QAA Podcast - Wild Faith feat. Talia Lavin (E303)

Episode Date: November 27, 2024

The election of Donald Trump means that the Christian right expects to have even more political influence than they did before. That might be bad news for those of us who don’t believe worldly event...s are merely the byproducts of a transcendent spiritual battle of good vs. evil. To better understand the philosophy and goals of American theocrats, Travis and Jake spoke to Talia Lavin, author of Wild Faith: How the Christian Right Is Taking Over America. We explore her research into how rightwing evangelical Christians have worked to become a powerful constituency over past five decades, the modern-day prophets and apostles who drive the movement, the Christian Patriarchy movement which justifies the subjugation of women and the abuse of children, and why extremist Christians so easily became online conspiracy theorists. It’s challenging subject matter which is made more palatable by Talia’s deep knowledge and Jake making an overextended metaphor about eating moldy bagels. Talia Lavin on Bluesky https://bsky.app/profile/swordsjew.bsky.social Wild Faith: How The Christian Right Is Taking Over America by Talia Lavin https://bookshop.org/p/books/wild-faith-how-the-christian-right-is-taking-over-america-talia-lavin/21057649 Subscribe for $5 a month to get all the premium episodes: www.patreon.com/QAA Editing by Corey Klotz. Theme by Nick Sena. Additional music by Pontus Berghe, Nick Sena, Jake Rockatansky. Theme Vocals by THEY/LIVE (https://instagram.com/theyylivve / https://sptfy.com/QrDm). Cover Art by Pedro Correa: (https://pedrocorrea.com) https://qaapodcast.com QAA was known as the QAnon Anonymous podcast.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Thank you. If you're hearing this, well done, you've found a way to connect to the internet. Welcome to the QAA podcast, episode 303, Wild Faith, featuring Talia Lavin. As always, we're your host, Jake Rockatansky, and Travis View. Listener, I know you have a lot on your plate right now. They're trying to keep your home in order and do a good job at work. And it's the holiday season, so your to-do list is even longer than usual. And if you're anything like me, you've been preoccupied with thinking about
Starting point is 00:01:00 how the forces of history are going to affect you and the people you care about. So I don't mean to pile on, but you should know that you were involved in a spiritual war. You are a figure in a cosmic battle that can be seen in interpersonal relationships and society, but has its source in a transcendent struggle of good versus evil. You may not believe this to be true, but the Christian evangelical right, a major faction of the ascendant political regime, does believe it's true. And if you're listening to this podcast, then they, probably would consider you a soldier in the devil's army.
Starting point is 00:01:33 That may become a bigger issue in the coming years because the people guided by these apocalyptic visions intend to win the spiritual war by exercising real political power. To get a better understanding of the Christian right and their vision for America, we are joined by three-time QAA guest Talia Lavin. She is the author of the book Culture Warlords, My Journey Into the Dark Web of White Supremacy.
Starting point is 00:01:56 Today we're going to talk about her newest book, Wild Faith, How the Christian Right is Taking Over America. Talia, thank you so much for coming on again. Oh my God, I'm so delighted. And also, that was an amazing cold open. Like, I thought you were going to be doing an ad for, like, SimplySafe. You know, or something? Yeah.
Starting point is 00:02:16 We haven't quite transitioned to advertising precious metals and stones and coins yet, but given the recent events, I think we're headed there shortly. I mean, I just was like, oh, cool. they're doing an ad for like square space but no it was like ah you're in the devil's army and it was so perfect and disarming i loved it i mean that that's more or less like how i start the book too it's like you don't know it oh yeah oh yeah no no i'll be clear i ripped off your concept it's very very good i thought i was like oh that's so good i'm gonna do it in podcast form oh no it was beautiful i have to be honest i have not finished the book yet but i have been listening
Starting point is 00:02:53 to it on audible and you do such a good job narrating the book like you have, Travis and I were talking about this actually before you hopped on, is you are delving into these very, very dark topics. But the writing and especially, you know, the way that you narrate the book is very gentle. You kind of like gently let people know how like disturbing some of this stuff is. And it's a very fine balance. So congratulations on figuring that out somehow. Well, it was my inner, it's my inner theater kid just like jumping up and like, Being so excited, I can do little voices, some unfortunate. I got called out on Goodreads for having a terrible Trump impression, but, like, who doesn't?
Starting point is 00:03:37 Yeah, who doesn't? I've got a horrible one. I'm lying. I think I'm probably top 50. Yeah, I mean, I'm not like James Adomian or whatever, or that guy on SNL. But, you know, yeah, like, one has to do what one has to do. No, and my goal, I think form and function are really tied together. I think a lot of books about the right wing are very dry, and I try to infuse the prose
Starting point is 00:03:58 with a little bit of that excitement, and then the narration, like, I'm in this with you, I'm angry with you, I'm frightened with you, I'm figuring this out with you, and like, let's delve into this madness together and do it in a way that's, like, bright and horrifying, but compelling. And that starts very much by being like, hey, you, you're in the army. The army of hell. Yeah. So you have, you make these little, you know, you have this creative use of language and the way that you sort of unfold the, information, even when you're talking about, like, really wretched things, like, like, you know, physical abuse, you're able to present it in a way that is, you know, very comfortable and
Starting point is 00:04:38 very sort of, like, easy to digest without, like, downplaying the darkness. So that's, that's, that's quite a feat. So I enjoy it. Well, I mean, you guys know how to do that better than anyone. That's what you do. Like, you have to look at the horror straight in the face, but, like, you know, you've got to make the occasional joke or just write a beautiful sentence, do something to redeem it because otherwise you're just driving yourself insane. Yeah. Well, that's what happens when we hit like stop record is that I, we leave the show and then at least for me personally, I go and I'm insane in my real life.
Starting point is 00:05:10 I mean, I'm sure you can relate to that as, you know, somebody who, you know, was raised Orthodox Jew, you know, diving into extreme Christianity and its pervasiveness, you know, throughout the history of this country. Oh, yeah. I mean, one thing I think that that did. give me as like so I was raised you know modern orthodox so I was allowed to go to college but um I went to modern orthodox school and I lived in a very heavily Jewish town and so I grew up like with modesty rules enforced on my clothing and like kosherut of dictating everything I ate in this very
Starting point is 00:05:45 homogenous closed religious community until college which is a huge culture shock and so when I interviewed about 150 former evangelicals for this book we'll see about gender roles and and abusive childhoods. And so I think I was able to approach it without being like, you freak, God determined your childhood, what are you talking about? But also without like a pocket Jesus that I was holding up against the version of their
Starting point is 00:06:09 that their churches held forward where I was like, your Jesus is wrong. I was like, I don't have one. So tell me what yours is like. So I think in that way, even though people are a little iffy about a Jew writing a whole book about the Christian, right? I'm like, actually, I think it equipped me
Starting point is 00:06:25 in certain ways. I can just approach this and be like, so what's, what's going on? What do you believe? And as I think you guys are uniquely equipped to, like, so much of like my work on extremism and now the Christian right, people approach it with the skepticism of just like, how can these people really believe that? You know, surely they can't really believe that stuff. And you have to be like, no, they really do. Like their belief is, you could bounce pennies off it. It is so strong. And just as they think, you think, believing that, like, politics is a theater of war between demons and angels and, like, everything you do is either in service of Lucifer or in the service of the host of
Starting point is 00:07:05 heaven seems bananas. Like, to them, the fact that we're so stuck in the material plane that we're completely ignoring this celestial war unfolding all around us is, like, just as bananas. You know, these are very durable, very real systems of belief that are not, I mean, sure, there's cynical power grabs involved too, but like they've also built up a very elaborate structure to justify wanting temporal power for celestial reasons. Yeah, I mean, this is, I mean, they have a, have an interesting experience because they're all, they're operating on multiple planes, right? This is not just like, you know, people who, you know, operate from a, I guess, materialist perspective, you know, there's just, that's just, uh, our dirty, uh, physical.
