and published. Humans only have one jawbone.
Starting point is 00:11:40 Men and women have the same number of ribs. The bones in your hands contain marrow, and skin is not a muscle. DeHumani corporous fabrica wasn't perfect, but it was a huge and vital improvement. And throughout the Western world, it opened the floodgates of advancement in anatomical science. The next few centuries saw immense progress. Through empirical study, the understanding of the human body grew by leaps and bounds. Thus, the path between surgery being a sure death sentence and modern medical science began to be paved in human dissections.
Starting point is 00:12:14 British anatomists first drew the attention of the rest of the Western world in the 17th century with the pioneering work of William Harvey, the first physician to demonstrate that the heart pumped blood through the body and to describe the course of circulation. In the following 17 and 1800s, British cities like London and Edinburgh became major centers of anatomical research and education. According to Peter Linebaugh, in the 1975 essay, Vathyburn riots against the surgeons,
Starting point is 00:12:39 which I depended on heavily while writing the section. The preeminence of British anatomy in the era depended on private teaching schools and hospitals such as St. George's, St. Thomas's, and St. Bartholomew's, pushing advances in the understanding of morphology, pathology, and therapeutics
Starting point is 00:12:56 by performing more and more dissections and incorporating autopsy into the standard training of physicians. William Hunter, an 18th-century anatomist and practicing surgeon, best known today for his revolutionary advances in obstetrics, wrote of the necessity of dissection. It informs the head, guides the hand, and familiarizes the heart to a kind of necessary inhumanity.
Starting point is 00:13:18 The anatomists and surgeons needed remains. But where would they get them? Utilitarian philosopher Jeremy Bentham encouraged people to volunteer their own remains for the benefit of science. He not only talked the talk, but upon his 1832 death walked the walk. Bentham stipulated in his will for his own remains to be dissected at an anatomy lecture. The body was subsequently mummified and put on display,
Starting point is 00:13:41 but very few of Bentham's 18th and 19th century contemporaries were of a similar mind. Instead, writes Linebaugh, it appears as though a precondition of the progress in anatomy depended on the ability of surgeons to snatch the bodies of those hanged at Tyburn. Wait, so these guys were waiting like under the gallows, basically. like with a sack, you know, that the body would just drop into it and they would, you know, run back to their labs. Oh, yeah.
Starting point is 00:14:07 They would. Oh, my God. Linebaugh writes of Tyburn. The engine, as much as the fact of the state's ultimate power, became the theme of scores of proverbs, riddles, words and descriptions, beating evidence to the facts that London, as an older historian put it, was a, quote, city of the gallows, and that its people both recognized this and accommodated themselves to it, but upon their own terms. The scaffold consisted of three posts, 10 or 12 feet high, held apart by three connecting crossbars at the top.
Starting point is 00:14:37 It stood at Tyburn from the early two-door period until when a new scaffold was constructed in Newgate. Tyburn was St. Tyburn, the three-legged mayor, the three-legged stool. As it bore fruit the whole year round, it was the deadly nevergreen. To be extremely clear, the fruit was dead people. The gallows at Tyburn were the primary place of execution for London and Middlesex, where criminals from poachers to thieves to rapists to murderers to traitors to the crown were hanged in a public spectacle before massive jeering crowds. According to the old Bailey online, about 1,100 men and 110 women were hanged at Tyburn during the 18th century. The hanging served as a form of social control, a morality play, and a reminder of the massive power of the state to inflict punishment on the lower classes when they got out of line.
Starting point is 00:15:24 And also entertainment, right? You would get dressed up and bring the family. to go see an execution in in the public square that was oh yeah and the people the people who were getting hanged there was this concept called dying game where you know you would go up and put on a show at the gallows where you know for your last like three minutes of being alive you're doing a stand-up routine up there what see it's amazing you know i'm always so fascinated by this and you know the sort of a decreased value of life and and perhaps you know that goes hand in hand with the society being more overwhelmingly religious and believing in an afterlife that you could go up and, you know, do a stand-up routine, you know, in the face of impending, impending death.
Starting point is 00:16:08 It's just a completely different world and mindset from what we know. In the 18th and the beginning of the 19th century, the source of legal remains were the gallows at Tyburn and later Newgate. The Crown and Parliament facilitated this harvest by granting of a college of barbers surgeons and the Royal College of Physicians a small number of of convicts corpses each year. Also, I just kind of love how barbers and surgeons were the same thing back in the day. Like, oh, we both need sharp objects. Same job.
Starting point is 00:16:37 Contemporary intellectuals praised this practice for its utilitarian function. Bernard de Mandville, an author best known for his work, The Fable of the Bees, wrote in an article in the British Journal. I have no design that savors the cruelty or even indecency towards a human body, but shall endeavor to demonstrate that superstitious, reverence of the vulgar for a corpse, even of a malefactor, and the strong aversion they have against dissecting them, are prejudice to the public, for as health and sound limbs are the most desirable of all temporal blessings, so we ought to encourage the improvements
Starting point is 00:17:13 of physic and surgery. Such arguments of scientific utility, however, tended to be mixed with unabashed class hatred. Mandeville further wrote, Even if the relatives of the dead felt themselves or their dead relation defiled by this procedure, the disorder would seldom reach beyond the scum of the people. Don't worry. We're only, you know, looting the scum of the earth. The people were scraping off the bottom of our shoe. Not real people.
Starting point is 00:17:44 Jesus Christ. Not people like you and me. Yeah. He felt the thieves who injured the public should be grateful for the opportunity to be an so that they could finally be of some use to society. The disdain for the criminal classes was even more obvious from the state. Linebaugh writes, neither the crown, which granted the bodies of condemned felons to the physician and the surgeons, nor of a legislature, which strengthened by law the royal grants,
Starting point is 00:18:11 regarded the dissection of felons from the standpoint of science. Far from it, they were motivated less by the hope of causing health and sound limbs than by the anticipation of dishonor to the scum of the people. The grants by the Crown and Parliament weren't enough to slake the anatomists thirst for bodies. The College of Barber Surgeons and Royal College were only promised about 10 corpses annually each. And private medical schools where most of the real anatomical innovation was happening weren't covered by the grants. So the surgeons set to purchasing bodies from the hangmen, who they would bribe with regular, lavish gifts for their favor, and would also purchase bodies from the condemned themselves.
Starting point is 00:18:51 agents of the anatomists would loiter outside Newgate prison were the condemned waited to be brought to the gallows and would offer them money in exchange for their remains. Many took the offer. Some had debts to settle for their families. Others wanted money to purchase fine food, alcohol, and sex work with in their last days, or even to buy nice clothes to die in. That is so messed up.
Starting point is 00:19:14 It's like, hey, you are about to not need any of this in approximately 48 hours. Would you like this sack of gold in exchange for your eyeballs? You can be blackout drunk until you're gone with this. I mean, that does sound, that does sound attractive. It's tempting. It is tempting. If I could interject while we're on the topic of all this hanging, have you guys ever seen the movie Peerpoint?
Starting point is 00:19:39 I think that's what it's called. I have not seen it. It stars Timothy Spall, and it is about the last great hangman in Britain. And if you're a morbid curious person... If you're a fan of capital punishment... Yeah, and a morbid curious person like myself, that is a really kind of in-depth look at capital punishment in the... I believe it's the 1800s.
Starting point is 00:20:05 I'm not totally sure. But it's called PurePoint. It's with Timothy Spall. It's kind of an under-known film. And if that's kind of stuff interests you, I suggest that you check it out. You know, I'll probably check it out. out. I mean, Timothy Spall, I mean, oh, it's a good, you know, good actor. Okay, sorry, go on. So, I don't think any of you will be surprised to learn that the common people of London
Starting point is 00:20:26 fucking hated the Anonymous that came to harvest bodies from the scaffolding. Linebaugh recounts an anecdote of a man named John Hill, who was sentenced to hang in 1744. On the morning of his execution, as Hill exited the chapel at Newgate Prison to be escorted to the gallows, he noticed a gentleman looking at him. He asked the man, Do you know me? No friend, replied the gentleman. I suppose. Said Hill. You are some kind of surgeon, and if I had a knife in my hand, I would slit you down the nose. Already at the mercy of a legal system that many saw as draconian arbitrary
Starting point is 00:21:02 and at the threat of execution for even minor crimes, the lower classes saw anatomization as a final outrage against them by their society's elite. And in response to this outrage, they would riot. Not usually to stop the execution, but to save the bodies of the condemned from the clutches of the surgeons. Author Samuel Richardson described one such riot that he witnessed in 1740. As soon as the poor creatures were half dead, I was much surprised before such a number of peace officers to see the populace fall to hauling and pulling the carcasses with so much earnestness as to occasion several warm recounters and broken heads. These were the friends of the persons executed and some sons sent by private surgeons to obtain bodies for dissection.
Starting point is 00:21:46 The contents weaned these were fierce and bloody and frightful to look at. So, yeah, when the surgeons were snatching the bodies below the gallows, crowds would rush them and start trying to just beat the crap out of them, and they would fight over the corpses. Well, I mean, that makes sense to me in a certain way, because, you know, once, you know, not even taking into account the severity of the crime, but once somebody was executed, they were, innocent. I mean, they had paid the price. They paid the ultimate price, you know, for whatever
Starting point is 00:22:16 they, they had done. And, you know, I could see, you know, family members and friends, you know, believing that the dissection or even just the sort of carting away of the body by people who they didn't know, you know, these sterile doctors and surgeons as further punishment. So that sort of makes sense to me. Absolutely. The composition of the rioting crowds at Tyburn indicates that there was no great separation and sympathy between the broader working class of the time and their society's criminal element. Lineball writes, Vesurgents and physicians called their opponents at the gallows loose and disorderly persons. To Mandeville, they were the scum of the people. To the newspapers that reported the disturbances,
Starting point is 00:22:57 they were simply the mob. Those to whom the felons appealed for help, and those actually initiating the battle for possession of the corpse, can conveniently be described by five kinds of Solidarities, the family, the personal friends, fellow workers, the Irish and sailors. Though, as we shall see, these particular divisions were often transcended in the general passion of struggle. Why do the Irish get their own? Get their own category. All right.
Starting point is 00:23:25 It's like, of course. It's like, you know, hold those Irishmen, they wait outside the dollars, they're waiting to grab the buddies. Yeah, yeah. So, yeah, the essay has a bunch of examples of these connections. For instance, friends and family of the condemned would pool money to outbid the surgeons and purchase the body from the hangmen. And when that failed, they would riot. Brickmakers' guilds, bargemen's associations, and throngs of coachmen would show up to protect members of their own profession who had committed crimes and were sentenced to hang.
Starting point is 00:23:53 And as you said, the Irish. The Irish were disproportionately represented among those who died at Tyburn. And crowds of 40 to 50 Irishmen would gather to snatch their countrymen's remains from the surgeons and ensure them a proper Catholic burial. One of the most interesting stories to me was that of a Scottish sailor named James Buchanan, like the terrible United States president, same name, different guy, who was hanged in a naval gallows in 1738 for murder after he stabbed his ship's fourth mate, arguably in self-defense, arguably, from Linebaugh. The Admiralty expected trouble at the hanging. It ordered the sheriff to mobilize a strong force and asked the parochial officers of Wapping to maintain order
Starting point is 00:24:34 with a competent and sufficient guard. The weather was bitter on the day of the hanging. As it tends to be, the stereotypical hanging weather. Oh, yeah. Hanging weather. The weather was bitter on the day of the hanging. The wind came out of the northeast. Snow had begun to stick on the warehouse gables
Starting point is 00:24:50 and ice formed at the river's edge by the wharfs. A vast crowd of sailors assembled upon the quays and in the wharries and lighters in the river. On the scaffold Buchanan usurped the prerogative of the ordinary of Newgate. He conducted the service from the Presbyterian paris. phrase, and then led the throng in singing the twenty-third psalm. Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil.