Starting point is 00:07:49 reality. But there's, there's this, in their world, there's this interaction between, you know, our physical reality and this, yeah, this higher transcendent reality where like the real important stuff is going on. And this stuff that we can see is just a manifestation what's going on in there. In incredibly literal ways, I mean, encountered this mindset in different ways, like just how many exorcists there are in the U.S., both like the Catholic exorcists, but also deliverance ministers is like the Protestant term for it. And like there is one in your town. Like if you Google deliverance minister in my town, there's one in your town, almost certainly. And you can also
Starting point is 00:08:28 do it by Zoom, get exorcised by Zoom. And it's like, are you tired? Are you clumsy? Are you sad? You may be the victim of a demon. And then you watch these like testimonial videos and it's people like throwing up in a bucket as like a congregation lays hands on them and like getting the demons out by like, you know in Jesus name and like frankly if I thought that that would cure my anxiety like I'm in that basement absolutely but you know the other piece is like so I did a lot of reading of like another commonality is like both you and me and you guys have consumed a lot of terrible right wing art or like propagandistic right wing art and media and one of the most striking ones and like every former evangelical kid of a certain age has read it this present darkness by frank
Starting point is 00:09:12 Peretti was this whole series of novels and this present darkness is about like the battle for the soul of an American town and like it's so literal like there's this whole scene where the pastor's wife is like in a parking lot and some scary demonically possessed like bikers like approaching her car and like an angel and a demon have a battle over her parking break and like the angel slays the demon but dies in the process and she's able to free her parking break and get home Oh my god. This is like Constantine with Keanu Reeves, but like, for children? Yeah, we're like, whatever. It's like written like Tom Clancy style.
Starting point is 00:09:48 It's sort of a supermarket thriller kind of prose and every single person. Like if you mention it on social media, like every former evangelical is like, oh yeah, I read that. Totally. Like I read that in church. I read that in camp. You know, everyone was reading it because it is like a fun, fun read. But it's like, and of course theologians are like, hey, this isn't really how that works. And everyone else is like, you're boring.
Starting point is 00:10:10 Shut up. So this pop culture influenced vision of like. A very literal war playing out all around us becomes the dominant, like, worldview on the evangelical right, and it's really so manifest in every day. And, like, why you'll see. Like, the term demoncrat is, like, actually quite literal for a lot of people. Yeah. Not just a clever word play. Well, gosh, if like every action and inaction can be explained or examined through the lens of two sides of morality, fighting against it like gosh if every time i was trying to like unscrew a screw that had been stripped and i couldn't get it i'm trying and i'm feeling like a failure and i'm no good at
Starting point is 00:10:55 carpentry or you know handy stuff if i could be like well the demons won that one like that kind of takes me out of the equation it's a very attractive way even though you're filled with fear all the time i would imagine at least it's not you it's these other entities that are controlling you or fighting for your love. And, you know, if you just pray hard enough, you know, you can sort of prevail. Yeah. And I saw a Christian podcast. It was like, you know, if you, like, have an appointment or like a date or something you want to go do, and then at the last minute, you feel like, I don't really want to go. I just want to stay home. That's the devil working on you. Because, like, you're meant to go do that thing in service of God. And that's the devil working on you. And I'm like,
Starting point is 00:11:38 for me, it usually means I just want to nap and I'm tired. But like, yeah, the devil is. is making you want to nap. Like, it's very literal. Or for me, it's like, I'm, like, having social anxiety and I'm worried that I'm going to, like, oh, if I go out into public, my friends, like, I could have a panic attack and embarrass myself. And if I just stay home, you know, I don't put myself out there. So, yes, of course, it would be very easy to be like, ah, well, the devil is trying to, like, it does, it takes, like, mental health out of the equation in a way that I think is
Starting point is 00:12:07 probably attractive for a lot of people. Or just like Satan is giving you panic attacks. Yeah. Which I do feel like sometimes. Yeah, sometimes. Whatever. Panic attacks are the worst. Like, I would love to blame them on like, but vomit instead of just like faulty genetics or whatever.
Starting point is 00:12:22 But no, and then the spiritual war is interesting also because there is, as a Christian, you're urged to don the whole armor of God. And it's like a mech suit, a spiritual mech suit of like, you know, the shield of truth and the sandals of righteousness and the sword of the Lord and all this stuff. And so, you know, you see this applied in so many cases, a lot of times it's like, if you are unhappy in your marriage, I'm like, you want to leave, you should don the whole armor of God and stay with your shitty husband forever. And it's like, oh, man, okay, woof. But yeah, I mean, spiritual warfare is a fascinating doctrine. And I think it explains a great deal of how pitched and how menachian American political dialogue is. But there's a lot that goes into the creation of that and a lot about the Christian right and many, many ways that it intersects with QAnon for sure. Yeah, you do have like some really interesting sections in QAnon in the book.
Starting point is 00:13:23 In fact, you quote, you quote Julian. And I especially love like there's this one paragraph that explains why evangelicals just immediately took the QAnon. They just, it was just natural for them to start engaging with that. Because, you know, it feels like that that requires some explaining. It's like, why did they, it seems like more than any other demographic, like hear about these internet posts that can reveal secrets about a history changing battle of good versus evil, but only if those posts are decoded properly and say, that makes perfect sense to me, I'm in. But in your book, you have this paragraph that you explain why QAnon falls perfectly in line with how a lot of evangelicals interact with text and reality. This kind of salvo connecting public events, demons and prophetic power, is something millions of American evangelicals, find comfortingly familiar. It mirrors their childhood information diets in which ministers cooked up
Starting point is 00:14:14 apocalyptic predictions from Bible verses and spiritual warfare doctrine placed a demon on every shoulder. As the journalist and ex- Evangelical, Sam Tealman put it in 2020, many evangelicals grew up with a mindset that, quote, takes metaphorical passages in the Bible and tries to decode them into both individual prophecies that refer directly to current events as well as a larger metaproids. prophecy, ending in the rapture of believers to heaven, the coming of the Antichrist, and the Battle of Armageddon, end quote. No wonder they've taken so well to digital era conspiracy theories. They were raised seeing signs and wonders, coded miracles and tribulations. They just took it to social media and found a plethora of new souls to convert. Yeah, couldn't say it
Starting point is 00:15:01 better myself. I mean, it really is. It's that simple. I love this because, I suppose like the stereotype is the idea of like if you're deeper religious, you have this old-time religion, maybe you're not, maybe you don't take too advanced or new communication technology that that easily. But it shows like, no, no, actually, the way that you sort of people interact and communicate and like understand information online is just perfect for like how evangelicals sort of like, you know, were raised with this idea of science and wonders and like Bible code stuff. Yeah, and prophecy. Like all these books of prophecy. And now like a charismatic movement towards prophecy and all these prophets.
Starting point is 00:15:39 I'm sure you guys have heard of like Julie Green and like Lance Walnau, and these people, you know, saying like the Biden is an agent of Satan and a whale will be in the news for an unusual reason, which is my favorite prophecy ever from Julie Green, like in the middle of like a really long diatribe. I think that was like in 2020 or whatever. I mean, religion and technology have always evolved together and often new technology can be like the site of religious anxieties. So we see that in like these.
Starting point is 00:16:06 recurrent mark of the beast panics that I talk about in the book like a barcodes were the mark of the beast and then it was you know RFID trips and then it was the COVID vaccine you have these recurrent like new technology becomes the outlet for religious anxiety or anxiety about technology is finds an outlet in religion and then at the same time I mean like from the printing press onward, like, which the printing press was a huge part of, like, the reformation wars about Christianity, you know, and social media has become a religious outlet for a lot of people. But, like, yeah, it doesn't have to be, like, the most ultra-sophisticated. I mean, we're talking about, like, memes on Facebook about how, like, Trump is King David reincarnate
Starting point is 00:16:50 and, you know, think of the, like, all the stuff about clocks and kids. But, you know, if you grow up with this idea that, like, the world is just this veil for for the spirit behind it and that we're counting down to the apocalypse and like here's all the ways that the apocalypse is nigh then yeah like understanding the world as a series of coded messages is really not that foreign an idea so i would say qanon is both like deliberately christian like q has like cited bible passages lots of times and it's also consonant with christianity evangelical christianity in the u.s and i would call it a christian movement so that like yoga moms who were anti-vax or worried about the fax in 2020, suddenly we're talking about
Starting point is 00:17:37 Satan, like within two months of starting to ask questions. You know, all of this stuff really taps into demons really fast. I mean, how much have you guys heard about sacrifices to Lucifer and children's blood and all the stuff? That's, I mean, that's the interesting stuff. Because, you know, QAnon at the very, very beginning, and I know that Travis and Julian have corrected me in the past that whoever was posting did dive into religious symbolism and ideology pretty early on. But it was, you know, it was like SpyGate stuff. It was about Trump was unfairly surveillance by the FBI and he had caught them in
Starting point is 00:18:12 this trap and everybody was going down. And that stuff didn't stick. As QAnon got more and more popular, it wasn't because there was more stuff coming out about SpyGate. It was because there was more content being written about this bad. between light and dark, a great awakening. All of this stuff is incredibly spiritual. Yeah, so it's, I totally agree with you that that is the exciting part, I think, for people who believe in QAnon still. I think that, like, belief has been a primary human drive since, like, the
Starting point is 00:18:49 Paleolithic era, you know? We've been carving gods out of rock since we could conceptualize in the abstract. And so it is this primal human drive. And even And secular folks, we have this drive to be part of something bigger than ourselves, to have ideals that we believe in, to make a mark and leave a legacy. So I think it really is this primal human drive that manifests in many ways. And one of those ways is QAnon and the Christian right that sort of gave birth to it or gave it its most compelling images. And so, you know, I think we do ourselves a disservice when we discount.
Starting point is 00:19:28 the strength that belief has. That being said, not all beliefs are created equal. And just because someone believes something sincerely doesn't mean you have to respect it. But you do have to understand it. In order to combat it, you do have to understand it as a sincerely held belief. That's the best way to understand it and therefore to combat it. Yeah, yeah. Sometimes you have to get around the ideas like, no one, no one actually believes that, right? There's something that they say or something that's like just part of maybe their internal kind of like, you know, to each other that they're serious. But they don't like really in their core believe some of these wild claims.
Starting point is 00:20:03 But they absolutely do. They operate, you know, they make their decisions and their interpersonal relationships and like, you know, their politics based upon this belief. Yeah. And you, this has been a particular, I think, failing of the media coverage where you have their coverage of evangelicalism is this fascinating mix of like undue deference where it's like you guys are the real Americans and we're, you know, just a bunch of panty waste elites who are true blue Americans under the flag and the cross, right? But also condescension
Starting point is 00:20:33 where like you guys are a bunch of rubs who don't really possibly, you can't possibly really believe all these things you say you do because everyone secretly in their head is a rationalist skeptic just like I am. I mean, and it's this total failure of empathy or at least like trying to project yourself into a fundamentally different mindset than like a Beltway journal. It's just Like, these are fundamentally different ways of approaching reality, and you can't measure someone else's wheat with your bushel. Like, you cannot project your own mindset into everyone because these are folks who've been inculcated since, like, birth into a very totalizing system of ideas that are fundamentally incompatible with secular, multiracial, multi-credal democracy. And that can be really hard, particularly for the sort of pundit class to wrap their head around. Yeah, yeah. Well, yeah, speaking of, I suppose, the attitudes of, like, you know, Christian nationalists about democracy, I think it's fair to say that they were, they're pretty enthused about the re-election of Donald Trump.
Starting point is 00:21:40 And they see this as an opportunity to remake the country. The Christian nationalist Lance Walnau, who you mentioned, made this explicit in a recent comment about Trump's win. And so we got one administration, one four-year period to do it. The church is going through a reconnolly. configuration right now. We want our revival. But like I was preaching last night, a group of leaders, I said, revival is for us. Reformation is for the institutions. We have to have revived believers, strong and connected as an ecclesia to go where the gates of hell are located in the DOJ, in the government, in the IRS. I know it's a daunting task. It sounds crazy, but that's exactly what the, what the believers said they do. They had to go up against giants. We have to see these strongholds come down. God's giving us a chance to see it happen.
Starting point is 00:22:27 If you take the elevator in the DOJ department building down to the 66th basement floor, you will find a doorway sealed by ancient magic. Like, what are you talking? This intersection of spirituality and, like, the government is so bizarre to me. Like, it's just, this is where I kind of check out, and I'm like, they really think Like, if you get, like, in the DOJ, like, if you, I don't know, if you, like, use a special kind of, like, Ghostbuster goggles that you'll be able to see, like, where the demons are coming in from and infecting this institution.
Starting point is 00:23:07 Sounds like your skepticism was given to you by Satan, Jake. I mean, I don't know. Yeah, the gates of hell and the DOJ. As I was preaching last night is a great opener, and I should use it more. But, yeah, I mean, listen, this guy has millions of followers. And there are many, many, many people like him, like very, like, this may not be a literal portal to hell, or it may be in his conception. But it's certainly a metaphorical portal to hell.
Starting point is 00:23:33 And it is fascinating to me that he brought up the IRS. Yeah, right. I mean, yeah. If there's anyone who's treated with kid gloves by the IRS United States as religious organizations. Well, yeah. And what's interesting is that, like, you can trace actually the rise of the Christian right as a political, movement to a backlash against the IRS, actually. So in the sort of post-pre and post-World War II years, like you had this very large population of Southern Protestants, but they were
Starting point is 00:24:05 more or less detached from politics, like kind of approved of McCarthyism. They were generally right-wing, but they weren't like political activists per se. They sort of viewed politics as worldly and beneath them. And then you had Brown versus Board of Education desegregating the schools and all across the south this absolute cluster of parochial schools that were segregated with church or Christian in the name like endable ACP reports at the time or like if you want to find a segregation academy which was the term of art for like schools that popped up to take white students out of integrated public schools like if you want to find a segregation academy look for church or Christian in the name and this was so widespread that throughout the you know late 50s
Starting point is 00:24:52 60s, there were entire counties in the south, you know, whose public school systems were drained of white students, drained of funds, and a lot of black students, like, fundamentally did not get an education. And so by the 70s, there was this landmark Supreme Court decision in 71 called Green v. Connolly that basically a couple of black parents, like, sued a segregation academy and were like, why are you a charitable tax-exempt institution when you are illegally segregated? And the Supreme Court found in the favor of those parents. And suddenly these segregation academies were no longer tax exempt. And the IRS started more aggressively like auditing these schools, including Jerry Falwell's Lynchburg Christian Academy, which believe it or not was segregated. I know that's
Starting point is 00:25:38 a shock to hear. And this was what woke the sleeping giant. And then a bunch of Catholics who like had already been really politically active, like Phyllis Schlafly and Paul Lerick and these savvy operators were like, hey, glad you're finally doing the politics thing. That's really cool. Like, the people who are like throwing tomatoes at Ruby Bridges and, you know, the screaming white mobs from the massive resistance movement, right? This is their moment of political awakening. The Catholics are like, well, this is great. I'm so glad. We're excited to expand the ranks of the religious right. But segregation now, segregation tomorrow, segregation forever, like has a limit in terms of its appeal. And like, you guys are kind of coming off.