Starting point is 00:25:12 For thou art with me, thy rod and thy staff they comfort me. Thou preparest a table before me in the presence of mine enemies. Thou anointest my head with oil, my cup runneth over. The sheriffs, tipstaffs, watch and constabulary could not assure the delivery of his body to the surgeons. Some sailors got on the scaffold and endeavored to cut him down, on which a scuffle ensued. sued. But many other sailors coming to the assistance of those who first made the attempt he was cut down and his body carried off with loud acclamations of joy, accompanied by a great many sailors. In the years following this incident, rumors arose that Buchanan had actually survived
Starting point is 00:25:48 his meeting with the hangman's noose and was still alive. But yeah, just completely crazy story. You know, you go up there, you do the 23rd psalm, and then, you know, you drop and all hell breaks loose. And of course, we are still dealing with this of people who, In some cases, have seen perish with our own eyes or well-documented by the, you know, various multiple media reports. And people still believe, no, no, no, they survived. They survived and they're still alive. And they're biding their time. And they're going to do something, something, something, Trump.
Starting point is 00:26:23 Hey, man, I saw JFK at that football game and Michael Jackson at Wendy's. He was ordering a baconator. I saw it with my own two eyes. He took one bite of the Baconator and was sick for 48 hours, thus preventing him from recording a podcast episode with Julian. Incredible. Okay. Not from personal experience or anything.
Starting point is 00:26:48 It's a different, Julian. By the middle of the 18th century, these riots posed a problem not only for the anatomists being denied bodies, but for the ruling class as a whole. The spectacle of execution was supposed to be a means of social control, by which fear of the state was impressed into the populace by public displays of violence against those who deviated from the imposed order. Instead, those hangings were becoming a stage for that very populace to defy the wishes of their social betters.
Starting point is 00:27:15 If the various apparatuses of the state, such as the city guard, couldn't project enough power to prevent handfuls of hooligans from rising up and saving a body from anatomization, what power would they have in the face of a real widespread social uprising? And maybe people were beginning to notice. These tensions hit ahead with the disturbances at the execution of Bossaberg-Pennlez in 1749. In July of that year, throngs of rowdy sailors returning from the war of Jenkins' ear incited a days-long riot on the strand in London, ultimately setting a number of large fires and destroying several taverns and body houses.
Starting point is 00:27:51 As the upheaval was winding down, two city watchmen discovered Bossaverne Penles, a wigmaker who lived across the street from one of the establishments that had been ransacked, out with an assortment of presumably stolen linens stuffed under his shirt. He was promptly arrested. Penless was tried, not for theft, but for disturbing the peace under the riot act, for being feloniously and riotously assembled to disturbance of the public peace. In September, he was convicted by a jury on this charge, and despite the jury's recommendation of lenience, sentenced to death, along with a number of rioters. Okay, so just for context, if we lived by these rules today, the guy who went to the middle of Times Square, the streamer and was like giving out PS5s, that guy would have been like convicted and hanged.
Starting point is 00:28:41 Well, you have to read the riot act first, which is like this long paper and people, it doesn't really do anything except if you're still rioting by the end of the guy reading the riot act, you get arrested. Oh my God. I can't, I'm just imagining like people standing around the gallows hoisting up their, you know, their brand new PS5s. Chats going wild, you know, they have to put it on slow mode because too many people are, I mean, God. You can find this getting streamed on Twitch from like eight different angles. Yeah. On the one hand, I'm not sure we're all that much better as a society. It's just a little bit sneakier and, and not. quite as public, but I also, oh, God, if this was the practice in today, yeah, exactly. It would be the number one thing streamed on Twitch. Oh, I'm just imagining, um, Gallo's TikTok.
Starting point is 00:29:35 Oh, my God. Like the executioner doing a little dance. Yeah, let's not give anybody any ideas, okay? Oh, no, we probably have. So the evidence on which Penlis was convicted was noticeably shoddy. The star witness against him was a disgruntled innkeeper who was notorious for lying. and in the past had been fined for fraud. And there was a significant doubt that the reading of the riot act,
Starting point is 00:29:57 which was necessary for a rioting conviction, ever actually happens. Justice for Penliz became a cause-seleb across London, with hundreds of people petitioning the king to pardon Penlis or in some other way mitigate his sentence. All 12 jurors on the original case joined the movement, claiming that they had been misled as to the witness against Penlis' credibility. No clemency came from the crown. The ensuing weeks between Penlis' sentencing and his hanging turned chaotic.
Starting point is 00:30:26 It's best here again to read from Linebaugh. The Tyburn Fair at which Penlis and 14 others were hanged were fraught with danger. Crowds had gathered menacingly at the old Bailey to protest at the imprisonment of other rioting sailors. In late September, three weeks before the hanging, some of the condemned prisoners sawed through their chains with tools smuggled into them by friends and attempted to break out. Less than a week before the hanging on 12th October, it was reported that the convicts under sentence of death in Newgate, having got a quantity of gunpowder, chips, and other combustibles, conveyed to them designed to attempt an escape by setting fire to or blowing up part of the said jail.