Starting point is 00:26:21 as the bad guys. Here's an idea. As late as 1973, like the Southern Baptist Convention, even after the passage of Roe v. Wade, like, was like, yeah, abortion is fine. They, like, voted in favor of abortion. It was very much seen as this niche Catholic issue. It was not a Protestant priority whatsoever. And then the Catholics kind of pitched it. Schlafly, in particular, had this goal of turning the Republican Party into the pro-life party. And she and others pitched it as a new civil rights movement. Like, okay, guys, you were on the wrong side of the other one, and it's made you look small and cruel, and, like, people don't like you.
Starting point is 00:26:58 You're the, like, guys that the hoses bring civil rights protesters. But now you can get in on the ground on the civil rights of the unborn. And so very early on, like, in the 70s, you have these comparisons of abortion to slavery and the Holocaust, and very much, like, up to and including in 2022, when the Dobbs' decision was happening, like the president of Susan B. Anthony pro-life America is saying, like, we're like the abolitionists, you know, we are like the people who are, you know, who fought against slavery. So it's been, it's been this internally ennobling image. And they've also been phenomenally successful at propagandizing Americans into sort of believing they're
Starting point is 00:27:36 the guardians of moral purity, that they have this profound care for the unborn child. And it's one of the greatest no jobs in like the history of ever, like that this movement, whose roots were entirely in segregationism, has been able to rebrand as the moral majority, the focus on the family, the like guardians of moral purity and given so much credence and so much leeway in that regard. Well, I mean, that's a shocking, shockingly successful PR effort. I mean, like, so it's one for the ages in terms of, yeah, right, it's for an image. You're right, that could have been sort of just more disastrous as the public became more, you know, tolerant and accepting, you know, I'm sure they could have been, they'd be, you know, as
Starting point is 00:28:23 marginalized as they imagine they are in their head. But, um, but no, but they, they did successfully pivot. Well, they chose to like delve into our country's other bottomless well, which is misogyny, um, and found a lot more success there. People were very anxious about feminism. Um, it was like civil rights had sort of been viewed as this triumphant moral struggle. Of course, they're still against civil rights. And, um, the Christian right is like, they have like a million different synonyms for it, as many as Chris Rufo comes up with on, you know, whatever, anti-D-E-I, let's not teach the history of slavery, let's ban books by black authors all over. So it's not that the like fight against civil rights has gone away, but they found this real
Starting point is 00:29:04 salience and this real resonance as defining themselves as protectors of the unborn. And the other thing, the other piece, and this was brought up by Rai Taron, who's like a really thoughtful ex-evangelical. She's like, the other reason why evangelicals love unborn babies, it's because they hate actual born babies. Like, and I'm not, like, there's this very Calvinist, very punitive view of, like, humanity as, like, fundamentally sinful and evil. So a baby is crying and sleeping and shitting because it's selfish and evil. And, like, you know, a baby is evil if it, like, is too greedy for milk. Like, it's really. It's really. really weird, these views, and they're very, very widely held. And that's why when you look at these
Starting point is 00:29:50 parenting manuals, I mean, some of the worst ones are like, if your baby bites your breast, like, tug its hair. Or, you know, if your baby is, like, crawling up the stairs, like, hit it. Because there's no earliest stage at which, like, mankind becomes evil, except those in the womb, they're perfect. And they'll never fight back. Well, and also this idea that, like, you have to spend your whole life devoted to God and the teachings of Jesus so that you can be absolved of this sin. But in the same breath, from what I understand that if you just, like, you could live an entire life filled with sin and on your deathbed, accept Christ into your heart and be
Starting point is 00:30:31 saved. So there's, there's like so much ideas that are in conflict with one another. And, you know, earlier you guys were talking and you were saying, image, you know, this image. And I think that that's really true. I was thinking about QAnon and, you know, how QAnon is this sort of Christian movement. Unlike the guy who is most likely most responsible for the majority of QAnon, Ron Watkins. Like, when you see videos of him in Cullen Hobex documentary or docu-series into the storm, he's like watching pornography in the car on the way to a restaurant.
Starting point is 00:31:04 Like, he can't not be watching pornography, you know, for long enough to get in his car and go somewhere, which is total antithesis to this image that, that, you know, or the morality that I think the, you know, the evangelicals believe that they exude, right? Yeah, and people very much have the same critique with Trump. And then you had the like, oh, he's the reincarnation of the emperor Cyrus. He's a heathen, but he's a tool of God. And he'll get us the, you know, repeal of Roe. And he did.
Starting point is 00:31:35 Yeah, you think that, you know, these people who act based upon their religious convictions would be, would be purists. But in fact, they're actually very utilitarian. You know, they act with, they operate with, you know, real politic. They're very pragmatic and vicious in that sense. Well, yeah. And you see that also in like who makes up the coalition, right? Like, so you have the Protestants and then the Catholics. And, you know, there was a religious war over that whole thing. And then the Mormons are part of it too, especially in Arizona and Utah and California. and all of these factions think the other ones are going to hell because they're papists or, you know, dirty followers of Luther
Starting point is 00:32:14 or weird space fake Christians. But they all have consonant political goals, which is this like stranglehold over women and children and women's bodies and bringing Christ into the public arena. And so they're like, we'll get along. You know, we'll march forward together for life. And I mean, I hate to say this, but like I would love to see even like a tiny fraction of like
Starting point is 00:32:36 that kind of coalition building on the left because right now it's just like yeah listen it's not that i want to like walk hand in hand with like the resist grifters necessarily but like a lot of people are like really shaken right now and struggling and grieving and like a really like you cannot build community in a meaningful and durable way without like hanging out with people who are kind of annoying and doing stuff together with people that kind of irritate you that's what it is that's one thing about the extreme right. They'll, like Travis said, they're very utilitarian. They'll put aside their differences to get something done for sure. I mean, back when I was researching cultural warlords, one of the funniest, like, neo-Nazi chats. I was part of was a group that composed
Starting point is 00:33:19 of like neo-Nazi pagans and neo-Nazi tradcats. And they were like, well, here's how we will hash out our differences. We'll have a fight club in the woods to raise money for like Augustus Invictus, who's this white supremacist asshole, to like get bailed out of gym. Like, you know, they're like, cool, well, you know, you may be a filthy odinist and I may worship Jesus and, you know, the other crew is like, don't you know Jesus is a Jew and they're too anti-Semitic to be Christian, which is awesome. But they're like, well, we'll hash it out together with a manly grapple in the woods. And meanwhile, like the left is so busying each other's faces like for, you know. I would love to like pull up in a DeLorean and like take these guys back to when Jesus was alive because what they would see is like a Middle Eastern looking guy. who probably looks like homeless, you know, not this like pristine, like, you know, pale, fair-skinned
Starting point is 00:34:13 white guy, you know, with the beard. And it's just, it's just like, all of this stuff is, is based on an idea that is creating reality, even though it's not based on anything real. Like you were saying, Jesus was Jewish. I've actually read a little bit more about Jesus than I probably would like to. And like, what I've read and what I find interesting about him is that what he was trying to do was like a more kind of radical form of Judaism. He basically thought that Judaism as it was practiced wasn't like it wasn't right that we could go further. Yeah, I mean, you see the fact of Christianity as a breakaway sect from Judaism, ironically, and like just how persistent Christian anti-Semitism has been over the centuries. Like, you always have to like, hey, kill your mom,
Starting point is 00:34:58 right? Like, you always have to rebel against your parent. And like, it does come out. Like, even in the terms like devout Christians used to, like, insult one another. They're like, you're so legalistic. You're a Pharisee. And like, all of those just mean Jew. Like, all of those terms. Just mean Jew. You know, but whatever.
Starting point is 00:35:15 That's like hardly, hardly the worst of the issues faced here. I think, you know, but it is interesting. And like, you know, the other piece I think that's really consonant with QAnon and the evangelical right is this idea that like everything important is happening behind a curtain. Everything important is secret and hidden. and is like this sort of cosmic celestial conflict. And like concurrently, most of what you see publicly reported is not important because it's public.
Starting point is 00:35:44 So it can't be true. And that's how you get such a polluted misinformation, like in information environment that fucking RFK Jr. is going to be in charge of health. I mean, the man looks like a slab of uncooked pork. He has worms. And he's going to be in charge of our meat. I'm not okay with it. I'm so not okay with it.
Starting point is 00:36:03 It's, like, sinking in slowly, and I'm like, this guy is a friend to measles everywhere. And it's just, I do think that, like, COVID broke a lot of brains, but also just, like, I did a lot of, like, looking into sort of the right-wing grifter ecology and, like, the mindset behind prophecy and the apocalypse and, like, all this stuff that's just inherent and constantly present in evangelical life. And it's all about fear. You're so afraid of the world all the time. You're buying survival kits and, like, Trump.
Starting point is 00:36:33 Bibles and you are like buying stuff out of fear, you're constantly in this like mixed state of agony and terror over at the rapture. So many former evangelical kids were like, I came home and my parents were gone. I got out of the shower and my parents were gone and I assumed they'd been raptured and like this moment of transcendent terror because the end of the world is always around the corner. And like now we have Mike Huckabee, a man who like is best friends with Timothy LeHaye who wrote the Left Behind series, which is all about the fucking apocalypse, he's the ambassador to Israel. And that scares the living shit out of me because these people are horny for the end of the world and it starts with a catastrophic war in the Middle East. Yep. Like, they're excited
Starting point is 00:37:17 about it. And I'm like, I don't want the world to end. I don't think Jesus is going to come back anyway, but I'm like just not, they're like, if you look at like, you know, John Hage and like his books. So, like, and then, like, Israel will be knee-deep in blood and the stench of bodies will be so thick. Like, no one will be able to breathe. And he's, like, so horny about it. And when, like, the most recent war genocide and Israel broke out, all these churches were, like, God's timepiece is ticking. Like, Jesus is coming. And they were so excited, like, excited, thrilled, and people were dying. That thousand people died on day one. And then, like, everyone has been, like, there has been so much death and it has been this this moment of like the prophecies are coming true jesus
Starting point is 00:38:02 closer than ever and it really brought home to me how like inhumane this this worldview is where everything is an instrument towards the fulfillment of prophecy and where bodies are so much less important than souls like when you govern theocratically you are far more interested in the business of souls than you are of bodies so if a woman dies of sepsis because she can't get an abortion. That's not a tragedy. That's a martyrdom. That's a fitting martyrdom. And she was saved from sin. Yeah. Sorry, that's really depressing, but it's like so, it's like true. No, it's real. It's real. Like I learned, I was, you know, somebody who's like fairly non-religious in my adulthood. You know, it was really crazy to learn that evangelicals or, you know, Christians or Republicans, you know,
Starting point is 00:38:49 were so pro-Israel because they think that the bodies of the Jews are going to be a landing pad for Jesus when the rapture comes, that like, you know, we got to protect Israel at all cost. Not because we care about Jewish people, but because that's where the reusable Jesus thruster will come back down, you know, the jaws will grab it, and the fire coming out of his feet will torch that entire area. And it's really, it's really upsetting, especially now you have this additional entity, this additional profit, right, quote unquote, in QAnon, which I'm assuming is going to come back, That is light, you know, light to dark, or dark to light, the Great Awakening, all of this language that feeds into these rapture beliefs.
Starting point is 00:39:33 Of course they think that it's close. And if you believe in an eternal life, you know, or an eternal afterlife, at least, and that this time on earth is just this blip or just essentially, you know, auditions to use a theater kit talk, like auditions to get into heaven, then like whatever carnage you create here, it doesn't matter. because your sole focus is on whatever awaits you in the Eternal Kingdom. And that's terrifying. Yeah, it's really scary.
Starting point is 00:40:04 Like, as someone who's like very firmly anchored in the material world, I'm like, no, bodies. Bodies are important. Don't feed kids poison milk and, you know, stop them from getting measles. And, like, the children don't urine for the minds and stop beating your kids. But, I mean, the other piece of it is that my term for, like, Christian Zionism, which, by the way, like, if you don't know about Christian Zionism, There are, like, more members of Christians United for Israel, which is just one Christian Zionist organization, than there are Jews in the United States.
Starting point is 00:40:33 Like, America's Israel policy must seem totally insane if you're not aware of this phenomenon. Like, you might think it's, like, a sinister Jewish control thing, because, like, why else would we, you know, never even move an inch? And there are, like, documented instances where, like, George W. Bush, like, slow walked any movement on peace with the Palestinians because he was like, oh, the evangelicals won't like it. you know, really, that religious belief has dominated our policy for a long time, certainly on the Republican side. And Trump's move of the embassy from the American embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem was absolutely a sob to evangelicals. And like the people giving the speeches
Starting point is 00:41:11 were like, some of the most anti-Semitic preachers you could possibly find. Because the way a Christian, particularly an evangelical, think loves a Jew is the way a hungry man loves a chicken wing. It's all about consumption and destruction and domination. And their final fantasy, right, is Jesus coming back and the Jews, like, are forced to convert or die, and there's a righteous remnant that become Christian and are saved, and everyone else is cast into the fiery pit. So their final conception of Jews and attitude towards Israel and Middle East policy, which are inextricable, because the way evangelicals relate to Middle East policy is through the lens of the apocalypse, which is terrifying. But their vision is like the total annihilation of
Starting point is 00:41:54 Jewry. And I'm like, I, you know, I definitely have Jewish friends who are like, okay, we'll worry about it when Jesus comes back. But I'm like, if these are your friends, like, you know, what do you need enemies for? Like, they're terrible influences and they're horny for war. Of course they'll never stop sending arms. They want a catastrophic end of world conflict. I don't know. It's very unnerving. And I think people are very not aware of like how intense Christian Zionism is. Totally. I've got a family member. I won't mention what kind. who is, like, a big Israel guy and big shoal guy, like he's, you know, very much into his shoal, and he's, that's kind of, like, what his life revolves around, and he's, like, diehard Trump guy, because he's like, well, Trump, like, cares about Israel and, like, Republicans want to protect Israel. It's like, oh, man, like, oh, dude, I don't know, it just seems very, you know, sort of against a conflict of interest, if you will, but, yes, some people just, like, I don't know. I don't know. It's hard to understand why anybody thinks what they think anymore. Everybody's just
Starting point is 00:42:59 the thing that their little beliefsies, you know, that keep it going, that make the hardships of this very real, you know, existence that is happening right now that, you know, not the afterlife, not the before life, but the thing that we're in now that can be very difficult at times, and it makes it seem, I don't know, less, less harsh or easier to endure or whatever it is. Yeah, I mean, people cling to beliefs and structures that make them either feel ennobled or make them feel like they can survive, even beyond death in some cases. Yeah, I remember I give a talk to a congregation and, like, it was, you know, talking about how shitty the evangelicals are and then how shitty the Nazis are. And, like, this guy stood up and was like, Talia, you don't like the phylo-Semites, you don't like the anti-Semites, who do you like? And I don't trust anybody, you know, and it's a tough sell, but I'm like, I don't know, like, you want to consume me in the rage of your Lord.