Starting point is 00:31:05 The plan was discovered, and its perpetrators were placed under heavy guard and chained to the floor. All accounts of the unusually large crowd in the streets that day stressed the prominence of sailors. At the hanging gathered some thousands of sailors, appearing armed with bludgeon's and cutlasses, according to one observer. With the exception of Penlis, all 14 men hanged were sailors. The one woman hanged that day was the daughter of a bar owner, who was married to a seaman. Attempts to rescue the condemned prisoners during the long, crowded procession, were widely reported and feared. Order at the hangings in the year or so preceding that of Penlis was maintained by reliance
Starting point is 00:31:42 upon contingents of the foot and horse guards. A force of over 300 men, armed with swords and javelins, was deployed against the crowd by the London and Middlesex sheriffs and marshals on the day of the hanging. Mounted it on foot, but troops formed concentric circles around the gallows at Tyburn. Linebaugh writes, The multitude of spectators was infinite, though a rescue had been threatened by many, there yet was not the least disturbance, except during a moment at the gallows were a vast body of sailors,
Starting point is 00:32:11 some of whom were armed with cutlasses and all with bludgeonings, began to be very clamorous as the unhappy sufferer was going to be turned off. Order was kept, but at a price. The sheriff avoided a battle at the gallows by taking responsibility for the dead bodies, which he delivered to the friends of the hanged. The vast body of sailors assembled there to save the bodies from the surgeons left Tyburn without having to fight against the surgeons. Penliss was buried in St. Clement's Burial Ground,
Starting point is 00:32:37 whose parishioners had raised a subscription for this purpose. There are some quotes from, like, old British stuff where the phrasing is so awkward. Yeah. You know, I had it once explained to me, you know, it's described as old English, but it's actually not. It's newer English. Yeah, this is modern English. The language was, yeah, the language was newer at that point. So, yeah, interesting stuff. But editing was an immature art at this point. Yeah, I guess, like, you know, they didn't have pencils. They just had, like, what, like quill ink or whatever? The fountain pen was something new and exciting. Yeah. The penless incident marked a major turning point in the relationship between the
Starting point is 00:33:13 masses of London, the surgeons in the ruling classes. In the following half decade, when riots seemed imminent, the guards at the hangings would intervene not to help the anatomists secure their bounties, but to prevent the surgeons from appropriating the remains. In 1752, Parliament passed the Murder Act, which both limited the penalty of anonymization to murderers and required all murderers to either be displayed in chains after their execution or be anatomized. This legislation was designed to relegate the punishment of dissection to only the least sympathetic criminals, while also attempting
Starting point is 00:33:45 to still ensure a steady supply of remains to the anatomists. But once again, the corpses of murderers were not enough to state the demand of the anatomists. While still taking corpses from the gallows, they'd also solicit grave robbers called Resurrection Men to bring them the freshly deceased. Some surgeons even commissioned murder to fill their tables. As in the famous 1828 case of Burke and Hare, when two Scottish inkeepers were caught killing tenants of their Edinburgh boarding house to sell to anatomist Robert Knox. Killing people to sell their bodies to surgeons became known as burking, and the profitable venture inspired a number of copycats,
Starting point is 00:34:21 most notably an entire crime ring that terrorized London in 1831. The history and social hysteria surrounding resurrection men and burkers are themselves very interesting, but we do not have time to get into them too deeply here. What a practice to have for your namesake is just murdering and selling the corpses for money, burking. A very funny thing was that because like Burke became like the namesake of it, when he was eventually tried for what happened, he was sentenced to death, anatomized himself. And I read somewhere that he was turned into wallets for the crowd like his skin was. Yet somehow hair managed to walk free, even though he was just as guilty. But it's not called hearing.
Starting point is 00:35:02 It was called burking. Sounds like hair was better at public relations. You know, you set up Burke to be the fall guy. Five years later, hair is in a general store, you know, buying some tonic. And he pulls out his wallet to pay. And, you know, his buddy with him was like, hey, man, that's, that wallet looks pretty familiar. You didn't, that's, you didn't get like your old buddy's skin, did you?
Starting point is 00:35:29 And he's like, oh, man, he's kind of embarrassed. but the wallet is so popular that, you know, all right, I don't know where I'm going with this bit. I think he might have actually gotten murdered by people who, like, recognized him later, but do not quote me on that. I know I looked up his ultimate fate and it was possibly unsure. I'll issue a correction. I'll issue a correction on the site formerly known as Twitter if I find it something different. I don't think anybody in any of these stories feels like they've got a happy ending. It's like if you somehow managed to escape the news, you're certainly not going to escape.
Starting point is 00:36:02 escape the angry throngs of barbers and surgeons, or, you know, townspeople. Or just random people who want to clobber someone for fun. And that was what happened back in those days. There was a lot more clobbering. You don't see a lot of clobbering today. Got to become a return guy for public violence. A return guy. All of these terrible sources of bodies, the anatomists were still short on corpses.
Starting point is 00:36:30 Janet Phillips' essay, Bodies and Bureaucracy, notes that the number of medical students in Edinburgh in London was increasing. In the 1790s, the number was around 300 across both cities, but by the 1820s, there were over 400 medical students in Edinburgh and almost 1,000 in London. More students meant more bodies were needed. Faced with the demands of the medical establishment and the public's agitation over the perceived endemic burking and grave robbing, Parliament acted and in 1832 passed the Anatomy Act, which would serve as a model for legislation about the procurement of human remains for research world round. The Anatomy Act of 1832 allowed relatives of the deceased
Starting point is 00:37:10 to donate their bodies to science voluntarily. But more importantly, it gave surgeons and their students legal access to the bodies from workhouses, hospitals, and prisons that remained unclaimed 48 hours after death. In the Anatomy Act of 1832, the story of body snatching dissections in the rise of anatomy. Rebecca Burroughs notes that many terms in the act remained ambiguous, vague, and did not touch upon how the bodies were to be chosen.
Starting point is 00:37:36 Workers at applicable institutions were not required to make the very poor who lived there, aware that they were required to affirmatively opt out of anatomization. The act also did not require that the family of the deceased be located and notified, so their absence could be taken as acceptance for dissection. That's crazy. The burden of anonymization, therefore, fell again on an underclass, and this time an especially friendless and destitute portion of it. The surgeon's harvesting of the remains transitioned from
Starting point is 00:38:05 playing out on the public stage of the execution scaffold to occurring as a quiet, unnoticed interaction in a back alley behind a poorhouse. Britain's poor, of course, found this horrific. Burroughs describes how the poor and workhouses began to petition Parliament to revoke the bill, because they regarded the bill as a gross violation of the feelings of our poor brethren, and one which encouraged a heartless system of infidelity, which would have us repudiate the blessed hope of immortality, and place ourselves on a level with the beasts that perish. Despite these petitions and a handful of smaller riots,
Starting point is 00:38:41 nothing in particular changed. In her seminal work on the topic, death dissection in the destitute, Ruth Richardson estimates that of the 57,000 bodies dissected within the first hundred years of the act's implementation, less than half of a percent came from anywhere other of an institutions which housed the poor. In some sense, like it had once been a final punishment for criminals, an atomization and dissection became a sort of final insult for the lower class. Each culture on this earth has its own unique belief surrounding death and the proper treatment of human remains. These rituals serve emotional needs for the loved ones of the deceased,
Starting point is 00:39:17 and in many cases the promise of receiving them after death comforts those who are still alive. Richardson wrote in Death Dissection in the Destitute that in 18th and 19th century London, there exists a widely held belief that a strong tie existed between the remains of a recently deceased individual and their soul for an undefined period after their death, and that the post-mortem customs and rituals enacted by the friends and family of the deceased could impact the ultimate fate of the deceased soul. Contemporary funeral customs, such as holding an in-house wake, washing the dead, and dressing the corpse for the grave, served to soothe, And I quote, that raw nerve of the psyche which finds great difficulty in adjusting to loss,
Starting point is 00:39:58 in contemplating death and in achieving the transition from grief to equilibrium, which treads a faltering path between love and mortal fear. According to Richardson, because of the meanings and values attached to the customary treatment of the dead in the early 19th century, dissection was not only seen as disrespectful towards the dead, but also the deliberate mutilation or destruction of identity, perhaps for eternity. horror of anatomization in the 18th and 19th century is, at least in part, deeply rooted in the dehumanization the process is perceived to entail. Lineball writes, with the advance and understanding
Starting point is 00:40:33 of anatomy and the corresponding development of private trade and corpses, we can find in the early 18th century a significant change in the attitude towards the dead human body. The corpse becomes a commodity with all of the attributes of property. It could be owned privately. It could be bought and sold, a value not measured by the grace of heaven nor the fires of hell, but quantifiably expressed in the magic of the price list was placed upon the corpse. Through the buying of a selling and the trade of remains, either at the gallows or in the poor house, or commandeered by a resurrection man or Berker, the deceased individual seized in many ways to be a person and became an object to be sold, bought, abused, and disposed of at the whims of others. And I think vits in large part the horror
Starting point is 00:41:19 of what happened to Mr. Dotson and Mr. Singleton, already incarcerated in a situation where they couldn't control their environment, they were at the mercy of the state. They died, and then they were further treated in a way that deeply disrespected them in their wishes, and the wishes of the family left behind to grieve them. They were people, but not in the eyes of the state apparatus
Starting point is 00:41:37 that controlled their fate. There is something deeply demoralizing about the idea that one is worthless to the powers that be as an individual person with unique thoughts, hopes, and dreams, then as an assembly of body parts to be subdivided in souls. This naturally leads to anxiety that one will be left to die or even be murdered for access to remains. And I also think that a similar fear is the driving force
Starting point is 00:42:01 at the heart of Adrenoth Chrome extraction conspiracy theories, where human life and agency are extinguished by an unstoppable cabal of elites, all for access to a wonder narcotic. It's a tale of transformation of the person into an anonymous consumable bio-resource against their will. a narrative of degradation and dehumanization. So in my opinion, there is certainly no inherent in dignity in having one's body dissected. Donated human remains are essential for medical education, training, and research.
Starting point is 00:42:31 Medical researchers developing new medicines, instruments, devices, and implants, and other treatments rely on bodies for their work. Doctors, dentists, nurses, paramedics, and surgeons all need access to human remains to learn how to do their jobs, which save and improve countless lives. And a lot of people nowadays genuinely like the idea that they can help society after they're gone by donating their remains. But what matters is that the people, and that to some degree their families, donate their bodies to science with informed consent and it's done so fully willingly without coercion. This is a fraught situation for prisoners, and it's also fraught for people who are so poor they cannot afford a cremation or burial. And that's right, we're going to get to the final section of today's episode.
Starting point is 00:43:12 Today is a bit of a spiritual successor to the Anatomy Act of 1832. There exists in the United States a troubling and by-large unregulated industry that profits from the donated dead, many of which are individuals that donated their bodies because their families could not afford a burial. Modern body trade. Okay, this is where it gets really fucking grim, by the way. All right, as if everything that has come before, this wasn't like super grim. It's going to get worse. So trigger warning, if decomposing deholified bodies, you know, give you the willies, maybe skip this part, would you say?