Starting point is 00:43:50 thanks. I will say it did get me a couple more interviews with like evangelical figures who were more down to talk to me because they're like, I could convert a Jew. And like, I still get, I still get emails from some of these folks, even though I'm like, I roasted you in public. But that would be a mitzvah for them to convert. Whatever their, whatever their terminology for a mitzvah is. It's like catching like a really rare Pokemon. Like it's really exciting. Yeah, like, I mean, I just wanted to reference that, you know, that you were talking about. How, genuinely concerning that someone as like evangelical as Mike Huckabee was named U.S. ambassador to Israel because there's like there was a recent appearance he had on Charlie Kirk, which Huckabby talked about
Starting point is 00:44:34 his new role and why he believed Israel to be important. But it didn't seem like his philosophy like as an ambassador is driven by like secular concerns like diplomacy or humanitarianism. Instead he referenced words spoken by God in the book of Genesis. I believe it is a special because God made it special. And so without any apology in saying this, you know, I'm a simple guy. I believe the scripture. Genesis 12, those who bless Israel will be blessed. Those who curse Israel will be cursed. I want to be on the blessing side, not the curse side. I'm not 100% comfortable with like, you know, just diplomats just openly saying that their that their policy is driven by a religious text. Yeah, but like, this is what I mean when people are like, but what about the
Starting point is 00:45:17 separation of church and state? I'm like, what about it? It doesn't fucking exist. Like, tell that to, like, a woman who lives in Idaho or Arkansas. Like, you know, and now we have, like, a secretary of defense. Pete Hucketh, who has, like, a Deiast Wolt tattoo. It's like a crusader tattoo. And it's like, his political positions have been described as Christian nationalists. Like, he literally wrote a book called American Crusade, you know, where he talks about the holy war for the righteous cause of human freedom.
Starting point is 00:45:44 And, you know, we are at a very strange tipping point where these people have so long to find themselves as persecuted and in opposition and all this stuff are really acquiring the temporal power they've been building and building and building for 50 years. This is in many ways the apotheosis of this movement and it started with judiciary capture and like by dint of that judiciary capture they were able to regain executive power and it's just I mean like I just would say like I find it really one of the best things you can do in this moment or at least it's been helpful for me in terms of conceptualizing and understanding this moment is like two things. First of all, like, abandon some of your myths about how America's special
Starting point is 00:46:24 and it can't happen here and all that. The separation of church and state has been gone for a very long time, as you would probably know better if you weren't born into a church. Sorry, but the other piece of it is that, you know, I find that a lot of people on the left are like, well, we've been an oligarchy for a long time. Biden was also giving blank checks to Israel. You know, essentially we have this fascist history. And all of that is true. And like, you can reckon with the sins of America. Absolutely. But like the axiom that I've been using is like more is new and more is worse. Like just because things are bad and have been bad and historically have been bad, doesn't mean they can't get worse. Like use your imagination. Like people who
Starting point is 00:47:04 want to turn the US into a domain of Christ where women are submissive and children are like objects to be beaten are now gaining more like power over some of the biggest and strongest and most lethal institutions in the world. It's scary, but it's also like you have to understand the parameters of the threat in order to even begin to marshal your counter zeal. You know what I mean? Yeah, it's like if I've got a bagel, right, and it's been sitting on the counter, it's the last bagel in the sleeve, the plastic sleeve, and I pull it out and there's
Starting point is 00:47:37 like a tiny spot of mold on it. And I eat the bagel and I'm like, ah, whatever, you know, I didn't realize there, or maybe it was the second to last bagel, and I didn't know. notice any mold on it, but like I see the last bagel that's got a little spot on. I go, oh, shit, okay. Well, I don't know. There's a difference between that and reaching into the bag and having a bagel that's covered in mold that I eat. And I go, well, it doesn't matter because I already ate the mold. I already ate a tiny piece of it. It's like, no, bad can become worse. And the, you know, one thing that I've learned over the course of doing, doing this show and
Starting point is 00:48:15 talking to a lot of people, is that the degree in which things are now and can be worse is a big difference. There's a big difference between what Trump is going to do for Israel and what Biden did for Israel. And that degree of, that degree, it doesn't seem like it matters. And, you know, we're lucky that, you know, we're lucky that we aren't living in the hellscape that people over there are, but it's going to feel, it's going to be worse. I mean, listen, it's like you can condemn a genocidal policy and also be like, it's also extra bad if like these messianic, like, apocalypse humpers are, are in charge of policy in this very volatile part of the world.
Starting point is 00:49:02 Like, these are two very consonant and okay views to hold at the same time. I don't know. It's like staring down the barrel of a second Trump term, having spent the last several years of my life, like, really digging out sort of. of, I mean, and once again, for the third election in a row, you have, like, Saddam Hussein numbers for for Trump among white evangelicals. It's 82% this time, 82 to 17. Crazy.
Starting point is 00:49:25 Yeah, like, Bathist numbers. And, you know, it's utilitarian and it's also like, yeah, we're winning. Fuck you. And, like, one thing that I've been thinking about in terms of, like, a counterzeal is a term that I like to think about. It's hard to say, like, you know, when you're, like, on team, like, on team, like, like autocracy and theocracy, you know what you're fighting for. You know, you have this set of ideas and principles that are deeply constraining, and we're talking about, like, the repeal of sodomy laws, drumming trans people out of public life,
Starting point is 00:49:57 like drumming women out of public life, forcing them back into the domestic sphere, like stripping autonomy from our bodies, all this stuff. You know, the parental rights movement mandating, like, child abuse, right? This is a very coherent set of principles, whereas, like, on the other side, you're like, no, we want cacophony, we want freedom, we want, like, a whole mix of people doing their thing in different ways. Like, we don't have a unitary vision. So how do you create, like, a counterzeal for cacophony, right?
Starting point is 00:50:26 How do you, how do you, like, create a joyous riot for freedom? It's tough. It's a tough ask. And one thing I think that's important, not I've been thinking about is just, like, as I mentioned earlier, like, faith is such a deep human drive, the desire to believe in something bigger than yourself and something that will last after you die. And we can't seed the idea of faith to this cruel, limited, and also deeply unpopular view of a faith, of Christianity, of religion. Like, there are so many people whose faith guides them towards wanting a better, kinder,
Starting point is 00:51:03 juster, and non-burning world. And I think that it's time for, like, those voices to show up and show out. And for all of us to say, like, no, your kingdom, I don't want to be part of your kingdom. Your God is not my God. Your God is a God of cruelty and narrowness and terrorizing people. And you don't have a monopoly over faith and who is faithful and who is true and good. And like, that's what I think about. And I think about how we even begin to fight back against a movement that sees us all as like minions of the devil. It's like, fuck you know, I'm not. Like, I know what the devil looks like, and he's in your eyes. Yeah, I do. I'm good. I'm a good person, actually. I do try to, like, treat other people well
Starting point is 00:51:44 and, you know, try to see everybody as equal. It's so funny. It's like, yeah, there's such, there's such a hypocrisy in it, and I think that that's infuriating for a lot of people who aren't in it. And we like to point that out, right? Anytime, you know, a pastor or somebody involved in the church is doing some horrible crime against children or whatever, that always bubbles to the top, but then once that person is punished, this entire institution, you know, this institution of faith or this system of beliefs, you know, that cultivates or sort of protects these people is like, oh, well, back to, you know, back to just like kind of being, you know, the sort of undertow of America, right?