Starting point is 00:43:52 Yeah, or listen to it twice. Yeah, or twice or three times. Or make it your new identity. Up to you. This next section relies heavily on the Reuters investigative series, The Body Trade, cashing in on the donated dead, published in 2017 and 2018. The link to this reporting is in the episode description, and I highly recommend. listeners read it. Fair warning, it is pretty gruesome, and there is so much screwed up about this industry that what I discuss here is just going to be the tip of the iceberg. So through
Starting point is 00:44:21 interviews and public records, Reuters identified 34 bodybrokers active across America in the five-year span prior to the publication of their story. 25 of the 34 body brokers were for-profit corporations, and the remaining nine operated as non-profits. Of America's 50 states, in 2018, only New York, Virginia, Oklahoma, and Florida closely tracked donation in sales of human remains. Data obtained by Reuters under public record laws from those states provide a snapshot of the industry. Reuters calculated that from 2011 through 2015, private brokers received at least 50,000 bodies and distributed more than 182,000 body parts. Florida and Virginia require permits for body sales, and the paperwork gives an illustration of the
Starting point is 00:45:08 state of the industry. A 2013 shipment to a Florida orthopedic training class included 27 shoulders. A 2015 shipment to a teaching seminar in carpal tunnel syndrome in Virginia included five arms. Listeners might want to know how much body parts cost. Reuters found that a whole body went for around $3,000 to $5,000, though prices may sometimes exceed $10,000 with market fluctuations. More often, cadavers are divided into multiple parts. A body, can fetch more dismembered and sold in pieces than it can hold. The costs of some of these. $3,500 for a torso with legs. $500 for a head. $350 for a foot and $300 for a spine. One of the brokers investigated by Reuters earned at least $12.5 million from their business over the
Starting point is 00:45:58 course of three years. Jesus. So basically the price for an entire human body is roughly about the same as getting a really good gaming PC. Like, if you're getting like a 40-90, you know, an RTX 40-80, 40-90, you're getting an I-7 or an I-9, you know, a solid SSD, you know, decent quality motherboard, you're paying about the same as these brokers do for a dead corpse. Yeah. So, you know, if you really want to upgrade your gaming experience, you know what you have to do. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Starting point is 00:46:36 They're introducing a new sort of liquid cooling apparatus that's made from the internal fluids of a corpse. I feel terrible making this joke. I'm going to say I want to cut it out, but I'm going to leave it in. You know, I don't quite fully understand the economics of this either, because you only have one spine in the body and two feet, yet a single spine that's worth less than a single foot. Maybe there's more demand for feet. Like, you know, foot doctors need to practice more. Hmm. Yeah, all right.
Starting point is 00:47:10 Maybe. Yeah, those cheapo chiropractors, those quack chiropractors. They are not willing to pony up for a spine to practice on. Dr. Scholes has enlisted the brokerage of 10,000 human bodies to perfect their in-soul orthopedics. Oh, God. Dr. Scholl, otherwise known as Dr. Death. Dr. Scholl, he's buying up bodies quicker than you could say Joe Biden. He's buying bodies.
Starting point is 00:47:40 He's taking their feet. It's Dr. Scholl, or we call him Dr. Death. Not to be confused with the other doctor death, Dr. Scholl, much more evil, part of the cabal. There's a couple of doctor deaths. So these remains do not always stay in the United States. An investigation by John Shipman and Reed Levinson tracked the sale of a pelvis and legs to a university in Malaysia, feet to medical device companies in Turkey, heads to hospitals in Slovenia and the UAE
Starting point is 00:48:06 and to plastic surgeon training schools in Germany. Demand for body parts from Americans is especially high in countries where laws or the religious traditions of large portions of the population prohibit the dissection of the dead. No other nation has both the infrastructure and lack of regulation
Starting point is 00:48:22 that enables the collection and sale of corpses in the same way America does. Reuters found that since 2008, America-based body brokers have exported parts of Americans to at least 45 countries, including Italy, Israel, China, Mexico, Venezuela, and Saudi Arabia. These body brokers have also become intertwined with the American funeral industry. Reuters identified 62 funeral operators in business arrangements with brokers. The brokers will pay morticians' referral fees ranging from $300 to $1,400 for access to remains.
Starting point is 00:48:56 These payments allow morticians to make money preparing the remains of loved ones of families who might not otherwise be able to afford cremation. These relationships raise conflicts of interest by incentivizing funeral homes to encourage grieving relatives to donate their loved ones remains, often glossing over or neglecting to inform them about what happens to the corpse. Sometimes funeral directors go into the body brokerage business for themselves, and some states, including Colorado, have tried to stem this practice by making it illegal for the same person to own a funeral home and a body broker business. But that won't stop the referral scheme described above.
Starting point is 00:49:31 One particularly upsetting story from the investigative series is that of a man named Cody Saunders. Cody was born in 1992 with multiple severe health problems, including a hole in his heart and failing kidneys. Over the course of his life, he took over 1,700 hours of dialysis and underwent 66 surgeries. Cody lived together with his parents in Tennessee. He enjoyed watching football, and when he was well enough, he worked on a farm with his father. On his 24th birthday, August 2nd, 2016, Cody suffered a heart attack and passed away.
Starting point is 00:50:03 Cody's parents wanted to bury Cody beside relatives in a nearby cemetery, but the family, living on an income of only $900 a month, did not have enough money to purchase a plot, afford a burial, or even spend about $700 to have Cody cremated. So they donated Cody's body to a company called Restore Life, which offered free cremation to the deceased in exchange for tissue for medical research. At the time of the arrangement, it seems like a blessing. Based on consent paperwork provided to the Saunders by Restore Life, the Saunders family believe this meant that restore life would remove small skin samples from Cody, cremate the rest of his body, and then return his ashes. Other reporting from the Reuter series indicates that many bereaved families and individuals
Starting point is 00:50:46 making their own end-of-life choices who read consent paperwork for body notations are led to believe that only skin samples are going to be taken from the bodies due to the use of the word tissue, which actually functions as a sort of euphemism for organs, limbs, torsos, basically the entire body. The Restore Life consent form, Vassander signed for Cody, didn't disclose that a donated body may be dismembered. From the article by Brian Groh and John Schiffman. The month after Cody died, Restore Life sold part of the young man's body, his cervical spine.
Starting point is 00:51:18 The transaction required just a few email exchanges and $300 plus shit. shipping. Whether Restore Life vetted the buyer is unclear, but if workers there had verified their customer's identity, they would have learned he was a reporter from Reuters. The news agency was seeking to determine how easy it might be to buy human body parts and whether those parts would be useful for medical research. In addition to the spine, Reuters later purchased two human heads from Restore Life each priced at $300. The transactions demonstrate the startling ease with which human body parts may be bought and sold in the United States. Neither the sales nor the shipments violated any laws, say lawyers, professors, and government officials who follow the issue
Starting point is 00:52:00 closely. Although it's illegal to sell organs used for transplants, it's perfectly legal in most states to sell body parts that were donated for research or education. Buying wine over the internet is arguably more tightly controlled, generally requiring at minimum proof of age. The hardship the family faced is not uncommon among donors, said Martha Thaler, chair of the mortuary science program at Arapaho Community College in Colorado. Brie families are, quote, vulnerable and are being put in the position of choosing. Brie families are, quote, vulnerable and are being put in the position of choosing this as an option when they don't have money, Thaler said. Quote, the only thing that's more sad than a person who can't afford to live is a person who can't afford to die.
Starting point is 00:52:43 Damn, that's a profound quote, and I think a chilling indictment of our current, of our current reality. Yeah. The Saunders say that they would not have donated Cody's remains if they would have known he would be dissected. They felt he had already been through too many surgeries during his short life. And yet, his father added, I couldn't afford to do nothing else, so I felt like that was the best option that we had. Another deeply upsetting story is that of Doris Stouffer, a 74-year-old aeros. Arizona woman who passed away in 2013 after a battle with Alzheimer's. Her family made the decision
Starting point is 00:53:19 to donate her brain to science, hoping the gift might aid the search for a cure to the disease that had taken their grandmother from them. From John Schiffman at Reuters. At a nurse's suggestion, the family contacted Biological Resource Center, a local company that brokered the donation of human bodies for research. Within the hour, BRC dispatched a driver to collect Doris. Jim Stouffer signed a form authorizing medical research on his mother's body. He also checked a box. prohibiting military, traffic safety, and other non-medical experiments. Ten days later, Jim received his mother's cremated remains. He wasn't told how her body had been used.
Starting point is 00:53:53 Records reviewed by Reuters showed that BRC workers detached one of Doris Stouffer's hands for cremation. After sending those ashes back to her son, the company sold and shipped the rest of Stouffer's body to a taxpayer-funded research project for the US Army. Her brain was never used for Alzheimer's research. Instead, Stouffer's body became part of an army experiment to measure damage caused caused by roadside bombs. Internal BRC and military records show that at least 20 other bodies were also used in the blast experiments without permission of the donors or their relatives, a violation of U.S. Army policy. BRC sold donated bodies like Stofer's for $5,893 each.
Starting point is 00:54:32 Army officials involved in the project said they never received the consent forms that donors or their families had signed. Rather, the officials said they relied on assurances from BRC that families had agreed to let the bodies be used in such experiments. The Army's human body experiments were part of a program to protect U.S. soldiers from improvised explosive devices or IEDs. Donated bodies are not obliterated in explosions, a director at the Army Project interviewed by Reuters said, but the blasts do break bones and snap spines. In an experiment witnessed by a Reuters reporter this year, two bodies wired to a hundred biosensors flailed violently during an explosion and came to rest slumped, but intact. This is so fucked up. Yeah, it's bleak. Can you imagine being the guys who are behind the window that are like, you know, doing the, you've got like a dead body strapped to a chair that's 10 feet away from a bomb? Jesus Christ.
Starting point is 00:55:24 Yeah, man, want to order Jimmy Johns for lunch? Like. Oh, yes, still, yeah. For Jimmy Johns, yeah. There's not one near me. So if that's the price I got to pay, then perhaps yes. Working in the explosive body farm? God.
Starting point is 00:55:40 Army policy requires that body donors are next of kin consent to the blast experiments, but records reviewed by Reuters show that the bodies or body parts of 34 people were shipped to the military without donor permission. In 18 of the 34 cases, the donor consent forms neither mentioned nor offered any warning language about potential military experiments. In the remaining 16 instances, the consent form presented an option to allow military and other violent experiments. 12 of the 16 families explicitly rejected violent experiments. Four made no choice. All 16 were shipped to the army anyway. Literally no one said yes to this.
Starting point is 00:56:19 Literally no one that ended up in this experiment said yes to this. And 12, 12 said I would really prefer if my loved ones were maids weren't exploded in military experiments. And they did anyway. Yeah. Yikes. But someone made approximately $6,000 off this. So who's to say if it's good or bad or not? I mean, yeah, I mean, it's like, they did check the form, but, you know, they was like,
Starting point is 00:56:46 there was a used Honda money to make per body. There was one used Honda per corpse being, so, you know, this is a pretty good deal. Hey, Colonel Phillips, come over here and check this form. It's a little bit smudged right on the area where it says, do not use for military explosions. Does that look like a check to me or does that look like a mistake? to, I think it kind of looks like a mistake to me. Unimaginably bleak. So currently no federal regulation of this body brokerage industry exists.
Starting point is 00:57:17 And at the more local level, regulation and enforcement varies from state to state. But that might change. Fortunately, coverage of this issue by reporters from Reuters and other outlets and advocacy of families and groups like the National Funeral Directors Association has led Congress to take notice. The Consensual Donation and Research Integrity Act, introduced by Gus Billeracus, a Republican from Florida, and Texas Democrat Lizzie Fletcher, provide the Secretary of Health and Human Services with oversight of entities that deal with human bodies and non-transplantable body parts donated for education, research, and the advancement of medical, dental, and mortuary science. Similar bipartisan efforts in the Senate are being led by Chris Murphy of Connecticut and Tom Tillis of North Carolina. Among other provisions in these bills, they will require inspections of facilities involved in the body trade, require informed consent when a donation is made, and create a clear chain of custody for each human body or body part.