Starting point is 00:52:23 Yeah, I mean, hypocrisy never matters to the will to power. And, like, also, in order to accuse someone of hypocrisy in a way that's durable and matters, you have to be seen as like a credible interlocutor by them. And that's just not the case when it comes to the Christian, right? Like, they view us of sinners and heathens and like lost to the will of God and like going to hell, right? So us saying like, you're hypocrites and you're, you know, you're not living your values. They're like, who are you? Like you're a Luciferian piece of shit, right?
Starting point is 00:52:51 So your standing matters. But also like in general when you're like, I'm going to obtain absolute power to build a kingdom of Christ. Like someone being like, he are a hypocrite. like doesn't really have a lot of weight. I think the stronger, like, it's been interesting to me. I've had to accept it. Like, when people use religious imagery to counter the Christian right, I find it kind of powerful.
Starting point is 00:53:13 When people are like, Trump is not Cyrus. He's not King David. He's the golden calf. You know, he's this idol that you've created. You know, or saying he fits a lot of criteria for the Antichrist or whatever. Like, that's not my approach to it. But it is an approach to it where people bring their faith with them. into the struggle. I think we should discount that as like part of, it has to be a broad,
Starting point is 00:53:36 strange arsenal for the army of like letting life be broad and messy and strange. And people, you know, instead of the like puritanical anti-sex gang, like winning, absolutely. Like, we have to like love as hard as we can and be strange and be cacophonous and be ungovernable and like not fit into these iron molds they've made for us. And in order to do, that like we have to bring every motivation that we have that's my um i'm like i'm so sorry i'm i have like sincerity disease where i've just like been reading this shit for so long and i like find it so upsetting when i'm like no like i'm gonna i'm gonna give the speech that saves america never apologize for being sincere and also it's just like it's so amazing because uh i believe
Starting point is 00:54:22 you're on east coast time and the sun is just setting in the background and the room is starting to become, like, darker and darker. Like, you can feel the devil, you know, basically ascending on, like, you know, where you are. I'm like, be gay, do crimes. And, like, little horns are, like, popping out of my head. I want to mention, so your book is really enlightening because I think it helps contextualize some of the bizarre statements and actions of right-wing figures. And I experienced this personally while I was reading your chapters on Christian corporal
Starting point is 00:54:55 punishment. And as you explain your book, there's a large body of literature directed towards Christians that explains the theory and practice of using physical pain to mold the behavior of a child. And this is, I think, I mean, I thought it was the most impactful chapter of your book. You talked to some people who suffered some very serious abuse as a children as a consequence of this philosophy. And this philosophy also just, it doesn't just have an impact on an individual level, but also has a society-wide impact. And while reading your book, I felt like I suddenly understood some bizarre comments that were made by Tucker Carlson in October at a Turning Point Action Conference. So he likened the American public to an out-of-controlled child and Donald Trump to a father who was obligated to correct bad behavior with physical punishment. If you allow your hormone-addled 15-year-old daughter to like slam the door of her bedroom and give you the finger, you're going to get more of it.
Starting point is 00:55:48 And those kids are going to wind up in rehab. it's not good for you and it's not good for them no there has to be a point at which dad comes home and when dad gets home you know what he says you've been a bad girl you've been a bad little girl and you're getting a vigorous spanking right now and no it's not going to hurt me more than it hurts you no it's not I'm not going to lie It's going to hurt you a lot more than it hurts me. And it has to be this way. It has to be this way because it's true.
Starting point is 00:56:25 And you're only going to get better when you take responsibility for what you did. That's not said in the spirit of hate. It's not said in the spirit of vengeance or bigotry. Far from it. It's set in the spirit of justice, which is the purest and best thing there is. And without it, things fall apart. Wow. Psycho. I know. It's psycho. When that happened, I mean, I saw some commentary from like liberals,
Starting point is 00:56:53 but like, oh, man, Tucker's just like playing out a weird fantasy or maybe he's just like, you know, he's kind of like saying odd shit to trigger their lips. But this idea of like Trump as this sort of like loving punisher who has to administer pain in order to avoid things from getting out of control, that sounds like really rooted in this right wing Christian parenting philosophy. Oh, yeah, like control the youth, control the future, right? And specifically control the youth through, like, physical abuse in the service of obedience, right? Like, the thing that this hypothetical daughter, who's a bad girl, is doing, is slamming the door on you.
Starting point is 00:57:31 She's saying that she's moving away from you. She's changing. That's not acceptable. And it's interesting. Tucker is a very savvy character in his way. And, like, he's been moving more towards the evangelical, right? Now that he no longer has a Fox show. Like some of his biggest statements lately that have like broken out of whatever weird silo he's in on X have been like experiences with demons and demonology like, oh, I was scratched by a demon in bed.
Starting point is 00:57:56 Oh, and like, and he's getting up and talking about spanking. Like he's speaking to a specific audience here. He's like signaling to the to the evangelicals like, you're my people. It's so depressing also that that was a winning electoral message. I think that's just sinking in now that like that won. I mean, the other piece of it is that like when you have as. as our country does, right? The Christian right has been on this
Starting point is 00:58:19 beat your kid into submission trained since like the 70s. When James Dobson, who redacted, redacted, redacted, redacted, redacted, redacted, stuff about how much I load that guy, wrote Dare to Discipline about how permissive parents in the 50s had been. And we have to go back to the Bible and the rod and spawned whole legion of imitators. And so for 50 years, these parenting tracts have come out. And all of them are like, beat your kid into obedience. but in, like, different ways.
Starting point is 00:58:46 I read God the Rod and your child's bond, so you didn't have to. Thank me. I mean, yeah, I do thank you, because I, it's fair to say, I would never pick that up. No, and I have it on my shelf and I feel like a monster every time I see it, like, glips it. But it's in my, like, horrible, like, my little, like, horrible quarantined corner of, like, Christian child rearing and parenting manuals. But, like, so you have, in aggregate, you know, right now they're about 14 million white evangelical Christians, right?
Starting point is 00:59:12 And a lot of them have a lot of kids. and they're also like generation since the 70s that have been raised this way. And when you raise a kid in a context like this, where obedience is the absolute sine qua non, it's the highest ideal, total obedience, where brutality and violence are derogor, they're the norm, what to expect. When authority, like violent authority and love come from the same place, you're building a nation of authoritarians. You're building a nation of people who are conditioned to,
Starting point is 00:59:44 see daddy's home and he's going to punish you as like the ideal method of governance because that's how they were raised and that's how they're raising their kids so it's like if you're wondering why the Christian right has so openly embraced you know an autocrat despite all their cries of like religious liberty religious freedom again hypocrisy is irrelevant but like I would argue that one very overlooked like very very overlooked cause of Americans willing embrace of authoritarianism in this populace is just like they were raised in deeply authoritarian homes. But the father is protector and the mother is submissive co-enforcer, and the children is, like, subject to ritualized violence.