Starting point is 00:58:17 If these bills are passed, they will ensure that shipments of human bodies and body parts are properly labeled and packaged, and ensure the respectful and proper disposition of donated bodies and parts. And importantly, the consensual donation and research integrity act would establish penalties for those who violate. these laws. The legislation has yet to be passed, and hopefully one day it will be. So thank you for sticking with me on this journey where I explained how modern medical science was in large part built and continues to grow upon a foundation of the appropriated skeletons of the lower classes. Do either of you have any closing thoughts on this? Well, you know, I again return to the bafflement of the richness of material that you could be outraged by. The, um, the, um, I, I again return to the bafflement
Starting point is 00:58:57 of the richness of material that you could be outraged by, the amount of real horror and exploitation that goes on in using people's organs and bodies and body parts. But instead, of course, conspiracists, they reject, you know, well-reported information like that from Reuters. Instead, they like talking about these fantasies and seeing secret codes. It's just, it's very, very frustrating because, you know, It's just a lot of outrage and energy that's being misdirected.
Starting point is 00:59:30 Yeah, as is usually the case. I mean, imagine the kind of mental gymnastics that a pilled person would have to do to come to terms with the fact that the U.S. military is actually the one trafficking body parts to figure out how to better protect their soldiers during an IED attack. It's pretty insane, I got to say. And I will close with this, a little bit of a personal story. I myself have seen and interacted with a cadaver. When I was about 14 years old, I enrolled in an AP Biology summer school program.
Starting point is 01:00:14 And one of the field trips, we took to a morgue. And I remember it pretty well. The thing that I remember the most is that we got into the sort of, examining room. And, you know, some kids were, you know, excused from it. There were a couple kids who basically got in. They smelled the formaldehyde. They were like, uh, I'm out. No thanks. Yeah, I'm out, which it was the smart thing to do. And the rest of us kind of stood and there was a body that was on a slab and it was covered, right? There was a sheet over its body and its head. And at one point, the medical student or the doctor, I can't remember which, walked over and he was
Starting point is 01:00:55 beginning to sort of do his lesson about, you know, human anatomy and that sort of stuff. And we got to hold the heart, we got to hold the lungs, all of this stuff. But the thing I remember the most is at one point he walked over to the body and he said, oh, we're actually not going to need this. And he reached down and grabbed the head, which was covered by, you know, a towel and lifted it up off the table and put it in a different, you know, different place. Up until this point, we had no idea. I had no idea that the body I was looking at already had a detached head.
Starting point is 01:01:24 It looked like it was all together. So he walked over, he picked this thing up, and he was like, oh, we're not going to be looking at this today. And he lifted the head up and, like, put it somewhere else. And I decided at that point that perhaps AP biology wasn't for me. I devoted my life to the arts and entertainment. I pursued an acting degree, and that was the last time that young Jake Rockatansky fortunately interacted with a human cadaver. Thank you for listening to another episode of the QAA podcast. You can go to patreon.com slash QAA
Starting point is 01:01:59 and subscribe for five bucks a month to get access to a whole host of premium episodes as well as ongoing miniseries like Perverts and a season two of trickle-down that are happening right now and also, you know, season one of trickle-down. You'll get access to Spectral Voyager, my series with Brad. So there's a whole lot of content there. so if you've run through all of the main episodes and you are bored and you like hearing us discuss weird kind of stuff like this,
Starting point is 01:02:27 I encourage you to go to patreon.com and sign up. Allie, where can people find more of your work? I post on, I guess, X sometimes at Pineal DeCalcalfi. Most of my account is just dedicated to complaining about the train service in Chicago. So if you want to check that out, you can find me there. Absolutely. If you're somebody who's upset at the standard of service of the trains running in Chicago, which are, you know, are said to have notoriously a decent public transportation, but you know the real truth. Go follow at Peneal to Calcify on X, platform formerly known as Twitter.
Starting point is 01:03:08 Listener, until next week, may Videep Dish bless you and keep you. It's not a conspiracy. It's a fact. And now, today's auto kill. This morning, the daughters of a New Hampshire sheriff's deputy who passed away in 2019 say they're horrified to learn their father's body was part of a grotesque criminal scheme at Harvard University. FBI agents yesterday arrested this man, Cedric Lodge, for allegedly stealing and selling dissected human body parts while he was manager of the morgue at Harvard Medical School. Investigators say in a scheme dating back to 2018, Lodge stole heads, brains, skin, and bones from cadavers
Starting point is 01:03:46 donated to the school for educational purposes. He then allegedly brought those parts to his home and, with his wife's help, sold them for tens of thousands of dollars. Who could do something like that? You know, what kind of person? No respect at all for the family. They need to pay. Do you have anything to say to the family?
Starting point is 01:04:03 No. Buyers identified in the indictment include Katrina McLean, owner of Cat's Creepy Creations, a Massachusetts store that advertises creations that shock the mind and shake the soul. Officials say she and others were allowed to enter the morgue and choose what they wanted to buy, some items selling for hundreds of dollars each. In one case, skin that was sold was allegedly made into leather. And a PayPal account from one client allegedly included a transaction labeled head number seven. The deans at Harvard Medical School calling the allegations an abhorrent betrayal.
Starting point is 01:04:33 But for the families involved, their trust has been lost. The family of that New Hampshire sheriff's deputy say his wife died earlier this year. Her body was also donated to Harvard. Her daughters now want her body returned. She's down there and we want her back.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.