Starting point is 01:00:25 And so I'm going to blame this on James Dobson. And there's also a podcast called I Hate James Dobson, so I'm not the only one. He's a monster, and like, all his imitators are monsters and, like, whew. Yeah, it sucks. It sucks to think about violence being done to children in the name of some sort of righteousness. Yeah, and those kids grow up, right? And some of them break away. And like so many of my interlocutors like talked about the damage they'd suffered or like a lot of them like moved away from this faith when they had kids. And they were like, I don't want to hit my kid. This is actually
Starting point is 01:00:59 immoral. It hurts me to hit my kid. I'm not going to do this. But a lot of people don't. A lot of people stay in it. It's much harder to leave than to stay. You lose a very tight-knit community. You lose your family. You lose like so much when you leave a totalizing religion like this. and, you know, especially in like as lonely and atomized as American life is without this kind of community. And so a lot of people stay in it. And like if we're wondering why American political life is so full of violent fantasy and punishment and the idea of punishment and vengeance and retribution and like, you know, strong autocratic leaders, like I think a lot of it comes down to this family model. And like these people are some of the most active people in politics. Like they showed up. 82% voted for Trump and they all showed up. Like the biggest winner in the 2024 election
Starting point is 01:01:48 wasn't Trump or Harris. It was staying the fuck home. And these people are motivated. They're out here to win the war against Satan. And that desire has been beaten into them since they, before they could walk. And so, you know, we're at this inflection point where it's like, we got to show up now.
Starting point is 01:02:05 But it's scary because these folks are very militant and conditioned to be so for sure. Should we end on a more positive note? A sobering way to end the show, terrible. God, I'm like, ugh. No, but it's like, it's, this is, this is the, we can do all the hyena laughing that we want as we stare down, like you said, the barrel of another four years of Trump and how melted it is going to be and what's this going to do for the conspiracy community on both political angles. But this is the real, this is the depressing shit. This is the shit that sinks in after a week or so, which is like where we are.
Starting point is 01:02:40 so it's appropriate. Here's how we're going to land this one. So Talia, I would recommend your account on X, but that was, that was nuked in the sort of tumultuous process of transfer ship to Elon Musk. What happened there? Yeah, so I'm on blue sky now. Oh, okay.
Starting point is 01:03:03 But the skies are blue. And like the resist lids just showed up and like all the like angry trans-Marxist-Leninist. are like, and it's an interesting dynamic right now. There have been like a million, literally a million new blue sky users this week as people are just like, fuck Twitter, it's a Nazi machine. So there was like this brief period after Elon took over where people who had like legacy blue checks, which I got when I was a fact checker at the New Yorker, like still had them, but they were going to be stripped away in favor of like paid blue checks, which is just like some random
Starting point is 01:03:35 asshole. And now it's like some random asshole using chat GPT. That's how it's evolved over the last year or so but like it was like the the twilight of the blue checks and i used mine to impersonate a like i had this account at swords jew that like had 100 000 followers and i was like fuck it like you know this place is going to the dogs i'm gonna go out you know you know like they used to say to warriors like come back with your shield or on it i'm like i'm going out on my shield like whatever so i impersonated jk rolling my handle was at swords drew so if you looked for like more than three seconds, like you would see. But I was like, sorry to be such a dementor all along. Trans people are great. And like, by the way, like, read another book. You know, trans women are
Starting point is 01:04:20 women. And then I just got fucking nuked. And I, for brief time, I use my former podcast account. And now I'm just like, I don't know, my last post on X goes, fuck all of you. Then I lost my password. Now I'm just on blue sky all the time. I think that's a great place to leave your account indefinitely is fuck all of you and then just never post again. I think about doing this on almost like a half-hourly basis. So I think you're ahead of the curve. Yeah. I think you should at least try Blue Sky. It's really nice because yeah, like it's online. So everyone's weird and like you'll have people that just like are misunderstanding or like possibly schizophrenic or whatever. But like the default isn't like defensive crouch because like a bunch of Nazis and or race scientists
Starting point is 01:05:06 and or like weird like AI bot farming accounts are like all the replies yeah like people will like engage with what you have to say it's great and you know you can't um go to heaven without passing through the blue sky i guess facts yeah no go go the blue sky if you if you're if you're if you're tired of twitter which is a reasonable stance and uh and then also pick up her book wild faith how the christian right is taking over america like it said this dark subject better, but it's beautifully written. There's some funny jokes, and it's just put together well, and it's enlightening. So, yeah, enjoy.
Starting point is 01:05:44 And if you enjoyed the melodic and sonorous tones of my voice, I read the audiobook. I was going to say, I was going to say, if you're like me and you have trouble with attention to sit down and read a book cover to cover, I've been listening to the audiobook, and it's very nice. Like we said at the beginning, you very gently sort of drop us into. the hellscape of this ideology and this movement that has, you know, been, yeah, so much, so much a part of our history, so much a part of this country will be so much a part of our future. But at least you sound very nice doing it, which is, you know.
Starting point is 01:06:23 Like, let me take your hand and lead you gently to it. Yeah, lead me gently to hell. Into the gates of hell in the DOJ basement. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, and I don't know, guys, my third book is going to be about sandwiches, and I probably who won't get invited on QAA to talk about it. No, no, you will. I like talking about sandwiches. That's
Starting point is 01:06:42 a good way to end it on a positive note. What current sandwich are you plug in? Like, what's your, what's your latest obsession? So, I generally, I am like a big stand of the grilled cheese sandwich. I think if I was going to start a cult or like a religious
Starting point is 01:06:58 movement, it would just be giving grilled cheeses to people who are sad or lonely or hungry. Like, I think a grilled cheese is so great because it's like a perfect thing in and of itself and every grilled cheese like I'm very ecumenical about it like I don't care if you do like yarlsburg on like the fanciest bread or wonder bread on an American cheese like you've created something warm and nourishing and like perfect and and it will sustain you and it will make you happy and if you listen to this whole
Starting point is 01:07:29 podcast like you deserve a grilled cheese and maybe a bowl of tomato soup yes absolutely and a little bit of comfort and warmth and a dark world. It's like a sun in your hand. Yes, folks. Get out. Get that wonder bread. Get those craft singles. Get yourself a nice tomato bisque. Do a little bit of dipping. Reset. Look forward. And we're going to be something. I'm not going to say okay, but we're going to be something. And yeah, Talia, thank you for spending your time with us. And thanks for writing the book. It was really lovely. It was an honor. And thank you so much. Thanks for listening to another episode of the QAA podcast. You can go to patreon.com slash QAA
Starting point is 01:08:11 and subscribe for $5 a month to get a whole second episode every single week, plus access to our entire archive of premium episodes. We've got a website, qa-a-a-podcast.com. Listener, until next week, may the Deep Dish bless you and keep you. We have auto-keyed content based on your preferences. So it is manifest and plain that God is currently judging America, one of the most fruitful nations ever to exist,
Starting point is 01:08:46 and he is judging us by turning us over to the fruitless deeds of darkness. He is letting us run headlong into the void where no fruit grows, where no harvest has ever been gathered. Fruitless. Pay attention to that italicized adjective, fruitless. What is anal intercourse? Among other things, fruitless. What do puberty blockers?
Starting point is 01:09:05 bring about. Fruitlessness. What is abortion? Violent and bloody fruitlessness? What is the dink double income no kids lifestyle? Fruitless. America has enslaved herself to the terrible bondage of orgasms without consequences. Under the weight of this severe judgment, we have demanded as our constitutional prerogative the right to become as fruitless as a dried out stick. It is our constitutional right, or so we have argued, to be struck in the forehead with the hammer of God. Thank you.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.